to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo...

39
s Il ., that prllj v rl ttv 1•ut i v tl'•,.,l g n, rlll'l•iul inll'Iroa . ; tuuk tilt, lllur l ' l ;reut t;l'ncrul intcn ",t s u1i g 11t I,y this tiluc have url•ullilvl ; t•t' S tl'll ri g ht : s luul lu c,tl iultl,itilln>r uru .e wul %N l'rv rl•ruy ilir .t'll ; unll ttll tlm,c had t o lit- ullnlittl•11 ; l : ox i ;tiu g in st 1~1'l'tl t' llCl1',1111 (Yl vl ;l .''1' uf 111'\'l'I1~111111'llt, tCI1Pll . u111' ('u11Ii'1'l'IICPi 1'l'l'r l,lII1 I tuf ;l;lhl'i• . ( II var, hl ) lr .) 'l'hl' II' ;,In 1 4 1 hi, II' ;n'ul'll Il•llnl this .111 ~ullll't'inR Ilt' Iln,u'Irr r c nlln'il' . II y Itriti , ll, .\ulcrilln s is 116,4 , that il' t% l+ I11~ . tilt' lin- .w'llt In'ullitilulv ullllltrtlnlitl' " w l' nl,l v litai it as h ;ull u li'tr Y l ;u'~ . 111 '1 lv' to p 't ml lutllj1711'l', - I'cl'u lilr,l p t' kinll 1 l 1 union (l' m' 1'llt .1iul,ril•un I'tli o n u< we jhunl ( l 1111 %'l' tillltlll it to nl'I it IIIWIllir lil , t l'lll' tlll' it !d' " 1,:1 ;1111'l' I I11111, tt'UIII lill' lull}1 1 w riull nt' P :.trirtl ;:ollll -nt :(n d III I II•iutl .rcilllf;l' N'lli( II llitll • X i S tl'll III'tN' v I'i l . : • thl' .<t+ lrrut'inl•l' ., unil Ille >,lu v l•i ;ll intl'rl' , t+ tt'llii ll hall g r mt•II Ill ill thl - Inr,ln- tilul' in en-l1 ut' I -hl'llt . ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lullli v r to unil o urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t .ll e ltltit motive s IIlIk1'll llt, i s 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\' lll' utll' 111'll .'llllullt:, No 1111' ,:Ilutll ul' Ils have ul w : o r; Imru ur~rl' . :it'r . 'I'lll'rt', llu ,; lil \ ,1} P, lu' v u it lll - ire lllllllll g !It tlll 'nl for thl' !N•Illl k ilinlt ul' t11•N' tl'l'l'itlll y , t11111 11 l' illl'\111',Illll' lHIY o f lll'ullu•r;tliu rsistl'til•I+ Ia'unl, . to lli' its ,Ill,~urllt il,u . 'lhl' V u v ntt -il Florida, unll j 1'iit'd if, the y c I+t'ct1,tl Luni s iuy(,I, mitai lirl'hn,l'll it ; the l'ut'1•tl'll `Ibxu, :, utlll • S tlill' it ; Itllll tJu e tl tlilt• l,it,'hi'tl it qulirr 0 a'i :h 1lexit'll, tcllir'h 1 11I ll'lI IIt" Ihl'i r . g1'llitll ; l'uliti,rnitt . (llrur, Ilo ;tr .) 'l'hl ;\• ,ulnl'tiliua .; Ilri' 'nll tulll' .Ilisl'tlll'sI,cll' lunil'N as Ilrizon Ilçnl'utlt thl'iru .n111itilnl ; llut h ;td %%'e It t llull tllc r•tj'I+n" arltl o1' I:nrl+uul-uvl'r its . we s4Fttittld not now lutrt' hall u,+i+ u•utl+ trxirtl'tii•l' . . (Cliver-) 'l'h,' ul~ll(i ütüllt'llf l', nnll,t was lllptr,t ntullitillu 1' fit, .1,uu'ril'uli l'ullli'dl'1•,Ir c, ;tnd ul,cer colt,jnl tl1 lle•sit, wlotl hl,r ti'wip,m'l'rltilt Iulu1N'ul Itnlt lll'r nut')' ht•lu•l•e it r+qlutllrun . la it Iikt'h' tu'LI' sit tliplrfl t .li it•, tvIlnu tau' cuuttt,4 11 el . lcntl, ufloatl.11(• thllur+linQ . and hvr'tt'uoyw 1,j' 1ttttlllri~lls of tltunwulllx ! t n 11 lis tu'Ilit'r ; It t'1•r)• t,u~t'I~rt'uI l'xlrru, .viiln ul'nllini„1} ~ut, Intl'I) itll~ll',uI 11 in lt 1tltLli,lll'll ll'11t'r ul : tfll' At•t'lll,islwll of tl+tiifita,''l)1' . .('usxnWL1', Who is tlll' .lrl•l+ltishull ut' Il,llililx Cn rithl'r ul' llia ruuz;t l'nlunii' :+, 411l;j'e lie IInH Iltliurhll ill lii, Ili}Îl tlu'ulilln fiir 111 l'nrly It thirîl (il* u,uentttr~y, it wrotil1l he ul,sw'll to usk the qucytiut~ ; l,itt i n '('tt Iullct he luu y tut 11 o rl(Nldi}• w0 1 knuit'tl . Some uP ult' Iwnllrullll, Trii'ull + in this and the ulller 14'liu ;n, it'Ilil N til'rit' his g uc,t s Illrit 1 )'l'ür, 11111A hli v ' bit lllc iruprc'sa uf Ili s î'bur ;u :ll'r as w 1+11 oui tlil+ tr,trnlth lll" hhis Illlhllitulits', (lll'itr, bcui' .i Well, hv.ix knlht'n it ., ultr oc titi th'nllinl'u in 11,utiluvitt' uKhl' is in (IUdli11F, itl,1115' ul'l1Mi+i''CUluilieA ; t'llüt III' l'' ;l s filt• ul1U1y yIVII•sIthl' ültillltltt' ,ts .tiuci,tlc of , tlis 1,tt1' Ili,titl}nishlvl 1•I14•l'rl', ,\r111Li•h111, I11'l ;lll•;4, fit' -New Yllrk ; that fit, kltl ov t+ thl' I'uit•l•11 tit`ntl'S its thln'llul;lll 3 "rn+ hl' 111 II'1 tltu' Ilrl,\ inl'l'-4, ,IUQ tlu' s c . un' Ili, t'il'«'s tilt this, lllla'tivni,n• hylillt ; tlli+ l'xtr,u•1 it, vutut't \ hul long, Ilut ; ll excl'lll'ntly llltt tlt,tt I'tun S w'l' tftl~ Illm .•l' will be ill,li};t'll tll Inl' lilr Iltl ! w hull' Ilt' it : In,ll'nll lit' 1'111'sinr, likl' tlu~ IIItt• ill thl+ njlturltl'll hold, and holding 4111' lttttll we Iltl' fitlt .l Y 1111 11111 Ilrtnk 11t the ('iltulrit(•t, ~~1' 11111~t III Ilttl'l' III' gIlt I1 1 111'11 t' and ; :trikl~ out lilr lln' .rhtort- lct• all nlv,ul•, III'Alre we RI't tutu 11lr llllirli tilt thl, vnn'l'nt . We Inu~ ut thi ;+ Inll,l 1•riti-cal, In\lulonl invIIIa'_Ihl' .\rllill .r of nntillna Ii'n' wislllml, mul ul'nnlllllliug ill fini' our III'rilnurl lul :itilm, we 111114t . t;trikl+ out Ilullll}•, +ulll it ~Ilnu' risl .', liir .~llnu' rul'k titi tlll' nl'nrr~ :t ~.Ilulve-,nlu o rrstin~! lllurl' Ilt' ljrl'utl'r til'onrity . ;A IVivlllry raid fit- It :'kit l'rUlnlutr l'i'Ifill u fril'nlln un lulr,cllul•k, thruugh t110 lllnin,l Ilt' l'ull :ul ;t and thc 1t,'Ytili' vllll')r

Transcript of to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo...

Page 1: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

s

Il .,

that prllj vrl ttv 1•uti v

tl'•,.,lg n, rlll'l•iul inll'Iroa .; tuuk tilt, lllur l ' l;reut t;l'ncrulintcn ",t s u1i g 11t I,y this tiluc have url•ullilvl ; t•t' S tl'll ri g ht :s luul lu c,tl iultl,itilln>r

uru .e wul %N l'rv rl•ruy ilir.t'll ; unll ttll tlm,c had t o lit- ullnlittl•11 ; l : ox i ;tiug in st

1~1'l'tl t' llCl1',1111 (Yl vl ;l .''1' uf 111'\'l'I1~111111'llt, tCI1Pll . u111' ('u11Ii'1'l'IICPi 1'l'l'r l,lII1 I

tuf;l;lhl'i• . ( II var, hl ) lr .) 'l'hl' II' ;,In 1 4 1 hi, II' ;n'ul'll Il•llnl this .111 ~ullll't'inR Ilt'Iln,u'Irr r c nlln'il' . IIy Itriti , ll, .\ulcrilln s is 116,4 , that il' t% l+ I11~ . tilt' lin- .w'lltIn'ullitilulv ullllltrtlnlitl' " w l' nl,l v litai it as h;ull u li'tr Y l ;u'~ . 111 '1 lv' to p 't mllutllj1711'l',- I'cl'u lilr,lp t' kinll 1 l 1 union (l'm' 1'llt .1iul,ril•un I'tli on u< we jhunl ( l

1111 %'l' tillltlll it to nl'I it IIIWIllir lil , t l'lll' tlll' it !d'" 1,:1 ;1111'l' I I11111, tt'UIII lill'

lull}1 1 w riull nt' P :.trirtl ;:ollll -nt :(n d III I II•iutl .rcilllf;l' N'lli( II llitll • X i S tl'll III'tN' v I'i l

. :

• thl' .<t+ lrrut'inl•l' ., unil Ille >,luv l•i ;ll intl'rl' , t+ tt'llii ll hall g rmt•II Ill ill thl - Inr,ln-tilul' in en-l1 ut' I -hl'llt . ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lullli vr to unil o urr,ltlu'ru IllulaUI t .ll e ltltit motive s IIlIk1'll llt, i s 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\' lll' utll' 111'll .'llllullt:, No 1111'

,:Ilutll ul' Ils have ul w : o • r; Imru ur~rl' . :it'r . 'I'lll'rt', llu ,; lil \ ,1} P, lu' v u it lll- irelllllllll g !It tlll 'nl for thl' !N•Illlk ilinlt ul' t11•N' tl'l'l'itlll y , t11111 11 l' illl'\111',Illll' lHIY o flll'ullu•r;tliu rsistl'til•I+ Ia'unl,. to lli' its ,Ill,~urllt il,u . 'lhl'V u v ntt -il Florida, unllj1'iit'd if, they c I+t'ct1,tl Luni s iuy(,I, mitai lirl'hn,l'll it ; the l'ut'1•tl'll `Ibxu,:, utlll •S tlill' it ; Itllll tJuetl tlilt• l,it,'hi'tl it qulirr0 a'i :h 1lexit'll, tcllir'h 1 11I ll'lI IIt" Ihl'i r

.

g1'llitll ; l'uliti,rnitt . (llrur, Ilo ;tr .) 'l'hl ;\• ,ulnl'tiliua .; Ilri' 'nll tulll' .Ilisl'tlll'sI,cll'

lunil'N as Ilrizon Ilçnl'utlt thl'iru.n111itilnl ; llut h ;td %%'e It t llull tllc r•tj'I+n" arltl o1'

I:nrl+uul-uvl'r its . we s4Fttittld not now lutrt' hall u,+i+ u•utl+ trxirtl'tii•l' . . (Cliver-)'l'h,' ul~ll(i ütüllt'llf l', ► nnll,t was lllptr,t ntullitillu 1' fit, .1,uu'ril'uli l'ullli'dl'1•,Ir c,

;tnd ul,cer colt,jnl tl1 lle•sit, wlotl hl,r ti'wip,m'l'rltilt Iulu1N'ul Itnlt lll'r nut')' ht•lu•l•e

it r+qlutllrun . la it Iikt'h' tu'LI' sit tliplrfl t.li ► it•, tvIlnu tau' cuuttt,4 11 el . lcntl, ufloatl.11(•thllur+linQ . and hvr'tt'uoyw 1,j' 1ttttlllri~lls of tltunwulllx ! t ►n 11 lis tu'Ilit'r ; It t'1•r)•t,u~t'I~rt'uI l'xlrru,.viiln ul'nllini„1} ~ut, Intl'I) itll~ll',uI 11 in lt 1tltLli,lll'll ll'11t'r ul : tfll'At•t'lll,islwll of tl+tiifita,''l)1' . .('usxnWL1', Who is tlll' .lrl•l+ltishull ut' Il,llililxCn rithl'r ul' llia ruuz;t l'nlunii' :+, 411l;j'e lie IInH Iltliurhll ill lii, Ili}Îl tlu'ulilln fiir

111 l'nrly It thirîl (il* u,uentttr~y, it wrotil1l he ul,sw'll to usk the qucytiut~ ; l,itt i n'('tt ► Iullct he luu y tut 11 o rl(Nldi}• w01 knuit'tl . Some uP ult' Iwnllrullll, Trii'ull + in

this and the ulller 14'liu ;n, it'Ilil N til'rit' his guc,t s Illrit 1 )'l'ür, 11111A hliv ' bit lllciruprc'sa uf Ili s î'bur ;u :ll'r as w 1+11 oui tlil+ tr,trnlth lll" hhis Illlhllitulits', (lll'itr,bcui' .i Well, hv.ix knlht'n it ., ultr oc titi th'nllinl'u in 11,utiluvitt' uKhl' is in (IUdli11F,

itl,1115' ul'l1Mi+i''CUluilieA ; t'llüt III' l'' ;l s filt• ul1U1y yIVII•sIthl' ültillltltt' ,ts.tiuci,tlc of ,tlis 1,tt1' Ili,titl}nishlvl 1•I14•l'rl', ,\r111Li•h111, I11'l ;lll•;4, fit' -New Yllrk ; that fit,kltlov t+ thl' I'uit•l•11 tit`ntl'S its thln'llul;lll 3 "rn+ hl' 111 II'1 tltu' Ilrl,\ inl'l'-4, ,IUQ tlu' s c .un' Ili, t'il'«'s tilt this, lllla'tivni,n• hylillt ; tlli+ l'xtr,u•1 it, vutut't\ hul long, Ilut ; llexcl'lll'ntly llltt tlt,tt I'tun S w'l' tftl~ Illm .•l' will be ill,li};t'll tll Inl' lilr Iltl ! whull'Ilt' it :

In,ll'nll lit' 1'111'sinr, likl' tlu~ IIItt• ill thl+ njlturltl'll hold, and holding 4111'lttttll we Iltl' fitlt .l

Y 1111 11111 Ilrtnk 11t the ('iltulrit(•t, ~~1' 11111~t III Ilttl'l' III' gIlt I1 1

111'11 t' and ; :trikl~ out lilr lln' .rhtort- lct• all nlv,ul•, III'Alre we RI't tutu 11lr llllirli tiltthl, vnn'l'nt . We Inu~ ut thi;+ Inll,l 1•riti-cal, In\lulonl invIIIa'_Ihl' .\rllill .r ofnntillna Ii'n' wislllml, mul ul'nnlllllliug ill fini' our III'rilnurl lul :itilm, we 111114t.t;trikl+ out Ilullll}•, +ulll it ~Ilnu' risl.', liir .~llnu' rul'k titi tlll' nl'nrr~ :t ~.Ilulve-,nluorrstin~! lllurl' Ilt' ljrl'utl'r til'onrity . ;A IVivlllry raid fit- It :'kit l'rUlnlutr l'i'Ifill u

fril'nlln un lulr,cllul•k, thruugh t110 lllnin,l Ilt' l'ull :ul ;t and thc 1t,'Ytili' vllll')r

Page 2: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

~~ . ' ~ ' . • ' ; .off `cwI,rllnaei,•k ' luitl, N ucn ti t •utin, may it mir- fit , t :;inl;l,+ w l'rk• tluUl

' Clillti -,l,'l'lltl III Ii i1' 111 11 It,'\t lill~' 7111,l il N',' ; 11'l ' I I , I I ,'lil'CI• \'lill, .11'll,'I', '

i~ tll,+ nl•curit v ,•t ,'n at tlu+

,

, Ilt iïlunl,•ttt rl gnill t tiia'll It,li - u<I Ill . ' \\'itii-

„tll I he 1l fit fit! Iou1w•l' ut Ittl• fit( ~1111'l' t' i l I111i r}' I I }' I ;tll,t 7111,1 ~l'il, and I i IL ,'i,IIPI'il'

tr ;ttiull ill n`illtI,' I fit 1,1 it I' .1ll tlll• alrn}flll fit* Itrili .Il .\i, wur,'un,liti m l

i .; ~ e 1'n at 11 g I,nlr,', \\'ll,'lli•C,'r 1111' (nr~ellt ,litli,•nltil' : \cill t,'rnlill ; lt,'-7ul,l

who l'an 1,'ll 1111' ill (I llli•Ilt !-w ,' K'Itl 11v at 1111 . 1 m 'l'P1', f 11 „111' I1,'i!1111 11 ,1' s ; a 11 d

cict l ,riulrH nl' ullll'nti ' i' . tll,'\' will Ii(, 1•111111,'1111 v it lllllllitl'}' 1 i ,•nlll " , Illlll N'lll l

-;II tll,'ir Ill,l,,ir,+nt inilitf,•iv'u, i' ,1 6nlll iulnl•xillt; t, 11k I•„uutl,t', ;ui,1 4 111 tlli' l'ril'nillt•

li•,•Iiu g~z tltllt nut v lil' t ;llkoll, '11116 • w ill Iln v r Ihr I„ m ',•r t o) ,trikr w llou thl .\ •I 1 Iru , i', and tll k k l l rl • i •i„'IY Itw f'l'rnol and 111 l • „rllt' I„nrh pniut „l' Ilrr' ~ v hulcli,u\„ ► lilti,m ,'ver had (if(, I,um ,'r nt' t'nnllüt' ;I Ih,U lli,l 11(,t n w il, ,,rnl,ll•,• it, 111 111 1 ' v ,•r

* v

til :,l t'. ► ~',~rall,l,' Illll,,,rhulit~' . \II 111nt' k ili,l Id ' 1111 tlilllgw lililnit v will t; 1 rI,011Y11llcr ul' IIli ;111t1' II ; iÎinn . wln Ilr rx`,lllill,'il off) thl ,lirinl ii,ll+ ul' li,'I r illl tt l,r,lil'nl'Y ,it ., tllt' tt•urlll ku„tt'~ . The tt'll„II' f,u•I k i,l'

Ian•i~) l,u has Ilecn t•Ilstn " l'll . ,ulll lllt• il vnu~li,' s I 1 I' iûilut Iluiltlrrll t' e In• s Illit'1+

LI' m l w w l'lll utt,u y tcitllin nilr „tt - 11 tilul•, tilt (lit' I,riut'il1Îl' ,il' )nl}tllt. nlnlll - tl~,\.

uilll' ' t, 1111+ ;.t1'urlt;,'4, nuit I1 '4 ra ► nl' WI 11011, have it, t1n' ttul :a s ;uu rlvl iot'nll litlrv .

Tlte Ihirt~ '- l'n Irrig iunl St :fit, .., I i I' .\lul'ri,•u, w ith fill tan•ir Irr„ti•, ..ilm s ul' rt'11=

Ill,uiltl,,lutc e 1 14 „r11 fill thl' tinlo, I1Y Inultl+y , Ilutrl'r and 1 0• n'lu•, nuit Ly .urgn-

liMiutt ; i+ x ft'utlinu thl~ir I'rcll)tic i r 11nÎiI tltr}'ttlllrl' than clululrtllllc'it llu'ir trrritilrt'

a•ithin t+i x t v y l'nr.:' ; mul hl'til't 'it it ttfi„ 11111v . III-(- tll,' v lunt' , i 1' thl'ir um•tl

nucl,rll tl o rulul+l o if full stop \n ; 11-1, long its thir \ • hlisl• tiu• ilntcl'r. th,'t.

Illu : ;t t;u (III uttw Ilyd : tilr it Is tlu, !

vert' tlntnr,' ilt' Iluicl - r fit grip tt•hiltc~~4rr is

w itl ► hl ita m,iclt . It. is t)nt thlAir lu, s tile ti't~lin gs , thl'rt'ti,rl', Ilnt it i s tltnir

pu«•ur, uull lu ► iy th u ir putt e r ; I 1lrcitll 1 null I Illlw autl, it, uq ► lly rlilt'ilttl A ;I,li-

t^irtiutl, tltu .I it IN+cln ► IC>f th„ dlit~'lll' c~tv'ry Itriti A l ritlljrct il ► 1h0-<I, Ilrti\•illf'l•3

t„ c'pntrcll t,llut Iltl wer, twl I,)' t111' illatn t ' pt,liry14, otttuckinl; ,41 Ir w c'uko liliti•

thum, luit by ,trt,ulslhonint; t,ul,~1~1\crs--ri ciul w ith fit(- whulc lu,wor o l' Itri .

tnilt Lut, 11111' bac k, t o , thrir I,' v ot Ittul it III' llre luirl'll ti,r Ilu \ • l'Inct•t;etlt' y .

'l'llern i i titi " , u A 111t' ur lnlllrl'juilicc'll mim in,thl - cnlnlulnlit ~ tt'hu Ilul• s luit mrv

th,tt, v ilcnrrnl, and tiuu'tr llrrlrtrlttiutl Is thl A „uly li,, .alIll . im,lu ► • c,V :,rn•iuR Its

1'ruut tlll' Itnrr,~r:I~I' tt \ cilr S ul'h Ilu thl• ~~I~rlll 1 1 I 1 s 'l'„I,i' f'nllY pro= .

purl'll i s tlu' ~mlt` llrnrtiivtl nrHuun'ul that c'nn hilt',' u•i•i}tlrt with it lln w c'rfltl

elJl+lu1', ;Illll n171ko Ililll Iul*l' lu'Ii,rl•hll ► 11l nuit l', o Itu1t Off, vu A . :\tllf It,th e ,I~rt

ut' prt'l,+u•itti, i u I s Ilcllk , I I' i•'uttt'rlt' Ilniu'll' :+ri \ritlu,ut th e, ulli,m uf'tll,' l,rl,t'in-

h, l off it 111 41l 1j,'IJI whl,+li ll~~lllio , i llinimn is living i 'lornuvl , i 11 titis 060 I m illt,

1+ nlll' Il,'l'III Y ,•„111•rrnrll, 1 1o -,'l if it Iln7 .t• to illv'lul'u lut„rll' Ilnlvlllit'„cr111 y ill

avoir ~ if* .('~~llti',II r~ttiull IS 1•li,' ;Il,lt''lutll Its ilulu,rnllly. I 1-4 lnl+•illll'-but l'Imli' d -

,'ItIIIi,ut .lU ; 111 Ilnzur,l'+ and fit all r, il ,,ll ll,ll+ rnl't•itil'l's .

Ih e Illr luu.t )Llntln'1 V 1'ull s icli'r1► 1i m t, and 1111 thl , in• 9 Illljl'Ittd I hil V l' h1Ul,lr

fill I,ntJl'' >;UIoK ti,r tlll' lil ,t nHlnllt, th,-.le lin, Int' itttll,Ia 1'I,n v ic'tiUll s ilp Off,

nrct's ;il t' tulll r1lPrit •,11' it Iu,',I ' ur 14 N:hit'll Itl„n0, tt)ltlor l'r m'illrul'l', can s I'cUr e

l,+ its hlll'üll 1 w,tt'l' 1111,l Ili'ltc ,', llllll l'+Ili„IF+11 lilloftt', 111 1 11 711l t11 * 1 1 I 1 ' "S ill}Id \1'l'

IN,N' Pllj,l y llll,l,'l' 1111,' Illil,ll' ' t 6 ,1\'i'rllllll'ttt 11I111 the ilitlll,R'1'11 i w-iillltl,o ll s Irf

tllr t'rt'ctzt uull hill,lli,• :t 1•nlintr. v in th,r wurl,l• "

'l'Itc•~ti nre the «',i•rll+ of if ytittl'+Inrtu-nt' it ntitreil rrtutewutuu-nnh of, that

.ti

,

Page 3: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

lullt'r (if tniyThty n i,o n, pn v v c'rlhl in tl ;l'ir p 'nr'rntilm, «•hn ,v sts► tl' A nllutl}- r ift ,,have l„ff'11 1• i L t I11 t,lll' 1- trl,Iij! illo llll! of U 1 co Inrlt' ;11 11 k (•Il,llllv-- s Itl'll 111~'ll ;I ;

N•i•re N 611i•:VI; s Itry ( 1 N`•.ul, s l•:1' . \u ~~n,t

,' Illul'~tpl~'lll'~'l'üldtif Ii ;llt I do t' II11~'l'Ii•l'-

rnrr of t I,'r}trnlrlt in ml'r, l,,lilr pulitir .: . and I think sttl'h k tlu+ ~1•Iltinl,'nt;11-1) „t' Ili . i,t' II,IIiC Ix ; but N► llk•ti it N lui i ;rtl,' uf 'W•nl'l' or w :Ir, „f

,Il'li ► ,'ruiuv' or c,r11qu,' .t, who I1 ;1 ; it lu•ttc+i•, t► h,r su Fulul it ,ri g llt tu rl,l'lll: uq

tl,l' luiltktl+r~4 l,(' the ( ;l,au'I of' l,l ;u. . . ,ulil•ju,ticl lulll trlji' fl'1•l'llilnt ?(IlI<,uu,•r ► rli,rf tll~ >r two do-iu ;, rl'nil'uccs . " I li'i•I it it 1110t•,'• r•ny , tilt, illt ► .;tliftuti

.1r,'lllliAi,1l, . "tu,Il'rllu•l' uly l11' unv,llliciA ;Illr in thVl,t• lit' ('0uli'lll'ralil,n 113,1ht• ;Itlly ,inll r► ; hr,nln•,ihly ul,t ;linl'll )l ; l,n;uilllh, but (.'lmlirllll',Ilion It .1111h+u ;nrl, and at all t•wl<uurlllll • :u eitil o . . .11tt%r Of- nlu,t lu .tlurl ~ ull~illl'rnti~,l~, •

.nul nll tilt, In•alull,il,t ., I. huto lll+ftil on lu,tll •iilv, torr, tilt, Irn,t tllullth, tlu"Zr•fl,l tI11• Illlllu'l 49,11\'ictll,lli n1I IIII• 11l1l41S's`ll1• 1111(1 IIIPI•lts oit' it IRI' ;tlll'l' \1'Ilil'l l

i •;Ilunv, ► rllill'r I1•ovill,•nl'r% ('lul srl•In•„ to I : ; :oI .i,tl lll'dl'r and llrlu•l' . and rlltiouullil,l•rl{', and Ill] tilt . I,lt' h~i11j1+ 1t'l' I1l)\t' 1'rljny uiul/'l' tlU- Iltillll',t linl•1!rlllllt'lllnull th,' Il ;tll„n`i•Il i1l ;titlFlalIhe l'ri'l'st ,1nd Il,ll,l,il'rl rltllutn iu tltc' t ► /nI11 ."

( Il,'nr, IIl'I ► r .) . 'l'hl' nuxt luutil-c li,r uuivn ti, tt•hiA I Kh,ttl- ..ri'ti'r is, tlutt it

d•ilÎ .trl'n ; thi'n rc ► thcr tluul tcl'ukl'It tht' cunnl'ttioli with the l'ntllirl', xu c'shc,n .Iinl to 1111••I' 'risiug l,rut•incc''; . 'l'hu>i' who nu ►}' 1m r'cllll ïl . il' lho% :tre ,ulv

sItl•11, thc', ,tnti•tu,}ioni .t ;, 11111' rl', that tllis ra'llrlnl' hrrl' .,'tll,ttlittj'll Nt'ilI In•ing

:{l'lluratiun ill itb -train,' , flow, p1•,tt• f By tnul+iug tIN'rso muutttie ; 'more -iiujii,rtltrlt,_«•iil 'fun u,nkt• 11il'm lr .;,4 Qc',irl ►hlr it,, rc,ntit'ctiutls l'r, ltinülitricl :

Itr .Inul ;inl ; tlu'ir U•Ildl' more t`uMrubll', tt ill y'nu . uttlkl' lll'1^ mono' atixil,n : to

I'l't rid of it ?V izr• rc+lluc•inlt thoir, }•'t<dernl•tltri(ï' «'ill you lf ;s'4,cln tlll•ir iuti'rest•t'nr P;n}rl ;md t liy liwk~in~,~ tht'lli •trungl'r 1i,t• i- ;tl'h l,tlu'r's nic1, trill t'c,ll Initkn',,. .lier lr~s millinu tn llkl'll';irjsf . it II',~,1'r th ;ui it krc•utt+r rl'"jn~ual,ility ?' Itlit N,

thé thillg .llid iuut uu~~ter it~ls!l', lai ; luull hqs,un•u•cre,l Iht}t vurilü111y-

alilir4 ► \'iof-'l1Ur l1I ;t.11 of . I'uiuu: "=•ancl slip hits ttltrnt•s I,c•eit üc'c'4r1u11el1 II ►lpi tti guliït jllilrc of lttr l,n•ti llnpr,rirtl itltorl• ;ts . (Ill'Itl, hl'iir.) hhll llnc:y

[tilt c•ImlAtlt'r lN ;r tlui,nt itlltnil'rll-tu thna• intt'rrsts . ln,teud of lucihiuq ulli~n

it >•t•itlt ,t?AI,irk and clial'ulil'nuillp t'rl,n•n, she ncvrr-.4-11+ on by ll ► 'r'atro .t l, rn'llilt l

allll ►'ui•u lutait bills Its it ltt',u'tr "ti,ul rpr!'ll " ill tttl! Itl+ti pntCi . we lnl.v t, c'lhllr:c'+ï•• 1n l'ntl'r. ( tllv ► r, hultr .)~ Huit I,put it tnll prm•inriul }rnnlrtl~rn .- w'll. . We Itt• c

Uul i11,1P to 1;1, IIIUIII', mutai it' %\'l' ;ltti'llll)tl'(I it NIt N'I,Illll llllll 1 ,A l'l'l'IOti1l1C }fl, 1„

our mcn lto,tt•Itotillll- ;n that its nl' 1•Itnn o t it lil,ml', 1 ItIII'11 ; we II.„ luit clr s ir vmli~nl with the t'nitr,l til, ► tl• :, it i s tlle clntY li t' eve ry niait to (lit all ii i, hi ,pum l'r Ill A r111 :11u n tilt, l' o tlnrc•tnm with (7rlvlt I tr it ;üil . : .\tlcl Iln w Ahall we

I l„ it ? Is iI I,~~ l'lnlll,l•Ilnig tdu : Ilul,l'rin) 61n'l'rnnlont tn- nl•t;c,liufll at

Charlottetown, l'or l'Chr}' 1111111 and IIIII s ICI•1 l'19111i1Y 'tl for wur Il e ti'll('l', tn' 111'Htt-

li ;ltl' n gnilt tut II ; ► lif11\1 and .nwuiil it t'r,•d,'ril•kt I ,u, qn+l nl;,liu nt ;t : .lnlln' s :+I 11 ll ' il1r11111 at (1111'lll'c 1 Is it by Ilucittl; tlil~ ;l' fit'e t.l•lnu•clll' l; ocl'rnluvltlt : that

\cl' are to rlrnllor.thc• r o unel'linll ► ll' h ir+li,le will ,Il,llrl'l'iutl'IT, or is it b3 lnlttiul:lÎll' power 4 if 1111'r'r cl ,l lit tt' .; IIItU 111(' 11711111> lit; ulltt'til'lll•l'1tl 4 1 t'CTItl1lPllt'ltllil

t)181 ;in g tlll' nt'go tiüti„n, 1,l•t w Pl'it No llrlil' : o ltlt• . t11Pr1•I,r `imlllil .% •ill}( ttl f •

tt'h o lt' tr,tllen c tiun nnll r'sl„ Ilitin}~'t~h,ltl't', r i s t ;, Ili, llun v hul w l• o n the No

couutril s , (I11•nr, hrur .) I will content In}• .- rll'. J1r. tirh .~r.Fat, with titu m 'I,rinci pal rl if i t tn unit lit ; lir.,t, lhr► t w t',rrr ilt tl,r r;lltilk , and Inn .t go ln ► :

Ut' ,x t, that mir IIPI ~, hl,o r.: w ill ll o t, f ,n 1 11i'il;Fill,', " I,'t IIN ri-st y1111in1•It , l 't•P11 it ~

• _ ' • .ti- •

r,♦P

-,1

Page 4: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

' 95

4

tcn t•ulil,l il,+ ~; „wfrr,nl•uthl'r nit<u~ : u11r1, thir,llF' ; tllut lit- ïua : :ing file lillitv(l

l'„luilir• ; Innrr' \,tltt,ll,lr• ,6•• ml •111}' t t , I ; r~•,It r lritaiu, \\•l' ;Ilull tr, nkl lu ll r,Ullo r

t ll,ltl \\, nl,r'n lit(, l,ui„•ri ;ll (1 '111 ,•r; .) ,Î,l•t ul,• u„\\ ,•,II1 )• irm• . f '

;Itl,•uti,rn t„ th, . i litlir•ulti,• s , ir - t ;luit lrrr I'llt, \\'IuIII tlli~`~nvlt Ilr,~j,'lt lla,l Irr

~n,Inlutl'r .Irvlo i•l' il r,vu•Ilu,l t lit- .,lo Ililuitlr' Ju lnlit .

11' lit il il \t,l , lir › t ait f"u, "ëIr d I I, % iud i\'irlllul, . Jl ow r :cl'r r'nlicr•rlt, 1 il' t . ultr' .1•, it.l l ait I , u l ~ . - , il t.t• l • Ili u l ut ' Il I* ' 1 1 1 1 1 . . . ( I l,•, r , Ill• ;u• . ) ti'ti,lt \\•,t .• Illi• lir>t :l t+l ;-I c ;

tua tai Id' lu Y Ilirlt ti'i,'nll (Mr . G .\tl'r' s ) turrtilm in I^ :+~, ;lull InY own Irwti,ru

Of Icltl' v l',u' . t111• Gull«u ;lrr ul' tllc t"o i,ruilll 1111ir•r', uf 11r. I„1tui,rl•tlt;uF:, n1 . 4

as part fit' its lrulil t. 1(', •r•l'k II c uut','rl'ncr \~itll lh i ; ' L,r w 1'r t' 41161l il• :, 111 1 4 1 4 .11 .

iu h .S Ilurl I-a ; ► , it'tlrnurl ;"utur \I- itll llr~\cllin r .,tr~•l'I . it ,~~itrll till-

e I.41 il,\,I~'. uj •rl, it Iuur•,i I III- •i',11,', ,u rilil , ,•,(' ln lll,' j . •+Ilu u

Mill di ctl,i t ru s \+ililJl llrar"~,vl th ;lt lr,u•tirul :ir • lul,lr•rt,lkiu g .- \1'llo 11 , its tn • !

in I~liu tlttt ~Ill jl l t w :i~ ,ulnutr,l ill tlli ; Ili,il r' li~ it irrM lt l ' ulr!tll, l 'a, lül'` .'

1lilli s tt') +1t' tiir• ,lu)• lunlll mo l-,ïllo \\• ~u I;ru\r• it tnl',1•lu•r tl, ;u c l•l•rvi iu utlu'r .'

hun,l , tinta til,•irr'\t°u ; \d ll n, u ;•\i•,I : fit o,•,1 l ,' in tlll' \liui.,tr\^ l'o ulnutlo, l

thl'ul-olcc+ tu it, Illl' nl'll 4l .4tirm c rnni,Lliurll 111111 l',Irll,liiu'nl hall not Îrl'l'I ►~ :'I \l t\~~,Rilrll,tllil . Ml'l,llrltlllvll W liait ('7111,1,1t IIi1+INr-,vl to IrltrC l', ill ,Il o u e

rl',aluiull 11 \~~Tt, u,\lr\,I +I oti,î fnu\rll, ill I~llt ► , \l \\ Itilul~\\'irk III. nrml'll

to vo t\•ith lll•r : ilt 1 III v cout -, i',Iti,(IGI ( lirl u,+t Ilu'rl 1• 1 +tl :,40 .11 t . ( lit-u1•, lu,u•. )

Sir itt : ocr;u Lv'r'ru s , and! rll' the Iauumtl•ll llukl' ut' \r,\\•c .\s 'rt,t`i \\•u , :ull•

, ;t,ultiltll~' A }trl'r luuun} ; 1'uttJ•a'I\i•, }ic ►Itleulell, nuit k\'l' will m,t - r ;tlui d i n

1 It1' \\'it\• ." A II ! I lit . l'1' was Illl• l'tlll -T` .it t,(l'l'rt ,Illlllllr %'Illlt°.k I'i1•Nr:'" l'.clWltl' ~i~lll -'', •

lllüll l1l I I1P, \1'ltll ti1'C' l'lrllNlll',: s n h r11J; t' sJl',llt}tr'll, and t\'all+ , l' t'ul'IIJI'C fl .l' g +rli,l-

tiutlis had } ;1'nl'rrtll y l'ulll'll iu I+iitor l•IinU•u\•l'wif , =, l'll i,+. tllt* I,I ;t ) ' var 't°hli1+ • .

il\•It s nn ç'uu,jiull tilr15 I+t=rircunl - t :pt1'l' .< t',It•nral,b' tu tlu• liritro l r nltuut or titis

tluiutl, and llrulltl .tll y if \\l' ,uili'r Ihi s o irp o ritulit Y III Iu' w ,1•11' 4 I we .ht+ll IlVl'\l r.

u};rl r- ~-,4l'' li};,ti ►► rttell it l ulljlull tirrn ut" l•ir/;lUlla,ulct'~ Its a~ilf l~nlllrll' Itt: If ,

t•el'n su far, ,unuul; uursol\r+. 1tv It tilua tirrtnrl,ttl' l'nlu•lu•ri'nrl• ut' ( •irl•turn-

s tuul•l' :=-tl )• \clutt I Ilt•o ~!lrlnl' t t r c rnll,•Kll,'ukiu g (of r• v r'ut+ 'o t' tlli s u1n ;:uithull', •

- It Ilr++\•illrnti ; ► I cuulvu•rr'li v r• ut' l•irl'11i1 ► .•tuul•l',--Illn tlm•l'rliuu•nt l l t' ( `,unl,l, l

\c,t : s0 1111ullitil•,I III,.t ~Inju} : It ; to Iulllllu it tr, ll,r ;ll 1 ;Irll • .•It' \t`itll Ilium •ul+-•

jl•rt, it tllr clla' ,unu,rut \ch,'u lhr l .010 l•ulullir ! .;, / li '=1i,lt•in g ut' it G uu111i ; ►u%

~ 111111~11, t1','IY' 111•l'ull}t illr it l'r~lll''rl'lll',' lii t11Plr I r\1• I+ ( i+l' it I1111„il o f"till'il' rrNtl .

Our G u\•l•rnnll'ut r lullr+u cil uliliulk it ., nll - nll,l'r .: fro lrl thl' \\ r' .tr'rll a l tiull tllr' .

Ir,ulor : or till' Grrln,'r alill k tr, v

,unl' f„rlnr'r UlrlïS, .itiutl l'ruul thNt A l

the tinte it \\,1 : l'nrlur'll it , ► nnulnu• e rl to tlli S Il• I u-l' Witt it ~\•,1- its intl'Itli,m

llaa\• i ir to Irriut!,Iturut ,I gr'n,•rul lulirrn, 'l'lli ; Il,rrn ;r t,rrul,lll~' "Me th,' lin\-' . . . .• . . . - ._ , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .• . ., . .r 11 . ,• . .,,I„•,• , o ,,t „l,l, ol ,, .1,.

r•uulnlit it-l'If t oi thr' Ilrinl'iplr• of it Inlil ' u Ill tlll• 1-nluuil', it' [I iulul Ilrn,•t ~ '+IIIII ' .

T lltlt I s 111\' ~'il'11',-, ► i1', „t lill' rl'i,IlUo ll ; Ut tlll , Il o llrl' to the (in\'1`l'11111,'llt 71111• r

it ~-~u\'l it l'slln'A)• it,; l'unti,l,•nlr . t ► tltl'r 16r•Inl„•r• of tll,• Ilnlt ;l+ takh

uncitlu'r t•ic\\' ut' that iuattl•r-tll, y do not tlliuk tlll'lll,l•Icl•,, c+rnllnittvrl-l'vl•u

tu thh prinl•iplo, ahll tll,'t• l•l'rt,linl~• III,(- wit to fil,, rll'tuik of the mrln'Iw' .

(llvar . ) Aft,'r the coalition %\-II, Ii,rnu'rl an üll•irl,'nt orl•nrrlrrl, \chil•h, ► ilulll ;h

not of uatilnull iwll„rt,uu•l' . it wunlîl be nlt"t nn9rutl•t'ul of tuo to t1n•ti,'t . 1n

I hl ► \1' n, ► llr ;irr t„ :~tr+lin torlus . it dol',; llillu',Ir to Il le tll,lt tiliy ilull mo llill

Page 5: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

Ki' 9A

ab .

,.r

,

11 t 4 •Cculnni ; ► 1 c"zrtu• w inn was 1 ► rnlm ,~ eil, an([ t%-.t . r► •mlrvvtl Irrsctit:nl ► lc throughthe pul ► liu spirit 411' two gi -nt1 ► •uu•n r ► • p r► wntinR our g r► •nt rhil %V n

, v

, (If' Nvl ► ich~-o tn .}nt' liard tliin g", ~ti ► t• ► • bi • v n 4ni d Ih ;tt I tit•) it tny d nl y to 114 ; 13 • thi~ t ;niultl ► iV- I roi•r tn thI, llon .11r . I'}atttttcn,uml :11r . ltttc TIGES . .(('lti•t• ► : .) Font .\ ;n ► oni b ► 4:•i ► I I' 1)1i :, Ilnu~ v , t v outy -fit'o tnemin•r s ul' thi+ ~ , tlucr Il o m sv ; ami f o rt}•1.' eutl ► •in ► •tn u1 the lino:.. iuul„nlit v r l l roh •••iuti Q I'r o tn l',tn ;til a , joinoll in tlu ► t.~ x ► •nr.iun . S n ► nrtnt' t'wn l uli,tn s hnil nr ► • ► •r ~i ► n .u 111110 1 nf' t he I . ► wcrProvinces I ► rli o r► •, rmil If►► , l~ u n p l ► • nt' III(, L owrr l'ri l t~in ► •e,: had n ► •ci•r r• ev n s uutnnt (' I ut,t ► linti s . % ( ►► n• rivv•1 ►tini{ Wa, lut• o uil all f Ic < c riliti om .kin d fin(]t•ru• l li I ► I . 'fh I • ri - itvrnl so •iiliui v tn I df nni f i ►► Nc,tx v v i•rt' w lu•ro • v I w i•r ed If I tl If ,► •t•liu, th ► m g h I :un .nrrv to tinil ihtit ntui• (i f' tIn 0 .:e l ►fiu ( .11 ( .1 . rr l l tlt ► •n, -w lu•nit «•, ► .Intt ,( }tenorul srntinn•tit, ~c .rn ► fit n c t t•t•rv ► litti•r o ► ttly f,nuw tltut it haqh rlho Ini, it rip •nt - tl p r(.,jw•t, and I li•nr tli ; ► t . tltrl• ( ln not iut ► •n d t o tut ► tl ► t o th( !trur ► l .a the y . Ih vn ttttt44 • ► 1 . 'fh ► ;t` uln y , rhnl~~;'rutrt ► il t o ► In 841 , bill tl wt' Itnt' ► su c ► •r%' odd, wut' uf' Poing uttu ►U it . ( L nn g hf u r.) 11'011, r+îr, this ;►' I t s inAnt;u s't ; tlio Charlottetown (' onfi •rnn ► • ► • w it s ► •,tll ► l in S i•pt i •t ►► lmr, the, l,►uc•1 ► w .(;(m1i•ronre ir ► ( ) ct I ► I i ► •r, and tlu• t ►ntr ut' tl ►r ntnrititiuv ► 1 ► •l egnt e y thr► mNh( .'mtntln t ►►+,k I o l,tc e in 1\ ov i•tit bo r . H'►►nr utunthr•üt' tlm i•itatt tvhi ► •h h, ►v ► +ulnl lsod S int•e we p r o uti s i•► l this Iluusc• to t 11-11 1 tvitl ► it have l ► rt - n ttltnus t

. tifi o llt' }riv ► •n ► tl ► 1 ►► this grrnt, ontrrl ►ri ..w. Lrt 1111, tsar niy h'ilal ► •, Mr~Sl~raxyat, n ► n~• tl ► ttt I rrti•r to thc► t•nnlhrt•nt•t•, tu the I; ► mtG•n ►f~ n fr i~n th~

" l,un•c~r l'rovittt•eN, tt•ho•t~nt H o n ► nn}• dn,rrt in c•oun ► •il with Its, tnrdi~r this i•tivf.(('lli•rrN .) A torr}' worthy citizen o t' M omtr eal, w hen I went nli it. o r twoittn ►lvtu ► r v of, the 1luntn•nl banque t, it ,"kcd me, with it eua•iutns sort ► f om-'pltnNie,-" 11'Itnt sort ► o f p► u ► p lr' are the Y f"-menninl; fit(, nim itin ►e ► lelehnten .I ttta swe rril hin ► tlj etu, its I rvo l m nt n ► ~w, ► nt they we r► •, is it b~ult', as able ► tndn ► •cumlilirsltc► 1 it boat* y n-i I- t} ►► nnew ► •rnmtrY i ►1 tltr• world t• ►► ul dp rodura,-nt► d that rc imp tu ► toul; thmn n•otild compare not unlitwornhly inubilily ► uiü intf ormnti ►► n N•it h nome ►►f the )entlinK ► utumunt r~ uf E ttjatuul, , A swnr fluv ► •rntn v nt in ► •Iui h •Q n,rv1 ► r~~, ruLa tiun 1 ►o th of the li ► rmi•r 111► 1►► wiliun' ontlth ► + tin•n ►►•r blini ,, t+•t•, H►► their de I el!nti ►ln>{ were ► • ►► htpose► t in nlu►ut e ► Ipnl 1 ►nrt,I ,t'tlw opposition ►uul n► ini s t ► •ri,il parties ► i f' th ► •ir>;rvi•rnl prov in-es . .1 moreli ; ► rd -t►' o rkittt; set ut' uum-itt P n nu ► ro Ii•nncint ► s of, th v ir u ►cn ri}rht,, t' ► ; t tnurt .v nn~i ► I ernt e firr, tlu► sn of o thers-tu ► •n ► i f' rta ► lier rr+ynnrces in tI ► • but e --nu•n nfy rntlt r'iututu ►"rx- ► nni ► ► nurv tvillin}; fo he ttr and fi ► rhr,u',_I nr ver vint h o lx• t o,i f + tuK ► •tiïO rttt o , rnnnv il h ► t,lr u}cnin . (l'hw•r :+ .) Ih ► t why uw• d I tlwoll ouithis lloilil ~ '1"ho~• tcrrn • ► •en tut ► I hr,u• 1 I in all mir Irrini•ilr, ► 1 ritivs , and j tut ►h ttre every ('nunQinn ►►•1 ► n ►net tltt'u ► haro ► t•u s 1 ► ruu ► t i i t'tltr•ui as tie ll i n► -xuhj e ► •t•,untl wunld l i e hnpl ►Y t o 11 •4•I thnt . lu t•u ► tltl Nvo n ► •nlt thrlu fi•IInH•-c•o nnh•S•r► trnill l'url nv well n ..'i in uuu ►r. Sir, l,t• tl► iN c ► nnliinatiun ►►f t ;r ► •nt. nhiliti ► w-11 vthi ~,i co ltliti ►► u fo f lou l l e r :+ who n ► • ver bulors nçl+•d t o y;atl ►vr-hy th k t•xtraor ► ll•n a rt' urn ► i s tit• ► + ut' p nr1

, %

• tcnrt ;rro, ► rhk ine d in every ~• o 1 ►mÿ ut tho i+nntemoment -,tlt v r ull this lal l ur itu ► I nll It ► i s holt s ac•ritie v-alter all li ► nncr im-imrlio► l,nty hn ► 1 hV ► •n Most fin•U ► L nt ► •I}' ►► reremne ,-the trent)• n•n i, r►mrl(ul ►• dand- hiltni•d by its n1l-,utd th i +ro it lies on Your tnbl ► • . The 1 ► rul►lkiti o n .,sr Onlnined ill it, have ht• v u ol .j ► •t•t ►vl file nnd we wrro mminllnil the iïtl ► c•revening by th ► + h ► m. n ► e ► nher fi ► r 1'lintcn ► t gnny, that Ave tire not a trcatc -u ►aking pn wor ; well . i ►r .p •li•ro n ►r to that ohjer'ti ► ,n, I l velit"tr tho Imperinl

r.

I

Page 6: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

p

' Gucerntnent ha,, i ► i ver lailt c :t~:,•,, ,nvh ,I : Iht, Rrt•iltrotritt-'I't'va t~•, i i~n~•~~i 1~•,Ito tht•w• pr~i~•int~~~s th(- rit,~ht t,t't•t, :u•til~n : :tntiiuthi•,tsi~tht•r~~ k th(- Iiulu :ri :tl,Ut•"liatch ut' to Lord 11t'Lult .~~'I' . Gnvernnr til' \ovn 14i•ntia . ili~liui•II)1ltthuriziuh lhc p tiII Ii(" ntvn tll' tliv i•oI"nîv + t„ ruut'rr h . ► .+i~•II i,tlter 4 pn tlivntthjt .vt of unitm, ,iIli tt•ritink tIu ;lif 1o kit lituit tltt• r+•,ttll ul' Ilwir c„A-r,•n(- .totliu Itulierial 'tluvo•rnnn-nt . (Iloar, It~,u• .) 11"v ,i< ;otuIplrt) nntlo•r,tnthmritytit'thut th•,ptttt•h, .,tnd ttc•tt•tl ttni1t•r tht• ; ,tlictiom it g,lt'r. I ;c~ t ;t lhitt! ; ttv dill

,wus, tlotut : ill litrlu muil tt'ith Int~lnit l~, atuil tilt, re ;nlt of 41111• Irr„wvwJin}r, i, tl l•tluvtntut•nt tÎutt hats' lwen "uhluitltvl to tlü• ItnW•n il 1~~ivi-rnniv :it t, . well :tà tuthirrlluuw•, and whirh We slirnk tlf hi'1•e as it trv,tt}' . \ titi tltnt tlii•rr 1„•

uu tlimht nhout our position lit rv{tartl to tlt :tl tlnottlrti•nt,wrr <n' v, l1!u•Ai„u it

yvotl ma}', rt'jPt•t it ytitl Jtul1•, (11* tU•tv+li1 it t'ont 11111Y . but ,tlter it \ n1t nriv tiot .'( Ilvar, hvtu•.) It is Itcyuntl pinr power, (if- lour puwt'r. t~, altvr it . l'lit r~ inot It, ru•ntenoe-hy'e, i~r et .)I it wurtl-}'ou (, :fit aller with„1tl rh•siritug t„Ihru«' wtt the thot•unnent . :Aller it, iuitl'%m kuu\%• at wucv' whal %•"u m,•-mi

you t)iwreby tlrwlnrc ytltrseIt'ei tuiti•nniomi :t . ( Ilottr. hwtr .) CÎtvlhi ,l reliunt ufïitr ttll luy hou . friv,l!tls Whlt fittvc lth•4,1141%' spukvit, tilr tmt• t,lalt e r it ttvrtt.y,.is, of con-se, to (11-,;truy it, I,t•1 Its he frs titk Vit Ii 1•,u•11 liItuy'tlu .}t-hn dt, not liktl mir «'trrk, nnr (Ili you likv uA'who a :rtitl Ili It, rltut~ln htclnnKtl, lint+ by II ►u~, and It~ttt~r by icltt~r ._ 1 ► I ► ' hnt flti~ t~l~•!uxhnt;ht to, rn~ithttH, and this utht~r ulnttr~ct t:htts. I ►ttrs tiny' .ht~u . Intmilu•r st~Fiott~iy' thiuk tlt :tnlty tretttt' in the wcirltl hottt•rtm tit•e mlltnrttti- prtn•inrrs over g:n•o fiill ;nt,F

vutirc+ stttir;tiucliun unoilrt' lrtl}int, to every luu'tv ' • Ihu~s ;tn.\• hum . Itivnihcr

Mrritt ► tyly exliet••t ttt have it romstittuioual net fr ;unetl to Ili,, orglt~r. tir nt%•urdnr, or twr r ►ualt'n urtler { No, I am Aure nt It-l;iaalor . ttt Iv,m sint•eJttvnc :tt,tilv ►a (,t,ul ► 'ri tas " .1ttOrnt~y'-(it•nornl of lht, htuu:ut t,c,•t•

exlu~t•tt,tl t+nt•h itlenl perlvMititt . (- tuot:hter.) It Ituty Iw .uiil I~t• rlinie Iiortgcutlenten that tluly uthuit the 1 ► ritucipIc nf thi, uuv:latrv t,t ÎI t - t ; o tul, bill ttuttit Nhtntitl be tlonlt with wt nn urdinttry 1 ►,u•linutrutnr, v EiIhje,•t iii tho ttyiiri l

c°~,purlituiueuttu•y wnnnor . Air . ;+t'F: .ttcrtt, this is utd tut o, •~lififnrY Itnrlüuttcutau ;t'ntcur+tlre . We tko nut .heRidntr, nlmn it, «o tltt not ~ .t nt . I il,---fV;tt k for ahi};ht-r nulhtlrity . ~`;ttltpusa the ,1doIrt•s~+,ttlttpted rit• 111 i Il~nt,:i .ttt .n!~n rt~n, i; •

t th e net, uf' thix, Iloilsu tinul +qtd cinlt ;lttsit'c ! \tt, t i .; lia' thl- Inilit•ri ;tll'nrliguumht to tu't ulutu it . (1{t•,ir, lhvar .) It t\ il) hou Of it hull}' thnl tx i1 1ontl4e tua t;et'ernl proluisilittns tlt he ►utlitltlrtl irttu it nti•,i , Itrv \01t01 will hm-4•ti o titrtn of liiH•, lUltl tllt'su-ri'sulttliu ► 14 will hrüln,hit hi~ llu~ i~r.ci .xiNirf Or,•l~~r

tI ~tho tnvitsnrc .thvt' will y ;it'uuv ,nid the otht•r Itrmin~~ .~ NO NOint• hom .getttlerncn ophor,,itv rrty, flint if' tht-re Ill, tleti-et-4 in Ih ;,~ tnt• :t,in-v iii..t~ t,nlrh!to be rrtnedietl utiw, and that thti'tim•ernnwut tnt{ Itt tt) lit- glati Iit hnt'i- tttrtu •

pnilttrtl (lut . - 1•c,:, sureIt•, it' thir Nvrv sintpl}• the nrt ~4' tlw Ilarliamvia lit'

l'ttundrt ; liut it is not ltt he our nrt ulomuv .' It IS :itt .`Ithlrv~s to tht•'l'Irrnnc,in

the tertnx (it' whit•h other colonies art, to ttqrrv :';uul t•cvn il' we ~vm In tn,tkt•

itilterntitruti in it, we t'nrtmit binti thvtn lu nt•rept tht•ut . II'tt•r «rre ttrak,tnd

wiuked, rntmqh till ttller• a Ntdeutn ;tl,~rt•vltit•nt tcilli tilt- othvr lrron'iut•v :, th,,moment lhvir relrrew-iltatit•ed hntl titrned thvit' LncI ;, utid gnitt• ho1uv, wht,t

Nurpusu w•utlid it rt•ren ext•ept that of tlvfivttiul; thv whnhe tntvtCnrè nuo1

throwing it as well as Ihc- country h,trk again iuto t•h,tos . `(Ilrnr, halr.) Iatlmit. eir, ntt u'e hn.\.r been told, that u'rtnnght to nim lit perfection ; 11111 Who -

Page 7: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

I

,,

„h1~ et•c,j att,l~te,j it, rxlrpt Prrhnl, : tl,r lion ., m o m4iVr fS,r ltro mr . ( Liught.e r.)~11'c•,~-ILrm, v ,ciid . I r it, and , ►iul ;if II„• Ih, t rk, In,l ~v I ~ Ihiuk w , - ulu,lr r

t~t„I« ruI11~• ~~,ùul.jl~,t . l'lli+ 11,~1 . uu•inl„•r 1„r t't„tut, i,nrlui}• t, ill nut I„ ~, ►fi -

to 111i - ri ;" Î lt," and an ,ulc•i,•ut (• , 14 ,•,I " I llc• lln . .il,l, I„• :I .° 11 1- 11, we I„•li,r~ -v wv

of tltc. tl't'tn, oui :1ra,li,ui . `Ir. ('nzy .tw, of New ~c,rk, who w•rot v it t't•r y

ti l ',I-ii, s liti,ll, ,tr, h, r!-11~,Ir~V %to Ilit" tlii (L,lil ght, r.) 11r h,ul .fricil,l i~ w, ll r, u,11~, ) ,ulit~, ;tl Ifl,vntrlr e-M ll he n„•nlinn n„ , nnc• allthï)ritV,td-ulu tito tir s t to . tlle I ;,<t, w ho 4-N hc•I l I Illat llull,iu gl u Ve nlrllc•tul , ;vv r N% lis ore ,mI,Î I„• :ul~~tl,itlg !11,16- Ill :ul IN-11 :0 *a lu„cl,•rn sage c,Ilc,l tilt al,l,ru x itul,tti„ u

ha~c I„ rl t~it, n t„ u,lr ,„Itulr~ nlc n„f I'tll th,• l,rntinc,• . tlu- 1,~,4 ;il,io I)1 .,t-tl,at tt•'• Iu,"• vit•c•n it IV th,•nt il l, uln .a iull„•r+ltit•,• nlnli,ol,t-th, ir rrt,rr-"-utntitv,; :uul ours have lulmrc•ll nt it, .l,•ttcr auil ~pirit, tirrln it1ul „th :t,ul,•v,

, Ilntil Ili( . .% tim n,l thi~ 1„i t : of :aRrl•/~ln,•ut, w•hi,•h wc~t, rc till ulitii• c•!,uticl,~tltwill not Ilutl•, IH,r tir IIIa11Y it llltt• In lvlll,t4, I„v ,vlnilC N• e l,t +Itttlt•. li v fi,lro I

11,1 .,k to AIN,lllor 1l,nlll, sir, 111'rdllil Ill,t to 11,1\' 111y 11'iI1111P UI' IIUIi•i g tU'tl lY• s lll-c l

tu uuu of' unr (.'arnslcliau c,,,ll v ,l};uor in this work, who is no longer with u .:- 1n„vtut th, .. In•c,eut Vive-l'h,tucellur id' I : I,ler Cul ► u,lu ( lion . lir. 31utt .t r) . ~~ Ilu

" took it cuilstnnt alld hom,rttl,la r+hnre it t11v l,rc•lutrlUi„n (,t' this In'c~jec•t,l:((:liw"ra .) Now, sir, I w•ikh lu say ït'ti•tç worll` in reti,reuce to what 1 c•, ► II tlleruviul rlrlutic,m w•llich I thilfh uitltllç to exist and ti•ill ,airinl; uli 1„ t.u•c•cil thepeople c,t'& Lower l'rm•itit•l- . ,ttltl'ulu:selt•o3 it'-tltcm• is it t'lu"c•r cnuuutntil't-tic,u entuhlip;lietl Lç,t;w•t•éu u+, and ttlsu .iu rcférullce to the ruc•iul fitut- .l't+~ lruc• h

. of po partiv,~ tc,'tttii proposed union . • .11i,t tir, ►r I will makr a:reul,u•k to ,S,`ulc~ of Ill(. Frcltch ('ttuacliinl gentlemen tt'h„ are said to he c,pl ;r, :c,,l to ,ntrproject, ut ► F1•euc'h t'uiln,lian Nruuudt t,uly . I will remint] the,,,, I h„pu notinlhruperlt•, tllitt vcert• oqe 411' the colonies we ]I„%%- prcl1,,,,:i, to l'e .twite uülleruuV rule-itl w'hit•II tl,lot• ;,hall have a l,,,tuutinl ruil•c-tt'i rc uul•i" Irol"rl,nuitcd, 115 New France . (t'threra.) New•tinutdiand, the ttttc'ruw,r,, .w•It . .tllrira, alld uuc large section of, il:~ toast is ,till knc,w•u as " thl. Fren,•h shl.,re'cGille I3retc,u u•n .,4 tht°irN, till tilt- filial (itll of fimi,sbllrgll ; l'riucu 1•:,lw•m•d .Isluud w•,t~ their lslïind of St . Jenu, aucl l'hnrlc,ttet~,tcn wrts their Port jol iin th( . hvnrt of' Nova '+t•c,ti,t was Ilnt fitir .1c•acli,ut Intl,l, tchrré the roll ut' •Lc,act•'t•,LLutt`,t 11011IV liiAttmrtera In,l;~~lult °ïl,l~ he hrur,l in ever}, w•,It•e thatI,renks upuu th(- I„t+i' of Cape I;luuleclcri,l . (('lle, .rs ., lu thv ntrrtheru uc~uutic~sof' \,~tcllruttsw•il•k, from the ltititluuth tc, th,r ,1lntapc'cliur, thl•~• had thc•irforts and t'arnls, tlueir c~hnml~c~s •nn,l thc+ir A iluvfi• cn' tiu, l ;nrlish speechhall- t•t•er once been henrcl bettti•crn tha .1° Sur is thnt. trunc•i,mR\,•I,Inn and 10r1-tc,u rare rxtinct in their old hatiut . au,l holnc . .~ I have

1 u arcl „ut• of' tilt, ulvml,ers li,r (,'al,(- Breton r•pe,tk in high l, rul~ uf that portionitf hi,, cutîstitncmtt•, and 1 leliti•vc- I aut correct itl rayillr tint air . I,)•;Vttic'c,Nrt:, tilt' Iatc• 1'iII :tllcv,Uillisler of Nova S,•„ti,t,_zt•n4, itl?he litt°rnl sr'nwv

reu,lnl,lv littll° hciak tll,° l,tllrr d,ly rtllc,tut Nova 6cutin, cle4ril,,,s thc•Preuc'hrr>i,l,•nts nl•, ►r tilt, L ;I,4ilt of \Iluu" 111141 lte xttYs, v~poc•iallY of, tlu+ ~tum n .

'" tll,•%; utiy ht have rt,•1,1„vl ùut „l' \,rrnl,ui,lt• it ltun,lri•,l yt• ;u•A ug„!" lu .\rw•Brunswick there is more titan ,m," t•c,lulty, cr•pec•ially in tltv•\crrth, tehorobn,iue5s, and l,tw•, ,ul,l pnlWic. ;, rrquirc it lul, ► w•Ic•dgr of l,,,th 1•'rrljch nuitE nglir;l ► . A Nc„rthe fril•ncl c11' ours, Ilnu . \Ir . Ut•t'cttt :LL, nf t'hutlutul, whowa: prhsent at the ,'+n•Gor nlaetiuks or the l'lnltlerouce, t1w•,'ll IIIH first Plrctiutt

w

Page 8: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

99"I ,

for one of tho~r c ►►nntjr'~:, lueonuse lit, w,ts l'icrrr J/i ►•h, 1, and cnu~oI shvak to his 1•'rW,'h cllustituont~ in finir ,Iwll l,in}:I1,1}Ce . I%%ill, xvith lc :l vo • o I' th'~ •

Mof.

Ilml,r•, rv :ul uti thi, ilit,•rrsting S 1 :11j c I•t n jll . : ;,ù,• .t'r, % nl a V1 'rY ► ,Illit,ll ,kl't~ h• A

,1f tlU' l'r,• m 'II district ,W Nvw lil•IIJI~N'11'k 111 H i ;t, ll1' I~'.I'llll•IlYllt•IiU1l'l' :?I `

(illltllll\ lit 1 , 111 ti .1LN~'ll~'V I Nl'Nf7ull Tu1IPl s I li I l• J~til ] .illI,l 1~ ~•\l'~','lllll~ ;il'

intvrr>ti11K tht'uu~h,ru t

ft

c ,

c . .~T!Ir Pn'nt•h plllllll ;ttinn, ahil'h to,rnl : li lolr-rl• ,t Ilrnllorti-m nnl„11_ the

iuluti,itnnl•+ of, the t'unutir• .• of Wr•atnrln•Ilu,ll . h~ ut, ,und til,l,ul"~ >tl r .'nlllll :ux

to lne ,l-A cuntentetl ua the I,oLihn,t's 4I1' \ il•turi ;l . 1 ►ut h:trdlv.I',pI,tIIl• tr~ t\rll

utl'. 'l'hl•ri , was 11n :tir of ►•otnt'urt ,tu,l'b o ,rr•r lrv ,Illutlt"thW Atr}:,• tilulu r t wo-

,t,lrivd huu~es, llntntvd ndirk Imlinn red, st :ttlrlinr anlnnv,tln• trw•;, thl,

nnuteruusqood lit . rs ►•s, the tt•eli-till ► 'd liolil, ;Intl "Ilv•k r'uttlt•~tt•hil•II k- wautil, ;:

on thu s;ou culvt . We ntul►lu•d ttl'trr .t ► Irll• :tsuut tlri>• ►•; tttlin•Ilint: tt<g;lud ~~i~•~r~

of the bt:ntitil'ul peak of l ;rvt•n Kivy'r Jlouutai ►► .at the hun~v of a J1'm~il•Irr

~ tlrt ttr, at thtt mouth (il' lir,utd River, whit'h was to fit- our A,lrtiilgo Iruitlt .

'Itltt- whnle aspect of the' farta was that of the 1tIçtuirit : in \orrltl,uul}•-th,'

4 ultor ,lrrtlra of the huuse' gaudily lutitttvtl-the pennl•1 . of, it tlillrr,'nt , ii uu 'r

Ir?Itu thr l'rutüt ;-the htrl ;r•, open, utU'urlrl :t ► ' ►1 ruuiu, with its luirr, r;liiniut!

11uur-the IuKsec+,tt the rl ► inltinlt•,whl•ël-th ► • Frun ► •h c,l .,ttnnr•,ulil ;Il,ln•ur,ulct.

of yudau ►o \'tw,hT aqtl her dunz and tlquhhters ; all cctrricd wv'lr.tc~ to thvrither ► ilr ul'the ltlultir4. . Altt r nshurt conversation xvill iwalked iluti•n to the bridge, whertr two lulc•t•nnuu, :, .r► luulne ►1 hy Fn•utaiulrn-thrcc Crtty and nTtun.%rutfac-a•ert• wnitinlt firt• u•, tiuïl lltt,hcd o1l'•t'roûït thnAh ► rrn . A tur+'t in the river t'vry >;pertlilt• hi ► 1 1'rvn'n us the, I ► ri,lgn niul Gtnn,

our t•lnpty carriage, and the l'rit•lid" wJln"'Ititzl urrrltirllunir•,I IN from Grand

Falls standing un the bank, in thl! irvt•ninu sun~'hinw, tt•ttO u g Its tllvit• titr+•-

H•ells, and it was not tt•ithuut hlra"rtr ► • thttt we li,lt that titi sali U' turn wllit•Ir •

,met:ut•d thnttt fromorur cirw, :aqpnrnttvl tt,,- for 51)111I time t t l c,lttu . l'ruur •`► •ivilixcd liG•; "

,

It a•ill~bc oLst•rced that Curt•nror Gt ► ttnna vpcnk~ of finir c,luntic :; in t l

north (o l' New ltrttan w irk which still bear n tnark etl F rvnrh ► •htu•ttct► 'r. 1~' II,

gentlemen ► i l' l'rcnch irri~!in, we pro llln. ►~ to ri-A lurr• fltl'~,• tun~~•lu,t t'nl ,ttt•irlt~tr ) your lrr~ltuct'run : in the 1'oQ,•rnl t't ► i,~n, which i~•111 rr ► ~rl niz~ lu,tllt• Ilo thI : ► n g tint, s , th, y will nntnrnlly look it4.p )and their rolnrru•nlot,icr m will nnturnll,} llr f~ltnul Itlir• i l ~citll lu . tinplln .r

tÎwa+ four New Itruqml•t c k ► ' ( iuntioa ttro inllu I ,nr,•tl by the F r e nr' 1 t o tr•,`A jll

two in "Nova Sc,Nin, and tme in \ewronuttlitnn d , p m w ill, rho uld von n~•,'rl

tlçrm, have tht• ► u n , •nrt• ,tllira to r ► üu•il w n compact htnlt', t o nul ,nn` 1,• g i .

tiluat e intlttl•rnr e in thl- h •d v ral l,',tncil= . ( l'h eu r .- .) I"h :rll prllt•r,•iI witlr

lily otttline nn+tl )• ' i . (if the nilu•timc p opultttinn, in o rd ,•r to (,tulthe ( •uu•

~ntity and c ► ~tl g vniul•i1y r of' our Irr► Ip,r<rd utlinn . In Ill,lr or ' tiutl', the n ► • \ t

~Iltl~~4 rh•nn•nt - in t1L :tt plll ► nlttti ► m is th e Iri .h "•ttlutnv1~t ut' l'i +rr ► Inn ►I, in

\r«ti ► nn ► Il,►ntl, nntlortnk ► •n by Lord I3 .tlrrnt ►► ttF: und Lord 1'Ata ;1, .tat ► ( I_rrrl t

l,ientclttqt of lrr'Inu (t at th e titnv), iu ► ln etliutt•ly n(t e r the ri ~- t,rr,t'um rit' liiul;

CilARl.ts§ I ., rOlln after IfiGO, ~N PN'ft T11n1II0n11 DtIII r e In,1111N tl'o II}!l y Iri s h, it,,

is nntttral, : int•r• it is thr~ next pnrinh t o Ir ► •I, ►nrl-(I :ulltht e r)--ru,ll I'ihiul: «r'~, -

.0

Page 9: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

•--an n t'ery vm-ellc•nt s Iie ► 'iutvu of it•+ Irklt ti ;itit• ► • :, at ► mr ('~~nti rt u~ ~ . in .1m-

to It ll ini•lndc.d in tltr new nrr,tnp•tnvut : . • ( II e ;u .) ltiutlil r mai n

at titi, uuwt tht+r ► : is nb►►ut ttvc•lve pi•r cvnt, of all iluntigr,int 1ivnl ► lr ; iit Nova

nit immigrant, of un .divi ► letl nlleuiluu~ct t ► r :Cnnttlh ► ttnil Nor int ► •n'sty ; NO i t

nlt ►► st•: (t'ric . 44 li,• ;u• : hvar . ) To Ille . I c(ltd`1• :4, it k tuu•tic•itl,irly g r,tt v -fltl II I ) .I •fIo4

,t t la t th I • una ll• Iri'h cl I I I I,Y , ;i~ it ni;iY Iu' •,• ;Ilti• ► I, II I' o ur t,~rim l ► , is

( •l 1 • 1 t 1 ot l t in-tti ► - Ia ► n•cr l'rowin ► •o 1m(hll ;ttiun k . t (It• lf S►~+ i t,•h . , I„trge Ir ;trt, (it•Prince I : d t% tri I , Ivul ;und c';iln• Itro•tcon' tcf•re g r;1ut vd aller th ('.,1'ruce ofl' ;tris . 141 litli ► •vrs tond ui 1 •It ilI' I It .~zt :nviali~ItLtn~l~ r.; ;uul 41014 .1, tii .40tti~h rv•~i-m ► nt~, tvlü ► h 11 n 11 ► listinguial ► •1I th vnl se Ivr .i 41111'in, tho• : e v v n v wu• s ' tv ;u' .•II•ni v hut1 . J'ric•nil I•rulu tll e n ► ;;û•1 ;►' (11r . I ) . .1, .11 t cun s .tt .n) hall h ; •rn ttitlt•it,;Ia,t `v1 ► tenilu•r at ( ;hiu•lnttrtmvn, h e ttulll ►1 hm- 1 . tlic•t 4•Itulvutvn, tvhniu lit .

cv~~ttltl h1t• ►s Iuv'n Ilrvoml to kltucv, stttd % vhu ► •uo llil ll,mn i•omvrr~wl with hint inhk uwu chw•khivl (inolic: I - .And I will t ► •II Ilüy ► ~i~h ;tt I tl~inl: i to tlif •ir Ilt ml it,, tll•tl the IIi} hlitn ► ll, rs inall thv (ir ► rvin ► •e . 1 ► ros► -rt•e t,ithl'itlly tilt, r ► •lil;inn, Its cv v 11 ü. thi• I,tn gn,t go - unAtrntlitii ► u,, (it' their t3tthvrs . The t' ;Uhoolic• itish► il ► ►► l' l'hnrlott ► •tootcn is it 11c-I .rrvttt: ; fti,à I{ight 114 -v . ltrv i ttit •r of' A richut (t'nloc Ilr►•tul,) i, it \Ic .Kls~ ►► ~ ctlnkiit thc~'li,t (iI' Qtu clc•rgy, I fTn ► I it run,+t+int riw rt ~~iun ul' ;+uc•tt nnnu•v 41iMI`I)l ► \A1,11, 11('lilLl .lB, lil11*611L\'Att1', M CI A.011 , 11t'Kh:\'Llh niai l' .\\II ;RO\-ttll " Anftlc ► .S ,t x ►► n s ," of' cuut,st . , 'tuld utirc•d up ct•ith thrln 1+'uwItvlRn-4 ,

vttW,At'N, I',\tilt'h7:s4i111 11 .\ItrIBLL,t, whostt+trit;inH,t c+usr to i1i>`cuver. (('hv► rs .)

,1tt•'i ► thwr'ut the original cl ► •meutK! ► l' that lu►pnhçtiun rotttainK to be ttutirt-tl-thti Ir 1 " . Iniynlist .,4, tvh ► t timn ► Ir.d New Ilrnnslvi ► 'h, just as riltroly tts'thvtfinulded t?pln+r Cnn,uln, Arr wh►►lir \oW ltrtul>+cr(A tc•u•ltlncle 11 sc•liortttr I ► ri .-vinctt Ili, 17111, as lihper l?+ttl#ln wax li ► r their l'rlntit•pH in'1791 . 'l'heir d ► -ei•u•

tlnnt ., still 11utlriyh fit thb Ginil, holding Intttty pmAtinuii (i1' hun►ar, n6 ► 1 +m it rey ► •reyunttltit'c+ tif the ç•lu4s; ISIntlt only mention Jtt ► lqo WIl,ailri','tvho the ► ltht•r

•cluy decluretl in chttrginl; one c ► t' his grand juriet<, that if it tvvrci ttcre>'~wtr}' to

ettrry .Cutl(cdcxttti ► itl in Now I3rttnsH1rk, a+o inll ► r64 ►srd was hu with the tlec•es•A

.i1j ► d' tlic itteilsztlrt! to thcxir)• exi ►+tmüee I& British lita-4itn11 British iuxtitu-

tiuns, h l- crtttt ttrc~lturud .tu c11tilt thu hrnch for lwlitit•4 : (l'hc c r+ :) Thcre are

cither c•lt+utetlt s ttls ►► uut . lit be ot'crh„oketl,• The thrittj' llc•rlntlus ul' Innll•n-herg, a•hcryc home :'t are the neutcyt upon the hthtl, its tltc•ir IG!vt is the ti};htestttl ► uti tlt~, rthli, tu,l1 utltel' t+nlttiltSr, Nllltllil'i :+iU114 ; I ► Itt I zahall nnt Ilro l ►utl; thisnnnlyri :+ . I niny uh,erce, htncvevcr,rthnt this ln,l ►nlutiun is ttf ► n, ► .t tnlivt•r.,tll~

it ttutir'e p ►►puluti ►►► t ut'thrt•e urti ►nr urmore qenewttinns . . In New ItrnuxtvicI:,

;:c•i1tin,, about ril.~ht ; in the two Islands, vi,rt• utn,•ll 1 ► • .v . . lit tlte r•y' o or th elaw we admit nu tlk l►nrity h e t,tveon natives nuit itnluig rnut3 lit thi s d' ►►üntrt' cbut it ità G ► be w ► yyi ► I e red that N•ht•m men are lu w n iu th( - lirv ► •tu•n „t' thv

;;rives ►► l' th v ir I;ItherK, For e t`en it Ii,tv };cuoruti ►► ns, tilt- inHurn ► 'o oi'thltt Iu•t:i s 1!rent in v rlhïtul'inl; their ttttui'hluc - nt . to that ,.oi t , l nd ltlit, 6 ►1• tnt' part, tt Y

tvmlltl lit) untruo and paltry to ► Icn ;{' it tlit•itlvtl tttli•rtüm ho•tcvi• ►•It th( - o I d "

country and the new. Kt•pt within just hc ►nnds, such nit ulll• ► timi is rrn-' ,4 c ► nnl ► l v , i-i rifçht nncl creditnhlr to thuat+ %cht ► ehi•riKh it . (Ilrur, h ► vu• .) Why•I reli!r lu this bron ► 1 Gtet, ~ehich ili>;titigttshn~ thc .+ popttlttti► ~n ► s of all the tiitlrscnm•ur'd pmvincen ua mlic•h as it dc ► erti Litn•er Canada heryell', is, t ►► 'r:huw the •lixity aucl ritltllility of that Imputation ; to show thst they ,trc+•1 ► r birth Ilritisth'

Page 10: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

U

.

y

A s lit•rit• :u1= ; that tluy t•uu tll ;ir1y all, ut evl'ry origiu, rnse Ill ;lt tlronlll 111r,rr

11•Lt'u tlu t• look Iluily tivlu tlll•ir Il~~ur,+, • this i' : niç• ull n, lul'11 :11i1't• I,lut l

~~'11~•l' .lllirll -••(IIV't•l'd .)• lut but that lllllll1l71t1o11 mlll'ullr~ t'~~Illt• tuprt111'l' for i t

411' Î ~ tl are tl~g' i'll'llli I11~ that t•0111111"+1•, Iloh tt}l' l'11IIIIIIllIL, lllal rlll-

rulllltl il -1111M41' 11111111t1l llr•t~'lli1 :1111~~)\Ill 111'Ul' \1'llll 11'i~l ~ü l','\clivIl'lli o

lli .•turl• ol'tlll'•l' llrl'-l'nt triul :actiuu : lm' writti•n ; that 111i ; I1Ln1 III.' lulinn 4'n11111

r1'er II ;ICe lw4•11 ~w1'1m111' t`plulrl•il by rlati•~Illi•11 111 14• ;Ill :lila, 411' IIr•1'o•

llr~'r• .) I :uil t lll, It l\I~ \rv . III• 41111• 401• 1\%u ► flrinlti .r . Ill' Illi- It4011-1•, ;11 .41. , .I~' 1~1 Ili i`. ~'I\'-luilult'll (',In ;nti ;ln4 40111 1-t' it, tllu! tlla'%• c,nlmtl 1•IIlt•1,t1titl lm-

1n111'I11111' ti'1'1llltf tf1 :IH11 jlll~! IIIIli111 \011 \r1`. 1 ;1'IIIIy\11rk trl' \I i1' .1 ?`Pl iIlst• flllll ••

I I 1 , 1 1 t l l l ' ç ' • I : r n l l 0 i II m{I; w itll lu* v iult•rt•A at t111., -utulI I ni`;<, \lilll llllirll lct•

IlUunit 111111~•l'In ~tl W1111' 7tZ>IwIqll4ill ., •" ~~tllill.~ Ilt•l'!Iltll In Itlt', n : ' j

Ilt•1-1111,1 '.'' i1•1•tl, l a1 ► ~~1r1't ., tfint . I,nl4 tllrln . will Ill}' 11•urlt likr it, .%1111 11111

1i41' t111•Itl . I Ilit le II1't•tf .4111 i It•u Ill' oi}tht jtI ►u•nf'yi thl'rr' . tlhll lllcl l~ I', •• .

Innl•II ol'tlil' I1t,4111ll', lulll fl ► l' luln~l' 1 Ilucli Si rU ul't111'nl, t111' ului'1' I rlt '114•04•Il

üut b•St1'1'411 ell IIIvIU (lltvu•. hlar .) . I rul_t•, thl'll, to Illl'<I• It'lut'll, Ill,ll ii'

% .4 111 ItiCllt l-t li•1•1 111~y pUtriuli .ut .un tI1N 61111j1'l't ; it' % I1II N•utJttn tir ull ,I

l1tl1,1111uU rvIltilllellt oI' ,lfl'Pi'tÎoil I11'11v1 rtl .tlll ~1 III'ulllr 111111 ulu5N1~1 5, I,riu}1 11 .mi

Ii Illlu I I~~=1•r l',I•IIIj1l111 1111!I'llli^l', allll IHlllllg the l•II'tlll•111-t of it 1Illol'llllti

n :ltil+linlit}• M1111uS,l' ;II-I111•ill fiI111mtlu+Îaliu}r-ttllï61 :um1 rt-I11'rt hi lhl'illlur ;luilfnu) 1•outillrlil•r tuill rt ,au'l'L 11'iil lilllml•, uull it l'v l'lil li}c III' living, I~ilytu g t'll iu11 41411111111111 t• :Illrl• Ior III l • }f l `rn ► ut' a 1•uJtlulull tlAtiull,llil* y 'Il ill gr11N• fit, III' it~si'Ifu itlll,lU II~'iur Iorl•l' :l 11% ,mr ru ;ul'~ •Irl l ihl lulr'~IC,II'r . ( tienr, hrlu•.) l'I) v -t Iliu g who All) : uli ~11+ lu•i► rt ,It.~tlilia lli~c, kiiulrl'il, hi : uoilsllllur~, iulll luis-t~•lll,ll• . :`ulljt'It=, ul+l/t• l'I+a. V I l'ry Ilrl'tty fi'Ilnll- tlt It,p :lrl•h ~Il~tl;t, bill do yo11i• ;lil Ifll•h It liu•kull-r:uli,41 u. thlli . if inlut .4 (I,nuyrhtcr .) "I ►nlv'sil :lllusl+. th o

C nlllllost >t•oi°II in tlu' I,ulyaul ge , (lluur, luwr,j '+ir, tlll'r is one uther ult•gl-tlll-. llt tin• tlli . nni1111 . or r,lthl't• lill illustration (,il' its auutuully I1çlIl-uutlrp-uu ,I hlu'nt'ti'r, whil•h I draw Î'rotu the phy'Nilul hl•Irymfphy and rlhydtal rl',otu•cw ;ï'ilI' thl'wholt• 11'rritlrry 11•Ilil'h it'is Ilrlljn,ell tu unitu ; Ilut hçtïirll I dputt t1wultt•Iaiiiil 111' tilr Ltlu~r tlI it, I ut ;iY pet•tinlitiorli`r lit u•l~lllu•1 ;11 tl ► itl j~rill ►itbl}'11•ill Ili' Illulll' 11lflllll1t lirr, Illnt I uul tnllkilll( N°ltllt null' Ulllloür to lue it liult-

tluliti 11'l'1•h. II' it Ilr. ninl-llulitit'a,ll in the i~tmw of unn•IIIirLiznn, then I1-,ut krtilty•lll thl 1 Il :uytrv ; but t lhink that titi Soute ul'~ thl ! puiilt s tu wIlil'h

I 11711171111IIlN11 l Ill . t't1111111•1• iri 111'nifullA 111' IlNilll ; ilLiiir1111'll, flillltlli II~IUry- llllll .

grutlt'llit•n h :ll't, nuit 114141 time Its nlA~i` it tllltr (if the 1•ouilU•y to Ihl : l`ust*uf us ,tllu ;t' 11'lln Il ;fl•r Illlil tilt, Ill,llurtnnit, I . of IluinH rl, l'ut ► llnt, I think, hl'ttl+re;ulr- •, t'rCl' I{Ir' inll•rt' .t 1 1 1' 1111, 1•Inlulllulit j• tll ;ln by g ie•ill}; R 6 : ► t,upill'lflk'h~'thl ul I t

l'Air, jll,t and trut hlili ;:k1't0h I It'tho ;l' llrllt•iug'o, und Iloir lleulrll', and tlllls ill-

tirrlning till,,;l' iii l',Inu11u tl•hil lulil•i' not had Ru' Itllliurtuuity of Illilkitll ;'ullNrrt'u-t itlll"i 161. tlll lu ;t'It'1 .r Iiu the rpul, ( I11'ur. . hu,u•.) l t çl'u-l rl,iuurkot] by Ihwl;ltl' Sit- Jllllx Itf;l taft,l ~ Itulltwal~, in Ili ..4 I/sttcr to, Lord Jtitfv ltrssr;r,t, iùI-131,11, '111,1t il, 1111 . Itl•iti'h ( ;uccrnllu'tll I1u11,tttl'ulptt'll tll iullillluitl thc all'ien't

Ilnlulll :uil' ., i~l' \1•\l' l'nu1~r, ill'Ihl+ tiavlty 11•hil•II iu'knull•lclll ;tvl thl' 1'1lit'l lit 11• 4 rlllll IW1'l' Itt'Pn'illllülvr+illll'tu 1111 Mli. 'I'III•II lllt l llullu•il', 1` x ll'lll j t

o ç► Ilio on tlll• Sulllll, lulll inllutll`tl'nlnc•h 111' 11hut iv now 1•,llltll Ilylutlr tlhiell-Ilulll's " illl' \ol'tl1-11'l'llPrl• 1,., wrrvlt lilrt•l•, I lllÎtli ;, in llli .4 uII ;IPI'1•+Iti1H1 .

But, ill rrlatituw to 11••hllt 1 tllny l'ull the pruuu/hpluu on 1,,•hicllti we propose t o

• ~s •

. ;,

Page 11: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

I

- . - • ' , ,

liait oty I . ;Ikr Si+ln'ri++r thr r,utut' trait ulat• cn,tst uuiutl•rrtllit v lll}', nl~~,It 4

+1111' l'+Ilt`Iltlltl++llrtl I'llllil•l', it q II+It111•+II U111'lll•tii Id IlltllItt•lltlll, to CVlltl`111-

I,Itt!l•, .•I'lll•lc k not "Ill! I,n ►•t llk-hlu•t ►uw• Ott' :Ill.tht, prl,t'iuct'~s iww 1► rl+Nu .yiuKit, i +,nti +Il ratl . w Ilicll t nullut lu r+'lil lu tl l'tl 1ul lt utlu r by illl .t't'a~' c'ly, il' tt„tu1 Il++, I[l'+Vlt +1!' 1 lllg llt, 1\ Itllt,llt l•v+•1• U111'l' Il•at\ ;111 g our Ir1t-11 1l'lltl•l'N : F rllltl ttl+•

t\ lillt!1 ~i111t 111 ++111' uN•tl rllul't1•, Il+'ttl•11' lllt' lliA üLt•t' (+t, it 1•'+1• age to I:It g l ;tlltf-- •

t,uïtlllt liilll,tiuli' it, nlnke, it juiu•ttt'y .tllruugh MA utt•u cuutltrt, will ulil ►• g +,

lit tln' litlrurt• III- Nyitl liull tin pxci:llwut sull .titute' for snob it vi+rn)rl+ in

1{t,trlt ,IunXtiTurN'~i l'hy.icrtfr .111un, a tuulk that u•Iloru nuc,irj ►ctlv ita Il',tt'l'1+ ,c ;ïtr tltittl'ltl~+~lüs,llr,lil ► nltott+ \%.•itb 11 1tl htulk. (l,ltulthttr .) He will finit tha t

S t . I,û1t•rr11i•tt t1J',lüih trt ► ► u•+', ► l ►f'1:1+I,01111 square tuilt-+, nt' NPhicb c ► uly V1,11111) 11-1

I . S t . .t++lllt,• \+•U'l o llll ( llnlt+t . W I+I'l - r+ .) W +' N11111et1111PV t't,11111lIN11 of ultl' ill .

rl ;,n+l n ;l~ i t,lli++ll . li1 :11 %t 4 ' iul v t' it 1•n•!• huit Illllf• the year round, but N% ltt i t

~ Itu {, :. ,at ++cil l+1-+m It ;uul,ly t ulnttl'n ntt ~ Ittjt A v,tàt t•af+nl•it Y . (Cllevl' .4 .

l .u :•t >lulul ;l'r. td u ,t )tv• vi s itl'll Iltllit'uz in tiu•.. Q rtrcil l'irho irrc, w llit'h .tha

S' .+U+Î lu 1+1+IP of Illlll lrll'II,1•it' rllllltillEi `'tl'1 ► 14}'1111i11 11115t1+llÎi 11+r 11 ( ;Iqltl'lll•1•rtlt'•

l rui~+ r . W r wl•rl' 11141 In-1 tt•r 1►nrt or a wrrh tt'uluiuF ntvny, nlw,lipr itl ürit imh

,11u1'rilvul ti nt~ r+, tti itllill sikllt of .thl' Il,lltl I tull llrautiful cir+t,ta, )vlricli it w,i -~

l+'tt Irricil+'t,,' to outil t► ur tttt•n : (('In•era .) White we A•eru thurt litlluwiup

t+ttr . river ~kstonl to tltc' lllli'u +t'u. Ipuitltt not Îlcll ► trtlclt rci•Itrrülu tll the v ;t~t

+xt~'ut l :'f III(. tsltllll' . Jt' any lun . gentleman tciu/ has c•ecr ttllutc, and bi t

u+'rill ►irtl by the lit 'l' tn'ct ► t•Inkc'a tl liken tltKptltrr . I S t1+111 not i;•ttOlul ► t tu trend

in tltr. ll,tth III' iny two li•ientltiI who mit ric'xt to tlu'. (1ltltt . 3ieN,+ra . (i .t(,r ntltl

Ilttl ► \rN') I ly 1'xl► 111itutg III ltlly ; dlt(nil tllt lrru:+pct'tv uI' rnlttu,tl rinniuereinlttlvluttuKc'i upt±uetl pli It} this uuiun : J• ltm I . 1 ►rt'I►nrttll a ritlttl~t4c'nt uu t lri ~,

,.ultjr~'l, Eit iitg c l!rtniu g1'ncrul myutm,•--tt hjch t Ilu . nnl prcs6ut as c'uiulrlc' tot .lrllt lNtI1• 11-4 ~rcrxihultlty rom-4-1,-and •wllicll• I now, .bck to reutf'ti ► the

71i► tticl•: (Ilcre ll Q ►'c•tid some Ftntiritietl . a

Wtt tllorn is one Rpuc•htl source of wenlth to 1 ►t., fcrosid in thc, Utlritilne

l'rlr~iui,-lrs, tvhic•h'wl ► n not in any detttil èxltillitrd I ►r nly lu111 .4i•itnl,l,--1

ultndo to thl' itllpi ► tttutt nrtit'Ie•llf'• cuttl . I thiuk 'tltltre can lu- nl, tlt~nitt •

that, in >'<llüu+ 1 ►nrt :+ lit' Cnnnd,i, we are Ih,t ptietihlR out of tlte tira of H•uull its

fiu'1. ,tnlf 1•utt'rilt}t uu th,► t of cl ► nl : [n tnt• uwu tsity every yrnr,'tlu'i•l' kstrr:it

sItiG'riuu nluunK the poor from tlli' cttl!ruwus ln'icv or 1'ttcl, luld largo --mm, ni•, ; -

tutu tt•hlrlr of 'thiy vnst rt•l;iun, lulll lias linlnll thc urwt l-lrtv'mll 11 y tl1,U cnll )

Ilnill ct~tu~ hY national ~ueit'til'a ittld bcurvulcut ihclivitlllolr, to lrrt'i•cni aiwll'

linnilil'4 1► t'ri,llinh li,l' a•,wt of filet . I- hclitlt'u we lun :t nll l nul'lutln tt ith si r

fY:1 .%t LtlclAN thnt t>'t, llncr ttu c'uul in l'tuhtdlt, uull I Iua1' vt ntlnn tu antl'++JI iu~- llt~~n 1ltltllurit}•, nilothPr lill'tLthut ~~•tl hnvl+-=a ti~~l' lnllltth~ ~eintl'r,

rl'lll'r11I~1' Ct'1•1'. l'ltlll . \(#%v -%vknt tire tht+ c'ual rt!4uurrt•+ l+l' l+ur nl,tritiull'

ti il nd,,, tu wIwse luinl' ,~, C`'unli~dt'rlttiuil wt ►ulll givc lis i'rlcc I► tltl tintltxrtl ulrl'•+

titri•vt'r! I t,tk ► • tlu'•1' dltt,t front the luttlluritt' in III} h,uul -liunl tlu' Ilighl"t

nutllltritv un the xut ►jrv1 I.tIR'a ('uctl l''il'l/l.> of 1/or J'tvr II'rr ► •Ill :-

" I11' . :% . (iN.VNl -A r, llt il !'Vllllllllllil'7ltilttl tll the (tlllll}!Il'lll titll'11•t1' gel' 1,1111(lC,11,

I 114 I 3 . ~tutl's tllut the Itrt•rt (il' osai Ii v lllx ili New liruu sw ic'I< Itu s .lrl l'n n l'l ntl~

llt'll•r111itlçtl tu Itl~ i,al ► t) .4 ttllrl' ❑ tilc s : Iu,Ulil) ,z ,lllurl' lilill~r~, inrlnlliu}! N t+ v ; ►

S r++ti,l, Iltlt osi lu :ivt' nt' ('nlle Itrell,u . s iu c l' hitz tire}t rrl ►++rt ltc lias rst► It,rt•tl

lilrluutiulr lit Itc no IuI?z thun H,000 squire tnik's in New llruttytvil•k . Il o . snva

Page 12: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

,

103

the In~r,t prtuluctit'i colt I,l•,l Itrrvltil in the iutt•1•it,r , while lhose of Nova

be •dunv , b ut not one m+lu or niu, Shillint,~_nl,trr thnn t'ntuul,t, pro r,tlf t, W ill, .

that Ille ~ültu ► who ti ►,~hta ti l r ' thl' t•nllt ~' uutl luu•Itl~ttr of ;~t . John, l,r t•t~l'u Ii,r ~

by ;t ulturh t'r,em it t•nnt•t'nit•nt rrntlt aron„tn I,nii t• ('hurrlllltti l l, t hrtnl}th L,ttt•r r

Svutin ut•t•ur un the tel' lier In ►ry ttnll tt'ht'rt' tlle%•ulii•r t•t•l'r}, ait .t•tultntn• t,r luiniug ultl`r,lti„I1~ . 'l'Ite i•,ull liel,l1 „t' tilt- two prut•iucvr art'nl ► itl'tl nt the Luuu t+rt• hu,' .,tultl lltrlun}in~g t„ tLlr tvul„millrt ü~ perit,d . 'l'llo

,.~ ;,li't•t•litl,n~,'ut~+',t~l ynskt i't`,•rt .:,•tl"m illn>trnt,• lur,• i•It• :Ith}• Ille il uq %nitn, b •

. . r cet' tlu•:Zt't•t'+tl tirl,l-:lei tl•hilh,•ztrutll'ruu ► \r~ll„nntll,lu,l Ill (' :Illr Itl•,'t,tll, l't•irlr,•

I~I,ulll, \ot•,t til•trtin, niai Iit•ru,s Il i ;tri,• portion fil' XN~e Itritn .n'i,• k

iltt .e tlll' :^tltll! 1,l' ~ttlillt' . ,II'. III{Vlt'llllll, il 1l'nl~t~'i~t tel' hlat tlllltlillg, 4' 1,•

~ rt - rtt• ,z llrlt lit(- Itt Illit~' and 0-\t,-ut tel* tht'>,• r Mil-lt'ru~'t ffi. il i-: i Ili lit '4 .iltl,• tu

tlt' :c riltl ' . In \ttl'n ti,•tqi,i, tir . I~hy~l :rt~ ~tallrntellt ,; t•elliltit un j u•, - :t l rt', - tjti •T,rrnlntinq ut' 2,500 >,tlltttrtt Inilt~~, n'ltilr' 1f,rs~rv I ., Ir X l.l .ttt•tiliv ~mtl Itut ) tt• v

+• ~gr,•:Itlt t~xt, lvl l't•N'n thttt Ili-va . Sir W . Loti ► s ill•nuurstrxttctl Irs• ,t l,thtrriuu .:yur1•l+y the +lli ►'kue•s or tlï•pth ,eI' the tch,lll' gruitit in \„i•thorii \tit'rt ;;tuti : ►lo be nt•l'r' :J tniln,:, tlli unluhnt- tt•Irit'h for c•et•t'oll l iltl{~thing st•lul'ila tue t•rn ► lformation in ltthe'r'ltrt+ of \trrl)t .1nlt'rirn : ilt tl,i~,, }rrt.lttp thl'rt' an- w% I •rnty- .

six c•uul ht'tl+t t►ue ulttlri the uther." ~ •~I must sit}', sir, that this i+'u alu't'riuq st+ttruu•rtt nI f+1Ctr, Clllllitl~,r t(i It's tell

tlu, t't'q Iti}tiu'st ,ttuhurity, tuitl I(i-,') tt•nrlning tt ith the Null,j,'rt, t't'11 ~lfiilt~

nutkinl; ttla~ ±t,itt'~ui'ItG. (IGTt~+y~► tt'r .) 'J'hr<i' i'~U,tn~tit'cllu~dioltk, will, un-

d,•r thiK Plnn-tt•hich is in liu'I~,ntr Pecihruttit„t` 'Crt',dt~ tt•ith the, I .Iltrc'r 'l'r„-

F11N•l'K•-=11nP11111P . ht'l''7lltt'r, tili~ }Lr1'Ht l't'~t,11Ç1 c'ul'tllll' (tllt`Il~ fut' tllt'1 : I " i'tl the

rr.%• is ruiKetl Loltttt• by the tnlli•liui tl ►ïa~ that to ilrtlet+l'Q Ath l'ta,ti'llr'nttitm

Wonitl Iro t.t ► etltrtil tilt! 101w ul: the Now laita,tWl Inttrkt't for their (4lulm . 1 du

n1,1 quitt,~ rco htttt• they ttiukt• that lltlt . Imt l .1ci•n nrl nnti•luü~iniht-.ntiltllC Kot' .

t)utt ilte pltliultNilm if l'nu ;itltt k tt•ithin tt l'r,u'tilm of that ul' 4►11 \(,w l'Jtilt•lunti ilut tokl'tla~r, .thttt .tt•i' ~•,iunltt iu tlliy t•u1tuU•.v it~.; luneh.-l'usJlp-r atltttuu11 .4 1.11t .}' tlt ► in '111 .1 New l;ll}~Itutll ; Ittlti, thi,ri'litrt~, that tt•i~`irtrt~r`1 ► t'ul,q Illrtrkr't

untlor the tu ►Gül'cquul to tltttt a'hit'p tlit'Kc then ►•ixt'rrwtiut ttl•pt',riwltll' t1aVir

fülltttcert+ tht't• trultlti Illrn. '(Ilt'tu, hi-an) Sir,uetttl►er, cq ritieetl I1. % • ttut

~ I►uti•twionia0 IlrI t-tr i-, t1111t tht',t• trnultl•Illtcr in livht firr III' (l('l11t4 't' 411' ('ünn-llÉt---û rerf spt'Citlltq nrguuu'n ; . `Whttf, ril., lhren+ luil itm+u and out+ ► nilli,murlitl', tutu the one Inillütuulu•t tlt~ tllr,tiulltinK torr all . proportion to tlu•irnluuhcl's 110 dttullt Ihl• .•r V+tliuut p•ntlt'lut'n tt'ill tim•e to ii}tht, if* tightilli ., is t,'o

t11r}• htn•l, to ligllt or sllentL Oit Iht' t•„Iltr,tQ', tilt' Krt'atttr t•ulumt>alit3%, it'Shl,shvtultl not fiulllm ty ht, iirst att :trkvtl, tt•nultlAt' tlllli}cl•.tl, to light tiot• tlu•In,rultl in tl„inyr Hn 1 fh~(rttt. ht• .it+ttl• to atl' . 4111 fur itrtter uuthority than ll ► r ,tlcll,

Il,tlitit . li'`Ilt,& for ('nnrulu . I will suppose ,ulttthwr not iulpulihlr c ;tsl' .I will suppose It lu,;lilt• :11nt ►rit•,ut nrln}•, on it li~ilt~ry or tell any ulllt•r wnr ,

1i11tlillr it P,lyif•r Illltl l'iÎl•üIN'r In st•iZ,' 1111+ in\1','r t•ulolli1+3 ltt' lttllll,lllall lW st-1k ,

('uutulu, into the Ulltmr part, III' \rtl Itrnnsttick,,uul :ar,lnantrnrtl Its tlu',+tvt-ri, umrt'll likc. tiltHatar .tN's Imu•,•II l'rt l lu Knoxville to fi,t v nnn+th . 11'hil,' at'

t,ll .trut't,vl -lu•h it Inur,•h by t't•t'r ;• lut• ;u),+ in our li,lllv'r, t'run ► tht'•Itit•Ilt•lit'u In

Iiit•iere (lit l,tull . trho•o Ir•tttlt', w t,nltl we lie li ►±htiu}c tht'n .' t1"ht• th,- •~r :t-• purtv ttitnt'tl ut,' titr ttur wlmmuou ,: ultitt,lrtilm .' ( llvnr, ht'ur .) Iiut thl' trutlt

; is, ull thcsc' st•liinc views and ttrruug,•altvut .' ;trc reuiarkuilly rhurt-sihlUt•tl, ttu-r

Page 13: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

II : tt. l,rtlty' l+t• lt le * >Il Ili t'l• le +ulll tnttt•+ A rt11 y uCl•u uf tln+;a ttlw tt il1 thcut . Iu u

" l l,tlnul'rt inl, in u militai- y , in o v l•1;y point (AI' ril'w , w u are ull, riKhtl}• t•lmKid-

~ l rt'tl, ll'ill•ulluut Agit wl,•II I,tlu•r . \l+tt li,untlluull llll ►uinntu ► tllu À lult•, niai uuult

'' o f u3 l•un Ill] i,r il fil til• rl•I„Irulrll t'ruur hor . l,llrll l'I ► n•r ► I A M nufill Ite w1luld ; ► ,,,+Ilt llnlull b, n l'ly ► uuutll ;t ., \I ,' tt li+tnltlllultl, and lie iti suitl tu hlt~ l' unticr~tuull

Ilntt• Ill r :,t'~•u lul•n. \u v u ;tvitilr ,ttul \l•tt• ltrun ~z tt•il ,k are ;ii,wu'r•l' ttt•in,<,

h,'Ill ttl ►c i •thl't• h.%- finit liu+lllnn ' Id llulll Ill'1~~', lyt 1filie Verte nui t

•It,l s in, lulll fil(- tiltl+ ut' tlu' unt' lun~t . ti,ll,l~~ thr ti ► lt+ (el, Ille nthl'r . ( IIe1u•,

hl•cu•.) Ih•inl•l Lll~~nrll •l• l~ill}• ;trlittle Ilit, Ilri ,kl•tu (bit, Ly tilt, ,\urthtmtllcrlluul

s lr,lit lruln thli;o ttt, l, I,i ; ~l r 1+1•l'Ihrl'n, luret l'lllwr ' nutt Lll w ur ( hnullu tur

; l•., l I,t il l t++ oul h ut lu'r's I,r+,SI u•rity. ( ►nr't l•ry l,lly'tiit•n) llutliilc tuut•hry lis . thu •I~• .>:un .ul' ulliutl, nuit indilvttl•r how nuuly nnNuul nt1 vuntn};l'n %w' ►n,ty' ull (If' .

1i~1 I'rl~lu tilt . !rl•nty Nv 1' I1,1 vl' n,•1111 . 11r. S ► 'N: .%)cNat, whill' we it, ('Itnullu have

ml li,~lil,t III, tilt-, rntiti,•1ltiun III • tllc Intl•rl•ul,nlilv 'I'rl'uty, Il ), lhk Ilullxl+unt l

.,•l,untrv , I l•,t -mot l•un,•l•+11 Iruut luy "l'II' that our l'ril'nIIK in thl,• Lu wl'r l'rllvin-~ l•, al.t• li~!Illilll! 7l 1111It11 I~it1l Illll. r+ ,m• v il~t,tunll vl'Ntl•ll illtPrP,td Nllich lur e

„It~ ut ~ luu .st 1,itl+•r in Illl, •;Inltllt'A lv,ntnlunit il• .,+. 'l'Ilorl+ Ill .(, t•Ilustinh trnlll'

itltl•rl•,t,~ ,lilll rittt•,ly iutvrv~l .y ut wl+t'k ; and tlu•rl' tlu+ ;ct1'unl; itltl'rost., l,l•

I„llll t ir[llilr,ltit•t' tlntl lli'lU'fll•"t ill};l'llttity . 11111Rt tut 111rM+ Illllt ► III(, ltll, N•hl ,

ur ♦r Ilu ! .J ► u thl'y , tw«~l,'I,uu'y they lvnl g l't u(iu~l rnaut'nt uttull+ tu tlu•ir

uh ll I+ricutl urllt'l' ! 1 ►u tlil\' (1}iuk Illl•y Ivan go (lit u11 illl I lllll +y ,it'lll 1 Ilu lhl'y

I111lut 1 1 1 g i % l' Ille Ill' lvluillry tu tlll' .\nll'ril,ulK ! 11'lly iU,t lllllll{ Ille al uuct, •- :

Ihr :i}cn, ', llll hl• I,rut il 1u u~1 l',ir \~'-11•r ► Il, lit -<II !-' }!rl l'ulr,u kK' lul .l•n lit

t'llll t'lllnl• "" I rl luil l Ill m- 1' tlll' Itnlil li,+l+ ++l• il (j Al ;'itilnt+ l't'll1'int t+v me rl+•

~ul~l ll, >l, lli}tlt rrjliril v tl mitai m l Illlill'II- IIII tII11tIrL Ilu'ir v il•lury` w ill uul Ill+°

lt,lu tt•illl,+ltl wl,rk, vil I l'é l'I u :.,lu~ 11 il ~t11~111' il 1•ictury . II' tlll~ lluno s t. luu l

111i .,vill,•11 tt•,+ulll I 1 IIt fl'lll'l•1 II )v it ulurlu'nt Ili riAp; t Ill'y rtm Ily lll•li'uling, u r

: . l\ru ,Il'luy ûlg this uNVt-jnrP,I run ;urc l'lll'y ~~•1, ll, l'cl•!1 yl•t,rl'trUl•t . (Illvtl'q

hlvu .) II• %t'l . rl'jl'l•t •it now, is 1111'rl ;uly lutluu IIrul,nLili(y Ihut . we nhull

+~t~,•r vr ,Ignin "I) Ilrl+lliliuu ; it set III' l•irl•uulwtulil•l•~• I+l IlrinK ulluttl , the I+u ► uu

n• .:1j11-; ! I ll,w thoy l•ntnt' nllulit w l+ all kltow . (11~ -u•, Ill•ur .) 'l'llll: ratruu};n;lutl lintlntntl l'cl•nls tlutt lutcl• ul•l•itrrlrtl lit t'lululln ; Illl+ l'alrnurlli ► Inry' l•un-

I'. l',•4.SI0IIM 111itlll! IIÇ tiU+ I1VI111'1•s 0 • ll,l' ti/l1•l'1'111111•111ti 11'IU11'-llt• . 'lT l'l'IiH1 flll t

\ueu Sl l+tilut l'rl'luil'r, lot In ., ulul l, . udlniltiug to hil+ •unlittl, ►u•l', null ln•inl;-

itlg willl hint Ill•rl' u,; hi s t u•rrllrr',l'lllnti~l'r, Il tell . 1111' . "rs . A tuc ttt ► IA 1 . 1) nnll

Ut•t't'i .t•Y, l Nvil 411, Id':{ luu"t llt•tl'rrlliltl•ll Ill,litil•ul t,llllu u•ut s-lvul ttv' l+t•ur

,• X I,l•rl, it• w l' rl'jt•l•t this rl•Ili'uu', that the sumo or sitnil tr thinl ;t will tt•ur

Ilt,lil ► t,~ lit~l lr it P . l'ntl we exlll'vblu Sol' the leader let' if I+,t'llltl'r ('unnlliut ►,„Ita'1't•uti~•l Iwrty''ttull llll' Il'It,ll'rl,l' .thl' lilllll+r(',tnnllilul ,illl'rul~c:itlillg~illl+ ` '

i ly, e;illl' + 114 uirl, il' thlx Ilrrljl ( t titilti fll work out, i ► I In ali it III' iuutlull rl+ltr

In+, ►ui•r utul l unl t'~rilm, tlu, Iln,llll'rlt of' w Ir rllu h ti ►utiuuuT ( lilNl'ullil'N I No

. ~tSr, il i~+ 14A l+ n ► ul - II tu rx lwt•I . 41ir,u•lok 1% 411111 l•l•ua+ tll Illl utirul•It+ :{ if they

w l•r i ' l• V l'nty ut' l %% l•r y lllty lli l urn nl l' ; I lit . t•rry ► u ► turl, lll' ~~lmtlt rn roqlti ► ;l'Ktlutt ' llu'y' t+ltlntltl he rutrl+ '; luul titis is it tt ► irlil uluux tuai %vo ullcrll► l' t'inc tuu-

•'rtrnuro, that lul' ► t at tlu+ hl•ull u1• thl' Rllt•l•rnlitl'nt4 in li%•l, -lllu•utl+ Ilruvinl•l'x,

ntrll ul'n nt tilt' hl'tul 411, Ihl' Imrtit• .'+ tllll,l,tiillt ; thl'ut, till u}(mt'tl at the t+uuw

tinlt+ tll Fi ► II; 111u•ty tlill'rroul't'xtA+r llll' good (il' all, will tlitl not shrink, at the

riHk ut' lun•inh,tlttrir tuuli%l'ls ►ninunlll ;,rsluutl, from uskuciutiul; together furtl w.

Page 14: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

1t1 5

r

IF

T

Intriutr 4 . I' In•il Ir l}; ulluut I hi, n• :ult . (l'ln t•r~. ) I h,t\ c lu6l•tl, sir, \\'htltri,:k,t do \\•r rutr il' \\•t_~ rt'Jl'Pt Illia llu•u ;url' !\1'l' rlul tilt! riak ut' I,oing s\\'ul-

It,\\•t•11 tll ) 11 %, 1 11 e r'iiirit ul' ulli\•l'r3111 lit'1,wi•rlu y tllat II['t'\Ilil>t in the l'uittnlSt,tll•4 ., 7'llt•ir wnlll will flt\'on'itt• luoflu i .;-_ • ~ '

' \1,l1,'nt tlll l'Iil•,t t•nntr,ll•t~4 ()tu' lh m t'r ; ,I o11 Illt• \\ Ilult' Iltulllltllt' ;s Iv11111N•Ill 1.,~ nlll' , . ' •

'1' ult is Ille llluu,llllu' .1~1' of' tIt\' 1lullrt,l• llw•Irillr . .\lul llll• 11,~11111 ;u' \uil't Il .t,I\'url'llItluil (lu' };rl•nl•'4 .41111 •,I 111 ' 11 ulnnllg tllt~nl have Itu

,kl'll nlluu it ni

illr\'itltl,ll'-IIRI• \ tt•II,iuIJ ut' Illt' 111-ilil'illIt•y III tll•Illttl•rlll•Y t,\'t'r thiv Utullillvllt .

\u\\', I,ulll,l, .1 t' II nnl\'t" r14kl ' Ilrnltit•ruWV i ; nt I nlt,rt• ul't•,•IIIuIIIIt 141 Il+ Ill,ul u'

tlni v or 'ul tntmlu't• l 1' v

in I ;nrttllt', :uul lit l'u1;11111'4' ri-nt nrii•s-l'rtml l'n,\ttl,t:y V .

ttl \ .\l'ut .lulN -uur Ir11ht•1 ;, l'i,ullluttvyl to tllr lit'+ttll Il ;rnin<t tln•,••ul,•jt•t•liun ul'

n11 I';In•t,lu' lu it rinl ;tt' a' ' 11•ul o r ,l sin}clt' 111 ;1,It•r, lultl Ilt• ;11,1'll u l l i t llt•I,t \\Hil'h

Ila A ,iurl+ Illnth('nl'll Ille I,rntlllriulr t•I~l~~rs of Illr t•nlllii't' \tilll un l'nt-rluuus

Inlul ul' 1,tlit itm, \tllirh .lu'rllnll-,lwn1• t i tllt•r t• \ l•l'Itl Ilu''Ji,lnl\' Illltl t\'l'r•}:rt~\\` .

in} ; iullu'tl;t' o l' lluta' lqll• Wulltl, t•,nltll II,1\'t• Ill 11,114 . iill nll .lt•r . (III' ;u•,Iltll• .) 'l'lll' itll'll Ill' IL 11111\t'l' .<11 Ilt'lllut'l'tl~!t 111 .\)111'l'It• .1 is lln IIIUI•l' \Cl'lrnllllt

ltl IIN' Illllltl s ltt lIlull}dlll fi ll lllt'll IIIItut1II -Z , Illhll \\il+ IIN11 Irl' it Ill) l\'t•G.' ll l

lu4 luli•t•I1 fit 1111• Iniull of' Illt• thl~uy[lltl'ill lut'n \\In I Ii,Ilt I \\Itl 1111• st luulltrll llt'

tilt' tllirtl \\'tt,t,l .\\t in I';tu't~lll', tir \\ht„Illl r\\',ntl .,, tnlll,'r tilt- g rlvlt 11 .\Itl .luln .ul ttll, t,llllt,a'll llll• lu•lulit•,+ of tilt, I1 :u'It1'1111tY Il~ ll l t s tY that nnll}!ht Ill p lut ( l

I•:urt,lw Int+1t'r it r;inyclt' tlt l lnilliult . (IIvar. Ilt• ;u•) It111 it' \l t• Ill .,- tll Int\'c it

Ulti\l'r'tll llrltllnv'+Il'\' ull Illiy cool iuolll, IIU' I,tm I .I . l't'u\t Ill, nlllltlll' r

l'r;ly;ulont s-\y ill lit, ;' }tulll,lt'tl 1111'' lir•,1, r1u11 \vt' \t ill t• oult' lit ullt•r\\`,u`ll s Il )'\vlty t,l' lll' .. a rt . (I,uu}clltrr .) 'l'IIO ln't,l,u .rtl l'lnll't'll,•rllti oll will l'n 1lltlt' u s .to I1o11' 1111^sllt,llllll'l' tu ~Ill,lll~l .'1` ; lu 1•t',kt tilt! x111't'm1 Itt Illi .; Illli\'Itl :',ll

. •. if l'nlw•r,u•t' Iltu•trint• f it \\111 lu,l h t' i1' ulnrt' llt'•irultlt' tn Inniutnin t,ll•Iwtll

:,ilÎl'-t tilt- tvuutu•tdiun that Itiulls its tll Illt• I'Ilrl~tlt tit ;ttl• ; it \\ill rui ..e its t'i'wll

. tllo ltt, .il : t,► t ttt' nlt'rl' lll'llerllil'ul l'oltmira lu It uo\\ will lutrrt' ililllurl,ult I16si .

lit•1 ► 1 ; it \riN "i\ I . it, it Ill'\\ llvll' 411, t'xi .,tt'llt'l' IllUlt'r 1i1111•1. 111111 lnltl•l' Iilcurlllll C

tl n' :i~t+uiro tu thi, Ilrttjl•ol, \\llil•II 1v (ln•HuluU \\'ilh ttr luan % •t•ttltililinn4 ; Wit t

ull\'lultlt}a'-A t,u ll x tUlll In 11111' l'llilllrl'Il, Illl•IItIN Nillllll~' .Illi,: ;1111illJlllo IlUlnll \l . ill l

Ihl' Ilnitt•11 tit,llt',+ . (l n t r.i .) ~ Ittlt Illl' .as lin, •nulll l'iluit 4 'r s , \clwlly tiu\\vo rth}•

ut tlll' tlltl'lllittll lil tilt, ti>II'I`IIti, Mid .\\\.\\Ir.Y, 111111 '11 .1yk;lt's ,\t'INllltl\'l'l'n111F+

titr\\'lu'll Iu ti,rllitl thc 1111nu,; o l' lirili .h .Elul'fiç ;l~ 1114, s1Ir . til'F .\tttat,

Itl'liln I l11-,l\\• to it t•Ina' Iilc littir rl'Inltinlll'l' t#' \rluti I 1111 t-O Ill ra,~-tllntl I Ilnl

lu Iln\e lll'I,lint'tl tlll' Ilult .;l' t:u'Ilul}; .-(t•rit'y lit' "\u,+,\il")--1 Iu'}; t o

ltll'lv !t lï'\\ ltll.l'l'\`t11iu11K N110'fijn, .. 1,1' lll y Itwtl position its lllt 1:11} li~~l- Ilt Ilkin}~

lul'lnlu'rtin• Ir p \\'t•rt',Inlul,l . 1\'l'ullu't',inth('lir :t Illnl'l',tullll :l't'\l'th ;tt 1 1i1•rr

til•l'n•is llt Iw It flood tll'III Itt' l' m lr} l'ruliomiun lltl' r:ultjl'l't ul' rat it, ul~t•Il , itmnll )' '

illll'tttlltl'l'll, Ilt,tll ttll tlll' t,lll' Fille tllHl I 1 11 lllll I,Illlrl', Ill titis 141'l'llt,ll' lit' 1fiN

t't~ulllr~' . I lvtuy;rtitulntl' IIiy lu,rlt1t'+tllit' l'ril'nll tilt! .\lltn•nt'\'-lil' ► wt•+tl tor this

r.w•tilm url his t'ml'tltml fruul -M l'11 ~irt'jlul~~ l' c ilt Prnl'rul, lhunrh I rlill tllillk in

In,ttll'r i ut' llntrilurl}tr will tllr Ii1 ;11 Iu' nl\cn ys tllinL, lir .:t o t' his li\\'n l'ont.

I, ;ltriul l-(Iltu} Iltl r) -li~r ~\Ilil h nl'ilhrr titi I 1llnnlt' hiul . Bill, llli .,+ llll'or1• f i t'

KunU'lilflrs lvtrril'll tilt all lulti•chri~lüul +lutl IuIllllilllatltllitvl) t'slt••• .

,W hnso \\•urlls ❑ ra tllo;u-" (.()h hltth tua/lu Ill' tml' Illttt,ll ull thl' n+ltiurta that

Page 15: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

.

cl~rt ll tm tllu flue ul'thv v +u•II ► {" . I>+ n ot that the truU tll e ury of* race I File

tll}' part, 1 nnl not + ► tl•,litl of Illr F ren c h l',ulutlilul nu kjurit y in the future Ltlc'nI

littctvnlut'lll tl o in g injtt,tit•t', t~st'vlll lu'c•itlt'lllutl~• ; not 1 ► i ~'lul ;t, I oui of tilts

FrUIIN+ religion as Iht'ul~t'llt'N-I~tr ttri g ill and Ifln g llll}(v are IIIU•riPrN hlrutlhHr to

tlit•itl e tu e n in tlli -A %I tn'Iti t 111111 is n'li}ti o n to (111111' tlit - nl . \t•ill'r do I Il e lit+t'u

thnt 11 13 ' 1rot t' :allul ct ml 11 :1U•iuty nt' e tl lllt v t+ llut• ki ut•1 ► tie ur . 'l'Ilr F rt'ul'lt

l'(tltltli011K 11111• 4 , IJl . ct'r llrl'tl nll it11u1rr1111t IHvo111t . ;~it~H not ill tlU'ir tt~11lIIPr ,

unlt' ;~ tht .% hnti Itvt - ► 1 lu,r,- l't'ult'tl, llt'rllull~, tuul 11uv+ ► t V }tlll have Itl'cn its it

has Ilt't'tl tt'illt wllorrut• e ;ul'+11l religions . l't'rhnll s , ► m llli .. + t;ullj c t•t, tilt, 1ltlw+

w ill ulltl w nuv to rt•lu1 n N •rl3 ,t ril,ill}; illnar,Uiuu lit' lllt. t o lt'rnutr ol' French

('nuutlilul t•1111i•IIt•tta• l'rn11u It Ilwo lc I Il o lcl in 111 v luultl, tilt, b i; /rs I of 1 b 1 ' S'yntuf

.1!pr+llr s ► tl' jA c !'rrxhqhriulr i'Ir ►n•t•h of c'►n► urlrt, 11 3' nly tct,rthy f 'it'rul, ilu+

Jtrv . 11r . KNatl" u1' tilt, F m e l'lllu•t•I1, of' 1lnntrtvlL 'l'ht+ Ilil s :n gu i ; tilt 1111-ii

14 t'i't'11 ul'tht+ ltllrutlut'liuu :- •

" .\Iltml the t't Iw, I 79 4 the l'a'sItytcrinni ul' 1ltlnlrt',Il 41 l' nll tlt ntmtinutiun~,

WON Ihi1i A 1 and •\lut'rit•,lu, ut• g+Inizt'tl tllrlu,t l ► ',' I into it C11111-ch, will in the

l'ttlltt w init y r,u' ;1•c'nrtvl the Ia - rt'ic'o . ul• the Ilt't' . ,lun s Ycll'xtl . At llli s, tiulv,

Ihrt' mot in lllr Itot•o llt'l Ilulluu .l- l'uthtdiv ( 'lllut'll, Inlt in the y trl' fitllt,tcjn);

lluev t~rr c l v tl the t'tlitit'~ , whit'I ► is lutw kntlw ll uy St . lillln•it - I ;ill't't'1 t'In1rl'li-

the ultlrxt l'rut++ ;tunt l'hlll't'll in 111 v l'rtn'itltr . I*rl Illcir tvu•I Y 1lillutt'N tt•r tintl

1ht'nl, in Ilt'knu~~ lrtl}liui ltl ul' I luv Icilulu v ;a ul' tlu . I(ocrll e l I' 11t11t'r;, Itrt' ;t'lltillH

tilt-ut tt•illl ' ( tnt , box of tvuullcr ;, i1ti111 ; ., nt Nil ., clntl tnlo ht, g ,alr,ul lit' ;+Il+lui ;h

NVI11V lit C( ; .5 .;

(I , lul ght e r .) I'llu q. tn y hnn . frit'ntl ;, who ull ► Y 11m v tlitli - rv ttt nuliuna fit'

t'llri ;titln illlt'rt' o 1 r ,Nttt 111i" lilul. Iii t1 ;1 v , j 11 ;l In tiuU•}` tlniUt,N ttt' tluttNurl .

(Il 1 '11r, 11tvu• .) Ilt'rt~, In Iht , ulu c Illlntl, ;u•t . dit, 16 ~t't111ot I'+tllll'rN )ti\'inu Itll nnt -

uf th ► •ir uu l ► t'hurt•ht'N ltl tht . tli , t•il l lt' ,~4 ul' ,lutl s K .N ux tu l'lutltl e tlu'lu Ill w ur-

Nllill ( ; ut ) uft v r Ilu+ir u wn lunnltrr, uucl Ilt'rhull ; (41 hm 4 . u g irtl lit l'o ll e rl' in thr

nlt'wltunt _O rolit Inll} lllt r)- ttlul Ili - rv , ttll tilt - ulhwr 111utt1, uro file tir,lt e l'lll

1'rP ;ll~ torilulN Ilrc'h1'lltilll ; to llu'a~ N1► 11Jt• St l lllili ;u•y In•it' ;IN 1%'iUl'tllltl wax tflllPrNr

in ut•kuu %%•Itvlhlm+nt ul' tht, tl,t~ ut tlu'ir c•hnrt'h lin' l'rt' ;l ►rtt~rillu N ort'it' .• l t,r.

tniul) ' It ult lr v c'1 ► nrnt'It'riNtj ► ' in ;t,lut 1e of trut' I 41 I 4-1,1 u ► l' e ul ► Ilttth Nitl(",-i ( .Ili) hnnll~'

Ill . Colin (I ill thl, Ili . ltlrr nI' 11113 • utht - r t'uw ► lr~' . I cll v this litdlt , incident to dru«'

l'rulu i t ' tluN~rrut'titvll•tni,rnl--lltut Ihn .;e who lire ~1•t'hitlti .Ilntl,`itl .uuln par .

lit'll~lll'N, I Ilt'Iit'Cl' ~II~II~' Nll'I~ill+!, 1llt' FI'1llt'1111111 Uf I'r o tt' .s tltllt l'tllh'I t llu11 il l

Ltm t•r Canada tilt tirnlt'r gnountl th1u1 it n o%t' o ► •c'ultit' "A , nli ght well aflitnl to

It'nt' ooll ht . t wo t;ront St'tllinurit't of' 11 o 1 ►lrtvtl 111111 llue h vc•' ut Iwlttve . . No hct ►

in .,, t lj nlitmN in t'hri ;lt'nllnlu ot v r more c•uu ;t'it'utinu ;l* v

fullillt'tl tht - t'utlx u1'

tht'i tqrctitnl ; arul tv lltt v ct 1 r tltuv + not kllu~►• all, but t~t•t~l it littit~, (if* tllv guutl•

~t r~ Ît rN tllo~' hu~ t' rt'tltlt•n'd to Luth tilt - people uiltl 1111 , lltl v t'rnr►h'nt ut' Lu we r

l'ulllitl,t, to the çiv ili/utitm 11 11 c1 NottI v nu'nt ttf this t'uuntrY , ht ► ; nlnt'h % t'1 t o

1' Irnt7w(;f 1h0 hiritur Y t ► t' l',ulutlu . ( Iltvu', 1uv1i .? To close tI11N t o l ► it', I 1111%.v n u

t1u11111 w lullr\• e r, %% illl it gond tl v , ► l ut' ulutlorntit,\ uutl it I ► rttll e ►' tlt~Krt'a 411' firnl .

~ nt•NV, nll that tht- l'rutt' s tnnt nliruo rit~' ili Ltl~~'rt' l'tultullt 4-1111 rc~yuii v , I ► Y w n y

„l' Kt, t•lu'ity to th e ir t•tlutvttiulutl r+y~t v tlt, w ill Ill, /' hc.erfull}' g runl e tl to theul by

this Fl ou -'e . I, lirr one, its it Roman l'utl ► o lit', w ill c•urdil ► 111' second and Null-

port ►wy Nuch uml+utln ► e utN, I rrull e rly fr,tutctl. I w ill tuc'rnly- utitl, in rolutiun

Page 16: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

O

107

11

I1 1 411 1 01-11-f\ illiuu III 1111' Irit'ntI ( Il 1 1 n . \I r . Ihtu\\ N ) lit ;l Ili} LL un tllo s I ►l+.l t t't' tl'ttll•I'Ilt If llil• S t'ImI•,Itt' S I•httttl .,nf' l'lllu'r Callao l,l,tll,lt I nl'1•t'lltl'll tür tu\' u\\•I 1

Ut, rl ; 11 Iiuillil}•, Illr nunt`ullt'tl nt`t II f' I - li,t. t tlitl it Iu't•,tll - i' it }cr,ultril n 1

tin' Ilrtitiont'r . ll :a~t tl, 111111 I tllinlc lllr.\ • nuprllt t o Iit' s ,It k lii•tl . I will lu' nu

111111Y tu II11' rP•ttllt'11i1t}('t'l't Ill . 4 111 1 `,tilill ; bill I rll Y tlli s , thllt il'lllrrl• aur t' I I 14,

; 1111• `ltrl'i,ll 1!luu' ;ult~i•t•~i III' }Ir111 1 t ; t•\li'utlt•tl tu'tlil' l'ro ll' S ttltll ilJil If ri t\'

.IJ.~tt\\t•r ( 'IUltltln, I tÎliill : tlli• ('i 1 tln'lit' IIIiUtnr il}• iU l'llllt•r nltlil ;l nlllCht il~ Ii C

'm I t l , u tvl in lirol'i , t'Ir Il( - •n>`ur . Illl .iliull -nt illli r . Ilt'Ittv' lit 01' \\ 4 n V . ( Ilt'iu• .ht`lu• .) At llrt - t'I!t Ikllnll nctt ntltl lul~ihl r\\ul•11 t i n thi ; - Iltijt l •I, n , I t1 11 1 nttl,iIN•,u•t' ul'tllt' Iltu•Iit•111~Ir 11t111u•t' 411,111v nnlt•ntlnlt•I11 ; 71~<I,t'll litr !It lirr=t•ilt, t•itht' r

tut lll'r l'tiuntrit'k tli", au',Ikiuy; ul'tlu•il' uw li, tllt'11 I s hllll ltn\ p It' ;+ Il l i llrt'ht•Il s il I n

t'il s t t'l' \\,t' L ~ Ilt tll: II1'lll' .) All \llin 11 ;11't' lu~l t 11 o ll tllk s llttji't't 111m . S Illt l

it g1„,tl tli' ;11, 11+ \vrl ., Il ;ltlu•111, 411 ' tllt• iult`r l ' :t .: it , tillo . iu tlll' ~ut l t .; : tlr fililln' vo l'thi,+ ilt,ln 111'l'tin fi 'lll'I:Il if Ill . I ► rll~l tllt' Iit 1 ll,o \\iIl 111•l-luit ttll' 1 f 1 ntltl lt l• w\1l ' I !I~ ltl llll' I11'111t ililt' 1~1 ' ( 't I lllt'tlt'1'lllitlll l't i ll~lillPtVI 111 Ilrt`lt, 111 ttlt' 11111t11•

1 il 1u11 1~1' Itl1~ IH•Illl llllt' lU tiil'llll'l' ( ' I 1 II , I1t11liuI1N, 1111`l't' t't•1I 11 illlt• 1llN,1{'a \\ll•i

nlu lillul llrli't I, Illt' t\t' akUr .: .r o 1• fila' t - rtlli'tnl lltitllnlil v . Ill' fill Iht' l't•tll'1rt1l'ttn,-, tit III iunv I lln\'t` v\ 4-1 . llrilnl III- tuait of, Iili :: \\ 1 1 ; I III, lilt III lunllnl Y : Ill l •l'\\l'rt'

-

rllt rt•li\1'tl, ft". '1• tli v ll ni' t'o ll 'm nllll if Ill . tI„lu g lllt'r .) Itlll I 11 1 11 ntll,llrl'lllll't'tl to s tl\' huit lit'l' ;111-1' Illt''l'ILm 'llll l .l',1 1:II 1 ' olt'l'll•1l It ; t'lli " Ilu,lri .- ll•llltl if'ur t\\•t l lu outll . ,Inll lu - lt`tl 11 t•l'I 1 tlu•111 1 1t tllt'rt'titl•t' lht' l't'ilt'r,ll llriut illltil'uiltvl . till llu' l'tlutr+lr}', IIu•rr it ,t - tul•I Ili ny: in Illl- l'revlut•ut, Iimtl 1•1 ' 4 •In•rt' 111 '0i

of Il111J11;illll to tll k Itfilll'illli', 11111P 11} : It 14 ` l'rt t' : .1 111'lllltt', in tllrir lit` .t tilllt'• litltl

\\• o l :;t tlnn}n•r t +, \l tlirh Itvltl s nlr tu lit-lit \ t•, 111,11 it I1 ;1 ,; it \ t•rt• tl~ l'll Il o lil illIInî1111J1 lllttltl•t' it , l'It - 11 1 1 t'\i•t`Ilt'lll Irlrk filr it Ij l t\t'rn11Jf'lll to 11 11,Cr . Itll t

iutlt'IVI, Ar, Illt' nl,lin of nt' s~ tit In i s Iln' 41 ne tli s lrilultiuu of' ltu\\•t'r> -11 tlul"t if 1 n Illurl' not Innt•h tut ni-:111, l'nt \\Ilil•h 1 11111v Ilt' lin•Il,lrrll 141 -'ilv -unu`Ihinl; t mlil`Ii lY` fllt' Cntt' it (+Ilii'll, 'l'llt' Ilrlllt'llilt' it t`1) rt't'l w; III -111v It , he i'tlli+1111 1 ' 44,

tlt'lllj~ " It Iltllllltl'tl !I l ltr lll'o lllntt' illlt`l'tltll lItVU't' 111141 t\1~ l'lltll ,~t'l'lll'l11', tllltl It~

4 '1111 1111u llt'1il )Il 11 ► !l'1111i1lt', t'11 1 1111'llll; llllt) Ilt•l'ilU• It,lti'It'l k lll . it . is 11 liait Of f

tlri . In•ini'illlt' that lu,ll,t'x tlu' nlt l tl o •rn It,llinn lo uR huis \\ith iti•rtt w nntl Ilritll+M'i'l' 11 111•tll't• * 11 ., tt' tlf ^l'rl'll t't'111111It• s lu 1111-1 i1111t I 11 ., fil-Id tut IVg lllllltt ; it \% a s111i 4 lirillriltlt' I,inlllt'+1 lit' llt'!It`ull, \\•hil•h Ii1n•I1 % 0 fill tllt' ro l'k , c i1f l'ri ;`il \rcl ..AÎlli . + 1 1 l •inl•ililt' tllllt Itrtil t' (hl II}'kl' . ttl' Ilt 1 llilultl nulal ttrtr w lulutll thl' Itu ua itll tlll' lilit' ul"ilu' I :fty lililul t~lipr(•„nr . . II i ;n Ilriuljlllt' lvlllilllll' nl'in,llirill~it 11111 fit- 111111 fit UNI lUI11 it 111t0 " lllli1111 .1' l'111111i11 if 11, i t ' ll II11C1' s I'llt }•tlllr ttlllt gIllt'll WI }!Ilill•ll 1• I p 111• f'I•t1111U•l'. . Y t p ll \\'itlll II IH•111t'llllt' tn Lilültl lttlll' y tillll}S I11t'11 ,

will tll lis tr111 Y Ilt'l p 'uil Y nur 1,1 .( 11 i tirr. For >,\•lult tlt ) g n oi l nll'n (\\ll - i lullkr tht lItt :t laIltlii'r•) li}tllt ! For ; ► lilli' of a'rilil+lrt' fit- t h+llk Iinl'--tio r It ltrt•tt' \ t orfor 11 111'llll'llilt' : W 1111t 1s if 14'l tt't' Itn111111 :11'1' I lt't1\ 1`l'll Iltl l lulli IIIJIII 11 1~ 11'lllll'1

t~t ~lllltiltlt`, t~l' t'l't ll A 11111111'ill trlirt ;lt'It' ~-\\'ll lt t'tV111C i~t't'll ; liati~tll~ Illltlt' t

nnll nlinl•t !- . !l'Iniul•ililt' . 11'llvn I t'nn Iu•,n'tlnr .% • I tiul} huit Nlt y 11J Ill-1111111Y .t~ (ll' l'l'tli'l'lltinll" iii '' tt!tt l't I tllltl\'," ucl, "tllll' l~lllj!illilll,'' 11 :IIIt (' I llltl}i Illt'11 4 1 t

I f ~r lhr 1.t• .;1111 t l' \\. hutlIcrr l ria l : thl• l'ulnrt' luu}• h ; ► \ o ill tlrt' t li r nÿ: /l'llt'tv:u.)

It mus Ilol'll s llitl• tllnt Illr I'tvloi•ul ttnu s lil III ittu 14, Illr 1'llillvl titnlt` . ht ► w

l'llil l •11 . 1, s ir, llu\•t' lit'\•or,nitt it . '1'ho . \t1~~rnt' Y -t k 'ur'rul 11't` A tultt Y lill tilt )

o thrr nig ht tll ;lt lu' tlill not ctmitlt'r it !1 lililtlp ; and I 1•t'lut'ntllrr that in I~lil,

whl'u il ► this Iltiusl' I ro lu ;lt'krll thl' runuv. t 11 iul ;, .thi+ utll)' 11 1ltn who titra

a

0

Page 17: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

u p l,lnlult• i l the I;tutl•In, l llt tt'll, 111r Atturn ey -6opt•rnl 11' e ,ta-a;tr that it i

ltr e tty plain he llitl n o t rillltlly I„irr„w Ili,, nrgulucllt fo r use thu .uth cr lliltllt,

Nl 114 .11 h ( , v~•n, aulrtuc nting it Fi- ,lor~ll l'uiun linlnn g uln•.advt .,. ( II, Ilr, ht•iu• .)

It uuly bu it Iilt9lhe III I' n,, lt,uut o\ it•lll as 111iy 1111 1 v ,l nllll p' t uut It luilul•e

li,r 1h, lu . 'l'Iù•Y llw v t• hlltl oi}rlll y ~t• ;u:;' II, t . uf it, 11114 1 hut•in}; tl k /•utolrll ita

llt•ti•(•t,, lull y ultlll y it rt•nuvl y Ilutl go nn w ith it v i ;chtti' yclu•n lunp . r. Hill wu

also art, luu h t•r, url, who r ;ll %\ • it, tlt•li•(•1 s its the Iliut•hirut N% urlw tl, and w h o

Ilu N-v llno lnu•t - tl t•tiutri vnntl, 1) w Ilirll it clln be illlln•ov (•d luul k t- llt in luurtt

ll e rfi •(•t urt lor m h vn u p ltliotl ttc o ;u•;,•I v ,•i . .\nll twlr of lllr to rt•Inu,l antt~nu l ►

in 1• ;Il g llulll, tl k~ lin g llk lu•t1 llli hi . ill I,ulitit•, tlutl Iïtt•ru ► lu•r, hll, t1, - cl,u• e ll, its tilt,

l'rt• ~, itlt :ut of tlu. 01 l 111c il iul ,11 l' 1111- ti w;, that \\v t•ulu b int•t1 .Iht . • br,t l,lu•1,

of tilt- Icriti .•h and the .\nuv ri i- eu >

, %

t, uls of g„ v l•rlliul•ut, and thi .; opiui„Il

W Ilv tl e lil le rtttt•I v Io rnlt•tl lit it ili,tullc" , \\ itho llt llrrjtld ic e , lultl I~ x Itnvsm•ll \\ il ll•

t I u1 il Ill, / as tlvl u If tir4 •, o f lin y tl}•,tvillti Ill . ( I l,vn', Il I . ;u• .) \1't- Im o, Ill rt I ;t-

ti on t t) the Lwntl o I'tllr linr0rnlu 1 •nt, in r c lutinn to lllr jullit•i,u ;t•, ill relation to

the ;t• c uutl ta1nnl1tor ut' tlu, I,l•gk l ;lturr, in rrlntit,n lu th l- linnn u iuI ro ~, ltull .i-

Ililit , v of Ihr li v nt•rul 6 utl•r 1 1 111 t•ut, 111111 in ru lutiuu tu the public nlli c i,Il s w h w u

t v lllll't ' uf fi IIirP is lllll'illg goutl ItClllll'iulll' lll s t u il,l lit' At 1111' (411t1'it•t' Of it ll m'1 3'•--

in nll tlu•,l, rt ~lu l t . MO hllco ntlo ltt c tl tllc Itriti,L r~Y ,tt•lu ; ill utllt•i• rt•apt•014

w r,llut ve I v ;Irut ' ,l .unltalling from tilt .\lut - ril•uu ,y ,to u, IInt1 I tru,l 1 11 111

In•lio- t+ \\ . , . have nlutl o u %v rY t o lv rnl 1 l„ v unl h iultti ou ttf .lwtll . ( Illvu•, ht• i u' .)

Till, lrrin c il,lr of I ' t•tl,v',Iti„n ix it I; envnou, prinl•iltlr, It i ; it Inint•il,l e Ilutt

I;itt•+ uu•u lt ic u1 t1111i, ", to t1i sc lltlr 't . , un,l intr .•t, lll, - lu nt llw snuuc tiul v tt•ith

p •ul•r,tl ,ul w rt i s it,ll, that r m- it c , it l iv ;llllll +-rll,v of re .llotliltilit Y un i l tolu- .

lrl•c h v li,iun. It is it I i rin(•il i lt . that lltl, ü ppllllrt•tl it tti, o liu,l Irni• rltirit 411'

tA ,ttl• .ulutl - llill ill Itll vurlnl rit•,+ in M1it•h if hu ;s ocr Itren n pp li,•cL It is it

ltrirlt•il i lt , 1 - n11ul - utll' tN vo rulil v t 41 lihi •rl Y , I ivwu 'l . Iuln1 ulfnirN Ira'u It 'l1 to Int

llrlllt Mill I1 y Il,rul b tnlil•,, rtmÎ~t aun~~t lit- iutt•rti - rt 'tl with hY tllw=u \dho have

uu Itu•ul illtrrt • .;t,, ill tllo nl, a\ llil o lultttttr s fit' it t;t•ni•ruI crll ;u•lu•tt•r ln•t, It ' lt t•x-

illl , i vv l~v t o ti li vnt•rul l„o t erulul•ut . It is It ltrillrilllt• cuin c itle nt w illl t:t .t,r y

goV t•rlllut - lll, that t• vv r 9+ttt, A ti•nlltvl uu i l iutluorlnut rïv v it•(•, t o it vo unU Y ,

lu - r+w,t' t111 }lu~ t rluut nt, lllt~ u 11t• eu ulurr or I, .,; l ullf~ ,It r,tli~,n l in tlll•ir

(•llurht•t e r. ,4 Ilnin t \ u ; it ti•ti v nttiim, li,r1tltÎuo llhll it had it king n i ; llin}; (.,\ t+Y

the Wfi o l e 61111) rt', it had 111 local ; t,t/rlunlllG, lor tlu - :It1luilli - tnltiun (,t'

local ulI,lit'+ . 'i l ;ritkh Wca are it couli -tlt•r,ttünl, Will thw ol,l l'rvucll .

lhll<l•tlulrt+ me r e (•ù tili• 4 1 4 • 1-11 totl in tlll• 1-411 ltl ' K G t•u u rnl . . Il is It llriu c iltlu tl1itt

rnlly thl'uu g 1 ► n11 ll W I 11-40 1•3' if 1'1\'iliTlltiWl ill one lio l•111 t i r 111Notllt•r, i111 i 1 1'Si,l ,t

ulil .o Ill rllulun•t ' hil - , ;lml tll•wo l•rnl•ir, ; llull lut v in g nl1 op tt•tl i l its tilt_ I l i'iul•iltl u

it,f trur futlllr }utrrnlul - llt, tht•m %t vIr o nly lit(- tlotuil, to nrrun};r tultlll} rou

llltUll . 11'11 0"0 llt'111i1h 7 ► r/' 1Hv6 q'l' 1't i ll . It is not ill o ur power to alto, tlll\' fit'

thv lu im t•Il if tl w 11un "c /l v ::il ;t•+ it . It' the Il ont,t- tll• .s irt•y it t - un rrjt• O tho

trr ;Uh', Inlt m. t . c llnrl o t, rlol' t . ;Ill lhu o 111or 11'u v inlov w llit•h tu ok lru '1 in itw

111090 tiulio l1, cou;t•llt that it nhnll be l1ltt+rrll ill thl- t=li g lltc,t. ltluti cul,u' . ( Il,vtr ,

11r . Frt: A rt:u, I 11 111 h o rr~ ' Ili lutt'h (11- htit lv ll tllu liuuno mi !tm}t,•11114 1

W ns not n W+IX e till I had but-11 ri,nl p tinlc ,it m}' It•gs thut nly Illl y ,ienl f,~ri't ,

~tu, su illtt,l v ynltt e t it th( ' (• X luo +l,tiuu (i t' tilt-,t+ frtt points w hit•h, not s Itt• v iully

nt~titetl 11 \' m) pre llol•t„nt i r, It thi ti ll p littte, I ulul erlul ) k to Kluvtk ultun .

laluiN ut llr e ,ent in tht t llu s itu,u : \\'u nrl, l, ( nulll in lwuln`, H'o are bouilli in ,

Page 18: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

,i

we Itutel n o III e•hltl'e'tnrul nl ( lllInlleuty 1, 11 luti .ul ) e 1 1 n SS euntu 1ur, 11'le•, ul~• . ,- .have nuul•..e~t tlw .~r ulll Ilnlml,lr le•l;l•nll~ will rte~rie•~ ~t•Ilich In e~thl•r e'o lntrie•vhave e , se•re i 'e'el n lul ► t'e•rl•lll •hluu irt tht~ .~ee ► e•t-iluwnt ; I11'ro,'~~~•e -r1' 1111111 i s tlll ,1,1111 ul' his utt•n ~'url~ s . ( IIe'nr, he'nr+) \1'e+ lutcr nulle eel' tll~~u~ iutlue'n11+3 *ntmut u l~► Ilie I1, e'I .e•tt•lu~rt~, hnt e~ th~'ir e•t1e•e•t rll~i~lt H~~~•crlillll•nt jllst its Inile•l itty llu iuci+iLle ullunalllt•rr it s eü tcnely tel iuflue'uce• lilie , and Illlimnl nnll

t•e~};e'tullll+ e' x i - te•ncr . Thi s TThis is n 111•Ir Ilulel-!► land ut' Ilre•te•uNiul1 l,e•ritu , ll it is

tle't►' ; Ilccull,v e•In ;•e' :1 uuel nCete~ll ► d hltt'e~ not L•pll that tiluu to } ;1•utt' he•r~>

llntlu-ully' . 11'e~ lut~•e nle lu•i .<te I e'ruc}"Ilut e if ~'irti u l nuel tule'ut, ~t'llicll is the~

ell~• true• tu-i s tut'rue ~', will i ;+ lile' I~lel miel trnu lue•nlling (if tllo-te•rul . ( lll'Itr,

lu• ;Il•.) 'l'lu•re~ is It .e•lu ,y ut' Ine•11 riein}t in the',e~ i•e i lluiir .:, aupl•rie~r itl u1n11}•

re• s Ile- rly to e~tllrr5 ~t•ith ~th~~ul Ille'1' Iili} ;ht lu r~~ullun o •tl . \1-hllt I s hutll~l U-4, ,

to sot i s , that fuir n•Imo :e'llluli l !•w (if the l'Iwulliul ► 'and Ae~ueliltu nristul•rul\-

c<huulll I ;t' KI•nt to the~ lieut (11, tlu , ''llrimo \t•jlll that r~cholue~, to e~I~tuin fier it the

1•ul •Itl t+ü1N'tii~ll--lt t+{'I11`Ille luitKII}!I!e'tilelI by e11111'rs, or i1111Ni+e•ll Illwll 118, IIIIt

01w the 11't~l•I~ of e~ll1`~1'I\e' .~, the l'l'e dlll~ll of U111• 1'll IIItOIII•t't and d 1 l f our UN'l l

frce+, tlltl~i ;l ; +e el, and IInU+uunlrlÎl ~l ~ ►'iN . I e+ltnullt lihe+ to >we•• our In',,t II11•n go

tlti're•, nnel t•uelev ►►'e~r te ► lt~~r this ul•+ ► sw•e~ ~•urrie•el thrllu g L the lllllmriul

l'urliuulwlt-}e~in}~ into her U .,jr t t~''r{ . Ilre~,cnce, ' unll 11~- tluir niu ►mer, if not

uctuullj; by the•ir qpl•l'ch, µlt~'int;--" I ►urin}t j• ~~nr \fyjl•rt~''e+ rt- i};11 we have had

109-i

} Ilud•fuith, to fi~ur Provinces ele•1•u~lie•II 11i- our G•lllitt~-e•~~luui .ts, UI carry wi ttll~+ lut• ;t>uru tl} i•I•rll nll~ru livre il l . lil,t t►'ev•k1~1' I Irtulle•r . WI, ilrl• Iwuu~l to

, c,u'r~' it Ill Illu•Ii;l~t e,t'tllu''llreeur, und usk thore~ front Ill,r'lfllje• .:t~•, III'~•iorilill}i, ,to tlu+ lir>I re•>~~lutie'll i,f tll~R .111e1re•+y, ttl ;lt she ~t•ill lro }'rlu iull,ly' lllivl~l Il t

o direct Ir},'i~luti~~u to be 111111 nll titis iIt1je••t. We }tel to tho Inllle•ri,ll (iui•rnl-uu' ► It, thu e•ulnnluu I ► rLih'ur eef Ili Itll, in our truu Fcilt•rnl nle•tnolll~lis-tlr gotlll•re• to Il,k li~r tour I\tlulanu•ulul ('hnrtor . \\'I• hop-, I 13 • Il,n•in}r that ('lulrte• rthat e•nu e~nl~• W! luu~•nlll,ll Ilt' tlù• rtuthuril j' that, 1u,lele•it, that t► o ►t•i11 ~ly tllo •

Ir,lsix lit' lu•rul,in~•tle ~' fur our Iltlm•„ }~ut erlune'llt . The two grral lhiu}; ; !lat.nll nle•n uinl lit iu 1111Y In,(, }ti~~'e'rllnle nt (Ire', lille•rt~• will luvrlultue'ue ~' . \1' el

Ilu\ l' h311 Iil~l•rt~• e•uuu}elt-ti (I 1un1•Ii, llorhtlli . ; Ill renuy re• .~IIi•i•Ix- Ilut t► t all

► 't~q~rlt,, lilu•rt)• to ullr llrnrt'~ e•ulltoul . 'l'h~ ro is n~et 4111 0.11. l'~le 1~ ul'thl• i• ;u~tll ;t

fie•e•r lit-4-111v thnll tlu• iul ;ullit ;lill, of tllo :el culuuil y. liut it is I~•e•e~~au•,y lllcrl•

rale ulll ho re' ;lu -4114lin lhu lu ►t', lt Ili}lll t•ntr,li nuthnrit~•, 11114 viltile lit, ( .i\ ilulle Ilie Ile e~,. i~ll~•~ in}; (Il(. I,t ►ti• fur the, I+t\%'`a .nhe•, e•t 4-11 tl 114-11 n nlllll' ; Ilrit•utll

e'ul ► 'rie'nt'e• may e•enlcine•c llilu sllllil'iolllki• that tlu• 1111V in .l~llle• e'a-_1• .; uut}• hoa'run,t, lit- is not tu se't 1111 Ili~s . iru~lit ieluul ~► ill u} ;niuxt the m ill .e~l' 1111' e'~~lurltl ~•

e'xlrre+~ ..oll Ihrlult;h itN re•e•uwuize'iI l'un .titutGa1 ;11 *r~l ►us .` \l'1+ uoe'~I iu th~•~•uI'ru\illre•s, ~ee• cau I,e'ur, n large irnfllililt uf .ultllurit~ 1 11111 not lit till ,il'rliil l

1&this l'nu,titiltiun e'rry on tlu tiiir of I~~n grlvtt, ('Im~t'rrnlisin . If it be 1,61111&•

tun l'onl,e'rt•ulit'e~ uu ►t•, ttu± elutln~turel tenlle'ue~ ill l1~~lilie•nl illl-u~+ tl'llie'h

t•hurnrte•ri~e'y lhi l ele luutr,Uie . II}co, i~ a tiuflie•iont Knlu~ ;wll'1~ for lunrnllulout. `

Thut is tllu Irrine'illle~ (ui illie•h thix!Mt .trullle'nt k s Irvena unel ~►'e~r1h)• ( ;t' th u

krtllpl~rt ut' uve•r~• e'~~lulli .t, and thrull} ll tt•hicll it ~► ~ill .141-111V tllb ►t•nrul Itllllru-li;ttiem Ill tllr In111e•rinl nlttlle~ritie•,+ . \l'e have llevl• 114, trnllitil~tl• and ;lul'ie•ut + ,

tl•nevulilo in~titlUie~us ; 11141-t-, lhev'e~ Ili-(- till tu-i,lut•rntir e'le•lue'ut~l lutlli~tt'rll fe~• •

tiluu or bright elre•11s ; lu•rl•, e•cl•r~• nlnll is tlïl• finit ne'ttle•r eil' tlu+ Iluld, or

r.~•trlm'e'(i 1`10111 the• lir .t ne•ttlrr one or two };rne•rltliuuK ut tltu' furlllr .,t ; hrre ,

II' ~ Il I "

.

Page 19: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

R e .11 o►► tz illlll fit/\'rrnlti w nt ~( 'nn( ;i'lIrtl 11 i'11 : ; N'h lln\'r IUl tnilui .,tt•el'll it Cor 1 ► Pnr) y

il llu+lrtt'r ul'It c i ,' nt Q4 tlll% \\'llirh Wo I111ct "Mil lhm llit'll ulu• lm lllllut h" triull ► ntirt' II11 ► n ltllullrnllltll our Irvll' . 'l'lu' r<I111111 t• o I l tlli l- . + w llit•II phlu•Ilnt• f ' .t on'y lvoultl m 'llrt• c l ~ Si')' tnl th l ' nlNll Ilil\r g rown•inttt }trt'lit l• onl ►ulniilit', .\}(l't't ► t 111111}Sl'l' lllli ill'lrl!It , ill o 111' Iii-II' 111'i~~1111ttI'll~~~ul . ( lçt'r our Ilnlllt'N 71 ('lulll l

luln}t+, tlnl'k 11 1141 I1 c 11\' y . We t lt, n o t kn o \\' \clual it ► u,ly Inn' ..1 . 1\'ith i 1 lu•,uU'll Nlrt'u W ll \\r tif +ItJt ON tll culnllllt n g ,1i11 .P tlll :•lurnl, \\'llüt \\t t,ulFtl~~•

n'l' \v ill t 11 i l•llt't'rt'u11 y tlull I o \ nllt' . Itllt \\r w lu ►t tilue 1 41 g r om-\\'e \\'uul,

111 4 +1 1 ' lil'Ll l lt' to tlll U111' l' o llltll'y , IIUon ' 1 ► III11 : trinll s t•IIIIIIIU'à o t Illt'll t o llt'1('lul it'our rv,ulu't•l' .-\\1' \\Illlt t o in c rtvl -v o lu' prua,l :rilt;---\to \\',ult n1 o rS' l'xti~n dcd

U'ullr and l•nllllut'rl't' 'wnllt more land -tillrll- luurl+ im 'u (-1'llll k llt• dtlu'oul}th tnrl• \\',IStt ;. 111141 We of tllr, Itritkh North Anivri(',anI~ft~\'llll t 8\1'lllll 1 o Ill, jnilll'll top ' 1 i 11 '1', tlllil. il. Itallhl'l' l'ulll~' :~, we t 1111 S Illlllul' t

t'at•II o tlu'r i ► 1 tlu' ll,ly o t'trinl• We ('ulul• to yollr 11 ;Ijt'ay, \\ ho have givt'll 11,4Iillt'rty , to ~ .~it'r n 4 lulit y , that we luu y I l rt'wr\c # Iu~l tu'rlu'tlultr t~ur l'rt'r'~inlu ;nu i l \\'llaf•ut'\'t'r t'h :u'tt'r, in tlu' \\i~ll oi nl'~~I' y i~ur1C1111jt•~t~' and oil' \ our l',Irlin-

lulvlt, ~'llu g i\r 11,, h~u I;ull filllil it 3 l, Inu}; u 'i it is 4 11 1 'Illl'll ."ine of t liw• 11 ;Ijt'ay null your rnrl•('a111 .8 it . IlnliuLlin tlu' lvlult't•tiuut)t'(1\'CI'll ( ir o Ut It17ti1111 OIItI tll e'l . ( 'ulUllll'y ." ( I , of (I ('lll'1 I;A .)

I'1.~

Page 20: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

a

w

r

I11O\T. J EA N C. U1I A L' .11 Sr _ .

is ('l ►ululi stiiu ilcr or l'ul ► lic, tiVurks. 1~Ir. .Lll;tl ►;tis is one or the tijllr French ( .ull ;t.lliu u

IIIC1111) 6 I•h or the . 111inista•y ami the ' tl ► irtl in cul ►se -llu e l ► cv. llc i s it ul ;lll ut' sulllc il ► fltue li ce vas t, orQ IIC' l ) vc', ;111(1 l'e lll'v tie lll,s tl f;l.t district or country illtue (,;tliïliet .. 1Ir . ('llnl ► ;titi is llut, ;tj 1 ► u.11 ul'llititillnlti ;;hw ll;tl ►ilit~y, ilnll l ► wt~s his ;tl ►►uilrtulcut- to his i11llu ► ~11~~~ .~'l'flin utilli,t ur if ;1 s Ove tv ll in Iti A l ti ►r It ;tlllutl-

r ; ► ,sk ;t, and ll ;l -s r►;tt, Ii ► r it, evcl• sill .c.e . He 1 ► us"vutullKtc;tliily witll t & F rench ( 'Itll ;tlli ;tn lll ;tjc ► 1•ity 1 ► 11 ;tlllltll`;+tl( ► IIK . Ilil v lllg 1 ► l'G1 15 y /' ;tl' ;1 111 l ►;ll'll ;tlill'llt. , h eis well vcrslll ill legisl;ttiull, and iy one or the l t~ ;ul-illg. tli eu ut' his 1 ►;trly . .

The office 11olll by Mr . (;II ;Lp;tiy is it very inllwrtcillt011t1 , and it, 1 ► 11g1 ► 1 tli 1 ►c lillelkl ►y it I1i ;111 who is ;tlivc

to t'll e wltillts ut' .U;LU ;tld;>, in rcg;trll to 1 ► 111 ►li6 wurks,'

und also wlll ► has solllc-illic;ti It l, , to cl ►st. and -utility or

wl .►rky,-t.wu .tllings tLltt ;tll ufuur Llll ► lllissil ► IlvrS

Publie `Vc.►rky have not lwyse•;;e ll . I t, is to be l ►1•c-Ktlu wli tll ;tt ,\Ir. Cll ;tltiy is the nl ;tlt or tlie. ,\Iinist .ry

'"Oyt, tit,l N i to till time l. ►Ilic (~ . lliy lit•ul e5s il ► It' ol' Sti ) r k! -

kccl ►er in the titr E' ct s t, ll o wcv v r, dues not, lnuc llllu;tlify ltinl for tllc llep;trtn w l ► t, .

On tlt e question or Cu1lt eclcritt 'iull, M r. Chalais

goes with his leader, ,11r' Cartier. , Ile did )lot. speakit, its iitvl ► r lluriltg thic lie lrtt cs , for he c,ulllut speak'wE~ll,_ and lei't"tll ;t.t t ;tsk to his n ► l ►rc fluent, CUIlI'itg tlcs ,and l ►r,re it III ;Ly 1)c sItlll tllat AIr . Langevin Ifi ► lc ikspeech bug cnùlt gll for lliul -*)clf and the Head or . the

M

~ . . .

Page 21: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

Public IVc)rks; so tll ;lt, if one or twc) of the four1+'renclï 06 lillllttll lI1C111I)t',r y 'o f' the M inCstry' wcreWitlltttl - , the s l)ercllc,~s of the two others utacle it ( ;uuditvcra(rt, ti)r t11é iùllr . ~

Alr. Cl ►itlais has it fitir sillu'c or the tvurlcl's goods, .but its Hot iLil1i111 of, wellltli. •lli s 1)rul e5s iull ll,ts 1 ► 4- cltefle rrcd to ; and it is llut vasy For i4tly mati to ula k e

1 luclt t ► tl)l1Cy east of (,►,Itrl ee, tllullnh ~i~ ►wtl ill tllltt,( l strict it sIllall ti)rtltnc i s rehltrdeil as wealtl) .

]\TI' . (,111-1 .1 )1LlN 114 It tlltlll (9f abolit, i)U y'ellr;t of age, 1 5

uwl ► i c ll, its 1)e f)rc itlti m ltt ed , lie hits 1)u s,cd ill Par-

llt4lll'itt .

Page 22: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

113 , '

110 .N .Wli,l,IA1i ~~tc. l)OCICAT .T,

• is Provincial Secretary .11r. 11It~1)utt ;;;tll i4 uite uI' 'th ► ! 11 ►1•vi, l1cl`►r ►►► t ► i0 ► it-

I ►er, t ► C the -Mii ► i's:t.}•, and tii ;tv• he rc' ., ► r ► le ► l as, tlw,tiecui ► tl irn r ;t ► tic ( ►f' the tl ► rev. 1lv is it 1 ►► ;tit 0 1' . ► I ► ilit y;u ►► I ul' ;t t;uml ► leitl uf' iialluet ►► •e i ►► tl ► o ; wr.'A . i11r .

. A1cUt ►►tnitll is ;tl, ►► It t; ►►ufli w i•it e r, ;i~u ► C ta ulce;t it b► ,u ► lsvc~.ret ;t ry .

'l'Liy M iitis tcr wity I :tcly 1 ► t 1 t. lit, the 1 ►eutl ut' theCm ttiuitis it ► u ;:~~ttt Ii,rt .ltl to "crlc I tt '%\- ii ► ; ► rk e tw forCutt a► l a 1 ►ru ► lt ce . I l e- tit 1 ►► l e his luur it, ,hm-t, uat c , t) ► t,bui»t; ,ts far 11's l3ruzil, 1 ►ttt, as it w en, , s l ;trlittri the

wtirlc tuttl l eiwinw it to 11r. I)iti ► scm ttl ►v and his party

to go to t,l ► it,t ► listltrnt Iwiut . '1'I ► e Provincial seerc .t ;iry'r4rel ►urt.uf'tlie wt ► r1c ► 1 ►► t ► ewill f ►vvev iiit ► .t•c.ti ►► t;

, to the cmtt ► ti;y .

in Parliament .

\Ir . ~11c~lluù ;;;t11 i~ it st .ru ► t~ 1 ►;trt .y 1111111, and u ►►c whottcts .l ►olilly ill all 1 ►►► lit,ic;tl i1itestit ► t ► y . . I .ilce ► u ►►,l men,lie tuad c his voit•v- 1 ►►.tr ► 1 ~llt ► •um ;;l ►►►► tt, the, l'ruwiure,.and wity lu,lific;tlly c;il ► tiuus, wl ► e ► t 8 ► ~vlcittg jiumvcr,and, ttuw t{t ;tt, iltc has t;ut, it-, he f 'ecls titur ►~'tt ;;y andquiet, cl ► sttt~;ii ► ~ his ~~icw ;t ~~itlt his . ~•li ;tttne ►► f' li ►rtti ►► c.•lIc is, l ► wcve r, mit. ( ► f' the tit ►►;;t able ;ttttl activc uie u

'l'Itis 111ittister 1 1 ►wf; ;t ► t 1 ► iil ► lic lit,( . iit, 1 8 ► ti as i ► tc,t ► 1l ►e t•for flic Nordi lLidi; ►► .r; uf' Oxli,r ► I . ,1 ►► 18ti2 ltt- c;t ► neAt ► to of

.rcc, its cotttt ►► i•sio ►► ~er. ( ► f' C rc ► ,v lt li ►► d .'. , ill the

lteti ►t•ttt Mini ;,tt•y, ► iit ► ler the l c t ► I ~ ► f' Ilc,n . J . ,5 .clcinul(l) and 1 ► cltl 1tis ,;e,tt. ut ► til l s l ;l, wlie tt tl ► cre w;tKit change (W Dliui ;~ti• ,~, ;tttci, alter » litth' iuterv ;il, he

T

Page 23: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

w ► 15 ►11 ► 1>► ,illtr ►] I'r ►► ~ i ►ir,i,ll ,~rcict,ll'ÿ

îll t,l ► e C► , ►hlitic~ll

lli ► lititl y~. '.1'lli i 1)1 ill~ i llilll to }liy ÀeHCllt l,u5itip1l .

Ife now rel ►reseuts flic North IIi ►lill-- of I.;llt ► irlc ,\Il . 11ç1)c ► I 14

r;tll has (;clt ()Il w c~ll i ► i" 1 ► c► lit.ic ►t'1 litè,,ow illri ' tu his e ll o l'~y ► lll ► 1 l,ul ► luc s's. Ih~ lias won 1 ► inw ily, ; . fi r~t, 1 ►y' g ►~ttill g III) sc~ctiult,tl• clllc s tic)ll~s in the~

, tlll~l til1 llYit \\. ill~ fri v llll`i l ►1' 1),lclc e l• y ► ll ► c ► Ilt, Ililn,t .ll ► , Il lis ill t ; this illfll ► e Ilc'c to c► l ►tttiill 'utlice . I 'lli s i s

. ulll.V Wllilt llluSt,'lil e li ► lu t ► , rgaill It 1 ►ulitic;il ul ► ject, and11 rt c I)uu~; ► 1ll i s ► ,ilc uCtl ►u5e ~~'llu ' llicve. 8 Ilccec ► ird

ill the e Ili ► 1•t . • • .

'I ' lll' l .► l'UVltll ;llll S l`l'l'l'ttll'j' 1s* OIll't)f', the N-81, debater s

ill the I l ►► Il,e, lliw 'r ;t yle 1 ►c~ill~; i•cm ► l,y and lluellt . 01't he tl ► rev 1Ze fi ► rul utvtltl ►cl•y in the ( 44'rv`erllnl e ut, he

►`1wulcs the best, and is the most ►t1t. in ► lefleu ►lilll; tlle"i«•ts ►► 1' liis 1) ► lrt,y:

In the ► i e l ► ,ltcs (,)Il Cullte ► le i'al.tii>li, Mr .' Mcl) ►► Itr; i llliliil -llut s l ►cak lunc•L, only making y o ►nl e rc', lua rlca.u ► 1tli e F l ►rvcllrv ►► C ►► 1 ► 1 ►c,tiit ►~ nl v li l ho rs, l,ut gave his iulitl-v llvr to the re lle lll e . , I I v ,

.► li) ► I 0 lll4,, ► l es ires t o see it,

rau•ri v ,1, fi6 1• it w ulllil .;i ve t ►► the 1Vest ► t, lrt ;i~l ;~ture ( ► ('its ►► %%•11 . •'l'lii'A, ul•, illcl•e,lsc ►1 rc~l,rèscllt .ctiun . in tlle1 ►re r:v ll,t . }ow i ", l a t I l rv , 11"I5 I ►oe ► l the ulijec .,t ul' ttl,l - hisl'flt)1•t`i, il~~ ► lln Wit.l ► tlll` 1•e•i, l)t' the Itl'fÛl•IIl I)7l l •t y ,

cltlrill~; the 1 ► ;lst f`e W, 'l'll e .i f llllte l ►ce ►► f' 111r. ,N lclrull -n lll l ies lllu;ltly v ► ls t

,111 ► 1 Nvc•A of 'l'urullt ► it 1 ►ci ► lt;, of, rc)tll;;e, t;rC ► tit .est, i ► 1lliy r.v ► istit.uellcy, t~•llirll is to the v,lht ( ►t' t,lle r.ity . ..lll , is now It Illllu of' til)1 ► IC 111('7111N , ►1n ► 1 in t}le vigor o f

He was 1 ► c ► rll ila 1S99 , and is , thrrrti,t•c, •1 4y ear,y of' ► 11;c.

The, fi ► lluwill( ; i;l ullc c ►•f Mr. 1\1 ► IC ► i~ul; ►~11'a bQ~stclli)rts ill e~l►culcillt;, eie~livcr~ ►I in the Ituusc, July 11t11,

Page 24: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

mi Mr. 11tr,G i ver ►► 'r ► ► lio.t iuu of 1Vttl t it, of Con tillel>.rr i l ►tl p c 'h'il ► ,tnci,tl ►uül C,'i ►nurlercial 1 ►blic.y of the Mi ►►-i>t ► y%.- • -

.,.

I11' ill III' nl' ► l'r rua ; tll ttllllr,• -,s lili : II,111~1 uP Ilti Iv r Illlllli,• ,1 .. :,•n1I . 1 \t'iIll" 1'1•,11,•1• l'lll11 ;11;1'il ssllll'llt or Il Pull II IItIP A lull ilit'1 f I1'rll•L' lll, w 1 Itlltlnl'1 1111 i" lll" •

Smnl'elilul . u gu luv '111111 titl6•I ; lul•nlll,•r. nl'' Ilu• 10 11-1-411 pal 1v If lunll th\•ul"l•I ► e

11t111'vll 111 11 IluAliull Ilt' vullll' tliitil'11111' . 'l'lll' 1111!lllllt'I• liq' tiulltll 110ll'It, V. l, n

A Inll Inug u,'Iullil•11 a Ilr~lluinl nl, mit tu r,lY 1111' lilrvluu ..1 I11 ;1,•1•, ill II,1• Il,•1 y.hall s111111,'lll\- l'lltl'l'1vl into Ill'.r,Itlüt1u11K Ill lill'lll,l l',ltlilllnll V. nit Ii1 4 ('ullr•ol'1,1-

rtl\'l'l1•11111'1'd,11111l titl'l' \\1'11' tlAl'ii ti1 -Il,l,lill I11111 ill IIIt1t l'11111'-I' . 1111d illg 1

+11 '

llrullllavl 1•II,Ilitinu II111) it g rnttt ulljl•t•1 In t il'1► -- u1111~, . III,u1 I ;1}•in,t th,' IiI urlalu-

tiuU of it 111'\C 011111ir1' ill \Ilrlil .\ Illt•rrl•u•- he nllll,l'1111•r Ill('11111cr .: 111' I!),• lhlrt y .tlllll l'~,II~PI111'll tlr .Il~ttllll il . I 111' lllllt .~l ll, l~~l'} :+'lllllr III ~I11'tl•!l l'l'I~L~ tll~ ~tlvl,i-

lil .<t I1 I) llll,~ itiun I1/ lhv l'IIn ;lv't' ;Ititl• .",,Inll nnV rl•tl,nU ., III' tlull tlt,•,Ilnlll ;liu I i t'tIIv I .un,lnl•t uf tllo Inoullu'r tilr N111tt11 ll~lùt•,l, bill 11 ,lll r:nunll~'' iul,l il ; tltu11i1i1•i,lu, III, cINl .hntr,l tu nur.t,lirt his l'ourse' +Ilül tll ill•l'l'111 tilt' ulurr llirl'"t -rl'rll,ln .~illilil v it all, ,Illiriul Ilual,iun .` III' laid Il~illl . 1111 Ill-I.,4111111 Ii•1•Inlg - tt11li•,•litll; l'11p1'ntll'rllll 11y tlu' l'inulnl't ul' tilt- hull . nll•ulllI'r lA\Im11 .> tlu' It ~t,'rll .llJOllt 1 ► l', tlir ,11611 . 1u1'1111/,'1• lilr ('orl1l\ ;II1, Ill' whil•h 1111iryn .: it l11('llljlt'r . tlln lunitwl 411'nrti h • %titll tlu• Itwuilll'r for Smith l ► x liu•II in Iill' t% ln'k tuilll•rl,lkoll Ilt .'Illut v llw' m + . 'l'luo utrnllue rs 111 the lilllrrnl' ll+u :t1' t A illu ullil,' %t'I rl' ~li,u r l iilNlllull Ino,INUrn tnllll'r i t l•I11tI1L 'l'1,1'ir c nlu• :r ill y( ,1 v 1'll- 11,'I- ~III 1 t11 n % N1•ll II ,lllilitil•nl r+ncriliur ., . 1♦ jlurlios wt•nl, they tcl'l'l' liu• it tilru' l'Wnr1 . 11' tlll't'hul'IV•1•IIIVI, tllrti' uliltllt'hlllle Ill ju~till' tln ,Illlllu•ollt +1CIho g ,ltiutl 1,l' ill'iuritlll'~ ;and lnlillll t\itlt tutu ~thllnl~l.unyuulr p';n• :i Illlt' ll,ul Ilrnululr,'11 •Kt' II, •1!l'l'tlllll' .,v 111' the 4 '1111 Ill 116111 .11 llt' NI11' l 1 lltIJlll'l' (11 I11111,11 4- 11 l't•l1111111 .~ ,

Ilul I )11 1t• tllu ll•t' Iull1 :,Inul• Ilillil nlt~ tll 111•r,ll ;llll' IIII ir li'il'nll,~ iu II1,'Ilul~l~ üull u11Î ul' it, to 114-111l il• s t•1 . ill til,' l'ullJmr Ilrlllnla•Ii . Ilnl i11 (llu' rIJ11 tli•u=

tlll+ }tl'lll'1•,1111' 1'llllll' tU 1111' allililrll'l 111 ' 1111 111, lu 1 tlll>l' l'l' (111' j;l'oill nllj,y•1 .,; 1111 %'lutai in \ io ► v . 'l'lu'v lul•t \t'itti tllr 11,•11•g u1 c ,: Iilllit Ihl' Ilml•r l,t'41\111,v . Ilt' l,jul' .

•I11•r, nn(l III' ulu .,l -I11Y iu,ju .,lil•l' .tu tlll nl, tu luis I,Ill~lv'~Ill it'1 1~~III,1} nl .:,Iwl,t4,tlll' UIr11111 c P for S1111111 t ► \lil1 11,4 \l'oll, llo) l,•li c \'I ,II 1141 (l ~, rl•u1111 1v ,/f Il i llllil• lul•11

in,Iny 1•ulultr* v

.' ► 'l'r,u•tlal in~n In,lrl''lllltlr .:t ',ulll IuIU'iutil• ' Iliril th,in 1111',111•II'•lCnlr .~ Ili (llill /vlll\'l'lltiull, ill Ill'1 k inl,! it "I•ilv 11J1' I il r 1h1• I•111111'l' gr u\, - r111111 , 11t ul' -

Illr~r 1 Illunil'~. \ Ai'hl'Inl' \\;1s nllo tlll'll t \ Ili,•il 1 ' 1'rtl v1llllllill,•II Ill 11 ','v r1ti1•i s li l 111' lllir 11\\'ll lltu•litlliU•ltt 111111 Ili' 1111' llr« d Ilulil ni ' lill• 1•ui'uuil• ;, ullll 1111 '

uwlhl'r 1•uuutry , 111111 un ttu' whllll' ro j,41h .cIt u,liailu'i ,Illllrllt ul li',nil Ilu'lll .111' N6 /11111 ullt s U y tllltt tlle 1711•t1111orA 'if' IhP tvlnirlltilln Ilill huit Illilik tlll•y1•uulll lil'r•suuull, v 1111c1' ilnlli'llvl•11 Ilnrl +,ll' it, Ilut ,1111 . ► ' nluuth :+ hall lnl,~l•11 Ilil,l

til,'rl' NVil ., tiuu•'Iilr lvllnu•r+lnll tullrl' Ilitltln'l' rolilv-linu, ho w,l-4 ;utililvl tlntt

Illl' YI11•[1 .ItrC mIIV it Nvi't' mnl' and 11 N'l't ;t' litir i•llllllumlli ;l'1,1',,Illfl nllill}( 1•huilll :

111141 Illliliil,ur: . Itn1 it lul't •utnt+ Ilitlii•ntl ;ok in Cil' Il/itlr .lnll~inll .~, J'JII'Nova si•uliu II'I;isluture Ilr .;ittlll'll to u,lullt it tlml thw lu'llllll' 111' Now Itluu ; .t► •il•R, when nlljivnll•Il tlr, 1'0f11,t•tl lli us-l•Ilt to it and 1•ulllilllvl thi' ~ilt'rruhu'uttll the hnnlk ul' its Illllllml'llt~. It 1,1'l' ;uuv nl'cl•,wll ;t' tll llu :tlume tlll' liunl1t11rti1111111' tllr cmuli'lll•r,ltilltt llolil'y rnnll Illr cutlitilill lilu,ll'lll+ll• tlll'%• 111111 I11

i

Page 25: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

rnrl;t• ,ril , the gu\•l'rlunrllt '4 of* tht, t•oI1nUt• lor,l longer tilne th ► tn thty hntl nlt-tiril .Itt•tL• 11'llilo \tuitinl ; ti,r tilt- n",'nt t 1 1 thv lnt ► riti ► Ile provinces thry hadtu tl v ; ►I \\•itll Ille ill ► Ilult ;iul illt,•rt• ..lv of, tllt, t•uilutY}', null rt't•rt!ut•t,^ to tllt lsI ;t lltr Iluuk li,r t ht• m o 11,► s t ~ t' ;u ~ .tt „ultl , ;ht~\\ ill W hut ,;llirit 111111 huqt• theylulll tl,•nlt \titll Ilu lu . 'l'ht, I ► t\t• ; ut' u 111" Irro \•ihtv' hutl lu'rll l'utlitit•tl,i ► nl ► urtnntInutlititvllinlls wl ► tl+ ; in thn s t , nl , tilt, titht•r. \u };r,•tit . intrre;t \;•uv l uo};It'ttotl .k IIt•r it \iu 4 fi-Il ,'\ pt'tli ► •nt ill vit .", of, tilt, lrr o l inl,li• loss All, thl' l'uite tl s t1Ut• n

dut u lr5• 1 ll, 1 itltl not iu ► llt'ril, it . t1t• v ,tur A l+ Ihw ro had hmult dilli,rencrx u1 '

nl,trkt•i, 11 l .,•n,l t• o Ilnni .niuluV IN to tilt' 11'oa Inllit•N luul t l lh,•r m mtlu'ru l'uun•of, 11 ~ 1 .4 tY, ► Itiu v rlt 1u,1 -w t - rtuil ► hu\\• tiu• r ► ,•\\•,Innrkt•ty IniKl ► t be ulu'nutl 1 ► 1l .

II o irltv a Ili•rt•,I Illo t•huirnun ► ,:hill or llu t,nilnli~~inn . Ilt' ti•II that \t•hilcIlln,•li n . v 111 ililitrnl ;lti o l ► rt• spmt'tin}t trntle tlutl uu•un . t,t' t•x toullin}t it cunltl III!pro" ► is~'t II', l }trt l;lt h ► ,turr tt~lls to I,t• t,~lt~lu',1, n, t \•t•r~• 1un};nitit+ut rt• "ult~+tu lu• t~l,lu1n~,I l'ruu .► Illi '.4 t•slll'tlitiun, ;uul li,••' itlo>t tlu•rc ttuv s t,nu• llt•rr+ulu ► I 0,4l,l Ill, rllll . 'I Ilt,a rt }ki,+ll~ \~t'rt' thrt' ;tt~ u ► ',I tlli+ y tvtr \\•ith t•Iu,ll'rlt, as \t•l'II as0 I 11 t'y Il k t I,t•4 iut•i ► It'I~lul to, t ► ul,itvtl t linlntr~. 11 v \t•Ilv ri'Inrtunt Ihori -Fort, t ogo) Illltl It't \t, N'11 ;11 I ► t i t'ullatlt•rl't L lllo l'N illll l ltl•lilllt 't 111 til7t lll'l'1 e , bill, Y it•lllotl • L titht+ Ill-gent lit,i'aul s in~► , 1(ul t ►Ill~t• t,l' his t~llue r tlllrrnKut•~, hut tuf tutu lllulnllortill' 5,rull ► l 1~xIi,rtl . l t~ nutlt'l'stu,nl \t•hrn lit, It'll that lht' IIIIIit!t• td'tho lul+t\\•onllll he ul ► til ►ut'tl luul ull Ilur .yilllt, ottliw~s of diKaenaun n\~uitlt~tl lu+t\\•IV'rl tht+tlilli'rt'nt 1~k ' +N•tit+ ill the t•,t;tlitiun, lin• thpy liutl 111t th,tt, h,tvink It l!rrut \\•urk to

tqliuiun \t+llit•lt had ltvl, ill r+tinu, instuuupN, Io' IIu+ .INlslllometrlt'nl of fiction ; ill411111'l'rt tul•ulltv!sKltt11N t111 ItIN, Nitle or lllt! Ittllt'1•, ül ► tl Ili) Atm- IIII11 I•pll flattat•1 Irnl• ;1 in In•g int ; 11 ► k ,td It tll~ll* v on hi .t t't,llt'n}truu+ thon thv llu' ► 1 ► llrr tilr Smith(I\ lil rd, lla hntl inNiylotl tliut tlu,i' \\•t•rt . Il~tuntl to luukicull rtnullroull :yrr{not•t•s•urt• ttl l'nrll' thrt ► nlcll lhr hll :+illrsr, whit•h t,.ttulll Huit lit, lltWtlltlut'd, untiltJuv grt'nt l'Inl ln•61lusril to thl•u ► +t'Ictv+ huit lotit uttniuwl . • 1C'hltt mas lli,tsin-ln-kt' I114 .11 wht'n ill I,ou,lon, and nbollt t(A tll•luu't thont•t• 1111 lus IIIIN;tillll liirIllr \1'r .:t lu,lilN, ttt ,Pl' in tllt, 7i m ns u lrleKrl ►nl lu ► n ► tllnt'iulC that Ilun . {it'nrhtrIh•uw1 ► had rt•tirt•tl Ilu ► u thl' ll„\•t•rIlln,•nt . Ilr mut Ilult tlnl' 'ln thI+ nlrri't"'itI ► t• Colonial \liliktrr, who \\tl-+ Illutilt srttinl,r mil ti,r O%li,r,l, and ntolrlytl 1 ►kcoach lit nsIc hilll if lit, knl'\\• \\•hut it li ► tvlnt . Ilr t'l'lllirtl 1 ► ;~ tlitl ntit, lait hadlol ► t•il Ih14t 11r . l,+u•tlt\•i•II Iln(l it ltri\•Ittt\ tt'!t'}cr,uu oit tlu, alllijrct . Nono hadI)t'1'u rrt•i'i\•rtl . \lr. 1';u,N4•II, \tilh nu littlo nnxit•1y, trvl,o'lt .\vIlnl• 0l,01 this\ct,ultl hu\•l' titi t•i, ► Ilivl`~ tti,m :'il•~\\r \t~t'ri~ to Illst+ titis grt~ut nuvt, ► n•l' thruuKhAll. . Itrt~\elt•K t•uur~t' . lis (11r . 1tt•tlollHnll'K) 1 ► nl.\ct'r was Ilt• hopt'tl tuut, tuullu' lironliist•11 that, at Car 11m hi-+ rtmtlut•I \t•nN 6mt•t'rnt'11, It r:hl,llltl luot loutl tor+lu•II• ►t rt•sult . III',Ntt'rlt ltt tlhl• 11't•st, lrlilit' c luul }nlt tllruuKh tilt' \\urk to hetlout, tll,'rt' 11I fast ny I ► „stlil,lr,5intl lit tlm+ tir :t Ilu,lurnt lit' li'It. hLA t•u111d !n•o-(lt'rly Irll\u lit- rluno Illu•k Ill l' ;ulmin . 11'llrll Il(- Klot ht'rr lit, Ilvu•nutl that, thuhun . l'u~hun~lt'r-l~t'utv ;11 hlutl tlrt•lint•tl fit IipII„~v tlu' tom .;e of* tllt, lnt'rrlht•rlitr?+t,nth (hlitrtl : that ho .ttitl nnlhhink tht'rr \6•rr uuY :nltlit'it'ul ltr„lultl :l lor hiIAl'l'sihnntitm, tlntl that it t•ullsillvr,tblt' tnuulror tll' Int'Inbri•+ of' tht' Iilptvul lutrlt•\\•l'rt' tll' the ; ;tnlo tillil ► i,lli . Ar► uthr ►• It•utliuu lut'mlirr of' the lutrtl' hntl ctll ► -

,tzrl ► tt'tl to till tilt' place \'mvttrtl In• Mr . Brown Ilr Ii,lultl llu• rt' :;i};nntiim llutlIii-vii titllo\ct•tl by rvu ►urkr ill the journal tv,ntlvllt'tl lly tht+ u ► en ► In'r for SouthlWirrd, not otlly 11g;lin-A tilt- lliuir+trr t,l' l'in+lut•l' but tl ►n l'u~tnut~ti'r-lirntrltl,c ;tlt'nl ► Itt'd cithrr to hrtrnk ► Ip tht, l'ultlijiwl fit- cause diziunitru in tilt, rtwkK tll'

Page 26: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

t a v

R

117 ,

the o ld lillt'rlll ptllfi', ill t'ttu w tlllcut e of \\'llirh uult!111

rn};rt', s NO lir('I ► lttutlt,in lur,luq~'Int'nt~ lt t (' s tnllli ;h It ll('t\• journul in tll o illtrrr .<t : o 1" th v p ,lrl Y , n p -h o l d ill g tlle t'ir\\' ., of liu'nllu'rv t'l'Inuiniu} ; in, tilt- (' o ulitiun, uil i t thut lu'iu "i`,I~1'tilSt'll tilt', t111' IIM'llll i t'l' lill' South (1\ti~l'll \tll~ Itl'o INtr i ' d to Illlll~li'l' ll k t'tll~iltll

Ilutl uutlutUlttvl nhilitit 's t'runl lhu 111t o Ar tu,:n~' II jnnr1111I . Ili- (.11r . 11 ;u'tIu1 ;~1,1I1){t onK the t'tlrli(' .a ollpnitiluit}' of rt•l'inE( tilt' tlll'lnlli ' r lo l• `onlth l W i l ril ; lit,II! lNtlllllt'tl fl' o I11 tllt\' ('UII\'PrrlltUo ll l\•Itil lll ..4 l' o 11 .N I'l'1'Uli\t' tVo llvi !!!11 l ' : ull tilt,t; 1111jt'ot, l' x t'l'llt iu tilt, nw.t Ht'Itt'r,ll trrlu s , lnltil lit, 111111 tlun l ' ao , un o l Ln1 l'ulland l'l',ulk ('xp luuutiouN \\ilh that htm. lurirll lt'r . l'nrt lit' that I ~ n\cr=llti~~u\\'n ~4 t i f a('unfi(It'ulilll t•luu•11rtt'P, but lu' Ii'll Ill, might sn .v this, Ilw h 4111 . lu~'In .

i IyrrtlrSt fit tll ( ) \ Ford i l i t l uut nll\i S t' I l i u l ' 1 0 I f I IIut\• II ix I 'snn11I IV ,111AI To?~nl .'l'hinpa Iltltl luLt'n rnvh n1'41111-:;i' rinrti his (\lr. Brinu',.) rt',i"nlltiurl n-A torrnllrr it n(lci"Illlt' he r:hullltl comtinutt iu.111o tvlllint't . ----

11r. Ittalwv (ilUrrrlllit ing .) -\u, I nw\t'1` g,m' ull\'it r tip , Inll ill ill. go "111to l'itht'r of Ilw lilu'rul n1r1u1wrr+ nu\t• in Ille vnl,iut't or tu tilt- Ion . Irlr'lllberlirr Il,lnlilt~m .

\II'. SIAI'1l1lCt ; .\L1, Wlitl II(' so 111111er,loulI 111o I1'11411' of 1111, l'ull\'l'l' Illiull, Ilil~ l

vt'rtl ;inly thlmhltt it. th(-' tlyt ►' of 111r. L'rt~t\n, tus it Ilvulin g nlolnllt'l' lit' Illeliht'l'nl lllrrt}• in the (:wlliut't \\•Iu'n )l(~~ j~~itlr~l it, tit };i\'l' lul\~it~r to thurn \chuInuit ('t~I1KOn1('ll to st~~\~u wnll'r tuul (1ifh Ilinl in it, Iit' ululerstooll tlu, htm :Ilu' ►nlrt'r to sit}' ihv \\•w& tllliltt llrt'llnrt'd it, nllllllort IlltA Ntl\•vrlullt'ut t11' l'outp'11-('rlttiom . Ill, ( M r . \t,u'tlonll;;lll) I ► utl Ili•ott'A('tl nHnill>;l (lu-('nluïv ul' Ihl' G luLt'

nn•likely Ili rlvulrr it i ► Illm-+ailllo tu kerll the lilli'rul 11 : ► rty lor011vr until attl•fvtlvruliorl n•tt4 st'('nrt'll, uutl l'rul('ttvurtvl to itullrrsa otklht . h~nl . Im'nlln'r, nl .u,that II' ho (ulln to l'tu'lilllll('nt and rtlisc'tl the 1;111 ('riv%uf rxtrn\•ugnnt'l' ; d'l' .,Ag+tinwt luinipit('rrt, \thil'll he llutl nl1nntltnu'(1 tlln•iu}r tilt- tinlo Ill . \c,la ill lln,

Ininislry, tlwt r, ► ui v l'\'ily of this kiun or tht' t1t'.<tru(•tiom tll' Iht+ (,lll liht'rnl lu ►rty,or ut' it coalition ntv'r-sur\' to uttuin l'ullli ll('rlltion 11111A rt'on11 . 'l'ht' ( ;h docrIllttl, unit il t'rt'entlv, lnu•-111'tl it Inort' Inollvr,t1r :1(1i1 fililtvr comy.s t'. Itut so snonits th(- tiluult•t± lui,llislt'r Its tilt- ort;,ln tut (Ill . }ciItt'rnnll :nl hlltl ulinollnt•i'lI his

butltil't he (\Ir . Brown) llu(1 \tilll trll that Ilu\it'r of th•('I :lill,iliull, of t\ .Ilirll llt,NV 11 .14 sit }tl•l'nt it Inrla('r, Ilrw'I,liluvil his lr,tilily to tl .ini'toy .•, lulll lu,t yilalt

hntl filll4 ttctvl it nll bY tilt . u ., .•,lillt . lul .avl Ilp iu it dirl't t\ote 4 it' \\•iult tit' l'onli-

tlt'il(fit intt'nilt'tl if pn:,ibit',tlttlri\'v InilliAt'1:.I•lY1lu Ilutrr . IIl',l`6rtmt' .\\4ml4lnot ('ttllst'llttvt tu lnu• ;Ilt . It t•uw' 'u Iltn'ill}c lirr it-A ('lli't•t the 41k ;ullltiun of

tht, uld lillt'1-111 pli, rlyol' l'llper ('nnntlll .'•'l'llo Ilnn . inelllluY ourght l'i1114'1' 141'

)1,1\'i' tll,st,lilu'tl li' o tu :;u('h tlplit'ition or ntlciscil thw lilli'r,ll rt'ln•t•<l'lilutivvs ill

t!I(` Ho\'l'I'1111It'lll to l'otll'l' . Ili' tnlla'tl ltliolll 11c111t ;t'1 .+ to ('I~Illt'~1~'l'nli~~ll . _Tho

('otn'st, lnlrt;ned II}- th(' hmn . ult'lnluer was nlomt' (•t1I1'al ;tli'd Ili tmllnlllprr or

in(1i'liuitt'It' tit'Iny it . II' th' "I f \\'lillt tll' t~onltitll'n('l' \tt~rve t~nrrir~l, lhol;+

IIIUa lu' l'itht'r u}n'ut'rtll ('1 ~Il ~~r, at lt' ;141, tilt l'Irrtiun ul' nli,lnl1rr,: 1 41 fill

tha''r('+ts ► n'lirtuch('s . \1 lu l'0nltl tt'll ill 11w nu'utltinnv \t'lull ntv•illvnt,+

uliHht oot'llr I 11'hnt thl'('llivcl uli} Ll lnv il ► Nova Ft'olitiatmÎ \l'\\• Ih•tllwwivk .'

All ol'tlt(' Nl'l'ut st'ht'll!v of ('outi'tlvr ;Uion or rwll ilul~urtluu'l' tcu~ mott• lu'ti,m

th(. Iltmse . (1111v (lu' tlltl'stiomof tht' tli,trilllltiuu ul' stvlt,~ was yct kciit Itni-k .

It \tt1,4 (if mt rrnl iufln('nt'e un tllr };culrcll tim' ;tiou, ,Intl it lutltto, to Iltk r :1+ily

r('mcllit'tl luter if iuly l'rrtrr c+houltl rn•('llr llotv . A1'ill it Icwu'ral v1o('timn or

prorogation now h('lp l ;ullfOl('rutiun I Or \\'ill the lo,t . .n}tv of Illn Inulgt't,

Page 27: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

,~l lii'Inl' iujlllt it ! 'l'hl r~ cl~ulll Ilt' 1 ►ul,nl':1 )III uiu1l=-th:lt unt thl' li,\'i•1•11-Inl'llt, luit thl• nll'nllll'r . un tIli• opposite ~jllo w Itrl' I,nttin g, tI`Ir l'7111 s 1' in 1,1'1•il .II1, \\-l,ltlll • ;1}• it li'\t• \t•i,l•Il . rl . .au'l-lin}~ it s( 'itl'uu' a, liuu'h 111) , jl'1•tl•ll tL, il . thci«ul' t11'1•tn•l't•nl ;t• II> ulli~:tin " fila' liilulc~ . 'l'hnt \\la .: Mill nulll•r the cvirI s i/ll•rn-flull lll II11' (i11C1'NI1111'llt : 111'11 tlll' :+l•l11'111P 1\'7I~'NIIl1I111111'll : its it \\•ulllil 1 t ,~ i n

- Inl' l•uln•~r' III ;1 tl'\C If71~••, tlll• 11i111 . 1111'üll,i'1N .ti,1' South (lxl,l .l and ('flili~l-'!il ;l\, it'!1l, C!\1 lhl il ;Iltl ntiull lYn•lit•Ill :n•Iy tll lllll-tinu .; ut' 111 ;11 kJ nll . \1l,alll lI1 :1\i' :in l,ll!i„1•tllnltv of, llkl•Il ..an : and ;it•inl; tliril• \il\\, nf,un it to tlli'Ill I lla' . lu tlll' ► nl• :Intinll' tlll• lMilt• Ijn~•~lil,tl l';lii•I\'~111'li,l•r lhl' 1•u11 .a11PlY1titln ll tt .Iu' IIl'n4i, W,1• tll :ll nl'tIll . tnl•.itl . It l nul~l nl,t hi . 111'rlii•11 that ill \\•I1l'rlt!lr lirr l'nl \lilliq l'r i,l', .I'in,lnl i' illt m lnl l i i i ► 1f11':I .In•t~ ill lil\'l,r of, fil! l'ïrll,r„~, •llutil~ .: !Il ' lt•iUl (if s llil•itic', ilU' Iwll . Int lill,t'r !i~l ~tilnllll UXtilrll Ill ulnnll vil it ,1. •

•'•Ill,jlll'li,ll '~ ln ;III, lu'A i1111'1•t•as l,t fit(- (•lltll)tl,\•, 11) 14 1 il -s Il!,IIi7 :1'll Of tllUrl' I11'llJ-

1. 1•il,li' .. \t•Ilir11 ilu• lilll'I11 llll}' lll' l'Illlrl• ('11117111ü l,l•Illi• .a'll 1n,11111tuIll . Now\l•lil•u tlli~ ( k ,\l•rlnul'lit . \\.ith tlll' N1nU' 117,11 . r;~~lltllinnn as 11iui .~lt'r of* l'in ;lnl•1• ,I r l :Ill •l ,. \\;!lil II Ilr Il :ul .ull!1 il tl(I~ l ',~LI;1inl'yl, liwl:ins til thl' hni' inlivr,a .

• ut'•1111• r~~inltl ;t• ,I1111 tllt' i'~;111•ril'nt•l' \\•Ilii•ll 11l' i~utl llt Ill . 1• liai ill•II Ili Pi'll ill Illl •11111111117 . 11'i111 , ,1I I I I' flll' tilltllll'llll Illlilll'S 1 T t!Il' 1,\'llll•11•,11111' ( !u\t'll \1'llll ilprulKl ;itillll IlI rl-l!ill•r tlir tarit), \\•hil•II liait Irrl'i1 i :uuw tl lrYl il llurl Ir 1~ tl lui l

r I I•) ~~tqltli s ldlllllfll( th;lt, tlll't' hallIiJUr; 1•l~lJl~l•I~lli~il lùr IIIn1 lirillril,ll' il .' tf :o,luliill• I11' It~\~'in~ inl~tl,rt~ \t•hit•h intlirir .lullrln~ nt \tu~ :ululll . l'lil ;\ l lin

.,} tu,„11~ ll"I thi' (iuill'in lltllll ri-spi-cl , ti~ll llall, uni lll<rl\' tu•lll'u1'l' m) iil,illl'lutl .~ to the Illtl'f,~ .<t < fit' tlll' l•u111t1 \•, tllil ftfil'~' vole d :I : ;linsl it, lnul tllo Ill,n . Inrluln'l' lilr tiinltll 1 ► ~ ;i,rll, ulll'r } i\ in}: ,t~r1771 luilli~ Ii~nlr .. kit I,ru\1• tlll' Iln~t,nnlllli,~. Ilf'tllc Ilrl,l~u :aln l,l' Ihl+ \lilli ..t~llil' l'illiuil•l•, \\t~ut l,fl tu ( .1

.iti1'i s l', il ;'il tthillc„thr ~<II1l'uli tlll'll !Irt,lntt'll :

'l'ill >1 \\rl't' 1!Il Ilull . )tt•Ilill'111 ;U1'v \\'nl'll~ 111 bis Ir\\'ll s Illlilll ;ll,1• nl'lll~ rli4'i•1•II t111(llut lul' ;1,lut ; I'Illt hull . 1 ;1•Illlrllli III (1fl• . ItruUtl) \rl•Ilt rnll Ill l•1•iliPil• tlll •l\ l rill llruvi,illll• of, t lu• t ;u•ill' ut } ;1•l' ;I 't 1l'll} t 11 . N'~~ill tllll,l•l,\ inl ; l/t ,,,1•1•ulu„v,tllntil's, llo lll'nuunl•l'll tllh ',Ittclnlkt, of' thr In'lli' :lu ;-lit'flt~rill (111• . l~ ;llt) It ,

!I . I~ItI~\\ \ ( Illll l'flllillll~~) r ;llll !Il' \1 ;1~ l':1111,'l' ;1<Il lli~11141 ,11 llll' ~lilll'llll'lltIlru ll jll •t u N\ 1,\' Ihi' lU,n . ;''~~I1111'nl :ln. ll \t :1 : tlul (lll' ,rrf ,rrfl,rt/,1 lilinl i!,I1 ,1~, \t'llil II In' tluil nl,jl'i Irll in I~ .~a, lilr I11• had nl\t~,l}', Ilt'an in I :Itvlr it, hut

.\t~!Uit Ili• i!ill u!IIIUW~ t\•il . 111v (lll,ilc' of' il,lllitil,ll l,rUlln<i'll n11 Illat iq•t•n~iu11 .~ll'. ( ; \I~'l' 1111,11," 11t his 1111'1111~Î1' i1 " 1 1 , 1'l'l'llt s I ul'tll,ll t11111' 1Y71 s IIIUIi' 111 .~1rl11•t,and hi, rolY,llo•lii,ll \t•il . tll ;ltlll'',\C;1 .. iPi'iltl\• Nlu•Ill . i , l'tl ilt tlli' \•utl• ( h ;ll liill ltllrn t ;ll,'n lllill•i', \t•hl'n Itli' Ilnn . Ini'Inlli•l'.; fill• ~liutll .( ► X Ii,rtl and ('hlltl'ilu ;aiu %•

Nv'1•u 61111111 i,l!iu;ril to tlliill; s \tI117•ll for 1'l' ;11's Illl,t' Ilall IIIYo li• .~~1'i l(~I1 ;11', llt ;ll' . )

I'. ItRU\t N l!i•IlUtt•il t111' Nt :llt'I~tnt tililt IN had \.litl'll 71L;t1i11a 111•illt'illll'a\1'llil'li h . lllnU• 1;1117!7711•tl'll .

\Ir . \I \1 Illtt'u .\t,l .-~1'i+ll . Ihl,a'tlirfulli'r~lil'tj1i . Ill,tt,l'•\\•hu \rl•1•l' ilu•n1Lr1'sul'dt ill I~:, :) t\'1111111, fit, t i,iu:a• . rl'nll'hll,l'I• \CliiJt liait tlll'11 till<l~ll l,lilrr . 11 \t :Inyllill• Into th ;lt III I . tiil• ;:,~Ufll (l~lillll nnll ('lultl'ull ;Itil~', ;tjlll l'IÎt I'r :tthi, lai•tt~ll in tilrrt iul; fit t•1,n11111•tinn tilt- mrl' :It liulil ;\• \\•itll tllrnl, diii ull!Iru\rhuui•fl fit' \ll• . liült'v I :Irill' If,, h ;ul rrti'rl•iii•o III lift 1 .11/on nr Ilntil 's , I,uI 1h1•\• •tuf iii il} ;iina it .' (l'Li•i'nl 111111 I•lu••ht •- \ I'

1 • ~tin171uril . (fil . file il . nil'llll„'1 li,r sl,llth 11xliil'tt rl•<ialvl (lia' uh iiIn'l', nlthnll .-, IIil› tlriul'i!,It' wav lnll' \t•llit•11 ho final ti,l' ' v l• ;u, llluti a il ti, lil\l,l •~

Page 28: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

~11l ► •

fur<•e the \t'hltlc+ trnlli, uC tlli . c c•nllutrt- into it c•h,tnnel at fit(- l•s 111 •1 1 >l• ,lt' Ilre ;lk_iug tlu\\'n all the Px i .tinR clnlulu•rt•i,ll nrlulrl•nil•nt .llt' tht• t•nl ;utr}-, iullt,th,ttW ithuut t•\'en n w t•t•k', \curnin ;: : he ritlil•Illt•cl the Iillillz,~ s eule ut' \tr liait llltsnp trs luul tt•a: ; as it tlinl .y c lluth for rtl s ing thl• lllttil•v oil what If(, hinl Sl•11'ndlllitletl to Ltt the dlt•ee ss ,u'iev u1' lit 'e . . Ilt• ntl,irkrtl the (1111 Y titi Iluitl; :, and

. 1 l•hnr}(Pll the nlllllini " trnti" ll \1'ith ntt (lit il,tilll(,11 y tlly il; Ill•N' Ill~la,lr!r tllllt- lillIïPR• :p ;ther ., thoir : .'l) l1eY rt•nt . on In'illtial ;C Inttiori7ll ., IY.i/(1 tllt•ir Illqil: inlllurl .tlult , Ili , ttllt tilt, clitfu s inn llt'kncl\,'It•tll ;l• . He ai-Wa•, trlm I- l}'nv ;liu s t t~lr tlntt ,ull `1P1•) nfllt irllil as llttltt•ri111 ." if lli•(•till!( i71t'}(el y tlll• IlJnllllflt c tluinr; illtl rras llt'tltt) l'1'u\'1111•l' . llP *llt'g lvl 1 -al'lll• s tI1' Ill] llll• Ill l ll~l' lllt' tl l lllr;t•l' Ill tlll I~rl'llll'l~-

•'c•ity 'l'roti t y trtn t•ulunl e luv inl! ,} \t',il' i gr,t4n ,t tilt- tlalle I,y 111 v .IIuIL l,u,,untl\\utnlll Illt \\itll 71 \1'nl'nl „nlll,l•ill to t110 IIItII sP t

( *l lul(l• 1 ► l) Av .itiljly•t l i t '

n\t•t•t•ltin}; rt•trt•nt•hul cnt Ll•li,rr t o nsitll•rin g \t -111(i ut ."' ltnrllt•11. ;lluulll 'lu,ilnllua•ll (,)If the people ." 11'ell, tlll•a• l,ninf,<, tir in,ln y 411' t,lll•In, at all v \-c ul " .tu \t'llll•11 the llltll . g l'lltll•lllnll 111';_0ll sui-If ~ll'llllr; ulljl•t•llnll ; 111 I` .,;I, \\l•l't• + 1 \ 'tll# llrl~ltu~itiull, Intrlt' .nllillitllvt I1y tlll• llu\ l•l'uull•Ilt I 111 l• rlnum l - ll, ,ulll ,rl t-tllt+ Illlll . " t•lltlttlllnll tiltlllll it Ilrt• c .~s ;11,1- to lllllln :r 1111• Illl•,1 s 111'l•, 111 v•1 ;11'lllh it Il lI,o inttllltllrttnle ;ultl iulllrlllll•1•. (Ilr,', hltr . 1 'l'llen tilt, Iti m . rl•iltlt nlnli illtli s r•lll•l•rh InA Ilil;llt ltn tllea , rl .~ullllitm .~llrtl,trltl that ho „ m llll tll , l l,l -w illiug lu't[jüntl ill tllt• "hot- :4 tll' llhl• l'ilrult~l• M in k tt•r null dri •t•ulnl• r c : lu,n A ,ll•liq' Ilillulit• y to Illi• 114-o llll• llt' l'lllu•r I ;In,lll,t 411. '111v rt•t~nu tl Irrtrl,l• . , 11 ;•II, lilit (\lr . 1lu0 lnl;nll) t•tluld say lit that was, tll,il lu• tlill Ilut li,•lii•t,• ILl• llun .gentlt•ninll rt•lirt• .wcut c tl Ilie o r l ? ltilli F m,; llI' the grilt IiluR,ll l, ;ur l}' tlt' 't ;llltt•r l'ullnlltl . ( Lund ~Ili•l•1 :~ . j

^It'. l 1 lt(1\1•N Ct'J'1' t•\l'IyPlll~' l'u t' to i111lIPl• ,4 i the Il Ill , t•, liltt hi s

clrn\\ notl nulitl luull l ri~ ~ l~l' " Ihlllv ." . 'At r . 11 .\c w lt't,\t .l,-'l'lltu'l• \t,l, llnt~tlll•r I,l,inl in tlll• llrnllll> u ll i ;u'itl'. to w lli c ll

th v (Illrl . };enlll•rll ;ul al ."() ul,jt•l , tltil . IIt• , lliil not Iltlulll• .Ilull lilt• l,t•,~lllt• Ill'lill g lLUlll \\'t,lll d rr gnttl til\lirtlllly thP u11111•tUon ut' IIIIIiD, tlll ul,lll ill~ll•tlirt•l l}~lwtl~, Itut Iht• hun . I ;ontll•In,nl n .kl•ll \~'yhA,ll \enulll thl y think t 11 ' tour illllwiny;llutil• s lln Innll~' nt ev .,nrft .lll' lili - t,l ~t . on Iluln', t• o rll . IIItIII r, t ht l ;,• luliuu~)nntt,llnut,t t•\v•.rt'thiu g thnt l•ntl•rt•ll illttl tilt- t•ttnalnllllilm 411 ' thl• uul~ .,,t' tfir .people tut' titis (•ulllltl;\' ? 'l'llt' Illl . }!t -111 l 4 •111,111 \1',1 s lll' 4 •ulll' s 0 ult l illayl Ill 7111thtc.:u tn m •v, nnti titnl•iotl lirulllo in I :ug l,uill lll lie al t•uu c t•rru•tl . ,ll,l,ut t11t•tu,@ iltl alunit (lut, iutt•ntnl c t•tlntlllly pwll•rnlly , that lli el,ulr it !If(- }rrlmnll 411 'cvtnlltlnillt, lu•lvlil "t Iht .a• inllltla . \\ltl~lt uut rtiri\•r tllt•ir 11111 lrO \•,11 . 11'l•ll,\chnt tlill the I :rllrli .h publie ,trt• ,iltllltt t ;l x t•v llll

kul,~ l•,1 t 1 ll curlt uli l l ullll . r V

llnttu'nl Itrlttltlt•ty in this l•,ûllltl ;t• t (Ill•,u•, lltu) 11"t• \t•ere l,l'wlutrl', it ,l st•t• ss tif mir wnnt ,4 , ul' ne,u•I y itll (Ili ., nrlit•Il• .a ntt•ntiullt•ll . 'l'hl'• ilnlnl..itilm. ul'tlutil•R nll .nl tht•11t \\'utlltl have little u ll o- tt ullllll their In•i ce , and Iluo llrt•Illi,u't•irt•Itln•t ;iu c t•v nutlt•r \rhit•II tht• ;tlrru g IUil - r ► nt' the It,•t•iltrut•ity 'l'l'lltt- nnltutllv,r rt•c•t~ut l'\' enta hall ltlnct•tI Ilu t•ntnUl;y lin(l, in tht - o l~iuiltu ul' tltutitt\-t•rillill•Ilt-n1a11 lit) Irl•lirtt•tl it \tntll,l nl,lt III, tltr tlllinittll c,l' Illt Iltllilll _.ju,lilit•ll tlu• ilulm;itittll 411 ' it I;nlnll• llllt y to Irr o lt ;t't ( 11t, llrrnlnl•l•r l in IhnProvince ut' v u;u:v };ruin . . , litr \t'llil•h they luul no litreign Ill-in',llt•ar .) He llt•lic•\- t•tl tht• mr llutit•s tll Itt• ui•c t•,,+ ..Z ut ;t' in`tht• position in ullü•h lilncountry was tllut•tvl, in c ull~t ttuout l o l' I lit- tuc ti ou tllnt had luv•n t,tkl•n Ill•t mllits lintit s , und to file rrli,rn ► Iruty l i t' l'ltller l',ulncl,t lie \% . ,l, rcatlY to I, lit'c• tht t

to

Page 29: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

tllc'rc'ün't•, to rc 'c' it -S nrl' (' ;•ftll, :ïul tlluY f'lt that tlu'ir c uu~tilnc llt + tt•rre of

the ~nnll' c~lciltil~u . Holding tlli~ alc - tic•l', llc' ruicl, III . 1111d hi ., rc - ti i rnt l ullcvl} ;nc'•

M crc' c :lllc ..il lllcicu, in ui•ilc'r to I,c•l~p Icacc' with tll t ' nl v nllu'r For Suut,ll l) .% toril,

tcc llvl v l' thl• ( ; u \ c . rtltuc'tlt . \tllu . :c• 1 110 il•y tllc ii ' ulcllrc IN c•cl, tc ) t!cll mil• 11itu ill hi s.II ilc,

i• :nh ttllii'' ihc hinl . tuc'lullrr for ticmth tlsticnl 11u11 rti,rll ill tllc ltl :lltl'r .

(11l' :n, hc' :u, ) ''hc :c' tl'rt' tltl' ttt'c~ rc'ut Ii•Ilturc• s lc1'thc~ tltl•i11' nlum «'hicfi

flic IiU11 . rl'lrtl l 'lllall llllll tlli~ll ' ltl it 11(' ci ' s-:I1•t' lll tll l ' 111tP1'('5tN of i11P ( .011110w,

its he (11r. lturclunr;111) Inn~t :t~ Snluc•, it, jc~ilt it) fit(- attc'nll~t to llc'livtt this

( cn rrnulc tlt, +litcl to llc'Îi ;lt tilt ! .,v important lulvt :urc', k~llil h the Ilcnt . glmtle-

lillln tlicl hc' ll :ul m :lclc+ , tlc•ll rn•ut „ u•rilirc' . in urclc't• to ~l't•ln•c! . ( Ilc' :n•.) H e

•(111• . \t :lc•clultK :lll) tn11~t rl'Icr :tl :Ir+lin llt :tt Ilr rc ;~n'itl'cl utin'r thlnl Ilc' ( .41111(1

\trll c'~Ilr~' :• tllr nrl•c'••it~` in tt~itil•ll he 1,41111111 llinrc'll', in c•cmuucnt ~t~itlt his

~ llun . Il~ic~tlcl thc' l'c ", film -(~c~nc'rall, Id' tcllcin}t 1 11 1 It llcc~itiull ~~~Ilic~ll Ilc' fi-111.4-1 1

ltlllrt' I IC v c•~ :It~i~t• . lcrcc~ln(•c' llitlic•ltll j :ulcl llilnt ot in tlt' 11111)rcr 1111. 1Lc' lilcor,ll

ucct `l Icclc'n III-q-11 ll lllucll 1uil1, l bill t l~nt'ill,llc lul~c1u lllr~•itltlti~Iccaitic~rl ll`Ilul it III

!

t :lhin i_ III Iinto it, he luu<t u!l•c•t it,+c : lcc~c•illuc' utlc' t~lw IuJcl u icu~itiui l nl thc' (iut•('rn-

tnc~tlt . (lic• :u• .) Ilc• :li i cl Ili~ ►rturlu tullcaru~'~ ~t•cre III thi . licl .itiuu .

Inu :+t c•itllt'r Ic~utv' tIli~ l ; uil•rtlluc•n t ttitllunt, tl~ In' Lc - 1~'t~c•ll, ; ► I1~' ju s t

c•Ilu .,'--I, o r flic ~' :lrrc•cvl 1hc'rl,n ;hl~• Ntitll tlu•ir i•c 1 llc• :I, uc', ül l~u' luclil•~• t~llic•h

lhr \1ini ' tc'r ~~I',I~illllr,l~r llad s Iltllllittc• , I t A c lllr Ilcqi ;c' . 'l'hc•~• Icc'lic'~•lvI it ~t•+1,

II r tlu' trrto illlc'rra. u I• l' :Inlul,t I11 :t1 it " luStalcl lu' ullc~lltell ; tlu~~• clc~•irl'cl ,

.l llcllll .l O llllusitic 1 n 1111 (1 s tilculit Inc'c'I,l k • to ntc' :1<Iln . ~~Iu(~h Ilc ! lul ; '

( N lr .' ; ;IC trn,rull) \\ as uut lcrV li,uv 4l, :l ,; lLr rl llrr~c ntlllivr if n t•c)nntitnc+ttc• Y in

t• Iclcl'r ('1111111h, tlncl n q it pull lit, tuiln, tu t ;lhc• Ill :tt c'cciu: :r . ( Inc ► ul c•1uvi*1•s .) :I ic' -

I c•lirt•vcl 11u1t tlli•`l ; lctt'rnlnc'nt h :ul, it tl,ii' tthc ' lc', ~ntc ruc' I Ilu' tutltitrl ttc IL

11 1 ' Ilrlil!t'cll th :lt, c I ll tlu' t1I1cIIl•, it hall h :iti~,lilc•tcirily Icc'rTI n•luc'cl 1111 it~ llutic'~

w; it (iut1-r111111•11t . It w lln Illlilo tolu tl ; :tl 111 .I111ittl'l' .4 ut' I•xlu•IUlitUn" l•Ilnl'ptl'a

nligllt be 1! g :IClc' by prccfr .•iultu) l'l•unntltiAit lulcl tltcca ; who ccmll'wlc•ct Air

t'otrtll hntc.. I III, ,lucl that olcjc'c•tiou, tuigllt lie jicuutl L. y rcu•ll that tltc'ir tt i hc',1

~lc'rc+ itc l c :t71'ivcl utti to ,tlclt It ~;tr'ctt llr}crc•c' tt; thn~• l'x lu'c•Ircl . 'l'hc' s tc lclljc'l'-

liuti 1s , lultt l't rr, lni) ht he lu :lclc' n4niur4 1111~' licli\c'rllnlc+utr 'l'lle e tuu~! j~rc~ltnll

III tlttnl~k hlul, in tàc•t, lu'c'n l~hcc•c•11 n}~uin,t tlllt, n .lnliui•tnt ► iun (i t' tlu, hcm .

1nc',nl w r 61 r Cornwall . It \\ ;l• t•c'r)• vils), Air all hotu . p-11111,1111111 who ll+ul n l i

~ 4~lllllrl', it, Nl11' Ill ;tt nllt 'h1p,lll~ll,lliilitl' tl~ Iil'01• in r~'lUllutl 1.A i the :1~1'tlÎl•+ or (It t •

lutcl z;tuc lt t'~.clut•rlous (•utllchl' :1,<ilY In' Iopp c'cl off, Iu't'iYatul tlll'l'c!, tait it \tclti it

11i11'rrvttt Iltillg w ilc'tl nll v tclty Ill :lroll ill tllcllt ul' I ltr s\• .tl'n ► wail•1 ► had Nrcca ti

n ;, with thi+ /'c,ltntrY, aucl wllil•h was clc• 4 - l,ly ('n}trllllc,(j ttjmu its itl .tittutiotl . .

Tho III III . grntlc'nlun''t'rccln ticcllth O .\ I o rcl Ilucl tl .rcltt•lt 1 twill the illv :t that tM'!

Miui-tc'rx had tlc'l'tt I•c'lui's itt tlu'ir cltlt, v

in thi . . rl'~llc l1, Im (i tll+tt Illr I had

Itlt o tt'i'll l'\trnv :t}~+tnlr . tt) vut(tinuo tt•Ilil'h thc'y cultlcl vualy have lltlt all oncl

to. \\'cll, he (~Ir. .11ct1'llcm};+tl1) nttt s t s u) • it \ t' :t, 11 littll' 11i1lhir rn1u1 lu ►•ju"t Io

his Inte l'i,lllvt} nc', tllc. Ilccn . } c'ntll'nl :ln, tll lnnl .c' that, t htup;t . (It car, hcltr.)

'l'ltc' hcm. Icl'lltlt'tunn llitnscll' htlil tu'vlt Itn inllul'nli,ll lu vnltlc~~ ul' the Go rrrtl-

nlrnt lor o~. var ati41 It lttllt . \1'hr was it tlult lllu•ill}r that ti`cc luo ltncl 11111

I,rcllcl„('ll scnur .,cltl'lne of r(•t.l'l'tu hnlrltt ~ \\•ll , v hall III, clllcck%v cl thllt long

lwrioll to vlulcsl', il'hl' Ilvlic'vcll iulllorl :lllt rrllifi-ticm, ulil;ht hclè' llc'cl l III :IcIe

ilt tlw ptthliu t'slll'ucliturr . tmcl that, inurlvtse/l l :tx+ttiuu tui}lht, lu ► t'o 1il't'n

Page 30: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

averted, without cle ►trur+ ► tiut; •► tud sul►mittitt*L' to his cullcuKuus autuu plau for

ubtaiui ►tg these rinluetious ! It' he had any rttt•h t;cltetne in his head-if heeutertaiuetl objections to tilt- expeuditurt• tl ► en guinl; nn, 1 ►h (11r. Mucduu)Call)hud uevt•r heard of it, and he wo~ultl ask hi ► u to state wh ► •th►•r he had everproposed to the adu

~uish•ntiun ut; which he «•usz ► t nu• ► nl ►►•r, a policy of

rrtreu ►•hun•nt-uut retfi•ncbnm•ut iii the t ►►nttvr fil' n fett• hundred Imuntl,,k-(hc ►► r. henr)-but a ctnnpri•lu•nsiv ► • " t•h ► •mi . which wo ul kl arcmnplish lit(-► rl ►j ee•t of eaviug so ►nuch if tht• pu1 ► üt• tnuuu Y u-4 wuultl ul ►pret•i,thlt' r ► •tluce'the chnr}!i• s ul ► un the p e uJ ► li• ot'tlu• country !'l'h ► • h o u . 1n•utlr ► n, ► n hutl u ►udenu such proposition to his (11r. 11ut•► lougull',:) kwowle ►1);v . ►► n ► l he h ► ,d not lt•Ittilt- (lut•i•rnmet ► t hecuu„• lliy cnlleu};tie• rofu•ed lit ►•urry out it pulieY of thatkind . (('heers .) 11 e was ►1 ► ucb a ."touislto► 1 tl ► it~ other d t• wI ► i• ►► . iu ilkcussing,till item in tl aul ► plir ., the hon. grntIvutan rn ;ï- to d ►► t• uny r►• .I~unsil~ilit~•For it . l~ut•u ► t• ►► t, ► tu ►1 t•~•luri•il that it huit I ► i•i• ► i ► n ;lo I~~ dl~•l~,u•tntt• ► a ;tl ur~l~•~•,and not by tht~ autiwril~• 4 i t' ► ut order iii ~•nunt•ii . t1tt~•r 111 is St ►► tI• ►i ► I - nt, w I ► iolihu I l ► • ►► n s t•tl him cunsiilt~rulllc Nurl ► rirr, bol 11 as to Lite t•i~w-titntiunul i14-ctriui•Inill ► luwn . ►uul also i ► • t to the ►nut1vr of l'au•t invoIvvd, It(• (fIlt ; ► ini•d fi•u ► n NI r .1,1 •cklut•k . o f tlu 1•aI•t•utii ►. t'„uu ► •il . ►t rol ► t• o1• .tlit• nrdi r i ►► "i•uu ► u .il . onlcrint;

thi, ~cr~ lutt ut~nt . . It was iI,U~-d \orr ► ttl ►►•r and uuthoirizo ► I III,, Ir ► v-tni•ulul'~,11 . ►►qu to 1 ► ;t~• 11r. S . It . l'~~nti• ter nrr ► vu•y 11 ►► uul t f, lit, ilnv~ lii ► u .•

ait orrdor in cuuncil was 1 ► u►"rd, it rvuu ► ini•d fitt n-î•ord, ai ► t1 wui III-( v .•i1 ► 1 ► • I t,

they 1 ► uti joitt ► • ►I the t~~)vI•rnuu•nt tu nrco ►►► pli'li, :tnil ti ► l•Y \%lI ul 1 l ► uo-vt uUt,ic k

(t'h ►•er . ► u ► t Inut;hter.) livre was u(•fip .\• (-l' t1w or i l l •r . ( IIvnr . 111,I1•.) , 11 eknew tl ► e lion . r ► •ntlrutut ► ~~~~nl ► l " nt• Ih ;n h ► , n ► iuu~ ~~~~~ul~l luit he I~~untl ► uuomy,•tluo :w lit't v 11it ► isier, m lit-il il m ► t., Iot ► t v% v ► Y lion. rrn ► Iunwi nwho xvu, u•yui ► i ►► ti•il %% itl ► tl ► v ►►► iu ► ; ► l- l•nii•nt of II ► ililii• ulGtir-f kni•w tl ► ; ► t ~ch~ t ►

s ui•I ► 1 1 ► • w• ► nt ) i•rS +t : ► u ► gltt mo t hut~o Ilovu (~ri• o ►► t w I ►► -il il I I n~'oi I . Mu:-Il

t6~ un in ~t tnt• ► ~ of 1111 . ► •~1 ►►milittnr ulo~~t ► ~chii-h lite h~~ ► t . 1.~~•ullcnt ► u ► ► u~~%• .

t;ruun ► l ► •i1 co ► piuint ny :ti ►1,t Hill linvrr ► nn ► •ut . (I1 v nr. Ir ► •,u .) \1' ► •II, this wu ~the I ► u sitiom i ► whiuh thw reliant uu• ►i ►he r .: of the 6overnun•ut stoulL 'I'lir}•► 1i ► 1 not li•rl I ► ut, in Im r .u ► tuce if, tlli,, on•dvr ►uul thi•ir o l ►► t y to thei rco

nstituent ., it re lrrevntutiv ► •y ttonn l'1 o lrr 1luuuln-tlu• y dul not 6-4o I tl ► ,tt ,acting in nw•ur Inuiv , tvith tilt- i ► tt~ r~ ~t+ fil' thu ~~~ui ► tr~• lit large . %%-Ibiilg l

I, o jn•titit• ►1 in ` mt•iul; their I ► Inc ► • i fm that ritlr of the Ilou m •, t o t : ► I o! tl v ir

, e ut s with Ille t I1~►► •r 1 101) . lt e ntlrn ►► •n o 1 ► 1 ► u.;it v . ( Ilwtr. hr ;tr :) 'l'lie}• Imlivtvd

that t o ( 1 4) •u wo tild imin - rjl tl ► l• prua ► vct .,z lot' t'~mla~l~ rnti~~n, an d lu• ;tn nt l n v~•, ► -

t Hill ► 1 1' th 1- frryu 11 tt tlr c lur►ttimu , tnut lr t o ►hi . 11 ► :u ,r and tu the couutr)• .

The remult ir+i, 1111(j tht•, hun . t ;i- ► ttlt• ► u ;u ► I ► ut•ing thn'ttn ► lmt•n 1I ► l• ► •lu ► Ilonpr .

hm i ►►g u ► rnno ►►nt•" ► l is il~ t~ rn ► in : ► li~~u to dv :troY thk (of )t w•u ► uvnt il' he 1•41nt1l,

lutN i ► i} ul ► p1• ;ilr►1 to he liln•rul iuet ► tlirt•4 l't'6 ► n l'plwr l'uuuiln tu zu .<t : ► in Iii ► I ►in this utle ► npt . Itut•tth ►t ul'o, It itlt rynu, AIegrr•e (1 I' : ►•, ► tr+tn ► ~, : ► I~I~~ nl~ ► I t o 11 14 •

h oa ► . ytot ► tlruu•ù who ~,tt on tl ► r Goveru ► ueut si ► 1e ul'the Ilnu~o•-1 ► m ing tuk(~n

this course, I ►r . (utr. 1i~ ► c ► Iun .vn11) and I ► k hon . Lrirnd tln l'u ;t ► nn~t~ r•ti~ n~ r ; ► 1 ,

tou, ► u ► ul6 . up thvir utintk tu au ►ml tl ► vir grommI, it, cm-r}• mit ttw luiljcy tl ► ; ► t

. by nttu ck, t . lu ► r}t o by c h :urKr . ►nul tin• Ktu ► fil r g un . ( Limi t c li t rr~ . ) 'l'lu• In s n .

}rrntlrtunn, n'n tlunl i l I ► :ul it g rv : ► t I~ lmu r at Iii< ( nutril l . ` II I • laid by in~lu tr % .

► tl l ilit V , u ► ul Oit' ( •un ► u ► uu 4 l ul' mi-ani s , t• s tn b li , lu• d nq i ua v rl'uI ur ;;un fit' Imblic

u p iuïuu, nutl• ~ e wa, able to l ► o I d it over tlt ►► hu :► d + fit' huu . ► ut•u ► lu•r ; in tha

Page 31: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

uu:e, aud to coerce them h e re nttit in other places out of it . The hou .

~.utlentnn litai talkc'rl of cuerciun being ofti'retl by the (iuc erotneut, but•thuy

km• W that co.rcix,u ciunt' n„nr from the quarter to which he rclèrr ea than by

holding in alw}•aur e it 1i•a• paltry otlic c -t in the gift of the (ion•ernnu'ut . . 11'ull

that "I t i ,ie o f tltinl: s tnu ' t l,(- n(r•t . ( Heitr, hear.) 'l'ht'1•,know that nu t,n•ifl

cuuld lie pr; I i ilu .v tl tlltlt w-o lllll not I111 Ul,jt'l•tc d to vithrr by one iuterc~t o r

~ auuther, bnt thev ►nutt louk,tu the adt•tuttnKc ut'tlu' great uta•• of* the people

(ii' the cuutttrt-, and in thnt• v iew this taritf', m hutc v t'r objections might he

. innt lc to p ,n•ticnlnr itv tnN, w u ,4 fair, huuest and a•+ we ll calculntcd fo prouuut e

the iutcre ' t 'a ut'thr' pi-41111t . nt large its any that v ~mld have becu t+ul►uiitte d t o

thc Iluu se . Now, it, aivak trotn it hurtt• point ut' rit'tt•, hr Itnd, as he hnd dnid,

w ith gmut rcgn•t, fi•lt c ow, pclle tl to tWkc titis course tu•dny . \1'ltatevt' r

~ uhl~len~,nttiu'~+ might t rke in cuu s rqucuce ut' it, was no t'uult of hi~ . Ilc

front the hull, v

inH of tlte organ t oi % t h iclt lit- had nllutl e,d. •( llenr, ht'ar.) lie

tùlluwctl the meuil,ér for Smith U .~t'urd into the ( ',u V ctvntcut, yuytaiucd hiut

w lüll' he rt'ntniueil in it, uctcd ith hiut Itunc~.tl%~, cordial 1v, and fruukly, and

he ht'lievr'd thut on tlie wltule nu cauat' ot ilil~W-nlty had nrkru bctwecn thew,

but the hot) . l;rntletuiui :t•im,licllwl hiu ► and his i•ullcuf;ue, tii take the cuur w .

tl,rt• now tlill . uud tlu' cun~cqu~ ncc .;, wlinte6cr tltcl• tuigltt 'I►r, would rt'~t

upuu Lim . However it tuil;ltt affect the lion ., jzicntlcnteu'ulipr'ate, whutevër

ditlirulties it might ralise in tilt- coouth•y, whatever cw ► te,;tz; in the cunst(tueu-

cics1 wLatcvcr'tltrchu tuiFht be hautletl about from one to nuotht'rrwlttcccr

griccnuce± iuif;l► t be npI ► culed to for redre~4 bi'firrt' the People, he brii`h~•cd the

h om . l;t'uth•utau ~~1 ► jLsitv NVtlultl u»t lw tell ulune to huld his nrn• ;pal,cr

in frrrorcul over tlit, hen(li u1' h om. utc ►nhrrtz ut' this llun<<; and tl ► e peu 11)11 . .

(Cltcrre .) .'l'le itlcti he (Mr . M+}il•duugnll) liait liouud in Toronto, w Itru lir

rrtt•uwl from l,i+ West Initia tui~sivu, ► nu"t In . revivcd and acted ulwu, utul

tlu'- v

tuust have in Uppcr t',ututla uuotht'r orrKau G)r the liberal liurty-an

organ that would cxllresv the views ut' that lnu•ty and ut' the great tu a•a of

the pt'oplo huucAl)•, and that tt•uultl t•rrt'the country l'ruut the iuc.ulrU and

tht, terrurisut and the disgrace of' the hou . Kentlt ►unn'sut't~ap.►ptv orgauizntiun .

The uteiuluvs uf the refornt parti . Ill-puppurting this Gureruuu'nt su long as it

exirtr,l under it+ prcscnt urK,tuizatiuu, at till e% cuO, would lie ~ allcd up(1 u tn

pursut• it cuuqo more in nccurnlnitce, with the w6hce of those who sent tltetn

-livre thon uppi„inl; the, (iut•t'rnmcut Iit'ciiu :e the huu gentleman opposit e

no lungcr it u ►rii,l,rr ut' it, nud in duinK this they would i,;,v lirutt-etud

( Sir atnrdutltull) was very much I► lcii~ed iuQcetl when the utcntlu'r fur Smit h

U % ti,nl Im~:c~l n ltiKh cul oKiutu ul i mt the .ltturncy •tieucrnl East ; he «•n,gla d

to hrnr it, bet'nnsi-, whatt+rc'r iuight have been their pu't part y di~putr-A, 1SEL

did nui more thnn tu his lion . rulltvt}(uc, w h o , r•incc tlu' adoption ul'th c

liulicy (if' the prc,ent tiuvrriuucut, Itntl pur:ui'd n s tr,ti g httiorwarrl, rnudr .t .

nud lovai cuiu•<c' tu w +u•tl .i his ro llcaguos in the Jtiui s try , and in regard to the

tu,•a ~' urr ,q Which it w : ► .,; tormcd to ,tci•utu p li -Ah . ( llcnr, hear .) ILu (Mr .

M ncdougnll ) c„uld s n y of lii -4 collv n}ti iv , thv A tturnr}•- G cuiv,tl Wr s t, ul .u, aud

he h e lievctl the uuv mhe r for Smith Oxford t% uul t l confirm luis s l a tt'tnr'ut, that,

utlcr the t' xperit'ucu lie had w ith Itin ► wt tu v ml ►cr ut' the Go t•rrutnt'nt, to

which he be l o up'. d, he hv lir V rtl hiiu to he tliatu,al to tut in all uccw,iuu3

fuirl y , lwut~s tlr, and impartinlly in regard to the ulenSürCtl N•lticl ► capte Iwti,ro

Page 32: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

further and s,tY that ittcc h,• had b,4,11 in the tiov,•rnuuvut with h,ai . l;outle .ntcu, on rcet;(• (III(- tion ► whicIt had cutt ►c tr ► ,d,•r their juri,dicti,w, oith,•t•cx,•,•utit•e or utht•rti+e, he had .huu•u hint"eIt' to be its progressive, as m•f .-ltint•linc,l to Support Ille l,nhliy ,iuter,•st by initinti ► tg giH)1 in,,tajr,s, itseco►w ► , ► i,•,tl ,und as I Imntl as th, hou . I :cutleutnu ol,po .:itv . (t'h,•,•r.: .', li

e (M r. \i,tc,I,)ug,tll) al,l,ru,trhe,1 tl,i . ►li :ru: .iu ► t n•ith thi .: eslrorikat,•v, tvith tIf •" ,Vieu•s, and with these filets, u"hich he ,•fntl,l hon,•stly nn,l,•„n-;1 •ü•tttiu,t ..lystl ► tctu this 11„u :c ; 'Air if it had luvv u uthcrM•iq, it >,"vm wpc,lle ., li,rhitlt to yuy hecuultl have rvutttine,l in Guveruu ►cut . 11' he hud li,uutl that th,• :\ttlmnvt•-Upnernl Wezt was int•liu etl to l M-ce utcn,,urcs u•bich wen• ul,l„om_tl to th4 _

the ndtniniytrntion .• ,<pf course, he (Mr. Mncd,tugnll) did not forget, thc'pn~tLluudersu•hich had been cu ► nwittetl ; he did not li,rget the ,ltic,tiuu ; whichhud long been in tlisputc I,etwmu the two l,nrtie, iu Upper ('tuZidi, 'or thepc►,itiu ► i ut' hi ; lion . frientl, who, its leader (of the ► ninurit ► • fi•out l'1 ► l,t-r (',ta,la,joined the tuujurit .• fiuu ► Luwer l',watla to p,tss inca :ur,, ; tchich were tli,taste-ful to tilt- uutjority , t• t•he pt•,~pl~ of lipl,er Canada, but he trou 1(1 WA ste p

• priuci ,les of lh v rtrh- tcit ► «hich he --• 1 1 j

I

L 1 j ~ t, +i•utnttt r u. t~,lu tl qtucklt hnt,~ \tintnd n rens,m ti,r ti,llun•i }t thc fin• South UxG,rtl, but it was not nuthis ground that the hou };eu ettuu ► hn~l withdrawn t•rn ► n th,~ t~u~•,•rtt,ncnt .I le IintnJ u,litli~rt•ut ►•xt•u,o , t m,i(trr uf .le . + inil,'•tnnce, and with regard tu«•hich his coll e n}tu e , the l'uantn~tcr-l~, urr,tl,' and it hirgr u„ijority „l' thiti'Il,tso, tlitli retl front hiw entirely . \, u•, that was the position iu which .they were plurr,l, und he (Jlt• . 11ur,lnttgnll) believt•,1 they wuttltl have thu .❑ tr,w, ,,f',nti•ft•ing tlt"e public ► uin,l thrit tite (i„t"i•rnutvnt was ,•un,l,u•t,•,1 ,t 'lf,tirlt', as ilolll'~,tly, as INItJ•U,til•dlll' 111 the i11, .,P11(•C UI' the tI1PU111,U1• Air South,Uxtirril as w hcu he w n .â a ttu•utlu•r tif it . (('lice r. ) Ili hrlim rtl the w,• ;i,tu eo f ('uuli•,li-nttif In was suite in thol<: hun,l,". The only l,eril that ~•uuld ► n v u,tt•e .it was Am the1u,ti hcutlè ►uuu to liu►t ,t large l,otly to su,tnin hitn in the cuur,oho had choa•n to utlulrt . 'l'h(, lio\•crnn,rut %wluld n ► niututin tl•ir Krouud,%t•uttltl carry out tue policy they tu„k office to uccuniplish, au,l tsuul,l co ►i,l,l,•t o

course as that, and let hiut h,tvl~ all the rcsl„nisibilit}• tIl' a,ain ► iul; n p l ,yiti,m

«•hich utitiht precipitate a 11iuistc ► ial cuisis in the t•uuuh;t•, and in ,Oril thocause nhivh the 11ocrruntrut . ucrc ti,rutetl to n,•çutuoi .h . Ilr ( r. Mac.dougull) did not believe that that would be the e1lict,d the hpu . gent 111all'sopposition, but etill that would ho hit; position if the (lpn•erumcut wcrn

attitude of untnl;uui,m ,tntl ho,tilit}• . Let hiiu have all thc t l tirr S ut•h ann issue o f no prtu•ht•ol uulwrtu ► tcr, un d .sutt•t . th,•u to h,tt r n•,tnut~~l ,t n

ul s t► tho •chr ► ue5 for In,•ttl ,•un m itutiou• u, c, ••ur~ uu,l e r,•,~n1i - ,l e r+ttiuu . 'l'hrhou . g,•utl,•n ► uu ulipo :iti• had ,•utulilniu,vl „t',I ► •lu}• itl c 41 t 111 ,•,•ti„t ► ttitl ► tl,i•~► tlu,t uuweul wtua re >, b ut w )tr \t•tt, it that ~~•ht~n Ili- ~t•ats in tilt, t„o t~,~rrnuu•ut

*114 . hall u,•\. , nuul ►• uu \• rul,,• .•tiun on the point ; I'th~rr wn ..,u ►r I,lutim• tolit, utln ►•h,~lhur not hucing th,-„e thiu};, ,li>•u~"•,1 at uu o,u •I•,v l,t+rio„l, thrhou . Keu(lclunti t►•,t ; the inuu to I1l,tnte . (ll,au•, h,•,► r .t It t\•n~tut u,•,•,• . . ;trcthat lie ( JIr.- ~l,ti•d„ul;,tll) >;h„ultl „ccul,)• the ,ttt ►►► tiu ► ~ „l' the il„u S ,~ ,ui~~longer . II,• hall rtute,l in a : - li+tt• wor,l, Its lit- t',ml,l the I,~ .tti,~u in t►•hi,•h hi,nn,l ttt• ►, of his cull,•utiu,•~+ ~t,~rc l,lnco,l . . .\v literai uuv ► 111r, front l'l,l,erCanada, thcir cour.-v w u. ,•le nr ; the y hall nuul e `up th e ir uuti` . Io n,ih,,r,• 1 ► ,tl1le• (lin•crntu e ut . The hou . 1;,•titlt• ► unn opposite hu,l ,•hu .~~t to' r,t~~a thout „ n

• ~

Page 33: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

defe ted on this motion . fie thought, however, the hnn . gentletu11n woul d

rj tin(Fhimself in prettj• ntnch the ejttnc position as that on R•hichi he wa-1

pl l i l'd the ++ther ui};ht in titis lluure, ~~'l~i~n lie appealed to his ti+rutçt• p++litical .

fri~tds in L'pper Cunullft to eupl+yrt him on' the bill tti•hic•h- was then uudcr

d~~cu~hiuu . It was it mcatiuro for tlip. enlt• of the, rectory land,; in l'ppcr

~ iutntln, trhiclr tlie liht•rul party hn(l ulsn}•a ndt'ti• ;Itr~l, but which the h+m .

rontl+•innn ol+ln+,t•~I. om fit(- grotnt+l~ that it ht+ul+l I+e left ot•crlior fu,tul~ . uKitii-

r tiun. lie had asked his frientls to rote with hirn 119nitl~t .Gl#++ hill, iuul ih+-

ti+unil hin ► s+•11' n~ith ju st two f++llowcrs tram l'l+}ier l'nna+ln . (I .+ru9htcr.) I t

wil, tCt~l~"ri l~ilinlilt+ s l+t• C tuclc .~, ( licm' Nvt•tl luu}*htcr'.) llr M n ► ptithizt+l

+lcel+lt• Witlt çite'e, t wo h+m . };entlcntt•n %%'h+ , hud h+~cn tlra}c}C+'tl throngh th+ •

nirv+ onicc lit the dict ;ttion of the incurb`c•r for South (letür'l, and he trwit+•+l •

. / ' tltat the remult ot•the vote would have (lie rlT~ct of cuitsin} Oient in"futurc t+ ~

` ul~u;ro muro 11111,111,01% to lhr ht'mctlii+ s++ f rnt l r t++u+ ; . I ,, . ,,, ., . . r . . . . . . . . . . . . .

limp ( l lüut~cll' w ith two nnli p urt ( V , , but in hi~ ptlier, tt :hirl ► w u, +ulip+rsctl t+ )

ull the uctca of the day, he carcfulla• nul+prt• :,ed thr division. l'hr

uuo tiun 'tt•,i+ Imt and was all that was qit•rn in dhut jan ni, hiU tht+

n,iuu' .' uftht• tnernl+cr for South Usti+rd and his lwtv +rfu1 pnrt y tt•+r outitte+l .

( I,nu}thter,) He (\lr. Jl+tcth+ngnll) had no dt+ s iru t o +le pre +'iute th o nl+ilit y ut' .

the hou~ g+•ntl e inun ; he l111 +1 l+t• eu I++n}t ci s•a•i,it+•tl w ith hini in linlitics, and

they had tlilh'rencr.4 ++utetintc : H•hi+•h %y t•n• of it I+ittur kin+l ; Intt, this tnuch

th e hun }!rntlvuiun ~'tmlQ tln him justice to r-n v , Ihut w hil++ h+• ti•+t . amie ++I'hi s

,ul+p++rtc`rs , h++ nln•+t y i nr}!u+' 41 w ith him i in+l It++int+•+l oiit his ul+jv +•ti++u s- t o hint

w hen,hu h e li+•ct -d hiin to I++• tt•runl;, and huit he hnd ne t• e r all any timc hv cn

i t s uh -i t•r v icnt fo llo w er . ( Il+•tu•, h+ l ,ir .) He ( litf+•rr+l t'r+mi hiut now, and lie'

would not t hrink fi-++m u -mnninK the r+ l~~m~il~ilit~ + 1 I' that +liffe r+•nt•+• . llt'

tt•++uld leave it to the lil+i•ruls of' t'liprr Ouiu+lu to s ny w h+ - thor th-py w•nnl+l

ullotc thcurt'It•c++ to he +lrath geil al'ter that lion . geutlrti+uu, or hum stly and

li'utlcy,ly p uca+m,thut rv+ur .<+ tt•hiclt they had lil+•ÎI};i•tj th e ui -+•Icc s t o pinte,

when the Coalition Go t• erunuiut t~•+ts ti+rmcd: 'l'h• h+nt . g ontI+•imtu h++petl, in

c+rnclu+'.inK, that in the tli s ciih s it~na tt•lrich ml};hl tuke placc, the cuurte;ie +

tltnt were duc fr++nr onr pnl,lit• 1111111 t~r ,tnutlu~r ~t'hul+l not hn,ft+r gottcn, and

revnln e ll his K+•at miii+l lon+l nltl~lnu ;e .~ • , , ,

~ . ~

Page 34: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

,

j

HON. WII.T~IA .14 P. IiO~~LANn\

is Postnltt.stcr Geuc'rrl .Mr. IlowlAtlll is th tiîit(l inetlil)cr of, the Itrl'Oi•lu

party, in thw 1Iini5tr •, an(l the le:tst of" the tllrl•c',t1lc1ur11 lli~ influence, ill . the Wc',,,t is of ~ .Sl)nle cull sv -ct~ll'u' . I~e i4 ~~cry a)t~ :it firurc~~, and c ► C u c,lll~lilut-lul; turn of iniucl . In t le West llis N•iews are listclll•( l

. to 11'ltll attention ; ltil( , l)11 C(lllllllel'('lal questions, he1s v l't•

, yllltl'll1 gellt . li ' l)lily be s ill(1 to be l)llt! l ► t' tllt \

l,t!yt l)tl .A llle INS men of' th l.~l)v llll'e .

'phis AIiuisti' r Nv :1 s l u the* Commission xc ilt, inFebl'llill'V littt,'tO thoU litl'll States G (1 vel•ltlllt'llt t ► )11lC~Ot ► ilth A 11C w treaty l) tl•2llle,7L11(l lie w :IS il lit titan

In 1857 M1• . II/1 w llltl d' was vit'ctell . f'11• \' llc ~Vl' st

to ;ts.,uc'iitte wit,ll Mr. Gil t in the mission . A lllurl •a11t, 11c 1 s ifli ec)lilcl not llu~ 1)l'lIn ~clcl•tc' ( l to talk ~~"itlltl ► cCuulnlittee ou way's a 1l1 .~lh:lrl s , ii)t ' the lutl" tiluc'tltilt 110 llas_•l)ellt in the )i•ucluce l,u s ille" ti . has tlt :illellll)1 . V et'' V Fllill'11 on tue 1 lltr~ tlUll of' l'('CIl)l'l)l'711 t'l'('t '

t t'Ade .

•" Ilidin~ l)t' 'York, itllclll,1 . ~ltt tin• it ul) tu tlll'111'c'tic'n tfinie. . 111 lti(i :; he was an i( of the IIi,'(i1t lt Gl)x•-eritlltent of' tlllit , tiute , filling the l)lliçe or Ite !e i N • e1•-Gc:.llerttl . In 186- 1 he went, out Av itll his 111th , but .in It little . tilll 0 , w its inclticed to enter the CoalitionINIini4try , in the uilice of' Post ni,l ster-G ellrr,ll . l~e.iu~;11.11 attenti~~l~ official, lie' II1Rke :+ a t;ual llea(l t

;ul+ tll t '

Post Office .This member is it strong, but quiet, 1)at•ty-t lt~tl .

He may now he regarded as the,foul•th man in il flu-

Page 35: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

ence of the Refurlll party, though the least of, the .three in office .,,III the l lotlsé this member (loes not cut a figure

(though so ~;ood Lit fi~;urrs) as lie, cannot . speak well .Ile took ,l very quiet part in the (lelltttes on Collfed-e r,Lil(► il . , From his l e .illillns it is likely that he wasnr)t llltl(~11 illteretite(t ill tue g reQbt question, 1)ut• w tlJ

l'l' l lectl ve w Ity, this 111(',1111)l'1' 1`l it grl'ilt colltl'il5t`to lllt' ,

;1(lvoc;ltill ;, a. f'ew of the, leading oues . In his quiet ,views arc liuly, but, he 11E1y to confine 111111SCl ~ to

l~y .(~lu(lui~lit tlr~uinént . ill tlle IIouse. His refuriulef;i-Altor, but lie has not the ability to urge his viewd •

lirlll~; it roo(1 tlllnker, 111r . llo Nv ltln(I lmikes it fill rre,1(iy to 110llow the lea(1 of Mr . 13ro NV 11 .

coile ag ue, Mr. `IcDonti,lll, who tllil tlus le," and Spe.lkawell and, boldly . The two toptllcr would make agood colllluittce ; -1111(l, on ronl-lllitte(.~y, the former i s

1V erv ilpt •

Owin - to tlli : ; ,11e took a);reltit illtercs t 1 1(1

»rt;o-

tliltlOll s fOr it ,11(' w tl't'Qlty of* free tl'il(le ~~~itl ► tha t~ '

(`O1111t1'j' . ~TO• ]llilll in Cllllililil is more fit t(1 talk over.

the state wr a flour market, or to calculate the chancesof ;1, ritie or titll, than l!(' . It 13 in this llg llt•• that M l• .I l(1Wli111(1 is seen to iL(l villltitg t' . On it Corn Exchangelie woul(l be i t man of.li(ltr .

T}lesulject of this short, sketch is flot a llititiv,e of Caalil(lal:,,, lie, having , lleell born in ' the ncit ;llllorin g

repuUlic: IIe is a man of about 50 years of' ngc~ ; with

yu,ultities Of fl(lur, to the Uni-tyd States market .

M r. 11u~~ lilll(I 18 il mail of so111e , ~1'l`l ► lt 1 l, Ull6(le 111 tlle

praluce bu s ilt e5s . 11e i s it nlill-( ► wner, illl(1 si elld5 l11•rt;e

the f'cititur~~g and look of tlle p~.~ilple from whom he-

takes his origin . ~ . ,

N. r

1 . . w. ~ ~✓1=.:

Page 36: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

110N. HECTOR L . LANGE'VI N

one ot' tlle first ill illtelli(Jence . Ilis influence in th e

is Solicitor-General East .Air . Langevin is the l'uurtll Frew'll t' ;Itludi,ill .-iu

tlw Ministry, and the least in couse(lllence, thoug h

.bast is considerable, and is iucreusing, .

the nuthor of li ~Prk elltitled Cirilcirlct i't .,' e ,v /,i-

►l'hi s lllem ber w :1y first elected to l'arliilnlcllt in1857 for Durclt ( ~ster, tulti l1 ;ls sillee 1),t(t ll (, l (tctc (

l 1) \

ucclllilllttiwl . lIe uwes his 1>re:4ellt place t~ ► his t ;i-lrn'~i ; and lie 11111y be ctLllecl the se (e unll 111,111 in t,ll o lltof his Party in the Ministry . A. guu ► 1, A'rit~~r, 11~~ i s

,Yttrur«pn,,,,, &e .The oflire of Dtr . L► lll~~~~ in renclery 1 ►illl ►L sort ot'

i lll'l)llty Ut' tlle A.ttOrllt'-(il'lll'rtl1 it . 1lC 1~ il ~~Ill' ,

010119I1 yUllllb, legislator, Ueitlf; well rvul in l,l~t•, andknowing L114 wlluts of tlle c~uu ►ltr~, un ►I is llc,tiN~ct andattentive to the dllt~s of his office .

, 11L•. Llln~evill speaks well, ►lncl made a t;uoll vIli.►rtin the cl~~ui>jt~~s o11 Cullfi ;~cl(trilf ll)11 . , ~,1 Ilc ►u~~~ ,~ ~ ll too ciiti'us~ ,his sherell was one of tllc` 1 ►(tst lu,lclo 011, t,lle uccusiull,and the best the four French nleulhors of' tlle 11in-istry, only two of wlwlu, llowever, 111uc1o spce(i,ltv-S,uuthe (lllcstioll, Mr. Langevili 1 ► ,i~ ii 1 ► 1ew4ur; uddrcssand speaks cuellI v, like it man wllo•iy rr5ulv (* ]lot, tobe put out, by interruptions. 'l'llonbll not a s tslt es-

\ mtlll, he is ~ nl,til wlle will w C ► lr well %N1111 y (tars . ,

The suuject. of' tlli-s sketch was Mayor of (lue l ► ecfor five years, and also l'res i ► iellt ul' tl ► r. North Shoi,6lluilwiiy Co. Ilis energy and itlt~ lli 0;~;nce I ►rucare ► 1

Page 37: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

at, tl ►c 13,tx . Lie 1s it, Illilll of ui eal is, .with it ciisposi-

remuiieratioii . e- • .. . .Mr. Langevin is IL AIerriber of the Bar of Love r

C. n ,ld a,'practi s i» g 1tit ' (1uebec. He has done well atliis profession,, and is re ga rd ed ,is Ohé of tue best 11j e n

;,lùr lïim those two place8 of distiiictioii, but of littl e

t i".11 to pnsli on ami inci'e,lse those means by enter-

linvi n g e nte red ~ I'a rlinuie»t in 1$57 , Mr. Lange-v i n has now l. eeii nine years in it, and i s about 40

.,, . .. , .r .,, . . .

prise.

Page 38: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

h

CION . JAMES CU(,'KI3II R~~• .

l'~ ► lwnr„ tltli the NVes t, ritliltu; ut' the Ci)ullt • l, . ~

l tiG 1 ; tùr the IV es t li.illill~; of' Nl>t•tittlull)c1lau~l, s>llllIll- ~; it s I , )l it Itu %V . Ile, in 1862-3) ~;sl,vc Support totllc lil~ti,rlll 1lilli~tl,v 1)1 ' tlfi,tt date, and ill 18G•!' tl)uktllllCC lll the, 11l't's t+ltt, i 4>\'l'l'llil tell t . IIl' Illlly ]Je1,00 strslcd ,tN It lil ►e rstl ct)uyon•utivc .

M 1• . Coclc bllrli is a I)slt•ri,tct;, 1 ►rstc l i s iii~; itt C'ul)on rb,;lllll llst, •urrchtl ell'sti his I ► rt,l le ;t`iol> luure by ;:tculii-Ill``N ;lltll stttclltil ► 11 tltstll by ht'illiitatt lllistlitieN. a i n

This luitli s t er I% . .1 .4 tics t l+l e l - trtl to I'stt'llsllilc'llt i n

to look ittt e l• tltr Ct•u I%•u Law l)iiire 1i ► t• the Wes t : *

tel- I .ell(lel .8,The o1lice_ e1' tlli,, luitii .s~Il of' tllc'~A tti,rnry -(3l~llc~rsil, `Ve,t, Who ltu w an dt.ll eil v c'tv llltlt~ll 1•t~ ( litirt'S 16,tc'suly and sltthlttivc,nlaa l

.. " llt 1 S W ell %"Cl',el l ill lstw . ^

~ Illlllll! j but Ill'. llill~t lil'. l lUlll tll'!i roi a' ir ~ ~n •t t)uli 1l a~vlsttur,1 '

~ t tu.ut uruull Ietltic sutll ecluca-t iuu, s"Id lut c sortie influ ence in t.ltc , West . lie ]m s 11llt)t ]l)111 ; Ii ";urell in public li('c and llus yôt to win n •

. I . (,uclcl)urll 1, t '

of, the 111ilti-stry.) ' :is sulicitul•i (Uctlorstl VV"t '011/flic twclt'th Itlc1ml 1 hl1

' I.ilce .luu>t ~;s)i)ll tl ► ittlct~r~, Mr. ('uckhltrll tiue,4 lu ► t~ -- l ►ltlc vvrY tlnrlltlY, and be iz-ttut llistitl'iliA ► ccl i n

:lhuul -tO yestl• ;s ot' u t ;t,' . -

lll I l . . ., . . . .

we ll ,l:ltu IV lt and likw sl . IIII is ' .III Ei n~;li s lllltstll stinl .l

Page 39: to motive s€¦ · tilul' in en-l1 ut' I-hl'llt. ( t'lu l r .) .\nnthel' lulllivr to unilo urr,ltlu'ru Illula UI t.lle ltltit motive sIIlIk1'll llt, is 11iiN, l{Illt the IlUlil'\'

This euds'tie ljst ut'.1liui~tci•~, wllc) ,i ► •~~ cl~~~~~c( a sliollow ,5 :- '

Coll,crvative, tllrcc tûurtl 1 s• • • • . . . . . P ,q Il )IZe 1 l 1 r 111, o i l h 1;)111111 • • • • • • • . • • • • • • • • • • ~Î

, • .

Of l;n'glisli c►ri~;iti, trr ü Cllircls. • • • • • • . .Of French : (Io. clle tllir ► i . . . . ••, . . • . .