Tundish Inclusion Arrest
-
Upload
amiy-srivastava -
Category
Documents
-
view
224 -
download
1
Transcript of Tundish Inclusion Arrest
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
1/71
REQUIREMENT OF TUNDISH IN CCM:
Quality Improvement through Inclusion assimilation, tundishis used as a refining vessel
Higher productivity rates driven by increased greater
machine availability and improved product yield
Slag-free transfer
Optimized metal delivery systems to the mold
Thermal control, Chemical homogenization
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
2/71
BENEFITS OF MORE TUNDISH DEPTH
Increases Metal Residence Time
Reduces the potential for Vortexing of tundish slags,
especially during transient conditions such as ladle exchanges.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
3/71
CRITERION FOR TUNDISH AS A REFINING
VESSEL
Elimination of sources of molten steel contamination,e.g., refractory erosion, reoxidation, ladle slag carryoverand tundish slag emulsification
Promotion of inclusion flotation and separation from themelt by means of flow modifying devices (FMDs), filters andengineered slags;
Introduction of technologies such as thermal control, slag-free transfer and optimized metal delivery systems to themold.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
4/71
CONSIDERATIONS FOR SELECTING OVERALL
TUNDISH DESIGN
Consideration of the product(s) to be cast.
Matching the number of strands to the shop pacing.
Cleanliness improvements.
Lining thickness and configuration.
Necessity for costly tundish furniture.
Tundish fly capability to support extended continuous
casting.
Yield losses.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
5/71
TYPES OF TUNDISH
B-TYPE TUNDISH: The trough-shaped tundish, alternately referred to as a boat- or bathtub-
shape, Variations of the rectangular-base trough include coffin-shaped and flared-trough
designs. The trough shape is commonly encountered in single- and two-strand slab casters,
and is also found on many bloom and billet casters.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
6/71
This type of Tundish offers a larger ladle stream pour box and a
more circuitous path to the strand than a conventional troughtundish.
V-shaped tundish
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
7/71
The C-tundish is a combination of the boat- and V-
tundishes.
C-shaped tundish
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
8/71
1. Encountered principally on bloom/billet machines,
2. Essentially a modified trough with a separate and usually central pour box
region. This design, while minimizing turbulence impacts to the inner strands
and ensuring a full metal head for delivery to all strands.
3. This design prone to short circuit issue of liquid steel, hence this is a
disadvantage of this design.
T-shaped tundish
POUR BOX REGION
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
9/71
1. Design essentially consists of linked troughs, allowing the bridging of a ladle
exchange period without the drop in tundish weight experienced in conventional
tundishes.
2. Separate hydraulics allow two ladles to be poured into the tundish simultaneously,
and the teeming rates of the old and new heat are matched to equal the output rate
of the caster strand(s), such that tundish level will remain constant.
3. The quality of the ladle exchange portion is comparable to that cast under steady-state conditions in the middle of a ladle.
4. The elimination of thermal events associated with heat losses through the tundish
walls, as can be induced by large tundish level fluctuations.
H-shaped tundish
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
10/71
1. Wolf and Chakraborty that longer tundishes withlower operating heights yieldmore efficient inclusions removal.
2. Flotation of larger inclusions is generally adequate for all tundishes, although small
inclusions (15 m) do not tend to be floated effectively in any tundish configuration.
3. Shallower designs allow better separation, as the relative distance to be coveredby an inclusion during StokesLaw flotation from the melt to the receptive
slag interface is smaller on average.
4. A shallower tundish also will provide better chemical transition compared to
tundishes of equal volume but greater operating depth, owing to the mixing behavior
of the streams. Notunderstood????
ADVANTAGES OF SHALLOWER TUNDISH:
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
11/71
DISADVANTAGES OF SHALLOWER TUNDISH:
1. Reduced ability to dissipate turbulent ladle stream energy.
2. Increased chances of top slag Vortexing from the tundish into the mold.
Tundish metallurgy- a solution or limitation to clean steel, J. van der Stel,M.C.M.Cornellison,
B.Deo and R.Boom, Tundish Metallurgy, Vol II, AIME, 1990
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
12/71
TUNDISH SOLUTION SHOULD PROVIDE FOLLOWINGS:
1. Sufficient volume to bridge ladle exchanges;
2. An appropriate operating depth;
3. Uniform flow distribution to all strands;
4. Optimal residence time for inclusion flotation;
5. A quiescent surface;
6. Thermal and chemical insulation, including appropriate refractories; and
7. Low drainage weight capability to optimize yield.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
13/71
Physio-Chemical Phenomena
13IIT Bombay7/5/2014
Ladle changeover and grade intermixing
Temperature drop and heat loss
Re-oxidation, inclusion generation
Slag emulsification
Slag vortexing
Inclusion removal
Strand freezing
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
14/71
Following solution may be provided to a Tundish for achieving required inclusion
floatation
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
15/71
PHYSICAL SHROUDING SYSTEMS
1. Fused silica ladle shrouds: Prone to chemical and physical
attack by the teeming stream
2. Alumina-Graphite (ALG) Refractories Shrouds: offers good
thermal shock resistance and resistance to metal and slag
attack,
TO PREVENT ASPIRATION THROUGH THE SHROUD WALLS:
1. sufficient refractory thickness and density, as well as low
permeability, are required
2. Glazes: By applying of glazes on the interior and exterior
surfaces of shroud walls to control oxidation
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
16/71
SHROUD NITROGEN ASPIRATION CURE
Argon gas is injected in the
shroud bayonet seal which
provides a positive pressure and
minimizes air aspirations.
Submerged opening practices in
the pour box by suppressing the
turbulence using the required
shapes of pour box.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
17/71
DISADVANTAGES OF UNSUBMERGED LADLE OPENING1. Forces vigorous slag/metal interactions, leading to increased inclusion
formation
2. Provides exposure of the steel in the falling stream as well as in thetundish pour box to the atmosphere.
NOTE:
A submerged opening practicedoes require a shroud with a larger
diameter at the bottom than at
the top to prevent so-called
blowbacks during ladle open,
induced by resistance fromconstrictions.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
18/71
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
19/71
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
20/71
TUNDISH LINING:
1. It should be Inert and not be contributed to exogenous
inclusions in the steel.
2. Applications are being developed where the tundish lining is
designed to actually react with solid inclusions in the melt to
form liquid compounds that do not clog.
3. The control of reducible components in the lining, such as
silica and alkali oxides is also very important. If uncontrolled,
these can be leached out during the casting process and
contribute to formation of alumina inclusions, as the
dissolved aluminum in the steel will react with the more
reducible oxide species at the tundish wall.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
21/71
TUNDISH TOP SURFACE COVER:
Top surface of the tundish is protected from the atmosphere bythe addition of a tundish flux layer.
A few casters around the world are equipped with fully sealed
lids that can sustain an inert gas atmosphere above the melt and
atmospheric control is maintained by means of oxygen sensors.
FUNCTION OF SLAG COVER:
1. Inclusion absorption2. Thermal insulation
3. Chemical insulation
4. buffering of ladle slag
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
22/71
STOPPER RODS:
A stopper rod is a tubular device that controls
flow to the mold by adjusting the openingbetween the rod tip and the tundish well nozzle.
Stoppers are mostly constructed of alumina
graphite, occasionally with tips incorporating the
use of magnesia, SiAlONs (pronounced sy-a-
lons, an advanced class of ceramics withexcellent wear characteristics) and/or porous
elements.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
23/71
A NEGATIVE PRESSURE AT THE FLOW CONTROL POINT i.e. UNDER THE STOPPER ROD TIP
Problem: A pressure difference of around 2035 psi between the tip of the stopper and
the metal above the flow control point.
Solution: Inert gas purging is required to negate air aspiration through the stopper rod.
Advantage of stopper rods is that it Reduce the propensity for vortex formation but it
doesnt completely remove the chance of vortexing.
Tundish well nozzles alignment has also become a very important and critical issue
which has to be taken care because just the misalignment of 2 degree from the vertical
can make tundish nozzle clogging worse or exacerbate and if the misalignment reaches
10 degrees from vertical it starts blocking or plugging faster significantly.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
24/71
SOME TUNDISH DESIGNS
HAVE TO ACCOMMODATE
FOLLOWING:
Product being cast like in a
combi-caster which are
designed to produce different
sections. These produce a
slab and sometime theseproduce 3 bloom strands.
When Slab is produced from
the combi-caster V-shaped
dam is replaced by two larger
angle dams and middle hole iscapped. This provision should
be given in a tundish.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
25/71
Water Modeling : An Effective First Approach
Our Water modelsflow system should be similar to the real flow system for Steel.
CRITERIA OF SIMILARITY:
GEOMETRIC SIMILARITY:
Geometric similarity requires that the ratios of all lengths be maintained to a constant
value. full-scale model detractors include requirements for large water supplies, large
building spaces, and significant pumping capacity. Thus, construction and operation ofsuch models are rather capital- and cost-intensive. reduced-scale models can be
constructed at a comparatively lower capital cost without requirements for extensive
bracing of the transparent Plexiglas walls.
REDUCED SCALE MODELS INCUR:
Lower Operating cost based mainly on the lower quantities of consumables, specificallythe water required.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
26/71
KINEMATIC SIMILARITY & DYNAMIC SIMILARITY:
Property Water (293K) Steel (1873K)Viscosity (cP) 1 6.4
Density (g/cm3) 1 7.08
Kinematic Viscosity (cs) 1 0.904
Surface Tension (mN/m) 7.3 1900
ADVANTAGES OF CHOOSING WATER:
1. Since the kinematic viscosities of the two fluids are nearly identical, water can
effectively serve as a medium to model liquid steel flow accurately.
2. It provides safe handling and transparency of medium, thus enabling simple and
effective flow visualization by means of a variety of fluid volume tracers
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
27/71
Kinematic and dynamic similarity signify that fluid streamlines and dynamic forces
in the model system and the actual system are equivalent in magnitude, geometry
and direction.
All the system dynamics are defined by well known dimensionless expressions as
follows:
Froude Number: relates inertial forces to gravity and represents the bulk flow
within the tundish.
Reynolds Number: relates inertial forces to viscosity and the boundary flow
conditions that account for only a small fraction of the total flow in a tundish.
Weber Number: relates inertial forces to surface tension effect
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
28/71
GOVERNING ACTIONS FOR THE FLUID FLOW:
A. The high-momentum incident ladle stream jet
B. Gravity-driven flow at the tundish-to-mold exit orifices
THERMAL SIMILARITY:
Thermal similarity is ignored generally due to the bulk flow of steel where forced
convection dominates such as tundishes, thermal phenomena may be ignored.
However, more recent studies have shown that thermal phenomena can result in
significant shifts in fluid flow behavior, even so-called INVERSION.
In tundishes, for example, this phenomenon is particularly important during ladle
switches, as steel from a new heat will mix in the tundish with the prior heat
under potentially non-isothermal conditions.
Depending on whether the thermal difference between the heats is positive or
negative, the flow kinetics are modified, and short-circuit times to reach different
strands are altered. Thus, recent water modeling studies have incorporated the
ability to mix cold and warm streams to provide simulation of transient
phenomena.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
29/71
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
30/71
TRACERS IN WATER MODELING:
DENSITY NEUTRAL TRACERS: EX. Water-soluble dyes
NON NEUTRAL DENSITY TRACERS: EX. saline solutions
Provide a slightly altered RTD profile
Relatively accurate
Repeatable RTD results
Provide valid modeling of the actual events occurring in these steelmaking reactors
Yield a profile of the concentration as determined at the outlet of the model
RTDcurves are drawn to obtain important information
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
31/71
CONCEPT OF RESIDANCE TIME DISTRIBUTION(RTD):
The RTD is frequently plotted as dimensionless concentration versus dimensionless time.
The standard time axis is expressed using the mathematical function of mean residencetime (MRT).
MRT= WorkingVolume of steel in the tundish/ flow rate of steel out of tundish
MRT = 40 tonnes /8 tonnes/min= 5 min
A period of one MRT is also defined as ,RTD or C curves are often plotted to 2.5or 3
In this case, 3would equate to 15 minutes for the given conditions of tundish volume
and throughput. As the flow rate changes, so does .
Characteristic information obtained through an RTD CURVE:
PLUG VOLUMEDISPERSED PLUG VOLUME
MIXED VOLUME
DEAD VOLUME
These characteristics are used to evaluate the tundish flow conditions at steady-state
casting conditions.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
32/71
DESCRIPTION OF DEAD VOLUME
1. The ratio of mixed to dead volume indicates the mixing capability of a tundish.
2. Lowest temperature zones (maximum cooling) indicate the Dead Volume regionsduring the Steel flow.
3. The value of the dead volume is found to be more sensitive than the other two
volumes to find mixing capability and hence important to reduce this stagnant portion
as far as possible.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
33/71
CALCULATION OF RTDOF MELT FLOWING IN THE TUNDISH:
It is done by solving a time-dependent mass transport equation in the tundish. The plug,
mixed and dead flow fractional components of a particular tundish configuration can be
gauged visually from an RTD curve.
FOR STEADY STATE CONDITION:
The calculation assumes that a tracer is injected at the inlet at a given time and it
flows/disperses with the melt with the specified velocity field and turbulence conditionsobtained from the steady-state calculations. The calculated concentration at the tundish
outlet(s) is recorded as a function of time.
BOUNDARY CONDITION FOR UNSTEADY STATE FLOW:
The boundary conditions required for the solution of the unsteady-state mass transportequation have to express the physical constraints that all the bounding surfaces are
impervious to the tracer. Mathematically, this corresponds to zero flux of the tracer at all
bounding surfaces.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
34/71
PLUG FLOW:The plug flow fraction is defined by the advent of the first injected tracer volume at the
tundish outlet nozzle. Also known as the minimum residence time, this characterizes
the portion of the fluid that moves through the tundish in a plug manner.
()
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
35/71
MIXED FLOW
The mixed fractionalsocalled dispersedvolume
is indicated by the tailof
the C-curve, viz. from the
apex to the time defined as
2. Mixed flow is an
important considerationfrom the perspectives of
temperature and chemistry
transition, as it shows the
tendency of two
concentrations to mix prior
to reaching the outletstream.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
36/71
Dead flow
It serves no useful purpose in the tundish and needs to be minimized, as it leads to
detrimental phenomena such as skull formation. Dead flow in RTD curves is generally
defined as the portion of the injected tracer persisting beyond 2.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
37/71
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
38/71
CONDITION TO ACHIEVE MAXIMUM INCLUSION SEPARATION RATIO:
1. a minimum spread of residence time
2. large ratio of plug to dead volume
3. relatively large ratio of plug to mixed volume
4. surface directed flow, and contained region of mixing.
REF: Y. Sahai, R. Ahuja, Fluid flow and mixing of melt in steelmaking tundishes, Ironmaking
Steelmaking 13 (5) (1986) 241252.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
39/71
BASIC SOURCE OF INCLUSIONS IN TUNDISH:
1. In the carry over slag from the ladle (micro droplets form)
2. Tundish slag
3. Eroded particles of refractory wall
4. Various chemical/steel deoxidation reactions
EFFECTS ON INCLUSION REMOVAL
Height and position of dams affect the removal of inclusion.[1]
The size of inclusions is the critical factor in determining the effectiveness of a giventundish design to separate and float out inclusions.
Inclusions with a large terminal velocity or larger particle diameter will readily float-up to
the slag-metal interface provided appropriate flow modifiers are incorporated into the
tundish geometry. [2,3]
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
40/71
[1] P.K. Jha, P.S. Rao, A. Dewan, Effect of height and position of dams on inclusion removal
in a six strand tundish, ISIJ Int. 48 (2008) 154160.
[2] S. Joo, R.I.L. Guthrie, Heat flow and inclusion behaviour in a tundish for slab casting,
Can. Metall. Q. 30 (1991) 261269.
[3] A. Ruckert, M. Warzecha, R. Koitzsch, M. Pawlik, H. Pfeifer, Particle distribution andseparation in continuous casting tundish, Steel Res. Int. 80 (2009) 568574
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
41/71
SIMULATION OF TUNDISH SLAG
1. Oils like Silicone and mineral oils are used to observe surface turbulence and
tundish slag emulsification.
2. It is desirable to minimize surface turbulence, which can cause disruptions to the
complete slag coverage of the tundish surface, often termed openeyes.
3. Slag emulsification be minimized during a ladle change during sequence casting,
this is the demand of clean steel practices.
4. The oil technique is very useful to model the slag/metal interfaces, but, from an
environmental standpoint, does require the modeler to exercise caution so that no
pollution from entrainment of the oil into the model discharge stream(s) occurs
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
42/71
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
43/71
A water modeling rule of thumb that should be enforced by the modeler is that the
steady-state flow pattern inside a tundish does not fully materialize until three
theoretical mean residence times (3)have elapsed.
Well-designed FMD systems improve the inclusion separation in tundishes.
In fact, a recent trend in water modeling has been the use of overhead mirrors to
allow simultaneous observations of front and plan views of the flow.
One recent study utilizing multiple views of the flow showed that streams do not
move as fronts, but rather tend to display split streams.[17]
Integrity of FMDs is important, as cracks and fractures in the shapes can significantly
impact the fluid flow.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
44/71
EXAMPLE OF EFFECT OF PLACING FMDs IMPROPERLY:
It was observed in one instance[18] that Vortexing from the tundish surface into mold
occurred under steady-state conditions with an improperly placed baffle at the full
tundish operating head of 1000 mm.
It should be noted that when the
baffle was repositioned in the
tundish, the Vortexing could not be
re-created, suggesting that theconcentric flow velocities required to
sustain vortex motion over the well
nozzle had been diminished
significantly.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
45/71
PICTURE OF A BAFFLE
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
46/71
Vortexing phenomena do not occur until the tundish level is in the 200300 mm
height range,[4] depending on tundish well nozzle placement.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
47/71
Wedged weir/dam combination
and partially collapsed baffles
have been known to cause
rolling action at the surface of
even deep tundishes;
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
48/71
OTHER REQUIREMENTS RELATED TO TUNDISH DESIGN
Our design should be accompanied with the physical designs of shop floor entities like
design of tundish Car etc as well as allowable floor loadings and space clearances.These physical limitations should always be inculcated in our design.
TRANSITION MODELING
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
49/71
TRANSITION MODELINGIn continuous casting, any grade change between heats results in a defined quantity of mixed
grade volume.
In modeling transitions, a tracer or dopant is introduced into the tundish model andhomogenized with water.
This mixture is considered the old steel (grade A). Grade A is drained to a specific depth to
simulate ladle exchange operations. Water of a different concentration, typically without tracer
addition, is used to simulate the introduction of new steel (grade B) at a flow rate simulating
normal tundish refill practice.
Once the normal operating depth is re-attained, the flow rate of grade B is throttled back to
normal steady-state casting conditions.
This procedure is visually observed, and the tracer concentration can be collected at the
outlet
Again, the data are graphed as a time-versus-concentration plot that is more commonly
referred to as an F-curve.
F-curves can be used to determine the length and predictability of grade change transitions at
various mixture requirements.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
50/71
Due to Reoxidation, we can see in the picture, the freshly made slag.
To avoid the reoxidation, we use a submerged nozzle, however during ladle changeoperation for few seconds there is an open ladle stream of steel entering the tundish.
The reoxidation product during that open stream pouring can actually affect the molten
steel of the tundish for the next 10 minutes of the casting.
Reoxidation during the transfer of heat
INACCURACY IN TRANSITION MODELING
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
51/71
INACCURACY IN TRANSITION MODELINGPoor Mechanical properties at customer end due to down grading of the material
Discrepancy between plant data and a rudimentary transition model outdated by FMD
setup changes.
The model underestimated the actualtransition at 80% of intermix by some 43
tons, while the discrepancy at 95%
intermix completion more than doubled
this figure.
As can be seen from the plant data, theactual chemical transition reached 95%
completion within 2530 minutes,
depending on strand throughput,
whereas the old model would continue to
downgrade the strand chemical quality
for an additional 2025 minutes.
The yield implications in this case
suggest a lost opportunity to sell about 90
tons of prime material per transition
event. BY U. S. STEEL IN 1992.[20]
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
52/71
Poor Mechanical properties at customer end due to down grading of the material
What is the reverse transitioning
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
53/71
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
54/71
Melt flow for any tundish design can be characterized by the followings:
Solving Standard fluid flow equations
Solving the Heat Transfer EquationsSolving associated turbulence equations
Steady State Equation of the above categories are solved for the
period of normal casting Operations.
Time dependent or unsteady state equations are solved for the
period of ladle change operation
flow in a tundish is not necessarily laminar, it becomes mandatory to incorporate equations
for a turbulence model, such as the commonly used K-
and two-equation models.
Turbulence flow equation for 3 dimension has to be studied because of introduction of
ladle change phenomenon. During ladle exchange flow does not remain laminar.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
55/71
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
56/71
At the free surfaceoften assumed to be flat
At the symmetry planes, the normal velocity components and the normal gradients of all
other variables (momentum and scalar transport properties) are defined as zero.
At the jet entry, the velocity perpendicular to the free surface may be calculated from
the volumetric flow rate and the area of nozzle.
Since the jet flow generally is in highly turbulent range, a flat velocity profile in the
incoming jet may be assumed. Similar boundary conditions may also be imposed at the
outlet nozzle(s). ..TO BE ASKED BY VICHU SIR..AND WHAT IS FLAT
VELOCITY PROFILE????
The incoming liquid jet may be considered at a constant temperature. For modeling heatfluxes through free surface and each wall, heat fluxes are assigned or estimated.
q. What is NO-SLIP BOUNDARY CONDITION???
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
57/71
The key to the success of modeling is, of course, the numerical solution procedure.
The computational domain is divided in a non-uniform grid in the three orthogonal
directions. It is generally a good practice to test the dependence of the grid size on thesolution of the problem. A finer grid does require more computing time but generally
results in a more accurate solution. Thus, a balance between the accuracy of the
solution and computer time must be struck.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
58/71
The solutions of the steady-state equations are:
Velocity
Temperature field: The temperature field in the tundish indicates the areas where it
may be possible to freeze metal.
Turbulence field: The turbulent flow field plots show fast-moving and relatively slow-
moving or stagnant regions in the tundish. Careful examination of the flow field may
give qualitative indications of the plug, mixed and dead volumes in the tundish. For
quantitative evaluation of the plug, mixed and dead volumes in a tundish, RTD
Techniques are used.
NOTE: The percentages of plug, mixed and dead flow is not sufficient for determining
what setup should be used.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
59/71
ROLE OF DEAD ZONES IN TUNDISH FLOTATION EFFICIENCY
Dead zones are mathematically defined by the region beyond 2on an RTD curve,
and physically are zones of quasi-stagnant flow.
These zones most prominently occur in the shadow of FMDs, viz. the areaimmediately behind a dam, weir, or baffle that the bulk flow bypasses.
The occurrence of dead volumes represents a deviation from ideal plug flow
behavior, resulting in a decrease in effective working volume of the tundish.
Mathematical modeling has proven to be quite effective in showing that merely
increasing the working volume of the tundish to counteract the reduced working
volume imposed by the stagnant flow region is not a guarantee for improved
inclusion flotation.
Fi id l f h f h h i l l i f h d d i ll
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
60/71
Figure provides an example of the factthat the spatial location of the dead zones is equally as
important as its magnitude.
normal weir/dam combination
The inclusion trajectory lines show that the first The inclusions are short-circuited toward the
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
61/71
scenario provides opportunities for contact
between the inclusions and the tundish slag
layer.
well nozzle and thus into the cast strand in
the case where the high dam precedes the
short weir.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
62/71
Effect of draining and filling as well as thermal gradients can be modeled using tank in
series approach borrowed from chemical Engineering concepts, These effects can have a
significant effect on the fluid flow in tundishes.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
63/71
ADVANTAGES OF CHANGING OPERATING PARAMETER
OVER USING Flow Control Devices.
Better Mixing may be achieved by changing the geometrical
parameters(width, height, nozzle distance and their simultaneous
change), compare to using flow control devices like weir, Dam etc.
The use of dams and weirs has also led to the formation of dead
volume regions in the leeward sides, which leads to inhomogeneous
mixing in the tundish.
Fixing up dams and weirs in a tundish being much-involved job
poses another difficulty.
MIXED VOLUME
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
64/71
The mixed volume of tundish is closely connected with its inflow part, in which the kinetic
energy of pouring flow from the ladle ensures intensive mixing of steel.
PLUG FLOW
The characteristic feature of plug flow is uniform flow of liquid steel during which no elementforeruns the other elements. In the area of plug flow the steel flow has already the laminar
character and so there are better conditions for the rise of inclusions here. The flow of a body of
ice or viscous fluid with no shearing between adjacent layers; idealized flow without any mixing
of particles of fluid.
DEAD VOLUME OF TUNDISHThere are also areas in the tundish with the very slow flow of steel. These areas represent so-
called dead volume of tundish. Dead volume is defined as the area where the liquid steel stays
in tundish longer than the double of the average residence time. Existence of dead volume can
substantially decrease the active volume of tundish and so reduce the residence times of steel
in the tundish.In the area of dead volumes, the greatest danger of local solidification of steel
also exists.This is the reason for minimizing the dead volume in tundish.
SHORT-CIRCUIT FLOW:
When the coming steel practically immediately gets into the outlet of tundish, which is
undesirable with regard to steel purity and thermal homogeneity of cast steel in individual
strands.
In case of open pouring of steel the plunging Jetentrains the significant volume of air(or Gas , in case
OPEN POURING
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
65/71
Ref: Y. Sahai, R. Ahuja, Fluid flow and mixing of melt in
steelmaking tundishes, Ironmaking Steelmaking 13 (5) (1986)
241252.
g ( ,
of an inert gas shrouded stream). The entrained gas
causes a strong upward buoyancy force and the
liquid flow in this region is reversed. The liquid
stream loses its downward momentum on entering
the tundish and reverses to the free surface, where
it flows downstream towards the tundish-mould
nozzle. In this case dead volume was found 23%
when no FMDs were used.
Use of Weir helps to push the flow downward and
eliminates the red circled dead zone but again
generate the blue circled dead zone region behind
itself. 17% DV is found.
Again use of Dam increases the dead volume by
creating the dead region (green circle) behind thedam. DV increases to 27% again by this.
Free surface and tundish wall Dead Zone remain
unchanged. (orange circled)
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
66/71
TURBULANCE INHIBITORS:
By using turbulence inhibitor solely causes shortcut flow and bigger dead volume in the
tundish, and the tundish loses its metallurgical character in temperature, composition
and inclusion separation, but the turbulence inhibitor with an inner helical groove can beused to control the flow field in the inpouring area.
Ref: LIU Jin-gang , YAN Hui-cheng , Liu Liu , WANG Xin-
hua, Water Modeling of
Optimizing Tundish Flow
Field, JOURNAL OF IRON
AND STEEL RESEARCH,
INTERNAITONAL. 2007,14(3): 13-19
Each of these physical control devices creates a slow, secondary recirculation in the
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
67/71
downstream region behind the device
The use of gas injection in conjunction with the physical control devices decreases the
dead volume by activating the low recirculating liquid and considerably increaes the
dispersed plug/dead volume ratio.
During Submerged stream pouring, liquid
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
68/71
During Submerged stream pouring, liquid
enters the pool with sufficient downward
momentum to carry it right to the bottom.
Red circled regions are shown as dead
volume when there is no flow control
devices, blue circled is the dead zone when
weir is used and green circle indicates the
dead regions when dam is used.
Free surface and tundish wall Dead Zoneremain unchanged. (orange circled)
Ref: Y. Sahai, R. Ahuja, Fluid flow and mixing of melt in
steelmaking tundishes, Ironmaking Steelmaking 13 (5) (1986)
241252.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
69/71
Melt Flow Characterization in Continuous Casting Tundishes, Yogeshwar SAHAI and
Toshihiko EMI, ISIJ International. Vol. 36 (1996), No. 6, pp. 667-672
SOME QUERIES:
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
70/71
Explain longitudinal mixing and transverse mixing??
In the plug fiow region, the longitudinal mixing is non-existent, however, there maybe
transverse mixing to any extent.
-
8/11/2019 Tundish Inclusion Arrest
71/71