Nsn High Capacity Mobile Broadband for Mass Events White Paper
Upgrade Strategies for Mass Market Mobile Broadband
description
Transcript of Upgrade Strategies for Mass Market Mobile Broadband
Upgrade StrategiesFor Mass Market Mobile Broadband
WHITE PAPER
Key Findings
• The“perfectstorm”ofwidespread3.5Gdeployment,flatratedatatariffs,andavailabilityofmobiles withinternetfriendlyfeatureswillresultinavirtualexplosionofwirelessbroadbanddemandleading tospectrumexhaustion,perhapsby2010.
• ThetechnologyadvancesincorporatedinLTEleadtoincreasednetworkcapacityandeconomic competitiveadvantage. • TheeconomicadvantagesofhighcapacityLTEwillbeinstrumentalindeliveringaffordable,wireless broadbandtothemassmarket,andisdeterminedbythemassmarkettotalaveragecapacityby minimizingtheneedforadditionalcellsitesandfewerradiospercellsite.
• WithLTEnearingcommercialdeploymentin2010,thewindowofopportunityforalegacytechnology upgradeissomewhatlimited.
• AnoperatorchoosinganearlydeploymentofLTEcanexerciseaconsiderablecompetitiveadvantage withtheeconomicbenefitsofLTEratherthaninvestingininterimupgrades.
Introduction
In2006,manycellularoperatorsbegan3.5Gnetworkdeployments(HSPA&EV-DO)andsubsequentlyintroducedverypopularflatratedatatariffs.Theseoperatorsnowenjoyagrowingsubscriberdataservicespenetrationandtheresultinggrowthindatatraffic.Inadditionmostofthedevicesavailabletodayfeaturetheabilitytoplayrichmediacontent,accessemailandanumberofmobilefriendlysitessuchasGoogle,Yahoo,NewYorkTimes,etc.Applicationvendorsarecreatingcontent,portalsandnewwebbrowsingadaptedtothemobilephonemarket.
Thesemarketforcescombinetocreateanexplosionofdatademandontheirnetworks,withmanyoperatorsreportingtripledigityear-on-yeargrowthinnetworkdatatraffic
Thedeploymentof3.5GHSPAnetworkswerecriticalfortheadoptionofmobilebroadbandbutfacedwiththemobilebroadbandmarketsuccess,operatorsmustnowconsidertheupgradepathstosupportthecontinuedgrowthwithwellperformingnetworkthatprovidessufficientcapacitytooffersubscriberagreatmobilebroadbanduserexperiencewhatevertheconditions.
Thenecessaryupgradesto3.5GnetworksoftenrequireincreasingthebackhaulcapacitybetweentheRadioNetworkControllerandCellsites,UTRANsoftwareandhardwareupgradestosupporthigherspeedHSPA,deployingasecondandthirdcarrier,additionalNCs,andadditionalPacketDataCorecapacity.Eventually,costlycellsplittingwillbeneededinmarketswheretheavailablespectrumisexhausted.
Thegrowthindatatrafficcontinuestoincreaseatunprecedentedrates(tripledigitpercentageincreasehasbeenobservedinmanyinstances)1,andmanyoperatorsarealreadyconsideringtheiroptionsfornearandlongtermgrowth.Thispaperstudiesvariousaspectsofchoosinganevolutionpath,withtheparticularfocusonHSPA+andLTEasthemostcommonchoicesfacing3GPPoperators.
WirelessDataBoom–thePerfectStorm
Inthenextfiveyearswirelessdataservice(HSPA)penetrationinsomemarketswillincreasetonearly85%,leadingtomassiveincreaseinpacketdatatrafficinthe2.1GHzUMTSband.AsshowninFigure1,subscriberacceptanceofhighspeeddatacapabilitywillmovewellintothemainstream.Thisuptakewillbeenabledwithfeature-richphonesandsmart-phonesthatwillachievemainstreammass-marketacceptance.
2 WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
1 Informa,2008,3GWirelessBroadband,“TheFutureisflatfornetworkarchitecture…”
-
250
500
750
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Subs
(mill
ion) 10x Penetration
GSM
GPRS EDGE
UMTS
3.5G4G
Figure1.Europeansubscribermigrationtowirelessbroadband.Source:Informa
Competitivepressureswillleadtowidespreaduseofsimplifiedandflatratetariffs,furtherencouragingconsumerutilization.Inmanydevelopedmarkets,feature-richmediahandsetsnowrepresentover50%ofnewhandsetsales.AsshowninFigure2,theworldwideAverageSellingPriceforfeature-richmediaphoneswillsooncrossunderthewidelyacceptedmassmarketthresholdof$150,withsmartphonesfollowingclosely.Asnewentrantsintotheultra-premiumhandsetmarketinevitablybegintomigratetowardthemainstream,increasingpressurewillmovetoday’shighendsmartphonesintothemainstreamaswell.
Figure2.Massmarketadoptionoffeaturerichandsmartphones.
Asthesemarketforces(tariffs,phones,andnetworks)convergeformobilebroadband,operatorswillincreasinglyexperiencecongestiononbroadbandnetworks,withearlyadoptiontechnologiessuchasHSPA(orEV-DORev.A)arefacedwitheverincreasingdemands.Operatorswith5or10MHzofHSPAspectrummayexperiencethisasearlyas2009-2010,dependingonthesizeoftheirsubscriberbaseandhowtherapidlysubscriberbaseandtrafficgrows.
3 WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
3GPPLTETechnologyAdvances The3GPPRelease8,layer1specificationwasfinalizedinJanuary2008,whiletheupperlayers’specificationsareanticipatedtobecompletedlaterin2008.ThehighperformanceLTEairinterfaceextendsthetechnologicalinnovationforthe3GPPoperatorwiththemostadvancedfeaturesbuilt-infromthestart,ratherthanaddedontoanexistingradiotechnology.Thisavoidstheperformancedilutionthatresultsfromlegacymobilesunabletoaccommodatethenewperformancefeatures.
SomeofthedistinguishingcharacteristicsofLTEinclude
• OrthogonalFrequencyDivisionMultipleAccess:SpectralEfficiencyandimprovedcoverage • AdvancedAntennaTechnology:MIMOandBeamForming • HigherOrderModulation:upto64-QAMforhigherdatarates • ScalableBandwidth:1.4MHz–20MHz,scaleforgrowthandincrementalmigrationofexisting spectrumusetoLTE • FrequencySelectiveScheduling:increasesefficiency • AllIPtothemobile:uncompromisedbylegacysupport • Semi-Flatarchitecture:simplifiesnetworkandallowsforeasier,mostcosteffectivescaling • Loweroverheadburden:increaseseffectiveefficiency • QualityofService:builtinfromthestart • LowLatency:Improveusersatisfactionandenableslatencysensitiveapplicationstofunctionbetter (e.g.gaming) • MultimediaBroadcastMulticastService(MBMS):designedfordramaticallyimprovedandefficient videodistributionwithaSingleFrequencyNetwork
PeakdatarateperformancecomparisonTheperformanceenhancingfeaturesof64-QAM,MIMO,andbroadbandspectrumdeliverexceedinglyhighpeakdatarates.Inanycellularnetwork,actuallyachievingthepeakdataraterequiresaparticularlybeneficialsignalenvironmenttodeliverontheirperspectiveperformancegains.Typically,asmallpercentageofsubscribersareinlocationssuitableforthepeakrates,whiletheremaindercanachievereceivesomethingless.
AtypicalmeasureofthecellularenvironmentisaSignaltoNoiseRatiocalledC/I.2x2-MIMOand64-QAMtypicallyrequireanenvironmentwhichexhibitsa10dBC/Iratioinordertodeliverbestresults.Amoreimportantmeasurementfortheremaining95%ofsubscribersistheaveragesectorthroughputforatypicalcellsite.
Figure3depictsactualmeasurementofC/Iin4majorurbanandsuburbanmarkets,withpopulationsrangingfrom1.5to10.5million.Hereweobserveonlyafewpercentofmobilesreportsuch“C/I”sufficientforeither64-QAMor2x2MIMO.
Asaresult,thehighperformancefeaturesofHSPA+willbenefitonlyfewsubscribers(typically2-5%percell)henceprovidelittlecellcapacityimprovement.
4 WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
Figure3.2x2MIMOand64-QAMlimitedbyenvironmentalconditions..
UMTS Release Antenna Technology Bandwidth
Type Qty 5 MHz 10 MHz 20 MHzR6HSPA SIMO 1x1,1x2 14.4 -- --
R7HSPA+ MIMO 2x2 28.8 -- --
R7HSPA+64-QAM SIMO 1x1,1x2 21.6 -- --
R8LTE MIMO 2x2 43 86 173(1)
R8LTE MIMO 4x4 82 163 326(1)
Table1.DLPeakDataRates,Mbps(1)3GPPTR25.912V7.2.0
ForthebestMIMOperformance,arichmulti-pathsignalenvironmentisrequired,andvarieswidelywithlocation.Atypicallocationwouldbewhenthemobiledevicehasadirectlineofsightpathtothetransmitterandanearbyreflectingbuilding.WhenconditionssuitableforMIMOexist,thentwonon-correlatingdatastreamscanbeeffectivelydeliveredtothemobile,withdataratesapproximatelydoubling.
Theeconomicvalueofthesesustaininginnovationsisdeterminedbytheeffectontotalaveragecapacityforanentiremassmarket,andnotjustthebenefitsdeliveredtothefortunatefew.TheaveragesectorthroughputisthemetrictoassesseconomicpotentialandtheonethatoperatorsshouldbeconcernedaboutasithasadirectimpactontheirnetworkCAPEXandOPEX.
5 WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
CellShrinkage
Unlikesharedcarriertechnologies(likeCDMAandWCDMA),LTEiseffectivelyimmunetocellshrinkageor“breathing”asnormallyobservedastrafficincreasesspreadspectrumtechnologies.Thiscanleadtolargerfootprintandfewercellsites,aswellasincreasethelikelihoodofexistingcellsitereuse.
TheImportanceofDownLinkSectorThroughput
Thetotalsectorthroughputissimplythetotalnumberofbitsdeliveredtoallusersinasector.Thesomewhatclover-shapeofacellsitecoveragehasrelativelyfewsubscribersclosetocelltowerthatcangetthehighestdatarates,whilemostsubscribersaredispersedfurtherfromthetowerandachievelowerdatarates.
Althoughtheadvancedtechnologiesof64-QAMand2x2MIMOwithLTEarenotyetdeployed,wecangainmuchinsightbyexaminingthesimulationoftypicalconditions.Usingatypicalreferencescenario2,LTEisexpectedtodelivernearlytwicethesectorthroughputthatoperatorscurrentlyexpect.Aswirelessbroadbandreachesthemassmarket,theLTEsolutionwillrequiresignificantlylessradioresourcethanlegacytechnologiestomeetthedemand.ExpensivecellsplittingmorelikelytobeavoidedandthusgivingasustainablecompetitiveadvantagetoanLTEoperator.
Figure4.DLAverageSectorThroughput2,Mbps.Source:Motorola
LTEImprovementstoDownlinkThroughputandCapacityWhilealsoutilizingMIMOand64QAM,LTEbringsanumberofimprovementsthathaveadirectimpactonthe
userexperienceofallusersinacell: • Bettermulti-pathsignalhandlingcapabilitythanCDMAtechnologies. • Nointra-cellinterference,aseachsub-carrierisuniquelyassigned. • Interferencecancellationisbetterforreducedinter-cellinterference. • Mitigatesthecellshrinkagevs.loadingphenomenaofCDMAtechnologies. • MoreefficientMulticast,Broadcast. • LowercontroloverheadthanCDMA. • FrequencySelectiveschedulingforadditionalflexibilityandefficiency.
2Performanceresultsbasedon2GHz,fullbufferdata,1.732kmintersitedistance,3km/hr,MMSEreceivers,2x2MIMO(HSPA1x2),and20dBpenetrationloss
6 WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
TheImportanceofUplinkPerformance3.5Gand4Gcellularnetworksarefrequentlyuplinklimited,eitherbythemaximumrangeofahandsetforcoveragelimitedcellsorbytheuplinkradiointerfaceincapacitylimitedcells.Thesearejusttwofactorsthatdeterminetheeffectivecellsize,numberofcarriers,andnumberofcellsitesdeployed.
Asnetworkloadingincreases,thatisnumberofsubscribersinthecell,thesharedcarrierofspreadspectrumCDMAtechnologieswillundergocellshrinkage(orbreathing)fromwhichLTEislargelyimmune.ThecauseoftheshrinkageissimplymoresubscribersonthesamecarrierintroducesmoreRFnoiseinthecell,reducingSignal-to-Noiseratio.Thismeansastrongersignalisrequiredtogetthesamedatarateaswhenfewersubscribersareactive.Sincethisisusuallyaccomplishedbyashorterrangefromthetower,thecelleffectivelyshrinks.
WithLTE,eachsubscriberhasuniqueuseoftheassignedindividualtonesduringatimeslot.ThereisnocellshrinkagephenomenonbecauseofsharedcarriersaswithspreadspectrumCDMAtechnologies.
Also,LTEwilllaunchwithsophisticateduplinkinterferencecancellationmethodsbuiltintotheairinterface,furtherincreasingtheuplinkspectralefficiencyandcapacitybyreducingtheapparentnoiselevels.
Assubscribersandoperatorsbecomemoresophisticatedintheuseofwirelessbroadband,usagepatternschangeaccordingly.Inhistoricalvoicedominatednetworks,aroughlybalanceduplinkanddownlinkweredesirable.
Withtheriseofpeer-to-peercommunication,socialnetworking,andusergeneratedcontent,theuplinkanddownlinktrafficprofilesbecomemorebalanced,andthisisreadilysupportedwiththe3.5Gtechnologies.Theuplinkperformancewillincreaseinimportanceasthesesocialnetworkingactivitymovestothemobilerealm.Recenthandsetintroductionsmakeshooting,editingandsharingvideosdirectlyfromyourmobileeasierthaneverbefore3.
EconomicCompetitiveAdvantageTotalCostofOwnershipAswirelessbroadbandreachesthemassmarket,theimpactofaveragethroughputorcapacitybecomesapparent.Assubscriberpenetrationandusagetransitionsfromearlyadopterstagetomassmarketpenetration,theadditionalcapacitydeliveredbyLTEwillyieldsignificantcompetitiveadvantage.Theearlyadopterstageischaracterizedasapredominantlylaptop,datacardandUSBdonglesubscriber.Thedatademandsmaybehigh,butthesubscriberpenetrationinthelowsingledigits.Massmarketinevitablymeanshandsetoriented,withsubscriberpenetrationbywirelessbroadbandapproaching85%,earlyinthenextdecade4.
Whentheaveragedatatrafficformassmarketsubscribersislow,amuchofthenetworkremainscoveragelimited,thatiscellsitesarenotoperatingnearthecapacityoftheradiointerface.Astrafficbuilds,thenasignificantportionofthenetworkbecomescapacitylimited,withadditionalradiocarriersdeployedtohandlethetrafficload.Afterspectrumlimitsarereached,additionalcellsitesaredeployed.
Theinflectionpointfromcoveragelimitedtocapacitylimitedwillofcoursevarybymarket,spectrum,radiotechnology,tariffplans,etc.LegacyCDMAbasedtechnologiesmayexhibitthisinflectionat1–2GBytes/monthforanaveragesubscriber,while4GOFDMtechnologiesmayexhibitsomesignswithat4GBytes/month.AsignificanteconomicadvantagedeliveredbyLTEcapacityistheabilitytomeetthegrowingwirelessbroadbanddemand.
3MotorolaZ10,http://www.motorola.com/mediacenter/news4Informa,FutureMobileBroadband,2ndEdition
7 WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
Figure5.TotalCostofOwnershipInflectionSource:Motorola
WindowofOpportunity
ThependinglaunchofLTEwillcauseoperatorstoconsidertheirCapExspendcycle,andhowthatcandeterminetheirpositionwhenacompetitordeploysLTE.Thewindowofopportunitytocapitalizeoninterimupgradesmaybelimitedbyavailabilityandsubscribermixofsuitabledevicesinthenearterm,andtheinevitablelaunchofLTEinthelongerterm.
Upgradecost
OperatorswithsignificantlegacyequipmentmaydiscoverasignificantCapitalExpenditureisneededforaninterimupgrade.ThismaybeduetolegacyhardwareunabletohandletheMIMOor64-QAMhighspeeddataratefeatures.Newancillaries(possiblyadditionalduplexersandcablingforMIMO,forexample)mayalsocomplicatethevalueproposition,especiallyifacompetitoradoptsLTEsoonerratherthanlater.
Therearealsocorenetworkupgradeimplicationstoconsider.Mostcorenetworkswillcontinuetorequireupgradetohandlethecapacitywithadvancing3.5Gand4Gtrafficdemands.TheEvolvedPacketCorenetworkismuchmoreefficientandscalabletodeploythanthe2G/3GderivedGPRScoreelements(RNCs,SGSNs,GGSNs,etc.).ThisisbecausetheEPCisoptimizedaroundbroadbanddatanetworktechnologies(vs.ATM,etc.).Theincreaseinbackhaulrequirementsarecompoundedoncespectrumisexhaustedandoperatorsresorttocell-splitting.
8 WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
TheLTEupgradeCapExcycleappearstohavecomplexitiesandconsiderationscomparabletomostnetworktechnologyupgrades,butitprovidesmuchbetterforwardlookingprospectsaswemoveintothemassmarketwirelessbroadbandera.
SpectrumforLTE
LicensedSpectrumacquisitionpresentsaseriousbarriertoentryformanypotentialcompetitors,hencethefiercecompetitionforavailableallocations.Currently,many3GPPoperatorsworldwidehave5MHzto15MHzallocationsofFullDuplexspectruminthe2.1GHzband.TherisingdemandforwirelessbroadbandmayverywellfillthisspectrumjustasLTEbecomesavailable.Aspectrumcrunchin2009–2011willincreasetheurgencyforLTEinnewspectrum(2.5–2.6GHz,AWS,700MHz)orofLTErefarmingexistingGSM/CDMAspectrums,furtherextendingwirelessbroadbandintothemassmarket.AsshowninFigure5,operatorswitharelativelyrapidmigrationofsubscribersfromGSMtoHSPAmaybethefirsttoexhausttheir2.1GHzcapacity
Figure7.OperatorswithrapidHSPApenetrationandlimitedspectrumareearlycandidatesforLTE.
Figure5.Operatorsintheupperleftwiththemostsubscribers,leastspectrum,andrapidupgradefromGSMwillbehighlymotivatedforLTEsoonerratherthanlater
Eventually,GSMwillbereplacedbymorecapable3GPPtechnologies,andLTEpresentsauniqueopportunityforin-bandmigrationmadepossiblebythescalablebandwidthofLTE.Ifaslittleas1.4MHzofGSMcanberefarmed,abaselineLTEsystemcanbedeployed.MultimodeGSM/LTEmobilescanthenfacilitatethemigrationofvoicetraffictotheall-IPLTEwitheachincrementaltransitionprovidinganincreaseinbothcapacityandperformance.Initialmobiledeviceswilllikelybemulti-mode,multi-banddatacardsandUSBdevicessubjecttooperatordemand.Basedonmobilechipsetavailability,Datadevicesshouldbeavailablein2010.Multi-band,Multi-modemobilessupportingLTEarealsosubjecttooperatordemand.Migratingvoiceservicesfrom2GtoLTEisdependentonVoIP/IMSuptakebyoperators.
OtherspectrumsuitableforLTEincludestheworldwideroamingpossibilityaffordedby700MHzspectrumintheU.S.andlaterinEurope,plustherefarmed900MHz/1800MHzspectruminEurope.
9 WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
UpgradeStrategyandBenefitsofEarlyLTEDeploymentLTEBusinessmodelingThechoicesanoperatormakesinmanagingtheevolutiontomassmarketwirelessbroadbandwillhaveaprofoundimpactontheirfutureprospects,especiallygiventhehighlycompetitivenatureofwireless.Asanexample,wesuggestamodelbasedonLondondemographicsforanoperatorwithapproximately2Millionsubscribers,withmostata2Gor2.5Ggenreofapplicationsophistication,thatis,namelyvoice.Overaperiodofafewyears,thewirelessbroadbandpenetrationwillriseto85%.Formodelingpurposes,considertheaveragesubscriberdatademandsalong3scenarios:reachingeither1Gbyte,3GByte,and5GBytepermonthin2011,10%ofthattraffichappeninginanybusyhour.FifteenMHzof2.1GHzspectrumisallocated.
Figure8.Exampleoperatormodelwithdemographicsandbroadbanddatagrowth.
Considerfourpossiblestrategiesfortheevolutionofthisnetwork.
1. StaywithfullspeedHSPAanddeploy3carriers,addingcellsitesasneeded 2. DeployHSPAandmobileswithReceiveDiversity 3. DeployHSPAfollowedwithupgradetoHSPA+(mobilesin2010). 4. 5MHzofHSPA(Rx.Div)+10MHzLTEforin-bandmigration.
Theresultshavesignificantimplications,andsummarizedinafourchartillustrationshowingcellsiteproliferation.Theverticalscaleindicatesthenumberofcellssitesrequiredovertimeassubscriberpenetrationincreasesanddatatrafficperuseralsoincreases.Theinitialconditionsareasinglecarrieralreadydeployedat2.1GHzprovidingbasiccoverageacrossthemarket.
Thefirstcaseillustratesasimpledeploymentofupto15MHzspectrum.3.5Gtechnologiesaloneareunabletosupportaverageusertrafficof3ormoreGBytepermonth.
Thesecondcaseshowsadefinitereductionincellsiteproliferationwiththewidespreaddeploymentofmobileswithreceivediversity.Theintroductionofmobileswithreceivediversityearlyinthebroadbandramp-upincreasestheaveragesectorthroughputto3.4Mbps.Deferringtheintroductionofmobileswithreceivediversitywouldreducenetworkcapacity,aslegacymobilesstillrequireservice.Theimprovementtocapacityreducescellsiteproliferationofcapacitylimitedcellsites,andassumesthatreceivediversityhandsets(inadditiontodatacards)aredeployedearlyinthesubscriberuptakeof3.5G.
10 WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
Thethirdcaseillustratestheeffectoffillingthesubscriberbaseduringthegrowthphasewithlegacymobiles.WhileHSPA+mobilesareintroducedin2010,thelegacydevicesdiluteoverallnetworkperformanceandresultsintheunwantedproliferationofcellsites.Thepresenceofthelowdataratelegacymobilesdilutingnetworkcapacityresultsintheoddcurve.ThefullbenefitsofHSPA+arerealizedasthosedevicesarereplacedwithnewermobiles.
Thefinalcaserepresentsanin-bandmigrationstrategythatminimizesinvestmentinthelegacytechnology,withtheforwardlookinginvestmentfocusedonLTE.LTEisthenintroducedin10MHzofspectrum,andworkingintandemwiththe3.5Gassets,meetsthetrafficdemandwhileminimizingcellsitesproliferation.
Figure9.CellSitesvstimefor4networkevolutionscenarios.
Withthecostofsite(bothOPEX/CAPEX)inlargeurbanareabeingsometimesashighas10xthecostoftheequipmentdeployed,onecaneasilyimagine,evenonthemostpessimisticdatagrowthscenario,howthecostofcellsplittingwillimpactoperatorson3.5Gtechnologycomparedtooperatorsthatwouldhaveupgradedto4GLTE.Modelingthemarketforecastsofdatauptakesuggeststhatinmanymarketsthe2.1GHzspectrummaybeexhaustedjustasLTEarrivesin20105.ThedeploymentofLTEinnewlyacquiredspectrumwilllargelyeliminatethecellsiteproliferationshownabove.
Motorolarecommendations
Theconvergenceofcompellingmobilessuitableforwirelessbroadbandandinternetaccess,widespreadacceptanceofcompetitivetariffs,andtheinevitableconsumerdemandformobilebroadbandsetsthestageforunprecedenteduptakeinwirelessdatatraffic,andtheexpectedspectrumcapacitycrunch in2009–2011.
Operatorscanbestpositionthemselvesby
1. Maximizingthecapacityoftheir3.5Gassetsbyupgradingtofullspeedinfrastructureandmobiles, `utilizeavailable2.1GHzspectrum,anddeploymobileswithReceiveDiversityearlyinthe3.5G uptakephase.Thiswillreapmostofthecapacityimprovementsandminimizecapital expenditureduringthemassmarketdevelopment.
5InformaWCIS,Motorolamodeling,andprivatediscussionswithoperators
11 WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
2. Operatorsthatexhausttheir2.1GHzspectrumshouldconsidersupportingtheirmassmarket wirelessbroadbanddemandwithearlyadoptionofLTEinthe2.6GHzUMTSexpansions bandandotherbands(700MHzorAWSbands).
3. Operatorswithlarge2.1GHzspectrumassetscouldconsiderinbanddeploymentofLTE.
CompetitiveadvantagefavorsanearlymovetoLTEWhilesomeoperatorsmaynotconsiderLTEuntilafter2012,asignificantcompetitiveadvantagecanaccruetotheoperatorthatpursuesanearlymigrationtoLTE.Inadditiontohighbroadbanddataratesthatsubscribersalwayschase,andtheenormouscapacity,thefirstmovingearlyadopterofLTEwillbenefitbyhaveasignificantportionofsubscriberdatadeliveredviaLTE,thusavoidingspectrumexhaustionandtheresultingcellsplittingtohandlecapacityneeds.
Thisisillustratedwithalargeurbanandsuburbanmarketexample,atheoreticaloperatorwith10MHzofFDDspectrumat1.9GHz.Investigationscomparingvarioustechnologiesareexamined.Allexternalinputsareheldconstant(thatis,subscriberpricesensitivity,trafficdemand,subscriberpenetration,cellsiteacquisitionanddevelopmentcosts,spectrumallocation,etc).
Theprincipleobservations: • Reflectsconsumerpricesensitivity–existingsubscriberpenetrationwithwireless broadbandincreaseswithlowertariffs. • Networksbasedonlegacytechnologiesresorttocellsplittingtomanagetotal trafficdemand. • TheLTEoperatorhasanincentivetodecreasewirelessbroadbandtariffstomaximize thediscountedcashflow–uptothepointofcellsplitting.
Inpractice,theLTEoperatorwouldpickupconsiderablemarketsharebyexercisingtheeconomicadvantageofLTE.Thisincreasedmarketsharewouldchangethediscountedcashflowpropositiontoadifferentandoptimumpricepoint.
Figure10..LTECompetitiveAdvantage.Source:Motorolamodeling
12WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
Inthisfigure,theNetPresentValue(discountedcashflow,verticalscale,in$Millions)vs.Tariff(horizontalscale,in$/Month)intheupperleftchartillustratestheincentiveandcompetitiveadvantagefortheLTEoperator.Thesweetspothereisa$30foraflatratetariff.Undertheseconditions,legacyCDMAtechnologiesarenotcompetitivewith4GOFDMALTE.
ConclusionsAnumberofkeyobservationsnowappearobvious.
1) WirelessBroadbandadoptionisboomingduetotheconvergenceofwidespread3.5GNetworks andattractivetariffs. 2) WirelessBroadbandwillpenetratethemassmarketcoincidingwiththedeploymentofmainstream featurerichphonesandsmartphones. 3) Legacytechnologyupgradeswillofferincrementalcapacityimprovements,mostofwhichcanbe achievedwiththedeploymentofmobilereceivediversity. 4) LTEoffersamuchstrongertechnologybase(radioandnetworkarchitecture)forawireless broadbanddataenvironmentthatcangrowmuchmoreefficiently(TCO)asbroadband adoptionclimbs
5) Severalstrategiesareavailableforoperatorstoevolvetheirnetworks.EarlyadoptionoftheLTE scenarioseemstoofferthebestforwardlookingopportunity.
6) TheeconomicadvantagesofanearlymovetoLTEformeetingthemassmarketdemandwillgive significantcompetitiveadvantage.
FormoreinformationonMotorolaLTEandhowLTEcanhelpyougainacompetitiveadvantage,pleasetalktoyourMotorolarepresentative.
13WHITEPAPER:UpgradeStrategiesForMassMarketMobileBroadband
motorola.com
PartnumberWP-UPGRADESTRATEGIES.PrintedinUSA,01/09.MOTOROLAandtheStylizedMLogoareregisteredintheUSPatent&TrademarkOffice.Allotherproductorservicenamesarethepropertyoftheirrespectiveowners.©Motorola,Inc.2009.Allrightsreserved.Forsystem,productorservicesavailabilityandspecificinformationwithinyourcountry,pleasecontactyourlocalMotorolaofficeorBusinessPartner.Specificationsaresubjecttochangewithoutnotice.