Trialogueclub inTernaTional

Vyacheslav TRUBNIKOV, General of the Army, Director of the Russian Foreign Intelligence Service (1996-2000), First Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs (2000 – 2004), Russian Ambassador to India (2004-2009) Member of the Trialogue Club (commenting on the Club meeting)

Today for the first time in the last 15-20 years I heard the most reasonable analysis of the situation in the energy world. Some may like it, some may not, but this is reality. «

«

In 2016-2017 meetings were devoted to:Russia’s pivot to the East - ASEAN dimension

Russia-United States relations and the future of global security

Development of the situation in Afghanistan and security threats to Central Asia

Situation in Syria and Russian policy in the Middle East.

Russia - China - United States: Setting the global rules of the game in Cyberspace

New situation in the energy markets, Russia’s interests and international politics.

It gives me a great pleasure to speak to such a distinguished

audience of professionals, to share

my views on foreign and defence policy

with you.

«

«

Evgeny BUZHINSKIY, Lieutenant General (Ret.),

Chairman of the Trialogue Club International, Chairman of the PIR Center’s Executive Board

Aim of the ТRIALOGUE Club International is to introduce the members of diplomatic, military diplomatic, political, and expert circles as well as business community with the relevant positions and opinions of Russian officials and leading experts on the pressing issues of international security, Russia’s foreign, defence, and security policy.

Trialogue is a meeting place for substantive talk on the key challenges of international security.

The meetings of the Club take place six times a year in Moscow in the form of business breakfast.

Meetings are informal in character, comprising of keynote speeches followed by Q&A and discussion sessions.

among the speakers at the club meetings were:Russian Deputy Minister of Defence Аnatoly Antonov, Russian Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Sergey Ryabkov,Chief of the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces Nikolai MakarovChairs of the Committee for Foreign Affairs of the Council of Federation of Russia Mikhail Margelov and Konstantin Kosachev, Chairman of the Russian State Duma Committee on Education Vyacheslav Nikonov, and the leading experts, including Evgeny Buzhinsky, Leonid Grigoryev Vitaly Naumkin, Vladimir Orlov, Victor Sumsky, Vyacheslav Trubnikov, and many others

You can join the Trialogue Club by paying either the individual or corporate membership fee. More information about the Club activities and fee rates you can find at club.pircenter.org or by contacting Club Secretary via e-mail: secretary@trialogue-club.ru, or by phone: +7 (985) 764-98-96

REV 17.11.30/ZUL

I find the Trialogue Club events highly interesting: they have a relatively a short format, but still give time to substantive discussions. The thematics are well focused and the speakers are excellent. The forum provides a good opportunity for participants to engage in the discussion. When I am not travelling, I prioritize attendance at the Trialogue Club

Join uS! Club members receive:INVITATIONS to the Club meetings and to events of the Club’s partner - PIR Center;

SUBSCRIPTION to the bullettin of exclusive analytisc “Russia Confidential”, reports from PIR Center and its partners, regular newsletters (PIR PRESS NEWS, bulletin “Yaderny Kontrol” (Nuclear Control), electronic journal “The CyberPulse”)

PRIORITY right to receive consultations from PIR Center experts

ACCESS to the special closed section of the Club website

Sergey RYABKOV, Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs of Russia:

The Russia Confidential analytical newsletter (we call it PIR Yellow Papers) are very stimulating to intellectual pursuit, going in many cases ahead a few steps further than official diplomacy allows. «

-1-

__________

____________________

____________________

____________________

___________

RUSSIA

The circulation of t

his report has been

strictly limited to

the members of the

Trialogue Club Inter

national

and of the Centre ru

sse d’études politiq

ues.

This issue is for yo

ur personal use only

.

Published monthly in

Russian and in Engl

ish

by Trialogue Company

Ltd.

Issue № 7 (235), vol

.15. 2016

7 ноября 2

016 г.

Алексей Лу

кацкий сообщает из М

осквы:

ЧТО НАДО ЗНАТЬ, ЧИТА

Я ОБВИНЕНИЯ В КИБЕРА

ТКАХ?:

АНАЛИЗ ЗАЯВЛЕНИЯ МИН

ИСТЕРСТВА ВНУТРЕННЕЙ

БЕЗОПАСНОСТИ И УПРА

ВЛЕНИЯ НАЦИОНАЛЬНОЙ

РАЗВЕДКИ США С ОБВИН

ЕНИЕМ РОССИЙСКИХ ВЛА

СТЕЙ В ОРГАНИЗАЦИИ К

ИБЕРАТАК НА

АМЕРИКАНСКИЕ ПОЛИТИЧ

ЕСКИЕ СТРУКТУРЫ

АННОТАЦИЯ

В последние месяцы количество

обвинений России в кибератака

х возросло

многократно. Прокремлев

ские хакеры, по заявлениям американск

их политиков и

СМИ, стоят за самыми громкими взломами

недавнего времени

– серверов

Демократической парт

ии США, антидопинго

вого агентства WADA,

американских СМИ,

избирательных комис

сий нескольких шта

тов США. Даже утеч

ка архива кибероружи

я

из АНБ также припи

сывается российским

киберпреступникам,

за которыми видит

ся

рука Кремля. Дело д

ошло до того, что

министерство внутрен

ней безопасности США

(DHS) и управления национальн

ой разведки (USIC) выступили

с официальным

обвинением российских

властей в организаци

и кибератак на американск

ие

политические структуры.

До этого такой чести удостаивались только Китай и

Северная Корея.

Член рабочей группы при Экспертно

м совете ПИР-Центра по междунаро

дной

информационной безопасно

сти и глобальному управлени

ю интернетом, бизнес-

консультант по безопасно

сти Cisco Systems Алексей Лукацкий предлагае

т

разобраться в американс

ких обвинениях и российско

й реакции, показать

пределы и возможности определен

ия инициатора кибератак

, оценить влияние

внутренней политичес

кой борьбы и глобально

го геополитического

противостояния на

возможности объект

ивного расследован

ия.

«

Trialogueclub inTernaTional

Magne BARTH, Head of the International Committee of the Red Cross Regional Delegation for the Russian Federation, Belarus and Moldova:

«

«