Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University...

119

Transcript of Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University...

Page 1: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

!!!

!!

!!

! !

Page 2: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

!

"#$%&'#(!)*+,*-./01!!!

!! !

!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!!

!!

!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

!

!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

"!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&1!23456!7++!$%-8'9!$,9,$:,;6!

</0+%98,;!0(!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&6!

=;%'*$!.$6!7;$%,+,!<$%&>?@,++*!!

AB8**+!*C!@,;%B%&,1!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&!

DAEFG!HIJ4JI4K3HLLJ!

!

!

Page 3: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!
Page 4: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

 

i    

Table  of  Contents    

MULTIFUN  Consortium  .............................................................................................  i

Dissemination  preface  .............................................................................................  1

WMIC  2012  Workshop  ............................................................................................  5

Workshop  Program  .......................................................................................................................  8

(I)  Advances  in  imaging  and  diagnostics  using  nanotechnological  tools  .......................................................................  9

(II)  Advances  in  imaging  and  theranostics  using  nanotechnological  tools  ..................................................................  17

(III)  Cluster:  Targeted  nanopharmaceuticals  and  diagnostics  .....................................................................................  25

(IV)  Imaging  cell  and  tissue  interaction  with  nanomaterials  ......................................................................................  30

EuroNanoForum  2013  ...........................................................................................  37

Nanomedicine  at  EuroNanoForum  2013  ......................................................................................  38

Highlights  I:  Nanomedicine:  Technology  Platforms  and  Breakthrough  Projects  (ENF  Workshop  7)  ............................  39

Highlights  II:  Market  Strategies  in  the  Medical  Device  Industry  (ENF  Workshop  8)  ....................................................  42

Final  Multifun  Workshop  2015  ..............................................................................  45

Workshop  program  .....................................................................................................................  46

Workshop  highlights  .................................................................................................................................................  51

Workshop  organising  committee  ..............................................................................................................................  52

Acknowledgements  ...............................................................................................  54

Funding  .................................................................................................................  54

Appendix  1  –  Final  Multifun  workshop  2015,  complete  booklet  ............................  55

Page 5: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!
Page 6: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!

;!Z!< > - , !!

8/,,51/+2./*+!9-562:5!!

!

1

F>&*M,;%B%&,! N$*M%9,9! '*! 0$%&-! 0,'',$! 8,>+'8! B>$,1!0,'',$! 8,>+'8! ,B*&*M%B9! >&;! '$/+(! N,$9*&>+%O,;! M,;%?B%&,6! .$/-! ;,+%:,$(! 8>9! >&;! P%++! -$,>'+(! 0,&,C%'! C$*M!&>&*',B8&*+*-(?;$%:,&! %&&*:>'%*&1!'8/9!N$*:%;%&-!9>C,$!>&;! M*$,! ,CC%B%,&'! '8,$>N%,96! F>&*',B8&*+*-(! %9! >+9*!;$%:%&-!'8,!;,:,+*NM,&'!*C!&*:,+!;%>-&*9'%B9!'**+9!>&;!'$,>'M,&'! C*$! N,$9*&>+%9,;! M*&%'*$%&-! *C! '8,! '$,>'?M,&'6!!

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

#>$-,'%&-!)A)!>++*P9!,>$+(!;,',B'%*&!*C!B>&B,$!;,?:,+*NM,&'! '8>'! P%++! $,W/%$,! %;,&'%C%B>'%*&! *C! 9N,B%C%B!M>$Q,$9! >&;! '8,! ;,:,+*NM,&'! *C! B*$$,9N*&;%&-! 9,+,B?'%:,! +%->&;9! T,6-6! >&'%0*;%,9! *$! N,N'%;,9S! '8/9! *CC,$%&-!>&!,>$+(!9'>-,!'/M*/$!;,',B'%*&6!7B-%,:%&-!'8%9!P%++!N$*?:%;,!0,'',$!B8>&B,9! '*! 9/BB,99C/++(! $,M*:,! '8,! B>&B,$1!'*!>:*%;!+*&-!>&;!8>$MC/+!N>'%,&'!$,B*:,$(!>&;!'/M*/$!$,+>N9,!>'!+>',$!N*%&'96!

#8,$,C*$,M!M/+'%M*;>+! '8,$>N,/'%B! >NN$*>B8! >N?N+%,;!>'!B,++/+>$!+,:,+!P%++!B*MN*/&;!'8,!,CC,B'9!N$*:%;?,;!0(!;%CC,$,&'!B,++!>N*N'*'%B!M,B8>&%9M9!>9!;,9B$%0,;!0,+*P6!X,&B,1!'8,!;,+%:,$(!*C!M%&%M>++(?%&:>9%:,!B>&B,$!'8,$>-&*9'%B! &>&*',B8&*+*-(! C*$! ;,:,+*N%&-! >&;! :>+%?;>'%&-! &,P! '/M*/$! ;,',B'%*&! >&;! ,+%M%&>'%*&! >N?

2

N$*>B8,91! ,RN,B',;! '*! 9%-&%C%B>&'+(! $,;/B,! 9%;,! ,CC,B'9!>&;!+>',$!$,+>N9,6!

#8,! C/&;%&-! *C! ;,',B'%*&! >&;! '8,$>N,/'%B! >N?N$*>B8,9!0>9,;!*&!&>&*',B8&*+*-%,9!8>9!0,,&!B*&9*+%?;>',;!>$*/&;!L3!@Y!%&!'8,!+>9'!Z!(,>$9!%&!$,9,>$B8!>$,>9!P%'8%&! '8,! A,:,&'8! U$>M,P*$Q! <$*-$>MM,! TU<IS6! .%C?C,$,&'!U<I!B>++9!8>:,!0,,&!+>/&B8,;!>&;!C/&;,;!9,:,$>+!N$*[,B'9! B*&B,$&%&-! '8,! /9,! *C! C/&B'%*&>+%9,;! &>&*9(9?',M9! C*$! ;%9,>9,! >&;! B>&B,$! ;,',B'%*&1! [email protected]?7#V=7@1! F7F\#X=V1! A\F\.V]^A1! _DEV7F#S! >&;!'8,$>N,/'%B!>NN$*>B8,9!0>9,;!*&!;$/-!;,+%:,$(!TA\F\?.V]^A1! @7^FDU`)\1! F7F\#X=VS1! 9%VF7! ;,+%:,$(!TF7F\#X=VS! >&;a*$! M>-&,'%B! 8,>'%&-! T@7^FDU`)\1!F7F\#X=V1! F7F\L#S6! .%CC,$,&'! &>&*B>$$%,$9! 8>:,!0,,&!;,9%-&,;!'*!'>$-,'!B,++!M>$Q,$9!$,9N*&9%0+,!*C!;%9?,>9,9! T_DEV7F#1! A\F\.V]^AS! %&B+/;%&-! B>&B,$! B,++9!TF7F\#X=V1! A\F\.V]^A1! @7^F`UD)\1! F7F\L#S! >'!;%CC,$,&'!'/M*/$9!9'>-,96!!

#8/91!=/$*N,!8>9!,9'>0+%98,;!%'9,+C!>9!>!M>[*$!;$%:?,$!C*$!'8,!-+*0>+!M>$Q,'1!,9N,B%>++(!%&!'8,!M,;%B>+!N$*;?/B'96!#8,!=/$*N,>&!F>&*@,;!@>N1!$,B,&'+(!;,:,+*N,;!0(!'8,!=/$*N,>&!#,B8&*+*-(!<+>'C*$M!*&!F>&*M,;%B%&,!'8$*/-8! '8,! C/&;,;! )**$;%&>',;! A/NN*$'! 7B'%*&! N$*?[,B'1! F>&*@,;23231! 98*P9! '8>'! '8,! &>&*M,;%B%&,!B*MM/&%'(!B*/&'9!>'!+,>9'!4533!=/$*N,>&!M>%&!>B'*$9b!'8,9,! %&B+/;,! M*$,! '8>&! 533! %&;/9'$%>+! N+>(,$9! >&;!A@=9! >B'%:,! %&! '8,! C%,+;1! >&;! 4333! >B'*$9! B*&;/B'%&-!8%-8?W/>+%'(! $,9,>$B8! %&! /&%:,$9%'%,9! >&;! $,9,>$B8! B,&?'$,9!>B$*99!=/$*N,6!!

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

Page 7: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

2!c!< > - , !!

!

!

)*&'$%0/'%*&!'*!F>&*M,;%B%&,!#$>&9+>'%*&!!

!

!"#$%&'#(()*#*+,-#.%$(

/%"0*+1+23(#*$('$%#.4(

567(#*$(!""8%$'/#9

+*.(

:*/%11%"/;#1(78+<%89%.(

78+=(+=("+*"%</(

>6?(%*#-1'*2(/++1.(=+8(/8#*.1#9+*(

7'1+/(1'*%(=+8(."#1%(;<(

@%2;1#/+83(#""%</#*"%(

A1'*'"#1(8%1%B#*"%(#*$(/8'#1.((

:*$;./83(#*$(

(6#8C%/(

D8#*.1#9+*#1(#*$(:**+B#9+*(<8+"%..(

3

M>Q,! */'B*M,9! >:>%+>0+,! '*! '8,! P8*+,! 9'>Q,8*+;,$!B*MM/&%'(6!

D&!'8%9!B*&',R'1!9,:,$>+!=]!N$*[,B'9!>&;!N$*C,99%*&?>+! &,'P*$Q9! >$,! %&',-$>'%&-! '*! >;;! :>+/,! '*! =/$*N,>&!&>&*M,;%B%&,G!#8,9,! %&B+/;,!'8,!=/$*N,>&!#,B8&*+*-(!<+>'C*$M! *&! F>&*M,;%B%&,b! '8,! )+/9',$1! d#>$-,',;!F>&*?<8>$M>B,/'%B>+9! >&;! =>$+(! .%>-&*9'%B9eb! '8,! =/?$*N,>&!U*/&;>'%*&!C*$!)+%&%B>+!F>&*M,;%B%&,!T)fDF7@S!>&;! %'9!=/$*N,>&!A/MM%'!C*$!)+%&%B>+!F>&*M,;%B%&,b!>9!P,++! >9! +>$-,?9B>+,! U<I! N$*[,B'9! 9/B8! >9! @]f#DU][email protected]#V=7@1! A7_=@=1! F7F\U\fA! >&;! L@D)V\F1!>M*&-!M>&(!*'8,$96!

#8,!=/$*N,>&!#,B8&*+*-(!<+>'C*$M!*&!F>&*M,;%?B%&,! T=#<FS! 8>9! %;,&'%C%,;! 9,:,$>+! B8>++,&-,9! C*$! '8,!$,>+%O>'%*&!*C!>&!,CC,B'%:,!*N,&!%&&*:>'%*&!M*;,+!>B$*99!

5

9'>Q,8*+;,$9! B>&! ->'8,$! P%'8! '8,! >%M! *C! 98>$%&-! ,>B8!*'8,$g9! N*',&'%>+9! >&;! &,,;96! #*-,'8,$! P%'8! =#<F1!)fDF7@1!>&;!'8,!,R%9'%&-!N$*C,99%*&>+!B+/9',$9!>&;!&,'?P*$Q9! %&! &>&*M,;%B%&,1! +>$-,?9B>+,! =/$*N,>&! N$*[,B'9!B>&!>B'!>9!B>'>+(9'9! C*$!'8,!B$,>'%*&!*C!M/+'%;%9B%N+%&>$(!,RB8>&-,!-$*/&;96!#8,!98>$%&-!*C!Q&*P+,;-,!>&;! %;,>9!'8>'!8>:,!;,:,+*N,;! %&!'8,!B*/$9,!*C!*&,!N$*[,B'1!P%'8!*'8,$!$,9,>$B8,$9!P*$Q%&-! %&!'8,!C%,+;!>&;!P%'8!'8,!,R?',&;,;! 9'>Q,8*+;,$! B*MM/&%'(1! B>&! 0$%&-! /9! B+*9,$! '*!>B8%,:%&-!$,>+!8,>+'8!>&;!9*B%,'>+!0,&,C%'96!

#8%9!P>9! '8,! -*>+! *C! '8,! ;%99,M%&>'%*&! ,:,&'9! *$?->&%O,;!0(!'8,! +>$-,?9B>+,! B*++>0*$>'%:,!=]?C/&;,;!U<I!N$*[,B'1!@]f#DU]F!T@/+'%C/&B'%*&>+!&>&*',B8&*+*-(!C*$!9,+,B'%:,!;,',B'%*&!>&;!'$,>'M,&'!*C!B>&B,$6!#8,!>%M!*C!'8,!N$*[,B'!P>9!;,:,+*NM,&'!%9!'*!;,:,+*N!>&;!:>+%;>',!

4

=/$*N,6! DMN$*:%&-! '8,! ;%>+*-! 0,'P,,&! ;%CC,$,&'! >B>?;,M%B! ;%9B%N+%&,91! %&;/9'$%,91! B+%&%B>+! *$->&%O>'%*&9! >&;!$,-/+>'*$(!>-,&B%,9!%9!B*&9%;,$,;!>!'*N!N$%*$%'(!0(!=#<F1!>&;!'8%9!P>9!;%9B/99,;!,R',&9%:,+(!>'!'8,!(,>$+(!)fDF7@!9/MM%'1!P8%B8!>%M9!>'!N$,9,&'%&-!>&;!$,C+,B'%&-!*&!'8,!+>',9'! &>&*9B%,&B,?$,+>',;! >;:>&B,9! %&! M,;%B%&,! 0(!9/NN*$'%&-! B+%&%B>++(! C*B/9,;! $,9,>$B8! >&;! %&',$>B'%*&!>B$*99! '8,! P8*+,! B*MM/&%'(! *C! &>&*M,;%B%&,! 9'>Q,?8*+;,$96!!

#*! C>B%+%'>',! 9/B8! %&',$>B'%*&1! %'! %9! ,99,&'%>+! '*! *$?->&%O,! M/+'%?;%9B%N+%&>$(! ,:,&'9! P8,$,! &>&*M,;%B%&,!

6

>!&*:,+! >&;!M%&%M>++(?%&:>9%:,!&>&*',B8&*+*-(! 9(9',M!'*! %MN$*:,!B>&B,$!;%>-&*9%9!>&;!'$,>'M,&'6!@]f#DU]F!&>&*',B8&*+*-(! %9! 0>9,;! *&! M/+'%C/&B'%*&>+%9,;! M>-?&,'%B! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! '*! 9,+,B'%:,+(! '>$-,'! >&;! ,+%M%&>',!0$,>9'!>&;!N>&B$,>'%B!B>&B,$!T9',MS!B,++96!#8,!%MN$*:,;!M>-&,'%B!C,>'/$,9!*C!'8,!@/+'%U/&!M>-&,'%B!&>&*N>$'%?B+,9!P%++! +,>;! '*! N*',&'%>+!M,;%B>+! >NN+%B>'%*&9! 9/B8! >9!B*&'$>9'!>-,&'9!>&;!M>-&,'%B!8,>'%&-!%&;/B'*$96!

#8,! %&',$&>'%*&>+! >&;!M/+'%;%9B%N+%&>$(!;%M,&9%*&9!*C!'8,!N$*[,B'!P,&'!0,(*&;!'8,!B*MN*9%'%*&!*C!%'9!N>$'?&,$91!>9! %'!->'8,$,;!*'8,$!N$*[,B'9!>&;!,RN,$'%9,!0(!>$?

Page 8: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!

M!Z!< > - , !!

!

!

!

7

$>&-%&-!*/'$,>B8!,:,&'9! %&! '8,! C%,+;9!*C!&>&*',B8&*+*?-(?,&>0+,;! M*+,B/+>$! %M>-%&-1! '8,$>N,/'%B91! >&;! M>$?Q,'! 9'$>',-%,9! C*$! &>&*M,;%B%&,6! A*M,! *C! '8,!M*9'! %&?C+/,&'%>+!,RN,$'9!>&;!N$*[,B'9! %&!'8,!C%,+;!P,$,!0$*/-8'!'*-,'8,$! ;/$%&-! '8,! F>&*',B8&*+*-(! P*$Q98*N! >'! '8,!h*$+;!@*+,B/+>$! DM>-%&-! )*&C,$,&B,1! 23421! %&! ./0+%&1!>&;! >+9*! >'! '8,! U%&>+!@]f#DU]F!P*$Q98*N6!@]f#DU]F!>+9*!0$*/-8'!$,9/+'9!'*!'8,!C+**$!*C!'8,!=/$*F>&*U*$/M!234L!B*&C,$,&B,! T%'9!*P&!>9!P,++! >9!'8*9,!*C!*'8,$!=/?$*N,>&! N$*[,B'9Sb! '8%9! P>9! >! /&%W/,! *NN*$'/&%'(! '*!B*MM/&%B>',!'8,!8/-,!N*',&'%>+!*C!&>&*',B8&*+*-(1!>9!>&! ,&>0+%&-! ',B8&*+*-(! C*$! M,;%B>+! >NN+%B>'%*&91! '*! >!+>$-,! N>&,+! *C! $,9,>$B81! %&;/9'$(! >&;! N/0+%B! >/'8*$%'(!$,N$,9,&'>'%:,96! #8$*/-8! '8,! 9/BB,99! *C! '8,9,! ,:,&'91!@]f#DU]F! 8>9! B>'>+(O,;! '8,! B$,>'%*&! *C! >! B*MM*&!-$*/&;!C*$!;%9B/99%*&!*C!9B%,&'%C%B!>&;!%&;/9'$%>+!%&&*:>?'%*&!9'$>',-%,9!>M*&-9'!'8*9,!P%'8!;%CC,$,&'!,RN,$%,&B?,9!>&;!%&',$,9'96!7!M>[*$!$,9/+'!*C!9/B8!*/'$,>B8!>B'%:%?

8

'%,9! P>9! '8,! 8%-8+(! N$*;/B'%:,! ,&->-,M,&'! *C! M>&(!@]f#DU]F!N>$'&,$9!%&',$&>'%*&>++(6!

U$/%'C/+! %&',$>B'%*&9! 8>:,! >+9*! 0,,&! ,9'>0+%98,;!P%'8! *'8,$! +>$-,?9B>+,! U<I! N$*[,B'91! M>[*$! =/$*N,>&!*$->&%O>'%*&9! >&;! %&;/9'$%>+! N>$'&,$91! >9! ;,9B$%0,;! %&!'8,!N$,9,&'!;*B/M,&'6!#8%9!0**Q+,'!>%M9!'*!N$*:%;,!>&!*:,$:%,P! *C! '8,!M/+'%;%9B%N+%&>$(! >B'%:%'%,9! %&%'%>',;! 0(!'8,!@]f#DU]F! ;%99,M%&>'%*&! +,>;%&-! N>$'&,$9! 9/B8! >9!#$%&%'(! )*++,-,! ./0+%&1! D@.=7! >&;! 7#\A! '8$*/-8! '8,%$!N>$'%B%N>'%*&! %&!@]f#DU]F!N$*[,B'9! TU<I!F@<!fA<!N$*?[,B'9! C/&;,;! *:,$! '8,! N,$%*;! 233Hi2345S! >&;! >+9*! >9!N>$'!*C!%'9!0$*>;,$!N>&?=/$*N,>&!,&->-,M,&'6!

Page 9: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

K!!

!!

!

!

<*-?,@*9!2.!.@5!<*-4E!"*45:042-!&12G/+G!)*+G-5,,!=>;=!B<"&)!=>;=C!

F>&*',B8&*+*-(!%&!.%>-&*9'%B91!@*&%'*$%&-!>&;!#$,>'M,&'!*C!)>&B,$G!7;:>&B,9!%&!@*+,B/+>$!DM>-%&-!

Page 10: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!

A!Z!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

<"&)!=>;=!<*-?,@*9!!

!

1

@]f#DU]F!N>$'&,$1!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&1!+,>;!'8,!N$*?[,B'!B*&9*$'%/M!%&'*!'8,!*$->&%9>'%*&!>&;!9B%,&'%C%B!;%9?B/99%*&! *C! '8,! h*$Q98*N1! '%'+,;1! (2+*.5:@+*4*GP! /+!8/2G+*,./:,Y!"*+/.*-/+G! 2+E! %-52.15+.!*6!)2+:5-!DE^F2+:5E! /+! "*45:042-! &12G/+G1! P8%B8! P>9! 8,+;! P%'8%&!'8,!C%C'8!>&&/>+!M,,'%&-!*C!'8,!h*$+;!@*+,B/+>$! DM>-?%&-! )*&-$,99! Th@D)S1! '8,! N$,M%,$! ,:,&'! %&! M*+,B/+>$!%M>-%&-! P*$+;P%;,6! h@D)! 2342! >''$>B',;! M*$,! '8>&!4I53! >'',&;,,9! '*! '8,!./0+%&! )*&:,&'%*&! ),&'$,! C$*M!A,N',M0,$! 5'8iJ'8! P%'8! *:,$! Z3! B*MN>&%,9! ,R8%0%'%&-!'8,! +>',9'! %&9'$/M,&'9! >&;! ',B8&%W/,9! C*$! B+%&%B>+! >&;!N$,?B+%&%B>+!%M>-%&-6!

#8,!-*>+!*C!'8,!'8%9!P*$Q98*N!P>9!'*!0$%&-!'*-,'8?,$!>&;!98*P!9*M,!*C!'8,!M*9'!%MN*$'>&'!9B%,&'%C%B!*/'?B*M,9! *C! =]! N$*[,B'9! >%M,;! >'! ;,:,+*N%&-! %&&*:>'%:,!&>&*',B8&*+*-(?0>9,;! %M>-%&-! N$*0,9! >&;! ;$/-! ;,+%:?,$(!B>$$%,$9!C*$!;%>-&*9'%B!>&;!'8,$>&*9'%B!N/$N*9,96!

\:,$>++1!h@D)!2342!P>9!>'',&;,;!0(!9B%,&'%9'9!>&;!9'>Q,8*+;,$91! B*:,$%&-! >&! %MN$,99%:,! P*$+;P%;,! ;%9'$%?0/'%*&! P%'8! K4j! *C! N,*N+,! B*M%&-! C$*M! =/$*N,1! K3j!C$*M!F*$'8!7M,$%B>1!4Zj!C$*M!79%>!>&;!'8,!$,M>%&%&-!Lj! C$*M! *'8,$! $,-%*&96! 7'! '8,! ,:,&'1! N$,9,&'>'%*&9!P,$,!;,+%:,$,;!0(!9B%,&'%9'9!C$*M!>B>;,M%B1!B+%&%B>+!>&;!$,9,>$B8! %&9'%'/'%*&91! P%'8! %&;/9'$%>+! +,>;,$98%N! %&! '8,!C%,+;! 0,%&-! $,N$,9,&',;! 0(! *:,$! Z3! ,R8%0%'%&-! B*MN>?&%,91! N$,9,&'%&-! '8,! +>',9'! %&9'$/M,&'9! C*$! B+%&%B>+! >&;!N$,?B+%&%B>+!%M>-%&-6!

@*$,!'8>&!443!9'/;,&'9!>&;!$,9,>$B8,$9!>'',&;,;!'8,!P*$Q98*N1!P8,$,!KZ!D&',$&>'%*&>+!>&;!K!D$%98!9B%,&?'%9'9! C$*M!;%:,$9,!>$,>9! *C! '8,!@*+,B/+>$! DM>-%&-! C%,+;!8>;! >! B8>&B,! '*! N$,9,&'! '8,%$! +>',9'! $,9/+'9! >&;! 98>$,!'8,%$!$,9,>$B8!,RN,$%,&B,6!

Q-5,5+.2./*+!O/G@4/G@.,!\:,$!443!9B%,&'%9'9!B*&:,&,;!>'!'8,!4?;>(!P*$Q98*N!'*!N$,9,&'! '8,%$! >NN$*>B8,9! '*! ;%>-&*9%91! M*&%'*$%&-! >&;!'$,>'M,&'! *C! 9*M,! *C! '8,! M>[*$! ;%9,>9,9! *C! '8,! 249'!B,&'/$(1!%&!N>$'%B/+>$!B>&B,$6!\:,$!23!*$>+!N$,9,&'>'%*&9!P,$,!*$->&%9,;!%&'*!C*/$!9,99%*&91!C*++*P,;!0(!>!N*9',$!9,99%*&6!

#8,! C%$9'! 9,99%*&! P>9! '%'+,;1!DEF2+:5,! /+! /12G/+G!2+E!E/2G+*,/,!3P!+2+*.5:@+*4*G/:24!.**4,1!>&;!%'!98*P?B>9,;! $,9/+'9! >&;! ',B8&*+*-%,9! C$*M! '8,! [email protected]?

2

7#V=7@!N$*[,B'6!!<$*C6! `/$%! _*+Q*:! C$*M! #$%&%'(! )*++,-,! ./0+%&! TD$,?

+>&;S!+,;!'8,!P*$Q98*N!>&;!;%9B/99%*&!>$*/&;!.%>-&*9?'%B1! @*&%'*$%&-1! #$,>'M,&'! >&;! N,$9*&>+%O,;! M,;%B%&,!>9! *NN*$'/&%'%,9! C*$! $*/'%&,! ;%>-&*9'%B9! >&;! ;(&>M%B!'$,>'M,&'! M*&%'*$%&-6! <$*C6! f/%-%! E*&>B%&>! C$*M! '8,!]&%:,$9%'(! *C! ^,&,:>! TAP%'O,$+>&;S! N$,9,&',;! '8,! 9,?B*&;?8>$M*&%B! -,&,$>'%&-! &>&*N>$'%B+,91!P8%B8! >%M! '*!N$*:%;,! >&! %&8,$,&'+(! &*&+%&,>$1! N8*'*9'>0+,1! %&C$>$,;?,RB%'>0+,!M%B$*9B*N(! N$*0,!P%'8!M/+'%M*;>+! ;,',B'%*&!B>N>0%+%'%,96!<$*C6!k*,$-!AB8*'',$!C$*M!'8,!7/9'$%>&!D&9'%?'/',! *C! #,B8&*+*-(! T7/9'$%>S! N$,9,&',;! '8,! <+>9M>-!9(9',M! >9! >! 8*M*-,&,*/9! %MM/&*+*-%B>+! ;,',B'%*&!'**+b! '8,! 9(9',M! %9! 0>9,;! *&! *N'%B>+! ;,',B'%*&! *C! '8,!M>-&,'%B! $,+>R>'%*&! '%M,9! *C! 8(0$%;! M>-&,'%B?B*$,1!-*+;?98,++!&>&*$*;96!<$*C6! D-*$!F>0%,:! C$*M!#$%&%'(!)*+?+,-,!./0+%&!TD$,+>&;S!N$,9,&',;!$,9/+'9!$,+>'%&-!'*!>NN+%?B>'%*&9!*C! C+/*$,9B,&'!9,M%B*&;/B'*$!W/>&'/M!;*'9!C*$!/+'$>9,&9%'%:,!M>$Q,$!;,',B'%*&!>&;!B>&B,$!;%>-&*9'%B96!7++! C*/$! N$,9,&','>'%*&9! >+9*! N$*:%;,;! >&! *:,$:%,P! *C!9/B8!>NN+%B>'%*&9!%&!'8,!d$,>+!P*$+;e!*C!B+%&%B>+!;%>-&*9?'%B96!!

[email protected]#V=7@! %&;/9'$%>+! N>$'&,$9!>+9*! N$,9,&',;!'8,%$! >;:>&B,9!>&;! '8,%$! $*+,! %&! '8,!N$*[,B'6! .$6! .>&%,+!)%,N%,+,P9Q%! */'+%&,;! F%Q*&g9! TU$>&B,S! >NN$*>B8! '*!&>&*',B8&*+*-(! C*$! >;:>&B,;! %M>-%&-6! .$6! U$>&9! F>/?P,+>,$9!8%-8+%-8',;!E.!E%*9B%,&B,g9!TE,+-%/MS!,CC*$'9!'*!,:*+:,!C+*P!B('*M,'$(!C$*M!B,++/+>$!'*!9/0?B,++/+>$!>&>+?(9%9!'8$*/-8!&>&*',B8&*+*-(?0>9,;!%M>-%&-6!U%&>++(1!.$6!<>'$%BQ! X*+,! ;%9B/99,;! '8,! /9,! *C! F>&*A%-8'! F#7! T]lS!C*$!'8,!M,>9/$,M,&'!*C!,R*9*M,9!>&;!*'8,$!&>&*9%O,;!0%*+*-%B>+!N>$'%B+,96!

#8,! 9,B*&;! 9,99%*&!B*&B,$&,;!DEF2+:5,! /+! /12G^/+G!2+E!.@5-2+*,./:,!0,/+G!+2+*.5:@+*4*G/:24!.**4,!>&;!N$,9,&'>'%*&9!P,$,! C$*M! '8,!@]f#DU]F!N$*[,B'6!@]f?#DU]F! T@/+'%C/&B'%*&>+! F>&*',B8&*+*-(! C*$! 9,+,B'%:,!;,',B'%*&!>&;!'$,>'M,&'!*C! B>&B,$S! %9! >! +>$-,?9B>+,!=]?C/&;,;! B*++>0*$>'%:,! N$*[,B'! P8*9,! >%M! %9! '*! ;,:,+*N!M/+'%C/&B'%*&>+! M>-&,'%B! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! T@F<9S! C*$! ;%?>-&*9%9!>&;!'$,>'M,&'!C*$!0$,>9'!>&;!N>&B$,>'%B!B>&B,$6!#8,! N$*[,B'! *0[,B'%:,9! $,+>',;! '*! ;%>-&*9%9!P,$,! %&'$*?;/B,;! 0(! <$*C6! V*;*+C*!@%$>&;>! C$*M! D@.=7!F>&*9B%?,&B,!TAN>%&S!>9G!T%S!9(&'8,9%9!*C!@F<9!>9!B*&'$>9'!>-,&'9!

Page 11: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

Z!c!< > - , !!

[F5-F/5L!

!

3

C*$!@VD1!T%%S!;,:,+*NM,&'!*C!9N,B%C%B!0%*M>$Q,$9!C*$!'>$?-,'%&-! 0$,>9'! >&;! N>&B$,>'%B! B>&B,$! 9',M! B,++9! T,>$+(!;%>-&*9%9S1! >&;! T%%%S! ;,:,+*NM,&'! *C! &,P! ',B8&*+*-%,9!C*$!'8,!;,',B'%*&!>&;!W/>&'%C%B>'%*&!*C!&>&*N>$'%B+,9! %&!'%99/,1!0+**;!>&;!/$%&,6!!

@]f#DU]F!9'$>',-%,9!C*$!'8,! 9(&'8,9%9! >&;!;%9N,$?9%*&! *C!M>-&,'%B! &>&*B$(9'>+9! C*$! >;:>&B,;!@VD! %M>-?%&-! >&;! 8(N,$'8,$M%>! P,$,! N$,9,&',;! 0(! <$*C6! @>$%>!;,+!</,$'*!@*$>+,9!C$*M!)AD)!TAN>%&S6!A8,!>+9*!N*%&',;!*/'! '8,!M>%&! ',B8&%B>+! B8>++,&-,9! '*! '8,! ;,:,+*NM,&'!>&;!B8>$>B',$%O>'%*&!*C!'8,9,!&>&*N>$'%B+,96!!

@]f#DU]F! 9'$>',-%,9! C*$! M/+'%C/&B'%*&>+%O>'%*&! *C!M>-&,'%B! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! C*$! '8,$>&*9'%B! >NN+%B>'%*&91!9N,B%C%B>++(! C*$!0$,>9'!>&;!N>&B$,>'%B! B>&B,$91!P,$,!;,?9B$%0,;! 0(! .$6! 7%'O%0,$! f6! )*$'>[>$,&>! C$*M! D@.=76! .$6!V,&m!E*'&>$!C$*M!l%&-g9!)*++,-,!f*&;*&! T]lS! $,N*$',;!$,9/+'9! B*&B,$&%&-!'8,! !"#$!%&'!0,8>:%*/$!*C!8(;$*N8%+%B!M>-&,'%B!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!'8>'!>$,!'*!0,!/9,;!>9!@VD!B*&?'$>9'!>-,&'96!#8,&1!.$6!D&-$%;!X%+-,$!C$*M!'8,!]&%:,$9%'(!*C! k,&>! T^,$M>&(S! *CC,$,;! >&! *:,$:%,P! *&! '8,! B+%&%B>+!/9,! *C!M>-&,'%B! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! >&;! '8,! B8>++,&-,9! '8>'!C>B,! '8,! ;,:,+*NM,&'! *C! 9/B8! 9'$>',-%,96! #8,! +>9'!N$,9,&'>'%*&! *C! '8%9! 9,99%*&! P>9! 0(! .$6! A',N8>&%,!#,/-8,+9! C$*M! <,N$%B! TE,+-%/MS! >&;! %'! ;,9B$%0,;! &,P!;,:%B,9! C*$! W/>&'%'>'%:,!M*&%'*$%&-! *C! '8,! 0%*;%9'$%0/?'%*&!>&;!Q%&,'%B9!*C!M>-&,'%B!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!>&;!+>0,+,;!B,++9!>&;!'%99/,96!

#8,! '8%$;?9,99%*&!N$,9,&'>'%*&9!P,$,!;,+%:,$,;!0(!M,M0,$9! *C! '8,! %2-G5.5E! (2+*^Q@2-12:50./:24,! 2+E!N2-4P! 8/2G+*,./:,! B+/9',$1!P8%B8! 0$%&-9! '*-,'8,$! >0*/'!25! $,9,>$B8! N$*[,B'9! C/&;,;! 0(! '8,! =]! A%R'8! >&;! A,:?,&'8! U$>M,P*$Q! <$*-$>MM,9! C*$! V,9,>$B8! TU<Z! >&;!U<IS1!/&;,$!'8,!N$%*$%'%,91!F@<!>&;!X=7f#X6!.$6!7;$%,+,!<$%&>?@,++*! C$*M! #$%&%'(! )*++,-,!./0+%&! TD$,+>&;S! %&'$*?;/B,;!'8,!B+/9',$1!P8*9,!>%M!%9!'*!;,:,+*N!9'>',?*C!'8,?>$'!&>&*',B8&*+*-%B>+!M,'8*;9!C*$!;%>-&*9%&-1!M*&%'*$?%&-! >&;! '$,>'%&-! >! P%;,! :>$%,'(! *C! ;%9,>9,91! %&B+/;%&-!B>&B,$6! D&! N>$'%B/+>$1! '8%9! 9,99%*&! 8*9',;! N$,9,&'>'%*&9!C$*M! '8,! A7_=@=1! F7F\U\f! >&;! L@D)V\F! N$*[,B'96!.$6! f*/%9! A8,&QM>&! TD9$>,+S! 98*P,;! $,9/+'9! C$*M! '8,!A7_=@=! N$*[,B'1! P8%B8! %9! ;,:,+*N%&-! >! &*:,+! M*;/+>$!&>&*9(9',M!N+>'C*$M1! %&',-$>'%&-! >;:>&B,;! C/&B'%*&>+?%O,;! &>&*?B*$,! N>$'%B+,9! >&;! >B'%:,! >-,&'96! F7F\U\f!P>9! N$,9,&',;! 0(! .$6! 7$'/$! )>:>B*?<>/+*! T<*$'/->+S!P8*!*/'+%&,;! '8,!;,:,+*NM,&'!*C! C*+>',?0>9,;!&>&*0%?

4

*;,:%B,9! C*$! %&',-$>',;! ;%>-&*9%9a'8,$>N(! '>$-,'%&-!B8$*&%B! %&C+>MM>'*$(! ;%9,>9,96! U%&>++(1! L@D)V\F! >%M9!>'!;,:,+*N%&-!>!'8$,,?M*;>+%'(!B*&'$>9'?%M>-%&-!9(9',M!/9%&-!M/+'%?C/&B'%*&>+%O,;!M>-&,'%B!N*+(M,$%B!M%B$*0>+?+**&91! >9! ;,9B$%0,;! %&! '8,! N$,9,&'>'%*&! *C! <$*C6! X>&9!X,$0,$'!TAP,;,&S6!

#8,!+>9'!9,99%*&!*C!'8,!h*$Q98*N!B,&'$,;!*&!&12G^/+G!:544!2+E!./,,05! /+.5-2:./*+!L/.@!+2+*12.5-/24,6!7;?:>&B,;!,RN,$%M,&'>+!M*;,+!9(9',M9!C*$!%M>-%&-!B>&B,$!B,++9!P,$,!'8,!9/0[,B'!*C!'8,!N$,9,&'>'%*&!-%:,&!0(!<$*C6!U$>/Q,! 7+:,91! X,$! ',>M! >'! '8,! @>R! <+>&Q! D&9'%'/',!T^,$M>&(S! 8>9! *N'%M%O,;! !"# $!$'! M*;,+9! TM*/9,S! C*$!+/&-1!N>&B$,>9!>&;!0$,>9'!B>&B,$!'*!,:>+/>',!'8,!9,&9%?'%:%'(!>&;! 9N,B%C%B%'(!*C!'8,!N8*'*+/M%&,9B,&'!W/>&'/M!;*'9! ;,:,+*N,;! %&! '8,! [email protected]#V=7@! N$*[,B'b! P8%B8!P,$,!B*MN>$,;!'*!9'>&;>$;!B*&'$*+9!>&;!,R%9'%&-!;,',B?'%*&! +>0,+96! F,P! ;,:,+*NM,&'9! %&! %M>-%&-! *C! !"# $!%&'#M*;,+9!P,$,!>+9*!*&!98*P!8,$,1!%&!'8,!N$,9,&'>'%*&9!*C!.$6!.>&%>!@*:%>!>&;!.$6!7;$%,+,!<$%&>?@,++*!C$*M!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&6!.$6!@*:%>!N$*N*9,;! L.!B,++! 9(9',M9! >9!&*:,+!!"#$!%&'!M*;,+9!C*$!9'/;(%&-!&>&*M>',$%>+!%&',$>B?'%*&9!P%'8!'%99/,96!#8,!$,9/+'9!*C!%M>-%&-!>&;!B('*'*R%B%?'(! ',9'%&-! *C! 9%&-+,! P>++! B>$0*&! &>&*'/0,9! TAhF#9S! %&!9/B8! L.1! '%99/,?+%Q,!M*;,+9!P,$,! N$,9,&',;6! .$6! <$%&>?@,++*!'8,&!;,9B$%0,;!'8,!/9,!*C!>!8%-8?B*&',&'!9B$,,&?%&-! 9(9',M! C*$! '8,!>&>+(9%9!*C! B,++/+>$! $,9N*&9,9! '*!&>?&*M>',$%>+91! ,MN8>9%O%&-! %'9! ,CC,B'%:,&,99! >9! >&! %M>-?%&-!>&;!;,B%9%*&?M>Q%&-!'**+6!

#8,!>NN+%B>'%*&!*C!V>M>&!',B8&%W/,9!'*!B+%&%B>+!%M?>-%&-!P>9!*/'+%&,;!0(!.$6!U/$%*!^$>M>'%B>!C$*M!'8,!.*&!^&*BB8%! U*/&;>'%*&!TD'>+(S6! D&!N>$'%B/+>$1!.$6!^$>M>'%B>!N$*N*9,;!>!9,+C?>99,M0+,;!A=VA!N+>'C*$M!C*$!0%*M>$Q,$!;,',B'%*&1!P8%B8!B>&!0,! %MN+,M,&',;! %&'*!>!d+>0?*&?>?B8%Ne!9(9',M1!%;,>+!C*$!B+%&%B>+!>NN+%B>'%*&9!9/B8!>9!8*9?N%'>+!+>0!',9'9!>&;!N*%&'?*C?B>$,!',9'96!!

#8,! %MN+%B>'%*&9! *C! &>&*'*R%B*+*-(! %&! &>&*M,;%?B%&,!P,$,!>;;$,99,;!0(!.$6!@>$B,++*!)>B>B,! C$*M!)FV!TD'>+(S6!.$6!)>B>B,!N*%&',;!*/'! '8>'!0*'8!&>&*M,;%B%&,!>&;! &>&*'*R%B*+*-(! ,R>M%&,! &,P! >&;! 9*M,'%M,9! /&?C*$,9,,&! ,CC,B'9! ,M,$-%&-! C$*M! 0%*&>&*! %&',$>B'%*&9b!*&,!9,,Q9!'*!,RN+*%'!'8,9,!,CC,B'9!C*$!'8,!0,&,C%'!*C!*/$!8,>+'81!P8,$,>9!'8,!*'8,$!>%M9!'*!C%&;1!/&;,$9'>&;!>&;!M%&%M%O,!'8*9,!'8>'!>$,!/&;,9%$>0+,6!

[0.:*15,!

Page 12: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!

I!Z!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

!! !

5

#8,!h*$+;!@*+,B/+>$! DM>-%&-!)*&-$,99! >''$>B',;!4233!>09'$>B'9b!8*9',;!253!*$>+!N$,9,&'>'%*&9!>&;!C*/$!N*9'?,$! 9,99%*&91! >&;! N$*:%;,;! 4K! ,;/B>'%*&>+! 9,99%*&91! I!9N*'+%-8'!9,99%*&9!>&;!5!%&;/9'$(!P*$Q98*N96!h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

#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&!/&;,$!>&!AUD!)*&C,$,&B,!>&;!h*$Q98*N!-$>&'! T>P>$;,;!'*!<$*C6!_*+Q*:!>&;! B*++>0*?$>'*$1! .$! <$%&>?@,++*S!N$*:%;,;!&,>$+(!453! '$>:,+! -$>&'!>P>$;9! '*!>'',&;,,9!$,B,%:%&-! '8,!0,9'! 9B*$,96! D&!>;;%?

6

'%*&1!'8%9!-$>&'!N$*:%;,;!C*$!L!(*/&-!%&:,9'%->'*$!>P>$;9!>&;!43!N*9',$!>P>$;9!'*! $,B*-&%O,! %&&*:>'%:,! $,9,>$B8!0(!(*/&-! %&:,9'%->'*$91!%&B+/;%&-![/&%*$!C>B/+'(6!D&;,,;1!'8$*/-8*/'! '8,! P*$Q98*N1! (*/&-! 9B%,&'%9'9! P,$,! N$*?:%;,;! '8,! *NN*$'/&%'(! '*! 8%-8+%-8'! '8,%$! >B8%,:,M,&'9!>&;! 98>$,! '8,%$!,RN,$%,&B,9!P%'8! ,9'>0+%98,;! $,9,>$B8?,$9!%&!>&!%&C*$M>+!&,'P*$Q%&-!>'M*9N8,$,6! !

Page 13: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

J!c!< > - , !!

[F5-F/5L!

!

<*-?,@*9!Q-*G-21!B&C!!DEF2+:5,!/+!/12G/+G!2+E!E/2G+*,./:,!0,/+G!+2+*.5:@+*4*G/:24!.**4, F>&*',B8&*+*-(!%&!;%>-&*9'%B!M*&%'*$%&-!>&;!'$,>'M,&'!*C!B>&B,$G!7;:>&B,9!%&!M*+,B/+>$!%M>-%&- X>$M*&%B!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!C*$!0%*+>0,++%&- <+>9M*&%B!M>-&,'%B!;,',B'%*&!C*$!>;:>&B,;!B+%&%B>+!;%>-&*9'%B9 n/>&'/M!;*'9!>9!C+/*$,9B,&'!N$*0,9!C*$!>;:>&B,;!%M>-%&- F>&*',B8&*+*-(!%&!>;:>&B,;!%M>-%&-! =:*+:%&-!C+*P!B('*M,'$(!C$*M!B,++/+>$!'*!9/0?B,++/+>$!>&>+(9%9 #8,!/9,!*C!F>&*A%-8'!F#7!'*!M,>9/$,!,R*9*M,9!>&;!*'8,$!&>&*9%O,;!0%*+*-%B>+!N>$'%B+,9

B&&C!DEF2+:5,!/+!/12G/+G!2+E!.@5-2+*,./:,!0,/+G!+2+*.5:@+*4*G/:24!.**4, @]f#DU]FG!<$*[,B'!8%-8+%-8'9 @>-&,'%B!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!C*$!>;:>&B,;!@VD!%M>-%&-!>&;!8(N,$'8,$M%> U/&B'%*&>+%O>'%*&!*C!M>-&,'%B!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!C*$!'8,$>&*9'%B9 F>&*N>$'%B+,9!>&;!>;:>&B,;!@VD!;,',B'%*&!>&;!%M>-%&- )+%&%B>+!/9,!*C!M>-&,'%B!&>&*N>$'%B+,9 F,P!;,:%B,9!0>9,;!*&!>;:>&B,;!%M>-%&-

B&&&C!)40,.5-J!%2-G5.5E!+2+*9@2-12:50./:24,!2+E!E/2G+*,./:, \:,$:%,P!*C!'>$-,',;!&>&*N8>$M>B,/'%B>+9!>&;!;%>-&*9'%B9!B+/9',$!>B'%:%'( U*+>',?0>9,;!&>&*0%*;,:%B,9!C*$!%&',-$>',;!;%>-&*9%9a'8,$>N(!'>$-,'%&-!B8$*&%B!%&C+>MM>'*$(!;%9,>9,9 A>:,@,G!7!M*;/+>$!>B'%:,!&>&*?N+>'C*$M!C*$!>;:>&B,;!B>&B,$!M>&>-,M,&'!o!)*$,!&>&*9(9',M91!'/M*/$!'>$-,'%&-!>&;!N,&,'$>'%*&1!M*+,B/+>$!%M>-%&-!>&;!;,-$>;*M,!0>9,;!'8,$>N( L!@%B$*&G!@/+'%M*;>+%'(!M%B$*0>++**&9

B&KC!&12G/+G!:544!2+E!./,,05!/+.5-2:./*+!L/.@!+2+*12.5-/24, 7;:>&B,;!M*;,+9!C*$!%M>-%&-!B>&B,$ F>&*'*R%B*+*-(!%MN+%B>'%*&9!%&!F>&*M,;%B%&,G!/&>&9P,$,;!W/,9'%*&9!>&;!C/'/$,!;%$,B'%*&9 DM>-%&-!B,++!>&;!'%99/,!%&',$>B'%*&!P%'8!&>&*M>',$%>+9G!U$*M!2.!'*!L.!M*;,+9 V>M>&!9N,B'$*9B*N(!%&!B+%&%B>+!;%>-&*9'%B9 X%-8!B*&',&'!9B$,,&%&-!*C!B,++/+>$!$,9N*&9,!'*!&>&*M>',$%>+9!%&',$>B'%*&!>9!%M>-%&-!>&;!;,B%9%*&?M>Q%&-!'**+

!!

Page 14: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

H!!

B&C!DEF2+:5,!/+!/12G/+G!2+E!E/2G+*,./:,!0,/+G!+2+*.5:@+*4*G/:24!.**4,!

! !

n/>&'/M!.*'9!

E>$B*;,;!@>-&,'%B!F>&*P%$,9!

XF<9!

<+>9@>-!

Page 15: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

43!c!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

(2+*.5:@+*4*GP!/+!E/2G+*,./:!1*+/.*-/+G!2+E!.-52.15+.!*6!:2+:5-J!DEF2+:5,!/+!1*45:042-!/12G/+G!`/$%!_*+Q*:b .,N>$'M,&'!*C!)+%&%B>+!@,;%B%&,1!AB8**+!*C!@,;%B%&,1!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&1!D$,+>&;6

!

_0-/!K*4?*FY!BQ@8Y!"8Y!"DY!'%)8C!

`/$%!_*+Q*:!$,B,%:,;!8%9!@.!C$*M!'8,!@*9B*P!@,;%B>+!]&%:,$9%'(!>&;!9/09,W/,&'+(!>!<8.!%&!0%*M,;%B>+!9B%,&B,9!C$*M!'8,!D&9'%'/',!*C!DMM/&*+*-(1!@*9B*P6!X,!%9!>!<$*C,99*$!>'!'8,!.,N>$'M,&'!*C!)+%&%B>+!@,;%B%&,!>&;!C*$M,$!.%$,B'*$!*C!V,9,>$B8!>'!'8,!AB8**+!*C!@,;%B%&,1!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&!T#).S6!<$*C6!_*+Q*:!B**$;%&>',9!>!+>$-,?9B>+,!=]!U<?I!N$*[,B'[email protected]#V=7@1!C*$!,>$+(!;%>-&*9'%B9!>&;!M*&%'*$%&-!*C!M>+%-&>&'!;%9,>9,91!P%'8!22!=/$*N,>&!>B>;,M%B1!$,9,>$B81!B+%&?%B>+!>&;!%&;/9'$%>+!N>$'&,$96!X,!%9!'8,!+,>;!#).!N>$'&,$!C*$!'8,!=]!U<?I!N$*[,B'1!@]f#DU]F1!>&;!<$%&B%N>+!D&:,9'%->'*$!*&!>!&/M0,$!*C!*'8,$!-$>&'96!<$*C6!_*+Q*:!%9!'8,!>/'8*$!*C!*:,$!433!9B%,&'%C%B!N/0+%B>'%*&91!%&B+/;%&-!>$'%B+,9!>&;!0**Q!B8>N?',$91!>&;!8,!%9!>&!%&:,&'*$!*&!9,:,$>+!N>',&'96! !

1

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

D&! C>B'1! %'! %9! C*$,9,,&! '8>'! >;:>&B,9! %&! M*+,B/+>$!%M>-%&-!C*$!!"#$!$' >&; %&!$!%&' $,9,>$B8!P%++!0,!C*B/9,;!*&!%&B$,>9%&-!'8,!9N,B%C%B%'(1!9,&9%'%:%'(!>&;!$,+%>0%+%'(!*C!B+%&%B>+1! +>0*$>'*$(! >&;! N*%&'?*C?B>$,! ;,:%B,96! #8,[email protected]#V=7@ N$*[,B'! %9! 0/%+'! *&! '8,! %&&*:>'%:,! B*&?B,N'9! *C! 9/N,$?9,&9%'%:,! >&;! 8%-8+(! 9N,B%C%B! d+>0?*&?>?0,>;e1! d+>0?*&?>?B8%Ne! >&;! d+>0?*&?>?P%$,e! &>&*?;,:%B,91! P8%B8 /'%+%O, N8*'*+/M%&,9B,&'1! N+>9M*&%B1!M>-&,'%B! >&;! &*&?+%&,>$! *N'%B>+! N$*N,$'%,9! *C! B,$'>%&!&>&*M>',$%>+96! #8%9!*CC,$9! -$*/&;?0$,>Q%&-! >;:>&'>-,9!

2

*:,$!N$,9,&'!',B8&*+*-%,9!%&!',$M9!*C!9'>0%+%'(1!9,&9%'%:%?'(1!'%M,!*C!>&>+(9%91!N$*0,!M/+'%N+,R%&-1!>99>(!M%&%>'/$%?O>'%*&1!$,N$*;/B%0%+%'(1!B*9'!>&;!9>C,'(6!

#8$*/-8!'8,! %MN+,M,&'>'%*&!*C!'8,9,! %&&*:>'%*&91!'8,!N$*[,B'!P%++!;,+%:,$ '8,!C*++*P%&-G!T4S!<8*'*+/M%&,9?B,&'! &>&*N>$'%B+,?0>9,;! $,>-,&'9! >&;! ;%>-&*9'%B! B8%N9!C*$! 8%-8! '8$*/-8N/'1! ,>$+(! ;%>-&*9%9! *C! B>&B,$! >&;!'$,>'M,&'! ,CC%B%,&B(! >99,99M,&'b T2S! F>&*N>$'%B+,9 ,&?>0+%&-!N+>9M*&?*N'%B>+!>&;!&*&+%&,>$!*N'%B>+!M*&%'*$%&-!*C!M*+,B/+>$!$,B,N'*$9!P%'8%&!0*;(!C+/%;9!*$!*&!'8,!9/$?C>B,! *C B>&B,$! B,++9b TLS! @/+'%N>$>M,'$%B 9B$,,&%&-! *C!B>&B,$! 0%*M>$Q,$9! %&! ;%>-&*9'%B! M>',$%>+! /9%&-! 9,-?M,&',;! M>-&,'%B! &>&*P%$,9b! TKS! _>+%;>'%*&! *C! &>&*?'**+9!C*$!,>$+(!;%>-&*9%9!>&;!8%-8+(!%MN$*:,;!9N,B%C%B%'(!%&!B>&B,$!$,9,>$B8!>&;!T5S!\=).?B*MN+%>&'!&>&*M>',$%?>+9!P%'8!%MN$*:,;!9'>0%+%'(1!9%-&>+!9'$,&-'8!>&;!0%*B*M?N>'%0%+%'(6

.%$,B'!+,>;!/9,$9!*C!'8,!$,9/+'9!P%++!0,!'8,!;%>-&*9?'%B! >&;! M,;%B>+! %M>-%&-! ;,:%B,! B*MN>&%,9! %&:*+:,;! %&!'8,!B*&9*$'%/M1 >+*&-!P%'8! B+%&%B>+! >&;! >B>;,M%B! N>$'?&,$96!

Page 16: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!!

;;!Z!< > - , !!

TDS!!7;:>&B,9!%&!%M>-%&-!>&;!;%>-&*9'%B9!/9%&-!&>&*',B8&*+*-%B>+!'**+9!

O2-1*+/:!+2+*92-./:45,!6*-!3/*423544/+G!f/%-%!E*&>B%&>1!^7<?E%*N8*'*&%B91!]&%:,$9%'(!*C!^,&,:>1!^,&,:>1!AP%'O,$+>&;6!

!

$0/G/!R*+2:/+2Y!Q@8!

f/%-%!E*&>B%&>!*0'>%&,;!>!@>9',$!;,-$,,!%&!\N'%B9!C$*M!'8,!]&%:,$9%'(!*C!@%+>&!%&!4HHH6!A/BB,99%:,+(1!8,!M*:,;!'*!'8,!=B*+,!<*+(',B8&%W/,!Um;m$>+,!;,! f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

1

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p!433!&MS!*C!;%C?C,$,&'! M>',$%>+9! TlF0\L1! E%U,\L1! f%F0\L1! l#<1! ,'B6S!

2

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

Page 17: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

42!c!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

Q42,1*+/:!12G+5./:!E5.5:./*+!6*-!2EF2+:5E!:4/+/:24!E/2G+*,./:,!k*,$-!AB8*'',$41!A',C>&!AB8$%''P%,9,$41!U$>&Q!f/;P%-21!k>&!.%,BQ8*CC21!l>',$%&>!A*/+>&'%B>L1!^/%++>/M,!_%>/L1!A,$-%*!@*O*!f,&'%[*L1!)*+%&!A,+CK1!<>'$%BQ!X*+,51!k*>&&>!A/++%:>&51!7&&,-$,'!^/,&'8,$Z1!7&;$,>9!#9B8*,N,Zb!T4S!X,>+'8!>&;!=&:%?$*&M,&'!.,N>$'M,&'1!7/9'$%>&!D&9'%'/',!*C!#,B8&*+*-(1!7/9'$%>b!T2S1!D&9'%'/',!*C!=+,B'$%B>+!@,>9/$,M,&'!>&;!U/&;>M,&?'>+!=+,B'$%B>+!=&-%&,,$%&-1!#,B8&%B>+!]&%:,$9%'(!E$>/&9B8P,%-1!^,$M>&(b!TLS!DFA71!]<A1!f<)F\1!>&;!)FVA1!]&%:,$9%'m!;,!#*/+*/9,1!f<)F\1!U$>&B,b!TKS!A,+,B'%:,!7&'%0*;%,9!f';61!]&%',;!l%&-;*Mb!T5S!F>&*A%-8'!f';61!]&%',;!l%&-;*Mb!TZS!]&%?:,$9%'>,'!;,9!A>>$+>&;,91!=RN,$%M,&'>+N8(9%Q1!^,$M>&(6!!

!

`*5-G!T:@*..5-Y!Q@8!

k*,$-!AB8*'',$!%9!>!9'>CC!9B%,&'%9'!>'!'8,!@*+,B/+>$!.%>-&*9'%B9!0/9%&,99!/&%'!*C!'8,!7/9'$%>&!D&9'%'/',!*C!#,B8&*+*-(!T7D#S6!X%9!N$%M>$(!9B%,&'%C%B! %&',$,9'! %9!'8,!>NN+%B>'%*&!*C!M>-&,'%B!',B8&%W/,9!'*!M*+,B/+>$!;%>-&*9'%B91!P8%B8! %&B+/;,9!0*'8!8,',$*-,&,*/9!M>-&,'*$,9%9'>&B,?0>9,;!0%*9,&9*$9!>&;!+>0?*&?>?B8%N!9(9',M9!>9!P,++!>9!8*M*-,&,*/9!&>&*N>$'%B+,?0>9,;!M*+,B/+>$!;,',B'%*&!M,'8*;96!!

k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

1

h,! %&'$*;/B,! >! &,P! 0%*9,&9*$! B*&B,N'! T;,&*',;! >9!q<+>9@>-g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g9!$*'>'%*&>+!;(&>M%B96!)*M?N>$,;! '*! ,R%9'%&-! &>&*N>$'%B+,?0>9,;! 8*M*-,&,*/9!%MM/&*;%>-&*9'%B!M,'8*;91!*/$!>NN$*>B8!N$*M%9,9! '*!B*M0%&,!,>9,!*C!/9,1!M%&%M/M!9>MN+,!N$,N>$>'%*&!>&;!>!9%MN+,!9,'/N!P%'8!8%-8!>&>+(',!9,&9%'%:%'(6!

h,! N$,9,&'! M*;,+! B>+B/+>'%*&9! *C! '8,! *N'%B>+1!M>-&,'%B!>&;!8(;$*;(&>M%B!N$*N,$'%,9!*C!0*'8! '8,!$,?W/%$,;! &>&*N>$'%B+,9!>&;!M,>9/$,M,&'! B*&;%'%*&96!7B?B*$;%&-!'*!'8,9,1!B*$,?98,++!&>&*$*;9!P%'8!>!B*0>+'!B*$,!9/$$*/&;,;!0(!>!-*+;! 98,++! >-%'>',;!0(!>!$*'>'%&-!M>-?&,'%B! C%,+;! >$,! 0,9'! 9/%',;! C*$! */$! 0%*9,&9%&-! N$%&B%N+,6!

2

h8%+,!P,!B/$$,&'+(!9'$%:,! '*! 9(&'8,9%O,! 9/B8!&>&*$*;91!P,!9'%++!8>:,!'*!9*+:,!9'>0%+%'(!%99/,9!*C!$,9N,B'%:,!&>&*?$*;! ;%9N,$9%*&96! #8/91! >9! >&! %&',$M,;%>',! 9*+/'%*&! P,!;,M*&9'$>',! '8,! q<+>9@>-g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aMM26!!

\/$! $,9/+'9! 9/BB,99C/++(! B*&C%$M! '8,! '8,*$,'%B>+!M*;,+!B>+B/+>'%*&9!*&!'8,!$*'>'%*&>+!0,8>:%*/$!*C!M>-?&,'%B!&>&*$*;!;%9N,$9%*&91! '8/9! 9,$:%&-!>9!>! C%$9'!N$**C!*C!'8,!q<+>9@>-g!B*&B,N'6!

Page 18: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!!

;M!Z!< > - , !!

TDS!!7;:>&B,9!%&!%M>-%&-!>&;!;%>-&*9'%B9!/9%&-!&>&*',B8&*+*-%B>+!'**+9!

a02+.01!E*.,!2,!640*-5,:5+.!9-*35,!6*-!2EF2+:5E!/12G/+G!7+,&>!A/Q8>&*:>41!X%+>+!X>C%>&21!k,>&?@>$B!@%++*'21!@%B8,+!<+/*'12!k>BW/,9!X6@6!)*8,&12!<>'$%BQ!)8>M,9L1!.>&%,+!E>'(L1!>&;!D-*$!F>0%,:41Kb!T4S!AB8**+!*C!@,;%B%&,1!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&1!D$,+>&;b!T2S!f>0*$>'*%$,!;,!V,B8,$B8,!,&!F>&*9B%,&B?,91!]&%:,$9%'m!;,!V,%M9!)8>MN>-&,?7$;,&&,1!V,%M91!U$>&B,b!TLS!D&9,$M!]43ZJ!>&;!)FVA!]@VI25J!)V)@1!D&9'%'/'!<>*+%?)>+M,'',91!7%R?@>$9,%++,!]&%:,$9%'m1!@>$9,%++,1!U$>&B,b!TKS!f>0*$>'*$(!*C!F>&*?E%*,&-%&,,$%&-1!F>'%*&>+!V,9,>$B8!F/B+,>$!]&%:,$9%'(!Tr@*9B*P!=&-%&,,$%&-!<8(9%B9!D&9'%'/',rS1!@*9B*P1!V/99%>&!U,;,$>'%*&6!!

!

Q-*67!&G*-!(23/5FY!Q@8Y!8T:/!

D-*$!F>0%,:!$,B,%:,;!8%9!<8.!%&!<8(9%B9!>&;!@>'8,M>'%B9!%&!4HJL!C$*M!f*M*&*9*:!@*9B*P!A'>',!]&%:,$9%'(!>&;!8%9!.AB!;,-$,,! %&!)8,M%9'$(!C$*M!'8,!A8,M(>Q%&! D&9'%'/',!*C!E%**$->&%B!)8,M%9'$(!*C!'8,!V/99%>&!7B>;,M(!*C!AB%,&B,96!7C',$!N$*C,99*$98%N9! %&!'8,!]A7!>&;!U$>&B,1!8,!P>9!&*M%&>',;1! %&!4HHK1!>9! C/++!<$*C,99*$!*C!E%*N8(9%B9! %&! '8,!]&%:,$9%'(!*C!V,%M9!)8>MN>-&,?7$;,&&,1!U$>&B,6!D&!233Ji233H!<$*C6!F>0%,:!P>9!>!$,B%N%,&'!*C!'8,!h>+'*&!7P>$;!C$*M!'8,!AB%,&B,!U*/&;>'%*&!*C! D$,+>&;6!A%&B,!2343!8,!8>9!0,,&!.%$,B'*$!*C!#,B8&*+*-%B>+!<+>'C*$M!A,M%B*&;/B'*$!F>&*B$(9'>+9!*C!'8,!df>$-,e!=/$*N,>&!<$*[,B'[email protected]#V=7@6!!

7'! '8,! ,&;!*C! 23441! <$*C6!F>0%,:! $,B,%:,;! >!@=^7?-$>&'! %&! '8,! C$>M,P*$Q!*C! '8,! <$*-$>M!*C!7''$>B'%*&!*C! '8,!h*$+;! f,>;%&-! AB%,&'%9'9! '*! V/99%>&! D&9'%'/'%*&9! *C! X%-8,$! =;/B>'%*&! >&;! C*/&;,;! '8,! f>0*$>'*$(! *C! F>&*?E%*,&-%&,,$%&-!%&!'8,!F>'%*&>+!V,9,>$B8!F/B+,>$!]&%:,$9%'(!r@*9B*P!=&-%&,,$%&-!<8(9%B9!D&9'%'/',6!! !

1

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n.S!'P*?N8*'*&!>0?9*$N'%*&!B$*99?9,B'%*&9!T#<7)AS!>$,!*$;,$9!*C!M>-&%'/;,!0%--,$1! M>Q%&-! '8,M! '8,! 0,9'! C+/*$,9B,&'! +>0,+! '*! 0,!/9,;!C*$!M/+'%N8*'*&!%M>-%&-6!

h%'8! >! M*+,B/+>$! P,%-8'! *C! *&+(! 4L! Q.>1! 9%&-+,?;*M>%&! >&'%0*;%,9! T9;709S! >$,! '8,! 9M>++,9'! 70! C$>-?M,&'9! B>N>0+,! *C! 0%&;%&-! '8,%$! >&'%-,&9!P%'8! >CC%&%'%,9!B*MN>$>0+,!'*!B*&:,&'%*&>+!7096!7!9;70!%9!*&+(!4a42!>9!+>$-,! %&! :*+/M,! >9! >! B*&:,&'%*&>+! D-^! M*+,B/+,1! >&;!'8,%$! 9%O,! >++*P9! '8,M! '*! 0%&;! ,N%'*N,9! %&>BB,99%0+,! '*!B*&:,&'%*&>+!D-^96! D&!>;;%'%*&!'*!'8,%$!9M>++!9%O,1!9;709!>$,! B8>$>B',$%O,;! 0(! >! +*P! ',&;,&B(! '*! >--$,->',1! ;%C?C/9,!M/B8!0,'',$!%&!'%99/,9!'8>&!C/++?9%O,!D-^91!>&;!'8,%$!

2

9%O,! >++*P! '8,M! '*! +>0,+! '8%&&,$! >&;! M*$,! ;%9'>+! 9,-?M,&'96!#8,9,!>;:>&'>-,9!M>Q,!9;709!'8,!0,9'!B>N'/$,!M*+,B/+,9!'*!N$,N>$,!n.?0>9,;!C+/*$,9B,&'!&>&*N$*0,9!C*$!0%*;,',B'%*&!>&;!;%>-&*9'%B96!

h,!8>:,! $,B,&'+(!;,:,+*N,;! >!N$*'*B*+! C*$!8%-8+(!*$%,&',;! B*&[/->'%*&! *C! 9;709!P%'8!n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n.!B*&[/->',9!*C!n.9!P%'8!9;7091!>NN+%,;!'8,M!'*!%M>-%&-!*C! &*$M>+! B*+*&! ,N%'8,+%/M! >&;! N>'8*+*-%B>+! 8/M>&!B*+*&!B>$B%&*M>!>&;!;,',$M%&,;!'8,!*N'%M>+!B*&;%'%*&9!C*$!'P*?N8*'*&!'%99/,!%M>-%&-!P%'8!'8%9!&>&*N$*0,!>&;!>B8%,:,;! '8,! 8%-8,9'! $>'%*! *C! '8,! C+/*$,9B,&B,! 9%-&>+!C$*M! 9;70?n.! '*! '8,! '%99/,! >/'*C+/*$,9B,&B,! ,&9/$%&-!B+,>$!;%9B$%M%&>'%*&!*C!'/M*$!>$,>9!C$*M!&*$M>+!'%99/,6!!

Page 19: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

4K!c!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

(2+*.5:@+*4*GP!/+!2EF2+:5E!/12G/+G!.>&%,+!)%,N%,+,P9Q%b!FDl\F!7^!D&9'$/M,&'91!<>$%91!U$>&B,6!

!

!

82+/54!)/59/545L,?/!

.>&%,+!)%,N%,+,P9Q%!%9!'8,!A>+,9!>&;!@>$Q,'%&-!@>&>-,$!>'!FDl\F!7^!D&9'$/M,&'9!TAP%'O,$+>&;S1!>!$*+,!8,!8>9!8,+;!9%&B,!23426!U$*M!2332!'*!2342!8,!P*$Q,;!>'!FDl\F!U$>&B,!A7A!D&9'$/M,&'9!T)8>MN%-&(!9/$!@>$&,!a!U$>&B,S1!P8,$,!8,!B*:?,$,;!9,:,$>+!C/&B'%*&9!9/B8!>9!M,>9/$%&-!N$*;/B'!9N,B%>+%9'1!>NN+%B>'%*&!,&-%&,,$!>&;!N$*;/B'!9N,B%>+%9'!%&!%M>-,9!>&>+?(9%91! 9N,B%>+%9'! B*&9/+'>&'! 9N,>Q,$! %&!]&%:,$9%'%,91! ',B8&%B>+!>&;!9>+,9! 9/NN*$'! C*$!,RN*$'!0/9%&,991!=/$*N,>&!9*C'P>$,!B**$;%&>'*$! C*$! %&;/9'$%>+! >&;!M>',$%>+! 9B%,&B,91! ',B8&%B>+! >&;! 9>+,9!M>&>-,$! *C! '8,! %&;/9'$%>+! >&;!M>',$%>+! 9B%,&B,9!9>+,9!',>M1!>&;!%&',$;%9B%N+%&>$(!0/9%&,99!,&-%&,,$!s!F>&*9B*N(!D?A<#aA#\V@!N$*;/B'!AN,B%>+%9'6!@$6!)%,N%,+,P9Q%!*0?'>%&,;! 8%9! =&-%&,,$! .%N+*M>! %&! <8(9%B9! >&;! D&9'$/M,&'>'%*&! >'! '8,! =B*+,! A/Nm$%,/$,! ;gD&-m&%,/$! ;g7&&,B(! U$>&B,! %&!23321!>&;!8%9!2!(,>$9!',B8&%B>+!;,-$,,!.]#!%&!<8(9%B>+!@,>9/$,9!9N,B%>+%'(! D&9'$/M,&'>+!#,B8&%W/,9!>'!'8,!]&%:,$9%'(!D&9'%'/',!*C!#,B8&*+*-(!*C!)+,$M*&'!U,$$>&;?U$>&B,! %&!4HHH6!7'!F%Q*&!7^!8,!N$,9,&'+(!M>&>-,9! '8,! D&9'$/M,&'9!.,?N>$'M,&'6!! !

1

f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

A/N,$?$,9*+/'%*&!M%B$*9B*N,!9(9',M9!F?AD@!T9'$/B?'/$,;! %++/M%&>'%*&!M%B$*9B*N(S!>&;!F?A#\V@!TA'*B8>9?'%B!\N'%B>+!V,B*&9'$/B'%*&!@%B$*9B*N(S!>$,!N$,9,&',;!>9!M,'8*;9! '8>'! B8>++,&-,! '8,! ;%CC$>B'%*&! +%M%'6! A/N,$?$,9*+/'%*&! %M>-%&-!>++*P9!C*$!9%&-+,!M*+,B/+,!;,',B'%*&!>&;! +*B>+%O>'%*&1! N$*:%;%&-! '8,!>0%+%'(! '*! C*++*P! B,++/+>$!M,B8>&%9M9! 9/B8!>9! '8,!;(&>M%B9!*C! '$>&9B$%N'%*&! C>B?'*$91!>9!>&!,R>MN+,6!

2

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lF0\L! &>&*B(9'>+9! B*>',;! P%'8! *$! lF0\L! A)XVD@<g9!B*>',;!P%'8!<=^!%&!9',M!B,++!9>MN+,96!

Page 20: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!!

;A!Z!< > - , !!

TDS!!7;:>&B,9!%&!%M>-%&-!>&;!;%>-&*9'%B9!/9%&-!&>&*',B8&*+*-%B>+!'**+9!

NF*4F/+G!64*L!:P.*15.-P!6-*1!:544042-!.*!,03^:544042-!2+24P,/,!U$>&9!F>/P,+>,$91!f%&,!.,!l%MN,1!#%&>!_>&!;,&!E$*,BQb!E.!E%*9B%,&B,9!E,+-%/M1!=$,M0*;,-,M1!E,+-%/M6!!

!

'-2+,!(20L5425-,Y!Q@8!

U$>&9!F>/P,+>,$9! %9!.%$,B'*$!*C! AB%,&'%C%B!7CC>%$9! >'!E.!E%*9B%,&B,9! =/$*N,6!X%9!N$%M>$(! 9B%,&'%C%B! %&',$,9'9! >$,! %&! '8,!C%,+;9!*CG! +,/Q>,M%>1!M%&%M>+!$,9%;/>+!;%9,>9,1!9',M!B,++91!>/'*?%MM/&,!;%9*$;,$91!>++,$-(!$,9,>$B81!N+>',+,'!>B'%:>'%*&!>&;!0+**;!0>&Q!n)!>99>(96!!

U$>&9!F>/P,+>,$9!P>9!0*$&!%&!@,B8,+,&1!E,+-%/M!%&!4HKJ6!X,!-$>;/>',;!C$*M!'8,!]&%:,$9%'(!*C!f,/:,&!P8,$,!8,!,>$&,;!8%9!<8.!%&!<8(9%B>+!)8,M%9'$(!%&!4HIK6!X,!P>9!$,9,>$B8!>99%9'>&'!>'!'8,!+>0*$>'*$(!*C!#8$*M0*9%9!>&;!X>,M*9'>?9%9!>&;!>99%9'>&'!>'!'8,!),&'$>+!)+%&%B>+!f>0*$>'*$(!*C!'8,!7B>;,M%B!X*9N%'>+!A'!V>N8>,+!%&!f,/:,&!/&'%+!4HJ36!U$*M!4HJ31!8,![*%&,;!'8,!C+*P!B('*M,'$(!;%:%9%*&!TE.!U7)A!A(9',M9S!*C!E,B'*&!.%BQ%&9*&!P8,$,!8,!8,+;!9,:,$>+!M>&>-,M,&'!N*9%?'%*&9! C$*M!4HJ3!'*!4HH36!U$*M!4HH3!/&'%+!4HHZ!8,!P>9!^,&,$>+!@>&>-,$!>&;!_%B,!<$,9%;,&'!*C!E.! DM>-,!)('*M,'$(!A(9',M9!%&!f,%;,&1!'8,!F,'8,$+>&;96!X,!P>9!^,&,$>+!@>&>-,$!*C!F,*<>'8!=/$*N,!C$*M!4HHI!'8$*/-8!4HHH!>&;!0,B>M,!.%$,B'*$!*C!AB%,&'%C%B!7CC>%$9!C*$!E.!E%*9B%,&B,9!%&!4HHH1!>!N*9%'%*&!8,!M>%&'>%&,;!/&'%+!'8,!N$,9,&'!'%M,6! !

1

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j6!

#8,! ,:*+/'%*&! *C! '8,! *N'%B>+! N>'8! '**Q! >0*/'! L3!(,>$9!'*!B*M,!'*!'8,!%&',-$>',;!;,9%-&!>:>%+>0+,!'*;>(6!D&!,99,&B,1!'8,!*$%-%&>+!N>'8!;,9%-&,;!$,C+,B',;!M/B8!*C!'8,! C+/*$,9B,&B,!M%B$*9B*N,! 9,'/N1! 0/'! '8%9! 8>9! 0,,&!*N'%M%O,;! 9(9',M>'%B>++(! >&;! -$>;/>++(! C$*M! B*++,B'%*&!+,&9!'*!<@#!'*!C%+',$!*:,$!'8,!(,>$96!f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

2

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

Page 21: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

4Z!c!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

%@5! 0,5! *6! (2+*T/G@.! (%D! .*! 152,0-5! 5W*,*15,! 2+E! *.@5-! +2+*,/b5E! 3/*4*G/:24!92-./:45,!<>'$%BQ!X*+,b!F>&*9%-8'1!@>+:,$&!D&9'$/M,&'9!f';61!@%&'*&!<>$Q1!f*&;*&!V*>;1!7M,90/$(1!]l6!!X,$,!P,!;%9B/99!'8,!F>&*N>$'%B+,!#$>BQ%&-!7&>+(9%9!TF#7S!',B8&%W/,! '8>'! 9%O,9! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! %&! 9/9N,&9%*&1! 0>9,;!*&!'8,%$!E$*P&%>&!M*'%*&!*&!>!N>$'%B+,?0(?N>$'%B+,!0>9%91!>&;! >+9*! (%,+;9! ;%$,B'+(! >! B*/&'aB*&B,&'$>'%*&!M,>9/$,?M,&'6!#8%9!',B8&%W/,!8>9!0,,&!,R',&9%:,+(!>NN+%,;!'*!'8,!M,>9/$,M,&'!*C!>!P%;,! $>&-,!*C!&>&*M>',$%>+9! 9/B8!>9!,R*9*M,91! :%$/9,9! >&;! _f<91! +%N*9*M,91! N$*',%&! >--$,?->',91!0>B',$%>!>9!P,++!>9!>!$>&-,!*C!,&-%&,,$,;!&>&*N>$?'%B+,9!C*$!'8,%$!/9,!>9!;$/-!;,+%:,$(!&>&*N>$'%B+,96!

#*! ;>',1! ,R*9*M,9! $,9,>$B8! 8>9! 0,,&! B*&9'$>%&,;!0(!>!+>BQ!*C!9/%'>0+,!M,'8*;9!C*$!B8>$>B',$%O>'%*&6!F>&*?N>$'%B+,! #$>BQ%&-! 7&>+(9%9! TF#7S! >;;$,99,9! '8%9! &,,;6!!F#7! >++*P9! 9N,B%C%B! ,R*9*M,9! >&;! M%B$*:,9%B+,9! %&! '8,!

$>&-,!*C!53o4333&M!%&! +%W/%;!9/9N,&9%*&!'*!0,!;%$,B'+(!>&;!%&;%:%;/>++(!:%9/>+%O,;!>&;!B*/&',;!%&!$,>+?'%M,6!#8,!',B8&%W/,! %9!,>9(! '*!/9,1! C>9'1! $*0/9'1!>BB/$>',!>&;!B*9'!,CC,B'%:,1! $,N$,9,&'%&-! >&! >''$>B'%:,! >+',$&>'%:,! *$! B*M?N+,M,&'! '*!,R%9'%&-!M,'8*;96!\N,$>'%*&! %&! C+/*$,9B,&B,!M*;,!,&>0+,9!B8>$>B',$%O>'%*&!>&;!9N,B%>'%*&!*C!9/%'>0+(!+>0,++,;! N>$'%B+,9! /9%&-! >! $>&-,! *C! ,RB%'>'%*&! P>:,?+,&-'896!

=R>MN+,9!*C!'8,!B8>$>B',$%O>'%*&!*C!9,:,$>+!*C!'8,9,!P%++! 0,! ;%9B/99,;! 8%-8+%-8'%&-! '8,! B$/B%>+! N>$>M,',$9! %&!,>B8!B>9,! T9/B8!>9! 9%O,!;%9'$%0/'%*&1!B*&B,&'$>'%*&1! C+/*?$,9B,&B,S!>+*&-!P%'8!98>$%&-!9',N9!'8>'!8>:,!0,,&!'>Q,&!'*!*N'%M%O,!9/B8!M,>9/$,M,&'96!

Q2.-/:?!O*45Y!Q@8!

.$! <>'$%BQ! X*+,! %9! X,>;! *C! .,:,+*NM,&'! C*$! F>&*A%-8'! >'!@>+:,$&! D&9'$/M,&'9! f';61! >! &>&*N>$'%B+,! B8>$>B',$%O>'%*&!B*MN>&(1!N$*:%;%&-!%&9'$/M,&'9!'*!0*'8!Vs.!>&;!n7!B/9'*M,$9!'8>'!8>9!-$*P&!%&!9%O,!>&;!$,N/'>'%*&!$>N%;+(!*:,$!'8,!+>9'!C%:,!(,>$96!<>'$%BQ!8>9!P*$Q,;!P%'8!F>&*A%-8'!C*$!9%R!(,>$9!>&;!&*P!M>&>-,9!'8,!;,:,+*NM,&'!*C!0*'8!8>$;P>$,!>&;!9*C'P>$,!>&;!8>9!0$*/-8'!'*!N$*;/B'%*&!'P*!>++?&,P!9(9',M96!X,!%9!B/$$,&'+(!$,9N*&9%0+,!C*$!;,:,+*NM,&'1!N$*;/B?'%*&!>&;!',B8&%B>+!9/NN*$'!W/>+%'(!P%'8%&!@>+:,$&!D&9'$/M,&'9!f';61!M>&>-%&-!>!',>M!*C!4K6!<$,:%*/9+(!8,!B*MN+,',;!8%9!<8.!>'!'8,!\N'*,+,B'$*&%B9!V,9,>$B8!),&'$,!T\V)S!%&!A*/'8>MN'*&!%&!*N'%B9!>&;!,+,B'$*&%B9!>&;!8>9!>!@>9',$g9!.,-$,,!C$*M!]&%:,$9%'(!*C!\RC*$;!%&!=&-%&,,$%&-6! !

Page 22: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

4I!!

B&&C DEF2+:5,!/+!/12G/+G!2+E!.@5-2+*,./:,!0,/+G!+2+*.5:@+*4*G/:24!.**4,!

!! !

Page 23: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

4J!c!< > - , !!

<*-4E!"*45:042-!&12G2/+G!)*+G-5,,!=>;=!

"#$%&'#(J!Q-*S5:.!@/G@4/G@.,!V*;*+C*!@%$>&;>41L1!7%'O%0,$!f6!)*$'>[>$,&>412b!T4S!D@.=7?F>&*B%,&B%>1!]&%:,$9%;>;!7/'t&*M>!;,!@>;$%;!1)>&'*0+>&B*1!2J3KH!@>;$%;1! AN>%&b! T2S!),&'$*!F>B%*&>+!;,!E%*',B&*+*-u>! T)FE?)AD)S! ?! D@.=7!F>&*B%,&B%>!799*B%>',;!]&%'1!]&%:,$?9%;>;!7/'t&*M>!;,!@>;$%;1! )>&'*0+>&B*1!@>;$%;1! AN>%&b! TLS!.,N>$'>M,&'*!;,! Uv9%B>!;,! +>!@>',$%>!)*&;,&9>;>!>&;!D&9'%'/'*!F%B*+w9!)>0$,$>1!]&%:,$9%;>;!7/'t&*M>!;,!@>;$%;1!)>MN/9!]&%:,$9%'>$%*!;,!)>&'*0+>&B*1!@>;$%;1!AN>%&6!

!#8,!>%M!*C! '8,!@]f#DU]F!B*&9*$'%/M! %9! '*!;,:,+*N!>&;!:>+%;>',! >! &*:,+! >&;!M%&%M>++(! %&:>9%:,! &>&*',B8&*+*-(!9(9',M! '*! %MN$*:,! B>&B,$! ;%>-&*9%9! >&;! '$,>'M,&'6!@]f#DU]F! &>&*',B8&*+*-(! %9! 0>9,;! *&! M/+'%C/&B'%*&>+!O,;! M>-&,'%B! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! '*! 9,+,B'%:,+(! '>$-,'! >&;!,+%M%&>',!0$,>9'!>&;!N>&B$,>'%B! B>&B,$! T9',MS!B,++96!#8,!%MN$*:,;!M>-&,'%B! C,>'/$,9!*C! '8,!@]f#DU]F!M>-&,'%B!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!P%++! +,>;! '*!N*',&'%>+!M,;%B>+! >NN+%B>'%*&9!9/B8!>9!B*&'$>9'!>-,&'9!>&;!M>-&,'%B!8,>'%&-!%&;/B'*$96!

@*$,*:,$1! M>-&,'%B! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! >$,! C/&B'%*&>+?%9,;!P%'8! +%->&;91! %&B+/;%&-! '>$-,'%&-! N,N'%;,9! >&;! >&'%?0*;%,9! '*! %&B$,>9,! '8,%$!>CC%&%'(! '*P>$;9!B>&B,$!B,++9! C*$!9,+,B'%:,! ;$/-! ;,+%:,$(! >&;! '*! C>B%+%'>',! ;%>-&*9%9! *C! '/?M*/$9!0(!@VD!M,>&96!

@/+'%C/&B'%*&>+! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! >$,! /9,;! 9%M/+'>&,?*/9+(!>9!C/&B'%*&>+!&>&*B>$$%,$9!>&;!8,>'%&-!%&;/B'*$9!%&!*$;,$! '*! N$*:%;,! >! B*M0%&,;! '8,$>N,/'%B!M*;>+%'(6! #8,!

9(&,$-%9'%B!,CC,B'9!*C!;$/-91!N,N'%;,9!>&;!8,>'!>$,!,:>+/?>',;! '*! ;,',$M%&,! '8,! ,CC,B'%:,&,99! *C! ;%CC,$,&'! '8,$>?N,/'%B! B*M0%&>'%*&96! #8/91!@]f#DU]F!M/+'%M*;>+! '8,$?>N,/'%B! >NN$*>B8! %9! ;,9%-&,;! '*! ,CC%B%,&'+(! $,M*:,! B>&?B,$!B,++9!C$*M!'8,!'/M*/$!9%',6!

#8,! '*R%B%'(! *C! C/&B'%*&>+%9,;! M>-&,'%B! &>&*N>$'%?B+,9!%9!>99,99,;!%&!:%'$*!>&;!%&!:%:*!'*!P>$$>&'!>!9>C,!/9,!>&;! 98,;! 9*M,! +%-8'! *&! '8,! $%9Q96! #8,! ;%9'$%0/'%*&! >&;!>B'%:%'(!,:>+/>'%*&!*C!C/&B'%*&>+%9,;!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!%9!N,$?C*$M,;!%&!8/M>&!0$,>9'!>&;!N>&B$,>'%B!B>&B,$!R,&*-$>C'!M*;,+96!

U%&>++(1! '8,!/9,!*C!&*:,+!M>-&,'%B!&>&*N>$'%B+,9! C*$!0%*M,;%B>+! >NN+%B>'%*&9! N$*:%;,9! *NN*$'/&%'%,9! C*$! ;,?:,+*NM,&'! *C! &,P! %&9'$/M,&'>'%*&! C*$! ;,',B'%*&! >&;!W/>&'%C%B>'%*&! *C!M>-&,'%B! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! %&! 0+**;1! /$%&,!>&;!'%99/,9!>&;!M>-&,'%B!8,>'%&-!%&;/B'%*&6!!

!

\*E*46*!"/-2+E2Y!Q@8!

V*;*+C*!@%$>&;>!-$>;/>',;!%&!<8(9%B9!C$*M!'8,!]&%:,$9%;>;!7/'t&*M>!;,!@>;$%;!T]7@S!%&!4HI56!X,!*0'>%&,;!>!<8.!%&!<8(9%B9!C$*M!'8,!]7@!%&!4HJ3!/&;,$!'8,!;%$,B'%*&!*C!<$*C6!k/>&!@6!V*[*6!V*;*+C*!@%$>&;>!P>9!>!X/M0*+;'!U,++*P!%&!@/&%B8!>&;!E,$+%&!T4HJ4?4HJKS!/&;,$!'8,!9/N,$:%9%*&!*C!<$*C6!.$6!^,$8>$;!=$'+1!F*0,+!<$%O,!%&!)8,M%9'$(!233I6!!

U$*M!@>$B8!4HH31!<$*C6!@%$>&;>!%9!U/++!<$*C,99*$!*C!)*&;,&9,;!@>'',$!<8(9%B9!>'!'8,!]7@6!X,!P>9!,+,B',;!U,++*P!*C!'8,!7M,$%B>&!<8(9%B>+!A*B%,'(!%&!233I1!>&;1!9%&B,!.,B,M0,$!233Z1!%9!.%$,B'*$!*C!'8,!D&9'%'/'*!@>;$%+,x*!;,!=9'/;%*9!7:>&O>;*9!,&!F>&*B%,&B%>!TD@.=7?F>&*B%,&B%>S1!>&!%&9'%'/'%*&!C*9',$%&-!F>&*9B%,&B,!>&;!F>&*',B8&*+*-(!%&!AN>%&6!

X%9!N/0+%B>'%*&9!TM*$,!'8>&!253!0(!&*PS!8>:,!0,,&!9',>;%+(!B%',;!*:,$!M*$,!'8>&!23!(,>$91!'*'>+%O%&-!M*$,!'8>&!I333!B%'>'%*&96!!#8,!N$,9,&'!8!%&;,R!*C!<$*C6!@%$>&;>!%9!KZ6!X,!8>9!;%$,B',;!M*$,!'8>&!K3!N$*[,B'9!>9!<$%&B%N>+!D&:,9'%->?'*$1!L3!<86!.6!#8,9%9!>&;!L3!<*9';*B'*$>+!$,9,>$B8,$96!X,!8>9!-%:,&!M*$,!'8>&!433!D&:%',;!#>+Q9!>'!%&',$&>'%*&>+!B*&C,$?,&B,96!!

<$*C6!@%$>&;>y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f#DU]F!N$*[,B'6!! !

Page 24: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

;H!Z!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

"2G+5./:!+2+*92-./:45,!6*-!2EF2+:5E!"\&!/12G/+G!2+E!@P95-.@5-1/2!@>$%>!;,+!</,$'*!@*$>+,9!X,$$,$*41!^*$Q>!A>+>921!!@>$O%>!@>$B%,++*41!f/Bu>!^/'%m$$,O41!A>0%&*!_,%&',M%++>9?_,$;>-/,$41!)>$+*9!k6!A,$&>4b!T4S!D&9'%'/',!*C!@>',$%>+9!AB%,&B,!*C!@>;$%;1!D)@@a)AD)1!@>;$%;1!AN>%&b!T2S!D@.=7!F>&*B%,&B%>1!)>M?N/9!]&%:,$9%'>$%*!;,!)>&'*0+>&B*1!@>;$%;1!AN>%&6!

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j1!:,$(!-**;!M>-&,'%B!$,9N*&9,!>&;!B*&9,W/,&'?+(!8%-8!F@V!$,+>R%:%'(!N>$>M,',$9!>&;!8,>'%&-!,CC%B%,&B(!T433!ha-!/&;,$!I3!QXO1!K3!M#S1!P8%B8!M>Q,9!'8,&!,RB,+?+,&'! B>&;%;>',9! C*$! B>&B,$! ;%>-&*9%9! >&;! 8(N,$'8,$M%>!'$,>'M,&'9!z4{6!

\&! '8,! *'8,$! 8>&;1! M>-&,'%',! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! 8>:,!0,,&! 9(&'8,9%O,;! 0(! >! 9%MN+,! >W/,*/9! $*/',! 0>9,;! *&!'8,!N$,B%N%'>'%*&!*C!>&!U,TDDS!9>+'!%&!'8,!N$,9,&B,!*C!>!M%+;!*R%;>&'1! P8%B8! +,>;9! '*! 8%-8+(! /&%C*$M! >&;! B$(9'>++%&,!M>-&,'%B! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! P%'8! 9%O,9! 0,'P,,&! L3! >&;! 23!

&M1!9>'/$>'%*&!M>-&,'%O>'%*&!*:,$!J3!,M/a-!>&;!8,>'%&-!B>N>B%'%,9! /N! '*! 233!ha-! /&;,$! I3! QXO1! K3!M#! z2{6! 7&!%MN*$'>&'!,CC*$'!8>9!0,,&!N>%;!*&!'8%9!N$,N>$>'%*&!$*/',!'*!9B>+,!/N!'8,!9(&'8,9%9!/N!'*!23!-$>M9!*C!N>$'%B+,9!>&;!$,>B8!B*++*%;>+!9'>0%+%'(!C*$!+*&-!'%M,!>'!8%-8!&>&*N>$'%B+,!B*&B,&'$>'%*&9! /9%&-! 0%*B*MN>'%0+,! N*+(M,$9! 9/B8! >9!;,R'$>&6!

\N'%M%O>'%*&!*C!M>-&,'%B!N$*N,$'%,9!*C!'8,9,!&>&*?N>$'%B+,9!>+9*!>++*P9!'8,%$!;,',B'%*&!,:,&!>'!+*P!;*9,9!0(!M>-&,'%B! M,'8*;96! .,',B'%*&! >&;! W/>&'%C%B>'%*&! *C! &>?&*N>$'%B+,9!%&!'%99/,9!*$!*$->&9!%9!N*99%0+,!C$*M!'8,!M>-?&,'%O>'%*&!B/$:,9!>&;!7)!9/9B,N'%0%+%'(!B/$:,9!-%:%&-!:>+?/>0+,! %&C*$M>'%*&! >0*/'! &>&*N>$'%B+,! N8>$M>B*Q%&,'%B!>&;!0%*;%9'$%0/'%*&!zL{6!

46 ^6!A>+>9!,'!>+61!k6!@>',$6!)8,M6!22!T2342S1!243Z56!

26 @6!@>$B%,++*!,'!>+61!A/0M%'',;6!

L6 f6!^/'%m$$,O!,'!>+61! k6!<8(96!.G!7NN+6!<8(96!KK! T2344S!2553326!

"2-/2!E54!Q05-.*!"*-245,Y!Q@8!

@>$%>!;,+!</,$'*!@*$>+,9!%9!>!9,&%*$!9B%,&'%9'!>'!'8,!D&9'%'/',!*C!@>',$%>+!AB%,&B,!%&!@>;$%;1!AN>%&!T)AD)S!9%&B,!233J6!X,$!$,9,>$B8!>B'%:%'%,9!>$,!C*B/9,;!*&!'8,!9(&'8,9%9!>&;!B8>$>B',$%O>'%*&!*C!M>-&,'%B!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!C*$!0%*M,;%B%&,6!

@>$%>!;,+!</,$'*!P>9!0*$&!%&!<+>9,&B%>!T)wB,$,91!AN>%&S!%&!4HZZ6!A8,!-*'!8,$!;,-$,,!%&!)8,M%9'$(!0(!'8,!]&%:,$9%'(!*C!A>+>M>&B>!%&!4HJH!>&;!8,$!<86.6!%&!@>',$%>+!AB%,&B,!C$*M!'8,!@>;$%;!7/'*&*M*/9!]&%:,$9%'(!%&!4HHL6!U$*M!4HHK!'*!4HHZ1!98,!P*$Q,;!>9!>!N*9';*B'*$>+!C,++*P!>'!'8,!AB8**+!*C!=+,B'$*&%B!=&-%&,,$%&-!>&;!)*MN/',$!A(9',M9!*C!'8,!]&%:,$?9%'(!*C!h>+,9!T]lS6!X,$!$,9,>$B8!>B'%:%'%,9!>$,!C*B/9,;!*&!'8,!>$,>!*C!&>&*',B8&*+*-(1!%&!N>$'%B/+>$!%&!'8,!9(&'8,9%9!>&;!B8>$>B',$%O>'%*&!*C!M>-&,'%B!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!C*$!0%*M,;%B%&,6!A8,!8>9!>/'8*$,;!9,:,$>+!0**Q!B8>N',$9!%&!'8,!C%,+;!*C!&>?&*N>$'%B+,!9(&'8,9%9!>&;!M*$,!'8>&!4L5!>$'%B+,9! %&! %&',$>B'%*&>+!9B%,&'%C%B! [*/$&>+91!8>9!;%$,B',;!L!;*B'*$>+!'8,9,9!>&;!8>9!-%:,&!&/M,$*/9!B*&C,$,&B,9!>&;!9,M%&>$96!A8,! %9!&*P!'8,!N$%&B%N>+! %&:,9'%->'*$! C$*M!'8,!)AD)!*C! '8,!=/$*N,>&?C/&;,;!$,9,>$B8!N$*[,B'!B>++,;!@]f#DU]F!>&;!$,9N*&9%0+,!C*$!'8,!h*$Q!N>BQ>-,!*&!9(&'8,9%9!*C!M/+'%C/&'%*&>+!M>-&,'?%B!%$*&!*R%;,!&>&*N>$'%B+,96!

!! !

Page 25: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

23!c!< > - , !!

TDDS!!7;:>&B,9!%&!%M>-%&-!>&;!'8,$>&*9'%B9!/9%&-!&>&*',B8&*+*-%B>+!'**+9!

'0+:./*+24/b2./*+!*6!12G+5./:!+2+*92-./:45,!6*-!.@5-2+*,./:,!7%'O%0,$! f6! )*$'>[>$,&>41L1! <%,$$,!)*/+,>/;41!7+C*&9*! f>'*$$,41!@>B>$,&>!)>+,$*4121!7&-,+,9!_%++>&/,:>4121!7+:>$*! A*M*?O>41Lb!T4S!D@.=7?F>&*B%,&B%>1!]&%:,$9%;>;!7/'t&*M>!;,!@>;$%;!1)>&'*0+>&B*1!2J3KH!@>;$%;1!AN>%&b!T2S!.,N>$'>M,&'*!;,!E%*+*-u>1!]&%:,$9%;>;!7/'t&*M>!;,!@>;$%;1!@>;$%;1!AN>%&b!TLS!),&'$*!F>B%*&>+!;,!E%*',B&*+*-u>!T)FE?)AD)S!?!D@.=7!F>&*B%,&B%>!799*B%>',;!]&%'1!]&%:,$9%;>;!7/'t&*M>!;,!@>;$%;1!@>;$%;1!AN>%&6!

!#8,!N$,9,&',;!P*$Q! %9!N>$'!*C!>!=/$*N,>&!<$*[,B'!B>++,;!d@]f#DU]Fe! C*$!@/+'%C/&B'%*&>+%O>'%*&!*C!M>-&,'%B!N>$?'%B+,9!C*$!9,+,B'%:,!B>&B,$!;,',B'%*&!>&;!'$,>'M,&'6!!

X,$,1! P,! N$,9,&'! '8,!M/+'%?C/&B'%*&>+%O>'%*&! *C! ;%?M,$B>N'*9/BB%&%B! >B%;! T.@A7S! B*>',;! %$*&! *R%;,! &>&*?N>$'%B+,9!TF<9S!P%'8!'>$-,'%&-!M*+,B/+,9!>&;!B8,M*'8,$?>N,/'%B! ;$/-96! #8,! .@A7! B*>',;! %$*&! *R%;,! F<9! 8>:,!0,,&!;,:,+*N,;!0(!D)@@?)AD)!%&!B*++>0*$>'%*&!P%'8!D@?.=7?F>&*9B%,&B,! P%'8! 9N,B%C%B! N$*N,$'%,9! C*$! M>-&,'%B!8,>'%&-! >&;a*$! M>-&,'%B! $,9*&>&B,! %M>-%&-6! h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

;,$! 8%-8+(! $,;/B%&-! ,&:%$*&M,&'1! 9/B8! >9! '8>'! N$,9,&'!%&9%;,!'8,!B,++96!

#8,! ;,'>%+,;! B8>$>B',$%O>'%*&! *C! C/&B'%*&>+%9,;!F<9!P%++!0,!N$,9,&',;!>&;!;%9B/99,;6!h,!P%++!>+9*!N$,9,&'!'8,!!"#$!%&'!9'/;%,9!'8>'!98*P!'8,!,CC,B'%:,!'>$-,'%&-!>&;!/N?'>Q,! *C! .@A7! C/&B'%*&>+%O,;! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! 0(! 0$,>9'?B>&B,$!B,++!+%&,96!

!

!!

D/.b/35-!$7!)*-.2S2-5+2Y!Q@8!

.$6! )*$'>[>$,&>! ,>$&,;! 8,$! <8.! %&! E%*B8,M%9'$(! C$*M! '8,! ]&%:,$9%;>;! ;,+! <>u9! _>9B*! %&! 23326! #8,&1! 98,! [*%&,;! '8,!-$*/N!*C!.$6! f6V,->&!>'! `>+,!]&%:,$9%'(1!]A71! >9! >!<*9';*B'*$>+! U,++*P6! A8,!P*$Q,;!*&!N$*',%&!;,9%-&1! 9'$/B'/$,!>&;!C/&B'%*&6!D&!233Z!98,!P>9!_%9%'%&-!AB%,&'%9'!>'!'8,!h,%OM>&&!D&9'%'/',1!D9$>,+1!P%'8!.$6!^6X>$>&!P*$Q%&-!*&!9%&-+,!M*+,?B/+,!9N,B'$*9B*N(6!A8,!B*&'%&/,;!8,$!P*$Q!>'!`>+,!]&%:,$9%'(1!>9!>&!799*B%>',!V,9,>$B8!AB%,&'%9'!P%'8!.$6!V,->&6!A8,![*%&,;!D@.=7!F>&*B%,&B%>!>9!^$*/N!f,>;,$!%&!k>&/>$(!23436!X,$!$,9,>$B8!C*B/9,9!*&!N$*',%&!,&-%&,,$%&-!>&;!-,&,$>?'%*&!*C!0%*C/&B'%*&>+!&>&*9'$/B'/$,9! C*$!>NN+%B>'%*&9! %&!&>&*?0%*',B8&*+*-(!>&;!&>&*?0%*M,;%B%&,6!.$6!)*$'>[>$,&>! %9!P*$Q?N>BQ>-,!+,>;,$!Th<2?@/+'%C/&B'%*&>+%O>'%*&!*C!@F<9S!%&!'8,!@]f#DU]F!N$*[,B'!TU<I?@F<?2343?2Z2HKL?2S6!! !

Page 26: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

=;!Z!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

(2+*92-./:45,!2+E!2EF2+:5E!"\&!E5.5:./*+!2+E!/12G/+G!.%$Q!l$|-,$41!^*$Q>!A>+>921!@>B>$,&>!)>+,$*21!A%+:%>!f*$$%*!^*&Ow+,O41!@>$%>!;,+!</,$'*!@*$>+,9L1!7&-,+,9!_%++>&/,:>2!1!V,&m!@6!E*'&>$4b!T4S!.%:%9%*&!*C!DM>-%&-!AB%,&B,9!s!E%*M,;%B>+!=&-%&,,$%&-1!l%&-g9!)*++,-,!f*&;*&1!f*&;*&1!]&%',;!l%&-;*Mb!T2S!D&9'%'/'*!D@.=7!F>&*B%,&B%>1!@>;$%;1!AN>%&b!TLS!D&9'%'/'*!;,!)%,&B%>!;,!@>',$%>+,9!;,!@>;$%;1!)AD)1!!@>?;$%;1!AN>%&6!

!f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z4{6!X,$,!P,!9*/-8'!'*! %&:,9'%->',! %M>-%&-!N$*N,$'%,9!*C!@F<9!>&;!:>+%;>',!'8,9,!%&!0$,>9'!>&;!N>&B$,>'%B!B>&B,$!B,++!+%&,96!!T03S5:.,! 2+E! "5.@*E,7! h,! /9,;! >! P>',$! N8>&'*M! '*!%&:,9'%->',! '8,! +*&-%'/;%&>+! >&;! '$>&9:,$9>+! $,+>R>'%*&!$>',9!*C!:>$%*/9!@F<!>+*&,!>&;!2K!8*/$9!N*9'!%&B/0>'%*&!P%'8!8/M>&!N>&B$,>'%B!B>$B%&*M>!B,++9!T%6,6!<7F)?4S6!h,!/9,;! >! 2.! M/+'%?-$>;%,&'?,B8*! 9,W/,&B,! T,B8*,9! }! 51!9+%B,!'8%BQ&,99!}!L!MM1!#=!}!46I!M91!#V!}!44!M91!U7!}!25~S!'*! M,>9/$,! #2�! >&;! >! 2.!M/+'%! 9N%&?,B8*! 9,W/,&B,! '*!M,>9/$,!#26!#4!P>9!;,',$M%&,;!0(!/9%&-!>!9,W/,&B,!'8>'!,MN+*(9! 'P*! &*&?9,+,B'%:,! %&:,$9%*&! N/+9,9! P%'8! %&:,$?9%*&! '%M,9! $>&-%&-! C$*M!23!M9! '*!2333!M91! C*++*P,;!0(!,%-8'!9,-M,&',;!$,>;*/'9!C*$!,%-8'!%&;%:%;/>+!%M>-,9!z2{6!

7++! ,RN,$%M,&'9!P,$,! N,$C*$M,;! *&! >! B+%&%B>+! L#! <8%+%N9!7B8%,:>!9B>&&,$6!!\5,04.,7! #8$,,! @F<9! T7.FX1! 7A%! >&;! \.45S! '8>'! 8>:,!0,,&! 9(&'8,9%O,;! %&! '8,! @]f#DU]F! B*&9*$'%/M! TU%-6! 4S!98*P!,RB,++,&'!$4!>&;!$2�!:>+/,9!M>Q%&-!'8,M!N$*M%9%&-!B*&'$>9'! >-,&'! N$*'*'(N,9! C*$! 0*'8! #4! >&;! #2�! %M>-%&-!T'>0!4S6!h,!>+9*!98*P,;!'8>'!@VD!B>&!0,!/9,;!'*!M*&%'*$!'8,!;*9,!;,N,&;,&'!/N'>Q,!*C! '8*9,!&>&*N>$'%B+,9! T,6-6!U45ZLS! 0(! <7F)?4! B>&B,$! B,++9! >9! ;,M*&9'$>',;! 0(! #2�!M>NN%&-6!!

)*+:40,/*+,7!h,! ;,M*&9'$>',! '8>'! '8,! %&:,9'%->',;! &>?&*N>$'%B+,9!8>:,!-**;!@V!%M>-%&-!N$*N,$'%,9!>&;!B>&!0,!/9,;!'*!+>0,+!B>$B%&*M>!B,++!+%&,96!#8,!%&:,9'%->',;!@F<9!98*P!N$*M%9%&-!%M>-%&-!>&;!+>0,++%&-!N$*N,$'%,9!>&;!!P%++!&*P! 0,! %&:,9'%->',;! %&! &/;,! '/M*/$! 0,>$%&-! M%B,!TE#KIK1! @.7?@E?2L41! ER<B?L! <7F)?4S! '*! ,:>+/>',! 0%*?;%9'$%0/'%*&1!9N,B%C%B%'(!>&;!9/%'>0%+%'(!C*$!%&!:%:*!%M>-%&-!>&;!'8,$>N(6!

46 <,&-1!Ä6?X61!,'!>+61!233J6!D&'!k!*C!F>&*M,;1!L1!NN6L44?246!

26 @>Q*P9Q%1!@6V61!,'!>+61!23446!F>'/$,!@,;1!4I1!NN6LJL?JJ6

!

!

Page 27: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

22!c!< > - , !!

TDDS!!7;:>&B,9!%&!%M>-%&-!>&;!'8,$>&*9'%B9!/9%&-!&>&*',B8&*+*-%B>+!'**+9!

!

\5+c!R*.+2-Y!Q@8!

.$6!E*'&>$!$,B,%:,;!8%9!<8.!C$*M!'8,!=#X!Å/$%B86!U$*M!4HHZiHI!8,!P>9!>!V,9,>$B8!799*B%>',!%&!'8,!.,N>$'M,&'!*C!V>?;%*+*-(!>'!'8,!]&%:,$9%'(!Å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Ç'!@|&B8,&!P8,$,!8,!9,'!/N!>!B>$;%>B!@V!N$*-$>M!P%'8!>!9N,B%>+!C*B/9!*&!N$,?B+%&%B>+!>&;!'$>&9+>'%*&>+!M/+'%?M*;>+%'(!%M>-%&-6!X%9!P*$Q!P>9!C/&;,;!0(!'8,!^,$M>&!@%&%9'$(!*C!V,9,>$B8!>&;!=;/B>'%*&1!0(!'8,!^,$M>&!=RB,++,&B,!<$*-$>M1!>&;!0(!%&;/9'$(6!7'!'8,!,&;!*C!233I1!8,![*%&,;!'8,!DM>-%&-!AB%,&B,9!.%?:%9%*&!>'!l%&-g9!)*++,-,!f*&;*&!P8,$,!8,!%9!B/$$,&'+(!)8>%$!*C!)>$;%*:>9B/+>$!DM>-%&-6!.$6!E*'&>$!%9!>!U,++*P!*C!'8,!D&?',$&>'%*&>+!A*B%,'(!*C!@>-&,'%B!V,9*&>&B,!DM>-%&-!%&!@,;%B%&,!>&;!P>9!>!0*>$;!M,M0,$!*C!A*B%,'(!C*$!)>$;%*:>9B/+>$!@>-&,'%B!V,9*&>&B,!C$*M!233J?23446!X,!%9!*&!'8,!9B%,&'%C%B!>;:%9*$(!0*>$;!*C!'8,!X%-8!V%9Q!<+>W/,!%&%'%>'%:,!>&;!%9!>+9*!*&!'8,!,;%'*$%>+!0*>$;!*C! '8,!=/$*N,>&!X,>$'! k*/$&>+G!)>$;%*:>9B/+>$! DM>-%&-6!X,!8>9!>/'8*$,;!M*$,!'8>&!4I5!N,,$?$,:%,P,;!*$%-%&>+!N>N,$91!25!$,:%,P!>$'%B+,9!>&;!23!0**Q!B8>N',$9!%&!'8,!C%,+;!*C!)@V6!X,!>+9*!8*+;9!5!N>',&'9!>&;!%9!>&!,;%'*$!*C!>!)@V!',R'0**Q!*&!)>$;%*:>9B/+>$!@>-&,'%B!V,9*&>&B,!DM>-%&-6!

! !

U%-6!4G!#$>&9M%99%*&!,+,B'$*&!M%B$*9B*N(!T#=@S!%M>-,9!*C!T>S!7.FX1!T0S!7A%!>&;!TBS!\.456!T;S!f%-8'!M%B$*9B*N(!%M>-,!*[email protected]?@E?2L4!B>$B%&*M>!B,++9!P%'8*/'!>&(!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!>&;!T,S!#=@!%M>-,!>C',$!%&B/0>'%*&!P%'8!45!

&M!N>$'%B+,9!T\.45S6!

Page 28: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

=M!Z!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

)4/+/:24!0,5!*6!12G+5./:!+2+*92-./:45,!D&-$%;!X%+-,$b!D&9'%'/',!C*$!.%>-&*9'%B!>&;!D&',$:,&'%*&>+!V>;%*+*-(!D1!k,&>!]&%:,$9%'(!X*9N%'>+1!k,&>1!^,$M>&(6!!@>&(!;%CC,$,&'!&>&*N>$'%B+,9! C*$M/+>'%*&9!8>:,!0,,&!;,:,+*N,;! C*$!0%*M,;%B>+!>NN+%B>'%*&9! %&!;%>-&*9'%B9!>9!P,++!>9!'8,$>N(6!D&!'8%9!B*&',R'1!>!:>$%,'(!*C!;%CC,$,&'!*$->&%B!>&;!%&*$->&%B!M>',$%>+9!>$,!0,%&-!,MN+*(,;6!7M*&-!'8,!%&*$->&%B!C*$M/+>'%*&91! %$*&! *R%;,?0>9,;! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! >$,! :,$(! N$*M%&,&'1! >9! '8,(! 8>:,! >+$,>;(! 0,,&! %&'$*;/B,;! %&'*! B+%&%B>+!N$>B'%B,!9/B8!>9!@VD!>NN+%B>'%*&96!U*$!'8,$>N,/'%B!>NN+%B>'%*&91!$,9,>$B8,$9!;,9%$,!M/+'%C/&B'%*&>+!&>&*N>$'%B+,91!P8%B8!B*M0%&,! 9,+,B'%:,! '>$-,'%&-1! ;%>-&*9'%B9! >&;! '8,$>N(! TP%'8! M>-&,'%B! N$*N,$'%,9! C*$! 8(N,$'8,$M%>! '$,>'M,&'! >&;a*$!9,+,B'%:,!;$/-!$,+,>9,S6!!

U*$!'8,$>N,/'%B!N/$N*9,91!'8,!/'%+%O>'%*&!*C!M>-&,'%B!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!8>:,!0,,&!N$*N*9,;!'*!,CC,B'%:,+(!Q%++!'/M*/$!B,++9! >&;! '/M*/$9! 0(! +*B>+! '8,$M>+! 9'$,991! ,6-6! 0(! 8(N,$'8,$M%>6! D&! -,&,$>+1! 8(N,$'8,$M%>! %&;/B,9! '8$*/-8! B('*'*R%B!',MN,$>'/$,9!N>'8*N8(9%*+*-%B>+!B8>&-,9!*&!>!B,++/+>$!+,:,+!'8>'!/+'%M>',+(!+,>;!'*!B,++!;,>'8!P%'8%&!'8,!'/M*/$!'%99/,6!h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~)!P%'8%&!'8,!'/M*/$6!#8,$,C*$,1!'8,!B*&'$*+!*C!'8,!;,N*9%'%*&!*C!&>&*N>$'%B+,!;*9>-,9!>&;!'8,!8>&;+%&-!*C!'8,!%&'$>'/M*/$>+!;%9'$%0/'%*&!N>'',$&9!>$,!Q,(!C>B'*$9!%&!;,',$M%&%&-!'8,!'8,$>N,/'%B!*/'B*M,6!

&+G-/E!O/4G5-Y!Q@8!

<$*C6!X%+-,$! %9!8,>;!*C! '8,!.,N>$'M,&'!*C! =RN,$%M,&'>+!V>;%*+*-(!>'! '8,!]&%:,$9%'(!X*9N%'>+1! k,&>1!^,$M>&(6!E*$&! %&!7$-,&'%&>1!98,!9'/;%,;!0%*+*-(!>'!'8,!)8$%9'%>&!7+0$,B8'9!]&%:,$9%'(!%&!l%,+1!^,$M>&(1!>&;!$,B,%:,;!8,$!;%N+*M>!%&!4HH36!A8,!N,$C*$M,;!9,:,$>+!9'/;%,9!%&!0%*+*-(!%&!A*/'8!7M,$%B>!>&;!79%>6!f>',$!*&1!98,!-*'!%&',$,9',;!%&!8/M>&!0%*+*-(!>&;!0%*B8,M%9'$(! $,B,%:,;!8,$!<8.!>'! '8,!@,;%B>+!X%-8!AB8**+!X>&&*:,$1!^,$M>&(1! %&!4HHZ6!A%&B,! '8,&1!98,! C*B/9,;!8,$!$,9,>$B8! >B'%:%'%,9! '*! '8,! >$,>9! *C! '8,$>N,/'%B! &>&*',B8&*+*-(! >&;! %&! :%:*!M,9*aM>B$*9B*N%B! &,>$?%&C$>$,;! C+/*$,9?B,&B,!M*+,B/+>$!%M>-%&-!>&;!N$,B+%&%B>+!%M>-%&-!%&!-,&,$>+6!A%&B,!233J1!98,!%9!C/++!N$*C,99*$!>'!'8,!]&%:,$9%'(!X*9N%'>+!k,&>1!^,$M>&(6!A8,!P>9!>P>$;,;!P%'8!'8,!h>+',$!U$%,;$%B8!<$%O,!%&!233L6!A8,!%9!'8,!9N*Q,9M>&!*C!'8,!^,$M>&!M*+,B/?+>$!%M>-%&-!&,'P*$Q!>&;!'8,!^,$M>&!$,N$,9,&'>'%:,!*C!'8,!=/$*N,>&!A*B%,'(!*C!@*+,B/+>$!DM>-%&-6!!

Page 29: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

2K!c!< > - , !!

TDDS!!7;:>&B,9!%&!%M>-%&-!>&;!'8,$>&*9'%B9!/9%&-!&>&*',B8&*+*-%B>+!'**+9!

(5L!E5F/:5,!32,5E!*+!2EF2+:5E!/12G/+G!A',N8>&%,!#,/-8,+91!<,',$!_>,91!k*,$%!_,$0%,9'b!<,N$%B!&:1!f,/:,&1!E,+-%/M6!!

!

!

T.59@2+/5!%50G@54,Y!Q@8!!

Stephanie!#,/-8,+9 is the )=\!>&;!U*/&;,$!*C!<,N$%BG!98, took the initiative to set-up the Pepric and now has 5 years’

experience in the business development and financial aspects of the company. Previous to Pepric, she prepared and

assisted spin-off projects at Imec as Venture Development Manager. During her PhD she worked at several international

particle accelerator facilities (France, US, Japan) on nuclear magnetic resonance techniques. This offered her the nec-

essary background for a clear understanding of the technological principles of MRI, PET and SPECT. Dr. Teughels has

obtained postgraduate degrees in Corporate Finance (2006), Business Administration (2005), and nuclear physics (PhD,

2001).

1

n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

U*$!:>+%;>'%*&!*C!'8,!;,:,+*N,;!N>$'%B+,9!>&;!B*>'?%&-91! %'! %9! &,B,99>$(! '*! ;,',$M%&,! '8,!N8>$M>B*Q%&,'%B9!*C! '8,! '8,$>N,/'%B! >&;! ;%>-&*9'%B! N>$'%B+,9! %&! '8,! 0*;(!C+/%;9!>&;!'%99/,96!n/>&'%'>'%:,!;%9'$%0/'%*&!*C! '8,!N>$'%?

2

B+,9!%9!Q,(!'*!,:>+/>',!'8,!9N,B%C%B%'(!*C!'8,!'>$-,'%&-!>&;!,CC%B>B(!*C!'8,!;$/-!;,+%:,$(6!n/>&'%'>'%:,!;%9'$%0/'%*&!*C!'8,$>N,/'%B!N>$'%B+,9!P%++!>++*P!'*!

!

• ;,',$M%&,!'8,!M>R%M>+!,CC,B'%:,!;*9,!B*&B,&'$>'%*&!>&;!*N'%M%O,!'8,!;*9,!$,N,'%'%*&!'%M,!

• $,;/B,! B*9'! %&! '8,! N$,?B+%&%B>+! '$>[,B'*$(! *C! N>$'%B+,!'8,$>N%,9!

• *0'>%&!>!N$,;%B'%:,!:>+/,!C*$!'8,!;,9%-&!*C!'8,!B+%&%B>+!'$%>+9!$,;/B%&-!'8,!N>'%,&'!9'/;%,9!

!The developed particle spectrometer is based on a di-

rect and selective detection method pEPR (particle Elec-

tron Paramagnetic Resonance). When combined with

MRI, the PPS offers the solution for quantitative distribu-

tion studies.

Page 30: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

25!!

!

B&&&C!)40,.5-J!%2-G5.5E!+2+*9@2-12:50./:24,!2+E!E/2G+*,./:,!

! !

()*+,-#.'/&%,-0#'1#%2,#3*&+,%,4#5*"'62*&)*.,/%!.*7-#*"4#8!*+"'-%!.-#97/-%,&:#

Page 31: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

2Z!c!< > - , !!

<*-4E!"*45:042-!&12G2/+G!)*+G-5,,!=>;=!

[F5-F/5L!*6!.2-G5.5E!+2+*9@2-12:50./:24,!2+E!E/2G+*,./:,!:40,.5-!2:./F/.P!`/$%!_*+Q*:b!AB8**+!*C!@,;%B%&,!>&;!)V7FF1!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&1!D$,+>&;6!

!F>&*M,;%B%&,!N$*M%9,9! '*!;,:,+*N!M*$,!,CC,B'%:,1! 9>C,!>&;! B8,>N,$! '8,$>N%,9! C*$! N>'%,&'91! >&;! '*! %MN$*:,! =/?$*N,g9! 8,>+'8! 9(9',M! 0(! 9/NN*$'%&-! %'9! 9/9'>%&>0+,! >&;!,B*&*M%B! -$*P'86! #8%9! *0[,B'%:,! %9! M*9'+(! >B8%,:,;! 0(!/'%+%O%&-! C+,R%0+,! >&;! M/+'%C/&B'%*&>+! >NN$*>B8,91! ',B8?&*+*-%,9! >&;! '**+9! '8>'! ,RN+*%'! '8,! 9N,B%C%B! N$*N,$'%,9!C$*M!'8,!&>&*P*$+;6!!

A,:,$>+! =]! C/&;,;! N$*[,B'9! >$,! ;,:,+*N%&-! %&&*:>?'%:,! '8,$>N%,91! ;,',B'%*&! >&;! ;%>-&*9%9! M,'8*;9! %&! '8,!C%,+;!*C!&>&*M,;%B%&,!>&;!B*:,$!>!P%;,!:>$%,'(!*C!;%9,>9?,96! #8,! É#>$-,',;!F>&*?<8>$M>B,/'%B>+9! >&;!=>$+(!.%>-?&*9'%B9É! B+/9',$! 0$%&-9! '*-,'8,$! >0*/'! 25! 9/B8! $,9,>$B8!N$*[,B'91!C/&;,;!0(!'8,!=]!A%R'8!>&;!A,:,&'8!U$>M,P*$Q!<$*-$>MM,9!C*$!V,9,>$B8!TU<Z!>&;!U<IS1!/&;,$!'8,!N$%*$?%'%,9!F@<!>&;!X=7f#X6!!

#8,!N$*[,B'9! %&! '8,!B+/9',$!,>B8!8>:,! '8,%$!*P&! $,?9,>$B8!*0[,B'%:,91!0/'!>&! %MN*$'>&'!B*MM*&!,+,M,&'! %9!'8,!,MN8>9%9!*&!'8,!>NN+%B>'%*&!*C!9'>',?*C?'8,?>$'!&>&*?',B8&*+*-(6! =>B8! *C! '8,M! 0$%&-9! '*-,'8,$! 9N,B%>+%9'9!C$*M! 5! '*! L3! N>$'&,$! +>0*$>'*$%,9! %&! ;%CC,$,&'! /&%:,$9%?'%,91! $,9,>$B8!*$->&%O>'%*&91! B+%&%B91! %&;/9'$%,9!>&;!A@=9!C$*M!>B$*99!=/$*N,! '*! B*++>0*$>',!*&! '8,!B*MM*&!>%M6!#8,!N$*[,B'!B*&9*$'%>!>$,!>+9*!>0+,!'*!*$->&%9,!,;/B>'%*&!

>B'%:%'%,91! P*$Q98*N9! >&;! B*&C,$,&B,9! %&! B**N,$>'%*&!P%'8!'8,!*'8,$!%&%'%>'%:,96!7++!'8,!$,9,>$B8!',>M9!%&:*+:,;!8>:,!>&!%&',$,9'!%&!0,%&-!Q,N'!/N?'*?;>',!*&!C/'/$,!$,-/?+>'*$(! $,W/%$,M,&'9! >&;! N$*B,;/$,91! %&! *$;,$! '*! >&'%B%?N>',!'8,!+%Q,+(!$,W/%$,M,&'9!'*!->%&!M>$Q,'!>/'8*$%O>'%*&!C*$!'8,%$!&,P!'8,$>N%,96!

#8,!B+/9',$!>B'%:%'%,9!N$*M*',!C/$'8,$!&,'P*$Q%&-!*&!>! =/$*N,>&! 9B>+,1! ,&>0+%&-! $,9,>$B8,$9! %&! '8,! :>$%*/9!*$->&%O>'%*&9! >&;! B*/&'$%,9! '*! -,'! '*! Q&*P! >&;! P*$Q!P%'8! ,>B8! *'8,$1! '8/9! B*&'$%0/'%&-! '*! '8,! =/$*N,>&! V,?9,>$B8! 7$,>6! U/$'8,$M*$,1! '8,! B+/9',$! >B'%:%'%,9! 8,+N! '*!%&B$,>9,!'8,!:%9%0%+%'(!*C!%&;%:%;/>+!N$*[,B'9!>9!P,++!>9!'8,!%MN*$'>&B,!*C!'8,!$,9,>$B8!C%,+;!>9!>!P8*+,6!

#8,! N$,9,&'! 9,B'%*&! P%++! 98*P! '8,! $>'%*&>+,! >&;!>:>%+>0+,! /N;>',9! *C! C%:,! N$*[,B'9! '8>'! C*$M! '8,! B+/9',$!>&;!>$,!C*B/9,;!*&!;%CC,$,&'!$,9,>$B8!>$,>9!*C!&>&*M,;?%B%&,G! L!@%B$*&! %9! C*B/9,;!*&!;%>-&*9%[email protected]#V=7@!*&! 0%*M>$Q,$91! F7F\U\f! *&! %&C+>MM>'*$(! ;%9,>9,91!@]f#DU]F! *&! 0$,>9'! >&;! N$*9'>',! B>&B,$1! A7_=@=! *&!B>&B,$!;%>-&*9%9!>&;!'$,>'M,&'6!U*$! C/$'8,$! %&C*$M>'%*&!*&! '8,! B+/9',$1! N+,>9,! :%9%'! '8,! P,0N>-,! >'[email protected]:750-*92750d-5,52-:@d/+E0,.-/24e.5:@+*4*G/5,d.2-G5.5E^+2+*^9@2-12:50./:24,[email protected]!

!

!

_0-/!K*4?*FY!"8Y!Q@8!

`/$%!_*+Q*:!$,B,%:,;!8%9!@.!C$*M!'8,!@*9B*P!@,;%B>+!]&%:,$9%'(!>&;!9/09,W/,&'+(!>!<8.!%&!0%*M,;%B>+!9B%,&B,9!C$*M!'8,!D&9'%'/',!*C!DMM/&*+*-(1!@*9B*P6!X,!%9!>!<$*C,99*$!>'!'8,!.,N>$'M,&'!*C!)+%&%B>+!@,;%B%&,!>&;!C*$M,$!.%$,B'*$!*C!V,9,>$B8!>'!'8,!AB8**+!*C!@,;%B%&,1!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&!T#).S6!<$*C6!_*+Q*:!B**$;%&>',9!>!+>$-,?9B>+,!=]!U<?I!N$*[,B'[email protected]#V=7@1!C*$!,>$+(!;%>-&*9'%B9!>&;!M*&%'*$%&-!*C!M>+%-&>&'!;%9,>9,91!P%'8!22!=/$*N,>&!>B>;,M%B1!$,9,>$B81!B+%&?%B>+!>&;!%&;/9'$%>+!N>$'&,$96!X,!%9!'8,!+,>;!#).!N>$'&,$!C*$!'8,!=]!U<?I!N$*[,B'1!@]f#DU]F1!>&;!<$%&B%N>+!D&:,9'%->'*$!*&!>!&/M0,$!*C!*'8,$!-$>&'96!<$*C6!_*+Q*:!%9!'8,!>/'8*$!*C!*:,$!433!9B%,&'%C%B!N/0+%B>'%*&91!%&B+/;%&-!>$'%B+,9!>&;!0**Q!B8>N?',$91!>&;!8,!%9!>&!%&:,&'*$!*&!9,:,$>+!N>',&'96!

! !

Page 32: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

=I!Z!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

'*42.5^32,5E!+2+*3/*E5F/:5,!6*-!/+.5G-2.5E!E/2G+*,/,d.@5-29P!.2-G5./+G!:@-*+/:!/+^642112.*-P!E/,52,5,!7$'/$!)>:>B*?<>/+*b!.,N>$'M,&'!*C!E%*+*-%B>+!=&-%&,,$%&-1!]&%:,$9%'(!*C!@%&8*1!E$>->1!<*$'/->+6!

!

D-.0-!)2F2:*^Q204*Y!Q@8!

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

!

! !

1

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

2

;%9,>9,!'$,>'M,&'!P8%+,!;,B$,>9%&-!'8,!9%;,!,CC,B'9!P%'8!>&!%MN$*:,;!B*9'?0,&,C%'!$>'%*6!D&! '8%9!N$,9,&'>'%*&!>$,! $,N*$',;! '8,! +>9'!;,:,+*NM,&'!>B8%,:,;! /&;,$! '8,!F7F\U\f!N$*[,B'6! #8,! B*&9*$'%/M!N$*;/B,;!UEF! T+%N*9*M>+1!N$*',%&?0>9,;!&>&*N>$'%B+,9S!P%'8!,&B>N9/+>',;!>&'%?%&C+>MM>'*$(!;$/-9!'8>'!98*P,;!'*! 0,! 0%*+*-%B>++(! >B'%:,1! &*&?B('*'*R%B! >&;! B>N>0+,! *C!9N,B%C%B>++(! '>$-,'%&-! C*+>',! $,B,N'*$! TUVS?N*9%'%:,! B,++96!#8,! B*&9*$'%/M! >+9*! 98*P,;! '8>'! UVÑ!M%-8'! 0,! ,RB+/?9%:,+(! ,RN$,99,;! *&! >! B,$'>%&! 9/09,'! *C! M>B$*N8>-,9!N$,9,&'! %&! 9,:,$>+! '(N,9! *C! %&C+>MM>'*$(! B*&;%'%*&96!AN,B%>+!>'',&'%*&!%9!0,%&-!-%:,&!'*!M%&%M%O%&-!'8,!/9,!*C!>&%M>+!',9'%&-!0(!,9'>0+%98%&-!>;,W/>',!%&!:%'$*!M*;,+96!

Page 33: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

2J!c!< > - , !!

TDDDS!!)+/9',$G!#>$-,',;!&>&*N8>$M>B,/'%B>+9!>&;!;%>-&*9'%B9!

T2F5"5J!D!1*E042-!2:./F5!+2+*^942.6*-1!6*-!2EF2+:5E!:2+:5-!12+2G515+.!f!)*-5!+2+*,P,.51,Y! .01*0-! .2-G5./+G! 2+E! 95+5.-2./*+Y! 1*45:042-! /12G/+G! 2+E!E5G-2E*15!32,5E!.@5-29P!f*/%9!A8,&QM>&b!#,+!7:%:!]&%:,$9%'(1!#,+!7:%:1!D9$>,+6!

!7&! ,9'%M>',;! L62!M%++%*&! &,P! B>&B,$! B>9,9! >&;! 46I!M%+?+%*&!;,>'89!N,$!(,>$!%&!=/$*N,!;,C%&,!B>&B,$!>9!>!B$/B%>+!N/0+%B! 8,>+'8! N$*0+,M6! A>:,@,! %9! ;,:,+*N%&-! >! &*:,+!M*;/+>$! &>&*9(9',M9! N+>'C*$M! %&',-$>'%&-! >;:>&B,;!C/&B'%*&>+%O,;!&>&*?B*$,!N>$'%B+,9!>&;!>B'%:,!>-,&'96!#8,!M*;/+>$!N+>'C*$M!P%++!,&>0+,!'8,!;,9%-&!*C!;%:,$9,!>B'%:,!&>&*9(9',M9! C*$! ;%>-&*9'%B! *$! '8,$>N,/'%B! >NN+%B>'%*&96!79!>!M*;,+!9(9',M1!A>:,@,!%9!;,:,+*N%&-!>&;!:>+%;>'%&-!'8,!N+>'C*$M!C*$!N>&B$,>'%B!B>&B,$6!<>&B$,>'%B!B>&B,$!8>9!'8,!8%-8,9'!*&,?(,>$!M*$'>+%'(! $>',!*C!>&(!B>&B,$!>&;! %9!=/$*N,É9!9%R'8!;,>;+%,9'!B>&B,$6!@*9'!N>&B$,>'%B!'/M*/$9!>$,!;,',B',;!+>',1!>'!M,'>9'>'%B!9'>-,!>&;!J5j!>$,!/&$,?9,B'>0+,!>'!'8,!'%M,!*C!;,',B'%*&6!#8%9! %9!;/,1! %&!N>$'1!'*!'8,! +%M%'>'%*&! *C! B/$$,&'! %M>-%&-! 9(9',M9! %&! ;%>-&*9'%B!>BB/$>B(1!N>$'%B/+>$+(!%&!%;,&'%C(%&-!9/0?BM!;%9,>9,6!!

U*$! ,>$+(! ;%>-&*9%91! >B'%:,! &>&*9(9',M9! >$,! 0,%&-!;,:,+*N,;!C*$!@V1!<=#!>&;!->MM>!B>M,$>!%M>-%&-6!U*$!'8>'! N/$N*9,1! &*:,+! C/&B'%*&>+%O,;! &>&*?B*$,! 9(9',M9!P%++!0,!B*&[/->',;!P%'8!9,M%?B*&C+/,&'!>B'%:,!98,++!+>(,$6!#8$,,!'(N,9!*C!98,++!+>(,$9!P%++!0,!;,9%-&,;!T4S!%$*&!*R%;,!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!>9!>;:>&B,;!@VD!B*&'$>9'!>-,&'9b!T2S!.\#7!B*MN+,R,9! C*$! @VD! TP%'8! ^;LÖS1! <=#! TP%'8! ^>?ZJS! *$!->MM>! B>M,$>! TP%'8! ^>?ZISb! TLS! 0*'8! %$*&! *R%;,! &>&*?N>$'%B+,9! >&;!.\#7?^>ZJ! B*MN+,R,9! C*$! >! 9,W/,&'%>+! *$!9%M/+'>&,*/9!@Va<=#!%M>-%&-1!>9!P,++!>9!>!&*:,+!8(0$%;!<=#a@VD!N$*'*'(N,6!!

U*$! '8,$>N,/'%B91! >B'%:,!&>&*9(9',M9!>$,!0,%&-!;,?:,+*N,;! '*! ;,+%:,$! >&'%0*;%,9! *$! &/B+,%B! >B%;9! %&B+/;%&-G!T4S! >&'%?M>'$%R! M,'>++*N$*',>9,9! T@@<S?%&8%0%'*$(?9BU:1!>&;!T2S!'8,$>N,/'%B!9%VF796!h,!8>:,!N$,+%M%&>$(!;>'>!%&!B,++! 9(9',M9!;,M*&9'$>'%&-! '8,! C,>9%0%+%'(! *C! */$!F<9! >9!

B>$$%,$9! *C! 9%VF7!>&;! '8,%$! ,CC,B'%:,&,99! %&! 9%+,&B%&-! 9,?+,B',;!-,&,96!

#8,! &>&*9(9',M9! P%++! 0,! ;,9%-&,;! C*$! %&'$>:,&*/9!TD_S! >;M%&%9'$>'%*&6! #>$-,'%&-! M*%,'%,9! P%++! B*&9%9'9! *C!'/M*/$! B,++! '>$-,'%&-! N,N'%;,91! %&B+/;%&-! &*:,+! 9*M>'*?9'>'%&! $,B,N'*$! >&>+*-/,! TAA#VS! 9/0'(N,9! >&;! '>$-,'%&-!M*%,'%,9! 9/B8! >9! '8,! $,B,N'*$a+%->&;! 9(9',M! ^>+?4a'<76!#8,! +>',$!M>(!>++*P!9,+,B'%:,!'>$-,'%&-!*C!N$,?M>+%-&>&'!N>&B$,>'%B!B>&B,$6!#*!,&>0+,!9N,B%C%B!'/M*/$!'%99/,!N,&?,'$>'%*&1! >! <=^i@@<?9/09'$>',?<=^! >-,&'! C*$! *N'%M>+!'%99/,!;%CC/9%*&!P%++!0,!/9,;6!!!

#*!;>',1!P,!8>:,!;,9%-&,;!>&;! 9B$,,&,;!&*:,+! -,?&,$%B! B*$,! N*+(M,$%B! &>&*9(9',M9! C*$! *N'%M>+! &>&*?M>',$%>+!N$*N,$'%,9!TF)!>:,$>-,!9%O,!>&;!+*P!9%O,!;%9N,$?9%:%'(1! C/&B'%*&>+%'(! +,:,+1! P>',$! B*MN>'%0%+%'(1! M%&%M>+!>--$,->'%*&! +,:,+S6! <*+(M,$9! /9,;! >$,! &*&?'*R%B1! 0%*;,?-$>;>0+,!>&;!0%*B*MN>'%0+,1!B+>99%C%,;!>9!^V7A!T^,&,$>+?+(! V,B*-&%O,;! 79! A>C,S! +%Q,! <f^7! TN*+(z+>B'%B?B*?-+(B*+%B!>B%;{! B*?N*+(M,$S1! <=^! TN*+(,'8(+,&,-+(B*+S! ;,$%:>'%:,9!%&B+/;%&-! <f^7! 8(0$%;91! 8/M>&! 9,$/M! >+0/M%&! TXA7S1!>&;! N*+(>B$(+>',96! _>$%*/9! &>&*C>0$%B>'%*&! M,'8*;*+*?-%,9! 8>:,! 0,,&! ,RN+*$,;1! %&B+/;%&-! N*+(>B$(+>',! T<79S!X/%9-,&! d)+%BQe! B(B+*>;;%'%*&9! TD&'$>M*+,B/+>$! N*+(M,$!9%&-+,!B8>%&!B$*99?+%&Q%&-aB*++>N9,S1!F)!&>&*N$,B%N%'>'%*&!T9*+:,&'!;,N*9%'%*&S!P%'8!*%+aP>',$!,M/+9%*&!>&;!;,9*+:?>'%*&!M,'8*;96!!

\/$!N$,+%M%&>$(! $,9/+'9! 98*P%&-!>''>B8M,&'!*C!F<9!'*!B>&B,$!B,++9!>&;!%&'$>B,++/+>$!N,&,'$>'%*&!>&;!9%+,&B%&-!*C!9,+,B',;!-,&,9!P%'8!9%VF79!%9!N$*M%9%&-!>&;!9/NN*$'9!'8,!:>+%;%'(!*C!'8,!B*&B,N'6!

!

$*0/,!T@5+?12+Y!"8!

f*/%9!A8,&QM>&!%9!>!N$*C,99*$!*C!M,;%B%&,!>'!#,+!7:%:!]&%:,$9%'(1!#,+!7:%:1!D9$>,+6!X,!%9!'8,!B**$;%&>'*$!*C!'8,!A>:,@,!N$*[,B'6!A8,&QM>&!-$>;/>',;!C$*M!F,,P!`*$Q!]&%:,$9%'(!AB8**+!*C!@,;%B%&,!>&;![*%&,;!'8,!C>B/+'(!>'!#,+!7:%:!]&%:,$9%?'(!%&!4HJ26!X,!P>9!B8>%$!*C!'8,!;,N>$'M,&'!*C!M,;%B%&,!>'!*&,!*C!'8,!>CC%+%>',;!89*N%'>+91!>&;!8,!8>9!0,,&!,&->-,;!%&!0%*M,;%B>+! $,9,>$B8!>++! *C!8%9!N$*C,99%*&>+! B>$,,$6!X,! B/$$,&'+(! %9! '8,!M,;%B>+!;%$,B'*$!*C! =+C%?#,B8! f';61! >!0%*M,;%B>+!B*MN>&(!9N,B%>+%O%&-!%&!&*&?%&:>9%:,!M,;%B>+!9,&9*$96!! !

Page 34: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

=H!Z!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

M"&)\[(J!"04./1*E24/.P!1/:-*3244**+,!X>&9!X,0,$'b!AB8**+!*C!#,B8&*+*-(!>&;!X,>+'81!l#X1!AP,;,&6!

!

O2+,!O535-.Y!Q@8!

<$*C6!X>&9!X,$0,$'! %9!X,>;!*C!.,N>$'M,&'!<$*C,99*$! %&!E%*',B8&*+*-(!>'! '8,!AB8**+!*C!#,B8&*+*-(!>&;!X,>+'8!>'! '8,!l#X1!>!N*9%'%*&!8,!8>9!8,+;!9%&B,!23356!X,!*0'>%&,;!8%9!@>9',$!*C!#,B8&*+*-(!>'!]NN9>+>!]&%:,$9%'(!%&!4HI51!8%9!<8.!>9!.*B'*$!*C!#,B8&*+*-(!>'!l>$*+%&9Q>!D&9'%'/','!TlDS!%&!4HIH1!>&;!.*B,&'!%&!M,;%B>+!N8(9%B9!>'!lD!%&!4HJ46!X,!8>9!9,:,$>+!>B>;,M%B!>&;!%&;/9'$%>+!N*9%'%*&9!>&;!M,$%'9G!<$*C,99*$!%&!)$(*!=+,B'$*&!@%B$*9B*N(1!f/&;!]&%:,$9%'(!%&!2334?233K1!V,?9,>$B8!N*9%'%*&!>'!AP,;%98!F>'/$>+!AB%,&B,!V,9,>$B8!)*/&B%+!%&!4HH5?23336!X,!%9!@,M0,$!*C!),&'$>+!<$*M*'%*&!V,:%,P!)*MM%'',,1!l#X1!9%&B,!2335b!M,M0,$!*C!U>B/+'(!799,M0+(1!l#X1!9%&B,!233Hb!<$,9%;,&'!*C!AB>&;%&>:%>&!A*B%,'(!C*$!=+,B?'$*&! @%B$*9B*N(1! 4HHJi2332b! @,M0,$! *C! '8,! =R,B/'%:,! E*>$;! C*$! '8,! =/$*N,>&! @%B$*9B*N(! A*B%,'(1! 4HHJ! i! 233Kb!#,B8&%B>+! N+>'C*$M! M>&>-,$1! AP,-,&,1! f/&;! ]&%:,$9%'(1! 2334?233Kb! _V?@! >99,99M,&'! -$*/N! M,M0,$1! 9%&B,! 233Hb!@,M0,$!*C! %&',$&>'%*&>+!>;:%9*$(!0*>$;!dD*&!N/MN!B*&9*$'%/Me!Ü$8/9!]&%:,$9%'(1! 9%&B,!233Ib! D&',$&>'%*&>+!7;:%9*$(!E*>$;!C*$!DA.AE233I1!#*Q(*b!D&',$&>'%*&>+!7;:%9*$(!E*>$;!C*$!4K'8!=/$*N,>&!@%B$*9B*N(!)*&-$,991!7>B8,&1!233Jb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

!

! !

1

D&! :%:*!M/+'%M*;>+%'(! %M>-%&-! %9! >! C>9'! -$*P%&-! C%,+;! %&!M,;%B>+!$,9,>$B86!7+'8*/-8!'8,!>B8%,:,M,&'9!>'!B+%&%B>+!+,:,+!*C!'8%9!;%>-&*9'%B!M,'8*;!>$,! $,B,&'1! %'! %9!>+$,>;(!*&,!*C!'8,!M*9'!N$*M%9%&-!>NN$*>B8,9!%&!'8,!;%>-&*9%9!*C!;%9,>9,9!>'!M>&(!$,9,>$B8!M,;%B>+!B,&'$,96!!

#8,!L@D)V\F!N$*[,B'!',>M!->'8,$9!'*-,'8,$!9B%,&?'%9'9! C$*M!9*M,!*C! '8,!M*9'!>;:>&B,;!=/$*N,>&!M,;%?B>+!>&;!',B8&%B>+! %&9'%'/'%*&9!'*!;,9%-&!>!9,'!*C!&,P!;%?>-&*9'%B9! 9'$>',-%,9! 0>9,;! *&! >;:>&B,;!M,;%B>+! %M>-?%&-1!>&;!'*!N/98!'8,!N*',&'%>+!*C!'8%9!',B8&*+*-(!0,(*&;!'8,!9'>',?*C?'8,?>$'6!!

@/+'%M*;>+%'(! %M>-%&-! %9! B/$$,&'+(! :%,P,;! >9! >!9%MN+,!>&;!N*P,$C/+!%&',-$>'%*&!*C!'P*!*$!M*$,!%M>-%&-!M,'8*;9! T,6-6! <=#?)#S6! D&! '8,! L@D)V\F! N$*[,B'1! '8,!M/+'%M*;>+%'(! >NN$*>B8! 0,%&-! '>Q,&! %9! 9/NN*$',;! 0(! >!

2

B+>99! *C! &,R'?-,&,$>'%*&! M%B$*a&>&*;,:%B,9! B>++,;! M%?B$*0>++**&96! D&! *'8,$! %M>-%&-! M,'8*;9! TA<=)#1! @VDS1!'8,9,!9/09(9',M9!>'!N$,9,&'!N$*:%;,!'8,!C/&B'%*&!*C!>&!/+'$>9*/&;!B*&'$>9'!>-,&'6!D&!'8,!>NN$*>B8!0,%&-!'>Q,&!0(! L@D)V\F1! '8,(! B*/+;! >B'! >9! >! M%&%M>++(! %&:>9%:,!;$/-!;,+%:,$(!M,'8*;!>&;!8(N,$'8,$M%>!;,:%B,6!!

#8,! N$*[,B'! ',>M! P%++! ',9'! '8,9,! M/+'%?C/&B'%*&>+!M%B$*0>++**&!;,:%B,9!0*'8! %&! :%'$*!>&;! %&! :%:*! %&!*$;,$!'*! >99,99! 0%*B+,>$>&B,! >&;! B('*R%B%'(! ,CC,B'9! '*P>$;!8%-8! %MN>B'! ;%9,>9,91! ,6-6! :>9B/+>$! >&;! %&C+>MM>'%*&!N>'8*+*-%,96!U%&>++(1!9,+,B',;!'(N,9!*C!M%B$*0>++**&9!P%++!/&;,$-*! N$,?B+%&%B>+! 9B$,,&%&-! C*$! >! B*&9*+%;>',;! >9?9,99M,&'!*C! '8,!d0,&B8?'*?0,;e!N>'8P>(! C*$!9/B8!&,P!M%B$*;,:%B,96!!

Page 35: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

L3!!

B&KC!&12G/+G!:544!2+E!./,,05!/+.5-2:./*+!L/.@!+2+*12.5-/24,!

! !

()*+,-#.'/&%,-0#'1#%2,#("-%!%/%,#'1#;'7,./7*&#;,4!.!",<#3&!"!%0#9'77,+,#8/=7!":#

Page 36: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!

M;!Z!< > - , !!

TD_S!!DM>-%&-!B,++!>&;!'%99/,!%&',$>B'%*&!P%'8!&>&*M>',$%>+9!

DEF2+:5E!1*E54,!6*-!/12G/+G!:2+:5-!k6=6!@>'8,[BO(Q41!U6!V>M*9?^*M,94b!76l6!h,-,21!h6!A'/,8M,$41!f6!<>$;*L1!#6!V>Q*:%B8K1!`6!_*+Q*:K1!76!<$%&>?@,++*K1!<6!)8>M,951!.6!E>'(51!76!A/Q8>&*:>K1Z1!D6!F>0%,:K1Z1!U6!7+:,941Ib!T4S!@>R!<+>&BQ!D&9'%'/',!C*$!=RN,$%M,&'>+!@,;%B%&,1!.,N>$'?M,&'!*C!@*+,B/+>$!E%*+*-(!*C!F,/$*&>+!A%-&>+9b!T2S!)+%&%B!*C!^(&,B*+*-(!>&;!\09','$%B91!)>$%'>9!X*9N%'>+!A'6!k*9,C1!]&%?:,$9%'(!*C!V,-,&90/$-1!^,$M>&(b!TLS!@>R!<+>&BQ!D&9'%'/',!C*$!=RN,$%M,&'>+!@,;%B%&,!\&B*N8(9%*+*-(!-$*/N1!^á''%&-,&1!^,$M>&(b!TKS!D&9'%'/',!*C!@*+,B/+>$!@,;%B%&,1!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&1!./0+%&1!D$,+>&;b!T5S!DFA=V@!),&'$,!;,!V,B8,$B8,!,&!)>&Bm$*+*-%,!;,!@>$9,%++,1!D&9,$M!]@V!43ZJ1!)FVA!]@V!I25J1!4L2JJ!@>$9,%++,!),;,R!3H1!U$>&B,b!TZS!f>0*$>'*$(!*C!F>&*?E%*,&-%&,,$%&-1!@*9B*P!=&-%&,,$%&-!<8(9%B9!D&9'%'/',1!445K3H!@*9B*P1!V/99%>&!U,;,$>'%*&b!TIS!.,N>$'M,&'!*C!X,M>'*+*-(!>&;!\&B*+*-(1!]&%:,$9%'(!@,;%B>+!),&',$1!^á''%&-,&1!^,$M>&(6!

'-20?5!D4F5,Y!"8!

U$>/Q,!7+:,9!%9!<$*C,99*$!*C!D&',$&>+!@,;%B%&,!>'!'8,!]&%:,$9%'(!@,;%B>+!),&',$!^*,''%&-,&!T]@^S6!A8,!-$>;/>',;!C$*M!'8,!]&%:,$9%'(!*C!^*,''%&-,&!%&!M,;%B%&,!%&!4HJH6!A8,!P>9!>!N*9';*B'*$>+!C,++*P!%&!'8,!.,N'6!@*+,B/+>$!E%*+*-(!T<$*C6!76!]++$%B8S1!>'!'8,!@>R?<+>&BQ?D&9'%'/'!C*$!E%*B8,M%9'$(1!@>$'%&9$%,;!C$*M!4HH4i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

1

#8,! >%M! *C! '8,! 9'/;(! P>9! '*! :>+%;>',! &,P! -,&,$>'%*&!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!TF<S!0>9,;!*&!W/>&'/M!;*'9!Tn.9S!*$!*&!9,B*&;!8>$M*&%B!-,&,$>'%*&!TAX^S!N$*N,$'%,9!B*&[/->'?,;!,%'8,$!'*!9%&-+,!;*M>%&!>&'%0*;%,9!*$!'*!9M>++!M*+,?B/+,9! '>$-,'%&-! '/M*/$! >99*B%>',;! >&'%-,&9! C*$! '8,%$!>0%+%'(!'*!;,',B'!'/M*/$!B,++9!%&!0%*+*-%B>+!9>MN+,96!

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

2

%&'*!&/;,!M%B,6!D&! *$;,$! '*! ,9'>0+%98! M,'>9'>'%B! 0$,>9'! B>&B,$!

M*;,+91! X=V2! N*9%'%:,! '/M*/$! B,++9! E#?KIK! B,++9! P,$,!*$'8*'*N%B>++(! %MN+>&',;! %&'*! &/a&/!M%B,! '8>'! 8>;! $,?B,%:,;!8*$M*&,?N,++,'9!9/0B/'>&,*/9+(6!X=V2!&,->'%:,!'/M*/$! B,[email protected]?@E2L4!P,$,! /9,;! >9! &,->'%:,! B*&?'$*+96! X=V2! N*9%'%:,! M>MM>$(! B>$B%&*M>! AlEVL! B,++9!P,$,! %MN+>&',;! %&'*! '8,! +%:,$!*C!&,*&>'>+! %MM/&*;,C%?B%,&'! F\.6)-?<$Q;B9B%;! D+2$-'M4h[+aAOk! M%B,! Tk7ÄàS!'8>'!P,$,!%$$>;%>',;!P%'8!4!^(!C*$!L!8*/$9!0,C*$,!'$>&9?N+>&'>'%*&6!E*'8!M*;,+9!$,9/+',;!%&!>!M,'>9'>'%B!9N$,>;!*C! '/M*/$! B,++9! %&! ;%CC,$,&'! *$->&96! E%*+*-%B>+! 9>MN+,9!P,$,! B*++,B',;! C$*M! '8,9,! '/M*/$?0,>$%&-! M%B,! C*$!C/$'8,$!>&>+(9%96!

E(!>NN+(%&-!9%&-+,!;*M>%&!>&'%?=^UV!>&'%0*;(!B*&?[/->',;! '*! n.9! P,! P,$,! >0+,! '*! 9'>%&! 9N,B%C%B>++(! '/?M*/$! B,++9! %&! N>$>CC%&! 9,B'%*&9! *C! 0%*+*-%B>+! 9>MN+,9!C$*M!M%B,!P%'8!0$,>9'! '/M*/$9!>&;!M,'>9'>'%B!9N$,>;6!U/$'8,$M*$,1! 9%&-+,! '/M*/$9! B,++9! P,$,! ;,',B',;! %&!0*;(!C+/%;9!+%Q,!>9B%',9!>&;!0+**;6!!

Page 37: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!

L2!c!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

(2+*.*W/:*4*GP! /194/:2./*+,! /+! (2+*15E/:/+5J! 0+2+,L5-5E! g05,./*+,! 2+E! 60.0-5!E/-5:./*+,!@>$B,++*!^6!)>B>B,b!D&9'%'/',!C*$!'8,!A'/;(!*C!F>&*9'$/B'/$,;!@>',$%>+91!F>'%*&>+!)*/&B%+!*C!V,9,>$B8!T)FVS1!E*+*-&>1!D'>+(6!

!7+M*9'! ,:,$(! %&;/9'$%>+%O,;! B*/&'$(! 8>9! +>$-,+(! %&:,9',;!%&! &>&*',B8&*+*-(?$,+>',;! %&%'%>'%:,9! '*! C*9',$! Vs.! %&!'8%9! >$,>1! P8%B8! ,&B*MN>99,9! D)#1! 8,>+'8?1! C**;?! >&;!M>',$%>+9?$,+>',;! '8,M,96! #8,! =/$*N,>&! )*MM%99%*&g9!B*&'$%0/'%*&! '*! '8%9!,CC*$'! %9!*C! '8,!*$;,$!*C!Y465!0%++%*&1!;,N+*(,;!M>%&+(1!0/'!&*'!,RB+/9%:,+(1!'8$*/-8!'8,!,R,B/?'%*&!*C!>+M*9'!Z33!&>&*9B%,&B,!N$*[,B'96!#8,!&>&*9>C,'(!C%,+;! 8>9! P%'&,99,;! >! 98>$N! %&B$,>9,! %&! %&',$,9'! >&;! %&!,&9/%&-!Vs.!N$*-$>MM,91!0(!&>'%*&>+!>&;!%&',$&>'%*&>+!>/'8*$%'%,9!>&;!%&9'%'/'%*&9!'*!C>B,!'8,!N$*0+,M!*C!N*99%?0+,! $%9Q9!N*9,;! '*!8,>+'8!>&;!,&:%$*&M,&'!0(! '8,!P%;,?9N$,>;!;%CC/9%*&!*C!'8,!&,P!M>',$%>+96!

\&!'8,!*'8,$!8>&;1!'8,!9B%,&'%C%B!B*MM/&%'(!>&;!%&?;/9'$(! 8>:,! +*&-! $,B*-&%O,;! '8,! ,&*$M*/9! N*',&'%>+! *C!,RN+*%'%&-! '8,!M/+'%?C>B,',;!N$*N,$'%,9!*C!&>&*M>',$%>+9!>&;!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!C*$!%MN$*:%&-!'8,!>:>%+>0+,!>99*$'M,&'!*C! '**+9! '*! '>BQ+,! M*$,! >&;! M*$,! N>'8*N8(9%*+*-%B>+!B8>++,&-,9!%&!M,;%B%&,6!

E*'8! &>&*M,;%B%&,! >&;! &>&*'*R%B*+*-(! >$,! %&W/%$?%&-! *&! '8,! &,P1! 9*M,'%M,9?/&C*$,9,,&! N$*N,$'%,9!,M,$-%&-! C$*M!'8,!0%*?&>&*! %&',$>B'%*&! '*!,RN+*%'! '8,M!C*$!%MN$*:%&-!*/$!8,>+'8!*&!*&,!9%;,!>&;!'*!N$,:,&'!>&;!B*&'$*+!/&;,9%$,;!,CC,B'91!*&!'8,!*'8,$6!]&;*/0',;+(1!>'!'8%9! 9'>-,! &>&*'*R%B*+*-(! >&;! &>&*M,;%B%&,! 98>$,! '8,!B*MM*&! W/,9'! *C! >! '8*$*/-8! /&;,$9'>&;%&-! *C! '8,! ;,?'>%+9!*C!'8,!0%*?&>&*!%&',$>B'%*&96!!

D!P%++!N$,9,&'!9*M,!,R>MN+,9!'>Q,&!C$*M!'8,!$,B,&'!+%',$>'/$,1!P8%B8!,R,MN+%C(! '8,! %&&*:>'%:,! C,>'/$,!*C! 0%?*+*-(?%&9N%$,;!&>&*',B8&*+*-(!$,9,>$B86! D&! C>B'1!,RN+*%'?>0+,! B*&9,W/,&B,9! M>(! ,M,$-,! C$*M! 9%'/>'%*&9! P8,$,!'8,!M,$,!C>B'!*C!'*/B8%&-!>&;!9>MN+%&-!'8,!'>$-,',;!0%*?+*-%B>+!,&'%'%,9!P%'8!&,P!M>',$%>+9! T0,B>/9,!*C!'8,%$!9%O,!>&;!N$*N,$'%,9S!,:*Q,!0%*N8(9%B>+!N8,&*M,&>!*C!%&'$%&9%B!N,B/+%>$%'(6!

!

"2-:544*!]7!)2:2:5Y!Q@8!

E,9%;,9!8%9!$,9,>$B8!>B'%:%'(!%&!'8,!C%,+;!*C!&>&*',B8&*+*-(1!0%*N8(9%B9!>&;!&>&*?0%*',B8&*+*-(1!.$6!)>B>B,!%9!B/$$,&'+(!7;:%9*$!'*!'8,!=/$*N,>&!)*MM%99%*&1!rF>&*!>&;!B*&:,$-%&-!AB%,&B,9!>&;!#,B8&*+*-%,9r!^K!]&%'1!.^!V,9,>$B81!C*$!N$*?[,B'9!$,+>',;!'*!'8,!C%,+;9!*C!F>&*M,;%B%&,1!F>&*M>',$%>+9!>&;!F>&*'*R%B*+*-(6!X,!8>9!9/N,$:%9,;!*:,$!45!N$*[,B'9!%&!'8,! >0*:,?M,&'%*&,;! C%,+;9! >&;! %9! %&:*+:,;! %&! B/$$,&'+(! $/&&%&-!8*$%O*&'>+! >B'%:%'%,91! 9/B8! >9! '8,!F>&*9>C,'(!)+/9',$!%&%'%>'%:,1!'8,!F>&*M,;%B%&,!)+/9',$!%&%'%>'%:,!>&;!A/NN*$'!7B'%*&9!%&!B*MM/&%B>'%*&!*C!&>&*',B8&*+*-(!$,9,>$B86!

X,! 8>9! 8,+;! :>$%*/9! ',>B8%&-! >NN*%&'M,&'9! >&;!P>9! $,9N*&9%0+,! N>$'&,$! %&! >! )FV!0%+>',$>+! N$*[,B'!P%'8! '8,!E%?*O,&'$/M1!]&%:,$9%'(!*C!E>9,+1!AP%'O,$+>&;1!C$*M!4HH5!'*!4HHJ1!>&;!$,9N*&9%0+,!N>$'&,$!%&!>!)FV!0%+>',$>+!N$*[,B'!P%'8!'8,!D&9'%'/',!*C!E%*N8(9%B91!E%*+*-%B>+!V,9,>$B8!),&',$1!X/&->$%>&!7B>;,M(!*C!AB%,&B,91!C$*M!4HHJ!'*!23326!X,!8>9!0,,&!'8,!B**$;%&>'*$!*C!'8,!=]!<$*[,B'!.F7!AP%'B81!U<5!rn]7fD#`!\U!fDU=!rG!nflL?)#?23321!>&;!8>9!N>$'%B%N>',;!>9!>!N>$'&,$!%&! '8,! U<Z! D&',-$>',;! <$*[,B'1! )7F7<=1! >&;! %&! 'P*!V#.?A#V=<! <$*[,B'91!F\)X=@U\\.! >&;!ED\.\#6!X%9! B/$$,&'! $,?9,>$B8!%&',$,9'9!>$,!*&!'8,!%&',$>B'%*&9!*C!0%*M*+,B/+,9!>'!9/$C>B,91!C/&B'%*&>+%O>'%*&!>&;!%&',-$>'%*&!*C!B,++9! %&'*!;,?:%B,96!! !

Page 38: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!

MM!Z!< > - , !!

TD_S!!DM>-%&-!B,++!>&;!'%99/,!%&',$>B'%*&!P%'8!&>&*M>',$%>+9!

&12G/+G!:544!2+E!./,,05!/+.5-2:./*+!L/.@!+2+*12.5-/24,J!'-*1!=8!.*!M8!1*E54,!.>&%>!@*:%>41!7;$%,+,!<$%&>?@,++*!4121!`/$%!_*+Q*:!412b!T4S!)V7FF!>&;!T2S!AB8**+!*C!@,;%B%&,1!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&1!D$,?+>&;6!

!D&! :%'$*! $%9Q! >99,99M,&'! *C! &>&*M>',$%>+9! B*MM*&+(! $,?+%,9!*&!'P*?;%M,&9%*&>+! T2.S!B,++!B/+'/$,!9(9',M91!P8%B8!;*! &*'! >BB/$>',+(! $,N$*;/B,! '8,! 9'$/B'/$,1! C/&B'%*&! *$!N8(9%*+*-(! *C! +%:%&-! '%99/,96! D&! :%'$*! '8$,,?;%M,&9%*&>+!TL.S! B,++! B/+'/$,! %9! >0*/'! B$,>'%&-! 9/%'>0+,! 9/$$*/&;%&-9!C*$!*N'%M>+! B,++! -$*P'81!;%CC,$,&'%>'%*&!>&;! C/&B'%*&6!L.!B,++! B/+'/$,9!>++*P! %&;%:%;/>+! B,++9! '*!M>%&'>%&! '8,%$!&*$?M>+!L.!98>N,!>&;!9'$/B'/$,!P%'8!M%&%M>+!9/09'$>',!%&',$?C,$,&B,!T%6,61!$,;/B%&-!9'$,99!>&;!>$',C>B'9!$,9/+'%&-!C$*M!B,++! >;>N'>'%*&! '*! 2.! -$*P'8! 9/$C>B,9S! >&;! '8,(! ,&>0+,!B+*9,! %M%'>'%*&! *C! '8,! &>'%:,! >$B8%',B'/$,! C*/&;! %&! '%9?9/,96! #8,! +%C,! 9B%,&B,9! M>$Q,'! %9! 98*P%&-! >! 9/09'>&'%>+!&,,;! C*$! %&B*$N*$>'%&-! %&! :%:*?+%Q,! B,++! 9(9',M9! T9/B8! >9!L.!B,++!B/+'/$,9S!%&!'8,!$%9Q!>99,99M,&'!*C!B8,M%B>+9!>&;!*'8,$!M>',$%>+96! F*'! *&+(! '8,$,! %9! '8,! ;$%:,! '*! %MN$*:,!'8,! W/>+%'(! *C! ;>'>! -,&,$>',;! C$*M! %&! :%'$*! >99>(91! 0/'!

'8,$,! %9! >+9*! '8,! N$,99%&-! ;,M>&;! C*$! 8%-8,$! ,CC%B%,&B(!>&;!;,B$,>9,;!B*9'!*C!'8,!Vs.!N$*B,996!

79! N>$'! *C! '8,! B*M0%&,;! ,CC*$'! *C! '8,! F>&*9>C,'(!>&;!F>&*M,;%B%&,!B*MM/&%'%,91!*/$!P*$Q!%9!C*B/9,;!*&!'8,!,:>+/>'%*&!*C!'8,!N*',&'%>+!*C!L.!B,++!B/+'/$,!M*;,+9!%&! N$*:%;%&-! -/%;>&B,! *&! &>&*M>',$%>+9g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

!

82+/2!"*F/2Y!Q@8!

.>&%>! @*:%>! %9! >! N*9'?;*B'*$>+! $,9,>$B8,$! >'! '8,! ),&'$,! C*$! V,9,>$B8! *&! 7;:>&B,;! >&;! 7;>N'%:,! F>&*9'$/B'/$,9!T)V7FFSaAB8**+!*C!@,;%B%&,!*C!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&!TD$,+>&;S6!D&!233I1!98,!P>9!>P>$;,;!>!EAB!%&!@,;%B%&>+!)8,M%9'$(!>'!]&%:,$9%'(!*C!#$%,9',!TD'>+(S6!D&!23441!98,!B*MN+,',;!8,$!<8.!%&!)8,M%9'$(!>'!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&!P%'8!>!'8,9%9!,&'%?'+,;!dA%&-+,?P>++,;!B>$0*&!&>&*'/0,9!>9!&*:,+!FDV!C+/*$,9B,&'!N$*0,9!C*$!0%*M,;%B>+!*N'%B>+!%M>-%&-e6!)/$$,&'+(!98,!%9!%&:*+:,;!%&!>&!=]!U<I!C/&;,;!N$*[,B'9!B>++,;!F7F*V=^1!>%M%&-!>'!;,+%:,$%&-!'8,!>&9P,$9!&,,;,;!0(!$,-/+>'*$9!>&;!+,-?%9+>'*$9!*&!=XA!T=&:%$*&M,&'>+!X,>+'8!>&;!A>C,'(S!*C!&>&*M>',$%>+96!

!! !

Page 39: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!

LK!c!< > - , !!

<[\$8!"[$N)#$D\!&"D]D&(]!)[(]\NTT!=>;=!

\212+!,95:.-*,:*9P!/+!:4/+/:24!E/2G+*,./:,!U/$%*!^$>M>'%B>b!U*&;>O%*&,!.*&!)>$+*!^&*BB8%!\Ff]A1!f>0*$>'*$(!*C!F>&*M,;%B%&,!>&;!)+%&%B>+!E%*N8*'*&%B9!Tf7ED?\FS1!@%+>&*1!D'>+(6!!@%&%M>+!V,9%;/>+!.%9,>9,[email protected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

#8,$,!>$,!M*+,B/+>$!0%*+*-%B>+!M,'8*;9!>:>%+>0+,!C*$!'8,! ;,',B'%*&! *C! $,9%;/>+! 0+>9'91! 0/'! 9,&9%'%:,1! C>9'! >&;!$,+%>0+,!@V.!;,',B'%*&!%9!9'%++!>!B8>++,&-,!%&!,9'>0+%98%&-!'8,!C*++*P?/N!N$*B,996!#8,!*:,$,RN$,99%*&!*C!'8,!h%+Mg9!'/M*/$! Th#4S! -,&,! '$>&9B$%N'! 8>9! 0,,&! N$*N*9,;! >9! >!-**;!@V.!M>$Q,$!%&!>B/',!M(,+*%;!+,/Q,M%>6!#8,!M,B8?>&%9M!*C!>B'%*&!%&!B>9,!*C!h#4!%9!&*'!B*MN+,',+(!B+>$%C%,;1!0/'! %'!P>9! 98*P&! '8>'!h#4!*:,$,RN$,99%*&! +,>;9! '*!/&?B*&'$*++,;! N$*+%C,$>'%*&! >&;! ;,C,B'%:,! ;%CC,$,&'%>'%*&! *C!+,/Q,M%>!B,++9!>&;!8>9!,CC,B'9!*&!'8,!,RN$,99%*&!*C!*'8,$!-,&,9! %&:*+:,;! %&! B,++?B(B+,! N$*M*'%*&1! ;%CC,$,&'%>'%*&!>&;!>N*N'*9%96!

X,$,!P,!N$,9,&'!'8,!9(&'8,9%9!>&;!9/$C>B,!M*;%C%B>?'%*&!*C! 9'>$! 98>N,;!-*+;!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!;,;%B>',;! '*!A/$?

C>B,! =&8>&B,;! V>M>&! AN,B'$*9B*N%B! TA=VAS! >NN+%B>'%*&!>9!>&>+('%B>+!'**+!C*$!h#4!'$>&9B$%N'!;,',B'%*&6!7!9%MN+,1!-*+;! &>&*N>$'%B+,! 9(&'8,9%9! M,'8*;! /'%+%O%&-! 8(;$*W/%?&*&,!>9!$,;/B%&-!>-,&'! %&!P>',$!0>9,;!$,>B'%*&!M%R'/$,!>'!$**M!',MN,$>'/$,!P>9!*N'%M%O,;!%&!*$;,$!'*!N$*;/B,!-*+;!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!C*$!A=VA!>NN+%B>'%*&6!

#8,! V>M>&! 9%-&>+! ,&8>&B%&-! ,CC%B>B(! *C! '8,! 9'>$!98>N,;!&>&*M>',$%>+!P>9!B*MN>$,;!P%'8!'8,!,CC%B>B(!*C!9N8,$%B>+! N>$'%B+,96! h,++?Q&*P&! V>M>&! $,N*$',$! ;(,9!P,$,!>NN+%,;!'*!,:>+/>',!'8,!,&8>&B,M,&'!C>B'*$! %&!'8,!9/9N,&9%*&9!*C!9'>$!98>N,;!>&;!9N8,$%B>+!-*+;!&>&*N>$'%?B+,9! P%'8! 9%M%+>$! N>$'%B+,! 9%O,! >&;! >'! '8,! 9>M,! N>$'%B+,!B*&B,&'$>'%*&!/9%&-!:>$%*/9!+>9,$!,RB%'>'%*&!P>:,+,&-'896!!

#8,! 9'>$! 98>N,;! N>$'%B+,9! 9(&'8,9%O,;! P%'8! '8%9!M,'8*;! >$,! ,>9(! '*! C/&B'%*&>+%O,! P%'8! '8%*+9! >&;! >+9*!'$>&9C,$>0+,!%&'*!*$->&%B!9*+:,&'!0>9,;!C/$'8,$!M*;%C%B>?'%*&96!#8,!-**;!N8(9%B*B8,M%B>+!B8>$>B',$%9'%B9!*C! '8,9,!N>$'%B+,9! >&;! '8,! 9,&9%'%:%'(! *09,$:,;! %&! A=VA! ,RN,$%?M,&'9! >++*P! /9! '*! ,RN,B'! -**;! N,$C*$M>&B,! %&! '8,! C/$?'8,$!;,:,+*NM,&'!9',N9!*C!>!&*:,+1!C>9'!>&;!$,+%>0+,!9N,B?'$*9B*N%B!M,'8*;!C*$!h#4!;,',B'%*&!%&!@V.!N>'%,&'96!

!

'0-/*!]-212./:2Y!Q@8!

U/$%*!^$>M>'%B>1!N8(9%B%9'1!P>9!0*$&! %&!@%+>&*! %&!4HZK6!X,! %9! '8,!)8>%$!*C! '8,!),&'$,! C*$! D&&*:>'%*&!>&;!#,B8&*+*-(!#$>&9C,$!T)D##S!>'!.*&!^&*BB8%!U*/&;>'%*&!i!>&!D'>+%>&!B8>%&!*C!L3!8,>+'8B>$,!>&;!$,9,>$B8!B,&'$,9!9N,B%>+%O,;!%&!$,8>?0%+%'>'%*&! i!P8,$,! 8,! >+9*! +,>;9! '8,!F>&*M,;%B%&,! >&;! )+%&%B>+! E%*N8*'*&%B9! f>0*$>'*$(! Tf7ED\FS6! U*$! C%:,! (,>$9! 8,!9,$:,;!>9!.%$,B'*$!*C!'8,!E%*M,;%B>+!#,B8&*+*-(!.,N>$'M,&'!d<*+*!#,B&*+*-%B*e!%&!'8,!9>M,!U*/&;>'%*&6!U*$M,$+(1!8,!9N,&'! 9,:,$>+! (,>$9! >'!)=VF! T^,&,:>S1! >'! D'>+%>&! D&9'%'/',!*C!F/B+,>$!<8(9%B9! >&;! %&!8%-8?',B8&*+*-(! B*MN>&%,91!P%'8!Vs.!M>&>-,M,&'! $*+,96!.$6!^$>M>'%B>! %9!>!M,M0,$!*C! '8,!=R,B/'%:,!E*>$;!*C! '8,!=/$*N,>&!#,B8&*+*-(!<+>'C*$M!*C!F>&*M,;%B%&,!T=#<FS!>&;!)8>%$!*C!'8,!=#<F!)+%&%B>+!D&',$C>B,!^$*/Nb!M,M0,$!*C!'8,!0*>$;!*C!,RN,$'91!,:>+/>'*$9!>&;!$,:%,P,$9!*C!'8,!=/$*N,>&!)*MM%99%*&!>&;!*C!h,++B*M,!#$/9'b!&>&*M,;%B%&,!AB%,&'%C%B!7;:%9*$!*C!'8,!D'>+%>&!@%&%9'$(!*C!X,>+'8b!&>'%*&>+!$,N$,9,&'>'%:,!*C!D'>+(!>'!=#<F!@%$$*$!^$*/Nb!M,M0,$!*C!F>&*',B8&*+*-(!)*MM%99%*&9!*C!799*0%?*',B!>&;!*C!@%+>&*!=&-%&,,$9!799*B%>'%*&b!C,++*P!N$*C,99*$!*C!N8(9%B9!>'!@%+>&!]&%:,$9%'(!@,;%B>+!AB8**+6!! !

Page 40: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!

MA!Z!< > - , !!

TD_S!!DM>-%&-!B,++!>&;!'%99/,!%&',$>B'%*&!P%'8!&>&*M>',$%>+9!

O/G@!:*+.5+.!,:-55+/+G!*6!:544042-!-5,9*+,5!.*!+2+*12.5-/24,!/+.5-2:./*+!2,!/12G/+G!2+E!E5:/,/*+^12?/+G!.**4!7;$%,+,!<$%&>?@,++*1!`/$%!_*+Q*:b!AB8**+!*C!@,;%B%&,!>&;!)V7FF1!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&1!D$,+>&;6!

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

N$,99%&-!;,M>&;!C*$!W/>&'%'>'%:,!'**+9!'8>'!%&C*$M!9,+,B?'%*&!*C!'8,!M*9'!,CC%B%,&'!>&;!B*9'?,CC,B'%:,!*C!'8,!M($%>;!N*',&'%>+!9*+/'%*&96!X)A!8>9!0,,&!98*P&!'*!%MN$*:,!9/B8!9,+,B'%:,! ;,B%9%*&?M>Q%&-! N$*B,99,9! >&;! 9/B8! 9(9',M9!>$,!0>9,;!*&!8%-8?$,9*+/'%*&!N$,B%9%*&! 9/0B,++/+>$! %M>-?%&-1!P8%B8!,&>0+,!;,',B'%*&!*C!&>&*N>$'%B+,9!P%'8%&!%;,&?'%C%,;!*$->&,++,91!'$>BQ%&-!*C!M*+,B/+>$!'>$-,'9!P%'8%&!'8,!B,++!>&;!W/>&'%C%B>'%*&!*C!9,+,B',;!'>$-,'96!!

!

DE-/545!Q-/+2^"544*Y!Q@8Y!"T:!

.$6!7;$%,+,!<$%&>?@,++*! %9!>!A,&%*$!V,9,>$B8!U,++*P!>'! '8,!AB8**+!*C!@,;%B%&,1!>!)V7FF! D&:,9'%->'*$!>&;!>!N>$'?'%M,!+,B'/$,$!>'!#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&6!X,!%9!>+9*!>!M,M0,$!*C!'8,!,R,B/'%:,!0*>$;!*C!'8,!=/$*N,>&!#,B8&*+*-(!<+>'C*$M!*&!F>&*M,;%B%&,1!>!F>&*9>C,'(!)+/9',$!M,M0,$!>&;!8>9!$,B,&'+(!0,B*M,!'8,!F>'%*&>+!)**$;%&>'*$!*C!'8,!F7F*V=^!N$*?[,B'!B*&B,$&%&-!$,-/+>'*$(!',9'%&-!*C!&>&*M>',$%>+96!

.$!<$%&>?@,++*!8>9!N/0+%98,;!,R',&9%:,+(!>B$*99!M>&(!C%,+;91! %&B+/;%&-!&>&*M,;%B%&,1!&>&*',B8&*+*-(1!&>&*'*R%?B*+*-(!>&;!0%*,&-%&,,$%&-6!.$!<$%&>?@,++*g9!M>%&!$,9,>$B8!%&',$,9'!%9!'8,!;,:,+*NM,&'!*C!C/'/$,!>NN+%B>'%*&9!C*$!&>&*?N>$'%B+,9!>&;!&>&*M>',$%>+9!%&!B+%&%B>++(!$,+,:>&'!0%*M,;%B>+!>&;!0%*,&-%&,,$%&-!C%,+;96!

.$! <$%&>?@,++*! %9! %&:*+:,;! %&! ;,:,+*N%&-! >&;! >;:>&B%&-! 9,:,$>+!M/+'%;%9B%N+%&>$(! $,9,>$B8! N$*[,B'9! 0,'P,,&! '8,!/&%:,$9%'(1!$,9,>$B8!8*9N%'>+!>&;!%&;/9'$(!N>$'&,$9!C*$!C/'/$,!>NN+%B>'%*&9!%&!M,;%B%&,!>&;!'8,!&>&*',B8&*+*-(!%&;/9'$(6!!.$6!<$%&>?@,++*! %9!>+9*!%&:*+:,;!%&!9,:,$>+!=]!U<I!C/&;,;!N$*[,B'9G!.,N/'(!)**$;%&>'*$!*[email protected]#V=7@!TF@<S1!;%9?9,M%&>'%*&!B**$;%&>'*$!*C!@]f#DU]F!TF@<S1!F>'%*&>+!B**$;%&>'*$!*C!F7F*V=^!TF@<S1!>&;!AB%,&B,!U*/&;>'%*&!D$,+>&;!)V7FF!<>'8C%&;,$!N$*[,B'6!

Cultured cells

Live or Fixed & Stained cells

Nanoparticles

!"#$%&'()*()%+,-**("(#%!"#$%&'(')*$(%+,-.'#/0%0,12,34,,

High content image acquisition Data analysis Multi-parametric automated image processing

•! Number •! Area •! Shape •! Intensity •! Gyration, etc.

!"#$%&'())*+,-+%$.+/*)0*1+2-3+4(1("%)+567)#8%9*$4+%1%#)%7)(+*$)#$(++

Page 41: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

LZ!!

! !

<*-?,@*9,!2.!N0-*(2+*'*-01!=>;M!

Page 42: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

 

37    

EuroNanoForum  2013    At   the   2013   EuroNanoForum   (ENF)   conference,   the  MULTIFUN   project   made   a   major   contribution   to   the  event,   through   the   Irish   project   partner   Trinity   College  Dublin,  to  bridging  the  gap  between  the  world  of  medical  research/innovation   and   that   of   the   nanotechnology  stakeholders,   by   collaborating   to   organize   two   work-­‐shops   entirely   dedicated   to   the   nanomedicine.   The   ENF  was  a  great  opportunity  for  the  nanomedicine  communi-­‐ty  to  emphasize  to  a  large  panel  of  research,  industry  and  public   authority   representatives,   the   huge   potential   of  nanotechnology   as   an   enabling   technology   for   medical  applications.  With  participation  at  ENF  supported  by  the  European   Technology   Platform   on   Nanomedicine   (ETP  Nanomedicine),   the  nanomedicine   field  was  widely   rep-­‐resented   and   specific   needs   and   requirements   for   the  successful   implementation   of   nanotechnologies   in   the  health  sector  were  highlighted.    

The   ENF   2013   conference,   organized   by   Enterprise  Ireland,  was  held   in  Dublin   in  June  2013  during  the   Irish  presidency   of   the   European   Union   under   the   motto  “Nanotechnology  Innovation:  From  research  to  commer-­‐cialization,  the  bridge  to  Horizon  2020”.  The  event  was  a  tremendous   success,   attracting   nearly   1,500   active  members   of   the   nanotechnology   community   from   50  countries  around  the  world.  Over  140  high-­‐level  speakers  presented   at   the   plenaries,   sessions   and   workshops.  Nanotechnology   developments   and   commercialization  success  stories  were  also  visible  at   the  coinciding  Nano-­‐tech  Europe  exhibition.  The  event  was  supported  by  the  European   Commission   and   its   Industrial   Technologies  programme,  and  co-­‐organised  by  Enterprise   Ireland  and  Spinverse  Ltd.  

The  focus  of  the  conference  was  the  commercializa-­‐tion   of   nanotechnology,   exploiting   its   potential   for   new  applications,   pushing   it   from   an   enabling   technology  through   to   use   in   end  products.   Industrial   and   research  organizations  such  as  BASF,  Shell,  Ottobock,  Nanobiotix,  Intel,   Philips   Healthcare,   Airbus,   VTT,   Fraunhofer,   Max-­‐Planck   Institute,   CRANN,   Tyndall,   MSSI   and   NanoStart,  initiated  a   thriving  discussion  about   the   future  of  nano-­‐technology,   its   economic   and   technological   impact   on  

European   growth   and   the   commercialization   challenges  of  nanoproducts.  Speakers  agreed  that  understanding  of  industrial   needs,   focused   R&D   and   suitable   funding   in-­‐struments   are   required,   as   is   the   identification   of   areas  where  nanotechnology  is  most  likely  to  have  an  impact.  

The  Nanotech  Europe  exhibition  completed  the  con-­‐ference.  Here,  70  innovative  organizations  from  20  coun-­‐tries   like   Austria,   the   UK,   Germany,   Denmark,   Finland,  France,  the  Czech  Republic,  Switzerland  and  the  Nether-­‐lands   showcased   their   ground-­‐breaking   innovations.   In  the  meantime,  a  brokerage  day  on  June  20th  saw  50  par-­‐allel  meetings   take  place,   sparking  new  businesses,  pro-­‐ject   consortia   and   cooperative   activities   for   technology  transfer.  

With   Horizon   2020   beginning   in   2014,   the   confer-­‐ence  offered  a  unique  chance  to   look  at  how  nanotech-­‐nology  will  fit   into  the  new  structure’s  key  priority  areas  of   excellent   science,   industrial   leadership   and   societal  challenges.  “Today,  as  demonstrated  in  ENF  2013,  nano-­‐technology   applications   can   be   found   in   all   areas   of   in-­‐dustrial  technologies”,  commented  Dr.  Herbert  von  Bose,  Director  of  the  Industrial  Technologies  Programme  of  DG  Research   and   Innovation   at   the   European   Commission.  “Still,  a  lot  more  needs  to  be  done,  especially  in  fastening  the  pace  of  industrial  innovation.  We  are  looking  forward  to   continuing   our  work  within   the   next   seven-­‐year   pro-­‐gramme  of  Horizon  2020,  following  the  principles  of  safe,  responsible   and   sustainable   nanotechnology   develop-­‐ment   and   ensuring   the   competitiveness   and   growth   of  European  industries”.  

The  central  role  of  nanomedicine  within  the  sphere  of  applied  nanotechnology  was  one  of   the  key   topics  at  the   conference;   and   this   point   was   emphasized   by   the  award   for   Best   Research   Project   going   to   the   EU   nano-­‐medicine  project,   SONODRUGS.   The  project   aims   to  de-­‐velop  novel   technologies   for   drug  delivery   to   enable   lo-­‐calized   treatment   of   cardiovascular   disease   and   cancer.  For   patients,   this   could   mean   a   treatment   with   fewer  side   effects   and   burdens,   in   addition   to   reduced   post-­‐intervention  recovery  times.  

 

 

Page 43: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!!

LJ!c!< > - , !!

!

(2+*15E/:/+5!2.!N0-*(2+*'*-01!=>;M!!F>&*M,;%B%&,!$,9,>$B8!>&;!>NN+%B>'%*&9!P,$,! '8,! C*B/9!*C! 'P*!P*$Q98*N9! >&;! 'P*! *C! '8,! +%C,! 9B%,&B,! 9,99%*&96!#8,(! $,B,%:,;! ,&;*$9,M,&'! >&;! ;%$,B'! B*&'$%0/'%*&9!C$*M!=#<!F>&*M,;%B%&,!!

./$%&-! '8,! C%$9'!;>(1! '8,!dX,>+'8B>$,!A,99%*&e!;,>+'!P%'8!',B8&*+*-(!'$>&9C,$!>&;!B*MM,$B%>+%O>'%*&!*C!&>&*?',B8&*+*-(?0>9,;! 8,>+'8B>$,! %&&*:>'%*&91! C*B/9%&-! *&!%&;/9'$(!&,,;91!P%'8!N$,9,&'>'%*&91!>M*&-!*'8,$91!0(!.$6!X>&9! X*C9'$>>'1! _%B,! <$,9%;,&'! *C! <8%+%N9! V,9,>$B81! >&;!.$6!<>'$%BQ!E*%99,>/1!)8>%$!*C!'8,!=#<!F>&*M,;%B%&,6!

#8,! dA,99%*&! *&! 7;:>&B,9! %&! E%*&>&*',B8&*+*-(e!P>9!8,+;! '8,! 9,B*&;!;>(6!X,$,1!&>&*0%*',B8&*+*-(!P>9!98*P&! '*!N$*:%;,! '**+9! C*$! '8,! 9'/;(!*C! +%:%&-!M>'',$!>'!'8,!&>&*9B>+,1!>&;!'*!-,&,$>',!9B%,&'%C%B!>&;!',B8&*+*-%?B>+!>;:>&B,9!%&!'8,!C%,+;9!*C!M,;%B%&,!>&;!0%*+*-(6!D&!>;?;%'%*&1!0%*M%M,'%B!>NN$*>B8,9!'*!B$,>'%&-!&,P!B$(9'>++%&,!&>&*?M>',$%>+9! P>9! %++/9'$>',;! >9! >! C/$'8,$! ,R>MN+,! *C!0%*&>&*',B8&*+*-(1! 8%-8+%-8'%&-! %'9! %MN>B'! 0,(*&;! '8,!0%*+*-%B>+!9B%,&B,96!

./$%&-!'8,!'8%$;!;>(1!'8,!'P*!&>&*M,;%B%&,?C*B/9,;!P*$Q98*N9!'**Q!N+>B,!P%'8!'8,!;%$,B'!%&:*+:,M,&'!*C!'8,!@]f#DU]F! >&;[email protected]#V=7@!N$*[,B'91!P8%B8! B*&'$%0?/',;! '*! ;,C%&%&-! '8,! P*$Q98*Ng9! M%99%*&! >&;! N$*-$>M6!#8,!M>%&!*0[,B'%:,9!P,$,!'*!;,9B$%0,1!P%'8!'8,!%&',$,9'9!*C! >++! 9'>Q,8*+;,$9! %&!M%&;1! '8,! B/$$,&'! >B'%*&!N+>&! >&;!M,>9/$,9!'>Q,&!'*!C*$,-$*/&;!'8,!C%,+;!*C!&>&*M,;%B%&,1!>&;!'*!8%-8+%-8'!'8,!N*+%B(!>B'%*&91!+,;!0(!'8,!=#<!F>&*?M,;%B%&,1!'*!%&',-$>',!&>&*M,;%B%&,!>9!>!8*$%O*&'>+!'*N?%B!%&!X*$%O*&!2323!TX2323S6!

h*$Q98*N! I1! '%'+,;1! dF>&*M,;%B%&,G! #,B8&*+*-(!<+>'C*$M9! >&;! E$,>Q'8$*/-8! <$*[,B'9e1! B,&'$,;! >$*/&;!*&-*%&-! =]! &>&*M,;%B%&,! N$*[,B'9! >&;! %&%'%>'%:,91! '8,!h8%',! <>N,$! B*&'$%0/'%*&! *C! '8,! =#<! F>&*M,;%B%&,! '*!X23231!>9!P,++!>9!B/$$,&'!>B'%*&9!'*!9/NN*$'!%&%'%>'%:,9!*C!'$>&9&>'%*&>+!M/+'%;%9B%N+%&>$(!$,9,>$B8!%&!&>&*M,;%B%&,!0(! C*9',$%&-! '8,!B*MN,'%'%:,&,99!*C! '8,!=/$*N,>&!&>&*?M,;%B%&,!>B'*$96!

#8,!B+%&%B>+!'$>&9+>'%*&!*C!&>&*M,;%B>+!',B8&*+*-%,9!$,W/%$,9! '8,! 9'>Q,8*+;,$9! '*! /&;,$9'>&;! >&;! >NN+(! '8,!N$*B,99!*C!*N,&!%&&*:>'%*&1!P8%B8!%9!,99,&'%>+!C*$!'$>&9+>?'%*&! %&'*! '8,! B+%&%B6! 79! 9'>',;! %&! '8,! =#<! F>&*M,;%B%&,!dh8%',! <>N,$e1! '8,! 0,9'! *N'%*&! C*$! 9/BB,99C/++(! %MN+,?M,&'%&-! '8,! *N,&! %&&*:>'%*&!M*;,+! %&! =/$*N,! %&:*+:,9!,9'>0+%98%&-! >! 9/NN+(! B8>%&! N$*:%;%&-! &>&*M,;%B%&,!N$*;/B'9!B*MN>'%0+,!P%'8! %&;/9'$%>+!N$*B,99,9!>&;!9'$>'?,-%,96!#8,!=#<!F>&*M,;%B%&,!8>9!>!'$>BQ!$,B*$;!>9!>!&,/?'$>+!B*MM/&%B>'%*&!N+>'C*$M!>&;!'8%&Q!'>&Q!C*$!>B>;,M?%>1!A@=9!>&;!%&;/9'$(b!'8%9!8>9!>++*P,;!%'!'*!C*9',$!%&',$?>B'%*&!0,'P,,&!Q,(!N+>(,$91!+,>;%&-!'*!'$>&9+>'%*&!*C!9B%?,&'%C%B!%&:,&'%*&9!%&'*!8,>+'8B>$,!N$*;/B'96!E>9,;!*&!'8%9!/&%W/,!=/$*N,>&!,RN,$%,&B,1!'8,!=#<!F>&*M,;%B%&,!>&;!%'9!U<I?C/&;,;!N$*[,B'9!>$,!P*$Q%&-!*&!B*++>0*$>'%:,!N+>'?C*$M9!'8>'!B*&'$%0/',!'*!'8,!;,:,+*NM,&'!*C!'8,!>99*B%?>',;!8,>+'8B>$,?%&;/9'$(!*$->&%O>'%*&9!>&;!>!&/M0,$!*C!'8,!$*>;M>N9!>&;!:%9%*&9!*C!'8,!=/$*N,>&!)*MM%99%*&6!

#8,!9,99%*&!P>9!B8>%$,;!0(!.$6!<>'$%BQ!E*%99,>/!T=#<!F>&*M,;%B%&,!>&;!)=7!^$,&*0+,1!U$>&B,S!>&;!B*?B8>%$,;!0(! .$6! f>/$,&'! f,:(! TF>&*0%*'%R1! <>$%91! U$>&B,S! >&;! .$6!7;$%,+,!<$%&>?@,++*! T#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0+%&1! D$,+>&;S6!#8,!N>&,+! *C! ,RN,$'9! P>9! B*MN*9,;! *C! =#<! F>&*M,;%B%&,!=R,B/'%:,! 0*>$;! M,M0,$9! >&;! =)! $,N$,9,&'>'%:,96! #8,!9,99%*&9! P,$,! *$->&%O,;! 0(! .$6! 7;$%,+,! <$%&>?@,++*[email protected]#V=7@!.,N/'(!)**$;%&>'*$S6!

h*$Q98*N!J!P>9!'%'+,;1!d@>$Q,'!A'$>',-%,9!%&!@,;%?B>+! .,:%B,! A,B'*$e6! #8,! 9'>$'%&-! N*%&'! *C! '8%9! P*$Q98*N!P>9! '8,! $,>+%O>'%*&! '8>'! &>&*',B8&*+*-(! >&;! &>&*?M>',$%>+9!8>:,!M>[*$+(!B*&'$%0/',;! '*! %&&*:>'%*&!P%'8%&!'8,!M,;%B>+!;,:%B,! %&;/9'$(6!#8%9!8>9! +,;!'*!'$,M,&;*/9!>;:>&B,9!%&!'8,!N$*:%9%*&!*C!B>$,!C*$!N>'%,&'9!P*$+;P%;,1!0/'! B*&'%&/,;!N$*-$,99!P%++! $,W/%$,! ,CC,B'%:,! %&&*:>'%*&!9*+/'%*&9! '>Q%&-! >;:>&'>-,!*C! '8,!M*9'! >;:>&B,;! 9B%,&?'%C%B!0$,>Q'8$*/-896!

! !

Page 44: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!!

MH!Z!< > - , !!

O/G@4/G@.,!&J!(2+*15E/:/+5J!%5:@+*4*GP!Q42.6*-1,!2+E!R-52?.@-*0G@!Q-*S5:.,!BN('!<*-?,@*9!IC!!

!

1

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

l,(! '>9Q9! '*! C*9',$! *N,&! %&&*:>'%*&! %&! &>&*M,;%?B%&,1!'*!0,!N/'!%&!N+>B,!0(!'8,!=#<!F>&*M,;%B%&,1!8>:,!0,,&!%;,&'%C%,;!>9!'8,!B$,>'%*&!*C!>!#$>&9+>'%*&!7;:%9*$(!E*>$;! T#7ES! >&;! &,P! %&C$>9'$/B'/$,9! 9/NN*$'%&-! '8,!'$>&9+>'%*&!*C!&>&*M,;%B>+!N$*;/B'9!%&'*!'8,!B+%&%B6!#8,!#7E!P%++!&,,;!'*!%&B+/;,!,RN,$%,&B,;!%&;/9'$%>+!,RN,$'91!P8*!P%++!>NN+(!8*$%O*&'>+!%&&*:>'%*&!C%+',$9!'*!Vs.!N$*?N*9>+9! C$*M! >B>;,M%B9! >&;! A@=9! '*! 9,+,B'1! -/%;,! >&;!N/98! '8,! 0,9'! '$>&9+>'>0+,! B*&B,N'9! '*P>$;9! C/&;%&-!>&;! B+%&%B>+! N$**C! *C! B*&B,N'6! #8,! &,P! %&C$>9'$/B'/$,9!9/NN*$'%&-!'8,!'$>&9+>'%*&!*C!&>&*M,;%B>+!M>',$%>+9!P%++!%&B+/;,! >! =/$*N,>&! F>&*?)8>$>B',$%O>'%*&! f>0*$>'*$(!T=]?F)fS1!>!=/$*N,>&!<%+*'!+%&,!C*$!^@<!M>&/C>B'/$%&-!*C!0>'B8,9!C*$!B+%&%B>+!'$%>+9!T^@<!<%+*'!f%&,9Sb!>!=/$*N,?>&!&,'P*$Q!*C!N$,B+%&%B>+!B,&'$,9!*C!,RB,++,&B,b!>&;!B*?*$;%&>'%*&! *C! '8,!,CC*$'9! *C!=/$*N,>&!B+%&%B>+!*$->&%O>?'%*&9!%&!&>&*M,;%B%&,6!#8,!#7E1!'*-,'8,$!P%'8!'8,!&,P!%&C$>9'$/B'/$,9! >&;! >&! >B'%:,! 9/NN*$'! '*P>$;9! '8,! 9,'?'%&-?/N! *C! >! ;,;%B>',;! F>&*@,;! A@=! %&9'$/M,&'! P%++!B$,>',!>&!/M0$,++>!*C!B*MN+,M,&'>$(!>B'%*&9!>&;!%&%'%>?'%:,9! P%'8%&! '8,! %-2+,42./*+24! O036! #8,! C*/$! Q,(! ,+,?M,&'9! B*MN*9%&-! '8,! #$>&9+>'%*&! X/0! T=]?F)f1! ^@<!<%+*'!f%&,91!'8,!A@=!D&9'$/M,&'!>&;!#7ES!>%M!'*!0,!'8,!M*9'! $,+,:>&'! B*&B,N'9! C*$! ,&9/$%&-! '8,! B*MN,'%'%:,?&,99! *C! =/$*N,>&! V,9,>$B8! >&;! D&&*:>'%*&6! @*$,! ;,?'>%+9!>$,!>:>%+>0+,!*&!'8,!=FU!P,09%',!P8,$,!%'!%9!N*99%?0+,! '*! ;*P&+*>;! '8,! N$,9,&'>'%*&! -%:,&! 0(! .$6! <>'$%BQ!E*%99,>/!T)=71!U$>&B,S1!B8>%$!*C!=#<!F>&*M,;%B%&,G!

2

[email protected]*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>IdR*/,,520^(2+*15E/:/+5^<*-?,@*979E6!

!dAM>++!0/'!8,>;%&-!'*!>!0%-!C/'/$,e!%9!'8,!M*''*!*C!

(2+*3/*./W1!0/'!'8%9!>M0%'%*&!B*/+;!0,!,R',&;,;!'*!'8,!,&'%$,! &>&*M,;%B%&,! C%,+;6! U*/&;,;! %&! 233L1! '8,! B*M?N>&(! 8>9! >+$,>;(! ,9'>0+%98,;! %'9,+C! >9! >! N%*&,,$! %&! &>?&*M,;%B%&,1!;,:,+*N%&-!>!N%N,+%&,!*C!C%$9'?%&?B+>99!N$*;?/B'9! '>$-,'%&-! B>&B,$6! #8,! C%$9'! N$*;/B'1! FE#ÄVL1! 8>9!&*P! >B8%,:,;! >! B+%&%B>+! M%+,9'*&,1! $,>B8%&-! N$**C?*C?B*&B,N'!%&!>!N8>9,!D!'$%>+!C*$!'8,!'$,>'M,&'!*C!9*C'!'%99/,!9>$B*M>6! f*B>+!N$*B,;/$,9! +%Q,!9/$-,$(!>&;!$>;%*'8,$>?N(!N+>(!>&! %MN*$'>&'! $*+,! %&! '8,!'$,>'M,&'!*C! 9*+%;! '/?M*/$91!>&;!'8,(!>+9*!%&B$,>9,!'8,!N$*0>0%+%'(!*C!9/BB,99!C*$! 9(9',M%B! '$,>'M,&'96! #8,! %&&*:>'%*&! %&! F>&*0%*'%R!+%,9! %&! '8,%$! F>&*Ä$>(! ',B8&*+*-(1! P8%B8! B*MN$%9,9!'8$,,! N$*;/B'9! '*! 9,+,B'%:,+(! %&B$,>9,! '8,! ,CC%B>B(! *C!$>;%*'8,$>N(! >->%&9'! '/M*/$! B,++91! N$*M%9%&-! '*!*:,B*M,!9*M,!*C!'8,!+%M%'>'%*&9!*C!9'>&;>$;!$>;%*'8,$?>N(6!./$%&-!'8,!P*$Q98*N1!F>&*E%*'%R!)=\1!.$6!f>/$,&'!f,:(1! ;,9B$%0,;! '8,! %MN$,99%:,! >B8%,:,M,&'9! *C! '8%9!B*MN>&(b!M*$,!;,'>%+9!B>&!0,!C*/&;!%&!'8,!N$,9,&'>'%*&!%'9,[email protected]*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>Id$^$5FP^(2+*15E/:/+5^<*-?,@*979E6!

!#8,! C%$9'! 0$,>Q'8$*/-8! N$*[,B'! '*!0,! N$,9,&',;!>'!

'8,!P*$Q98*N! P>9!(D"8&D%\ND"! >&;! '8%9!P>9! ;*&,!0(!%'9!B**$;%&>'*$!<$*C6!`/$%!_*+Q*:!T#$%&%'(!)*++,-,!./0?+%&S6! #8,! [email protected]#V=7@! N$*[,B'1! P8%B8! '>$-,'9! ;,:,+?*NM,&'! *C! &>&*',B8&*+*-%B>+! '**+Q%'9! C*$! M/+'%?M*;>+!B>&B,$!;%>-&*9'%B9!>&;! '$,>'M,&'!M*&%'*$%&-1! %9! >&!,R?B,++,&'! ,R>MN+,! *C! >! 9'$*&-! %&',$;%9B%N+%&>$(! ,CC*$'! %&!&>&*M,;%B%&,6! D'! %9! >! N>&?=/$*N,>&! B*&9*$'%/M! 0/%+'!>$*/&;!I!8%-8?',B8!A@=91!2!M/+'%&>'%*&>+! B*$N*$>'%*&9!>&;!4L!>B>;,M%B!%&9'%'/'%*&96!#8,!0$,>Q'8$*/-8!%&&*:>?

Page 45: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!!

K3!c!< > - , !!

!

3

'%*&9!'8>'[email protected]#V=7@!0$%&-9!'*!M,;%B%&,!B,&'$,!*&!'8,! B*&B,N'9! *C! 9/N,$?9,&9%'%:,! d+>0?*&?>?0,>;e1! d+>0?*&?>?B8%Ne!>&;!d+>0?*&?>?P%$,e!&>&*?;,:%B,91!P8%B8!>$,!'>BQ+,;!C$*M! '8,! 9'>&;N*%&'9!*C!0*'8!>B>;,M%B!>&;! %&?;/9'$%>+!9B%,&B,6!<$*C6!_*+Q*:g9!N$,9,&'>'%*&! %9!>:>%+>0+,!C$*M!'8,!=FU!P,09%',G!

@..9JddLLL750-*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>Id_^K*4?*F^(2+*15E/:/+5^<*-?,@*979E66!

!@/+'%C/&B'%*&>+! F>&*',B8&*+*-(! C*$! 9,+,B'%:,! ;,?

',B'%*&!>&;!#$,>'M,&'!*C!B>&B,$1!"#$%&'#(1! %9!>&!U<I!+>$-,?9B>+,! B*++>0*$>'%:,! &>&*M,;%B%&,! N$*[,B'6! #8,!@]f#DU]F!B*&9*$'%/M!C*B/9,9!*&!'8,!;,:,+*NM,&'!>&;!:>+%;>'%*&! *C! &,P! &>&*',B8&*+*-%B>+! 9(9',M9! C*$! '8,!,>$+(1!9,+,B'%:,!;,',B'%*&!>&;!,+%M%&>'%*&!*C!0$,>9'!>&;!N>&B$,>'%B!B>&B,$!P%'8!$,;/B,;!9%;,!,CC,B'96!#8,!N$*[,B'!P%++! ;,N+*(! >! 9'$>',-(!0>9,;! *&! '8,!M/+'%C/&B'%*&>+%O>?'%*&! *C! M>-&,'%B! %$*&! *R%;,! &>&*N>$'%B+,9! T@F<9S! '*!N$*;/B,!>!N*',&'%>+!d'8,$>&*9'%Be!'**+1!B*M0%&%&-!;%>-?&*9'%B! >&;! '8,$>N,/'%B! C,>'/$,9! >->%&9'! B>&B,$*/9!0$,>9'1!N>&B$,>'%B!>&;!9',M!B,++96!#*!%MN$*:,!'8,!'$>&9?+>'%*&! *C! '8,! $,9,>$B8! */'B*M,9! >&;! '8,%$! ,B*&*M%B!N*',&'%>+1! >! M>[*$! N>$'! *C! '8,! N$*[,B'! %9! C*B/9,;! *&!9'/;(%&-!'8,!9B>+,?/N!*C!'8,!N$*;/B'%*&!M,'8*;9!C*$!'8,!M>%&! B*MN*&,&'9! @*$,! %&C*$M>'%*&! %9! >:>%+>0+,! C$*M!'8,!N$,9,&'>'%*&!*C!<$*C6!E*&%C>B%*!_,->!TD@.=71!AN>%&S!>'!'8%9!+%&QG!

@..9JddLLL750-*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>IdR^K5G2^(2+*15E/:/+5^<*-?,@*979E6!

!%\D(T^&(%! %9! >! +>$-,?9B>+,! B*++>0*$>'%:,! U<I! N$*?

[,B'!;,:*',;!'*!'8,!;,:,+*NM,&'!*C!&>&*B>$$%,$9!C*$!'8,!'$>&9N*$'! *C! '8,$>N,/'%B! M>B$*M*+,B/+,9! >B$*99! '8,!%&',9'%&>+! 0>$$%,$6! #8,! >;M%&%9'$>'%*&! *C! M,;%B>+! M>B?$*M*+,B/+,9! :%>! '8,!*$>+! $*/',!P%++!-$,>'+(! %&B$,>9,!N>?'%,&'g9! B*MN+%>&B,! >&;! W/>+%'(! *C! +%C,1! ,9N,B%>++(! C*$!B8$*&%B! ;%9,>9,9! '8>'! $,W/%$,! ;>%+(! >;M%&%9'$>'%*&! *C!M>B$*M*+,B/+>$! ;$/-91! 9/B8! >9! ;%>0,',96! `,'! '8,! *$>+!>;M%&%9'$>'%*&! $*/',! N*9,9! >! 0%-! B8>++,&-,! ;/,! '*! '8,!->9'$*%&',9'%&>+! ,&:%$*&M,&'1! P8%B8! ;,-$>;,9! M*9'!M>B$*M*+,B/+,96! F>&*N>$'%B+,9! >$,! >0+,! '*! *:,$B*M,!

4

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email protected]*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>Id8^R-2PE5+^(2+*15E/:/+5^<*-?,@*979E6!

!D$NhD(8N\! %9! >&*'8,$! +>$-,?9B>+,! B*++>0*$>'%:,!

U<I!N$*[,B'1!P%'8!'8,!>%M!*C!%;,&'%C(%&-!&*:,+!9'$>',-%,9!C*$! '8,! ,CC%B%,&'! '$>&9N*$'! *C! &>&*B>$$%,$9! '8$*/-8! '8,!M/B/9!-,+! +>(,$!T,6-6!%&',9'%&>+1!*B/+>$S1!P8%+,!>+9*!*N'%?M%O%&-! ,R%9'%&-! 9'$>',-%,96! D&! N>$'%B/+>$1! Vs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f=Ä7F.=V!B*&9*$'%/M!B*&?9%9'9! *C! 4K!N>$'&,$9! C$*M! J!=/$*N,>&! B*/&'$%,91!P%'8!5!/&%:,$9%'%,91! 2! $,9,>$B8! %&9'%'/',91! L! +>$-,! %&;/9'$%>+!N>$'&,$9!>&;!L!A@=96!@*$,!;,'>%+9!B>&!0,!C*/&;! %&!'8,!N$,9,&'>'%*&! *C! '8,! B**$;%&>'*$1! <$*C6! A%+Q,! @,-,+9Q%!T.=)X=@7!,6_6S!>'!'8,!C*++*P%&-!+%&QG!

!

@..9JddLLL750-*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>IdT^"5G54,?/^(2+*15E/:/+5^<*-?,@*979E6!

!#8,! +>9'! N$,9,&'>'%*&! *C! '8%9!h*$Q98*N! P>9! ;,;%?

B>',;! '*!N0-*(2+*"5E! &&! T=F@! DDS1! >&! =V7?F=#! /&;,$!'8,!U<I!F@<!N$*-$>MM,!2342i234Z1!N$,9,&',;!0(!'8,!

Page 46: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!!

V;!Z!< > - , !!

!

! !

5

B**$;%&>'*$1!<$*C6!F>'>+%>!@>$'%&1!*C!'8,!U$,&B8!F>'%*&?>+!V,9,>$B8!>-,&B(!T7FVS6!=F@!DD!%9!0>9,;!*&!'8,!C*/&?;>'%*&9! *C! =F@! D! T=V7?F=#! /&;,$! '8,! U<I! F@<! N$*?-$>MM,1! 233Hi2344S1! P8%B8! +>%;! '8,! -$*/&;! C*$! >!'$>&9&>'%*&>+!$,9,>$B8!N$*-$>MM,!'8>'!$,9N*&;9!'*!'8,!&,,;9!*C!'8,!&>&*M,;%B%&,!B*MM/&%'(!T=F@!D!9'$>',-%B!>-,&;>1!=#<!F>&*M,;%B%&,S6! =F@! DD!8>9!23!N>$'&,$9! %&!4I!B*/&'$%,91!>&;!%'9!M>%&!*0[,B'%:,9!>$,!'*!

!

• ;,:,+*N! %&&*:>'%:,!;%>-&*9'%B!>&;! '8,$>N,/'%B! 9*?+/'%*&9!C*$!'8,!N>'%,&'!

• 9*+:,! /&M,'!M,;%B>+! &,,;9! >&;! %MN$*:,! '8,! ,CC%?B>B(!*C!B/$$,&'!M,;%B>+!9*+/'%*&9!

• B*&'$%0/',! '*! M>'/$>'%*&! *C! '8,! &>&*M,;%B%&,!C%,+;!%&!=/$*N,!

• >++*P!M/+'%;%9B%N+%&>$(! B*++>0*$>'%*&! 0,'P,,&! '8,!0,9'!$,9,>$B8,$9a',>M9! %&!&>&*M,;%B%&,1!0$%&-%&-!'*-,'8,$! ',>M9! C$*M! >B>;,M%BaN/0+%B! $,9,>$B8!>&;!'8,!B+%&%B>+aN/0+%B!8,>+'8!%&;/9'$(!

• %&B$,>9,!'8,!>''$>B'%:,&,99!*C!M/+'%;%9B%N+%&>$(!>&;!'$>&9:,$9>+!&>&*M,;%B%&,!$,9,>$B8!'*!'8,!(*/&-,$!-,&,$>'%*&!*C!9B%,&'%9'9!

6

! N$*:%;,! >! N+>'C*$M! ;,;%B>',;! '*! (*/&-! 9B%,&?'%9'9g!%&C*$M>'%*&!>&;!&,'P*$Q%&-!

! /9,! 9N,B%C%B!M,>9/$,9! '*! 9'%M/+>',! '8,!N>$'%B%?N>'%*&!*C!(*/&-!9B%,&'%9'9!%&!'8,!=F@!DD!B>++9!

\'8,$!*0[,B'%:,9!*C!'8,!=F@!DD!>$,!'*!B*&'%&/,!'8,!=/$*N,>&! B**$;%&>'%*&! *C! $,9,>$B8! N$*-$>MM,9! %&! &>?&*M,;%B%&,1! %&',-$>'%&-! &,P! M,M0,$91! Q,,N%&-! B+*9,!$,+>'%*&9!P%'8! '8,! $,+,:>&'! 9'>Q,8*+;,$9! T,9N,B%>++(!'8,!=#<!F>&*M,;%B%&,S!>&;! '8,! $,9,>$B8!B*MM/&%'(! %&!*$?;,$!'*!$,>B'!C+,R%0+(!'*!&,,;9!>&;!&,P!;,:,+*NM,&'9!%&!&>&*M,;%B%&,6! D&! >;;%'%*&1! =F@! DD! >%M9! '*! B*++>0*$>',!P%'8!*'8,$!=V7?F=#9! '*!B$,>',! 9(&,$-%,9! '8>'! %&',-$>',!+,99*&9a9*+/'%*&9! +,>$&,;! C$*M! *'8,$9! Tk#)91! (*/&-! $,?9,>$B8,$91! 9/9'>%&>0%+%'(1! ,'B6S! >&;! %MN+,M,&'! B*MM*&!>B'%:%'%,9! TB>++91!P*$Q98*N91!,'B6S6! U/$'8,$!;,'>%+9!*C! '8,!N$,9,&'>'%*&!*&!=F@!DD!>$,!>:>%+>0+,!>'!'8%9!+%&[email protected]*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>Id(^"2-./+^(2+*15E/:/+5^<*-?,@*979E66!!

Page 47: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!!

K2!c!< > - , !!

O/G@4/G@.,!&&J!"2-?5.!T.-2.5G/5,!/+!.@5!"5E/:24!85F/:5!&+E0,.-P!BN('!<*-?,@*9!UC!!

!

1

F>&*M,;%B%&,!8>9!,9'>0+%98,;!>!9/09'>&'%>+!N$,9,&B,!%&!'*;>(É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â,+;1!N*%&'%&-!'*!'8,!C>B'!'8>'!>! +>$-,!N*$'%*&!*C! '8,!&>&*M,;%B%&,! >NN+%B>'%*&9! %;,&?'%â,;!>$,!9'%++!%&!'8,!$,9,>$B8!>&;!;,:,+*NM,&'!9'>-,6!!#8,! 9'/;(! $,:,>+9! 'P*! B+,>$! &,,;9! '8>'! 98*/+;! 0,! >;?;$,99,;! C*$! &>&*M,;%B%&,! '*! 9/BB,,;G! 4S!;,:,+*NM,&'!*C!>!B+,>$!>&;!,CC,B'%:,!*C!'8,!â,+;!>&;!2S!B$,>'%*&!*C!>!9'>&;>$;%O,;!>NN$*>B8!C*$!->'8,$%&-1!98>$%&-!>&;!'$>BQ?%&-! $,+,:>&'! %&C*$M>'%*&! *&! &>&*M,;%B>+! >NN+%B>'%*&9!>&;! N$*;/B'91!P%'8*/'! '8,! >;;%'%*&! *C! &,P! 0>$$%,$9! '*!M,;%B>+!%&&*:>'%*&6!!

#8,!(2+*.5:@+*4*GP! &+E0,.-/5,! D,,*:/2./*+! B(&DC!%9!>!B*MM%'',;!N>$'&,$!*C!%&;/9'$(!'8>'!9,,Q9!'*!>B8%,:,!'8,9,!9*+/'%*&96!FD7!>+9*!9/NN*$'9!M>$Q,'!%&',++%-,&B,!%&!&>&*M,;%B>+! >NN+%B>'%*&9!>&;!N$*;/B'9! '8$*/-8!>!&>&?*;>'>! 9,$:%B,! T>! ',&;,$! C*$! ;>'>?N$*:%;%&-! 9,$:%B,9! %&!9/NN*$'! *C! $,9,>$B8! >&;! N*+%B(! %&! '8,! C%,+;! *C! &>&*9B%?,&B,9!>&;!&>&*',B8&*+*-%,9S1!B*MM%99%*&,;!0(!.^!V,?9,>$B8!s! D&&*:>'%*&! C$*M! 234L! '*! 234I6!#8,! >%M! %9! '*!N$*:%;,! d9(9',M>'%B! %&9%-8'9! %&'*!'8,!P8*+,!&>&*?:>+/,!B8>%&1! C$*M!9B%,&'%C%B! $,9,>$B8! '*!M>$Q,'e! >&;!M,;%B>+!;,:%B,9!P%++! 0,! '8,! C%$9'! 9,B'*$!>&>+(O,;6! U/$'8,$! %&C*$?M>'%*&!*&!FD7g9!9/NN*$'!C*$!&>&*M,;%B%&,!B*MM,$B%>+?%O>'%*&!B>&!0,!C*/&;!%&!'8,!N$,9,&'>'%*&!*C!.$6!U$,;,$%BQ!F'*P!TFD7S!*&!'8,!=FU!P,09%',!>'!'8%9!+%&QG!

@..9JddLLL750-*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>Id'^(.*L^"2-?5.^T.-2.5G/5,^/+^.@5^"5E/:24^85F/:5^&+E0,.-P79E6!

!8&T)! \N]N(N\D%&[(! %9! >! N$*[,B'1!P8%B8! >%M9! '*! '$,>'!%&',$:,$',0$>+!;%9B!TD_.S!;,-,&,$>'%*&!:%>!>!'%99/,!,&-%?&,,$%&-! T#=S! >NN$*>B8! +,>;%&-! '*! '8,! $,-,&,$>'%*&! *C!

2

'8,!;%CC,$,&'!8%9'*+*-%B>+!B*MN>$'M,&'9!*C!'8,!;%9B6!#8,!N$*[,B'!*0[,B'%:,9!>$,!>9! C*++*P9G! T4S!V,-,&,$>'%*&!*C!>!8,>+'8(! D_.! >&;! $,9'*$>'%*&! *C! >! N8(9%*+*-%B>+! ;%9B?:,$',0$>+! 9(9',M! '8$*/-8!>NN$*N$%>',!0%*?M%M%BQ%&-!*C!'8,!>&>'*M(1!N8(9%*+*-(1!B,++!0%*+*-(!>&;!M,'>0*+%9M!*C!'8,! $,+,:>&'! &>'/$>+! 9'$/B'/$,9b! T2S! .,:,+*NM,&'! *C!&*:,+! 0%*M>',$%>+9! B>N>0+,! *C! B*&'$*++%&-! >&-%*-,&,9%9!9/B8! '8>'! %'! B>&! N$*B,,;! '*! '8,! ;%CC,$,&'! ,R',&'9! $,?W/%$,;!0(!;%CC,$,&'!$,-%*&9!*C!'8,!;%9B!9'$/B'/$,b!>&;!TLS!=&8>&B,;! %&',-$>'%*&!*C!'8,! D_.!P%'8!'8,!>;[>B,&'!:,$?',0$>+!0*;(!/N*&!%MN+>&'>'%*&6!#8,!N$,9,&'>'%*&!0(!.$6!f/%-%! 7M0$*9%*! >&;!.$6! f/%9>! #*&;,++%! B>&! 0,! C*/&;! >'!'8,!+%&Q!0,+*[email protected]*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>Id$^%*+E544/^"2-?5.^T.-2.5G/5,^/+^.@5^"5E/:24^85F/:5^&+E0,.-P79E6!

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

7ME,V! %9! >! N*%&'?*C?B>$,! N$*'*'(N,! ;,:%B,! ;,:,+?*N,;! >'! '8,! D&9'%'/',b! %'! >++*P9! C*$! M*&%'*$%&-! 0$,>'8!>MM*&%>!:%>!N$%&',;!9,&9*$!',B8&*+*-(!'8>'!/9,9!&>&*?N>$'%B/+>',!N*+(>&%+%&,!TF>&*<7FDS6! D'! %9!>! +*P?B*9'1!;%9?N*9>0+,! >&;! M>99?M>&/C>B'/$>0+,! 9>MN+,$a9,&9*$!B*MN*&,&'1! P%'8! >! B/9'*M?;,9%-&,;! 0$,>'8! 9>MN+%&-!9(9',M6! )+%&%B>+! >NN+%B>'%*&9! >$,! l%;&,(a+%:,$! ;(9C/&B?'%*&!>&;!X6N(+*$%!;,',B'%*&6!\'8,$!,R>MN+,9!*C!>B'%:%'%,9!>$,! >&'%0*;(! *N'%M%O>'%*&! C*$! 0%*B8%N! >NN+%B>'%*&9! T)?$,>B'%:,! N$*',%&1! )V<S1! -+>99(! 9/$C>B,! ;,N*9%'%*&! 0(!<=)_.!C*$!N*+(M,$!0%*B8%N!C/&B'%*&>+%O>'%*&!>&;!.%)7A#!T;%$,B'! B+*&,! >&>+(9%9! >&;! 9,+,B'%*&! ',B8&*+*-%,9S6! U/$?'8,$!;,'>%+9!B>&!0,!C*/&;!%&!.$6!E/$Q,g9!N$,9,&'>'%*&!*&!

Page 48: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!!

VM!Z!< > - , !!

!

3

'8,!=FU!P,09%',G!!

@..9JddLLL750-*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>Id)^R0-?5^"2-?5.^T.-2.5G/5,^/+^.@5^"5E/:24^85F/:5^&+E0,.-P79E6!

!/[(N1! DMN+>&'>0+,!\$->&%B!F>&*?=+,B'$*&%B91! %9! >&!

U<I!N$*[,B'!'8>'!>%M9!'*!0/%+;!'8,!Q&*P+,;-,!>&;!',B8?&*+*-(!$,W/%$,;!'*!$,-,&,$>',!&,$:,9!>'!'8,!9%',!*C!%&[/?$(6!#8,!/9,!*C!C+,R%0+,1!*$->&%B1!,+,B'$*&%B!;,:%B,9!T/9%&-!/+'$>?'8%&! C%+M! *$->&%B! C%,+;! ,CC,B'! '$>&9%9'*$9! zU=#9{1!*$->&%B! ,+,B'$*B8,M%B>+! '$>&9%9'*$9! *$! &>&*N>$'%B+,1!*$->&%B!M,M*$(!U=#9S!P%++!>;:>&B,!'8,!9'>',?*C?'8,?>$'!C*$! %MN+>&'>0+,! ;,:%B,9! C$*M! N>99%:,! '*! >B'%:,! +>(*/'9!'8>'!P%++!N$*M*',!&,$:,!$,-,&,$>'%*&!0(!>!B*M0%&>'%*&!*C! +*B>+! 9'%M/+%! ;,+%:,$,;!*&! ;,M>&;6! D&!>;;%'%*&1! '8,(!P%++! 9,&9,! %&C+>MM>'%*&! >&;! B*&'$*+! '8,! %MM/&,?a&C+>MM>'*$(!$,9N*&9,6!<$*C6!U>0%*!E%9B>$%&%!T]&%:,$9%'ä!;%!@*;,&>!,!V,--%*!=M%+%>!s!)FV?DA@FS!N$,9,&',;!'8,!N$*[,B'1! >&;! C/$'8,$!;,'>%+9! >$,!>:>%+>0+,!>'! '8,! C*++*P?%&-!+%&QG!

!

4

@..9JddLLL750-*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>Id'^R/,:2-/+/^"2-?5.^T.-2.5G/5,^/+^.@5^"5E/:24^85F/:5^&+E0,.-P79E6!

!%-2+,42./+G! -5,52-:@! .*! /+E0,.-/24! /++*F2./*+J! K5+5.*!(2+*.5:@! /+F*4F515+.! /+! .@5! 15E/:24! ,5:.*-!P>9! '8,!'%'+,! *C! .$6! <*OO%! @/B,++%g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email protected]*+2+*6*-01=>;M750dL9^:*+.5+.d094*2E,d=>;Md>IdT^Q^"0:544/^"2-?5.^T.-2.5G/5,^/+^.@5^"5E/:24^85F/:5^&+E0,.-P79E6!

Page 49: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!

KK!!

! !

!

2015 workshop

final multifun

february23-252015

'/+24!"04./60+!<*-?,@*9!=>;A!

Page 50: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

VA!Z!< > - , !!

'/+24!"04./60+!<*-?,@*9!=>;A!!

!

2

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

welcome

#multifunworkshop

During the last four years the MULTIFUN consortium has focused its activity on the development and validation of new systems based upon minimal invasive nanotechnology for the early and selective detection and elimination of breast and pancreatic cancer. The project has successfully produced multifuntionalised magnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (MNP) that combine diagnostic and therapeutic features against these two types of cancer.

The therapeutic approach developed within the project includes a synergistic effect between the therapeutic effect produced by magnetic hyperthermia and that due to the intracellular drug delivery selectively targeted to tumour cells.

Some of the designed formulations have proven their efficiency, safety and non-toxicicty in in vivo models, making them promising candidates to produce new nanomedicines against breast and pancreatic cancer.

The Madrid Institute for Advanced Studies in Nanoscience (IMDEA Nanociencia) is responsible of the scientific coordination of the project. Atos Spain S.A is the Administrative Coordinator and Contract Manager.

Prof. Rodolfo Miranda, MULTIFUN Scientific Coordinator &

IMDEA Nanociencia Director

Page 51: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!

KZ!c!< > - , !!

!

<*-?,@*9!9-*G-21!

!

4

nano

cien

cia

Monday 23 February 08.30 - 09.30 Registration

09.30 - 10:00 Opening session

Prof. Rodolfo Miranda, (MULTIFUN Scientific Coordina-tor & IMDEA Nanociencia Director)

Session 1: Introduction and Perspectives: Cancer Science

Chairperson: Prof. Rodolfo Miranda, IMDEA Nanociencia

10:00 - 10:45 Keynote speaker: Dr. Manuel Hidalgo, Centro Nacional de Investiga-ciones Oncológicas

“Nanodrugs: Development and Applications to Pan-creas Cancer Treatment”

10:45 - 11:30 Keynote speaker: Dr. José Antonio López, Instituto de Investigación Hospital 12 de Octubre

“An overview of cancer and (druggable-) immune response”

11:30 - 12:00 COFFEE BREAK

Session 2: Nanotoxicity, Biodistribution, Biodegradation

Chairperson: Prof. Yuri Volkov, Centre for Research on Adaptive Nanostructures, Trinity College Dublin

12:00 - 12:40 Keynote speaker: Prof. Florence Gazeau, Université Paris-Diderot-CNRS

“Ageing and biotransformation of nanomagnets in the body: How to conciliate therapeutic efficiency and safe life-cycle?”

12:40 - 13:30 Round table on regulation for manufacturing and biomedical applications of nanomaterials: safety on nanohandling.

Members: Prof. África González-Fernández Instituto de Investigaciones Biomédicas de Vigo - Universidad de Vigo, Prof. Florence Gazeau Université Paris-Diderot-CNRS, Prof. Yuri Volkov Trinity College Dublin

Moderator: Dr. Pilar Calvo Pharmamar

13:30 - 15:00 LUNCH BREAK

15:00 - 16:40 Poster session

Chairperson: Dr. Domingo F. Barber, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

16:40 - 17:10 Invited speaker: Prof. África González-Fernández, (Instituto de Investigaciones Biomédicas de Vigo - Uni-versidad de Vigo)

“Safety of nanomaterials: Immunotoxicology and inter-action between Nanomaterials and human proteins”

17:10 - 17:30 Mr. Vladimir Mulens, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

“Effect of Polyethylenimine-coated SPIONs on mac-rophage activation and podosome dynamics”

17:30 - 17:50 Dr. Lucía Gutiérrez, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

“Tracking magnetic nanoparticles in tissues by AC magnetic susceptibility: Recent achievements and future challenges”

17:50 - 18:10 Dr. Francisco Javier Chichón, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

“Soft X-ray tomography as quantitative tool to deci-pher the interaction between DMSA-SPION and MCF7 cancer cells”

18:10 - 18:30 Mr. K. Crosbie-Staunton, Trinity College Dublin “Multiparametric High Throughput Methods for Mag-

netic Iron Oxide Nanoparticle Lead Selection”

Tuesday 24 February Session 3: NanoDiagnostic

Chairperson: Prof. René Botnar, King’s College London

09:30 - 10:15 Keynote speaker: Prof. Kannan Krishnan, University of Washington

“Tracer development critical for translational medical applications of Magnetic Particle Imaging”

10:15 - 10:35 Prof. Yung-Ya Lin, University California, Los Angeles “Early Detection of Pancreatic Cancers & Brain

Tumors by MR Molecular Imaging”

10:35 - 10:55 Dr. F. Herranz, Centro Nacional de Investigaciones Car-diovasculares

“Parallel multifunctionalisation of Nanoparticles: A One-Step Modular Approach for in vivo Imaging”

10:55 - 11:15 Dr. Rocío Costo, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

“Improving magnetic properties of ultrasmall magnetic nanoparticles by biocompatible coatings”

10:15 - 11:30 Ms. Yurena Luengo, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

“Synthesis and characterization of bimetallic mag-netic oxides obtained by oxidative precipitation”

11:30 - 12:00 COFFEE BREAK

Chairperson: Dr. Jose Courty, CRRET-CNRS

12:00 - 12:20 Dr. Marzia Marciello, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

“Coating strategies for the application of magnetic nanoparticles in cancer diagnosis and therapy”

12:20 - 12:40 Dr. Wim Busing, FEI “Beyond the frontiers of the cell: unveiling the wonders

of nature at a molecular level”

12:40 - 13:30 Round table on entrepreneurship: from results to industry.

Members: Dr. Stephanie Teughels (CEO at Pepric), Dr. Rafael Ferritto (Co-founder and General Manager

Page 52: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

VI!Z!< > - , !!

!! !

5

nano

cien

cia

at NanoInnova Technologies), Ms. Cecilia Hernández (Head of Department Health, Bioeconomy, Climate and Natural Resources, Centre for Industrial Technological Development); Mr. Eduardo Díaz (Head of Unit New Technology Based Firms Unit, Fundación para el Cono-cimiento madri+d)

Moderator: Mr. Bonifacio Vega (Technology Transfer and Business Development Manager at IMDEA Nanociencia)

13:30 - 15:00 LUNCH BREAK

15:00 - 16:40 Poster session

Chairperson: Dr. Aitziber L. Cortajarena, IMDEA Nano-ciencia

16:40 - 17:10 Invited speaker: Dr Gray Kueberuwa, Institute of Cancer Sciences, University of Manchester

“Chimeric Antigen Receptor T-cells for Cancer Therapy”

17:10 - 17:30 Dr. Antonio Benayas, University of Quebec “At the Fluorescent Nanoprobes´ Frontiers: Multifunc-

tionality for Bio-Imaging and T-Sensing”

17:30 - 17:50 Dr. Ángel Millán, Instituto de Ciencias Materiales de Aragón

“Joining time-resolved thermometry and magnetic-induced heating in a single nanoparticle”

20:30 NETWORKING DINNER

Wednesday 25 February Session 3: NanoTherapy

Chairperson: Dr. Mª del Puerto Morales, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

09:30 - 10:15 Keynote speaker: Prof. Ingrid Hilger, University Hos-pital Jena

“Magnetic hyperthermia, a promising tool for the minimal-invasive treatment of tumors”

10:15 - 10:35 Dr. A. Roig, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Bar-celona-CSIC

“Encapsulation of VEGF165 in magnetic PLGA nano-capsules for potential local delivery and bioactivity into human brain endothelial cells”

10:35 - 10:55 Mr. D. Cabrera, IMDEA Nanociencia “Influence of nanoparticle size and field frequency on

the concentration dependence of magnetic heating”

10:55 - 11:15 Ms. Blanca del Rosal, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid “Intratumoral thermal reading during photothermal

therapy by multifunctional fluorescent nanoparticles”

11:15 - 11:35 Prof. Nguyen TK Thanh, University College London “Magnetic nanoparticle-based therapeutic agents for

thermo-chemotherapy treatment of cancer”

11.35 -12:00 COFFEE BREAK

Chairperson: Dr. Sara Trabulo, Barts Cancer Institute

12:00 - 12:20 Dr. Cristina Fornaguera, Instituto de Química Avanzada de Cataluña-CSIC

“Nano-emulsion templating: a versatile technology to prepare multifunctional polymeric nanoparticles for advanced biomedical applications”

12:20 - 12.40 Dr. Anna Aviñó, Instituto de Química Avanzada de Cataluña-CSIC

“G-quadruplex aptamers with therapeutic applications”

12:40 - 13:30 Round table on nanotherapy: small treats different.

Members: Prof. Ingrid Hilger (University Hospital of Jena), Dr. Domingo F. Barber (Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC), Dr. Petra Gener (Hospital Vall d’Hebron)

Moderator: Dr. Aitziber L. Cortajarena, IMDEA Nano-ciencia

13:30-15:00 LUNCH BREAK

Chairperson: Dr. Pilar Calvo, Pharmamar

15:00 - 15:30 Invited Speaker: Dr. Petra Gener, Hospital Vall d’Hebron “Targeted Drug Delivery Systems against Cancer Stem

Cells”

15:30 - 15:50 Ms. Alicia Soler Cantón, Delft University of Technology “Development of gene-expressing liposomes as drug

delivery systems”

15:50 - 16:10 Dr. Laura Gallego-Yerga, Universidad de Sevilla “Self-assembling nanoparticles based on calixarene-

cyclodextrin heterodimers for targeted delivery and controlled release of docetaxel”

16:10 - 16:30 Mr. Gustavo da Silva, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

“Design of biocompatible magnetic nanoplatforms for potential platinum-based drug delivery applications”

16:30 - 17:00 CLOSING REMARKS

Page 53: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!

KJ!c!< > - , !!

!

6

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

ORAL contributions

Monday 23rd (morning session)

1. Nanodrugs Development and Applica-tions to Pancreas Cancer, Dr. Manuel Hidalgo, Centro Nacional de Investigaciones Oncológicas

2. An overview of cancer and (drugabble-) Immune response, Dr. José Antonio López, Instituto de Investigación Hospital 12 de Octubre

3. Ageing and biotransformation of nanomagnets in the body: How to con-ciliate therapeutic efficiency and safe life-cycle, Prof. Florence Gazeau, U. Paris Diderot-CNRS

Monday 23rd (afternoon session)

4. Safety of Nanomaterials: Immunotoxicol-ogy and interaction between Nanoma-terials and human proteins, Prof. Africa González Fernández, Instituto de Investiga-ciones Biomédicas de Vigo (UVIGO)

5. Effect of Polyethylenimine-coated SPIO-NS on macrophage activation and podo-some dynamics, Dr. Vladimir Mulens, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

6. Tracking magnetic nanoparticles in tissues by AC magnetic susceptibility: Recent achievements and future chal-lenges, Dr. Lucía Gutiérrez, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

7. Soft X-ray tomography as quantitative tool to decipher the interaction between DMSA-SPION and MCF7 cancer cells, Dr. Francisco Javier Chichón, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

8. Multiparamagnetic High Throughput Methods for Magnetic Iron Oxide Nano-particle Lead Selection, Mr. K. Crosbie-Staunton, Trinity College Dublin

Tuesday 24th (morning session)

9. Tracer development critical for transla-tional medical applications of Magnetic Particle Imaging, Prof. Kannan Krishnan, University of Washington

10. Early detection of Pancreatic Cancers & Brain Tumors by MR Molecular Imaging, Prof. Yung-Ya Lin, University California, Los Angeles

11. Parallel multifuncionalisation of nano-particles: A One-Step Modular Approach for in vivo Imaging, Dr. Fernando Herranz, Centro Nacional de Investigaciones Cardio-vasculares

12. Improving magnetic properties of ultras-mall magnetic nanoparticles by biocom-patible coatings, Dr. Rocío Costo, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

13. Synthesis and characterization of bimetal-lic magnetic oxides obtained by oxidative precipitation, Ms. Yurena Luengo, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

14. Coating strategies for the application of magnetic nanoparticles in cancer diagno-sis and therapy, Dr. Marzia Marciello, Insti-tuto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

Page 54: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

VH!Z!< > - , !!

!

7

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

15. Beyond the frontiers of the cell: unveiling the wonders of nature at molecular level, Dr. Wim Busing, FEI

Tuesday 24th (afternoon session)

16. Chimeric Antigen Receptor T-cells for Cancer Therapy, Dr. Gray Kueberuwa, Institute of Cancer Sciences, University of Manchester

17. At the Fluorescent Nanoprobes’ Fron-tiers: Multifuncionality for Bio-Imaging and T-sensing, Dr. Antonio Benayas, University of Quebec

18. Joining time-resolved thermometry and magnetic-induced heating in a single nanoparticle, Dr. Ángel Millán, Instituto de Ciencias de Aragón

Wednesday 25th (morning session)

19. Magnetic hyperthermia, a promising tool for the minimal-invasive treatment of tumors, Prof. Ingrid Hilger, University Hospital Jena

20. Encapsulation of VEGF165 in magnetic PLGA nanocapsules for potential local delivery and bioactivity into human brain endothelial cells, Dr. A. Roig, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Barcelona-CSIC

21. Influence of nanoparticle size and field frequency on the concentration depend-ence of magnetic heating, Mr. David Cabrera, Fundación IMDEA Nanociencia

22. Intratumoral thermal reading during photothermal therapy by multifunctional

fluorescent nanoparticles, Ms. Blanca del Rosal, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid

23. Magnetic nanoparticle-based therapeu-tic agents for thermo-chemotherapy treatment of cancer, Prof. Nguyen TK Thanh, University College London

24. Nano-emulsion templating: a versatile technology to prepare multifunctional polymeric nanoparticles for advanced biomedical applications, Dr. Cristina Fornaguera, Instituto de Química Avanzada de Cataluña-CSIC

25. G-quadruplex aptamers with therapeutic applications, Dr. Anna Aviñó, Instituto de Química Avanzada de Cataluña-CSIC

Wednesday 25th (afternoon session)

26. Targeted Drug Delivery Systems against Cancer Stem Cells, Dr. Petra Gener, Hos-pital Vall d’Hebron

27. Development of gene-expressing lipo-somes as drug delivery systems, Ms. Alicia Soler Cantón, Delft University of Technology

28. Self-assembling nanoparticles based on calixarene-cyclodextrin heterodimers for targeted delivery and controlled release of docetaxel, Dr. Laura Gallego Yerga, Universidad de Sevilla

29. Design of biocompatible magnetic nan-oplatforms for potential platinum-based drug delivery applications, Mr. Gustavo da Silva, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

Page 55: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!

53!c!< > - , !!

!

8

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

POSTER contributions

23rd and 24th afternoon session

P1. Interaction of multifunctional magnet-ic nanoparticles with biological mem-branes, Ms. María José Rodríguez, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

P2. Biodistribution of magnetic nano-particles evaluated by AC magnetic susceptibility in a murine model, Mr. Eduardo Lorente-Sorolla, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales-CSIC

P3. C. elegans: an in vivo model to evaluate nanoparticles?, Dr. A. Roig, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Barcelona-CSIC

P4. Iron quantification inside cells incubated with SPION by Soft-Xray Absorption Spectro-Tomography (SXAST), Mr. José Javier Conesa, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

P5. Following the transformation of mag-netic nanoparticles over time in mac-rophages by AC magnetic susceptibil-ity, Ms. Vanesa del Dedo, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

P6. pH-Dependent Switch for Anticancer Metallodrugs, Mr. Francisco Martínez, Fundación IMDEA Nanociencia

P7. Superparamagnetic properties of hydrothermally prepared CoFe2O4 as a function of size (6–10 nm) and coating (oleic/citric acid or TiO2), Dr. Daniel Nižnanský, Charles University in Prague

P8. Targeting cancer cells with photoac-tive silica nanoparticles, Ms. Wioleta Borzecka, University of Aveiro

P9. Combinational sensitization of tumor cells with two photosensitizers syn-ergistically enhances their photody-namic inactivation in vitro, Ms. And-rea Tabero, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid

P10. Synthesis Strategies of Single-Core Magnetic Nanoparticles, Ms. Helena Gavilán, Instituto de Ciencia de Materi-ales de Madrid-CSIC

P11. Silica encapsulation of magnetic nan-oparticles, Ms. Leonor de la Cueva, Fundación IMDEA Nanociencia

P12. Synthesis of hybrid magneto-plas-monic nanostructures based on Au nanorods and iron oxides nanoparti-cles, Mr. Jesús G. Ovejero, Universidad Complutense de Madrid

P13. Functionalized magnetic nanoparti-cles for cancer therapy, Dr. Antonio Aires, Fundación IMDEA Nanociencia

P14. Detection and Inhibition of Mutated GNAQ Gene using Spherical Nucleic Acids, Ms. Ana Latorre, Fundación IMDEA Nanociencia

Page 56: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

A;!Z!< > - , !!

!

<*-?,@*9!@/G@4/G@.,!!F*P>;>(9!'8,$,!%9!>!9%-&%C%B>&'!->N!0,'P,,&!F>&*M,;%B%&,!$,9,>$B8!>&;!'8,!B+%&%B>+!N$>B'%B,6!#8,!'/+24!"04^./60+!<*-?,@*9!>'',MN',;!'*!*:,$B*M,!'8%9!->N1!>&;!+,:,$>-,;!'8,!'$>&9+>'%*&!C$*M!'8,!+>0*$>'*$(!'*!'8,!8*9N%'>+6!!

#8,!M>%&!>%M!*C!'8%9!P*$Q98*N!P>9!'*!B$,>',!>!9/%'>0+,!,&:%$*&M,&'!'*!C>:*/$! %&',$>B'%*&9!>&;!;%9B/99%*&!>M*&-!$,9,>$B8,$91!M,;%B>+!;*B'*$91!,&-%&,,$91!,&'$,N$,&,/$9!>&;!9'>Q,8*+;,$9! C$*M!;%CC,$,&'!;%9B%N+%&,96!#8,$,0(1! '8,!>0*:,!$,N*$',;!;%CC,$,&'!9,99%*&91! $*/&;'>0+,9!>&;!Q,(!9N,>Q,$9!>++*P,;!98>$%&-1!,RN,$%,&B,!>&;!C*9',$%&-!B*++>0*$>'%*&9!>B$*99!'8,!;%CC,$,&'!;%9B%N+%&,9!'8>'!'8,!&>&*M,;%B%&,!$,9,>$B8!C%,+;!,&'>%+,;6!

#8,!P*$Q98*N!%&:*+:,;!*/'9'>&;%&-!%&',$&>'%*&>+!9N,>Q,$9!>&;!9'>Q,8*+;,$9!%&!F>&*M,;%B%&,!>&;!\&B*+*-(1!N/0+%B! >/'8*$%'%,9! >&;! $,9,>$B8,$9! >$*/&;! =/$*N,6! #8,! N$*-$>MM,! %&B+/;,;! B*MN$,8,&9%:,! '>+Q91! 9N,B%>+!9,99%*&9!%&!B+%&%B>+!'$>&9+>'%*&!>&;!,&'$,N$,&,/$98%N1!;,0>',91!>&;!*$>+!>&;!N*9',$!N$,9,&'>'%*&9!T*C!@]f#D?U]F!$,9,>$B8,$9!>&;!$,9,>$B8,$9!*/'9%;,!'8,!B*&9*$'%/MS!*C!N,,$?$,:%,P,;!B*&'$%0/'%*&96!

\$>+!>&;!<*9',$!B*&'$%0/'%*&!;,'>%+9!B>&!0,!C*/&;!%&!N/$N*9,+(!N$,N>$,;!>&;!N/0+%B+(!>:>%+>0+,!C%&>+!@]f#D?U]F!P*$Q98*N!>:>%+>0+,!*&+%&,!>'!'8,!@]f#DU]F!N$*[,B'!P,09%',6!!U*$!B*&:,&%,&B,!P,!8>:,!>+9*!>''>B8,;!'8%9!>9!>NN,&;%R!>'!'8,!,&;!*C!'8,!;*B/M,&'6!

\&+%&,!h,0!>;;$,99G!8''NGaaPPP6M/+'%C/&?N$*[,B'6,/aB*&',&'aC%&>+?M/+'%C/&?2345?P*$Q98*N!

!

!

U%&>+!@]f#DU]F!P*$Q98*NG!,R>MN+,!*C!%&;/9'$(!;$%:,&!$*/&;!'>0+,!;%9B/99%*&!>$*/&;!'8,!',B8&*+*-%B>+!;,:,+*NM,&'!*C!F>&*M,;%B%&,?0>9,;!N$*;/B'9!

!

Page 57: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!

52!c!< > - , !!

<*-?,@*9!*-G2+/,/+G!:*11/..55!!

!

3

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

organizing committee

Chairperson:

Prof. Rodolfo Miranda (IMDEA Nanociencia)

Dr. Francisco J. Terán (IMDEA Nanociencia)

Dr. Adriele Prina Mello (TCD-CRANN)

Dr. César Mediavilla (ATOS)

advisory board committee Prof. Rene Botnar (KCL)

Dr. Pilar Calvo (Pharmamar)

Dr. Robert Clarke (UNIMAN)

Dr. Jose Courty (CRRET)

Dr. Domingo F. Barber (CSIC-CNB)

Prof. Christopher Heeschen (QMUL)

Dr. Aitziber L. Cortajarena (IMDEA Nanociencia)

Dr. Farouk Markos (UCC)

Dr. Mª del Puerto Morales (CSIC-ICMM)

Dr. Gorka Salas (IMDEA Nanociencia)

Prof. Yuri Volkov (TCD-CRANN)

Page 58: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

AM!Z!< > - , !!

!

!

Q034/:!9-*S5:.!L53,/[email protected]./60+^9-*S5:.750d:*+.5+.d9034/:^-5,04.,!

!

! !

Page 59: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!

5K!c!< > - , !!

D:?+*L45EG515+.,!#8,!<$*[,B'!)**$;%&>'*$!>&;!AB%,&'%C%B!)**$;%&>'%*&! B*MM%'',,!P*/+;! +%Q,! '*!>BQ&*P+,;-,! '8,! ,CC*$'9!*C! >++! N>$&',$9!%&:*+:,;!%&!'8,!@]f#DU]F!B*&9*$'%/M6!!

AN,B%>+!'8>&Q9!'*!'8,!P*$Q98*N!*$->&%9%&-!B*MM%'',,9!*C!'8,!'8$,,!,:,&'9!>&;!N>$'%B%N>'%&-!N>$'&,$9!C*$! '8,%$!;,;%B>?'%*&!>&;!8>$;!P*$Q!>'!'8,!B*$,!>B'%:%'%,9!*C!'8,!@]f#DU]F!N$*[,B'6!!

h,!,RN$,99!*/$!9%&B,$,!-$>'%'/;,!'*!'8,!@]f#DU]F!.%99,M%&>'%*&!B*MM%'',,!C*$!'8,%$!P*$Q6!

h,!P*/+;!>+9*!+%Q,!'*!N,$9*&>++(!'8>&Q!'8,!#).!F7F\@=.D)DF=!',>M!%&:*+:,;!%&!@]f#DU]F!N$*[,B'!>&;!.$6!.>$$>-8!)$*''(!C$*M!#).!C*$!'8,!P*$Q!>&;!;,;%B>'%*&!'*!N$*;/B,!'8%9!0**Q+,'6!

!

'0+E/+G!#8%9!P*$Q!P>9!9/NN*$',;!0(!'8,!=/$*N,>&!)*MM%99%*&!/&;,$!'8,!A,:,&'8!U$>M,P*$Q!<$*-$>MM,!C*B/9,;!*&!F>&*9B%?,&B,91!F>&*',B8&*+*-%,91!@>',$%>+9!>&;!F,P!<$*;/B'%*&!#,B8&*+*-%,9!TF@<S1!>9!'8,!@]f#DU]F!N$*[,B'!TU<I!F@<K?f7?2344?$,C6!2Z2HKLS6!! !

Page 60: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

!!!!

AA!Z!< > - , !!

D995+E/W!;!X!'/+24!"04./60+!L*-?,@*9!=>;AY!:*1945.5!3**?45.!!

!\&+%&,!h,0!>;;$,99G!8''NGaaPPP6M/+'%C/&?N$*[,B'6,/aB*&',&'aC%&>+?M/+'%C/&?2345?P*$Q98*N!!

!

2015 workshop

final multifun

february23-252015

Page 61: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

2

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

welcome

#multifunworkshop

During the last four years the MULTIFUN

consortium has focused its activity on

the development and validation of new

systems based upon minimal invasive

nanotechnology for the early and selective

detection and elimination of breast and

pancreatic cancer. The project has

successfully produced multifuntionalised

magnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (MNP)

that combine diagnostic and therapeutic

features against these two types of cancer.

The therapeutic approach developed within

the project includes a synergistic effect

between the therapeutic effect produced

by magnetic hyperthermia and that due to

the intracellular drug delivery selectively

targeted to tumour cells.

Some of the designed formulations

have proven their efficiency, safety and

non-toxicicty in in vivo models, making

them promising candidates to produce

new nanomedicines against breast and

pancreatic cancer.

The Madrid Institute for Advanced Studies

in Nanoscience (IMDEA Nanociencia) is

responsible of the scientific coordination

of the project. Atos Spain S.A is the

Administrative Coordinator and Contract

Manager.

Prof. Rodolfo Miranda, MULTIFUN Scientific Coordinator &

IMDEA Nanociencia Director

Page 62: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

3

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

organizing committee

Chairperson:

Prof. Rodolfo Miranda (IMDEA Nanociencia)

Dr. Francisco J. Terán (IMDEA Nanociencia)

Dr. Adriele Prina Mello (TCD-CRANN)

Dr. César Mediavilla (ATOS)

advisory board committee Prof. Rene Botnar (KCL)

Dr. Pilar Calvo (Pharmamar)

Dr. Robert Clarke (UNIMAN)

Dr. Jose Courty (CRRET)

Dr. Domingo F. Barber (CSIC-CNB)

Prof. Christopher Heeschen (QMUL)

Dr. Aitziber L. Cortajarena (IMDEA Nanociencia)

Dr. Farouk Markos (UCC)

Dr. Mª del Puerto Morales (CSIC-ICMM)

Dr. Gorka Salas (IMDEA Nanociencia)

Prof. Yuri Volkov (TCD-CRANN)

Page 63: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

4

nano

cien

cia

Monday 23 February 08.30 - 09.30 Registration

09.30 - 10:00 Opening session

Prof. Rodolfo Miranda, (MULTIFUN Scientific Coordina-tor & IMDEA Nanociencia Director)

Session 1: Introduction and Perspectives: Cancer Science

Chairperson: Prof. Rodolfo Miranda, IMDEA Nanociencia

10:00 - 10:45 Keynote speaker: Dr. Manuel Hidalgo, Centro Nacional de Investiga-ciones Oncológicas

“Nanodrugs: Development and Applications to Pan-creas Cancer Treatment”

10:45 - 11:30 Keynote speaker: Dr. José Antonio López, Instituto de Investigación Hospital 12 de Octubre

“An overview of cancer and (druggable-) immune response”

11:30 - 12:00 COFFEE BREAK

Session 2: Nanotoxicity, Biodistribution, Biodegradation

Chairperson: Prof. Yuri Volkov, Centre for Research on Adaptive Nanostructures, Trinity College Dublin

12:00 - 12:40 Keynote speaker: Prof. Florence Gazeau, Université Paris-Diderot-CNRS

“Ageing and biotransformation of nanomagnets in the body: How to conciliate therapeutic efficiency and safe life-cycle?”

12:40 - 13:30 Round table on regulation for manufacturing and biomedical applications of nanomaterials: safety on nanohandling.

Members: Prof. África González-Fernández Instituto de Investigaciones Biomédicas de Vigo - Universidad de Vigo, Prof. Florence Gazeau Université Paris-Diderot-CNRS, Prof. Yuri Volkov Trinity College Dublin

Moderator: Dr. Pilar Calvo Pharmamar

13:30 - 15:00 LUNCH BREAK

15:00 - 16:40 Poster session

Chairperson: Dr. Domingo F. Barber, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

16:40 - 17:10 Invited speaker: Prof. África González-Fernández, (Instituto de Investigaciones Biomédicas de Vigo - Uni-versidad de Vigo)

“Safety of nanomaterials: Immunotoxicology and inter-action between Nanomaterials and human proteins”

17:10 - 17:30 Mr. Vladimir Mulens, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

“Effect of Polyethylenimine-coated SPIONs on mac-rophage activation and podosome dynamics”

17:30 - 17:50 Dr. Lucía Gutiérrez, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

“Tracking magnetic nanoparticles in tissues by AC magnetic susceptibility: Recent achievements and future challenges”

17:50 - 18:10 Dr. Francisco Javier Chichón, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

“Soft X-ray tomography as quantitative tool to deci-pher the interaction between DMSA-SPION and MCF7 cancer cells”

18:10 - 18:30 Mr. K. Crosbie-Staunton, Trinity College Dublin “Multiparametric High Throughput Methods for Mag-

netic Iron Oxide Nanoparticle Lead Selection”

Tuesday 24 February Session 3: NanoDiagnostic

Chairperson: Prof. René Botnar, King’s College London

09:30 - 10:15 Keynote speaker: Prof. Kannan Krishnan, University of Washington

“Tracer development critical for translational medical applications of Magnetic Particle Imaging”

10:15 - 10:35 Prof. Yung-Ya Lin, University California, Los Angeles “Early Detection of Pancreatic Cancers & Brain

Tumors by MR Molecular Imaging”

10:35 - 10:55 Dr. F. Herranz, Centro Nacional de Investigaciones Car-diovasculares

“Parallel multifunctionalisation of Nanoparticles: A One-Step Modular Approach for in vivo Imaging”

10:55 - 11:15 Dr. Rocío Costo, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

“Improving magnetic properties of ultrasmall magnetic nanoparticles by biocompatible coatings”

10:15 - 11:30 Ms. Yurena Luengo, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

“Synthesis and characterization of bimetallic mag-netic oxides obtained by oxidative precipitation”

11:30 - 12:00 COFFEE BREAK

Chairperson: Dr. Jose Courty, CRRET-CNRS

12:00 - 12:20 Dr. Marzia Marciello, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

“Coating strategies for the application of magnetic nanoparticles in cancer diagnosis and therapy”

12:20 - 12:40 Dr. Wim Busing, FEI “Beyond the frontiers of the cell: unveiling the wonders

of nature at a molecular level”

12:40 - 13:30 Round table on entrepreneurship: from results to industry.

Members: Dr. Stephanie Teughels (CEO at Pepric), Dr. Rafael Ferritto (Co-founder and General Manager

Page 64: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

5

nano

cien

cia

at NanoInnova Technologies), Ms. Cecilia Hernández (Head of Department Health, Bioeconomy, Climate and Natural Resources, Centre for Industrial Technological Development); Mr. Eduardo Díaz (Head of Unit New Technology Based Firms Unit, Fundación para el Cono-cimiento madri+d)

Moderator: Mr. Bonifacio Vega (Technology Transfer and Business Development Manager at IMDEA Nanociencia)

13:30 - 15:00 LUNCH BREAK

15:00 - 16:40 Poster session

Chairperson: Dr. Aitziber L. Cortajarena, IMDEA Nano-ciencia

16:40 - 17:10 Invited speaker: Dr Gray Kueberuwa, Institute of Cancer Sciences, University of Manchester

“Chimeric Antigen Receptor T-cells for Cancer Therapy”

17:10 - 17:30 Dr. Antonio Benayas, University of Quebec “At the Fluorescent Nanoprobes´ Frontiers: Multifunc-

tionality for Bio-Imaging and T-Sensing”

17:30 - 17:50 Dr. Ángel Millán, Instituto de Ciencias Materiales de Aragón

“Joining time-resolved thermometry and magnetic-induced heating in a single nanoparticle”

20:30 NETWORKING DINNER

Wednesday 25 February Session 3: NanoTherapy

Chairperson: Dr. Mª del Puerto Morales, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

09:30 - 10:15 Keynote speaker: Prof. Ingrid Hilger, University Hos-pital Jena

“Magnetic hyperthermia, a promising tool for the minimal-invasive treatment of tumors”

10:15 - 10:35 Dr. A. Roig, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Bar-celona-CSIC

“Encapsulation of VEGF165 in magnetic PLGA nano-capsules for potential local delivery and bioactivity into human brain endothelial cells”

10:35 - 10:55 Mr. D. Cabrera, IMDEA Nanociencia “Influence of nanoparticle size and field frequency on

the concentration dependence of magnetic heating”

10:55 - 11:15 Ms. Blanca del Rosal, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid “Intratumoral thermal reading during photothermal

therapy by multifunctional fluorescent nanoparticles”

11:15 - 11:35 Prof. Nguyen TK Thanh, University College London “Magnetic nanoparticle-based therapeutic agents for

thermo-chemotherapy treatment of cancer”

11.35 -12:00 COFFEE BREAK

Chairperson: Dr. Sara Trabulo, Barts Cancer Institute

12:00 - 12:20 Dr. Cristina Fornaguera, Instituto de Química Avanzada de Cataluña-CSIC

“Nano-emulsion templating: a versatile technology to prepare multifunctional polymeric nanoparticles for advanced biomedical applications”

12:20 - 12.40 Dr. Anna Aviñó, Instituto de Química Avanzada de Cataluña-CSIC

“G-quadruplex aptamers with therapeutic applications”

12:40 - 13:30 Round table on nanotherapy: small treats different.

Members: Prof. Ingrid Hilger (University Hospital of Jena), Dr. Domingo F. Barber (Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC), Dr. Petra Gener (Hospital Vall d’Hebron)

Moderator: Dr. Aitziber L. Cortajarena, IMDEA Nano-ciencia

13:30-15:00 LUNCH BREAK

Chairperson: Dr. Pilar Calvo, Pharmamar

15:00 - 15:30 Invited Speaker: Dr. Petra Gener, Hospital Vall d’Hebron “Targeted Drug Delivery Systems against Cancer Stem

Cells”

15:30 - 15:50 Ms. Alicia Soler Cantón, Delft University of Technology “Development of gene-expressing liposomes as drug

delivery systems”

15:50 - 16:10 Dr. Laura Gallego-Yerga, Universidad de Sevilla “Self-assembling nanoparticles based on calixarene-

cyclodextrin heterodimers for targeted delivery and controlled release of docetaxel”

16:10 - 16:30 Mr. Gustavo da Silva, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

“Design of biocompatible magnetic nanoplatforms for potential platinum-based drug delivery applications”

16:30 - 17:00 CLOSING REMARKS

Page 65: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

6

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

ORAL contributions

Monday 23rd (morning session)

1. Nanodrugs Development and Applica-

tions to Pancreas Cancer, Dr. Manuel

Hidalgo, Centro Nacional de Investigaciones

Oncológicas

2. An overview of cancer and (drugabble-)

Immune response, Dr. José Antonio

López, Instituto de Investigación Hospital 12

de Octubre

3. Ageing and biotransformation of

nanomagnets in the body: How to con-

ciliate therapeutic efficiency and safe

life-cycle, Prof. Florence Gazeau, U. Paris

Diderot-CNRS

Monday 23rd (afternoon session)

4. Safety of Nanomaterials: Immunotoxicol-

ogy and interaction between Nanoma-

terials and human proteins, Prof. Africa

González Fernández, Instituto de Investiga-

ciones Biomédicas de Vigo (UVIGO)

5. Effect of Polyethylenimine-coated SPIO-

NS on macrophage activation and podo-

some dynamics, Dr. Vladimir Mulens, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

6. Tracking magnetic nanoparticles in

tissues by AC magnetic susceptibility:

Recent achievements and future chal-

lenges, Dr. Lucía Gutiérrez, Instituto de

Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

7. Soft X-ray tomography as quantitative

tool to decipher the interaction between

DMSA-SPION and MCF7 cancer cells,

Dr. Francisco Javier Chichón, Centro

Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

8. Multiparamagnetic High Throughput

Methods for Magnetic Iron Oxide Nano-

particle Lead Selection, Mr. K. Crosbie-

Staunton, Trinity College Dublin

Tuesday 24th (morning session)

9. Tracer development critical for transla-

tional medical applications of Magnetic

Particle Imaging, Prof. Kannan Krishnan, University of Washington

10. Early detection of Pancreatic Cancers &

Brain Tumors by MR Molecular Imaging,

Prof. Yung-Ya Lin, University California, Los

Angeles

11. Parallel multifuncionalisation of nano-

particles: A One-Step Modular Approach

for in vivo Imaging, Dr. Fernando Herranz, Centro Nacional de Investigaciones Cardio-

vasculares

12. Improving magnetic properties of ultras-

mall magnetic nanoparticles by biocom-

patible coatings, Dr. Rocío Costo, Instituto

de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

13. Synthesis and characterization of bimetal-

lic magnetic oxides obtained by oxidative

precipitation, Ms. Yurena Luengo, Instituto

de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

14. Coating strategies for the application of

magnetic nanoparticles in cancer diagno-

sis and therapy, Dr. Marzia Marciello, Insti-

tuto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

Page 66: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

7

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

15. Beyond the frontiers of the cell: unveiling

the wonders of nature at molecular level,

Dr. Wim Busing, FEI

Tuesday 24th (afternoon session)

16. Chimeric Antigen Receptor T-cells for

Cancer Therapy, Dr. Gray Kueberuwa, Institute of Cancer Sciences, University of

Manchester

17. At the Fluorescent Nanoprobes’ Fron-

tiers: Multifuncionality for Bio-Imaging

and T-sensing, Dr. Antonio Benayas, University of Quebec

18. Joining time-resolved thermometry and

magnetic-induced heating in a single

nanoparticle, Dr. Ángel Millán, Instituto

de Ciencias de Aragón

Wednesday 25th (morning session)

19. Magnetic hyperthermia, a promising

tool for the minimal-invasive treatment

of tumors, Prof. Ingrid Hilger, University

Hospital Jena

20. Encapsulation of VEGF165 in magnetic

PLGA nanocapsules for potential local

delivery and bioactivity into human brain

endothelial cells, Dr. A. Roig, Instituto de

Ciencia de Materiales de Barcelona-CSIC

21. Influence of nanoparticle size and field

frequency on the concentration depend-

ence of magnetic heating, Mr. David

Cabrera, Fundación IMDEA Nanociencia

22. Intratumoral thermal reading during

photothermal therapy by multifunctional

fluorescent nanoparticles, Ms. Blanca del

Rosal, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid

23. Magnetic nanoparticle-based therapeu-

tic agents for thermo-chemotherapy

treatment of cancer, Prof. Nguyen TK

Thanh, University College London

24. Nano-emulsion templating: a versatile

technology to prepare multifunctional

polymeric nanoparticles for advanced

biomedical applications, Dr. Cristina

Fornaguera, Instituto de Química Avanzada

de Cataluña-CSIC

25. G-quadruplex aptamers with therapeutic

applications, Dr. Anna Aviñó, Instituto de

Química Avanzada de Cataluña-CSIC

Wednesday 25th (afternoon session)

26. Targeted Drug Delivery Systems against

Cancer Stem Cells, Dr. Petra Gener, Hos-

pital Vall d’Hebron

27. Development of gene-expressing lipo-

somes as drug delivery systems, Ms.

Alicia Soler Cantón, Delft University of

Technology

28. Self-assembling nanoparticles based on

calixarene-cyclodextrin heterodimers for

targeted delivery and controlled release

of docetaxel, Dr. Laura Gallego Yerga, Universidad de Sevilla

29. Design of biocompatible magnetic nan-

oplatforms for potential platinum-based

drug delivery applications, Mr. Gustavo

da Silva, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales

de Madrid-CSIC

Page 67: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

8

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

POSTER contributions

23rd and 24th afternoon session

P1. Interaction of multifunctional magnet-

ic nanoparticles with biological mem-

branes, Ms. María José Rodríguez, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

P2. Biodistribution of magnetic nano-

particles evaluated by AC magnetic

susceptibility in a murine model, Mr.

Eduardo Lorente-Sorolla, Instituto de

Ciencia de Materiales-CSIC

P3. C. elegans: an in vivo model to evaluate

nanoparticles?, Dr. A. Roig, Instituto de

Ciencia de Materiales de Barcelona-CSIC

P4. Iron quantification inside cells

incubated with SPION by Soft-Xray

Absorption Spectro-Tomography

(SXAST), Mr. José Javier Conesa, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC

P5. Following the transformation of mag-

netic nanoparticles over time in mac-

rophages by AC magnetic susceptibil-

ity, Ms. Vanesa del Dedo, Instituto de

Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid-CSIC

P6. pH-Dependent Switch for Anticancer

Metallodrugs, Mr. Francisco Martínez, Fundación IMDEA Nanociencia

P7. Superparamagnetic properties of

hydrothermally prepared CoFe2O4

as a function of size (6–10 nm) and

coating (oleic/citric acid or TiO2), Dr.

Daniel Nižnanský, Charles University in

Prague

P8. Targeting cancer cells with photoac-

tive silica nanoparticles, Ms. Wioleta

Borzecka, University of Aveiro

P9. Combinational sensitization of tumor

cells with two photosensitizers syn-

ergistically enhances their photody-

namic inactivation in vitro, Ms. And-

rea Tabero, Universidad Autónoma de

Madrid

P10. Synthesis Strategies of Single-Core

Magnetic Nanoparticles, Ms. Helena

Gavilán, Instituto de Ciencia de Materi-

ales de Madrid-CSIC

P11. Silica encapsulation of magnetic nan-

oparticles, Ms. Leonor de la Cueva, Fundación IMDEA Nanociencia

P12. Synthesis of hybrid magneto-plas-

monic nanostructures based on Au

nanorods and iron oxides nanoparti-

cles, Mr. Jesús G. Ovejero, Universidad

Complutense de Madrid

P13. Functionalized magnetic nanoparti-

cles for cancer therapy, Dr. Antonio

Aires, Fundación IMDEA Nanociencia

P14. Detection and Inhibition of Mutated

GNAQ Gene using Spherical Nucleic

Acids, Ms. Ana Latorre, Fundación

IMDEA Nanociencia

Page 68: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

ORAL contr ibut ion

Page 69: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

10

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

2 .An overview of cancer and (druggable-) immune responseDr. José Antonio LópezTranslational Oncology Group co-Director,`12 de Octubre’ Research Institute Attending Physician,

‘12 de Octubre’ University Hospital

Abstract: The immune system has a great potential for the specific destruction of tumours

and for long-term memory that can prevent cancer recurrence. The probability of an effec-

tive tumour immune response depends on 1- the existence of tumour antigens and 2- the

possibility of modulating the mechanisms of suppression of tumour immune response.

Tumour escape from immunosurveillance be achieved either by changes in the tumour cells

(loss of tumour antigens, loss of human leukocyte antigen molecules, loss of sensitivity to

complement, or T cell or natural killer (NK) cell lysis) or by tumour subvertion of the normal

immune regulation. Tumour immunity can be enhanced by blocking inhibitory pathways and

inhibitory cells in the tumour microenvironment, or by increasing the specificity of antitumour

immunity, inducing the expansion of T cells and antibodies directed to well-defined tumour

antigens (e.g. cancer vaccines, potent adjuvants, immunostimulatory cytokines). These

strategies can be pursued either alone or as part of a multimodal therapy.

3 .Ageing and biotransformation of nanomagnets in the body: How to conciliate therapeutic efficiency and safe life-cycle?Florence GazeauMatière et Systèmes Complexes, CNRS / Université Paris Diderot

75205 Paris Cedex 13, FRANCE

[email protected]

The increasing exposure of living organism to nanoparticles calls for a comprehensive assess-

ment of the processing of nanomaterials in vivo. Understanding nanoparticles distribution,

transformations, persistence, ageing and degradation will help to predict exposure risks as

Page 70: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

11

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

well as therapeutic efficiency of nanoparticles. The challenge is to establish how the synthetic

identity of nanoparticles can determine their whole life cycle in the body.

We have developped a multiscale methodology to examine the influence of biological envi-

ronment on the structure and physical properties of magnetic nanoparticles that show

outstanding properties for magnetothermal therapy and MRI detection.

Our approach, which is based on materials sciences, is combining nanoscale electron micro-

scopy observations of nanoparticle with the follow-up of magnetic properties in biological

environments. From several examples of magnetic nanostructures – iron oxide nanospheres,

nanocubes, cooperative nanoflowers and iron oxide/gold dimers with different coating – we

will examine how cell-induced transformations critically alter the nanoparticles magnetic

properties, heating power and Magnetic Resonance relaxivity over time and determine the

long term fate of the nanoparticles in the organism. In the research for safe and efficient

nanoparticles for nanomedecine, one should control the balance between short term efficacy

in the relevant biological context and long term degradability and clearance from the body.

References1. Lartigue L, Alloyeau D, Kolosnjaj-Tabi J, Javed Y, Guardia P, Riedinger A, Péchoux C, Pellegrino T, Wilhelm C,

Gazeau F. Biodegradation of Iron Oxide Nanocubes: High-Resolution In Situ Monitoring. ACS Nano 2013, 7, 3939-3952.

2. Kolosnjaj-Tabi J, Di Corato R, Lartigue L, Marangon I, Guardia P, Silva AK, Luciani N, Flaud P, Clément O, Singh JV, Decuzzi P, Pellegrino T, Wilhelm C, Gazeau F. Heat-Generating Iron Oxide Nanocubes: Subtle “Destructu-rators” of the Tumoral Microenvironment. ACS Nano 2014, May 27;8(5):4268-83

3. Javed Y, Lartigue L,Hugounenq P, Vuong QL, Gossuin Y, Bazzi R, Wilhelm C, Ricolleau C, Gazeau F*, Alloyeau A*. Biodegradation mechanism of iron oxide monocrystalline nanoflowers and tunable shield effect of gold coating, Small, 2014 Aug 27;10(16):3325-37

4 .Safety of nanomaterials: Immunotoxicology and interaction between Nanomaterials and human proteins. Prof. África González-FernándezMD, PhD, Immunologist

Professor of Immunology

Director of the Biomedical Research Center (CINBIO)

Coordinator of BIOCAPS (EU 7º FW program)

Page 71: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

12

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

UNIVERSITY OF VIGO Campus Lagoas Marcosende

36310 Vigo, Pontevedra

Spain

phone: +34-986812625

fax: +34-986812556

email: [email protected]; [email protected]

The use of nanomaterials (NMs) is increasing in the last years because of their potential to

improve a wide range of applications, especially in the biomedical field. However, NMs can

interact with the body inducing undesirable or desirable effects. It is crucial to understand

their potential harmful effects, and the success of the NMs on biomedical applications will

partially depend on their interactions with blood and immune components. The immune

system has the role, between other functions, of defending the body from foreign materials.

The study of the interaction between the components of the immune system and NMs is,

therefore, an area of great interest. Moreover, NMs can be used in biomedicine to target

different cells to modulate their function towards a desired response, for example in vac-

cines. The talk will focus on how the interactions between NMs and biological systems could

affect to the normal function of these systems.

5 .Effect of Polyethylenimine-coated SPIONs on macrophage activation and podosome dynamicsAuthors: Vladimir Mulens1, José Manuel Rojas1, Sonia Pérez-Yagüe1, María del Puerto Mora-

les2, Domingo F. Barber1*

1. Department of Immunology and Oncology and NanoBiomedicine Initiative, Centro Nacional de

Biotecnología (CNB)/CSIC, Darwin 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

2. Department of Biomaterials and Bioinspired Materials, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid

(ICMM)/CSIC, Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

Mulens V. email address: [email protected]

Huge efforts have been made to develop multifunctional platforms for cancer gene therapy.

One of the current strategies is the combination of SPIONs (superparamagnetic iron oxide

nanoparticles) and polyethylenimine (PEI), due to their unique chemical and physical proper-

ties. PEI appears to activate different immune cells toward an inflammatory response (M1/

TH1), whereas the response induced by SPIONs seems to be controversial. Nonetheless,

Page 72: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

13

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

the immunoreactivity of PEI-coated SPIONs has not been addressed so far. In the present

study, we proved that PEI-coated SPIONs (PMag) induce an M1 phenotype. PMag induced

phosphorylation of p38 MAPK, p44/p42 MAPK and JNK, and upregulation of CD40, CD80,

CD86 and I-A/I-E activation markers. Importantly, PMag-induced macrophage activation

depended partially on TLR4 (Toll-like receptor 4) and ROS (reactive oxygen species) signal-

ing, and was different from that induced by LPS. Intriguingly, PMag promoted podosome

formation in murine macrophages, but inhibited gelatin degradation. This effect seems to

be due to the overexpression of genes related with MMP inhibitors and downmodulation

of active MMP-2. In conclusion, PMag induced an M1-like phenotype that was partially

dependent on both TLR4 and ROS, and modulated the dynamics of podosomes.

6 .Tracking magnetic nanoparticles in tissues by AC magnetic susceptibility: Recent achievements and future challengesLucía Gutiérreza, Raquel Mejíasb,c, Domingo F. Barberb, Francisco J. Lázarod and M. Puerto

Moralesa

a. Dept. Biomaterials and Bioinspired Materials, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid (ICMM)/

CSIC, Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

b. Dept. Immunology and Oncology, and NanoBiomedicine Initiative, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología

(CNB)/CSIC, Darwin 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

c. Department of Biomedical Engineering, Vanderbilt University, 5824 Stevenson Center, Nashville,

Tennessee 37235-1631, USA

d. Dept. de Ciencia y Tecnología de Materiales y Fluidos, Universidad de Zaragoza, Maria de Luna

3, 50018, Zaragoza, Spain

[email protected]

The quantitative determination of magnetic nanoparticles in tissue samples from animal

models using magnetic measurements is helpful but not free of difficulties. Once the particles

enter the body, they become surrounded by a wide variety of proteins and other molecules,

altering their environment, possibly their degree of aggregation, and therefore the magnetic

interparticle interactions. Also, due to ultrastructural differences, each organ may present

a characteristic way of packing the particles forfurther processing that can also result in

an alteration of the magnetic properties of the material. Furthermore, these systems suffer

a continuous transformation process, where degradation of the particles also affects the

magnetic properties of the whole tissue. Due to these complex factors, the comparison

Page 73: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

14

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

between the magnetic properties of the administered compound and those of the tissue

samples containing the particles is not always straightforward.

Based on AC magnetic susceptibility measurements of freeze-dried tissue samples, we

have developed a protocol to quantify magnetic nanoparticles in animal organs [1]. This

characterization protocol has been recently used to study the biodistribution of magnetic

nanoparticles in mouse models, and the effects of the particle coating on the biodistribution

[2,3]. It has also been used to follow particle transformations over long time periods [4]. The

advantages of this technique include the possibility to distinguish the particles from other

endogenous species such as the ferritin iron cores, and that no prior isolation procedures,

potentially altering the results, are required. Nevertheless, especial attention has to be paid

to the influence of interparticle dipolar interactions in the different tissues and the possible

reduction of the particle size due to degradation processes, as both parameters affect the

magnetic susceptibility results. We will describe the developed quantification protocol and

our recent results on the quantification of magnetic nanoparticles in tissue samples. Future

possible approaches to improve this characterization technique will be discussed.

Figure 1. Schematic representation of some parameters that affect the out-of-phase susceptibil-

ity used for the quantitative determination of magnetic nanoparticles in tissue samples.

References1. L. Gutiérrez et al. Phys.Chem.Chem.Phys.,16 (2014) 4456.2. R. Mejías et al. Biomaterials, 32 (2011) 2938.3. L. Gutiérrez et al. J. Phys. D, App, Phys.,44 (2011) 2550024. R. Mejías et al. J. Controlled Release, 171 (2013) 225.

Page 74: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

15

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

7 .Soft X-ray tomography as quantitative tool to decipher the interaction between DMSA-SPION and MCF7 cancer cellsFrancisco Javier Chichóna, José Javier Conesa1a, Michele Chiappia, Eva Pereirob, Maria Josefa

Rodrigueza, and José L. Carrascosaa,c

a. Centro Nacional de Biotecnología (CNB-CSIC), Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain.

b. ALBA Synchrotron Light Source. MISTRAL Beamline - Experiments division. 08290 Cerdanyola

del Vallès, Barcelona, Spain.

c. Instituto Madrileño de Estudios Avanzados en Nanociencia (IMDEA Nanociencia), Cantoblanco,

28049 Madrid, Spain

[email protected]

In the last years the use of nanotechnology in medicine opened a broad field for studying cell-

nanoparticle interaction. Due to their relatively easy generation and their low toxicity, iron magnetic

nanoparticles are nowadays very promising. Superparamagnetic nanoparticles (SPION) could be

coated with specific agent to target cells for drug delivery. Their magnetic properties also allow the

manipulation of threated cells for cellular sorting or to induce cellular death by processes, such as

hyperthermia. Those are feasible and important objectives in nanobiotechnology. In this frame, we

have used Soft-X-ray microscopy to decipher and quantify the interaction of superparamagnetic

iron oxide nanoparticles with average diameter of 15 nm (DMSA-SPION) with MCF-7 human

breast cancer cells [1]. SPION were incubated from 0 to 24 h with cells and cryo-preserved

by plunge freezing. We also performed correlative microscopy to locate by cryo-epifluorescent

microscopy the Internalized SPION accumulations in the endocytic pathway and therefore, the

samples were submitted to cryo Soft X-ray tomography (cSXT) to get whole cell volume maps.

This is an emerging three-dimensional technique that exploits Soft X-rays high penetration into

the biological matter to imaging vitrified cells at nanometric 3D resolution without chemical fixa-

tion or staining agents [2]. The three-dimensional reconstructions of whole cells allowed us to

perform statistical analysis of SPION accumulation. Our results enlighten parameters such the

average vesicles size, distance between them, distance to the nucleus and accumulation rates

that characterize this type of accumulation. This new approach opens a new door to study in a

quantitative way and with high resolution the interaction of nanoparticles and cells.

References1. [1] M.Calero, M.Chiappi, et al., “Characterization of interaction of magnetic nanoparticles with breast cancer

cells”. Journal: Journal of Nanobiotechnology “in press”.

2. [2] Pereiro, Eva; and Chichón, Francisco Javier (November 2014) Cryo-Soft X-ray Tomography of the cell. In: eLS. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd: Chichester. DOI: 10.1002/9780470015902.a0025582

Page 75: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

16

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

8 .Multiparametric High Throughput Methods for Magnetic Iron Oxide Nanoparticle Lead Selection

K. Crosbie-Staunton1*, G. Salas2,3, O. Gobbo4, M. Marciello2,3, P. Couleaud3, B. M Mohamed1,

T. Rakovich1, R. Miranda5,6, M. del Puerto Morales2, A. Prina-Mello1,7, Y. Volkov1,7

1. School of Medicine, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland.

2. Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid/CSIC, Madrid, Spain.

3. IMDEA Nanociencia, Madrid, Spain.

4. School of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland.

5. Instituto Madrileño de Estudios Avanzados, IMDEA Nanociencia, Madrid, Spain.

6. Departamento de Física de la Materia Condensada, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain.

7. CRANN and AMBER Research Centres, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland.

* Corresponding author, [email protected]

Introduction: The application of magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) can be tailored on a case

by case basis by coupling them simultaneously with targeting moieties and medicinal drugs,

which make multifunctional (MF) MNPs suitable for theranostic applications. Their poten-

tial role as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) contrast agents, in drug and gene delivery

platforms and hyperthermia are being intensely researched [4]. This study, as part of the

MULTIFUN FP7 project, focuses on the multiparametric biocompatibility testing of a range

of MNPs to select lead formulations. Further testing of the selected leads following function-

alization with a targeting ligand (NUCANT 6L, N6L) and chemotherapeutic drugs (Doxoru-

bicin and Gemcitabine) in breast cell lines was conducted to identify suitable theranostic

MF-MNPs. Experimental procedure: Physicochemical characterisation of MNPs was carried

out by transmission electron microscopy, dynamic light scattering and nanoparticle tracking

analysis prior to cell exposure. A high throughput approach to determine biocompatibility

was implemented with a range of MNP concentrations tested in breast-derived cell lines.

Multiparametric analysis was conducted to determine the changes in the total cell count,

cell membrane permeability and lysosomal mass/pH while flow cytometry was employed

to further investigate the effect on cell cycle progression with one lead MNP. Main results:

OD15 and MF66 MNPs below 100 µg/mL did not reduce cell viability or induce damage to

the cell membrane, and were selected as the lead formulations for functionalization. Cell

cycle analysis by flow cytometry with cells exposed to a range of MF66 MNP concentra-

tions was conducted to ensure that MF66 was suitable to bring forward. It was determined

that MF66 did not alter the normal cell cycle at concentrations below 100 ug/mL and was

considered a suitable lead formulation. N6L was previously shown to target nucleolin and

nuclophosmin on the cell surface and inhibit malignant tumour growth, angiogenesis and

cancer cells invasion alike [5]. We demonstrate that free N6L exposure at 72 h timepoint

Page 76: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

17

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

reduces cell count in a dose dependent manner and is most pronounced in breast cancer

cell lines compared to the normal-like breast-derived cell line, which is consistent with previ-

ously published data. However, functionalised OD15 and MF66 MNPs containing N6L did

not demonstrate similar efficacy compared to the free ligand. Therefore, we utilised N6L as

a targeting moiety to facilitate greater MNP uptake into the MCF-7 and MCF-10A cells with

chemotherapy drug-functionalised MNPs. We found that N6L-functionalised MF-MNPs

had enhanced uptake and chemotherapeutic drug delivery efficacy compared to N6L-free

MF-MNPs. Conclusion: This study demonstrates that by implementing an in-depth investiga-

tion of physicochemical properties and multiparametric cytotoxicity analysis, it is possible

to select MNP formulations and subsequently select targeted MF-MNP leads for transfer to

in vivo animal models and clinical exploitation.

Acknowledgement: This work is partially funded by the European Commission under the

FP7 programme (MULTIFUN project: NMP4-LA-2011-262943)

References:1. Gultepe E, Reynoso FJ, Jhaveri A et al.: Monitoring of magnetic targeting to tumor vasculature through MRI and

biodistribution. Nanomedicine (Lond) 5(8), 1173-1182 (2010).

2. Roca AG, Veintemillas-Verdaguer S, Port M, Robic C, Serna CJ, Morales MP: Effect of nanoparticle and aggregate size on the relaxometric properties of MR contrast agents based on high quality magnetite nanoparticles. The journal of physical chemistry. B 113(19), 7033-7039 (2009).

3. Corr SA, O’byrne A, Gun’ko YK et al.: Magnetic-fluorescent nanocomposites for biomedical multitasking. Chemical communications (43), 4474-4476 (2006).

4. De Jong WH, Borm PJ: Drug delivery and nanoparticles:applications and hazards. International journal of nano-medicine 3(2), 133-149 (2008).

5. Destouches D, Huet E, Sader M et al.: Multivalent pseudopeptides targeting cell surface nucleoproteins inhibit cancer cell invasion through tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinases 3 (TIMP-3) release. The Journal of biological chemistry 287(52), 43685-43693 (2012).

9 .Tracer development critical for translational medical applications of Magnetic Particle Imaging

Kannan M. KrishnanDepartment of Materials Science & Engineering

University of Washington, 323 Roberts Hall,

Box 352120, Seattle, WA 98195

Page 77: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

18

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

The performance of Magnetic Particle Imaging (MPI), a new whole-body medical imaging

technology with promise in vascular angiography and molecular imaging, depends largely

on the structural, chemical, magnetic, and biological characteristics of the tracers. In fact,

MPI is the first biomedical imaging technique that truly depends on nanoscale materials

properties; in particular, their response to alternating magnetic fields in a true biological

environment needs to be optimized.

I will describe the development of our highly optimized nanoparticle tracers with magnetic prop-

erties tailored for the unique physics of MPI using a sound theoretical framework, an organic

synthetic route producing phase-pure magnetite cores with controlled shape and narrow

size-distribution. Their subsequent phase-transfer without agglomeration, even in biologically

relevant media, and functionalization for targeting, biocompatibility, adequate in vivo circulation

(tailorable between 4-80 minutes in mice models) and tailorable biodistribution (no uptake

in the kidneys, critical for imaging patients with chronic kidney disease) will be presented.

In MPI phantom images, reconstructed in either real or Fourier space, these optimized trac-

ers showed significant improvement compared to existing commercial particles (Resovist®),

in both normalized signal intensity (6x) and spatial resolution (50% better) approaching sub-

mm at 6 T/m/µ0 field gradients. Further, their MPI signal is linear with concentration, with

minimal contribution from Brownian relaxation, making them suitable for molecular imaging.

Finally, we have established a flexible platform for functionalization of the magnetic cores

with PEG (to increase water solubility, enhance circulation time, and improve shelf life),

dyes (to turn them into multimodal -- MRI, MPI and NIRF -- contrast agents and used to

further enhance studies of their biodistribution with significant anatomical detail in rodent

models) and ligands (such as Lactoferrin with specific affinity for glioma cells) tailored for

targeted molecular imaging.

These critical results, that pave the way for improved clinically relevant MPI performance,

will be discussed with emphasis on the tracer response to both the alternating magnetic

field and the biological environment.

This work was supported by NIH grants 1RO1EB013689-01 (National Institute of Biomedical

Imaging and Bioengineering, NIBIB) and 1R41EB013520-01.

Page 78: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

19

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

10 .Early Detection of Pancreatic Cancers & Brain Tumors by MR Molecular ImagingYung-Ya Lina, Zhao Lia, and Chaohsiung Hsua

a. Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of California, Los Angeles

[email protected]

Introduction: Early detection of high-grade malignancy, such as pancreatic cancers (PC) and

glioblastoma multiforme (GBM), using enhanced MRI techniques significantly increases not

only the treatment options available, but also the patients’ survival rate. For this purpose,

a conceptually new approach, termed “Active-Feedback Controlled MR”, was developed.

An active feedback electronic device was homebuilt to implement active-feedback pulse

sequences to generate avalanching spin amplification, which enhances the weak field

perturbations from magnetic nanoparticles in targeted PC or malignant physiological condi-

tions in GBM.

Theory and Methods: The general principles of the “Active-Feedback Controlled MR” can

be found in our publications [1-6] (and references therein). Here, its specific applications

to early tumor detection were developed and demonstrated. (i) First, an active-feedback

electronic device was home-built to generate feedback fields from the received FID current.

The device is to filter, phase shift, and amplify the signal from the receiver coils and then

retransmit the modified signal into the RF transmission coil, with adjustable and programma-

ble feedback phases and gains. The MR console computer can execute the active-feedback

pulse sequences to control the trigger signal, feedback phase/gain, and the duration of the

feedback fields, allowing us to utilize the active feedback fields in novel ways. (ii) Next, an

active-feedback pulse sequence was developed for early tumor detection and was statisti-

cally tested on in vivo mice tumor models. In essence, the enhanced tumor contrast arises

from “selective self-excitation” and “fixed-point dynamics” generated by the bulk water 1H

under active feedback fields. Use the sensitive detection of magnetic nanoparticles as an

example. A small flip-angle (q=5-10o) RF pulse tilts the sample equilibrium magnetization.

Since the averaged transverse magnetization is mainly contributed from the bulk water 1H

spins, the resulting active feedback field possesses a frequency closer to that of the bulk

water 1H spins which are distant from the dipole center. By “selective self-excitation”, the

feedback field tilts the bulk water 1H spins more effectively towards the stable fixed-point,

–z-axis (assume feedback phase 180o), while the 1H spins near the dipole center are less

affected due to resonance mismatch. This “selective self-excitation” process continues and

enlarges the contrast between the longitudinal magnetization of the 1H spins in bulk water

Page 79: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

20

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

and those near the dipole center. Maximum contrast in the longitudinal magnetization can

be achieved and locked when all spin magnetizations evolve to the fixed point: all align

along –z in this case.

Results (1): Early Detection of Pancreatic Cancers: Anti-CA 19-9 antibodies were conjugated

to NH2-PEG-coated magnetic nanoparticles. The antigen binding capacity to CA 19-9 over-

expressing cell lines (BxPC3) was confirmed by in vitro MR cellular images. In vivo images of

human pancreatic tumors from nude mouse xenografts show that, while T2-weighted image

cannot clearly locate the magnetic nanoparticles, the active-feedback images successfully

highlight the magnetic nanoparticles distribution with a close correlation with iron-stained

histopathology.

Results (2): Early Detection of Glioblastoma Multiforme: Stage-1 orthotopic GBM mouse

models infected with human U87 cell line were imaged. While both T2 parameter images

and T2-weighted images by spin echo successfully locate the GBM tumor, our active-

feedback images and decay constant mapping provide 4-5 times of improvements in GBM

tumor contrast through sensitively imaging the susceptibility variations due to irregular water

contents and deoxyhemoglobin.

Discussion and Conclusion: In vivo PC and GBM mouse models validated the superior

contrast/sensitivity and robustness of the “Active-Feedback MR” for early tumor detection.

Statistical results (N>10) for PC and GBM mouse models at various cancer stages, alternative

active feedback pulse sequences with further improved performance, and active feedback

pulse sequences for enhanced R1/R2-weighted images will also be presented.

References1. Science 290, 118 (2001) 2. Magn. Reson. Med. 56, 776 (2006) 3. Magn. Reson. Med. 61, 925 (2009) 4. J. Phys. Chem. B 110, 22071 (2006) 5. Magn. Reson. Med. (2015, in press) 6. Biomaterials 32, 2160 (2011)

Page 80: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

21

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

11 .Parallel Multifunctionalisation of Nanoparticles: A One-Step Modular Approach for in vivo Imaging Fernando Herranza, Hugo Groulta, Juan Pellicoa, Ana V. Lechuga-Viecoa, Riju Bhavesha, Jesús

Ruiz-Cabelloa

a. Advanced Imaging Unit, Department of Atherotrombosis and Imaging, Fundación Centro Nacional

de Investigaciones Cardiovasculares (CNIC) and CIBER de Enfermedades Respiratorias (CIBERES),

Melchor Fernández-Almagro, 3, 28029 Madrid, Spain

[email protected]

Multifunctional nanoparticles are usually produced by sequential synthesis, with long

multistep protocols.1 Until now additional functionality meant additional synthetic steps

and costs, lower yields and a complex mixture on the surface of the particles.2 Our study

reports a generic modular strategy for the parallel one-step multifunctionalisation of differ-

ent hydrophobic nanoparticles.3 The aim was to apply the concept of parallel synthesis,

developed in organic chemistry, for the synthesis of multifunctional inorganic nanopar-

ticles. The method was designed and developed by taking advantage of the natural non-

covalent interactions between the fatty acid binding sites of the bovine serum albumin and

the aliphatic surfactants on different inorganic nanomaterials. As a general example of the

approach, three different nanoparticles – iron oxide, upconverting nanophosphors and gold

nanospheres – were nanoemulsified in water with albumin. To support specific applications,

multifunctional capability was incorporated with a variety of previously modified albumin

modules. These modules include different conjugated groups, such as chelating agents

for 68Ga or 89Zr and ligand molecules for enhanced in vivo targeting. A large library of 13

multimodal contrast agents was developed with this convergent strategy. This platform

allows a highly versatile and easy tailoring option for efficient incorporation of functional

groups. Finally, as demonstration of this versatility, a bimodal probe (PET/MRI) including

a maleimide-conjugated BSA was selectively synthesized with an RGD peptide for in vivo

imaging detection of tumour angiogenesis.

Page 81: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

22

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

Figure 1. General scheme for the parallel functionalisation of hydrophobic nanoparticles with ap-

plications in cell labelling, PET imaging (68Ga or 89Zr) and MRI (T1 and T2 contrast).

References1. F. Herranz, J. Ruiz-Cabello et al. Contrast Media Mol. Imaging 7(2012) 435.2. Z. Cheng, A Tsourkas et al. Science 338(2012) 903.3. H. Groult, F. Herranz et al. Bioconjugate Chem. (2015) doi: 10.1021/bc500536y

12 .Improving magnetic properties of ultrasmall magnetic nanoparticles by biocompatible coatingsRocio Costo,a M. Puerto Morales,a and Sabino Veintemillas-Verdaguera

a. Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid (CSIC). Sor Juana Ines de la Cruz, 3. 28049 Madrid

[email protected]

During last decades much has been written about the use of magnetic iron oxide nanoparti-

cles for applications in biomedicine as contrast agents for magnetic resonance imaging, drug

delivery or hyperthermia cancer treatment [1]. In any case, particles should be coated with

biocompatible molecules to avoid aggregation, improve the colloidal stability and guarantee

the biocompatibility of the final product. However, as a result of the interactions between the

particle surface and the coating, magnetic properties can be modified [2]. Understanding

these changes in magnetic behavior is critical for developing magnetic nanoparticles for

biomedical applications since the properties of the final product may be greatly different

from those of the initial iron oxide cores.

To study this phenomenon, ultrasmall particles were synthesized by laser pyrolysis and fully

oxidized to maghemite by acid treatment. The surface of the magnetic nanoparticles was

Page 82: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

23

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

systematically coated with either phosphonate (phosphonoacetic acid or pamidronic acid)

or carboxylate-based (carboxymethyl dextran) molecules and the binding to the nanoparticle

surface was analyzed. Magnetic properties at low temperature show a decrease in coercivity

and an increase in magnetization after the coating process. Hysteresis loop displacement

after field cooling is significantly reduced by the coating, in particular for particles coated

with pamidronic acid, which show a 10% reduction of the displacement of the loop. We

conclude that the chemical coordination of carboxylates and phosphonates reduces the sur-

face disorder and enhances the magnetic properties of ultrasmall maghemite nanoparticles.

Figure 1. Left: Magnetization curves at 5 K of the coated and un-coated particles. Right: Colloidal

stabilization of the particles with the three studied coatings: phosphonoacetic acid (red dots), pamid-

ronic acid (blue squares) and carboxymethyl-dextran (green diamonds)

References

1. S. Laurent et al. Chem. Rev. 108 (2008) 2064 2. C.E. Vestal et al. J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 125 (2003) 9828

13 . Synthesis and characterization of bimetallic magnetic oxides obtained by oxidative precipitationY. Luengoa, M.A. Roldánb, M. P. Moralesa, M. Varelab,c and S. Veintemillas-Verdaguera

a. Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid, ICMM-CSIC, Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz 3, Canto-

blanco, Madrid, Spain

b. Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Departamento de Fisica Aplicada III, Madrid 28040, Spain

c. Materials Science and Technology Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN 37831,

United States

[email protected]

Page 83: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

24

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

Bimetallic magnetic oxides in nanoparticulated form have plenty of potential applications

in many fields such as biomedicine (MRI contrast agents, magnetic hyperthermia agents,

drug delivery, biosensors), technology (magnetic recording), environmental remediation

(removal of pollutants with magnetic nanoparticles), etc. due to the combination of proper-

ties of both oxides. In the biomedical field, iron oxide is the most usual material because of

its low toxicity, high biocompatibility and good magnetic properties. However, there is still

plenty of room for research; for instance special features could be obtained by combination

of iron oxide nanoparticles with another metal oxide in a single entity.

Thus, bimetallic nanoparticles consisting of magnetite and other metal oxide, Fe3O4@MOx

(M: Bi, Gd, Co), were obtained by oxidative precipitation in aqueous medium. The different

metals were chosen due to their special properties: the presence of Bi may confer TC con-

trast while Gd could be used as T1 contrast agent in MRI and Co will enhance the magnetic

properties of the iron oxide particles. The maximum amount of metal oxide incorporation

without segregation and the type of distribution (solid solution, core-shell, decoration with

oxide particles, etc) were studied by scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM)

and electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS). The materials were characterised by X-Ray

diffraction, thermogravimetric analysis, infrared spectroscopy and chemical analysis. The

saturation magnetization, initial susceptibility and coercivity of all the samples were meas-

ured at room temperature and 5 K to study the effect of these metal oxides on the magnetic

properties of magnetite.

Figure 1. HAADF STEM micrographs of nanoparticles doped with: a) Bi, b) Gd and c) Co

Page 84: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

25

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

14 .Coating strategies for the application of magnetic nanoparticles in cancer diagnosis and therapy Marzia Marciello,a Marlène Branca,b,c Susana I.C.J. Palma,d Maryam Zahraei,e Diana Ciucu-

lescu-Pradines,b,c Behshid Behdadfara,e Ana Cecilia A. Roque,d Catherine Amiensb,c and M.

Puerto Moralesa

a. Biomaterials and Bioinspired Materials Dpt., Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid (ICMM-

CSIC), Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain;

b. CNRS, LCC (Laboratoire de Chimie de Coordination), 205, route de Narbonne, F-31077 Toulouse,

France;

c. Université de Toulouse, UPS, INPT; LCC; F-31077 Toulouse, France;

d. UCIBIO, REQUIMTE, Chemistry Dpt., Universidade Nova de Lisboa, 2829-516 Caparica, Portugal;

e. Materials Engineering Dpt., Isfahan University of Technology, Isfahan 84156-83111, Iran.

[email protected]

In the last decades the use of magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) for cancer diagnosis and

therapy has quickly increased. An important requirement for MNPs in vivo application

is the presence of an opportune coating that stabilizes them in physiological conditions,

and provides multifunctionality, biocompatibility and protection of magnetic core against

degradation.

In this work MNPs synthesized by different routes (aqueous and organic medium) [1-4]

have been coated using some opportune strategies: ligand exchange [2,3,4] superficial

chemical modification [1,3,4] and encapsulation [4] (Scheme 1).

Small molecules (DMSA, citric acid, TEOS, APTS) or biocompatible polymers (dextran,

polyethylene glycol, chitosan, gum arabic) have been strongly attached to MNPs surface

to avoid coating loss in physiological conditions. The objective was to make these particles

suitable as contrast agents for MRI or therapeutics for hyperthermia. All the coated MNPs

were characterized by good stability in physiological conditions and displayed opportune

size for biomedical application.

Page 85: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

26

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

Scheme 1: Different coating strategies used to enable MNPs bioapplication: A) Ligand exchange,

B) Chemical modification and C) Encapsulation.

References1. Marciello M. et al., J. Mat. Chem. B., 1 (2013) 5995.2. Kossatz S. et al. Pharm. Res., 31 (2014) 3274.3. Palma S. et al., J. Colloid Interf. Sci., 437 (2015) 147.4. Branca M. et al., J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 377, (2015) 348.

15 .Chimeric Antigen Receptor T-cells for Cancer TherapyDr David Gilham Institute of Cancer Science - University of Manchester, Manchester, UK

One mechanism employed by tumors to avoid immune medicated destruction is reduced or

loss of expression of Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) proteins which are essential

for T cell recognition processes. To overcome this avoidance strategy, CAR technology has

been developed that exploits antibody-based target binding thereby allowing the T-cell to

recognise cell surface tumor associated antigen directly thereby circumventing loss of MHC

expression. The CAR consists of four key elements; firstly, the antigen binding domain that

is most commonly a single chain antibody fragment (scFv) derived from an antibody but can

be derived from any potential ligand. Secondly, an extracellular spacer domain that allows

Page 86: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

27

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

for optimal binding of the scFv to its cognate target. Thirdly, a transmembrane domain that

tethers the CAR to the surface of the T cells and finally, an intracellular signalling domain

that engages with downstream pathways that initiate T-cell effector function upon ligation

of the CAR with target antigen. However, to date there has been consensus single optimal

configuration. Consequently, many different CARs are currently in clinical testing. These

will be discussed as well as recent developments in the CAR T cell field.

17 .At the Fluorescent Nanoprobes´ Frontiers: Multifunctionality for Bio-Imaging and T-SensingAntonio Benayas,a Fuqiang Rena, Blanca del Rosalb,Wagner F. da Silvac, Elisa Carrascob,

Francisco Sanz-Rodríguezb, Vicente Marzal2, Karla Santacruz-Gómezd, Gustavo A. Hiratae,

Dongling Maa, Daniel Jaqueb, Fiorenzo Vetronea.

a. Univ Quebec, INRS-EMT, 1650 Blvd. Lionel Boulet, Varennes, PQ J3X 1S2, Canada.

b. UAM, Cantoblanco 28049, Madrid, Spain.

c. UFAL, Maceió, 57072-900 Alagoas, Brazil.

d. Univ Sonora, Hermosillo 83000, Sonora, Mexico.

e. CNyN, Ensenada, 22800 Baja California, Mexico

[email protected]

Nowadays, new and better light-emitting probes are being demanded to fulfill the needs

and specific requirements of nanomedicine, especially at the cancer diagnosis and therapy

battleground. There is an intense appetite for multifunctional, non-invasive and biocompat-

ible platforms to be designed and implemented.

In this work on fluorescent nanoparticles (NPs) for bio-imaging, we present our last outstand-

ing results obtained throughout a research lines promoted at Vetrone group (INRS-EMT,

Canada). Starting with dielectric hosts, a remarkable outcome has been reached using

NaGdF4 lanthanide-doped NPs for cell imaging. They provide an extended colour-palette

within both visible and near-infrared spectral ranges, using two alternative excitation wave-

lengths (793 and 980nm). It should also be highlighted the pivotal role that fluorescent

nanothermometry has been playing within our investigations. Thus, the second project here

explained is constituted by the development of efficient Nd:YAG near infrared fluorescent

nanothermometers1,3, that have demonstrated remarkable performance on a broad range

of temperature-monitoring applications (electrical circuits, sub-tissue measurements and

optical trapping context). Finally, our most standing platform PbS/CdS quantum dots (QDs)

Page 87: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

28

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

fi nal multifun

for in vivo imaging, which wavelength-wise design (they emit ~ 1.3µm) increases penetration

depth2, and their high-brightness allows a remarkable low dose of them to provide fluores-

cence images, upon injection in live animals. This system has also shown some promissory

nanothermometry features, demonstrated through ex-vivo experiments.

References1. D. Jaque et al. Nanoscale 4 (2012) 4301-4326.2. T. Lim et al Mol. Imaging 2 (2003) 50-64.3. A. Benayas et al. Advanced Optical Materials (2015) DOI: 10.1002/adom.201400484

Figure 1: a) Left: graph showing the evolution of the QDs emitted intensity from three different

parts of the mouse body (tail/green, liver/red and lungs/blue) as a function of time after injection

inside the mouse´s body. Right: Combination of optical and fluorescence images taken from the

live specimen. b) Left: Schematic representation of an optical trapping setup. A 1480 nm laser

is focused into a microchannel filled with Nd:YAG NPs. Right: Thermal image of a 900 µmx900

µm area around the laser focus. Laser power was set to 62 mW. Figure taken from the author’s

recently published Ref. [3].

18 .Joining time-resolved thermometry and magnetic-induced heating in a single nanoparticleAngel Millan,a Rafael Piñol,a Carlos D. S. Brites,b Rodney Bustamante,a Abelardo Martínez,c

Nuno J. O. Silva,b José L. Murillo,a Rafael Cases,a Julian Carrey,d Carlos Estepa,a Cecilia Sosa,e

Fernando Palacio,a Luis D. Carlos,b

Page 88: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

29

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

a. ICMA, CSIC–Universidad de Zaragoza, 50009 Zaragoza (Spain).

b. Departamento de Física and CICECO, Universidade de Aveiro, 3810–193 Aveiro (Portugal)

c. Departamento de Electrónica de Potencia. I3A. Universidad de Zaragoza 50018 Zaragoza (Spain)

d. Université de Toulouse, INSA, UPS, CNRS (UMR 5215), F-31077, Toulouse (France)

e. Departamento de Toxicología, Universidad de Zaragoza, 50013 Zaragoza (Spain)

[email protected]

Magnetic- and light-induced thermal heating of nanoparticles are powerful non-invasive

techniques for bio and nanotechnology applications, such as hyperthermia therapy of can-

cer and other diseases. To be effective this local heating requires an adequate monitoring

of the nanoheaters local temperature. However, efficient and sensitive single nanoparticles

integrating heaters and thermometers are a real synthetic challenge. Here we present a

successful realization of this challenge. The nanoheaters are magnetic nanoparticles coated

with amphiphilic polymers that had been already used in magnetic hyperthermia [1]. The

ratiometric thermometric system was also developed in our group a few years ago [2]. The

temperature readout is optical and the thermometric probes are dual-emissive Eu3+/Tb3+

lanthanide complexes. These complexes are encapsulated in the hydrophobic inner part

of the nanoparticle coating, around the iron oxide magnetic core. The resulting heater/

thermometer nanoplatform shows an outstanding performance in terms of: low thermometer

heat capacitance (0.021·K-1) and heater/thermometer resistance (1 K·W-1); high temperature

sensitivity (5.8%×K-1 at 296 K) and uncertainty (0.5 K), physiological working temperature

range (295-315 K), readout reproducibility (>99.5%), and fast time response (0.250 s).

Experiments of time-resolved thermometry under an AC magnetic field reveal the existence

of an unexpected temperature gradient between nanoheaters and surrounding media for

relatively long time intervals (t > 10 s) and relatively low heat powers (10-16 W/heater). The

fitting of the data to simple heat models evidences the failure of using macroscopic thermal

parameters to describe heat diffusion at the nanoscale. A proof of concept of tempera-

ture mapping has been realized on cells that were incubated with the nanoparticles. The

fluorescence microscopy in two different wavelengths simultaneously after beam splitting

permits the mapping of the intracellular local temperature using the pixel-by-pixel ratio of

the Eu3+/Tb3+ intensities.

References1. Brites, C. D. S. et al. Adv. Mater. 22(2010), 4499.2. R. Bustamante et al. Phys. Rev. B 88(2013), 184406.

Page 89: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

30

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

19 .Magnetic hyperthermia, a promising tool for the minimal-invasive treatment of tumorsIngrid HilgerInstitute for Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, Jena University Hospital, Erlanger Allee 101.

D-07747 Jena, Germany

Early detection of tumours has been distinctly improved in the last years, which favours the

development of minimal-invasive therapeutic methods promising a high therapeutic effi-

cacy. Herein, the treatment of small tumours via magnetic heating was proposed, meaning

the selective accumulation of magnetic materials, magnetite, at the tumour area and the

exposure of the breast to an alternating magnetic field for several minutes. This will pro-

duce a selective heating spot which allows for a localized elimination of tumour cells. Even

though the principle seems to be simple at a first glance, the efficacy of the methodology

will strongly depend on how the different biomedical, physical and technical parameters are

being combined and adjusted between each other. Therefore, in the present study we will

consider the different aspects that have to be taken into account to fulfil these requirements.

20 .Encapsulation of VEGF165 in magnetic PLGA nanocapsules for potential local delivery and bioactivity into human brain endothelial cellsRoig,1 E. Carenza1, O. Jordan2, P. Martínez-San Segundo3, R. Ji�ík4, Z. Star�uk jr.4, G. Borchard2,

A. Rosell3

1. Nanoparticles and Nanocomposites Group (www.icmab.es/nn), Institut de Ciència de Materials

de Barcelona, Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (ICMAB-CSIC), Campus de la UAB,

Bellaterra, Catalunya, E-08193 Spain.

2. School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Geneva, University of Lausanne, Quai Ernest

Ansermet 30, 1205 Geneva, Switzerland.

3. Neurovascular Research Laboratory and Neurovascular Unit, Vall d’Hebron Institut de Recerca,

Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona; Passeig Vall d’Hebron, Barcelona, Catalunya, E-08035 Spain.

4. Institute of Scientific Instruments, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Královopolská 147,

612 64 Brno, Czech Republic.

[email protected]

Page 90: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

31

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

fi nal multifun

The administration of pro-angiogenic proteins is an attractive therapeutic strategy to enhance

angiogenesis after an ischemic event [1,2]. Nevertheless a labile structure and short circula-

tion time in vivo are the main obstacles that reduce protein bioactivity and dose at the target

site. Biodegradable magnetic nanomaterials, intravenously administrated and accumulated

at the diseased zone under an external magnetic field, may circumvent these limitations.

We report on the synthesis of poly(D,L-lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) nanocapsules (diam-

eter less than 200 nm) loaded with the vascular endothelial growth factor-165 (VEGF165)

confined into the inner core and superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPIONs)

embedded in the polymeric shell (Fig. 1 inset). The system showed high encapsulation

efficiencies and sustained protein release over 14 days (Fig. 1). In vitro studies confirmed

protein bioactivity after encapsulation. Moreover, through MRI measurements we demon-

strated excellent T2 contrast image properties. We therefore suggest the nanoconstruct as

new targeted protein delivery carrier useful in pro-angiogenic treatments, especially after

an ischemic event [3].

References1. Rosell, A.; Morancho, A.; Navarro-Sobrino, M.; Martinez-Saez, E.; Hernandez-Guillamon, M.; Lope-Piedrafita, S.;

Barcelo, V.; Borras, F.; Penalba, A.; Garcia-Bonilla, L.; Montaner, J., Factors secreted by endothelial progenitor cells enhance neurorepair responses after cerebral ischemia in mice. PloS one 2013, 8 (9), e73244.

2. Carenza, E.; Barceló, V; Morancho, A.; Lisa Levander, L.; Boada, C.; Laromaine, A.; Roig A.; Montaner, J.; Rosell, A., In vitro Angiogenic Performance and in vivo Brain Targeting of Magnetized Endothelial Progenitor Cells for Neurorepair Therapies. Nanomedicine: NBM 2014, 10, 1 225-234.

3. Carenza, E.; Jordan O.; San Segundo Martínez, P.; Ji�ík, R.; Star�uk jr., Z.; Borchard, G.; Anna Rosell, A.;* and Roig, A.*. Encapsulation of VEGF165 in magnetic PLGA nanocapsules for potential local delivery and bioactivity into human brain endothelial cells. J. Mater. Chem. B, 2015, Accepted Manuscript DOI: 10.1039/C4TB01895H

Figure 1: Protein release over a period of 2 weeks. Inset: scheme and cryo-TEM image of a PLGA

nanocapsule dispersed in water

Page 91: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

32

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

21 .Influence of nanoparticle size and field frequency on the concentration dependence of magnetic heating David Cabrera,a Gorka Salas,a Robert Ludwig,d Julio Camarero,a,b, Rodolfo Miranda a,b, Ingrid

Hilger,d and Francisco J. Terána, c

a. IMDEA Nanociencia, Ciudad Universitaria de Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain ;

b. Dpto. Física de la Materia Condensada, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, 28049 Madrid, Spain

c. Unidad Asociada de Nanobiotecnología, CNB-CSIC & IMDEA Nanociencia, 28049 Madrid, Spain;

d. Institute for Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology I, Jena University Hospital, Friederich Schiller

University of Jena, Bachstraße 18, D-07740 Jena, Germany;

[email protected]

Iron oxide nanoparticles (IONP) have attracted much attention for their potential in bio-

medical applications in the last years. Their precise size control and tailored chemical

features favor their internalization into cancer cells acting as drug-delivery nanocarriers

without cytotoxicity drawbacks. In addition, their size-driven magnetic properties allow

IONP to efficiently act as contrast agents, or intracellular hyperthermia mediators.

Recent works have shown that the internalization of IONP into cells and/or tissues lead

to significant changes of their magnetic properties, resulting in a remarkable reduction of

their heating efficiency [1]. The underlying reasons are yet to be clarified. At a first glance,

IONP processing into biological matrix (cells or tissues) increases IONP clustering favoring

magnetic dipolar interactions, which may be altered by viscosity. Hence, understanding

the role of dipolar interactions is of great importance towards the use of IONP as reliable

heating mediators.

Here, we report on the study of specific absorption rate (SAR) as a function of IONP con-

centration at different field frequencies and particle sizes. Our results indicate that both

parameters (size and frequency) lead to distinct concentration dependences matching within

the single picture described by Martinez-Boubeta et al [1]. While 19 nm size IONP show

a non-monotonic behaviour with a relative SAR maximum the 12 nm size IONP shows a

progressive decrease of SAR values until reaching a value which maintains constant in the

overall concentration range studied. When varying filed frequency, the variety of behaviours

becomes richer, resulting in the observation of an evolution from non-monotonic behaviour

of SAR vs concentration to the progressive SAR decay (at low frequencies). However, we

observe a shift of the relative SAR maximum which is clearly frequency-dependent and has

not been considered by recent theoretical models [2]. Our data provide new experimental

evidences which require novel theoretical models for understanding the role of magnetic

Page 92: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

33

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

dipolar interactions in determining the heat dissipation processes of IONP under alternat-

ing magnetic fields.

(a)

0 5 10 15 200

10203040

200

250

300

350

400

19 nm 12 nm

SAR

(W/g

Fe)

[Fe](gFe/L)

(b)

0 5 10 15 200

100200300400

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

435 kHz 150 kHz 84 kHz 49 kHz

SAR(

W/g

Fe)

[Fe](gFe/L)

Figure 1. (a) Concentration dependence of SAR values obtained IONP water dispersions of different sizes (19 and 12 nm) at given field conditions (104 kHz and 50mT), (b) Concentra-tion dependence of SAR values obtained in 19±2 nm IONP water dispersions at different field frequencies and given field amplitude (40 mT)

References1. C. Martínez-Boubeta et al. Advanced Functional Materials 22 (2012) 37372. R. P. Tan, et al. Phys. Rev. B. , 35 (2014) 214421.

22 .Intratumoral thermal reading during photothermal therapy by multifunctional fluorescent nanoparticlesBlanca del Rosal,a Elisa Carrasco,b Francisco Sanz-Rodríguez,a,c,d Ángeles Juarranz de la

Fuente,b,c Patricia Haro-Gonzalez,1 Ueslen Rocha,e Kagola Upendra Kumar,e Carlos Jacinto,e

José García Solé,a and Daniel Jaque.a

a. Fluorescence Imaging Group. Departamento de Física de Materiales, Facultad de Ciencias. Campus

de Cantoblanco, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid. Madrid 28049, Spain

b. Instituto de Investigaciones Biomédicas “Alberto Sols”, CSIC-UAM. Madrid 28029, Spain

c. Departamento de Biología, Facultad de Ciencias. Campus de Cantoblanco. Universidad Autónoma

de Madrid. Madrid 28049, Spain

d. Instituto Ramón y Cajal de Investigación Sanitaria, Hospital Ramón y Cajal, 28034 Madrid, Spain

e. Grupo de Fotônica e Fluidos Complexos. Instituto de Física, Universidade Federal de Alagoas

57072-970, Maceió, Alagoas, Brazil

[email protected]

Page 93: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

34

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

Photothermal therapy, which relies on light-induced heating to irreversibly damage cancer

cells is nowadays attracting a great deal of attention as an effective and low cost technique

for treating malignant tumors.[1] An adequate temperature monitoring during the treatment

is key to minimizing damage to the surrounding healthy tissues while ensuring the effective-

ness of the therapy. However, measuring intratumoral temperature constitutes a challenge

that cannot be solved by traditional thermometry techniques.

Multifunctional nanoparticles, acting simultaneously as temperature sensors and photo-

thermal agents upon excitation with a single light source are excellent candidates for this

task. In this work, neodymium-doped LaF3 nanocrystals have been successfully used for

continuous intratumoral temperature monitoring during photothermal therapy in mice. These

infrared-emitting nanoparticles double as efficient in vivo heating agents and temperature

sensors. The use of this kind of nanoparticles for temperature-controlled therapy opens the

way for highly efficient and minimally invasive photothermal treatments of cancer tumors.

References1. D. Jaque et al. Nanoscale, 6 (2014) 9494.

23 .Magnetic nanoparticle-based therapeutic agents for thermo-chemotherapy treatment of cancerProf Nguyen TK ThanhUCL Healthcare Biomagnetic and Nanomaterials Laboratories

21 Albemarle Street, London W1S 4BS &

Department of Physics & Astronomy

University College London

Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK

Email: [email protected]

http://www.ntk-thanh.co.uk

Magnetic nanoparticles have been widely investigated for their great potential as mediators

of heat for localised hyperthermia therapy. Nanocarriers have also attracted increasing

attention due to the possibility of delivering drugs at specific locations, therefore limit-

ing systematic effects. The enhancement of the anti-cancer effect of chemotherapy with

application of concurrent hyperthermia was noticed more than thirty years ago. However,

combining magnetic nanoparticles with molecules of drugs in the same nanoformulation

Page 94: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

35

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

has only recently emerged as a promising tool for the application of hyperthermia with com-

bined chemotherapy in the treatment of cancer. We will present some of our recent work

in the development of nanoparticles and effort in developing multifunctional therapeutic

nanosystems incorporating both magnetic nanoparticles and drugs.

.

References1. Blanco-Andujar, C., Southern, P., Ortega, D., Nesbitt, S.A., Pankhurst, Q.A., Thanh, N.T.K.* (2015) High per-

formance multi-core iron oxide nanoparticles for magnetic hyperthermia: microwave synthesis, and the role of core-to-core interactions. Nanoscale.. 7: 1768-1775. Open Access

2. A. Hervault and Thanh, N. T. K* (2014) Magnetic Nanoparticles-Based Therapeutic Agents for Thermo-Chemo-therapy Treatment of Cancer. Nanoscale, 6: 11553-11573. Open Access.

3. Thanh, N. T. K*, N. Maclean, S. Mahiddine. (2014) Mechanisms of Nucleation and Growth of Nanoparticles in Solution. Chemical Reviews. 114: 7610–7630. Open Access.

4. A. Dunn, D. Dunn, M. Lim, C. Boyer, N. T. K. Thanh. (2014) Recent Developments in the Design of Nanocom-posites for Photothermal and Hyperthermia Induced Controllable Drug Delivery. Royal Society of Chemistry Specialist Periodical Report on Nanoscience. 2: 225-254.

5. C. Blanco-Andujar, D. Ortega, Q. A. Pankhurst, N.T. K. Thanh* (2012) Elucidating the morphological and struc-tural evolution of iron oxide nanoparticles formed by sodium carbonate in aqueous medium. Journal of Material Chemistry. 22: 12498-12506 Open Access

24 .Nano-emulsion templating: a versatile technology to prepare multifunctional polymeric nanoparticles for advanced biomedical applicationsCristina Fornaguera, Gabriela Calderó, Conxita Solans Institute of Advanced Chemistry of Catalonia (IQAC-CSIC) and CIBER of Bioengineering, Biomaterials

and Nanomedicine (CIBER-BBB)

[email protected]

Page 95: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

36

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

Nano-emulsions are fine emulsions with droplet sizes between 20 – 200nm, showing high

kinetic stability and transparent to translucent aspect. Since they are thermodynamically

unstable systems, an energy input is required for their formation. Among the methods for

nano-emulsion preparation, low-energy methods, which take advantage of the chemical

energy of nano-emulsion components, are advantageous for pharmaceutical applications,

since they enable obtaining nano-emulsions with smaller and less polydisperse droplets.

Specifically, the phase inversion composition method (PIC), in which phase inversion is

produced by changing the composition during the emulsification process at a constant

temperature, is adequate for thermolabile compounds because it can be performed at mild

temperature and process conditions [1]. Polymeric nanoparticles (pNP) can be obtained

from nano-emulsions with an oil phase consisting on a preformed polymer dissolved in an

organic volatile solvent followed by solvent evaporation [2]. In this context, the objective of

this work was to obtain pNP, from nano-emulsion templating, as advanced pharmaceuti-

cal agents for diagnosis and/or therapeutic specific uses. O/W polymeric nano-emulsions

were firstly obtained by the PIC method, using poly-(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) as the

preformed polymer [3,4]. They showed hydrodynamic radii between 20 – 140 nm, negative

surface charge and enough stability to prepare nanoparticles. Nano-emulsions with 90wt%

W, 70/30 O/S ratio were selected for further uses because they represent a compromise

between small sizes (around 40nm) and low surfactant concentration. pNP were prepared

from these nano-emulsions by solvent evaporation, resulting in hydrodynamic radii of around

20 nm, negative surface charge and stability higher than 3 months. These pNP were loaded

and /or functionalized to achieve different purposes. Fluorescent dyes (e.g. coumarin 6) or

inorganic nanoparticles (e.g. magnetic nanoparticles) were encapsulated in the pNP to use

them as diagnosis carriers, obtaining very high encapsulation efficiency. pNPs were also

designed as therapeutic agents following a pharmacological approach, in parallel to a gene

therapy approach. Model analgesic and antiapoptotic drugs were successfully encapsu-

lated to develop the pharmacological therapy, achieving also high encapsulation efficienciy

and sustained drug release, maintaining the pharmacological activity of the drugs. To use

nanoparticles as non-viral gene delivery systems, they were cationized to further electrostati-

cally bind antisense oligonucleotides. Very high gene transfection efficiencies were obtained

in cell cultures, with the advantage of pNPs over commercial vectors of a lower toxicity and

over viral vectors of lower immune detection. In addition, with the purpose to actively target a

specific organ, pNP surface was functionalized with a model monoclonal antibody targeting

the Blood-Brain Barrier (BBB). In vivo studies of the BBB crossing evidenced that antibody

functionalized pNP were able to cross the BBB in a similar extent than positive controls.

Therefore, it can be concluded that the preparation of polymeric nano-emulsions by low-

energy methods, followed by solvent evaporation to obtain polymeric nanoparticles is a very

versatile technology that enables tailoring their properties rendering them useful for both,

therapeutic and diagnosis purposes, achieving also an active targeting to the desired organ.

Page 96: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

37

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

References1. C. Solans et al., Curr Opin Colloid Interface Sci, 17 (2012) 246.2. C. Calderó et al., J Colloid Interface Sci, 353(2011) 406.3. C. Fornaguera et al., Colloid Surf B, 125(2015) 58.4. C. Fornaguera et al., Int J Pharm, 478(2015) 113.

25 .G-Quadruplex aptamers with therapeutic applicationsAnna Aviñóa, Santigo Grijalvoa, Carme Fàbregaa, Maria Tintoréa, Stefania Mazzinib, Juan

Carlos Moralesc and Ramon Eritjaa

a. Networking Center on Bioengineering, Biomaterials and Nanomedicine (CIBER-BBN), Institute

for Advanced Chemistry of Catalonia (IQAC), CSIC, Jordi Girona 18-26 08034 Barcelona, Spain

b. Department of Food, Environmental and Nutritional Sciences (DEFENS), Section of Chemical and

Biomolecular Sciences, University of Milan, Via Celoria 2, 20133 Milan, Italy.

c. Instituto de Investigaciones Químicas, CSIC - Universidad de Sevilla, Americo Vespucio, 49, 41092

Sevilla, Spain.

[email protected]

Aptamers are short DNA- or RNA-based oligonucleotides selected from large combinatorial

pools of sequences for their capacity to efficiently recognize targets, ranging from small mol-

ecules to proteins or nucleic acid structures. Like antibodies, they exhibit high specificity and

affinity for target binding. Aptamers can be considered as antibodies, but, unlike antibodies

they can be chemically derivatized to extend their lifetimes and/or their bioavailability and

are non-immunogenic. As a result, they may display effective interference in biological proc-

esses, which renders them not only valuable diagnostic tools, but also promising therapeutic

agents. Among several architectures, the polymorphic G-quadruplex structure is adopted by

multiple aptamers. G-quadruplexes are very stable structures generated by the association

of steps of four guanines (G-quartets) held together by hydrogen bonds. G-quadruplexes

acting as aptamers can be powerful inhibitors of different proteins. Particularly, large research

efforts have been focused on the 15-base long thrombin binding aptamer (TBA) sequence,

which was derived as an inhibitor of �-thrombin, a key enzyme in the blood clotting cascade.

In addition, several anti-HIV aptamers also adopt DNA quadruplex structures. Among them,

“Hotoda’s aptamer” has significant affinity to the HIV protein gp120. These aptamers are

potentially prone to be modified in order to improve biological properties.

Page 97: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

38

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

Figure 1. Struture of the TBA, G-tetrad and Hotoda.

References1. A. Aviñó, S. Mazzini, R. Ferreira, R. Eritja, Bioorg. Med. Chem., 18 (2010) 7348.2. H. Saneyoshi, S. Mazzini, A. Aviñó, G. Portella, C. González, M. Orozco, V. Marquez, R. Eritja, Nucleic Acids

Res., 37, (2009) 5589.3. J. Gros, A. Aviñó, J. López de la Osa, C. González, L. Lacroix, A. Pérez, M. Orozco, R. Eritja, J.L. Mergny. Chem.

Commun., 25 (2008) 2926.4. I. Gómez-Pinto, E. Vengut-Climent, R. Lucas, A. Aviñó, R. Eritja, C. González, J.C. Morales, Chem. Eur. J., 19,

(2013) 1920.5. A. Aviñó, S. Mazzini, R. Ferreira, R. Eritja, R. Gargallo, V. E. Marquez, R Eritja. Bioorg. Med. Chem., 20, (2012)

4186.

26 .Targeted Drug Delivery Systems against Cancer Stem CellsDr. Petra Gener Vall d’Hebron Research Institute,

Barcelona, Spain

Despite the progress in understanding the mechanism of carcinogenesis, and the develop-

ment of more effective therapies against cancer, advanced cancer is still remaining to be

an incurable disease. The cure of advanced cancer is hampered because of metastatic

spread to distal organs and resistance to therapy. Both phenomena are sustained by the

presence of cancer stem cells (CSC) within the tumor. This minor cell population retains the

capacity of spreading the tumor, while being insensitive to conventional anticancer therapies,

Page 98: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

39

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

antimitotic agents or radiation. Specific delivery of chemotherapeutic compounds to CSC

by nanotechnology based drug delivery systems (DDS) has great potential to increase CSC

sensitivity. To be able to study efficacy of nanomedicines in population of CSC we devel-

oped an original CSC model, in which we stably tagged CSC population. This CSC model

we used to study the impact of targeted/non-targeted DDS on CSC presence and behavior

in continuous cell culture.

27 .Development of gene-expressing liposomes as drug delivery systemsAlicia Soler Canton,a Christophe Danelonb

a. Department of Bionanoscience, Kavli Institute of Nanoscience, Delft University of Technology,

Lorentzweg 1, 2628 CJ, Delft, The Netherlands

b. Department of Bionanoscience, Kavli Institute of Nanoscience, Delft University of Technology,

Lorentzweg 1, 2628 CJ, Delft, The Netherlands

[email protected]

Targeted drug delivery in human body can be mediated by diverse nanocarriers. Among the

different types, liposomes – artificial phospholipid vesicles – have received the most atten-

tion during the last three decades for numerous reasons. Current liposomal systems deliver

therapeutic compounds that have been directly packaged upon manufacturing. However,

recent advances on the development of synthetic gene circuits prompt us to explore the

biomedical potential of gene-expressing liposomes. In this work we aim to express small

interfering RNA (siRNA) molecules of therapeutic value from a DNA template inside <

200 nm sized liposomes. Two main reasons drag us to work on the development of gene-

expressing liposomes for the production of therapeutic siRNA. First, we hypothesize that

the siRNA concentrations reached upon synthesis inside liposomes could be higher than

those obtained through the encapsulation of molecules produced in bulk (current method).

Second, we believe that future genetic-circuit-containing liposomes could manage a control-

led expression and release of the therapeutic molecule. Early steps towards the realization

of this new generation of programmable drug delivery systems include 1) the validation of

the production of functional shRNA by in vitro transcription and 2) the development of a

protocol for optimized transcription inside small unilamellar vesicles, which we have man-

aged so far inside 800nm liposomes. Later steps on this project will involve the merging

of these advances to transfect shRNA-expressing liposomes into cells and track specific

gene silencing.

Page 99: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

40

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

28 .Self-assembling nanoparticles based on calixarene-cyclodextrin heterodimers for targeted delivery and controlled release of docetaxelLaura Gallego-Yerga,a Francesco Sansone,b Carmen Ortiz Mellet,a Alessandro Casnatib and

José M. García Fernández.c

a. Departamento Química Orgánica, Facultad de Química, Universidad de Sevilla, E-41012 Sevilla

Spain;

b. Dipartimento di Chimica, Università degli Studi di Parma, I-43124 Parma, Italy;

c. Instituto de Investigaciones Químicas (IIQ), CSIC – Universidad de Sevilla, E-41092 Sevilla, Spain

[email protected]

The development of drug delivery systems able to improve bioavailability of insoluble or

biodegradable drugs and avoid secondary effects through targeted transport is essencial

for the success in administration of therapeutic agents. In this work we have succeeded at

preparing molecularly defined calixarene-cyclodextrin heterodimers filled with the capacity

to self-assemble in water or buffer media to form functional nanoparticles. These nanos-

tructures have an inner core formed by hydrophobic calix[4]arene (CA4)[1] units and an

external hydrophilic shell exposing b-cyclodextrin (bCD) moieties[2,3]. The CA4 scaffold is very

well suited to promote tight packing of fatty chains installed at the narrower ring in its cone

conformation, providing a lipid matrix where hydrophobic drugs can be entrapped, whereas

the presence of hydrophilic bCD moieties at the nanosphere surface allows nanoparticle

solubilization in water as well as ligand incorporation by inclusion complex formation. The

potential of the new systems in nanomedicine is illustrated by their capacity to encapsu-

late and provide sustained release of the anticancer agent docetaxel (DTX) and undergo

supramolecular surface post-modification with adamantane-armed glycoligands targeting

the human macrophage mannose receptor (MMR). Since docetaxel can induce apoptosis

in tumor cells which overexpress this receptor, this targeting is expected to improve cancer

immunotherapies.

References

1. Sansone, F.; Casnati, A. Chem. Soc. Rev. 2013, 42, 4623-4639.

2. Martínez, A.; Ortiz Mellet, C.; García Fernández, J. M. Chem. Soc. Rev. 2013, 42, 4746-4773.

3. Ortiz Mellet, C.; García Fernández, J. M.; Benito, J. M. Chem. Soc. Rev. 2011, 40, 1586-1608.

Page 100: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

41

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

29 .Design of biocompatible magnetic nanoplatforms for potential platinum-based drug delivery applicationsGustavo B. da Silva,a,b Rocío Costo,b Marzia Marciello,b Maria D. Vargas,a Célia M. Ronconi,a

M. Puerto Moralesb and Carlos J. Sernab

a. Instituto de Química, Universidade Federal Fluminense, Campus do Valonguinho, Centro, 24020-

150 Niterói-RJ, Brazil

b. Department of Biomaterials and Bioinspired Materials, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid

(ICMM)/CSIC, Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

[email protected]

Cisplatin (cis-[Pt(NH3)2Cl2]) and its derivatives have been widely used in cancer treatment,

however they have shown several side effects. To overcome these drawbacks, the use of

magnetic nanoparticles as carriers and drug delivery systems could be a good strategy [1].

Iron oxide nanoparticles e. g. maghemite (g-Fe2O 3) are biocompatible, superparamagnetic

and can reach different regions of the body upon an external magnetic field. Furthermore,

they are easily modified to which platinum(II) derivatives can be attached and protected

against early deactivation, with consequent enhancement in their cytotoxicity.

Aim of this work was the synthesis of superparamagnetic g-Fe2O3 nanoparticles and sub-

sequent surface modification with a biocompatible polymer for the conjugation of cisplatin

derivatives with potential anticancer properties. The g-Fe2O3 nanoparticles were synthesized

Page 101: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

42

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

by co-precipitation method followed by an acid treatment [2]. Then they were coated with cit-

ric acid (CA) and amine dextran (ADex), through amide bonds. Investigation of the conditions

(iron and dextran concentrations, reactive type and pH) to best attach the ADex polymer to

the surface of g-Fe2O3 resulted in g-Fe2O3@CA@ADex containing ~70% of anchored polymer.

The materials were characterized by TEM, DRX, IR, TG-DTA and ICP-OES measurements.

Magnetic data confirmed a superparamagnetic core. The colloidal properties (hydrodynamic

size - DHyd, potential z) were evaluated and the stability in the physiological environment were

enhanced after functionalizations. Finally cisplatin related compounds (cis-[Pt(NH3)2(NO3)2]

and cis-[Pt(DMSO)2Cl2]) were attached to the ADex polymer to yield cis-[Pt(X)2(ADex)2], X =

NH3 or Cl, (25-45%). These platinum-modified polymers were then anchored to the surface

of g-Fe2O3@CA nanoparticles under the conditions employed for the synthesis of g-Fe2O3@

CA@ADex. Studies of colloidal stability and drug release are in progress.

References1. B. W. Harper et al. Chem. Eur. J., 16 (2010) 7064.2. R. Costo et al. Langmuir, 28 (2012) 178.

6 nm

biocompatibili ty

OO

OOHO

OH

O

HOHO

ONH

OHN

ADex-CA�-Fe2O3

ADexenhance

cell uptake

% coating = 14-70%DHyd = 100-200 nm

Msat = 65 emu.g-1

of nanoparticle

% coating = 10%DHyd = 27 nm

Pt

PtPt

Pt

PtACMDex

ACMDex

NH3

NH3

PtACMDex

ACMDex

ClCl

or

cisplat in der ivatives

O

HO OH

O

OH

OHO

Citric acid (CA)

ADexmodified

with cisplatinderivatives

Magneticnanoplatforms

Lack of stabilityat pH 7.0

�-Fe2O3�-Fe2O3@CA

�-Fe2O3@CA@ADex�-Fe2O3@CA@ADex-Pt

Figure 1. General route for design of magnetic nanoparticles of iron oxide (g-Fe2O3) and its modi-

fication with citric acid, amine dextran and cisplatin derivatives.

Page 102: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

POSTER contr ibut ion

Page 103: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

44

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

P1.

Interaction of multifunctional magnetic nanoparticles with biological membranes

María Josefa Rodrígueza, Marzia Marciellob, Antonio Airesc, Sandra M. Ocampoc, Aitziber L. Cortajarenac, Puerto M. Moralesb, José L. Carrascosaa

a Department of Structure of Macromolecules, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología-CSIC (CNB-CSIC), Campus Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

b Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid (ICMM)-CSIC, Campus Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

c Instituto Madrileño de Estudios Avanzados en Nanociencia (IMDEA Nanociencia). Cantoblanco, Madrid, Spain.

[email protected]

Abstract

The possibility to selectively introduce magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) inside cells for further manipulation is a key objective in nanomedicine. To achieve this purpose, MNPs need to overcome a first barrier represented by biological membranes, which also define the selectivity characteristics of the target cells. The biological functionalization of the MNPs will enhance the selectivity toward the desired cells, improving the efficiency of incorporation of therapeutic molecules and reducing the effects. In this study, imaging of thin sections of cultured cells by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) have allowed us to evaluate at an ultrastructural level the interaction of MNPs with cellular membranes and the characteristics of uptaking and accumulation inside the cells of nanoparticles with different coatings and functionalizations. In particular, MNPs with two different coatings, a small molecule (dimercaptosuccinic acid, DMSA) and a biocompatible polymer (polyethylene glycol, PEG) have been studied. We have found that the different nature of the coating and the functionalization influence nanoparticle biodistribution in cellular membranes and entry characteristics.

Page 104: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

45

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

P2.P1 .

Biodistribution of magnetic nanoparticles evaluated by AC magnetic susceptibility in a murine model

Eduardo Lorente-Sorolla,a Gustavo B. da Silva,a,b Sonia Perez-Yagüe,c Rocío Costo,a Sabino Veintemillas-Verdaguer,a Domingo F. Barber,c M. Puerto Morales,a Marina Talelli c and Lucía Gutiérrez a

a Department of Biomaterials and Bioinspired Materials, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid (ICMM)/CSIC, Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

b Instituto de Química, Universidade Federal Fluminense, Campus do Valonguinho, Centro, 24020-150, Niterói, RJ, Brasil

c Department of Immunology and Oncology, and NanoBiomedicine Initiative, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología (CNB)/CSIC, Darwin 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

[email protected]

Abstract

Iron oxide nanoparticles for biomedical applications preferentially accumulate in the liver and spleen, therefore reducing their possible uses in other organs, unless external magnetic fields or other functional molecules are used to target the particles to specific sites.

It is known that in thalassemia patients undergoing chronic blood transfusions, the excess iron from the blood cannot be properly bound to transferrin, leading to accumulation in the heart though the formation of iron-citrate complexes called NTBI (non-transferrin bound iron), as in the heart the metal-ion transporter ZIP14 is present, which mediates NTBI uptake [1]. The aim of this project was to mimic this NTBI function using citrate coated magnetic nanoparticles, in order to generate bio-inspired materials that may target the nanoparticles to the heart, therefore changing their biodistribution pattern.

We have performed a single administration of magnetic nanoparticles coated with citric acid and phosphonoacetic acid in mice and evaluated the presence of these nanoparticles in the heart, liver, lungs, spleen and kidney 24h after their administration. Nanoparticles with both coatings were clearly observed by AC magnetic susceptibility measurements in the liver, lungs and spleen tissues. The presence of nanoparticles in the heart was very small in comparison to the other tissues. Transmission electron microscopy in liver sections showed the presence of magnetic nanoparticles inside lysosomal structures. In addition, ferritin, the iron storage protein, was frequently observed localized near the lysosomes containing the magnetic nanoparticles in the liver tissues.

References

[1] J.P. Liuzzi et al. Proc. Nat. Acad.Sci. 103 (2006) 13612.

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

0,0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1,0

Sca

led

out-o

f-pha

se s

usce

ptib

ility

Temperature (K)

Liver Lung Spleen Blood NPs-citric

Figure 1. (Left) Transmission electron micrograph of a liver tissue section showing the presence of magnetic nanoparticles and ferritin. (Right) Temperature dependence of the out-of-phase susceptibility of different tissue samples from the same mouse showing a maximum corresponding to the presence of

magnetic nanoparticles.

Page 105: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

46

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

fi nal multifun

P3.

C. elegans: an in vivo model to evaluate nanoparticles?

Anna Roig, Laura Gonzalez-Moragas, Elisa Carenza, Siming Yu, Anna Laromaine

Nanoparticles and Nanocomposites Group, Institut de Ciència de Materials de Barcelona, Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (ICMAB-CSIC), Campus de la UAB, Bellaterra, Catalunya, E-08193 Spain.

[email protected]

Abstract

Caenorhabditis elegans (C. elegans) is a 1-mm long free-living soil nematode widely used in biology as a model organism. The key attributes that make C. elegans a promising in vivo animal model to evaluate nanoparticles include simplicity, transparency, short life cycle, sequenced genome, small body size and ease of cultivation in the lab. Here, we investigate the effect of surface functionalization (citrate and protein-coated) of superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles in C. elegans combining techniques from materials science and biology confirming the worm as a suitable in vivo platform to advance in the understanding of nano-bio-interfaces (Figure 1). The survival and nanoparticle distribution of worms treated with the two nanoparticles was studied. By using magnetometry, quantitative uptake and magnetic properties of the nanoparticles inside the worms were evaluated. Interestingly, results indicate the protective effects both to the protein to the nanoparticles and to the worms especially at high concentrations. Thus, our results endorse the potential of C. elegans to assess nanomaterials at early stages of their synthetic formulations and to reduce the number of candidate materials to be screened in mammalian models.

Figure1. Visualization of a C. elegans: Prussian Blue stained worm where iron oxide nanoparticles appear blue.

50  µm

Page 106: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

47

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

P4.P3 .

Iron quantification inside cells incubated with SPION by Soft-Xray Absorption Spectro-Tomography (SXAST)

José Javier Conesa,a Francisco Javier Chichón,a Michele Chiappi,a Eva Pereiro,b and José L. Carrascosa.a,c

a Centro Nacional de Biotecnología (CNB-CSIC), Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain. b ALBA Synchrotron Light Source. MISTRAL Beamline - Experiments division. 08290 Cerdanyola del

Vallès, Barcelona, Spain. c Instituto Madrileño de Estudios Avanzados en Nanociencia (IMDEA Nanociencia), Cantoblanco, 28049

Madrid, Spain

[email protected]

Abstract

One of the mayor issues related to Superparamagnetic nanoparticles (SPION) internalization is the estimation of the amount of nanoparticles that are inside the cells. The answer to this question will determine the dose for drug-delivery or whetherhyperthermia treatments are feasible. To get an insight into this problem we used 15 nm DMSA-SPIONs interacting with MCF-7 breast cancer cells [1] as an experimental model, and Soft-X-ray spectral-microscopy to calculate the iron content -main component of the SPION- using the specific absorption of the element.

X-ray absorption is a widely used technique that exploits the singular interaction of the elements with X-rays [2]. For this study we developed a new approach called Soft X-ray Absorption Spectro-Tomography (SXAST) acquiring spectral tilted series of the same cell between at 700 and 709 eV. In this context, the iron abortion changes dramatically from 700 to 709 eV, while the rest of the cellular compound remains with the same contrast (Figure). We used this property to subtract the images corresponding to the tilted series acquired at 700 from the ones form the 709 eV tilted series. The result is a differential tilted series where the cellular background was eliminated. Then, tomographic reconstructions allowed us to obtain iron absorption coefficients, hence the iron mass, associated to three-dimensional cellular ultrastructure (Figure).

References [1] M.Calero, M.Chiappi, et al., “Characterization of interaction of magnetic nanoparticles with breast cancer cells”. Journal: Journal of Nanobiotechnology “in press”. [2] .Henke, B. L., E. M. Gullikson and J. C. Davis (1993). "X-Ray Interactions: Photoabsorption, Scattering, Transmission, and Reflection at E = 50-30,000 eV, Z = 1-92." Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables 54(2): 181-342.

700 eV 709 eV Fe signal image Fe signal slice

Figure. Soft-X ray Absortion Spectro-Tomography (SXAST) workflow. First two images represent 0º projection images of a dehydrated MCF7 cell incubated with OD15-DMSA SPION using Fe pre edge and edge energies (700 and 709 eV respectively). Alignment of projections at each different energy yield ratio images that must be aligned and then submitted to tomographic reconstruction (fourth image, central slice of the quantitative volume). Modified EFTEM TOMOJ software was used to create differential maps and reconstruction.

Page 107: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

48

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

P5.

Following the transformation of magnetic nanoparticles over time in macrophages by AC magnetic susceptibility

Vanesa del Dedo,a Marina Talelli,b José M. Rojas,b Gustavo B. da Silva,a,c Rocío Costo,a Sabino Veintemillas-Verdaguer,a Domingo F. Barber,b M. Puerto Morales,a Marzia Marciello a and Lucía Gutiérrez a

a Department of Biomaterials and Bioinspired Materials, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid (ICMM)/CSIC, Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

b Department of Immunology and Oncology, and NanoBiomedicine Initiative, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología (CNB)/CSIC, Darwin 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

c Instituto de Química, Universidade Federal Fluminense, Campus do Valonguinho, Centro, 24020-150, Niterói, RJ, Brasil

[email protected]

Abstract

Little is known about the degradation processes that magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) undergo after their administration, which can give insight on their potential side effects when used for biomedical applications. A promising approach to follow the MNPs transformations in tissues is the use of AC magnetic susceptibility measurements [1,2]. However, once the nanoparticles start to transform in the body, the analysis of the magnetic susceptibility data for quantification purposes is not straightforward, as a reduction in the particle size cannot be easily distinguished from a disaggregation process that can also reduce inter-particle interactions.

To gain insights into the transformations of magnetic nanoparticles in biological systems, and therefore be able to better understand the changes of their magnetic properties, we followed their degradation in a macrophage cell line (THP1) for 5 days. Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) and AC magnetic susceptibility measurements have been performed at different time points after treatment of the cells with the nanoparticles. Results indicated that a partial degradation of the nanoparticles occurs during this time period, with a shift of the particle size distribution towards smaller particles. Further reduction of the particle sizes may require longer incubation times, however, this will require optimization of culture conditions.

References

[1] R. Mejías et al. J. Controlled Release, 171 (2013) 225.

[2] L. Gutiérrez et al. Phys.Chem.Chem.Phys.,16 (2014) 4456.

Figure 1. (Left and center) Transmission electron micrographs at two different magnifications of a THP1 cell line incubated with magnetic nanoparticles. (Right) Temperature dependence of the out-of-phase

susceptibility of cells incubated with the MNPs at different times after the administration.

Page 108: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

49

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

P6.P5 .

pH-Dependent Switch for Anticancer Metallodrugs

Francisco Martínez, Ana M. Pizarro

IMDEA Nanociencia, Ciudad Universitaria de Cantoblanco, 28049, Madrid

[email protected]

Abstract The successful development of platinum-containing anticancer drugs that began with cisplatin (cis-diamminedichloridoplatinum(II)) has triggered the investigation of other metal-based agents with cytotoxic activity for drug design. Ruthenium, osmium, iridium and rhodium organometallic complexes have been in the last few years one of the most promising findings due to their inherent anticancer activity and to the possibility of a different cytotoxic profile than platinum-based drugs. In general, ruthenium(II) arene-complexes of type [(η6-arene)RuII(XY)Z]n+ (Z = monodentate ligand; XY = chelating ligand such as ethylenediamine, en) are cytotoxic to cancer cells including cisplatin-resistant cell lines. Recently, new ruthenium(II) arene compounds with a hemilabile amino-derivatised arene ligand have been published,1,2 where the amino group offers two reversible functionalities: (i) binding to the RuII center to form a tether-ring-closed (inactive) complex, or (ii) dissociation of the amine from the RuII center (as a dangling arm) to afford an open-tether complex with a pendant free amino group. In the open form the vacant site on the ruthenium is occupied by either chloride, a solvent molecule or a biomolecule (active complex). Most importantly, in aqueous solution, the tether-ring dynamics are pH dependent, giving the potential to finely tune the activation process to biological conditions, for example, the acidic microenvironment of the tumor.3 In the present work, we show a series of ruthenium(II) “tethered” arene complexes bearing different hemilabile amino-derivatised arene ligands. They have been characterized by NMR and elemental analysis. The understanding of the conditions and kinetics that control the opening of this tether would be crucial for rationally designing drugs with controlled biological target recognition, enhanced cytotoxic activity and minimized off-target effects. The aquation and anation phenomena for this type of compounds are under investigation to finely tailor the structures where the opening-closing pKa is most suitable for switching on in tumours, sparing healthy cells and therefore optimising selectivity and efficacy. Finally, the extraordinary versatility of the metallodrug structure is amenable for engrafting onto nanoparticle carriers. Nanoparticles as drug delivery systems have received much attention due to their elegant capabilities to target and accumulate in tumour tissues as well as drop deadly cargoes in a more efficient, controlled, on-target manner.4 For example, the bidentate chelating ligand in the metal complexes can be modified to carry groups that can react with suitable functionalities on the surface of the selected nanoparticles.

References

[1] M. Melchart et al. Inorg. Chem, 46 (2007) 8950

[2] A. M. Pizarro et al. Inorg. Chem, 49 (2010) 3310

[3] D. Neri et al. Nat. Rev. Drug. Discov., 10 (2011) 767

[4] X. Wang. Chem. Soc. Rev, 42 (2013) 202

Page 109: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

50

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

P7.

Superparamagnetic properties of hydrothermally prepared CoFe2O4 as a function of size (6–10 nm) and coating (oleic/citric acid or TiO2)

Daniel Nižnanský,a Anton Repko,a Jana Vejpravová,b and Taťána Vacková c

a Charles University, Faculty of Science, Department of Inorganic Chemistry, Hlavova 2030/8, 128 43 Prague 2, Czech Republic

b Institute of Physics AS CR, v.v.i., Department of Magnetic Nanosystems, Na Slovance 2, 182 21 Prague 8, Czech Republic

c Institute of Macromolecular Chemistry, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, 162 06 Prague 6, Czech Republic

email: [email protected]

Abstract

Magnetic properties of cobalt ferrite nanoparticles prepared by hydrothermal hydrolysis of Co-Fe oleate in the presence of pentanol/octanol/toluene and water at 180 or 220 °C were prepared. The particle size (6.2, 9.1 or 10.5 nm) was controlled by the organic solvent and temperature. The inter-particle distance was then changed by a surface modification with citric acid or titanium dioxide.

The as-prepared hydrophobic nanoparticles (coated by oleic acid) had an inter-particle distance of 2.5 nm. Their blocking temperature (estimated as a maximum of the zero-field-cooled magnetization) was 179 K, 283 K and 331 K. Replacement of the oleic acid by citric acid imparted hydrophilicity and the inter-particle distance decreased to almost zero, while the blocking temperature increased by approximately 10 K, as a consequence of stronger dipolar inter-particle interactions.

Another modification was achieved by coating with titanium dioxide, supported by nitrilotris(methylphosphonic acid). The increased inter-particle distance implied lowering of the blocking temperature by ca. 20 K. The CoFe2O4@TiO2 nanoparticles were sufficiently stable in water, methanol and ethanol.

Magnetic structure was also investigated by Mössbauer spectroscopy. The effect of dipolar interactions on relaxation phenomena of the nanoparticles of different size and coating was finally studied by alternating-current (AC) susceptibility measurements.

Page 110: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

51

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

P8.P7 .

Targeting cancer cells with photoactive silica nanoparticles

Wioleta Borzęcka a, b, c, Tito Trindade b, Tomás Torres c and João Tomé a, d

a QOPNA and b CICECO, Department of Chemistry, University of Aveiro, 3810-193 Aveiro, Portugal c Department of Organic Chemistry, Autonoma University of Madrid, 28049 Madrid, Spain

d Department of Organic and Macromolecular Chemistry, Ghent University, B-9000 Gent, Belgium

[email protected]

Abstract

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is an emergent cancer medical treatment that combines a nontoxic drug, a particular type of light and oxygen. This drug, called photosensitizer (PS) or photosensitizing agent, when in contact with molecular oxygen and exposed to light can produce reactive oxygen species (ROS) that are strongly cytotoxic to cancer cells. An ideal PS should be a single pure compound with high absorption peak between 600 and 800 nm (red to deep red), should have no dark toxicity, and relatively rapid clearance from normal tissues [1].

Like other clinical protocols, PDT also has some limitations. To avoid some of these disadvantages, different PS nanoformulations have been tried. This target strategy can improve PDT treatments by increasing the aqueous solubility of the hydrophobic photosensitizers, their blood circulation, and their selective accumulation in tumor tissue, thanks to the enhanced permeability and retention effect [2]. In this field, silica nanoparticles (SNPs) have recently emerged as promising vehicles for PDT owing to their: high biocompatibility, controllable size formation, unique physicochemical properties, the possibility for tumor targeting through facile surface modification [3].

Some of our recent work on smart porphyrin-SNP materials, presenting their synthetic strategies and obtained photo-chemical and -physical results will be highlighted.

References

[1] P. Agostinis; K. Berg; K. A. Cengel; T. H. Foster; A. W. Girotti; S. O. Gollnick; S. M. Hahn; M. R. Hamblin; A. Juzeniene; D. Kessel; M. Korbelik; J. Moan; P. Mroz; D. Nowis; J. Piette; B. C. Wilson; J. Golab A Cancer J Clin, 61 (2011) 250

[2] P. Couleaud; V. Morosini; C. Frochot; S. Richeter; L. Raehma J. O. Durand Nanoscale, 2 (2010) 1083

[3] L. Tang; J. Cheng Nano Today, 8 (2013) 290

[4] F. Figueira; J. A. S. Cavaleiro; J. P.C. Tomé J. Porphyrins Phthalocyanines, 15 (2011), 517

Figure 1. Differente methodes for the synthesis of nanoparticles [4].

Acknowledgements: Thanks are due to the Universities of Aveiro and Autonoma of Madrid, FCT, European Union, QREN, FEDER and COMPETE for funding the QOPNA research unit (PEst-C/QUI/UI0062/2013; FCOMP-01-0124-FEDER-037296), CICECO Laboratory (Pest-C/CTM/LA0011/2013, FCOMP-01-0124-FEDER-037271). Thanks are also due to the Seventh Framework Programme (FP7-People-2012-ITN) for funding the SO2S project (grant agreement number: 316975).

Page 111: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

52

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

P9.

Combinational sensitization of tumor cells with two photosensitizers synergistically enhances their photodynamic inactivation in vitro

Andrea Tabero,a Ana Lazaro-Carrillo,a,b Pilar Acedo,c Macarena Calero,a,b Juan Carlos Stockert,a Magdalena Cañete,a Angeles Villanueva a,b

a Departamento de Biología. Universidad Autónoma de Madrid. Spain b Madrid Institute for Advanced Studies in Nanoscience (IMDEA). Spain

c Karolinska Institute. Stockholm. Sweden.

[email protected]

Abstract Liposomal lipid-based nanocarriers are widely used in drug delivery, especially in the treatment of cancer disease. Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a minimally invasive and clinically approved procedure for cancer treatment. It can be defined as the administration of a drug known as photosensitizer (PS), which preferentially accumulates in tumor cells and that does not induce a cytotoxic effect by itself. However, after being irradiated with light of appropriate wavelength, the PS is able to trigger photochemical and photobiological reactions that lead to the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS, mainly singlet oxygen), which cause irreparable damage, cell death and tumor regression. Our work is focused on a new photodynamic treatment based on the combination of two PSs: the hydrophobic Zinc(II)-phthalocyanine (ZnPc) incorporated into nanoliposomes and the hydrophilic cationic porphyrin meso-tetrakis(4-N-methylpyridyl)porphine (TMPyP). These PS have different subcellular location (Golgi apparatus for ZnPc and lysosomes for TMPyP) and therefore ROS are generated simultaneously in two different subcellular targets, which induces a synergistic effect using very low doses of PDT in human adenocarcinoma HeLa cell line. Cytotoxic MTT assay showed that the combined treatment has a powerful cell inactivation effect (cell death > 95%), while photodynamic treatments with each PS alone did not significantly affect cell survival. Using different morphological and biochemical analysis we have demonstrated that combined treatment triggers apoptotic cell death via mitochondrial-related pathway (1). On the other hand, caspase-3 is an important effector protease that cleaves many proteins in the apoptotic pathway. For this reason, we also analyzed the response to this treatment in human breast carcinoma cells (MCF-7), which do not express caspase-3. Our results revealed that this new strategy of photodynamic treatment induces over 95% MCF-7 cell death 24 h after treatment by a caspase 3-independent apoptotic pathway. In summary, combined PDT with ZnPc and TMPyP increases the ability to inactivate human tumor cells through apoptosis, even if they have activated a mechanism of evasion of this type of cell death, such as the caspase-3 deficiency. Our results provide a novel and valuable information that will contribute to the development of better PDT approaches for the treatment of various cancers.

References

[1] Acedo P, Stockert JC, Cañete M, Villanueva A. Two combined photosensitizers: a goal for more effective photodynamic therapy of cancer. Cell Death Dis. 2014, e1122. doi: 10.1038/cddis.2014.77.

This work was supported by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (CTQ2013-48767-C3-3-R).

Page 112: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

53

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

fi nal multifun

P10.P9 .

Synthesis Strategies of Single-Core Magnetic Nanoparticles

Helena Gavilán,a Rocío Costo,a Sabino Veitemillas- Verdaguer,a Lucía Gutiérrez,a and M. Puerto Moralesa

Dept. Biomaterials and Bioinspired Materials, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Madrid ICMM/CSIC, Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

[email protected]

Among other functional nanomaterials, magnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (MNPs) are especially promising as contrast enhancement agents for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), drug carriers and for cancer treatment by hyperthermia. For all these biomedical applications, MNPs require among others, good magnetic properties, biocompatibility and stability. The former is deeply influenced by the crystal structure of the iron oxide nanoparticles and the magnetic interaction between the particles. It is essential therefore to control such characteristics.

Different synthesis strategies have been developed considering the fact that magnetic nanoparticles tend to form aggregates in the absence of specific coatings. There are mainly two kinds of systems that have been defined: multi-core and single-core particles.1 The former is composed of several magnetic cores per particle and although it is generally easy to synthesize such particles, it is difficult to control the number of cores per particle. The latter contains just one core per particle and nowadays there are just few coating methods that can be used to prevent aggregation by minimizing the inter-particle interactions.

Various synthesis strategies can be used to obtain these systems, being thermal decomposition in aqueous or organic solutions the most common one.2 Although thermal decomposition in organic media prevent the agglomeration of the particles as they are formed, it requires also complicated operations and sometimes expensive/toxic reagents. Nevertheless these particles possess high crystallinity and monodispersity and are the ideal material for standardization purposes.

As part of the NanoMag-project, we have prepared both single-core and multi-core magnetic particles. The iron oxide cores have been synthesized by thermal decomposition of iron oleate complex, and subsequently coated either individually with silica via microemulsion, or forming clusters with 2,3-dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA) by ligand exchange, being both colloids stable in water (essential pre-requisite for a biomedical application). In addition, we present a three-step aqueous approach to obtain Fe3O4 single-core particles based on the synthesis of antiferromagnetic nanoparticles, its coating and subsequent reduction to magnetite. This method has the advantage of the low inter-particle interactions of as-synthesized nanoparticles and the different morphologies that these materials exhibit.

References

[1] L. Gutiérrez et al., Dalton Trans, In press (2015)

[2] Xin Liang et al., Adv. Funct. Mater., 16, 1805 (2006)

Figure 1. Iron oxide nanoparticles: (A) Fe3O4 NPs synthesized by thermal decomposition in organic media. (B) Fe3O4 NPs coated with silica by microemulsion process. (C) α-FeOOH NPs synthesized by thermal decomposition in aqueous media. (D) β-FeOOH NPs synthesized by thermal decomposition in aqueous media.

A B C D

Page 113: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

54

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

P11.

Silica encapsulation of magnetic nanoparticles

Leonor de la Cueva,a Paloma Rodríguez,a Rebeca Amaro,a David Cabrera,a María Acebrón,a Beatriz H. Juárez,a,b Francisco J. Terán,a and Gorka Salasa

a IMDEA Nanociencia b Departamento de Química-Física Aplicada, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid

e-mail [email protected]

Abstract

Iron oxide nanoparticles (IONPs) based on magnetite and maghemite are promising tools for biomedical applications in treatment and diagnosis of tumours.[1] For treatment they can be employed as selective drug carriers or as nano-heaters. The latter application is known as magnetic hyperthermia and is based on the ability of these materials to dissipate heat under the influence of an alternating (AC) magnetic field.[2] However, there exist some problems limiting the use of IONPs as hyperthermia mediators in in vivo tissues. It has been observed that once into the cells the heat generation ability is seriously harmed mainly due to aggregation caused by the intracellular environment and processing.[3] This aggregation leads to magnetic dipolar interactions between particles that may worsen their heat dissipation power. One plausible approach to avoid this problem is to encapsulate the individual IONPs in a stable and rigid material to prevent those destructive interactions. Alternatively, a controlled aggregation of IONPs in an ordered fashion may enhance their magneto-thermal capacity, instead of damaging it.

In this work we show the encapsulation of individual IONPs in silica (IONP@SiO2 core@shell nanostructures) with controlled thickness, along with magnetic measurements comparing IONP@SiO2 with the initial non-encapsulated nanoparticles. Preliminary results on the encapsulation of nano-assemblies of IONPs will be also presented.

References

[1] M. Colombo et al. Chem. Soc. Rev. 41 (2012) 4306.

[2] S. Dutz and R. Hergt Int. J. Hypertherm. 29 (2013) 790.

[3] J. P. Fortin et al. Eur. Biophys. J. 37 (2008) 223; Q. A. Riegler, J. et al. Biomaterials 34 (2013) 1987.

Figure 1. Individual IONPs encapsulated with a silica shell.

Page 114: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

55

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

fi nal multifun

P12.P11 .

Synthesis  of  hybrid  magneto-­‐plasmonic  nanostructures  based  on  Au  nanorods  and  iron  oxides  nanoparticles  

Jesús  G.  Ovejeroa,b,  Eva  Mazariob,  Alexandra  Muñozb,  Patricia  Crespoa  and  Pilar  Herrastib  

aInstituto  de  Magnetismo  Aplicado  Salvador  Velayos  (UCM)  P.O.  Box  155,  28230  Las  Rozas,  Madrid,  Spain  bDepartamento  de  Química  Física  Aplicada,  Universidad  Autónoma  de  Madrid,  28049,  Cantoblanco,  Madrid,  Spain  

 Abstract  

Magnetic  and  plasmonic  nanoparticles  have  brought  a  large  number  of  biomedical  solutions  in  the  fields  of  detection,  diagnosis  and  treatment.  Both  kinds  of  nanoparticles  present  their  own  limitations,  but  a  question  arises:  Can  we  get  unexpected  synergetic  properties  in  hybrid  systems?  

Surface  plasmon  resonance  of  Au  nanoparticles  is  commonly  used  in  biological  sensing  (SERS),  medical  imaging  techniques  (PAI,  OCT,  X-­‐Ray,  etc.)  and  in  certain  therapies  (Photo-­‐hyperthermia,  thermally  enhanced  drug  delivery,  etc.).  Moreover,  different  geometries  of  Au  nanoparticles  have  been  developed  with  the  aim  of  shifting  the  plasmon  resonance  to  the  near  infrared  biological  absorption  window.  Silica  coated  nanorods  (Au@SiO  NR)  stand  out  from  the  rest  of  geometries  due  to  their  chemical  stability  and  optimum  optical  properties  [1],[2].  

O   the  other  hand,  magnetic  nanoparticles   (MNP)  have  been  used  as  alternative  approach   in  fields   such   (MRI,  MPI,  magnetic   hyperthermia,   etc.).   Thus,   the   combination  of  magnetic   and  plasmonic   properties   in   a   single   nanoparticle   offers,   at   first   approximation,   an   interesting  platform   for   multimodal   imaging   or   a   combined   magneto-­‐optic   therapies.   In   addition,  magnetomotive  effect  has  been  successfully  used  to  improve  the  resolution  of  plasmon-­‐based  imaging  techniques  [3,4].  

This  work   presents   novel   hybrid  magneto-­‐plasmonic   nanoparticles   based   on   the   coupling   of  Au@SiO   NR   with   different   types   of   ferrite-­‐based   magnetic   nanoparticles   (MNP).   Both,   the  Au@SiO  NR   and   the  MNP   are   synthesized   separately   and   coupled   afterwards.   The   followed  process   allows   the   tailoring   of   the   magnetic   and   the   plasmonic   properties   independently.  Finally,   the  magneto-­‐plasmonic  nanoprobes  have  been   functionalized  with   folic  acid   in  order  to   improve  their  biocompatibility  and   internalization   in  cancer  cells  which  overexpress   folate  receptors.  

References  

[1] Chen-­‐Wei  Wei  et  al.  J.Biomed.  Opt.  2010,  15(1):016010    [2]  Laura  M.  Maestro  et  al.  Langmuir  2014,  30:  1650  [3]  R.  Jhon  et  al.  Proc.  Natl.  Acad.  Sci  U  S  A.  2010  107(18):  8085    [4]  Y.  Jin  et  al.  Nature  Comm.  1:41  

This  work  has  been  supported  by  MAT2012-­‐37109-­‐C02-­‐01  project  of  the  Spanish  Ministery  of  Economy  and  Competitivity    

Figure  1.  TEM  image  of  Au@SiO  NR  coupled  with  Fe3O4  

MNP  

Page 115: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

56

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

P13.

Functionalized magnetic nanoparticles for cancer therapy

Antonio Aires,a,b Sandra M. Ocampo,a David Cabrera,a Leonor de la Cueva,a Yael Fernandez,a Gorka Salas a,b, Francisco J. Terán a,b, and Aitziber L. Cortajarena.a,b

aInstituto Madrileño de Estudios Avanzados en Nanociencia (IMDEA Nanociencia).

b CNB-CSIC-IMDEA Nanociencia Associated Unit, Cantoblanco, Madrid, Spain.

email address of the Presenting Author: [email protected]

Abstract

In recent years, magnetic nanoparticles (MNP) have been widely investigated for their potential in biomedical applications acting as contrast agents for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI),1 nanocarriers for selective targeting and drug/gene-delivery,2 and as magnetic heating inductors for thermal therapeutic approaches.3 For successful in vivo application, MNP have to satisfy several requirements such as biocompatibility, invisibility to the immune system to avoid fast liver clearance, high colloidal stability and long blood circulation time. To achieve a long-term colloidal stability and long blood circulation time of MNP, different polymers coatings including poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG), dextran, chitosan, poly(ethylenimine) (PEI), and dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA), have been employed over the last years. Among the commonly-used polymer materials, proteins or polypeptides are considered to be among the most promising materials as protective layers of MNP due to their biocompatibility and hydrophilicity.4

In this study, we have developed MNP functionalized with an anti-cancer drug, in particular gemcitabine (GEM) to target pancreatic cancer. In order to achieve formulations with improved properties for in vivo use in drug delivery and hyperthermia treatment we developed a formulation in which the MNP are previously coated with BSA to provide enhanced colloidal stability in biological environments and long blood circulation time to the final formulation. The effect of surface functionalization on the colloidal stability in different media, magnetic properties, internalization behavior and in vitro cytotoxic effect in pancreatic cancer cells were investigated for their potential in vivo application in controlled drug release and/or magnetic hyperthermia.

References

[1] A. Masoudi et al. Int. J. Pharm. 433 (2012) 129. [2] N. S. Barakat et al. Nanomedicine, 4 (2009) 799. [3] E.K. Wang et al. Biomaterials, 30 (2009) 1881. [4] Z. Li et al. Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochem. Eng. Aspects, 436 (2013) 1145.

Page 116: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

57

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

fi nal multifun

P14.P13 .

Detection and Inhibition of Mutated GNAQ Gene Using Spherical Nucleic Acids

Ana Latorrea, Christian Poschb, Alfonso Latorrea, Michelle B. Crosbyb, Anna Cellib, Igor Vujicb, Martina Sanlorenzob, Gary A. Greenb, Jingly Weierb, Mitchell Zekhtserb, Jeffrey Mab, Gabriela Monicob, Devron

H. Charb, Denis Jusufbegovicb, Klemens Rappersbergerb, Susana Ortiz-Urdab. Álvaro Somozaa

a Instituto Madrileño de Estudios Avanzados en Nanociencia (IMDEA Nanociencia), & CNB-CSIC-IMDEA Nanociencia Associated Unit "Unidad de Nanobiotecnología“

b University of California San Francisco, Mount Zion Cancer Research Center, 2340 Sutter Street, San Francisco, USA

[email protected]

Abstract

Uveal Melanoma (UM) is one of most common tumors of intraocular malignancies. In 90% of the cases, UM is generated due to a single point mutation of GNAQ gene. Currently, the diagnosis of this disease is based on morphological changes of medium-large sized lesions, which are prone to be disseminated to other organs. What is more, the treatment of this metastatic tumor is for now ineffective [1]. Therefore, the development of systems allowing an early detection and treatments of UMs could improve greatly the survival of the patients.

Spherical nucleic acid conjugates (densely oligonucleotide functionalized AuNPs), are nanostructures that present remarkable properties for biomedical applications such as high colloidal stability and biocompatibility. In addition, they show an excellent cellular uptake and due to the negative charged shell, the oligonucleotides are largely protected from nuclease degradation. These properties make them ideal systems to develop biosensors and delivery systems of drugs and oligonucleotides [2].

In this study, we report a single point mutation gene sensor using AuNPs modified with fluorescent Molecular Beacons (Figure 1a). Molecular Beacons were designed to target specifically the mutated GNAQ gene, which can be visualized due to an increase in the fluorescent signal. In addition, we have developed a new release system of siRNAs from AuNPs (Figure 1b), which have shown excellent efficiency to downregulate the mutated GNAQ gene and decrease the cellular viability.

Results showed in this work, evidenced that spherical nucleic acid are excellent new tools to detect the presence of mutated GNAQ gene and modulate its expression [3].

References

[1] Van Raamsdonk, C. D. et al. N Engl J Med, 23 (2010), 2191. [2] Joshua I. et al. J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 134 (2012), 1376. [3] Posch, C. et al. Biomed Microdevices, (2015), 17:15, 14.

Figure 1: a) Schematic structures of AuNPs modified with fluorescent Molecular Beacon. b) New

approach of delivery system of siRNA targeting GNAQ gene. Acknowledgments: IMDEA Nanociencia and Asociación Española Contra el Cancer (AECC) are acknowledged for financial support.

a)

AuNP

5’

3’5’

3’

siRNAAuNP

Molecular  Beacon

b)

Page 117: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

58

nano

cien

cia

2015 workshop

final multifun

venueIMDEA NanocienciaCampus Excelencia UAM-CSIC de Cantoblanco

Calle Faraday,9

28049 Madrid

Spain

how to arrive

Public transport

From Madrid downtown:• Train: C4A y C4B Local (Atocha, Nuevos

Ministerios, ó Chamartín). Cantoblanco

Universidad. Station

• Bus: Line 714 (from Plaza de Castilla).

From Airport:• Underground: Line C8 (to Nuevos Minis-

terios) y then Line C4A y C4B Local (Ato-

cha, Nuevos Ministerios, ó Chamartín).

Cantoblanco Universidad. Station

• Bus: Intercity services: Lines 827/828

(T4); Urban services: Line 204 (T4)

and Line 200 (T1, T2, T3) to Avenida

de América.

By Car

From Madrid downtown:30 minutes. We recommend that you use the

M-30 Nord sens, following signs for Colme-

nar Viejo (M-607), that will guide you to the

University Campus. Take exit 15 (Valdelatas)

and go straight up to coming to the Campus y

then follow the signs to IMDEA Nanociencia.

From Airport:20 minutes. We recommend that you use the

M-40 Nord sens, following signs for Colme-

nar Viejo (M-607), that will guide you to the

University Campus. Take exit 15 (Valdelatas)

and go straight up to coming to the Campus y

then follow the signs to IMDEA Nanociencia.

Page 118: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!
Page 119: Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland · Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin, Ireland ... multifun!!

2015 workshop

final multifun

�������������������������������������