True Crime With Aphrodite Jones S3 Ep 02 930056TX
-
Upload
pianinocska -
Category
Documents
-
view
25 -
download
0
description
Transcript of True Crime With Aphrodite Jones S3 Ep 02 930056TX
**
Job ID: 45557True Crime With Aphrodite Jones S3930056 Ep 02TX Script
68
DISCOVERY COMMUNICATIONS EUROPETRUE CRIME WITH APHRODITE JONES S3930056 EP 02TRANSMISSION SCRIPT
JOB ID:45557CLOCK INFO:
True Crimes with Aphrodite Jones (S3)
Ep.2 - A Bite, A Bullet, and A Broken Heart
EHD/930056B
Seg.1- 9:48
Seg.2- 6:28
Seg.3- 17:28
Seg.4- 10:31
TRT - 44:15
13/02/13
Track 1: Full Mix Left
Track 2: Full Mix Right
Track 3: Mix Minus Left
Track 4: Mix Minus Right
Cover Page
Transcripts provided by
Tel: 0800 0854418
+44 (0)1580 720923www.take1.tvTime-codes & CaptionsDialogue
10:00:01:04NARRATOR
A PRETTY, YOUNG NEWLYWED FOUND MURDERED WITH THREE SHOTS TO THE CHEST. A BAFFLING CASE THAT GOES UNSOLVED FOR YEARS, UNTIL FORENSIC
10:00:11:06SCIENCE REVEALS THE MOST UNLIKELY OF SUSPECTS.
10:00:15:04Aphrodite Jones
When I first heard about this case, I felt, Oh my God, is this possible?
10:00:19:21Shannon Presby
The line dividing good and evil runs through the heart of every human being.
10:00:25:13TITLE SEQUENCE
10:00:26:14NARRATOR
MY NAME IS APHRODITE JONES. AS A TRUE CRIME AUTHOR, I TAKE ON CONTROVERSIAL CASES. I TRACK DOWN THE STORY BEHIND THE STORY AND I WONT STOP UNTIL I GET
10:00:38:08THE TRUTH.
10:00:44:03Aphrodite Jones
There are certain cases that I cannot just let go, because theres so much deception involved, so much evil underneath, that I feel it has to have attention.
10:01:01:03NARRATOR
THE CASE IM TALKING ABOUT TOOK PLACE IN THE CENTRE OF THE SAN FERNANDO VALLEY IN THE COMMUNITY OF VAN NUYS. ITS NO DIFFERENT THAN MANY LOS
10:01:09:11ANGELES NEIGHBOURHOODS. A MAIN COMMERCIAL STRIP DOTTED BY PALM TREES, BUT THEIR ARE SECRETS HERE BEHIND THE LOCKED ENTRANCES TO THE
10:01:17:24GATED COMMUNITIES. COMMUNITIES LIKE THE BALBOA TOWNHOMES.
10:01:24:13NARRATOR
WHERE, ON FEBRUARY 24TH 1986, SOMETHING TRULY HORRIFIC HAPPENS IN UNIT 205.
10:01:38:21NARRATOR
ITS A MONDAY EVENING AND ENGINEER JOHN RUETTEN IS COMING HOME FROM WORK.
10:01:45:17NARRATOR
HE TAKES THE GARAGE STAIRS UP TO THE CONDO.
10:01:52:1010:01:53:08
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
NARRATOR
HE CAN TELL IMMEDIATELY THAT SOMETHING IS WRONG.
10:02:00:0110:02:00:14
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:FROM JOHN RUETTENS TESTIMONY
John Ruetten (Actor) VOAt first I wondered
10:02:01:10John Ruetten (Actor)
Sherri!
10:02:01:21
John Ruetten (Actor) VO
whats going on? Why is she lying there on the floor?
10:02:05:10John Ruetten (Actor)
Sherri!
10:02:05:22
10:02:07:11
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
John Ruetten (Actor) VO
right in the middle and I went over and started to look closely and tried to see what was going on.
10:02:12:09Aphrodite Jones
I tried to imagine what this poor man must have felt like, John Ruetten, coming home to his brand new wife and finding her bloodied and beaten.
10:02:27:11John Ruetten (Actor) VO
I could tell by her eyes that she was gone.
10:02:31:14NARRATOR
HIS WIFE, SHERRI RASMUSSEN, IS DEAD, ONLY FOUR MONTHS INTO HER MARRIAGE, ONLY 29 YEARS OLD. IN A FLASH JOHN RUETTEN GOES FROM NEWLYWED TO
10:02:44:12WIDOWER.
10:02:49:21NARRATOR
I LOOKED IT UP. IN 1986 831 PEOPLE WERE MURDERED IN THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES, MORE THAN TWO EVERY DAY. SHERRI RASMUSSEN WAS JUST ONE OF THEM. HER
10:03:02:14DEATH GOT A BRIEF MENTION ON PAGE EIGHT OF THE LOS ANGELES TIMES.
10:03:08:10NARRATOR
BUT SHERRI WAS MORE THAN A STATISTIC, A LOT MORE, AS DISTRICT ATTORNEY, PAUL NUNEZ, WOULD LATER COME TO APPRECIATE.
10:03:16:17Aphrodite Jones
Did you feel youd got to know her in the process of investigating this case?
10:03:20:21
10:03:23:19
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:PAUL NUNEZ
Deputy district attorney
Paul Nunez
Yes. Sherri embodied such a giving spirit and it was a tremendous loss for everyone.
10:03:28:06NARRATOR
SHERRI RAE RASMUSSEN HAD FOUND HER CALLING AS A NURSE WHEN SHE WAS JUST 21. BY 29 SHE WAS MADE A DIRECTOR OF NURSING AT GLENDALE AVENTIST MEDICAL
10:03:38:23CENTER.
10:03:39:23Aphrodite Jones
Sherri was a smart young woman. She was pretty, she was savvy. This is a young woman who wanted to serve and who really cared about other people.
10:03:53:11NARRATOR
IN 1984 SHERRI MEETS A YOUNG UCLA GRADUATE NAMED JOHN RUETTEN WHOS JUST BEGUN A CAREER IN MECHANICAL ENGINEERING. THE COUPLE FALLS IN LOVE
10:04:04:02AND LATE THE FOLLOWING YEAR THEYRE MARRIED. SHERRIS PARENTS APPROVE.
10:04:08:1610:04:11:09
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:JOHN TAYLORRasmussen family attorney
John Taylor
Nels and Loretta Rasmussen were ecstatic that Sherri had found somebody to share her life with. They loved John; they were really excited for them.
10:04:20:02NARRATOR
THE NEWLYWEDS CANT WAIT TO START THEIR NEW LIFE TOGETHER, MAYBE EVEN START A FAMILY. THATS NOT WHAT HAPPENS.
10:04:28:09
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
10:04:30:21NARRATOR
DETECTIVES ARRIVE AT THE BALBOA TOWNHOMES AT ABOUT 7.30 THE EVENING OF THE MURDER.
10:04:38:15NARRATOR
THEY SEE HER BEATEN BODY
10:04:41:10NARRATOR
AND CLEAR SIGNS OF A LIFE AND DEATH STRUGGLE.
10:04:45:11Sherri Rasmussen (Actress)Help!
10:04:47:13Lead Detective Lyle Mayer (Actor)
Look I know this is difficult, but if you dont mind answering a couple of questions for us?
10:04:53:15NARRATOR
JOHN RUETTEN IS BARELY ABLE TO SPEAK.
10:04:56:23Lead Detective Lyle Mayer (Actor)
And how would you describe your wifes mood when you left this morning? Was she in a good mood?
10:05:01:15NARRATOR
AT FIRST, LEAD DETECTIVE LYLE MAYER QUIZZES JOHN ON HIS WHEREABOUTS THAT DAY.
10:05:06:24John Ruetten (Actor)
I got home at six.
10:05:08:11Lead Detective Lyle Mayer (Actor)
Six pm.
10:05:09:01NARRATOR
IN ANY HOMICIDE THE SPOUSE IS USUALLY CONSIDERED A SUSPECT, BUT JOHNS ALIBI SEEMED SOLID AND HIS SHOCK GENUINE AND LATER DETECTIVES WILL RULE HIM
10:05:19:18OUT.
10:05:23:10NARRATOR
AFTER EXAMINING SHERRIS BODY AND HER WOUNDS, MAYER NOTICES A DRAWER THATS BEEN PULLED OPEN. SOMEONE HAD BEEN SEARCHING FOR SOMETHING.
10:05:34:07NARRATOR
TWO PIECES OF STEREO EQUIPMENT SIT ON THE FLOOR NEAR THE DOOR LEADING TO THE GARAGE.
10:05:40:21NARRATOR
DETECTIVE MAYER STARTS TO FORM AN IDEA ABOUT WHAT MIGHT HAVE HAPPENED.
10:05:45:14Aphrodite Jones
From the evidence, as I recall, the two detectives actually thought this was an interrupted burglary, yes?
10:05:53:00Paul Nunez
The theory was that you had burglars that came in and they were interrupted by Sherri.
10:06:01:19Sherri Rasmussen (Actress)
John? Honey?
10:06:05:06Sherri Rasmussen (Actress)
What are you doing in my house?
10:06:09:0010:06:09:11
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
NARRATOR
THE DETECTIVES BELIEVE SHERRI STRUGGLED WITH HER ATTACKERS.
10:06:13:0210:06:15:20
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:SHANNON PRESBYDeputy district attorney
Shannon Presby
We all know that Sherri was fighting for her life by the front door, because two of Sherris fingernails are broken off and found on that tiled entry way.
10:06:24:0910:06:31:15
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
Shannon Presby
Once Sherri made it to the carpeted living room, it was at that point that she was struck in the face with this heavy, ceramic vase.
10:06:34:09NARRATOR
STUNNED BY THE BLOW, SHERRI WOULD NO LONGER HAVE BEEN ABLE TO OFFER ANY RESISTANCE. STILL, BASED ON HER WOUNDS, POLICE THINK ONE OF THE
10:06:42:2410:06:45:07
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
BURGLARS DECIDED TO FINISH HER OFF WITH A 38 CALIBER [GUN SHOTS] REVOLVER.
10:06:51:02NARRATOR
A BLANKET WITH GUNPOWDER BURNS INDICATES THAT THE SHOOTER USED IT TO MUFFLE THE WEAPON AND THEN THE BURGLARS MUST HAVE FLED TAKING
10:06:59:20SHERRIS CAR, WHICH IS MISSING FROM THE GARAGE.
10:07:04:09NARRATOR
THERES NO EVIDENCE OF SEXUAL ASSAULT, BUT WHILE EXAMINING SHERRIS BODY, THE CORONER NOTICES AN UNUSUAL WOUND ON HER LEFT FOREARM. IT LOOKS
10:07:14:07A LOT LIKE A BITE MARK.
10:07:16:16Aphrodite Jones
Sherri was trying to get out of the door and thats why the person bit her on the arm.
10:07:21:02Paul Nunez
Yes. She was probably either trying to escape, or pushing that gun away and the killer had to regain control of the situation.
10:07:30:20NARRATOR
THE CORONER TAKES A SWAB OF THE WOUND AND PLACES IT IN AN EVIDENCE TUBE FOR BLOOD TYPING. HE CANT POSSIBLY KNOW HOW CRUCIAL THIS SWAB
10:07:39:24WILL BE 25 YEARS LATER.
10:07:46:01NARRATOR
PROCESSING A CRIME SCENE IS ALWAYS A TOUGH JOB, BUT EVEN TOUGHER IS NOTIFYING THE PARENTS.
10:07:53:05John Taylor
Nels and Loretta Rasmussen received a phone call about two oclock in the morning. They were incredulous, devastated.
10:08:03:22NARRATOR
SHERRIS PARENTS GET ON THE FIRST PLANE FROM TUCSON, ARIZONA TO LOS ANGELES. THEY WANT TO KNOW WHAT HAPPENED TO THEIR DAUGHTER.
10:08:11:19John Taylor
Nels met with Lyle Mayer when they first came to the Van Nuys Division of the LAPD.
10:08:18:05NARRATOR
NELS RASMUSSEN TELLS MAYER THAT SHERRI HAD BEEN COMPLAINING RECENTLY ABOUT A WOMAN SHED SAID WAS HARASSING HER, A WOMAN FROM JOHN
10:08:26:19RUETTENS PAST.
10:08:27:22Nels Rasmussen (Actor)
I think you should take the time to look into this woman.
10:08:30:19John Taylor
In those meetings, detective Mayer was always dismissive of Nels repeated requests that John Ruettens ex-girlfriend be investigated as a suspect.
10:08:43:10Lead Detective Lyle Mayer (Actor)
All due respect, I think you should leave the detective work to us.
10:08:46:17John Taylor
They told them to, sort of, butt out. The Rasmussens, at this point, felt scared.
10:08:54:17Aphrodite Jones
When Nels Rasmussen, the father, went to the police and had multiple things to say, the LAPD officers he was talking to said, You know what buddy, you go home, youve been watching too
10:09:04:18much TV.
10:09:06:12NARRATOR
DETECTIVES ALREADY THINK THEY HAVE A PRETTY GOOD IDEA OF WHAT HAPPENED.
10:09:10:24John Taylor
From the time that Sherri Rasmussen was murdered, the detectives, charged with solving the crime, very quickly concluded that the crime had been an interrupted burglary.
10:09:25:09NARRATOR
AND THEIR THEORY LOOKS LIKE IT WILL PAN OUT, BECAUSE A FEW WEEKS LATER, JUST THREE BLOCKS AWAY, THERES ANOTHER ARMED BURGLARY USING A 38
10:09:34:15CALIBER.
10:09:36:05
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:COMING UP
10:09:36:15NARRATOR
UP NEXT.
10:09:37:18Aphrodite Jones
I really was stunned.
10:09:40:06John Taylor
And the Los Angeles Police Department did absolutely nothing.
10:09:44:00
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:true
CRIME
WITH APHRODITE JONES
10:09:48:00END OF PART 1
CLOCK INFO:
NO CLOCK SCREEN
10:11:00:00PART 2
10:11:00:01GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:true
CRIME
WITH APHRODITE JONES
10:11:06:1110:11:13:03
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
NARRATOR
LOS ANGELES, A TOWN WITH MORE THAN ITS SHARE OF HEART-BREAKING STORIES, BUT THE 1986 MURDER OF SHERRI RASMUSSEN HAS TO BE ONE OF THE SADDEST.
10:11:16:19Aphrodite Jones
This was such a happy, newlywed couple. For that to be destroyed it's unfathomable.
10:11:24:14NARRATOR
BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AT THE CRIME SCENE, LEAD DETECTIVE LYLE MAYER CONCLUDES THAT SHERRI WAS KILLED IN THE COURSE OF A BURGLARY.
10:11:35:07NARRATOR
ATTORNEY MARK OVERLAND CAN SEE WHY MAYER CAME TO THIS CONCLUSION.
10:11:39:1210:11:39:12
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:MARK OVERLANDDefense attorney
Mark Overland
A very similar burglary occurred in a very similar condo complex.
10:11:47:04Aphrodite Jones
When you say similar burglary, what was similar?
10:11:49:17Mark Overland
There was stacked stereo equipment by the door leading to the garage. The victim had a 38 caliber revolver pointed at her. 38 caliber was a caliber that was used to kill Miss Rasmussen.
10:12:07:09NARRATOR
THE VICTIM OF THIS LATEST ARMED ROBBERY WAS ABLE TO GET AWAY AND BASED ON HER DESCRIPTION OF THE TWO MEN, INVESTIGATORS PUT TOGETHER A COMPOSITE SKETCH AND POST IT ALL OVER THE
10:12:18:23NEIGHBOURHOOD.
10:12:21:03NARRATOR
MAYER IS SURE THAT IF HE CAN FIND THESE TWO, HELL HAVE FOUND SHERRIS KILLERS AS WELL.
10:12:28:05Aphrodite Jones
Certainly when theres another burglary in the same area with the same MO. and the robbers have a gun in the victims face, now we can say, Jeez maybe it was a burglary.
10:12:40:04NARRATOR
BUT THE TWO MEN NEVER SURFACE AND AS WEEKS GO BY THE INVESTIGATION STALLS.
10:12:47:24NARRATOR
SHERRIS PARENTS EVENTUALLY LEAVE LOS ANGELES AND RETURN TO ARIZONA.
10:12:53:1310:12:58:00
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:JOHN TAYLORRasmussen family attorney
John Taylor
The Rasmussens felt that the LAPD wanted them to butt out. There was nothing more they could do.
10:13:01:21NARRATOR
ONE YEAR PASSES AND THEN ANOTHER WITH NO NEW LEADS. THE MURDER IS RELEGATED TO THE COLD CASE FILES AND IT WILL STAY COLD FOR ALMOST 20 YEARS.
10:13:19:08NARRATOR
IN THE 1990S THE VIOLENT CRIME RATE IN LOS ANGELES BEGINS TO DROP.
10:13:26:04NARRATOR
POLICE HAVE TIME TO RE-OPEN UNSOLVED CASES.
10:13:30:14NARRATOR
FINALLY, IN 2005 THE SHERRI RASMUSSEN MURDER CASE IS RE-OPENED, BECAUSE OF ONE PARTICULAR PIECE OF EVIDENCE IN THE CASE FILE.
10:13:39:1610:13:42:23
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:PAUL NUNEZDeputy district attorney
Aphrodite Jones
You have a bite. Saliva from that bite thats preserved since 1986.
10:13:44:14Paul Nunez
Yes.
10:13:45:18
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
10:13:46:00NARRATOR
IN 1986 THE SWAB OF SHERRIS WOUND WOULDNT HAVE TOLD DETECTIVES MUCH, BUT IN 2005 IT MIGHT TELL THEM EVERYTHING, BECAUSE IT HAS A SAMPLE OF THE KILLERS DNA.
10:13:58:22Paul Nunez
DNA, that was evidence that was not available to detective Mayer at the time.
10:14:02:22Aphrodite Jones
And then its tested in 2005.
10:14:05:07Paul Nunez
Yes.
10:14:06:01NARRATOR
DNA ANALYSIS OF THE SWAB DROPS A BOMBSHELL ON THE COLD CASE.
10:14:11:14NARRATOR
THE SAMPLE HAS A MIXTURE OF TWO GENETIC PROFILES. ONE MATCHES THE VICTIM AND THE OTHER THE PERSON WHO BIT HER AND THAT PROFILE BELONGS TO A WOMAN.
10:14:28:04Aphrodite Jones
The first time I heard female DNA was in a bit mark, I really was stunned.
10:14:40:03Paul Nunez
Once we saw that the DNA profile was of a female, and not of a male, it really took the investigators by surprise and so they started looking at the case freshly.
10:14:50:18NARRATOR
STILL NO SUSPECTS ARE IDENTIFIED, AND ACCORDING TO THEIR LAWYER, SHERRIS FAMILY GROWS FRUSTRATED.
10:14:57:12John Taylor
That information sat with the detectives for more than two years. The Los Angeles Police Department did absolutely nothing.
10:15:06:13NARRATOR
BUT APPARENTLY THEY DIDNT DO NOTHING.
10:15:10:00Paul Nunez
The handling detective thought, Okay, well they had looked at burglars; lets see if there was a male/female burglary team that was working at that time. He came up with absolutely nothing and that cold case detective had other cold cases that
10:15:25:01developed, so the triage of his work
10:15:28:11Aphrodite Jones
Kept this case
10:15:29:07Paul Nunez
kept this case
10:15:30:01Aphrodite Jones
at the bottom.
10:15:30:21Paul Nunez
behind.
10:15:33:22John Taylor
The detectives, who were responsible for investigating the cold case evidence from Sherri Rasmussens murder, sent it back to the Van Nuys Division as a closed case.
10:15:42:07NARRATOR
THE CASE FILE SITS IN STORAGE UNTIL 2009, WHICH IS WHEN VAN NUYS DETECTIVE JAMES NUTTALL DECIDES TO TAKE A LOOK AT IT.
10:15:51:03John Taylor
If it wasnt for detective Nuttall who, on his own, decided to look in a box that had been sealed for storage, then this crime would never have been solved.
10:16:01:08NARRATOR
THE UNUSUAL RESULT OF THE DNA ANALYSIS OF THE BITE MARK, POINTING TO A FEMALE KILLER, GRABS HIS ATTENTION. HE AND HIS TEAM GO BACK THROUGH THE ORIGINAL FILES AND COMPILE A LIST OF FIVE WOMEN
10:16:14:14WHO MIGHT HAVE HAD A MOTIVE FOR THE MURDER. THEY QUICKLY ELIMINATE SHERRIS MOTHER AND TWO SISTERS AND A DNA TEST RULES OUT A FOURTH WOMAN, A DISGRUNTLED EMPLOYEE AT THE HOSPITAL
10:16:25:04WHERE SHERRI WORKED. THAT LEAVES ONE NAME ON THE LIST, THE WOMAN NELS RASMUSSEN HAD ASKED DETECTIVES TO INVESTIGATE ALL THOSE YEARS AGO.
10:16:34:21John Taylor
For more than 25 years, Nels believed that Johns ex-girlfriend, whose name he didnt know, was a suspect. He had urged the LAPD to look into that to no avail.
10:16:47:12NARRATOR
BUT THERES A PROBLEM WITH THIS MYSTERIOUS EX, SUMMED UP IN DETECTIVE MAYERS ORIGINAL INVESTIGATION FILE.
10:16:55:05NARRATOR
JOHN RUETTEN CALLED. IT READS. VERIFIED: STEPHANIE LAZARUS, PO, WAS FORMER GIRLFRIEND. PO - POLICE OFFICER. THE REMAINING SUSPECT IS AN LAPD DETECTIVE.
10:17:09:19NARRATOR
UP NEXT.
10:17:10:24
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:COMING UP
10:17:11:05Aphrodite Jones
Whats truly unusual here is typically if a woman is scorned she will go after the man that shes angry at.
10:17:18:14Steven Lazarus
She says, Hes coming over and sleeping with me. If he is engaged with you, tell him to stay away.
10:17:24:00GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:trueCRIME
WITH APHRODITE JONES
10:17:28:00END OF PART 2
NO CLOCK SCREEN
10:18:00:00PART 3
10:18:00:01GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:TrueCRIME
WITH APHRODITE JONES
10:18:05:0810:18:07:14
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
NARRATOR
WHEN VAN NUYS DETECTIVE JAMES NUTTALL DIGS INTO THE CASE FILE OF SHERRI RASMUSSENS 23 YEAR OLD MURDER, HE COMES TO A STUNNING AND TERRIBLE
10:18:14:22CONCLUSION. IT LOOKS LIKE HIS BEST SUSPECT IS A LOS ANGELES POLICE OFFICER, A WOMAN NAMED STEPHANIE LAZARUS.
10:18:24:16Aphrodite Jones
Police dont like to take one of their own down.
10:18:27:08
10:18:29:19
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:PAUL NUNEZDeputy district attorney
Paul Nunez
They knew that it would create some professional disturbances within the department.
10:18:33:21NARRATOR
JUST WHO IS STEPHANIE LAZARUS AND WHAT WAS HER RELATIONSHIP TO JOHN RUETTEN AND HIS MURDERED WIFE. TO FIND OUT I SAT DOWN WITH STEPHANIES MOTHER, CAROL
10:18:44:08LAZARUS.
10:18:46:17NARRATOR
SHE AGREED TO TALK WITH ME, THOUGH SHE HAS NEVER SPOKEN BEFORE ON TELEVISION ABOUT HER DAUGHTER.
10:18:52:24Aphrodite Jones
How long were they involved, John and Steph?
10:18:56:2110:18:56:23
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:CAROL LAZARUSStephanie Lazarus mother
Carol Lazarus
She went into ULCA in 1978 and they met somewhere after that time. I know that they played tennis together, they were friends, they went out.
10:19:12:00
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
10:19:12:07Aphrodite Jones
So she was athletic.
10:19:13:14Carol Lazarus
Oh yes, she played organised softball with girls leagues.
10:19:17:04Aphrodite Jones
Was she a tomboy?
10:19:18:09Carol Lazarus
No, not really. Shes just really very athletic.
10:19:22:17NARRATOR
TURNS OUT STEPHANIE AND JOHN SHARE A LOVE OF SPORTS, ESPECIALLY BASKETBALL AND THEY FIND THEMSELVES SPENDING A LOT OF ONE ON ONE TIME TOGETHER.
10:19:32:20ACCORDING TO HER DIARY, STEPHANIE DEVELOPED STRONG FEELINGS FOR HER FRIEND, THOUGH HE DOESNT SEEM TO SEE HER THAT WAY, AT LEAST NOT AT FIRST, BUT
10:19:42:11AFTER COLLEGE THEIR RELATIONSHIP BECOMES SEXUAL. ACCORDING TO MUTUAL FRIENDS, JOHN SEES IT AS A FRIENDS WITH BENEFITS TYPE THING.
10:19:52:07Aphrodite Jones
He looked at Stephanie Lazarus as a sleeping partner, a sex buddy and
10:20:00:18Aphrodite Jones
unfortunately, women dont think that way about making love.
10:20:05:21NARRATOR
FOR STEPHANIE IT'S FAR MORE.
10:20:10:10Aphrodite Jones
She wanted to be his wife.
10:20:12:0310:20:12:13
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:MARK OVERLANDStephanie Lazarus defense attorney
Mark Overland
She did. Theres no question about that.
10:20:16:05Mark Overland
And that Stephanie thought that the relationship was going somewhere, whereas he apparently never intended it to go anywhere, but he never told her that.
10:20:28:23NARRATOR
THEIR CASUAL RELATIONSHIP CONTINUES ON AND OFF FOR YEARS. JOHN BECOMES A MECHANICAL ENGINEER AND IN 1983, STEPHANIE EMBARKS ON HER OWN CAREER
10:20:40:03WITH THE LAPD. IT ISNT WHAT HER YOUNGER BROTHER, STEVEN LAZARUS, WAS EXPECTING.
10:20:46:15
10:20:48:07
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:STEVEN LAZARUSStephanie Lazarus brother
Steven Lazarus
I do remember getting a phone call from her saying, Hey, I got accepted into LAPD Academy and was a bit of a surprise.
10:20:54:23Aphrodite Jones
Back in time, women that was kind of a, you know, still a shaky area if you will.
10:21:00:12Steven Lazarus
There wasnt a lot of women police officers.
10:21:05:14NARRATOR
STEPHANIE BUILDS A REPUTATION AS A SMART, CONSCIENTIOUS COP AND RISES STEADILY THROUGH THE RANKS.
10:21:14:10Aphrodite Jones
Was she a good cop?
10:21:15:21Steven Lazarus
She was a great cop.
10:21:18:18NARRATOR
PROFESSIONALLY, STEPHANIES LIFE IS ON TRACK, BUT ACCORDING TO A DIARY ENTRY IN JUNE OF 1985, SHE GETS SOME HEART-BREAKING NEWS.
10:21:28:06Stephanie Rasmussen (Actress) VO
I really didnt feel like working. I found out that John is getting married. I was very depressed. This is very bad.
10:21:37:02NARRATOR
SHE ALSO REVEALS HER FEELINGS TO JOHN RUETTENS MOTHER THAT AUGUST IN A LETTER.
10:21:43:06Stephanie Rasmussen (Actress) VO
Im truly in love with John and this past year has really torn me up. I dont think Ill ever understand Johns decision.
10:21:51:07NARRATOR
STILL STEPHANIE APPEARS TO REBOUND FROM HER DISAPPOINTMENT AND FOCUS ON HER CAREER.
10:21:57:15NARRATOR
SHE MAKES DETECTIVE IN 1993 AND THREE YEARS LATER SHE MARRIES A FELLOW POLICE OFFICER
10:22:06:11NARRATOR
AND ADOPTS A CHILD.
10:22:09:23NARRATOR
SHE THEN SPENDS OVER A YEAR WORKING IN THE INTERNAL AFFAIRS DIVISION, BEFORE LANDING A PLUM ASSIGNMENT WITH THE LAPDS ART THEFT UNIT. SHE HAS A
10:22:19:12REPUTATION FOR BEING UPBEAT AND GENEROUS.
10:22:22:2110:22:24:10
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:SUSAN MEYERLos Angeles Police Dept. (Ret.)
Susan Meyer
Stephanie was a really hard worker. She always sort of that bubbly, cheerful personality. She was always willing to go the extra mile to get the job done. She put others before herself.
10:22:35:12Aphrodite Jones
Is there something that you want people to know about Stephanie?
10:22:38:00Carol Lazarus
Anyone that knows her knows that shes not a mean, spiteful person. Shes a very caring, giving, compassionate person. I know that, her family knows that, her friends know that.
10:22:53:12NARRATOR
AS HE READS THROUGH STEPHANIES IMPRESSIVE RESUME, DETECTIVE NUTALL REALISES HE WILL HAVE TO TREAD CAREFULLY. CLEARLY, SHE IS WELL
10:23:01:16RESPECTED AND WELL LOVED IN THE DEPARTMENT, BUT HE CANT IGNORE THE FEMALE DNA SAMPLE TAKEN FROM SHERRIS BITE WOUND. STEPHANIE LAZARUS MUST BE
10:23:11:13CONSIDERED A SUSPECT.
10:23:15:23NARRATOR
BEFORE APPROACHING HER DIRECTLY, NUTTALL DECIDES TO TALK OVER HIS SUSPICIONS WITH SHERRIS FATHER, NELS RASMUSSEN.
10:23:24:10Aphrodite Jones
Nels Rasmussen, Sherris father, played an immense role in this case. He knew his daughter had been stalked by this woman.
10:23:33:16NARRATOR
SHERRIS FATHER REVEALS THAT JUST WEEKS BEFORE THE MURDER, HIS DAUGHTER TOLD HIM ABOUT STEPHANIE LAZARUS. APPARENTLY, STEPHANIE HAD PAID A VISIT
10:23:43:05TO SHERRIS OFFICE AT THE GLENDALE AVENTIST MEDICAL CENTER.
10:23:48:01Sherri Rasmussen (Actress)
Come in.
10:23:48:09NARRATOR
ACCORDING TO NELS, HIS DAUGHTER WAS INTIMIDATED BY THE UNEXPECTED VISIT.
10:23:52:07Stephanie Lazarus (Actress)
I need to talk to you about John.
10:23:54:12NARRATOR
AND FELT THREATENED.
10:23:55:21Sherri Rasmussen (Actress)
What about John?
10:23:56:23NARRATOR
STEPHANIE WAS THERE TO INFORM HER THAT HER FIANC JOHN HAD DROPPED BY RECENTLY.
10:24:02:00Stephanie Lazarus (Actress)
He came to my place last week.
10:24:04:16NARRATOR
HE HAD SAID HE WAS THERE TO BREAK THINGS OFF FOR GOOD, BUT APPARENTLY OLD HABITS DIED HARD.
10:24:12:13Stephanie Lazarus (Actress)
We made love.
10:24:15:23Aphrodite Jones
Whats truly unusual here is typically if a woman is scorned she will go after the man that shes angry at, but in this case, what does she do? She decides to confront Sherri.
10:24:33:09Aphrodite Jones
Stephanie went where Sherri works and confronted her and said, Im sleeping with John. There was an altercation there. No?
10:24:40:10Steven Lazarus
No, I dont think thats accurate. I think she says, Hes coming over and sleeping me. If he is engaged with you, tell him to stay away, cause hes not staying away from me.
10:24:51:09NARRATOR
WAS STEPHANIE SIMPLY TELLING HER RIVAL AN UNPLEASANT TRUTH, OR DID SHE THREATEN SHERRI AS NELS BELIEVES. THE CONVERSATION ALONE CANT REALLY PROVE
10:25:02:0510:25:05:17
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
ANYTHING. WHAT DETECTIVES NEED IS PHYSICAL EVIDENCE [GUN SHOTS] THAT POINTS TO STEPHANIE LAZARUS.
10:25:10:23NARRATOR
AS STEPHANIES MOTHER POINTS OUT, THERE DOESNT SEEM TO BE ANY PHYSICAL EVIDENCE TYING HER TO THE MURDER.
10:25:17:17Carol Lazarus
No blood, no fibres, no hair. None of the bloody fingerprints, palm prints on the wall anywhere, have any evidence of it being from Stephanie Lazarus.
10:25:30:10Aphrodite Jones
So shed have to be the master crime master to not leave anything there.
10:25:35:15Carol Lazarus
Exactly.
10:25:38:08NARRATOR
BUT THE KILLER DID LEAVE BEHIND SOME EVIDENCE INSIDE SHERRIS BODY, BULLETS THAT HAVE A DISTINCTIVE MARKING, OR HOOK ON THEM.
10:25:48:1410:25:52:05
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:SHANNON PRESBYDeputy district attorney
Shannon Presby
These were LAPD bullets. The only bullets that LAPD officers could use at the time of the murder.
10:25:56:01Steven Lazarus
And anybody who says that, including the DA and Shannon Presby, theyre lying.
10:26:02:10NARRATOR
STEPHANIES BROTHER INSISTS THAT JUST BECAUSE THEY WERE THE TYPE OF BULLETS USED BY LAPD, DOESNT MEAN POLICE WERE THE ONLY ONES USING THEM.
10:26:11:19Aphrodite Jones
The hook in the bullet
10:26:13:08Steven Lazarus
Okay, but Aphrodite.
10:26:13:23Aphrodite Jones
matches the type of bullet that was matching the gun.
10:26:17:17Steven Lazarus
But its the identical bullet that was sold to the general public. Youre talking about hundreds of millions of bullets. Youre wrong, Im sorry, Im not trying to be argumentative with you, but youre
10:26:28:17wrong.
10:26:28:13Aphrodite Jones
No I welcome your argument.
10:26:30:00Steven Lazarus
Youre wrong!
10:26:31:00Aphrodite Jones
I welcome your argument.
10:26:31:16Steven Lazarus
Im just telling you, your wrong.
10:26:34:01NARRATOR
BUT ITS NOT JUST ABOUT THE BULLETS; ITS ALSO ABOUT THE GUN THAT SHOT THEM. THE MURDER WEAPON WAS A 38 CALIBER REVOLVER WITH AN USUALLY SHORT
10:26:43:15BARREL.
10:26:44:12Shannon Presby
Sherri Rasmussen was murdered by a gun that had a two inch barrel. That was conclusively established by the barrel cylinder gap residue that was left on the blanket that was used to muffle the firearm.
10:27:00:01NARRATOR
IN 1986 STEPHANIE LAZARUS MAIN SERVICE WEAPON IS A LONG BARREL 38 SPECIAL - NO MATCH, BUT HER BACK UP GUN IS A 38 CALIBER SNUB NOSE REVOLVER, EXACTLY
10:27:13:06THE SAME KIND OF GUN THAT WAS USED TO MURDER SHERRI RASMUSSEN.
10:27:17:20
Shannon Presby
Her Smith and Wesson had a five shot capacity. There were five shots fired during the course of this murder and the wound on Sherris eye matched the physical characteristics of the barrel of that gun
10:27:32:18exactly.
10:27:34:07Aphrodite Jones
But theres the gun, by the way.
10:27:35:15Steven Lazarus
Wheres the gun?
10:27:37:15Aphrodite Jones
Thats a good question.
10:27:41:05NARRATOR
THE THING IS, INVESTIGATORS CANT USE BALLISTICS TO MATCH STEPHANIES WEAPON TO THE BULLETS RECOVERED FROM THE SCENE, BECAUSE TWO WEEKS AFTER THE
10:27:50:09MURDER SHE REPORTED IT STOLEN. SHE CLAIMS SOMEONE HAD SNATCHED THE GUN OUT OF HER CAR.
10:27:56:11Shannon Presby
It is incredibly suspicious that a gun that matched the murder weapon in every respect disappeared shortly after the murder.
10:28:04:04Aphrodite Jones
For me, the fact that she reported that gun missing, stolen, two weeks after the murder, is highly problematic.
10:28:13:11Mark Overland
When you report a gun stolen its to do it as an alibi that you dont have that gun at the time of the killing, therefore, it couldnt have been you. Reporting it stolen two weeks after doesnt help you, you still had
10:28:25:14it at the time of the killing.
10:28:28:00Aphrodite Jones
The murder weapon matches the issued gun by the LAPD to your sister.
10:28:32:09Steven Lazarus
It doesnt match it. You tell me how it matches. It doesnt exist. How can you say it matches? Come on report
10:28:37:12Aphrodite Jones
Because she reported it missing!
10:28:41:06Aphrodite Jones
What a coincidence that Stephanie happened to have her gun stolen two weeks after the murder. Where is that gun? [GUN SHOTS] I dont know, probably at the bottom of the pacific ocean.
10:28:51:20NARRATOR
THERES LITTLE CHANCE THAT GUN WILL EVER BE FOUND. STILL, DETECTIVE NUTTALLS TEAM CAN FOLLOW UP ON THE CASES MOST IMPORTANT PIECE OF EVIDENCE
10:29:02:10- THE SWAB TAKEN FROM THE BITE MARK ON SHERRIS ARM. TO DETERMINE IF THAT UNKNOWN FEMALE DNA BELONGS TO STEPHANIE LAZARUS
10:29:12:11NARRATOR
THEY HAVE TO GET A SAMPLE FROM HER WITHOUT TIPPING HER OFF.
10:29:19:09NARRATOR
NOT SO EASY.
10:29:21:04Aphrodite Jones
As I understand it, police had a surveillance team out on Stephanie.
10:29:26:10Paul Nunez
They saw her drink from a cup, use a straw
10:29:30:20Paul Nunez
and then they saw her put it in the trash can.
10:29:41:05NARRATOR
DETECTIVES IMMEDIATELY PICK IT UP AND BRING IT BACK TO THE DNA LAB FOR ANALYSIS.
10:29:50:13Aphrodite Jones
And it matched Stephanie Lazarus.
10:29:53:09Paul Nunez
That DNA that was on that cup matched the profile.
10:29:57:20NARRATOR
WITH THIS TEST RESULT, NUTTALL SENDS THE CASE OVER TO THE LAPDS ROBBERY HOMICIDE DIVISION. ITS A SENSITIVE, POTENTIALLY EXPLOSIVE SITUATION, THEY
10:30:08:11SHOULD BE THE ONES TO QUESTION ONE OF THEIR OWN.
10:30:11:11Aphrodite Jones
They had a DNA sample that matched Stephanies DNA, so now they had to fill in the pieces of the puzzle.
10:30:21:18NARRATOR
LAPD DETECTIVES ARRANGE TO INTERVIEW STEPHANIE IN THE SAME BUILDING WHERE SHE WORKS, THE PARKER CENTER. THEY DONT TELL HER THEYRE WORKING ON A
10:30:30:22MURDER CASE.
10:30:32:04
10:30:35:19
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:ACTUAL INTERROGATION FOOTAGEShannon Presby
When Stephanie Lazarus was brought into that interrogation room, she believed that she was there to talk about an art theft and then they slowly began to talk about her relationship to John Ruetten.
10:30:46:20LAPD Detective (Archive)
Do you know John Ruetten?
10:30:48:19Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
John Ruetten? John Ruetten?
10:30:52:13LAPD Detective (Archive)
Ruetten.
10:30:53:14Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
Oh yeah, I went to school with him.
10:30:54:19LAPD Detective (Archive)
You did?
10:30:55:07Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
Yeah.
10:30:56:03LAPD Detective (Archive)
Were you guys friends, close friends?
10:30:57:14Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
Yeah, we were very close friends. I mean, tell me whats this all about?
10:31:00:24Paul Nunez
She wasnt under arrest. She sat down voluntarily to speak with the investigators.
10:31:07:12Aphrodite Jones
But it wasnt voluntary, it was a trap. She sits down and suddenly the detectives are saying to her, Do you know who John Ruetten is?
10:31:16:21Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
You know, I dont It was kind of a weird relationship. I mean, we dated. Um, I cant say that he was my boyfriend. I dont know that he considered me his girlfriend. Um, we just, you know,
10:31:30:19it just didnt work out. I mean, I dont know what to tell you. It was, like, I went out with other guys.
10:31:36:15Aphrodite Jones
She thought, well perhaps theyre solving this old case and, since I was mentioned in the case file, they think that I might know something about it.
10:31:44:15Paul Nunez
The detectives did a brilliant job of keeping her guessing in that interview, acting as if they didnt know very much about the case.
10:31:54:01NARRATOR
DETECTIVES QUESTIONED STEPHANIE FOR OVER AN HOUR.
10:31:56:18Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
Its about nine now.
10:31:57:17LAPD Detective (Archive)
Had you ever met his wife?
10:32:00:06Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
I may have.
10:32:01:12LAPD Detective (Archive)
Do you know do you remember her name or anything?
10:32:09:14Aphrodite Jones
She pretended like she didnt remember Sherris name.
10:32:13:14Paul Nunez
Yes.
10:32:14:24Aphrodite Jones
Lets put this in perspective here for normal people. If someone asks you about somebody who was your teen rival from high school, you know that persons name, but she was casually, Oh I dont know
10:32:26:05what cant remember the name.
10:32:27:16Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
Shelly, Sherri. Something maybe like, you know, like I said its been so many years and
10:32:37:20LAPD Detective (Archive)
From all the years, as far as you can remember, do you remember ever talking to her?
10:32:42:03Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
Well, its just I said earlier, you know, I mean, I may have. You know, I may have talked to her.
10:32:49:09NARRATOR
EVENTUALLY SHE REMEMBERS CONFRONTING SHERRI AT THE HOSPITAL.
10:32:54:04Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
The conversion lasted a few minutes. I cant even remember. It wasnt like we went out to lunch, or anything.
10:32:59:22LAPD Detective (Archive)
Right, but there was no, like, arguments or fights, or it didnt get heated or anything like that?
10:33:02:07Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
I dont think so. Not that I recall, no. I mean, I couldve said, Okay, well if hes dating you, he keeps calling me. Why dont you tell him to knock it off or whatever
10:33:13:18Aphrodite Jones
It was like watching them paint her into a corner.
10:33:17:16Aphrodite Jones
And you could see her, you know, start to twitch almost.
10:33:21:08Paul Nunez
Shes probably thinking in her head, am I giving background information to these detectives, or am I under suspicion and you can see her figuring all of that out whilst shes talking to these investigators.
10:33:33:00NARRATOR
FINALLY, STEPHANIE DOES FIGURE IT OUT.
10:33:38:00LAPD Detective (Archive)
So you, off hand, you dont recall ever going into her house and having words and physically, you know
10:33:44:17Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
No.
10:33:45:04LAPD Detective (Archive)
attacking her, her attacking you.
10:33:47:13Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
No.
10:33:48:00LAPD Detective (Archive)
Nothing like that?
10:33:48:17Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
No. I mean, thats no. If youre doing this as an interrogation, youre saying, Hey, Im a suspect, well, now I got a problem with, you know, now youre accusing me of this. Is that what youre saying?
10:34:01:02LAPD Detective (Archive)
Were trying to figure out what happened Stephanie.
10:34:03:23Shannon Presby
At any point in that interview she couldve said, this interviews over, Im leaving, but she chose not to do that. Was that a mistake on her part? Maybe it was a tactical mistake on her part.
10:34:15:08Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
Ive been doing this a long time.
10:34:16:15LAPD Detective (Archive)
Yeah we know.
10:34:17:03Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
Okay and now I know it sounds like youre trying to pin something on me.
10:34:20:16LAPD Detective (Archive)
No.
10:34:20:19Stephanie Lazarus (Archive)
Now I got that sense.
10:34:22:06
NARRATOR
Several of Stephanies LAPD collEAGUES SEE NOTHING UNUSUAL ABOUT HER RESPONSES IN THE INTERROGATION.
10:34:28:23Susan MeyerI didnt see anything wrong with that interview. I thought she looked good and she looked like someone who was pretty much caught off guard and not understand what was going on.
10:34:39:00Sherri Rasmussen (Archive)
Its not ringing a bell.
10:34:40:08Aphrodite Jones
Shes doe-eyed. To me, she looks like a rat in a trap.
10:34:47:09Sherri Rasmussen (Archive)
I mean, I dont know what else to tell you.
10:34:49:16LAPD Detective (Archive)
Okay. Thanks for your time.
10:34:51:10NARRATOR
WHEN STEPHANIE LAZARUS LEAVES THE INTERROGATION ROOM, SHE IS IMMEDIATELY ARRESTED. TWO MINUTES LATER SHE RETURNS IN HANDCUFFS.
10:35:03:06LAPD Detective (Archive)
Stephanie, you know you have the right to remain silent. Do you understand?
10:35:05:19Sherri Rasmussen (Archive)
Yes.
10:35:06:24LAPD Detective (Archive)
Anything you say may be used against you in court. Do you understand?
10:35:09:15Sherri Rasmussen (Archive)
Yes.
10:35:10:12LAPD Detective (Archive)
You have the right to the presence of an attorney before and during
10:35:13:01
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:COMING UP
10:35:13:18NARRATOR
UP NEXT.
10:35:14:17Shannon Presby
We told this jury that the evidence in this case consisted of a bite, a bullet, a gun barrel and a broken heart.
10:35:24:00GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:trueCRIME
WITH APHRODITE JONES
10:35:28:00END OF PART 3
CLOCK INFO:
NO CLOCK SCREEN
10:36:00:00PART 4
10:36:00:01
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:true
CRIME
WITH APHRODITE JONES
10:36:05:07NARRATOR
ON JUNE 5TH 2009 VETERAN LAPD DETECTIVE, STEPHANIE LAZARUS IS ARRESTED FOR THE MURDER OF SHERRI RASMUSSEN.
10:36:15:12Aphrodite Jones
This murder case was buried for 17 years. The great thing is that theres no Statute of Limitation on murders and the truth does come out.
10:36:24:16NARRATOR
THREE DAYS LATER SHES CHARGED WITH CAPITAL MURDER. IF CONVICTED, SHE FACES THE DEATH PENALTY.
10:36:32:1110:36:32:23
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:JUNE 5,2009
WILLIAM BRATTONChief, Los Angeles Police Dept.
William Bratton (Archive)
The investigation revealed that she had had a previous relationship with the victims husband prior to the murder.
10:36:39:18Aphrodite Jones
When you first heard of your sisters arrest what was your reaction?
10:36:43:2410:36:44:08
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:STEVEN LAZARUSStephanie Lazarus brother
Steven Lazarus
If I sit here and think about it too strongly, Ill breakdown because, you know, its horrific. I mean, Steph is just this wonderful person. Sitting there in an orange jumpsuit it wasnt registering. And she,
10:36:57:14honestly, did not know what was going on.
10:37:00:17NARRATOR
THE COURT SETS A STAGGERING AMOUNT FOR HER BAIL - $10,000,000.00. HER FAMILY CRIES FOUL.
10:37:08:09Steven Lazarus
You can take a Phil Spector or a Robert Blake, those people are pretty wealthy both of those guys were charged with a similar crime. Both of those individuals had $1,000,000.00 bail set in their case.
10:37:21:1610:37:23:15
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:SHANNON PRESBYDeputy district attorney
Shannon Presby
Reasonable bail is not necessarily bail that a Defendant can meet; it is bail that will assure their appearance at trial. If you have DNA that shows theres no other person on this planet that couldve
10:37:38:06committed this crime, if it were me in your position, I would run.
10:37:44:17Aphrodite Jones
So why did they set such a high bail?
10:37:47:06Carol Lazarus
I think that they didnt wanna her out.
10:37:49:12Aphrodite Jones
Why didnt they want her out?
10:37:50:1610:37:51:22
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:CAROL LAZARUSStephanie Lazarus mother
Carol Lazarus
Because she is probably, without a doubt, the best investigator that department has ever had and if she was out, she couldve worked with the team to investigate the whole crime.
10:38:07:16Aphrodite Jones
Stephanies family, my heart bleeds for them, because they truly wanna believe that she is not guilty and I get that. You never wanna think somebody, one of your own, is guilty of something
10:38:18:17so horrible.
10:38:23:20NARRATOR
IN FEBRUARY 2012, THE TRIAL OF STEPHANIE LAZARUS BEGINS. THE STAR WITNESS FOR THE PROSECUTION, STEPHANIES OWN DNA.
10:38:34:2410:38:38:01
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:ADALBERTO LUPERPrivate investigator for the defense
Adalberto Luper
I already knew what the prosecution would ultimately trying to show in trial, which was the DNA and the DNA evidence, whether its 17 sextillion, or whatever, makes it very difficult to overcome no
10:38:52:09matter what avenues you go.
10:38:55:08Paul Nunez
An analyst took a reference sample from her mouth that matched four hundred and two quadrillion to one.
10:39:01:10Aphrodite Jones
Four hundred and two quadrillion to one.
10:39:03:22Paul Nunez
Four hundred and two quadrillion to one.
10:39:06:01Aphrodite Jones
I dont know what quadrillion is, but I think that means shes the only person who couldve possibly done this.
10:39:10:11NARRATOR
BUT AT THE TRIAL, DEFENSE ATTORNEY MARK OVERLAND POINTS OUT THAT THE ENVELOPE CONTAINING THE ORIGINAL SAMPLE FROM THE CRIME SCENE WAS FOUND
10:39:18:02RIPPED OPEN, THE TUBE STICKING OUT.
10:39:21:16Adalberto Luper
When they discover it in the coroners office, he found the vial, the envelopes are torn, vials up above the torn portion and theres no seal on it, so it comes the argument becomes, well, that it was
10:39:39:16tampered with, so that was a gaff.
10:39:44:0610:39:49:05
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:SUSAN MEYER
Los Angeles Police Dept. (Ret.)
Susan Meyer
The chain of evidence was broken. Obviously, that envelope has been tampered with. You can never convince me that that DNA was collected at the scene of the crime.
10:39:54:24Aphrodite Jones
Are you suggesting that somebody actually put your sisters DNA into that tube?
10:40:00:12Steven Lazarus
I mean, is there any question that Im suggesting that? Thats exactly what Im suggesting.
10:40:05:24Aphrodite Jones
Why would somebody do that?
10:40:08:23Steven Lazarus
She had officers fired. She did other things that resulted in officers being punished criminally.
10:40:17:09NARRATOR
STEPHANIE ONCE WORKED IN THE INTERNAL AFFAIRS DIVISION INVESTIGATING FELLOW POLICE OFFICERS. ITS QUITE POSSIBLE SHE MADE ENEMIES.
10:40:26:09Steven Lazarus
Is it really that much of a stretch to say, could someone be so vindictive to go after somebody.
10:40:34:03Aphrodite Jones
If there was a disgruntled co-worker in the LAPD who had it in for Stephanie Lazarus, is it possible to take her DNA and add it to an old test-tube?
10:40:47:04Paul Nunez
Absolutely not. You have Sherris DNA, right, cause its her skin, then you also have the saliva of the biter, the suspect.
10:40:56:19Aphrodite Jones
You cant tamper with that and add to that later?
10:40:59:14Paul Nunez
Its just like adding anything, if you have two profiles and you add a profile, youre gonna have a third profile and it would not have made any sense.
10:41:09:06Aphrodite Jones
I really grappled with the idea that theres a possibility that someone could have tampered with this evidence. That theres a possibility that Stephanie Lazarus couldve been framed, but the
10:41:21:01DNA evidence ultimately brings us to two people, Sherri Rasmussen and Stephanie Lazarus as being the only two people that were there at the time of this murder and I dont see any way around it.
10:41:36:23NARRATOR
DURING THE TRIAL PROSECUTORS LAY OUT WHAT THEY THINK REALLY HAPPENED IN UNIT 205 ON FEBRUARY 24TH 1986. SOME TIME AFTER HER HUSBAND LEFT FOR WORK
10:41:48:03Sherri Rasmussen (Actress)
Honey?
10:41:48:0910:41:48:16
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
NARRATOR
SHERRI RASMUSSEN WAS SURPRISED
10:41:51:00Sherri Rasmussen (Actress)
Honey?
10:41:51:14NARRATOR
NOT BY TWO BURGLARS
10:41:54:03Sherri Rasmussen (Actress)
What are you doing in my house?
10:41:55:14NARRATOR
BUT BY STEPHANIE LAZARUS.
10:41:57:17Shannon Presby
Did she intend to kill Sherri when she came in that day? Was she intending to confront her and then things got out of control? Those are questions for which there are no answers.
10:42:09:17Adalberto Luper
I think that she went over to see Sherri
10:42:12:07Sherri Rasmussen (Actress)Why are you here?
10:42:13:09Adalberto Luper
knew that Sherri was ill, knew that she was gonna give it one more try
10:42:22:19Adalberto Luper
one more confrontation, woman to woman kind of a thing, that got outta hand. I think that
Stephanie didnt realise how combative Sherri would become.
10:42:39:09
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
10:42:40:20NARRATOR
THE TWO WOMEN HAD A PROLONGED STRUGGLE.
10:42:48:10NARRATOR
THEN, AT SOME POINT, STEPHANIE DREW HER GUN.
10:42:52:0910:42:55:22
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
Shannon Presby
Sherri tried to move the gun away from her, probably grabs Stephanies right arm. At that point the Defendant bit Sherri on the left inner forearm and that bite, likely, is what made Sherri let go of the gun.
10:43:13:02NARRATOR
SHERRI STRUGGLED TO GET AWAY, BUT STEPHANIE DRAGGED HER BACK.
10:43:17:21Shannon Presby
It was at that point that she was struck in the face with this heavy, ceramic vase.
10:43:23:04
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
10:43:25:19NARRATOR
THE BLOW, LIKELY, STUNNED SHERRI ALMOST TO THE POINT OF UNCONSCIOUSNESS.
10:43:30:10Shannon Presby
We know that Sherri is lying now on the carpeted living room area and we know, essentially, that she is unable to resist. The Defendant had time to find a blanket, wrap her firearm in a blanket, point it at
10:43:48:12Sherris chest and fire three times. [GUN SHOTS].
10:43:51:08
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:Reconstruction
10:43:57:24NARRATOR
AS FOR THE BURGLARY SUGGESTED BY THE ORIGINAL LEAD DETECTIVE ON THE SCENE, IT WAS FAKED BY A KILLER WHO KNEW HOW TO STAGE A CRIME SCENE.
10:44:07:04Shannon Presby
As a police officer she knows she gonna be a prime suspect. She had a relationship with Sherris husband, so in order to mislead the original investigators, she took two stereo components and
10:44:22:20placed them at the base of the stairs and she took a drawer from an end table and spilled its contents onto the floor in an effort to make this look like an interrupted burglary.
10:44:46:01NARRATOR
ON MARCH 7TH 2012, MORE THAN 26 YEARS AFTER THE KILLING
10:44:51:08Jury Foreperson
We the jury find the Defendant, Stephanie
10:44:53:20NARRATOR
STEPHANIE LAZARUS
10:44:55:02Jury Foreperson guilty
10:44:55:20NARRATOR
IS CONVICTED OF THE FIRST DEGREE MURDER OF SHERRI RASMUSSEN. THE JUDGE SENTENCES HER TO 27 YEARS TO LIFE IN PRISON. IF STEPHANIE LAZARUS WAS A
10:45:07:08DECENT, COMPASSIONATE PERSON FOR MOST OF HER LIFE, THAT DOESNT MAKE HER INCAPABLE OF MURDER.
10:45:14:00Shannon Presby
The line dividing good and evil runs through the heart of every human being.
10:45:19:13NARRATOR
AS FOR THE MAN WHO BROUGHT SHERRI AND STEPHANIE TOGETHER, JOHN RUETTEN, HE IS CONSPICUOUSLY ABSENT FROM THE TRIAL.
10:45:28:16Aphrodite Jones
The fact that he did not want to be present at the trial to see justice done, why is that? Because he feels guilty. He cant stand it and he said so himself, in as much, in his victims impact statement.
10:45:44:1410:45:45:12
GRAPHICS ON SCREEN:FROM JOHN RUETTENS TESTIMONY
John Ruetten (Actor) VO
The fact that Sherris death occurred because she met and married me brings me to my knees. I do not know, and fear I will never know, how to cope with this appalling fact.
10:46:00:18
NARRATOR
THE MIND IS A STRANGE PLACE. STEPHANIE LAZARUS WAS ABLE TO COMMIT A HORRIFIC ACT OF VIOLENCE
10:46:08:16NARRATOR
AND THEN LOCK IT AWAY SOMEWHERE DEEP. IT SEEMS SHE JUST FORGOT ABOUT IT. SHE WENT ON TO HAVE A LIFE, A CAREER AND RAISE A FAMILY. SHERRI RASMUSSEN DIDNT
10:46:20:07HAVE THAT OPTION, BUT IN THE END, SPEAKING FROM THE GRAVE, SHE BROUGHT HER KILLER TO JUSTICE.
10:46:31:13
END CREDITS (rolling over dialogue):
HostAPHRODITE JONES
Executive Producer
LLOYD FALES
Co-Executive Producer
APHRODITE JONES
Series Producer
BRUCE KENNEDY
Producer
PAUL SPILLENGER
Editors
ALESSANDRO BARNETT
DAVID KIRKMAN
MARION DELARCHE
Associate Producer
KATE WALKER
Director of Photography
AJ RICKERT-EPSTEIN
Sound Recordist
JENNIFER RICCIARDI
Line Producer
ROBYN ALCOCK
Technical Operations Manager
JONATHAN DAMOUR
Post Production Supervisor
BRANDT GASSMAN
Assistant Editors
GINA GIRODIER
DAVID SCORCA
Production Assistants
KEVIN WALTERS
AARON EPSTEIN
DANI HIRAVY
Casting Director
ERIN BROWNE
Graphic Designers
DISCOVERY CREATIVE
Post Production Facility
TECHNICOLOR/POSTWORKS
Online Editor
SEAN R. SMITH
Assistant Online Editor
MICHELLE CHERIPKA
Audio Mixer
JARED SEIDMAN
Archival Footage
DATELINE NBC
DISCOVERY ACCESS
NBC NEWS ARCHIVES
Executive Producer
KNUTE WALKER
Executive Producer
BENJAMIN RINGE
Executive-in-Charge of Production
SHARON SCOTT
For Investigation Discovery
Executive Producer
EUGENIE VINK
For Investigation Discovery
Producer
KEILA WOODARD
For Investigation Discovery
Senior Vice President of Production
SARA KOZAK
For Investigation Discovery
President and General Manager
HENRY SCHLEIFF
Produced by Peacock Productions
for Investigation Discovery
MMXII DISCOVERY COMMUNICATIONS, LLC