Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of...

38
Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao [email protected] 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air- Conditioning, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Helsinki University of Technology Ene-39.4053 Postgraduate Seminar on Energy Technology

description

Why? 1Predicting indoor comfortable level 2Evaluate the ventilation effectiveness 3 Indoor gaseous pollutants and associated air quality control 1 Introduction

Transcript of Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of...

Page 1: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet

Guangyu [email protected]

02-04-2007Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Helsinki University of

Technology

Ene-39.4053 Postgraduate Seminar on Energy Technology

Page 2: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Content

1 Introduction2 Description of the experiment 3 Air jet distribution in the space4 Airflow modeling 4.1 Turbulence modelling 4.2 Near-wall treatment 4.3 Boundary conditions5 Results and discussions6 Conclusion

Page 3: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Why?

1 Predicting indoor comfortable level2 Evaluate the ventilation effectiveness3 Indoor gaseous pollutants and associated air

quality control

1 Introduction

Page 4: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

The draught rate model(ISO 7730:2005 standard)

)14,337,0()05,0)(34( ,62,0

,, TuvvtDR lalala

where DR is the draught rate, ta,l is the local air temperature, va is the local mean air velocity, Tu is the local turbulence intensity

Page 5: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

The ventilation effectiveness

• CR pollutant concentration in exhaust air;• CS pollutant concentration in supply air;• CP pollutant concentration in the inhalation zone.

SP

SRV CC

CC

Page 6: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

2 Description of the experiment

Page 7: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Air jet outlet and inlet

Page 8: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,
Page 9: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Investigation of 4 plans

The median plan x = 1.55 m Three vertical plans located at y = 0.60m,

y =1.10 m and at y = 1.60m

The median plan is scanned with 1892 positions of the mobile arm; each vertical plan is scanned with 440 positions.

Page 10: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

3 Air jet distribution in the space

Page 11: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Only the values superior to 0.05 m/s were retained

Page 12: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,
Page 13: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,
Page 14: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Figs. 4–6 present the velocity isovalue lines obtained with the experimental set-up. The hot case is reaching the ceiling faster than the isothermal case. The jet in the cold case does not attach but collapse from the ceiling.

Page 15: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

4 Airflow modeling

Page 16: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

What kind of problems will be confronted by CFD modelling ? Inside heat plumes will disturb the normal air jet performance.Low air inlet velocity will result in incompletely mixing of indoor air with large temperature gradient from ceiling to floor.The ineffective simulation of air outlet will underestimate the percentages of the uncomfortable people due to draught.

Page 17: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

(1) What kind of model can be used to predict the turbulence of indoor air distribution?

(2) What kind of CFD models can predict indoor air distributions accurately?

4.1 Turbulence modelling

Page 18: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS)

• The equations represent transport equations for the mean flow quantities only, with all the scales of the turbulence being modeled.

• The approach of permitting a solution for the mean flow variables greatly reduces the computational effort. If the mean flow is steady, the governing equations will not contain time derivatives.

• A computational advantage is seen even in transient situations, since the time step will be determined by the global unsteadiness rather than by the turbulence.

Page 19: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

The k–ε realizable model • This model uses the transport equations of k and

ε to compute the turbulent viscosity by Shih,• Compared with the other k–ε models, the

realizable one satisfies certain mathematical and consistent with the physics of turbulent flows (for example the normal Reynolds stress terms must always be positive).

• A new model for the dissipation rate

Page 20: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

RNG k–ε Model

• The RNG k–ε Model is derived from the instantaneous Navier- Stokes equations, using a mathematical technique called renormalization group methods.

• The RNG theory provides an analytical formula for Prt.

• It provides an analytically derived differential formula for effective viscosity.

Page 21: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

The standard k– ω model

• The two equation k– ω models are based on model transport equations for the turbulent kinetic energy and the specific dissipation rate which can also be thought of as the ratio of ω to k.

Page 22: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

The Shear-stress transport (SST) k–ω model

• The standard k- ω model and the transformed k- ω model are both multiplied by a blending function and both models are added together. The blending function is designed to be one in the near-wall region, which activates the standard k- ω model, and zero away from the surface, which activates the transformed k- ε model.

Page 23: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

4.2 Near-wall treatment

Correct calculation of a wall-bounded flow and its associated transport phenomena is not possible without the adequate description of the flow in the near wall region.

Page 24: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Near wall treatment for the k– ε models

In FLUENT, the near-wall treatment combines a two layer model with enhanced wall functions. In other words, the first cell values of temperature and velocity are given by enhanced wall functions applicable in the entire near-wall region, and the viscosity affected region is resolved by the two-layer model.

Page 25: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Near-wall treatment for the k– ω models

The near-wall treatment for the k– ω and k– ω SST models is computed following the same logic as for the k– ε realizable model. However, there is no need for a special treatment for the viscosity affected region because of the low-Reynolds correction in the k– ω and k– ω SST models.

Page 26: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

4.3 Boundary conditions

In our case, there are three kinds of boundary conditions: air inlet conditions, air outlet conditions and wall boundary conditions.

Page 27: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

5 Results and discussions

Page 28: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

The axisymmetric wall jet

Page 29: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Fig. 10 presents the maximum velocity decay for the experimental data and the numerical models for the isothermal case.

Page 30: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Fig. 11 presents the maximum velocity decay for the experimental data and the numerical models for the hot case.

Page 31: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

• Concerning the maximum temperature presented Fig. 12, the k– ω model is in good agreement with the experiment.

Page 32: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Fig. 13 is the maximum velocity curve for the cold case.

Page 33: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Fig. 14 shows that none of the models can give the good maximum position value.

Fig. 14. Velocity profile—hot case—median plan y= 1.60 m.

Page 34: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

The velocity profile of Fig. 15 illustrate the incapacity of the numerical models to predict the jet behavior.

Fig. 15. Velocity profile—cold case—median plan y= 1.60 m.

Page 35: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Jet expansion

rates

Page 36: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

The experimental data show that the axisymmetric wall jet is highly anisotropic.

Page 37: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

6. Conclusion1 None of the four numerical models can predict

correctly the expansion rates for the cold case. 2 None of the turbulence models is reliable for predicting

either the global values for temperature and velocity or the maximum velocity decay.

3 The k–ω model seems to give better results for the expansion rates. The three other models give expansion rates lower than the experimental results.

4 For the hot case, the k–ω and k– ε realizable models are closer to the experiment.

Page 38: Turbulence Models Validation in a Ventilated Room by a Wall Jet Guangyu Cao 02-04-2007 Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning,

Thank you!