Trouble Shooting for Turbine
Transcript of Trouble Shooting for Turbine
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
1/57
TROUBLE SHOOTINGTROUBLE SHOOTING
FORFOR
STEAM TURBINESTEAM TURBINE
MHI TURBO TECHNO CO.MHI TURBO TECHNO CO.HIROSHIMAHIROSHIMA
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
2/57
INDEX
1. GENERAL
2. VIBRATION3. UNUSUAL SOUND
4. BEARING TEMPERATURE
5. TROUBLE ON GOVERNOR
6. BOILER CARRY OVER
7. VACUUM FAILURE
8. OTHERS
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
3/57
1.1. GENERALGENERAL
I t is most important to keep the continuous operation without troubleobserving the operating conditions@carefully.
This text describes the possible causes and the necessary check and handlingitems for the unusual operating conditions.
Emergency shut down may be required in worst cases due to the serioustrouble, however causes of the unusual condition shall be investigatedduring operation and the countermeasures shall be taken to avoid shut downand / or to minimize shut down duration.
Usually, one trouble causes another troubles to damage the unit seriously,
the investigation of the prime cause is the most important things to find out.
Troubles as described hereafter can be avoided if appropriatecountermeasures are taken, therefore daily maintenance and care for theunit are fully recommended.
In case that the cause of trouble is not confirmed and that thecountermeasure requires some engineering and technical information and /
or skill, it is recommended to contact toMHI TUR O TECHNO CO
HI TUR O TECHNO CO..
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
4/57
2.2. UNUSUAL VIBRATIONUNUSUAL VIBRATION
PHENOMENON 1 No indication of
vibration monitor
POSSIBLE CAUSE Monitor failure
Probe failure Wire failure
Driver failure
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
5/57
By pass the monitor Check the vibration monitor
Check gap voltage of the probe Check the wiring
Check the driver
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
6/57
2.2. UNUSUAL VIBRATIONUNUSUAL VIBRATION
PHENOMENON 2 Excess vibration on NC1
during start up.
POSSIBLE CAUSE Thermal deformation by
steam introductionwithout turning of therotor
Turning duration is tooshort
Long term storage athorizontal condition
NC1
Speed(RPM)
Am
plitude
N
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
7/57
Speed down keep around 300rpm as long as possible
Retry to speed up If the vibration level dose not reduced,
rebalancing of the rotor would berequired
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
8/57
2.2. UNUSUAL VIBRATIONUNUSUAL VIBRATION
PHENOMENON 3 Shaft vibration is
increased correspondingto speed up in governorspeed range
POSSIBLE CAUSE Gear coupling lock
Miss-alignment
NC1
Speed(RPM)
Gov. range
Amplitude
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
9/57
Continue operation monitoring thevibration
Lower lube oil supply temperature Make frequency analysis
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
10/57
2.2. UNUSUAL VIBRATIONUNUSUAL VIBRATION
PHENOMENON 4 Shaft vibration is
increased gradually andbearing metaltemperature is alsoconstantly high.
POSSIBLE CAUSE Over heat of bearing
and increasing bearingclearance
Lube oil property isfailed
Time
Amplitude
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
11/57
Lower lube oil supply temperature Watch drain oil temperature of bearings
carefully Analyze lube oil property
Decrease speed if the vibration levelreaches at alarm point
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
12/57
2.2. UNUSUAL VIBRATIONUNUSUAL VIBRATION
PHENOMENON 5 Shaft vibration is
increased suddenly andcontinued the amplitudeat same level
POSSIBLE CAUSE Failure of shaft
A part of shaft is blewoff
Time
Amplitude
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
13/57
Check history of vibration Make frequency analysis
Check phase of vibration
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
14/57
2.2. UNUSUAL VIBRATIONUNUSUAL VIBRATION
PHENOMENON 6 Shaft vibration is
increased and after awhile it is decreasedperiodically
POSSIBLE CAUSE Light rubbing of rotor
with stationary parts Heavy rubbing of rotor
with stationary parts bymovement of the lower
half case
Time
Amplitude
Cyclic
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
15/57
Make frequency analysis Check phase
Check thermal expansion of case Monitor bearing metal temperature
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
16/57
3.3. UNUSUAL SOUNDUNUSUAL SOUND
PHENOMENON 1 Light noise
continuously Heavy noise
continuously
Noise discontinuously
POSSIBLE CAUSE Contact with internal
labyrinth Contact with nozzles
- Contact with foreignmaterial
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
17/57
Monitoring with sound detecting rodand keep your eye on the vibrationmonitor, try to increase speed
If the noise and/or vibration is notreduced, shutdown the unit and
overhaul the case
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
18/57
3.3. UNUSUAL SOUNDUNUSUAL SOUND
PHENOMENON 2 Noise from Governor
side bearing pedestal
POSSIBLE CAUSE Failure of Governor
driving gear Failure of tripping lever
for emergency tripdevice
Loosening of internal oilpipe if provided
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
19/57
Analyze frequency of the noise If the noise and/or vibration is not
reduced, shutdown the unit andoverhaul the bearing pedestal
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
20/57
3.3. UNUSUAL SOUNDUNUSUAL SOUND
PHENOMENON 3 Noise from valve chest
during throttling or atfully opening
POSSIBLE CAUSE The valve body is
vibrating by steamstream at small opening
Failure of valve body,stem, seat etc.
Plugging by foreignmaterial
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
21/57
Passing quickly through this valveopening
Check steam pressure, temperature,flow and lift to compare with expecteddata
If the steam consumption is extremelyhigh, the unit would be shutdown torectify the problem in the valve
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
22/57
4.4. BEARING TEMPERATUREBEARING TEMPERATURE
PHENOMENON 1 TG indication is lower
than actual temperatureat oil drain line
POSSIBLE CAUSE Failure of TG
Thermo well is notimmersed in oil
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
23/57
Calibrate TG Check installed position of TG
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
24/57
4.4. BEARING TEMPERATUREBEARING TEMPERATURE
PHENOMENON 2
TG indication is
incorrect
POSSIBLE CAUSE
Failure of TG
Shortage of oil flowto thermo well
Thermo well
Oil
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
25/57
Make calibration of TG Turn back the thermo well to release the
plugging of the oil hole
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
26/57
4.4. BEARING TEMPERATUREBEARING TEMPERATURE
PHENOMENON 3
IT indication of thrustbearing metal is toohigh
Maximum allowabletemperature is 125
POSSIBLE CAUSE
Bearing clearance is toosmall
Supply oil flow is tooshort
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
27/57
Adjust lube oil temperature to lowerward
Adjust to increase lube oil pressure Check oil drain condition
If the bearing metal temperaturereaches to 125 , shutdown the unitand inspect the bearing
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
28/57
4.4. BEARING TEMPERATUREBEARING TEMPERATURE
PHENOMENON 4 TI indication of thrust
bearing metal is notsame at upper and lowerpad
POSSIBLE CAUSE Thrust bearing clearance
is not same through allthe pads and thrust discis slightly inclined
Force
Shaft
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
29/57
Check TI indication per each pad Check thermal distribution of the
flexible support
Check thermal expansion of the turbinecase
If the bearing metal temperaturereaches to 125
, shutdown the unitand inspect the bearing
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
30/57
4.4. BEARING TEMPERATUREBEARING TEMPERATURE
PHENOMENON 5 Fluctuation of lube oil
supply temperature
POSSIBLE CAUSE Fluctuation by air inside
of oil Fluctuation of oil
pressure
Fouling of oil cooler
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
31/57
Vent air from oil lines Check lube oil pressure control valve
Check oil tank level Drain out water from oil tank, if any
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
32/57
5.5. TROUBLE ON GOVERNORTROUBLE ON GOVERNOR
PHENOMENON 1 Turbine speed is
slightly lower thanindication from C.C.R
PG-PL Governor
POSSIBLE CAUSE Leakage air from
instrument tubing and /or fittings
Miss setting of air signaland speed of Governor
Air pressure 1.0k0.2k
105%
85%
Speed
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
33/57
Check any leakage from instrumenttubing and / or fittings
Check water contents in the instrumentair
Try to adjust manual knob on Governorto upper ward
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
34/57
5.5. TROUBLE ON GOVERNORTROUBLE ON GOVERNOR
PHENOMENON 2 Governing valve lift is
greater thancorresponding lift tosteam flow
POSSIBLE CAUSE Spindle of inner bar is
damaged and bar isreclined on valve seat
Stem of governing valveis damaged and stayed
on valve seat Plugging strainer in
T.T.V by foreignmaterial from upstream
Steam flow
Valve
Lift
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
35/57
Check history of valve lift, if any Check vibration and its frequency the
spindle by handy vibro-meter
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
36/57
5.5. TROUBLE ON GOVERNORTROUBLE ON GOVERNOR
PHENOMENON 3 Extraction steam flow is
not increased and thepressure is not increasedeither
POSSIBLE CAUSE Failure of governing valve
and shortage of inletsteam flow
Miss lever setting ingovernor system
Excess consumption ofextraction steam
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
37/57
Check steam pressure, temperature andflow to compare with expected data
Check relative valve lifts of governingand extraction control valves
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
38/57
5.5. TROUBLE ON GOVERNORTROUBLE ON GOVERNOR
PHENOMENON 4 Governing linkage
levers are not smoothlystroked
POSSIBLE CAUSE Hysterics of linkage by
loosening or hard contact Stick on piston of pilot
valve
Stick on piston of power
cylinder
Stick in PG-PL Governoror E/H actuator
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
39/57
Changing the load, find out the stickingpoint
Check relation between Governoroutput and lift of E/H actuator
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
40/57
5.5. TROUBLE ON GOVERNORTROUBLE ON GOVERNOR
PHENOMENON 5 Movement of E/H
actuator is not smooth
POSSIBLE CAUSE Piston is sticking by oil
contamination Hunting by air in oil
Reduced manipulationpressure by pressure
drop through in linefilter
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
41/57
Check actuator lift corresponding tooutput signal of Electronic Governor
Vent air from control oil line Switch over in line filter
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
5 O O GO OTROUBLE ON GOVERNOR
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
42/57
5.5. TROUBLE ON GOVERNORTROUBLE ON GOVERNOR
PHENOMENON 6 T.T.V is not fully closed
when emergencyshutdown is made
POSSIBLE CAUSE Stationary parts such as
hydraulic shutdownpiston, shutdown cams,valve stem is sticking inlong term operation
The valve stem isbending by roughhandling
Scale accumulation in
the bush in long termoperation
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
43/57
Close main stop valve in steam inletline
After the shutdown, overhaul the T.T.V Activate partial stroke test device
periodically during operation
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
66 B ilB il
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
44/57
6.6. Boiler carry overBoiler carry over
PHENOMENON 1 Steam header pressure
and temperature arewent down suddenly
Excess thrust force isindicated by axial
displacement probes
POSSIBLE CAUSE Water mist is carried
over to Turbine
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
45/57
Check fluctuation of Boiler drum Observe steam pressure and
temperature
Observe thrust bearing metaltemperature and axial displacement
In case axial displacement reaches tothe trip level, the turbine will be trippedas a one of interlock system
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
66 B ilB il
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
46/57
6.6. Boiler carry overBoiler carry over
PHENOMENON 2 Turbine thermal
efficiency goes downand steam consumptiongoes up gradually
POSSIBLE CAUSE SiO2 in steam makes
deposit on blade andnozzle, and steampassage area becomesnarrow to reduce
thermal efficiency Hematite (Fe2O3), which
is formed in boiler andalso inlet steam pipe,
will also attack turbineto accumulate on bladeand nozzle
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
47/57
Check relation of steam flow and valvelift of Governing valve and Extractioncontrol valve
Check steam pressure after 1st stage ofHP or LP case corresponding to inlet
steam flow
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
66 Boiler carry overBoiler carry over
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
48/57
6.6. Boiler carry overBoiler carry over
PHENOMENON 3 Shaft vibration is grown
up suddenly undernormal operation
POSSIBLE CAUSE Corrosive material (SO2,
NaOH, NaCl) attacksblade and breaks it dueto repeated stress
Time
Amp
litude
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
49/57
Make frequency analysis and checkphase change
Decrease speed if the vibration levelreaches at alarm point
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
77 VACUUM FAILUREVACUUM FAILURE
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
50/57
7.7. VACUUM FAILUREVACUUM FAILURE
PHENOMENON 1 Condenser absolute
pressure is higher thanspecified pressure
Shortage of vacuum
POSSIBLE CAUSE Air leakage to condenser
is more than the capacityof air ejector system
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
51/57
Check the driving steam pressure to airejector
Check the cooling water quantity andsupply temperature
Check sealing water distribution system
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
77 VACUUM FAILUREVACUUM FAILURE
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
52/57
7.7. VACUUM FAILUREVACUUM FAILURE
PHENOMENON 2 Air ejector system is not
stable and the vacuum isfluctuated
POSSIBLE CAUSE Foreign material is
plugging to the ejectornozzle or strainer
Air trap in drain line forafter cooler is not
functioned well
Time
Vacu
um(P)
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
53/57
Stop operating of air ejector system toknow the vacuum retention timewithout service of air ejector
Prepare spare of ejector nozzle and /orair trap to replace under operation
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
88 OTHERSOTHERS
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
54/57
8.8. OTHERSOTHERS
PHENOMENON 1 Condenser hot well tank
level is increasecontinuously
POSSIBLE CAUSE Fluctuation of level
control Suction strainer is
plugging due to scalesor foreign materials
Cavitation of thecondensate pump
Cooling water leaks tothe shell side
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
55/57
Check pressure of suction anddischarge of condensate pump
Check abnormal sound fromcondensate pump
Adjust level controller (P and I), if
necessary Check conductivity of condensed water
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION
88 OTHERSOTHERS
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
56/57
8.8. OTHERSOTHERS
PHENOMENON 2 Oil leaks through
bearing pedestal
POSSIBLE CAUSE Large clearance of oil
slinger ( Labyrinth ) Air breather is plugging
( higher internal pressure )
Windage by the coupling
( higher internal pressure )
Insufficient bolting of thestud bolts ( split bolts )
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
-
8/10/2019 Trouble Shooting for Turbine
57/57
Check internal pressure of the bearingpedestal by manometer
Check condition of the air breather
Retighten stud bolts of the bearingpedestal
CHECK & HANDLING ITEMSCHECK & HANDLING ITEMS
DURING OPERATIONDURING OPERATION