UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS...

42
UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015

Transcript of UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS...

Page 1: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT

Joe TenerelliOcean Data Lab

SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre

Barcelona, Spain21-23 April 2015

Page 2: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

PRIORITIES (HIGHEST TO LOWEST)

1. Land contamination

2. Sun glint

3. Galactic glint

4. Short term (latitudinal) drift

Page 3: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

SUN GLINT IN EAF FOV IN DESCENDING PASSES IN NOVEMBER-JANUARY

Page 4: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

Huge first stokes bias on western side of EAF FOV in descending passes, peaking around December:

THE SUN GLINT IMPACT IN THE EAF FOV IN DESCENDING PASSES

Page 5: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

Huge first stokes bias on western side of EAF FOV in descending passes, peaking around December:

THE SUN GLINT IMPACT IN THE EAF FOV IN DESCENDING PASSES

Page 6: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

Bias can exceed 20 K in first Stokes divided by two, but is mainly in the EAF-FoV!

THE SUN GLINT IMPACT IN THE EAF FOV IN DESCENDING PASSES

Page 7: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

GO model (with total MSS=0.01, Sun Tb=100000 K) shows this signal too, but need to tune the model to fit the data:

THE SUN GLINT IMPACT IN THE EAF FOV IN DESCENDING PASSES

Page 8: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

WHERE DOES SUN GLINT IMPACT THE DATA?The sun specular point (where the sun glint is maximum) is closest to boresight in descending passes late in the year, from November through January:

Page 9: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

WHERE DOES SUN GLINT IMPACT THE DATA?The sun specular point (where the sun glint is maximum) is closest to boresight in descending passes late in the year, from November through January:

Page 10: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

EXTRACTING SUN GLINT FROM THE DATA

To determine the impact of sun glint on the data, we need to find a way to extract the contribution of the sun glint to the total scene brightness temperature. Below is an example the the reconstructed scene brightness (Tx+Ty)/2 obtained from the MIRAS visibilities:

Page 11: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

EXTRACTING SUN GLINT FROM THE DATA

To extract the sun glint over pure open ocean scenes, we evaluate the forward ocean model over the entire FHS. Below is an example of this model over just the fundamental hexagon:

Page 12: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

EXTRACTING SUN GLINT FROM THE DATA

The visibilities corresponding to this model are calculated using the G-matrix, and then the model scene is recomputed by applying the J+ matrix and then computing the inverse Fourier transform, producing for this example:

Page 13: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

EXTRACTING SUN GLINT FROM THE DATA

Subtracting the reconstructed model from the total data yields the sun glint + scene bias + random noise:

Page 14: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

EXTRACTING SUN GLINT FROM THE DATA

To remove the scene bias we compute an OTT using an ascending pass that does not contain sun glint:

Page 15: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

EXTRACTING SUN GLINT FROM THE DATA

Subtracting this OTT from the image below

Page 16: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

EXTRACTING SUN GLINT FROM THE DATA

Yields the sun glint after correction for the OTT. This is the estimated sun glint.

Page 17: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

EXTRACTING SUN GLINT FROM THE DATA

We then replicate the solution by tiling the solutions over the fundamental hexagon to yield, after removal of discs around the direct sun aliases:

Page 18: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

EXTRACTING SUN GLINT FROM THE DATA

Finally, we remove the part of the solution that is contaminated by aliases to yield the final sun glint image:

Page 19: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

MODELING THE SUN GLINT

Some examples of model solutions for the sun glint:

Kirchhoff model with Kudryavtsev wave spectrum evaluated at wind speed of 20 m/s

Page 20: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

MODELING THE SUN GLINT

Some examples of model solutions for the sun glint:

SSA-1 model with Kudryavtsev wave spectrum evaluated at wind speed of 20 m/s

Page 21: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

MODELING THE SUN GLINT

Some examples of model solutions for the sun glint:

Geometric optics model with an isotropic slope PDF with total MSS = 0.03:

Page 22: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

MODELING THE SUN GLINT

Some examples of model solutions for the sun glint:

Difference between the geometric optics and KA solutions:

Page 23: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

GLINT EVOLUTION ALONG AN ORBIT

Sun glint can vary rapidly in time in response to variations is roughness and sun brightness temperature:

-40 K 160 K

Page 24: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

GLINT EVOLUTION ALONG AN ORBIT

Sun glint can vary rapidly in time in response to variations is roughness and sun brightness temperature:

-40 K 160 K

Page 25: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

GLINT EVOLUTION ALONG AN ORBIT

Sun glint can vary rapidly in time in response to variations is roughness and sun brightness temperature:

-40 K 160 K

Page 26: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

GLINT EVOLUTION ALONG AN ORBIT

Sun glint can vary rapidly in time in response to variations is roughness and sun brightness temperature:

-40 K 160 K

Page 27: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

GLINT EVOLUTION ALONG AN ORBIT

Sun glint can vary rapidly in time in response to variations is roughness and sun brightness temperature:

-40 K 160 K

Page 28: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

GLINT EVOLUTION ALONG AN ORBIT

Sun glint can vary rapidly in time in response to variations is roughness and sun brightness temperature:

-40 K 160 K

Page 29: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

NEED SOLAR FLUX DATA TO MODEL SUN GLINTSun brightness temperature varies greatly over the mission!

Page 30: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

NEED SOLAR FLUX DATA TO MODEL SUN GLINTSun brightness temperature varies greatly over the mission!

Page 31: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

NEED SOLAR FLUX DATA TO MODEL SUN GLINTSun brightness temperature varies greatly over the mission!

Page 32: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

NEED SOLAR FLUX DATA TO MODEL SUN GLINT

Main possible sources: Observatories at San Vito, Sagamore Hills (USA East Coast), Palehua (Hawaii), Learmonth (Australia), Penticton 10 cm (Western Canada)

But for desc passes in East Pacific only data from Learmonth useful (daytime).

Can compare flux data from different sources in overlapping time periods.

Page 33: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

GLINT EVOLUTION ALONG AN ORBIT

In this example the glint variations are apparently not associated with variations in sun brightness temperature:

Page 34: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

COMPARING MODEL AND DATA

To evaluate the various model solutions we divide the domain into strips bounded by curves of constant specular slope. The overlapping bands have width of 0.05 in slope and are spaced by 0.01 is slope.

Page 35: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

COMPARING MODEL AND DATA

Within each band we compute the average glint from both the data and model solutions as well as the average 10-m NE wind speed from ECMWF:

Page 36: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

COMPARING MODEL AND DATA

Within each band we compute the average glint from both the data and model solutions as well as the average 10-m NE wind speed from ECMWF:

Page 37: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

WAY FORWARD

• Calculate a set of SSA-1 and KA solutions over a range of wind speeds on hexagonal grid and apply Blackman apodization.

• Compare solutions to the data as a function of some sort of geometry variable such as specular surface slope.

• Fit models to the data in both quasi-specular and EAF-FoV zones. May need to patch different models (GO in quasi-specular lobe, SSA-1 or KA in EAF-FoV?)

Page 38: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

COMPARING MODEL AND DATA

Page 39: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

COMPARING MODEL AND DATA

Page 40: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

COMPARING MODEL AND DATA

Evolution of specular sun incidence angle for descending passes:

Page 41: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

COMPARING MODEL AND DATA

Page 42: UPDATE ON THE SUN GLINT Joe Tenerelli Ocean Data Lab SMOS Level 2 OS Progress Meeting 26 SMOS Barcelona Expert Centre Barcelona, Spain 21-23 April 2015.

COMPARING MODEL AND DATA