V8: Hematopoeisis Moignard et al., Nature Biotech. 33, 269 (2015) Blood has long served as a model...

V8: Hematopoeisis

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

Blood has long served as a model to study organ development owing to the accessibility of blood cells and the availability of markers for specific cell populations.

Blood development initiates at gastrulation from multipotent Flk1+ mesodermal cells, which initially have the potential to form blood, endothelium and smooth muscle cells.

Blood development represents one of the earliest stages of organogenesis, as the production of primitive erythrocytes is required to support the growing embryo.

SS 2015 – lecture 81

Modeling Cell Fate

Flk1 and Runx1 staining in E7.5 mesoderm and blood band, respectively

Early stages of hematopoesis

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

The first wave of primitive hematopoiesis originates from Flk1+ mesoderm, with all hematopoietic potential in the mouse contained within the Flk1+ population from E7.0 onwards.

Single Flk1+ cells were flow sorted at E7.0 (primitive streak, PS), E7.5 (neural plate, NP) and E7.75 (head fold, HF) stages.

We subdivided E8.25 cells into putative blood and endothelial populations by isolating GFP+ cells (four somite, 4SG) and Flk1+GFP− cells (4SFG−), respectively


Modeling Cell Fate

Material

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

Cells were sorted from multiple embryos at each time point, with 3,934 cells going on to subsequent analysis.

Total cell numbers and numbers of cells of appropriate phenotypes present in each embryo were estimated from fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) data.


Modeling Cell Fate

What experiments should be performed

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

Genes essayed- 33 transcription factors known to be involved in endothelial and hematopoietic development -9 marker genes (needed for FACS-sorting)-4 house-keeping genes (needed for quality checks and normalization)


Modeling Cell Fate

Discard cells that did not express all 4 house-keeping genes, or for which their expression was more than 3 standard deviations from the mean.

Fluidigm biomark: collect gene expression in single cells

www.fluidigm.com

“Fluidigm’s revolutionary integrated fluidic circuits (IFCs) empower life science research by automating PCR reactions in nanoliter volumes.”


Modeling Cell Fate

Hierarchical clustering of gene expression data

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

3 main clusters:

Cluster I (right side) contains mostly PS and NP cells

Cluster III contains exclusively 4SG cells

Cluster II is mixed (NF, 4SFG- , …)

Cell differentiationprogresses asynchronously


Modeling Cell Fate

Dimensionality reduction: diffusion maps

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

Similarity of expression in cells i and j :


Modeling Cell Fate

P(i,j) is normalized so that

The cells are organized in 2D or 3D such that the Euclidean distance between the cells corresponds to the diffusion metric P(i,j) .

The quantity P(i,j) can then be interpreted as the transition probability of a diffusion process between cells.

Axes: eigenvectors of matrix P with largest eigenvalues.

Quorum sensing of Vibrio fischeri

LuxR

LuxR

LuxI

AI

luxICDABEluxR

LuxB

LuxALuxBLuxALuxR

LuxR

LuxR

LuxI

AI

luxICDABEluxR

LuxB

LuxALuxBLuxALuxR

SS 2015 – lecture 8 Modeling Cell Fate8

Boolean Networks

Densities of the species

Progress in time

Network of dependencies

<=> discrete propagation steps

<=> discrete states: on/off, 1/0

<=> condition tables

Simplified mathematical description of the dependencies:

"Blackboard explanations" often formulated as conditional transitions

• "If LuxI is present, then AI will be produced…"

• "If there is AI and there's no LuxR:AI bound to the genome, then LuxR will be expressed and complexes can form…"

• "If LuxR:AI is bound to the genome, then LuxI is expressed…"


Boolean Networks II

State of the system: described by vector of discrete values

Si = {0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 1, …}

Si = {x1(i), x2(i), x3(i), …}

fixed number of species with finite number of states each

Propagation:

→ finite number of system states

→ periodic trajectories

with fi given by condition tables

→ all states leading to an attractor = basin of attraction

Si+1 = {x1(i+1), x2(i+1), x3(i+1), …}

x1(i+1) = f1(x1(i), x2(i), x3(i), …)

→ periodic sequence of states = attractor


A Small Example

State vector S = {A, B, C} → 8 possible states

Conditional evolution:

A is on if C is on A activates B C is on if (B is on && A is off)

Ai+1 Ci

0 0

1 1

Bi+1 Ai

0 0

1 1

Ci+1 Ai Bi

0 0 0

1 0 1

0 1 0

0 1 1

assume here that inhibition through A is stronger than activation via B

Start from {A, B, C} = {1, 0, 0}

periodic orbit of length 3

# Si A B C

0 S0 1 0 0

1 S1 0 1 0

2 S2 0 0 1

3 S3 = S0 1 0 0


Test the Other States

Test the other states Ai+1 Ci

0 0

1 1

Bi+1 Ai

0 0

1 1

Ci+1 Ai Bi

0 0 0

1 0 1

0 1 0

0 1 1

# A B C

0 1 1 1

1 1 1 0

2 0 1 0

3 0 0 1

4 1 0 0

5 0 1 0

# A B C

0 1 0 1

1 1 1 0 # A B C

0 0 1 1

1 1 0 1

Same attractor as before:100 → 010 → 001 → 100

also reached from:110, 111, 101, 011

→ Either all off or stable oscillations

# A B C

0 0 0 0

1 0 0 0


Who regulates hematopoiesis? Design Boolean Network

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

Determine suitable expression thresholds for each gene to categorize its expression levels into binary on / off states.

Note that only a small number of the possible states has been observed.


Modeling Cell Fate

State graph

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

State graph (largest connected component) of 1448 states reaching all 5 stages.

Edges connect all states that differ in the on/off levels of a single gene.


Modeling Cell Fate

Automatic derivation of rules for Boolean Network

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

We are given:

-a set of variables V, corresponding to genes,

- an undirected graph G = (N,E) where each node n ∈ N is labeled with a state s:V→{0,1}, and each edge {s1,s2} ∈ E is labeled with the single variable that changes between state s1 and s2.

We are also given a designated set I N of initial vertices and a designated set F N of final vertices, along with a threshold ti for each variable vi ∈ V.


Modeling Cell Fate


Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

Our synthesis method searches for an orientation of G, along with an update function ui:{0,1}n→{0,1} for each variable vi∈V, such that the following conditions

hold:

1. For each edge (s1,s2) labeled with variable vi in the orientated graph, the update function for vi takes state s1 to state s2: ui(s1) = s2(i).

2. For every variable vi ∈ V, let Ni be the set of states without a vi-labeled edge. For every i the number of states s ∈ Ni such that ui(s) = s(i) is greaterthan or equal to ti. (This condition “maximizes the number of states in which no

transitions induced by the update functions are missing”.)

3. Every final vertex f ∈ F is reachable from some initial vertex i ∈ I by adirected path in the orientated graph.


Modeling Cell Fate


Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

We restrict the update function ui to have the form:f 1 ^¬ f2

where fj is a Boolean formula that has and-nodes of in-degree twoand/or-nodes of arbitrary in-degree, and where f1 has a maximum depth ofNi and f2 has a maximum depth of Mi.

Ni and Mi are given as parameters to the method.

The search for edge orientations and associated Boolean update rules isencoded as a Boolean satisfiability (SAT) problem.


Modeling Cell Fate

Generated rules

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

Additional validity check of the postulated rules:

check whether regulated genes contain TF-binding motifs in their promoters (right column).

This is the case for 70% of the rules.


Modeling Cell Fate

Core network controlling hematopoiesis

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

Derived core network of 20 TFs.

Red edges: activationBlue edges: repression


Modeling Cell Fate

Predict effects of perturbations as validation

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

In silico perturbations predict key regulators of blood development. Overexpression and knockout experiments were simulated for each TF and the ability of the network to reach wildtype or new stable states was assessed

Red indicates expressed; blue indicates not expressed.

S2-S6: blood-likeS7: endothelial-like

Network stable states for wt and Sox7 overexpression.

Enforced expression of Sox7 (that is normally downregulated) stabilized the endothelial module and an inability to reach any of the blood-like states.

Sox7 is predicted to regulate more targets than any other TF, suggesting that perturbing its expression could haveimportant downstream consequences


Modeling Cell Fate

Control experiments

(b) Colony assays with or without doxycycline from genotyped E8.25 embryos from iSox7+rtTA+ mice crossed with wild types.

(c) Quantification of primitive erythroid colonies after 4 days.

Embryos carrying both transgenes (bottom) showed a 50% reduction of primitive erythroid colony formation and simultaneous appearance of undifferentiated hemangioblast-like colonies following doxycycline-induced Sox7 expression compared to controls.This suggests, in agreement with modeling data and gene expression patterns, that downregulation of Sox7 is important forthe specification of primitive erythroid cells.


Modeling Cell Fate

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

In iSox7-mouse, overexpression of Sox7 is

stimulated by inducing the Sox7-promoter

by addition of the chemical doxycycline

(+Dox).

Conclusions

Moignard et al.,

Nature Biotech.

33, 269 (2015)

The results indicate, at least for cells destined to become blood and endothelium,that these cells arise at all stages of the analyzed time course rather than in a synchronized fashion at one precise time point, consistent with the gradual nature of gastrulation.

Using an automated Boolean Network synthesis toolkit we identified a core network of 20 highly connected TFs, which could reach 8 stable statesrepresenting blood and endothelium.

We validated model predictions to demonstrate e.g. that Sox7 blocks primitive erythroid development.


Modeling Cell Fate

Cytosine methylation

Observation: 3-6 % of all cytosines are methylated in human DNA.

This methylation occurs (almost) exclusively when cytosine is followed by a guanine

base -> CpG dinucleotide.

Esteller, Nat. Rev. Gen. 8, 286 (2007)www.wikipedia.org

Mammalian genomes contain much fewer (only 20-25 %)

of the CpG dinucleotide than is expected by the G+C content

(we expect 1/16 ≈ 6% for any random dinucleotide).

This is typically explained in the following way:

As most CpGs serve as targets of DNA methyltransferases,

they are usually methylated.


Modeling Cell Fate

Cytosine 5-methyl-cytosine

Cytosine methylation

Esteller, Nat. Rev. Gen. 8, 286 (2007)www.wikipedia.org

5-Methylcytosine can easily deaminate to thymine.

If this mutation is not repaired, the affected CpG is permanently converted to TpG

(or CpA if the transition occurs on the reverse DNA strand).

Hence, methylCpGs represent mutational hot spots in the genome.

If such mutations occur in the germ line, they become heritable.

A constant loss of CpGs over thousands of generations

can explain the low frequency of this

special dinucleotide in the genomes of human and mouse.


Modeling Cell Fate

5-methyl-cytosine thymine

effects in chromatin organization affect gene expression

Schematic of the reversible changes in chromatin organization that influence

gene expression:

genes are expressed (switched on) when the chromatin is open (active), and they

are inactivated (switched off) when the chromatin is condensed (silent).

White circles = unmethylated cytosines;

red circles = methylated cytosines. Rodenhiser, Mann, CMAJ 174, 341 (2006)


Modeling Cell Fate

Enzymes that controlDNA methylation and histone modfications

These dynamic chromatin states are controlled by reversible

epigenetic patterns of DNA methylation and histone modifications.

Enzymes involved in this process include

- DNA methyltransferases (DNMTs),

- histone deacetylases (HDACs),

- histone acetylases,

- histone methyltransferases and the - methyl-binding domain protein MECP2.

For example, repetitive genomic sequences

(e.g. human endogenous retroviral sequences

= HERVs) are heavily methylated,

which means transcriptionally silenced. Rodenhiser, Mann, CMAJ 174, 341 (2006)Feinberg AP & Tycko P (2004) Nature Reviews: 143-153


Modeling Cell Fate

DNA methylationTypically, unmethylated clusters of CpG pairs are located in

tissue-specific genes and in essential housekeeping genes.

(House-keeping genes are involved in routine maintenance roles and are expressed in most tissues.)

These clusters, or CpG islands, are targets for proteins

that bind to unmethylated CpGs and initiate gene transcription.

In contrast, methylated CpGs are generally associated with silent DNA,

can block methylation-sensitive proteins and can be easily mutated.

The loss of normal DNA methylation patterns is the

best understood epigenetic cause of disease.

In animal experiments, the removal of genes that encode DNMTs is lethal;

in humans, overexpression of these enzymes has been linked

to a variety of cancers.Rodenhiser, Mann, CMAJ 174, 341 (2006)


Modeling Cell Fate

Differentiation linked to alterations of chromatin structure


Modeling Cell Fate

ML Suva et al. Science 2013;339:1567-1570

(B) Upon differentiation, inactive genomic regions may be sequestered by repressive chromatin enriched for characteristic histone modifications.

(A) In pluripotent cells, chromatin is hyperdynamic and globally accessible.

Epigenetic stability

Cantone & Fisher,

Nature Struct Mol

Biol. 20, 292 (2013)

In somatic tissues, CpG islands at housekeeping or developmental promoters are largely unmethylated, whereas non-regulatory CpGs distributed elsewhere in the genome are largely methylated.

This DNA methylation landscape is relatively static across all somatic tissues.

Most of methylated CpGs are pre-established and inherited through cell division.

In at least two phases of the life cycle of mammals, epigenetic stability is globally perturbed: -when gametes fuse to form the zygote and -when gamete precursors (primordial germ cells; PGCs) develop and migrate in the embryo.

This in vivo ‘reprogramming’ of the epigenetic landscape signals the reacquisition of totipotency in the zygote and the formation of the next generation through PGCs.


Modeling Cell Fate

30

Waddington: Epigenetic landscape

Modeling Cell FateSS 2015 – lecture 8

Konrad Hochedlinger and Kathrin Plath,

Development 136, 509-523 (2009)

Conrad H. Waddington 1956: "Principles of Embryology“; www.nature.com

Epigenetic changes during in vivo reprogramming

Cantone & Fisher,

Nature Struct Mol

Biol. 20, 292 (2013)

Global DNA and histone modifi-cations that lead to transcriptional activation of the embryonic genome between the late zygote (paternal genome only) and the 2-cell stage.

Protamines are small, arginine-rich, nuclear proteins that replace histones late in the haploid phase of spermatogenesis and are believed essential for sperm head conden-sation and DNA stabilization. In humans, 10-15% of the sperm's genome is packaged by histones thought to bind genes that are essential for early embryonic development (www.wikipedia.org).


Modeling Cell Fate

Gamete genomes undergo different epigenetic programs after fertilization.

The paternal genome is mostly subject to epigenetic remodeling at the zygote stage. The maternal genome gradually loses repressive modifications during the subsequent cleavage divisions.

Epigenetic changes during germline development

Cantone & Fisher,

Nature Struct Mol

Biol. 20, 292 (2013)

Global epigenetic changes during germline development from PGC specification (E6.5) to the mitotic/meiotic arrest at E13.5.

Two major reprogramming phases can be distinguished during PGC migration toward the genital ridges (E7.5–E10.5) and upon their arrival into the gonads (E10.5–E12.5).


Modeling Cell Fate

V8: Hematopoeisis Moignard et al., Nature Biotech. 33, 269 (2015) Blood has long served as a model...

Documents

Transcript of V8: Hematopoeisis Moignard et al., Nature Biotech. 33, 269 (2015) Blood has long served as a model...