Unforeseen Consequences

21
8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 1/21 Ufdm{eseef Cmfsexuefces H Cmnzhfbmf qm ,Rmu Chffmq [uf D{mn Rmu{seod, kr K{bhf \& Zm{qe{ Sefhqm{ Pekuomf @edd{bes +Qge{e qger lm(+ H{qgu{ Dohffblhf l{bffea hs |e sqmma qmleqge{ bf qge TBZ secqbmf md qge Hb{ hfa Szhce Nuseun,s BNHW Qgehqe{ |hqcgbfl qge oh{le sc{eef& B cmuoaf,q see |ghq |hs sm ewcbqbfl/ ufoess bq |hs qge sbpe md qge BNHW sc{eef& Hoo B sh| mf qghq sc{eef |hs h oh{le {mci |bqg h dhbfq koue dohne hq mfe efa hfa szh{ioes ge{e hfa qge{e mf qge su{dhce& Qge zbcqu{e |hsf,q etef sqehar& Qge mfor qgbfl lmma hkmuq qge szhce cbqr oehtbfl |hs hoo qge scun bfsbae qghq |e{e muq md mu{ ghb{& B shba/ +Lmma {baahfce& H{qgu{/ nr kmr/ qghq |hs h ahnfea lmma baeh rmu gha& Lmq {ba md h kufcg md oedq oehfbf, lhrs hfa cobnhqe hoh{nbsqs& Ahnfea lmma baeh&+ Qge sgm| |hs mte{& Hoo |e,a see d{mn fm| mf |hs z{eqqr nucg qge shne zbcqu{e/ ewcezq qge {mci |muoa leq snhooe{/ ufoess bq koe| uz& Bd qghq ghzzefea/ bq,a ke keqqe{ bd |e |e{e muq md {hfle md qge dhoomuq& B hsiea/ +Sm |ghq,s fewq mf rmu{ hlefah=+ Sqboo |hqcgbfl qge sc{eef/ ge shba/ +B ghte hfmqge{ FEH zbciea muq& Nr c{e| bs `usq hkmuq {ehar qm zbci bq uz&+ Hfmqge{ FEH= +Ghtef,q geh{a md hfrqgbfl ahfle{mus&+ B ghte

Transcript of Unforeseen Consequences

Page 1: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 1/21

Ufdm{eseef CmfsexuefcesH Cmnzhfbmf qm ,Rmu Chffmq [ufD{mn Rmu{seod,

kr

K{bhf \& Zm{qe{

Sefhqm{ Pekuomf @edd{bes+Qge{e qger lm(+ H{qgu{ Dohffblhf l{bffea hs |e sqmma

qmleqge{ bf qge TBZ secqbmf md qge Hb{ hfa Szhce Nuseun,s BNHWQgehqe{ |hqcgbfl qge oh{le sc{eef&

B cmuoaf,q see |ghq |hs sm ewcbqbfl/ ufoess bq |hs qge sbpe md 

qge BNHW sc{eef& Hoo B sh| mf qghq sc{eef |hs h oh{le {mci |bqg hdhbfq koue dohne hq mfe efa hfa szh{ioes ge{e hfa qge{e mf qgesu{dhce& Qge zbcqu{e |hsf,q etef sqehar& Qge mfor qgbfl lmmahkmuq qge szhce cbqr oehtbfl |hs hoo qge scun bfsbae qghq |e{e muqmd mu{ ghb{&

B shba/ +Lmma {baahfce& H{qgu{/ nr kmr/ qghq |hs h ahnfealmma baeh rmu gha& Lmq {ba md h kufcg md oedq oehfbf, lhrs hfacobnhqe hoh{nbsqs& Ahnfea lmma baeh&+ Qge sgm| |hs mte{& Hoo|e,a see d{mn fm| mf |hs z{eqqr nucg qge shne zbcqu{e/ ewcezq

qge {mci |muoa leq snhooe{/ ufoess bq koe| uz& Bd qghq ghzzefea/ bq,ake keqqe{ bd |e |e{e muq md {hfle md qge dhoomuq&

B hsiea/ +Sm |ghq,s fewq mf rmu{ hlefah=+Sqboo |hqcgbfl qge sc{eef/ ge shba/ +B ghte hfmqge{ FEH zbciea

muq& Nr c{e| bs `usq hkmuq {ehar qm zbci bq uz&+Hfmqge{ FEH= +Ghtef,q geh{a md hfrqgbfl ahfle{mus&+ B ghte

Page 2: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 2/21

keef feloecqbfl qge scbefce fe|s md ohqe& Qge{e,s qmm nucg lmbflmf bf \hsgbflqmf/ |ghq |bqg qge Aenmc{hqs q{rbfl qm {hbse qhwesmf qge {bcg/ zemzoe obie ne/ nr cmfsqbquefqs& Geoo/ qger |hfq qmzhr zemzoe qm sbq hq gmne& Hq oehsq qge Szehie{ |hs zusgbfl

|eodh{e {edm{n/ dm{ce qge aehakehqs qm coehf qgbfls uz hfa squdd/nhie qgen |m{i dm{ qgeb{ lmte{fnefq nmfer& B ghaf,q geh{a{unm{s md hfrqgbfl ahfle{mus bf szhce/ qgmulg& Nr zemzoesgmuoa ghte qmoa ne bd smneqgbfl |hs qge{e& B,a ghte qm ommi hqqge obsq&

Ge zuq nr nbfa hq ehse hs |e oedq qge qgehqe{& +Qgbs mfe bsfmq gehaea dm{ us/ req& \gm ifm|s |ghq qge duqu{e |boo k{bfl/ sm|e qhie z{echuqbmfs&+

Bq smufaea obie hf ewcuse qm ne/ h |hr qm gbae qge q{ue{ehsmf d{mn qge nhsses& B luessea/ +Hfa rmu nhie nmfer&+\gef bf amukq/ dmoom| qge nmfer& Bq,s ho|hrs nmfer&

+Bq bs bf h cmftefbefq m{kbq qghq |boo qhie obqqoe qm {eab{ecq& Res/ B|boo nhie nmfer |bqg qgbs mfe hosm&+

B ife| bq& Fm| gm| qm cmftbfce qge kobfa babmqs mf qge domm{ |efeeaea qgbs=

+\gm am |e sefa qgbs qbne=+

+Kr qge qbne qgbs mfe bs {ehar dm{ gunhfbqr/ |e |boo ifm| |gmqm sefa& Ufqbo qgef/ B am fmq |m{{r hkmuq bq&+ Qghq hfs|e{ oedq h omqmzef&

\e |hoiea muq bfqm ahroblgq& Nr a{bte{ |hs hoe{q/ hs usuho/hfa bnneabhqeor zuooea qm qge cu{k bf d{mfq md ne&

B qu{fea hfa sgmmi H{qgu{,s ghfa& +Qghq,s lmma qm geh{/ nrkmr& \e,oo ghte qm qhoi hkmuq dufabfl ohqe{/ mte{ abffe{ m{ smneqgbfl qghq,oo lbte us qhw {eobed&+

Qge a{bte{ mzefea qge amm{ bf d{mfq md ne& +\eoo/ B,te lmq qmlm& Qgbfls qm am/ rh ifm|&+

+B |boo see rmu hq hfmqge{ qbne/ Sefhqm{&+ Ge smufaea honmsqghzzr qm leq {ba md ne&

Hs nr a{bte{ comsea qge amm{/ B oehfea khci bf qge zousg {eh{ sehq md qge Chaar hfa {unbfhqea hkmuq nr aehobfls |bqg H{qgu{ Dohffblhf& Qghq kmr |hs ho|hrs sm dm{nho/ kuq ge aba ghte hf

Page 3: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 3/21

baeh gm| qm nhie qge |m{oa h keqqe{ zohce& H ahnfea lmma baeh/hfa |bqg qge szbf |e haaea/ |eoo/ qghq B haaea/ bq lhbfea nez{esqble hfa zm|e{& B,a ghte qm ieez bf qmucg/ ieez |hqcgbfl gbn/zhr hqqefqbmf qm |ghq ge |hs ambfl& Nhrke/ |bqg smne ouci/ B

cmuoa nhie nr `mk etef ehsbe{& Leqqbfl {ba md qgmse |gm chusez{mkoens ho{ehar nhae mu{ `mk bf Cmfl{ess oess md h ghssoe&\e,a zhssea sete{ho kboos/ |hrs md |hqcgbfl ecm d{ehis hfa mqge{ z{mkoens/ hfa mfe kboo qghq |muoa honmsq eobnbfhqe nr qhw omha/ hoo|bqgmuq geh{bfl mzzmsbqbmf d{mn qge babmq nhsses& Lmte{fbfl |hsh geoo md h omq ehsbe{& Qge a{bte{,s amm{ comsea&

B shba/ +K{uce/ khci qm qge mddbce&+ B gha qmoa qge q{uqg |gef Bshba B gha |m{i qm am& \e qu{fea mfqm qge sq{eeq/ B zuooea muq nr

ceoo/ qu{fea bq mf/ hfa abhoea fbfe ablbqs& H nhoe zbciea uz qgemqge{ efa& B zbcqu{ea qge iba/ rmufl/ hll{essbte/ |bqg gbs dbfle{ mfqge zuose md cmfqenzm{h{r q{efas& H lmma cmfsuoqhfq/ kuq fmq hze{smf qm sgm| rmu{ dhce |bqg& B qu{fea mf qge Nba|esq cgh{n&

+Gef{r= @edd{bes ge{e&++Sefhqm{& Lmma qm geh{ d{mn rmu& B gmze rmu,{e ambfl |eoo=

Rmu{ dhnbor=++Res/ res/ ambfl dbfe& Rmu{s qmm=+

+Cmuoaf,q ke keqqe{&+Qge hnefbqbes mte{/ B lmq qm |m{i& +Lmma/ lmma& Oeq,s sqh{q qgecomci&+

+\ghq,s mf rmu{ nbfa qmahr=++Ommi/ qge {ehsmf B chooea& B geh{a qmahr qghq smne Fm{qg

Chfhabhf qm|f uz qge{e mf qge Guasmf Khr bs mzefbf, uz h fe|sehzm{q& Smneqgbfl hkmuq qge bce neoqbfl sm qger ghte nm{emzef |hqe{& Rmu ifm| hfrqgbfl hkmuq qghq=+

+Mg/ su{e& \bqg qge qenze{hqu{e {bsbfl qger ghte sbw nmfqgsmd mzef |hqe{ fm| bfsqeha md qge qg{ee qm dmu{ nmfqgs qger gha haechae hlm& Bq,s z{eabcqea qger,oo ghte mzef |hqe{ reh{ {mufa bfhfmqge{ q|efqr reh{s m{ sm& Qge Fm{qg|esq Zhsshle bs mzefbfluz/ hfa qge mfe hkmte Hsbh& Qge chfhos h{e sc{hnkobfl/ Suephfa Zhfhnh& Mqge{ zohces uz fm{qg h{e mzefbfl zm{qs/ m{ ghtbflz{mkoens& Qge fhqbtes |gm ghte keef bce gufqbfl dm{ qgmushfas

Page 4: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 4/21

md reh{s ghte qm oeh{f fe| |hrs/ hfa keobete ne qger amf,q obieomsbfl q{habqbmfs& Bq,s hoo h z{maucq md lomkho |h{nbfl/ rmu ifm|&+

Gug& Lomkho |h{nbfl& Ewcuses dm{ |ghq |efq |{mfl hfa{ehsmfs dm{ qge Aenmc{hqs qm zhss nm{e {esq{bcqbmfs hfa {hbse

qhwes& Kufcg md gml|hsg/ qghq,s hoo bq |hs&B smufaea hnhpea& +[ehoor= Reh{ {mufa |bqgmuq bce= Qghq

nucg= Bq,s fmq lmbfl qm gu{q mu{ ecmfmnr/ mu{ zm{qs/ bs bq=++Bq sgmuoaf,q& Fmq hs nucg hs qghq mfe bf Kh`h Chobdm{fbh bs

gu{qbfl Shf Abelm hfa Omfl Kehcg hq OH& Zhfhnh |boo ghte qgez{mkoen qgbs qbne& Fm| qghq qge{e,s h d{ee cghffeo keq|eef qgeHqohfqbc hfa Zhcbdbc Mcehfs/ q{hddbc |boo use qghq bfsqeha md zhrbflqg{mulg qge fmse qm lm qg{mulg qge Bsqgnus& Dm{ us= Fm& Qghq

zm{q/ m{ qge mqge{ qgbfls uz h{mufa qge Guasmf Khr/ |mf,q ke hz{mkoen& Fmq ufqbo qge zmzuohqbmf nmtes uz qge{e qm eschze qgegehq&+

Lmma fe|s& +Bq |mf,q gu{q us= Qgef qge{e,s fmqgbfl qm |m{{rhkmuq& Qghq,s lmma qm ifm|& MI/ qghfis&+

+Rmu,{e xubqe |eocmne& Choo ne hfr qbne&+Ge |hs hoo gmfer sulh{/ hfa |m{se qghf h sgh{i/ ho|hrs

{ehar qm ehq qge |ehi& B ecgmea qge qmfe& +Su{e& Hfr qbne& Kre

fm|/+ hfa dmoaea qge zgmfe&\ghq |hs qghq ge shba hkmuq zemzoe nmtbfl fm{qg qm eschzeqge gehq= @esus G& Cg{bsq bf h kucieq/ ge hcqea obie B abaf,q ifm| hqgbfl hkmuq |ghq |hs lmbf, mf/ obie B |hs bf h a{ehn |m{oa m{ smneqgbfl& Bq |hs bfsuoqbf,/ hffmrbf,& B gha efmulg sq{ess |bqgq{rbf, qm nhfbzuohqe qge kmrs mf qge Gboo& B sgmuoa aesq{mr gbshccmufq/ kuq |e,oo see |ghq ghzzefs& Ge nhr ifm| nm{e qghf geoeqs mf& Fm| |ghq= Oehf khci/ k{ehqge/ qgbfi& Mg rehg& Bq,s szeeaabho qgbs qbne& Qge z{bthqe obfe |hs zbciea uz kedm{e qge db{sq {bfldbfbsgea/ hs bq gha keqqe{ ke&

+@mgf=++Sefhqm{& Lmma qm geh{ d{mn rmu& Gm|,s qge |ehqge{ muq

qge{e= Keef h kbq sqm{nr ge{e&++Hoo,s |eoo ge{e& Gm| ,kmuq khci gmne=++\e nbss rmu hfa rmu{ db{n ghfa hq qge geon& \gef h{e rmu

Page 5: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 5/21

cmnbfl khci hfa qhoibfl qm rmu{ cmfsqbquefqs=++\eoo/ qge{e,s qge qgbfl& B amf,q feea qm qhoi qm qge cmfsqbquefqs

qm geh{ |ghq,s lmbfl mf& B geh{ d{mn efmulg zemzoe hs bq bs& Qhieshf ewq{h ze{smf `usq qm mzef qge nhbo& Hfa B,n leqqbfl, h omq md nhbo

hkmuq qgese z{mzmsea |bfanboos mf Qhun Shui&+ Ge sgmuoa geh{ etef nm{e cmnzohbfqs sbqqbfl muq qge{e bf cgh{le md qge SqhqeMddbce&

Ge zhusea dm{ h nmnefq/ qgef shba/ +\e feea qgen/ Sefhqm{&Qger,oo lefe{hqe efmulg eoecq{bcbqr qm zm|e{ Sz{bfldbeoa hfaCobfqmf cmnkbfea/ muq bf h {elbmf |bqgmuq h zohfq& \bqg qge EZH{uoes |e chf,q kuboa hfrqgbfl eose&+

+Rehg/ rehg& B ifm| |e feea qge efe{lr/ kuq cmho,s cgehze{ 

hfa sm bs sh| l{hss/ |gbcg bs sucg h ah{obfl md qge ecm d{ehis qghqbq sgmuoa leq zhsq qge EZH& Febqge{ md qgmse |boo k{bfl uz hs nucgb{e hs gule qm|e{s mf qmz md h {bale bf h Lmaahnf Sqhqe Zh{i&Qm|e{s rmu chf see dm{ nboes& Qger,{e h koblgq mf qge ohfaschze/mf qghq {bale |e,te z{mqecqea hoo qgese reh{s&+ Gm| qge geoo chfge qgbfi ge chf nhie zmobcr= B,n qge ducibf, Sefhqm{/ hfa ge,s hfuzsqh{q hq qge |m{sq& Qgbfis ge,s lmq nm{e bfdouefce qghf ge ames&

Ge sblgea hfa qmoa ne |ghq B ho{ehar ife|& +\bfa efe{lr/ m{ 

smoh{ |gbcg |boo ke nm{e ewzefsbte hfa szmqqr {blgq qge{e/ qgmseq|m h{e qge mfor qrzes hzz{mtea kechuse bq bs h Sqhqe Zh{i& Bq,shkmuq zmoouqbmf/ coeh{ hb{ sm rmu chf see& Hfr|hr/ ghte rmu ete{ seef h kbl |bfanboo= Qger ommi nh`esqbc |bqg qgmse gule kohaesqu{fbfl bf qge |bfa& Bq,s zm|e{ rmu chf see& Kuq bd rmu |hfqsmneqgbfl eose/ sm ke bq& Rmu,oo `usq ghte qm cghfle qge oh|&+

+Rehg=+ Uzsqh{q& Kuq ge |hs {blgq& B,a tmqea hlhbfsq qghq kboo/kuq qge ahnf ecm d{ehis ghaf,q oedq req& B,a ghte qm see |ghq Bcmuoa am qm nhie h de| xubeq cghfles& Dm{ fm|/ ge,a leq gbsbfsq{ucqbmfs&

+\eoo/ see bd rmu chf nmte qgen smnezohce eose m{ smneqgbfl& Hfa ommi bfqm qghq l{hss squdd& Qgmse cmnnbes obieqghq&+

Qge uzsqh{q gha qge nmwbe qm q{r qm qehcg& +Amf,q ifmci qgesh| l{hss/ m{ hfr md qge l{hsses& H zm|e{ zohfq su{{mufaea kr

Page 6: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 6/21

qge squdd ghs h smu{ce md dueo qghq |boo fmq dhbo/ hfa ghs obqqoe cmsq/eszecbhoor dm{ q{hfszm{qhqbmf& Bq,s hcquhoor cgehze{ qghf cmho m{ fhqu{ho lhs& Bf h zh{i obie qghq/ rmu chf l{m| bq mf qge lefqoe{ somzes hfa gbae qge kbmnhss zohfq bf h thooer& Qge eddecq mf hb{ 

xuhobqr hfa lomkho |h{nbfl d{mn qge snmie qghq,s lbtef muq bsxuesqbmfhkoe& Sqboo/ nhfr zemzoe muq ge{e qgbfi bq,s qge kesqsmouqbmf/ hfa B am/ qmm&+

+Mg/ rmu am/ am rmu= \eoo/ fm nhqqe{& @usq nmte qgmseqm|e{s&+

+Bd rmu,{e lmbfl qm ghte |bfa zm|e{ qghq bs qge kesq omchqbmf&+Ze{sbsqefq obqqoe ducie{/ kuq ge |hs usuhoor qge kesq dbwe{/ sm B

|muoaf,q db{e gbn& Req& Ge,a `usq geh{ qge dm{ce md Lma& +B amf,q ch{e

bd qghq {bale bs qge kesq omchqbmf/ ahnf bq& B amf,q |hfq fmqgbfl mfqghq {bale |gef bq,s h Sqhqe Zh{i( Fm| nmte qgen(+ B zmcieqea qgezgmfe&

Lmaahnf ecm d{ehi cmnnbes& B qgmulgq |e lmq {ba md qgen&Sqboo geh{bf, hkmuq d{bllef dmssbo dueos hfa Lmaahnf lomkho|h{nbf,& \eoo/ B ifm| |gm |boo ke mf qghq fewq {mci etef bd Dohffblhf amf,q& Nm{e md qge shne/ ahnf bq&

+K{uce/ gm| nucg omfle{=+

+Q{hddbc/ Sb{& \e,oo ke khci qm Qge Gboo sgm{qor&+B geh{a h {bflbf, d{mn nr zmcieq/ nr ceoo zgmfe& \bqg hoo qgeeoecq{mfbc lhaleqs h{mufa/ B chf,q leq h nmnefq,s zehce& B dobzzeabq mzef hfa ommiea hq qge BA& Bq |hs nr nhbf nhf bf qgeGmneqm|f Mddbce/ nr dhce dm{ qge lmma md qge sqhqe/ qge mddbcenhfhle{& Ge,a mfor choo bd bq |hs bnzm{qhfq&

+@edd{bes&++Bq,s [hozg& \e lmq h z{mkoen& Gha h cmuzoe nh`m{ sqm{ns

cmne qg{mulg Cobfqmf& Fmq nucg oedq md qge qm|f&+Cg{bsq qghq |hs comse qm gmne& Gm| qge geoo cmuoa sqm{ns

|bze muq h qm|f qgbs qbne md reh{= Qm{fham sehsmf |hs omfl zhsq&Bd |e |e{e bf gu{{bchfe cmufq{r B cmuoa see bq/ kuq etef qgesq{mflesq sqm{n qgbs qbne md reh{ |muoa mfor ifmci am|f h cmuzoe|b{es m{ smneqgbfl& B gha qm ghte nm{e bfdm{nhqbmf&

+\ghq= \gef=+

Page 7: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 7/21

+Cmuzoe gmu{s hlm&+ Ge smufaea |eh{r& Fm/ qghq |hsf,q {blgq&Su{z{bsea/ dohkke{lhsqea/ h|ea& H|ea |hs bq/ hs bd ge cmuoaf,qkeobete |ghq gha ghzzefea& Bq haaea c{eaefce qm gbs fe|s& Bcmuoaf,q kohne gbn/ ebqge{& B cmuoa see bq bf eh{or sz{bfl m{ 

sunne{/ kuq geoo/ qge oehtes |e{e qu{fbfl& Bq |hs gh{tesq qbne&+Fm& Qghq,s fmq zmssbkoe& Bq,s muq md sehsmf& Gm| nhfr

sqm{ns= Gm| nucg/ fmq nucg oedq rmu shba=+B cmuoa geh{ gm| |bae gbs eres |e{e bf gbs tmbce& Ge |hs

sch{ea&+Qm{fhames& Q|m D.5s |bqgbf nbfuqes md ehcg mqge{& Qmmi muq

 `usq hkmuq ete{rqgbfl&+Qm{fhames= Fm|= Qghq,s fmq lmma& Fmq lmma hq hoo& Ahnf& B,a

ghte qm sgm| nr dhce hs smmf hs zmssbkoe& B cgeciea qge Gboo,sscgeauoe& +MI& Ommi& Qge{e h{e fm tmqes cmnbf, uz/ sm B,oo ke muqqge{e qmnm{{m| nm{fbf,/ eh{or& Ghte smnemfe neeq ne hqSz{bfldbeoa& B,oo ghte Sgb{oer lbte rmu qge qbne |gef B ifm| qgedoblgq& Bq nhr ke z{bthqe&+

+Qge xubcie{ rmu sgm| rmu{ dhce/ qge keqqe{&+Hs bd B abaf,q ifm| qghq/ kuq ge aba smufa {eobetea& +Rehg/ B

ifm|& See rh bf qge nm{fbfl&+ B gbq szeea abho hlhbf hfa chooea qge

\hsgbflqmf mddbce&+Sgb{oer/ leq ne h doblgq qm Sz{bfldbeoa& Lmq qm ke qge{eqmnm{{m| nm{fbfl& Qeoo [hozg |ghq qbne B,n aue bf&+

Rmu cmuoa ho|hrs geh{ ge{ snboe mf qge zgmfe& +Ho{eharamfe/ Kmss& Geh{a hkmuq qge sqm{ns mf qge fe|s& Dmu{ bf qgenm{fbfl muq md [ehlhf& Bq,s h z{bthqe& Hoo cmnne{cbho qm qge{e,skeef chfceoea&+ Qm shr Sgb{oer |hs eddbcbefq |muoa ke hfufae{sqhqenefq& Fm nhqqe{ |ghq B feeaea/ sge |hs mf qmz md qgbfls& B zhba ge{ h gblg shoh{r/ hfa sge |hs |m{qg bq& Sge |hsmfe {ehsmf B |hs |ge{e B |hs/ gha qge zm|e{ B aba& Su{e/ sge,sfmq qge kesq ommibfl denhoe h{mufa/ kuq bd B |hfq smneqgbfl ewq{h/qge{e h{e efmulg l{muzbes h{mufa qm shqbsdr nr feeas&

B qmoa ge{/ +Rmu,{e qge kesq& Am B feea qm somulg hfrqgbfl= Fm=Qghq,s lmma& Qghfis h omq& B amf,q qgbfi B,oo ke bf hlhbf qmahr&+

+MI/ Kmss& Qeoo [hozg B,n z{hrbf, dm{ gbn& Dm{ hoo md qgen&+

Page 8: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 8/21

B gufl uz& Hfa qge zgmfe {hfl& +@edd{bes&++Qgbs bs FKC& Am rmu ghte h cmnnefq mf qge {ecefq sqm{ns

bf rmu{ sqhqe=++Fm& B,te keef bf cmfde{efce hfa `usq oeh{fea hkmuq qgen&

\hbq& H xumqe dm{ rh& B ufae{sqhfa qge aethsqhqbmf bs nhssbte& B,ooke muq qge{e eh{or bf qge nm{fbfl qm mkse{te dm{ nrseod hfa geozmuq |ge{e B chf& Ufqbo qgef B chf shr fm nm{e&+

) ) )

H{qgu{ DohffblhfQge Szhce Cefqe{ hfa Ea|h{as Hb{ Dm{ce Khse gmsqea nmsq

md qge lmte{fnefq,s q{hteo bfqm szhce/ kuq schqqe{ea h{mufa qgecmufq{r |e{e sete{ho z{bthqe ohufcg sbqes& Qger cmfsbsqea md sgmesq{bfl mze{hqbmfs |ge{e doealobfl cmnzhfbes sq{ulloea qm dbfashqeoobqes m{ zhssefle{s qm sefa homdq/ hfa mfe muqdbq qghq sefqhsges bfqm szhce dm{ l{betbfl {eohqbtes& Qge muqdbqs |bqg nmfer/ qgede| qghq zbciea uz Lmte{fnefq cmfq{hcqs dm{ snhooe{ ohufcges/|e{e schqqe{ea h{mufa qge |m{oa&

Nr mze{hqbmf keomflea qm qge ohqqe{ chqelm{r/ qghfis qm

Lmte{fnefq l{hfqs |gef B db{sq sqh{qea/ |gbcg nehfq B gha obqqoeaekq qm zhr khci& \e gha h ohufcg sbqe muqsbae md Khce{efh/K{hpbo/ hc{mss qge {bte{ d{mn Keoen/ |gbcg gha hf hb{zm{q dm{ ehsrhccess& Bf fm |hr cmuoa B cmfsqhfqor cmnnuqe qge{e/ sm B gha hsuze{tbsm{ muq qge{e B cmuoa q{usq/ mfe |gm |hqcgea ete{r obqqoeqgbfl hq qge zohce& Sbfce sm nucg md qge mze{hqbmf |hs szhcekhsea/ B hosm gha h gule qeoecmnnufbchqbmfs cefqe{ muqsbae md \hsgbflqmf&

Qge cmfq{mo {mmn gha sete{ho {m|s md |m{isqhqbmfs |bqg dbtem{ sbw nmfbqm{s ehcg/ sgeotes md {ede{efce nhqe{bhos |bqgbf ehsr{ehcg/ hfa {hcis md eoecq{mfbc nhcgbfe{r qghq obfea qge |hoos& Bq|hs h fmbsr zohce bf h xubeq |hr/ qge |hr hfr mddbce bs |gefzemzoe nusq cmfsqhfqor cmnnufbchqe& H lohss obfea mkse{thqbmfh{eh |hs hkmte hfa kegbfa qge cmfq{mo {mmn/ kegbfa h omcieaamm{/ h zohce |ge{e B cmuoa |hqcg ete{rqgbfl hfa fmq absqu{k

Page 9: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 9/21

qgmse |gm cmfcefq{hqea mf qge nbssbmf& B efqe{ea qge z{mze{ cmaebfqm qge ierzha fewq qm qge amm{/ efqe{ea qge {mmn/ hfa sqezzeakegbfa qge Nbssbmf Nhfhle{/ Scmqq Hk{hfpb/ |gm sefsea nrz{esefce hfa qu{fea qm|h{a ne& Ge fmaaea gbs l{eeqbfls&

+Scmqq& Sqhqus&++\eoo/ N{& Dohffblhf/ Sb{/ qge dmu{qg ch{lm qhfi bs {ehar& Bq,oo

ohufcg hq q|m mu{ qbne/ |gbcg |boo |hie qge feblgkm{s am|f qge{eh kbq eh{or/ kuq qghq,s lmma dm{ qgen& Doblgq c{e| bs dbfbsgbfl dbfhoq{hbfbfl hs |e szehi& Nmfahr qger lm& H d{mfq bs z{eabcqea qmc{mss K{hpbo mf Quesahr/ sm |ehqge{ sgmuoa fmq ke h z{mkoen&+

+Lmma& Ewceooefq& B |hfq ete{rqgbfl {ehar mf qbne& B |boo ghteGunhf [esmu{ces sqh{q qm {ec{ubq c{e|s qm kuboa qge cbqr& Qgbs qbne

|e feea qm bfcouae eflbfee{s hfa ewze{qs |gm |boo |hqcg qgexuhobqr cmfq{mo kechuse qger `mbf qge hatefqu{e& B am fmq |hfq qmcuq hfr cm{fe{s m{ use nh{lbfho xuhobqr nhqe{bhos qgbs qbne&

+Qge |m{oa lmes am|fgboo/ Scmqq& Cmfl{ess/ bf bqs sgm{qsblgqea hfa dmmobsg |hr/ aba fmq `usq leq {ba md qge aetbhfqs md qge|m{oa9 bq lmq {ba md qge snh{q zemzoe& Fm| |e dhce nh`m{ z{mkoens&lomkho z{mkoens& Te{r de| ghte qge ifm|oeale hfa bnhlbfhqbmf qmdbw qgen& B nhr lm homfl&+

+\boo ke amfe/ Sb{& B,oo cgeci mf bq nrseod&+ Ge qu{fea khci qmqge {mmn hfa szmie bfqm qge nbie hs ge bssuea bfsq{ucqbmfs m{ efcmu{hlenefq&

B |hqcgea h de| nbfuqes nm{e& Ge gha h lmma hqqbquae& Geiezq ete{rqgbfl mf scgeauoe/ |eoo q{bnnea/ hfa sgh{z&Ufdm{qufhqeor/ qge |m{oa |muoa fmq cmmze{hqe& Nm{e hfa nm{e qgez{mkoens gha kuboq uz/ hfa |bqg te{r de| oedq qm |h{f qge nhsses/gunhfbqr |muoa cmfqbfue mf bqs aesq{ucqbte zhqg&

Hs B |hoiea muq md qge kuboabfl qm nr ch{/ B chooea [mf bfNeqem{momlr& \ghq ge qmoa ne |hs kmqg lmma/ hfa h dm{echsq md z{mkoens qm cmne&

+Res/ Sb{& Ohufcg sgmuoa lm |bqg fm gbqcges& Mg/ hfa B ghteqge ohqesq dblu{es d{mn FHSH& Uzze{ hqnmszge{e bs uz hfmqge{ qefqg qgbs reh{&+

Page 10: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 10/21

) ) )

Sefhqm{ Pekuomf @edd{bes+Sefhqm{/ |ghq |e h{e lmbfl qm see ommiea obie qgbs mfor

|eeis hlm&+[hozg hfa B |e{e bf h geobcmzqe{ hzz{mhcgbfl Cobfqmf d{mn qge

smuqgehsq/ qge sgham|s sqboo zmbfqbfl h omfl |hrs qm qge |esq& Bqmmi qge z{mdde{ea zmsq ch{as hfa geoa qgen bf qge oblgq cmnbflqg{mulg qge ehsq |bfam|& Qge db{sq mfe sgm|ea h snhoo qm|f d{mnqge hb{/ qge sq{eeqs ohba muq homfl qge omflbquae hfa ohqbquae obfeshs dh{ hs B cmuoa see/ qge lefe{ho sz{h|o bf h fm{qg|esqe{orab{ecqbmf d{mn qge nhbf c{mss{mhas& H snhoo hb{zm{q nh{iea qge

fm{qgehsq eale md qm|f/ qmm snhoo dm{ hfr qrze md `eq& Mqge{ ch{assgm|ea cefqe{.cbqr d{mn qge hb{& Qge {uffbfl q{hci/ dmmqkhoosqhabun/ hfa khsekhoo dbeoa sgm|ea |ge{e qge gblg scgmmo sqmma

 `usq ehsq md qge qm|f,s cefqe{& Zbcqu{es md qge qm|f ghoo/ gmszbqho/smne gbsqm{bc |mmaef kuboabfls/ hfa h oh{le dmufqhbf bf mfe md qgezh{is cmnzoeqea qge sqhci md ch{as& B ommiea uz hq [hozg&

+Obie B shba/ Kmss/ qghq,s |ghq bq ommiea obie `usq ahrs..fm/ oessqghf q|efqr.dmu{ gmu{s hlm& Rmu chf see bq fm|&+

B ommiea muq qge |bfam|& Qge l{ba |hs sqboo qge{e/ kuq qgesq{eeqs |e{e fm| cmte{ea |bqg {ukkoe hfa c{usgea ch{s bfsqeha md obfea |bqg q{ees hfa kuboabfls& Fm kuboabfls sgm|ea ewcezq hsnhoo kuboq uz h{eh mf qge |esq sbae md qm|f& Qge {esq md qge qm|fommiea hs bd smnemfe gha a{mzzea h kmnk/ m{ nhrke hf hsqe{mbaobie qge Ohrmuqs gha khci bf qge Chqe{zbooh{ \h{ & Qge{e |e{e h de||hoos/ hfa mfe kuboabfl qghq ommiea obie bq gha ghod su{tbtea/ hsomfl hs bq |hsf,q nm{e qghf q|m sqm{bes qhoo& H qefq bf qge nbaaoe md qge aek{bs gha zemzoe kusqobfl h{mufa bq& Homfl qge eales/cmfsq{ucqbmf exubznefq |hs kelbffbfl qm mzef sq{eeqs& Zemzoeseh{cgea qg{mulg smne md qge {ukkoe&

[hozg/ ah{i ghb{ nussea/ a{essea bf h qg{ee zbece subq qghqgha seef keqqe{ ahrs/ qghq ommiea hs bd ge,a keef |m{ibfl bf bqsbfce resqe{ahr/ hfa ge z{mkhkor gha/ ewzohbfea/ +Qghq zh{qbhokuboabfl qghq,s sqhfabfl/ qge mfe |bqg qge qefq/ qghq,s |ghq,s oedq md 

Page 11: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 11/21

qge gmszbqho&+ Qge zmsqch{a B ommiea hq sgm|ea h dbte sqm{r |gbqekuboabfl/ fe| ommibfl/ |bqg oh{le chfmzbes mte{ q|m efq{hfcecb{coes&

+\e cmuoaf,q qhie ch{e md qge bf`u{ea kechuse md qge

aesq{ucqbmf& Qge nmsq |e chf am bs q{bhle bf qge qefq/ h sm{q md NHSG ufbq/ hfa sgbz qgen muq&+

+\ghq qge geoo ghzzefea=++Obie B shba resqe{ahr/ q|m D.5s/ kmqg md qgen honmsq h nboe

|bae/ hfa kmqg mf honmsq qge shne q{hci& Qge db{sq |ehiefea|ghq bq abaf,q aesq{mr/ hfa qge secmfa mfe coehfea uz&+

B,a fete{ seef hfrqgbfl obie qgbs& Qge sq{eeqs bf zohces |e{ecmte{ea |bqg zh{qs md |hoos hfa q{ees hfa |mma& H ch{ shq bf h

s|bnnbfl zmmo/ bf sete{ho zohces& Mfe bfqhcq {mmd ohr bf qgenbaaoe md hf bfqe{secqbmf& B sh| qge c{mss d{mn mfe md qge cgu{cgsqeezoes sqhfabfl e{ecq bf |ghq usea qm ke h dmufqhbf& Feh{kr|hs hf bfqhcq sqeezoe/ kuq qge{e |e{e fm cgu{cges bf qge h{eh hssgm|f kr qge zmsqch{as& Qge scgmmos |e{e lmfe/ gblg scgmmo/nbaaoe scgmmo/ hfa eoenefqh{r& Bd qgbs gha ghzzefea au{bflscgmmo gmu{s/ |e,a ghte gufa{eas md l{betbfl dhnbobes& B cmuoabnhlbfe qge kusr sq{eeqs md h keqqe{ qbne/ md resqe{ahr/ |bqg

kusbfess kmmnbfl& Fm|/ mqge{ qghf {escue |m{ie{s hfa {ezhb{ c{e|s/ fmqgbfl nmtea&B nunkoea/ +Qge{e,s fmqgbfl oedq&+[hozg geh{a/ qgmulg B amf,q ifm| gm| mte{ qge {mh{ md qge

{mqm{s& +Obqe{hoor& Nmsq md qgese zemzoe gha sqm{n sgeoqe{s md qgeb{ m|f m{ feblgkm{,s sgeoqe{s comse kr& Qger gha dbte nbfuqes|h{fbfl dm{ qge db{sq/ hfa qge secmfa dmoom|ea sm comseor fm mfegha ene{lea req& Nmsq md qge su{tbtm{s h{e bf sgeoqe{s muqsbae md qm|f& Mfor z{mdessbmfhos h{e hoom|ea bf fm|& Omcho gmszbqhos h{eduoo hfa sgbzzbfl fe| zhqbefqs etef dh{qge{ h|hr&+

B ommiea muq qge |bfam|& +Gmor @esus& Ommi am|f qge{e& Zbomq/chf |e leq comse{ |bqgmuq absqu{kbfl qgen=+ \e |hqcgea hs hl{muz md zemzoe cousqe{ea h{mufa mfe h{eh/ h aml kh{ibfl feh{krhfa geoa khci kr h ghfaoe{& Qger,a ch{eduoor obdq h zbece md aek{bs/qgef qg{m| bq mdd qm qge sbae& B cmuoa see hf h{n |hte d{mn ufae{ 

Page 12: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 12/21

mfe oh{le zm{qbmf md a{r|hoo& \gef qghq zbece |hs {enmtea/ hkomqcgr kmar hzzeh{ea& B {ehobpea qge ah{i |hs komma/ hfa qgeoblgq |hs zohsqe{ ausq& Qgbs ze{smf |hs oucir qm ke hobte&

H cmftmr md nbobqh{r tegbcoes h{{btea/ sqmzzea k{bedor/ qgef

schqqe{ea/ smoabe{s nmtbfl |ghq qger cmuoa kr ghfa/ hfa zusgbfloh{le{ mk`ecqs muq md qge |hr& Sete{ho uqbobqr q{ucis dmoom|ea bf qgeb{ |hie/ sguqqbfl mdd eoecq{bcbqr hfa fhqu{ho lhs obfes& B fmqbcea hdohne ku{fbfl bf qge nbaaoe md h sq{eeq& H c{e| sqmzzea sete{hobfqe{secqbmfs h|hr hfa lhqge{ea bf qge nbaaoe md qge sq{eeq& Hookuq mfe ze{smf xubcior oedq hfa qge q{ucis |e{e zuooea khci& Qgeze{smf |gm sqhrea aba smneqgbfl bf qge sq{eeq/ hfa {hf hs bd aenmfs |e{e dmoom|bfl gbn&

Qge dohne abea muq&[hozg ewzohbfea/ +B ufae{sqhfa bq,s soblgqor zmssbkoe qghq qge

db{e chf dmoom| qge lhs qg{mulg qge zbze bd qge gmoe bs kbl efmulg&Sbfce qger chf,q bfszecq qge k{ehi ufqbo qge db{e bs muq/ bq,s h cghfcrmze{hqbmf qm sguq qge thotes&+

+\ghq,s oedq=++Fmq nucg& Qghq secqbmf rmu see qm qge |esq ghs ahnhle

d{mn aek{bs/ {mcis hfa |mma hfa squdd/ kuq qge kuboabfls h{e

smufa& Mqge{ qghf qghq/ fmqgbfl&+Hoo qghq aesq{ucqbmf& Bq |hs obie qge ghfa md Lma chne am|fhfa |bzea muq Smamn m{ Lmnm{{hg& \ghq gha |e amfe qmaese{te qgbs= \ghq cmuoa |e am qm geoz qgese zemzoe= \ghqcmuoa B am=

B qmoa [hozg/ +B feea qgese zmsqch{as&++Su{e& Fm z{mkoen& Kuq kedm{e hfa hdqe{ shqeoobqe bnhles h{e

ho{ehar hthbohkoe mf qge feq&+Qghq |hs qge hfs|e{& B gha qm choo \hsgbflqmf/ leq qgen

kusr& B mzefea nr zgmfe hfa lmq h |ehi sblfho&[hozg ewzohbfea/ +Omcho qm|e{s h{e am|f/ md cmu{se& Bd |e lm

gblge{ rmu chf z{mkhkor zbci uz muqorbfl qm|e{s&+Ge |hs {blgq& Qge choo |efq qg{mulg hs |e cobnkea hfa

gehaea smuqg& Qge \hsgbflqmf efa hfs|e{ea&+Sgb{oer& Lm mf qge |ek hfa leq shqeoobqe zbcqu{es md..|ghq=+

Page 13: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 13/21

+\e aba qghq ho{ehar/ Sefhqm{& Mg nr Lma& Bq ommis qe{{bkoe&Hfa DENH bs mf qge |hr& Z{ep z{mnbsea hba&+

Sge smufaea d{hppoea/ bf sgmci/ hfa B cmuoaf,q kohne ge{&Sge gha d{befas muq ge{e& Hq oehsq bf qgbs nr sqhdd aba qge {blgq

qgbfl/ cmfqhcqea DENH hfa qge mqge{s& Gbs Honblgqr Gblgfessz{mkhkor sh| bq mf qge fe|s hfa dblu{ea ge,a mfe uz ne&

B shba/ +Qger h{e= Ge aba= Lmma& B,oo hffmufce qghq |gef |eohfa& Gm| omfl=+

+Rmu ifm| Cmfl{ess& Rmu,oo feea qm zusg&++Rehg/ B ifm|& \eoo/ bq chf,q ke geozea& MI& Qghfis/ Sgb{oer&

Hfa cb{cuohqe qgmse zgmqms& Leq qgen qm ete{rmfe/ hfa fmq `usq qmsqhdde{s& Kuqqmfgmoe qge Nenke{s qgenseotes& Hfa am bq rmu{seod bd 

rmu ghte qm&+ B gufl uz hfa snboea& Z{mnbses |e{e `usq qghq/ fmqqge lmmas/ kuq |bqg geoz d{mn nr sqhdde{s/ qger,a ke duodbooea&

B qu{fea qm nr gmsq& +Lmq lmma fe|s/ [hozg& Oeq,s seq am|f&+Ge qmoa ne/ +Nhrm{ ghs h Cmnnhfa Cefqe{ hq qge omcho sgeeq

neqho sgmz h kbq |esq/ muq md qge zhqg md aesq{ucqbmf& \e,oo seqam|f qge{e&+ Ge szmie qm qge zbomq& \e qu{fea h|hr d{mn qge suf&

Qge geobcmzqe{ om|e{ea us mfqm hf mzef l{hssr h{eh feh{ hdhcqm{r |bqg ab{qr |hoos zhbfqea |gbqe hfa zeeobfl& Hq oehsq bq |hs

sqhfabfl& Mddbcbho ch{s hfa q{ucis md ete{r aesc{bzqbmf |e{eschqqe{ea hc{mss qge ab{q zh{ibfl omq& [hozg escm{qea ne bfqm qgemddbce h{eh md qge xubeq dhcqm{r&

+\ghq,s qge Nhrm{,s fhne=+ B hsiea hs |e efqe{ea qge d{mfqamm{s&

+Lmma{bale&+ [hozg hfs|e{ea&H zmobce mddbce{ sqmzzea us hs |e efqe{ea qge snhoo omkkr hfa

cgeciea mu{ BA& Qg{mulg qge |bfam| hq qge sbae |ge{e qge{ecezqbmfbsq usuhoor shq B cmuoa see ampefs md zemzoe mf zgmfes/hfa mqge{s sguddobfl zhze{s hfa qhoibfl qm qgmse |gm |m{ieamuqsbae/ `ualbfl d{mn qge |hr smne |e{e a{essea& Hfmqge{ mddbce{ sgm|ea us qm qge amm{ md qge cmnzhfr m|fe{,s mddbce/ kuq |ecmuoa kh{eor leq bfsbae& Qge aesi |hs su{{mufaea kr gh{{beaommibfl zemzoe hoo qhoibfl hq mfce& H khoabfl/ soblgqor mte{|eblgqnhf bf h qg{ee.zbece subq shq kegbfa qge aesi q{rbfl qm chon

Page 14: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 14/21

qgbfls& B ife| |ghq |muoa |m{i&+Nhrm{ Lmma{bale(+ B chooea mte{ qge fmbse& Bf qge efsubfl

sboefce B cmfqbfuea/ +Bq seens rmu ghte smne z{mkoens&+Gbs eres loh{ea muq hq ne/ hfle{ea hq qge absqu{khfce& +Hfa

 `usq |gm qge geoo am rmu..Sefhqm{ @edd{bes( Bq,s lmma md rmu qm `mbfus&+ Gbs aenehfm{ cghflea bfsqhfqor |gef ge {ecmlfbpea ne/ qgeZm|e{ md \hsgbflqmf/ Deae{ho [eobed/ hfa Mfe \gm Cmuoa Geoz&

B k{mulgq nr \hsgbflqmf lmma|boo hfa zm|e{ qm keh{& +Db{sqoeq ne shr qghq DENH |boo ke ge{e qmnm{{m|/ hfa B,oo ke zusgbfldm{ abshsqe{ dufas& Nr zemzoe h{e ho{ehar cb{cuohqbfl shqeoobqezgmqms& Rmu ghte mfe geoo md h ness ge{e/ Nhrm{/ hfa rmu amf,qfeea haaea cmfdusbmf& Qgmse md rmu |gm chf,q see |ghq feeas qm

ke amfe qu{f bf rmu{ BAs hfa oeq rmu{ qgbfibfl sukm{abfhqes qhiemte{&+ Qge {mmn coeh{ea obie B ife| bq |muoa&

Qge Nhrm{ cmoohzsea bfqm gbs cghb{& +Z{hbse Lma rmu,{e ge{e/Sefhqm{/ eszecbhoor |bqg qghq fe|s&+

B snboea& +Fm| rmu chf leq mf |bqg qge Nhrm{,s kusbfess& ObieB shba/ DENH |boo ke muq& Qmnm{{m| qge bftesqblhqm{s/ qgef ohqe{/ hssmmf hs B zusg Cmfl{ess qm huqgm{bpe bq/ h qehn md hccmufqhfqs|bqg cgecis/ gmzeduoor fewq |eei& \e,oo leq rmu geoz/ kuq rmu

ifm| gm| Cmfl{ess bs& Ete{rqgbfl qhies dbte qbnes hs omfl hs bqsgmuoa&+ B ommiea hq nr |hqcg& B,a keef bf sqhqe dm{ honmsq dmu{ gmu{s ho{ehar hfa ghaf,q amfe nm{e qghf ommi h{mufa& Fm/ B abageoz coeh{ qge {hkkoe&

+Oeq,s see& Bq,s fbfe& Rmu,te lmq h kufcg md {ezm{qe{s muqsbae&Oeq,s lm muq qge{e hfa sgm| mu{ dhces/ oeq qgen ifm| |ghq,sghzzefbfl/ lbte qgen h smufa kbqe m{ q|m qger chf use kedm{eqger gbq aehaobfe& Qgef |e chf tbsbq qge sgeoqe{s hfa B,oo lbte qgenqge lmma fe|s/ uz qge nm{hoe h kbq& Qgmse |m{ibfl |e,oo seeau{bfl oufcg& B amf,q |hfq qm kmqge{ qgen ufqbo bq,s qbne qm ehq& Fm|/|ghq feeas qm ke shba qm qge neabh=

) ) )

Page 15: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 15/21

H{qgu{ DohffblhfQge cmfq{mo {mmn |hs h squar md xubeq bfqefsbqr& Qecgfbcbhfs

hfa eflbfee{s nhffea hoo qge sqhqbmfs/ ete{r nmfbqm{ sgm|eacmounfs md funke{s hfa {m|s md cgeciobsqs/ hfa hoo qge

qecgfbcbhfs blfm{ea ete{rqgbfl ewcezq qgeb{ qhsis hs qge nhbfetefq a{e| comse{& Scmqq sqmma fewq qm ne/ cmfdbaefq hfa {eohwea|bqg gbs gehaseq zoullea bfqm qge `hci `usq ufae{ qge lohsszh{qbqbmf&

Gbs eres ommiea bfqm qge fmfewbsqefq absqhfce dm{ h nmnefq&Qgef ge hffmufcea/ +N{& Dohffblhf/ Sb{/ c{e| {ezm{qs h omci mfhoo qge ch{lm qhfis& Qger,{e mf qh{leq hfa sgmuoa {efaeptmus |bqgqge {mci |bqgbf qge nmfqg&+

+Sm& H nmfqg d{mn fm| qger |boo sqh{q qm |m{i& Lmma&+B sqmma hfa |hqcgea qge gblg chsg dom| B cmuoa hddm{a/ h

fecessh{r sq{ehn md nmfer qghq |muoa k{bfl h lmma {equ{f& Bd qgelmte{fnefqs md qge |m{oa cmfqbfuea qm zohr qgeb{ lhnes/ B |muoafeea qgbs cbqr qm shte nrseod&

) ) )

Sefhqm{ Pekuomf @edd{bes+Bq,s keef h |eei( H Lma& Ahnf& \eei( \ghq qge geoo bs qhibf,sm omfl= Rmu,{e som|e{ qghf sfhbos {hcbf,& Nr zemzoe feea geoz(Fm| / ahnf bq(+

B sqmma bf qge mddbce md qge geha md DENH/ oeqqbfl muq nrd{usq{hqbmfs/ qge ha{efhobfe dom| haabfl qm qge q{ue hfle{ B deoq&Zemzoe/ hf efqb{e qm|f md zemzoe/ omsq qgeb{ gmnes& Smne omsqd{befas hfa dhnbor& Hoo omsq qgeb{ bfcmne& Bq |hsf,q `usq dhnbobes/ebqge{/ kuq kusbfesses/ qmm& Qge qm|f,s ecmfmnr gha cmne qm hl{bfabfl ghoq& Qge{e |hs fm nmfer qge{e ewcezq |ghq mqge{slhte/ hfa B |hfqea Mu{ Lmte{fnefq qm am bqs zh{q& Fm|&

Qge sqmzze{,s ze{smfho hssbsqhfq efqe{ea hfa sgm|ea gbn hzbece md zhze{& Ge xubcior {eha bq qgef shba/ +Sefhqm{& Bufae{sqhfa rmu{ d{usq{hqbmf& Qge cgecis |boo ke |{bqqef qgbshdqe{fmmf& Ete{rmfe,s bf zohce& B,te `usq keef |hbqbfl dm{ qgbs

Page 16: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 16/21

huqgm{bphqbmf&++Qghq |hs tmqea mf Qgu{sahr( Bq qhies h |eei dm{ rmu qm qhie

hcqbmf=+ Fm| nr du{r |hs {eho& B,a zusgea dm{ qghq oelbsohqbmf mte{ mqge{ z{mkoens |e gha/ hfa nr |m{i |hs `usq kelbffbfl qm

sgm|= Nr cmfsqbquefqs |muoa qgbfi B |hs sohcibfl&+Sefhqm{& Sefhqm{& Bq,s mfor keef q|m ahrs& Rmu ghte rmu{ dbte

gufa{ea nboobmf& Bq,s mf qge |hr& Rmu sgmuoa ifm| qge srsqen/gm| bq |m{is& Ehcg sgeoqe{ ho{ehar lmq h cgeci dm{ dbte qgmushfad{mn qge ene{lefcr dufa qge ahr hdqe{ qge sqm{ns& Fm/ B,n sm{{r&Q|m ahrs& B ufae{sqhfa Mnhgh Sqehis amfhqea cmnzoeqe abffe{sohsq Sufahr dm{ hoo qge |m{ie{s hfa qge abszohcea dhnbobes/ hfaqger |boo amfhqe qgbs |eei/ hosm& Q{hboe{s h{e kebfl kuboq hs |e

szehi/ q{hboe{s |bqg nucg oess dm{nhoaegrae& B ufae{sqhfa qghqchne d{mn qge bfsuohqbmf/ qghq bq,s h kr.z{maucq md dmhn bfsuohqbmfhs bq cu{es/ mfe md qge tmohqboes/ sm |e cghflea szecbdbchqbmfs qmdbke{lohss khqqs& Fmq hs eddbcbefq/ kuq fm dm{nhoaegrae& Bq |boo hooghzzef Sefhqm{/ hfa rmu,oo ommi lmma dm{ qge fewq eoecqbmf& @usqke zhqbefq&+

B loh{ea am|f hq qge zemf kegbfa qge aesi/ h zemf |bqgzm|e{& +Rmu,a qgbfi |bqg hoo qge z{hcqbce rmu,{e leqqbfl, ohqeor rmu,a

ke leqqbfl, keqqe{&++Cobnhqe cghfle& Hs omfl hs zemzoe blfm{e qge etbaefce/ |e,oocmfqbfue qm ghte z{mkoens&+

@esus& Hfmqge{ mfe& +,Khg( Gunkul(, bf qge |m{as md Sc{mmle&+ B szuf mf nr geeos hfa gehaea qm nr mddbce& B ghazgmfe choos qm nhie& Etef ge{e B cmuoaf,q leq h|hr d{mn ecmd{ehis&

Hs B sq{mae qg{mulg qge mddbce/ B qmoa Sgb{oer qm choo Nhrm{ Lmma{bale/ qge nhrm{ |bqgmuq h qm|f& Kr qge qbne B {ehcgea nraesi qge zgmfe |hs kobfibfl&

B qu{fea mf nr kesq Nba|esq cgh{n hfa cobciea qge szehie{ kuqqmf& +Nhrm{ Lmma{bale& Pekuomf @edd{bes ge{e& B |hfqea qm lbtermu qge lmma fe|s {blgq h|hr/ nr d{befa& Cmfl{ess ghs hzz{mteadufabf,/ aba qghq h cmuzoe ahrs hlm/ hfa DENH bs dbfhoor hcqbf, mfbq&+ Qghq sgmuoa ke lmma dm{ hf efam{senefq fewq eoecqbmf/ bd ge

Page 17: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 17/21

|hs sqboo h{mufa&+Z{hbse Lma( Z{hbse Lma& \e feea bq Sefhqm{& \e feea bq

aesze{hqeor& Obtbfl mf qge cgh{bqr hfa lmma|boo md mqge{s leqs moaxubcior& Hfa bq amesf,q ohsq&+ B cmuoa zbcqu{e gbn bf qghq mddbce/

ewcezq qge cmnzhfr |muoa ke ambfl kusbfess hlhbf& Ge |hsebqge{ bf h km{{m|ea gmuse/ nmqeo {mmn/ m{ zmssbkor |m{ibfl muqmd gbs ch{&

B qmoa gbn/ +B,n sm{{r bq qmmi sm omfl/ kuq qge{e |e{e h omq md zemzoe qm cmftbfce/ hfa nhfr gha qgeb{ m|f z{mkoens& Qge{e|hs qghq nbfe cmoohzse/ |gbcg bs qge dhuoq md qge nbfbf, cmnzhfr Bchf luh{hfqee rmu/ hfa qgef qge{e |hs qghq eh{qgxuhie bfQeffessee qge mqge{ ahr&+

+Res/ qghq mfe bs sq{hfle& Rmu |mfae{ hkmuq qge \boo md Lmasmneqbnes&+

B {enenke{ea ge chnzhblfea hs h Lma deh{bfl Cg{bsqbhf/hfa |mf mf qghq zohqdm{n& +B amf,q |mfae{/ Nhrm{& \ghq Lma |boosqm ghzzef/ ghzzefs&+

Ge zhusea/ z{mkhkor qm oeq qge fe|s smhi bf& B |hs hkmuq qmshr lmmakre |gef ge shba/ +Sm |e ghte dufabfl& Gm| nucg=+

+Dbte gufa{ea&+

+Dbte gufa{ea qgmushfa= Qghq,s fmqgbfl/ fm geoz hq hoo& \e,tekeef z{hrbfl dm{ nm{e& Nucg nm{e&+ Ge smufaea abshzzmbfqea/uzseq/ kuq qghq |muoaf,q ohsq&

Ge |hs qgbfibfl bf qm|f dufabfl oeteos/ fmq qge oeteos md qgeUfbqea Sqhqes md Hne{bch& B oehfea khci bf nr cghb{ hfa zbcqu{eaqge snboe ge,a ghte bf `usq h nmnefq&

+Fm/ Nhrm{ Lmma{bale& Qgbs bs Cmfl{ess rmu nusq {enenke{&Qge lmte{fnefq md qge Ufbqea Sqhqes md Hne{bch& Bq,s dbte gufa{eanboobmf& Ghod h kboobmf& Rmu chf `usq hkmuq {ekuboa qge |gmoe qm|f&Nhie cghfles& Bnz{mte&+

+Mg/ qghfi Lma& Qghfi Lma& Qghq,s lmma& [eho lmma& Fm| hooB ghte qm am bs cmftbfce qge zemzoe qm cmne khci&

) ) )

Page 18: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 18/21

H{qgu{ Dohffblhf+\e ghte enk{rms dm{ q|efqr.dbte absqbfcq szecbes md qble{s&+Qge qe{n |hs suk.szecbes9 etef B ife| qghq& B szmie |bqg qge

nhfhle{ md qge Hfbnho Comfe secqbmf |gm/ hq qge te{r oehsq/

sgmuoa ifm| qge z{mze{ qe{nbfmomlr& Gbs aezh{qnefq |hs hosm|m{ibfl mf h srsqen qm sqm{e enk{rms c{rmlefbchoor& Sbfce |egha abscmte{ea gm| qm {etbte qge ceoos hdqe{ qger gha keef d{mpef/|e gha |m{iea mf h |hr qm sq{eflqgef nhfr szecbes dm{ use bf|ghqete{ cmomfr |e dmufaea& Kuq qble{s=

Ge cmfqbfuea/ +Qghq,s nm{e qghf efmulg dm{ h tbhkoe szecbes&[hbse qge ibqqefs |bqg zemzoe hfa qger,oo ieez qge cmomfr shde&+

Ge |hs hfmqge{ |gm cmuoa fmq oeh{f |ghq ewze{qs gha ifm|f

dm{ reh{s& \boa hfbnhos h{e |boa/ fm nhqqe{ |ghq& B |mfae{ea |ghqqesqs ze{smffeo gha hanbfbsqe{ea&

B hsiea/ +H{e rmu su{e qger h{e fecessh{r= \e am ghteqecgfmomlr dm{ qghq/ ze{bneqe{ hoh{ns/ qgbfls obie qghq& B hn fmqsu{e |e nusq cghfle hfmqge{ zohfeq,s ecmomlr qm subq mu{ feeas&Bq bs kha efmulg |ghq |e ghte amfe qm mu{ m|f&+

+Rmu/ qmm= B qgmulgq rmu |hfqea qm leq {ba md qge ecm d{ehis&Qge{e seen qm ke nm{e md qgen qghf ete{&+

B l{m|oea/ +Qge{e h{e nm{e zemzoe |gm ghte mzefea qgeb{ eres qm qge etbaefce/+ hfa gufl uz& Oeq gbn qgbfi hkmuq qghq dm{ h|gboe& Zemzoe obie gbn |e{e sqboo h{mufa/ zemzoe obie @edd{bes/fhrshre{s |gm cmuoa fmq see |ghq qgeb{ eres sgm|ea qgen& B `usqommi hq qge etbaefce& Su{e/ B ghte nm{e bfdm{nhqbmf ehsborhthbohkoe qm ne qghf qge hte{hle ze{smf ames/ kuq |bqg h kbq md {eseh{cg/ ete{rqgbfl B ghte bs hthbohkoe& Rmu am fmq etef ghte qmabl bd rmu zhr hqqefqbmf qm qge fe|s& Qge{e h{e sqm{bes hkmuqneoqbfl bce chzs hfa sq{hfle sqm{ns hfa lomkho aesq{ucqbmf&Qgmse |gm cmuoa fmq see |e{e dmmos |gm |muoa fmq lm homfl mfqgbs q{bz& B |muoa oehte qge |m{oa qm qgen& Qger cmuoa abe hfa oeqqge cmci{mhcges qhie mte{&

B z{essea qge bfqe{cmn& +Nh{r/ sqh{q qm sefa muq oeqqe{s qm qgeohsq c{e| |e gha& Qeoo qgen |e |boo gb{e qecgfbcbhfs hlhbf/bfqeooblefq zemzoe |gm |bsg qm lm homfl&+

Page 19: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 19/21

) ) )

+N{& Dohffblhf/ Sb{/ qger,te ohfaea&+

B shq bf nr mddbce hfa {eha qge ohqesq FHSH {ezm{qs mf bce omssbf qge Hfqh{cqbc& Nm{e hfa nm{e B qgmulgq qghq B gha nbs{eha qgesblfhos reh{s hlm& Qge |m{oa |hs lmbfl qm geoo hs smne shba/ hfazmobqbcbhfs/ obie qghq dmmo @edd{bes/ |muoa oeq bq& Qgmse B gb{ea |e{efmq dmmos/ gm|ete{&

+Qghq bs ewceooefq fe|s/ Scmqq& B qhie bq hoo |efq |eoo=++B keobete mfe chkoe sfhzzea/ kuq fmqgbfl |hs omsq& H

sz{hbfea |{bsq bs qge mfor bf`u{r |e,te gha sm dh{&+

+Qghq bs ewceooefq fe|s& H reh{ hfa h ghod dm{ qgen qm hqqhbfm{kbq/ qgef dbte reh{s qm nbfe hfa kuboa/ hfa |e h{e {ehar qm lm&Qgbs qbne |e chf seoo ke{qgs qm qgmse |gm am fmq cmfq{bkuqe& Qgesnh{q zemzoe |boo ke sch{ea efmulg qghq qger |boo `unz hq qgecghfce/ hfa zhr ewcessbte dh{es& Rmu ghte nhae ne ghzzr&+

) ) )

Sefhqm{ Pekuomf @edd{besB |hs hq nr aesi/ schffbfl smne k{beds hkmuq fe| oelbsohqu{ecmnbfl uz dm{ tmqes/ smneqgbfl hkmuq cmho hfa ch{kmf abmwbae/qgmulg |gr rmu |muoa |hfq qm haa ewzefse qm qge cgehzesq dm{nmd zm|e{ B ghte fm baeh/ |gef Sgb{oer reooea qg{mulg qge amm{/+Sefhqm{= Rmu feea qm qu{f mf CFF& Fm|&+

+MI/+ B shba hs B cobciea qge obke{ho fe|s kuqqmf& \ghq gha nrsec{eqh{r sm {boea= Su{e/ CFF |hs obke{ho hs geoo/ su{e qger shbaqgbfls hkmuq ne/ hkmuq qge |m{oa/ qghq |e{e honmsq szufkhci|h{a/ kuq qm ke sm uzseq mte{ smneqgbfl obie qghq abaf,qsmufa obie Sgb{oer& Sge aba leq e.nhbos hkmuq k{ehibfl fe|s/ kuqsge |muoaf,q kmqge{ ne |bqg bq& Usuhoor& Fmq ufoess bq |hsbnzm{qhfq&

Qge z{ml{hn chne uz mf qge nmfbqm{& Mfe md qge hfcgm{s|hs sbqqbfl hq gbs aesi/ gbs qhoibfl geha subq |{bfioea hfa gbs ghb{ 

Page 20: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 20/21

nessr hs bd ge,a `usq {usgea bfqm qge squabm& B qu{fea uz qge smufa&+..ne {ezehq qgbs& \e,te bfqe{{uzqea mu{ {eluoh{or scgeauoea

Nbaahr Kusbfess [ezm{q qm k{bfl rmu k{ehibfl fe|s& QgeHohkhnh Fhqbmfho Luh{a ghs `usq efqe{ea Qeffessee& H sq{mfl

dm{ce bfcouabfl qhfis/ nbssboe ohufcge{s/ hfa h{nm{ea tegbcoes/|bqg smoabe{s |e keobete qm ke h{nea |bqg hsshuoq |ehzmfs/ ghsc{mssea bfqm Qeffessee& Qger hzzeh{ qm ke gehaea qm|h{aCghqqhfmmlh&

+\hbq h nmnefq& \e,te `usq keef bfdm{nea qge Lmte{fm{ md Hohkhnh bs hkmuq qm gmoa h z{ess cmfde{efce& \e qu{f rmu fm| qmqge Chzbqmo bf Nmfqlmne{r Cbqr hfa Lmte{fm{ \gbqegeha&+

Rez/ qghq |hs qghq gmqgeha \gbqegeha |gm chne mf qge

sc{eef/ qbe ufamfe/ ghb{ hsie|/ hfa ommibfl hffmrea& Ge zohceah sgehd md zhze{s mf qge zmabun/ hfa qgef ommiea mdd sc{eef&

+H{e |e mf req= Lmma& Nr deoom| cbqbpefs md qge l{ehq sqhqe md Hohkhnh/ B ghte absq{essbfl fe|s& Kechuse md qge sgbdq bf |ehqge{ zhqqe{fs/ chusea kr qge sgm{qsblgqeafess md bfausq{bho cmfce{fshfa qgeb{ l{eea dm{ qge Honblgqr Amooh{/ bfausq{bho zohfqs qghqsze|ea zmbsmfs bfqm qge hb{ etef hdqe{ Scbefce |h{fea us md qgeahfle{/ qgbs Sqhqe ghs sudde{ea qg{mulg a{mulgq dm{ qge zhsq setef

reh{s& Mu{ |hqe{ suzzor/ fmq |hqe{ dm{ {ec{ehqbmf/ kuq |hqe{ dm{ dh{nbfl hfa |hqe{ dm{ a{bfibfl/ ghs a|bfaoea ufqbo {hqbmfbfl bsfecessh{r& Mu{ dh{ne{s chffmq l{m| qgeb{ c{mzs kechuse qgerghte fm |hqe{& Mu{ cbqbpefs chffmq a{bfi kechuse qger ghte fm|hqe{& Mu{ te{r obtes h{e qg{ehqefea kr qge a{mulgq& Qgbs a{mulgqbs qge ab{ecq {esuoq md lomkho |h{nbfl/ |gbcg qge babmqbc [ezukobchfsbae md Cmfl{ess sqboo {eduses qm hccezq hs {eho hnba hz{ezmfae{hfce md etbaefce&

+Aeszbqe {ezehqea {exuesqs d{mn qgbs sqhqe/ hfa z{mmd md mu{ ab{e cb{cunsqhfces/ qge Sqhqe md Qeffessee ghs {ezehqeaor{eaucea qge dom| d{mn qge Qeffessee [bte{ Z{m`ecqs qm gmoa qge|hqe{ oeteo bf qge ohies kegbfa qge ahns hq qge geblgq md qgeamcis& Qgbs bs dm{ {ec{ehqbmfho zu{zmses mfor& Fmq qm shte c{mzs/fmq qm a{bfi/ kuq sm qgeb{ qmu{bsqs/ qgeb{ tbsbqm{s/ chf s|bn bfcmndm{q/ hfa |hqe{ sib/ hfa ommi hq z{eqqr scefe{r/ |gboe mu{ 

Page 21: Unforeseen Consequences

8/7/2019 Unforeseen Consequences

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/unforeseen-consequences 21/21

zemzoe h{e abebfl(Bf qgbs qbne md fm {hbf/ qgbs |hqe{ smu{ce nusq ke sgh{ea kr

hoo& Exuhoor& Qge{edm{e/ B,te sefq mu{ Fhqbmfho Luh{a qm z{mqecq qgesmu{ce md |hqe{ dm{ Qgbs L{ehq Sqhqe& Qge Hohkhnh Fhqbmfho

Luh{a |boo efsu{e qghq qge nbfbnun haexuhqe dom| bs nhbfqhbfeasm mu{ zemzoe hfa mu{ dh{ne{s |boo ghte qge nbfbnun hnmufq md |hqe{ qger feea&+

B qu{fea qge fe|s mdd& Su{e qge{e |hs h a{mulgq bf qgeSmuqgehsq/ kuq geoo/ qghq |hs lmbfl qmm dh{& \ghq |muoa ghzzeffewq= B ife| qge hfs|e{& Cbtbo \h{& \h{ Keq|eef qge Sqhqes& Qgbsqbne/ sete{ho md qgmse sqhqes gha hccess qm fuies& B zbciea uz qgezgmfe& Bq |hs hfs|e{ea mf qge secmfa {bfl&

+H{qgu{/ nr kmr& Gm|,{e rmu ambf,=++\eoo/ Sefhqm{/ kuq B {ehoor am fmq ghte qbne qm qhoi& B zhci qm

lm hkmh{a qge fe| Cbqr&++Rmu am= Rmu h{e= Gm| dm{qubqmus& B |hs lmbfl qm hsi bd qge{e

|hs {mmn dm{ ne&++B hn sm{{r/ Sefhqm{/ kuq sbfce B ghte squabea qge etbaefce/ B

|muoa ghte qm hl{ee |bqg Lmte{fm{ \gbqegeha qghq qgmse |gmcmfq{mo qgbs Fhqbmf,s oh|s ghte qgmulgq md qgeb{ zmcieqs {hqge{ 

qghf qge |m{oa,s su{tbtho/ hfa B ufae{sqhfa gbs aesb{e qm seceaed{mn qge Ufbmf& Sbfce rmu h{e mfe md qge chuses md qgbs z{mkoen/rmu nhr obte |bqg bq& Lmma ahr/ Sefhqm{&

* * *

Mqge{ sgm{q sqm{bes/ esshrs/ hfa zmeq{r d{mn qgbs huqgm{ h{e hthbohkoe hq

gqqz0--|||&sc{bka&cmn-K{bhf%;:\%;:Zm{qe{ &

* * *

Cmzr{blgq ;:88 Hqq{bkuqbmf Fmf.cmnne{cbho Fm.ae{bts  

Rmu nhr sgh{e qgbs |m{i |bqg hfrmfe bf hfr |hr |bqg qge dmoom|bfl z{mtbsbmfs&

Rmu nusq sgh{e qge cmnzoeqe |m{i/ bfcouabfl qge qbqoe hfa qgbs fmqbce& Rmu nhr fmq

nhie hfr cghfles& Rmu nhr fmq use qgbs |m{i cmnne{cbhoor m{ hccezq zhrnefq

|bqgmuq qge |{bqqef ze{nbssbmf md qge Huqgm{& Hfr hfa hoo {blgqs hfa c{eabq h{e geoa

 kr K{bhf \& Zm{qe{&