v. COA Statement...3 Uh, we will resume, uh, her testimony as soon as she is 4 here. 5 Uh, before...

11
No. 71628-0-1 IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON DIVISION ONE STATE OF WASHINGTON, Respondent, v. DARYL BERRY, Appellant. STATEMENT OF ADDITIONAL GROUNDS FOR REVIEW . . ... '-- .. ... .... .. ..• !" -' . ! ' . {,. : . ! (,,;1 ....

Transcript of v. COA Statement...3 Uh, we will resume, uh, her testimony as soon as she is 4 here. 5 Uh, before...

No. 71628-0-1

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF WASHINGTON,

Respondent,

v.

DARYL BERRY,

Appellant.

STATEMENT OF ADDITIONAL GROUNDS FOR REVIEW

;~ . . ...

{:-:~- '-- ..... ...... ....• !" -' . ! ' .

{,. : .

! (,,;1 ....

:",~ :o, ~ ,' , '

!

~~:~~~~bJJPL1CjL ~!t~15 _~&*7i62<s~o-l_ , \(\- .. ~ S f r NO --J ' . OJ (i i

, ~)\\\>-'Y\\ . ,fA Qe ' 'tH?L"6"O-, l':") --\-iQ~~b'''LK~

'II~'\\\"~ L. A Jd,' h "n ~ l-; 5 S iA ~ )) '--.::1i;;;re'1U'-'-'1~:tI:=~g;;;:i?lL-;:;-;1 b--:::" Z-~S-::=--. ------QLj[ £An lJ..pp~llO-.te. LOLlV+ to r e..v ers~fi\.Q.. JLA J9M~1t-on t-h'f- I~~v on fl-t.c bQ)iS' of (I) /eSoJ eff'ors-thoJ--

: d -e. po' iff J CJ 6 /,I of Q £oJ,'rrn1et l Or (1-) l -~ 5 ully

; J\5ut.fl< C.I\:'il{-e.'Jl'd·~I\('~ +0 ~v..p port fill t.a(\\f:(.t~ cdI'[

06uMCtV ?e..-tK (eveT)Q{ {)f\ +l1:c La),J 01\ 5r()L~J\d.5

ot- 1~5cd err6r5 f~t dtprl'v-tALj>U ()t-~ -Ga.l V-

tr;{Jf h,c\.v ~ pr6p,e..d y pr-CS '{l~v'eJ H'\;e..s't ext-6r~ I, i, VV' ["tV; C W,' ( ),'>, ) -t,',r~o t~ € 0, ~5 ,e,\f" ~ Ii ~l\ t; c,-ry (~F Vl~ 5 [4) PmS-e...cufo!5 /'ltSc.onJlALt L'I) 'YVtpreper JM~ lift~tr[(Lt;DlLS (~ ,'WlfHlPf-1' ,'nt!u.<ulC( 01'1. tk't iwry No+~ ! "rl~ +h (f"t l\.V't? Mo,.Jty 0 t~~~r pc+t~'\+-i\:d It ~ ell t'(t-OI:J

i CAntll S PO#t'rt) MtJ11. reqlv're5+hor6tA7k -fC~j~l' [I(~r;ty \rJ/fh (--el t..\JCAJ1+ boclt'ts ot {<X-~V (lnt-t L\cl;'n~ e.\J~-l.t.U\[t-

I t o-.\,V Ct;m ;'n~l fro c.-echur-L C\'f)Q stC\+c. MA {2{ cl~rtAl . Con)+tt-t\.t~onQl l~\JlJ Ly0iJ. CRbV1Cf.. b £- r(A-r/€.d..

how {}J "(v 0 VLL 5) Co u. 'ft t S cJu's ;11 (' S 5 eel 0 n (l r peed

lor i Yl ~ pC>S+-'-'~llJs rVle..n\- ()rJ~f{~) ~ott ll/leJ.,y abo 5<L<1~

I V' £v"-'~Ql OIL Pc,,- leulv' 0 i\ 910 \-li'\ds d' (escd ;'IlS u#:~ -ei\(y LeJ~{ i~15' !-4/Ci'e i1Cy fVl~Q)15 ~hkt- ~e. t\j; \'~e h l..G

I p r .os\: Il ~e,{ bv +1-. e. pro) nilt-; on N of <;u N' I ~ " 'i'lll- 1-0 pro K a II , lne~*,-ss"'ry 'doY\«-l1f5 {i,etJim<& wlt.'ch Wer{. CorI\; ; (}eel.

I ~. e,~~ havd3)5eV\-t (\,\c: f\<;; H iSTOrt prfor-iD \ I f· 1.. r- ,J I r () ~ f\ T L (\Ih \It f. "tl (") h~

, i'

' " .f

, t ',-

'\ :'f"-

V"' Q(\' "\;F

"- ~Z'\,f .f~~ "

6

9

13

15

Page 7 1 0f ttl1G1.

p(~'j{. '6

5 Ltpe r(fJ 0 L':S -L -l 0 Dbb <-.r- \V

Itf yO~~ ~Nb"lllo 'l ~-U' 140 - --

/1fv\~Ncl /V\~,~-l;SM; S~·~ ~

jury has been, uh, held in abeyance, urn, for an hour. And

that may, uh, be attributed to Mr. Berry, even if it's

subconsciously. -'- ,.---:=-~---~~

,.....- " / At this point, the Defense would ask the Court to

inquire is the State ready to go forward. And if not, then

this, uh, Counsel for Mr. Berry would ask that this matter

~--- '

- ." ". ' . . c •. __ •. __ ' _" " "~

inclined, the D~ieri-seask's-'- that the Court inquire promptly

at 10:00 a.m. whether or not the State is ready to move

forward. And if the Court is, uh -- strike that -- if the

State is not ready to move forward at that time, based upon

Ms. Stump, uh, then the Defense would ask that this matter

!.:'?"'t. ... ,

& '''~1-6-----he _di§lIl2:sseq!_, __ Tbank you, Your Honor. . '_ , - .c· ._ . ... ••· ,- - ,. - -~_---..._. ___ •• _ .. _ ' . ____ , . ~ , . ___ ----

17 THE COURT: All right. Thank you. The objection is

18 noted, urn, for the record. Uh, uh, it's, urn, overruled.

19 The oral motion to dismiss is denied. Urn, the

2 0 circumstances, uh, urn -- the -- the Court has, uh -- is

21 accepting the recitation of the State that this is

2 2 something that just carne up this morning. Uh, we did

23 expect to start at 9:00. A number of things have delayed

24 this trial. Unfortunately, our jury's had to wait for any

2 5 number of reasons, s ometimes because of the Court, CATHERINE M. VERNON & ASSOCIATES , LLC

3641 North Pearl Street, Building 0, Tacoma, WA 98 407 - (253) 627- 2062

L Page 8 of 140

1 sometimes because of Counsel. And, uh, now we're going to

2 have a bit of a delay while, uh, Ms., uh, Stump gets here.

3 Uh, we will resume, uh, her testimony as soon as she is

4 here.

5 Uh, before the Court recesses, until that point, I

6 will, uh -- although I have not completed my review of the

7 instructions, I've, uh, done enough on it that I have a few

8 questions that may assist the Court in, uh, at least

9 putting together its, uh, final version. Uh, first of all,

10 uh, to address the, urn, uh, Defense, uh, uh in --

11 instruction -- I appreciate, uh, getting those. Urn, uh,

12 but one thing, just to confirm, uh, the Court infers

13 just wanted to confirm on the record that, uh, Defense

14 Counsel, uh, does agree, at this point, that

15 instruction would not apply in this case and

the ~etrich 1-I

that's why

and

---~--.-->. . ! ---~~- ----.. = ------16 it's not propos~by anyone. {

-.--~~ 17 MS. KEMP: Yes, Your Honor.

18 THE COURT: All right. The record will so reflect.

19 The, urn -- the, urn --

20 MS. WASHINGTON: And, Your Honor, can I briefly --

21 sorry -- urn, just so the record is clear, I'm sure any

22 Appellate Court listening to this would understand what a

23 Petrich instruction is. I just wanted to clear that. It

24 Le ~ I )/t'.: S'«

is WPIC 4.25. - .(t<." P~:J~t~c1: 2 25 THE COURT: Thank you. The record --

CATHERINE M. VERNON & ASSOCIATES, LLC 3641 North Pearl Street, Building D, Tacoma, WA 98407 - (253) 627-2062

j

i

fr[~ .. :.i~§e Wlu HW &1.6N~Sr(~~y~; o~:i:~;::0 ~ . ~ . ID~r(.1 L-. L .Gti11CtL .'B:trci . ~(£7qb~C;-\ . . .~ . .. i >~.pe.t!: oL/\JQ;1]·.~J=LDtbb11J~Nl .. ~~cldsN Pt .] l b2k-.11'=::::£;-1. ---=-,~=-:-. 1- .. pCQ1)¥_ .. _. Vi6LATl O~~ I 'Bmclyvs,f&£.S1<1:tL QIMo,r4 LCLM1 '313, US':i'3j

j 10 Le-.J . ·2.15i~35. _Lt:JJqHl L9h3)+ht-i:f:-l Tool- +0 ! Vt[I' ,A/lie'/Jc= . L . _h.Odff.. ._ o._CQN5-ta~: Lt, 1=,' DtJ! Al .K ~ '5' Ht .. 1 •

j,Ot .... ' . l!.~·tBJ~Vj·.ew ._. ±he. ... \itctLi\f~ _ ~ N /YJ y ... c~s :e. .... )~;tL ( I \J; .~tl<f .. t\iJ . _Q. .tJ J:) .5 J-LQwf 6 rth t.. . i~ t f-Y' Vl£:\iV ;

tH~I\J .. - ~Oi&~-.C,\\"'B .... .c\-..... -M-cl:\Q.'A ..... Lsc\~~~Drl)_.\js, .. th.~ 15h:l-:t? b .f . \\i~S\{~ t~ ) ~0N)\~ Lb. \"3 5 ~ J-W\{ '\ Ct-i . If'J\t-.lAN..SNo\Ect\N\ . f\to CC\S-tjf~'!. ; . .... _ .. _.M ____ __ __ · .... - - _ .. C;Rc~\JtarD - \J \D\..-O\;t\ QN~_ \

~ ._ Ll/Y\oJLNO'-m-e~ C6.nv~ H e.l'a.tL1 t/.NL>. SH~ \'\1

... l CrQ\w.£0rD . ~:s - +h~St~\-tL o-~ W~S\:Cl N 9t~C\) J~jS. . I (t-j . 135tfl~QQ~-).tkttLS Su.p(~N\t- . [OLU,tt1C\.\)e..

jIte bt-~\ . . 1hf~{-'toL\L-L . StQ1:-e.}\l\LNJs Ct l \ 1o..v~S bJtLt~tv\s5\:~\t'C!'A",<JJ-\-)1L~NNa .kof\J~\~' 'b-(. U5e..D J It f'J .+rI (\\-\\-th~\t ·~Ltl\\J\~ .s . !\fO±- . Pr e.SQ Nt\{) ~

I t-est~\tYH +6StACJi . fVLy·tNkJ~-# . 'i\" J..h /' 'l· r--. 1 ' bi/O'3Y u k O at

l V/(iJ().-,b\Of~ otf~hts ... prO)( ; f'vlclte.l" . LCkU.$~~kJy~,- r'U~f\f IClL-DnstV'Lct{f tol6r Ok 50~-<L\Y\c.\. r€.~tTG,-l I~~ I ,~

1 A ~ K l~ ~ tJ ( l'r, I t' /) J ¥ 1 l- (k~~'V\\lssed [(1 )t~

i

1[4) ,. j R

______ ~ocS-f _ __ _On m__ m &~;DI1j loc<J.!!I\;st6 o.J _ _ __ _ 5 iA p.::(v~f\lQ,J~,:bD'{b.!,-U V - _ , _ _ ___ _

---------- --- --1- _-,d- __ p-e~l5NQ~JLb~2-[:Q·~J;J -Cj~-clcL~J-LDJtC~t~=J))j,-\;~5) ------- -- ---- --~S, kJi..41[2:;" (ILif. !1I2L _TtnMo.v :f)~ 'J --i'1l(Affi; :;J:[;"L 'i3R.~ ---- - -----.-.. . ----- - . ..--_l~Pj,\,t=.-~-t-lCRbL--- hQ~ -. -~·iJJ.~-~JA L±y-.. £~Yb~A-.-k~ - --b~l ~jlV\it\5- .--... ---..-.- . ---. __ . __ .. __ _ ___ -----I-c?f---th:s ... -prof. ~.d(&C~ . __ .\1J_~il __ re-~~~t __ if? .±--~th __ ~.B<e.K:y\) ___ _ _

_ J Ck . , t\i\t5J'I~pJ~::tiL( .f{Of]Ot _.tJe<\(_fho...t __ whe.J\' _ th.'f- -<~te,_ i .-l

_. _____ --. -----.--.-. ----l ClMfJl ~t~~ - -:±h-"---- (.-hO"':8e5 - --- _lhvJ~ ___ 5erc1 -... h&s ____ ht?gtt _C()rJG\.S~ _ ,

-... ----- - --· · -----11~tQ±-- -.b~-e-,~--9:}1~- . iQ _. Ltv\d. ~f~:f Mel _iJ.E\J.J __ th~r9 ?)-.5(.(fCt --. --_ ______ _ ______ jIU\._L!'J ()tb~~l1.cJ,e._ fa ---fiX, ssbJ-_1-til! Vl-5~ (-----1U-:121'11d:\,,,, A,'1_ ------- ----------------___ . _. ___________ __ J~~J\Am £.-l1t --w~S . ~'lc~cL·c __ LD-u..v~6f.L ·-{'ox: ±b:L . 'D eA~·_e_U}s_? __ ._. _______ __ __ __. _._

---- -- --- - -j tifJlC~~~~-}~:tj~:~{)JT~~§~"-d~~o~~:re:J~~c.~ K~ - --- ---__ . __ ._ .. ____ . ___ . _;+h~ ___ L{1lt~ ___ . ~ __ ._~~ jL_±b~t --.---~m5 J -. --- !el - of. ~l\ .

I 1} . . --- - .. -. ----I ~ -- 9a()c\. -- .. ·~/Jh. - L\.r3~l!1'(!\ffO -. 6h/J?c-t - ±6±h~ __ _______ . _____ . +~m.'f11clt11:eJ'I,tQJ:. ih:tc - (hG'r~:~s .±he. .. 1~s:~~Jlfi~L _

I

-.~ -- . -.-. ... . . . · · --- ·~IJ3k(~1R-cy .. - ..Lh~~ ~~s ___ . -~j - - . L--t-ci- ~~.~\'l .. --\JJ ;{~~.-Jhe__ --E~~f31 c',JlI · -.... -

_______ __ .. __ . __ __ ._._! ;' l!Llk~ __ ._flr5t---- 1).e.:)r-'t---~- i~"IA.t':~ e L ___ h~\.d., ... -. \~.:ert~D~pc~t~ . .-- ... ... _

_____ .. _. _._ ... j_ b~SgJ __ -Qll-__ ~~S.CJ~5);DnS~.tfh_ .. ~ht .... ~+aJe-. ... Be-r(~ ... d;~cL __ ~I\Pt __ .. . .... . __ _

___ ........... j __ tA-.ncL'e..f·5'+QJ'\..~ .. C~\tl _. __ ~~-\_ _h'L_ .. _ 'do~ c!. __ J\~e~_ ... M or£-.- .-. I

___ __ .... _ .. _ ... _j ___ t_llh:L .. __ QC __ C_Q':-~v~5:~J_ _\v~ul~-j\~f~- - ....so .IY\.~ - ~ \t~~\.~ OX\ . .. __ I

.. _____ . ~ .. ~[\ -. ..LI1M~tU\~L~"t . ~J!l~ .. --±Q- - B~C(i --. - -- ..... .-- .. -- .. -- -.. --- .-.-- .-. I . ··_-t · -,--.- . ~ - -- -,_. . --... -.. - .~ .. --.. --. I

I , I

I . L ..

1 I

!

-' . . I (!f) Pttjt .

RECEIVED ------------;JmlA/v-fr;Zz014

-~-__+li_0....L~~-..lUl~44-'-~--t-- ~----/-...nJU:tflD6E-jA . HITE

/ ------~---~-I ------~----~--~L--~~

1./

II II

I hd\Vt. Gl CoN,~+;}tJ.+;b(vLtL P":sHf fo NO[;J~llt- r iu'\.5 b~fn [h(\,fStcJ

\fJ/+h 1-- ~{'Uje.. 0-.- COfv5+-/-It.A+i'ONC\./r l,\i1cl .AfVlfr\fJ*1-eVt ·~ CAh(A

MClr r; (~)t. r/~hf- to ,tff~ct; Ii ~ QtJ') ~5+?lJ~(C 0 f- L-1J0..fl'5'<.l 8e-fl~

['5 NOt- O-bk to iv\deI)'h\Jvl iJvh(\.t- 'd- ~st~6>t h~ .been Chcu,)<:.t".

5(f~ AMtNd.M<..Nt ~;'5tlf X cli{,t fJD~ 9crr-- out ~;J 1 wetS ·""~{t.\~\--~rre:st-;Ytr~ To ~ I< ~ cI. U.'?i1.ttt5f- 0 f M r r; A v-Go.k i 0 rJ Alt.lt\Jl f-<t5 <C (j f Dl5~bd,ty g; D~t-CheyyL /), CCLrey w~5 /vLy Jtt(,~,~ on (;L in~4<~c;,:t-:orv o~ .rJo LCN{o.C+ on:ler W()..S (t~5M~S5

,NO L.ItS<: LoLU+ crd-er t\SLl~J ~-Q..l.Q{l)€d 2.J30U14tf (: NO·itI3,~q6)'~l ') NO CL()~ l'\~ focoJ~(.\ 1)(~+lZrC T Cou.r+

~ f '3 - 6~c.,$~11 . JU 0'3 e:- L(\~~ey ~·.iA-Sf1y JLAc[9~NO J;.ywtl.Lfe.. iltVc'JtjL'j{tf/()1v ~1:'ON-htf JtLclS~ Cct.rFY th-e du-JCJ~ I\J D C~Q5'e ~Lf WHa-t- Dettblz JQob:\ftl'{ :r GJ~s IJ6t- 'Rele,~5ec\ -PO(Yl

ere\.: [ /n &~tNei.;J LHQnc'c ,,H€- C~\; &sc:is All the TLM fS We:sf's f.((jj;se! L,D~ of w,,';K;"'')+o/\ UNAI\lr:Jg+~ted .-+~tl 'e. Q4,. ~J'O-~ H~fVS+ON LrCtV\~I\JllL C orlt tUa.pte r <lA, ,-/0 ~ K~cL I'JL\.PP{\j~

UJV La..wF ilL ;-N1 pr~ 50 {V fr1 eIU -t- L\.J\£1 t.tls t () cl tc~L- ~ .1\1 f e,(.t f-fG,{0 CL ..

'7(ult ~IS U5·~ .. at f\(~~Leubt~G £!1tQL$AtJ~DL fuvt5~ .)hR({N'ot-­if~tfl1,l:-tttJJtc\.{(y cl;'SL[ b)C OY USc N'o,fJfUbL'L j(jI\,tor~k~otV G\€.qLtireJ.

j'i\tl fud/Cl1Ck.1 LQPClL~-ty-fDr fAf\y plAr pose unr-e6t-ecl +0 --{if\.~. crud..cyej 1L\'~ ~c~cJ d ut ,'e5,

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF KING

STATE OF WASHINGTON, ) )

Plaintiff,

v.

) No. 13-1-10866-2 KNT )

) Court of Appeals No.: ) 71628-0-1

; ?roJ /h.r<f... ~ 'C(;rrL~ f\Ql h.~5+oy ; J7 --e.~ A\\ OR +h~ ~ O-.Cvf...-

DARYL LAMAR BERRY,

Defendant. ') (11/' J

)

) EXCERPT OF VERBATIM REPORT OF PROCEEDINGS

(FROM TAPED PROCEEDINGS) VOLUME VII

BE IT REMEMBERED that the foregoing and numbered proceeding was heard on December 12, 2013~ before THE HONORABLE JAY WHITE, Judge.

LAKEYSHA WASHINGTON, Deputy Prosecuting Attorney, 401 4th Avenue North, #2A, Kent, WA 98032, appearing on behalf of the Plaintiff;

TERI R. KEMP, Attorney at Law, PO Box 3454, Seattle, WA 98114, appearing on behalf of the Defendant, who also appeared. .

Lr~~tr~cn)~~mm~~rie(V\; f~' I

WHEREUPON, the following proceedings were had and done,

to?-/); ,1"0 U/ {1 --1J. ~ JA'/ yJH;r£ ~r- S:~ II I" .. " ~ JfJ.o .J

CATHERINE M. VERNON & ASSOCIATES, LLC -~ ,"",.,' l_"~~ n '1'=>rnm.=.. WA 98407 - (253) 627-2062

· 1 Cg~ P~:re-

5~9J\'Ll{-~(~ 01l th:-e... l-e-tt-(;( 'f- d..e.(\~·fe.. UY\cl~Jr

p.e.Julity0!:- pe,\' ~O--Yy f-h.Dl+ f-h--c bOI'L9 0;i\{ 0 . /5' ffitt-(uiL(,{ tcJrrf,t+C~<-c~ted.. on. .

,-t2--J-lLf -dtJ(t-L--Jlew7~ ~-

~;~Y\~tLl{·-L .

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON DIVISION ONE

STATE OF WASHINGTON,

Respondent,

v.

DARYL BERRY,

Appellant.

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

NO. 71628-0-1

DECLARATION OF DOCUMENT FILING AND SERVICE

I, MARIA ANA ARRANZA RILEY, STATE THAT ON THE 4TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2014, I CAUSED THE ORIGINAL STATEMENT OF ADDITIONAL GROUNDS FOR REVIEW TO BE FILED IN THE COURT OF APPEALS - DIVISION ONE AND A TRUE COPY OF THE SAME TO BE SERVED ON THE FOLLOWING IN THE MANNER INDICATED BELOW:

[X] STEPHANIE GUTHRIE, DPA [[email protected]] KING COUNTY PROSECUTOR'S OFFICE APPELLATE UNIT 516 THIRD AVENUE, W-554 SEATTLE, WA 98104

(X) U.S. MAIL () HAND DELIVERY () E-MAIL BY AGREEMENT

VIA COA PORTAL

SIGNED IN SEATTLE, WASHINGTON THIS 4TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2014.

X----f--f1-/\J-

washington Appellate Project 701 Melbourne Tower 1511 Third Avenue seattle, WA 98101 Phone (206) 587-2711 Fax (206) 587-2710