UTEN Workshop Negotiation of R&D...
-
Upload
hoangthuan -
Category
Documents
-
view
215 -
download
0
Transcript of UTEN Workshop Negotiation of R&D...
© Fraunhofer
UTEN WorkshopNegotiation of R&D contractstraining session – University of Porto
Porto, December 2011
Dr. Lorenz KaiserDivision Director Legal Affairs and Contracts Fraunhofer Headquarter
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 2
Fraunhofer profile in 2011
60 Institutes at 40 locations
17 000 employees
about € 1.7 billionresearch budget
7 Alliances Information and Communication Technology Life Sciences Materials and Components Microelectronics Production Surface Technology and Photonics
Defense and Security
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
Food should be delicious, healthy and sustainably produced.
Researchers are working on new methods to use as many parts of plants as possible for nutrition. In the future, vegetable ingredients could replace animal raw materials. Lupin seeds, for instance, can be used to produce low-fat, exquisite sausage products.
© Fraunhofer IVV
Eating low-fat, thanks to lupin proteins
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
Wounds have to be regularly checked, to make sure any complications in the healing process are detected at an early stage.
A new material will make it possible to check wounds without changing the dressing: If an infection arises, the material changes its color.
© Fraunhofer EMFT
Dressing indicates infections
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
Flexible yet rigid like a human bone, and immediately capable of bearing loads: A new kind of implant, made of titanium foam, resembles the inside of a bone in terms of its structural configuration.
Not only does this make it less stiff than conventional massive implants. It also promotes ingrowth into surrounding bones.
© Fraunhofer IFAM
Titanium foams replace injured bones
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
Many of the world's remote areas with water shortages also have three things in abundance: Sun, wind and sea
How renewable energies can be harnessed more effectively in the future to transform salty seawater and brackish water into drinking water is the subject of a current study issued by an EU initiative dubbed »ProDes«. © Fraunhofer ISE
Solar ray converts sea into drinking water
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
Know-how protection in the Preparation Phase
8
Naive trust in the confidentiality obligation of the partner
Missing factual control mechanisms of own Know-how
Unprotected exchange of Know- how in the preparation phase
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 9
The use of non disclosure agreements for damage compensation in case of breach of confidentiality??
Most Legal Systems do not compensate the real loss in case of breach of confidentiality.
Disadvantage in competition cannot be figured out
No legislation about this question available (at least not in Germany)
Consequence
Find additional effective technical protection of your IPesp. protect electronic data against espionage
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 10
Essential measures for know-how protection
Legal: Confidentiality Agreements with satisfactory rules
Check rules of labour contracts about confidentiality clauses,also "for the time after"
IP - Professionals for Contract-Negotiations
Check, observe and complete patent portefolio
Technical:
Control electronic data, seperate internal server recommendedwith reduced access to sensitive data
Remove Mobiles and Memory Sticks out of the meetings
Install a person responsible for Know-how protection
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 11
JOSEPH VON FRAUNHOFER-AWARD 2009
Coining by blast with explosive agents to create holographic structures in steel as protection against counterfeiting expensive metal spare parts of machines and automobile parts.
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 12
Forms of non disclosure agreements
NDA
Identification of confidential information
Consequences in case of breach of confidentiality
UnilateralObligation
Bi- and MultilateralMutual Obligation
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 13
Non disclosure agreement
Content
Definition of Confidential Information/Materials/Samples Broad Definition (common) Listing in Attachment (exception) Marking as Confidential (US)
Right to use and Return of Papers/Materials/SamplesNo confidentiality time limits publicly known/free accessable Exception Clauses
No commitment about ownership of IPLiquidated Damages
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 14
Contracts for the performance of R&D projects
contract research (vertical)
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 15
Success and failure close togetherThe different applications of service-robots
WindowcleaningEntertainment / Info / Guidance
Inspection of chemical facilities
Maintenance and Inspection
Floorcleaning
Hospital Guarding Manufacturing
Housekeeping
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
© pi4_workerbot
A robot with finger-tip sensitivity
Two arms, three cameras, finger-tip sensitivity and a variety of facial expressions – these are the distinguishing features of the pi4-workerbot. Similar in size to a human being, it can be employed at any modern workstation in an industrial manufacturing environment.
Its purpose is to help keep European production competitive.
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 17
General FhG IP-strategie for contract-research foreground
FhG
ownership, unlimited exclusive right of use of FhG Foreground IP
Client
loses Foreground IP
FhG Client
keeps Foreground IP
non-exclusive/optional exclusive rights on FhG Foreground limited to the defined field of use
Exception
The exception applies to individual cases, in the event, that multiple exploition is not realistic (low exploitation potential, low exploitation power), FhI's portfolio serves as an indicator
Rule
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 18
The »Rights-to-the-Results-Problem« of contract research
field of application exklusive
option for another fields of application
other fields of applicaton to be negotiated
field of application for third paty (comeptitor!)
other field of application non exclusive
field of application exclusive for a limited time period
Property
Patents a.o.
Know-how
Rights to the Results
usual industry position: overall property of IP in contract research
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 19
R&D - results: contracted to client - foreground
Know-howCopyrights
non - exclusive
royalty - free license
for the field of application
on which the R&D contractis based
exclusive license
for the field of application
on which the R&D contractis based
Know-hownon – exclusive
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 20
R&D results: contracted to client - foreground
Inventions/Patents
or
non - exclusive
royalty - free licensefor the purpose of application on which the R&D contract is basedinventors fee (+)costs for registration, maintenance and defence -partial reimbursement - (+)
exclusive
royalty - bearing licensefor the purpose of application on which the R&D contract is based
FhG retains non - exclusive right of use for R&D purposes
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 21
royalty - bearingnecessary for exploitation
of the client
non - exclusive
R&D - Background - a crucial pint in any kind of cooperation
Background IPTake Care of your Background
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 22
Functions of IP in a research organization depending on the form of cooperation
IP as asset for securing a position in technology
IP as patent manifesting market power
IP as aquisition instrument for business
IP as defending instrument against competitors
IP as basis for licence revenues
IP as incentive and motivation of staff
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 23
Warranty in R&D projects
Defect of titleFree and clear of any third party rights
Defect of qualityBenefits offered in R&D
State of the art
Definition of defect in R&D
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 24
R&D contract - legal background for warranty remedies
Contract for workand services
(Contrato de empreitada)
Contract for service
(Contrato de prestacao de servicio)
obligation to reach a result; guarantee for
success
Obligation to provide services;
performance, no guarantee for success
Product, Prototype
Applied Research Basic Research
Service
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 25
The enforcement problem in R&D contracts
Client: guarantee for no conflicting rights in the commercialisation phase
R&D Performer: No guarantee, but hold harmless against third party claims
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 26
Contractual solutions to remedy infringement of third party rights
IndemnitySolution
SearchSolution
TechnicalSolution
LicensingSolution
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 27
Cooperation Contract
between science and industry(horizontal)
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 28
Fleeces as »skeleton« for artificial tissues
Cartilages, sinews, bloodvessels may be produces in laboratories soon.
The respective cells will be breeded on a cavernous skeleton i.e. on fleeces.
A new software helps to characterize and optimize these fleeces
© Fraunhofer IWMRuptured fiber after a pull out test in a Microtest machine
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 29
Safely anchored at sea
Different layers of the seabed reflect sound waves in a specific way.
Researchers are harnessing the benefits of this fact to efficiently track down suitable offshore sites for wind energy plants.
They use pressurized cannons, which emit acoustic signals that are recorded by underwater microphones.
© Fraunhofer IWES
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 30
R & D - collaborative research between science and industry
Research Insitute
i.e. FhG
IndustrialPartner University
Cooperation based on division of labour and exchange of information/results
Most difficult question:
User rights
for commercialisation
non-exclusive ?
royalties (for research)
state aid topic !!!!
art. 3 of Framework
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 31
Rights of Use in collaborative (and funded) research
Foreground Background
For the duration of the project
• non-exclusive rights
• royalty free
Beyond it, especially for commercial exploitation of the results
PRO‘s Position
•non-exclusive rights
• against royalties
Industry Position
Exclusive right
Royalty free
Where required for the exploitation of the results
• non- exclusive rights
• against royalties
Where required for the execution of the project
• non-exclusive rights
• free or against royalties
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 32
Block exemptions with relevance for R&D contracts(Art. 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the EU)
Block-exemption for vertical agreements
Block exception for r&d agreements
Technology transfer block exemption
2010
2011 consultation
2004
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 33
Preconditions for exemptions of the R&D block exemption
Joint R&D - Art. 2 Nr. 111. Conditions for exemption of R&D cooperation
Joint R&D and joint (Art. 1a,b) or separate commercializationArt. 1 (1) c)
Market share threshold not exceeded Art. 4 - (Joint market shares of competitors may not exceed 25 % of the relevant market)
(Exemption for non-competitors for the duration of R&D project) No breach of black clauses (Art. 5 und 6) In case of separate commercialization access to the results for all partners. The
use for universities can be limited for research purposes
2. Noticability of restraint of competition
Art. 101 (1) of the treaty on the functioning of the European Union
3. Exception to antitrust? Art. 101
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal 34
EU Antitrust Law - R&D block exemption
Art. 5 Hardcore Restrictions Restricition of freedom to carry out r&d in a unconnected field or (after competion of
the project) in a related field
Limitation of output or sales (except by setting of production or sales targets
Fixing of prices
Restrictions of territory for passive sells
Requirement to make any sales to territory which is not supplied or where a specialization of one partner is denied
Requirement of making problems for resellers
Art. 6 Excluded Restrictions Prohibition of Challenge of IP after the completion of project
Requirement to not grant licenses unless one of the parties exploits in the internal market
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
Non Disclosure Agreement
Please check the following Non Disclosure Agreement and assess whether the grey highlighted clauses are
Standard Clauses ? Useful Clauses ? Dangerous Clauses ?
35
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft zur Förderung der angewandten Forschung e.V.Version 2002/II
Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft pursues exclusively and directly non-profit objectives, conducting contractual research in the field of applied research and breaking new ground in doing so. The following General Terms and Conditions reflect the nature of these objectives.
42
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft1. Scope of application
1.1 The following General Terms and Conditions shall apply to all research and development projects contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft. Divergent, contrary, or additional terms requested by the client shall not form part of the contract without the prior written consent of Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft. Where the following General Terms and Conditions do not provide any other regulation of the matter, the provisions of service contract law (Arts 611 et seq. German Civil Code) shall apply to all research and development contracts.
1.2 Where the following General Terms and Conditions provide the barring or limitation of damage liability of Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft, its legal representatives or agents, such barring or limitation shall not apply to liability for damages from injury to life, body, or health.
43
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft2. Object of the contract, period of performance
2.1 The research and development project shall comprise the work defined in the offer of Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft.
2.2 Where the offer or the research and development contract includes a period of performance or deadlines, these shall only be deemed to be binding after express acknowledgement by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft. Should Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft recognise that the binding period of performance or the binding deadline cannot be met then it shall notify the client of the reasons for delay and shall agree on an appropriate adjustment with the client.
44
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft3. Fee
3.1 The fee shall be a fixed price. Notwithstanding this, the contracting parties may agree that the fee will be charged according to cost, where applicable with a maximum cost limit. VAT shall be added to the fee in each case, if applicable.
3.2 Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall immediately notify the client if it foresees that the result intended by the research and development contract cannot be achieved at the agreed fee. Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall simultaneously propose an adjustment of the fee to the client. Should this be necessary for reasons which were neither foreseeable when the contract was concluded nor the responsibility of Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft and if no other agreement is reached with the client, then the adjustment proposed by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall be binding.
45
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft4. Payments
4.1 Payments shall be due according to the agreed payment schedule. In the absence of a payment schedule, the due date shall be the date stated in the invoice. Payments shall be made without a cash discount and with an indication of the invoice number and the performing Fraunhofer-Institute to the account designated by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft.
4.2 Setoff against claims of Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall only be allowed if the counterclaim is uncontested or if it is the subject of a final court decision.
4.3 The client may only exercise a right of retention if its counterclaim is based on the same contractual relationship.
46
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft5. Result of Research and Development, Rights of Use
5.1 The research and development result shall be made available to the client after completion of the project in accordance with the offer.
5.2 The client shall be granted a non-exclusive, royalty-free right of use for the purpose of application on which the contract is based to inventions generated during the performance of the project as well as to industrial property rights filed by and granted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft for these inventions. The client shall reimburse Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft an appropriate part of the costs for registration, maintenance and defence of the industrial property rights to be agreed upon between the contracting parties and shall pay, in case of use of the inventions, a comprehensive employee inventors fee, the amount of which shall be agreed in each individual case.
47
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
5.3 Upon request and in lieu of the right according to Section 5.2, the client shall be granted an exclusive, royalty bearing right of use for the purpose of application on which the contract is based to inventions generated during the performance of the project as well as to industrial property rights filed by and granted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft for these inventions. The request shall be made in writing addressed to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft, at the latest three months after the client's notification of the invention. Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall insofar retain a non-exclusive, royalty-free right of use for purposes of research and development.
5.4 The client shall be granted a non-exclusive, royalty-free right of use for the purpose of application on which the contract is based to copyright protected works, databases, and know-how created during the performance of the project. The granting of an exclusive right of use for the purpose of application on which the contract is based shall require a separate agreement.
48
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft5.5 Inventions jointly achieved by the contracting parties during the
performance of the project (joint inventions) may be used and licensed by each contracting party without any financial compensation. The contracting parties shall each bear a to be agreed portion of the costs for registration, maintenance and defence of the industrial property rights in question. In the case of copyright protected works jointly created during the performance of the contract (joint authorship) Section 5.5, sentence 1 shall apply correspondingly.
5.6 If during the performance of the contract already existing industrial property rights or copyrights of Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft are used which are required for the client's commercialisation of the result of the research and development project, then the client shall be granted a non-exclusive, royalty-bearing right of use under a separate agreement unless other obligations entered into by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft preclude this.
49
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft6. Third party property rights
6.1 Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall immediately notify the client of any third party industrial property rights of which it becomes aware during the performance of the contract and which could preclude the client’s use agreed pursuant to Section 5. The contracting parties shall decide in joint consultation how such industrial property rights shall be taken into consideration in the further performance of the project.
6.2 In the case of infringement of third party industrial property rights Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall be liable under the provisions of Sections 7.2 and 8.4, sentence 1 if it has violated its obligation to notify the client. Notwithstanding the liability under Section 8, the client shall have no further claims against Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft.
50
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft7. Liability
7.1 Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall be responsible for applying scientific care and for complying with accepted scientific standards but not for actually achieving the research and development goal.
7.2 The liability of Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft, its legal representatives and agents in the case of violation of obligations and tort shall be limited to intent and gross negligence. Only in case of violation of essential contractual obligations (cardinal obligations) Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft, its legal representatives and agents shall also be liable in case of slight negligence. In any case, liability shall be limited to the foreseeable, contractually typical damages.
7.3 Should Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft neither fulfil the performance as agreed upon nor do so at the time due nor in the manner agreed upon, then the client may only demand compensation in lieu of performance if the client has unsuccessfully set an appropriate deadline for the performance by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft including the
51
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft
statement that it would otherwise reject acceptance of the performance after the passing of that deadline.
8. Special conditions for delivery and work performance within the research and development project
8.1 Where Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft on the basis of an express commitment owes performance or delivery of work results corresponding to the accepted state-of-the-art as the result of research and development then in the case of defects the relevant provisions for sales contracts (Kaufrecht) and contracts for work and services (Werkvertragsrecht) shall only be applicable subject to the following Sections.
8.2 Should the result of the research and development work generated by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft prove to be defective, then Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall first be given the opportunity to supplementary performance - depending on the nature of the result of the research and development, the defect and other circumstances also repeatedly -either by means of remedying the defect or substitute delivery.
52
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft8.3 Should Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft reject supplementary performance or if
supplementary performance cannot be achieved or the client cannot reasonably be expected to accept supplementary performance, then the client may either terminate the contract or demand reduction of the fee owed (reduction) or damages. The right to termination may be exercised only in case of a serious defect. Such right lapses if the client does not declare the termination of the contract within 14 days after receiving notification of rejection or failure of supplementary performance or at the latest 14 days after the date at which it is recognised that the client cannot reasonably be expected to accept supplementary performance. Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall pay damages only under the further conditions of Section 7.2 and, if Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft has rejected supplementary performance, Section 7.3 shall apply also.
53
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft8.4 In the case of an infringement of third party intellectual property rights
Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall only be liable if such rights apply in the Federal Republic of Germany, if the client uses the research and development result in a manner consistent with the contract, if a court decision based on infringement by the client of third party intellectual property rights is rendered against the client, and if the client has immediately notified Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft in writing of the claims asserted by such third party. Supplementary performance under Section 8.2 will be carried out by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft by either obtaining a contractual authorisation for the client's use or by modifying the result of the research and development that the relevant third party intellectual property rights are no longer infringed.
8.5 The client shall immediately examine the research and development result supplied by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft and report any defects found without undue delay. Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft only warrants for recognisable defects if it has been notified thereof within a period of 14 days from the date of delivery.
54
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft8.6 Claims due to defects shall be statute-barred in accordance with the
provisions of Section 9.
9. Statutes of limitation
9.1 The claims of the client for breach of duty and tort shall be statute-barred within 12 months. This shall not apply where legislation prescribes longer periods of time in Arts 438, para 1, no 2, 479, para 1 (regress claim) and 634a, para 1, no 2, alt 1 (construction defects) German Civil Code or Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft is liable due to intent or gross negligence.
9.2 Should acceptance of the research and development result be agreed upon, the statute of limitations on claims due to defects pursuant to Section 9.1 shall commence upon acceptance, otherwise upon delivery.
9.3 Negotiations between the contracting parties over claims or over circumstances giving rise to claims shall suspend the statutes of limitation. The suspensive effect shall end if one of the contracting parties has not complied within four weeks with the request of the other contracting party to continue negotiations.
55
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft10. Retention of title
10.1 The client shall only be granted ownership to the result of the research and development as well as to the right of use according to Sections 5.2, 5.3, 5.4, and 5.6 after full payment of the agreed fee. Ownership and rights of use held by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft may neither be mortgaged nor transferred as security.
10.2 In the event that the ownership of Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft to the result of the research and development lapses through combination, commingling, or processing it is already hereby agreed that the ownership to the combined object created in such a case shall, until full payment of the agreed fee, be proportionally assigned (invoiced value) to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft.
10.3 In the event of onward sale of the result of the research and development, the client shall cede all rights in rem to onward sale to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft until full payment of the agreed fee.
56
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft11. Confidentiality
11.1 The contracting parties shall for the duration of the contract and for a period of five years after its termination not make accessible to third parties information of a technical or commercial nature disclosed to each other and declared to be confidential. This shall not apply to information known or generally accessible to the other contracting party or to the public, or information which becomes known or generally accessible to the public after disclosure without any involvement or fault on the part of the other contracting party, or correspond to information disclosed or made accessible to the other contracting party by an entitled third party, or independently developed by an employee of the other contracting party not in possession of the information disclosed.
57
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft11.2 Third parties within the meaning of this provision shall not include
subcontractors of Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft if these have been entrusted with a part of the services by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft within the context of the assignment and if they have been placed under an obligation of confidentiality.
12. Publication, advertising
12.1 The client shall be entitled to publish the result of the research and development including identification of the author or the Fraunhofer-Institute involved only after prior consultation of Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft. Such consultation shall take into consideration that, for instance, dissertations, master's theses or applications, and/or registrations of intellectual property rights are not impaired. For purposes of advertising, the client may only mention the name of Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft or of the Fraunhofer-Institute involved with their express consent.
58
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft12.2 Publications by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft relating to the purpose
of application on which the contract is based and for which the client has been granted an exclusive licence as specified in Section 5.3, shall only be made after consultation with the client in due time prior to publication.
13. Termination
13.1 Should no essential progress in work have been achieved within a significant period of performance then each contracting party shall be entitled to terminate the contract with one month notice to the end of a calendar month. However, termination is excluded within a six months period since the beginning of the contract. Except as provided in this Section 13, there shall be no further right of termination.
13.2 Each contracting party shall be entitled to terminate the contract with immediate effect for good cause.
59
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft13.3 Upon termination Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall submit within four
weeks the result of the research and development achieved until expiry of the period of notice. The client shall be obliged to compensate Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft for costs incurred up to the expiry of the period of notice. Personnel costs shall be reimbursed as incurred up to the date of termination. In the event that the termination is due to a fault by one of the contracting parties, this shall not affect damage compensation claims.
14. Miscellaneous
14.1 Ancillary understandings, amendments and supplements hereto must be made in writing.
14.2 Place of performance for Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft shall be the place of business of the Fraunhofer-Institute involved. Place of performance for payments by the client shall be Munich.
60
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
14.3 This contract shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the Federal Republic of Germany. The United Nations Convention on the International Sale of Goods (CISG) shall not apply.
14.4 Should one or more provisions of these General Terms and Conditions be or become fully or partially void then the validity of the remaining provisions shall remain unaffected. The same shall apply in the case of a gap in the provisions of these General Terms and Conditions.
61
General Terms and Conditions for Research and Development contracted to Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft
© Fraunhofer
Dr. Lorenz Kaiser 20111214 Uten, Portugal
Cooperation Agreement on the U.K. Lambert model contract
Please check whether the grey highlighted clauses
Useful
Necessary
Legal or illegal
65