Rohit JainDesign Dissertation

2013NMIMS Balwant Sheth School of Architecture

ABSTRACT

Transcripts always resuppose a reality already in existences, a reality waiting to be deconstructed and eventually transformed.The transcripts take elements from the city. Role of the transcript is never torepresent, they are not mimetic. They are very subjective.Reality of its sequences does not lie in the accurate transposition of the outside world, but in the internal of the outside world, but in the internal logic these sequences display.It attempts to play with the fragments of the given reality at the same time as the rational structure of abstract concepts.Transcript favors those activities generally considered negative and unproductive; mourning’s, wars, cults etc.

Transcripts always resuppose a reality already in existences, a reality waiting to be deconstructed and eventually transformed.The transcripts take elements from the city. Role of the transcript is never torepresent, they are not mimetic. They are very subjective.Reality of its sequences does not lie in the accurate transposition of the outside world, but in the internal of the outside world, but in the internal logic these sequences display.It attempts to play with the fragments of the given reality at the same time as the rational structure of abstract concepts.Transcript favors those activities generally considered negative and unproductive; mourning’s, wars, cults etc.

The 2008 Mumbai attacks were twelve coordinated shooting and bombing attacks across Mumbai, India's largest city by members of Lashkar-e-Taiba, the Pakistan-based militant organisation.The attackers allegedly received reconnaissance assistance before the attacks. Ajmal Kasab, the only attacker who the only attacker who was captured alive, later confessed upon interrogation that the attacks were conducted with the support of Pakistan's ISI.The attacks, which drew widespread global condemnation, began on Wednesday, 26 November and lasted until Saturday,29 November 2008, killing 164 people and wounding at least 308

BRIEF

EVENT SELECTED

Why this as an Event?

???? ??? ?? ?????? ???????????? ????? ???? ???????? ?? ?????????? ????????? ????????? ?? ??? ???? ???? ???????????????????? ??? ???? ?? ?????? ????? ???????? ????? ???? ?? ?????? ????? ???????? ????? ??????? ??? ???? ?? ???????

E???? ?? ??? ?tt???? ???????? ?? S???? M??b??: ?? C?????????? S????j? ????????, ??? Ob???? ???????,??? ??j M???? P????? & ?????,L?????? C???, C??? H?????????? N?????? H???? J????? ????????? ??????,??? M???? C?????,[14] ??? ? ???? b????? ??? M???? C?????,[14] ??? ? ???? b????? ??? ????? ?? I???? b??????? ??? S?? X?????'? C???????

Taj hhel

Cst station

DOCK

Leopord cafe

Nariman chabad house

Six explosions were reported at the Taj hotel - one in the lobby, two in the elevators, three in the restaurant.

Nariman House, a Chabad Lubavitch Jewish center in Colaba known as the Mumbai Chabad House, was taken over by two attackers and several residents were held hostage

The attacks began around 21:30 when the two men entered the passenger hall and opened fire,[43] using AK-47 rifles.[44] The attackers killed 58 people and injured 104 others,[44] their assault ending at about 22:45

The Leopold Cafe, a popular restaurant and bar on Colaba Causeway in South Mumbai, was one of the first sites to be attacked.[49] Two attackers opened fire on the cafe on the evening of 26 Novembe evening of 26 November, killing at least 10 people, (including some foreigners), and injuring many more.[50] The attackers fired into the street as they fled the scene.

LOCATION MAP

My experiences there fortified a conviction that architecture must address seemingly intractable problems like these,

First of all, because buildings were damaged or lost, and this directly impacts people’s lives.

It’s not hypothetical. They have to be repaired, rebuilt. Secondly,

the attack on Mumbai the attack on Mumbai was an attack on civilization. The aggressors wanted to destroy its urbanity, its tolerance, its complexity, its cosmopolitan spirit. So, it was an attack on the idea of the city, and therefore on cities everywhere.. If we, as architects, ignored it, we would be ill-equipped

to deal with the same sort of attack when it fell upon our city.I don’t think so. It is just architecture doing what it is

supposed to do—dealing with supposed to do—dealing with human conditions and problems.

The followingtextured montage shows or represnt this entire event as WOUND to the City.

My theory was clear: the siege, and the sixty-hours long war,changed everything. Socialism was out, and an uncertain privatization was in. The city was losing its ethnic diversityThe infrastructure of utilities and services was severely damaged,Buildings vital to the social and economic functioning of the city wwere damaged More than all this, the people of the city had suffered hours of deprivation, terror, and uncertainty, and many would be transformed by it.

A wound is a type of injury in which skin is torn, cut, or punctured (an open wound), or where blunt force trauma causes a contusion (a closed wound). In pathology, it specifically refers to a sharp injury which damages the dermis of the skin.

Wounds can be classified according to the object that caused the wound. The types of wound are:

Incisions or Cut wounds, caused by a clean, sharp-edged object such as a knife, razor, or glass splinter.

Lacerations, irregular tear-like wounds caused by some blunt trauma. Lacerations and incisions may appear linear (regular) or stellate (irregular).

Abrasions (scraping), superficial wounds in which the topmost layer of the skin (the epidermis) is scraped off. Abrasions are often caused by a sliding fall onto a rough surface. onto a rough surface.

Puncture wounds, caused by an object puncturing the skin, such as a nail or needle.

Classification

a.Cut b.Tear

c.Scrapping d.Puncture

A wound is a type of injury in which skin is torn, cut, or punctured (an open wound), or where blunt force trauma causes a contusion (a closed wound). In pathology, it specifically refers to a sharp injury which damages the dermis of the skin.

Wounds can be classified according to the object that caused the wound. The types of wound are:

Incisions or Cut wounds, caused by a clean, sharp-edged object such as a knife, razor, or glass splinter.

Lacerations, irregular tear-like wounds caused by some blunt trauma. Lacerations and incisions may appear linear (regular) or stellate (irregular).

Abrasions (scraping), superficial wounds in which the topmost layer of the skin (the epidermis) is scraped off. Abrasions are often caused by a sliding fall onto a rough surface. onto a rough surface.

Puncture wounds, caused by an object puncturing the skin, such as a nail or needle.

Classification

a.Cut b.Tear

c.Scrapping d.Puncture

Why is wound closure important?

eC?????? ?e ???? ?p???e??pp?????? ??? ??????????? e????? ????? ??????? ????????? ????? ??????? ?????????e??? ??????????? ?e ??????? ???????? ???????? ??? ??????e????? ?e ??????

How u repair a wound????????? ?? ????????? ?????? ???????? ????????????????????? ???????? ?????? ???? ?? ??????? ??? ???????? ?? ???? ??? ??????? ?????????

Types of suture??????? ??? ?? ????????? ?? ????? ??????? e??? ?????????? ?????????? e??? ???e?????????????? ????e?????? e??? ????????????????? ?????? ??????? ???? ??e?????? ???e ???? ??????? ????????????????? ?????? ??????? ???? ??e?????? ???e ???? ??????? ????????V???????? ??? ?????? ????????? e??? ?? ???????? e??? ????????e?????????? ??????? ??? ??e??? ?? ????? e???? ?????? ????? ??????? ?????????B?????? ??????? ????? ?? ?? ???? ?????e? ??? ????? ?????? ??e?????? ???e???? ???????? ?e ??????????? e????? ?? ?e?? e?? ?? ?????? e??? ? ????e?????????? ???????????????????? e??? ???? ?? p???p??p??????????? ??? ????????? ??????

Sizes of suture?????? ??e? e??? ?? ?????????? ?? ??? ??e? ?e ??? e????? ??? ?????? ?e ??????? ?????? ??e? e??? ?? ?????????? ?? ??? ??e? ?e ??? e????? ??? ?????? ?e ??????? ???????? ??q????? ?? ??? ??????? ??? ??? ???? e?? ????????? L????? ?????e??? ??????? e??? ?? ?????? e?? ????? e????? e???? ??? ????? ?????? ??? ?? ??? ??q???? ???????? ???????? ??? ?????? ?e ?????? ??????q?? ??p???? ????? ??p? ??? ???????? ???????? ?e ??? e???????? ????e???? ?e ??? ?e?????? ?????? ?e ???????? ??? ??? ?????? ?e ???????? ??? ??? ??????? ???????? ???????

?????? p?tt???? ??? ???????? ??????e?? ?? e????e?: C????????ep???? ?e ?????? ?? ??????? ??? p???? ?????p?????? ???????? ?????I??????p???e???? ??? ??? ?e??? ?e??? 1e2 ?????

• App?????????; ????? ??????? ???? ??? ?????? ?? p???? ?? ??? ?????? ?????????? ?????????? ???? ?? e??? ?e?? ???????? •• I?e??????; ????? ???? ??? ????? ?e ??? e???? ??e????? e?? ?x??p?? e??? ??p?????? ?????????? ???????????? • Ee??????; ????? ???? ??? ????? ?e ??? e???? ???e????? ??? ??? ???e?? ?? ?????????? ????? e???? ??e?????? ?e ? e???? ??? ?p??????????? ?????? ???? ?? ???p ???????????? I? ???? ????????? ?? ?????????? ?e?????? ??????? e????? ? ???? ?e ?pp????????? ??????? ?? ???e???• ??????? ?????e???e????e?? ?e ??? ??????? e??? ??? ???????

There are many types of sutures patterns available to close the incisions and wounds encountered.selecting the appropriate type of pattern is important to achievenot only uncomplicated wound healing,but also good cosmetic appearance.

suture patterns are typically categorised as;1.continuous or interrupted2.inverting,appositional,or everting3.the effect the suture patterns has on wound tension.3.the effect the suture patterns has on wound tension.

Depending on that the there are nine different sutures pattern1.simple interrupted2.interrupted cruciate3.simple continous4.ford interlocking5.lembert6.cushing6.cushing7.connell8.interrupted vertical mattress9.interrupted horizontal matrtress.

3.Si

mpl

e co

ntin

ous

2.In

terr

upte

d cr

ucia

te

1.si

mpl

e in

terr

upte

d

4.Fo

rd In

terl

ocki

ng

5.Le

mbe

rt

6.C

ushi

ng

Ford Interlocking

Lembert

Deep cut as a Wound

Cut as a Wound

Puncture as a Wound

Simple continous

Scraping as a Wound

interrupted vertical mattress

How, I asked, could architecture play any positive role in all of this?

My answer was that architecture, as a social and primarilyconstructive act, could heal the wounds, by creating entirely new types of space in the city. These would be what I had called ‘freespaces,’ spaces without predetermined programs of use, but whose strong forms demanded the invention of new programs corresponding to the new, post-the new, post-war conditions. I had hypothesized that “90% ofthe damaged buildings would be restored to their normal pre-war forms and uses, as most people want to return to their old ways of living….but 10% should be freespaces, for those who did not want to go back, but forward

” The freespaces would be the crucibles for the creation of new thinking and social-political forms, small and large. I belie I believed then–and still do–that the cities and their people who have suffered the most difficult transitions in the contemporary world, in Mumbai and elsewhere, have something important to teach us, who live comfortably in the illusion that we are immune to the demands radical changes of many kinds will impose on us, too.

SITE SELECTED -Stretch from vt station to nariman house.(4km in length)

PROGRAM-MEMORIAL as a freespace and breathing space within city

Criteria for theselection of the site was to identify the fault line in mumbai,Basically there Basically there were two option first was looking at the existing faultlines of mumbai which is probabletear or cut in theurban fabricurban fabricor movement of the event 26/11which caused the fault line between two differentsocieties.

Wound line Final planPoints which can contract and expand on basis of urban conditons

WOUNDS_SUTURES_SPACE

Puncture_As a structural system_free spacepuncture_As a circulation_breathing space

Tear_Injecting green space/breathing spaces.

Cut_As a follower

Cut_As a follower

Cut_As a follower

Tear_As a connector_breathing space

Puncture_as a program_free space.

Scraping_Circulation_free space

Scraping_Circulation_free space

Deep cut_connector_Attraction

TEA

R_I

NJE

CTI

NG

GR

EEN

SPA

CES

Activities at Hornimon circle

PUNCTURE_STITCH AS STRUCTURAL SYSTEM_ FREE SPACE

One can see the glimpses of free spaces and breathing spaces within the hornimon cirlce so theidea was so the extend this and tear it within the urbanwithin the urbanfabric wheras the stitch acta as a structral sysytem for the insertion of free space.

CUT_AS ATTRACTOR AND AS FOLLOWER

PUNCTURE_STITCH THROUGH PROGRAM_FREE SPACE

Tear or Puncture is stitch through the placement of programmtic blocks which resembles one of the stitch pattern used for closing of the wound.

TEA

R_S

TITC

H A

S A

C

ON

NEC

TOR

/CIR

CU

LATI

ON

_ PR

OG

RA

M_F

REE

SPA

CE