Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection...

31
Today’s Talk • Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” • Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” • Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian; Cho et al….) • Particle acceleration in turbulence (Dmitruk et al. 2003, ApJ, 597, L81) • Particle simulations (Tanuma et al.)

Transcript of Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection...

Page 1: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Today’s Talk• Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference”

• Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003”

• Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian; Cho et al….)

• Particle acceleration in turbulence (Dmitruk et al. 2003, ApJ, 597, L81)

• Particle simulations (Tanuma et al.)

Page 2: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Priest 60 Years Old Conference• http://www-solar.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/~mhd03/

• Magnetic Reconnection and the Dynamic Sun

• 8-10 September 2003

• Institute of Mathematics, University of St. Andrews, Scotland.

• Linton’ talk

Page 3: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Programme• Reconnection Theory and Applications (Forbes,

Drake, Fujimoto, Linton, Birn, etc.)• The Dynamic Sun (Proctor, Weiss, Asai,

Klimchuk, Longcope, Galsgaard, Neukirch, Kusano, etc.)

• The Dynamic Sun and Astrophysics (Dahlburg, Antiochos, Roussev, Heyvaerts, Casse, Baty, etc.)

• Poster (Chen,Yokoyama, Miyagoshi, Suzuki, Tanuma etc.)

• Annual PLATON Network Meeting follows the meeting.

Page 4: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

MR2003• http://www.aph.caltech.edu/mr2003/

• Fifth US-Japan Workshop on Magnetic Reconnection, Plasma Merging, and Magnetic Jets

• November 3-5, 2003

• Catalina Canyon Resort, Catalina Island, California

• Ono-san’s talk

• Tanuma’s talk

Page 5: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Program• Particle heating during reconnection (Lin, Hoshino,

Oieroset, Birn, Ono)• Jets, dynamo, & reconnection (Hirose, Kudoh, Bellan, Li)• Turbulent versus Laminar reconnection (Wygant, Ji,

Diamond, Bale, Horiuchi, Lazarian)• Macroscale structure (Kawamori, Tanuma)• Structure and scaling of reconnection (Egedal, Terry, Shay,

Cowley, Fujimoto, Kusano)• Guide versus null field reconnection (Prager, Porcelli,

Cothran, Fuselier, Hesse, Swisdak)• Poster (Colgate, Furno, Uzdensky, T.Nakamura, Phan,

M.Nakamura, Tanaka, Yamada, Tripathi, Jorne, Vou, Romero-Talamas, Izzo)

Page 6: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

My Recent Study about Turbulent Reconnection

• Talk at MR2003

• Internal shocks created by some instabilities and Turbulence in the reconnection jet

Page 7: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Turbulent Reconnection• Matthaeus & Lamkin 1985, Phys. Fluids, 28, 303,

‘Rapid magnetic reconnection caused byu finite amplitude fluctuations’

• Matthaeus & Lamkin 1986, Phys. Fluids, 29, 2513, ‘Turbulent magnetic reconnection’

• Enhanced viscous and resistive dissipation

Page 8: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Turbulent Reconnection

Page 9: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Coronal Heating by Turbulence

• Matthaeus et al. 1999, ApJ, 523, L93, ‘Coronal heating by magnetohydrodynamic turbulence driven by reflected low-frequency waves’

Page 10: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Reconnection Rate Enhanced by Turbulence

• Vishniac & Lazarian 1999, ApJ, 511, 193, ‘Reconnection in the interstellar medium’

• Lazarian & Bishniac, 1999, ApJ, 517, 700, ‘Reconnection in a weakly stochastic field’

Page 11: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Reconnection Rate Enhanced by Neutral Gas

• Cho, Lazarian, & Vishniac 2002, ApJ, 564, 291, ‘Simulations of magnetohydrodynamic turbulence in a strongly magnetized medium’

• Yan & Lazarian 2003, ApJ, 592, L33, ‘Grain acceleration by magnetohydrodynamic turbulence: Gyroresonance mechanism’

• Cho, Lazarian, & Vishniac 2003, ApJ, 595, 812, ‘Ordinary and viscousity-damped magnetohydrodynamic turbulence’

• Many papers are posted in astro-ph.

Page 12: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

MHD Simulations of Turbulent Reconnection

• In Yokoyama-san’s results, the reconnection rate is not enhanced.

• They are same with Tanuma’s results.

• Much more simulation grids would be required.

Page 13: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;
Page 14: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Particle Acceleration in Analytic Reconnection Current Sheet• Craig & Henton’s analytic solution(Craig &

Henton 1995, ApJ, 450, 280)

• Hirose, Litvinenko, Shibata, Tanuma et al. (2003): MHD simulations of stability.

• Heerikhuisen, Litvinenko, & Craig (2002), ApJ, 566, 512, ‘Proton acceleration in analytic reconnecting current sheets’: Test particle in Craig & Henton solution

• Takasaki, Asai, et al.: Test particle in Craig & Henton solution

Page 15: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Craig & Henton(1995)’s Solution

Page 16: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Numerical Test of Stability• Hirose, Litvinenko, Shibata, Tanuma et al. (2003)

examine stability of Craig & Henton solution by performing MHD simulations.

• It is revealed that Craig & Henton solution is unstable to tearing instability or Kelvin-Helmholtz instability in some cases.

Page 17: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Particle Acceleration in Analytic Solution

• Heerikhuisen, Litvinenko, & Craig (2002), ApJ, 566, 512, ‘Proton acceleration in analytic reconnecting current sheets’: Test particle in Craig & Henton solution

Page 18: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Trajectories of Test particles

Page 19: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Spectrum of Test Particles

Page 20: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Particle Acceleration in Turbulence• Dmitruk, Matthaeus, Seenu, &

Brown 2002, ApJ, 597, L81, ‘Test particle acceleration in three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic turbulence’

Page 21: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

MHD Equations

Page 22: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Simulations• Mach number is 0.25.

• Specific heat ratioγ=5/3

• The random fluctuation is assumed at 1<k<4.

• R=Rm=1000

• Pseudospectral code (Ghosh, Hossain, & Matthaeus 1993)

• The resolution is 256^3 Fourier modes.

Page 23: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Ohm’s law

Page 24: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Results• Turbulent |B| (upper) and |E|

(lower). Yellow shows high, blue shows low.

• The energy spectrum of the MHD fields (not shown in the paper) is consistent with a Kolmogorov 5/3 power law.

Page 25: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Nonrelativistic Equations of Motion

• α=Ωi Ta relates the turbulent field scales with the particle motion scales. In general, α>>1: turbulent time scale is much slower than gyro frequency. In this paper, α=10^2, 10^3, 10^4, 10^5.

• Ωi=qi B/ mi c is normalized gyro-frequency.• 50000 particles• Runge-Kutta 4th order.

Page 26: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Trajectories• 100 test particles (out of 50000)

• The color shows velocity.

Page 27: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Particle Energy Distribution

-2

-0.6

Page 28: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Emax and <E> v.s. α

• Emax=2αE||λ||• Solid line: This simulation• Dotted line: Particle simulation• Dashed line: Integration

Emax

<E>

Page 29: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Emax• Emax=2αE||λ||∝ vBL.

• These results are consistent with Swarthmore Spheromak laboratory reconnection experiment (Brown et al. 2002, ApJ, 577, L63) and a wide range of space and astrophysical systems (Makishima 1999, Astron. Nachr., 320, 1997Proc. Of ASCA 4th Meeting)

Page 30: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Particle Simulations• Tanuma et al.

• Nishikawa et al. 2003

• To obtain spectrum.

• Naito: Monte-Carlo simulations

Page 31: Today’s Talk Report on “Priest 60 Years Old Conference” Report on “Magnetic Reconnection 2003” Turbulent reconnection (Tanuma et al.; Vishiniac & Lazarian;

Summary• Report of conferences

• Turbulent reconnection

• Particle acceleration

• Particle simulations