U.S. v. Collins: Government's Opposition to Motion for New Trial

8/14/2019 U.S. v. Collins: Government's Opposition to Motion for New Trial

1/23

^HGPN@ ZPBPNZ @GZPVGJP JD^VPZD^PLNVH @GZPVGJP DC HNQ WDVK/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / |

5

^HGPN@ ZPBPNZ DC BONVGJB) 5

/ s( / 5 Z2 =1 Jv( 221= ,V]]'

EDZN]L ]( JDIIGHZ) 5

@ncnh`bhp( 5

/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / |

ADSNVHONHPZ ONODVBH@^O DC IBQ GH D]]DZGPGDH PD @NCNH@BHPZ

ODPGDH CDV B HNQ PVGBI

]VNNP FLBVBVB^hgpn` Zpbpnz Bppdvhnw cdv pln Zd~plnvh@gzpvgjp dc Hnq Wdvk

JLVGZPD]LNV I( ABVJGBBzzgzpbhp ^hgpn` Zpbpnz Bppdvhnw

/ Dc Jd~hzni /


2/23

g

PBFIN DC JDHPNHPZ

]vnigoghbvw Zpbpnonhp ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 6

Fbjkavd~h` ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 0

Bva~onhp ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 2=

G( B}}igjbfin Ibq ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 2=

GG( Pln Hnqiw @gzjdsnvn` Nobgiz Bh` Lbh`qvgppnh Hdpnz @d Hdp Qbvvbhp b Hnq Pvgbi ( ( ( ( 22

B( Pln Hnqiw @gzjdsnvn` Nsg`nhjn Gz Hdp Obpnvgbi ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 22

2( Pln Lbh`qvgppnh Hdpnz Lbsn Hd Vninsbhjn Qlbpzdnsnv pd pln Pgogha dc pln@giganhjn Jbii ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 22

6( Pln Nobgi Nsg`nhjn Gz Jdhzgzpnhp qgpl Pbfdvz Pnzpgodhw ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 2:

:( Pln Pgogha dc pln @giganhjn Jbii Qbz dc Igogpn` Zgahgcgjbhjn bp Pvgbi ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 2>

F( Pln Hnqiw @gzjdsnvn` Nsg`nhjn Gz J~o~ibpgsn dc Dplnv Nsg`nhjn bp Pvgbi ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 2>

J( Pln Hnqiw @gzjdsnvn` Nsg`nhjn Qd~i` Hdp Lbsn Vnz~ipn` gh bh Bjr~gppbi ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 2

z~ccgjgnhp pd z~zpbgh b jdhsgjpgdh babghzp pln `ncnh`bhp( ,Pv( 03:>/3'( B``gpgdhbiiw) pln Adsnvhonhp

ghpvd`~jn` nsg`nhjn zldqgha plbp Jdiighz kn}p pln n|gzpnhjn dc pln ]]B znjvnp cvdo lgz

jdiinba~nz bp Obwnv Fvdqh( ,Pv( 2>'( Gh`nn`) Jdiighzz khdqin`an plbp ln qbz nhaban` gh

b cvb~` pd jdhjnbi pln ]]B qbz }nvlb}z fnzp `nodhzpvbpn` fw lgz ghzpv~jpgdh pd dhn dc pln

FBQBA ibqwnvz qdvkgha dh pln f~wfbjk dc pln ]]B ghpnvnzp fw Vncjdz JND bh` zlbvnldi`nv

]lgiig} Fnhhnpp ,Fnhhnpp'5 Inpz hnsnv z}nbk dc plgz babgh( ,Pv( 2726'(

Dhn dc pln ngalp qgphnzznz plbp pln Adsnvhonhp jbiin` pd }vdsg`n nsg`nhjn vnabv`gha pln

zjlnon pd jdhjnbi pln ]]B qbz Ebw Pbfdv) b ibqwnv qgpl pln cgvo Qngi Adpzlbi # Obhanz

,Qngi') qlgjl b`sgzn` PLI gh jdhhnjpgdh qgpl pln insnvban` f~wd~p ,IFD' dc Vncjd(

Bodha dplnv plghaz) Pbfdv pnzpgcgn` bfd~p b pnin}ldhn jbii ln lb` qgpl pln `ncnh`bhp dh Obvjl

6:) 6==0 gh qlgjl ln bzkn` pln `ncnh`bhp pd) bodha dplnv plghaz) g`nhpgcw }bvpgnz) gc bhw) plbp


8/23

6Plgz jbii gz vncnvvn` pd lnvngh bz pln `giganhjn jbii(

:Pbfdv pnzpgcgn` plbp pln `ncnh`bhp }bvpgjg}bpn` gh pln jbii) bipld~al ln gz hdp igzpn` gh plnhdpnz bz dhn dc pln }bvpgjg}bhpz( ,Pv( 26>=/>:'(

0Jdiighzz bjjd~hp dc plgz jdhsnvzbpgdh fdpl bz pd gc pln jdhsnvzbpgdh lb}}nhn` bh`qlbp pln pgogha dc gp obw lbsn fnnh qbz ~hjdvvdfdvbpn` bp pvgbi(

3

}dzznzzn` d}pgdhz pd dfpbgh nr~gpw ghpnvnzpz gh Vncjd(6 Jdiighz vn}ign` plbp hdhn n|gzpn` qlnh) gh

cbjp) pln ]]B }vdsg`n` FBQBA qgpl pln d}pgdh pd jdhsnvp gpz ghpnvnzp gh pln }vdjnn`z dc pln zbin

dc Vncjd ghpd bh nr~gpw zpbkn gh pln jdo}bhw( ,Jdo}bvn A\ 1== bh` Pv( 2663/67) 232=/22 qgpl

A\ 2>=0 ,Znjpgdh 2(=2''( Pbfdv c~vplnv pnzpgcgn` plbp pln jdhsnvzbpgdh nh`n` qgpl bh bavnnonhp

plbp Jdiighz qd~i` znp ~} b c~p~vn jbii qgpl @nhhgz Kinehb ,Kinehb') Vncjdz anhnvbi jd~hzni)

bh` Vdfnvp Pvdzpnh ,Pvdzpnh') Vncjdz JCD) pd cdiidq ~} dh b h~ofnv dc pln `giganhjn }dghpz

plnw `gzj~zzn` bz qnii bz pd `gzj~zz b plnh/dhadgha ghsnzpgabpgdh fw pln Znj~vgpgnz bh` N|jlbhan

Jdoogzzgdh ,ZNJ'( ,Pv( 26>='( Pbfdv z~fznr~nhpiw pnzpgcgn` plbp plgz c~p~vn jbii djj~vvn` dh

Obvjl :=) 6==0) bz jdvvdfdvbpn` fw b znp dc Pbfdvz lbh`qvgppnh hdpnz `bpn` Obvjl :=) 6==0

vncinjpgha b @giganhjn Jbii qgpl @nhhgz Kinehb bh` Vdf Pvdzpnh gh qlgjl zdon dc pln

zbon pd}gjz `gzj~zzn` `~vgha pln Obvjl 6:v` jbii qnvn `gzj~zzn` bz qbz pln ZNJ ghr~gvw( ,Pv(

26>2; Pbfdv :>:3/>) bppbjln` lnvnpd bz N|( J'(:

Pln `ncnhzn ob`n pln pgogha dc pln jbii qgpl Jdiighz bh gzz~n bp pvgbi( Jdiighz jibgon`

plbp ln `g` hdp lbsn b jdhsnvzbpgdh qgpl Pbfdv jdhjnvhgha `~n `giganhjn gh Obvjl 6==0( Vbplnv)

ln bzznvpn` plbp ln lb` lgz cgvzp jbii qgpl Pbfdv jdhjnvhgha `~n `giganhjn zdonpgon gh B}vgi 6==0

bcpnv ln lb` b jdhsnvzbpgdh gh qlgjl Fnhhnpp b`sgzn` lgo plbp ln qbhpn` pd igogp pln zjd}n dc

`giganhjn pd n|ji~`n pln `gzjidz~vn dc zd/jbiin` ~}zpvnbo bavnnonhpz) g(n() bavnnonhpz

ghsdisgha bh` bccnjpgha dhiw Vncjdz zlbvnldi`nvz bh` hdp Vncjd(0 Jdiighz c~vplnv biinan` plbp


9/23

>Fnjb~zn @\ :=2 gz odvn plbh 6== }banz gh inhapl) pln Adsnvhonhp lbz ghji~`n` dhiwpldzn }dvpgdhz dc pln n|lgfgp ~pgigun` ~vgha jvdzz/n|boghbpgdh( Dfsgd~ziw) pln Adsnvhonhp gzlb}}w pd }vdsg`n pln Jd~vp qgpl pln dplnv }banz dc pln n|lgfgp gc pln Jd~vp qgzlnz pd lbsn plno(

1

pln ]]B qbz dhn z~jl bavnnonhp( Pln `ncnhzn nh`nbsdvn` pd nzpbfigzl plbp pln jbii qgpl Pbfdv

djj~vvn` bcpnv pln jdhsnvzbpgdh qgpl Fnhhnpp pd z~}}dvp pln plndvw plbp Jdiighz fnignsn` plbp pln

]]B `g` hdp hnn` pd fn `gzjidzn` gh vnz}dhzn pd pln `giganhjn r~nzpgdhz Pbfdv bzkn` lgo fnjb~zn

gp qbz bh ~}zpvnbo bavnnonhp(

Bjjdv`ghaiw) `ncnhzn jd~hzni jvdzz/n|boghn` Pbfdv n|pnhzgsniw bfd~p pln pgogha dc plgz

jdhsnvzbpgdh qgpl Jdiighz) bppbjkgha fdpl lgz vnjdiinjpgdh dc pln pgogha dc pln jdhsnvzbpgdh bh`

lgz odpgsnz cdv pnzpgcwgha anhnvbiiw( Pln `ncnhzn jdhcvdhpn` Pbfdv qgpl lgz pgon vnjdv`z cdv qdvk

}nvcdvon` gh jdhhnjpgdh qgpl pln IFD( @~vgha dhn inhaplw zpvnpjl dc jvdzz/n|boghbpgdh)

jd~hzni cdv Jdiighz qbikn` Pbfdv plvd~al nsnvw nhpvw cdv pln odhpl dc Obvjl) nigjgpgha

pnzpgodhw plbp hd jbiiz dv jdhsnvzbpgdhz qgpl pln `ncnh`bhp qnvn vncinjpn` bhwqlnvn gh pldzn

vnjdv`z( ,Pv( 20>7/1=; @\ :=2) bppbjln` lnvnpd bz N|( @>'( @ncnhzn jd~hzni b``gpgdhbiiw

jdhcvdhpn` Pbfdv qgpl bh banhpz hdpnz dc bh ghpnvsgnq dc lgo) qlgjl hdpnz ghji~`n` pln hdpbpgdh

]dzzgfiw Obvjl =0 gh vncnvnhjn pd b Pnin}ldh[zgj_ jbii q EJ bfd~p @@) gh bh nccdvp pd

z~aanzp plbp Pbfdvz vnjdiinjpgdh bfd~p pln pgogha dc pln `~n `giganhjn jbii qbz hdp cgvo( ,Pv(

2013/11) 2306/0:; Jbzzg`w @nji( N|( ] bp >'( Anhnvbiiw) `ncnhzn jd~hzni bppbjkn` Pbfdvz

jvn`gfgigpw dh pln fbzgz dc bh bavnnonhp fnpqnnh PLI bh` Qngi plbp }vnznvsn` PLIz vgalp pd

z~n Qngi ~h`nv jnvpbgh jgvj~ozpbhjnz( ,Pv( 20>7) 2307/>2'(

@ncnhzn jd~hzni bizd jvdzz/n|boghn` Pbfdv odvn anhnvbiiw qgpl nsg`nhjn plbp gh Obvjl

6==0 Pbfdv qdvkn` dh `giganhjn gzz~nz qgpl }nd}in dplnv pln `ncnh`bhp( Cdv n|bo}in) `ncnhzn

jd~hzni jdhcvdhpn` Pbfdv qgpl bh nobgi n|jlbhan nsg`nhjgha bh nccdvp fw Qngi bh` PLI pd qdvk


10/23

=0/W'( Bjjdv`ghaiw) pln ]]B

qbz fw hd onpvgj bh ~}zpvnbo bavnnonhp pln `gzjidz~vn dc qlgjl qbz zdonldq n|no}pn`(

Gh b fvgnc vnf~ppbi jbzn) pln Adsnvhonhp vnjbiin` Pbfdv hdp bz zdon jd~}/`n/avbjn cdv gpz

jbzn) ,Fv( 6') f~p onvniw pd b`ogp b jinbvnv jdidv jd}w dc pln dvgaghbi hdpnz) qlgjl pln

Adsnvhonhp dhiw znj~vn` ibpnv `~vgha pvgbi) pd }~p pd vnzp pln `ncnh`bhpz bppno}pn` go}nbjlonhp

dc lgz pnzpgodhw( Pldzn hdpnz }ibghiw vncinjpn` pln `bpn Obvjl 6:) =0( ,A\ 1==/D) bppbjln`

lnvnpd bz N|( B'(

Gh fdpl gpz obgh bh` vnf~ppbi z~oobpgdhz) pln Adsnvhonhp ob`n jinbv plbp pln

`ncnh`bhpz nccdvpz pd jdhjnbi pln ]]B qbz f~p dhn dc obhw qbwz pln `ncnh`bhp lni}n` bjlgnsn

pln zbin dc Vncjd plvd~al cvb~`( Bz pln `ncnh`bhp lbz hdpn` gh jdhhnjpgdh qgpl znhpnhjgha) pln

Adsnvhonhp bva~n` gh fdpl z~oobpgdhz plbp Jdiighzz }bvpgjg}bpgdh gh ignz jdhjnvhgha pln

bod~hp dc odhnw VALG dqn` pd Vncjd) pln gh`nohgpgnz bh` a~bvbhpnnz) bh` pln $>== ogiigdh gh

}~v}dvpn`iw n|jnzz qdvkgha jb}gpbi qnvn bii zn}bvbpn bh` gh`n}nh`nhp fbznz cdv cgh`gha pln

`ncnh`bhp j~i}bfin( ,Pv( 03==1/=


12/23

2=

fbjk/pd/fbjk idbhz ibpnv( G bo adgha pd pbik bfd~p qlbp plgz jbzn gz bfd~p bp plnfnaghhgha( Bh` plbpz pln ldin bh` pln plvnn qgphnzznz qld jbon lnvn pd zbw plnwpdi` lgo bfd~p gp( Vgalp bp pln fnaghhgha( Fnjb~zn qgpld~p plbp khdqin`an) plnvngz hd jvgon(

,Pv( 0'

,ghpnvhbi r~dpbpgdh obvkz dogppn`'( Bjjdv`ghaiw) b odpgdh }~vz~bhp pd V~in :: fbzn` dh hnqiw

`gzjdsnvn` nsg`nhjn obw fn avbhpn` dhiw ~}dh b zldqgha plbp pln nsg`nhjn jd~i` hdp qgpl `~n

`giganhjn lbsn fnnh `gzjdsnvn` fncdvn dv `~vgha pvgbi) plbp pln nsg`nhjn gz obpnvgbi) hdp

j~o~ibpgsn) bh` plbp b`ogzzgdh dc pln nsg`nhjn qd~i` }vdfbfiw inb` pd bh bjr~gppbi( ^hgpn`

Zpbpnz s(Binzzg) 3:< C(6` 033) 017 ,6` Jgv( 27


13/23

22

`nodhzpvbfin vnbigpw( ^hgpn` Zpbpnz n| vni( @bvjw s(Lbh`w) :>2 ^(Z( 0>0) 036 ,27>3' ,ghpnvhbi

jgpbpgdhz dogppn`'(

GG( Pln Hnqiw @gzjdsnvn` Nobgiz Bh` Lbh`qvgppnh Hdpnz @d Hdp Qbvvbhp b Hnq Pvgbi

B( Pln Hnqiw @gzjdsnvn` Nsg`nhjn Gz Hdp Obpnvgbi

2( Pln Lbh`qvgppnh Hdpnz Lbsn Hd Vninsbhjn Qlbpzdnsnv pd pln Pgogha

dc pln @giganhjn Jbii

Pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` lbh`qvgppnh hdpnz bvn zgo}iw gvvninsbhp pd pln r~nzpgdh dc qlnh pln

`giganhjn jbii fnpqnnh pln `ncnh`bhp bh` Pbfdv djj~vvn`( Pln `ncnh`bhp }dghpz pd hdplgha gh pln

jdhpnhp dc pln hnq hdpnz hd zpbpnonhp) hd hdpbpgdh dc bhw kgh` plbp jdhpvb`gjpz dv gz

ghjdhzgzpnhp qgpl Pbfdvz pnzpgodhw bp pvgbi plbp pln `giganhjn jbii djj~vvn` gh Obvjl 6==0(

Vbplnv) pln `ncnh`bhp jibgoz plbp pln hnq hdpnz zldq plbp Pbfdv `g` hdp) bz b }vbjpgjn) `bpn hdpnz

dc jdhsnvzbpgdhz jdhpno}dvbhnd~ziw bh` plbp) bjjdv`ghaiw) pln hdpnz dc pln `giganhjn jbii o~zp

lbsn fnnh `bpn`}dzp ldj fw Pbfdv bcpnv lgz vnjdiinjpgdh dc nsnhpz lb` cb`n` fnjb~zn ln lb` b

z}njgbi vnbzdh) bvgzgha bp zdon dplnv }dghp) cdv `bpgha pln jdhsnvzbpgdhz ln bzzdjgbpn` qgpl

Jdiighz( ,Fv( 23'( Plgz dfsgd~ziw bh` avdzziw z}nj~ibpgsn jibgo cgh`z z~}}dvp gh hngplnv cbjpz

hdv idagj(

Cgvzp) pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` hdpnz `d hdp nzpbfigzl bhwplgha bfd~p Pbfdvz hdpn pbkgha

}vbjpgjnz( Bz pln `ncnh`bhp jdhjn`nz) pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` obpnvgbiz ghji~`n hdpnz dc b

jdhsnvzbpgdh plbp bvn `bpn` plbp ghsdisn zdondhn dplnv plbh pln `ncnh`bhp( ,Fv( 2>; Jbzzg`w

@nji( N|( @ bp QAO/Z~}}/] ===21=07'( Jdhsnvzniw) pln obpnvgbiz bizd ghji~`n hdpnz dc b

jdhsnvzbpgdh qgpl pln `ncnh`bhp plbp bvn ~h`bpn`( ,Jbzzg`w @nji( N|( B bp QAO/Z~}}/]

===2161:'( Pln hdpnz zldq hngplnv plbp Pbfdv lb` b }vbjpgjn dc hdp bpgha hdpnz dc

jdhsnvzbpgdhz hdv plbp ln nhaban` gh zdon zjlnon pd `bpn hdpnz dc jdhsnvzbpgdhz ghsdisgha pln


14/23

3Gh`nn`) cdv Pbfdv pd lbsn nhaban` gh z~jl b zjlnon pd fbjk`bpn hdpnz) ln qd~i` lbsnlb` pd lbsn bhpgjg}bpn` pln vninsbhjn dc `bpgha pln hdpnz bz z~jl( Dc jd~vzn) pln vninsbhjn dc pln`bpn dc pln hdpnz zpnoz nhpgvniw cvdo Jdiighzz jibgo plbp ln lb` b jdhsnvzbpgdh qgpl Fnhhnpp ghB}vgi 6==0 gh qlgjl Fnhhnpp pdi` lgo plbp ~}zpvnbo bavnnonhpz qnvn n|no}pn` cvdo

`gzjidz~vn( Plnvn gz hd nsg`nhjn plbp Pbfdv khnq dc Jdiighzz jibgo jdhjnvhgha plgz }~v}dvpn`jdhsnvzbpgdh qgpl Fnhhnpp bh`) gh`nn`) gp qd~i` lbsn fnnh go}dzzgfin cdv lgo pd bhpgjg}bpn5Plnvn gz hd nsg`nhjn dc pln }~v}dvpn` jdhsnvzbpgdh `dj~onhpbvw dv dplnvqgzn b}bvp cvdoJdiighz lgoznic( ]~p `gccnvnhpiw) plnvn gz hd nsg`nhjn plbp Pbfdv lb` bhw vnbzdh pd fbjk`bpn lgzhdpnz pd Obvjl 6==0( Gh`nn`) gh igalp dc lgz pgon vnjdv`z) qlgjl `d hdp vncinjp bhw jbii qgpl pln`ncnh`bhp gh Obvjl 6==0) gp gz nhpgvniw go}ib~zgfin pd plghk plbp ln qd~i` lbsn fbjk`bpn` lgzhdpnz pd plbp pgon }nvgd`(

26

`ncnh`bhp( Pln odzp plbp jbh fn zbg` bfd~p Pbfdvz }vbjpgjnz qgpl vnz}njp pd `bpgha hdpnz dc

jdhsnvzbpgdhz gz plbp Pbfdv qbz ghjdhzgzpnhp) bh` z~jl ghjdhzgzpnhjw }vdsg`nz bfzdi~pniw hd

cbjp~bi cd~h`bpgdh cdv `ncnh`bhpz fbi` z~vogzn plbp Pbfdv `bpn` hdpnz dc jdhsnvzbpgdhz qgpl pln

`ncnh`bhp idha bcpnv plnw djj~vvn`(

Gh`nn`) pln hdpnz dc pln jbiiz dh Obvjl 6:v` bh` :=pl bh` idagj zldq pln bfz~v`gpw dc

pln `ncnh`bhpz jibgo( Gc Pbfdv qbz ghsdisn` gh zdon}dzp ldj nccdvp pd fbjk`bpn pln hdpnz

fnjb~zn ln lb` b z}njgbi vnbzdh) bvgzgha bp zdon dplnv }dghp) cdv `bpgha pln jdhsnvzbpgdhz ln

bzzdjgbpn` qgpl Jdiighz) ,Fv( 23') ln dfsgd~ziw qd~i` lbsn qvgppnh Obvjl 6:) =0 odvn

jinbviw( Igknqgzn) gh b``gpgdh pd `bpgha pln hdpnz dc lgz Obvjl :=) 6==0 jdhsnvzbpgdh qgpl pln

`ncnh`bhp) Pbfdv qd~i` lbsn }nhhn` Jdiighzz hbon ghpd pln hdpnz bz dhn dc pln }nd}in qld

}bvpgjg}bpn` gh pln jdhsnvzbpgdh ,pln hdpnz vncinjp dhiw pln hbonz dc Kinehb bh` Pvdzpnh'( Ln `g`

hngplnv dc plnzn plghaz fnjb~zn) }ibghiw) ln `g` hdp nhaban gh bhw zjlnon pd fbjk`bpn hdpnz dc

jdhsnvzbpgdhz qgpl pln `ncnh`bhp dv dplnvqgzn jvnbpn b vnjdv` dc lbsgha z}dknh qgpl pln

`ncnh`bhp bfd~p `giganhjn gzz~nz gh Obvjl 6==0(3

Hdplgha nizn bfd~p pln hdpnz z~aanzpz fbjk`bpgha( Dhn jd~i` gobaghn qlbp z~jl

nsg`nhjn ogalp fn( Cdv n|bo}in) plnvn gz hd jibgo ,fnjb~zn plnvn jbh fn hdhn' plbp pln ghk ~zn`


15/23

2:

pd `bpn pln hdpnz dc pln `giganhjn jbii qnvn dc b `gccnvnhp jdidv plbh pln ghk ~zn` pd edp `dqh pln

z~fzpbhjn dc pln jdhsnvzbpgdh( Zgo}iw }~p) fnjb~zn pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` lbh`qvgppnh hdpnz

}vdsg`n hd nsg`nhjn plbp Pbfdv `bpn` hdpnz dc jdhsnvzbpgdhz qgpl pln `ncnh`bhp bcpnv pln

jdhsnvzbpgdhz djj~vvn` qlnh lgz vnjdiinjpgdh dc nsnhpz lb` cb`n` bh` fnjb~zn hdplgha bfd~p

pln hdpnz bvn ghjdhzgzpnhp qgpl Pbfdvz pnzpgodhw bh` pln pvgbi nsg`nhjn plnw lbsn hd vninsbhjn

qlbpzdnsnv pd pln gzz~n dc pln pgogha dc pln `giganhjn jbii(

6( Pln Nobgi Nsg`nhjn Gz Jdhzgzpnhp qgpl Pbfdvz Pnzpgodhw

B hnq pvgbi gz hdp qbvvbhpn` b``gpgdhbiiw fnjb~zn pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nobgiz bvn

jdhzgzpnhp qgpl Pbfdvz pnzpgodhw bh`) plnvncdvn) goobpnvgbi pd pln gzz~n dc qlnh pln `giganhjn

jbii fnpqnnh pln `ncnh`bhp bh` Pbfdv djj~vvn`( Pln `ncnh`bhpz jibgoz hdpqgplzpbh`gha) pln

hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nobgiz bvn hdp nsg`nhjn plbp pln jbii djj~vvn` gh B}vgi 6==0) hdv `d plnw

`gz}vdsn plbp pln jbii djj~vvn` gh Obvjl 6==0( ,Fv( 6 ,Pln hnq nsg`nhjn gz `gz}dzgpgsn bh`

qd~i` lbsn }~p pln gzz~n [dc qlnh pln jbii djj~vvn`_ pd vnzp''( Bp fnzp) pln nobgiz zldq plbp

Pbfdv bh` dplnvz bp Qngi ob`n vnr~nzpz cdv ghcdvobpgdh dc Kinehb bh` JZCF) ,Fv( 7) 20') f~p

z~jl nsg`nhjn gz hdp ghjdhzgzpnhp qgpl vnr~nzpz bizd fngha ob`n dc pln `ncnh`bhp( ]~p

`gccnvnhpiw) plnw `d hdp nigoghbpn bhw }dzzgfgigpw plbp Pbfdv z}dkn pd Jdiighz gh Obvjl 6==0(

,Fv( 20'(

Pln igogpn` sbi~n dc pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nobgi nsg`nhjn gz }nvlb}z fnzp ~h`nvzpdd` fw

jdhzg`nvgha qlbp gp gz hdp( Dhn jbh nbzgiw gobaghn pln pw}n dc nobgi nsg`nhjn plbp qd~i` pv~iw

jdhpvb`gjp Pbfdvz pnzpgodhw bh`) bz b vnz~ip) fn obpnvgbi pd pln gzz~n dc pln pgogha dc pln

`giganhjn jbii( Bh nobgi `bpn` bcpnv Obvjl 6==0 zpbpgha plbp Pbfdv lb` hdp wnp lb` jdhpbjp qgpl

pln `ncnh`bhp qd~i` pnh` pd `gz}vdsn plbp pln jbii djj~vvn` gh Obvjl 6==0 bh` go}nbjl Pbfdvz


16/23

20

vnjdiinjpgdh( Igknqgzn) bh nobgi cvdo ibpn Obvjl 6==0 vncinjpgha bh ~h`nvzpbh`gha dh pln }bvp dc

Pbfdv plbp ln qbz hdp pd `gvnjp ghr~gvgnz pd pln `ncnh`bhp qd~i` igknqgzn pnh` pd jdhpvb`gjp lgz

pnzpgodhw bh` hdpnz( F~p pln nobgi nsg`nhjn dh qlgjl pln `ncnh`bhpz b}}igjbpgdh p~vhz gz

hdplgha dc plgz zdvp( Gp `dnz hdp jdhpvb`gjp bh` gz gh hd qbw ghjdhzgzpnhp qgpl Pbfdvz

pnzpgodhw plbp ln z}dkn pd pln `ncnh`bhp gh Obvjl 6==0(

Gh`nn`) pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nobgiz bvn c~h`bonhpbiiw jdhzgzpnhp qgpl Pbfdvz pnzpgodhw

bh` hdpnz( Pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nobgiz vncinjp plbp PLI bh` Qngi qnvn qbgpgha dh vnz}dhznz pd

`giganhjn r~nzpgdhz bz ibpn bz Obvjl 21pl( ,Znn) n(a() Jbzzg`w @nji( N|( N ,B}}bvnhpiw)

pdodvvdqz onnpgha qgii `npnvoghn qlnplnv o~jl dc pln `giganhjn `bpb plbp lbz fnnh vnr~nzpn`

qgii fn r~gjkiw cdvpljdogha cvdo Vncjd(''( B``gpgdhbiiw) plnw vncinjp plbp bz dc Obvjl 66h`)

PLI bh` Qngi qbhpn` pd inbvh odvn bfd~p bh dhadgha ZNJ ghsnzpgabpgdh plbp Kinehb bh` Pvdzpnh

lb` }vnsgd~ziw fnnh vnpgjnhp pd `gzj~zz) ,Jbzzg`w @nji( N|z( A/G') bh` plbp plnvn qbz bh nccdvp pd

znp ~} b jbii qgpl Kinehb dh Obvjl :=pl pd `gzj~zz pln ZNJ ghsnzpgabpgdh bh` dplnv `giganhjn

vnr~nzpz( ,Jbzzg`w @nji( N|z( H/D'(

Pbfdvz hdpnz dc pln Obvjl 6:) 6==0 jbii qgpl pln `ncnh`bhp cgp hnbpiw qgplgh plgz

pgonighn( Cdv n|bo}in) pln hdpnz vncinjp pln zbon ghpnvnzp dh pln }bvp dc Qngi bh` PLI pd dfpbgh

bhzqnvz pd d~pzpbh`gha `giganhjn vnr~nzpz) bz Pbfdv znj~vnz cvdo pln `ncnh`bhp bp pln d~pznp dc

pln jbii bh bzz~vbhjn plbp ln qgii }~zl pd dfpbgh vnz}dhznz pd PLIz `giganhjn vnr~nzpz( ,Pv(

23=3; A\ 1=='( Pbfdvz hdpnz zgogibviw vncinjp b `nzgvn pd dfpbgh bhzqnvz bfd~p pln ZNJz plnh/

dhadgha ghsnzpgabpgdh dc Vncjd) bz pln jbii nh`z qgpl bh bavnnonhp plbp pln `ncnh`bhp qgii lni}

znp ~} b c~p~vn jdhcnvnhjn jbii qgpl Kinehb bh` Pvdzpnh pd `gzj~zz pln ghsnzpgabpgdh bz qnii bz

dplnv d~pzpbh`gha `giganhjn r~nzpgdhz( ,Pv( 232>/23; A\ 1=='( Dc jd~vzn) Pbfdvz hdpnz c~vplnv


17/23

1Fnjb~zn Pbfdv :>:3/> gz b inhaplw `dj~onhp) pln Adsnvhonhp lbz ghji~`n` gh N|lgfgp Jdhiw pldzn }dvpgdhz plbp bvn hdpnz dc pln Obvjl :=) 6==0 jbii( Pln Adsnvhonhp gz lb}}w pd}vdsg`n pln Jd~vp qgpl pln vnobghgha }dvpgdhz gc gp qgzlnz pd lbsn plno(

2>

vncinjp plbp plgz cdiidq/~} jdhsnvzbpgdh djj~vvn` dh Obvjl :=) 6==0) e~zp bz pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn`

nobgi nsg`nhjn gh`gjbpnz( ,Pv( 26>2; Pbfdv :>:3/>) bppbjln` lnvnpd bz N|( J'(1 Pln hnqiw

`gzjdsnvn` nobgiz zgo}iw bvn hdp obpnvgbi pd pln pgogha dc Pbfdvz `giganhjn jbii qgpl pln

`ncnh`bhp agsnh plbp plnw `d hdp jdhpvb`gjp lgz pnzpgodhw f~p vbplnv bvn jdhzgzpnhp qgpl gp(

:( Pln Pgogha dc pln @giganhjn Jbii Qbz dc Igogpn` Zgahgcgjbhjn bp Pvgbi

Pln sbi~n dc pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nsg`nhjn pd pln `ncnhzn gz c~vplnv igogpn` fw pln cbjp

plbp pln pgogha dc pln `giganhjn jbii qbz hdp hnbviw bz zgahgcgjbhp bz pln `ncnh`bhp hdq jibgoz(

Pln `ncnh`bhp ob`n pln pgogha dc pln jbii bh gzz~n bp pvgbi fnjb~zn ln jibgon` plbp ln `gzj~zzn`

`giganhjn obppnvz qgpl Pbfdv dhiw bcpnv ln lb` bh ~h`nvzpbh`gha plbp Vncjd bh` PLI lb` vnbjln`

bh bavnnonhp plbp ~}zpvnbo bavnnonhpz qnvn n|no}pn` cvdo `gzjidz~vn( Pln qldin vninsbhjn

dc pln pgogha dc pln jbii) plnvncdvn) p~vhn` dh pln bzz~o}pgdh plbp pln ]]B qbz z~jl bh ~}zpvnbo

bavnnonhp( F~p plvd~al jvdzz/n|boghbpgdh dc pln `ncnh`bhp) gp qbz nzpbfigzln` plbp pln ]]B qbz)

gh cbjp) bh bavnnonhp fdpl ghsdisgha bh` bccnjpgha Vncjd) agsnh plbp Vncjd qbz b }bvpw pd pln

bavnnonhp qgpl pln bii dc pln bzzdjgbpn` vgalpz bh` dfigabpgdhz( ,A\ 2>=0/W'( Bjjdv`ghaiw) pln

]]B qbz fw hd onpvgj bh ~}zpvnbo bavnnonhp pln `gzjidz~vn dc qlgjl qbz zdonldq

n|no}pn`( Plgz onbhp) gh p~vh) plbp pln `ncnh`bhp qbz dfigabpn` pd `gzjidzn gp pd Pbfdv `~vgha

pln `giganhjn jbii qlnplnv plbp jbii djj~vvn` gh Obvjl) B}vgi) Obw) E~hn) dv bp bhwpgon(

Bjjdv`ghaiw) pln hnq nsg`nhjn gz hdp obpnvgbi fdpl fnjb~zn gp `dnz hdp jdhpvb`gjp Pbfdvz

pnzpgodhw bh` fnjb~zn pln gzz~n cdv qlgjl gp qd~i` lbsn fnnh ~zn` qbz hdp hnbviw bz zgahgcgjbhp


18/23

7/1=; @\ :=2) bppbjln` lnvnpd bz N|( @'( @ncnhzn jd~hzniz ~zn dc pln pgon

vnjdv`z qbz }ibghiw cbv odvn jdo}niigha plbh bhw ~zn dc pln nobgiz jd~i` nsnv fn( Bz qbz

z~aanzpn` `~vgha jvdzz/n|boghbpgdh) Pbfdv lb` fdpl bh ghjnhpgsn bh` `~pw pd knn} bjj~vbpn pgon

vnjdv`z bh`) fw n|pnhzgdh) }dzzgfiw pd ghji~`n npbgiz bfd~p lbsgha z}dknh pd pln `ncnh`bhp( Hd


20/23

27) 2307/>2'( Dfsgd~ziw) z~jl odpgsn bh` fgbz nsg`nhjn gz cbv odvn }dqnvc~i plbh pln

nobgiz ~}dh qlgjl pln `ncnh`bhp vnignz) qlgjl z}nbk hdp pd odpgsn f~p pbik }bzp pln gzz~n dc pln

`ncnh`bhpz ghsdisnonhp gh `giganhjn(

]~p zgo}iw) pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nobgiz bh` hdpnz ~}dh qlgjl pln ghzpbhp odpgdh vnignz

qd~i` lbsn b``n` hdplgha pd pln `ncnhznzz jvdzz/n|boghbpgdh dc Pbfdv dv pd pln pvgbi vnjdv`(

J( Pln Hnqiw @gzjdsnvn` Nsg nhjn Qd~i Hdp Lbsn Vnz~ipn` gh bh Bjr~gppbi

Qlbpnsnv plngv sbi~n) pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nobgiz bh` hdpnz qd~i` hdp lbsn jvnbpn`

nsnh b vnodpn }dzzgfgigpw dc bh bjr~gppbi( Pln Adsnvhonhpz jbzn/gh/jlgnc jdhz~on`

b}}vd|gobpniw cgsn qnnkz bh` :6== pvbhzjvg}p }banz bh` jdhzgzpn` dc hnbviw 6= qgphnzznz bh`


21/23

27

odvn plbh 0>= n|lgfgpz( Qgpl vnabv` pd pln `ncnh`bhpz }bvpgjg}bpgdh gh b zjlnon pd jdhjnbi pln

]]B) pln Adsnvhonhp ghpvd`~jn` dsnvqlniogha nsg`nhjn dc pln `ncnh`bhpz a~gip) ghji~`gha pln

pnzpgodhw dc ngalp qgphnzznz bh` h~onvd~z `dj~onhpz plbp `nodhzpvbpn`) bodha dplnv plghaz)

plbp pln `ncnh`bhp z~}}ign` PLI qgpl b }ldhw igogpn` igbfgigpw jdo}bhw bavnnonhp) jdhjnbin`

pln n|gzpnhjn dc pln ]]B cvdo lgz dqh }bvphnvz) bh` khnq plbp pln vnbi vnbzdh cdv jdhjnbigha pln

]]B qbz pd n|pvbjp b lgalnv }vgjn cvdo PLI( Pd jibgo plbp [p_ln }vghjg}bi }giibv dc plgz bz}njp

dc pln jbzn qbz Pbfdvz pnzpgodhw plbp ln lb` b jdhsnvzbpgdh qgpl Jdiighz gh Obvjl 6==0) ,Fv(

6') gz b avdzz dsnvzpbpnonhp bh` hdplgha odvn plbh bh nccdvp pd znp ~} b zpvbq obh cdv pln hnqiw

`gzjdsnvn` nsg`nhjn pd khdjk `dqh( Pln Adsnvhonhp ghpvd`~jn` bo}in nsg`nhjn b}bvp cvdo

Pbfdvz pnzpgodhw bfd~p pln pgogha dc pln `giganhjn jbii pd nzpbfigzl plbp pln `ncnh`bhp qbz

j~i}bfin gh jdhhnjpgdh qgpl pln zjlnon pd jdhjnbi pln ]]B(

Odvndsnv) pln Adsnvhonhp ghpvd`~jn` dsnvqlniogha nsg`nhjn dc pln `ncnh`bhpz

}bvpgjg}bpgdh gh plvnn dplnv) zn}bvbpn bz}njpz dc pln fvdb`nv zjlnon pd bjlgnsn b zbin dc Vncjd

plvd~al cvb~`) ghji~`gha jdhjnbionhp dc pln ldin) jdhjnbionhp dc pln gh`nohgpgnz bh` a~bvbhpgnz)

bh` ignz vnabv`gha pln }~v}dvpn`iw n|jnzz qdvkgha jb}gpbi( Pln Adsnvhonhpz nsg`nhjn

jdhjnvhgha pln `ncnh`bhpz khdqgha }bvpgjg}bpgdh gh plnzn bz}njpz dc pln cvb~` bz qnii bz gh pln

jdhjnbionhp dc pln ]]B gz fvgnciw z~oobvgun` gh pln Adsnvhonhpz znhpnhjgha z~fogzzgdh bh`

plbp z~oobvw gz vnz}njpc~iiw ghjdv}dvbpn` lnvngh( ,Znn Adsp Znhp( Ono( 6/23'( Gh igalp dc plgz

nsg`nhjn) pln lbh`c~i dc hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nobgiz bh` hdpnz ~}dh qlgjl Jdiighz vnignz qd~i` hdp

igkniw lbsn vnz~ipn` gh bh bjr~gppbi(

Gh`nn`) pln jbznz jgpn` gh `ncnh`bhpz fvgnc zldq qlbp pw}n dc d~pjdon/jlbhagha

nsg`nhjn pw}gjbiiw onvgpz pln avbhp dc b hnq pvgbi odpgdh nsg`nhjn jdo}inpniw ~higkn plbp qlgjl


22/23

6=

pln `ncnh`bhp vnignz ~}dh gh obkgha pln ghzpbhp odpgdh( GhBvvdwd) b pqd/`bw cnidh/gh/

}dzznzzgdh dc b cgvnbvo jbzn) pln Adsnvhonhpz jbzn p~vhn` n|ji~zgsniw dh pln pnzpgodhw dc pqd

ibq nhcdvjnonhp qgphnzznz( Znn^hgpn` Zpbpnz s(Bvvdwd) :=2 C( Z~}}( 6` 621) 663 ,@( Jdhh(

6==0' ,[g_c pln e~vw `gzfnignsn` plnzn dccgjnvz) plnh plnvn qbz igpnvbiiw hd nsg`nhjn dc Bvvdwdz

a~gip'( Pln dccgjnvz pnzpgcgn` plbp plngv nhjd~hpnv qgpl pln `ncnh`bhp ibzpn` b}}vd|gobpniw 21

znjdh`z( Gp qbz `gzjdsnvn` bcpnv pvgbi plbp b }digjn vb`gd pvbhzogzzgdh vnibpgha pd pln ghjg`nhp

jinbviw nzpbfigzln` plbp pln nhjd~hpnv pddk odvn plbh pqd ogh~pnz) `gvnjpiw jdhpvb`gjpgha pln

dccgjnvz bjjd~hpz bh` nzpbfigzlgha plbp pln bjjd~hpz qnvn c~h`bonhpbiiw cbizn dv ghbjj~vbpn(

G`( bp 667 h(:( Igknqgzn) gh Dvpgu) pln Adsnvhonhpz jbzn p~vhn` nhpgvniw dh pln pnzpgodhw dc pqd

}digjn dccgjnvz qld qgphnzzn` b lbh`/pd/lbh` `v~a zbin( Znn^hgpn` Zpbpnz s( Dvpgu) 277: QI

2:2:67) bp %6 ,B}v( 6:) 277: N(@( ]b('( Pln dccgjnvz pnzpgcgn` plbp pln }nvzdh plnw dfznvsn`

jdh`~jpgha pln zbin qbz qnbvgha b qlgpn p/zlgvp qgpl b `nzgah dh gp( Bcpnv pvgbi) b }dzp/bvvnzp

}ldpd dc pln `ncnh`bhp qbz ~hjdsnvn` zldqgha plbp pln `ncnh`bhp qbz qnbvgha b }ibgh qlgpn p/

zlgvp pln hgalp dc pln zbin) `gvnjpiw jdhpvb`gjp[gha_ plngv pnzpgodhw( G`( bp %7( GhOjIb~aligh) b

pb| nsbzgdh jbzn) pln `gzpvgjp jd~vp cd~h` plbp pln `ncnh`bhpz d~pzg`n bjjd~hpbhp) b Adsnvhonhp

qgphnzz bp pvgbi)}nve~vn`lgoznic qlnh ln zbg` plbp b jnvpbgh fbhk bjjd~hp dc pln `ncnh`bhpz qbz

jdhjnbin` cvdo lgo) bz `nodhzpvbpn` fw zpbpnonhpz cdv pln bjjd~hp plbp ghji~`n` hdpbpgdhz fw

pln bjjd~hpbhp( Znn ^hgpn` Zpbpnz s(OjIb~aligh) ) 361/6< ,N(@( ]b(

6==='(

Bvvdwd) Dvpgu bh`OjIb~aligh bvn }ibghiw `gzpgha~gzlbfin cvdo plgz jbzn( Plnw bvn

}vnjgzniw pln pw}nz dc jbznz qlnvn pln avbhp dc b V~in :: b}}igjbpgdh obw fn b}}vd}vgbpn dh pln

fbzgz dc hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nsg`nhjn pnh`gha pd go}nbjl pln dhiw qgphnzznz pd `gz}~pn` cbjpz5 pln


23/23

62

a~gip dc pln `ncnh`bhpz gh pldzn jbznz p~vhn` nhpgvniw dh pln pnzpgodhw dc pln qgphnzznz bfd~p

pldzn cbjpz) bh` pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nsg`nhjn `gvnjpiw jdhpvb`gjpn` plbp pnzpgodhw( Lnvn) pln

`ncnh`bhpz jdhsgjpgdh `g` hdp p~vh dh Pbfdvz pnzpgodhw) bh` pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nsg`nhjn

`dnz hdp jdhpvb`gjp lgz pnzpgodhw) `gvnjpiw dv gh`gvnjpiw( Bz b vnz~ip) gp gz lgaliw go}vdfbfin

gh`nn`) go}dzzgfin pd gobaghn plbp pln e~vwz snv`gjp qd~i` lbsn fnnh `gccnvnhp gc pln `ncnhzn

lb` fnnh bfin pd jvdzz/n|boghn Pbfdv qgpl pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nobgi bh` hdpn nsg`nhjn(

JDHJI^ZGDH

Gh z~o) pln hnqiw `gzjdsnvn` nsg`nhjn ~}dh qlgjl `ncnh`bhpz ghzpbhp odpgdh vnignz gz

goobpnvgbi) j~o~ibpgsn) bh` qd~i` hdp igkniw lbsn vnz~ipn` gh bh bjr~gppbi gc gp lb` fnnh

b`ogppn`( Znn ^hgpn` Zpbpnz s( Binzzg) 3:< C(6` bp 017( Hdv jbh gp fn zbg` plbp pln hnqiw

`gzjdsnvn` nobgi bh` hdpn nsg`nhjn agsnz vgzn pd b vnbi jdhjnvh plbp bh ghhdjnhp }nvzdh obw

lbsn fnnh jdhsgjpn`( ^hgpn` Zpbpnz s( Jbhdsb) 026 C(:` bp :07( Bjjdv`ghaiw) fnjb~zn ln lbz

hdp zbpgzcgn` pln lnbsw f~v`nh plbp o~zp fn onp pd qbvvbhp vnzdvp pd pln n|pvbdv`ghbvw vnon`w dc

`gzp~vfgha b e~vwz snv`gjp) pln Adsnvhonhp vnz}njpc~iiw z~fogpz plbp Jdiighzz odpgdh cdv b hnq

pvgbi }~vz~bhp pd Cn`nvbi V~in dc Jvgoghbi ]vdjn`~vn :: zld~i` fn `nhgn`(

@bpn`5 Hnq Wdvk) Hnq Wdvk@njnofnv 6

U.S. v. Collins: Government's Opposition to Motion for New Trial

Documents

Transcript of U.S. v. Collins: Government's Opposition to Motion for New Trial