ULTRA ORTHODOX IN ISRAELCAI MARCH 2013

WHO ARE THE HAREDIS?

Haredi  is the most conservative form of Orthodox Judaism, often referred to by outsiders as ultra-Orthodox.

The word means fearful/afraid (from god, from change)

Haredi Judaism is not an institutionally cohesive or homogeneous group.

These groups often differ significantly from one another in their specific ideologies and lifestyles.

HAREDI DEMOGRAPHICS IN ISRAEL

According to the Central Bureau of Statistics Haredi’s make between 700,000-800,000 as of 2009.

Draft: 16% of Haredi youth compared to 75% of the rest of Israeli public.

Employment: 56% of Haredi women employed, compared to 85% non-Haredi women.

40% of Haredi men employed, compared to 88% non-Haredi men.

MAIN CONFLICTS WITH HAREDI SOCIETY

The Haredi community's low contribution to the economy. 

The absence of “equal burden-sharing“

Haredi religious coercion on various matters

CLIP – “STRANGE WORKERS”

RECRUITMENT OF HAREDIES “Toratam Emoonatam”- “The Tora is their belief” a regulation Enacted by the first government of Israel. The goal was to save the “dying” studies of the Jewish law and way, after the Holocaust.

The law has changed many times - limiting the amount of exemption.

1977- The first majority right wing government canceled all limitations. Any person claiming to learn in a known Orthodox “Yeshiva (heder)” was released automatically from serving in the IDF.

WHAT LED TO THE TAL LAW 1999- “The high court for justice in Israel”

had decided that there has to be an official law (as opposed to a regulation) that permits students of Jewish Orthodox Law, to be exempt from army service.

1999- A committee headed by justice Tzvi Tal was founded to form a new law that would suit the new situation (a growth of the Haredi world, Jewish studies was no longer at risk).

The law was approved by the Knesset in 2002. It stated that the minister of defense would

dismiss for a period of 1 year a student that would have a signed authorization from the head of the yeshiva he studies in, based on the following conditions:

1. He studies at least 45 hours a week.2. He doesn’t work in any other field.

de-facto the minister would automatically dismiss any applicant and would extend the dissmission every year.

Note- any married person/ any person over 23 is automatically exempt from army service.

THE TAL LAW

Tal law was legislated for 5 years.

2007- The law was about to expire. It was brought to “The high court of justice” a few times.

June 2007- The ruling was to extend the law for 5

more years claiming that it is constitutional and does not breach the constitutional law “Human Dignity and Freedom (1992)”. The plaintiff claimed the government is treating it’s citizens unequally.

10 YEARS OF TAL LAW

END OF TAL LAW February 2012- “The high court for justice”

reversed the decision saying “Tal law was not Proportionate to it’s initial cause” and therefore should not be renewed (meaning that it would end on July 2012).

PLASNER COMMITTEE 2012 Benjamin Netanyahu decided to form a new

committee on May 2012 that would recommend what steps should be taken.

Due to Disagreements the committee Dissolved on July 2012 with no formal outcome.

DECEMBER 2012 Government grants release to 1,300

Haredi’s . Yair Lapid (head of “Yesh Atid”) takes the

case to court, claiming that the decision is a contempt of the ruling made by “The high court of Juctice”.

There is no new ruling as of today.

WHAT NOW?No big change has happened yet. The majority of the public in Israel is

determined that Haredi’s should be drafted to the IDF or engage in alternative “national service” in order to maintain “equality of the burden”.

The outcome of the elections Mirrors this feeling.

WINDS OF CHANGE?

WINDS OF CHANGE?

WINDS OF CHANGE?

WINDS OF CHANGE?

CLIP – “DIFFERENT ISRAELI PERSPECTIVES”

SOME QUESTIONS: What are some real problems with the Haredi’s being

recruited? (more money, Haredi’s going into “bad culture”, risking Jewish studies)

Is there a value to the existence of the Haredi denomination in Judaism?

What can we learn from them? Are they ready and able to learn from us? Can the secular society in Israel replace their roll (do they

know enough about Jewish law)? What will make Israel Jewish if they do not monopolize

Jewish rituals in Israel? How liberal can Israel be? Should Israel claim to be liberal? If Israel becomes more liberal does this endanger the

existence of a Jewish state? Can liberal streams of Judaism (reform, conservative est.)

agree?

SOME QUESTIONS: Secular Israeli’s willing to cooperate with Haredis, but

the opposite is not true. Unacceptable that a group would get all privileges

without any of the responsibility.

Haredi city never had a demonstration or public disorder.

Haredi mayor would rather live in a separate environment so that his children would not be exposed secular world.

Women approached the mayor asking to have segregated buses.