UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

41
UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014

Transcript of UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

Page 1: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

UFOs, Greased

Pigs, and

Pensions

Joint Accountants

MeetingMay 15, 2014

Page 2: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

Show of hands…

• Do you currently participate in a defined benefit pension plan?

• Has your utility made significant changes to the pension plan in the last several years or is considering changing it soon?

2

Page 3: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

3

Goals

1. Basic Pension Concepts2. Awareness of New Rules for Recording

Pensions3. General Update on Other Pension Stuff

(Tennessee Law, PBGC, Funding)

Presented in no particular order

Page 4: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

4

Defined Benefit Pension Plans

• Why have a Pension Plan?• 1. Incentivize workers to not leave until retirement age• 2. Incentivize workers to leave at retirement age

• Types of Plans:-Single Employer-Multiple Employer – group of employers treated as one plan-Multiple Employer - Agent: grouped for administration but separated

actuarially

Page 5: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

5

Multiple Employer Plan ExamplesCooperatives:

NRECA

CSA

Municipals:

TCRS - Tennessee

RSA – Alabama

PERS - Mississippi

CERS – Kentucky

ERSGA – Georgia

NCRS – North Carolina

VRS – Virginia

CSA

Page 6: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

The worst and best funded…

Market Valued Liability vs Actuarial Assets

Statebudgetsolutions.org

Promises Made, Promises Broken - The Betrayal of Pensioners and Taxpayers

by Cory Eucalitto | September 3, 2013

Page 7: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

- Pay the required contribution and report it as expense

- Add a footnote to their financials (that no one really understands)

Currently most utilities account for pensions as …

Page 8: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

Why the Analogy to UFO’s and Greased Pigs?

Page 9: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

9

UFO - Unidentified Flying Objects -

Pensions - Undeterminable Financial Obligations

Greased PigWhen you think you have it in your grasps it wiggles loose and sends you chasing after it again

Page 10: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

10

• How much has your employer recorded as a liability for the service that you have accrued?

• How much SHOULD it accrue?

Page 11: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

+ Benefits Paid + Expenses – Investment ReturnNet Cost of Pension

Calculate your cost….

Page 12: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

Susie Sample:

$50,000

X

25 years service

X

2% multiplier

=

Retirement Benefit of $25,000 at age 65

Susie is currently 50 years old.

HOW MUCH SHOULD THE UTILITY HAVE ACCRUED FOR SUSIE TODAY?

Page 13: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

13

Accounting for the PAST is so much simpler than accounting for the FUTURE.

Page 14: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

14

How much liability should be accrued today for Susie?

Depends on who you ask….

Cooperative

NON-Governmental

• FASB (GAAP)

• ERISA

• PBGC

• IRS

• Bond underwriters, Banks, and lenders

• TVA

• Public Service Commissioners

• U.S. Congress

• State and local governments

MunicipalGovernmental

• GASB

• Bond underwriters, Banks, and lenders

• TVA• Public Service Commissioners• U.S. Congress• State and local governments

Page 15: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

15

The Society of Enrolled Actuaries

We enhance the ability of actuaries to be trusted financial and business advisors on problems involving uncertain future events.

- 24,000 Enrolled Actuaries

Page 16: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

16

An actuary is someone who wanted to be an accountant, but didn't have the personality for it.Actuaries are accountants who couldn't stand the

excitement.After collecting hundreds of obituaries, an actuary

concludes that on any given day, people die in alphabetical order!

Source: www.actuarialjokes.com

Page 17: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

17

How much liability should be accrued today for Susie?

• ESTIMATED present value of the expected benefits payable at the normal retirement date adjusted for

• probable mortality and disability occurrences,

• anticipated raises,

• likelihood of termination or early or late retirement (healthcare cost?),

• assumed investment rate,

• projected overtime pay in the final five years,

• projected sick leave added to service

• Only two things are certain: 1. her name is Susie 2. the cost that the actuary projects will be wrong

Page 18: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

18

Present Value of Current Accrued Benefitsor

Present Value of Future Benefits?

Current

At age 50

$50,000 Salary

x 25 years

_____x2%_____

$25,000

At age 65

How much liability should be accrued today for Susie?

At age 50 with projected

salary

$65,000 Salary

x 25 years

_____x2%_____

$32,500

At age 65

Future

At age 65

$65,000 Salary

x 40 years

_____x2%_____

$52,000

At age 65

Page 19: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

19

How much liability should be accrued today for Susie?

• ASSUME an actuary determines Susie’s accrued service (25) with projected salary ($65,000) will be $32,500. • The present value of Susie’s benefit today is $600,000*.• Susie’s cost is added to all the other employees to come

up with the total amount of pension liability….say $6,000,000*

* Note that there are numerous methods and assumptions required to be used by various regulators that can significantly change this.

Page 20: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

Susie’s Employer does not have $6,000,000 put aside in the plan.

They only have $4,000,000 in Plan Asset.

The unfunded $2,000,000 balance is amortized over a set period of time.

Here is where the “IT DEPENDS ON WHO YOU ASK” gets really tricky…

Page 21: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

21

“It Depends on who you ask”… amortize the $2,000,000 unfunded over a set period of time….• GASB – up to 30 years• FASB ( GAAP) – average working life of participants• ERISA – 7 years (Pension Protection Act of 2006)• PBGC – the shorter the better for less risk exposure• IRS – the longer the better so there is less tax deductions• Bond underwriters, Banks, and Lenders -reasonable for business cash flow • TVA - Protection of the current rate payers (Maybe Distributors should be asking

about TVA’s unfunded pensions)• U.S. Congress – whatever will appease the squeaky wheels, improve the economy,

and protect the growing national debt• State and local governments –???

(Each of the above typically has differing methods of determining discount rates, costing methods, mortality tables, retirement assumptions, etc., etc., etc.)

How much liability should be accrued today for Susie?

Page 22: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

22

It really depends on who you ask

Let’s see what the Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB) has to say about it….

How much liability should be accrued today?

Page 23: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

23

GASB 68Accounting and Financial Reporting for

Pensions• Who – Governmental organizations with pensions (includes

Multiple and Single employer plans)

(Coops don’t go to sleep…it does not apply YET, but it could be coming …)

• What – Record net pension liability on books and changes footnotes.

• When – Fiscal years beginning after June 15, 2014.

• Where – On the Statement of Net Assets, Statement of Revenue and Expenses, and footnotes.

• Why – Better presentation of financial position

• How - ??? (GASB issued guidance January 30, 2014) www.gasb.org

Page 24: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

24

GASB 68 is for Governmental Employers

Does NOT require employers to contribute more to their pension plans!

Page 25: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

25

Before

Current Rules –

GASB 25 & 27

• Pension expense = contributions required to be paid during the year

• Unfunded pension liability recorded in the footnotes

New Rules –

GASB 67 & 68

• Pension expense = change in Net Pension Liability from one year to the next

• Unfunded pension liability is now recorded on the financial statements.

After

Page 26: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

26

Concerns about GASB 67 & 68

• Increase contributions? – No, not directly… may increase political pressure• Bond, ratings, and lenders: Will it cause non-compliance

with covenants?• TVA – what about the cash ratio policy?• City Government – are the liabilities accurately separated

from the City and other utility departments?• Media – (Think it is hard enough for accountants to

understand… just let a local reporter try to do an article on the local utility’s unfunded pension obligations)• Comparative financial statements – should you show

restated prior year impact or just try to get by with just showing non-comparative statements?

Page 27: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

27

Where to get specific unfunded info for your group?

• Your Plan’s Actuary or the Plan Administrator • Your Auditor

Don’t wait until you start closing books for June 30, 2015 to look at this.

Could be a shocker for your board.

Page 28: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

Tennessee Public Employee Defined BenefitFinancial Security Act of 2014

• Approved by Tennessee Senate and House – April 2014

• Main emphasis is to require employers to pay the minimum Actuarially Required Contributions (which some large underfunded employers were not doing)

• Will require governing boards to officially adopt a funding policy by June 15, 2015 and submit a copy to the State Treasurer

• Funding requirements include up to 30 year amortization and rates that are similar to the TCRS assumptions.

• Modifies the enforceable right precedence.

28

Page 29: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

29

Tennessee Public Employee Defined BenefitFinancial Security Act of 2014

9-3-506.

(a) The following provisions shall apply to all political subdivisions subject to this act:(1) For political subdivision employees hired on or after the later of effective date of the political subdivision’s chief legislative body by resolution, the political subdivision may freeze, suspend or modify benefits, employee contributions, planterms and design on a prospective basis; and(2) For any pension plan that is funded below sixty percent (60%), the political subdivision shall not establish benefit enhancements. (b) For all political subdivision employees hired on or after the effective date of this act, the accrued benefits earned prior to any adjustment pursuant to subsection(a)(1) above shall remain an enforceable right and may not be reduced without thewritten consent of the employee. 

9-3-507.

(a) In the event the political subdivision shall fail to fund the ADC according tothe percentages established in § 9-3-505, the commissioner of finance andadministration, at the direction of the comptroller of the treasury, is authorized towithhold such amount or part of such amount from any state-shared taxes that areotherwise apportioned to such political subdivision. The money withheld from state sharedtaxes shall be paid to the political subdivision’s pension plan. (b) The deduction shall be made as a first charge against any moneys payableto such political subdivision regardless of the source of such payment and regardless ofthe purpose or contemplated use of such funds.

Tennessee Enforceable Right Precedence

http://www.capitol.tn.gov/Bills/108/Bill/SB2079.pdf

Page 30: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

30

Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation

• The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) protects the retirement incomes of more than 40 million American workers in more than 26,000 private-sector defined benefit pension plans.

• PBGC is not funded by general tax revenues. PBGC collects insurance premiums from employers that sponsor insured pension plans

• The maximum pension benefit guaranteed by PBGC is set by law and adjusted yearly. For plans that end in 2014, the maximum guarantee for workers who retire at age 65 is $59,318.16 yearly ($4,943.18 monthly).

• What plans are “insured” by the PBGC?• Private non-governmental defined benefit pension plans.• PBGC does NOT insure any governmental pension plans

Page 31: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

31

Recap Goals

1. Basic Pension Concepts2. Awareness of New Rules for Recording

Pensions3. General Update on Other Pension Stuff

(Tennessee Law, PBGC, Funding)

Page 32: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

32

Polling questions:

How much will GASB 68  require employers to increase contributions to their Pension Plans? • a.       50%• b.      25%• c.       10%• d.      0%

Page 33: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

33

Polling questions:

Which type of Pension Plans are insured by the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation? • a.  All Pension Plans• b.  Only U.S. Government Employees• c.  Non-governmental Private Employer Plans,

including Cooperatives• d. State and Local governmental Plans, including

Municipal Utilities

Page 34: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

34

Questions, comments, or appropriate humor?

Page 35: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

Scott Blassingame, CPA, CPESecretary TreasurerCentral Service Association

 After eight years in public accounting, Scott joined Central Service Association in 1997 as its Secretary-Treasurer.  In addition to reporting as Secretary to the CSA Board of Directors, he serves as CSA’s Chief Financial Officer.  He also serves as the Plan Administrator for CSA’s employee benefit programs offered to CSA Members.  These programs include:  Governmental and Non-Governmental multiple-employer Defined Benefit Pension Plans (15+ utilities, 1,000+ participants, $190+ million in assets); 401k & 457 Defined Contribution Plans ( 35+ utilities, 1,200+ participants, $40+ million in assets);  and Life, Dental, LTD, and Retiree Medical Insurance Programs (60+ utilities, 1500+ participants, $2+ million annual premiums).

[email protected]

Central Service AssociationP.O. Box 3480Tupelo, MS 38803-3480662-842-5962www.csa1.com

Page 36: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

36

To be added to the weekly CSA Money Minute newsletter email [email protected]

Page 37: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

37

CSA Employee Benefits

For over 65 years, CSA has provided pooled purchasing and administration of Employee Benefit programs that benefits CSA Members and CSA employees.

It is the intent that CSA will not create any unreasonable financial gain from sponsoring benefit plans nor will it create a significant financial drain on resource in other areas of the Association.

Page 38: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

GASB S-65 ITEMS PREVIOUSLY REPORTED AS ASSETS AND LIABILITIES

GASB Concepts Statement No. 4, Elements of Financial Statements

Assets-resources with present service capacity that the institution presently controls (BS)

Liabilities-present obligations to sacrifice resources that the institution has little or no discretion to avoid

(BS)

Outflow of resources is a consumption of net assets by the institution that is applicable to the reporting

period (IS)

Inflow of resources is an acquisition of net assets by the institution that is applicable to the reporting period

(IS)

Page 39: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

GASB S-65 ITEMS PREVIOUSLY REPORTED AS ASSETS AND LIABILITIES

GASB Statement No. 63, Financial Reporting of Deferred Outflows of Resources, Deferred Inflows of

Resources, and Net Position

A deferred outflow of resources is a consumption of net position by the institution that is applicable to a

future reporting period (BS)

A deferred inflow of resources is an acquisition of net position by the institution that is applicable to a

future reporting period (BS)

Net position is the residual of all other elements presented in a statement of financial position (BS/IS)

Page 40: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

ANSWERS KEYWORD

a. 50% 297516

b. 25% 297519

c. 10% 297520

d. 0% 297521

Text a KEYWORD to 22333 or Submit responses at PollEv.com

How much will GASB 68 require employers to increase contributions to their pension plans?

Page 41: UFOs, Greased Pigs, and Pensions Joint Accountants Meeting May 15, 2014.

ANSWERS KEYWORD

a. All pension plans 297680

b. Only U.S. Government employees

297689

c. Private Employer Plans, including Cooperative Utilities

297691

d. State and Local Government plans, including Municipal Utilities

297697

Text a KEYWORD to 22333 or Submit responses at PollEv.com

Which type of Pension Plans are insured by the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation?