thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ /...

143

Transcript of thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ /...

Page 1: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�������������� ���������������������������������� !���"�#���%$����$&�%�'�)(*����$!��(+����� !�,�� -�����(* !�����(+�.���%��(*���

/�0

1)2�354)6�784)9;:�<=2�3?>A@CB / @#<

DFEHGIE�J?K;@#LMBN3PORQ 0TSVU 4)QPO5K�JW2�Q54)<NBX6*2YGZO[2\O5@^]_6;BN`�@CQP35BNO 0+a8b�c)c\dDFEeG�E*fF@CQP4)35g;2�hC@jik6;:)BN6;@C@#Q5BX6+: S�U 4)QlORK'JW2�Q54�<XBX6;2mG�O[2%OR@j]n6;Bo`)@#Q535BoO 0+apb.c)c�d

qAEeG�ErJ?K+@CLsBX3PO5Q 0tS >�2�u�@^v*4)Q5@#3PO_]n6+BN`)@#Q53PBNO 0+awb.c)c)x

fzy;BN3535@#QPOR2\ORBN4)6{359 / LsBNOPOR@#y|BN6{g*2�QPO5B=2�<I3R2\O5BX3l}�2�h#O5BX4)6"4�}�ORK+@Q5@#~Z9;BXQP@CLs@C6�OR3�}�4)QWORK+@jy+@C:)QP@C@w4�}

784�h�OR4)Q�4�}��kK;BX<N4)354�g;K 0

BN6

J?K;@#LMBN3PO5Q 0

BX6"O5K;@

�w� fF7p]nfk��i-78���F�lG��l� U4�}

J?f � U i � ��i�q'i��&��� U ] U ���pi � G����?�

J?4)LsLMBoO5O5@C@8BN6|h[K;2�Q5:)@\�7p2.`�BXy���2�QP4)6��;fny+`�BX354�Q� 0 9+6;:��pBNL1�@��r@#Q 0 q'2�y+9;QR2� BXh[K*2\Q5y�q�h�J?9+<X<X4�9;:)K��BX6+y*2Y�!@#[email protected]�6Z9

���)� b

Page 2: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�������������� ���������������������������������� !���"�#���%$����$&�%�'�)(*����$!��(+����� !�,�� -�����(* !�����(+�.���%��(*���

J?4�g 0 QPBX:)K�O ���)� b/�0

1)2�354)6�784)9;:�<=2�3?>A@CB / @#<

Page 3: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

BNBXB

��K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#y�OR4 � @ / @#hChC2+�k7 0 <=2�6r��784)9+:)<=2�3j2�6+y J?4)6;6+BX@M>A@CB / @#< 2�6;yAO54��K;4)LM2�3�2�6+y�fn6;6;@,q'2�Q5BN@ U BNhC4)<N<X3C�ZORK;2�6;uZ3_}�4�Q�2�<X< 0 4)9;Q_K;@#<Xg|2�6;y|359;g+gI4)QlO

Page 4: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

BN`

������������ ����� ��� ������

����4)9;<Ny�<NBXu�@�O54|O5K*2�6;utL 0 2�y+`�BX3P4)QC��78QCE�7p2.`�BNy ��2�Q54)6 }�4)Qj2�<N< K;BX3wK;@#<XgABX6 L�2\u�BN6;:{359;QP@ORK;2\O����?2�3n2 / <X@8O54Y:)@#O�O5K;@wLM4)3lO�4)9+O_4�}!L 0�0 @.2�QP3nK+@CQ5@^2\OnJW2�QP6;@C:�BX@jq�@#<X<X4�6�E

����4)9;<Ny�2�<N354|<XBNu�@�OR4{ORK;2�6;u'O5K;@MLs@CL / @#Q53p4�}?L 0 hC4�LMLsBNOPOR@C@\�&78QCEs� 0 9;6+: �pBXL|��78QCE1�@#�I@CQ 0 q'2�y;9;Q52+� 78Q#E � BXh[K*2�QPy q�h.J?9;<X<N4)9;:)Kr��2�6+y 78QCE��&BN6;y*2|�!@�[email protected]\6�9 }�4�QwOR2�uZBX6;:{ORBNLM@4)9+Oj4�} ORK+@CBXQw3Ph[K;@Cy;9+<X@C3jOR4|2�h�O,2\3^L 0 @��+2�LsBX6;BN6;:"hC4)LsLsBNO5O5@C@\EY78QCEs�pBXL K;2�3 / @C@#6�Ls4)3POK;@#<Xg+}�9;< ��BNORKYK;BN3kBX6;3PBX:)K�OkBN6�OR4pORK;@WO5K;@C4�Q5@#O5BXhC2�<*2�3PgI@#h#OR3 4�}IL 0 ��4)QPum2�6;yM78QCE"! 3���@#[email protected]�6Z9�2\6;yq�h.J?9;<X<N4)9;:)K K*2.`)@ / @C@C6 @���ORQP@CLs@C< 0 BNLMg�4)QPOR2�6�OsBX6-QP@CLsBX6;y;BN6;:TLM@|4�}pORK+@'@���g�@CQPBXLs@C6�O[2�<2�3PgI@#h#OR3_4�}!h[K;@CLsBX3lORQ 0 �*K;@#<Xg;BN6;:�OR4Yu�@#@Cg Ls@pBX6"O54)9;h[K#��BNORK{[email protected]�<NBNO 0 E

�$�?4�9;<Xym2\<X354F<XBXu\@ O54FORK;2�6;upORK;@?4�ORK;@#Q�Ls@CL / @CQP3�4�}+ORK;@���2\Q54)6^:)Q54)9+g��)g*2�3lOk2�6+y�g;Q5@#35@#6ZOC�2�6;y^@C3PgI@#hCB=2\<X< 0 q�BX3P3 0 2�6+y�ikQ5BNh%��K+4���@CQ5@ K;@#Q5@?BN6pORK;@ / @#:)BX6+6;BX6;:+E�fn6;y,�&�?4)9+<Xy^2�<X3P4n<NBXu�@ O54ORK;2�6;up2�<N<\O5K;@�LM@#L / @#Q53�4�}�ORK+@ y+@Cg*2�QlORLs@C6�O�4�}�h[K;@CLsBX3lORQ 0 }�4)Q�K;@#<Xg;BN6;:�L�2\u�@kORK;BN3�@���g�@CQ5BN@C6;h#@2sO5Q59;< 0 Ls@CLs4)QR2 / <X@p4)6;@\�*}�4)Q�BX6�OR@#Q5@C3lORBN6;:�2�6+y'3PO5BXL�9+<=2\O5BX6;:m3PhCBX@#6�ORB(';h^y;BN35h#9;353PBX4)6;3#�r2\6;y|}�4�Q2�<N<�O5K;@CBNQ K;@C<Ngs2�6;ym359+g;gI4�QPO.E���2�<N3548:�QR2\O5@#}�9;<N< 0 2�h[uZ6;4)��<X@#y;:)@_2�<X<ZORK+@�K;@C<Ng � @C2jv*QP@C@C<X2�6;ymK*2\3:)Bo`)@C6�LM@*�?4�Q5uZBX6;:�4)6�L 0 g+Q5@C3P@C6�O[2%ORBX4�6 2�6;yA~�9+@C3PO5BX4)6 2�6;3+��@CQPBX6;:'35uZBX<N<X3CE"�82�<X3P4':)[email protected]\O5< 02�g;g+Q5@Ch#B=2\O5@82�<N<�O5K;@83P9;g;g�4)QPO�ORK*2\O?��K*2.`)@pQ5@#hC@#BN`)@#y"}�Q54)L L 0 }�2�LsBX< 0 ��BX6-,�<=2.��3#�+2�6+y�}�Q54)L L 0}�Q5BN@C6;y+3_4�9+OR3PBXy;@p4�}�ORK+@jh[K+@CLsBX3PO5Q 0 y+@Cg*2�QlORLs@C6�O.E

v�BX6;2�<X< 0 ����2�L y;@C@#g;< 0 BN6;y;@ / OR@CyjOR4F2�<X<�O5K;@ K;@C<Ng��\h#4)6�`)@#Q53R2%ORBX4�6��)hC4�6/'*y;@#6;hC@\��2�6;y^359;g;g�4)QlOORK;2\O ��K*2.`)@nQ5@#hC@CBo`)@#yM}�Q54�L L 0 ��B"'*@ � @ / @#hCh.2��+2�6+yM6;4)� 2\<X354p}�QP4)L 4)9;Q�<NBNO5O5<X@ / 4 0 ��7 0 <=2�6rE

Page 5: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

`

� �����������

� �V�#�s��� �?(��!����� �&�V���� �V�#�s��� ������$&���� �� � ������ !$�������� �

b E b ��K;@C3PBX3�4�`)@#QP`�BX@�� E^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE �

� � ���������� ���� �"!������#�%�%$ � �/ ��&�'�%� � () * ���%���Z�_�� I����� �$!������� ���� ��� ��V�� &��(+���&+����V�)(*� ��(+�.���%��(*��� ,

� E b ��6�ORQ54�y;9;h�ORBN4)6 EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE c� E � q�9;<oORBXg�4)<X2�Q�3 0 3POR@#LM3 EjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b)b� E-� �8g+ORBNh.2�<�g�4)<NBX6;: EjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b �� E d ��K;@���Q5BoOR@�'*@C<Ny"OR@C6+354)QME^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b �

� ."�� &���(*���0/�(+����I �����&� �� I���Z�% &(*�1+k���.�� ����(;�^���� ����8��� �T$�� ��324+k����(+�t ��� 52�V�� &��(+���&+����V�)(*� �%�������&+�&������ �76�+E b ��6�ORQ54�y;9;h�ORBN4)6 EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b98�+E � ��6�OR@CQP6*2�<&��4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<�q|4�y;@#< E^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE � b�+E-� :89*2�6�OR9;L J?K;@CLsBXhC2�<&JW2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;38EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE �<;�+E d G 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 fF6*2�< 0 35BX3 EjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE � 8�+E ; G�BX6+:)9;<=2\Q�� 2�<N9;@w78@Ch#4)LMg�4)3PBNORBN4)6 E^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE � ��+E x U 4)6+<[email protected]�QPBNO 0 > BNORK+BX6�ORK+@j��6�O5@CQ56;2�<&v�BX@#<Xy|q�4�y;@#< EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE � ��+E>= � U 7w� JW2�<Xh#9;<=2%ORBX4�6;3�4)6 G�g�@Ch#B('*hTJ?K;@#LMBNh.2�<FfFhCh#@Cg+O54)Q|2�6;y 784)6;4�Q{G�9 / ,

3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3�EjE^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE �?=�+E>=�E b � 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO5BX@C3 EjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE �?=�+E>=�E � ��@CQPL�2�6+@C6�OFq�4)Ls@C6�OR3 EjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE d;b

�+E 8 J?4)6;h#<X9;3PBX4)6TE^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE d ��+E c fFg;g�@C6+y;B"� E^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE d =

�+E c E b :89*2\6ZO59;L h[K;@CLsBXhC2�< Q5@Cg+Q5@C3P@C6�O[2%ORBX4�6 4�}�2�h#hC@#g+OR4)Q�2�6;y�y+4)6;4)Q^359 / ,3lORBoOR9;@#6ZO53 E^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE d =

Page 6: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

`�B

� � �I���#������(+����� t����(* ! �� ����� &(*�&����������$���(+�w�.$ �!�#�� �$�����I +�(+�.�.���% ��p$!�C�V &�"������� &�Z�(*�V�0/��� -�� I���Z�% �(*� +k�*���� I���(*�?���� ���� � 6d E b ��6�ORQ54�y;9;h�ORBN4)6 EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE d?8d E � G 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 fF6*2�< 0 35BX3 EjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE d�cd E-� G�BX6+:)9;<=2\Q�`\2�<X9+@py;@Ch#4)LMg�4)3PBNORBN4)6 E^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ;��d E d 78BX3PhC9;3P35BX4�6 E^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ;)�

��� � ��&��� � � � $ � �� ��&� �%��� ���

� * ��V ������ !$�������� ����+k�Z�\���� ��V�{�����#����� � ���; E b ��6�ORQ54�y;9;h�ORBN4)6 EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ; d; E � ��K;@w<=2\OPORBNhC@84�}�ORK+@jg�@CQPBX4�y;BXhF3 0 3PO5@CL E^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ; d; E-� �!@#Q5BX4�y;BNhF}�9;6;h�ORBX4�6;3�EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ; x

; E-�+E b D�<X4�h[K{}�9+6;h#O5BX4)6;3zEjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ; x; E-�+E � ��K+@jQP@Ch#BXg;QP4�hC2�<�<=2%O5ORBNhC@ EjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ; =; E-�+E>� >�2�6;6+BX@CQW}�9+6;h#O5BX4)6;3�E^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ; 8

; E d �8gI@#QR2\O54)Q�@#`\2�<N9*2\ORBN4)6;3WBN6{gI@#Q5BX4�y;BNh / 4�9;6;y*2�Q 0 hC4�6;y;BNO5BX4)6+3�E^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ; c; E d E b 78@�OR@#Q5LsBX6*2\O5BX4)6�4�}!O5K;@j�9;h[u\@C<&@C6;@#Q5: 0 BX6|2mgI@#Q5BX4�y;BNh83 0 3PO5@CL EjEjE x+b

� � � ��������� � �� +k�Z�%���� !��� �k�I$� � �(;��� �)�I � �������� !��� ��� (��!�C��� +&����� � +k��� 2���%$!� ��� +k����������� �!� 24+!��� "�&���� �� �&�V #�&���� &��$ � �x E b ��6�ORQ54�y;9;h�ORBN4)6 EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE x �x E � v*4)Q5LM2�<XBN35L E^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE x ;

x E � E b �n2�QPO5Q5@#@�,�v*4�h[u E^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE x ;x E � E � >�2�6;6+BX@CQW}�9+6;h#O5BX4)6;3�E^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE x =x E � E>� J?4�6/'*:)9;Q52\ORBN4)6{��6�OR@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6{EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE x)cx E � E d ��QR2\6;35BoORBX4�6"LM4)Ls@C6�O53_EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE = �

x E-� � @#359;<oOR3^E^EjE^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE = �x E-�+E b [email protected]\<&G�ORQP9;h#O59;Q5@#3 EjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE = �x E-�+E � �n2�QPO5Q5@#@�,�v*4�h[u / 2\6;y�3lORQP9;h#O59;Q5@^2�6;y{> 2\6;6;BX@#QW}�9;6;h�ORBX4�6;3 E^EjE^EjEjE = dx E-�+E>� G�BX6;:)<N@C3 ,lJ?� EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE = ;

x E d 78BX3PhC9;3P35BX4�6 E^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE =<=x E ; J?4)6;h#<X9;3PBX4)6TE^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE 8 =x E x fFh[uZ6;4)��<X@#y;:)Ls@C6�OR3 EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE 8<8

% & �������.�%�� 52[&����� ���&� ���������"�!��Z(�'��� �� �� �)(+� �k�� �(; ��*�$��k���| �$&� �.� &�?��� ��Z(;����#�� ������� �k���"�V ����Z�%(;������� �� 6 ,=�E b ��6�ORQ54�y;9;h�ORBN4)6 EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE 8)c=�E � �9;h[u\@C<���K;@#4)Q 0 2�6+y � QR2�g+K|��K+@C4)Q 0 E^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE c+b=�E-� fFy;y+BNORBN4)6"4�} U @ ��O U @.2�QP@C3PO U @#BX:)K / 4)Q���@CQ5Ls3 EjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE c �=�E d ik<X@Ch�ORQP4)6 ,�K+4)<X@83 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0"/ [email protected]�uZBN6;: E^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE c�d

Page 7: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

`�BXB

=�E d E b i �I@Ch�OR3_4�}�@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6 ,�K;4)<X@F3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0"/ [email protected]\u�BN6;:Y4)6{ORK;@ / 2�6+y�:�2\g E c<8=�E ; i �r@#h#OR3_4�}!@C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6-,�K;4)<N@83 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0"/ Q5@C2�uZBX6;:Y4)6{ORK+@wO5K;@CQPLM4�@C<N@Ch�ORQ5BNh8g�4 ��@CQ c<8=�E x 78BX3PhC9;3P35BX4�6 E^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b � b

����� � � � �� ���&� � �� �� ��� �����

6 ���& �(;� �V�� !�������������%���M�.�)��Z�� !�� &�t(* ! �?�&�����.�I �!�V � ��V &�t�� ��Z����������� �)�I �.$52��(+���� +k�����&�A���%� � �8 E b ��6�ORQ54�y;9;h�ORBN4)6 EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b � �8 E � J?4)Lsg;9+O[2%ORBX4�6*2�<�q|@#ORK+4�y;3 E^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b � x

8 E � E b �n2�LsBX<NO54)6;BX2�6-EjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b � x8 E � E � 78@#35h#Q5BXg�ORBX4�6"4�}�BN354)<N9+OR@#y{354)<N9+OR@ EwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b � 88 E � E>� D?2�35BN3�35@#O_}�4)Q�3P4)<N`�@C6�O_gI4)<X2�Q5B @.2\O5BX4)6ME^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b � 88 E � E d G�BXLsg;<XB"'*@Cy�[email protected]�h�ORBN4)6 , ';@C<Xy"Ls4�y;@C<wEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b � c8 E � E ; G�hCQ5@#@C6;@#y'@#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6 ,�K+4)<X@pBN6ZO5@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6"Ls4�y+@C<zE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b)b �8 E � E x ik<N@Ch#O5Q54)6+BXhw�!4�<=2�QP4)6�q�4�y+@C< E^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b)b �

8 E-� � @#359;<oOR3^E^EjE^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b)b�b8 E d J?4)6;h#<X9;3PBX4)6;3 EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b)b �8 E ; fFh[uZ6;4)��<X@#y;:)Ls@C6�O EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b)b ;8 E x fFg;g�@C6+y;B"� E^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b)b.x

8 E x E b i `\2�<N9*2\ORBN4)6"4�}�ORK;@wLM2\ORQPB"��@C<N@CLs@C6�OR3�EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b)b.x

�m�0�����������(�+!"� � )�

Page 8: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

`�BNBXB

� � � ��� � ��� � �

�+E b G 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 ,�2\y*2�g+O5@Cy{K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 OR@#6;354)QP3F2\6;y�BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3}�4)QnO5K;@�7��mg�4)BN6ZOF:)Q54�9;g 4�} / @C6�@#@C6;@\Ew��K;@m6;4�OR2\ORBN4)6� �������� ����� ��� BX6;y;BNh.2\O5@C3ORK*2%O{2�6 0 <NBX6;@C2�Q�h#4)L / BN6*2\ORBN4)6-4�} ���� 2�6;y ���� � ��BX<N<_O5QR2�6+3P}�4)QPL ��BNO5K-ORK;@BX6;y+BXh.2%OR@CyM3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 E ��K;@8BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<N3�2\Q5@F:�BN`)@#6"2�3?2^6;4)QPL�2\<XBA@#@Cy`)@#h#OR4�Q�QP@Cg;QP@C35@#6�ORBX6+:,ORK;@�`\2�<X9+@_4\}rORK+@ng�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<*4)6�@C2�h[K�4�}rORK;@_35B �Yh.2�Q / 4�62\OR4�LM3WBN6 / @#6�@C@#6;@���� 4\}�@#~�E S �+E b�x�a E EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE � c

�+E � � @#359;<oOR3_4�}�O5K;@mGZ�p7 2�6;2�< 0 35BN3�4)6�O5K;@ / @C6 @C@C6+@�35u\@C<X@�OR4)6r�I9;3PBX6;:sORK;@j~Z9*2�6 ,OR9;L h[K;@#LMBNh.2�<�Ls4�y+@C<X3sy;BN35hC9+3535@#y�BX6-G�@Ch�ORBX4�6 �+E-�+E ��K+@�`\2�<X9+@C3�:�BN`)@|ORK;@L�2\:)6;BNO59;y;@84\}!O5K;@wK 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0�S BN6|@#359$! 3 a BX6+y;9;hC@#y /�0 2\6|BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<I4�}�9;6;BNOWL�2�:�6;BNO59;y;@ S BX6�`�4)<NO53 a �;2�<X4)6+:[email protected]�h[K{4�}&ORK+@j3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 y;B",Q5@#h#ORBN4)6;3mBN6 �!2 / <N@ �+E b E v*4)Q,ORK+@|� U 7w� Ls4�y+@C< ��QP@C359+<NOR3Y2\Q5@{35K;4)��6 ��BNORKORK;@pBN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�2�g+g;<XBN@Cy�OR4�O5K;@w@C6�ORBNQ5@w2\O54)L 2\6;y"OR4�ORK+@��P9+3PO�ORK+@�4)Q / BNO[2\<X3CE EjE^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE � �

�+E-� � @#359;<oOR3W}�QP4)L � U 7w�zh.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3�4)6�3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#y / @C6 @C@C6+@^Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3#Ek��6ORK;@j6;4�OR2\ORBN4)6"}�4)Q_359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6|g*2\OPOR@CQP6;3C��359+h[Kt2�3 S! ���j�I�j���^���^��� a }�4)QLM4�6;4)359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6���ORK+@ng*2\Q5@C6�O5K;@C3PBX3?@#6;hC<N4)35@�ORK+@_3P9 / 3lORBNO59;@C6�O53W2\OPO[2�h[K;@#y�[email protected]�h[Kt4\} ORK;@,h.2�Q / 4)6 2\OR4)Ls3_BX6'4�Q5y;@#Q82�QP4)9;6;y'O5K;@�QPBX6;:;E���K;@,9;6;BNO53n}�4)Q_ORK;@K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 2�QP@ b � � ��" @#359�E E^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE �?=

�+E d � @#359;<oOR38}�QP4)L � U 7w� hC2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5BX4)6+3n4)6tO5Q5BX3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#y / @#6�@C@#6;@YLM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@#3C�9;35BN6;:�ORK+@j6+4�O[2\O5BX4)6�4�}��!2 / <N@ �+E-�+E �86;< 0$# � # BN3�Q5@Cg�4)QlOR@Cy{3PBX6;h#@ ���% � 2�QP@8ORK;@4)6;< 0 2�<N<X4)�?@#y{hC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�OR3#E EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE � 8

�+E ; J?4)Lsg*2�Q5BN354)6�4�}&ORK;@wg�@CQ5LM2�6;@#6�O�LM4�LM@#6ZO53�4�}&ORK;@� @#<X@#h#ORQP4)6{y;@C6+35BNO 0 ��BNORKORK;@�K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 ��2\3 y+BX35h#9;353P@Cy�BN6sG�@Ch�ORBN4)6 ��E =�E � E q�4)6;4)3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#y3 0 3PO5@CLs3�h#4)Q5QP@C3PgI4)6+yMOR4pO5K;@�359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6Yg*2\OPOR@#Q56 S& ���j�Z�^�Z�j�Z�^�Z� a 2�6+yORQPBX359 / 3PO5BNOR9�OR@Cy{3 0 3lOR@#LM3_hC4)QPQ5@#35g�4)6;y�O54 S! � �^� � �^� � � a EzE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE d �

Page 9: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

B"�

d E b G 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 ,�2\y*2�g+O5@Cy{K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 OR@#6;354)QP3F2\6;y�BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3}�4)QWOR@�ORQ52�K;@Cy+QR2�<V�*BXy;@C2�<XB @C@Cy"O5Q5BXg+K;@C6 0 < ��2�6+y':)@#4)LM@�ORQ 0 4)g+O5BXLsBA@C@#y�ORQPBXg;K;@#6 0 <LM4�<X@Ch#9;<=2\Qm35u�@#<X@�OR4)6;3�4�}wv�BN:)9;Q5@ d E b E ��K;@�6;4�O[2%ORBX4�6 �� �� � �� �� � � BX6;y;BNh.2\O5@C3ORK*2%OF2\6 0 <NBX6;@C2�QWh#4)L / BN6*2\ORBN4)6"4�} � �� 2�6;y � �� � ��BN<X<rO5QR2�6+3P}�4)QPL ��BNO5K|O5K;@wBX6 ,y;BXhC2\OR@#y 3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 EM��K;@sBX6�O5@CQ56;2�< g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<N3w2�Q5@Y:)Bo`)@#6�2�3j2"6;4)QPL�2\<XBA@#@Cy`)@#h#OR4�Q�Q5@Cg+Q5@C3P@C6�ORBN6;:mORK;@n`�2\<X9;@n4�}&ORK;@8g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<I4�6"@.2�h[K{4�}&ORK+@FORK;QP@C@phC2�Q�,/ 4�6 2\O54)LM3 ; � b)b �!2�6;y b ="}�4)QwORK+@MORQPBXg;K+@C6 0 <�3Pu�@C<N@#O54)6 4�}�v!BX:)9;QP@ d E b E"��6ORK;@Yy;4�9 / < 0 2�6;y ORQPBXg;< 0 y;@#:)@C6+@CQR2%OR@YBX6�OR@#Q56*2\<kgI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3#��2�6 0 <NBX6;@C2�Q8hC4�L*,/ BX6;2\ORBN4)6�4�}!ORK;@w:)Bo`)@C6{g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<X3�BX3W`\2�<NBXy�E EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ; b

d E � � @#359;<oOR3_4�}�O5K;@mGZ�p7 2�6;2�< 0 35BN3�4)6�O5K;@ / @C6 @C@C6+@�35u\@C<X@�OR4)6r�I9;3PBX6;:sORK;@j~Z9*2�6 ,OR9;L h[K;@CLsBXhC2�<+Ls4�y;@C<N3 y;BX3PhC9;3P35@#yMBN6sG�@Ch�ORBX4�6 ��E>�+E �86;< 0 ORK;4�35@�`\2�<X9;@#3 4�}�ORK;@L�2%ORQ5BNhC@#3�� 2\6;y�� h#4)Q5QP@C35g�4)6;y+BX6;:jOR4,6+4)6�@C@#Q54,`\2�<N9;@C3 4�}�� 2�QP@nQP@Cg�4)QPO5@Cy�E��6�ORK;@t� U 7w� Ls4�y+@C<X3#�nQP@C3P9;<NO53{2�Q5@t3PK;4)��6���BoORK-ORK+@tBX6�OR@#Q56*2�<FgI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<2�g;g;<NBX@#y�OR4mORK;@w@#6ZO5BXQP@^2%OR4)L 4)Q�OR4mORK;@ �P9;3lO�ORK;@ �T4)Q / BNO[2\<X3CE EwE^EjE^EjEjE ;)�

x E b G�O[2%OR@�@C6;@#Q5:)BN@C3#��4)3PhCBX<N<=2\O54)Qr3lORQP@C6;:�O5K;3C�)2�6;y / 2�6;y^hC4)LsgI4�35BNO5BX4)68}�4�Q&O5K;@�3POR2\OR@#3:)BN`�BN6;:�QPBX3P@sO54 gI@C2�uZ3,BN6AORK+@�2 / 3P4)Q5g�ORBX4�6�35g�@Ch�ORQ52'4�}_v�BN:;E x E � E{��K;@ / 2�6+y<=2 / @C<N3WhC4�Q5Q5@#35g�4)6;y{OR4YORK;4�35@w4�}�v�BX:;E x E � E8EwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE = x

x E � � 2%ORBX4�3�4�}kBX6�O5@C6;3PBNORBN@C3�}�4)Q�35@#<X@#h#OR@#y g�@.2�uZ3FBN6|O5K;@j35g�@Ch#O5QR2�4\}kv�BN:)3CE x E ; � x E x �2�6;y x E>=�E EjE^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE 8 �

Page 10: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� � � ��� � ����� � �

� E b G+2�Lsg;<X@�7 � �WLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@�y;@ '*6+BX6;:FO5K;@�2�6+:)<X@���9;3P@Cy�OR4ny;BX3PhCQPBXLsBX6*2\O5@ / @�O �?@#@C6ORK;@p`\2�QPBX4)9;3�4�Q5BX@#6�O[2\O5BX4)6;3?4�}!O5K;@wLM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@\E EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b �� E � �k<X4�O^4�}�Q5@#<=2\O5BN`�@�2 / 9+6;y*2�6;h#@�`�3CEt4)QPBX@C6�OR2\ORBN4)6�2\6;:)<X@\��� }�4)Q,2'@#`�@C6;< 0 y;BN3�,

ORQPB / 9+O5@Cy{3R2\LMg;<N@�EIE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b �� E-� �k<X4�Ok4\}rQP@C<=2%ORBN`�@�2 / 9;6+y*2�6;h#@�`�3#Ek4)Q5BN@C6�O[2\O5BX4)6Y2\6;:)<X@\��'}�4)Q ORK+@_352�Lsg;<X@�2%} OR@CQ

K*2.`�BX6;:Y9;6;y+@CQ5:�4)6;@wORK;@wK;4)<N@�, / 9;Q56+BX6;:;��4)g+O5BXh.2\<rg�4)<XBN6;:mg;Q54�hC@#353#E E^EjE^EjEjE b.d� E d G�h[K;@#L�2\O5BXh�4�}�ORK;@?O5K;@W4)6+@�2�6;y�O ��4wg;K;4�O54)6Y2 / 3P4)Q5g+O5BX4)6,g;Q54�hC@#3535@#3�BX6�`)4)<o`)@#y

BX6"4)g�ORBXhC2�<�g�4)<XBN6;:;E EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b.d�+E b 78BXg�4)<=2\QY2�6;y�4�h#OR9+gI4)<X2�Qs359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6-g;2\O5O5@CQ56+3�}�4)Q / @C6 @C@C6+@�Ezf�2�6+y 7

Q5@#g;Q5@#35@C6�On@C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6�2�6;y{y;4�6;4)Q�359 / 3PORBoOR9;@#6�OR3C��QP@C35g�@Ch�ORBo`)@C< 0 E EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b�c�+E � U 4)QPLz4�}*ORK;@�K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 BN6;y;9;h#@Cy /�0 2�6mBX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<�4\}�D ��3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 }�4)QpORK;@M�9;h[u\@C< S 3P~�9;2�Q5@#3 a � � ��� S hCBXQPhC<N@C3 a ��2�6;y�� U 7w� S O5Q5BX2�6 ,

:)<X@#3 a �F2�LsBX<oOR4)6+B=2�6;3#Er�-BN3�O5K;@ Q54�4�O�[email protected]\6,35~Z9*2\Q5@ S � q'G a LM2�:)6;BoOR9;y+@ 4\};ORK;@gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<VE v*4)Q�2�<N<I�,�+ORK;@pK 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 OR@C6+354)Q�K*2�3�D �� 3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 ����� � ���� � E E^EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE �<�

�+E-� U 4)QPLz4�}*ORK;@?K 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 BX6+y;9;hC@#y /�0 2�6,BX6�OR@#Q56*2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<�4�}�i ��3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 }�4)Q8ORK+@M�9;h[u�@#< �&�����!�&2�6;yT� U 7w� �F2�LsBX<oOR4)6+B=2�6;3#Ew��K;@YBX6;3P@CQPOBX3w2"y;@�O[2�BN<�}�4)Qp35LM2�<N<!����3PK;4)��BX6;:{ORK;2\OpORK;@Y3P<X4)g�@C3w6;@C2�Qp��� � 2�:)Q5@#@ ��BNORKORK;@w<NBX6;@C2�QWQ5@#35g�4)6;3P@^QP@C359+<NOR3�4�}!�!2 / <X@ ��E � E U 4�O[2%ORBX4�6"BX3�2�3�BX6|v�BN:)9;QP@1�+E � E � ;

�+E d 78@Ch#4)LMg�4)3PBNORBN4)6�4�}IORK;@_� U 7w� Q5@C3P9;<NO53�4�}�v�BN:)9;QP@ �+E>�wBX6�O54^BoOR3�35g;[email protected]�<;O5@C6 ,354)Q_hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53CE���K;@^BX6;3P@CQPOnBX3n2My+@#O[2\BX<�}�4)Q_35LM2�<X<��,E U 4�O5@jO5K*2\O_ORK;@ ���% �hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O^BX3 @C@CQP4 BX6TORK;@M<XBN6;@.2�QwQP@C35g�4)6;3P@"2�6*2\< 0 35BN3C� 2\6;y K;@#Q5@�:)QP4)��3,BX6~Z9*2�y;Q52\ORBNh.2�<N< 0 ��BNORK ��E&��K;@*'*<N<X@CyT35~Z9*2\Q5@C3,2�Q5@mO5K;@sO54�O[2\<kQ5@C3PgI4�6;35@\�'*<N<X@CyhCBNQ5hC<N@C3|2�QP@AORK+@TO54�O[2�<���� � h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3#�wO5K;@T@CLsg+O 0 hCBXQPhC<N@C3�2�Q5@ ORK;@��� � ��� � ��hC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�OR3#��ORK+@�hCQP4)353P@Cy h#BXQ5h#<X@#3�2�QP@MORK+@���� � ��� � bhC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O53C��ORK+@ '*<X<N@Cy ORQPB=2�6+:)<X@#382�QP@�ORK;@�O54�O[2�<���� b hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53C�&2�6+yORK;@wh#Q54)3P35@Cy|ORQPB=2�6;:�<X@C3�ORK;@���� b ��� � b hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53CE EjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE � x

�+E ; J?4)Q5QP@C<X2\ORBN4)6M4\}�ORK;@n6;4)QPL 4�}�ORK+@FK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 ��BNORKsORK;@ngI@#Q5LM2�6;@#6ZO4�h�OR9;g�4)<N@�Ls4)Ls@C6�O.�%}�4)Q�O5K;@?O5Q5BX3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#y,Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3�6Z9;L / @CQ5@#y%�nORK+Q54)9;:�K=�BX6{��2 / <X@ �+E-�+Ek��K;@j<XBN6;@8BN3�2Y<[email protected]�3lO�35~Z9*2�QP@C3�';O�OR4M2m<[email protected]�QWQP@C<X2\ORBN4)6;35K+BXg�E d �

Page 11: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

��B

�+E x J?4)Q5QP@C<X2\ORBN4)6�4\} ORK;@^6;4)QPL 4�}kORK;@�1 � b g�4)QPO5BX4)6|4�} O5K;@,K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0��BNO5KsO5K;@ng�@CQPL�2\6;@C6�O�y;BXg�4)<X@�Ls4)Ls@C6�O�}�4)QkORK;@_Ls4)6;4)3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+OR@#yMLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C36Z9;L / @CQ5@#y �mORK+Q54)9;:�K =�BN6|�!2 / <N@ �+E-�+E EwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE d)d

�+E>= G�h[K;@#L�2\O5BXhpQP@Cg;QP@C35@#6�O[2\O5BX4)6�4�}!O5K;@w@#�I@Ch�OR3_4�}�@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6|y;4)6;4)Q_2�6+y'2�h#hC@#g+OR4)Q359 / 3PORBoOR9;@#6�OR3�4)6mORK;@ / @C6 @C@C6+@_3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6�Ek��K;@�<N@#} Okg;2�6;@C<+35K;4)��3�ORK;@�BN6ZO5@CQ52�h�,ORBN4)6 / @�O �?@#@C6�O5K;@�g ,�4)Q / BNOR2�<;4)6 / @C6�@#@C6;@n2�6;yYORK;@n�8�wq � 4�}�2py;4)6+4)QCE ��K+@Q5BN:)K�O g*2�6+@C<;3PK;4)��3�O5K;@WBN6ZO5@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6 / @#O ��@C@#6MO5K;@Wg ,�4)Q / BoO[2�<�4)6 / @C6�@#@C6;@_2�6+yORK;@j�&]8q'� 4�}�2�6|2�hCh#@Cg+O54)QCE EjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE d =

d E b q�4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q&35u\@C<N@#OR4�6;3!}�4)Q S 2 a hC2�Q / 4)6^O5@#O5QR2 � 9+4)Q5BNy;@�� S�/�a ORK+@[email protected]�<NBA@C@#ypORQ5BNg;K ,@C6 0 <^:�@C4)Ls@#O5Q 0 �82�6;y S h a ORK;@T:)@#4)LM@�ORQ 0 4)g+O5BXLsBA@C@#y�ORQ5BNg;K;@#6 0 <jLM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@\Eq�4)<N@ChC9+<X@ S 2 a K*2\3�O5@#O5QR2�K;@#y;QR2\< S ��� a 3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 ��Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@ S�/�a 7 � �F3 0 LMLs@�,ORQ 0 ��2�6;y{Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@ S h a 7 � 3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 E EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE d�c

; E b �86;@'y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<�BN6/'*6;BoOR@|h[K*2�BN6���BNO5K-<=2\OPORBNhC@"`)@#h#OR4�Q����E ��K+@ hC@#6ZO5@CQP@Cyg;Q5BNLMBoORBo`)@mhC@#<X<�4�}�ORK;BN3^<X2\O5O5BXhC@YK*2\3^BoOR3j4)Q5BN:)BX6T2\O^4)6;@s4�}WO5K;@�2\O54)Ls3j4\}WORK;@<=2\OPORBNhC@�Ej��K;@Yy;BN3PO[2\6;hC@m}�Q54�L O5K;@Y4)Q5BN:)BX6 4\} O5K;@Yg;Q5BNLMBoORBo`)@,h#@C<N<!OR4{BoOR3p35BNy;@C3BX3��� �� E ��K;@ y*2\35K;@#y <NBX6;@ BN6;y;BNh.2\O5@C3�O5K*2\O"4)6+< 0 4�6;@t4�}wORK;@tO ��4 35BXy+@C3{BX3hC4)6�OR2�BX6;@#y{BX6"ORK;@wg;QPBXLsBNO5BN`)@n4)Q�9;6;BoO�hC@C<N< E E^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ;<;

; E � � �?4"y+BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6*2\<�<=2\OPORBXh#@C3#EF�&2\OPORBXh#@ S 2 a K;2�3F4)QlORK;4�:)4)6*2�<&<X2\O5O5BXhC@j9;6;BoOn`�@Ch ,OR4)QP3 S� � � 2�6;y � � a EM�&2\OPORBNhC@ S�/*a K;2�3w6;4)6 ,�4)QPO5K;4):)4)6;2�< <=2%O5ORBNhC@,`�@Ch�OR4)QP3 S� ��� �2�6;y ���� a E8��K;@,hC@C6�O5@CQ5@#y g;Q5BNLMBoORBN`�@whC@C<N<X3F2�Q5@,2�<X3P4�35K;4)��6 }�4)[email protected]�h[K <X2\O5O5BXhC@\E��6'ORK+@,K;@ �;2\:)4)6*2�<!<=2\OPORBNhC@��*O5K;@,h#Q 0 3POR2�<X<N4):)QR2\g;K;BXhw9;6+BNO8h#@C<N<�BN3F3PK;4)��6���BX<N<X9;3 ,ORQ52\ORBN6;:YK;4)� ORK;@jhC@#6ZO5@CQP@Cytg;QPBXLsBNORBo`)@ph#@C<X<&@ �+g+Q5@C3P35@#38ORK;@j3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 4\} ORK;@K;@��+2�:�4)6*2�<�<X2\O5O5BXhC@\E�EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ; x

; E-� i �;2\LMg;<N@�4�}&2pO �?4�y+BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6*2\< �)K;@ �+2�:)4)6*2\<I<X2\O5O5BXhC@�3PK;4)��BX6;:jORK;@n9;6;BoO `�@Ch ,OR4)QP3 4�}�ORK+@ S 2 a y+BXQ5@#h#O�<X2\O5O5BXhC@ S� � � 2�6+y � � a 2�6;ymO5K;4)35@�4\}�O5K;@ S�/*a Q5@Ch#BXg;QP4�hC2�<<=2\OPORBNhC@ S � � 2�6+y � � a Ej��K;@ '*<N<X@Cy'hCBXQPhC<N@C384)6 v!BX:)9;QP@ S�/*a Q5@#g;Q5@#35@C6�O^gI4�BX6�OR3��K;@CQP@pORK;@wD?QPBX<N<X4)9;BN6 @#4)6;@wBX6�O5@CQ53P@Ch�OR3�ORK;@wv*@#Q5LsBr359+QP}�2�h#@^2\6;y{4�ORK;@#Q�gI4�BX6�OR34�}!BX6�OR@#Q5@C3lO_BX6"ORK;@jD?QPBX<N<X4)9;BN6��r4)6+@�EWEjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ; =

; E d i �;2\LMg;<N@C3j4�}�ORK+@�Q5@#hCBNg;Q54�h.2�<�<X2\O5O5BXhC@#3j}�4�Q S 2 a 2\6 4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<kh[K*2\BX6��S�/�a 2�O �?4 y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<_hC9 / BXh QP@ChCBNg;Q54�h.2\<F<=2%O5ORBNhC@\��2�6;y S h a 2 K;@��+2�:�4)6*2�<Q5@#hCBXg+Q54�h.2�<I<=2\OPORBXh#@�E!��6|@C2�h[K|<=2\OPORBXh#@82�6"@ �+2�LMg+<X@84�}!2�g�4)353PB / <N@8h[K;4)BNhC@8}�4)Q ��4�} � � � � � BX3�3PK;4)��6�EWEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE ; c

; E ; DW2�6;y 3PORQP9;h#O59;Q5@t3P4)<X9�ORBX4�6;3M4\}w@C~�E ; E b ; }�4)Q�2�6 4)6;@'y+BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6*2\<_BN6/'*6;BoOR@h[K*2�BN6�E�> K;@#Q5@��-BN3jO5K;@s4)Q5BN:)BX6 4�}�ORK;@�D?Q5BN<X<X4�9;BX6 @#4)6;@�2�6;y�� BX3j2�g�4)BX6�O4)6�O5K;@j359;Ql}�2�hC@^4�}�O5K;@�D?QPBX<N<X4)9;BN6 @C4�6;@�2�<N4)6;:mORK+@,y;BNQ5@Ch�ORBN4)6 �� BX6;y+BXh.2%OR@Cy|BX6v�BX:�9;Q5@ ; E d�S 2 a E EjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE x �

x E b � @#4)Ls@#ORQ 0 4�}�2'9+6;BNO^hC@#<X<�4�}���� ���!@���ORQ52�h#O5@Cy }�Q54�L 2�6 fpq b h.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)64)6|2�6|4)<XBN:)4)Ls@CQ���BoORK|35B �"g;K;@#6 0 <�Q5BN6;:)3�2�6+y ; y;4)9 / <X@ / 4)6;y;3#��h#4)6;3lORQR2\BX6;@#yOR4YQ5@#L�2\BX6"g;<X2�6*2�Q#E�D?4)6;y{<X@#6;:�O5K;3_2�Q5@pBN6|fn6;:)3lORQ54�LM3#EjEjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE = �

Page 12: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

��BXB

x E � � / 2�6+yt3PORQP9;h#O59;Q5@Y2\6;y / 2�6;yt<X2 / @C<X3�}�4)Q S 2 a 9;6;359 / 3PO5BNOR9�OR@Cyr��g;<=2�6;2�QF��� ���S�/�a � � � ��BoORK'O5K;@���� ,�4�Q / BoO[2�<N3_4�6th.2�Q / 4)6+3 � 2�6;y ; g�@CQPO59;Q / @Cy /�0 , b @#�S 3P9 / 3�,����k� a � S h a g;<=2�6;2�Q y;B ,�K 0 y;Q54.� 0 ,���� � S �w� ,���� � a �w2�6;y S y a }�9;<N< 0 ,4)g+O5BXLsBA@C@#y��+6+4)6 ,�g+<=2�6*2\Q��p� ,���� ��E�EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE = �

x E-� > 2\6;6;BX@#Q8}�9;6;h�ORBX4�6;3p}�4)Q8ORK;@ � , / 2�6;y+3j4\}���� � BN6Tv�BX:;E x E � S 2 a EY��K;@Y35B @C@#34�}FO5K;@|hCBXQPhC<N@C3M2�Q5@{g;QP4)gI4�QPORBN4)6*2�<WO54TO5K;@�2 / 354�<X9+O5@|`\2�<N9;@{4�}FO5K;@�>�2�6;6;BN@CQ}�9;6;h�ORBX4�6�4)6 O5K;@���� ,�4)Q / BoO[2�<_4�}jORK*2%O{h.2�Q / 4)6rE �8gI@#6 2�6+y h#<X4)3P@Cy hCBNQ5hC<N@C3BX6;y+BXh.2%OR@8g�4)35BoORBo`)@w2�6;y|6;@#:�2\ORBo`)@p`\2�<X9+@C3C�+Q5@C3PgI@#h#O5BN`)@#< 0 EsEjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE = ;

x E d > 2\6;6;BX@#Q'}�9;6;h�ORBN4)6;3t4�}YORK+@ �&, / 2�6+y;3t4�}sg;<=2\6*2�Q y;B ,�K 0 y;Q54.� 0 ,���� � S �p� ,���k� a BX6|v�BX:+E x E � S h a E E^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE =<=

x E ; f / 3P4)Q5g�ORBX4�6A3PgI@#h#ORQ52'4�} S 2 a 9;6;3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+OR@#y��kg;<=2\6*2�Qj���k�,� S�/�a � � � ��BNORKORK;@�����,�4)Q / BNOR2�<X3�4�6 hC2�Q / 4)6;3 � 2�6;y ; gI@#QPO59;Q / @Cy /�0 , b @#� S 3P9 / 3 ,���� � a �S h a g;<=2�6;2�Q8y;B ,�K 0 y;Q54.� 0 ,���� � S �p� ,���� � a �&2�6;y S y a }�9;<X< 0 ,�4)g+O5BXLsBA@C@#y���6;4)6 ,g;<=2\6*2�Qw�p� ,����k�,E���K;@Y354�<XBXyt<NBX6;@,BX3FO5K;@mOR4�OR2�<k2 / 3P4)Q5g�ORBX4�6t35g�@Ch#O5Q59;L|��ORK;@y;4�OPOR@CyY<NBX6;@�BX3k2 / 354)QPg+ORBN4)6mgI4�<=2�QPBA@C@#y�g�@CQ5g�@C6+y;BXh#9;<=2�Q!OR48ORK+@�h[K*2�BX6Y2 �+BN3C�Z2�6+yORK;@wy*2\35K;@#y'<XBN6;@pBX3_2 / 354)QPg+ORBN4)6{gI4)<X2�Q5B @C@#y"g*2�QR2\<X<X@#<rOR4mO5K;@^h[K;2�BX6�2 ��BX3#E ��K+@gI@C2�uZ3_2�Q5@w<=2 / @#<X@Cy{2\hChC4�Q5y;BN6;:mOR4mORK;@wy;BN35h#9;353PBX4)6|BX6�G�@#h�E x E d E^EwE^EjE^EjEjE = 8

x E x f / 3P4)Q5g�ORBX4�6,35g�@Ch�ORQP9;L 4\}�4)<XBN:)4)Ls@CQ53�4\}����k�,��h#4)6;35BN3PO5BX6;:n4�}�� g+K;@C6 0 <;Q5BN6;:)3hC4)6+6;@Ch�OR@Cy /�0 ORQ52�6;3 ,�`�BX6 0 <X@#6;@�:)QP4)9;g;3#E�� � y;@C6+4�OR@#3�ORK+@�<X4�6;: ,�h[K;2�BX6<XBNLMBoO.�4 / OR2�BX6;@#y�}�Q54)L 28h.2\<XhC9+<=2\O5BX4)6^4)6 � b 9;6;BoOkhC@#<X<X3���BNO5Ksg�@CQPBX4�y;BXh / 4)9;6;y ,2�Q 0 hC4)6;y+BNORBN4)6;3 S 2�3�BX6Mv�BX:;E x E ; a E!��K;@_gI@C2�uZ3?2�QP@n<X2 / @C<X@#yY2�hCh#4)Q5y+BX6;:wOR4wORK;@y;BX3PhC9;3P35BN4)6YBX6MG�@Ch\E x E d � ��BoORKYg�@.2�uZ3�� / 2\6;yM��h�h#4)6�`)@#Q5:)BN6;:jO54wgI@C2�u���BX6mORK;@<XBNLMBoO�4�}�2�<X4)6+:�h[K*2�BN6�E ��K;@p4)<NBX:)4�LM@#Q 3PgI@#h#O5QR2Y2�Q5@ny;BN`�BNy;@Cy /�0 O5K;@86Z9;L / @CQ4�} g;K;@#6 0 <N@C6;@Y9;6;BoOR3#���A��3P9;h[KTO5K*2\O8O5K;@�BN6ZO5@C6;3PBNO5BX@C382�Q5@mh#4)LMg;2�QR2 / <X@�Ep��K+@BX6�OR@#6;35BoO 0 4�}�ORK;@n<X4)6+: ,�h[K*2\BX6�3PgI@#h#O5Q59;L BX3?2�y �P9;3lOR@Cy"3P9;h[K�ORK;2\O?O5K;@8g�@.2�uY�5�P�BX6�OR@#6;35BoO 0 BX3�@#~Z9*2�<�OR4mO5K;@j2�`�@CQ52�:)@j4�}!O5K*2\O�3P@C@C6|}�4)QWORK+@j4�<XBX:�4)LM@#Q53#E EjEjE = c

x E>= f / 3P4)Q5g�ORBX4�6 35g�@Ch�ORQP9;L 4�}p4)<NBX:)4)Ls@CQP3m4�}8}�9;<N< 0 ,�4�g+ORBNLMB @C@Cyr� 6+4)6 ,�g+<=2�6*2\Qmy;B",K 0 y+Q54.� 0 ,����k� S �p� ,����k� a E*��K;@w6;4\O[2\O5BX4)6"BN3�2�3�BX6|v�BX:+E x E x E EwE^EjE^EjEjE 8 �

x E 8 ik6;@CQP:)BX@#3 4�}mORK+@ 3POR2\OR@#3t:)BN`�BX6+: Q5BN35@TOR4�g�@.2�uZ3 BN6 ORK;@�35g�@Ch#O5QR2�4�}m}�9;<N< 0 ,4)g+O5BXLsBA@C@#y��_6;4)6 ,�g;<=2�6;2�Q|�p� ,���� � S v�BN:;E x E>= a �n`)@CQP359;3 b � � ��K;@CQP@�� BX3ORK;@�6Z9;L / @CQ 4�}rg;K;@C6 0 <X@#6;@F9+6;BNO53 BN6mORK;@_4)<XBN:)4)Ls@CQ#E���K+@n3P4)<XBNys<NBX6;@#3khC4)6+6;@Ch�OORK;@|g�4)BX6�OR3#�W2�6+y ORK+@�y;4\O5OR@#y-<XBN6;@C3m3PK;4)� ORK;@�Q5@#359;<oOR3s4�}p2T<[email protected]�QmQP@C:)QP@C3�,35BN4)6�E���K;@�<[email protected]�QpQP@C:)QP@C353PBX4)6�:)BN`�@C3jBX6/'*6+BNOR@Yh[K*2\BX6�<NBXLsBNO5384�}���g�@.2�ut� S hCBNQ�,hC<N@C3 a � E c+b @#����g�@.2�u"� / S 3P~�9;2�Q5@#3 a � E d?8 @#����g�@.2\u"�5� S y;B=2�Ls4)6;y+3 a �+E c)x @����gI@C2�u��P�5� S 9;g �?2�Q5y ,�gI4�BX6�ORBN6;:8ORQPB=2�6;:�<X@C3 a ; E b�c @#���Z2�6;yYgI@C2�u���� S y+4 ��6 �?2�Q5y-,gI4�BX6�ORBN6;:,ORQPB=2�6+:)<X@#3 a ; E>= � @#�,E EjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE 8�d

x E c �835hCBN<X<X2\OR4)Q_3PO5Q5@#6;:�ORK+3 S BX6�OR@#6;35BoORBN@C3 a }�4)QFORK+@m3PO[2%OR@C3p:�BN`�BX6;:"QPBX3P@,OR4"g�@.2�uZ3wBX6ORK;@�35g�@Ch#O5QR2 4�}�}�9+<X< 0 ,�4)g+ORBNLMB @C@#y��&6;4)6 ,�g;<=2�6;2�Qm�p� ,����k�,E���K;@�6;4�O[2%ORBX4�6 BX32�3jBX6 v!BX:;E x E 8 E{��K;@MBX6�OR@#6;35BoORBX@#3,2\Q5@�3PK;4)��6 4)6 2|gI@#Q�,�9;6;BNO�,�h#@C<X< / 2�35BN3C� /�0y;BN`�BNy;BX6;: /Z0 O5K;@w4)<XBN:)4)Ls@CQ <X@#6;:�ORKr���AE'EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE 8 ;

Page 13: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�+BNBXB

=�E b f g�4)QPO5BX4)6�4�}�2�:)QR2�g+K;BNO5@,35K+@C@#Oj3PK;4)��BX6;:�O5K;@�<X4�h.2%ORBX4�6'4�}�ORK+@�<=2\OPORBNhC@,9+6;BNO`)@#h#OR4�Q53 � 2�6;y � 2\6;y'ORK+@,h[K*2�Q52�h#O5@CQPBX3PO5BXh,2�Q5Lsh[K*2�BNQ_O59 / @ ��QR2�g+g;BX6;:s`)@#h#OR4�Q��z}�4�Q�� ���*E���K;@wy;B=2\LM@�OR@CQ�4\}!O5K;@wQ5@C3P9;<NO5BX6;:�O59 / @ ��4)9;<Ny / @�� � � � �� E c �

=�E � f gI4)QlORBN4)6A4\}�2{:)QR2�g+K;BNO5@s3PK;@C@�O�3PK;4)��BX6;:|ORK;@s4)Q5BN@C6�O[2%ORBX4�6T4\}?ORK+@MhC2�Q / 4)6 ,h.2�Q / 4�6 / 4)6;y;3p}�4)Q8O5K;@YORK;QP@C@Y:)@C6+@CQR2\< h#<=2�3P35@#3^4�}�6*2�6+4�OR9 / @C3#EM��9 / @ S 2 a BX32�6 2�QPLMh[K*2\BXQMO59 / @���OR9 / @ S�/*a 2@CBN:<@.2�: 4�Q�g*2�Q52�<X<N@C<�OR9 / @��n2�6;y-O59 / @ S h aBX3Y2 h[K;BXQ52�<?O59 / @\E ��K+@�y*2\35K;@#y-2�QPQ54)� 3PK;4)��3sO5K;@{y;BXQP@Ch#O5BX4)6 4�}nORK;@"O59 / @2 ��BX3#Ek��K;@ / 4)<Ny{35@CQPBX@#3_4\}�hC2�Q / 4)6 ,�h.2�Q / 4)6 / 4)6;y;3_2�6+y|3P4)<XBNy|2�Q5QP4 � 35@#QP`�@^OR4BX<N<X9;3lORQR2%OR@FK+4 � ORK;@w4)QPBX@#6ZOR2\ORBN4)6"4�}�ORK;@ / 4)6;y;3�y;Bo�r@#Q53�BX6"O5K;@pOR9 / @C3#E EjEjE c+b

=�E-� ��K;@ / @#6�@C@#6;@,Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@��*BoOR3�:)QR2\g;K�QP@Cg;QP@C3P@C6�O[2\O5BX4)6r�r2�6+y|O5K;@^QP@C3P9;<NO5BX6;:M2�y ,�52�hC@#6;h 0 LM2\O5Q5B"�IE E^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE c �

=�E d f 35@#h#ORBN4)6t4�} ORK;@m:�QR2�g;K+BNOR@,35K;@#@#Oj35K;4)��BN6;:"ORK;@m6;@C2�Q5@#3PO^2�6;y 6;@ ��Ow6;@.2�QP@C3lO6;@CBN:)K / 4�QW2\O54)LM3W2�6;y{2�6"@ �;2\LMg;<N@84�}&ORK+@835~Z9*2�QP@w4�}&ORK;@p2\y �52�hC@#6;h 0 L�2\O5Q5B �}�4)Q / @C6�@#@C6;@\E EjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE c ;

=�E ; v*9;<X<N@CQ5@#6;@8O 0 gI@w3lORQ59+h#OR9+Q5@ S BX6"ORK+BX3�h.2\35@,J " a ��BNO5K|4�6;< 0 ORK;@ / 4�6;y|}�Q52�Ls@�,�?4�Q5u"2�6+y|}�QP4)6�O�}�2�hCBN6;: / 4)6+y;3�35K;4)��6�}�4�Q�hC<=2\Q5BNO 0 E E^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE c ;

=�E x f gI4�QPORBN4)6p4�}+2�K;@��+2�:)4�6*2�<Z2�<oOR@CQP6*2�6�O&35K+@C@#O�3PK;4)��BX6;:�ORK;@�g*2\QPORBoORBN4)6;BX6+:?4�}�ORK;@h.2�Q / 4�6 2\O54)LM3nBX6�OR4sO �?4�y;BX3&�P4)BX6�On35@#O5384�}k3lO[2�QPQ5@#y 2�6;y 9;6+3PO[2\Q5Q5@#yth.2�Q / 4�6;3CE��K;@w@CBN:)@C6�`\2�<X9+@C3�4�}�O5K;@j2�y �52�h#@C6;h 0 L�2%ORQ5B ��BN6�3P9;h[K 2mhC2�35@^2�Q5@w3 0 LsLs@#ORQPBXh2 / 4)9+O @C@#Q54;E EjEjE^EwEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE c)x

=�E>= �k<X4�OF4�}�ORK;@�K+BX:)K;@#3POw4�hCh#9;g;BX@#y 2�6;yt<N4 ��@C3lOw9;6;4�hCh#9;g;BX@#y / 2�6;y;38}�4�Qp2 S ; � ; ah.2�Q / 4�6|6;2�6�OR9 / @ S @C~�E =�E b ; a ��BNORK|2�6+y#��BoORK;4�9+O�6;@���O�,�6;@C2�Q5@#3PO+,�6;@CBN:)K / 4�Q�BX6 ,OR@#QR2�h�ORBX4�6;3_2�3nhC2�<Xh#9;<=2%OR@Cy{9;3PBX6;:s@C~�E =�E b � E b�� JW2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5BX4)6"4\}�ORK+@ / 2\6;y;3_BX6 ,hC<N9;y;BX6+:^4)6+< 0 6;@.2\Q5@C3lO+,�6;@CBN:)K / 4)Q�BX6�OR@#QR2�h�ORBN4)6;3�2�Q5@nQ5@Cg+Q5@C3P@C6�OR@#y /Z0 ORK+@8354)<NBXy<XBN6;@C3,2�6;y ORK+@"y*2�35K+@Cy <XBN6;@C3�QP@Cg;QP@C3P@C6�OYORK;@"hC2�<Xh#9;<X9*2%ORBX4�6;3^y+4)6;@ ��BNO5K ORK;@BX6;h#<X9;3PBX4)6 4�}?6;@���O�,�6;@C2�Q5@#3PO+,�6;@CBN:)K / 4�Q^BN6ZO5@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6;3#E � 4\}W@C~�E =�E b � �?2�3j35@�OOR4 , � E d @#� b�� 2�6+y�� �W2\3s3P@#OmO54 ���e� � � � E J?Q54)3P35BN6;: 4�}�ORK;@|v*@CQPLMB�<X@#`�@C<4�h#hC9;QP3_2\O � � � � �kE EjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE c =

8 E b J?K;@CLsBXhC2�<�3PORQP9;h#O59;Q5@�4\}*ORK;@W3 0 3POR@#L 9;3P@Cy�OR4p3lOR9;y 0 O5K;@W@#�I@Ch�OR3k4�}�BN6ZO5@CQPh[K*2�BX6BX6�OR@#QR2�h�ORBN4)6;3W4)6�O5K;@p@���h#BNOR4�6 / BX6;y;BN6;:�@#6;@CQP: 0 E���6|2�<X<�ORK;@phC2�<Xh#9;<=2%ORBX4�6;3�g+Q5@�,35@#6ZO5@CyYK;@#Q5@��)O5K;@W3P4)<N`�@C6�Okh[K*2�BN6�K*2�3 b ; 9;6;BoO h#@C<X<N3CE!��K;@W354�<X9+O5@?h[K*2�BN6m<X@#6;:�ORKBX3W`\2�QPBX@Cy{BN6{O5K;@wh.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3#E EjE^EjE^EjEwE^EjEjE^EjE^EjEjE^EjEwE^EjE^EjEjE b � x

8 E � G�4)<o`�2%ORBX4�6"@C6;@#Q5: 0 4�} 2sg�4)< 0 @C6;@jh.2%ORBX4�6|y+9;@jO54�BN6ZO5@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6 ��BNO5K'2Y354�<N`)@#6�Oh[K*2�BN6 4�} b ; 9;6+BNO�h#@C<N<X3CE'��K;@�Q5@C2�h#O5BX4)6-, '*@#<Xy�� 3PhCQP@C@C6+@Cy @C<X@#h#O5Q54)6 ,�K;4)<N@�2�6+y@C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6+BXh�,�gI4�<=2�QP4)6YLM4�y;@C<N3 2�Q5@ny;@C3PhCQ5B / @#y�BX6�G�@Ch#3CE 8 E � E d � 8 E � E ; ��2�6;y 8 E � E x E��K;@"354�<XBXy�<XBX6+@C3�2\6;y '*<X<N@Cy 3 0 L / 4)<N3m2�QP@�ORK;@"QP@C3P9;<NO53m4 / O[2\BX6;@#y 9;35BN6;: ORK;@��� �zLs4�y;@#<k}�4)Q^O5K;@�354�<N`)@#6�O.E ��K;@�y*2�35K+@Cy <XBN6;@C3,2�6;y 4�gI@#6 3 0 L / 4)<X3,2�Q5@ORK;@wQP@C359+<NOR3�4 / O[2�BN6;@Cy{9;3PBX6;:mORK+@^�9;h[u�@#<�Ls4�y;@C<r}�4�QWORK;@w354�<N`)@#6�O.E EjE^EjEjE b)b �

8 E-� G�4)<o`�2%ORBX4�6�@C6;@#Q5: 0 4�}&ORK;@p@ �+h#BNO54)6�3lO[2\O5@py;9;@pOR4mBN6�OR@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6 ��BoORK|2�354�<N`)@#6�Oh[K*2�BN6 4�} b ; 9;6+BNO�h#@C<N<X3CE U 4�O[2%ORBX4�6 BX3,2�3�BX6 v�BX:)9+Q5@ 8 E � E ]_35BN6;: ORK;@�� ����F2�LsBX<oOR4)6+B=2�6M4�}!O5K;@w354)<o`)@#6ZO_4)6+< 0 <X2�:� � Q5@#359;<oOR3 ��@CQ5@j4 / OR2�BX6+@Cy�E"EjE^EjEjE b)b �

Page 14: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

b

* �������(*���

U @ � Ls@#O5K;4�y;4)<X4�:)BX@#3?}�4)Q�@C<N@Ch�ORQ54�6;BXhp3lORQ59+h#[email protected]�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3?4�6�4)QP:�2�6;BNh8LM2\OR@#Q5B=2\<X3

/�0

1)2�354)6�784)9;:�<=2�3?>A@CB / @#<784�h#O54)QW4�} �kK;BX<N4)354)g+K 0 BX6�J?K;@#LMBN3PORQ 0

JW2�Q56;@#:)BX@^q�@#<X<N4)6{]n6;Bo`)@#Q535BoO 0

7p2�`�BNy"��2\Q54)6��+fFy+`�BX3P4)Q

�8Q5:�2\6;BXh L�2%OR@CQPB=2�<N3�K*2.`)@�:)[email protected]\O!g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<�}�4)Q!9;35@?BX6,@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6;BNh?2�6+y�g;K;4�O54)g;K 0 35BNh.2�<�y;@#`�BXh#@C3#Ef-y;@�O[2�BN<X@#y�9;6;y;@#Q53lO[2�6;y+BX6;:w4�}�ORK+@�@C<X@#h#O5Q54)6;BNh?3lORQ59+h#OR9+Q5@�4�}*ORK+@C35@�LM2\OR@#Q5BX2�<X3���BX<N<+2�<N<X4)� 9;3 O54/ @#O5O5@CQ_9;6;y;@#Q53lO[2�6;y|ORK;@j3PO5Q59;h�OR9;QP@�,�g;Q54)g�@CQlO 0 Q5@C<X2\ORBN4)6;3PK;BXg;3�4\} Q5@#<X@�`�2\6;hC@wOR4sy;@#`�BNhC@jy;@C3PBX:)6�E��K;BN3!ORK+@C35BN3�y;@�`)@#<X4)g;3 2�6;ym2�g+g;<XBN@C3&LM@�ORK;4�y;3�}�4)Q!3lOR9;y 0 BN6;:FO5K;@?@#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6;BXh 3PO5Q59;h�OR9;QP@W4�};O5K;Q5@#@hC<X2�353P@C3m4�}�4�Q5:�2�6+BXh�@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6;BNh�LM2\OR@#Q5B=2\<X3C�m6+4)6;<XBN6;@.2\Q,4)g+O5BXhC2�<�h[K+Q54)Ls4)g;K;4�Q5@C3#��hC4)6 �P9+:�2\OR@#yg�4)< 0 Ls@CQ53#�*2�6;y|h.2\Q / 4)6{6*2�6;4�O59 / @C3CE

��K;@ '*Q53lOmg*2�QlOm4�}�ORK+BX3,O5K;@C3PBX3m@��+2�LsBX6+@C3,O5K;@�6;4)6+<[email protected]�Q^4)g+ORBNh.2�<�g;Q54�gI@#QPORBN@C3�4\}nL,9;<NO5B",g�4)<=2�Qw4)QP:�2�6;BNhMh[K+Q54)Ls4)g;K;4�Q5@C3#E'��K;BN3,BN3,y;4)6+@ /�0 @ ��OR@C6+y;BX6;:�ORK;@�BN6�OR@CQP6*2�< '*@#<Xy Ls4�y+@C<�4�}�89;y*2�Q#�-��K+BXh[K�BN3 2�g;g;<NBXh.2 / <X@�4)6+< 0 O54,g;3P@C9;y;4^4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<;3 0 3POR@#LM3?359;h[K"2\3�g;9+35K ,�g;9;<X<g�4)< 0 @C6;@#3C�!O54'h[K;QP4)Ls4)g;K;4)QP@C3 ��BNO5KA:)@#6;@CQ52�< L�9;<NO5B",�y;BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6;2�<�2�hCh#@Cg+O54)Q�,�y;4)6;4)Qj359 / 3PO5BNOR9-,ORBN4)6{g*2\OPOR@CQP6;3CE���K;@jLM4�y;@C<�y+@#`)@#<X4)g�@Cy�K;@CQP@jOR2�u�@#3_}�9+<X<&2�h#hC4)9;6�On4�}�ORK;@jL�9;<oORBXg�4)<X2�Q?6*2%OR9;QP@4�} ORK;@YBN6ZO5@CQP6*2�< g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<k2�g;g;<NBX@#y /Z0 O5K;@s2�hCh#@Cg+O54)Q53j2�6+yAy;4�6;4)Q53#��2�6;ytORK;@mO5@C6;3P4)Qwg;Q54)g-,@CQlORBN@C3�4�}�O5K;@�Q5@#359;<oORBN6;: 6;4)6+<[email protected]�Qj4)g+O5BXh.2\<�3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBNO 0 Et��K;@"Ls4�y;@#<�BN3,OR@#3PO5@Cy 2�:�2�BN6;3PO~Z9*2�6�OR9+L h[K;@CLsBXhC2�<�h.2\<XhC9+<=2\O5BX4)6;3?4)6{Q5@Cg+Q5@C3P@C6�O[2%ORBN`�@,3 0 3lOR@#LM3#E

��K;@j35@Ch#4)6;y g;2�QPO_4�}�ORK;BN3�ORK;@#35BX3�h#4)6;hC@#Q56;3_ORK;@jy;@�`)@C<N4)g;Ls@C6�O_4�}k2YLs@#ORK+4�y"ORK;2\On2�<X<N4 ��3BX6�O5@CQ5Ls@Cy+B=2\O5@k6;@C:)<N@Ch�O!4\}+y;Bo�r@#Q5@#6ZO5B=2�<�4�`�@CQ5<X2�g S � U 7w� a hC2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5BX4)6+3�OR4 / @ g�@CQP}�4�Q5Ls@Cyw9;6;y;@#Qg�@CQ5BN4�y+BXh / 4)9;6+y*2�Q 0 hC4)6+y;BNO5BX4)6;3#E^��K+BX3w2�<N<X4)��3FORK+@mQ5@C3P9;<NO53p4�} h.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3n4)6 hC4)6 �P9+:�2\OR@#yg�4)< 0 Ls@CQ53&OR4 / @�@���g;QP@C353P@CysBX6jORK;@�<=2�6;:�9*2�:)@ 4�}*3P4)<XBNy,3POR2\OR@�g;K 0 35BXh#3CE ��K+@WLM@�ORK;4�y,BN3!9+35@Cy�O543PO59;y 0 ORK;@�2 / 354)QPg+ORBN4)6�35g�@Ch�ORQP9;L 4�}�g�4)< 0rS g*2�QR2 ,�g;K;@#6 0 <N@C6;@W`�BN6 0 <N@C6;@ aWS ��� � a E)� U 7w��h.2�<NhC9 ,<=2%ORBX4�6;3k4)6�4�<XBX:�4)LM@#Q53 4\}&���k� 2�3%�?@#<X<�2�3 <X4)6;:jh[K*2�BN6;3%��BNORKsg�@CQ5BN4�y+BXh / 4�9;6;y*2�Q 0 hC4)6+y;BNO5BX4)6;3

Page 15: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

2�QP@�QP@Cg�4)QPO5@Cy�E-��K+@'<X4�6;: ,�h[K;2�BX6 hC2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5BX4)6+3Y2�Q5@|9;35@#y OR4A2�3P35BX:�6 ORK+@�3PgI@#h#ORQ52�<�}�@.2\O59;Q5@#3OR4sORQ52�6;35BoORBN4)6;3 / @#O ��@C@C6 / 2�6;y;3#��2�6;y|ORK;@#35@,2�353PBX:)6;Ls@C6�O53F2�QP@jO5QR2�6+3P}�@CQPQ5@#y'OR4M4)<XBN:)4)Ls@CQ53 /Z0@��+2�LsBX6+BX6;:�K+4 � ORK+@�h.2�<NhC9;<X2\OR@#yt4)<XBN:)4)Ls@CQ�35g�@Ch�ORQ52{@�`)4)<o`)@ ��BNO5Kth[K*2�BN6t<X@C6+:�ORK�Ej��K;@mh#4)L*,

/ BN6*2\ORBN4)6'4\}�g�@CQPBX4�y;BXhjh.2\<XhC9+<=2\O5BX4)6;3F2�6;yt4)<NBX:)4�LM@#Q_hC2�<Xh#9;<=2%ORBX4�6;3n@#6*2 / <N@C3p2�Ls4)QP@�hC4)Lsg;<N@#OR@y;@#35hCQPBXg+O5BX4)6{4�}�ORK+@j@ ��gI@#Q5BXLs@C6�OR2�<&2 / 3P4)Q5g+O5BX4)6{3PgI@#h#ORQ52s4\} ��� � 2�6;y|BNOR3�y+@CQ5Bo`\2\ORBo`)@C3#E

��K;@�3P@ChC4�6;y g*2�QPOF4�} O5K;BX3_ORK;@#35BX3F2�<X3P4�@��+2�LsBX6+@C3F@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6 ,�K;4)<X@j3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0�/ [email protected]\u�BN6;:�BN6h.2\Q / 4)6 6;2�6;4�O59 / @#3CE���K;BN3Y3POR9+y 0 BX3m}�2�hCBN<XBoO[2\O5@Cy /�0 2�6 2\6*2�< 0 O5BXh.2\<�2�g;g;QP4�2�h[K }�4)QYBX6;h#<X9;y ,BX6+:,ORK;@p@��r@#h#O53�4�}�6;@���O+,�6;@.2\Q5@C3lO+,�6;@CBN:)K / 4)Q�BN6�OR@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6+3?BX6�� 9;h[u�@#<�h.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3 4)6"h.2\Q / 4)66*2�6+4�OR9 / @C3#EY��K;@C3P@M6;@ ��O+,�[email protected]�QP@C3PO�,�6;@#BX:)K / 4)QwBX6�OR@#QR2�h�ORBN4)6;3 / [email protected]�u @#<X@#h#ORQP4)6 ,�K;4)<X@m3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 E> K;BN<X@nO5K;BX3�3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0�/ Q5@C2�uZBX6;:,y;4�@#3�6;4�O�2\<NOR@#Q�O5K;@ / 2�6+y":�2�g���BNOWy+4�@#3�2�<NO5@CQ�O5K;@FO5K;@CQPLM4 ,@C<N@Ch�ORQ5BNhpgI4)��@CQ ��K;BXh[K|BX3 @#@CQP4MBN6{2s3 0 3lOR@#L ORK*2\O_K*2\3_@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6 ,�K;4)<X@F3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 E

��K;@"ORK;BNQ5y 2�6+y '*6*2�<Wg;2�QPOm4\}_O5K;BX3^ORK;@#35BX3m@ ��OR@C6+y;3sO5K;@"y 0 6*2�LsBXhMy;BX@#<X@#h#ORQPBXh�Ls4�y;@C< 4�}q�4�4)Q5@��������� ��6+hC<X9+35BX4�6�4�}jy;BX@#<X@Ch�ORQPBXh @��r@#h#OR3{BN3�6;@Ch#@C3P3R2�Q 0 OR4 4 / OR2�BX6-QP@C<NB=2 / <N@'@ �+h#BNO54)6/ BN6;y;BX6+: @C6;@#Q5:)BN@C3�}�4)Q�h#4)6 �P9;:)2\OR@#y g�4)< 0 Ls@CQP3CE ��K;@ 4)Q5BN:)BX6*2\<ny 0 6*2\LMBNh y;BX@#<X@#h#ORQPBXh Ls4�y;@C<9;3P@Cy-�9;h[u�@#<_O5K;@C4)Q 0 OR4 y;@#35hCQPB / @|O5K;@|gI4)<X2�Q5B @.2\O5BX4)6�BX6;y;9+hC@Cy BX6 ORK+@�y;BN@C<N@Ch#O5Q5BNh�LM@#y;BX9+L�E�n@#Q5@\� O5K;BX3m�9;h[u�@#<�LM4�y;@C<?BX3�QP@Cg;<X2�hC@#y /�0 2 Ls4)QP@{2�hCh#9;QR2\O5@{��2�QPBX3P@CQ�,���2�QPQ�,��!4)g;<N@�Ls4�y;@#< E��K;@�QP@C3P9;<NO538BX6;y+BXh.2%OR@wORK*2\OnORK;@^9;35@,4�} �9;h[u\@C<!O5K;@C4�Q 0 BX3n`\2�<NBXy���g;QP4�`�BNy;@Cy�ORK;@�g;2�QR2�Ls@#O5@CQP32�QP@jh[K+4)35@#6'hC4�Q5Q5@#h#O5< 0 E

Page 16: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� � ��� ��� � �

� ��� � ��� � � � � ���

�8Q5:�2�6+BXhpLM2\OR@#Q5B=2\<X3?K;2�`�@^4�gI@#6;@Cy|9;g|L�2�6 0 gI4)3P35B / BX<NBNORBN@C3�BX6"ORK;@wh#[email protected]%ORBX4�6|4\}�@#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6;BXhy;@�`�BNhC@#3�359+h[Km2�3 � 2\O!35hCQP@C@#6�y;BX3Pg;<=2 0 3 �+� d � ��<X2�35@#Q53 ; � x � ��6+4)6;<XBN6;@.2\Q�4)g+ORBNh.2�<�h[K+Q54)Ls4)g;K;4�Q5@C3 -=+�8 � c � b � � b)b�� �;2�6+y�ORQR2\6;35BN3POR4�Q53 b � � Ek��K;@FgI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<I2�y+`\2�6�O[2�:�@C3W4�}�9;35BN6;:�4)QP:�2�6;BNhnLM2\OR@#Q5BX2�<X3BX6+hC<X9+y;@�@.2�3P@n4�}rhC4)6+3PORQP9;h#O5BX4)6r��<N4)�-hC4�3PO.��<X4)� �?@#BX:)K�O.��2�6+y � @ �+B / BX<NBNO 0 E c � 8 � b � � ��4^O[2\u�@�}�9;<X<2�y+`\2�6�OR2�:)@?4\};ORK;@�3PO5Q59;h�OR9;Q52�< � @���B / BN<XBoO 0 2\�I4)Q5y;@#y /�0 4)Q5:�2\6;BXh 3 0 6�ORK;@#35BN3C��BNO!BX3�9;3P@#}�9;<ZOR48K;2�`�@2"LM4�Q5@�h#4)LMg+<X@#O5@m9;6;y;@#Q53lO[2�6;y+BX6;:{4�} ORK;@mQP@C<X2\ORBN4)6;35K+BXg;3 / @#O ��@C@#6AO5K;@Yh[K;@CLsBXhC2�< 3PO5Q59;h�OR9;QP@2�6;yTORK;@Mg;Q54�gI@#QPORBN@C3j4�}�QP@C<X@�`\2�6;hC@sOR4|y;@#`�BNhC@�y+@C35BN:)6�E{��K;@M@C<X@#h#O5Q54)6;BNh�2\6;y�g;K+4�OR4)g+K 0 3PBXh.2\<g;QP4)gI@#QPO5BX@C3�2�Q5@My;BXQP@Ch#O5< 0 Q5@#<=2\O5@Cy�O54'ORK;@�@C<X@#h#O5Q54)6;BNh�3PO5Q59;h�OR9;QP@"4�}�ORK+@�L�2%OR@CQPB=2�<N3C��2�6;y ORK+@y;@�`)@C<N4)g;Ls@C6�O_2�6;y{2\g;g;<XBNh.2\O5BX4)6M4�}�@C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6+BXhF3lORQP9;h#O59;Q5@wLs@#ORK+4�y;3�OR4�ORK+@C35@pLM2\O5@CQ5BX2�<X3 BX3W2�62�h�ORBN`�@|2�Q5@C2 4\}8Q5@#35@C2�Q5h[K�E b.d � b ; � b.x � b =�� b98 � c � =�� 8 � b�c � ��� � b)b � ��K;BX3mORK+@C35BN3Yy;@#`�@C<X4�g;32�6;y�2�g;g;<NBX@#3�2w6Z9;L / @CQ 4�}�6;@���Ls@#ORK+4�y;3�}�4)Q�3PO59;y 0 BX6+:^ORK+@F@C<N@Ch�ORQ54�6;BXh�3PO5Q59;h�OR9;QP@F4�}r4)Q5:)2�6;BXhLM2\OR@#Q5B=2\<X3CE���K;@8LM2\O5@CQ5BX2�<X3�2\6;y�Ls@#O5K;4�y+3?3PO59;y;BN@Cy�K;@#[email protected]�6 / @_:)Q54)9+gI@#y�BX6�OR4jORK;QP@C@nhC<=2\3535@#34�}*4�Q5:�2�6+BXh @C<X@#h#O5Q54)6;BNh�LM2\O5@CQ5BX2�<X3#��6;4)6+<[email protected]�Q�4)g+O5BXh.2\<�h[K+Q54)Ls4)g;K;4�Q5@C3#�)hC4�6 �P9;:�2\O5@Cy�g�4)< 0 Ls@CQP3C�2�6;y|h.2\Q / 4)6{6*2�6;4�O59 / @C3CE

��� �� ������������������������

��2�QlOW�k4�}rORK;BN3 O5K;@[email protected]�<N3���BNO5K�hC2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5BX4)6+3 4�6�6;4)6-,�<XBN6;@.2\Q 4�g+ORBNh.2�<�LM2\OR@#Q5B=2\<X3CE���K;@#35@LM2\OR@#Q5B=2\<X3?O 0 g;BNh.2�<N< 0 h#4)6;35BN3POn4�} Ls@Cy+BX9;L ,�3PBA@C@#y�4�Q5:�2�6+BXhpLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3�ORK*2%O82�QP@whC4)<N<X@Ch�OR@#y'BX6�O542 / 9+<Xu 3R2�Lsg;<N@�OR4A}�4)Q5L 2�6�2\h#OR9;2�<Fy;@�`�BXhC@\E ��6 ORK+@C35@t3 0 3POR@#LM3#�nhC2�<Xh#9;<=2%ORBX4�6;3M4�6-35BN6;:)<X@

Page 17: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

d

Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3�2�QP@^2\y;@C~Z9*2\O5@jO54MQP@ � @#h#O_ORK;@wg;QP4)g�@CQPO5BX@#3_4\}!O5K;@ / 9;<Xu�352�Lsg;<X@\E � b � c � J?K*2�g+O5@CQ �y;@�`)@C<N4)g;3_354)Ls@ / 2�h[uZ:)QP4)9;6;y�4)6"ORK;@wLM2\OR@#Q5B=2\<X3C��BX6;h#<X9;y+BX6;:�O5QR2�y;BoORBN4)6*2�<Ih[K;Q54)Ls4)g;K+4)Q5@#3n2\6;y6;@��-L�9;<oORBNgI4)<X2�Q�h[K;Q54)Ls4)g;K+4)Q5@#3�O5K*2\O�K*2.`�@ / @Ch#4)LM@�4\}rBN6ZO5@CQP@C3PO y;9+@�O54pORK;@�y;@�`)@C<N4)g;Ls@C6�O 4�}4)g+O5BXhC2�<�gI4)<NBX6;:wOR@#h[K;6;BN~�9+@C3CE���O?BX3�ORK;@8y+@C35h#Q5BNg+ORBN4)6�4�}rORK;@#35@86;@�� L�9;<NO5BXg�4)<=2\Q h[K;Q54�LM4)g+K;4)Q5@#3ORK;2\O�LM4\ORBN`\2\O5@Cy�O5K;@pORK;@#4)Q 0 y;@�`)@#<X4)g�@Cy|K;@CQP@�E

fF6 @ �+g;2�6;35BN4)6 4�}�O5K;@�@C6+@CQ5: 0 4�}�O5K;@�Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@MBN6 2 '*@#<Xy����Y� y;@�'*6;@C3�O5K;@�6;4�6;<XBN6;@.2�Q4)g+O5BXhC2�<�359+35hC@#g+ORB / BX<NBNO5BX@C3#�

� ��� "���� � �b��� �

��

b� � � � �

bd ��� � ����� � S�b E b�a

��K;@#Q5@�� " BX3 O5K;@�@C6;@#Q5: 0 BN6%@C@CQP4 ';@C<Xyr�Z2�6;yYORK;@�6;4)6+<[email protected]�Q 4�g+ORBNh.2�<;3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBoORBX@#3 2�QP@�OR@C6-,354�Q53�4\}�BX6;h#[email protected]\35BX6+:FQR2\6;u��

�'*QP3POkQ52�6;u��

�35@#hC4)6;ymQ52�6;u�� � O5K;BXQPy�QR2�6+u�� �Y}�4)9;QPO5K�QR2\6;u���2�6;y�3P4

4)6�E!��K;@?BN6;[email protected]�3PBX6;:�< 0 hC4�LMg;<N@��wO5@C6;3P4)Q�6*2%OR9;QP@?4�};O5K;@?K+BX:)K;@#Q!4�Q5y;@#Q!OR@#Q5Ls3�BN6jO5K;@?@ �+g;2�6;35BN4)6LM2�u�@#3,ORK;@#BXQ^y;@C3PhCQ5BNg+ORBN4)6 BX6+hCQ5@C2�35BN6;:)< 0 h[K*2�<X<N@C6;:�BX6;:;E�fFy;y+BNORBN4)6*2�<N< 0 �!3PBX6;h#@�ORK;@�4�y;y 4�Q5y;@#QQR2\6;u'3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBNO5BX@#3p2�Q5@ @#@CQP4|BN6 2"LM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@^4)Q / 9;<Nu'3R2\LMg;<N@,ORK;2\OpBX3ph#@C6�ORQP4)3 0 LsLM@�ORQPBXh��Ls@#ORK+4�y;3�L,9;3PO / @w}�4�9;6;y{OR4Y@C6;3P9;Q5@^2�6{6;4)6-,�hC@#6�ORQ54�3 0 LMLs@#O5Q5BNhjy+BX3PO5Q5B / 9+ORBN4)6�E

�!Q52�y;BoORBX4�6*2�<X< 0 �#6;4)6;<NBX6;@C2�Q�4)g+O5BXhC2�<�h[K;QP4)Ls4)g;K;4)QP@C3�2�QP@khCQ5@C2\OR@#y /�0 2�y+y;BX6;:�@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6wy;4)6;4�Q2�6;y � 4)Q 2�hCh#@Cg+O54)Q�359 / 3PORBoOR9;@#6�OR3�O54pORK;@_@C6;y+3�4�}�2p<[email protected]�Qkh#@C6�ORQP4)3 0 LsLM@�ORQ5BNh�LM4)<N@Ch#9;<=2�Q!35u\@C<X@ ,OR4�6�E'��K;@�g;Q5@#35@C6+hC@{4�}WO5K;@�359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3 / [email protected]�uZ3,O5K;@�BN6Z`�@CQP35BX4�6 hC@#6ZO5@CQm4�}�O5K;@�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q35u\@C<N@#OR4�6 2�6;[email protected]\O5@C3w2�y+BXg�4)<X@jLM4�LM@#6ZO���BNO5K;BX6|ORK;@,LM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@\EF��K;@m2 / 35@#6;hC@m4�} 2�h#@C6�OR@#Q4�}�3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 2�<X<N4 ��3w}�4)QwORK;@MgI4�3535B / BX<NBNO 0 4\}�6;4)6 , @C@CQP4 4�y;y ,�4�Q5y;@#Q^6;4�6;<XBN6;@.2�Qj359+35hC@#g+ORB / BX<NB",ORBN@C3#��3P9;h[K 2�3pO5K;@ ';Q53PO^K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 � � EM��K+@Mg;QP@C3P@C6;h#@�4�}?2|y;BNgI4�<X@mLs4)LM@#6�Oj2�<X3P42�<N<X4)��3WORK;@jLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3�4�}�O5K;@ / 9;<Xu�3R2�Lsg;<X@pO54 / @,2\<XBX:�6;@Cy"9;3PBX6;:�2sy+h^@#<X@Ch�ORQPBXh�'*@C<Ny�E�G�BX6;h#@ORK+@M3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3jO 0 g;BXhC2�<X< 0 <XBN@Y2�<X4)6+:{O5K;@s3R2�Ls@�2 �+BN3C�&ORK;@sK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO5BX@C3n4�}?O5K;@C3P@ORQ52�y;BoORBX4�6*2�<+<NBX6;@C2�QC��Q54�y ,�<NBXu�@�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3�2\Q5@�y;4)LsBX6*2%OR@Cy /�0 2w35BN6;:)<X@�h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�O.E ��K+BX3�4)6;@ ,y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<�h[K*2\QR2�h�OR@CQn:)Q5@C2\OR< 0 35BNLMg+<XB(';@C3�ORK;@,2�6*2�< 0 35BX3#EW��6 g*2\QPORBNhC9;<X2�QC���89;y;2�Qny+@CQ5Bo`)@#yt24)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<IBX6�OR@#Q56*2\<$'*@C<Ny�Ls4�y+@C<rO5K*2\O_Q5@#<=2\O5@C3�ORK;@wQP@C35g�4)6;3P@,4�}�ORK+@jLs4)<N@ChC9+<X@8OR4YORK+@g;QP4)gI@#QPO5BX@C3�4\}�ORK+@j3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6�E ��� �

�8g+ORBNh.2�< g�4)<NBX6;:"K*2\3jLM2�y;@YBoOwgI4)3P35B / <X@�O54|9�ORBX<NBA@#@m2|6+@ � h#<=2�3P3j4\}?h[K;QP4)Ls4)g;K;4)QP@C3���BNO5KL�9;<oORB ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<�359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6�g;2\O5O5@CQ56+3CE v*4)Q?2^L�9;<NO5B",�gI4)<X2�Qk3 0 3lOR@CL|�+O5K;@FQP@C35g�4)6;3P@pL�2 06;4{<X4�6;:)@CQ / @my;4�LMBN6*2\OR@#y /�0 2"35BX6+:)<X@�h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�O.E^��K;@YgI4)3P35B / BX<NBNO 0 4�}�L�9;<NO5BXg;<N@^h#4)LsgI4 ,6;@#6ZO53?BN6sO5K;@�Q5@C3PgI4�6;35@nK*2�3 6;@Ch#@C353PBNOR2\OR@#y�ORK;@_y;@�`)@C<N4)g;Ls@C6�O�4�}�2jLM4�y;@C< ��K;@CQP@nORK+@n@#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6

Page 18: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

;

2�h#hC@Cg�OR4)QP3?2�6+yMy;4�6;4)Q53 2�QP@�`�BN@ ��@Cy�2�3�hCQ5@C2\ORBN6;:j2�6sBX6�OR@#Q56*2�<+gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�</��BoORK;BN6YO5K;@�LM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@2�6;y{ORK+@j3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBoORBX@#3�2�QP@8ORQ5@C2\OR@#y�BN6"ORK;@#BXQW}�9;<N<rOR@#6;354)QPB=2�<I}�4)Q5L|E

J?K*2�g+O5@CQ � / @C:)BN6;3 4)9;Q y;@#`�@C<X4�g;LM@#6�O?4�}�2j:)@#6;@CQ52�<�BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<*LM4�y;@#<;}�4)Q�L,9;<NO5B",g�4)<=2�Qp6+4)6 ,�<NBX6;@C2�Qp4)g+O5BXhC2�<kh[K;Q54�LM4)g+K;4)Q5@#3CE��FBX@ ��BN6;:{ORK;@s359 / 3PORBoOR9;@#6�OR3�2\3^h#[email protected]%ORBX6+:'2�6ABX6 ,OR@#Q56*2\<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<&2�6;y|9;3PBX6;:YORK;@p}�9;<N<�OR@#6;354)Q�@ �+g;2�6;35BN4)6'4\}!O5K;@^@#6;@CQP: 0 2�<N<X4)��3W}�4)Q_2sLs4�y;@C<ORK;2\O.�I35BXLsBX<X2�QWOR4MORK;@�<NBX6;@C2�Q_LM4�y;@C<V�IQP@C<X2\OR@#3nORK+@�6;4)6 ,�<XBN6;@.2�Q_Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@,OR4�O5K;@,3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6g*2\OPOR@#Q56|4�} 2\hChC@#g+OR4�Q53n2�6;y{y;4)6;4�Q53�4)6{ORK;@wLs4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Q?3Pu�@C<N@#O54)6�E

��K;@mBX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�';@C<Xy'LM4�y;@C<&BN382�<NBX6;@C2�QnQP@C3PgI4)6+35@,O5K;@C4)Q 0 Ep��4�4 / OR2�BX6�BX6+}�4�Q5LM2\ORBN4)6"}�Q54)LORK+@�hC4)Lsg;<N@��AOR@C6+354)QPB=2�<�Q5@C<X2\ORBN4)6;3PK;BXg / @�O �?@#@C6 ORK;@�BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�'*@C<Ny 2�6;y ORK+@�K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�QPBA@�,2 / BN<XBoO 0 �!O5K;@�g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<X3^2�Q5@ ';Q53PO�@���g;Q5@#353P@Cy BX6�`�@Ch#O54)Q�}�4)QPL�E ��K+@�Q5@#<=2\O5BX4)6;3PK;BXg / @�O �?@#@C6ORK+@�BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<�2�6+y ORK+@�K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 ORK+@C6 QP@Cy;9+hC@C3MOR4A2TLM2\ORQPB"� L,9;<NO5B",g;<NBXh.2%ORBX4�6�EY�!4'2�6*2�< 0 3P@sO5K;@sQ5@C<X2\ORBN4)6;3PK;BXg / @#O ��@C@C6 3P9 / 3lORBNO59+ORBN4)6A2�6;y�K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@��+3PBX6;:�9;<=2�Qk`\2�<N9;@�y;@Ch#4)LMg�4)3PBNORBN4)6 S G��87 a BN3�gI@#QP}�4)QPLM@#y�4)6sORK;@_L�2%ORQ5B �YhC4�6;6;@Ch�ORBN6;:ORK+@jBN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�2�6;y|K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@ S � a E

�!4t@ �+2�LMBN6;@�O5K;@"@#�I@Ch�ORBN`�@C6;@#353Y4�}�ORK+@�:)@C6+@CQR2\<XBA@#@Cy BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<?g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�Ls4�y;@C<V� h.2�<NhC9 ,<=2%ORBX4�6;3Y2�Q5@|g�@CQP}�4�Q5Ls@Cy 4)6-2 / @#6�@C@#6;@'3Pu�@C<N@#O54)6�2�6;y 2A3P@CQ5BN@C3s4�}p3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+OR@#y / @#6�@C@#6;@C3#E��6 2 K+BX:)K;< 0 3 0 LMLs@#O5Q5BXh�LM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@\�k359;h[K 2�3 / @#6�@C@#6;@���3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 2�6*2�< 0 3PBX3Y2�6+y 3PBX6;:�9;<=2�Q`\2�<X9+@my;@Ch#4)LMg�4)3PBNORBN4)6t:)Bo`)@mORK;@Y352�LM@YQP@C359+<NOR3#E�JW2\<XhC9+<=2\O5BX4)6;3Fy;4)6;@Y9;3PBX6;:|BX6�OR@#Q56*2\< gI4\OR@C6-,ORBX2�<�g*2\O5O5@CQP6;3���BNO5K"2�Q / BNO5QR2�Q 0 3lORQP@C6;:�O5K|2�6;y"4)6"2�3P@CQPBX@C3?4�}&359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5@Cy / @C6�@#@C6;@w35u\@C<N@#OR4�6;3��BNO5K�359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3�4�}*`\2�Q 0 BN6;:83lORQ5@#6;:�O5Kmg;Q54�`�BXy;@?BX6+}�4)QPL�2%ORBX4�6^2 / 4)9�O�ORK+@WQR2�6+:)@W4�}�h[K;@#LMBNh.2�<2�h#hC@Cg�OR4)QP3F2�6+y|y+4)6;4)QP3_4�`�@CQ ��K;BXh[K{ORK;@w:)@#6;@CQ52�<XB @C@#y|BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�Ls4�y;@#<�BX3W`\2�<NBXy�E

J?K*2�g+O5@CQ d hC4)6�ORBN6Z9;@C3n4)9;QF@ �+2�LMBN6*2\O5BX4)6|4�} O5K;@�:)@#6;@CQ52�<XB @C@Cy�BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<!Ls4�y;@C<ORK+Q54)9;:�K h.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3j4)6 ORK;QP@C@"2\y;y;BNO5BX4)6;2�<�LM4)<N@Ch#9;<=2�Qj35u\@C<N@#OR4�6;3CET��K;@"3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 2�6;2�<",0 35BN3�2�6+y 35BN6;:)9;<X2�Q�`\2�<X9+@|y+@ChC4�LMg�4)35BoORBN4)6 }�4)QmORK;@#35@ 2\y;y;BNO5BX4)6;2�<WLs4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Qm35u\@C<X@�OR4)6+3�2�QP@g�@CQP}�4�Q5Ls@Cy"}�4)<X<N4)��BX6;:,O5K;@wLM@�ORK;4�y;3�4�}kJ?K*2�g+O5@CQ �+E

��2�QlOY�5�j4�}_ORK;BN3,ORK;@#35BN3sh#4)6;h#@CQ56+3shC2�<Xh#9;<=2%ORBX4�6;3,y;4�6;@"4)6 2ty;BN�I@CQP@C6�OYhC<X2�353m4�}_Ls4)<X@#hC9 ,<=2\Q�3 0 3lOR@CL|Ez��6-ORK;BN3�g*2\QPO.��hC2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5BX4)6+3�2�QP@ g�@CQP}�4�Q5Ls@Cy-4)6�h#4)6 �P9;:)2\OR@#y�gI4)< 0 LM@#Q53�2\6;yLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3n}�4�Q���K;BNh[K ORK;@�9+35@m4�}�g�@CQPBX4�y;BXh / 4�9;6;y*2�Q 0 h#4)6;y;BoORBN4)6;3_BX38h#4)6�`)@C6+BX@C6�OCE,J?K;2�g+OR@#Q; g;QP4�`�BNy;@C3?2,:)@#6;@CQ52�< / 2�h[uZ:)Q54)9+6;y"4)6�g�@CQPBX4�y;BXh / 4)9;6;y*2\Q 0 hC4)6+y;BNO5BX4)6;3#�Z4)9+OR<NBX6;BN6;:whC4)6+hC@Cg�OR3359+h[K 2�3MO5K;@'<X2\O5O5BXhC@{4�}FORK;@�3 0 3PO5@CL|��O5K;@'QP@Ch#BXg;QP4�hC2�<�<=2\OPORBXh#@�� ORK;@'D?Q5BN<X<X4�9;BX6 @#4)6;@���}�4)QPLM3}�4)Q8g�@CQPBX4�y;BXh �W2.`�@Y}�9+6;h#O5BX4)6;3#�&2�6;yT2�6t@ �;2\LMg;<N@�4�}�ORK+@m@#`\2�<X9;2\ORBN4)6 4�}�2�6t4)g�@CQ52\OR4�Q89;6;y;@#Q

Page 19: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

x

g�@CQ5BN4�y+BXh / 4)9;6;y;2�Q 0 h#4)6;y;BoORBN4)6;3CEJ?K*2�g+O5@CQ x y;BX3PhC9;3P35@#3p2�6;y @#3POR2 / <XBN35K;@#3nO5K;@^}�4)QPL�2\<XBX3PL }�4)Q_9;3PBX6;:sORK;@^BX6�OR@#Q5Ls@Cy;BX2\OR@w6;@ ,

:)<N@Ch#On4�}�y;Bo�r@#Q5@#6ZO5B=2�<&4�`)@#Q5<X2�g S � U 7w� a Ls4�y+@C<�9;6;y;@#QFg�@CQ5BN4�y+BXh / 4)9+6;y*2�Q 0 h#4)6;y;BoORBN4)6;3CEn78@�,`)@#<X4)g+LM@#6ZO�4\}�O5K;BX3?LM4�y;@C<r2�<X<N4)��3?ORK;@pQP@C3P9;<NO53�4�}�h.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3�O54 / @p3lO[2\O5@Cy|BX6�O5K;@phC4)6�O5@���O4�}�354)<NBXy{3POR2\OR@jg;K 0 35BXh#3C��354MhC4)Lsg*2�QPBX354�6;3�h.2�6 / @wLM2�y;@ ��BNORK|4�O5K;@CQ�h.2\<XhC9+<=2\O5BX4)6;3#EWJW2\<XhC9+<=2 ,ORBN4)6;3kg�@CQl}�4)Q5Ls@Cys9;6;y;@#Q�gI@#Q5BX4�y;BNh / 4�9;6;y*2�Q 0 hC4)6+y;BNO5BX4)6;3�2\<X354j2�<N<X4)� ORK;@�4)g�ORBXhC2�<+O5QR2�6;3PBNO5BX4)6;3BX6{4)<NBX:)4�LM@#Q53�O54 / @j2�3P35BX:�6;@Cy{OR4 / 2�6+y;3CE

fF3!2�6^2�g;g;<NBXh.2%ORBX4�684�}�ORK;BN3!2\g;g;Q54)2�h[K�� �?@ 3PO59;y 0 ORK+@?2 / 354)QPg+ORBN4)6w35g�@Ch#O5Q59;L 4\};g�4)< 0rS ��� � ��,g;K;@#6 0 <N@C6;@w`�BX6 0 <X@#6;@ awS ��� � a 2�6+y|O5K;@w~�9+@C3PO5BX4)6+3_h#4)6;h#@CQ56+BX6;:M2�353PBX:)6+LM@#6ZO�4\}�ORK+@w]_� � �8�lG2 / 3P4)Q5g�ORBX4�6'35g�@Ch�ORQP9;L�E_��K;@�9+35@,4\} ORK;@^� U 7w� Ls4�y;@#<�2�<X<N4 ��3�}�4)Q_:)@#4)LM@�ORQPBXhj@#�I@Ch#O53C�I359;h[K2�3�6;4�6 ,�g;<X2�6*2�Q?LM4)<N@Ch#9;<=2�Q�:)@C4�LM@�ORQ5BN@C3#�+OR4 / @w@��+2�LsBX6;@#y{2�6;y{ORK;@pg�@CQPBX4�y;BXh / 4)9;6+y*2�Q 0 hC4)6-,y;BoORBX4�6;3"2�<N<X4)� / 2�6;y 2�3P35BX:�6;LM@#6�OR3�OR4 / @tL�2\y;@�E ��6 2�y+y;BNO5BX4)6 O54 h.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3�9�ORBX<NBA@#BX6;:g�@CQ5BN4�y+BXh / 4)9;6;y;2�Q 0 h#4)6;y;BoORBN4)6;3C��hC2�<Xh#9;<=2%ORBX4�6;3 2�QP@_2�<X3P4jy+4)6;@�4)6s2j3P@CQPBX@C3�4�}r��� � 4�<XBX:�4)LM@#Q53��BNO5K `�2\Q 0 BX6;:t6Z9;L / @#Q53m4�}ng;K;@#6 0 <N@C6;@{Q5BN6;:)3#E���K;@{<X4�6;: ,�h[K;2�BX6 hC2�<Xh#9;<=2%ORBX4�6;3�2�QP@"9;35@#y O542�3P35BX:�6|O5K;@^3PgI@#h#O5QR2�<&}�@.2\O59;Q5@#3_O54sO5QR2�6+35BNO5BX4)6+3 / @#O ��@C@#6 / 2�6;y+3C��2�6;y|ORK;@#35@�2\3535BN:)6;Ls@C6�OR3n2�QP@ORQ52�6;3l}�@CQ5QP@Cy O54�4)<NBX:)4�LM@#Q53 /�0 @ �+2�LMBN6;BX6+:AK;4)� O5K;@'hC2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5@Cy 4)<XBN:)4)Ls@CQm3PgI@#h#ORQ52�@#`�4)<N`�@��BNO5K�h[K*2�BN6�<X@#6;:�O5K�Ekv*Q54)L 4�9;Q?3lOR9;y 0 �+ORK+@8hC4)L / BX6*2%ORBX4�6M4�} '*6;BNO5@Fh[K*2\BX6�3PBA@C@\�+3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3#�2�6;yt6+4)6 ,�g+<=2�6*2\Q5BNO 0 4�}kORK;@,3R2�Lsg;<X@^Q5@#359;<oOR3FBN6t2 / @#OPOR@CQF9;6;y;@#Q53POR2�6;y;BN6;:"4�}kO5K;@m2 / 3P4)Q5g�ORBX4�635g�@Ch�ORQ52+E

J?K*2�g+O5@CQ =nh#4)6;h#@CQ56+3 ORK;@W@ �+2�LMBN6*2\O5BX4)6^4�}�@C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6-,�K;4)<N@�3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0^/ Q5@C2�uZBX6;:8BN6�h.2\Q / 4)66*2�6+4�OR9 / @C3#Ek��K;BX3�BN3 }�2�hCBN<XBNOR2\OR@#y /�0 2p6;@ ��Ls@#O5K;4�yY}�4�QkBX6;h#<X9;3PBX4)6m4�}I6;@ ��O�,�6;@C2�Q5@#3PO�,�6;@#BX:)K / 4)QBX6�O5@CQR2\h#ORBN4)6;3�BN6"359;h[K�3 0 3PO5@CLs3CE ��K;BX3�Ls@#O5K;4�y{9;3P@C3_2m:)QR2\g;K"ORK;@#4)Q5@�ORBXhC2�<�QP@Cg;QP@C35@#6�O[2\O5BX4)6|4�}3 0 3lOR@CL hC4)6;6+@Ch#O5BN`�BNO 0 OR4my;@#Q5Bo`)@w2�6|2�6*2\< 0 ORBNh.2�<�@���g;QP@C353PBX4)6{}�4)Q ORK;@p@��r@#h#OR3�4�}�6;@ ��O+,�[email protected]�QP@C3PO�,6;@#BX:)K / 4)Q�BN6ZO5@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6;3#E���K;@#35@�BX6�O5@CQR2\h#ORBN4)6;3 / Q5@C2�u^@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6 ,�K;4)<X@�3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0^/�0 @ �+g;2�6;y;BN6;:ORK+@?`\2�<X@#6;hC@ / 2�6;y;3 2�6;y�h#4)6�ORQR2\h#ORBN6;:FO5K;@?h#4)6;y;9;h�ORBN4)6 / 2�6;y+3CE!> K+BX<X@ ORK;BN3!3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0^/ Q5@C2�u ,BX6+:My;4�@C3_6;4�OF2�<oOR@CQ�O5K;@ / 2�6;y':)2�g���BNO�y;4�@C3F2�<NO5@CQ�ORK+@jO5K;@CQPLM4�@C<N@Ch#O5Q5BNhpgI4)��@CQCE���6'2M3 0 3lOR@#L��BNO5K,@#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6 ,�K+4)<X@ 3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 �\O5K;@�O5K;@CQPLM4�@C<N@Ch#O5Q5BNh g�4)�?@#Q BX3 @C@#Q54;E � �+� � d � �<; � ��K;@WLs@#O5K;4�yy;@�`)@C<N4)g�@CyYK;@CQP@_2�<X<N4 ��3�ORK;@WO5K;@CQPLM4�@C<N@Ch�ORQ5BNh?g�4)�?@#Q 4\}r283PBX6;:�<X@?6;2�6;4�O59 / @WO54 / @�y+@#OR@#Q5LsBX6;@#y2�6*2\< 0 ORBNh.2�<N< 0 E

v�BX6;2�<X< 0 ���!2�QPO �5�P� 2�6+y"J?K*2�g�OR@CQ 8 @��+2�LsBX6;@�y;BN@C<X@#h#O5Q5BXh�@��r@#h#O53�BN6MhC2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5BX4)6+3 4)6shC4)6 �P9-,:�2\O5@Cytg�4)< 0 Ls@CQP3CEwG�@#LMB ,�@#LMg;BNQ5BNh.2�<�~Z9*2\6ZO59;L h[K+@CLsBX3PO5Q 0 hC4)6;3PBX3lOR@C6�O5< 0 y;@#O5@CQ5LsBX6+@C38@ �+h#BNO54)6

Page 20: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

=

/ BN6;y;BX6+:s@#6;@CQP:)BX@#3�ORK*2\On2�QP@w<=2�QP:)@CQWO5K*2�6{ORK;4)3P@w35@C@#6 BX6{@ �+g�@CQPBXLs@C6�O.E � x � � =Z� � 8 � ��4M4 / O[2�BN62�:)QP@C@#LM@#6ZO ��BoORK|@���gI@#Q5BNLM@#6ZOC�*L�2\6 0 ~�9;2�6�OR9;L h[K;@#LMBNh.2�<�hC2�<Xh#9;<=2%ORBX4�6;3�2�QP@jg;2�QR2�Ls@#O5@CQPBA@C@#y354YORK;2\O�ORK;@,J?4)9;<N4)L / BNh8Q5@#g;9;<X3PBX4)6 / @#O ��@C@C6'@C<X@#h#O5Q54)6;3_BX3�L,9;h[K'<N4 ��@CQ�O5K*2�6�O5K*2\O�}�4)9+6;y'BN6:�2�3Fg;K*2�[email protected]�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3CE � c � � � � � b�� ��K;BX3F<XBXu\@C< 0 QP@ � @#h#O538ORK;@mBNLMg�4)QPOR2�6;h#@^4�} BN6ZO5@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6;3/ @#O ��@C@C6{g�4)< 0 Ls@CQ h[K*2�BN6;3WBX6MORK;@n354)<NBXy�3lO[2\O5@�E �89;Q�:)Q54)9+g"K*2�3?g+Q5@#`�BN4)9;35< 0 y+@#`)@#<X4)g�@Cy{2^y 0 ,6*2�LsBXhky+BX@C<N@Ch�ORQ5BNhkLM4�y;@#<)ORK*2\O!@���g;<NBXh#BNOR< 0 BN6;hC<N9;y;@#3!y;BN@C<N@Ch#O5Q5BNhkBX6�OR@#QR2�h�ORBX4�6;3 ��BNORKj359+Q5Q54�9;6;y;BN6;:g�4)< 0 Ls@CQ h[K*2\BX6;3#E � � � J?K*2\g+OR@#Q 8 hC4�6ZO5BX6Z9;@#3 O5K;@�BX6�`)@#3PORBN:�2\O5BX4)6mBN6ZO54pORK;BN3ky 0 6*2�LsBXh�y;BN@C<X@#h#O5Q5BXhLs4�y;@#< E|�8Q5BN:)BX6;2�<X< 0 ��ORK+@�Ls4�y;@#<�9;35@#y � 9;h[u�@#< O5K;@C4�Q 0 }�4)QjO5K;@�3P4)<N`�@C6�O�h[K;2�BX6;3#E'�_@CQP@�� ORK+@��2\Q5BX3P@CQ ,���2\Q5Q�,��!4)g+<X@{LM4�y;@#<�BX3Y9;35@#y }�4)QmORK+@�3P4)<N`�@C6�O.��2\6;y O5K;@�QP@C3P9;<NO53�2�QP@�h#4)Lsg*2�Q5@#y O54ORK+4)35@�4 / O[2�BN6;@Cyt9+35BX6+:�ORK;@�� 9;h[u�@#< Ls4�y;@#< E8��K+@�Q5@#359;<oOR38BN6;y;BXhC2\OR@jORK*2%O8ORK;@,9;35@m4�} �9;h[u�@#<ORK+@C4)Q 0 BX3�2�y+@C~Z9*2\O5@���g;Q54�`�BXy+@Cy{ORK;@j�9;h[u\@C<&g*2�Q52�Ls@#OR@#Q53�2�QP@wh[K;4)35@#6 2�g+g;Q54)g+Q5B=2%OR@C< 0 E

Page 21: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

8

� � � � �

� ��� � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � ��� � � � �

Page 22: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

c

� � ��� ��� � �

� � � � � � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � ��� � ��� � � � � � �

��� � ��� � � � � ��� � � � �

� �� ������� ���� �� � ���

��K;@ @#6;@CQP: 0 4\}w2ALs4)<X@#hC9;<N@�BN6-2�6 @���OR@#Q56*2\<F@C<N@Ch�ORQ5BNh ';@C<Xyr� �s�WhC2�6 / @'@ �+g;2�6;y;@#y 2\3}�4)<N<X4)��3C�

� ��� "���� � �b� � �

��

b� � � � �

bd ��� � ����� � S � E b�a

��K;@#Q5@ � " BX3�O5K;@"@C6;@#Q5: 0 BN6 @C@CQP4 '*@C<Ny��?2\6;y O5K;@{6;4)6;<NBX6;@C2�Q�4)g�ORBXhC2�<?3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBoORBX@#3m2�QP@OR@#6;354�Q53p4�}�BN6;[email protected]�3PBX6;:�Q52�6;u��

�';Q53POwQ52�6;u��

�35@Ch#4)6;y QR2\6;u�� � ORK;BNQ5y Q52�6;u�� �T}�4)9;QPO5KtQR2�6+u��

2�6;y 3P4�4)6rE���K;@YQ5@#35g�4)6;35@s4�}�g;Q5BNL�2\Q 0 BX6�OR@#Q5@C3lOjK;@CQP@sBN3FORK+@*';Q53POjK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 �I4�Q35@#hC4)6+y'4)QPy;@CQ�6;4)6+<[email protected]�QW4�g+ORBNh.2�<I359;3PhC@Cg�ORB / BX<XBoO 0 � � E

�8y;y ,�4�Q5y;@#Q?Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@C3C�+359;h[K"2\3�ORK+@�'*QP3PO�K 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 ��2\Q5@ @#@CQP4�BN}IORK;@_LM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@4)Q / 9;<Nu�3R2\LMg;<N@pBX3�h#@C6�ORQP4)3 0 LsLM@�ORQ5BNh�E � � � � 0 g;BNh.2�<N< 0 �*hC4)6;3lORQP9;h#O5BX4)6|4�}�2s6;4�6;<XBN6;@.2�Q�4�g+ORBNh.2�<h[K;QP4)LM4�g;K;4)QP@�3lO[2�QlOR3���BNORK,2_h#@C6�ORQP4)3 0 LsLM@�ORQPBXh LM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@\�O54���K;BNh[K,3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3�2�Q5@�2�y;y+@CyOR4 / [email protected]\uFORK;@kh#@C6�OR@#Q&4�}+3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 E���6pORK;@ / 9;<Xun3R2�Lsg;<X@\�.ORK;@#35@�Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3�LM2 0F/ @kQR2�6+y;4)Ls< 0y;BN3PORQPB / 9�OR@Cys354^2�3�OR4jg;Q54�y;9;h#@F2whC@#6�ORQ54�3 0 LMLs@#O5Q5BNh_y+BX3PO5Q5B / 9+ORBN4)6�E!�!4j4 / OR2�BX6s2 / 9;<Xum3P@Ch#4)6;y4)QPy;@CQk6;4�6;<XBN6;@.2�Q!4)g+O5BXh.2\<+359+35hC@#g+ORB / BX<NBNO 0 ��2pLM@�ORK;4�y;3 L�9+3PO / @W}�4)9;6;ymOR4w2\<XBX:�6,ORK;@�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@C32�6;ymh#Q5@C2\OR@�2n6;4)6 ,�hC@C6�O5Q54)3 0 LsLs@#ORQPBXhWy+BX3PO5Q5B / 9+ORBN4)6�E&��6mLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3���BNORK�28gI@#Q5LM2�6;@C6�Oky+BXg�4)<X@Ls4)LM@#6�O.�;ORK+@^Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3�LM2 0{/ @j2�<NBX:)6;@#y ��BNORK'2sy+h^@#<X@Ch�ORQPBXh�'*@C<Ny�E?��6�LM4�Q5@whC4)Lsg;<NBXh.2%OR@Cy

Page 23: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

b �

Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3^O5K*2\OYLM2 0 6;4\OmgI4�3535@#353s2 g�@CQ5LM2�6;@#6�OYy;BXg�4)<X@MLM4�LM@#6ZOC�k2�<oOR@CQP6*2\O5BN`)@�LM@�ORK;4�y;3C�359+h[K 2�3�4)g+O5BXhC2�<�g�4)<XBN6;:;��L�9;3PO / @8}�4)9;6;y{OR4YBN6;y;9;h#@^2\<XBX:�6;LM@#6�O.E

�!Q52�y;BoORBX4�6*2�<X< 0 ��<XBN6;@.2\QnLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3���BNORK 2�g�@CQPL�2\6;@C6�Opy;BNgI4�<X@jLM4)Ls@C6�OpK;2�`�@ / @#@C6 9;3P@CyOR4s:)@#6;@CQ52\OR@^6;4)6;<NBX6;@C2�Q�4)g+O5BXh.2\<�Q5@C3PgI4�6;35@#3 / @#h.2�9+35@^O5K;@jg;Q5@#35@C6+hC@�4�}!ORK;@^y;BXg�4)<N@w2�<X<N4 ��3W}�4�Q2�<NBX:)6;Ls@C6�O_4�} O5K;@,Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3_BX6|ORK;@ / 9;<Nu|352�Lsg;<X@pORK+Q54)9;:�K'ORK;@^9;35@,4�}�2�y;h^@C<N@Ch#O5Q5BNh '*@#<Xy�E��K;@jy;@C3PBX:)6{3Ph[K;@CLs@^4\}!O5K;@C3P@jO 0 g�@C3_4�}�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3?BX3�O 0 g;BXhC2�<X< 0 g;3P@C9;y+4�4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<V�

784)6+4)Q � , ik<X@Ch�ORQP4)6;BXhFhC4)6 �P9+:�2\OR@#y{g*2\ORK �?2 0 � , fFh#hC@#g+OR4)Q � ���BNO5K�O5K;@^h#4)6 �P9;:)2\OR@#y g*2\O5K �?2 0'/ @CBN6;: / @#6�@C@#6;@��IgI4)< 0 @#6;@���3PO5BX< / @C6+@^4)Q_35BNLMBN<=2�Q?hC4)6 �P9+:�2\OR@#yLs4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Q�35u\@C<N@#OR4�6�E = � � 2�QPB=2\O5BX4)6;3,BX6 hC4)6 �P9+:�2\ORBN4)6 <X@#6;:�ORK 2�6+y-2�h#hC@Cg�OR4)Qs2�6;y � 4)QYy;4)6;4�Q3PO5Q5@#6;:�ORK'2�Q5@wh#4)LMLs4)6"Ls@#O5K;4�y+3_9+6;y;@CQlO[2�u\@C6'O54M4�g+ORBNLMB @C@FO5K;@^6+4)6;<XBN6;@.2\QWQ5@#35g�4)6;35@\� ��K+BX<X@3PO5BX<N<+LM2�BX6�O[2\BX6;BN6;:[email protected]�3P4)6*2 / <N@�3POR2 / BX<NBNO 0 E =�� b � � c � ��O�K;2�3 / @#@C6s35K;4)��6YORK*2%O � 35K+4)9;<XyY3Ph.2�<N@��BNO5K�h[K*2\BX6 <N@C6;:�O5K�E � d � c � ��K+@CQ5@�}�4)Q5@\� 4)6;@MLM@�ORK;4�y�4\}�2\O5O5@CLsg+ORBN6;:{OR4 2\h[K;BX@�`)@�<X2�Q5:)@sK 0 ,g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoORBX@#3 BX3 OR4�BN6;[email protected]�3P@FORK+@8h[K*2�BN6�<X@#6;:�ORK / @�O �?@#@C6|@C<X@#h#O5Q54)6{2�6+y�y;4)6;4�QW:)Q54�9;g;3CEfF<N4)6;:mORK+@C35@^<XBN6;@C3#��q'2�Q5y+@CQ ��� �����WK*2.`)@ / @#@C6 2 / <X@pOR4M2�h[K;BN@#`�@,K;BN:)K�K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoORBX@#3/�0 Q5@#y;9;h#BX6;:mORK+@j@��r@#h#O5BN`)@ / 4)6;y{<X@#6;:�O5K�2\<NOR@#Q56*2%ORBX4�6�BX6�O5K;@whC4)6 �P9+:�2\OR@#y{g*2\ORK �?2 0 E ��K;BX3�BN3y;4)6+@ /�0 OR9;6;BN6;:MO5K;@,QP@C<X2\ORBo`)@jhC4)6�ORQPB / 9�ORBX4�6;3n4\}k6;@C9�ORQR2\<!2\6;y h[K*2�QP:)@�,�35@#g*2�QR2%OR@CytQP@C3P4)6*2�6;h#@OR4MORK;@^:)Q54)9+6;y @C<N@Ch�ORQ54�6;BXh^3PO[2%OR@�En��K;@ 0 K*2.`)@ / @C@#6 2 / <N@^OR4�2�h[K;BX@�`)@�K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoORBX@#3/ @#O ��@C@C6 ��� 2�6;y c+b)b � b � � ��" @#359�E b � �

J?4)<X<N@Ch�ORBX4�6 2�6+y�2�<XBN:)6;Ls@C6�Os4�}p<NBX6;@C2�QM4�g+ORBNh.2�<�h[K;QP4)LM4�g;K;4)QP@C3�BN6 O5K;@ / 9;<Nu 3R2�Lsg;<N@�BN34�} O5@C6-y;4�6;@ 9;3PBX6;: h#4)Q54�6*2�g�4)<XBN6;:;E � ; � ��6-hC4)QP4)6*2�g�4)<NBX6;: ORK;@'3R2�Lsg;<X@|BX3My;BX3PgI@#Q53P@Cy�BX6 2g�4)< 0 Ls@CQjL�2\O5Q5B �rE{��K;@�h[K;Q54)Ls4)g;K+4)Q5@ � gI4�< 0 LM@#Q^LM2\O5Q5B"�tBX3^O5K;@C6�K;@.2\O5@Cy 2 / 4�`)@�O5K;@�:�<=2�3P3ORQ52�6;3PBNORBN4)6 O5@CLsgI@#QR2\O59;Q5@'4�}pORK;@'gI4)< 0 LM@#QMLM2\ORQPB"� BN6 ORK;@'g;Q5@#35@C6+hC@ 4�}j2 3PO5Q54)6+: @C<X@#h#O5Q5BXh'*@#<Xy�E��[email protected]%ORBX6+: ORK;@{3 0 3lOR@CL 2 / 4�`�@{O5K;@"g�4)< 0 Ls@CQ ! 3m:)<X2�353,O5QR2�6+35BNO5BX4)6AOR@CLsg�@CQR2%OR9;QP@{2�<X<N4 ��3ORK+@,h[K;QP4)LM4�g;K;4)QP@C3�OR4�2\<XBX:�6|BN6�QP@C3PgI4)6+35@,O54MORK+@,2�g+g;<XBN@Cy|@C<X@#h#O5Q5BXh '*@#<Xy 2\6;y'h#[email protected]%OR@^2M6;4)6-,hC@#6�ORQ54�3 0 LMLs@#O5Q5BNh,y;BN3PORQPB / 9�ORBX4�6�EW��K;@�3 0 3POR@#L BN3_O5K;@C6 2\<X<X4)��@Cy{OR4�h#4�4�<�BN6�O5K;@,g;QP@C3P@C6;h#@�4�}ORK+@j@#<X@#h#ORQPBXh�'*@#<Xy��+Q5@#OR2�BX6+BX6;:�O5K;@j2�<XBN:)6;Ls@C6�O�BX6"O5K;@ / 9;<XuM3R2�Lsg;<N@�E

Page 24: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

b)b

� � � ��� � ��� ����� � ���� � �� �

fF6;4\ORK;@#Q�hC<X2�353M4�}pLM2\OR@#Q5B=2\<X3 ��K;4)3P@ K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 QP@C3PgI4)6+35@ BN3�9;6;y+@CQ�BN6�`)@C3lORB ,:�2\O5BX4)6 BN3"LM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@#3#��BoORK L�9;<oORB ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<_359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5BX4)6 g*2%O5OR@#Q56;3#E =+� 8 � �F} OR@#6��8ORK+@L�9;<oORB ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<�LM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@#3�y;4�6;4\OFg�4)353P@C3P3p2Mg�@CQPL�2�6+@C6�OFy+BXg�4)<X@wLs4)LM@#6�O.��g;Q5@#hC<N9;y;BX6+:ORK+@m9;35@m4�}�2�y;hm@#<X@#h#ORQPBXh '*@C<Ny O54{2�<XBN:)6�O5K;@�Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C38BN6'ORK+@ / 9;<Xu|3R2\LMg;<N@�Ejik<XBNLMBN6*2\ORBN4)64�}8O5K;@'h#@C6�OR@#Q"4�}p3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 BX6 h#4)<X<N@Ch�ORBX4�6;3Y4�}pL�9;<oORB ,�g�4)<=2�Q,LM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@#3MhC2�6 / @ 2�h[K;BN@#`�@CyORK+Q54)9;:�K O5K;@"9;3P@|4\}n4�g+ORBNh.2�<�gI4)<NBX6;:'LM@�ORK;4�y;3CE �86;@{359;h[K LM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@M4�}nBX6�OR@#Q5@C3lOYBX3m@�ORK 0 <`�BX4)<N@#OC�&2�6A4�h#O59;g�4)<=2�Q8O5Q5BNg;K;@C6 0 < / 2�3P@Cy ��� � ��,�359 / [email protected]\O5BX4)6�E � 0 353 ��� ������K*2.`)@ / @#@C62 / <N@�OR4�2�h[K;BN@#`)@M2"K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 Q5@#35g�4)6;35@s4�} / @�O �?@#@C6 ; b � 2�6;y ; 8 � � b � � ��" @C3P9�BN6@#O5K 0 <�`�BX4�<X@#O�2\} OR@#Q�4)g+ORBNh.2�<rgI4)<NBX6;:+E � x � �?= �

�kQ54):)QP@C3P35BX6+: / @ 0 4)6;y�2\6^@��r@#h#ORBo`)@#< 0 4)6+@�,�y+BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6*2\<�Ls4�y;@#<�4)g�@C6;3&9;g^2 ��@.2\<NORKw4�}�O �?4 ,2�6;y^ORK;QP@C@�,�y;BXLs@C6+35BX4�6*2�<�h[K;@CLsBXhC2�<�g�4)3P35B / BX<XBoORBN@C3CE��86;@�L�9;3lO�2�<X3P4Fu\@C@CgYBN6�LMBN6;y^O5K*2\OC�)2\O!ORK;BN3ORBNLM@\�rORK+@s:�4�2�< 4�}�O5K;@Y3POR9+y 0 4�} L�9;<oORB",�y;BXLs@C6+35BX4�6*2�<&h[K;Q54�LM4)g+K;4)Q5@#3pBX3p6;4\Ow6;@Ch#@C35352�Q5BN< 0 O54LM2 ��BXLsBA@C@mO5K;@�QP@C35g�4)6;3P@�� / 9�O�OR4�@C<XBNLMBN6*2\O5@m354)Ls@�4�}�O5K;@�g+Q54 / <N@CLs3,2\35354�hCBX2\OR@#y ��BNO5K�ORK+@<XBN6;@.2\Q?Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3C��359;h[K|2�3�y+BX35QP9;g+O5BX4)6"4�}�h#Q 0 3POR2�<X<[email protected]%ORBX4�6My;9+@8OR4my;BNgI4)<X2�QW2\:):)Q5@#:�2\O5BX4)6��ZORK+@6;@#hC@C3P35BoO 0 4�}�9+35BX6+:s@#<X@#h#ORQPBXh�'*@#<Xy;3�O54M2\h[K;BX@�`)@jg*2�QR2\<X<X@#<r2\<XBX:�6;LM@#6�O�4�}�ORK;@wLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3C��<XBNLMBoOR34)6"ORK+@p@C<X@#h#O5Q54�4)g+ORBNh82�g+g;<XBNh.2\O5BX4)6;3�y;9;@8O54�ORK;@w2�6+BX354\ORQ54�g;BXh83lORQP9;h#O59;Q5@p4�}�ORK+@pL�2\O5@CQPB=2�<V��2\6;yORK+@�Q5@#~�9+BXQ5@#LM@#6�OpORK*2\OFORK;@�Ls4�y;9;<=2%ORBX6+: '*@#<Xy 2�6+yt4)g+ORBNh.2�< / @.2�L / 4�O5K / @mg*2�QR2\<X<X@#<�OR4�ORK+@hC4�LMLs4)6"hCQ 0 3PO[2\<X<XBN6;@w2�6;y{Ls4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Q�2 ��BN3CE-=Z� 8 �

�86;@ �?2 0 4�}�9;6+y;@CQP3PO[2\6;y;BX6+:-2�6;y g;QP@Cy;BNh#ORBN6;: ORK;@T6;4)6;<NBX6;@C2�Q�4)g�ORBXhC2�< / @CK*2.`�BX4)Q{4�}�2Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@"BX3mOR4Ty;@#`�@C<N4)g-Ls4�y;@#<X3�O5K*2\OsQ5@#<=2\O5@{O5K;@|359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6 g*2\OPOR@CQP6 4)6 2TLs4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q35u\@C<N@#OR4�6AOR4|ORK;@s4)g+O5BXhC2�< Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@MORK;2\O,BN3w:)@C6;@#QR2\O5@Cy /Z0 O5K;@Mg�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< '*@C<NyABN6;y;9;h#@Cy /Z0ORK+4)35@W3P9 / 3lORBNO59;@C6�O53CE�> K;@#6�ORK;@�h[K;@CLsBXhC2�<�359 / 3lORBoOR9;@#6ZO53k4�};O5K;@?Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@�<NBX@ 2�<N4)6;:nO5K;@?352�Ls@2 ��BX3#�rORK+@mQ5@C3PgI4�6;35@#3^y;9+@�OR4�ORK+@mBX6�OR@#Q56*2�<�'*@C<[email protected]\O5@Cy /�0 ORK;@#35@Y359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3j2�QP@�y;4)LsB",6*2\O5@Cy /�0 2m35BN6;:)<N@FhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZOCE�D?@ChC2�9;3P@wO5K;@pQ5@#35g�4)6;3P@C3n2�Q5@8@#353P@C6�ORBX2�<X< 0 4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<V�2�y;BNQ5@Ch�OwQ5@#<=2\O5BX4)6;3PK;BXg / @�O �?@#@C6TORK;@mBN6ZO5@CQP6*2�< '*@#<Xy 2�6+y O5K;@mK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 QP@C35g�4)6;[email protected]\6 / @py;@#Q5BN`�@Cy�E v*4)Q�2mLs4)Q5@FhC4)Lsg;<XBNh.2\O5@Cy���L�9;<oORB ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<*3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6"g*2\OPOR@CQP6��;ORK+@Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@C3?y+9;@�OR4wORK;@�BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�'*@C<Nys2�Q5@�6;4j<X4)6+:)@CQky;4�LMBN6*2\OR@#y /Z0 2j3PBX6;:)<N@�hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�OCE ��64)QPy;@CQ�OR4^2�hCh#4)9;6�O?}�4�Q�O5K;@_L�9;<NO5B",�y;BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6;2�<Z6*2\OR9+Q5@_4�}�ORK+@n3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6Mg;2\O5O5@CQ56r��O5K;@n@ � ,g*2�6+35BX4�6�4�}IORK;@n@C6;@#Q5: 0 4�}�O5K;@_LM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@�BX3�y;4�6;@FBN6MBoOR3�}�9;<X<;O5@C6;3P4)Q5BX2�<*}�4)Q5L|E�f Q5@#<=2\O5BX4)6;3PK;BXg

Page 25: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

b �

35BNLMBN<=2�Q_OR4|ORK;@s4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�< 4�6;@Yh.2�6TORK;@#6 / @m}�4)9+6;yA}�4)Qj2�6 0 359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6Ag*2%O5OR@#Q56�E��K;@My;@#`�@C<X4�g;LM@#6�O�4�}WO5K;@�:�@C6;@#QR2�<NBA@C@#y�Ls4�y+@C<k}�4)QwORK;@sK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 QP@C3PgI4)6+35@�hC2�6/ @w}�4�9;6;y{BX6{y;@�O[2�BN<�BX6{h[K*2�g�OR@CQP3 �Y2�6+y d E

� �� � � ��� � � � ��� � ���

��6-4)QPy;@CQY}�4)QM2ALM2\OR@#Q5B=2\<?OR4A@���K;B / BNO�2�6 4�y;y ,�4)Q5y;@#QMQP@C3PgI4)6+35@'3P9;h[K 2�3 � � ORK;@�L�2%OR@�,Q5BX2�<_h.2�6;6+4�O / @thC@C6�O5Q54)3 0 LsLs@#ORQPBXht2\6;y � 4)Q�2 6;4)6 ,�hC@#6ZO5Q54)3 0 LMLs@#O5Q5BXh'y;BX3lORQ5B / 9+O5BX4)6 BX6-ORK+@/ 9;<NutL�2%OR@CQPB=2�<�L�9;3PO,g;Q54�y;9;h#@Cy�E{��QR2�y+BNORBN4)6*2�<N< 0 ��~Z9*2�35B 4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<V��Q54�y ,�<NBXu\@���<[email protected]�QLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3pORK*2%O�g�4)353P@C353�2�g�@CQ5LM2�6;@#6�O�y;BNgI4)<N@YLM4)Ls@C6�O^K*2.`)@ / @#@C6 9;3P@Cy BN6 2�g;g+<XBXhC2\ORBN4)6;3/ @Ch.2\9;35@mORK+@�y;BXg�4)<N@�2�<N<X4)��3nO5K;@m6;4)6 ,�hC@#6ZO5Q54)3 0 LMLs@#O5Q5BXh,y;BX3lORQ59 / 9+ORBN4)6 4�} Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3nBX6 ORK+@/ 9;<Nu�352�LMg+<X@8OR4 / @whCQ5@C2\OR@#y'9;3PBX6;:s2my;hw@C<N@Ch�ORQ5BNh�'*@C<Ny�E

v*4)Q,2|L�9;<oORB",�y;BXLs@C6+35BX4�6*2�<�359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6Tg*2\OPOR@CQP6�� 3P9;h[K 2�3jORK;@s4�h�OR9;g�4)<X2�Qw359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5@Cy/ @C6�@#@C6;@s4�}�v�BX:�9;Q5@ � E b �rO5K;@YLM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@,L�2 0 6+4|<N4)6;:)@#Q8g�4)353P@C353^2"gI@#Q5LM2�6;@#6ZOwy+BXg�4)<X@^LM4 ,Ls@C6�Os2�6;y ORKZ9;3s2ty;h{@C<N@Ch�ORQ5BNh '*@#<Xy h.2�6 6;4�O / @{9;3P@Cy OR4T2�h[K;BN@#`)@{Ls4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Q�2\<XBX:�6;LM@#6�O.E�8g+ORBNh.2�<�g�4)<XBN6;:TLM@�ORK;4�y;3sK*2.`)@ / @C@#6�y;@#`�@C<X4�gI@#y-ORK*2\O�2�<N<X4)� }�4)QYORK;@�hC@#6ZO5@CQ�4\}w3 0 LMLs@�,ORQ 0 4�}kO5K;@ / 9;<Nu�352�Lsg;<X@jOR4 / @ / Q54)u\@C6���@�`)@#6ABN6 LM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@#3 ��BNO5K;4)9+O82�gI@#Q5LM2�6;@#6ZOwy+BXg�4)<X@Ls4)LM@#6�O.E �?=Z� � b � =�� 8 � ��K;@�4)g�ORBXhC2�<8g�4)<XBN6;: Ls@#ORK+4�y;3|9;3P@C3|BX6�OR@#QP}�@CQP@C6;h#@ / @#O ��@C@#6 4)6;@ ,2�6;y�O ��4 ,�g+K;4�OR4�6 2 / 354)QPg+ORBN4)6�g;QP4�h#@C353P@C3{OR4 y;BN35h#Q5BXLsBX6;2\OR@ / @�O �?@#@C6 Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3 / 2�3P@Cy 4)6Ls4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Qn4�Q5BX@#6�O[2\O5BX4)6�En��6 4�ORK;@#Q ��4)Q5y;3#��4)6;< 0 Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3nBX6 h#@CQlO[2�BN6 4)Q5BN@C6�O[2%ORBX4�6;3���BoORK;BN6ORK+@�3R2\LMg;<N@ ��BN<X< / @�@���hCBoOR@#y /�0 O5K;@�BX6+hC4)LsBX6;:|<XBN:)K�O / @C2�LM3^[email protected]\O5BX6;:�4)Q5BN@C6�O[2\O5BX4)6;2�<�K;4)<X@/ 9;QP6;BX6+:Ah#4)6;y;BoORBX4�6;3CE-��K+@'@���h#BNOR@#y Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3mORK+@C6-9;6+y;@CQP:)4�QP@C<=2 �;2%ORBX4�6 O5K;Q54�9;:)K 3P4)Ls@g;K;4\OR4 ,�BX6;y;9+hC@Cy BX3P4)Ls@CQ5B @.2\O5BX4)6r� BN6�ORQR2\LM4)<N@Ch#9;<=2�Q#�k4)QYBX6�OR@#Q5Ls4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Q,`�B / QR2\O5BX4)6*2\<Wg;Q54�hC@#353#�Q5@#359;<oORBN6;:mBX6|2my;BX3lORQPB / 9+O5BX4)6�4�}�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q�4)Q5BN@C6�O[2\O5BX4)6+3?ORK*2%O�y;BN�I@CQP3W}�Q54)L ORK;@w4)6;@pg+Q5@C3P@C6�O2\O�O5K;@w3PO[2\QPO_4�}�ORK;@w4)g+O5BXhC2�<�g�4)<XBN6;:�g;QP4�h#@C353#E

fF3�2�6s@��+2�Lsg;<X@\� �?@ ��BX<N<;3POR2�QPO /�0 y;@ ';6;BX6;:wORK+@_4�Q5BX@#6�O[2\O5BX4)6Y4�}r2^7 � �_O 0 gI@_LM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@ /Z02�6j2�6;:�<X@�� S v�BN:)9;QP@ � E ba E���K;@C6j<X@�O&9;3&2�3P359;Ls@��}�4)Q�BX<N<X9;3lORQ52\ORBo`)@�g+9;Q5g�4)35@#3C�%ORK*2\O�O5K;@�gI4�3535B / <X@4)QPBX@C6�OR2\ORBN4)6;3F4\} O5K;@YLM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@#3FBN6 ORK;@m352�LMg+<X@m2�QP@�@#`�@C6;< 0 y;BN3PORQPB / 9�OR@Cy S v�BX:�9;Q5@ � E � a E,��@�OORK+@p@���hCBoO[2\O5BX4)6 /�0 O5K;@���Q5BoOR@ / @.2�Ls3W4)6+< 0 @#�I@Ch#O�O5K;4)35@p4�Q5BX@#6�O[2\O5BX4)6;3?4�} � / @�O �?@#@C6 � � 2\6;y� � Ek��K+BX3?3P9 / 3P@#O�4�}�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3%��BX<N<;ORK;@#6"Q5@#<=2 �I��Q5@C3P9;<NO5BX6;:^BX6�2,y;BX3lORQPB / 9+O5BX4)6s4�}�O5K;@8QP@C<=2 �+@#yLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3W3PBXLsBX<=2\Q O54YO5K*2\O�4�}�ORK+@jBN6;BNO5B=2�<�hC4�6/'*:)9;Q52\ORBN4)6�E ��K+@j6+@ � 4�`)@#QR2�<N<�y;BN3PORQPB / 9�ORBX4�6�4�}

Page 26: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

b �

v�BN:)9;Q5@ � E b �nG+2�Lsg;<X@,7 � �mLM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@jy;@ ';6;BX6;:�O5K;@m2�6+:)<X@ � 9;35@#ytOR4�y;BN35h#Q5BXLsBX6;2\OR@ / @�O �?@#@C6ORK+@w`\2�QPBX4)9+3�4)Q5BN@C6�O[2\O5BX4)6+3W4�}�ORK;@wLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@�E

v�BN:)9;Q5@ � E � ���k<X4�O�4�}*QP@C<X2\ORBo`)@�2 / 9;6;y;2�6;hC@�`�3#E 4)QPBX@C6�OR2\ORBN4)6,2\6;:)<X@\� �"}�4)Q!2F@#`�@C6;< 0 y+BX3PO5Q5B / 9+OR@#y3R2\LMg;<N@�E

4)QPBX@C6�OR2\ORBN4)6;3���BN<X<�K*2.`�@,2my;BNg|BN6"ORK;@j2�[email protected] / @�O �?@#@C6 � � 2\6;y � � S v�BX:)9+Q5@ � E-� a E

� �� �� �� � � � � � � ��� ��� � � � �

�8g+ORBNh.2�<kg�4)<XBN6;: / Q5@C2�uZ3,h#@C6�OR@#Q,4�}?3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 BN6TO5K;@M352�Lsg;<X@mORK+Q54)9;:�K 2{L�9;<NO5BXg;K+4�OR4)62 / 3P4)Q5g�ORBX4�6�g;Q54�hC@#353ky;@#35h#Q5B / @Cy /�0 O5K;@���QPBNOR@�'*@C<Ny,OR@#6;354)Q#�Z2FORBNLM@ ,�2.`)@#QR2�:)@#y,OR@#6;354�Q5B=2\<+g;QP4�y ,9;h�Ow4�} 4)g+ORBNh.2�<�'*@C<Ny;3C����� ����� � � � � ����� E �?=�� � b �#� x � 8 � ��K;@mh#4)L / BN6*2\O5BX4)6 4\}�4�g+ORBNh.2�<'*@#<Xy;3p4)6 O5K;@m3R2\LMg;<N@^OR2�u�@#3^2\y+`\2�6�O[2�:)@,4�}�2�6tBX6�OR@#QP}�@#Q5@C6+hC@mg*2\OPOR@#Q56 [email protected]\O5@Cy /�0 2�hC4�L / B",6*2\O5BX4)6T4�}�4�6;@�2\6;yAO ��4 g;K;4\OR4)6�2 / 354�Q5g+O5BX4)6Tg;Q54�hC@#353P@C3 S 3P@C@�v�BX:)9+Q5@ � E dZa E���K+@�g�4 ��@CQ^4�}ORK+@jBN6;hC4�LMBN6;:�<XBN:)K�O / @.2�Ls3�BX3�h[K+4)35@#6'354 / 4�ORK|2 / 354)QPg+ORBN4)6{g;Q54�hC@#3535@#3n4\} v�BN:)9;QP@ � E d ��4)9;<Ny

Page 27: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

b.d

v�BN:)9;Q5@ � E-�+�8�k<X4\Op4�} Q5@#<=2\O5BN`)@�2 / 9;6;y;2�6;hC@m`�3CE^4)Q5BN@C6�O[2%ORBX4�6t2�6;:)<N@�� �-}�4�QFORK;@m352�Lsg;<X@,2\} OR@#QK*2.`�BX6;:Y9;6+y;@CQP:)4)6;@wORK;@wK;4�<X@�, / 9;QP6;BX6;:+�+4)g+O5BXhC2�<�g�4)<XBN6;:�g;QP4�h#@C353#E

v�BN:)9;Q5@ � E d �pG�h[K+@CLM2\ORBNh�4�}�ORK;@�O5K;@m4)6;@�2�6;ytO �?4{g;K+4�OR4)6 2 / 354)QPg+ORBN4)6tg;QP4�h#@C353P@C3wBX6�`�4)<N`�@CyBX6{4)g�ORBXhC2�<�g�4)<XBN6;:;E

Page 28: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

b ;

<X@C2�y"OR4Y@C~Z9;Bo`\2�<X@#6ZO_g�4)g;9;<X2\ORBN4)6�O5QR2�6;3l}�@CQP3CEi �;2\LMBN6*2\ORBN4)6s4�}�K;4)��ORK+@F4)g+O5BXhC2�< '*@C<Ny;3�hC2�6�BN6ZO5@CQ52�h#O�OR4,g+Q54�y;9;hC@_ORK;@n6;@Ch#@C3P3R2�Q 0 BX6�O5@CQ�,

}�@CQP@C6;h#@mg*2\OPOR@CQP6;38hC2�6 / @�2�h[K;BX@�`)@#y /�0 hC4)6;3PBXy;@#Q5BN6;:�ORK+@�@C<N@Ch#O5Q5BNh '*@C<Ny hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO5384�}�ORK+@BXLsg;BN6;:)BX6+:�4)g�ORBXhC2�<%'*@C<Ny;3CETf :)@#6;@CQ52�<�}�4)QPL 4\}_O5K;@�@#<X@Ch�ORQPBXh '*@#<Xy `�@Ch#O54)Qm4�}�ORK+@�BX6;h#BXy;@#6�O4)g+O5BXhC2�< '*@#<Xy{BX3

�� S �� ��� a � S � � � � � � � � � a����� �� � � ����� S � E � a

��K;@#Q5@ � � 2�6+y � � 2�Q5@�O5K;@mhC4�LMg;<N@�� 2�Lsg;<XBoOR9;y;@#3F4�} ORK+@�`)@Ch�OR4)QpBN6 ORK;@my+BXQ5@#h#O5BX4)6;3 � � 2\6;y � � Q5@#35g�@Ch#O5BN`�@C< 0 � �� BN38ORK;@ �?2.`)@Y`)@#h#OR4�QC� �� BX38O5K;@my;BNQ5@Ch�ORBN4)6t4�}�g;Q54)g;2�:�2\O5BX4)6��r2�6;y�� BX38ORK+@}�Q5@#~Z9;@C6;h 0 E � 8 � ��K;@CQP@�2�Q5@ O �?4wBNLMg�4)QPOR2�6�O�h#4)6;h#@Cg+O53kBX6�h#4)6;35BNy;@CQPBX6;:nORK;@�@��r@#h#OR3k4\}*ORK;@���QPBNO5@'*@#<Xy"OR@#6;354)Q#�

� � ��� � � � � � � � � � S � E>� a4)6wORK;@�352�LMg+<X@�E�v�BNQ53lO.��ORK;@�ORBNLM@ 2�`�@CQ52�:)@ 4�}+@#~�E � E>��L�9;3lO / @�6;4)6 , @C@#Q54;E�G�@Ch#4)6;y��\hC4)9+g;<XBN6;:�4�}ORK+@ ORK;QP@C@�@C<N@Ch#O5Q5BNh '*@C<Nyp`)@Ch�OR4)QP3&4�}�O5K;@k4)g+O5BXhC2�< '*@#<Xy;3�L,9;3PO&K*2.`�@�O5K;@k3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53Q5@#~Z9;BXQP@Cy{}�4)Q�BX6�OR@#QR2�h�ORBN4)6 ��BNORK{Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3W4\}�h#4)Q5QP@C35g�4)6;y+BX6;:s3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 E

�!4�y;@#O5@CQ5LsBX6+@^ORK+@,hC4�6;y;BNO5BX4)6+3n6;@#hC@#353R2\Q 0 }�4)Q_4)g+O5BXhC2�<&gI4)<NBX6;:*��@ ��BX<N<�3lO[2�QlO /�0 hC4)6+35BXy-,@CQPBX6;:{O ��4 '*@#<Xy;3 ��BNO5K�2\Q / BoORQR2\Q 0 }�QP@C~Z9;@#6;hCBN@C3C��� � 2�6;y�� � E���K+@Mg;QP4�y+9;h#Oj4�}�ORK;@*'*@C<Ny;3w4�}@C~�E � E � BX6"@C~�E � E-�mBX3C�

� � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � �� �� � � � �� � � �� � ��� ��� � �� � ��� �� � � � � ��� ��� � �� � ��� �� � � � � ��� ��� � S � E d�a

��K;@#Q5@ �� 2\6;y �� 2�QP@mORK;@m`)@#h#O54)QwhC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�OR3j4�} ORK;@Y@#<X@Ch�ORQPBXhmhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZOj4�} ORK+@s4�g+ORBNh.2�<'*@#<Xy;3#� S � � ��� �� � � � � � ��� �� � � a 2�6;y S � � ��� �� � � � � � ��� �� � � a QP@C3PgI@#h#ORBo`)@#< 0 EFJ?4)<N<X@Ch�ORBN6;:mORK;@^35g*2�h#B=2�<2�6;ysOR@#LMg�4)QR2\<*@���gI4�6;@C6�ORBX2�<*OR@#Q5Ls3�4�}r@C~�E � E d @���g;QP@C3P35@C3WO5K;@F@#~Z9*2\ORBN4)6sBX6M2j}�4)QPL ��K;@CQP@FORK+@ORBNLM@82�`�@CQ52�:)@^2�6;y{35g*2\hCB=2\<�@#�I@Ch#O53n4\}�4)g�ORBXhC2�<rg�4)<NBX6;:mhC2�6 / @pBX6�`�@C3PO5BX:�2%OR@Cy|BX6+y;BN`�BXy+9*2�<X< 0 �

� � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � �� � �� � �� � �!� � �� � � �� �� � � �!� ��� � ����� � � � S � E ; a

��K;@�'*Q53lO_hC4)6;y+BNORBN4)6�ORK;2\O�L�9;3lO / @pLs@#O�BN6"4)Q5y;@#Q�}�4)Q?ORK+@jh#4)L / BN6*2\O5BX4)6�4\}!<X2�35@#Q / @C2�Ls3BXLsg;BN6;:)BX6+:|4�6�ORK;@M3R2�Lsg;<N@sO54 K*2.`)@"2�6;@#Om@��r@#h#OmBN3jO5K*2\O^ORK;@sORBXLs@M2�`�@CQ52�:)@�4�}�O5K;@ ��QPBNO5@'*@#<Xy OR@#6;354�Q S @C~�E � E-� a L,9;3PO / @m6;4)6 , @C@#Q54;E �<=��5� x ��=�� 8 � �86;< 0 ORK;@m3P@Ch#4)6;yT@���gI4�6;@C6�ORBX2�< BN6@C~�E � E ; h#4)6;hC@#Q56;3 ORBNLM@\E � @Ch.2\<X<XBN6;:wik9;<X@#Q ! 3�QP@C<X2\ORBN4)6;3 }�4)Q � �#" 2\6;yMO5K*2\O BNO BX3kO5K;@[email protected]�<�g*2\QPO 4�}

Page 29: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

b�x

@C~�E � E ; ORK*2%O?LM2�u�@#3W9;g�O5K;@82\h#OR9;2�<I@#<X@#h#ORQPBXh_hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O�4�}�ORK+@F4)g+O5BXhC2�< '*@C<Ny���O5K;@nO5@CLsgI4�QR2�<hC4�6ZO5Q5B / 9+ORBN4)6�OR4s4)g+O5BXhC2�<rg�4)<XBN6;:mBX3#�

� � ��� � � ��� � � ����� ������� S � � � � � � a � � � S � E x)a

��K;@'O5BXLs@'2.`�@CQR2\:)@'4�}w@#~�E � E x BN3 @C@#Q54 @ ��hC@Cg�O ��K;@C6 � � � � � � ��2�3MO5K;@'hC2�35@ K+@CQ5@ S 35@#@v�BN:;E � E dZa E

i�2�h[K�4�}IORK;@�4)g�ORBXhC2�<;@#<X@Ch�ORQPBXh '*@C<Ny;3�4�}�@#~�E � E>�pBX6�O5@CQR2\h#ORBN6;:���BNO5KsO5K;@�3R2�Lsg;<X@�2\Q5@�`)@#h#OR4�Q534�}!ORK;@wO 0 gI@^4�} @#~�E � E � ��� � � �� $';Q53POnQR2\6;u�OR@#6;354)QP3���BoORK'1 � b E�J?4�9;g;<XBN6;:mORK;QP@C@ '*Q53lOFQ52�6;u|1� b OR@C6+354)QP3wO54):)@�ORK;@#Q8Q5@#359;<oOR3pBX6�ORK;@�}�4)QPL�2%ORBX4�6'4�}�2�ORK+BXQ5y'QR2�6;u|OR@#6;354)Q���BoORKT1 � � � b � � �2�6;y ��3Pg;K;@CQPBXhC2�< hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53CE^��K;@Yg;Q5@#35@C6+hC@Y4�}W1 � ��hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O53pBX6 ORK+@mBX6�OR@#QP}�@CQP@C6;h#@g*2\OPOR@#Q56shCQ5@C2\OR@#y /�0 ORK+@_`�@Ch#O54)Q5BX2�<*4)g+O5BXhC2�</'*@#<Xy;3�h.2\6�BX6�O5@CQR2\h#O%��BNO5KYO5K;@F1 � �phC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO534�}�ORK+@�6;4)6;<NBX6;@C2�QFQP@C3PgI4)6+35@m4�}�ORK+@�3R2�Lsg;<N@�Ewv*4)QF@ �+2�LMg+<X@���2�7 � �YLM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@\�I3P9;h[K�2\3FORK*2%O35@#@C6 BX6'v�BX:�9;Q5@ � E b �ry;4�@C3F6;4�O8g�4)3P35@C3P3w2�g�@CQ5LM2�6;@#6�Oj1 � b y;BXg�4)<N@^Ls4)Ls@C6�On`�@Ch�OR4)Q#Ep��K;@2 / 3P@C6;h#@p4�}�2m1�� b hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO?4�}�ORK+@84)g+O5BXh.2\<�QP@C3PgI4)6+35@pg;QP@ChC<N9;y;@#3WORK;@n9;35@p4�}�2�1�� b y;h@C<N@Ch�ORQ5BNh '*@C<NysO54j2�h[K;BX@�`)@n2�<XBN:)6;Ls@C6�O 4\}rORK+@_Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3#E���K;@#35@n7 � �nLs4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3ky+4;��K;4)�?@�`)@#QC�g�4)353P@C353p1 � �M4�h#O59;g�4)<=2�Q�h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3_BX6{ORK;@#BXQ�6;4)6+<[email protected]�Q�Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@C3CE���K;@^g;Q5@#35@#6;hC@�4\}�1� ��QP@C3PgI4)6+35@�h#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3,BN6TO5K;@�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@s2�<X<N4)��3w}�4�Q,2�6ABX6�OR@#QR2�h�ORBN4)6 ��BoORKTORK;@�1 � �hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53F4�}�ORK;@^BX6�OR@#QP}�@CQP@C6;h#@�g*2\OPOR@#Q56 h#[email protected]%OR@Cy�ORK;QP4)9;:)K BN6�OR@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6|4�} O5K;@^O5K;Q5@#@Y1 �b hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O53_4\}!O5K;@w4)g+ORBNh.2�<&'*@C<Ny;3CE

�!4A9;6;y;@#Q53lO[2�6;y K;4)� ORK;@|BX6�O5@CQP}�@#Q5@#6;hC@|4�}FO ��4�BN6;hCBNy;@C6�Os4)g+O5BXhC2�< '*@C<Ny;3sh.2�6 BX6;y+9;hC@�2K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 BN6�2 / 9;<Xu 3R2\LMg;<N@���hC4�6;35BNy;@CQ"K;4)� ORK;@t3Pg*2�h#B=2�<8y+@Cg�@C6;y;@#6;hC@ 4�}jORK+@BX6+hC4)LsBX6;:,4)g+ORBNh.2�<&'*@C<Ny;3�BX3�Ls4�y;9+<=2\O5@Cy��

� � ��� � � � � � ���������������� ����� S � �� � � �� ��� a � �� � � S � E = a��K;BN3 BX3!4 / O[2\BX6;@#y,}�4)<X<N4)��BX6;:�ORK;@�3R2�Ls@Wg;QP4�h#@Cy;9+Q5@W9;3P@CyYBX6,@C~�E � E x 2�6+ym9;35BN6;:FORK+@WuZ6;4)��<X@Cy+:)@ORK;2\O � � � � � � EpfF3w2�6t@ �;2\LMg;<N@,4�} K;4)�zORK+@�`)@Ch�OR4)Qpg�4)QlORBX4�6;3F4�}�@#~�E � E � hC4)9+g;<X@\� �?@ ��BN<X<hC4�6;35BNy;@CQ�ORK+@^@ �;2\LMg;<N@p4�}k2Y35BNLMg+<X@8g;<X2�6*2�Q�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@84)QPBX@#6ZO5@Cy�359;h[K|ORK*2\O_BoO�<XBX@#3�BX6"ORK+@��! g;<X2�6;@ ��BNORKYORK+@ �{2 ��BN3 / @CBN6;:,2\6�2 ��BX3�4�}rO �?4 , }�4)<Xys3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 ��2�6;y�3P9;h[K�O5K*2\O ORK;@_LM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@g�4)353P@C353P@C3�4)6;< 0 �#"�"�" 2�6;y �#"�$%$ Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@_h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3 S 35BXLsBX<X2�Q&OR4w2�6Y@��+2�Lsg;<N@�g;Q54�`�BXy;@#y /Z0� 0 353?2�6;y���@#y;4)9 �sBN6MQP@#}�E 8 � a Ekv*4)QkORK;BN3 @ �+2�LMg+<X@��ZORK+@81 � b 2�6;y�1 � �wBXQPQ5@Cy+9;hCB / <X@�OR@#6;354 ,Q5BX2�<&35g*2\hC@C3w2\Q5@,3Pg*2�6;6+@Cy /�0 �

�& � � �& � �& � �' � �' � 2�6+y �

�& � � �& � �&

����' � �' � �

Page 30: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

b =

Q5@#35g�@Ch�ORBN`�@C< 0 ����K;@#Q5@ �& 2\6;y �' 2�Q5@8`�@Ch#O54)Q53_BX6"O5K;@ �t2�6+y My;BXQP@Ch�ORBX4�6;3CE >A@���BX<X<�'*QP3PO_hC4)6-,35BNy;@CQph#BXQPhC9;<X2�Q5< 0 g�4)<X2�Q5B @C@Cyt<NBX:)K�O���BNORK / 4�ORK � ��� 2�6;y � � K*2.`�BX6+:{O5K;@Y3R2�Ls@�K*2\6;y;@Cy+6;@C3P3C�}�4)QW@ �+2�LMg+<X@��+Q5BX:�KZO�,�K*2\6;y;@Cy"g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2\O5BX4)6�E���}��?@pOR2�u�@8O5K;@p`)@Ch�OR4)Q�g�4)QlORBX4�6�4�}!@C~�E � E � OR4 / @�� � � � �& � � �' � �+O5K;@C6{ORK+@jg+Q54�y;9;h#O_@#~�E � E-� / @#hC4)Ls@C3

� � ��� � � � � � � ���� � � � ��� S � � a � �& � � �& � �& � �' � �' � � S � E 8)a

��K;BNh[K^K*2\3�O5K;@�3R2�Ls@ }�4)Q5L 2�3�ORK;@�1 � b BNQ5QP@Cy;9;h#B / <N@khC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O&4�}�ORK;@�K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 EJ?4)6;3PBXy;@#QWBX6;3lOR@C2�y��ZO �?4mBN6;hC4)LsBX6+:^h#BXQ5h#9;<=2\Q5< 0 gI4)<X2�Q5B @C@#y / @.2�Ls3���BoORK�4�g;gI4�35BNO5@FK*2\6;y;@Cy-,

6;@#353C��}�4)QF@��+2�Lsg;<X@\� �� � ��� � � � � ��� � � �& �� �' � 2\6;y �� � � � � � � � � � �& � � �' � E,i�~�E � E>��6;4)�

/ @ChC4�LM@#3

� � ��� � � � � � � ���� � � � ��� S � � a � �& � � �& � �&

����' � �' � � S � E c)a

��K;BNh[K^K*2\3�O5K;@�3R2�Ls@ }�4)Q5L 2�3�ORK;@�1 � ��BNQ5QP@Cy;9;h#B / <N@khC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O&4�}�ORK;@�K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 E��K;BN3�35BNLMg+<X@|@��+2�Lsg;<X@|BX<N<X9;3lORQR2%OR@C3YORK+@'9;3P@t4�}w2�6-BN6�OR@CQl}�@CQP@C6;h#@ g*2\OPOR@CQP6�4�}8O ��4 BX6;h#BXy;@#6�O4)g+O5BXhC2�<�'*@C<Ny;3 BX6shCQ5@C2\ORBN6;:wORK;@_BXQPQ5@Cy+9;hCB / <X@�OR@#6;354�Q�h#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3 4�}�ORK+@nK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 E

Page 31: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

b98

� � ��� ��� � �

� � � � � � � ��� � � � ��� ��� � � � � ����� � � � �

� � ��� ��� � � � � ��� � � ��� � � �#� ��� � � � � �

� ��� � � � � � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � � ��� � � � �

>A4)Q5u�y+4)6;@wBX6{hC4�<X<=2 / 4)Q52\ORBN4)6 ��BoORK|�kQ54�}�@#353P4)Qn1�4)35@#g;K � 0 353ikhC4)<N@ U 4)QPL�2\<X@wG�9+g��@CQPBX@C9+Q5@jy;@^JW2�h[K*2�6���JW2\h[K*2�6���v*QR2�6+hC@

� �� ������� ���� �� � ���

��K;@CQP@{2�Q5@sO �?4tLM2�BN6 2�3PgI@#h#OR3�O54'ORK+@�y;@#35BX:�6 4�}�4)Q5:)2�6;BXhsLM2\OR@#Q5B=2\<X3p}�4)Q,3P@Ch#4)6;y ,�4)Q5y;@#Q6;4)6+<[email protected]�Q84�g+ORBNh.2�<�2�g;g;<NBXh.2%ORBX4�6;3CEj��K;@ '*Q53lOjBX38ORK+@my;@C3PBX:)6T4�}�ORK;@Y6;4�6;<XBN6;@.2�QF4)g+ORBNh.2�<!h[K;Q54 ,Ls4)g;K;4)QP@�E ��K;@|35@#hC4)6;y BX3�O5K;@�h#4)6;3lORQ59+h#ORBN4)6 4�}82 LM2�hCQP4)35h#4)g;BXh"352�Lsg;<X@"BN6 ��K+BXh[K O5K;@C3P@h[K;QP4)LM4�g;K;4)QP@C3{2�QP@t2�Q5Q52�6;:)@#y�BX6 2 6;4�6 ,�h#@C6�ORQP4)3 0 LsLM@�ORQ5BNh LM2�6;6;@#QCE J?4)6;3PO5Q59;h�ORBN4)6�4�}^2h[K;QP4)LM4�g;K;4)QP@|O 0 g;BNh.2�<N< 0 3lO[2�QlOR3*��BNORK 2Ah#@C6�ORQP4)3 0 LsLM@�ORQPBXh|hC4)6 �P9+:�2\OR@#y Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@"359;h[K 2\3/ @C6�@#@C6;@\�_3lORBN< / @C6;@\�?4)QM2Ag�4)< 0 @C6;@\E ��K;@'3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 BX3YORK;@#6 / QP4)u�@#6 /�0 2%O5O[2\h[K;BX6;:T@C<N@Ch ,ORQP4)6�y;4)6+4)Q{2�6;y 2�h#hC@#g+OR4)Q{3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3#E ��6 LM4�3PO"hC2�35@#3C�FO5K;BX3�3P9 / 3lORBNO59+ORBN4)6�BX6+y;9;hC@#3{2359 / 3POR2�6�ORB=2\< gI@#Q5LM2�6;@#6ZO8y;BXg�4)<X@^BX6'O5K;@mLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@�EpfF6T2�y�`�2\6ZOR2�:)@�4\} O5K;BX3Fy;BXg�4)<X@^LM4�LM@#6ZOBX3pO5K*2\OjBNOj2�<N<X4)��3pLM2�hCQP4)35h#4)g;BXhY2\<XBX:�6;LM@#6�OpOR4 / @sBX6+y;9;hC@#yA`�B=2{2�6T@���O5@CQ56;2�<�@C<X@#h#O5Q5BXh '*@#<Xy��

Page 32: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

b�c

ΑΑ

ΑDD

DD

Α

a) b)

x

y

v�BN:)9;Q5@ �+E b �k78BNgI4)<X2�Q 2�6;y�4�h#O59;g�4)<=2�Q 359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6�g*2\OPOR@CQP6;3?}�4)Q / @#6�@C@#6;@�E f 2\6;y{7 Q5@#g;Q5@ ,35@#6�OF@#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6|2�6;y|y;4)6;4)Q�3P9 / 3lORBNO59;@C6�O53C��Q5@C3PgI@#h#O5BN`)@#< 0 E

2�3wBX6 h#4)Q54)6;2|g�4)<XBN6;:;E � ; � �_4)�?@�`)@CQ#��ORK+@sLM2�h#Q54)3PhC4)g;BNhmgI4�<=2�[email protected]%ORBX4�6 4�} ORK;@sQ5@#359;<oORBX6+:"L�2 ,OR@#Q5BX2�< <X@C2�y;3pOR4|<X4�6;: ,�O5@CQPL 3POR2 / BN<XBNO 0 BX3P359;@#3CE 8 � f 6Z9;L / @CQj4�}?2�g;g;QP4�2�h[K;@#3,2\Q5@ / @#BX6;:|9;3P@CyOR4 2\y;y;Q5@#353mORK+@C35@{3lO[2 / BN<XBoO 0 BN353P9;@C3#��BN6;hC<N9;y;BX6+:'hCQP4)353 ,�<NBX6;uZBX6+: 4�}n2tK;4)3POYg�4)< 0 Ls@CQ,2�6;y ORK+@2\OPO[2�h[K;Ls@C6�OF4�}kORK;@,h[K;Q54)Ls4)g;K+4)Q5@,2�382�3PBXy;@^h[K*2�BN6'OR4�O5K;@,K+4)3POpg�4)< 0 Ls@CQ#E�fF6 2�<oOR@CQP6*2\O5BN`)@BX3kO54jh#Q5@C2\OR@n2�6M2�hCh#@Cg+O54)Q�,�y;4)6;4)Q�3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6Mg;2\O5O5@CQ56r��3P9;h[K"2�3kO5K;@n4�h#O59;g�4)<=2�Q�359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5@Cy/ @C6�@#@C6;@_35K;4)��6MBX6sv�BX:�9;Q5@ ��E bZS�/�a E���K;BX3kO 0 gI@�4�}I4�h#OR9+gI4)<X2�Q 3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6Yg*2\O5O5@CQP6My;4�@C3�6;4\OBX6+y;9;hC@M2{gI@#Q5LM2�6;@C6�O^y;BXg�4)<N@�LM4�LM@#6ZOjBN6TO5K;@MLs4)<N@ChC9+<X@�� / 9+O,BoOwy;4�@C3j<[email protected]\yTO54'2{359 / 3PO[2\6 ,ORBX2�<rK 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 E-=)� 8 � fF<oORK;4)9+:)K"ORK;@p<X2�h[u�4�}!2my;BNgI4)<N@FLs4)Ls@C6�O�g;QP@ChC<N9;y;@#3_h#4)Q54�6*2g�4)<X<NBX6;:;�C4)g+ORBNh.2�<�gI4)<N<XBN6;:�O5@Ch[K;6;BN~Z9;@C3!h.2�6 / @�9;3P@CyjOR4_2�h[K;BN@#`)@ LM2�hCQP4)35h#4)g;BXh�2\<XBX:�6;LM@#6�OR3CE =Z� 8 ���6;y;@#@Cy��+4)g+ORBNh.2�<*g�4)<NBX6;:wLM2 0 K;2�`�@p2�y+`\2�6�OR2�:)@C3 }�4)Q�ORK;@_hC4)6+3PORQP9;h#O5BX4)6�4�}�6;4�`)@#<rLM2\OR@#Q5BX2�<X3kBN6��K;BNh[K�ORK;@�4)g�ORBXhC2�<�359;3PhC@Cg�ORB / BX<XBoORBN@C3!2�Q5@WLs4�y;9;<=2%OR@Cy ��BNORK,LMBNhCQ54�6�Q5@#354)<N9+ORBN4)6�E�J?4)6;3PO5Q59;h�ORBN4)64�}�3P9;h[K"LM2\OR@#Q5B=2\<X3kBX3�2�6�BN6�OR@CQP@C3lORBX6+:,y;@#35BX:�6�g;QP4 / <X@#L 35BX6+hC@ / 4�O5KMORK+@F<XBN6;@.2\Q�2\6;y�6;4�6;<XBN6;@.2�Q359+35hC@#g+ORB / BX<NBNO5BX@C3?L�2 0�/ @wLM4�y;9;<X2\OR@#y{2�6;y"ORK+@C35@jLs4�y;9+<=2\O5BX4)6Mg*2\O5O5@CQP6;3nLM2 0�/ @pBX6�ORBNL�2%OR@C< 0hC4�9;g;<X@#y�E_��6 y;@C3PBX:)6+BX6;:Mh[K;Q54)Ls4)g;K+4)Q5@#3n}�4)Q_ORK;BN3n6;@�� hC<=2\353F4\}kL�2%OR@CQPB=2�<N3C����@�h.2\6'O[2�u\@m2�y ,`\2�6�O[2�:�@�4�}nORK;@ � @ �+B / BX<NBNO 0 2\�r4�Q5y;@#y /�0 ORK;@|<=2�QP:)@{6Z9;L / @CQs4�}p2.`\2�BX<X2 / <N@�@C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6 y;4)6;4�Q2�6;yM2�h#hC@Cg�OR4)Q 359 / 3PORBoOR9;@#6�OR3C�ZORK+@n6Z9;L / @CQ�4�}I359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6M3PBNOR@#3�4)6�2ph[K;QP4)Ls4)g;K;4)QP@�359;h[K"2\3/ @C6�@#@C6;@_4)Q�3PO5BX< / @C6+@ ��K;@CQP@�O5K;@C3P@nLM2 0m/ @�g;<=2�h#@Cy���2�6+ysO5K;@ �?@C2�<NO5Ks4\}�g�4)353PB / BN<XBNO5BX@#3!4)g�@C6+@Cy9;g ��BoORK O ��4{2�6;y ORK+Q5@C@my+BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6*2\<�3P9 / 3lORBNO59+ORBN4)6 g*2%O5OR@#Q56;3#Ew�!4�OR2�u�@�}�9;<N<�2\y+`\2�6�O[2�:)@^4�}ORK+BX3 � @���B / BX<XBoO 0 �%BNO!BX3�9;35@�}�9;<�O5489;6;y+@CQ53lO[2�6+y�ORK;@�3PORQP9;h#O59;Q5@ � g;QP4)gI@#QPO 0 Q5@C<X2\ORBN4)6;3PK;BXg;3�2�6+y�K;@CQP@ORK+@C35@^2�QP@p@���g;<X4�Q5@Cy|9;3PBX6;:s35@#LMB ,�@CLsg;BNQ5BXhC2�<�~Z9*2�6�OR9;L h[K+@CLsBX3PO5Q 0 E

��6 hC4)6;3lORQP9;h#O5BX6;: 2'Ls4�y;@C<�}�4)Q,O5K;@�3PO5Q59;h�OR9;QP@ � g+Q54)g�@CQlO 0 Q5@#<=2\O5BX4)6;3PK;BXg+3C��BoO�BN3,9;3P@#}�9;<?O54

Page 33: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

���

/ @^2 / <X@8O54sh#4)6�ORBN6�9+4)9;35< 0 `\2�Q 0 ORK;@w3lORQ5@#6;:�O5K'4�}�ORK;@w@#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6|2�hCh#@Cg+O54)Q53n2�6;y{y;4)6+4)Q53#E � ��4:)@#6;@CQ52�<�35h[K;@#LM@#3m2�Q5@shC9+Q5Q5@#6�OR< 0 BN6A9;3P@�E{��6 4)6+@M3Ph[K;@CLs@���O5K;@M2�hCh#@Cg+O54)Q53,2�6;y y;4�6;4)Q53^2�QP@`�BX@��?@#y 2\3�2�g;g+< 0 BX6;:�2�6�BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<n@#<X@#h#ORQPBXh '*@C<Ny OR4�O5K;@ h#@C6�ORQ52�<Fh#4)6 �P9;:�2%OR@Cy 9;6;BNOCE ��K;BN335h[K+@CLs@ �?2�3�QP@ChC@#6�OR< 0 9;35@#y{O54mg;Q54�`�BXy+@w2�9;6;B(';@Cy{y;@C3PhCQPBXg+O5BX4)6"4�}&O5K;@p<XBN6;@.2�Q?2�6;y"6;4�6;<XBN6;@.2�Q359+35hC@#g+ORB / BX<NBNO5BX@C3M4�}jg;9;3PK ,�g;9+<X<Fg�4)< 0 @C6+@t3 0 3PO5@CLs3CE b � � ��K;BX3"9+6;B('*hC2\ORBN4)6��?2�3{2�h[K;BN@#`�@Cy /Z0��Q5BoORBN6;:�ORK;@w@#6;@CQP: 0 �*>z�;4�} 2�6{9;6;3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+OR@#y'g�4)< 0 @C6;@wBX6|2�6{@#<X@Ch�ORQPBXh�'*@#<Xy�2�3

� �� �

S � a � � �� �

S � a � � � � S � a � � � � S � a � � S �+E b�a

��K;@#Q5@�S � a BX3m9;3P@Cy OR4 BX6+y;BXhC2\OR@�O5K*2\OmORK+@|g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 BX3Y2 }�9;6;h�ORBN4)6 4�}nO5K;@|2�g;g;<NBX@#y

@C<N@Ch�ORQ5BNh�'*@C<Ny�Ek��O�}�4)<X<N4)��3?ORK*2%O.�

� S � a ���� �

S � � a�� �

����� ��� � �� � S � a � �

� S � � a�� �

����� ��� � �� S �+E � a

q'2�QPy;@CQ�ORQ5@C2\OR@#y�ORK;@82�hCh#@Cg+O54)Q�2�6;y�y+4)6;4)QW4\}�2,g;9;3PK ,�g;9+<X<rg�4)< 0 @C6+@83 0 3PO5@CL 2\3�2�g;g;< 0 BX6;:,2�6BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<I@#<X@#h#ORQPBXh�'*@C<Ny�OR4,O5K;@8h#@C6�ORQ52�<�g�4)< 0 @C6;@\� ��BNO5K�ORK+@8354)<o`)@#6ZOW35@CQl`�BX6;:�O54�Q5@#BX6+}�4)QPhC@_ORK;BN3BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<&'*@#<Xy�E b � � ��K+@j<NBX6;@C2�QW2\6;y{6;4)6;<NBX6;@C2�Q?3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBNO5BX@#3���K;@#Q5@8ORK+@C6{35K;4)��6{OR4m4 / @ 0@C~�E S �+E � a ����BNO5K � / @#BX6;:mORK+@jBN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�@#<X@Ch�ORQPBXh�'*@#<Xy�E

��K;@,3P@Ch#4)6;y'3Ph[K;@CLs@,h#4)LsLM4)6+< 0 9+35@Cy|OR4MhC4)6�ORBN6Z9;4)9;3P< 0 `\2�Q 0 ORK;@j3PO5Q5@C6+:�ORK�4�} @#<X@Ch�ORQP4)62�h#hC@Cg�OR4)QP3W2�6;ysy;4)6+4)Q53 BX3kOR4w`�BX@��-ORK;@n2�h#hC@Cg�OR4)Q�4)Q�y;4)6;4)Q 2�3 g�@CQPO59;Q / BX6;:wORK;@_@C6+@CQ5: 0 4�}�[email protected]\Q / 4)6�2\O54)L O54���K;BNh[K,BNO�BN3!2%O5O[2\h[K;@Cy�E � c � ��K;BX3�35@#hC4)6+y�35h[K;@#LM@�BX3�LM4�Q5@�hC4)6�`�@C6;BN@C6�O�}�4)Q&ORK+@hC9+Q5Q5@#6�O�3lOR9;y 0 E���6jg;9;3PK ,�g;9+<X<�g�4)< 0 @C6;@#3C�\O5K;@�4)g+O5BXh.2\<)359;3PhC@#g+ORB / BX<NBNORBN@C3�<NBX@kg;QPBXLM2�Q5BN< 0 2�<N4)6;:�ORK+@<X4�6;:j2 ��BX3 2�6;ysORKZ9;3C�ZORK+@n4)6+@ny;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<;2�g;g;QP4)��BNL�2\O5BX4)6m4\}�@C~�E �+E b BN3 3P9��shCBN@C6�O.E�v*4)QkORK+@359 / 3PO5BNOR9�OR@Cy / @C6�@#@C6;@#3�9;6;y+@CQ�hC4)6;3PBXy;@#QR2\O5BX4)6pK+@CQ5@\��4)Q�4\ORK;@#Q�L,9;<NO5BXy;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<�3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6g*2\OPOR@#Q56��*ORK+@j3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBoORBX@#3�2�Q5@w6;4\Ony+4)LMBN6*2\O5@Cy /�0 2�6 0 4)6;@pOR@#6;354)Q_hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZOCE > K+BX<X@BNO!LM2 0^/ @WgI4�3535B / <X@�OR4p9+35@�2�6,BX6�OR@#Q56*2�<�@C<N@Ch#O5Q5BNh�'*@#<Xy�3Ph[K;@CLs@WOR483lOR9;y 0 ORK+@C35@W`\2�QPBX4)9+3�O5@C6;3P4)QhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53C��O5K;@W3P@ChC4�6;yY35h[K;@#LM@WBN3�Ls4)Q5@�hC4)6�`�@C6;BN@C6�O�35BN6;hC@WBoO 2\<X<X4)��3�9;3�[email protected]�3PBX< 0 h#4)6;3PBXy;@#Q359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6|@��r@#h#O53F2\O�@C2�h[K'4\}!O5K;@ / @#6�@C@#6;4)BXy|h.2\Q / 4)6;3CE

78@C3Pg;BNO5@,ORK;@^hC4)Lsg;<N@���BNO 0 BX6�O5Q54�y;9;hC@#y /�0 O5K;@�<=2\Q5:)@j6Z9;L / @CQ84�}kO5@C6;3P4)Q8h#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR38BN6ORK+@n3P@ChC4�6;y�K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 �)2^Q52\ORK+@CQ 35BXLsg;<N@�g;BXh�OR9;QP@_@#LM@#Q5:)@#3?BN6YO5K;@_<XBXLsBNO ��K;@CQP@nORK+@K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 BX3�<NBX6;@C2�Q5< 0 y;@#gI@#6;y;@#6ZO?4)6YORK;@�3PO5Q5@#6;:�ORKM4�}rO5K;@_2�hCh#@Cg+O54)Q53�2�6;yMy;4)6;4�Q53CE��6�O5K;@w}�4)Q5LM2�<XBN35L 4�}k@#~�3#E ��E b 2�6;y �+E � �;ORK;BN3n<NBX6;@C2�Q�Q5@#:)BXLs@pL�2 0{/ @j`�BN@ ��@Cyt2�3�O5K*2\OnQR2�6;:�@

Page 34: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� b

4�}!BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�@C<N@Ch#O5Q5BNh�'*@C<Ny ��� ��K;@CQP@

� ��� � � ��� � ��� � S �+E>� a

>A@ / @#:)BX6 /�0 h[K*2\QR2�h�OR@CQPBA@#BX6;:sORK;BN3F<XBN6;@.2\QnQP@C:)BNLM@ ��BNO5K;BX6|ORK;@,� 9;h[u�@#< �r��2�QPBX35@#Q�,���2�QPQ�,���4)g;<N@S ����� a 2�6;y BX6�O5@CQ5Ls@Cy+B=2\O5@'6;@#:)<X@#h#O"4�}jy;Bo�r@#Q5@#6ZO5B=2�<_4�`)@#Q5<=2\g S � U 7w� a ~Z9*2�6�O59;L h[K;@#LMBNh.2�<y;@#35hCQPBXg+O5BX4)6+3CE � U 7w� hC2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5BX4)6+3,g�@CQP}�4�Q5Ls@Cy 4)6 2 `\2�Q5BN@#O 0 4\}nh[K+Q54)Ls4)g;K;4�Q5@C3Y2\Q5@�ORK+@C69;3P@CytOR4�y+@#OR@#Q5LsBX6;@^K;4)� h#<X4)3P@^O5K;@C3P@mh[K;Q54)Ls4)g;K+4)Q5@#3p2�Q5@^OR4�O5K;@�<XBN6;@.2\QnQP@C:)BNLM@^4�}�@C~�E5��E>�+E>A@wO5K;@C6|y;BN35hC9+353�ORK;@w@���O5@C6;3PBX4)6{OR4s6;4)6;<NBX6;@C2�QW@��r@#h#OR3n2�6;y{3P9;LMLM2�QPBA@C@8O5K;@wQ5@#359;<oOR3CE

� � ����� ��� � � ��� � � � ��� ��� � � ��� �

��K;@�Ls4�y+@C<�y;@#`�@C<N4)gI@#y K;@CQP@�@���O5@C6;y;3^ORK;@M4)6;@�,�y;BXLs@C6+35BX4�6*2�<�35hC2�<=2�Q ,�<NBXu�@YBN6ZO5@CQP6*2�< '*@C<NyLs4�y;@#<^4\}M�p9+y*2�Q'O54-L�9;<oORBXg�4)<X2�Q"3 0 3PO5@CLs3CE ��� � ��6 @���O5@C6;y;BN6;:-ORK+@ LM4�y;@#< ���?@�hC4)6�ORBN6Z9;@OR4T`�BX@ � ORK;@|LM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@|2�3M2 35u�@#<X@�OR4)6 O54 ��K;BNh[K @#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6 ,�2\hChC@#g+OR4�Q � @#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6 ,�y+4)6;4)Qs359 / ,3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3FK*2.`)@ / @C@C6T2\OPO[2�h[K+@Cy�Ep��K;@#35@m3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3p@ ��@CQPOj2\6t@#�I@Ch#O5BN`�@�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<�4)6 ORK+@35u\@C<N@#OR4�6 ��K;BNh[K ��@ ��BN<X<�QP@#}�@CQ�OR4M2�3�ORK+@^BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<VE���K;BX3_BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�g�@CQ ,OR9+Q / 3?O5K;@F3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6{2�6;y�2�hCh#4)9;6�OR3?}�4�Q�ORK+@FK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 4�}�ORK+@FOR4�OR2�< �Z4)Q�Py;QP@C3P35@Cy�;�3 0 3lOR@CL|E�v*4)Q BN6;3POR2�6;hC@\��BN}���@n2\35359+LM@WO5K;@�3 0 3PO5@CL O54 / @�@C3P35@#6ZO5B=2�<N< 0 4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<V�)2�3kBN6�89;y*2�Q ! 3�QP@C3PO5Q5BNh#OR@#y'2\g;g;Q54)2�h[K��*ORK;@#6|O5K;@wBX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�hC2�6 / @p`�BX@ ��@Cy'2�3�ORK;@w3P4)9;Q5h#@4�}&2\6�BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�@C<X@#h#O5Q5BXh '*@#<Xy�2�g;g;<NBX@CyM2�<N4)6;:wORK;@ �M2 ��BX3C� � " E�]n6;y;@#Q?<X2\OR@#Q BN<X<N9;LMBN6*2\O5BX4)6��ORK+@35u\@C<N@#OR4�6�@ �+g�@CQPBX@#6;hC@#3 / 4�ORK"O5K;BX3�BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�< '*@#<Xy�� � " ��2�6+y{O5K;@w@���OR@#Q56*2\<�@C<X@#h#O5Q5BXh�';@C<Xy{4�}�ORK+@<=2\35@CQ#� � " �*359;h[K|ORK*2%O�ORK;@pOR4\O[2�< ';@C<Xy�2�g;g+<XBX@#y�OR4mORK+@j3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6'BN3

� �� �����" � � " � � " S �+E d�a

��K;@j@C6;@#Q5: 0 � � �;4�}�ORK;@w35u\@C<N@#OR4�6'BX6"O5K;@pOR4�OR2�< '*@#<Xy{4�}!@C~�E �+E d BN3�:)BN`�@C6 /Z0 �

� � � " � � " � �� �����" �

b� � "�" � �

� �����" ��

b� �#"�"�" � �

� �����" ��

bd � "�"�"�" � �

� �����" S �+E ; a

��K;@#Q5@ � " BN3�ORK;@t@#6;@CQP: 0 4�}wO5K;@ 35u�@#<X@�OR4)6 BX6 @#@CQP4 ';@C<Xyr�F2�6+y���� � 2�6;y � 2\Q5@ ORK+@

359+35hC@#g+ORB / BX<NBNO5BX@C3�4�}�ORK+@W35u\@C<X@�OR4)6rE ��6m@C~Z3CE<�+E x , �+E c � ��@�2�3P359;Ls@�2FhC@#6�ORQ54�3 0 LMLs@#O5Q5BNhW35u\@C<X@�OR4)6r�359+h[KTO5K*2\O

�2�6+y � 4�}�O5K;@�35u\@C<N@#OR4�6A2\Q5@ / 4�ORK @#@CQ54+E^��K;@m3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBoORBX@#3F4�}kO5K;@my;QP@C353P@Cy

Page 35: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�)�

3 0 3lOR@CL LM2 0�/ @j4 / O[2�BN6;@Cy /�0 3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN6;:Y@C~�E �+E d BN6ZO54Y@C~�E&�+E ; ��� � �� " � �� " � " � b

� �� "�" � " � �b� ��#"�"�" � " � � b

d �� "�"�"�" � " S �+E x)a

�� "�" � � "�" � �� "�"�"�" � � "�"�"�" S �+E = a�� " � � "�" � " S �+E 8)a

��#"�"�" � � � "�"�"�" � " S �+E c)aS ��K+Q54)9;:�K;4)9+O ORK;BN3�g*2�g�@CQC� ��@���BX<N<;9;3P@82 / 2�Q�OR4jy;@C6;4\OR@_g;Q54)g�@CQlORBN@C3 4�}rO5K;@ny+Q5@C3P35@#y"3 0 3PO5@CL|�2�3�h#4)Lsg*2�Q5@#y OR4 O5K;4)35@"4\}_O5K;@�3Pu�@C<N@#O54)6�E a >A@{2�<X3P4 BX:)6+4)Q5@sOR@CQPLM3^ORK*2\Om2�Q5@�K+BX:)K;@#Q,ORK;2�6<XBN6;@.2\Qp4)Q5y;@#Q,BN6 � " E"��K;BX3^2�3P359;Lsg+ORBN4)6T4�}�<XBN6;@.2\QpQ5@C3PgI4�6;35@ ��BoORKAQ5@C3PgI@#h#O^OR4�O5K;@sBX6�OR@#Q56*2�<g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<rBX3�y;BN35hC9+3535@#y'BN6|Ls4)QP@py;@#OR2�BX< / @C<N4)�wE

U 4�O5@nO5K*2\O�2\hChC4�Q5y;BN6;:^O54,@C~Z3#E��+E 8 2�6+y �+E c ��@�`)@#6"QR2�6;umO5@C6;3P4)Q53 �� 2�6;y ��'2\Q5@_9;6;h[K*2�6+:)@Cy2\O '*Q53lO�4)QPy;@CQMBX6 � " E ��K;@'4�y;y-,�QR2\6;u OR@#6;354)QP3 �� 2�6;y �� 2�QP@ / 4�O5K-g;Q54�gI4)QlORBN4)6*2�<?O54�ORK+@BX6�O5@CQ56;2�< '*@C<Ny�� � " ����BNO5K�g;QP4)gI4�QPORBN4)6*2�<NBNO 0 hC4�6;3POR2�6�OR3^O5K*2\O^y;@Cg�@C6+y�4)6;< 0 4)6Ag;Q54)g�@CQlORBN@C3w4�}ORK+@m35u�@#<X@�OR4)6�Em��K+BX3pLs4�y;@#<!O5K;@CQP@#}�4)QP@sg+Q5@Cy+BXh#O538ORK*2%OpORK;@mQ52\ORBN4 �� � �� ��BX<X< / @�ORK;@Y3R2\LM@,}�4�Q2�<N<rh[K;@#LMBNh.2�<I359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6;3?4�} 2�:�BN`)@#6{35u�@#<X@�OR4)6�E v*9;QlORK;@#Q5Ls4)Q5@\��ORK+BX3WQ52\ORBN4�h.2�6 / @py;@CQPBN`�@Cy}�Q54�L ORK+@j3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBoORBX@#3C�

�2\6;y �!�*4\}!O5K;@w35u�@#<X@�OR4)6�E

��6t4)Q5y+@CQFO54":)@C6;@#QR2�<NBA@#@^ORK+BX3FLs4�y;@C<!354{2�3FO54"2�<N<X4)� }�4)QFO5K;@�y;@#35h#Q5BXg�ORBX4�6 4�} L�9;<oORBXg�4)<X2�Q3 0 3lOR@CLs3C� ��@ L�9;3lO�OR2�u�@ BN6�OR4 2\hChC4�9;6�O�ORK+@�}�9;<N<�O5@C6;3P4)Q�h[K*2\QR2�h�OR@CQM4�} / 4�ORK ORK;@�BX6�OR@#Q56*2�<g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�< 2�6+y ORK;@MQ5@C3P9;<NO5BX6;:�K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 E"> K;BN<X@*�?@ ��BX<X<�QP@#O[2\BX6AO5K;@�`�BX@�� ORK*2%OORK+@�359 / 3PORBoOR9;@#6�OR3j2�g;g;< 0 2\6 @C<N@Ch#O5Q54)3lO[2\O5BXh�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�O54�ORK+@m35u�@#<X@�OR4)6��$��@ ��BX<N<&9;35@Y2�Ls4)Q5@:)@#6;@CQ52�<�@���g*2�6+y;@Cy|}�4)Q5L }�4�QWORK;@wBX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<V�

� S � ��� ��� a � ��� � "

��� � � ��

�� � � ' �� S � ��� a S �+E b � a

S G�@C@"fFg+gI@#6;y;B"� �+E c E b�a ��K;@� � b OR@#Q5Ls3�4�}�@C~�E���E b � 2\Q5@�@#~�9+BN`\2�<X@#6�O�OR4 2�g+g;<XBNh.2\O5BX4)6T4�}2�9+6;BN}�4)QPL�@C<N@Ch�ORQ5BNh '*@C<NyAOR4|ORK;@s35u\@C<N@#OR4�6�� ��BNO5KTO5K;@�h#4�@ �shCBX@#6�OR3C�

��� � / @CBN6;:{ORK;@M@C<X@#h#O5Q5BXh

'*@#<Xy{@���g;QP@C353P@Cy BN6"35g;[email protected]�<�O5@C6;3P4)Q�6;4�OR2\ORBN4)6�E fn<NO5K;4)9;:)K"O5K;@��� b O5@CQ5L BX3W3P9��shCBX@#6�O_}�4�QORK+@_4�6;@�,�y;BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6;2�<�Ls4�y;@C<;3P9;LsL�2�QPBA@#@CyY2 / 4�`)@��ZL�9+<NORBNgI4�<=2�Q&3 0 3lOR@CLs3 Q5@C~Z9;BNQ5@WO5@CQ5Ls3 ��BNO5K� � b ����K;BXh[K|h.2�6|6;4�O / @wLM4�y;@C<N@Cy{2�3_2�6|BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�@C<N@Ch#O5Q5BNh�'*@C<Ny�E�J?4)6;35BNy;@CQ#�;}�4)Q�BX6;3lO[2�6+hC@��ORK+@,4�h#OR9+gI4)<X2�Q�359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5BX4)6|g*2\OPOR@#Q56 4�}kv�BX:)9+Q5@ �+E b � ��K+BXh[Kt2�g+g;<XBN@C3_2�6'BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<hC4�Q5Q5@#35g�4)6;y;BN6;:mOR4���1�+E

Page 36: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �

��6�@C~�E �+E ; �%O5K;@?@#6;@CQP: 0 4�};O5K;@�3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6�BN3!@ �+g;2�6;y;@#yY2�3�2_gI4)��@CQ!35@CQPBX@#3�BX6wORK+@ O54�O[2�< '*@#<Xy�E��K;BN3_LM2 0{/ @w:)@#6;@CQ52�<XB @C@#y|O54sO5K;@wBX6�OR@#Q56*2�< ,�g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<rLs4�y;@#< /�0 @���g*2�6;y+BX6;:sORK;@w@C6+@CQ5: 0 2\32mgI4)��@CQ_35@#Q5BX@#3�BX6"ORK;@wh#4�@ �Mh#BX@#6ZO53C�

��� �*4\}�@#~�E �+E b � E

� � � " � ���� �� � � �

�� �b�

���� � � � � � � �

� ��� � �� � � � ��� �

� �� � S �+E b)ba

b� ���� � � � � � � �� � � � � � �

� ��� � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ��� �

� �� � �� � �� � �

bd

���� � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� ��� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� �

� �� � �� � �� � � �

� � � �� � � �

��K;@#Q5@8ORK+@ � ! 3�2�QP@8:)@C6+@CQR2\<XBA@#@Cy"3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBNO5BX@#3�4�}&O5K;@835u\@C<N@#OR4�6�E���K;4)35@pO5@CQ5Ls3W4�}�@#~�E��+E b�b}�4)Q���K;BNh[K 2�<N< ! 3j2�QP@M@#~�9;2�<kOR4 b 2�QP@Y@C~Z9;BN`\2�<N@C6�OwOR4{ORK;@s@���g*2\6;35BN4)6A4\}W@C~�E �+E ; ����BNORK ORK+@359+35hC@#g+ORB / BX<NBNO5BX@C3nORQR2\6;3P}�4)QPLM@#yt}�Q54)L�JW2�QPO5@C35BX2�6tOR4{35g+K;@CQPBXh.2\< OR@C6+354)Qw6;4�OR2\ORBN4)6�Emv*4)QpL,9;<NO5B",g�4)<=2�Q 3 0 3lOR@CLs3C�;O5K;@8BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<rK;2�3WhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53���BNO5K � � b �;2�6+y�ORK;BN3?BX6�O5Q54�y;9;hC@#3:)@#6;@CQ52�<XB @C@CyT359+35hC@#g+ORB / BX<NBNO5BX@C3���K+BXh[K y;4�6;4�Oj4�hChC9+Q ��K;@#6�ORK+@�@C6+@CQ5: 0 BN3w@���g*2�6;y+@Cy BN6AORK+@g;QP@C35@#6;hC@Y4�} 2\6t@C<X@#h#O5Q5BXh '*@C<Ny�E8��K;@ � ! 38LM2 0�/ @,y;@�'*6;@Cy BN6'OR@#Q5Ls384�}�@C6+@CQ5: 0 y;@#Q5BN`\2\O5BN`�@C3C�}�4)Q�@ �;2\LMg;<N@��

� ��� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �b��� �

� ��� � �

� �� � � �� � �� � � � �

� � � �� � � �S �+E b � a

D 0 2\6*2�<X4�: 0 O54"@C~�E#�+E d ��O5K;@mgI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<!@���gI@#Q5BN@C6;h#@Cy /Z0 ORK;@m3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6TBX3p2�3P9;L 4�} ORK+@@���O5@CQ56;2�<ng�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�y;9;@|OR4AO5K;@|<=2�3P@CQC� S

��� a��

" � �W2�6;y O5K;@'BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<�y+9;@�O54AORK+@h[K;@#LMBNh.2�<�3P9 / 3lORBNO59;@C6�O53C� S

��� a ���

��� � �

��� � �

" �� �

��� � ��

�S �+E b � a

fF3���BNORKM@C~�E���E x ��ORK;@n359;3PhC@#g+ORB / BX<NBNORBN@C3 4�}�O5K;@8y;QP@C353P@Cy{3 0 3lOR@CL L�2 0s/ @F4 / OR2�BX6+@Cy /�0 359 / 3lORB ,OR9�ORBX6+:m@C~�E&�+E b ��BX6�OR4m@#~�E �+E b)b �*2�6+y|@ ��ORQR2\h#ORBN6;:�ORK+@jh#4�@ �shCBX@#6�O�4�}&ORK;@j2�g;g+Q54)g;QPB=2\O5@8g�4 ��@CQP34�} S

��� a��

" � E^��@CQPLM38O5K*2\Ow2�QP@m<XBN6;@.2�QnBX6 O5K;@m@���OR@#Q56*2\< gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<!:)BN`�@�ORK;@mg�@CQPL�2�6+@C6�Op@C<N@Ch ,ORQP4)3POR2\ORBNh�Ls4)LM@#6�OR3m4�}_ORK;@{y;QP@C3P35@Cy 3 0 3PO5@CL|E v*4)QmBX6;3lO[2�6+hC@���ORK+@"hC4�@ �shCBN@C6�OR3s4�} S

��� a �

" � �S��� a �

" � 2�6+y S��� a �

" � 0 BN@C<NyYO5K;@�gI@#Q5LM2�6;@#6ZO y;BNgI4�<X@���~�9;2�y;Q59+gI4)<N@�2�6;ys4�h�OR9;g�4)<N@WLM4�LM@#6ZO53k4�}ORK+@^y;QP@C3P35@Cyt3 0 3POR@#L�EnG�BNLMBN<=2�QP< 0 ��O5K;@,3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBNO5BX@#3 ��BNORK�Q5@#35g�@Ch#OnOR4�2�6 2�g+g;<XBN@Cy|@C<X@#h#O5Q5BXh'*@#<Xy 2\Q5@j4 / O[2\BX6;@#y|}�QP4)L ORK;@^hC4�@ �shCBN@C6�OR3n4�}�O5K;@�2\g;g;Q54�g;Q5BX2\OR@wg�4 ��@CQP3F4�} S

��� a �

" � E_1�9+3POp2\3

Page 37: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� d

BX6^ORK;@�4)6+@Wy;BXLs@C6+35BX4�6*2�<�LM4�y;@C<�4�}�@C~�E?��E x � �?@�QP@#O[2\BX6�4)6+< 0 9;gmOR4p<NBX6;@C2�Q�O5@CQPLM3 ��BoORKmQP@C35g�@Ch�OOR4jORK;@nBX6�OR@#Q56*2\<Ig�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\< E���K+BX3�O5K;@CQP@ /�0 g;Q54�`�BXy;@#3�2^QP@Ch#BXg�@n}�4)Q Q5@#<=2\O5BX6;:wORK;@ng;Q54�gI@#QPORBN@C3 4�}ORK+@^y;QP@C3P35@Cyt3 0 3POR@#L O54sO5K;4)3P@,4�}!ORK;@j35u\@C<X@�OR4)6 2�6;y�O5K;@jBX6�OR@#Q56*2�<&g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\< E�v�4�Q_@ �+2�LMg+<X@��OR4t4 / O[2�BN6�ORK+@ '*Q53lOYK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 ����K;BNh[K BN3,QP@C<=2%OR@Cy O54 �� � � � � �� � � � � � � � � �?@"@ ��ORQR2\h#OmORK+@hC4�@ �sh#BX@C6�O_4�} � S

��� a �

" � � � 2�6+y�QP@#O[2\BX6"9;g{OR4Y<XBN6;@.2\Q?OR@#Q5Ls3_BN6 S��� a ���

�� � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ����

� ����� � � � �

� � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � ��

�S �+E b.dZa

��K;BN3WBX3?2,:)@C6+@CQR2\<XBA@C2\ORBN4)6�4\}&@C~�E��+E c O5K*2\O�2�<N<X4)��3�}�4)Q / 4�ORK{2^L�9;<NO5BXg�4)<=2\QkBX6�OR@#Q56*2�<IgI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<2�6;ysBX6+hC<X9+y;@C3�2�<N<�O5@C6;3P4)Q�h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3k4�}�ORK+@_3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBoO 0 E ik~�E7�+E b.d L�2 0 2\<X354 / @ ��Q5BoO5OR@#62�3

�� � � � � �� � � � � � � � � �� � � � �� � � � � � � � � �

��� � � � � ��� � � � �� � � � � � � �

����� � � � � ���

� ���� � � � � ���

�� S �+E b ; a

��6 2�6*2�<N4): 0 OR4t@#~�E��+E x � ��K;@CQP@ �-BX3^ORK;@"y;@#Q5Bo`�2%ORBN`�@�4�} � ��BNO5K Q5@C3PgI@#h#OYOR4 O5K;@ '*@#<Xy��kORK+@y;@#Q5BN`\2\O5BN`�@�BX6 @#~�E��+E b ; BX3,Q5@C<X2\OR@#y OR4 � BN} � b 2�6+y O54t2 :)@#6;@CQ52�<XB @C@Cy 3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBoO 0 Bo}� � b E

ik~�9;2\ORBN4)6;3 �+E b�b O5K;Q54�9;:)K �+E b ; QP@Cg;QP@C3P@C6�Op2m}�4)Q5LM2�<I:)@C6;@#QR2�<NBA@C2\ORBN4)6"4�}�O5K;@wBX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�gI4 ,OR@#6�ORB=2\<!Ls4�y+@C<�OR4�L,9;<NO5BXg�4)<=2�Q?3 0 3PO5@CLs3C��g;QP4`�BNy;BX6;:�2�[email protected]�6;3_}�4)Q_4 / O[2\BX6;BN6;:sO5K;@�g;QP4)g�@CQPO5BX@#34�} O5K;@jy;Q5@#3535@#yt3 0 3PO5@CL }�Q54)L O5K;@,g+Q54)g�@CQlORBX@#3n4\}�ORK+@,35u\@C<N@#OR4�6t2�6;y|ORK;@^BX6�OR@#Q56*2�<&g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\< E�n4)��@#`�@CQC��y+9;@^O54MORK+@,<=2\Q5:)@j6Z9;L / @CQF4\} OR@#6;354)QnhC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O53FBX6 / 4\ORK'O5K;@,BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<&gI4\OR@C6-,ORBX2�<�2�6;yAORK;@M:)@C6;@#QR2�<NBA@#@CyT359;3PhC@Cg�ORB / BX<XBoORBN@C3C��BNO^BX3w9;3P@#}�9;< OR4�y;@#`�@C<X4�g 2�3 0 3lOR@#L�2\O5BXhMLM@C2�6;3C�Q5@C2�y;BN< 0 hC4�6;6;@Ch�OR@#y OR4'3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 Q5@#y;9;h#O5BX4)6+3C� OR4�359;LsLM2�Q5B @C@mORK;@�Q5@C<N@#`\2�6�O^Q5@C<X2\ORBN4)6;3PK;BXg;3}�4)Q�g*2\QPORBNhC9;<X2�QW3Pu�@C<N@#O54)6;3CE

f h#4)6�`)@C6+BX@C6�O,Q5@Cg+Q5@C3P@C6�O[2%ORBX4�6 4�}WO5K;@MBN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<�BN3j4 / O[2�BN6;@Cy /�0 QP@Ch#4):)6;B @CBX6+:ORK;2\O�ORK;@_LM4�<X@Ch#9;<=2\Q @C6;@#Q5: 0 BN3�LM4)3lO 35@C6+35BNO5BN`�@_O54jO5K;@_`\2�<N9;@�4�}�ORK;@_gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<�2\O�O5K;@F2%OR4)Ls3CE��6;y;@#@Cy��}�4)Q�O5K;@k~Z9*2�6�OR9;L h[K;@CLsBXhC2�<)Ls4�y;@#<X3I9;35@#y^BN6p35@Ch�ORBN4)6 �+E>���O5K;@��F2\LMBN<NOR4�6;B=2�6_hC4�6ZOR2�BX6+34)6;< 0 O5K;@�`\2�<X9;@"4\}nO5K;@{gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<W2%OmORK;@|2\O54)LMBNh�3PBNOR@#3CE ��K;@{BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<Wg�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<?}�4)Q�ORK+@/ @C6�@#@C6;@A35u�@#<X@�OR4)6 h.2�6 ORK;@#6 / @AQP@Cg;QP@C35@#6�OR@Cy /�0 BoOR3"`\2�<X9;@T2\O|@C2�h[K 4�}^ORK;@T35B � h.2\Q / 4)62\O54)LM3#Ek��K;@C3P@^3PB"�{y+@C:)QP@C@C3_4�}�}�Q5@#@Cy;4)L L�2 0�/ @j2�Q5Q52�6;:)@#y�BN6�`)@#h#OR4�Q_}�4)QPL��

��� S�����

� � ����

� � �����

� � �����

� �����

� � ����

a � S �+E b�x�a

Page 38: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�<;

��K;@#Q5@�����

� BX3mORK;@{ORK+@|`\2�<N9;@�4\}FORK+@�g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<�2\OMO5K;@ �� � 3PBNOR@\E G�BN6;hC@\�WBX6 Q5@#<=2\O5BX6;:tORK+@

g;QP4)gI@#QPO5BX@C3�4�}�ORK+@jy+Q5@C3P35@#y 3 0 3PO5@CL OR4mO5K;4)35@j4�}�ORK;@w3Pu�@C<N@#O54)6�� �?@jQ5@�O[2�BN6{4)6;< 0 9;g{OR4s<[email protected]�QOR@#Q5Ls3���BoORK'QP@C3PgI@#h#O8O54�ORK;@^BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<!g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\< ��BNOnBX3_hC4)6�`�@C6;BN@C6�OpOR4MQ5@ ��QPBNO5@,@C~�E �+E b ; BX6'2LM2�6;6;@#Q?ORK*2%O�@CLsg;K*2�3PBA@C@#3WORK;BN3�<XBN6;@.2�Q�Q5@#<=2\O5BX4)6;3PK;BXgrE���K;BN3�L�2 0�/ @8y;4�6;@ /Z0 2�Q5Q52�6;:)BN6;:�ORK+@OR@#6;354�Q,hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53,4�}?ORK;@�3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBoO 0 BX6�OR4'2'hC4�<X9;Ls6T`�@Ch�OR4)Q#E v*4)QjBX6;3lO[2�6;h#@���ORK;@ � =OR@#6;354�QphC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�OR3p4\} O5K;@ '*QP3POwK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 L�2 0 / @m2�QPQR2�6+:)@CytBN6ZO54{2�`)@#h#OR4�Q � Eik~Z9*2\ORBN4)6 �+E b ; L�2 0 O5K;@C6 / @���QPBNO5O5@C6��

�� � � � � � � S �+E b = a��K;@#Q5@ �-BX3�2mL�2%ORQ5B � ��BoORK{@C<N@CLs@C6�OR3�y;@�'*6;@#y 2�3#�

� � � � � �� �

� �����

�� S �+E b98�a

ik~�9;2\ORBN4)6 �+E b = g+Q54�`�BXy;@#3t2 <XBN6;@.2\Q|QP@C<X2\ORBN4)6;35K+BXg / @�O �?@#@C6 ORK;@�359;3PhC@Cg�ORB / BX<XBoO 0 4�}mORK+@y;QP@C353P@Cy 3 0 3lOR@CL 2�6;y'O5K;@,BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<VE_��K+@�<XBN6;@.2�Q�QP@C35g�4)6;3P@�LM2\ORQPB"�I� ����BX3n2M}�9;6;h ,ORBN4)6Y4)6;< 0 4�}�ORK;@_35u\@C<N@#OR4�6���2�6;yshC4)Lsg;<X@�OR@#< 0 3PgI@#hCB"'*@C3�ORK;@�<NBX6;@C2�QkQ5@#35g�4)6;35@_4�}�ORK;@�Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@�ED?@#<X4)�w�&��@,9;3P@�~Z9*2�6�OR9+L h[K;@#LMBN3PO5Q 0 OR4�hC2�<Xh#9;<=2%OR@wORK;@^L�2\O5Q5B � �_Erv*4)Q_O5K;@ / @C6 @C@C6+@�35u\@C<X@ ,OR4�6�� � BX3�2^<X2�Q5:�@ � = /�0Mx LM2\ORQPB"�s2�6+y �?@���BX<N<*hC4)6;3PBXy;@#Q�O ��4 �?2 0 3?O54,@ ��O5QR2�h�O?O5K;@FQP@C<X@�`\2�6�OBX6�}�4)Q5LM2\ORBN4)6�E���K;@ '*QP3POFBX3p2�6 2�6*2�< 0 3PBX3 / 2�35@#yt4)6 ORK+@,Ls4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Qn3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 4�}�ORK;@^35u\@C<X@ ,OR4�6�Ew��K;@m35@#hC4)6;yTBX3n35BN6;:)9;<X2�Qn`\2�<N9;@�y;@#hC4)LsgI4�35BNO5BX4)6 S G��87 a �r2�6�9+LM@#Q5BXhC2�< 2\g;g;Q54)2�h[K ORK*2%O359+LMLM2�Q5B @C@#3WORK;@wBX6�}�4)Q5LM2\ORBN4)6�h#4)6�O[2�BN6;@Cy|BX6 ��E

� �� � � � � � �� � ��� � � ��� � � ����� ����� � �

��K;@w<XBN6;@.2�Q Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@jLM2\O5Q5B"�I� � 4�}�@C~�E ��E b =�� ��BX<N< / @8hC2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5@Cy"9;3PBX6;:�O5K;Q5@#@p~Z9*2�6�OR9;Lh[K;@#LMBNh.2�<�Ls4�y+@C<X3#�W�9+h[u�@C<�O5K;@C4)Q 0 ������� S �!2�Q5BN35@CQ ,��!2�Q5Q ,��!4�g;<X@ a O5K;@C4�Q 0 �W2�6;y � U 7w� S ��6-,OR@#Q5Ls@Cy;BX2\OR@ U @#:)<X@#h#OF4�} 78BN�I@CQP@C6�ORBX2�<��F`)@CQP<=2�g a ORK+@C4)Q 0 EF��6 2\<X<�ORK;QP@C@^LM4�y;@C<N3C��ORK;@ / @#6�@C@#6;@Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@mBX3pO[2�u\@C6�O54�<NBX@mBN6 O5K;@ S �I� 0+a g;<=2�6+@*��BoORKA7���3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 2�6;y / 4�6;y�<N@C6;:�O5K;3w4�}b E d;b��fz2�6+y b E b � �f }�4�QWORK;@^J�,lJ 2�6;y�J�,�� / 4)6;y;3#�*Q5@#35g�@Ch#O5BN`�@C< 0 E

D?4�O5K|O5K;@j� 9;h[u�@#<&2�6;y���� � LM4�y;@C<N3WhC4�6;35BNy;@CQ�4)6;< 0 O5K;@ �A@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6;3#E ��K+@w}�4�Q5L 4�}�ORK+@� ,�@C<X@#h#O5Q54)6|�F2\LMBN<NOR4�6;B=2�6MBX3#�

���� ��� � �

� � ���

� ������ � � �

� � ��� � � � � � �

� � � � ���� � � � �

���

S���ba

Page 39: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� x

� � ������ �� S

� �barS

� � � b�a � S �+E b�c�a

��K;@#Q5@ � � � S �� a h#Q5@C2\OR@#3 S y;@#3PO5Q54 0 3 a 2�6"@C<N@Ch�ORQ54�6 ��BNO5K"35g;BN6 � BX6�O5K;@ ����4)Q / BNOR2�<�4)6�ORK+@ �

� �h.2\Q / 4)6"2\O54)L��

� ��� � � �� �� BN3�O5K;@F6Z9;L / @CQ?4)gI@#QR2\O54)Q�}�4)Q?@#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6;3W4)6�h.2�Q / 4)6 � � �

BN3

ORK+@^4)6-,�35BoOR@p@#6;@CQP: 0 �I2�6;y{ORK;@j359+LM3n2�Q5@w4�`)@#Q_O5K;@j35B"�"h.2�Q / 4)6'2\OR4�LM3�4�} / @#6�@C@#6;@�E?�!Q52�6;3P}�@#QLM2\ORQPB"��@C<X@#LM@#6�OR3C� �

� �*2\Q5@wBX6;h#<X9;y+@Cy{4)6;< 0�/ @#O ��@C@C6 2�y �52�h#@C6�O_h.2�Q / 4)6�2\O54)LM3#E�9;h[u\@C<FO5K;@C4)Q 0 BN:)6;4)QP@C3{J?4�9;<X4)L / BX6�O5@CQR2\h#ORBN4)6;3 / @�O �?@#@C6 @C<X@#h#O5Q54)6;3�2�6;y�354 BN6;hC<N9;y;@#3

4)6;< 0 ORK;@ '*Q53lO�O ��4�OR@#Q5Ls3M4\}p@C~�E �+E b.c E ��K;@'K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 g;Q5@#y;BXh�OR@#y /�0 �9;h[u�@#<ORK+@C4)Q 0 y;@Cg�@C6;y+3�4)6;< 0 4)6wORK;@�Ls4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Q�3lORQ59+h#OR9+Q5@W2\6;yjO5K;@�ORQR2\6;3P}�@#Q!BN6ZO5@C:)Q52�< � �

� � � / @�O �?@#@C6

2�y �52\hC@C6�O�h.2�Q / 4)6+3CEkG�BX6;h#@ O5K;@?QP@C359+<NOR3���BX<N< / @�hC4)Lsg*2�QP@CyjOR4�ORK;4)3P@?4�};� U 7w� ORK+@C4)Q 0 �)2\6;y,ORK+@K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 BN3835@#6;35BoORBN`�@�OR4"ORK+@m@C6;@#Q5: 0 4�}�O5K;@m<X4)��@C3lOw@���hCBoOR@Cy 3lO[2\O5@���ORK;@Y�9;h[u�@#<ORQ52�6;3l}�@CQWBN6ZO5@C:)Q52�<�BX3?3P@#O�O54 , � E x ; @���E�]n3PBX6;:�O5K;BX3 `�2\<X9;@\��ORK+@8<X4)��@C3POW4)g+ORBNh.2�<N< 0 2�<N<X4)��@Cy�3lO[2\O5@4 / OR2�BX6+@Cy"}�Q54)L �9;h[u\@C<�ORK;@#4)Q 0 2�:)Q5@#@C3 ��BNO5K|O5K*2\O�4�}!� U 7w� ORK;@#4)Q 0 E

��� � O5K;@C4�Q 0 BN6;hC<N9;y;@C3�J?4)9+<X4)L / BN6�OR@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6+3 / @�O �?@#@C6 @#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6;3"`�B=2�ORK+@T<X2�3PO"O ��4OR@#Q5Ls3?4�}�@C~�E ��E b�c E ��K;@8hC2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5BX4)6+3kg;Q5@#35@C6�O5@Cy{K;@CQP@89;3P@nORK+@p�8K;6;4�g;2�QR2�Ls@#O5@[email protected]%ORBX4�6Y}�4�QORK+@j@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6 ,�@C<X@#h#O5Q54)6{g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<V�

�� � � �

� � bCd � � c =� � � �� ������ � � � � � � � � �� � � �

� S �+E ��� a

��K;@":)QP4)9;6;y�@C<X@#h#O5Q54)6;BNh�3lO[2\O5@"BX3,4 / O[2�BN6;@CyA}�Q54)L �F2\QPORQP@C@ ,�v*4�h[u ORK+@C4)Q 0 ��2�6;y O5K;@�@ �+h#BNO5@Cy3POR2\OR@#3s2�Q5@{4 / OR2�BX6+@Cy }�Q54�L 35BN6;:)<X@#3�,�hC4)6/';:)9;QR2%ORBX4�6 BX6�OR@#QR2�h�ORBN4)6 S G ,�J?� a ORK;@#4)Q 0 E ��K;@ G ,lJ?�h.2\<XhC9+<=2\O5BX4)6;3kBN6;hC<N9;y;@n2�<X<*Ls4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q�4)Q / BNOR2�<X3#E!��K;@nORQR2\6;3P}�@#Q�LM2\ORQPB"�Y@#<X@#LM@#6ZOC� �

� � / @�O �?@#@C62�y �52\hC@C6�O?h.2�Q / 4)6+3?BX3 35@�O?O54 , � E ;)� @#���Z3P9;h[K�ORK*2%O�O5K;@F<N4 ��@C3lOW4)g�ORBXhC2�<X< 0 2�<N<X4)�?@#yM3lO[2\O5@82�:�Q5@C@#3��BNO5K"ORK*2\O_4 / O[2�BN6;@Cy"}�Q54�L � U 7w� ORK;@#4)Q 0 E

� U 7w� ORK;@#4)Q 0 BN6;hC<N9;y;@#3 / 4�O5K � 2�6+y �T@#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6;3_2�6;y{BX6+hC<X9+y;@C3_J?4)9+<X4)L / BN6ZO5@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6;3/ @#O ��@C@C6 @C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6+3CE ]n6;<NBXu�@ O5K;@ 2 / 4�`)@ O ��4 Ls4�y;@C<N3C��ORK;@t� U 7w� Ls4�y;@C<nK*2�3 / @C@C6 g*2 ,QR2\LM@�OR@CQPBA@#@Cy�3P9;h[K ORK;2\O^O5K;@��n2�LsBX<NO54)6;BX2�6tL�2 0T/ @M4 / O[2�BN6;@CyT}�4)Q,2\6 0 4)QP:�2�6;BNhsLs4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q3PO5Q59;h�OR9;QP@ � = � Ek��K;@F@#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6;BXh_3POR2\OR@#3�2�QP@F4 / OR2�BX6+@Cy�BN6MO5K;@F352�LM@nL�2\6;6;@CQ�2�3 }�4)Q?����� ORK;@ ,4)Q 0 E �n2�QPO5Q5@#@�,�v*4�h[upORK;@#4)Q 0 BX3�9;3P@Cy�}�4)Q&ORK;@?:)Q54)9+6;y,3lO[2\O5@�2�6;y�G ,lJ?��O5K;@C4)Q 0 ��BoORK,2FhC4)Lsg;<N@#OR@35@�OF4\}�Ls4)<X@#hC9;<X2�QW4)Q / BNOR2�<X3�BN3�9;35@#y�}�4)Q�O5K;@w@���hCBoOR@Cy�3POR2\OR@#3CE�G�BX6;h#@j� U 7w� BX3�g;2�QR2�Ls@#O5@CQPBA@C@#y}�4)Q�2\Q / BoORQR2\Q 0 4)Q5:�2\6;BXhn3PORQP9;h#O59;Q5@#3C� ��@w2�<X3P4m9;35@p� U 7w� O5K;@C4)Q 0 }�4)Q?O5K;@8hC2�<Xh#9;<=2\O5BX4)6+3?4)6"ORK+@359 / 3PO5BNOR9�OR@Cy / @#6�@C@#6;@jLM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@#3Wg;Q5@#35@#6ZO5@Cy / @C<N4)�wE

Page 40: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� =

��K;@ <XBN6;@.2�Q�Q5@C3PgI4�6;35@ LM2\ORQPB"�I� � 4�}j@C~�E �+E b98 �_BX3"4 / OR2�BX6+@Cy /�0 2�y;y+BX6;: ORK+@tBX6�OR@#Q56*2�<g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<r4�}�@#~�E&�+E b.x O54sO5K;@j�F2�LsBX<oOR4)6+B=2�6��

� ��� �� ��� � � � �

����� ��

S �+E � ba

v*4)Qp�9+h[u�@C< 2�6;y ����� ORK;@#4)Q 0 ��

BX3FO5K;@�6Z9;L / @CQp4)g�@CQ52\OR4�QF}�4)QnO5K;@mg ,�4)Q / BoO[2�<�4)6 O5K;@�

� �h.2\Q / 4)6�2\O54)L|E�v*4)Q&� U 7w� O5K;@C4�Q 0 � �?@?hC4)6;3PBXy;@#Q�O ��48g�4)353PB / BN<XBoORBX@#3r}�4)Q&ORK;@�6Z9;L / @CQ�4�gI@#QR2\O54)QCE��K;@ '*Q53lO BX3 OR4j9;3P@_O5K;@�6�9+L / @#Q�4)gI@#QR2\O54)Q }�4)Q �P9;3lO�O5K;@�g ,�4�Q / BoO[2�<�4)6sO5K;@

� � hC2�Q / 4)6�� ��K+BXh[KBX3_hC4�6;35BN3POR@#6�O ��BNO5K�O5K;@^4�Q / BoO[2�<�g�@CQlOR9;Q / 2\ORBN4)6 2\Q5:)9;Ls@C6�OnBX6|fFg;g�@C6+y;B"� �+E c E b E���K;@,3P@Ch#4)6;yh[K;4)BNhC@8BN3?OR4,9;35@8O5K;@p6Z9;L / @CQW4)g�@CQ52\OR4�Q�}�4)Q?O5K;@FO54�O[2�<�6Z9;L / @CQ�4�}�`\2�<N@C6;h#@8@C<N@Ch�ORQ54�6;3�4)6�ORK+@

� � h.2�Q / 4)6r�-��K;BNh[K�h#4)Q5QP@C35g�4)6;y+3�OR4jg;<X2�hCBN6;:pORK;@_@C6�ORBNQ5@_2\O54)L BX6s2�6M@C<X@#h#O5Q54)3lO[2\O5BXh�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<��BNO5K"`�2\<X9;@

���� E

��K;@�K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 �;BX6 JW2�QPO5@C3PB=2�6 h#4�4�Q5y;BN6*2\OR@#3C��BX3_h.2�<NhC9;<X2\OR@#y'9;3PBX6;:�2M359+L 4�`)@#Q3POR2\OR@#3�@���g;Q5@#353PBX4)6

� ��� �b���� �

� � �

�� "

� � #� � #

� � � � #��� � # � � � � # � # � �� " � � " � � S �+E �)� a

��K;@#Q5@ # � � BN3�ORK;@T�F2\QPORQP@C@ ,�v*4�h[u :)Q54)9+6;y 3PO[2%OR@�� # � � 2�6;y # � � 2\Q5@TG ,�J?��@���h#BNOR@#y 3lO[2\O5@C3#��� � � � � � � � #

� � # � � � � " � BN3 O5K;@Fy+BN�I@CQ5@#6;hC@nBX6M@C6;@#Q5: 0M/ @�O �?@#@C6"ORK+@F:)QP4)9;6;y�2�6;y�@ �+h#BNO5@Cy3POR2\OR@#3C�+2�6;y��{BX3�2^3P9;LsL�2\O5BX4)6s4�`)@#QW2�<N<*35B"�Mg�@CQPL�9+O[2%ORBX4�6;3�4�}�ORK+@nOR@#6;354�Q?BX6+y;BXh#@C3CE i�~�E �+E ���BX3�'*Q53lO�@#`\2�<N9*2\O5@Cy�BN6�2\O54)LMBNhn9+6;BNO53 S @#6;@CQP: 0 BX6"�n2�QPO5Q5@C@#3C��h[K*2�Q5:�@8BX6�9+6;BNO53?4�} � �+2�6;y�<N@C6;:�O5KBX6|D?4�K;Q�QR2�y+BXB a �;2�6+y|O5K;@C6|L�9;<oORBXg+<XBX@#y /�0 8 � x � c ��� b � � ��� O54Mh#4)6�`)@CQlOnO54Y@C359 b)b � E

��OWBN3�h#4)6�`)@C6+BX@C6�O�O54^ORQ52�6;3l}�4)Q5L ORK+@pJW2�QlOR@C3PB=2�6MOR@C6+354)Q�4�}&@C~�E �+E ��� OR4�2^35g+K;@CQPBXh.2\<�O5@C6;3P4)QQ5@#g;Q5@#35@#6ZOR2\ORBN4)6�E ��K+BX3 BN3 y;4)6;@W`�BX2pJ?<X@ / 35h[K , � 4�Q5y;4)6Yh#4�@ �Mh#BX@#6ZO53C��2�3 y+BX35h#9;353P@CysBX6�QP@#}�@#Q5@C6+hC@ d � � Ek��K;@^6+4)Q5L 4�} � BX3WO[2\u�@C6�2�3#�

��� � � ��� �� �� S � � a � � �� � � # � # � � �� �

S � � a � � �� � S �+E � � a

��K;@#Q5@YORK;@Y359+L BX3p4�`)@#Q,2�<N<k1|2�6;y�qAE&789;@�OR4��p<X@#BX6;LM2�6;6 3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 =�� 8 � BN6tORK;@Y6;4)6-,Q5@#354)6;2�6�OnQP@C3PgI4)6+35@���4)6;< 0 O5K;@���� b 2�6;y � � �sh#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3_2�QP@p6;4)6 , @C@CQP4;E

��K;@�<XBN6;@.2�QIQ5@#35g�4)6;35@�LM2\ORQPB"�I� ���.BX3�4 / O[2�BN6;@Cy /�0 6Z9;[email protected]\<�@#`\2�<N9*2\O5BX4)684\}�O5K;@ky;@#Q5BN`\2\O5BN`�@BX6w@#~�E �+E b98 �9;3PBX6;:_hC@#6�ORQR2\<�y+BN�I@CQ5@#6;hCBN6;: ��BNO5K,2�3PO5@Cg^35BA@#@�4�} � E �)� b @#��E���K+@ h#@C6�ORQ52�<Zy;BN�I@CQP@C6;h#@BX3�@#`\2�<N9*2\O5@Cy,}�4)Q�@.2\h[Km4�};ORK+@?BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�`�2\<X9;@#3C�

�����

� 4\}�@C~�E ��E b�x E v*4)Q�@��+2�Lsg;<X@\�\ORK+@

Page 41: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� 8

y;@#Q5BN`\2\O5BN`�@m4�}�O5K;@YK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 ��BNO5K Q5@C3PgI@#h#OwOR4"O5K;@ '*Q53lO^h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�Ow4�}�@C~�E �+E b.xBX3#�

��

� �����

�� � S

�����

� ��� a�� S�����

� ��� a

� � � S �+E � dZa��K;@#Q5@��sBN3�ORK;@�3lOR@#gM3PBA@C@W2�6;y � S

����

� ��� a BX3�O5K;@ '*Q53lO�K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 @#`\2�<N9*2\O5@Cy ��BNO5K2�6{BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<�4\}�LM2�:)6;BoOR9;y+@��'2�g;g+<XBX@#y�OR4s35BoOR@ b E� �� � � � � � � � � � � ����� �

��K;@�~Z9*2\6ZO59;L h[K;@CLsBXhC2�<wLM@�ORK;4�y;3{y;@#35hCQPB / @Cy 2 / 4�`)@ 0 BX@#<Xy 2 � = � x <XBN6;@.2�Q{QP@C35g�4)6;3P@LM2\ORQPB"�I� � 4�}�@C~�E �+E b =�EF��K;@ ';Q53POp2�g;g;QP4�2�h[K ��@ ��BX<N<�9+35@�OR4�@���ORQ52�h#OpBN6+}�4)QPL�2\O5BX4)6"}�QP4)L��BX3 / 2\35@Cy'4)6|O5K;@jLM4)<N@Ch#9;<=2�Q?3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 4�}!ORK;@j35u\@C<N@#OR4�6�EW��6�O5K;BX3_2�g+g;Q54�2\h[K���O5K;@wOR@C6+354)QP3 �2�6;y � 2�Q5@�y+@ChC4�LMg�4)35@#yMBN6�OR4phC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53kORK*2\OkO5QR2�6+3P}�4)QPL 2�3�BXQPQ5@#y;9;hCB / <X@?Q5@Cg+Q5@C3P@C6�O[2%ORBX4�6;34�} ORK;@s7��sgI4�BX6�Op:)QP4)9;g 4�} ORK;@ / @C6�@#@C6;@s35u\@C<X@�OR4)6rEMv*4)Qp3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#y / @C6 @C@C6+@C3C� � 4�} ORK+@35u\@C<N@#OR4�6�BN3 @#@CQP4�2�6+y|@#~�E ��E b = / @Ch#4)LM@#3

�� � � � � S �+E �<; a

G�BN6;hC@ �-BN3�2mg;Q54)g�@CQlO 0 4�}&ORK+@jLs4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q�35u�@#<X@�OR4)6��*BoOWORQ52�6;3l}�4)Q5Ls3�2�3WORK+@wO54�O[2\<X< 0 3 0 LsLs@#O+,Q5BNhFQP@Cg;QP@C35@#6�O[2\O5BX4)6��+f ��� Ek��K;@pg;QP4�y+9;h#O � � ORK;@#6�ORQR2\6;3P}�4)QPLM3W2�hCh#4)Q5y;BN6;:,O54,ORK;@F3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0g;QP4)gI@#QPO5BX@C3n4�}�� ��35BN6;hC@^f ��� � � � � }�4)Q82�6 0 3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 QP@Cg;QP@C3P@C6�O[2\O5BX4)6 �kEn��K�9+3p2�g;g;<NB",h.2%ORBX4�6�4�}&2\6�BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<Ig�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<�O5K*2\O ORQ52�6;3P}�4�Q5Ls3W2�3�3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 Q5@#g;Q5@#35@#6ZOR2\ORBN4)6��tBX6+y;9;hC@#32mK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 ORK*2%O_2�<X3P4YO5QR2�6+3P}�4)QPLM3�2�3 �kE

�!4�h#[email protected]%OR@�3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 ,�2�y*2�g+O5@Cyp}�4)QPLM3�4\}�O5K;@kK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 OR@#6;354�QC� �?@ '*QP3PO�y;@ ';6;@2'g;QP4 �P@Ch�ORBN4)6 4)g�@CQR2%OR4)Q���ORK*2\OC� ��K;@C6 2�g+g;<XBN@CyAO54t2'}�9;6;h�ORBN4)6�� QP@#O[2\BX6;3^4)6;< 0 ORK;2\O�h#4)L*,

g�4)6;@C6�Oj4�}�ORK+@Y}�9+6;h#O5BX4)6 O5K*2\OpORQ52�6;3l}�4)Q5Ls3w2�38ORK+@m3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 35g�@ChCBN@C3 �kE���6T4�ORK;@#Q��?4�Q5y;3#� BN3WORK;@wg;QP4 �P@Ch�ORBX4�6|4�gI@#QR2\O54)QW}�Q54)L ORK;@w9;6+Q5@C3lORQPBXh#O5@Cy{OR@#6;354)Q�4)6�O54YO5K;@wBXQPQ5@Cy+9;hCB / <X@83P9 / 3P@#O�kE?��O_BX3�h#4)6�`)@C6+BX@C6�OnOR4*�?4)QPu ��BNO5K�3Pg;K;@CQPBXhC2�<�OR@C6+354)QP3C� �� � �*359;h[K�ORK*2\O�O5K;@jO5QR2�6+3P}�4)QPL�2\O5BX4)6g;QP4)gI@#QPO5BX@C3?4�} �� � 2�Q5@8BNy;@C6�O5BXh.2\<�O54�ORK;4)3P@p4�}&ORK;@F35g;K;@#Q5BNh.2�<�K;2�Q5Ls4)6;BNh ' �

Ek��K;@pg;QP4 �P@Ch�ORBN4)6

4)g�@CQ52\OR4)Q� �YBX3�y+@ '*6;@#y /�0 BNO53�2�h#O5BX4)6"4�6 �� � 2�3#�

� �� � ����� ���� � � � � S � aCS � ba ����� � ��� � �

�S � a �� �� S �+E � x�a

Page 42: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� c

�!2 / <X@ �+E b �?G 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 ,�2\y*2�g+O5@Cy|K 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 O5@C6;3P4)Q53n2�6;y�BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3W}�4�QORK+@�7��|g�4)BX6�Om:)QP4)9;g 4�} / @#6�@C@#6;@�E ��K;@|6;4�OR2\ORBN4)6 ����� � ����� � � BX6+y;BXhC2\OR@#3,ORK*2%O�2\6 0 <[email protected]�QhC4�L / BX6;2\ORBN4)6M4\} ���� 2�6;y ���� � ��BN<X<;O5QR2�6;3l}�4)Q5L ��BoORK�O5K;@FBN6;y;BXhC2\OR@#y�3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 Ek��K;@FBX6�OR@#Q56*2�<g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<N3?2\Q5@8:)Bo`)@#6{2�3�2,6;4�Q5LM2�<XB @C@Cys`)@#h#OR4�Q�Q5@Cg+Q5@C3P@C6�ORBN6;:�ORK+@8`�2\<X9;@n4�}�ORK;@FgI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�4)[email protected]\h[K�4�}!ORK;@w3PB"�"hC2�Q / 4)6�2\OR4�LM3WBN6 / @#6�@C@#6;@���� 4\}�@#~�E S �+E b�x�a E

� 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO5BX@#3G 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 1 � � 1 � b

f � �� �" �� �"D �� ����� � ����� �D � ����� � � �����i �� ����� � ����� � � �� �� � �� �� � �i � ������ � ����� � ���6ZO5@CQP6*2�<��!4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3D �� �

� b � � b � b � � b � b � � b �i ���

��� �

� � � � � b � � b � � � � � b � b �i � � ��� �

� � � b � b � � � � b � � b �

i � � �� � � � � � b � � b � � � � b � � b �i � � �

� � � b � � b � � � b � � b �

f ��� �� b � b � b � b � b � b �

��K;@#Q5@ �'BN3�ORK;@j4)Q5y+@CQ_4�} ORK+@^:)QP4)9;g���y�BX3�ORK;@jy;@#:)@C6;@#QR2�h 0 4\}�ORK+@^3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 35g�@Ch#BX@C3��k� �<=2 / @#<X3nO5K;@m3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 4)g�@CQ52\ORBN4)6;3F4\} O5K;@mg�4)BX6�Op:)QP4)9;g�� � BX3nORK;@mh[K*2\QR2�h�OR@CQ8}�4�Q84)g�@CQR2%ORBX4�6� BX6|3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 35g�@ChCBN@C3 �k�I7 S � a BN3�ORK;@jQ54�OR2\ORBN4)6{L�2%ORQ5B �{2�3P354�hCBX2\OR@#y ��BoORK{ORK;@j4)g�@CQR2%ORBX4�6� d;b � ��2�6;y �

�� BN3 b BN} � BN6�`)4)<o`)@C3,2�6�BN6�`)@CQP35BN4)6 2�6;y�@C@#Q54'4\ORK;@#Q+��BX3P@�E|D 0 2�g;g+< 0 BX6;:{ORK+@

g;QP4 �P@Ch�ORBX4�6"4)gI@#QR2\O54)Q�O54�@.2\h[K|4\}�ORK;@ph#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3C� �� � �/��@ph.2�6"y+@#OR@#Q5LsBX6;@F2�<X<�<XBN6;@.2\Q�h#4)L*,

/ BN6*2\ORBN4)6;3�4�} O5K;@ �� � ORK*2%OnO5QR2�6;3l}�4)Q5L 2\3F35g�@Ch#BX@#3 �kE���K;@,QP@C359+<NOR3F2�Q5@j<XBN3PO5@Cy'BN6��!2 / <N@ ��E b Efz35BNLMBN<=2�Q g;Q54�hC@#y;9;QP@ 0 BN@C<Xy+3�O5K;@w3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 ,�2�y*2�g+O5@Cy{BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<N3W4�}!��2 / <X@ �+E b E

fF3��?2�3py;BX3PhC9;3P35@#y 2 / 4�`)@��&3PBX6;h#@%� 4�} @C~�E��+E �<; ORQ52�6;3l}�4)Q5Ls3w2�38ORK+@�OR4�OR2�<X< 0 3 0 LMLs@#O5Q5BXhQ5@#g;Q5@#35@#6ZOR2\ORBN4)6���f ��� �I2�6 2�h#hC@#g+OR4)Q ,�y;4�6;4)Q_359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6|g*2\OPOR@CQP6'ORK;2\OFhC2�9;3P@C3nO5K;@,3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6OR4T@���g�@CQPBX@C6+hC@ 2\6 BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�4�}F3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 �k����BoORK;BN6 O5K;@|<[email protected]�QmQP@C35g�4)6;3P@t2�g ,g;QP4)��BNL�2\O5BX4)6r��BX6;y;9+hC@C3W2,K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 4\}�3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 �tBX6sORK;@ny;Q5@#3535@#y{3 0 3PO5@CL|E�v*4)Q@��+2�Lsg;<N@��k2�6 BN6�OR@CQP6*2�< gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<%��BNO5K D �� 3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 �khC4)QPQ5@#35g�4)6;y;BN6;:'OR4 O5K;@�4�h#O59;gI4�<=2�Q359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6tg*2\O5O5@CQP6T4\}?v!BX:)9;QP@ �+E b � ��BN<X<�BX6;y+9;hC@Y2�K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 QP@C3PgI4)6+35@Y4�}�D ��3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 � ����� � ����� � EMJ?4)Lsg*2�QPBX3P4)6 4�}�O5K;@Y3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 2�y*2�g+O5@CyABX6�OR@#Q56*2�<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3w2\6;yK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO5BX@C3!Q5@�`)@.2\<X3 354)Ls@�:)@C6;@#QR2�<*}�@C2\OR9;QP@C3#Ek��6M�!2 / <N@ ��E b 4)6;< 0 ORK;@nD �� 2\6;y�i ��

Page 43: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �

Q5@#g;Q5@#35@#6ZOR2\ORBN4)6;3w2�QP@mg;Q5@#35@#6ZOwBN6 / 4\ORK ORK+@�3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 ,�2�y*2�g+O5@Cy K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO5BX@C3�2\6;yBX6�O5@CQ56;2�< g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<N3CEjfF<oORK;4)9+:)KtBNOpBN3pgI4�3535B / <X@^OR4"}�4)Q5L K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO5BX@C3�O5K*2\OpORQ52�6;3 ,}�4)QPL 2�3?f � �;D � �;2�6;y{i � ��ORK+@C35@���BN<X<�6;4�O�2\Q5BX3P@F}�Q54�L 2�<NBX6;@C2�Q?QP@C3PgI4)6+35@���BNO5K"Q5@#35g�@Ch#O�O542�6|BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�2�g+g;<XBN@Cy"OR4mORK+@^hC2�Q / 4)6�2\OR4)Ls3�4�} / @#6�@C@#6;@�E�G�BXLsBX<X2�Q5< 0 ��ORK;@j2 / 35@C6+hC@4�}�: ,�3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 K 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 OR@#6;354)QP3^BN6t��2 / <X@%�+E b BX6+y;BXhC2\OR@#38ORK*2\Oj2\g;g;<XBNh.2\O5BX4)6�4�}ORK+@^: ,�3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<&g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<N3C�*f ��� 2�6;yti � � ����BX<N<�6;4�OnBX6;y+9;hC@,2sK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<",BNO 0 E ��K;BN3 BN3�2�3�@���g�@Ch#O5@Cy���35BN6;hC@_2�g;g+<XBXhC2\ORBN4)6�4�}�2�� ,�3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<*gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<;y;4�@C3�6;4\OQ5@#LM4�`�@wO5K;@whC@#6ZO5@CQ_4�}!3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 E

� �� � � ������� � ��� � � ��� � � �� � ����� ����� �

��K;@_3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 2\6*2�< 0 3PBX3k4�}IORK;@�g;QP@#`�BX4)9+3�3P@Ch#O5BX4)6sQ5@�`)@C2�<X3�h[K*2�Q52�h#O5@CQPBX3PO5BXh�y;BNQ5@Ch�ORBN4)6;3�2�3 ,354�hCBX2\OR@#y ��BNO5K�ORK;@W<NBX6;@C2�Q�QP@C3PgI4)6+35@�LM2\ORQPB"�I�<��E fF6+4�ORK;@#Q�2�g;g;QP4�2�h[K�O54p@���ORQ52�h#O�BN6+}�4)Q5LM2\O5BX4)6}�Q54�L ORK;@w<NBX6;@C2�QWQ5@#35g�4)6;3P@,LM2\ORQPB"�I������BX3W`�B=2Y35BN6;:)9;<X2�Q?`\2�<X9+@py;@Ch#4)LMg�4)3PBNORBN4)6 S GZ�p7 a E�GZ�p7BX3j@C3P35@#6ZO5B=2�<N< 0 ORK+@�y;BX2�:)4)6*2\<XBA@C2\ORBN4)6t4�}�2�Q5@Ch�O[2�6+:)9;<=2\Q^LM2\ORQPB"�T2\6;y y;@#hC4)LsgI4�35@C3^ORK;@ � = � xLM2\ORQPB"�I���-BN6ZO54s2Yg+Q54�y;9;h#O_4�}�ORK+Q5@C@wLM2\ORQPBXh#@C3

��� � � � � S �+E � = a

��K;@#Q5@ � 2�6;y � � 2\Q5@j9;6;BNOR2�Q 0 L�2\O5Q5BNhC@C3 ��BoORK|35B @C@C3 � = � � =Y2�6;y x � x QP@C3PgI@#h#ORBo`)@#< 0 E � BX3_2� = � x L�2\O5Q5B �pORK*2%O�BN3 @#@CQ54n@���hC@#g+O }�4)Q&ORK+@?9;g;g�@CQ ,�<N@#} O�hC4)QP6;@CQ���K;BXh[K,hC4)6�O[2\BX6;3!2ny;BX2�:)4)6;2�< x � xLM2\ORQPB"�IEkik~�E S �+E b = a L�2 0M/ @pQP@ ��Q5BoO5O5@C6{BX6�O5@CQ5Ls3�4�}&ORK+@p4)9+ORg+9+O�4�}&ORK;@jGZ�p7 }�2�h#O54)Q5B @.2\O5BX4)62�3#�

�� � � � � � � � � � S �+E � 8�aik~�E S �+E � 8�a h.2�6 / @WBN6�OR@CQPg;Q5@�OR@#yM2\3�}�4)<X<N4)��3CE���K;@WQ54)��3k4�} � � :)BN`�@Wh[K*2�Q52�h#O5@CQPBX3PO5BXhWy+BXQ5@#h#O5BX4)6;3}�4)Q_ORK;@�BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<!gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< Enf :)@#6;@CQ52�<�BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<!gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�� h.2�6 / @ ��Q5BoO5O5@C6t2�382�<[email protected]�QhC4�L / BX6;2\ORBN4)6A4\}_O5K;@C3P@�h[K*2�Q52�h#O5@CQPBX3PO5BXh�y+BXQ5@#h#O5BX4)6;3#E ��K;BN3,BX3,2�hCh#4)Lsg;<XBN35K;@#y /�0 O5K;@�LM2\ORQPB"�L�9;<oORBNg;<XBNh.2\O5BX4)6�� � � �A� ��K;BXh[K"QP@#OR9+Q56;3�2w`)@#h#OR4�QWhC4)6�OR2�BX6;BN6;:wORK;@8g+Q54 �P@#h#ORBN4)6�4\} � 4�6ZO54,ORK+@h[K*2�Q52�h#O5@CQPBX3PO5BXhwy;BNQ5@Ch�ORBN4)6;3CEk��K+@^@#<X@CLs@C6�O53_4\}!O5K;@^y+B=2�:)4�6*2�<rLM2\O5Q5B"� � :)BN`�@pORK;@wLM2�:)6;BoOR9;y;@4�}�O5K;@FK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 BX6;y+9;hC@#y /Z0 2�6�BX6�OR@#Q56*2�<�g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<�4�}&9+6;BNO�L�2\:)6;BNO59;y;@n2�g;g;<NBX@#y2�<N4)6;:�@C2�h[K�4�}pO5K;@C3P@th[K*2�QR2\h#OR@#Q5BN3PORBNh'y;BNQ5@#h#ORBN4)6;3#E v�BN6*2�<X< 0 ��BX6 O5K;@ L�9;<oORBNg;<XBNh.2\O5BX4)6 /�0 � �

Page 44: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� b

ORK+@ hC4)<N9;Ls6;3�4�} � :)BN`�@�O5K;@ty;BX3lORQPB / 9+O5BX4)6 4�}pORK+@ Q5@#35g�4)6;35@ 2\LM4)6+:�ORK;@�`�2\Q5BX4�9;3MO5@C6;3P4)QhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53CE���6 g*2\QPORBNhC9;<X2�QC��2\g;g;<XBNh.2\O5BX4)6{4�}k2�6'BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<&gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�< ��BNO5K 2Y}�4)Q5L @#~�9;2�<�O54ORK+@ �

� � Q54)� 4�} � � BN6;y;9;h#@C3k28K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 ��BNORK,6;4)Q5L�� � � � 2�6;ymK 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53�:)BN`�@C6 /Z0 ORK;@ �

� � hC4)<N9;Ls6|4\} �tEv*4)QjO5K;@ / @C6 @C@C6+@�35u\@C<X@�OR4)6r��ORK;@sh[K*2�Q52�h#O5@CQPBX3PO5BXhsy;BXQP@Ch�ORBX4�6;3j}�4�QjO5K;@�BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<

2�QP@My;@�OR@#Q5LsBX6;@#y /�0 3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 ��2�6;y�O5K;@�QP4)��3,4�} � 2�QP@MBNy;@C6�ORBNh.2�<kO54�ORK+@�3 0 LsLM@�ORQPBA@C@#yBX6�O5@CQ56;2�<rg�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<X3?4\}&��2 / <X@1�+E b E ��K+@phC4)<N9;LM6+3W4�} � BX6;y;BNh.2\O5@nO5K*2\O�2�g+g;<XBNh.2\O5BX4)6s4�}!2mD ��g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<IBX6;y+9;hC@#3n2�K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 4�}&}�4)Q5L ������� ����� � ���P9;3PO_2�3�BN6"��2 / <X@1��E b E�v*4)QW2�6i �� BX6�O5@CQ56;2�< g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<V��ORK;@shC4�<X9;Ls6;3p4�} � BX6;y+BXh.2%OR@�ORK;2\O ����� � �

���� � � 2�6;y �� �� � ��� � � � E

U 4\OR@ ORK;2\O{D �� gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<N3�BX6+y;9;hC@ � � � hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O53C����K+BX<X@'i �� g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<X3�BN6;y;9;h#@� � b h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3#E

��2 / <X@ �+E � 35K;4)��3�ORK+@�L�2\:)6;BNO59;y;@s4�}�ORK+@�K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNORBN@C3pBN6;y;9;h#@Cy /�0 D �� 2\6;yi �� g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3#��2�3 :)Bo`)@#6 /�0 ORK;@�y;BX2�:)4)6;2�<�@#<X@#LM@#6ZO53k4�} � BX6m@#~�E?�+E � 8 E���K+@WORK;QP@C@�~Z9*2�6�OR9;Lh[K;@#LMBNh.2�<�LM4�y;@#<X3!2�Q5@�35K;4)��6mBX6^4)Q5y+@CQ�4\}�BX6;h#[email protected]\35BX6+:FhC4�LMg;<N@���BNO 0 E!fn3 ��@W:)4n}�QP4)L �9;h[u\@C<�O54����� O5K;@C4)Q 0 � ��@W3lO[2 0 ��BoORK;BN6�2 �"@C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6,LM4�y;@C< / 9�O�2�y;yYJ?4�9;<X4)L / BX6�O5@CQR2\h#ORBN4)6;3 / @�O �?@#@C6@C<N@Ch�ORQ54�6;3CE8fny;y;BoORBX4�6'4�}kO5K;@C3P@sJ?4)9;<X4�L / BN6ZO5@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6;3nQ5@#y;9;hC@#38ORK;@�D �� Q5@#35g�4)6;35@ /�0'x)x��2�6;yTORK;@ � �� QP@C3PgI4)6+35@ /�0Ac � � E"��K;@�Q52\ORBN4�4\}?ORK+@�D �� O54 i �� Q5@#35g�4)6;35@MBX3wORK;@#6 QR2\BX35@#y}�Q54�L��MBX6t�9+h[u�@C<!ORK;@#4)Q 0 OR4 b � BX6t������ORK;@#4)Q 0 Ep��6t:)4)BX6+:MOR4�� U 7w� ORK;@#4)Q 0 � ��@mBX6;h#<X9;y;@ORK+@ � / 4)6;y+BX6;:s6;@#O ��4)QPu�2\3���@C<X<�2�3�ORK+@ � @#<X@#h#ORQP4)6;3#E�fF3Fy+BX35h#9;353P@CytBN6 G�@#h#O5BX4)6 �+E>����O5K;@CQP@2�QP@�O ��4 �?2 0 3�OR4^2�g;g+< 0 2\6MBN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<*g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<���BoORK;BN6Y� U 7w� O5K;@C4)Q 0 E ��K+@�'*QP3PO�BX3 O54,2�g+g;< 0ORK+@�g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<kO54�ORK+@ �-4)Q / BNOR2�<X3w4)6+< 0 E|v*4)QwORK;BN3,hC2�35@\��ORK;@M4)6;< 0 y;BN�I@CQP@C6;h#@ / @�O �?@#@C6 ORK+@� U 7w� 2�6;y���� �-Ls4�y;@C<N3�BX3WORK+@j@ ��g;<XBNhCBNO�BN6;hC<N9;35BN4)6"4�}�ORK;@w3PBX:)LM2m@C<X@#h#O5Q54)6;3#E���K;BX3�Q5@#y;9;h#@C3ORK+@mD �� Q5@C3PgI4�6;35@ /�0 2 / 4)9�O � � � 2�6;y O5K;@ � �� QP@C35g�4)6;3P@ /�0 4)6;< 0 � � �IORK;@#Q5@ /�0 <N4)�?@#Q5BX6+:ORK+@ � �� OR4 � �� Q52\ORBN4FOR4w2 / 4)9+O =�E v�BN6*2�<N< 0 �%�!2 / <X@ �+E � 3PK;4)��3 ORK;@�QP@C3P9;<NO53 ��K;@C6mORK+@�BX6�OR@#Q56*2�<g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<�BX3w2�g;g+<XBX@#ytOR4 / 4\ORKtORK;@ � 2�6;y � @C<X@#h#O5Q54)6;3w4�} ORK+@s� U 7w� Ls4�y;@#< E � @C<X2\ORBo`)@,O54ORK+@ � @C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6 g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< ��ORK;@{D �� 2�6+y � �� Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@C3s2�Q5@�<X4)�?@#Q5@#y /�0Ad � � 2�6;y b ; � �ORK+@CQ5@ /�0 <X4)��@CQ5BN6;:,O5K;@ � �� OR4 � �� QR2\O5BX4,O54m2 / 4)9+O ; E G�BX6;h#@FORK;@F� U 7w� LM4�y;@C<�BX3�ORK;@pLs4)3POhC4�LMg;<N@#O5@�� �?@FOR2�u�@nORK;@8Q52�6;:)@ ; OR4 =,2�3W2^[email protected]\354)6*2 / <X@n~�9;2�6�OR9;L h[K;@CLsBXhC2�<�@C3PO5BXLM2\OR@n4�}�ORK+@� �� OR4 � �� QR2\O5BX4;E

Page 45: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �

�!2 / <X@ �+E � � � @C359+<NOR3F4�} ORK+@mG��87 2�6*2�< 0 3PBX3_4)6'O5K;@ / @C6�@#@C6;@�3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6���9+35BX6+:MORK+@�~Z9*2�6�OR9;Lh[K;@#LMBNh.2�<8Ls4�y;@C<N3"y;BX3PhC9;3P35@Cy BX6 G�@#h#ORBN4)6 �+E-�+E ��K;@t`�2\<X9;@#3|:�BN`)@ O5K;@ L�2\:)6;BNO59;y;@ 4\},ORK+@K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 S BN6�@#359$! 3 a BN6;y;9;h#@Cy /�0 2�6�BX6�OR@#Q56*2�<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<&4�} 9;6+BNOnL�2�:�6;BNO59;y;@ S BN6`)4�<NOR3 a ��2�<X4�6;: @.2\h[K 4�}_ORK+@|3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 y+BXQ5@#h#O5BX4)6;3mBN6 ��2 / <X@ �+E b E v*4)Q^ORK;@{� U 7w� Ls4�y;@#< �Q5@#359;<oOR3j2�QP@s3PK;4)��6 ��BoORK ORK;@YBX6�O5@CQ56;2�< g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�< 2�g;g;<NBX@CytO54|O5K;@Y@C6�ORBNQ5@s2\OR4�L�2�6;y OR4{ORK+@�P9;3lO_O5K;@ �T4)Q / BoO[2�<N3CE

� 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 q'2�:)6;BoOR9;y+@C3C�;}�QP4)L O5K;@wL�2\O5Q5B � ��n2�LMBN<NO54)6;B=2\6 D �� i ���9+h[u�@C< d E-� 8 b E>= c

��� ���IG ,lJ?� b E d = � E b.d?8� U 7w����G ,�J?�[� �A4)Q / BNOR2�<X3W4�6;< 0 b E ��� � E b.d �� U 7w����G ,lJ?�[�*@#6�ORBXQP@w2\OR4�L � E x+b ; � E b � b

� �� ��� ��� � ��� � � � � � � � �� � � �� �� ����� ��� � � ��� ����� � �����

D?4�O5K�ORK+@^3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 2�6;ytGZ�p7 2\6*2�< 0 3P@C382\35359+LM@j<XBN6;@.2�Q�QP@C3PgI4)6+35@��I359;h[K O5K*2\O�ORK+@,4)g ,ORBNh.2�<*3P9;35h#@Cg+O5B / BN<XBoORBX@#3 2�6;y�4\ORK;@#Q?g;QP4)gI@#QPO5BX@C3 4�}IORK;@ny;Q5@#3535@#y"3 0 3PO5@CL 2�Q5@_<XBN6;@.2\Q5< 0 Q5@C<X2\OR@#ysO54ORK+@,BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<!g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< S @C~Z3#E5�+E �<; 2\6;y �+E � 8�a E_��6�ORK;BN3n3P@Ch#O5BX4)6r�&��@,3POR2 0 ��BoORK;BN6�ORK+@,BX6�O5@CQ�,6*2�<�g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<kLM4�y;@C<V� / 9+O^hC4)6;3PBXy;@#Q / [email protected]\u�y+4 ��6 BN6TO5K;@s<[email protected]�QwQ5@#35g�4)6;3P@�2�g;g+Q54.��BXLM2\ORBN4)6�E��K;BN3�BN3 y+4)6;@ /Z0 @ �;2\LMBN6;BX6;:pO5K;@nK 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 2\3?2w}�9;6;h#O5BX4)6s4�}IORK;@_3PO5Q5@C6+:�ORKM4�}�ORK+@BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< Es��K;@sgI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<kBN3,2�g+g;<XBN@CyT2�<X4�6;:|O5K;@s3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 ,�2\y*2�g+O5@Cy�y+BXQ5@#h#O5BX4)6;34�}��!2 / <N@ ��E b E U 4�OR@sORK*2%O,BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<N3j4\} � � � � � � 3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 y;4'6;4\O,QP@CLs4`�@�ORK+@hC@#6�OR@CQ_4�}!3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 ��2�6;y{354sy;4s6;4�O�BN6;y;9;h#@^2mK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 E

v�BX:�9;Q5@ �+E � 35K;4)��3!O5K;@�6;4)QPL 4�}+O5K;@ K 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 BX6;y;9+hC@Cy /�0 BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X32�g;g+<XBX@#y BX6�ORK;@YD �� 3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 y;BNQ5@#h#ORBN4)6�Ep�!2 / <N@ �+E b BX6;y;BNh.2\O5@C3_ORK*2\OFORK;@m<NBX6;@C2�QFQP@C35g�4)6;3P@��BNO5K,QP@C35g�@Ch�O OR4nORK;BN3!BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< ��BX<N< / @�4�}*ORK;@ }�4)Q5L � �� � � � �� � E���K+BX3�K+4)<Xy;3�2�<X3P4_}�4�Q2�Q / BNO5QR2�Q 0 3lORQP@C6;:�O5KYBX6�OR@#Q56*2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<N3CE S ��K;@�g�@CQlOR9;Q / @#ys3 0 3POR@#L K*2�3�7 � ��3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 �Z2\6;y���� � � ���� � BX3�O5K;@�4�6;< 0 O5@C6;3P4)Q&ORK*2\O&O5QR2�6;3l}�4)Q5Ls3�2�3&ORK;@�OR4�OR2�<X< 0 3 0 LsLs@#ORQPBXhkf � � Q5@#g;Q5@#35@#6ZOR2\ORBN4)64�}�ORK;@j7 � �jgI4�BX6�O�:)Q54�9;g�E a

��K;@MO5K;Q5@#@M~Z9*2\6ZO59;L h[K;@CLsBXhC2�<�LM4�y;@#<X3 0 BX@#<XyT35BXLsBX<X2�QFQP@C3P9;<NO53CE"v*4)Qj2�<N< ORK;QP@C@sLM4�y;@C<N3C�ORK+@sQP@C3PgI4)6+35@YQ5BN35@C3pO54�2"LM2 ��BXL�9+L / @#O ��@C@#6 2�g;g+Q54.��BXLM2\OR@#< 0 � E ; 2\6;y d @#��ErfF3w@���g�@Ch#O5@Cy}�Q54�L O5K;@pQ5@#359;<oOR3W4�}&O5K;@p<XBN6;@.2�Q Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@^2\6*2�< 0 3PBX3WBN6���2 / <X@1��E � ��ORK;@pg+Q5@Cy+BXh#O5BX4)6+3?}�Q54)L ORK+@�9;h[u\@C<�Ls4�y;@#<k2�QP@M3P9 / 3POR2�6�ORBX2�<X< 0 <X2�Q5:)@#Q8ORK*2\6TO5K*2\Oj4�}?O5K;@s��� � 4�Qj� U 7w� Ls4�y+@C<X3#EY��K;@K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 BX6^v�BX:)9+Q5@ �+E � BX6;h#Q5@C2�35@#3 6;@.2\Q5< 0 <NBX6;@C2�Q5< 0 ��BNO5K,BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<ZgI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<Z9;g,O54

Page 46: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�<�

β

v�BN:)9;Q5@ �+E � � U 4)Q5L 4�}kO5K;@�K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 BN6;y;9;h#@Cy /�0 2\6tBX6�OR@#Q56*2�<!gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<�4�}�D ��3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 }�4�Q_O5K;@��9+h[u�@C< S 3P~Z9*2�Q5@#3 a ����� � S h#BXQPhC<X@#3 a �I2\6;y � U 7w� S ORQPB=2�6;:�<X@C3 a �F2�LsBX<oOR4)6;B ,2�6;3#E"� BN3jO5K;@�QP4�4�[email protected]�6A35~Z9*2�QP@ S � q G a LM2�:)6;BoOR9;y;@Y4�}?ORK;@sgI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<VE"v*4)Q,2\<X< ���&ORK+@K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 OR@#6;354�Q_K;2�3_D �� 3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 � ���� � ���� � E

Page 47: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� d

2 / 4)9+O � @����*h#4)Q5QP@C35g�4)6;y+BX6;:mOR4s2�6{BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�< ��BNO5K|LM2�:)6+BNOR9+y;@ � E 8 @#� 2�<oOR@#Q56*2\O5BX6;:}�Q54�L 2\O54)L OR4 2\O54)L 2�hCh#4)Q5y;BN6;:�O54 ORK;@ BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<ngI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<_4�}j��2 / <X@ ��E b Ez��K;BN3�g;<X2�hC@#3ORK+@�`\2�<XBNy;BNO 0 4\}�ORK;@M<[email protected]�QjQ5@#35g�4)6;35@�Q5@C:�BXLs@�2\O�2 / 4)9+O � E 8 @�� 2�g+g;<XBN@CyAO54 @.2\h[K 2\OR4)L|��4�Q@C~Z9;Bo`\2�<X@#6ZO5< 0 �;2�y;Bo�r@#Q5@C6+hC@p4�} b E x @#� BN6�ORK;@pg�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�2�g+g;<XBN@Cy�O54Y2�y �52�h#@C6�O�h.2�Q / 4�6�2%OR4)Ls3CE

��K;@?@ ��BX3PO5@C6;h#@�4\}*2�L�2 ��BNL�9;L BN6,v!BX:)9;QP@ �+E � LM2 0p/ @�Q52\ORBN4)6*2�<NBA@C@#y /�0 2\6*2�<X4�: 0 O54F2�35BNL*,

BX<X2�Q / @CK;2�`�BN4)Qk35@#@C6�BN6Yg;9;35K-,�g;9;<N<;g�4)< 0 @C6;@#3 ��� � E���6sO5K;4)35@�3 0 3lOR@#LM3#��BN6;[email protected]�3PBX6;:8O5K;@�3PORQP@C6;:\ORK4�}�ORK;@^2�h#hC@Cg�OR4)QP3n2\6;y�y+4)6;4)QP3_@#6;K*2�6+hC@C3_ORK;@wh[K*2\6;:)@jBX6{gI@#Q5LM2�6;@#6ZO_y;BNgI4�<X@8Ls4)Ls@C6�O�9;g�4)6@���h#BNO[2%ORBX4�6wO54_O5K;@ h[K*2�Q5:�@�,�O5QR2�6+3P}�@CQ�3POR2\OR@#3C� ��K;BX<N@ 3PBXL�9+<NO[2\6;@C4)9+35< 0 y;@Ch#Q5@C2�35BN6;:nO5K;@ O5QR2�6+35BNO5BX4)6Ls4)LM@#6�OR3?O54�ORK;@#35@w3POR2\OR@#3CE�G�BX6+hC@8ORK+@C35@8O ��4m}�2�h#O54)Q53�K;2�`�@w4)g;g�4)35BN6;:�@#�I@Ch�OR3�4)6�O5K;@pK 0 g�@CQ ,g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 �&2'L�2 �+BNL�9;L Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@�BX3^4 / O[2\BX6;@#y�}�4)Q�2\6 BX6�OR@#Q5Ls@Cy;BX2\OR@M2�hCh#@Cg+O54)Q�,�y;4)6;4�Q3PO5Q5@#6;:�ORKrEkfF<NO5K;4)9;:�K�ORK;@#Q5@nBX3?6+4�gI@#Q5LM2�6;@#6ZO?y;BXg�4)<N@_Ls4)Ls@C6�O }�4)Q�O5K;@F:)QP4)9;6;y�2�6;y�@ �+h#BNO5@Cy3POR2\OR@#3W4�}�2 / @#6�@C@#6;@pgI@#QPO59;Q / @Cy ��BoORK"2�D �� gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< �ZBoO?3P@C@CLs3W<NBXu�@#< 0 O5K;@8LM2 ��BXL�9;L 3PORBN<X<Q5@#359;<oOR3w}�Q54)L�2 / 2\<=2�6;h#@ / @�O �?@#@C6 O5K;@s2�LM4�9;6�O^4\}Wh[K*2�QP:)@ / @#BX6;:{y;BN35g;<X2�hC@#yA4)6T@���h#BNO[2%ORBX4�62�6;y{ORK+@wO5QR2�6+35BNO5BX4)6"Ls4)Ls@C6�OWO54YO5K;@C3P@^h[K;2�Q5:)@ ,�y;BN35g;<X2�hC@#y�3lO[2\O5@C3#E

��K;@{K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 BN6;y;9;h#@Cy /�0 2�6 BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<Wg�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<%��BNO5K i �� 3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 BN335K+4 ��6tBN6 v�BN:)9;QP@C3 �+E>�M2�6;y �+E d E_��K+@,OR4�OR2�<&L�2\:)6;BNO59;y;@w4�} O5K;@,QP@C3PgI4)6+35@�BN3n3PK;4)��6tBX6 v!BX: ,9;QP@ �+E-�+E ��6YORK+@n<NBX6;@C2�QkQ5@#35g�4)6;35@F2�6*2�< 0 35BX3k4\}��!2 / <X@ �+E � ��ORK+@nK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 g;QP@Cy;BNh#O5@Cy/�0 �9;h[u\@C<+O5K;@C4�Q 0 BN3�2F}�2�h#O54)Q 4�} b � <X2�Q5:�@CQ�O5K*2�6�ORK;2\O�4�}I��� �T4)Qk� U 7w�-ORK+@C4)Q 0 Ekv�BN:)9;QP@ �+E-�35K+4 ��3jORK*2%OjO5K;BX3wy;BN35h#Q5@Cg;2�6;h 0 / @Ch#4)Ls@C3j@#`)@#6 <=2\Q5:)@#Q8}�4)Qw3PORQP4)6;:|gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<N3CEYfFg;g;2�Q5@#6ZO5< 0 �BX6+hC<X9+35BX4�6t4�}W@#<X@Ch�ORQP4)6 ,�@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6 BX6�OR@#QR2�h�ORBN4)6;3wK*2�3j2{<=2�QP:)@m@#�I@Ch�O^4�6TO5K;@Mg+Q5@Cy+BXh#O5@CyTK 0 g�@CQ ,g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 2�6;y�354m�9+h[u�@C<�ORK+@C4)Q 0 BN3�6+4�OW2\y;@C~Z9*2\O5@F}�4)Q h.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3k4)6MORK;@#35@F3 0 3POR@#LM3#E

v�BX:�9;Q5@ �+E d 3PK;4)��3 ORK;@�`�2\Q5BX4�9;3!O5@C6;3P4)QkhC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O53 4�}*ORK+@�K 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 BN6;y;9;h#@Cy/�0 2�6 � �� BX6�OR@#Q56*2�<�g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\< E���K+@F35<N4)g�@[email protected]�Q @C@#Q54�g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<I2\Q5@n2�3?@ �+g�@Ch�OR@#y�}�Q54)L ORK+@<XBN6;@.2\QFQ5@#35g�4)6;3P@mQ5@C3P9;<NO53pBX6 �!2 / <N@ �+E � E^v�4�QnORK+@mL � b hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O538ORK*2\Op2�Q5@m2\<X<X4)��@CytBN6<XBN6;@.2\Q?Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@�� ���% � 2�6;y � �% � �+O5K;@w<[email protected]�Q�Q5@C:�BXLs@8@���OR@#6;y;3�OR4s2 / 4)9+O ; @#�,E;��K;@wy;4)LsBX6*2\6ZO6;4)6+<[email protected]�Q!@#�I@Ch#O BN3 ORK;@�2�g+gI@C2�QR2�6+hC@�4�}IL � �+� ���% � ��hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53CE fn<NO5K;4)9;:)K�O5K;@C3P@_2�Q5@�6;4\O2�<N<X4)�?@#y BX6t<XBN6;@.2\Q8Q5@#35g�4)6;35@\��O5K;@ 0 :)Q54)� BX6 6;4)6;<NBX6;@C2�Q5< 0 2�6;y / @#hC4)Ls@YhC4)Lsg*2�Q52 / <N@,OR4"ORK+@4�O5K;@CQkh#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3 2 / 4`�@�2 / 4)9+O � @���E)fWO�ORK+BX3 LM2�:)6;BoOR9;y+@���O5K;@�h.2�Q / 4)6s2\O54)Ls3k2\Ok4)g+gI4)3PBNO5@35BNy;@C3�4�}�ORK+@ / @C6 @C@C6+@^QPBX6;:Yy;Bo�r@#Q�BX6{gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�< /�0 9+g|O54 � @#��E

Page 48: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� ;

β

v�BN:)9;Q5@ �+E-�+� U 4)Q5L 4�}�ORK+@mK 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 BX6+y;9;hC@#y /�0 2�6tBN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�4�} i ��3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 }�4)QFO5K;@s� 9;h[u�@#< �������!�&2�6;yT� U 7w� �F2�LsBX<oOR4)6+B=2�6;3#Ew��K;@MBN6;35@#QPOwBN3w2{y+@#O[2\BX<!}�4�Q35LM2�<N<�����35K;4)��BX6+:�ORK*2%OFORK+@,35<N4)g�@C3_6;@.2�Q_��� � 2�:�Q5@C@ ��BNO5K�ORK+@,<XBN6;@.2\Q_QP@C3PgI4)6+35@�QP@C359+<NOR3n4�}�!2 / <X@ ��E � E U 4�O[2%ORBX4�6"BX3_2�3�BX6|v�BN:)9;QP@ �+E � E

Page 49: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� x

β

v�BN:)9;Q5@ �+E d �k78@Ch#4)LsgI4)3PBNO5BX4)6s4�}�ORK+@8� U 7w� Q5@#359;<oOR3W4�}�v!BX:)9;QP@ �+E-�,BN6ZO54�BNO53?3Pg;K;@CQPBXhC2�<IO5@C6;3P4)QhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53CE ��K+@tBX6;3P@CQPO�BX3�2�y;@#OR2�BX<�}�4)Qs35LM2�<X<��,E U 4\OR@�O5K*2\O�O5K;@ � �% � h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�O�BN3@C@#Q54ABX6 ORK;@�<[email protected]�QmQP@C35g�4)6;3P@t2�6*2\< 0 35BN3C�W2\6;y K;@#Q5@|:)Q54)��3MBX6 ~�9;2�y;QR2%ORBXhC2�<X< 0 ��BoORK �,E���K;@'*<N<X@Cy�35~Z9*2�QP@C3Y2�QP@�ORK;@MOR4�OR2�<?QP@C35g�4)6;3P@�� '*<N<X@Cy�hCBXQPhC<N@C3�2\Q5@�O5K;@�OR4\O[2�< � ���'h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3#�ORK+@T@#LMg�O 0 hCBNQ5h#<X@C3{2\Q5@tORK;@ � � � ��� � � hC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�OR3#�FORK+@Th#Q54)3P35@#y h#BXQ5h#<X@#3{2�Q5@tORK+@��� � ��� � b h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3#��ORK;@ '*<N<X@Cy�ORQ5BX2�6;:)<N@C3p2\Q5@,O5K;@mOR4�OR2�< � � b h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3#�!2\6;yORK+@jh#Q54)3P35@#y�ORQPB=2�6+:)<X@#3?ORK;@���� b ��� � b h#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3CE

Page 50: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�?=

�!2 / <X@ �+E>��� � @#359;<oOR3W}�QP4)L � U 7w�zhC2�<Xh#9;<=2%ORBX4�6;3�4�6|3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#y / @#6�@C@#6;@wLM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@#3CE ��6"ORK+@6;4�OR2\ORBN4)6�}�4)Q�3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6{g*2\O5O5@CQP6;3C��359+h[K 2�3 S! �*�^���j���^���j��� a }�4)Q�Ls4)6;4)3P9 / 3lORBNO59+ORBN4)6��ORK+@�g*2�Q5@#6�ORK;@#35BX3k@#6;hC<N4)35@WO5K;@W3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3 2\OPO[2�h[K+@CymOR4p@C2�h[KY4�}*ORK;@�hC2�Q / 4)6Y2\O54)Ls3�BX6m4�Q5y;@#Q2�QP4)9;6;y{ORK;@wQPBX6;:;E���K;@^9+6;BNO53W}�4)QWORK;@wK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 2�QP@ b � � ��" @C3P9�E

������� � ��� � � � � �� ���

�� � � � � � � ����� �� � � � ����� �� � � � ��� � �� � � � � ������ � �

� � ������ � � � � �� "!#�$� �� � �� "!%��� �� � & �('*) � �+� � � + � � + � � � + � � + " � � + �

�� & �-,.' " + � �

" + 0/ " + � "�� " + � � � + "�" � + � � � & �21 " + � " " + � � " + � " + � � � � + ��� " + � /� & �-,.3 � " + � " + � � � " + � / " + � � � + � " + � � �

� & �-)4,.3 � � + � " + � � " + � � � " + " � � + ��� " + / � � & �-)*3 � + ��� " + � ��" " + � � " + � � � + "�" " + / " / � & �('53 � � + � � � + " " + � � + � / � + ��� " + "6�798�:�6<;� ������ � � �%= � 3 = & = & = 3 = 3 = 3

�,>��? ��� @ � � ��� �A?B����� � ��� � � � �C�

� ����� � � � � � � ����� �� � � � ����� �� � � � ��� � �� � � � � ������ � �

� � ������ � � � � �� "!#�$� �� � �� "!%��� � � � �D�$�� � � E9F� � ������ � � "G�HIG

� � �J���� � � E9F� � �J���� � � "G�HIG� � & �('*) � � + � � " + � �

� + � � � + � " + � � " + " ��" � + ��" " + ��� & �-,.' " + � � " + � � � " + � ��� " + ��� / � + "�" " + � " + � � � " + � � �� � & �21 " + / �

" + "�" � � � " + � � " + � � � + "�" " + "�"�� � � � + / � + / � & �-,.3 � " + / � � " + " � � � " + � � � " + 0/ � + � � " + " � � � � + � � + / �

� & �-)4,.3 � � + � � " + "���� / " + / " � + � � + " " + "�"���� � � + � � � + "�" � & �-)*3 � + � � " + " / " + " � + � � � + "�" " + " � / � � + / � � + / � � & �('53 � � + � � " + "�" / � + " � + " � + � " + "�"�����" � + � � + �KALM8ONP;� ������ � � �%= � & = 3 = & = 3 = 3 = 3

�,>��? ��� @ � � ��� �B?B����� � ��� � � � � �

� ����� � � � � � � ����� �� � � � ����� �� � � � ��� � �� � � � � ������ � �

� � ������ � � � � �� "!#�$� �� � �� "!%��� � � � �D�$�� � � E9F� � ������ � � "G�HIG

� � �D�$�� � � E9F� � �D�$�� � � "G�HIG

� � ������ � � E F� � �J���� � � "G�H�G� � & �('*) � � + ��" �+ � � " + � � + � � + "�" � + � � + " " + � / " + � /�

� & �-,.' � + � � " + / � " + " � " + � � � + "�" �+ " � + � " + � � � " + � � �� � & �21 " + / � " + � � � " + � � / " + � � � + "�" � + � � + � � " + � " + � �

� & �-,.3 � " + � " + " " + � � � " + � � � + � � + � � + " / � + " / " + � � �

� & �-)4,.3 � � + � � � + � " + ��" / " + � � + ��� � + " � � + � " + / " + / � � & �-)*3 � + "�� � + � � " + � / � " + �� � + "�" � + " � + � � " + / " + / � & �('53��

+� � � + � � " + � � � � + � � � + " � � + � � � + � " + � � " " + �����

� #Q � � � � � � � ����� � ��� � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � SR

��� � � � � �� � � ��� � ��UT � � � � ��� ��� �

��K;BX3F35@Ch�ORBN4)6 Q5@#gI4�QPOR3F� U 7w� h.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3�}�4)QF2M`\2�Q5BN@#O 0 4�}�2�h#hC@#g+OR4)Q � y;4)6+4)Q8359 / 3PO5BNOR9-,ORBN4)6{g*2\OPOR@CQP6;3�4)6"ORK;@ / @C6�@#@C6;@^35u\@C<X@�OR4)6r�*9;35BN6;:mORK;@j2�g;g+Q54�2�h[K|y;BN35hC9+3535@#y BX6�G�@#h#O5BX4)6 �+E-�+E

�WV�XSV � Y[Z ! ��&! ��� ���&�0\#�^]1�+�'� ��� ����2 / <X@#3 �+E>� 2�6+y �+E d 35K;4)� ORK;@ 6;4)QPL 4�}wO5K;@ K 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 }�4)Q"2 `\2�Q5BN@#O 0 4�}

359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6 g;2\O5O5@CQ56+3�4)6 ORK+@ / @C6�@#@C6;@T35u\@C<N@#OR4�6�����K;BXh[K��?@ ��BX<N<F@ �;2\LMBN6;@ BX6 <XBN:)K�O"4�}ORK+@w2 / 4�`�@^2\6*2�< 0 3P@C3CE��!2 / <N@1�+E-��hC4)Lsg*2�QP@C3�Ls4)6;4)3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+OR@#y|3 0 3POR@#LM3 ��BoORK{y;BX3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#y

Page 51: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� 8

�!2 / <X@ �+E d � � @#359;<oOR3_}�Q54)L � U 7w� hC2�<Xh#9;<=2%ORBX4�6;3n4�6'ORQPBX359 / 3PO5BNOR9�OR@Cy / @#6�@C@#6;@mLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3C��9;3 ,BX6+:'ORK;@"6+4�O[2\O5BX4)6A4�}_��2 / <X@ ��E>�+ET�86;< 0 # � # BX3^Q5@#gI4)QlOR@#y 3PBX6;h#@ ���% � 2�Q5@MORK;@�4�6;< 0 2�<X<N4)�?@#yhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53CE

ORQ5BN359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5@Cy S! ���^� ���^� ��� aG�9 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�O # � # # � � � # � # � � �

�� � � � # # � � ��� # S � � � �� � � a � � � � #ba � U � � b)b E>= � E b � �+E b �

� a � J U b E d�c b E c)c �+E �<;� a � v b E b = � E c = d E c�bdZa � JW� � b E d � � E 8<8 d E = 8; a � �wJW� � �+E b98 �+E � � d E 8 =x�a � �p� � E c�d �+E � 8 d E c 8= a � U � � ; E d ; �+E ��� ; E bCd

35g�@Ch#BX@#3C��}�4)Q / 4�O5K-4)QlORK;4�2�6;y-Ls@#OR2A359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6�E�� � � ��3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6 BN3�6;4�OMBX6+hC<X9+y;@Cy��35BN6;hC@{3P9;h[K-3 0 3lOR@CLs3sK*2.`)@ 2th#@C6�OR@#Q�4�}n3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 2�6;y 3P4AK;2�`�@�6+4AK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 EfF3P359;LsBX6+:wO5K*2\OkO5K;@�359 / 3PORBoOR9;@#6�OR3 h.2�6 / @W`�BN@ ��@Cy�2\3�2�<NO5@CQ5BN6;:8ORK+@�BX6�OR@#Q56*2�<+gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<;4�}�[email protected]\Q / 4)6�OR4 ��K;BXh[K�O5K;@ 0 2�QP@82\OPO[2�h[K;@#y���O5K;@8BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3�4�}�O5K;@n`\2�QPBX4)9+3�3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6g*2\OPOR@#Q56;3�h.2\6 / @ ��Q5BoO5O5@C6s2�3k<XBN6;@.2\Q hC4)L / BX6*2%ORBX4�6;3�4�}�ORK+@�3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 ,�2\y*2�g+O5@CysgI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3!4�}�!2 / <X@ �+E b Ekv*4)QkBN6;3POR2�6;h#@���2j9;6+BNO�BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<+}�4)Q�Ls4)6;4)3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#y / @C6 @C@[email protected]\6 / @��Q5BoO5O5@C6'BN6�O5K;@^`�@Ch#O54)Q86;4\O[2\O5BX4)6|4�}��!2 / <X@ �+E b 2�3

� ���� � b � � � � � � � � � � � EW��K;BX3ngI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<

h.2\6 / @w@���g*2�6;y+@Cy 2\3C�

� ���� � b

� x � ��� � �� b � � � � ��� � �

� b � � � � �� � � b� x � �� � S �+E � c�a

G�BNLMBN<=2�QP< 0 ��O5K;@wy;B",�359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6;3?<[email protected]\y{O54;�

�� � � � � b

� � � ��� � b� 8 � ���

��� � � �

8 � � � ��� � b� 8 � ���

�� � � b

� � d � � � �� � � S �+E-� � a

2�6;y

� � �

��� b� � � ��� � b

� 8 � � ��

�� �b� � d � � � ��� � b

� 8 � ����� � � b

� � d � � � �� � � b� � �� � S �+E-� ba

��K;@�� � � ��� �pBX6�O5@CQ56;2�<kgI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<N3^2\Q5@YhC@#6ZO5Q54 ,�3 0 LsLM@�ORQ5BNhs2�6;y�3P4'y;4|6;4�OjBN6;y;9;h#@�2{K 0 g�@CQ ,g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 E���K;@jK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 ORK;@#6�y+@Cg�@C6;y;3n4)6;< 0 4)6{ORK;@wQ5@#<=2\O5BN`�@w2�LM4�9;6�OR3�4�}ORK+@,O �?4���� � � ��� �_hC4�6/'*:)9;Q52\ORBN4)6;3#EFfF3P359;LsBX6+:MORK+@�K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 y+@Cg�@C6;y;3p<NBX6;@C2�Q5< 04)6tORK+@sBN6�OR@CQP6*2�<kg�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\< �rO5K;@YK 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 OR@#6;354)QwBN6;y;9;h#@Cy /Z0 2 � �� gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<

Page 52: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� c

@���K;B / BNO53n4�6;< 0 L �1�mhC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�OR3#� ���% � � ��K;BN<X@j2�6 � �� gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<&BX6;y+9;hC@#3n4)6+< 0 L � b h#4)L*,

g�4)6;@C6�O53C� ���% � � � �% � E ��6M2�y;y+BNORBN4)6���}�4�Q�2�6 � �� gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< �\ORK;@�6;4)QPL 4�}�ORK+@F1 � b hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53BX3"g+Q5@Cy+BXh#O5@Cy OR4 / @ O ��BNhC@tORK;2\O{4�}jORK;@A1 �1�+� # � � # � # � � # � � E ��K;BX3{QR2%ORBX4 BN3"4 / 3P@CQP`�@Cy}�4)Qn2�<X<&Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3�BX6���2 / <X@ �+E>���I@ �+h#@Cg+OFORK;4)3P@,BN6Z`�4)<N`�BN6;:�Ls@#O5K 0 <�359 / 3PORBoOR9;@#6�OR3p2�6+y LM@�O[2 ,y;BN6;BNO5Q54 / @C6�@#@C6;@\E

fFh#hC4)QPy;BX6;:mO54m@C~�E&�+E-� � ��O5K;@�� � �����FBX6�O5@CQ56;2�<rg�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<rK*2�3�6+4 � �� h#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�O.�*2�6+y|3P4ORK+@FK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 35K;4)9+<Xy�QP@ � @#h#O�4�6;< 0 O5K;@ � �� gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<VE���K;@8K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0Q5@#359;<oORBN6;:F}�Q54�L 2�6 � �� g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�K;2�3C��2�3P359;LsBX6;:F<[email protected]�Q!Q5@C3PgI4�6;35@\��4�6;< 0 L � b h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3#E��6 v!BX:)9;QP@ �+E d ��L �1�sh#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3n2�Q5@j35@#@C6'O54�QP@C359+<NO_}�Q54)L 6+4)6;<XBN6;@.2\Q_@��r@#h#O53C�I2�6;y'3P4�ORK+@LM2�:)6;BoOR9;y;@M4�}�ORK+@"L �1��h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�[email protected]�3P9;Q5@#3�ORK;@�y;@C:)QP@C@"4�}�6+4)6;<XBN6;@.2\Q5BNO 0 Etv*4)Q�Ls4)3PO359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3nBX6{��2 / <X@ �+E-�+�;ORK+@jL �1�mhC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�OR3n2�QP@wO ��4�4�Q5y;@#Q53_4�}�LM2�:)6+BNOR9+y;@p35LM2�<X<N@CQORK;2�6|O5K;@wL � b h#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3C�*BN6;y;BNh.2\O5BX6;:,O5K*2\O�ORK+@j6+4)6;<XBN6;@.2\Q5BNO 0 BX3�~Z9;BoOR@p3PL�2�<N< Ek�_4)�?@�`)@CQ#�}�4)QFO5K;@Y6;BNO5Q54{2�6+yTh 0 2�6+4�3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3#��ORK;@YL � ��h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3w2�QP@m6;@.2\Q5< 0�b � � ORK;4)3P@m4�}ORK+@jL � b hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O53CE

f hC4)6�`�@C6;BN@C6�O�[email protected]\6;3�4�}�hC4)Lsg*2�QPBX6;:�ORK;@kLs4)6;4)3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#yj2�6;ypy;BN359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5@CywLM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@#3BX3 /�0 hC4)6;3PBXy;@#Q5BN6;:jO5K;@_@#�I@Ch#O53W4�}rQ54�OR2\ORBN4)6;3�4)6MO5K;@FL �1�^2\6;y�L � b h#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3 4�}�ORK+@FK 0 ,g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 O5@C6;3P4)QCE_> BNORK+BX6'<NBX6;@C2�Q�Q5@#35g�4)6;35@\�rORK+@�@#�I@Ch�OR384�}�ORK;@�BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<2�QP@�2\y;y;BNO5BN`�@�E ��K;@#Q5@�}�4)Q5@\�?ORK;@{4)QlORK;4 ,�359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6 h.2�6 / @"h#4)6;3PBXy;@#Q5@Cy 2�3mORK;@{3P9;L 4�}F2 b � � � � � � � � � � � BX6�O5@CQ56;2�< g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�< 2�6;yA2 � � b � � � � � � � � � BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<kg�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\< EYG�BN6;hC@�O5K;@C3P@sO ��4g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<N3F2\Q5@�QP@C<=2%OR@Cy /Z0 2 x �

�Q54�OR2\ORBN4)6 2 / 4)9�OFORK+@���p3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 2 ��BX3n4�}kORK+@ / @#6�@C@#6;@

35u\@C<N@#OR4�6�� ORK;@#BXQjhC4)6�O5Q5B / 9+ORBN4)6;3wOR4�O5K;@�K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 h.2\6 / @MLM4�y;@#<X@Cy /�0 QP4�O[2\O5BX6;:ORK+@jK 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 4�}!O5K;@wLM4�6;4)359 / 3PO5BNOR9�OR@Cy|3 0 3lOR@CL /�0{x �

�2�6;y�2�y;y;BN6;:mORK;@pQP@C3P9;<NO�,

BX6+:MOR@#6;354�QnOR4sORK;@^4)Q5BN:)BX6;2�< �;9+6;Q54�OR2\OR@#y'OR@#6;354�QCE8v*4)Qn2MQP4�O[2%ORBX4�6 /�0 2�6 2�6+:)<X@ � 2 / 4)9�OFORK+@���3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 2 �+BN3C��ORK;@FO5@C6;3P4)QWh#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3?O5QR2�6;3l}�4)Q5L 2�3 � � ��� Ekv*4)Q�L � b �ZORK;BN3?BN3?@C~Z9;Bo` ,2�<N@C6�O�OR4�O5K;@8ORQ52�6;3P}�4�Q5LM2\ORBN4)6�g;QP4)gI@#QPO5BX@C3�4\} 2,`�@Ch#O54)QC��2\6;y�3P4 �[email protected]\6|9+35@p`)@#h#OR4�Qn2\y;y;BNO5BX4)6OR4Yy;@�OR@#Q5LsBX6;@8O5K;@w@���gI@#h#O5@Cy'Q52\ORBN4 / @�O �?@#@C6�y;BX3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+OR@#y'2�6+y�Ls4)6;4)3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#y{35g�@ChCBN@C3#EfFy+y;BNO5BX4)6�4\}�O ��4Y9;6;BoO?`)@#h#O54)Q53 ��BNO5K{2 x �

�2\6;:)<X@ / @�O �?@#@C6{ORK;@#L 0 BX@#<Xy;3�2,`�@Ch�OR4)Q�4�}&<N@C6;:�O5K

� ��E���K;@#Q5@�}�4)Q5@\� ��BNO5K;BX6A<[email protected]�QwQ5@#35g�4)6;3P@�� ORK+@�QR2%ORBX4|4�}WO5K;@�K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoORBX@#3F}�4)Qjy;B",2�6;y�LM4�6;4)359 / 3PO5BNOR9�OR@Cy�35g�@Ch#BX@C3#� # � � �

�% � # � � � # � � �

�% � # � � � � ��35K+4)9;<Xy / @^2 / 4)9+O b E>=�EW��K;BN3�BNO�ORQP9;@jO54

��BNO5K;BX6M2 / 4)9+O b � � }�4)Q�2�<N<�3P9 / 3lORBNO59;@C6�O53W@���hC@#g+O�h 0 2�6;4�2�6;y�6;BoORQP4;� ��K;BXh[K�y+@#`�B=2\O5@ /�0 9;gMO54= � � E!��K;@C3P@F2�QP@?ORK+@�3R2�Ls@WO �?4w3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3kO5K*2\O�35K+4 ��@Cys35BN:)6;B"'*h.2�6�Ok6+4)6;<XBN6;@.2\Q5BNO 0 2 / 4�`)@\�

Page 53: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

d �

2�3�[email protected]�3P9;Q5@#y /�0 O5K;@wL�2�:�6;BNO59;y;@p4�}�ORK;@wL �1��hC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�OR3#E��K;@pLs@#O[2jy;BX3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#y"35g�@Ch#BX@C3?L�2 0s/ @nORQ5@C2\OR@#y"BX6�2,L�2\6;6;@CQ�35BNLMBN<=2�Q O54,ORK*2%O�4�}�ORK+@

4)QlORK;4;� / 9+O ��BNO5KY28Q54�OR2\ORBN4)6�4�} b �\��hC4�6;6;@Ch�ORBN6;:pORK;@?O ��4whC4)6�O5Q5B / 9+ORBN6;:pBX6�OR@#Q56*2\<+g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<N3C�

b � � � � � � � � � � � 2\6;y � � � � b � � � � � � � Ekfny;y;BNO5BX4)6M4�}&O �?4m9+6;BNOW`�@Ch�OR4)QP3 ��BNORK{2 b ����2\6;:)<X@ / @�O �?@#@C6

ORK+@CL 0 BN@C<Ny;3�2{`)@Ch�OR4)Qm4\}�<X@#6;:�ORK b E���KZ9;3�O5K;@�Q52\ORBN4�4�}�O5K;@�Ls@#OR2'y;BN359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5@Cy 3PgI@#hCBX@#3OR4tO5K;@{LM4)6+4)359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5@Cy 35g�@Ch#BX@#3C� # � � �

�% � # � � � # � � �

�% � # � � � � ��35K;4�9;<Xy / @{2 / 4)9�O b ��BoORK;BN6 <[email protected]�Q

Q5@#35g�4)6;3P@�E-��K;BN3YBNOmORQP9;@"OR4 ��BNO5K;BX6 2 / 4)9+O b ; � }�4)QY2�<X<?359 / 3lORBoOR9;@#6ZO53�@ �+h#@Cg+O�h 0 2�6;4 2\6;y6;BoORQ54+�*2�:�2�BN6"hC4)6 '*Q5LsBX6;:�O5K*2\O�O5K;@C3P@^3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3_<X@C2�y"OR4s35BN:)6;B(';h.2�6�O�6;4)6+<[email protected]�QPBNO 0 E

��K;@{L �1�'h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3m4�}�O5K;@"K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 ORQ52�6;3l}�4)Q5L 2�3 � � � � ��BNORK QP@C35g�@Ch�OOR4|Q54\O[2\O5BX4)6T2 / 4)9+OwORK+@���^2 ��BX3#E���K;@ x �

�Q54\O[2\O5BX4)6T2�3P354�hCB=2%OR@Cy ��BNO5K�4)QlORK;4{3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6

ORK+@CQ5@�}�4)Q5@w<[email protected]�y;3�O54M2\6|@ �+2�h#Onh.2�6+hC@C<N<=2\O5BX4)6�4�}�O5K;@wL �1��hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53�4�}!O5K;@wK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�QPBA@�,2 / BN<XBoO 0 Ew��K;BX3wBN38hC4)6+35BX3lOR@#6ZO ��BoORKtORK;@Y2 / 4�`)@s2�6;2�< 0 35BN3 ��K;BNh[KAh#4)6;hC<N9;y;@#y O5K*2\OpO5K;@m<=2�h[u�4�}2 � �� hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O^BX6 ORK;@sBX6�O5@CQ56;2�<kgI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<�4�}?@C~�E ��E>� � g;QP@#`)@#6�OR3C�kBN6A<NBX6;@C2�Qp4)QPy;@CQ#�!ORK+@g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<&}�Q54�L BN6;y;9;h#BX6;:�L �1�MO5@C6;3P4)Q8hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO538BX6�ORK;@�K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 Env�4�QnORK+@b ���

�QP4�O[2\O5BX4)6|2�3P354�hCBX2\OR@#y ��BNO5K � ��� �j3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6��*ORK;@^L �1�YhC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O53n4�}�ORK;@jK 0 g�@CQ ,

g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 2�y;y�hC4)6+3PORQP9;h#O5BN`�@C< 0 �I3P9;h[K'O5K*2\O_ORK;@j6;4)QPL 4�} ORK+@^L �1�sh#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3_4�} ORK+@K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 � # � � �

�% � # � � � # � � �

�% � # � � � � �I35K;4�9;<Xy / @ � }�4�Qn<NBX6;@C2�QnQP@C3PgI4)6+35@�Ep��K+@�4 / 3P@CQP`�@Cy

QR2%ORBX4�3�2�Q5@���BoORK;BN6 b � � 4�}�ORK+BX3W`\2�<X9+@8}�4)Q�LM4�3PO�359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3#E�fn3n@ �+g�@Ch�OR@#y / 2�3P@Cy�4)6{g;Q5@ ,`�BX4)9+3�[email protected]�3P9;Q5@#3?4�}r6;4)6;<NBX6;@C2�Q5BoO 0 �)O5K;@ny+@#`�B=2\O5BX4)6sBX3�<X2�Q5:)@#Qk}�4)Q�h 0 2\6;4m2�6;yM6;BNO5Q54;E G�4)Ls@ ��K*2%O359+Q5g;QPBX35BN6;:)< 0 ��O5K;@j2�LsBX6;4m3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6{y;@#`�B=2%OR@C3 /�0 ORK+@j<X2�Q5:�@C3PO_2\LM4)9+6ZOC� �?= � E

v*4)Q8ORK;@mO5Q5BX3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#y 35g�@ChCBN@C3j4�}���2 / <X@%�+E d ��ORK+@sBN6�OR@CQP6*2�< g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< h.2\6 / @mhC4)6+35BXy-,@CQP@Cy|2�3�2\Q5BX3PBX6;:j}�Q54)L ORK+@p2�y;y;BoORBN4)6�4�} b � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � b � � � � � � � �;2�6;y � � � � � � � � b � � � E ��K;@#35@hC4�6ZO5Q5B / 9+ORBN4)6;3 2�QP@_QP@C<X2\OR@#y /�0{b ���

�QP4�O[2\O5BX4)6+3C�Z2�6;ysORK;@_359+LMLM2\ORBN4)6Yh.2�9+35@C3 ORK;@_L � b h#4)L*,

g�4)6;@C6�O53_O54MhC2�6;hC@#<�2�6;y{ORK;@jL �1�mhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53�OR4M2�y;y|hC4)6;3lORQP9;h#O5BN`)@#< 0 E?��K;@j<=2�h[u�4�} L � bhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53?BN3W2,:)@#6;@CQ52�<�hC4)6;3P@C~Z9;@#6;hC@w4�}�O5K;@ � � �p3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 4\}�ORK;@ny;Q5@#3535@#y{3 0 3PO5@CL 2\6;y354w2\g;g;<XBN@C3 @�`)@#6MBN6�6;4)6;<NBX6;@C2�Q�4�Q5y;@#QCEkG�BX6;h#@WORK;@WL �1�FhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53�2�y;ymh#4)6;3PO5Q59;h�ORBo`)@C< 0 ��ORK+@6;4)QPL 4�}�O5K;@�K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 4�}�O5K;@WORQPBX359 / 3PO5BNOR9�OR@CyY3PgI@#hCBX@#3k35K;4�9;<Xy / @WORK;QP@C@WORBNLM@#3�ORK+@6;4)QPL 4�}�ORK;@�L �1�8hC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�OR3�4�}IORK;@�Ls4)6;4)3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#yY35g�@ChCBN@C3#E��n4)�?@�`)@#QC��O5K;@�4 / 3P@CQP`�@CyQR2%ORBX4wBN3�L�9+h[K�hC<N4)35@#Q O54 ; }�4)Q 2�<X<*3P9 / 3lORBNO59;@C6�O53C� ��BoORKM6;BNO5Q54j2�6;yMh 0 2\6;4�359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3W:�BN`�BX6;:2YQR2\O5BX4YhC<N4)35@pOR4 �+E?G�4)Ls@ ��K;2\OF3P9;Q5g+Q5BX3PBX6;:�< 0 ��ORK;@w@���g�@Ch�OR@Cy'QR2\O5BX4Y4�}��YBX3�4 / O[2�BN6;@Cy{}�4)Q�ORK+@QR2%ORBX4 / @#O ��@C@C6 O5K;@�K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 4�}WORK+@MORQPBX3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+OR@#y 35g�@Ch#BX@C3�2�6;y�O5K;@�6;4�Q5L 4�}

Page 54: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

d;b

ORK+@,1 �1�mhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53�4�}!O5K;@wLM4�6;4)359 / 3PO5BNOR9�OR@Cy|35g�@Ch#BX@#3CE��6-ORK;@ 2 / 4�`)@ 2�Q5:)9+LM@#6ZO53C��ORK+@tL �1� S � �� 3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0+a 2\6;y�L � b S � �� 3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0+a

hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53n4\}�ORK+@^K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 ��@CQ5@^hC4)Lsg*2�QP@Cy / @�O �?@#@C6ty;Bo�r@#Q5@#6ZO_3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6g*2\OPOR@#Q56;3#E��n@CQP@�� ��@nh#4)6;35BNy;@CQ�ORK+@_QP@C<X2\ORBo`)@�LM2�:)6;BoOR9;y;@�4\}IO5K;@nL �1�w2�6;ysL � b hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53}�4)QM2�:)Bo`)@C6 359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5BX4)6 g*2\O5O5@CQP6�E ��K+@tG��87 2�6*2�< 0 3PBX3s4�}p�!2 / <N@ �+E � BN6;y;BXhC2\OR@#3sO5K*2\O�2� �� g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< ��BX<X<*BN6;y;9;h#@F2jK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 ORK*2\O�BX3 ; O54 =pORBNLM@#3 <X2�Q5:�@CQkORK*2\6�2�6 � ��g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<�4�}+BNy;@C6�O5BXh.2\<�LM2�:)6;BoOR9;y;@\E&��K;BX3#�\h#4)L / BN6;@Cy���BNO5KpORK;@ky;@#hC4)Lsg�4)35BoORBX4�6;3�4�}�@C~Z3CE �+E � c ,�+E-� b 2\<X<X4)��3�9;3_OR4�g+Q5@Cy+BXh#O_ORK+@,LM2�:)6;BoOR9;y;@w4�}!ORK;@^L �1�s2�6;y L � b O5@C6;3P4)QFh#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3_4�}ORK+@�K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 E v�4�QYO5K;@|LM4)6+4 ,�3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6 gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�4�}p@#~�E ��E � c ��ORK+@�Q52\ORBN4/ @#O ��@C@C6�ORK;@ � �� 2\6;y � �� h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3_BX3 b � � � E ��K;BN3C�*hC4�L / BX6+@Cy#��BNORK"O5K;@,2 / 4�`)@wQ52\ORBN44�} ; OR4 =�3P9;:):)@#3PO53,ORK*2%O,ORK+@�QR2\O5BX4|4�}�6;4)QPLM3^4�}WO5K;@�L � �{OR4 L � b h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3�3PK;4)9;<Ny/ @ / @#O ��@C@#6 �+E ; 2�6;y ; E?�_4)�?@�`)@CQ#��O5K;@w4 / 3P@CQP`�@Cy Q52\ORBN4)3�2�QP@j<N@C3P3�O5K*2�6|4)6;@\E ��K+BX3_359;:):�@C3PO53ORK;2\OY2�6 � �� g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<?BX6+y;9;hC@#3s2 K 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 4�}_Q54)9+:)K;< 0 @C~Z9*2\<�L�2�:�6;BNO59;y;@MO54ORK;2\O�BX6+y;9;hC@#y /Z0 2 � �� gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<I4�}�ORK;@p352�Ls@83PO5Q5@C6+:�ORK��+BX6"y;BN3R2�:)QP@C@#LM@#6ZO���BNORK�O5K;@8Q52\ORBN44�} b � ; OR4 b � =m4 / O[2�BN6;@Cy"}�QP4)L O5K;@^G��p7 h.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6�E

�WV�XSV � � ���� �%�� ��� $ ���� ������

��6�ORK+@ b ,�7 Ls4�y;@#<�4�}�@C~Z3#E �+E 8 2�6+y �+E c ��2\g;g;<XBNh.2\O5BX4)6 4�}�2�6 BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�@C<X@#h#O5Q5BXh*'*@#<XyAO54ORK+@�35u�@#<X@�OR4)6sBX6;y+9;hC@#3 / 4�O5KY2wg�@CQPL�2\6;@C6�O�y;BNgI4)<N@?Ls4)Ls@C6�O�2�6;ys2pK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 E���K;@QR2%ORBX4|4�}�O5K;@C3P@�O �?4'~�9;2�6�ORBNO5BX@#3,BX3wORK+@C6 2'h#4)6;3lO[2�6�O�O5K*2\O^y;@Cg�@C6;y+3m4)6;< 0 4�6�ORK;@M35u\@C<X@�OR4)6rE�n@#Q5@\� ��@FhC4�6;35BNy;@CQ ORK;@n@���OR@#6;35BN4)6�4�}�O5K;BX3 Q5@#<=2\O5BX4)6mO54,L�9;<oORB ,�g�4)<=2�Q�3 0 3PO5@CLs3C� /�0 hC4)Lsg*2�QPBX6;:ORK+@8gI@#Q5LM2�6;@#6ZO?LM4�LM@#6ZO53?4�}�O5K;@ / @C6 @C@C6+@p35u�@#<X@�OR4)6 ��BoORK�O5K;@8K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 E!��6�hC2�<",hC9+<=2\O5BX6;:8O5K;@ng�@CQPL�2\6;@C6�O LM4�LM@#6ZO53C� ��@nh#4)6;3PBXy;@#Q 4�6;< 0 O5K;@�h[K*2�QP:)@C3 y;9;@�OR4pORK+@ ��@C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6+34�}�O5K;@ / @C6 @C@C6+@p35u�@#<X@�OR4)6���35BN6;hC@nBNO�BX3�ORK;@ �t3 0 3PO5@CL ORK*2\O�y;4)LsBX6;2\OR@#3 O5K;@FK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<",BNO 0 Ek��K;@p4�h#OR9+gI4)<N@nO5@C6;3P4)Q�4�}&ORK;@ � @C<X@#h#O5Q54)6{y;BN3PORQPB / 9�ORBX4�6�BX3�'*Q53lO�h.2�<NhC9;<X2\OR@#y"BX6{JW2\QPOR@#35BX2�6hC4�4)QPy;BX6*2%OR@C3#�

� � � ��� � ��

� � � � � � � ��� � � � �S �+E-� � a

��K;@#Q5@ � � � �BN3nORK+@�gI4�35BNO5BX4)6|4�}kO5K;@ �

� � 2%OR4)L 2�<N4)6;:MO5K;@ �� � JW2�QPO5@C35BX2�6t2 ��BN3C��2\6;y � �

BX3_BNO53�-h[K;2�Q5:)@\E���K+BX3,JW2�QPO5@C35BX2�6AO5@C6;3P4)Q,BN3jO5K;@C6AORQR2\6;3P}�4)QPLM@#y�BN6ZO54'3Pg;K;@CQPBXhC2�<kOR@C6+354)Q^6;4�O[2%ORBX4�69;3PBX6;:mORK+@j352�Ls@jLs@#O5K;4�y�2\3 �W2�3_9;3P@Cy'BN6|G�@Ch�ORBN4)6 ��E>�+E

Page 55: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

d �

�!2 / <X@ �+E ; �'J?4)LMg;2�Q5BN354)6 4�}FO5K;@'g�@CQPL�2\6;@C6�OMLM4)Ls@C6�O53s4\}8ORK;@ � @#<X@#h#ORQP4)6 y;@C6;3PBNO 0 ��BNO5KORK+@�K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 ��2\38y;BX3PhC9;3P35@#yTBN6tG�@#h#O5BX4)6 �+E>=�E � Epq|4)6;4)3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+OR@#yT3 0 3POR@#LM3FhC4)Q ,Q5@#35g�4)6;yTOR4�O5K;@s359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6Tg*2\OPOR@CQP6 S& �&�^���j�!�j���^��� a 2�6;yTORQPBX359 / 3PO5BNOR9�OR@CyT3 0 3lOR@CLs3hC4�Q5Q5@#35g�4)6;y{OR4 S! �H�j� �H�j� �H� a E

q�4)6;4�359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5@Cy O5Q5BN359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5@Cy# � ��� � # # � ��� � # # � ������ �

# # � ������ � # # � ��� � # # � ������ �#

ba � U � � b�c E b b =�E d � E � c+b � E b�c�c x � E � � E b 8<8� a � J U 8 E �)� 8 E x = � E � c�b � � E � x�c+b � �+E 8 � E � x � x� a � v =�E 8 � 8 E ;�� � E �?;\� � � E � d<8 � � ; E>= � E � � � 8dZa � JW� � b.d E>� � E ��� � E � � d � � E b = � ; x E 8 � E �)� d�x; a � �wJW� � � b E � d E>� � � E � d)c)x � E � � b c � E>= � E � � d �x�a � �p� �)� E ; d E ; c � E � d � d � E ��� b c)x E ; � E � � �?;= a � U � � �<; E>� �+E b = � E � x�c�d � E ; x�c b � c � E �<;�� b

��K;@�g�@CQPL�2�6+@C6�O8Ls4)Ls@C6�OR3_4�} O5K;@,Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@ / 2�35@#y 4)6'O5K;@ � @#<X@#h#ORQP4)6'y+@C6;3PBNO 0 4)6'ORK+@35B �Th.2�Q / 4�6 2\OR4�LM3w4�} / @C6 @C@C6+@ �?@#Q5@�y+@#OR@#Q5LsBX6;@#y 2�6;y�2�Q5@M35K;4)��6 BN6��!2 / <N@ �+E ; E d+b � ��K;@JW2�QlOR@C3PB=2�6mg�@CQPL�2\6;@C6�O�4�h#OR9+gI4)<N@?Ls4)Ls@C6�OkBX3!ORK;@#6YO5QR2�6+3P}�4)QPLM@#ymBX6�OR4p3Pg;K;@CQPBXhC2�<+h#4�4)QPy;BX6;2\OR@#39;3PBX6;:mORK+@p3R2�Ls@pLM@�ORK;4�y|2�3 �?2�3�9;35@#y�BN6|G�@Ch�ORBX4�6 ��E>�+E > BoORK�O5K;@wgI@#Q5LM2�6;@C6�O�Ls4)Ls@C6�OR3�BN635g+K;@CQPBXh.2\<�hC4�4)QPy;BX6*2%OR@,6+4�O[2\O5BX4)6r� ��@mh.2�6th#4)Lsg*2�Q5@^ORK;@ � � ��2\6;y � � b hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O5384�}ORK+@jg�@CQPL�2\6;@C6�O_LM4�LM@#6ZO53�2�6;y{ORK;@�'*QP3PO_K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 QP@C35g�4)6;3P@C3#E

v�BX:�9;Q5@ �+E ; 3PK;4)��3?ORK+@nQP@C<=2%ORBX4�6;35K;BNg / @�O �?@#@C6�ORK+@ng�@CQPL�2�6+@C6�O?4�h#O59;g�4)<X@�Ls4)Ls@C6�O 4�}�ORK+@Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3p`)@#Q5359+3^ORK+@ � � �{hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O^4�}?O5K;@sK 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 Em��K;4�35@�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3��K;BNh[K �?@#Q5@W3PK;4)��6YO54 / @W<XBN6;@.2\Q�BN6��!2 / <X@ �+E-� S Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3 �nO5K;Q54)9+:)K%= a @���K;B / BNOk2_:)4�4�y^hC4)Q ,Q5@#<=2\O5BX4)6 / @�O �?@#@C6'O5K;@ ��� �mhC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�O�4�}�ORK;@pK 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 2\6;y"ORK;@wg�@CQ5LM2�6;@#6�O4�h#OR9+gI4)<N@wLM4)Ls@C6�O53CE�v�BN:)9;QP@ ��E x 35K;4)��3FO5K;@jQ5@C<X2\ORBN4)6;3PK;BXg / @#O ��@C@C6 O5K;@ � � b h#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�O4�};O5K;@?g�@CQPL�2\6;@C6�O!4�h�OR9;g�4)<X@ Ls4)LM@#6�O!4\};ORK;@�LM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@�y;9+@�OR4_ORK;@�g;Q5@#35@#6;hC@W4\}*359 / 3PORBoOR9;@#6�OR32�6;y"O5K;@ ��� b hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO�4\}�O5K;@pK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 4\}�O5K;@pLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@�Ek]_6;<XBNu�@FO5K;@ph.2�3P@��BNO5KsO5K;@�4�h�OR9;g�4)<N@�LM4)Ls@C6�O53C� �?@_y;4j6;4�O 35@#@_O5K;@�3R2�Ls@�O 0 gI@_4�}IhC4)QPQ5@C<X2\ORBN4)6 / @�O �?@#@C6�O5K;@C3P@`\2�<X9+@C3CE

� �� � � �� � � ����� ���K;BX3�h[K*2�g�OR@CQ!@���OR@#6;y;3�O5K;@?4�6;@�,�y;BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6;2�< ��3Ph.2�<X2�Q�,�<XBXu\@kBX6�OR@#Q56*2\< ';@C<XyjLs4�y;@#<Z4�}��89;y*2\Q

OR4|L�9;<oORBNgI4)<X2�QFh[K+Q54)Ls4)g;K;4�Q5@C3#E���K;@MBX6�OR@#Q56*2\< '*@C<NyA4�}�ORK;@s4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<�LM4�y;@C<�BX3wQ5@ ,

Page 56: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

d �

β3

v�BN:)9;Q5@ �+E ; �sJ?4)QPQ5@C<X2\ORBN4)6T4�}�ORK;@M6;4)QPL 4�}?ORK;@�K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 ��BNO5KAO5K;@�g�@CQ5LM2�6;@#6�O4�h#OR9+gI4)<N@�Ls4)Ls@C6�O.�%}�4)Q!O5K;@�O5Q5BN359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5@CymLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3�6�9+L / @#Q5@#y%�nORK;QP4)9;:)K =nBX6^��2 / <X@ ��E>�+E��K;@j<XBN6;@8BX3�2m<[email protected]�3lO�35~Z9*2�QP@C3�'+O�OR4s2s<NBX6;@C2�QWQP@C<=2%ORBX4�6;35K;BNg�E

Page 57: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

d)d

β1

v�BN:)9;Q5@ ��E x ��J?4)QPQ5@#<=2\O5BX4)6 4�}_ORK;@|6;4)QPL 4�}nORK;@�1 � b g�4)QlORBX4�6 4\}nO5K;@�K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0��BNO5KTO5K;@YgI@#Q5LM2�6;@#6ZOjy;BNgI4�<X@mLs4)LM@#6�Op}�4)Q8ORK;@YLs4)6;4)3P9 / 3lORBNO59+OR@#yALs4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3p6Z9;L / @#Q5@Cy �ORK+Q54)9;:�K =�BX6{�!2 / <N@ �+E>��E

Page 58: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

d ;

g;<X2�hC@#y ��BoORKT2�:)@#6;@CQ52�<XB @C@Cy BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< ��2\6;ytORK;BN3pBX6�OR@#Q56*2�<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�LM2 0 BN6;y;9;h#@K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO5BX@C3 ��BoORK{2,`\2�Q5BN@#O 0 4�}&OR@C6+354)Q�h#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3CE�fn3�BX6�ORK+@p4)6;@�,�y;BXLs@C6+35BX4�6*2�<Ls4�y;@#< �ORK;@�g;Q54�gI@#QPORBN@C3!4�}*ORK;@�359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5@CymLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@ 2�Q5@�y;BXQP@Ch#O5< 0 Q5@#<=2\O5@CyjOR4FO5K;@?g;QP4)g�@CQPO5BX@#34�}�ORK;@wLs4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Q?3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6���@C~�E �+E b ; E

��K;@8BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<�Ls4�y;@#<�2�353P9;LM@#3�O5K;@FK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 2�6;y�g�@CQPL�2\6;@C6�O�LM4 ,Ls@C6�OR3F2�Q5@j<XBN6;@.2�QP< 0 Q5@C<X2\OR@#y�O54MORK+@,BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<&gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< E�fF6t2\6*2�< 0 3PBX3 / 2�3P@Cyt4)6�3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0<X@C2�y;3WO54s3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 ,�2�y;2�g+OR@#y{BX6�OR@#Q56*2�<IgI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<N3���K;BXh[Kr����K;@C6�2�g;g;<NBX@#y�OR4mORK;@pLs4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q35u\@C<N@#OR4�6���BX6;y+9;hC@WK 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoORBX@#3$��BNO5K�ORK;@Wh#4)Q5QP@C3PgI4)6+y;BX6;:p3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 E�v*4)Q / @C6�@#@C6;@\�O ��4sO 0 g�@C3_4�} g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<X3C�+D �� 2\6;y'i �� �*<X@C2�y"OR4Y6;4)6-, @C@#Q54sK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNORBN@C3#E!��K;@jK 0 ,g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 BX6+y;9;hC@#y /Z0 28D �� gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<�K*2�3 4�6;< 0 � � �FOR@C6+354)Qkh#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3C� ��K+BX<X@ORK;2\O8BN6;y;9;h#@Cy /�0 2�i �� g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<!K*2\384)6;< 0 � � b O5@C6;3P4)Q8h#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3CEFfF6 2�<oOR@CQP6*2\O5BN`)@2�g;g+Q54�2�h[K OR4T2�6;2�< 0 35BN6;: ORK+@|<NBX6;@C2�Q�QP@C35g�4)6;3P@�BN3�ORK;QP4)9;:)K 3PBX6;:)9+<=2�Q,`\2�<N9;@"y;@#hC4)LsgI4�35BNO5BX4)6S GZ�p7 a E+��K;@jG��p7 2�6*2\< 0 35BN3 0 BX@C<Ny;3�2�<N<I4�}�ORK+@pBX6+}�4)QPL�2%ORBX4�6�@���O5QR2�h�OR@Cy{}�Q54�L O5K;@w3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 02�6*2\< 0 35BN3C�Z2�6;yYBN6M2\y;y;BNO5BX4)6r�)g;Q5@#y;BXh�OR3kORK;2\O 2wD �� g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\< ��BX<N<+BN6;y;9;h#@n2pK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<",BNO 0 ORK*2%O�BX3 ; O54 =�O5BXLs@C3W<X2�Q5:�@CQ?BN6"L�2\:)6;BNO59;y;@FO5K*2�6"ORK;2\O�BX6+y;9;hC@#y /�0 2�6|i �� g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<I4�}@C~Z9;Bo`\2�<X@#6ZO�LM2�:)6+BNOR9+y;@�E

D 0 2�g;g;< 0 BN6;:'BN6�OR@CQP6*2�<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3j4�}�<X2�Q5:)@sLM2�:)6;BoOR9;y;@YOR4 O5K;@ / @C6 @C@C6+@"35u�@#<X@�OR4)6�� ��@h.2\6�y;@#O5@CQ5LsBX6+@�ORK+@tgI4)BN6�O"2\O ��K;BXh[K�6;4�6;<XBN6;@.2�QM@#�I@Ch�OR3 / @ChC4�LM@�BXLsgI4)QlO[2�6�OCE U 4�6;<XBN6;@.2�Q@#�I@Ch�OR3 / @Ch#4)Ls@FBXLsg�4)QPOR2�6�O ��K;@C6�O5K;@Fg�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\< / @#O ��@C@#6|2�y �52�h#@C6�O�2\O54)Ls3�y;Bo�r@#Q53 /�0 Ls4)Q5@ORK;2�6{2 / 4)9+O b @#��E+v*4)Q?2\6{i �� g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\< �Z6;4)6;<NBX6;@C2�Q @#�I@Ch#O53�BX6�ORQP4�y+9;hC@8K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0OR@#6;354�Q h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3 ��BNO5K � � ��� ��K;@[email protected]�3 4)6;< 0 � � b hC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�OR3 2�QP@�2�<X<N4)�?@#ysBN6Y<[email protected]�QQ5@#35g�4)6;3P@�E

f 35@#Q5BX@#3p4�} 359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5@Cy / @#6�@C@#6;@YLM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@#3p2�QP@�9;35@#yTO54�OR@#3POp`\2�Q5BN4)9;38g+Q5@Cy+BXh#O5BX4)6+384�}ORK+@�BX6�O5@CQ56;2�<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<�LM4�y;@#< E"v*4)QpORK+@�359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3 S v?�!JW� � � �jJW� � �k�p� 2\6;y U � � a �LM2�6 0 4�};ORK+@?g;QP@Cy;BNh#ORBN4)6;3�4�};O5K;@?BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<ZgI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<ZLs4�y;@#<�2�g;g;< 0 E&>�@���BX<X<�QP@#}�@#Q!OR4_ORK;@#35@�2\3��@.2�u{359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3#EW��K;@j359 / 3lORBoOR9;@#6ZO53 U � � 2�6;y J U 2\g;gI@C2�Q�OR4 / @w4)9�OR35BNy;@w4�}�O5K;@j<[email protected]�QQ5@#35g�4)6;3P@FQ5@#:)BXLs@��Z2\6;y ��@���BN<X<;QP@#}�@#Q�O54jO5K;@C3P@82�3�3lORQ54�6;:,3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3#E��pQlORK;4w3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6hC4�Q5Q5@#35g�4)6;y;3nOR4�2sg;9;QP@�i �� gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<�2�6;y'354�3PK;4)9;<Ny <X@C2�y�O54�K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO5BX@#3���BNO5K4)6;< 0 � � b h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3#E^��K;BN3pBX38BN6;y;@#@Cy 35@#@C6 }�4)QFORK+@ �?@C2�u�@#Q^3P9 / 3lORBNO59;@C6�O53C� ��K;BX<N@,ORK+@3PO5Q54)6+:)@CQ83P9 / 3lORBNO59;@C6�O53py;4"BX6;y+9;hC@�3P4)Ls@ � � ��hC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O53CEp��K;@Y2�3P359;Lsg+O5BX4)6�4�} <[email protected]�QQ5@#35g�4)6;3P@82�<N354w<X@C2�y;3�OR4j35g�@ChCB"'*h_g;Q5@#y;BXh�ORBX4�6;3k}�4)QkORK;@�QR2%ORBX4�3 / @#O ��@C@#6�ORK+@nK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<",

Page 59: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

d�x

BNO 0 BN6;y;9;h#@Cy /�0 LM4)6+4 ,[�%4)QPO5K;4 ,�2�6;ymLs@#OR2 ,I359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6�4�6 / @#6�@C@#6;@�E���K;@Wg;QP@Cy;BNh#OR@#ymQR2\O5BX4)3y;Bo�r@#QW}�4)QWORK;@ � � b 2\6;y � � �mhC4)Lsg�4)6;@C6�O53C�*35BN6;hC@wORK+@C35@wK*2.`�@^`)@#Q 0 y;Bo�r@#Q5@#6ZO�O5QR2�6;3l}�4)Q�,LM2\ORBN4)6"g;Q54�gI@#QPORBN@C3 ��BNO5K�QP@C3PgI@#h#O_OR4YQ54�OR2\ORBN4)6|2 / 4)9+O�ORK+@�J F2 ��BX3�4�} / @#6�@C@#6;@�E�fF:�2�BN6��;ORK+@g;QP@Cy;BNh#OR@#y�Q52\ORBN4)3j2�Q5@Y}�4)9;6;y OR4�K;4)<NyT}�4)QpO5K;@ ��@.2\uT3P9 / 3lORBNO59;@C6�O53 / 9+O^6;4�Oj}�4)QpORK+@M3lORQ54�6;:359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3#E{�&BN6;@.2\QjQP@C3PgI4)6+35@M2�<X3P4�g;QP@Cy;BNh#O53jO5K*2\OwORK;@sQR2%ORBX4 / @#O ��@C@#6�ORK;@�1 �1�|h#4)LsgI4 ,6;@#6ZO53k4�};O5K;@WK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 2�6;y�ORK+@WgI@#Q5LM2�6;@#6ZO�4�h�OR9;g�4)<N@�Ls4)Ls@C6�O 4�}+ORK;@WLs4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q35u\@C<N@#OR4�6 35K;4�9;<Xy / @�2shC4)6+3PO[2\6ZOFORK*2\Ony;@#gI@#6;y;384)6+< 0 4)6 g+Q54)g�@CQlORBX@#3n4\} ORK;@^35u\@C<X@�OR4)6rEF��K;BN3QR2%ORBX4wBN3�QP@C<=2%ORBN`�@C< 0 hC4�6;3POR2�6�O?}�4)QkORK+@���@.2�uY359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3#� / 9+O�6;4�O ORK+@n3lORQ54�6;:,3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3#EG�4Y}�4)Q�ORK;@���@.2�u"3P9 / 3lORBNO59;@C6�O53C��2m6Z9;L / @CQ_4�}�ORK;@jg;QP@Cy;BNh#ORBN4)6;3�4�}�ORK;@jBX6�O5@CQ56;2�<$'*@C<Ny�Ls4�y;@C<2�QP@w}�4�9;6;y"OR4YK;4)<Ny"}�4)Q�359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5@Cy / @#6�@C@#6;@^Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@C3#E

G�4)Ls@tg;Q5@#y;BXh�ORBN4)6;3"4�}^ORK;@ BX6�O5@CQ56;2�< '*@#<Xy LM4�y;@#<p2�Q5@ 6;4\O{4 / 35@#QP`�@Cy BN6-ORK;@ 35@#Q5BN@C3{4�}359 / 3PO5BNOR9�OR@Cy / @C6�@#@C6;@{Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3CE�v*4)Q�BX6+3PO[2\6;hC@\� O5K;@|G��p7 2�6*2\< 0 35BN3�g;Q5@#y;BXh�OR@#y O5K*2\OmORK+@K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO 0 BN6;y;9;h#@Cy /Z0 2jD �� g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<;35K;4�9;<Xy / @ ; O54 =8O5BXLs@C3 <X2�Q5:�@CQ�O5K*2�6mORK*2%O}�4)QF2�6ti �� g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< E � @#359;<oOR3�}�4)QnO5K;@�3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+OR@#y / @#6�@C@#6;@mLM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@#3FBN6;y;BXhC2\OR@wORK;2\O8ORK+@K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO5BX@C3�BX6+y;9;hC@#y /�0 ORK+@C35@ g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<N3�K*2.`)@ Q54)9+:)K;< 0 @C~Z9*2�<ZLM2�:)6;BoOR9;y+@C3CE���K;BN3359+:):)@C3lOR3WO5K*2\OWg+Q5@Cy+BXh#O5BX4)6+3�ORK;2\OWQP@C< 0 4)6MORK;@8QP@C<X2\ORBo`)@_L�2�:�6;BNO59;y;@C3�4�}�ORK+@8Q5@#35g�4)6;35@\�;QR2%ORK;@#QORK;2�6 �P9;3POkO5K;@�ORQR2\6;3P}�4)QPL�2%ORBX4�6,g;QP4)gI@#QPO5BX@C3k4\}IO5K;@W`\2�Q5BN4)9;3�O5@C6;3P4)Q�hC4)LsgI4�6;@C6�OR3#��L�2 0 6;4�O / @Q5@#<XBX2 / <X@\E?��BN6;@.2�Q�QP@C35g�4)6;3P@�2�<N354sg;Q5@#y;BXh�OR3�ORK*2%OnO5K;@^Q52\ORBN4 / @�O �?@#@C6 ORK+@ � � b hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO534�}�ORK;@sK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 2�6;y ORK;@sg�@CQ5LM2�6;@#6�O^y+BXg�4)<X@mLs4)Ls@C6�Ow35K;4�9;<Xy / @M2{hC4)6;3lO[2�6�OCE��K;BN3_BN3�6;4�O�4 / 35@CQl`)@#y'OR4 / @wO5K;@wh.2�3P@�E

��6 3P9;LsL�2�Q 0 ��O5K;@ BX6�OR@#Q56*2�< ';@C<XyzLs4�y+@C<mK*2�3 / @C@#6 @ ��O5@C6;y+@Cy O54 L�9+<NORBNgI4�<=2�Q|h[K;Q54 ,Ls4)g;K;4)QP@C3#�*2�6;y"OR@#3PO5@Cy�2�:�2�BN6;3PO?@���g;<XBNhCBoO�h.2�<NhC9;<X2\ORBN4)6;3 4)6{359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5@Cy / @#6�@C@#6;@wLM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@#3CE��K;@mQP@C359+<NOR3pBN6;y;BNh.2\O5@^ORK;2\OF}�4)Q��?@C2�u 2�h#hC@#g+OR4)Q ,�y;4�6;4)Q83P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OR3#�&L�2�6 0 4�}�ORK;@,g;Q5@#y;BXh ,ORBN4)6;3k4�}IORK;@�BN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�'*@#<XyYLM4�y;@#<*K;4)<XyrE���O�ORK;@#Q5@�}�4)Q5@�g;QP4`�BNy;@C3�2j:�4�4�ym3POR2�QPO5BX6;:wg�4)BX6�O ��BNO5K��K;BNh[K�OR48ORK+BX6;uj2 / 4)9+O O5K;@?O5@C6;3P4)Q hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53k4�}*ORK+@WK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNO 0 O5K*2\O ��BN<X<ZQ5@#359;<oO}�Q54�L `\2�Q5BN4)9;3�3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6{g*2\O5O5@CQP6;3CE

Page 60: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

d =

v�BN:)9;Q5@ �+E =��|G�h[K;@CLM2\O5BXh"Q5@#g;Q5@#35@#6ZOR2\ORBN4)6 4\}nO5K;@"@#�I@Ch�OR3s4�}F@#<X@#h#ORQP4)6 y;4)6;4)QY2\6;y 2�hCh#@Cg+O54)Q359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3w4)6tORK+@ / @#6�@C@#6;@Y35u�@#<X@�OR4)6�E,��K;@m<X@�} Opg*2�6;@#< 35K+4 ��3pO5K;@mBX6�OR@#QR2�h�ORBN4)6 / @�O �?@#@C6ORK+@ g ,�4�Q / BoO[2�<�4)6 / @#6�@C@#6;@ 2�6;y O5K;@t�F�jq'� 4\}j2�y;4)6;4�QCE ��K+@ Q5BN:)K�O�g*2\6;@C<n35K;4)��3�ORK+@BX6�O5@CQR2\h#ORBN4)6 / @#O ��@C@C6�ORK;@wg ,�4)Q / BoO[2�<I4)6 / @#6�@C@#6;@,2\6;y|O5K;@j�&]8q �z4�}k2�6|2�h#hC@#g+OR4)Q#E

� �� � ��� � �� ���

�WV��WV � ��� �%� ���� ��� �� ���#�%� � ! � �� �� � � ������� � � � � � !���� � �%��� ������� ��� ]�� � � ���� ����/�

��K;@8g;QP@C3P@C6;h#@84�}&2�h#hC@#g+OR4)Q?2�6;yMy;4)6;4)Q 359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OR3�2%O5O[2\h[K;@Cy�O54�2jLM4)<N@Ch#9;<=2�Qk3Pu�@#<X@#O54)[email protected]\O5@C3^2�6 BX6�OR@#Q56*2\< gI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�< ��BoORK;BN6 ORK;@YLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@�E^�!4�2�h[K;BN@#`)@mO5K;BX3pBN6 O5K;@YLM4�y;@#< � ��@`�BX@�� O5K;@�@#�I@Ch#O 4�}�ORK+@�359 / 3lORBoOR9;@#6ZO�2�3 2pg�@CQPO59;Q / 2\ORBN4)6�OR4pORK+@�@C6;@#Q5: 0 4\}IO5K;@�4)Q / BoO[2�<N3�4�}�[email protected]\Q / 4)6{2\OR4�L OR4 ��K+BXh[K"ORK;@p3P9 / 3lORBNO59;@C6�O_BX3W2\O5OR2�h[K;@CyrE ��K+@jQ52\ORBN4)6*2�<N@_}�4�Q?ORK;BN3�2�g;g+Q54�2�h[K{BN335K+4 ��6�35h[K;@#L�2%ORBXhC2�<X< 0 BN6|v�BX:)9+Q5@1�+E>=�E

v*4)Q�2�6Y@C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6Yy;4�6*2\ORBN6;:w359 / 3PORBoOR9;@#6�O.��ORK;@_�F�jq'� 4�}�ORK;@�3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�O�BX6�OR@#QR2�h�OR3 ��BNO5KORK+@,4)Q / BNOR2�<X3�4�}�ORK;@ / @#6�@C@#6;@�Q5BN6;:;E�G�BX6;h#@jO5K;BX3_4)Q / BNO[2\<�K*2�382\6'@C6+@CQ5: 0'/ @C<N4 � ORK;@ / @#6�@C@#6;@� 3 0 3PO5@CL|��BN6�OR@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6+3�QR2�BN35@�O5K;@"@C6+@CQ5: 0 4�}�ORK;@"4�Q / BoO[2�<N3,4)6 O5K;@"h.2�Q / 4�6 O54 ��K;BXh[K ORK+@359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OwBX3n2\O5OR2�h[K;@#y�Ewv*4)Q82�6'@C<X@#h#O5Q54)6 ��BoORK;y+QR2.��BX6;:�359 / 3lORBoOR9;@#6ZOC�rORK+@m�&]8q � 4�}kORK+@359 / 3PO5BNOR9+@C6�OYK*2�3Y2�6 @#6;@CQP: 0 2 / 4�`)@�O5K;@ / @C6�@#@C6;@ � 3 0 3lOR@#L���2�6;y BN6ZO5@CQ52�h#O5BX4)6;3^<X4)��@CQ�ORK+@@C6+@CQ5: 0 4�}!O5K;@wh.2�Q / 4�6�2%OR4)L OR4*��K;BXh[K{ORK;@w3P9 / 3PO5BNO59;@C6�OnBX3�2\OPO[2�h[K;@#y�E

Page 61: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

d?8

� � ��� ��� � �

� ����� � ��� � � � ��� ��� ��� � � � � ��� � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � ��� � �

� � � � � � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � ����� � � � �

� � ��� ��� � � � � ��� � �

>A4)Q5u�y+4)6;@wBX6{hC4�<X<=2 / 4)Q52\ORBN4)6 ��BoORK|�kQ54�}�@#353P4)Qn1�4)35@#g;K � 0 353ikhC4)<N@ U 4)QPL�2\<X@wG�9+g��@CQPBX@C9+Q5@jy;@^JW2�h[K*2�6���JW2\h[K*2�6���v*QR2�6+hC@

���� ������� ���� �� � ���

��K;BX3kh[K;2�g+OR@#Q�g;Q5@#35@C6�O53?3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 2�6*2\< 0 35BN3k2�6;yY35BN6;:)9;<X2�Q�`\2�<N9;@Wy;@#hC4)LsgI4�35BNO5BX4)6 S G��87 ah.2\<XhC9+<=2\O5BX4)6;3&}�4)<N<X4)��BX6;:_ORK;@�g+Q54�hC@Cy+9;Q5@#3 4\}Ih[K;2�g+OR@#Q �84)6mORK;QP@C@�2�y+y;BNO5BX4)6*2\<�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q�35u\@C<X@ ,OR4�6;3CE ��K+@|Ls4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q^35u�@#<X@�OR4)6;3shC4�6;35BNy;@CQP@Cy BX6 ORK+BX3mh[K*2�g�OR@CQs2�QP@{2th.2�Q / 4)6 O5@#ORQ52�K;@#y;QR2�<35u\@C<N@#OR4�6 S ��� a �?7 � ����2�6;y 7 � LM4�<X@Ch#9;<=2\Q,35u\@C<N@#OR4�6;3 S v�BX:�9;Q5@ d E ba E ��K;@|h.2�Q / 4)6 O5@#ORQ52�K;@ ,y;Q52�<&35u�@#<X@�OR4)6�BX3�4�} BN6�OR@CQP@C3lO / @Ch.2\9;35@^BNO�K*2�3�ORK+@^352�LM@j:)@#4)LM@�ORQ 0 2�3_h.2�Q / 4)6|OR@�ORQR2\h[K;<X4)QPBXy;@��K;BNh[K��82�3�@.2�QP< 0 2\3 b�c)x�d �nK*2\y / @#@C6 35K;4)��6�OR4 @���K;B / BNO�4)6;< 0 �#"�$ �|K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0hC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZO53CE d � � ��K;@AORQ5BNg;K;@#6 0 <^35u�@#<X@�OR4)6 BN3'4�}YBN6ZO5@CQP@C3PO / @#h.2�9;3P@ BNO�BX3|ORK;@ Ls4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q

Page 62: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

d�c

v�BN:)9;Q5@ d E b �8q|4)<X@#hC9;<X2�QF3Pu�@C<N@#O54)6;38}�4)Q S 2 a hC2�Q / 4)6'O5@#ORQ52 � 9;4�Q5BXy+@�� S�/�a ORK+@mBXy;@C2�<XB @C@Cy|ORQPBXg;K ,@C6 0 <&:)@C4�LM@�ORQ 0 �*2�6;y S h a ORK;@w:)@#4)LM@�ORQ 0 4)g+O5BXLsBA@C@#y�ORQPBXg;K;@#6 0 <�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@�Ekq�4)<X@#hC9;<N@ S 2 a K*2\3OR@�ORQ52�K;@Cy+QR2�< S ��� a 3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 �ZLM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@ S�/�a 7 � �n3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 �+2\6;y�Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@ S h a 7 � 3 0 LMLs@�,ORQ 0 E

35u\@C<N@#OR4�6 }�4)QYLs4)<X@#hC9;<N@C3m359+h[K�2�3YhCQ 0 3lO[2�<_4)QY@#O5K 0 <�`�BX4�<X@#O ��K+BXh[K K;2�`�@ / @C@#6 ORK+@|3P9 / �P@#h#O4�}k6Z9;Ls@CQP4)9;3n@���gI@#Q5BNLM@#6ZOR2�<&3PO59;y;BX@#3CE � b � � x � d � � ��K;@C3P@m35u\@C<X@�OR4)6+382�<N<X4)� 9;3_OR4M@��+2�LsBX6;@^2`\2�Q5BN@#O 0 4�}�O ��4�2\6;y"ORK;QP@C@jy;BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6;2�<r3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6{g*2\O5O5@CQP6;3CE

�� � � � � � � � � � � � ����� �

v*4)<X<N4 ��BN6;:pORK;@_g;QP4�h#@Cy;9;QP@84�}�3P@Ch�ORBX4�6 �+E d �ZORK;@_3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 ,�2�y*2�g+O5@Cy�K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0OR@#6;354�Q53 2\6;y�g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<N3 �?@#Q5@?y+@#OR@#Q5LsBX6;@#y^}�4)Q&ORK+@�ORK+Q5@C@�LM4�<X@Ch#9;<=2\Q�35u�@#<X@�OR4)6;3!4�}�v�BN:)9;QP@ d E b EJW2�Q / 4)6TOR@�ORQR2 � 9;4)QPBXy;@sK*2�3jOR@#O5QR2�K+@Cy;Q52�< S ��� a 3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 ��ORK;@MBXy;@C2�<XB @C@CyTg;<X2�6*2�QpORQPBXg;K+@C6 0 <Ls4)<X@#hC9;<N@,K*2�3w7 � �Y3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 ��2\6;ytORK;@�4�g+ORBNLMB @C@Cy':)@C4)Ls@#O5Q 0 K*2�3w7 � 3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 E^]n6;<NBXu\@35@#h#O5BX4)6��+E d K+4 ��@#`�@CQ#��K;@#Q5@s4)6;< 0 2"<XBXLsBNO5@Cy 6Z9;L / @#Qj4\}?3PBNOR@#3w4)6tORK;@YLs4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Q835u\@C<N@#OR4�6;32�QP@Mh#4)6;35BNy;@CQP@Cy�2�3^<N4�hC2\ORBN4)6;38}�4)Q^2�h#hC@Cg�OR4)Q ,�y;4)6+4)Qw359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5BX4)6�E���6AORK+@MhC2�Q / 4)6AO5@#O5QR2 � 9-,4)QPBXy;@�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q_35u\@C<X@�OR4)6r�&O5K;@ � 9;4�Q5BXy+@Y2\OR4)Ls382\Q5@mhC4�6;35BNy;@CQP@CyA2�38359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6T3PBNO5@C3CE^��6

Page 63: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

;��

ORK+@�ORQ5BNg;K;@#6 0 < 3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6���2\O54)LM3 ; � b)b ��2\6;y b =�2�Q5@,hC4)6;3PBXy;@#Q5@#y�2�3p3P9 / 3lORBNO59+ORBN4)6t35BoOR@#3 S 35@#@v�BN:)9;Q5@ d E ba E

i �;2\LMBN6*2\ORBN4)6 4�}�O5K;@�3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 2�y*2\g+OR@#yTBN6�OR@CQP6*2�<!gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3F2�6;ytORK+@�K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�QPBA@�,2 / BN<XBoORBX@#3 35K+4 � 3P4)Ls@n4�}rORK;@_3R2�Ls@_h[K*2�QR2\h#OR@#Q5BN3PORBNhC3�2�3�O5K;4)3P@n3P@C@C6"BN6M3P@Ch�ORBX4�6 �+E d E U 4�OR@�ORK*2%O6;4)6+@n4�}�ORK+@nLs4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Q 3Pu�@C<N@#O54)6;3?h#4)6;3PBXy;@#Q5@CyMK;@CQP@nK;2�`�@F2whC@#6�OR@CQ�4�}�BN6�`)@CQP35BN4)6�E ��K;@#Q5@�}�4)Q5@\�BNOwBN3pgI4�3535B / <X@�O5K*2\OpO5K;@Y359 / 3lORBoOR9+O5@Cy�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<X@�LM2 0 :)Bo`)@YQ5BN35@�OR4�2"6;4)6 , @C@#Q54|K 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q�,BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 EW��K;@m2 / 35@#6;hC@�4\} 2MhC@#6�OR@CQF4�}�BX6�`)@#Q53PBX4)6 BN3nQP@ � @#h#O5@Cy /�0 O5K;@^O5K;@,g+Q5@C3P@C6;h#@m4�}kORK+@OR4\O[2�<N< 0 3 0 LsLs@#ORQPBXhwBXQPQ5@#y;9;hCB / <X@jQ5@#g;Q5@#35@#6ZOR2\ORBN4)6;3nBX6�O5K;@,K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoORBX@#3�2�6;y�gI4\OR@C6-,ORBX2�<X3 4�}��!2 / <X@ d E b E�D?9+O.�+2�3WBN6"35@Ch�ORBN4)6 �+E d �+4)6+< 0 ORK;4)3P@pK 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNORBN@C3k4�}��!2 / <N@ d E bhC4�Q5Q5@#35g�4)6;y;BN6;:�O54�ORK;@,LM4)<N@Ch#9;<=2�Q�3P9 / 3PO5BNO59+ORBN4)6 g*2\OPOR@#Q56;3 S � a }�4)9+6;ytBX6|ORK;@,OR2 / <N@�2�QP@�2�h ,hC@#353PB / <N@�E v*4)Q�@��+2�Lsg;<X@\�F2�<oORK;4�9;:)K O5K;@t3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 2�6*2�< 0 35BX3�35K;4)��3{� � 3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 2�3{2g�4)353PB / <N@MK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 }�4)QwORK;@sOR@#O5QR2�K+@Cy;Q52�<�3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6�� BoO,BN3^6+4�Om2�h#hC@#3535B / <X@ /�0 2\6 0359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6 g*2\O5O5@CQP6 4�6 O5K;@{LM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@\E ��6 O5K;@"4)g+O5BXLsBA@C@#y�ORQPBXg;K+@C6 0 <�:)@C4)Ls@#O5Q 0 K 0 g�@CQ ,g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO5BX@C3 ��BoORK f � ��f � �&2�6;yAi QP@Cg;QP@C35@#6�O[2\O5BX4)6;3^2�QP@mgI4)3P35B / <X@\EY�F}�O5K;@C3P@��&K;4)�?@�`)@#QC�4)6;< 0 f � 2�6;yYiAQP@Cg;QP@C3P@C6�O[2\O5BX4)6+3�2\Q5@�2�h#hC@#3535B / <X@WO5K;Q54�9;:)KmLs4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Q!3P9 / 3lORBNO59+ORBN4)6mg*2\OPOR@#Q56;3#EfF<N354;��2�3jBX6 / @C6�@#@C6;@\�!ORK+@�G��87 QP@C359+<NOR3j35K+4 � O5K*2\OwORK+@MK 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2\Q5BA@C2 / BN<XBNO 0 y;@#gI@#6;y;3^4)6ORK+@ � `\2�<N9;@^4\} ORK;@^35g;[email protected]�<�K*2�QPLM4�6;BXhpQP@Cg;QP@C35@#6�O[2\O5BX4)6�E_��6 4�O5K;@CQ ��4)Q5y;3#�IO5K;@,f � Q5@#g;Q5@ ,35@#6�O[2\O5BX4)6'}�4�QnORK+@,OR@�ORQR2\K;@Cy;Q52�<�LM4)<N@Ch#9;<X@j4�}��!2 / <X@ d E b 4)6;< 0 K*2�3 � � � h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3p2\6;yORK+@j� � Q5@#g;Q5@#35@#6ZOR2\ORBN4)6'K;2�3 � � � � b � ��h#4)LMg�4)6;@#6�OR3CE

���� � � ������� � � � � � ��� �� �� � ����� � ��� �

fF3jBX6 35@#h#O5BX4)6 �+E ; ��BoOwBX3j2�<N354{gI4�3535B / <X@�O54�@ ��ORQR2\h#OjORK;@sBX6+}�4�Q5LM2\ORBN4)6 hC4�6ZOR2�BX6+@CyTBX6 ��2 ,/ <N@ d E b ORK;QP4)9;:)K 3PBX6;:)9+<=2�Qj`�2\<X9;@�y+@ChC4�LMg�4)35BoORBN4)6 S G��p7 a E ��6 ORK;@�O5@#O5QR2�K;@#y;QR2\<WLM4�<X@Ch#9;<X@#3C�ORK+@ � LM2\O5Q5B"�T4\}�@C~�E ��E � =|BX3 � = � d 2�6;y }�4�QjO5K;@�ORQPBXg;K+@C6 0 <?35u\@C<N@#OR4�6;3C� � =)����E'fF3,BX6 / @C6-,@C@#6;@�� O5K;@�h[K*2\QR2�h�OR@CQPBX3lORBXhMy;BXQP@Ch�ORBX4�6;3,4�}?ORK;@�O5@#O5QR2�K;@#y;QR2\<?2�6+y ORQ5BNg;K;@#6 0 <�35u�@#<X@�OR4)6;3,L�2\O5h[KORK+4)35@jy;@#O5@CQPLMBN6;@Cy{BX6"O5K;@^3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 2�6;2�< 0 35BN3�4�}�ORK;@wg;QP@#`�BX4)9+3n3P@Ch#O5BX4)6 S �!2 / <N@ d E ba E�G�BNL*,

BX<X2�Q,O54T3P@Ch�ORBX4�6"�+E ; � ORK;@"`\2�<X9+@C3Y4�} � S ��2 / <X@ d E � a h.2\6 g;QP4�`�BNy;@{BX6+}�4�Q5LM2\ORBN4)6 2 / 4)9+OYORK+@Q5@#<=2\O5BN`�@sh#4)6�ORQPB / 9+O5BX4)6+3p4�}?O5K;@�2\<X<X4)��@CyT359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5BX4)6Tg*2\OPOR@#Q56;3j4�}W�!2 / <N@ d E b BX6T2|:)@C6;@#QR2�<359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6|g;2\O5O5@CQ56|4)6|2mLM4�<X@Ch#9;<=2\Q?35u\@C<N@#OR4�6�E���6"O5K;@C3P@^Ls4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Q?3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6;3#�I2\<X<�4�}�ORK+@Q5@#g;Q5@#35@#6ZOR2\ORBN4)6;3n2�Q5@p@ ��gI@#h#OR@#y'OR4YK*2.`�@^QP4)9;:)K;< 0 @#~�9;2�<�L�2\:)6;BNO59;y;@#3CE

Page 64: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

; b

�!2 / <X@ d E b �?G 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 ,�2\y*2�g+O5@Cy|K 0 g�@CQPgI4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BX<XBoO 0 O5@C6;3P4)Q53n2�6;y�BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�gI4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3W}�4�QOR@�ORQ52�K;@Cy+QR2�<V��[email protected]�<NBA@C@#yAO5Q5BXg+K;@C6 0 < �k2\6;y :)@#4)LM@�ORQ 0 4�g+ORBNLMB @C@Cy ORQPBXg;K+@C6 0 <?Ls4)<X@#hC9;<X2�Qp35u\@C<X@ ,OR4�6;3p4�} v�BN:)9;Q5@ d E b Ew��K;@Y6;4�O[2%ORBX4�6� ����� � ����� � � BN6;y;BXhC2\OR@#3FORK;2\Ow2�6 0 <NBX6;@C2�Q_hC4)L / BX6*2\O5BX4)6�4�}���� 2�6+y ���� � ��BN<X<�ORQ52�6;3l}�4)Q5L ��BNO5K�O5K;@^BN6;y;BNh.2\O5@Cy'3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 E���K+@�BX6�OR@#Q56*2\<�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�<X3_2�QP@:)Bo`)@C6�2�3^2�6;4)QPL�2\<XBA@#@Cyt`)@#h#O54)Q,QP@Cg;QP@C35@#6�ORBX6+:'ORK;@s`\2�<X9;@Y4�}�ORK;@MgI4\OR@C6�O5B=2�<k4)[email protected]�h[K�4�}WORK+@ORK+Q5@C@{hC2�Q / 4)6 2\OR4)Ls3 ; � b)b ��2�6;y b ='}�4)Q�O5K;@"ORQ5BNg;K;@#6 0 <�3Pu�@C<N@#O54)6 4�}Fv�BN:)9;Q5@ d E b E ��6 ORK+@y;4)9 / < 0 2�6;y�O5Q5BXg+< 0 y;@#:)@C6;@#QR2\O5@pBX6�OR@#Q56*2\<rg�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<N3C��2�6 0 <NBX6;@C2�Q�h#4)L / BN6*2\O5BX4)6M4�}�ORK;@p:�BN`)@#6g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<N3WBX3W`\2�<NBXy�E

, � @�� ��� � @ ��� � � @ � ���=���� � � ?B? 9 @ �3 � � @ � � ��� @ � � � � � � � � �� � ?B? 9 @ � � � � � � � � � ���� � �� � � � ����� � � � �� � � � � � � � �� � � �� � � � � � � � � � ��� � � �� � � �� � � � �� �� � � � �� � � �� � � � � � � � �� � � � �� � � � �� � � �� � � � �� �� � � @ � ����� � � � ����� �

� � ��� � � � � � � ���� � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � ��� = � ��� " � " � � � � ��� = � � � " � � � � � � � ��� �� �� ��� � @ � ��� � � � � ��? 9 @ � = ; �"!

� � ?B? @ �3 � � @ � � ��� @ � � � � � � � � �� � ?B? 9 @ � � � � � � � � � � � �� � �� � � � � � �# � � � �� � � �� � � � � �� � � �� � �

� � � @ � ����� � � � ����� � � � � � � � � � ���# � � � � � � � � � � ��� = � � � " � � � � ��� �

) � � ? � � �$� @ � ��� � � ��� ��? @ � = ; �� � ?B? 9 @ �3 � � @ � � ��� @ � � � � � � � � �� � ?B? 9 @ � � � � � � �

� � ���� � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �% � �� � = � �� � �� � ��# � � �� � � �� ��� � � �� � � �� ���� � � @ � ����� � � � ����� �

� � � � � � � � ���# � � � � � � � � � � � ��� = � � � " � � � � ���

Page 65: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

;)�

�!2 / <X@ d E � � � @C359+<NOR3F4�} ORK+@mG��87 2�6*2�< 0 3PBX3_4)6'O5K;@ / @C6�@#@C6;@�3Pu�@#<X@#O54)6���9+35BX6+:MORK+@�~Z9*2�6�OR9;Lh[K;@#LMBNh.2�< Ls4�y;@C<N38y;BX3PhC9;3P35@#yABN6�G�@Ch#O5BX4)6 ��E>�+Em�p6+< 0 ORK;4)3P@m`�2\<X9;@#3p4�}�ORK;@YLM2\ORQPBXhC@#3 � 2\6;y� hC4�Q5Q5@#35g�4)6;y;BN6;:MO54�6;4�6�@C@#Q54M`\2�<N9;@C3_4�} � 2�QP@^QP@Cg�4)QPO5@Cy�E���6'O5K;@j� U 7w� Ls4�y;@#<X3#��QP@C3P9;<NO532�QP@j3PK;4)��6 ��BoORK"ORK;@wBN6ZO5@CQP6*2�<�g�4�OR@#6�ORB=2\<�2�g;g;<NBX@#y{O54mORK;@w@C6�O5BXQ5@j2\O54)L 4�Q�O54mORK;@ �P9;3lO_O5K;@ �4)Q / BNOR2�<X3#E

� 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoO 0 q'2�:)6;BoOR9;y+@C3C�;}�QP4)L O5K;@wL�2\O5Q5B � �JW2�Q / 4)6{��@#ORQ52 � 9;4�Q5BXy+@��*���F3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0

f � � �� E � = d = � E �?;<;��

��y;@.2\<�:)@C4)Ls@#O5Q 0 �*7 � �^3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0f � � i �x =�E � x �+E ;

�8g+O5BXLsBA@#@Cy":)@#4)LM@�ORQ 0 ��7 � 3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0f � i� c E d � x E d

���� � � � � ������� �

��K;@"Ls@#ORK+4�y;3^y;@#`�@C<N4)gI@#y BX6 J?K*2\g+OR@#Q � 2�QP@"2�g;g;<NBX@#yAOR4�ORK;QP@C@{2�y;y+BNORBN4)6*2�<kLs4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q35u\@C<N@#OR4�6;3CE|��K;@�QP@C3P9;<NO53 0 BX@#<Xy�3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 2�y*2\g+OR@#y 359 / 3PORBoOR9+O5BX4)6Ag*2\OPOR@CQP3�2�<N4)6;:#��BNO5KAORK+@K 0 gI@#Q5g�4)<=2�QPBA@C2 / BX<NBNO5BX@C3�BN6;y;9;h#@Cy /�0 O5K;@C3P@mg*2\OPOR@CQP6;3CEwfn3pBX6 / @C6�@#@C6;@\��y;BN�I@CQP@C6�Op3 0 LsLs@#ORQ 0 ,2�y*2\g+OR@#yAg*2%O5OR@#Q56;3j<X@C2�y OR4{K 0 g�@CQPgI4�<=2�[email protected] / BX<NBNORBN@C3���BNORK y;Bo�r@#Q5@#6ZO � `\2�<N9;@C3#EM��K+@s`\2�QPBX4)9;3359 / 3PO5BNOR9�ORBX4�6^g*2%O5OR@#Q56;3�2�Q5@ g;QP@Cy;BNh#OR@#y,OR4 0 BX@#<Xy,K 0 g�@CQ5g�4)<X2�Q5B @.2 / BN<XBoORBX@#3r4�}+35BNLMBN<=2�Q�LM2�:)6+BNOR9+y;@�E

Page 66: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

; �

� � � � � �

� � � � � � ��� ����� � � � �

Page 67: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

; d

� � ��� ��� � �

� � � ��� � ��� � � � � ��� ��� � � � � � � ���

�� ��� �

� �� ������� ���� �� � ���

��K;@Y}�4)<X<N4 ��BN6;:�O5K;Q5@#@Mh[K*2\g+OR@#Q53jy;@.2�< ��BoORK h.2\<XhC9+<=2\O5BX4)6;3FBX6�`)4)<o`�BX6;:"g�@CQPBX4�y;BXh / 4)9;6;y;2�Q 0hC4�6;y;BNO5BX4)6+3CEj��K;BX3ph[K*2\g+OR@#Qjg+Q5@C3P@C6�OR3j354�LM@mg;QP@C<NBXLsBX6*2�Q 0{/ 2�h[uZ:)QP4)9;6;yTBX6+}�4�Q5LM2\ORBN4)6�O5K*2\OpBN39;3P@#}�9;<�BX6 O5K;@Yy;BX3PhC9;3P35BN4)6A4\}�O5K;@m}�4)<X<N4 ��BN6;:�h[K*2\g+OR@#Q53CEMG�BN6;hC@mO5K;@m}�4)<X<N4 ��BN6;:�h[K*2\g+OR@#Q53jy;@.2�<��BNO5Kt4)6;@ ,n2�6;ytO �?4 ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<!gI@#Q5BX4�y;BNh,3 0 3lOR@CLs3C� ��@ ��BX<X<!hC4)6+hC@C6�O5QR2\O5@s4�9;Qpy;BX3PhC9;3P35BN4)64)6{@��+2�Lsg;<N@C3 ��BNO5K{O5K;@C3P@jO ��4sy;BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6;2�<XBoORBX@#3CE

� � �� �� ��� � � � � ��� �� �� � ��� ��� � ���� ���

>�@ ��BN<X<�3POR2�QPO /�0 y;@ '*6+BX6;:�O5K;@mgI@#Q5BN4�y;BNh^3 0 3POR@#L�9;6;y+@CQphC4�6;35BNy;@CQ52\ORBN4)6�EwfF3p2\6T@ �+2�L*,

g;<N@��*hC4�6;35BNy;@CQ_2m4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<�BN6/'*6;BoOR@ph[K*2\BX6 ��BNO5K|O5K;@w<=2\OPORBXh#@F`)@#h#O54)QC������*y;@ ';6;BX6;:YORK+@y;BN3PO[2\6;hC@s}�Q54)L 4)6+@�35BoOR@MBX6AO5K;@�h[K;2�BX6�O54 2�6+4�ORK;@#Q S v�BX:)9+Q5@ ; E ba E|fF6 0 ORQR2\6;35<X2\ORBN4)6T2�<X4)6+:ORK+@8h[K*2�BN6 /�0 2�6�BX6�OR@#:)@CQ�L�9;<NO5BXg;<N@_2�LM4�9;6�O?4�}�O5K;@8<X2\O5O5BXhC@�`�@Ch#O54)Q S � �� a <X@C2�`�@C3?O5K;@83 0 3lOR@#L9;6;h[K;2�6;:)@#y�E d)d �&� 8 � d ; � d)x �

��6�2pL�9;<oORB ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<Z3 0 3lOR@CL|�ZORK;@�ORQ52�6;35<X2\ORBN4)6�`)@#h#O54)Q �� K*2�3 L�9;<oORBXg+<X@?h#4)LsgI4)6+@C6�OR3#��� � � � � � � � � ��K;@#Q5@ � � BN3m2�6 BN6ZO5@C:)@#Qm2�6;y � � BX3m2�9;6;BNO,`)@Ch�OR4)Qm4\}�ORK;@"<X2\O5O5BXhC@\Eti�2�h[KhC4�LMg�4)6;@#6ZOw4\} �� Q5@#g;Q5@#35@#6ZO53,2�O5QR2�6+35<=2%ORBX4�6 /�0 2�6 BX6�OR@#:)@CQ82�LM4�9;6�OpBX6t3P4)LM@my+BXQ5@#h#O5BX4)6tBN6

Page 68: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

;<;

v�BN:)9;Q5@ ; E b � �86;@py;BXLs@C6+35BX4�6*2�<�BX6/';6;BNO5@8h[K*2�BN6 ��BNORK"<X2\O5O5BXh#@n`)@#h#O54)Q ���Ek��K;@whC@#6ZO5@CQP@Cy|g;Q5BNL*,BNO5BN`�@phC@C<N<�4�}�ORK;BN3�<=2\OPORBNhC@FK;2�3�BNOR3�4�Q5BX:�BX6"2\O�4�6;@w4�}&ORK;@j2\O54)LM3�4\}!O5K;@p<=2\OPORBNhC@�E���K;@^y+BX3POR2�6;h#@}�Q54�L ORK+@p4)Q5BN:)BX6M4�}!O5K;@pg;QPBXLsBNORBo`)@nhC@C<N<IO54sBoOR3W3PBXy;@#3�BX3�� � �� E���K;@py*2�3PK;@Cy|<XBN6;@8BX6+y;BXhC2\OR@#3?ORK*2%O4)6;< 0 4)6+@j4\}!O5K;@pO �?4s35BNy;@C3�BX3�h#4)6�O[2�BN6;@Cy|BX6"O5K;@wg;Q5BNLMBoORBN`�@F4)Q�9;6+BNO�h#@C<X<VE

ORK+@ <X2\O5O5BXh#@k359;h[KjORK*2\O&O5K;@�<=2\OPORBXh#@ Q5@#L�2\BX6;3�9;6+h[K*2�6;:)@#y�Ekv*4)Q�@ �;2\LMg;<N@��BX6j2�O �?4_y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<3 0 3lOR@CL �� ��4)9;<Xy�K*2.`)@�O5K;@M}�4)QPL �� � � � � �

� � � S v�BN:)9;Q5@ ; E � a E|��K+@�9;6;BoO,h#@C<X<�BN3^ORK+@

Q5@#:)9;<X2�Qng�4)< 0 K+@Cy;QP4)6 ORK*2%[email protected]\O5@Cy /�0 9;6+BNOFO5QR2�6+35<=2%ORBX4�6;3F2\<X4)6;:sORK;@,<=2\OPORBXh#@j`�@Ch�OR4)QP3CE d)d ���K;@�h[K;4)BXh#@�4\}p<=2\OPORBNhC@�`)@#h#O54)Q53�BN3Y6;4�OM9;6;BX~Z9;@ �nO5K;@�4�6;< 0 QP@C~Z9;BXQP@CLs@C6�OMBX3mORK*2%O�QP@Cg�@.2\O5@CyORQ52�6;3P<=2\O5BX4)6 /Z0 ORK;@�9;6;BNO,`)@Ch�OR4)QP3mg;Q54�`�BXy+@"2 hC4�`)@#Q5BN6;:t4�}�ORK;@�<=2\OPORBXh#@�E d�d � d ; � ��6 2 h#9 / BNh<=2%O5ORBNhC@\��3P9;h[K'2\3?ORK*2%O�4�}!v�BX:�9;Q5@ ; E � S 2 a � � � 2�6+y � � 2�Q5@p4)QlORK;4�:)4)6*2�<V��2�<NO5K;4)9;:)KMORK;@#Q5@pBX3?6;4Q5@#~Z9;BXQP@CLs@C6�O ORK;2\O ORK+@W9;6;BoO�`)@#h#O54)Q / @?4)QPO5K;4):)4)6;2�< � � � � �X��ORK+@W9;6;BoO�`)@#h#O54)Q53k4�}*O5K;@�K;@ �;2\:)4)6*2�<<=2%O5ORBNhC@8BN6|v�BX:)9+Q5@ ; E � S�/�a K*2.`)@^2�6|2�6;:)<N@p4�} x �

�/ @�O �?@#@C6'O5K;@CL|E d)d � d ; �

��O�BX3�4�} OR@#6�hC4�6Z`�@C6;BN@C6�O�OR4,y;@#O5@CQ5LsBX6+@nORK+@8LMBN6;BXL,9;L 6Z9;L / @CQ�4�}&gI4�BX6�OR3 ORK*2\O?h.2�6"LM2�u\@9;g 2�9+6;BNOFhC@C<N< �IQ5@#}�@#Q5QP@Cy OR4{2\3FORK;@,g;Q5BNLMBoORBN`�@w9;6;BNOFhC@#<X< EF��K;@�g;QPBXLsBNORBo`)@jhC@#<X<�BX38y;@�'*6;@#yA2\3ORK+@sLM2 ��BXLM2�<&35@�Oj4�}�O5QR2�6+35<=2%ORBX4�6*2�<X< 0 BX6;@#~Z9;BN`\2�<N@C6�Opg�4)BX6�OR3pBN6 ORK;@Y<X2\O5O5BXhC@\E^��K+@Mg;QPBXLM2\ORBo`)@9;6;BoO�hC@#<X<;h#4)6;35BN3PO53 4\}�2�6s4)g�@C6YQ5@#:)9;<X2�QkgI4�< 0 K;@Cy+Q54)[email protected]\O5@Cy /Z0 ORK;@�6;4)QPL�2\< / BN35@Ch�OR4)Q�g;<X2�6;@#34�}�ORK;@�9;6+BNO�`)@#h#OR4�Q53 4�} �� S v�BN:)9;QP@C3 ; E b 2�6;y ; E � a � ��K;BNh[K /�0 y;@�'*6;BNO5BX4)6Yy;4�@C3�6;4\O�h#4)6�O[2�BN6s2�<X<4�}&BoOR3?3PBXy;@#3 S 4�ORK;@#Q+��BN35@83P4)LM@ngI4�BX6�OR3��?4)9+<Xy / @FLs@CL / @CQP3?4�}&L�9+<NORBNg;<X@�g;QPBXLsBNO5BN`)@�h#@C<X<N3 a E d)d ���6 ORK;@Y@��+2�Lsg;<N@s4\}W2"4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<!BX6/';6;BNO5@mh[K*2�BX6 ��BNO5K 4)6;< 0 4)6;@mO 0 gI@Y4�}W2\OR4)L|��ORK+@g;QPBXLsBNORBo`)@�h#@C<X<�hC4�Q5Q5@#35g�4)6;y;3�OR4,4�6;@82\O54)L gI@#Q�h#@C<N< Ekv*4)Q 354)<NBXys3POR2\OR@_ORK;@#4)Q 0 BNO�BX3�2�<N354,9+35@#}�9+<OR4wg;<X2�hC@�O5K;@�4)Q5BN:)BX6m2%OkORK;@�hC@#6�OR@CQ 4�}�ORK;@�h#@C<X<V�Z2�3�BX6Yv�BN:)9;QP@C3 ; E b 2\6;y ; E � E��F} OR@C6r��h#@C6�OR@#Q5BN6;:ORK+@�g;Q5BNLMBoORBN`�@�h#@C<N< / @C3PO�QP@ � @#h#O53�O5K;@�3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 4�}�ORK+@�3 0 3PO5@CL|� � � � �� ;h#4)LMg;2�Q5@?O5K;@�hC@#6�OR@CQP@Cyg;QPBXLsBNORBo`)@ hC@#<X<�4�}�ORK;@WK+@��+2�:)4)6;2�<;<=2%O5ORBNhC@%��BNO5K�ORK;@Wh#Q 0 3POR2�<X<N4):)Q52�g;K;BNh�h#@C<X<�4�}*ORK+@�3R2�Ls@?<X2\O5O5BXhC@S 3P@C@nv�BX:�9;Q5@ ; E � S�/�a�a E d)d � J?@C6�OR@#Q5BX6+:jO5K;@ng+Q5BXLsBNO5BN`�@WhC@#<X<�2�<N<X4)��3�}�4)Q�354�<X9+O5BX4)6;3 O54^4�gI@#QR2\O5BX4)6;34)6 ORK;@s3 0 3lOR@CL �?2.`)@#}�9+6;h#O5BX4)6;3#� 359+h[K 2�3j354)<N9+ORBN4)6;38OR4{ORK+@��n2�QPO5Q5@C@ ,�v*4�h[u g;Q54 / <X@#L���OR4 / @3 0 LsLM@�ORQPBXh 2 / 4)9�O�ORK;@th#@C<N<F4)QPBX:)BN6��?ORKZ9;3{QP@ � @#h#ORBN6;: ORK+@tBX6�`\2�Q5BN@C6;h#@ 4�}pORK+@t354)<N9+ORBN4)6;3MO54

Page 69: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

; x

v�BN:)9;Q5@ ; E � �"� ��4�y+BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6*2\<?<=2%O5ORBNhC@#3CE �&2\O5O5BXhC@ S 2 a K*2�3Y4)QlORK;4�:)4)6*2�<?<=2\OPORBXh#@"9;6;BoOm`)@Ch ,OR4�Q53 S� � � 2\6;y � � a E,�&2\O5O5BXhC@ S�/�a K*2\3p6;4)6 ,�4)QPO5K;4):)4)6;2�<!<X2\O5O5BXh#@^`)@#h#O54)Q53 S� ��� � 2�6+y ���� a E^��K;@hC@#6�OR@CQP@Cy g;Q5BNLMBoORBo`)@{hC@#<X<X3�2�Q5@ 2�<X3P4 35K;4)��6�}�4)[email protected]�h[K <=2%O5ORBNhC@\E ��6-ORK+@ K;@��+2�:�4)6*2�<n<=2\OPORBXh#@��ORK+@|h#Q 0 3POR2�<X<N4):)Q52�g;K;BNh�9;6;BoOmhC@#<X<WBN3m35K;4)��6���BX<N<X9;3lORQR2%ORBX6+:'K;4)� O5K;@"hC@#6�OR@CQP@Cy g;Q5BNLMBoORBN`�@�h#@C<X<@���g;QP@C3P35@C3nORK;@w3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 4�}!ORK;@wK;@ �;2\:)4)6*2�<r<=2\OPORBXh#@�E

h[K*2�6+:)BX6;:mO5K;@w35BX:�6|4\}!O5K;@��W2.`)@�`)@#h#OR4�QC� � � � �X� � S ��+a � � S���*apS 35@C@ / @C<X4)� a E d)d � d ; �

� �� � ��� ��� � � ���� ����� � �

�!4|4 / OR2�BX6tBN6+}�4)QPL�2\O5BX4)6'2 / 4)9+OpORK+@sBN6/'*6;BoOR@�g�@CQPBX4�y;BXh,3 0 3PO5@CL|�&}�9+6;h#O5BX4)6;3pO5K*2\Ow@���K;B / BNOORK+@"3R2�Ls@�ORQ52�6;3P}�4�Q5LM2\ORBN4)6 g;QP4)gI@#QPO5BX@C3Y2\3�ORK;@{g�@CQ5BN4�y+BXh�3 0 3POR@#L 2�Q5@"QP@C~Z9;BNQ5@CyrE ��K;@{:)4�2�<BX3pO54'[email protected]\O5@M}�9;6+h#ORBN4)6;3pORK;2\O�2\Q5@sBX6�`\2�Q5BX2�6�Ow9;6;y;@#Q^ORK+@�4)g�@CQ52\ORBN4)6;3w4�}?O5K;@s3 0 3PO5@CL ! 3�g�4)BN6ZO:)QP4)9;g�E

�SV �WV � � ��� � � ����� � � �������6|2Yh#Q 0 3POR2�< �[email protected]�h[K|@C<N@Ch#O5Q54)6"@ ��gI@#Q5BX@#6;hC@#3F2�g�4�O5@C6�ORBX2�< '*@#<Xy"y;9;@pO54�ORK;@pg;QP@C3P@C6;h#@^4�}�ORK+@

4�O5K;@CQw@C<N@Ch�ORQ54�6;3j2�6;yT6�9+hC<X@#B EMv*9;6;h#O5BX4)6+3���K;BXh[K�2�Q5@Yg�@CQ5BN4�y+BXhm2�6+yTOR2�u�@sBX6�OR4|2�h#hC4)9+6ZOjORK+@g�4�OR@#6ZO5B=2�<&'*@C<Ny|L,9;3PO_3R2%ORBX3l} 0 D?<N4�h[K$! 3WORK+@C4)QP@CL d)d � d ; � �

� � �� � �� � � � � �� � � S �� a � S ; E b�a

Page 70: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

; =

v�BN:)9;Q5@ ; E>�+��i �;2\LMg;<N@�4�}�2pO �?4^y;BXLs@C6+35BX4�6*2�< �\K;@��+2�:�4)6*2�<�<=2%O5ORBNhC@�3PK;4)��BX6;:wORK;@_9;6;BoOk`)@#h#OR4�Q534�}�ORK;@ S 2 a y;BXQP@Ch�O!<X2\O5O5BXh#@ S� � � 2�6;y � � a 2\6;yjO5K;4)3P@ 4\}�O5K;@ S�/�a Q5@#hCBNg;Q54�h.2�<�<=2\OPORBXh#@ S � � 2\6;y � � a E��K;@ '*<X<N@Cy hCBNQ5hC<N@C3w4)6�v�BX:)9+Q5@ S�/*a QP@Cg;QP@C35@#6�O�g�4)BX6�OR3���K;@#Q5@sORK;@MD?Q5BN<X<N4)9;BX6 @C4)6;@MBX6�OR@#Q53P@Ch#O53ORK+@^v*@#Q5LsB�359;Ql}�2�hC@j2�6+y�4�O5K;@CQ�g�4)BX6�O53�4�}�BN6�OR@CQP@C3lOnBN6"ORK;@jD?QPBX<X<N4)9;BN6��r4)6;@\E

��K;@#Q5@ �� BN3F2�6 0 `)@#h#O54)QC� �� BX3n2M<X2\O5O5BXhC@p`�@Ch#O54)QC�r2�6;y �� BX3�ORK+@ �?2�`�@#`�@Ch#O54)QCEnfF6 @ �+2�LMg+<X@w4�}2�}�9;6;h�ORBX4�6{O5K*2\O_3R2%ORBX3�'*@C3_D?<N4�h[K ! 3�ORK+@C4)QP@CL BN3WORK;@jD?<N4�h[K"}�9;6;h�ORBN4)6��

� S �� a � � � �� �� S �� a � S ; E � a

��K;@#Q5@ � S �� a BX3�2�}�9;6+h#ORBN6;4)6{ORK*2%O�BX3�g�@CQ5BN4�y+BXh8BN6{O5K;@w<=2\OPORBNhC@��

� S �� � �� a � � S �� a � S ; E>� a

�SV �WV � � � � �����! � � �#�%� �'� �-� � � fF38BN3F3lO[2\O5@Cy BN6 35@#h#ORBN4)6 ; E � ��ORK;@,<=2\OPORBXh#@p`)@Ch�OR4)QP3w2�Q5@^6;4�OF6;@Ch#@C35352�Q5BN< 0 4)QPO5K;4):)4�6*2�< E���4

4 / OR2�BX6'2�g�@CQ5BN4�y+BXhw}�9;6;h#O5BX4)6'BX6 2M<=2\OPORBXh#@ ��BoORKt2M6;4)6 ,�4)QPO5K;4):)4)6;2�<&35@#O84�}�9;6;BoOF`)@#h#O54)Q53p4)6+@L�9;3lO�y;@ ';6;@,2m3P@#O�4�}!Q5@#hCBXg+Q54�h.2�<�<X2\O5O5BXh#@F`)@#h#OR4�Q53C� � � �;3P9;h[K�O5K*2\O � � � � � � � ��� � � � E > BoORK ��4�}!@C~�E ; E � QP@Cy;@�'*6;@#y 2�3#�

�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � S ; E d�a@C~�E ; E � 3PO5BX<N<!352\ORBN3+'*@#3^D�<X4�h[K$! 3nORK;@#4)Q5@#L�E^��OwBX386;4)� 9;35@�}�9;< OR4"QP@#}�@#Q8OR4�ORK+@m<=2\OPORBXh#@,}�4)QPLM@#y/�0 � � 2\3�O5K;@_y;BXQP@Ch#O�<=2%O5ORBNhC@�2�6+yMORK+@n3P@#O�4�}�g�4)BX6�O53 }�4)QPLM@#y /Z0 QP@Cg�@.2\O5@CyMO5QR2�6+35<=2%ORBX4�6;3�4�} � �2�3?O5K;@FQP@Ch#BXg;QP4�hC2�<I<X2\O5O5BXh#@�Ekv�BN:)9;QP@ ; E-�,3PK;4)��3�@��+2�Lsg;<X@#3W4�} / 4�ORK�O5K;@8y;BNQ5@#h#O�2\6;y�Q5@#hCBNg;Q54�h.2�<<=2%O5ORBNhC@#3�4�} 2�O ��4 ,�y+BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6*2\< ��K;@��+2�:)4�6*2�<�3 0 3lOR@CL|E

��K;@pg;QPBXLsBNORBo`)@_hC@#<X<r4\}�ORK;@8QP@Ch#BXg;QP4�hC2�<r<X2\O5O5BXhC@_BX3?Q5@#}�@#Q5QP@Cy�OR4Y2\3?ORK;@�'*Q53lO_D?Q5BN<X<X4�9;BX6%@C4�6;@S y+@ '*6;@#yYBX6^O5K;@W352�LM@ }�2�35K+BX4)6m2\3!ORK+@Wg;Q5BNLMBoORBo`)@�hC@#<X<�4�}*ORK;@�y;BXQP@Ch�Ok<=2\OPORBNhC@ a E&��6�ORK;@?D?Q5BN<X<X4�9;BX6

Page 71: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

; 8

@C4�6;@���`\2�<N9;@C3p4�}�O5K;@ �W2.`�@#`)@#h#O54)Q / @Ch#4)LM@my+BX35h#Q5@�ORBA@#@CytBN6thC4)QPQ5@C3PgI4�6;y;@C6+hC@YOR4�ORK+@s6Z9;L / @#Q4�}�9;6;BNO�h#@C<N<X3�@���g;<NBXhCBoOR< 0 h#4)6;35BNy;@CQP@Cy�BX6{ORK;@w3 0 3lOR@CL|E d)d � d ; � v*4)Q�gI@#Q5BN4�y;BNhp3 0 3PO5@CLs3���BoORK �9;6;BoO hC@C<N<X3 O5K;@_}�9+6;h#O5BX4)6sL�9;3lO / @�BX6�`\2�Q5BN@C6�O�OR4wORQR2\6;35<X2\ORBN4)6;3 /�0 � ���E ��K+BX3 BX3 2�hCh#4)Lsg;<XBN35K;@#y/�0 35@#OPORBN6;:

� � � � � ��� � ��BNO5K � � � b � ����� � �TE d)d � d ; � d�x � ��O?BX3 9;35@�}�9;<�OR4�y;@�'*6;@_ORK;@FD?Q5BN<X<X4�9;BX6

@C4�6;@F3P4,ORK*2%O�O5K;@F@#6;@CQP: 0 BN3�3 0 LMLs@#O5Q5BXhn2 / 4)9+O ORK;@n4)Q5BN:)BX6s4�}�O5K;@8D�Q5BX<N<X4)9+BX6 @C4�6;@�Ek��K;BN3?hC2�6/ @82�h[K;BN@#`�@Cy /�0 3P@#O5O5BX6;:^ORK;@ngI4)3P35B / <X@_`�2\<X9;@#3?4�} # ���# O54

���� �

�� � ����� � �

�� �

�� 2\6;y"LM4�`�BX6+:^ORK+@

4)QPBX:)BN6TO54 ORK;@�h#@C6�OR@#Qm4�}�ORK+@"D?Q5BN<X<N4)9;BX6 @#4)6;@�Et��O�BX3�2\<X354�9;35@�}�9;<?O54 y;@ ';6;@"hC@#QPO[2\BX6 g�4)BX6�O534�}�K;BX:)K�3 0 LsLM@�ORQ 0 ��BoORK;BN6"ORK;@,D?Q5BN<X<X4�9;BX6 @#4)6;@ �IORK+@^4)QPBX:)BN6{4�}�O5K;@,D�Q5BX<N<X4)9+BX6 @C4�6;@^BN3n:�BN`)@#6ORK+@M3 0 L / 4)< ��2�6+y�g�4)BX6�OR3j2\OjORK+@M3P9;QP}�2�h#@�4�}�ORK;@MD?QPBX<X<N4)9;BN6 @C4)6;@M2�<N4)6;:{y;BXQP@Ch�ORBX4�6;3 �� 4�}K;BN:)KA3 0 LMLs@#O5Q 0 2�Q5@s:)Bo`)@C6TORK;@M3 0 L / 4)< � S @ �+2�LMg+<X@C3j4�}WO5K;@C3P@�g�4)BX6�O53^hC2�6 / @s}�4�9;6;y BN6v�BN:)9;Q5@ ; E>� a E d�x �

> BNO5K;BX6 ORK;@�D?QPBX<X<N4)9;BN6 @C4)6;@\��359;Ql}�2�hC@#3�4�}FhC4)6+3PO[2\6ZO�@C6;@#Q5: 0 hC2�6 / @�y;@�OR@#Q5LsBX6;@#y��?ORK+@y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6�4\} ��K;BNh[K BX3_4)6;@j<X@#353�ORK*2�6�ORK*2\O_4�}�ORK;@^y;BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6{4�}�ORK;@^D?Q5BN<X<N4)9;BX6 @#4)6;@\Env*4)Q@��+2�Lsg;<N@��;BN6�2�O ��4�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<rD?Q5BN<X<N4)9;BX6 @C4)6+@��;ORK+@jh#4)6;3lO[2�6�On@C6;@#Q5: 0 3P9;QP}�2\hC@C3n2�QP@j<NBX6;@#3CE�86;@F3P9;h[K"359+QP}�2�h#@84�}�g*2\QPORBNhC9;<X2�Q�BX6�OR@#Q5@#3POWBN3 O5K;@pv*@CQPLMB�3P9;QP}�2�h#@��+2^359+QP}�2�h#@ ��K;4)3P@8@C6;@#Q5: 0 BN3K*2�<o} , �?2 0�/ @#O ��@C@C6|ORK;@w@#6;@CQP: 0 4�}�ORK;@pK+BX:)K;@#3PO�4�hCh#9;g;BX@#y�Ls4)<N@ChC9+<=2�Q�4)Q / BoO[2�< S �F�jq'� a 2\6;yORK+@,@C6+@CQ5: 0 4�}�ORK;@^<X4)�?@#3POF9;6;4�hChC9+g;BX@#y LM4�<X@Ch#9;<=2\Q�4)Q / BoO[2�< S ��]Fq � a E���K;@,<N4�hC2\ORBN4)6{4�}kORK+@v*@CQPLMB&359+QP}�2�h#@�K*2�3nBXLsgI4)QlO[2�6�O_hC4�6;35@#~�9+@C6;h#@C3jBX6'y+@#OR@#Q5LsBX6;BN6;:MO5K;@,h#4)6;y;9+h#ORBN4)6 g;QP4)g�@CQPO5BX@#34�}�2_L�2%OR@CQPB=2�<VE���K;@?3PBA@#@�4�}+ORK;@ :�2�g / @�O �?@#@C6mORK;@��8�wq ��2�6+y��&]8q � y+@#OR@#Q5LsBX6;@#3��K;@�ORK;@#QORK+@nLM2\OR@#Q5BX2�<+BN3�2whC4�6;y;9;h�OR4)Q#��BN6;359;<X2\OR4�QC�)4)Q�3P@CLsB",�Ls@#OR2�< E!�86;@_y;@ ';6;BNO5BX4)6Y4�}�2jh#4)6;y;9;h�OR4)Q�BN3ORK;2\O / 4�O5KsO5K;@n�8�wq � 2�6+y��&]8q'� BX6�OR@#Q535@#h#O ORK;@_v*@CQPLMB*<N@#`�@C<�2\OkORK+@n352�LM@�g�4)BX6�OCE�fF3%�?2�3y;BN35hC9+3535@#y 2 / 4`�@���`\2�<X9;@#3n4\} �� BN6|O5K;@�D�Q5BX<N<X4)9+BX6 @#4)6;@�2\Q5@jy;BX3PhCQ5@�ORB @C@CyrE�f g�@CQPBX4�y;BXhp3 0 3lOR@#LBX3W2Yh#4)6;y;9+h#OR4�Q�BN}!2\O�<X@C2�3POW4)6;@p4�}&ORK+@^2\<X<X4)��@Cy�`\2�<N9;@C3�4�} �� g*2�3P35@#3�O5K;Q54�9;:)K|2mgI4)BN6�O ��K;@CQP@ORK+@^�F�wq � 2�6;y|�&]8q'� OR4)9+h[K�ORK+@^v*@#Q5LsBr359+QP}�2�h#@�E

�SV �WV � � �%���1� �� � ����� ��� �����D?<X4�h[K"}�9;6;h�ORBX4�6;3C�;@#~�E ; E � �*2�Q5@py+@C<X4�h.2\<XBA@#@Cy�4�`�@CQ�ORK;@ph[K*2\BX6|2�6;y{Q5@ � @Ch�O�ORK;@wg�@CQ5BN4�y+BXhCBoO 0

4�}�ORK+@sy+BXQ5@#h#Op<X2\O5O5BXh#@�E d ; � ��}��?@ ��BN35KtOR4"@ �;2\LMBN6;@m<X4�h.2�<NBA@#@Cy'g+K;@C6;4�LM@#6*2+��ORK;@#6t}�9;6;h#O5BX4)6+3ORK;2\O{2�QP@ <X4�h.2�<NBA@#@Cy 4�6 9+6;BNO�hC@C<N<X3 ��4)9;<Ny / @t9+35@#}�9+< E d)d � >�2�6;6;BN@CQ�}�9;6+h#ORBN4)6;3#� � �

����

�S �� a �

2�QP@�2{O 0 g�@�4\}?}�9;6;h�ORBN4)6TO5K*2\O^BX3jgI@#Q5BN4�y;BNhmBX6 ORK;@MQ5@#hCBXg+Q54�h.2�<k<X2\O5O5BXhC@s2�6+y�<X4�h.2\<XBA@#@CytBN6AORK+@

Page 72: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

; c

v�BN:)9;Q5@ ; E d �?i �+2�Lsg;<N@C3_4�}�O5K;@,QP@ChCBNg;Q54�h.2\<�<=2\OPORBXh#@C3�}�4)Q S 2 a 2�6�4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<�h[K*2\BX6�� S�/*a2sO ��4�y+BXLs@C6;3PBX4)6*2\<�hC9 / BXhjQ5@Ch#BXg;QP4�hC2�<�<=2%O5ORBNhC@\��2�6;y S h a 2MK;@ �+2�:)4)6*2\<�QP@Ch#BXg;QP4�hC2�<�<=2\OPORBNhC@�E���[email protected]\h[K�<X2\O5O5BXhC@w2\6|@ �+2�LMg+<X@p4�}�2sg�4)3P35B / <X@8h[K;4�BXhC@p}�4)Q �� 4�} � � � � � BX3�3PK;4)��6�E

y;BNQ5@Ch�Ok<=2%O5ORBNhC@\E d ; � ��K;@�v*4)9;QPBX@#Q�35@#Q5BN@C3 }�4)Q�ORK;@��?2.`)@�}�9;6;h#O5BX4)6sLM2 0^/ @���Q5BoO5OR@#6Y2�3k28g�@CQPBX4�y;BXh}�9;6;h�ORBN4)6{BX6"ORK;@wQP@ChCBNg;Q54�h.2\<�<=2\OPORBNhC@��

� � ��

���� S �� a � �

������� S �� � �� a � � � � � S ; E ; a

��K;@#Q5@YORK;@Y359+L BX3p4�`)@#Q,2�<N< <=2%O5ORBNhC@,`�@Ch�OR4)QP3CEs��K;@s>�2�6;6+BX@CQ8}�9+6;h#O5BX4)6TBX38O5K;@C6 ORK;@sBX6�`�@CQ53P@v*4)9;QPBX@CQ�ORQR2\6;3P}�4)QPL 4�}�ORK;@jD?<N4�h[K"}�9;6+h#ORBN4)6;3#�

������ S �� � �� a � b

� ��

� � � � � ��� �

������ S �� a � S ; E x)a

��K;@#Q5@�� � ��

���� S �� a 2�QP@�O5K;@ LM4)<N@Ch#9;<=2�Q �W2.`�@#}�9;6;h�ORBN4)6;3 ��QPBNO5O5@C6jBX6jD?<N4�h[Kp}�4)QPL�E&> K;BX<N@�� �

������ S �� a

BX3^2�3P354�hCB=2%OR@Cy ��BNO5K 2�g;2�QPO5BXhC9+<=2�Q��?2�`�@#`�@Ch#O54)Q S ��;a 4�}WO5K;@�<X2\O5O5BXh#@���ORK;@s> 2\6;6;BX@#Qj}�9+6;h#O5BX4)6��������

�S �� a �*BN3�2Y<N4�hC2�<XB @C@#y�}�9;6;h�ORBX4�6�h#@C6�OR@#Q5@Cy�4)6{ORK;@w9;6;BoO�hC@#<X<VE

� �� � � � � � ����� ��� � � � � � ��� � � � � � ��� ��� � T � ���� � � � ��� R

� � ��� � �

fF3?2�6M@ �+2�LMg+<X@_4�}�K;4)� g�@CQPBX4�y;BXhW}�9;6+h#ORBN4)6;3 h.2�6 / @_9;3P@Cy�O54^4 / O[2�BN6MBN6+}�4)Q5LM2\O5BX4)6m2 / 4)9�OORK+@T3 0 3POR@#L�����@ ��BX<X<nhC4)6+35BXy+@CQ"ORK;@T�n2�QPO5Q5@C@ ,�v*4�h[u-g;Q54 / <X@#L ��BNO5K;BX6�g�@CQPBX4�y;BXh / 4)9;6;y;2�Q 0

Page 73: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

x �

hC4�6;y;BNO5BX4)6+3CE G�OR2�QPO ��BoORK|2 �W2.`)@�}�9;6;h�ORBX4�6�}�4)Q�2Y4)6;@ ,�y;BNLM@#6;35BN4)6*2�<Ih[K*2�BX6r�

# � � � b� �

��

� ��� � # � � � S ; E = a

��K;@#Q5@�BN3�2m9;6;BNO�h#@C<N<�BX6;y;@ �I��� BN3WORK;@pO54�O[2�<r6�9+L / @#Qn4\}�9;6+BNO�hC@#<X<N3C� � BX3WO5K;@��W2.`)@�`)@#h#OR4�QC�

� � � ���?2�6;y # � � BX3mORK+@{>�2�6;6+BX@CQm}�9;6+h#ORBN4)6 hC@C6�O5@CQ5@#y�4)6 ORK;@|9;6;BoOMh#@C<N<

�E�J?4�6;35BNy;@CQM2

:)@#6;@CQ52�< 4)g�@CQ52\OR4)Q#� � ��ORK*2\O8y;@Cg�@C6;y+3j4�6;< 0 4)6 ORK+@my;BX3lO[2�6;h#@ / @�O �?@#@C6A9;6;BNO8hC@C<N<X3#� � � � �X�rORK+@v*4�h[uF4)gI@#QR2\O54)QC� � 2�6;ywORK;@ �F2\LMBN<NOR4�6;B=2�6r� �AE���K;@ @���g�@Ch#OR2\ORBN4)6p`\2�<X9;@k4\} � }�4)Q�O5K;@ }�9;6;h�ORBN4)6� BX3WO5K;@C6

� � � � # � # � � � b��� � �

� � ��� � � � � # � # � � � ��� � S ; E 8)a

� b��� � �

� ����� � � � �� � � # � # � �

S ���� � � a hC2�6 / @wQP@ ��Q5BoO5O5@C6|2�3 ��S

�� � a � S � �

��;a � 2�6+y{O5K;@wy;BX3lO[2�6+hC@ / @#O ��@C@C6'9;6;BNO

hC@#<X<N3�y;@ '*6+@Cy 2\3 � � S�� � a E�G�9 / 3lORBNO59+ORBN6;:mORK;@#35@wQ5@#<=2\O5BX4)6+3�BX6�OR4m@#~�E ; E 8 :)BN`�@C3#�

� � � � # � # � � � b��� � �

� ��� �� � ����� � � � � � � # � # � � � S ; E c)a

� @Ch.2\<X<IO5K*2\OWO5K;@84)g�@CQ52\OR4�Q � y;@#gI@#6;y;3�4)6;< 0 4�6�ORK;@8y+BX3POR2�6;h#@ / @�O �?@#@C6|9;6;BNOWhC@C<N<X3�6;4�OWO5K;@CBNQ2 / 3P4)<X9�OR@pg�4)35BoORBX4�6�4)6"ORK;@ph[K;2�BX6��;2�6;y{354YORK;@pLM2\O5Q5B"��@C<N@CLs@C6�OR3 / @#O ��@C@#6'9;6+BNO�h#@C<X<N3 � 2\6;y�BX3

� � # � ���� � � � � # � ��� � � � S ; E b � a

��6 359+LMLM2\ORBN4)6;3w4�`)@#Q � ��ORK;@�35@Ch#4)6;y @ �+g�4)6;@#6�ORB=2\<?BX6A@C~�E ; E c QP@Cy;9+hC@C3�O54 � � � � E ]_35BN6;:@C~Z9*2%ORBX4�6 ; E b � �;@C~�E ; E c hC2�6 / @wQ5@���Q5BoO5OR@#6 �

� � � � # � # � � � ��

� ��� �� � � # � ��� � � � � � � S ; E b)ba

J?K;4)BNhC@#3w}�4�QwO5K;@m`\2�<X9;@#3p4�} � 2\6;y � hC4�Q5Q5@#35g�4)6;y;BN6;:"OR4{ORK*2%Ow4�}?3P@Ch�ORBX4�6 ; E-�+E � hC2�6 / @Y4 / ,O[2\BX6;@#y{}�4�Q?ORK;@w@ �+g�4)6;@#6�ORB=2\<�BX6{@C~�E ; E b)bp/�0 3P@#O5O5BX6;: � � � �� 2\6;y|2�<X<N4 ��BN6;: � OR4YQ52�6;:)@p4�`)@#Q

���� �

�� � ����� � �

�� �

�� ��� 4�y;y�E

Page 74: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

x+b

�SV�� V � � $�/ ��� ��� � � � ��� � � ��� Y�������� �� ��� �� � Z �+� � ! ��&��� � � � �"Z������ ��

�!4�BX<X<N9;3PO5QR2\O5@pORK;@^9;35@^4�}�@C~�E ; E b�b }�4)QF2M35g�@Ch#B('*h^4)g�@CQR2%OR4)Q#� ������@ ��BX<N<�y;@#O5@CQ5LsBX6+@^ORK+@@C6+@CQ5: 0 4�}�2,<NBX6;@C2�Q h[K*2�BX6�4�} ��2\O54)LM3#��3P9;h[K|2�3?O5K*2\OW3PK;4)��6{BX6"v�BN:)9;QP@ ; E b E ��K+@p@C6;@#Q5: 0 4�}ORK+@j3 0 3POR@#L h.2�6 / @jy+@#OR@#Q5LsBX6;@#y /�0 �

� S ��;a � � � � # � # �

�� � � # �

�� S ; E b � a

G�9 / 3PORBoOR9+O5BX6;:Y@#~�E ; E b)b BN6ZO54Y@C~�E ; E b � �*2�6+y�3PBX6;h#@��;}�4)Q # � � 4�}!@C~�E ; E>=�� � � � # � � � b �

�� S ��;a � � � � # � # �

� � ��

� ��� �� � � # � # � � � S ; E b � a

��6�� 9;h[u�@#<�ORK;@#4)Q 0 �

� � # � # � � ������� ����� � �� � � ���� � � � ����� �� � ������������! "�

# ;%$ �'&�(

�����)��� ��* + ,�-���.�0/%1324�-�056��/��)��7�892�/�: � ! ,�-�;�<���0=;=�!/�7>!/?����70��2�@A�B���05C��/��<2D�-�05E���F�-�;�/��HG%� $�I%J;K "��+� J �-!��/L���M�)N $ ;%$ �'& +/����O�)N $ ;%$ �QP �"�� J @+�- F!/L2�/R�SG%=��"�� " �!��/R�B�0�>����� K 24/�: "��� J�T � J �"�U�4�V2��0/��H13:�+5F�)/� �+�0/W2�@YX>ZJ�T\[ ��@ T �W2�+/A]

� # �� ( � �^* � #�� ( �

� ��� �� �� � � � �

� � � � � #`_ $ � _ (

� �^* � #�� (ba � ��� � � � ��� Hc

� �^*�ed � ��� # � � ( �

f +7 J ��� _ $ _ "���Q�� g����� K 2�/�:h "��� J�T � J �"�i�B���j��N $ _ $ � _ $kI +/ T � ��� # � � ( ! l=m����+�%:; T �Qn0�)��-�;�.��2�/�70� � � ��� � ]W��N $ _ $ � _ 2�/�: f !7 J ��� _ $ _ "���-2�+70�?���B�0���o2��":�@+8p!@+@ J ��-�-2D�-�q�;�r� T ���s�0 �+/�7� � � �� 2�/�:t2�@+@!�Q��!/�7 � �-�u��2�/�70�v�Qn0��� � �

�� �

�� � ����� � �

�� �

�� ] � �s:�:A]0�"� � � T �- w�����o=m����+�%:; T �38

���x�-���M�HG;=m�0/��)/?�-y24@ $

Page 75: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� d

Γ

Ε0 − 2 β

Ε0 + 2 β

f +7 J ��� _ $ _���� 2�/�:p ��-� J�T � J ��� "�0@ J �-!��/� ��� ��N $ _ $ � _ �B���b2�/F�0/�� :�!5>��/� "!�0/�2�@W!/���/�+��� T ��2�!/ $� ���)��� � ! u�-���>�0�"!70+/ ���b����� � ��!@+@!� J !/�)�0/��F2�/�: � ! .2 = �0+/?�U��/i�����F J �"��2 T �>���o�-�;�� �"!@!@+� J +/����/��.2�@!�0/;7 �-���M:�+��� T �-+�0/ �� +/�:� T 24����: !/ f +7 J ��� _ $ & # 2 ( $

Page 76: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� P

� � ��� ����

� � � � ��� � � ��� � �� ����� ��� � ��� � � ��� ��!�"� � � � ����� #!$ �%� � � � #&� �%� � ���"�# � � � �'� � ( �*) � ��+ � ,.-�/102/435� � � � � + � � �

6 ��� � + � � �87

9;:=< >@?4A�BDC;EGFGH.A�IJCK?LNMPORQTS 7PUWVYXJZ\[ MP] 8_^`XbaTcdUeafXgU Oih ^`[ M aTVYU O Vkj ] Uecfc Mel�M a"7mU Onh jocfXJ^ h j MPO Z S jJV M afc.VYpnUWVd^qU'8r X S cTX lsSn]tlsM auVfpnXvj MPO cTVfa S jwV hxMPO4Melzy URVNcTjbafXJX O Z h cf[ ] UQ8_c|{~}��_�e���_VfaYU O c h c�V M aTc={����R��U O Z ] UecfXJafc|{����� ���d�.pnX�X ] XbjwVYa MPOnh j�cTVfa S jwV S aTX Mel VYpnXJcfX�^KUWVYXJa h U ] c h c�� Snh VYX�j M ^`[ ] X�����U O Z�j MeO cTVfa S jwVYc r M a��

a M=� XbZ r M VYp l a M ^�VYpnX�[np M V M [�p�8_c h jbc MWl@M a�7mU Onh j�^ MP] Xbj Sn] XJckU O Z4VfpnXo[np M V M [�p�8_c h jbc Mel r Sn]��cfXJ^ h j MPO Z S jJV M afc�p�U| PXq[na M  PX O¡S cTX lsSn]uh�O VYpnX h a�ZnXbcTjba h [�V hxMPO �4¢£jbX O VYaYU ] 7 M U ]DMel VYp�X �uM a �[naTXbcfX O VYXbZ5pnXJafX h c@V M ZnXw PX ]�M [�^`XJVfp M Znc¤U O Z�V M_MP] c@Vfp�UWV lsS aTVfpnXba�[na M ^ M VfXDVfpnX hxO VfX�7PafUWV hxMPOgMelVYp�XbcfX¥V �NM Ue[�[na M UWj¦pnXbcJ�o�.pnX�§ O VYXJaf^`XbZ h UWVYX�¨�X)7 ] XJjJV MWlª©ohx« XbafX O V h U ]¤¬  eXba ] Ue[®­s§¯¨ ©g¬g° {~�P±��^`XJVYp M Z4pnUec r XJX O²lsMPSnO Z4V M r X�� Snh VfX S cfX lsSn]³hxO ZnXbcTjba h r hxO 7�VYpnXv[np M V M [np?8_c h jJc Mel ^KXJZ h�S ^5�c hx´ X M a"7mU Onh j²^ MP] Xbj Sn] XJcbµkp M=� XJ eXbab�dj S afaTX O V h ^K[ ] Xb^`X O VYUWV hxMPO c MWl §¯¨ ©g¬ VYpnX M a"8®^KU'8 r XUe[n[ ]�h XJZ MeOn] 8¡V M'MP]xh 7 M ^KXJafc Mel j MPORQTS 7mUWVYXJZ¶[ MP] 8_^`XbaTc={·�¸±����º¹�XJafXe� � X Z�XJ PX ]�M [1VYpnX;V M_MP] cO XJXbZnXJZ!V M [�XJa lsM aT^ §¯¨ ©g¬ j|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO c �dh Vfp h�O [tXba h�M Z h j r MeSnO Z�Uea�8¶j MPO Z h V hxMPO cb��.p h c7PX O XbafUWVYXJcuj MPO cTVfa S jwVYcªc S j¦p4Uec�VYpnX r U O ZKc�VYa S jJV S afX�U O Z5»¡U O�Onh XJa lsSnO jJV h�MPO cDVfp�UWVªpnX ] [5j|Uec�V

Page 77: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �VYp�XiaTXbc Sn] Vfc hxO VfpnX ] U O 7 S U�7PX MWl c MP]�h Z�� c�V¦UWVfX²[np?8�c h jJcb�¶§ O UeZnZ h V hxMPO ��VYp�X S cfX Mel [tXba h�M Z h jr MPSnO Z�UWa"8 j MPO Z h V h�MPO c`^KU � XJc4j|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO c MPO¶] Uea"7PX\c�8_cTVYXJ^Kcqj M ^`[ S VYUWV hxMPO U ]x] 8 l XbUec h r ] XU O Z��³Z S X�V M VYpnX h�O VYa M Z S jJV hxMPO�Mel VfpnX2jba�8_cTV¦U ] ^ M ^KX O V S ^*Uec�Uj7 M_M Z � S U O V S ^ O¸S ^ r XbaJ�U h Znc hxO VYpnX h�O VYXJaf[naTXJV¦URV h�MeO�Mel VYp�Xkj M ^`[ ] Xw�¥X O XJa�7�8m� ] XJ eX ] c�VYa S jJV S afXkVfp�UWV�UWa h cTXbc l a M ^ §¯¨ ©g¬j|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO c MPO;] Uea"7PX�c"8_cTVfXb^`cb��.pnXbcTX V M�Me] c�UWafXkXJcf[tXbj h U ]�] 8 S cfX lsS�]�lsM a�c�V S Z;8 hxO 7�VYpnX.[np M V M [�p�8_c h jbc MWl j MPORQTS 7PUWVYXJZ`[ MP] 8¸�

^`Xbafc �dh Vfp�^ M afX¥Vfp�U O�MeO X2UejwV h  eX� WU ] X O jbX�U O ZGj MPO Z S jwV hxMPO r U O Z³� � S j¦p MelDMeS avj S afaTX O VVYp�X M aTXJV h j|U ]tSnO Z�Xbafc�V¦U O Z h�O 7 MWl VYpnXoX ] XJjJVYa MPOnh jvcTVfa S jwV S aTX Mel j MeORQTS 7mUWVfXbZ²[ MP] 8_^`XbaTc h c r UecTXbZMPO c�V S Z h Xbc¤[�XJa lsM aT^KXJZ MPO V �uM � r U O Z2c"8_c�VYXb^`cb�mc S j¦p`Uec¤VfpnX���� X ] XJjJVfa MPO ^ M ZnX ]_Mel [ MP] 8PUejbXwV38m�] X O Xe� lsM a � p h j¦p;VfpnXbaTX h c MeOn] 8 MPO XoV38_[tX Mel p MP] XoU O Z MPO XvV38_[tX Mel X ] XJjJVfa MPO {·�������|�n����±���� � � ��.p h c ]xh ^ h VYcuVYpnX O_S ^ r XJa Mel [�UeafUe^KXwVYXJafc hxO VfpnX�^ M ZnX ] U O Z ^KU � XJc h V [ M cfc h r ] X�V M X���[ ]�M aTXU �dh ZnX`aYU O 7PX MWl [�UeafUe^`XJVYXJagcf[�UejJXe�²§ O Z�XbXbZ��¤c S j¦p¡cTV S Z h XJc�p�U| eXqafXw PXbU ] XJZ'^KU O 8 7PX O XJaYU ]l X|URV S aTXbc MWl VYpnX�[np M V M [np?8_c h jbcJ� h�O j ]�S Z h�O 72VfpnX O URV S aTX Mel VYpnX��W¢��gX ] XJjJVYa MPOnh j�c�V¦UWVfXm{��|�n�@��±R�U O Z;VYp�X�XJcfcTX O V h U ] cTVYUWVYXJc Vfp�UWVdZ M ^ h�O UWVYXvVfpnX OnMPOn]xh�O XbUea M [�V h jbU ] aTXbcf[ MPO cTXm{�� � ���

��� U O Z2^qU O 8 M VYpnXJa�j MPO�QTS 7mUWVfXbZ2[ MP] 8_^`XbafcJ�Pp M=� XJ PXJab��p�U| PX U O¸S ^ r Xba Mel r U O Znc�VYp�URV[�Uea�V h j h [nUWVYX h�O VYp�Xv[np M V M [np?8_c h jbcNU O ZqVfp h cDaYU h cfXJc O X � U O Z h�O VYXJafXbc�V hxO 7�� S XJcTV hxMPO cªVYp�UWVNUeaTXr X�7 hxOnOnh�O 7qV M r X2UeZnZnaTXbcTcfXbZz{ �����@�� ��@���e�z�P�R�����¸V S Z h Xbc Mel VfpnXbcTX`c�8_cTVYXJ^Kc�UeaTX2j M ^`[ ]xh j|URVYXbZr 8 VYp�X ] Uea�7eX O¸S ^ r Xba Mel [�UeafUe^KXwVYXJafc²[naTXbcfX O V hxO ^ M ZnX ] c Mel ^ Sn] V h � r U O Z c"8_cTVfXb^`c U O ZVYp�X�� O Z h�O 7&VYp�URVq^KU O 8 [nafXJZ h jwV h�MeO c`UeafX\cfX O c h V h  eX\V M VYp�X j¦p MPh jbX Mel VfpnXbcTX�[�UeafUe^KXwVYXJafcb�§¯¨ ©g¬ p�Uec�VfpnX²UeZ� eU O VYU�7PX Mel [na M   h Z h�O 7GU�c"8_cTVfXb^KUWV h j²Ue[n[�a M Uej¦p%V M VYpnX²ZnXwVYXJaf^ h�O UWV h�MPOMel VYpnXJcfXi[�UeaYUW^KXwVYXbaTc l a M ^�VfpnX;j¦pnXb^ h jbU ] cTVfa S jwV S aTXe��� h  eX O VYpnX;j¦pnXJ^ h j|U ] c�VYa S jJV S afX MelM a"7mU Onh jK^ MP] XJj Sn] XbcJ�¤§¯¨ ©g¬ p�UWc r XJX O � Snh VYXqc S jbjJXbcTc lsSn].hxO [naTXbZ h jJV hxO 7 VfpnXq[np M V M [�p�8_c h j|U ][na M [�XJaTV h XbcJ� § V4VfpnXbaTX lsM aTX�[na M   h Z�Xbc;U S cTX lsSn] cTVYUeaTV h�O 7¡[ MPhxO V lsM aqc�V S Z h Xbc Mel ^ Sn] V h � r U O Zj MeORQTS 7mUWVfXbZi[ Me] 8_^KXJakc"8_c�VYXb^`cb�¢vcdU���aTcTV Ue[n[ ]�h jbUWV hxMPOqMWl VfpnXbcTXoV M_MP] cJ� � X�[nafXJcfX O V�cTV S Z h Xbc Mel VYp�X�X ] XJjJVfa MPOnh jocTVfa S jwV S aTXMel ��� �dU O!h ^`[ M a�V¦U O Vqj|U O Z h Z�UWVfX&^qUWVfXba h U ]dlsM a y UWV�� cTjbafXJX O Z h cT[ ] U'8¶VfXbj¦p O�MP]�M 7 h XbcJ��§ O

[�Uea�V h j Sn] Ueab� � X5j MPO c h Z�XbaoVYp�X M a h 7 h�O MWl VfpnX`}�� ±qX VYaYU O c h V h�MeO�h�O VfpnX�� ��� §��Gcf[tXbjJVfa S ^Mel ���� {��P�_� �e}�� �W�n� �e��� � � ���q�.p h c�VYafU O c h V hxMPO r XJj M ^`Xbc�U ]x]�M=� XJZ MeOn] 8\VYpna MPS 7Pp X ] XbjJVfa MPO �p MP] X�c"8_^`^KXwVYa�8 r afXbU �¸h�O 7��@U O Z&pnXbaTX � X5Xw��[ ]xM afX� WUea h�MPS co^KXJj¦p�U Onh cf^`c lsM a r aTX|U �¸hxO 7²VYp h cc"8_^`^KXwVYa�8P���.pnX lsM aT^qU ]xh cT^ h ckZnXw PX ]xM [tXbZ h�O ��XbjW� � � ��U O Z²VYpnXgZnXwV¦U hx] c MWl VfpnXgj|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO cUeaTX.7 h  PX O;h�O ��XbjW� � � }�� lsMP]�]xM=� XJZ r 8;U2Z h cfj S cfc h�MPOih�O ��XJje� � �~�n�

Page 78: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �9;:�� �²C`B�� ���|I��� ������� ������������� ���! #"%$�.pnXv§¯¨ ©g¬ ¹vUe^ h�] V MPO�h U O�h cuZ h cfj S cfcTXbZ hxO ZnXwV¦U hx] h�O'& X l ��{~�P±R���_U O Z h cDc S ^`^qUWa h�´ XbZ`pnXbaTX

UWVNU ] Xw PX ] VYpnUWVNXJcTVYU r ]�h cfpnXJcuVfpnX OnM VYUWV hxMPO ���.pnX MPO X�� X ] XbjwVYa MPO ^KUWVYa h �`X ] Xb^`X O Vfc MPO U�c hxO 7 ] XUWV M ^\� (*),+ ) �NUeafX M r V¦U hxO XbZ l a M ^�VYpnX � ] UWVYXJa�� LNMeO Z MPO%l UejwV M aTcb�.-uXJV � XbX O UWV M ^`cb�DVYp�X MPO XX ] XbjwVYa MeO ^KUWVYa h �qX ] Xb^`X O VYcdUeaTXM7 h  eX O r 8e�

­0/2143657108 °:9<;= ),+ >¤­@?�ACBD?%E °�F �HG ­ � �x� °� pnXJafX ;= ),+ > h c`VYpnX M  eXba ] Ue[ r XJV � XbX O VfpnXI/@JLK�U O ZM8NJLK M a r h V¦U ] cb�kcTj|U ] XbZ c S j¦p VYp�URVqVYp�X �M  PXJa ] UW[nc r XwV � XJX OPO � M a r h VYU ] c�UeafX²^ Sn] V h [ ]xh XbZ r 8 �P� � �P� U O Z®VfpnXRQ M  PXba ] Ue[�c r XJV � XbX OSO �M a r h VYU ] c�UeafX�^ S�] V h [ ]�h XbZ r 8 �� ���m����?�A2U O ZT?%EKUeafX�cTXb^ h � XJ^K[ h a h j|U ] [�UWaYUe^`XJVfXbafc³Vfp�UWV@ZnXJ[�X O ZMPOn] 8 MPO VYpnX�afXJcf[tXbjJV h  eX�X ] Xb^`X O VYcJ�N�.pnX M  PXba ] Ue[�c r XJV � XbX O � ] UWVfXba M a r h VYU ] cdUWafX�j|U ] j Sn] UWVYXJZS c h�O 72VYp�X�^`XJVfp M Z MWlU Xba O U O Z�X ´V& h j MXWZY\[^] {��P±�� �»'X S cTX'j¦pnXJ^ h cTV_~c OnM V¦URV h�MeOºlsM a;VfpnX&V �NM X ] XJjJVfa MPOnh j h�O VYX)7PaYU ] cb��­@/`8T1�a�b ° {~� �W���c- M VfpLNMPSn]xM ^ r U O Z;Xw��j¦p�U O 7eX hxO VYX�7eaYU ] ckUeaTX�afXJVYU h�O XbZ lsM a M a r h V¦U ] cuaTXbc h Z h�O 7 MPO VYpnX�cfUe^`X�UWV M ^\�

­@/d/21@8*8 °fe JLgdh A 9ji A)k+ > ­ � � � °­0/`8l1@8�/ ° e JLgmh A 9on A),+ > G ­ � � } °

�.pnXJcfXuUeafX M r V¦U hxO XbZ l a M ^ VYp�X�� ] UWVfXba¯� LNMPO Z MPO�l UejJV M afc@Uec hxOT& X l �¸{~�P±R�����.pnX ´ Xba M Z h « XJafX O V h U ]M  PXJa ] UW[ Ue[�[na M � h ^KUWV hxMPO4h cdUecfc S ^KXJZ r XJV � XbX O UWV M ^KcJ�­0/`8T1�a�b °:9qp A%+ EsrZ),+ >�rZtu+ v ­ � ��� °

� pnXJafX²VYpnXR/ JLK M a r h VYU ]ªh c MPO UWV M ^�¢¥��U O Z%VfpnXwa JLK M a r h V¦U ]uh c MeO URV M ^<-v� p Ax+ E h c�U ] c MS cTXbZGV M ZnXJcfjJa h r X�VYp�X LNMPSn]�M ^ r afXJ[ Sn] c h�MeO r XwV � XJX O O¸S j ] X h �³U O Z�VYp�X5UWVfVfaYUejwV h�MeO r XwV � XJX OU O X ] XbjJVfa MPOiMPO UWV M ^ ¢ U O ZiVfpnX�j M aTX MWl UWV M ^y-v���.pnX � UWVYU�7mUR� ¨ h cfp h ^ M V M�lsM aT^ h c S cTXbZlsM a p Ax+ E

p Ax+ E 9 z|{� z{ F ­ p A�ACB p ExE ° BM}�~�Ax+ E ­ � � � °� pnXJafX p A%+ A h c.VYp�X�¹ S rnr UeaTZ [�UWaYUe^`XJVfXba lsM a�UWV M ^�¢�� U O ZX~�Ax+ E h c.VYpnX�Z h cTV¦U O jbX r XwV � XJX OUWV M ^Kc ¢ U O Z�-v�t�.pnX lsM aT^ S cfXJZ h�O §¯¨ ©g¬ h c Xb� Snh  WU ] X O VvV M VYpnUWV MWl�� � ��­ � � � °k�dh VYp�} 9

Page 79: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P�� F ��� ���³Uq eU ]�S X¥j¦p M cfX O V M²M r VYU h�O r XJVTVYXbaoU�7PafXJXb^`X O V �dh Vfp�VYpnX2cT[�XJjJVfa S ^ MWl r X On´ X O Xm{~�P±e� �- S VNUWV ]�MPO 7�aYU O 7PXe�¸VYp�X�[ M VYX O V h U ]th cªVfpnX O cTVYa MPO 7PXJaªVfp�U O U r UeaTX LNMPS�]�M ^ r lsM afjJXe��U O Z`VYp h ch c OnM VkUe[n[na M [na h UWVYX lsM a ] Uea�7eX�c�8�c�VYXJ^Kc.c S j¦piUecNVYp M cfXoj MPO c h ZnXJafXbZ;pnXJafXW��§ O [�UeaTV h j Sn] UeaJ�mVYp h c�uMPSn] Z&cTXbaT eX2V M aYU h cfX�VfpnX2Xw��j h V MeO r h�O Z hxO 7²X O Xba�748P��§ O VYp�X2j|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO cv[�afXbcTX O VYXJZ'pnXJafXW�� X S cTX } 9 �P��.pnX U M j �4M [tXbafUWV M ab� � a h VfVfX O;h�O UWV M ^ h j M a r h V¦U ] cb� h ckVYpnX O ��

/�G //����

9 (*),+ ) B �>�A� >f+ > � i A>f+ )�� �� n A>f+ )�� ­ � � � °

B �E��� A�� E ��� E������� p A%+ E�/�G�8/�G�8����

9 ),+ > � } � n A)k+ > � �� i A)k+ > � ­ � � ± °

�/�G�8)!� Ax+ >�|E

9 ;= ),+ > ­@?�A B ?%E °� � �� ),+ > p A%+ E ­ � � � °

� pnXJafXl/uU O Z 8 ] U r X ] UWV M ^ h j M a r h V¦U ] cb�"� U O Z$# ] U r X ] UWV M ^KcJ� )k+ > h c.VfpnXgZnX O c h V38²^KUWVfa h ��� E h ckVfpnX�V M VYU ] X ] XbjwVYa MeO ZnX O c h V38 MPO UWV M ^%#q� U O Z � E����� h ckVYp�X�j M afXgj¦p�UWa�7PX Mel UWV M ^y-v�U�M akU�[ MP] 8_^`Xba �dh VYp'& SnOnh VNjbX ]�] ckU O Z²[tXba hxM Z h j r MPS�O Z�Uea�8qj MPO Z h V h�MeO cb�_VYpnXo^ MP] Xbj S�] UeaM a r h VYU ] ck^KU'8 r X � a h VTVYX O �(((*),+ t -. e0/2143 9 �5 & � /76 )ft / � e98 + t-e + . e:/;1 (((((=< >,? G ­ � � � °

� pnXJafXdVYpnX OnM VYUWV hxMPO ((((( < > ? �dhx]�] r X S cfXJZKVfpna MPS 7Pp MPS VDVfp h c�[�UW[�XJaDV Mgh�O Z h j|UWVfXkVYpnX > JLKoURV M ^ h jM a r h VYU ]�h�O VYpnX < JLK SnOnh VNjJX ]�] ��� On] XJcfc M VfpnXba �dh cTX OnM VfXbZ³��U ]�] c S ^`ckUeaTX M  PXJaNVYpnX�X O V h afX�aYU O 7eXMel VYpnXdc S ^K^KUWV hxMPO2h�O ZnXw��� h �~Xe� < 9 ���2�;�@& ���.pnX ] U r X ] c�A > <CB U O ZRa2ZnX OnM VYXdVYp�X r U O Z4U O Z� U= eXJ eXbjJV M a Mel VYp h c M a r h V¦U ] �la 9ED 8 �dh VYp 8\U OGh�O VYX)7PXba r XwV � XJX O �5U O ZF&��@U O Z D'9HG�IJ �- M Vfp < U O ZR8²UWafX h�O  WUea h U O V �dh VYpiafXJcf[tXbjJVvV M UWZnZ h V h�MPO;Mel &���U O Z h V h c Mel VYX O j MeO  eX Onh X O VV M5S cTX�VfpnXgaYU O 7PX �LK �2�2� K � �dh Vfp K 9 J�M 5G U O ZN& M Z�Z³�

Page 80: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� ±¨ M VfX�VYp�UWV lsM a a��9 �� 8 + t-e + . e0/21 h cdj M ^K[ ] Xw�����.pnXgZnX O c h V38;^qUWVfa h � h ckVYpnX O �

/ + h� 1 9 �& � t g ����. e0/21 6 ) t + / M h - 8 + t-� + . e:/;1 8 + t-��1 + . e:/;1 � ­ � � � °�.pnX U M j �4M [tXbafUWV M a h c r ]�M j � Z h U47 MPO U ]�h�O VYpnX � U| eXJ PXJjJV M ala�� ] XbUeZ h�O 75V M & r ]xM j � c Mel VYp�XlsM aT^\� � + t -e + . 9 � / 6 M ) t / � / + �e . G ­ � � �P� °� pnXJafX � / + �e . h c VfpnX U M j �;M [tXbaYURV M a h�O VYpnX¥UWV M ^ h j r Uec h cb� � �_cJ��­ � � � � � � � ° � ©oS X¥V M [tXba h�M Z h jr MPSnO Z�UWa"8&j MeO Z h V h�MPO cb� U O URV M ^ h c h�O  WUea h U O V�V M Z h cf[ ] UejJXb^`X O V r 8 &��4� � pnXJafX� h cgVYp�X-Na h�]�]xh�MPS�O  eXbjJV M adj MPO�O XbjwV h�O 7 S�Onh V.jJX ]x] cb�¤§ O Xw WU ]�S URV h�O 7 � / + �e . ��VYp�XgUWV M ^`c.UeaTX�Z h cT[ ] UWjbXbZ4V MM r VYU h�O VfpnXgcfp M aTVYXJcTV�Z h c�V¦U O jbXgj MPO c h c�VYX O V �dh Vfp²VYpnXg[tXba hxM Z h j r MPSnO ZnUea"8²j MPO Z h V hxMPO cb��.pnX�¹vUea�VYafXJXw� U M j � c MP]�S V h�MPO5h c M r V¦U h�O XJZ h VYXbafUWV h  PX ] 8P�ecTV¦UWaTV hxO 7 �dh VfpqU�Z h U�7 MPO U ] ZnX O c h V38

^KUWVYa h ��j MeO cTVfa S jwVYXbZ5c S j¦p2VYp�UWV�VYpnXkUWV M ^`c�UeafX O X S VfaYU ] U O Z�VfpnXkX ] XbjwVYa MeO ZnX O c h V38 h c�Xb� S U ]x] 8Z h cTVYa h r S VYXbZ�Ue^ MeO 7vVYp�X M a r h V¦U ] c MPO Uq7 h  PX O UWV M ^i� �.pnXd¹vUea�VYaTXbXw� U�M j �gh VfXbafUWV hxMPO c j MPO V hxO¸S XSnO V hx] VfpnX ] Uea�7eXbcTV¥j¦p�U O 7PX h�O U O 8 c h�O 7 ] X U�M j � ^KUWVYa h �&X ] Xb^`X O V h c ] XbcTc¥Vfp�U O¡MPO Xq[�Uea�V hxO� 5� �� ������� � � ����� ��������� " ��� ���

�.pnX�^ MP] Xbj Sn] Uea M a r h V¦U ] c Mel � � �¤­ � � � ° ^qU'8 r X � a h VfVfX O �((( ) + t-. e0/21 3 9 �5 & � / 6 )�t / (((�� . e:/;1/ 3 G ­ � � ��� °� pnXJafX (((�� . e0/21/ 3 h cvVYp�X�»¡U O�Onh XJa lsSnO jwV h�MeO jbX O VfXbafXJZ MPO VfpnX < JLK SnOnh V�jbX ]�] ��§ O VYpnX5URV M ^ h jr Uec h cJ�nVYpnXJcfX�UeafXM7 h  PX O r 8P� (((�� . e0/21/ 3 9 �

h +e�� . e0/21

h M /e((((( � > ? ­ � � �=} °

� . e0/21h e 9 �& � t 6 ) t h 6 )�� ��!#"%$& 8 + t-e + . e0/21 ­ � � �|� °�.pnX�[np�UecTX l UejJV M ab� 6 )�� ��!'"($& � h c hxO j ]xS ZnXJZ h�O � �t��­ � �x�|� ° r XbjbU S cfX�VYpnX�[np�UecTX Mel VfpnXv^ MP] Xbj S�] UeaM a r h VYU ] cJ� � � �t­ � � � ° �m^KU'8 r X.j¦p M cTX O UWa r h VYaYUWa h�] 8P� U�M a�j MPO  PX Onh X O jbXW��VYp�Xk»¡U O�Onh XJa lsSnO jJV h�MPO cUeaTX2^qUeZ�X�afXbU ] r 8�j¦p M_M c h�O 7�) . e0/21t c S j¦p Vfp�UWV 6 )�� ��!'"($& 8 + t-e + . e0/21 h c�VYpnX2j M ^K[ ] Xw��j MPO�QTS 7mUWVfX Mel

Page 81: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �6 )�� ��!'"($� & 8 + M t-e + . e0/21 ���.p h c ] X|U| PXJc + J M 5 -G SnO ZnXwVYXJaf^ h�O XJZ²[np�UecTXbcb� � p h j¦p;^KUQ8 r Xoj¦p M cTX O V M 7 h  PXvU»'U OnOnh Xba lsS�O jJV h�MPO�MWl ^ hxOnh ^KU ] c h�´ Xe� U�M a VYpnX ���� ^ M ZnX ]@Mel [ MP] 8mUejJXJV38 ] X O Xe� � XJaTVYXJc ´ {�� �e�cfp M�� XbZ¡Vfp�UWV¥U²»¡U O�Onh XJa lsS�O jJV h�MPO Mel ^ h�Onh ^qU ] c h�´ X h c M r V¦U hxO XbZ r 8&j¦p M�M c h�O 7\XJ� S U ] U O ZM [n[ M c h VYX&[npnUecfXJc lsM a²VYp�X V �uM O � M a r h V¦U ] c h�O VYp�X SnO�h VijbX ]�] � »�X'UeaTX O�M V\U � UeaTX Mel U OU O U ] 8¸V h j|U ] c Me]�S V h�MPO lsM aoU O Uea r h VfaYUea�8 SnOnh VvjbX ]�] ��U O Z hxO cTVfX|UeZ S cTX2U O¸S ^`Xba h j|U ] Ue[n[�a M Uej¦p���.pnX�c hx´ X Mel VYpnX�»'U OnOnh Xba lsSnO jwV hxMPO;h c.ZnX � O XbZ Uecb�

= /�� 6 9 � / < G (((( � + . e0/21 -/ e (((( G � ­ � � ��� °�.pnX ) . e0/21t VYp�URV¤^ h�Onh ^ hx´ X¤VfpnXNc h�´ XkUeaTXuZnXwVYXJaf^ h�O XJZ S c h�O 7vVfpnX�� h ^`[ ] X��¥U ] 7 M a h VYpn^ { � b� ���.pnXafXJc Sn] V hxO 7 ^ h�Onh ^ S ^ h c�c M ^`X � p�URV�cTX O c h V h  PXqV M VfpnXqc�V¦Uea�V h�O 7\[ MPh�O Vb��U O Z � Xqp�U| PX lsMPS�O ZVYpnUWV¥VfpnX lsMP]�]xM��dhxO 7;[na M jbXJZ S aTX ] XbUeZnc�V Mi� X ]�] � ]�M j|U ]�h�´ XbZ�»'U OnOnh Xba lsSnO jwV hxMPO cb�²�.p�Xqc hx´ X MelVYp�Xq»¡U OnOnh XJa lsSnO jwV hxMPO¡Mel U Z h ^`Xba hx´ XJZ MPO X�� Z h ^KX O c hxMPO U ] j¦p�U hxO%h c¥^ hxOnh ^ h�´ XbZ � pnX O VYp�X� U| PXJaYU�7eXv[np�UWcfX�� Mel VfpnX M a r h V¦U ] j M X��`j h X O VYc h c ´ Xba M {����W� � � pnXJafX�VfpnX [np�UecTX r X h�O 7�U| PXJaYU�7eXbZZ M Xbc OnM V h�O j ]�S ZnX\VYpnXGc h 7 O j¦p�U O 7PX&Uecfc M j h UWVfXbZ �dh Vfp OnM Z�Xbc h�O VfpnX � U= eX lsSnO jJV hxMPO ��� M7PX O XbafU ]�hx´ X2VYpnXKj MPO jbXb[�V Mel U O � U| PXJaYU�7eXq[np�UWcfX���� � X ��aTcTV r a h�O 7iVfpnXqj M X��Kj h X O Vfc lsM agVYp�X WUea hxMPS c � U| PXw PXbjwV M aTc h�O V M j M UeaTcfX U ]xh 7 O ^`X O V r 8 h ZnX O V hxl 8 h�O 7vVYpnX M a r h VYU ]_h�O ZnX���� > v e � ��� J � lsM a� p h j¦p 8 t � �e + . e:/;1 p�Uec�VfpnX ] Uea�7eXbcTV O�M af^i�@U O Z&VYpnX O�lsM aTjbX ~ 6 � 8 te� !���������� + . e:/;1���� � lsM a¥U ]�]��r 8�^ S�] V h [ ] 8 hxO 72VYpnX � U| PX lsSnO jJV h�MPO c r 8 � �e� � pnX OGO XbjbXJcfcfUea"8e�¥¢ O U= eXbafU�7PX2[np�UWcfX h c�VYp�X OZnX � O XbZ Uecb� ;) . e0/21t 9 �= � e Uea"7 � ­ � � °�� 8 te + . e0/21�� ­ � � � � °� pnXJafX¥VfpnX�c S ^ h�O j ]�S ZnXbc MPOn] 84VYp M cfX¥ WU ]xS Xbc Mel > lsM a � p h j¦p ((( 8 te + . e:/;1 ((( � � � ((( 8 te !���������� + . e0/21 ((( �U O Z � h ckVYp�X O¸S ^ r Xba Mel VYXJaf^`c h�O j ]�S ZnXJZ hxO VYpnXgc S ^\�D§ O jbU ] j Sn] URV h�O 7�VYpnX�U| PXJaYU�7eXw� [�p�UecfXW�� X&UeafX O�M V hxO VfXbaTXbcTVfXbZ h�O VYpnX¡� � ^g4[npnUecfX�cTp hxl Vfc²Uea h c hxO 7 l a M ^ OnM Z�Xbc hxO VYpnX\»¡U O�Onh XJalsSnO jwV hxMPO �q�.p�XbcfXKcfp h l VYc�UeaTXKaTXb^ M  eXbZ   h U;VfpnX ­ � � ° � VYXbaT^ Mel � � �u­ � � � � ° � �dh VYp O 9 � h l~ 6 � 8 te + . e0/21�� � KU O Z OX9 M VYpnXJa �dh cfXe�v�.pnX�cTVYUeaTV h�O 7K[ Meh�O V lsM a�VYp�X�c h ^K[ ] Xw�\U ] 7 M a h Vfpn^h c M r V¦U hxO XbZ r 8;cfXwVfV h�O 7 ) . e0/21t 9 � ;) . e0/21t ��.pnX MPO X5U O Z�V �NM X ] XbjwVYa MPO ¹vUe^ h�] V MPO�h U O ^KUWVYa h �iX ] Xb^`X O VYcgUWafX�VfpnX O VYafU O c lsM af^`XbZ V M

VYp�X`»'U OnOnh Xba lsSnO jwV hxMPO r UWc h cJ�4� aYU O c lsM af^KUWV h�MPO&Mel VYpnX5V �NM X ] XJjJVfa MPO ^qURVYa h �GX ] Xb^`X O Vfc h cUejJjbX ] XbafUWVYXJZ r 84Vfa SnO jbUWV hxO 72VYpnXo»'U OnO�h Xba lsS�O jJV h�MPO cJ�D�.pnX�»¡U O�Onh XJa lsSnO jJV h�MPO cdUeafXg[tX|U � XbZMPO VfpnX�jJX O VYXJab� < 9 �� SnOnh VvjJX ]x] U O Z�ZnXJj|U'8 �dh VYp h�O jJafX|UWc h�O 7S1 < 1 � �.pnX¥»'U OnO�h Xba lsSnO jwV hxMPO

Page 82: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �h cdVYa SnO jbUWVYXJZ r 8\cfXwVfV h�O 7 � + . e:/;1 -/ e 9 lsM a < � � ��� J ��U O Z VfpnX O OnM af^KU ]xh�´bhxO 72VYpnX¥afXJc Sn] V h�O 7lsSnO jwV hxMPO ��§ O VfpnXoj|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO cª[naTXbcfX O VYXbZ r X ]xM�� � � ��� J � UeckcfXwVkV M � SnOnh VNjbX ]�] cJ� � p h j¦p � Uecc S �Kj h X O V lsM a.j MPO  PXba"7PX O jbXe�� ������� � ����� �!��� ��� � �\���*��� " ��� �§ O [tXba hxM Z h j r MeSnO Z�Uea�8`j MPO Z h V hxMPO cJ�_VfpnXvc h�O 7 ] X�X ] XJjJVYa MPO � p MP] Xd[�U h a r Uec h c lsS�O jJV h�MPO cu^qU'8r X � a h VTVYX O � � + � -� � �. e:/;1 . e0/21�� 9 �5 & � /76 ) � /�� / � /��

�. e0/21 . e0/21 � ­ � � ��± °� pnXJafX S [n[�XJa�� j|UecTX n�h cdVfpnX � U| PXw PXJjJV M a Mel VfpnX¥^KU O 8m� r M Z%8 � U| eX lsSnO jwV hxMPO ­ ]xM�� Xba¯� jbUecfX�ah c S cTXbZ lsM a VfpnX¥^ MP] Xbj S�] Uea M a r h V¦U ] c Mel:� � �¤­ � � � °f° � � / � / �. e0/21 . e0/21 � h c U5c h�O 7 ] XwV�X ] XJjJVYa MPO � p MP] XlsSnO jwV hxMPO �_j MPO V¦U h�OnhxO 7�U¥p MP] X hxO VfpnX  WU ] X O jJX r U O ZK»'U OnOnh Xba lsSnO jwV h�MeOqMPO VYpnX < JLK SnO�h VujbX ]x] �� + . e0/21 -/ ��U O Z4U O X ] XbjwVYa MeOqh�O VfpnX�j MPO Z S jJV hxMPO r U O Z M a r h V¦U ]nMeO VYp�X < � JLK SnOnh VªjbX ]x] � � + . e:/;1�� -/ � �¨ M VYX�Vfp�UWV|�zZ S X�V M VfaYU O c ] UWV h�MPO U ] c"8_^K^`XJVfa"8e� MPOn] 8\VfpnX2cfXJ[�UeaYURV h�MeO r XwV � XJX O VYpnX2X ] XbjwVYa MPOU O ZGp MP] XW���²� h c�afX ] XJ WU O Vb� U�M a�j MPO  eX Onh X O jJXe� � X h�O VYa M Z S jbX�VfpnX lsMP]x]�M=�dh�O 7 OnM VYUWV hxMPO\lsM avU7PX O XbafU ] ^qU O 8m� r M Z;8 r Uec h c lsS�O jJV h�MPO �((( � �e 3 9 �5 & � / 6 ) � / 1 > B < � ­ � � � � °� pnXJafX > ] U r X ] cdU`[�UeaTV h j Sn] UeadUWafaYU O 7PXb^`X O V Mel X ] XbjwVYa MPO c�U O Z p MP] XJcvU O Z 1 > B < � h�O Z h j|URVYXbcVYpnUWV.VYpnXJcfX�p�U| PX r XJX O Z h cT[ ] UWjbXbZ r 8 < SnOnh VdjbX ]x] cJ��.pnX�^qUWVfa h �4X ] Xb^`X O Vfc MWl VfpnX�¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O UWafXoVYp�X O 7 h  PX O r 8e�� � �e (((��� (((�� = 3 9 �5 & �

�6 M ) � � � > B!� 1 �� 1 � = �

9 5 & � > 1 �� 1 � = � r � + � ­ � � � � °U O Z�� � � �. ((("�� ((( � �e 3 9$# �& �

�6 ) � � � A�B%�I1 �� 1 > ��& r � + � ­ � � � °

� pnXJafX 1 � = � h c.VYpnXM7Pa MPSnO Z;X ] XbjwVYa MeOnh j�c�V¦UWVfXe�

Page 83: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

± � ����� � � ��� ��� ����� ��� � � ��� �

� M M r VYU h�O UkVYafU O c h V hxMPO ^ M ^KX O V M [�XJaYUWV M azVYp�URV h c@j MPO c h c�VYX O V �dh VYpgVYpnXD[tXba hxM Z h j r MPSnO Z_�Uea�8Gj MPO Z h V h�MPO cJ� � X S cTX`Vfp�UWV lsM agU²a h�O 7 Mel [ Me] 8_^KXJa �dh Vfp & S�Onh VgjJX ]�] c={ � �e� � �_� � }�� �2»�Xr X�7 hxO��dh Vfp5U SnOnh V¤jbX ]�] Vfp�UWV ]�h XJc.­ Uec�^ S j¦p5Uec¤[ M cTc h r ] X ° h�O VfpnXg­���G�� ° [ ] U O X.U O Z5U�-Na hx]�]�MeSnh�O PXJjJV M ab� �4�³VYpnUWV ]�h Xbc�U ]�MPO 7KVYpnX��¸�¯UR� h cb���.pnX2 PXbjwV M a�� + � / ) J -> 7 h  PXbcoVfpnX2[ M c h V h�MeO�Mel VYpnXT8NJLKUWV M ^ hxO VYpnX SnOnh V.jbX ]�]��dh VYp;afXJcf[tXbjwV V M VYpnX�jJX O VYXJa Mel VfpnX SnOnh VkjbX ]x] ���.p�X�jJX O VYXJa h ckj¦p M cTX Or 8 r h cTXbjwV h�O 7;VfpnX ]�h�O X�VYp�URV¥j MPOnO XJjJVfc¥VYp�X �nafcTVq­ ] X l V�� ^ M cTV ° UWV M ^ Mel VYpnX SnOnh VgjbX ]�] V M VYp�Xj M afafXJcf[ MPO Z hxO 7�URV M ^ Mel VYpnX O Xw�_V SnO�h VªjbX ]�] �¤¢ a h�O 7 h�O VYpnX�­��G � ° [ ] U O X h cªVfpnX OKlsM af^`XbZ r 8UeaTaYU O 7 h�O 7�VfpnXgjbX O VfXbafc Mel VYpnX SnO�h VdjbX ]�] c MPO U2j h afj ] X �dh VYp;aYUeZ h�S cJ�

~ 9 1*#�1��c hxO ­ � F & ° G ­ � � ��� °j¦p M cTX O c S j¦p¡VYp�UWV¥VYpnXqj¦p M afZ'j MPOnO XbjJV h�O 7�VfpnXqjJX O VYXJafc Mel VfpnX S�Onh V¥jbX ]�] c¥p�Uec ] X O 7eVYpo1 ��1 ��.pnX SnOnh V�jJX ]�] c�UWafX`a M VYUWVYXJZ¡U r MPS V�VYpnX�m�¯UR� h cgc S j¦p'VYpnUWV¥VfpnX)8�UeaTX`VYU O 7PX O V�V M VYp�Xqa hxO 7n��.pnX��¸� j M_M aTZ h�O URVYX Mel VYp�X 8NJLK�UWV M ^ Mel VYpnX < JLK SnOnh VdjbX ]x]zh ckVfpnX O 7 h  eX O r 8� < 8 9 � + � / ) J -> j M c ­ D < ° B � ~ � � + � / ) J -> � c h�O ­ D < ° G ­ � � �P� °

� pnXJafX DV9 G�IJ ­ cfXJX�VYXw�_V r X ]�M=� Xb� ��­ � � � °f° �§ V h c�j MPO  eX Onh X O VgV M4hxO Vfa M Z S jJX2U O�M [tXbafUWV M ab� �� � � p h j¦pGp�Uec�VYpnX lsMe]�]�M=�dhxO 7q^KUWVYa h �iX ] Xw�^`X O VYc h�O VfpnX�UWV M ^ h j r Uec h cb� <8 ((((( �� ((((( � b ? 9 ­ � � �e} °

�� � � + � / ) J -> B / � � ~.B � + � / ) J -> � � r / + h r >f+ v�.pnX��¸� M [tXbafUWV M aNj M aTafXbcT[ MeO Z h�O 7`V M'� � ��­ � � �P� °ªh c.VYpnX O �

�� 9 �� 6 )�� B ���� 6 M )�� ­ � � �W� °�.pnX M [�XJaYUWV M a �� h c�j MPO  eX Onh X O V r Xbj|U S cfX �� aYU h cfXJc�VfpnX � U= eXJ eXbjJV M a Mel Uq^KU O 8m� r M Z;8ic�V¦UWVfXr 8 D � � p h�] X �� � ]�M=� XJafc.VYp�X � U| PXw PXbjwV M a r 8 D �� � �e ((( �� 1 � = � 9 ­ � � �P� °

Page 84: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

±��

5 & � � > 1 �� 1 � = � r � + � � ��B � > 1 ���� 1 � = � r � + � M � �� � �. ((( �� ((( � �e 3 9 ­ � � � � °

� / 6 M ) � / � � A�B < 1 �� 1 > � r � + � � �*B � AB < 1 �� 1 > � � r � + � M � ��.pnXvVfaYU O c h V h�MPO ^ M ^KX O V M [tXbafUWV M aNU ]xMPO 7gVYpnX 8¸� UR� h cJ��[tXbaT[�X O Z h j Sn] UWaªV M VYp�Xv[ MP] 8_^`XbauUR� h cb�h c.Z h U�7 MeO U ]�hxOwn U O Z h VYc.XJ WU ]xS UWV h�MPO²h c.c h ^ h�] UeaDV M VYp�URV MWl VfpnX�¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O � � �¸cb��­ � � � � °U O Z'­ � � � ° ��.pnX�a h�O 7>7eX M ^`XJVfa"8 h c S cfXbZ MPOn] 8qV M`M r VYU h�O U5[�XJa hxM Z h jvVYafU O c h V hxMPO ^ M ^KX O V M [�XJaYUWV M ab�

¢vc�Z�XbcfjJa h r XJZ h�O ��XJje� � � ��� �P��VfpnX2¹�Ue^ hx] V MPOnh U O [�UWaYUe^`XJVfXbafcoUeafX�Vfp M cTX lsM a�U ]xh�O XbUea�j¦pnU h�O �U O Z`VYp S ckZ M�OnM V h�O j ]�S ZnXdj S a� eURV S aTXvX « XbjwVYc � p h j¦p �uMPSn] Z4cfXJaT eX MPOn] 8�V M c ]�M=� j MPO  PXJa�7PX O jbXV M VYp�X ]xMPO 7W� j¦p�U h�O;]xh ^ h V|��§ O 7PX O XbaYURV h�O 7KcT[�XJjJVYafU�� h V h c S cTX lsSn] V M afXJ^ M  eX�Uea�V h l UejJVfc�UWa h c h�O 7l a M ^ VYpnX S cfX Mel Uva h�O 7^7PX M ^KXwVYa"8e� U�M a�U�a h�O 7 h�O VYpnXo­��G � ° � [ ] U O XW�WVfpnXkU r c M aT[�V hxMPO�hxO VfX O c h V38Z S X.V M VYaYU O c h V h�MeO c�[ MP] Uea h�´ XbZ�[�UWaYU ]x] X ] V M VfpnX.[ Me] 8_^KXJa�UR� h c h c�cf[�afX|UWZ`XJ� S U ]�] 8 r XJV � XbX O VYp�X� U O Z ´ UR��XbcJ� � p hx] XgVYp�UWV�[ MP] Uea h�´ XbZi[�XJaf[tX O Z h j Sn] UeadV M VfpnX�[ MP] 8_^`Xba UR� h c ]�h Xbc MPOn] 8iU ]�MPO 7VYp�X<8GUR� h cb��§ O VYp�X2U r c M af[�V h�MPO cf[tXbjJVfaYU²cfp M��dO r X ]xM�� ��VYpnX�[nUeaYU ]x] X ] VfaYU O c h V h�MPO cf[tXbjJVfa S ^h cª^ Sn] V h [ ]�h XbZ r 8²���_c M VYp�UWV h�O VYpnX ]�MPO 7R� j¦p�U hxOK]xh ^ h Vb�eVYpnXvafX ] UWV h  PX h�O VYX O c h V h XbcªafX y XbjJVNVYp M cTXMel U2j¦p�U h�O aYURVYpnXJakVYp�U O U2a hxO 7n��.pnX L BTB"j M ZnX S cTXbZ hxO VfpnXbcTX j|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO c h cKUi7PX O XbafU ]dh ^`[ ] XJ^KX O V¦UWV h�MPO%Mel ����

U O Z5§¯¨ ©g¬ j|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO c lsM a r M VYp OnMPO � [tXba hxM Z h jkU O Z5[�XJa h�M Z h jkc"8_cTVfXb^`cb���.pnX OnMeO � [tXba h�M Z h jlsSnO jwV hxMPO U ]xh V38 � Ueck PXJa h �nXbZ r 84j M ^K[�UWa h c MPOq�dh VYpqVfpnX���§¯¨ ©g¬ [na M 7PaYUW^�{~�P±������.pnX�[tXba h�M Z h jlsSnO jwV hxMPO U ]xh V38 � UWc5 eXba h ��XJZ r 8%j M ^K[nUea h c MPO%Mel c�V¦UWVfXiX O Xba"7 h XJc5U O Z r M VYp%VYp�X ]�h�O X|Uea2U O ZOnMPO � ]�hxO X|UWa M [�V h jbU ] [ MP] Uea h�´ U r h�]xh V h Xbc MWl U²a hxO 7 Mel [ Me] 8_^KXJab�³jbU ] j Sn] URVYXbZ �dh VYp U O Z �dh VYp MPS VVYp�X¥UWcfc S ^K[�V h�MPO;Mel [tXba hxM Z h j r MPSnO ZnUea"8²j MPO Z h V hxMPO cb�

Page 85: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

±P�

1.405

1.390

1.403

1.451 1.344

1.4521.101 1.100

1.106

1.105

119o

120o118o

119o 114o

125o

120o

1

2 3

4

56

7

8

U¤h 7 S afX � � ��� ��X M ^`XJVfa"8 Mel U SnOnh VojbX ]x]¤Mel ��� �zX���VfaYUejwVYXJZ l a M ^�U O ¢ � �5j|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO\MPOU O²MP]xh 7 M ^KXJa �dh VYp²c h �²[�pnX O 8 ] a hxO 7PckU O Z\��Z MPS r ] X r MPO ZncJ�nj MPO cTVYafU h�O XbZ4V M aTXb^KU h�O [ ] U O Ueab�- MPO Z ] X O 7eVfpncdUeaTX hxO ¢ O 7Pc�VYa M ^KcJ�9;:�� ���!��F��JA��� ��� ��� ���!��� � " ��� ��� � " ���!��� �

�.pnXt7PX M ^KXwVYa"8 Mel U S�Onh VgjJX ]�]¤Mel ��� U O Z h Vfc�ZnXba h  WUWV h  PXJc � UWc M r V¦U hxO XbZ l a M ^"¢ � �j|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO c|{ � �R� MPO U O`MP]xh 7 M ^`Xba�j MPO VYU h�OnhxO 7 � [npnX O 8 ] a hxO 7Pc�j MeOnO XbjwVYXJZ r 8K� Y� �[���� Z MPS r ] Xr MPO ZncJ��� M U ]�]xM=�1lsM aDU�a h 7 M a MeS c�cfXJ[�UeaYURV h�MeOKMel Q�U O Z�� M a r h VYU ] cJ� � X ��afc�VNj MPO c�VYaYU h�O XJZKVYp�X7PX M ^KXwVYa�8�V M afXb^KU hxO [ ] U O UWab� U M a S�O c S r cTV h V S VfXbZ ��� �@VYp h cgj MPO cTVYafU h�O V�p�Uec�XbcTcfX O V h U ]x] 8OnM X « XJjJV MPO VYpnXj7eX M ^`XJVfa"8P�DU O Z h Vfc�afXJ^ M  WU ]ª]�M=� Xbafc¥VYpnX4jbU ] j Sn] URVYXbZ'pnX|UWV Mel.lsM aT^qUWV h�MPOr 8 ] Xbcfc�Vfp�U O �� � � jbU ] � ^ MP] Xe�G�.pnXl7eX M ^`XJVfa"8 Mel VYpnX SnO�h V�jJX ]x] ��cfp M��dO®hxODU¤h 7n� � � �P� � UecM r VYU h�O XbZ l a M ^8VYp�X�jbX O VfaYU ] Z MeS r ] X r MPO Z;U O ZiU O UeZ Q UejJX O V [npnX O 8 ] a hxO 7 Mel VYp�X M [�V h ^ hx´ XbZMP]xh 7 M ^`XbaucTVfa S jwV S aTXe�¢vc.U�c h ^K[ ] X�^ M ZnX ] Mel � � ¹.� ��� � M av7PX O XbafU ] U ]��eM �s8`c S r cTV h V S VfXbZ ��� � � Xoj MPO c h ZnXJa

Z h p�8_Zna M �%8m� ���� ­ ¬ ¹d� ���� °5M r V¦U hxO XbZ VYpna MPS 7Pp p?8�Z�a M �s8¶c S r cTV h V S V hxMPO URVKVfpnX��&U O Z �[ M c h V h�MeO c Mel VYp�X [npnX O 8 ] a hxO 7 hxO U¤h 7n� � � �P�º�.pnX�^ MP] XJj Sn] Uea�7PX M ^KXwVYa h Xbc � XbafX M r VYU h�O XJZlsMP]x]�M=�dh�O 7�VYpnX.[na M jJXbZ S afX MPS V ]�h�O XbZ5U r M  PX lsM a ��� �¸¹ M=� XJ eXbab� � pnX O VYp�X^7eX M ^`XJVfa"8 MWl³¬ ¹.���� h ckj MeO cTVfaYU hxO XbZ²V M r X�[ ] U O UeaJ��VYp�X�afXbc Sn] V h�O 72X O Xba"7�8 h c � � j|U ] � ^ MP] X p h 7PpnXbakVfp�U O VYp�XX O Xba�748 M r V¦U hxO XbZ l a M ^U O�SnO j MPO c�VYafU h�O XJZ 7PX M ^KXwVYa�8 M [�V h ^ hx´ UWV h�MPO �z§ O VYpnX lsS�]�] 8 M [�V h ^ hx´ XbZcTVfa S jwV S aTXe�_VYpnXd  h�O 8 ] X O X r MPO Zncªa M VYUWVYX MPS V Mel [ ] U O X r 8KU r MPS VN� g � & XJc Sn] VYcNUeafX [nafXJcfX O VfXbZr X ]�M=� lsM a r M Vfp [ ] U O Uea U O Z lsSn]�] 8m� M [�V h ^ h�´ XbZ³� OnMPO � [ ] U O Uea ¬ ¹.� ��� � �.pnX�aTXbc Sn] Vfc lsM adVYp�X

Page 86: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

±e}

U¤h 7 S afX � � � ��� r U O Z;c�VYa S jJV S afXgU O Z r U O Z ] U r X ] c lsM ao­�U °uS�O c S r cTV h V S VfXbZ³��[ ] U O UWa ��� �@­ r °��� �dh VYp�VYpnX O � � M a r h VYU ] c MPO j|UWa r MPO c5��U O Z �\[�XJaTV S a r XbZ r 8��Y�4X ­sc S r c�� ��� ° � ­ j °[ ] U O UeakZ h � p?8_Zna M �s8m� ��� ­ ¬ ¹d� ���� ° � U O Z'­ Z °ulsSn]�] 8¸� M [�V h ^ h�´ XJZ³� OnMPO � [ ] U O Uea ¬ ¹d� ���� �

Page 87: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

±W�[ ] U O Uea�cTVYa S jJV S afX.cTp M=� VfpnX.X « XbjwVYc Mel VfpnXkp?8_Zna M �s82c S r cTV h V S V h�MeO � �dh Vfp MPS V¤VYpnX.UWZnZnXbZ5j M ^5�[ ]xh j|URV h�MeO²Mel VfpnXVQt� � M a r h V¦U ] ^ h � h�O 72VYpnUWV�Uea h cfXbc l a M ^�VYp�X�  h�O 8 ] X O X�a M VYUWV hxMPO � & XJ[ ] UWj h�O 7VYp�X�p?8�Z�a M �s8R7Pa MPS [nc �dh VYp¶^KXwVYp M �s8L7ea MPS [�cG­ � X ¬ � ��� °K] X|U| PXJcqVYp�X�cTVfa S jwV S aTX Mel VYp�Xr Uej � r MPO X5XbcTcfX O V h U ]x] 8 SnO j¦p�U O 7PXbZ³��� h�O jJX�VYpnX5[np M V M [�p�8_c h j|U ] [nafXJZ h jwV hxMPO c lsM a � X ¬ � ���UeaTXKXJcfcfX O V h U ]�] 8 h ZnX O V h jbU ] V M VYp M cfX Mel ¬ ¹d� ���� � r X ]xM=� � � XK[�afXbcTX O V5U;ZnXJVYU h�] XbZ�U O U ] 8_c h cMel VfpnX r U O Z�c�VYa S jJV S afX2U O Z�[np M V M [np?8_c h jbc Mel VYpnX¥c h ^`[ ] Xba ¬ ¹d� ��� c�8_cTVYXJ^\� § O [�UWaTV h j S �] UWab� ¬ ¹.� ��� h c.c h ^K[ ] Xba r XbjbU S cTX�VfpnXg^KXwVYp?8 ] 7Pa MPS [nc Mel � X ¬ � ��� ^qU � X�VYpnXgcTVfa S jwV S aTXOnMPO � [ ] U O Uea.U O Z\[�afXJ eX O VvU`a h 7 M a MPS ckcTXb[�UWaYUWV h�MPO;Mel Q'U O Z � X ] XbjwVYa MPO cb��.pnX�j¦pnXb^ h jbU ] cTVfa S jwV S aTXbc Mel VYpnX MP]xh 7 M ^`XbaTcNc�V S Z h XbZ r X ]�M=� � XbaTX M r V¦U h�O XJZ l a M ^ ¢ � �

7PX M ^KXwVYa�8 M [�V h ^ h�´ UWV hxMPO c MPO2MP]xh 7 M ^KXJafc �dh VYp r XJV � XbX O �gU O Z �o[npnX O 8 ] X O Xda hxO 7Pc�j MPOnO XbjJVfXbZr 8 � � > < � �   h�O 8 ] X O XbcJ�� ��� ��� ������������� ���! #"%$�� � ��� � ��� � " ���!��� � ��� � � �����f����� ��� " ��� ���

�.pnX�� r U O Z\c�VYa S jJV S afXbc Mel ��� U O Z ¬ ¹.� ��� � M r VYU h�O XbZiUec ZnXbcTjba h r XJZ hxO �_Xbje� � � ��� ��dh Vfp�& 9 �_� SnOnh V jbX ]x] cJ��UWafX�cfp M=�dOGh�O�U¤h 7n� � � ���k�.pnX¥afXbc Sn] Vfc lsM a SnO c S r c�V h V S VYXJZ ��� UeaTXcfp M��dO h�OIU¤h 7n� � � �n­�U ° �g�.pnX y UWV r U O ZncgUWafX ] U r X ] XJZ�b lsM a ]�M j|U ]xh�´ XJZ³��U O Z�VYp�X2ZnX ]xM jbU ]�hx´ XbZr U O ZncvUWafX ] U r X ] XbZ B / �dh VYp OihxO jbaTX|Uec h�O 7`Uec MPO X�^ M  PXJcvU � UQ8 l a M ^�VfpnX U XJaf^ h X O Xba�748P�ª¢� h c S cTXbZ\V M5h�O Z h j|UWVfX�j MPO Z S jJV h�MPO � Uec M [n[ M cfXJZ\V M  WU ] X O jJXe� r U O Zncb�

� afXJ  hxMPS c.cTV S Z h Xbc={~�P���n���b���n[�XJa lsM aT^KXJZ S c hxO 75U ��� X ] XJjJVfa MPO ^ M Z�X ] � h�O j ]�S ZnXbZ²VYp�X�X « XbjJVfcMel U ]��WM �s8`c S r cTV h V S V h�MeO r 8KU ] VfXba h�O 7oVfpnXvX O Xba"7�8 Mel VfpnX O � M a r h VYU ] V Mg� p h j¦pqVYpnX c S r cTV h V S X O Vh c¥UWVTV¦Uej¦pnXJZ³�;¢�c h ^ h�] UWa�Ue[n[na M Uej¦p�j|U O r X h ^`[ ] XJ^KX O VfXbZ h�O VYpnXK§¯¨ ©g¬ ¹�Ue^ hx] V MPOnh U O r 8UeZnZ h�O 7qUK[tXbaTV S a r UWV hxMPO V M VYpnX�¹vUe^ h�] V MPO�h U O²Mel ��XbjW� � � ��� �¥VYpnUWV�U ] VYXJafcdVYpnX¥X O XJa�7�8 Mel VYp�X�W[ �

M a r h VYU ]³MPO VYp�X¥aTXbcf[tXbjwV h  PX�j|Uea r MPO UWV M ^`cb���.pnX�afXJc Sn] VYc h�OwU¤h 7n� � � �n­ r °u� XJafX M r VYU h�O XJZr 8�c S r VYafUejJV h�O 7 ��X l a M ^ VYpnX M a r h V¦U ] X O Xba�748 Mel VfpnX O �

M a r h VYU ]@MPO j|Uea r MeO cg�qU O Z � Mel��� ­ U¤h 7�� � � � ° ��»�X �dh�]x] afX l Xba.V M VYp h c.c"8_c�VYXb^�Uec.c S r c¯� ��� lsM a.c S r cTV h V S VYXJZ ��� �

U¤h 7�� � � �n­ j ° cTp M=� c�VfpnX�� r U O Znc MWl [ ] U O Uea ¬ ¹d� ��� � U�M a U [ ] U O Ueaz^ MP] Xbj S�] UeaA7eX M ^`XJVfa"8P�c S j¦p Uec hxO U�h 7PcJ� � � �n­�U ° �w­sj ° �DVfpnXbaTX h c2U&a h 7 M a MPS c�cfXJ[�UeaYURV h�MeO MWl Q!U O Z � M a r h V¦U ] cb�DU O ZMPOn] 8GVYpnX � r U O Znc�UeafX`cfp M=�dO ��� S j¦p%U\cTXb[�UeafUWV hxMPO'h c OnM V¥a h 7 M a MPS c lsM a lsS�]�] 8m� M [�V h ^ hx´ XJZ³�OnMPO � [ ] U O Uea ¬ ¹d� ��� �_U O Z5VYpnX r U O Z�cucTp M=�dO4h�O'U¤h 7�� � � �n­ Z ° UeaTX.VYp M cTX �dh VYp`VYpnX ] UWa�7PXJcTV�j MeO VfX O V|��� h 7 Onh ��j|U O V�^ h � hxO 7 Mel �\U O ZCQ;j¦p�UeafUejJVfXba M jbj S afc MPOn] 8 hxO VfpnX lsMPS a ]xM=� XJcTVT� X O XJa�7�8

Page 88: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

±P�

d3 d2

d1l

d1

d2 d3

l* *

* *

U¤h 7 S afX � � } �v»¡U OnOnh XJa lsSnO jwV hxMPO c lsM aoVfpnX���� r U O Znc Mel ��� h�OPU¤h 7�� � � �n­�U ° ���.pnX5c h�´ XJc MelVYp�X¥j h afj ] XJc�UWafX�[na M [ M a�V h�MeO U ] V M VfpnX�U r c MP]xS VYXg WU ]�S X MWl VYp�X�»'U OnOnh Xba lsSnO jwV hxMPO\MeO VYp�X O � �M a r h VYU ]�MWl VYp�UWVkj|Uea r MPO � ¬ [�X O U O Z4j ]xM cfXJZ²j h afj ] Xbc hxO Z h j|UWVfXv[ M c h V h  eXoU O Z O X�7mURV h  eXv WU ]�S Xbcb�afXJcf[tXbjwV h  eX ] 8P�r U O Znc MelU�h 7n� � � �n­sZ ° ��.pnX5»¡U O�Onh XJa lsSnO jJV h�MPO c lsM aoVYpnX�� r U O Znc Mel ��� U O Z&[ ] U O Uea ¬ ¹d� ��� UeaTX5cfp M=�dOh�OwU¤h 7Pcb� � ��}KU O Z � ���n��aTXbcT[�XJjJV h  PX ] 8P�

� ��� ��� � �(� � � � � � U¤h 7�� � � ��cfp M=� c2VYp�X;U r c M af[�V h�MPO cT[�XJjJVYafU l a M ^ c hxO 7 ] XJc�� j MPO ��7 S aYURV h�MeO¡h�O VYXJaYUejwV hxMPO ­ �m�L § ° j|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO c lsM aqVfpnXGc"8_c�VYXb^`c MelVU¤h 7�� � � ��� U�M aqVfpnXG[ ] U O Ueaq^ MP] Xbj S�] Uea`cTVfa S jwV S aTXbcMel U¤h 7Pcb� � � ��­�U ° �w­ j ° ��VfpnXbaTX h c OnM ^ h � h�O 7 Mel Q!U O Z � r U O Znc5U O Z%VYp�X �¸� L §�j|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO ch�O j ]�S ZnX`U ]�] � r U O ZncJ� U M a O�MPO � [ ] U O UWa ¬ ¹.� ��� � U¤h 7�� � � ��­ Z ° � VfpnXKjbU ] j Sn] URV h�MeO hxO j ]xS ZnXJc

VYp�X �2p h 7PpnXJcTVT� X O XJa�7�8K WU ] X O jbX�U O Z � ]�M=� Xbc�VT� X O Xba"7�8²j MPO Z S jwV hxMPO r U O ZncJ�ª��U r ] X � � ��cfp M=� cVYp�Xoj MPO Vfa h r S V hxMPO c Mel  WUea hxMPS c r U O ZncuV M VfpnX�VfaYU O c h V h�MPO c ] U r X ] XbZK§�VYpna MPS 7Ppq§ h�O U¤h 7n� � � ���

U¤h 7ecb� � � � U O Z � � ±\cfp M�� cT[�XJjJVYafU M r VYU h�O XJZ l a M ^ �¸� L §�j|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO c MPO¡MP]xh 7 M ^KXJafc Mel��� U O Z ¬ ¹d� ��� �u�.p�X MP]�h 7 M ^`Xbafc5j MPO V¦U hxO r XJV � XbX O & 9 �%U O Z & 9 �'[np�X O 8 ] a hxO 7Pcb�j MeOnO XbjwVYXJZ r 8'VfaYU O c¯�   h�O 8 ] X O XbcJ� U�M a & 9 �GVYp�a MPS 7ep & 9 � ��VYpnX��¸� L § r UWc h c � Uec lsM aT^KXJZl a M ^ U ]�] X���j h VYUWV hxMPO c r XwV � XJX O VYpnX � & p h 7Pp�XbcTV�� X O Xba"7�8 � ]�] XbZi^ MP] Xbj Sn] Uea M a r h V¦U ] c�U O Z VYp�X� & ]xM=� XJcTVT� X O XJa�7�8¥Xb^`[�V38¥^ Me] Xbj Sn] UWa M a r h V¦U ] cb� U�M a & 9 ±�U O Z & 9 ���RVYpnX r Uec h c � Uec lsM aT^KXJZl a M ^�VYpnX����5p h 7epnXbc�V � ]�] XJZiU O Z\} � ]xM=� XJcTV�Xb^`[�V38 M a r h V¦U ] cb�D�.pnX ] U r X ]�h�O 7 Mel VfpnX�[�XbU � c h cZ h cfj S cfcfXJZ hxO �_Xbje� � �~�n�

Page 89: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

± �

��U r ] X � � �����_V¦UWVfX5X O XJa�7 h Xbcb� M cfj h�]x] UWV M aocTVfafX O 7eVYp�cb��U O Z r U O Z'j M ^K[ M c h V hxMPO�lsM a�VYpnX`cTVYUWVYXJc7 h   hxO 7ga h cfXdV M [�XbU � c h�O VfpnXoU r c M aT[�V hxMPO cT[�XJjJVfaYU MWlsU¤h 7n� � � �����.pnX r U O Z ] U r X ] c�j M aTafXJcf[ MPO ZV M Vfp M cfX MelU¤h 7�� � � ���������� � ��� ��� � ������������������ ������+ � - �����������! �"#���"��#���� ��"#�����$�%�'&( )#* � 5�#� ++ * )-,

1. � 10/

.(�(21�* � � * G 3 )#* )-,1. �Iv / �) 5 * 14, v � 10/

.(�(21�* � � * 5 3 )#* )-,1. �Iv / �) 5 * 14, v � 1 /

.(6(�( 7#* 1 G 5 7 + * � , v � 1 /. �) 3 * 14,

1. ��v /

(8& 3 * 7 G � 3 )#* + , v �Iv / 5 )#* 3 , 1. � 1 /

9 + * ) 5 , 1

9 � 1 /. �50* 114,

1. � 1 /

.+ � - �������:���;�%�<&>=;� ��?@��?��A���#����B��C��D<�������E����F����� G ���#�$7 + G���B�* 3 * 5 - ���!=H�������C�4� 5 �I&( G * + 5�#� +J * 14,1. � 1 /

.(�(21�* � 5 3 50* � , 1. �Iv / 5 3 * J , v � 1 /

. J * JJ ,1. � 1 /

.(�(21�* � 7 3 50* + ,1. �Iv / 5 50* � , v � 10/

. �50* 3=G , 1. � 1#/

.(6(�( 7#* 7 5 3 7#* 7-,1. � 10/

. 5 3 * J , 1. ��v / 5 7#* )-, v � 1#/

.(6(�( 7#* 7 J ) J * )-,1. � 1 /

. :) 3 * 3 , v � 1 /. G � * 5, 1

. �Iv /(8& 3 * 5 5� 5 J * 5,

1. �Iv / 5 G * 3 , v � 1 /

. 3 * 7 + ,1. � 1 /

.(8& 3 * 7 G � ) G * � , v �Iv / 5�J * )-, 1. �Iv / 5 G * J , 1

. � 1 /K 5 G * � , 1

. � 1 /9 + * 1-)-, v � 1 /

. + * 5�+ , 1. � 1 /

.(8& 3 * 7 5 )7#* 3 ,1. �Iv / 5 3 * 3 , 1

. � 1 /9 5 3 * � , 1

. � 1 /K 5 G * 5 , v �Iv / 3 * 7 5 , v � 1 /

. 3 * 1 3 ,19 � 1 /

. 7#* G=G , 1. � 10/

.+ � - �������:���L��� M8?4�0���! 4�4MN�%�'&( )#* � 5�#� + 3 * 14,1. � 10/

.(�( )#* + 1 1 G * J , v � 1#/. #1 5 * � , 1

. ��v / 5� * 5, 1. � 1#/

.(6(�( 7#* 5 7 � 7 G * G , 1. �Iv / #1 5 * 7-, v � 10/

.(8& 7#* 5 ) � 1-)#* 14, v �Iv / G 7#* 3 , 1. �Iv / 5 3 * 14, v � 10/

. 5�5 * 7-, 1. � 1 /

9+ � - ����#MN�����������! :��� M8?4�0������ 0�4MN�<�<&( )#* � 5�#� + 50* G , 1. � 1 /

.(�( )#* + 1 1 + * J ,1. �Iv / �)7#* 14, v � 1 /

. 3 * ) + ,1. � 1 /

.(6(�( 7#* 5 ) � 11�* 7-, v � 1 /. �)�1�* )-,

1. ��v / 5�J * )-, 1

. � 1 /.(8& 7#* 5 ) � 1-7#* + , v �Iv / G + * G , 1

. �Iv / 5�5 * 14, 1. � 1 /

9 50* 145, v � 1#/.

Page 90: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

±P±

d3d2

d1

ld1

d2 d3

l

* *

* *

O 2 O 1

U¤h 7 S afX � �~� �k»'U OnOnh Xba lsS�O jJV h�MPO c Mel VfpnX ��� r U O Znc Mel [ ] U O Uea Z h � p?8_Zna M �s8m� ��� ­ ¬ ¹d� ���� °h�OwU¤h 7n� � � �n­ j ° �9;:�� � I��H F����IbC`?�.pnX�Xw��[�XJa h ^KX O VYU ] U r c M aT[�V hxMPO cf[tXbjJVfa S ^ {~�P���t�e}_�t�W���t�P�_� � � � MWl ��� X���p h r h VYc.c�VYa MeO 7

VYafU O c h V hxMPO c�URVªU r MeS Vu���~��X �P��� ±oX U O Z � X �m¢ VYafU O c h V hxMPO UWVªU r MPS Vª}�� ±vX h c M r cTXbaT eXbZh�O c S r cTV h V S VYXbZ ���� cYUe^`[ ] XJcb� �dh Vfp¡U O h�O VYX O c h V38&VYp�UWV h c¥a MPS 7Pp ] 8GXb� S U ] V M Vfp�UWV Mel VYp�XVYafU O c h V hxMPO UWV��n� ±4X �³»�X �dh�]x] afX l Xba�V M VYp�XbcfX5VYafU O c h V hxMPO cgUecg§�­ ���~�PX ° �z§T§�­ }�� ±²X ° �z§T§f§­ ��� ±2X ° U O Z\§ ­ � � 5X ° ��� aYU O c h V h�MPO cd§NU O Zi§ UeaTXg[ MP] Uea hx´ XJZ²[�UeaYU ]�] X ] V M VYp�X�[ MP] 8�^`XbaUR� h cvU O Z�VfaYU O c h V h�MPO §f§f§ h cv[ MP] Uea h�´ XbZ [tXbaT[�X O Z h j Sn] Uea�V M VYpnX�[ MP] 8_^KXJavUR� h cb��� aYU O c h V h�MPO §f§Ue[n[tX|UWafc.V M r X�[�a h ^KUea h�] 85[ MP] Uea hx´ XbZ²[nUeaYU ]x] X ] V M VfpnXg[ MP] 8_^KXJadUR� h c={~�P�¸�t�W���t�P��� �§ O [naTXJ  h�MPS c¥VYp�X M aTXJV h j|U ] c�V S Z h Xbc|{ ���n�����e�¤�e�R� � VYpnXJafX h cU7eX O XJaYU ] U�7PaTXbXJ^KX O V¥VYp�URV�[tX|U �

§oj MPO c h cTVfc Mel U O X���j h VYUWV hxMPO l a M ^�VYp�XKp h 7PpnXJcTV� eU ] X O jbX5V M VfpnX ]�M=� XJcTV�j MPO Z S jJV h�MPO r U O Z³�B 5�� B � 5 �nU O ZqVYpnUWVk[tX|U � § UWa h cTXbc l a M ^£U¥VfaYU O c h V h�MPO r XwV � XJX O VYp�X ]�M j|U ]xh�´ XbZ5 eU ] X O jbXoU O Zj MeO Z S jwV h�MeO r U O Zncb�6b�� b � � � h ^ h�] UWakafXJc Sn] VYc�UeafX M r VYU h�O XJZ pnXJafX l a M ^ §¯¨ ©g¬ j|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO cMPO�]�MPO 7R� j¦p�U hxO c Mel ��� �dh VYp [�XJa hxM Z h j r MPS�O Z�Uea�8&j MPO Z h V hxMPO cJ� U�M a r M Vfp SnO c S r c�V h V S VfXbZU O Zºc S r cTV h V S VYXJZ ��� �N�¤U r ] X � � � h�O Z h j|URVYXbcKVYp�UWV4[�XbU � § h cj7eafX|URVYXbaKVYp�U O �m��� B 5��

Page 91: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

± �

U¤h 7 S afX � � � �ª¢ r c M aT[�V hxMPO cT[�XJjJVfaYU MWl ­ U °kSnO c S r cTV h V S VYXbZ���[ ] U O Uea ��� ��­ r ° ��� �dh VYp;VYp�XO� � M a r h V¦U ] c MeO j|Uea r MPO cª�oU O Z`�v[tXbaTV S a r XbZ r 8��Y�kX ­sc S r c¯� ��� ° �t­ j ° [ ] U O Uea�Z h � p?8_Zna M �s8m���� ­ ¬ ¹d� ��� ° � U O Z'­ Z °NlsSn]x] 8m� M [�V h ^ hx´ XbZ�� O�MPO � [ ] U O UWa ¬ ¹d� ��� ���.p�X¥c MP]�h Z ]�h�O X h c.VYp�XV M V¦U ] U r c M aT[�V hxMPO cT[�XJjJVfa S ^i��VfpnXqZ M VfVYXJZ ]xh�O X h c�U r c M aT[�V hxMPO [ MP] Uea hx´ XbZ&[tXbaT[�X O Z h j Sn] UWagV MVYp�X�j¦pnU h�O UR� h cJ��U O Z²VfpnXgZ�Uecfp�XbZ ]xh�O X h c.U r c M aT[�V hxMPO [ MP] Uea hx´ XJZ²[�UeaYU ]�] X ] V M VYpnXgj¦p�U hxO UR� h cb��.pnX�[�XbU � c UeafX ] U r X ] XbZ;UWjbj M afZ hxO 72V M VYpnXgZ h cfj S cfc h�MPOih�O ��XJje� � ���n�

Page 92: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

± �

U¤h 7 S afX � � � �d¢ r c M af[�V h�MPO cf[tXbjJVfa S ^ MelDMP]xh 7 M ^`XbaTc Mel ��� ��j MPO c h cTV h�O 7 MWl &�[npnX O 8 ] a h�O 7Pcj MeOnO XbjwVYXJZ r 8¡VYafU O c¯�   h�O 8 ] X O X 7Pa MPS [ncb�9& 9�� ZnX OnM VYXJc`VfpnX ]�MPO 7W� j¦p�U h�O¡]xh ^ h V|� M r VYU h�O XJZl a M ^ U�j|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO�MeO �_� S�Onh V�jJX ]x] c �dh Vfp2[�XJa hxM Z h j r MPSnO Z�UWa"8�j MPO Z h V hxMPO cd­ Uec h�O U¤h 7n� � � � ° ��.pnX�[tX|U � cvUeafX ] U r X ] XbZ\Uejbj M afZ h�O 7`V M VfpnX�Z h cfj S cfc h�MPO�hxO ��XJje� � �~�n� �dh VYp\[�XbU � co§ r U O Z\§ jj MeO  eXba"7 h�O 7²V M [tX|U � § h�O VYp�X ]�h ^ h V Mel U ]�MeO 7²j¦p�U hxO ���.pnX Me]�h 7 M ^KXJa�cT[�XJjJVfaYUiUeafX�Z h   h ZnXJZr 8²VYpnX O¸S ^ r Xba Mel [npnX O 8 ] X O X SnOnh Vfcb� &���c S j¦p Vfp�UWVdVYpnX hxO VfX O c h V h Xbc UeaTXgj M ^`[�UeafU r ] XW�D�.pnXh�O VfX O c h V38 Mel VYp�X ]�MeO 7W� j¦pnU h�O cf[tXbjwVYa S ^ h c�UeZ QTS cTVYXJZ%c S j¦p¡Vfp�UWV¥VYpnXK[�XbU � §f§f§ hxO VYX O c h V38 h cXb� S U ] V M VYpnX�U| PXJaYU�7PX Mel VYpnUWV cfXbX O\lsM akVfpnX MP]�h 7 M ^`XbaTcb�

Page 93: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

U¤h 7 S afX � � ± � ¢ r c M af[�V h�MPO cT[�XJjJVYa S ^ MelKMP]xh 7 M ^`XbaTc Mel`lsSn]x] 8m� M [�V h ^ h�´ XbZ³� O�MPO � [ ] U O UWa�Z h �p?8_Zna M �s8m� ��� ­ ¬ ¹.� ��� ° ���.p�X O�M V¦UWV h�MPO;h cdUec h�OwU¤h 7n� � � � �

B � 5 hxO j¦p�UeaYUWjJVYXJab�1¢ ] Vfp MPS 7ep®VfpnX;j|U ] j Sn] UWVYXJZ%VYaYU O c h V h�MeO X O Xba"7�8 Mel }�� X h c5c M ^`X � p�URVp h 7PpnXbauVYp�U O VfpnXgXw��[�XJa h ^KX O VYU ]�] 8 M r cfXJaT eXbZG�_���5X �nVYp h c h c.[tXbaTp�Ue[nc.X���[�XJjJVYXJZ c h�O jJXgVfpnXbcTXj|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO cvUeafX lsM a�U OGh c MP] UWVYXJZGj¦p�U h�O U O Z&Z h X ] XbjwVYa h j�X « XJjJVfc�[�afXbcTX O V h�O VfpnX2c Me]�h Z_� cTVYUWVYXUeaTXGXw��[�XJjJVfXbZºV M%] XbUeZ V M U¡aTXbZ�� cfp h l V Mel U l X � VYX O Vfpnc Mel U O X { � ���.}m�=� � �.pnXG§¯¨ ©g¬j|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO c¥U ] c M c S [n[ M aTV�VfpnX;Uecfc h 7 O ^KX O V Mel [�XbU � § V M b � b � �DU ] Vfp MPS 7Pp�VYpnXJafX;UeaTX}m� � j MPO VYa h r S V h�MeO c l a M ^ M VYpnXJa`j MPO �W7 S aYUWV h�MPO c hxO ��� U O Z®VYp h c hxO jbaTX|UecTXbc`V M �P� � hxO¬ ¹d� ���� �z�.p h c h�O jJafXbUecfX ]�hx� X ] 8�aTX y XJjJVfc�VfpnXK^ h � hxO 7 r XwV � XJX O¡]xM jbU ]�hx´ XJZ&U O Z ZnX ]xM jbU ]�hx´ XbZr U O ZncucTXbX O4h�O U¤h 7n� � � �n­ j ° � ¬  eXbaYU ]�] �PVfpnXd§¯¨ ©g¬ aTXbc Sn] Vfc lsM a�[tX|U � cu§�U O ZK§ UeafXdj MPO c h cTVfX O V�dh Vfp;[�UecTV �uM a � �

� XbU � ci§T§5U O Z §T§f§`UeafXiV38_[ h jbU ]�] 8¶UWcfc h 7 O XJZ¶V M c�V¦UWVfXbc²Uea h c h�O 7 l a M ^ VYp�X b � B � 5 U O ZB 5�� b � X���j h VYUWV hxMPO cbµ¸p M=� XJ eXbab��VYpnX ZnXJVYU h�] c Mel VfpnXbcTXoUecTc h 7 O ^`X O VYcDZ h « XJa={~���e���P�=� ��¢ºjbX O VYaYU ]h cTc S X h c.VfpnX r afX|U �_hxO 7 Mel X ] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] Xgc"8_^`^KXwVYa�8P�tU ] c M5�_O�M��dO UecvU ] VYXJa O U O j)8 M adj¦p�UWa�7PX��j MeORQTS 7mUWV h�MPO c"8_^`^KXwVYa"8�{ } �W��� ��] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] X¥c"8_^K^`XJVfa"8 h c�[nafXJcfX O V lsM a ��� X ] XJjJVYa MPO ^ M Z�X ] c

Page 94: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

���VYpnUWV h�O j ]�S ZnX MPO�] 8 O X|UeaTXbcTV O X h 7Pp r M a�VYaYU O c l XJa hxO VYX�7eaYU ] cb�mc S j¦p²Uecª¹��S j � X ]tM a � UeaTa h cfXba¯� � Ueafa¯�� M [ ] Xq­ ��� ° VYp�X M a�8³{��|�e���tU O Z\j¦pnXb^ h jbU ] cTVYa S jJV S afXJc�Vfp�UWVvUeafX¥U ] VfXba O U O V|�k§ O U O U ] VYXJa O U O Vj¦pnXJ^ h j|U ] c�VYa S jJV S afXW� MPOn] 8�jbUea r MPO UWV M ^Kc�[�UWaTV h j h [�UWVYX h�O VYpnX���� X ] XbjJVfa MPO�h j2cTVfa S jwV S aTXqU O ZVYp�XbcfX�j|UWa r MPO cd^qU'8 r XgZ h   h ZnXbZ hxO V M V �NM Z h c QTMPh�O V.cTXJVYcJ� � ¢���U O Z � -��¸�nc S j¦p\VYpnUWV OnM j|Uea¯�r MPO UWV M ^ h c r MPO Z�XbZ&V M U OnM VfpnXba�jbUea r MPO UWV M ^ hxO VYpnX2cfUe^KX2cTXJV={~} �e����»ºpnX O U ] VYXJa O U O j)8c"8_^`^KXwVYa�8qUW[n[ ]�h XbcJ�_VfpnX� WU ] X O jJXoU O Zqj MPO Z S jJV h�MPO r U O Z M a r h VYU ] c lsM aT^£[nU h aTc �dh VYpqX O Xba"7 h XJcZ h cTVYa h r S VYXbZic"8_^`^KXwVYa h j|U ]�] 84U r MPS VdVYpnX U XbaT^ h X O Xba"7�8P� � h�O jJX ��� h c�U O U ] VYXJa O U O V�cTVfa S j��V S afXe�n¹��S j � X ]zM a � UWafa h cfXJa�� � Ueafa¯� � M [ ] X2­ ��� ° VfpnX M a�8p8 h X ] Znc r U O Znc.Vfp�UWV.X���p h r h V.X ] XbjJVfa MPO �p MP] X�c�8_^K^`XJVfa"8P��§ O VYpnXJcfXv^ M ZnX ] cb�¸VYpnX r U O Z4c�VYa S jJV S afXoaTXbcTXb^ r ] XbcªVYp�UWV Mel*U¤h 7n� � � �n­�U ° r S V�dh Vfp r U O Znc B 5oU O Z B � 5 r X hxO 7;[�XJa l XJjJV�^ h afa M a h ^qU�7eXbc MeluMPO X M VfpnXbagU O Z ]xh�� X �dh cTX lsM aoVYp�XM VfpnXba r U O Zncb� ­s�.pnXdc ]�h 7PpmV r afXbU �¸h�O 7 Mel VYp h cDc"8_^K^`XJVfa"8 hxO U¤h 7n� � � �n­�U °¤h c�Z h cTj S cTcfXJZ r X ]�M=� � °§ O ^ M ZnX ] c �dh VfpKX ] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] X.c�8�^`^`XJVYa�8P�mVYp�X�j MPO �W7 S aYUWV h�MPO c lsM af^`XbZ l a M ^ U O b � B � 5 X��¸�j h V¦UWV h�MPO UWafX�ZnX)7PX O XJaYUWVfX �dh VYp²VYp M cfX lsM af^`XbZ l a M ^ B 5 � b � �D§ O ¹��S j � X ] VfpnX M a"8P�nVfp h c ] X|UeZ�cV M V �NM²M  PXJa ] Ue[n[ hxO 7qVYafU O c h V hxMPO c �dh VfpGU O X O Xba"7�8 pnU ]xl � � U'8 r XwV � XJX O VYpnUWV Mel [tX|U � cv§�U O Z§ �_§ O U�^ M ZnX ] c S j¦piUec ��� VYpnX M a"85VYpnUWV hxO j ]xS ZnXbcªX ] XbjwVYa MeO � X ] XbjwVYa MPO4h�O VfXbaYUWjJV hxMPO cJ�¸VfpnXbaTXh coU4c h 7 Onh ��jbU O Voj MPS [ ]xh�O 7 r XJV � XbX O VfpnXbcTX�V �NM j MeO �W7 S afUWV hxMPO cJ�¥�.p h coj MeO �W7 S afUWV hxMPOGh�O VfXba��UejwV h�MeO ] XbUeZncvV M4h�O � [np�UWcfX�U O Z MPS V�� Mel � [np�UecTX�j M ^ r hxO UWV hxMPO c Mel b � B � 5 U O Z B 5 � b � �v�.pnXXbc�V h ^qUWVfXbZ2cT[ ]�h VfV hxO 7 r XJV � XbX O VfpnXbcTX h�O � [np�UecTX.U O Z MPS VT� MWl � [np�UWcfXNj M ^ r hxO UWV h�MPO c h c�c S �`j h X O VV M Uejbj MPSnO V lsM a¥cTV¦URVYXbc�UWV�VfpnX4[ M c h V h�MeO c MWl [�XbU � c�§f§gU O Z%§f§f§¦µ p M=� XJ PXJab� MPOn] 8 VfpnX S [n[�XJacTVYUWVYX h cN[�afXbZ h jJVfXbZ4V M j|UeaTa"8 M [�V h j|U ]th�O VfX O c h V38P� � M ZnX ] c �dh VYpqX ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] Xvc"8_^`^KXwVYa�8qjbU OVYp�XbafX lsM afXoUejbj MPSnO V lsM au[�XbU � §T§f§ªU O Z lsM akU�c�V¦UWVfX �dh Vfp²U O X O Xba"7�84UW[n[na M [na h UWVYX lsM aN[tX|U � §f§¦µp M=� XJ PXJab� VYpnXS8;j|U O�OnM V UejJj MPSnO V lsM akVYp�X M r cfXJaT PXJZ hxO VfX O c h V38 hxO [�XbU � §f§¦�§ V¤pnUec r XbX O c S 707PXbc�VYXJZ�VYp�URV¤j¦pnXJ^ h j|U ] c S r c�V h V S V hxMPO �Rc S j¦p5UWc hxO � � ¹.� ��� �R^qU'8 r aTX|U �

j¦p�Uea"7PX`j MPORQTS 7mUWV hxMPO c"8_^K^`XJVfa"8 U O Z Vfp S c�UejJj MPSnO V lsM a�VYpnX h�O VYX O c h V38 h�O [�XbU � §f§w{~���P� �e�R� �¹�XJafXW� � XdXw��Ue^ h�O XuVYp h cDU O Z M VfpnXba�c�8�^`^`XJVYa�8 r aTX|U �¸h�O 7�^KXJj¦p�U Onh cf^`cb�¤§ O Xw��Ue^ h�O�h�O 7vVfpnXbcTX^`Xbj¦p�U O�h cf^`cb� � Xqj MeO c h ZnXbagVYpnX h agX « XbjwVYc MPO VfpnXKaTX ] UWV h  PX h�O VYX O c h V h Xbc Mel [tX|U � c�§f§�U O Z'§T§f§­ cTXbX���U r ] X � � � ° ��§ O VfpnXoX���[tXba h ^`X O V¦U ] cT[�XJjJVYa S ^ MWl c S r c�V h V S VYXJZ ��� _�cJ�nVYpnXJcfXoV �uM [�XbU � cp�U| PX�a MeS 7Pp ] 84Xb� S U ]zh�O VYX O c h V38³{~�P���t�W}��t�W�n���P��� � � � �»ºp h�] X ¹��S j � X ] U O Z ��� VfpnX M a"8 h�O j ]�S ZnX MeO Xw� X ] XJjJVfa MPO ^qUWVfa h �2X ] Xb^`X O VYc MPOn] 8 r XwV � XJX O

UeZ Q UWjbX O VqUWV M ^KcJ�uVYp�X §¯¨ ©g¬ ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O¡hxO j ]xS ZnXbc MPO X�� X ] XbjwVYa MPO ^KUWVYa h �¡X ] XJ^KX O VYc r X��V � XbX O U ]�] URV M ^`cb� � � �N­ � � � ° �`�.p h c r aTX|U � c�X ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] X2c"8_^K^`XJVfa"8 U O Z�jbU S cfXJc¥VfpnX` WUR�

Page 95: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�m���U r ] X � � � � & URV h�M c Mel h�O VfX O c h V h Xbc lsM akcfX ] XbjwVYXJZi[tX|U � c hxO VYpnXvcf[tXbjJVfaYU Mel U¤h 7Pcb� � � ��� � � � �nU O Z� � ±��

���������4����� ��������"����F������#� �#�"���6��� ��"#�����$�%�'& (N�-�����#�� �N� ���LMN�%�'& ���-�������� �N� ���$�IMN�<�<& ���-�������� �N�

�������C(6(���������� (�(6( �������@(6(��#�E�����C(�(6( �������@(6(�� (�(6(�������:��� 5 � G 1�* � �������:��� 5 � 5 G * G

� ��#M8�������:��� 5 � G3 * 5 ����#MN�#�����:��� 5 �%50* � ����0MN�������:��� 5 � J * +�"���6MN�%�'& 5 � 5 * 5�

���;MN�<�<&� ����B��������;"�� �����L��D�������B ���-�������� �N� ���-�����#�� �N�

���C��?�����LMN�%�'& �����B������ �������@(6(��#�E�����C(�(6(2�������@(N���<(6(1 5 �<)#* + 3 5 � 5 * 1457 5 �'1�* G3 5 � 5 * 1 J3 5 �<)#* J 5 5 � 5 * J 35 5 �<)#* JJ 5 � 5 * � 3J 5 �'1�* 1-) 5 * 5�J � 5

�$��� MN�%�'&� ����B��������;"�� �����L��D�������B ���-�������� �N� ���-�����#�� �N�

��� ��?���$� � M8�%�<& �����B������ �������@(6(��#�E�����C(�(6(2�������@(N���<(6(1 5 �'1�* +#� 5 � 5 * 5 37 5 � 3 * 3 ) 5 * G + � 53 5 �'1�* 5 J 5 � 5 * 1455 5 �<7#* � 5 5 * 5 3 � 5J 5 �'1�* 11 5 * ) G � 5

] X O jbX r U O Znc�V M r X �dh ZnXJaoVYp�U O VYpnX5j MeO Z S jwV h�MeO r U O Znc hxOSU�h 7n� � � �n­�U ° ���.pnX r aTX|U �¸hxO 7 MelX ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X;c"8_^`^KXwVYa"8 h c`U ] c M Ue[�[�UeafX O V hxO VfpnX\»'U OnOnh Xba lsSnO jwV hxMPO c Mel U¤h 7n� � ��}��¶¢�cZ h cfj S cfcfXJZGU r M  PXe� U O U ] VYXJa O U O Vdj¦pnXJ^ h j|U ] c�VYa S jJV S afX h c MPO X � p�XbafX h V h c.[ M cfc h r ] XoV M Z h   h ZnXVYp�Xvj|UWa r MPO c h�O V M V �NM Z h c QTMeh�O VªcfXJVfcb� � ¢��gU O Z � -��¸�¸c S j¦p4Vfp�UWV OnM jbUea r MPO URV M ^ h c r MPO Z�XbZV M U OnM VfpnXba�j|Uea r MeO UWV M ^ hxO VfpnX�cfUe^KX¥cfXwV|�d»ºpnX O X ] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] X�c"8_^`^KXwVYa"8\Ue[�[ ]�h Xbcb� VYp�X WU ] X O jbX5U O Z&j MPO Z S jJV h�MPO r U O Z M a r h V¦U ] c�UeafX2aTX ] UWVYXJZ r 8�j¦p�U O 7 hxO 7²VYpnX2c h 7 O&Mel VfpnX � U| PX��lsSnO jwV hxMPO�MPO�MPO X MWl VYpnXJcfXkcTXJVfcb� � ¢�� M a � - �¸�¤�.p h c h c@VYp�XNj|UWcfX lsM a@VYp�XNafX ] UWV h  eX ] 8 y UWV r U O ZncJ�B ) G B �) U O ZSb�G b � �5¹ M=� XJ PXJab� VYpnX M VfpnXba r U O Zncb� h�O j ]�S Z h�O 7KVYpnX5p h 7PpnXbc�V� WU ] X O jbX`U O Z ]xM�� Xbc�Vj MeO Z S jwV h�MeO r U O Zncb�¸ZnXw  h UWVfX afUWVYp�Xba�cTVfa MPO 7 ] 8 l a M ^ Vfp h c�[nUeaTV h j ] Xw� p MP] Xuc"8_^`^KXwVYa"8 r XJp�U|  hxM ab�»ºp hx] XvVfp h c.c�8�^`^`XJVYa�8 r aTX|U �¸hxO 75Z M XJc,7 h  eX�c M ^`X h�O VfX O c h V38qV M [�XbU � §T§ hxO U¤h 7n� � � �n­�U ° ��VYp�XaYURV h�MGMWlvhxO VfX O c h V h Xbc lsM a2[�XbU � §f§�V M [tX|U � §T§f§ h c²��� �W�1­ ��U r ] X � � � ° �ªUec5j M ^`[�UeaTXbZ%V M VYp�Xa MeS 7Pp ] 84Xb� S U ]zh�O VYX O c h V h XJc.cfXJX O X���[�XJa h ^`X O VYU ]�] 8P�LNMPO c h ZnXJaYU r ] 8 ] Uea"7PXba.X « XJjJVfc l a M ^ X ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] X�c"8_^K^`XJVfa"8 r aTX|U �¸hxO 7qUWafX�cfXbX O�h�O VYp�Xr U O Z cTVfa S jwV S aTX Mel [ ] U O UWav�_� �5Z h p?8_Zna M �s8m� ��� ­ ¬ ¹.� ��� ° � U¤h 7n� � � �n­ j ° �.�.pnX ]�MPO X¥[�U h afcMPO VYpnX M �s8s7PX O c Mel VfpnX&p?8�Z�a M �s8 c S r c�V h V S X O Vfc�UeZnZºV �uM UeZnZ h V hxMPO U ]  WU ] X O jbX r U O ZnciV MVYp�X ��� r U O Z�c�VYa S jJV S afXKU O Z&VYpnXJcfXKUeafX ] U r X ] XbZ � 5oU O Z � G h�OSU¤h 7n� � � �n­ j ° �5�.pnXbaTX h c�U ] c M

Page 96: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P}c S r cTVYU O V h U ] ^ h � hxO 7 Mel VYpnXgZnX ]�M j|U ]xh�´ XbZ;U O Z ]�M j|U ]�h�´ XbZq WU ] X O jJX r U O ZncJ�tU O Z;VYp h c.^ h � hxO 7 h cOnM Vd^ h aTa M aTXbZ hxO VfpnXgj MPO Z S jJV h�MPO r U O Zncb� LNM ^`[�Uea h c MeOiMWl VfpnX�»¡U O�Onh XJa lsSnO jJV h�MPO c Mel�¬ ¹.���� ­ U¤h 7n� � ��� °N�dh VYp SnO c S r cTV h V S VYXbZ ���� ­ U¤h 7n� � ��} ° U ] c M aTXJ eX|U ] c�c h 7 Onh ��j|U O V ] 8²c�VYa MPO 7PXJaX « XbjwVYc l a M ^ X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X5c"8_^`^KXwVYa"8 r aTX|U �¸hxO 7n�;§ O'SnO c S r c�V h V S VfXbZ ��� ��VfpnX5»¡U O�Onh XJalsSnO jwV hxMPO c lsM a r U O Znc B ) U O ZlbnUeaTX�afX ] UWVYXJZoV M VYp M cfX Mel B �) U O Zlb � r 8�X ] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] X�c�8_^K^`XJVfa"8P�§ O ¬ ¹.� ��� � OnMPO X MWl VfpnX r U O Znc UeaTX�[nU h aTXbZ h�O VYp h c.^qU OnO XbaJ�u�.p�X¥U r c M aT[�V hxMPO cf[tXbjJVfa S ^Mel#U�h 7n� � � �n­ j ° cTp M=� c5U � X|U � [�XbU � §f§¦� �dh Vfp'[ MP] Uea h�´ UWV hxMPO [�UeaYU ]�] X ] V M VYpnX4[ MP] 8�^`Xba�UR� h cU O ZiU O;hxO VfX O c h V38qaYUWV h�M��dh Vfp²[�XbU � §T§f§ Mel ���x�=�i­scfXJX���U r ] X � � � ° ����U r ] X � � � hxO Z h j|UWVfXbcNVfp�UWV|�h�O UeZnZ h V hxMPO V M VYp�X\X���[tXbjwVYXJZqb � B � 5 U O Z B 5 � b � X���j h VYUWV hxMPO cJ�N[tX|U � §T§�p�UecKU O �P� �j MeO Vfa h r S V hxMPO�l a M ^ B 5 � B � 5 � �.p h c�^KUQ8 aTXbc S�] V lsM af^ VYpnXKc S r cTV h V S V h�MPO � h�O Z S jbXJZ¡^ h � h�O 7r XJV � XbX O VYpnX ]�M j|U ]�h�´ XbZ²U O Z\Z�X ]�M j|U ]�h�´ XbZ r U O Zncb��.pnX r U O ZicTVYa S jJV S afX�U O Z U r c M af[�V h�MPO cf[tXbjwVYa S ^ Mel¤lsSn]x] 8m� M [�V h ^ hx´ XbZ�� OnMeO � [ ] U O Uea ¬ ¹.�

��� UeafX�cTp M=�dO&h�O�U¤h 7Pcb� � � �n­ Z ° U O Z � � �n­sZ ° ��afXbcT[�XJjJV h  PX ] 8e��§ O VfpnX M [�V h ^ h�´ XbZ�c�VYa S jJV S afXW�VYp�Xd  hxO 8 ] X O X r MPO ZncªUeaTX a M V¦URVYXbZ MPS V MWl [ ] U O X r 8`U r MPS Vu� �gb� � p h j¦p`j|U OK] X|UeZ2V M ^ h � h�O 7 MelQ&U O Z � r U O Zncb��»ºp hx] X VYpnX�j MPO Z S jwV hxMPO U O Z;p h 7PpnXbc�Vk WU ] X O jbX r U O ZncdUeaTXoc h ^ hx] Uea�V M VYp M cTXMel VYp�Xi[ ] U O UWa�cTVfa S jwV S aTXe�ªc h 7 Onh ��jbU O V2Z h « XJafX O jbXbcKUeaTX4cfXJX O¶hxO VYpnX ]xM=� XJa�� X O Xba"7�8¡ WU ] X O jJXr U O Zncb�D§ O VYpnX�U r c M aT[�V hxMPO cf[tXbjwVYa S ^\��[tX|U � §f§ªafXwV¦U hxO c.a MPS 7Pp ] 8`VYp�X�cYUe^`X h�O VYX O c h V38²Uec lsM aVYp�Xu[ ] U O Ueazc�VYa S jJV S afXW� r S V [tX|U � §T§f§ ]xM cfXJc hxO VYX O c h V38gc S j¦p�Vfp�UWV@VYpnXªaYURV h�MdMel VYpnX h�O VfX O c h V h Xbc h c��� ±4­ cTXbX���U r ] X � � � ° �¤¢ c h ^ hx] Uea r Xbp�U|  h�M a h cucfXbX O;h�O VfpnX r U O Z²j M ^`[ M c h V h�MeO c MWl �¤U r ] X � �x�P�»ºp hx] X\VfpnX r U O Zºj M ^`[ M c h V h�MPO Mel [tX|U � §f§5cTVYUQ8_c²a MPS 7Pp ] 8®VYpnXGcfUe^KX�Uec lsM aqVfpnX�[ ] U O UeacTVfa S jwV S aTXe�D[tX|U � §f§T§M7mU h�O c�U r MPS Vq� � � B 5 � B � 5 j¦p�UeaYUWjJVYXJab��§ O ¬ ¹.� ��� ��VfpnX4a M V¦UWV h�MPOMel VYpnX5  h�O 8 ] X O X r 8��� ^g�p�Uec�U;c h 7 Onh ��jbU O VgX « XbjwV MeO VfpnX h�O VYX O c h V38GaYUWV h�M;Mel [�XbU � §T§���[tX|U �§f§T§¦� � p h j¦p h c4��� ��� lsM a�VYpnX²[ ] U O UWa�cTVfa S jwV S aTX;U O Zº��� ± lsM a�VfpnX OnMPO [ ] U O Uea�c�VYa S jJV S afXe��§ OSnO c S r c�V h V S VYXJZ ��� �dU%a M V¦UWV h�MPO Mel VfpnXG  hxO 8 ] X O X r 8!� �g²p�UeciU%^ S j¦p!cf^KU ]�] XbaqX « XJjJVb�j¦p�U O 7 h�O 72VfpnXgaYUWV h�M�l a M ^���� �W��V M ��� �P±;­ cfXJXg�¤U r ] X � � � ° �¢vcoZ h cfj S cfcTXbZ h�O ��XbjW� � ��}�� ��� ��� X ] XbjJVfa MPO ^ M ZnX ] c�^KU'8 h�O j ]�S ZnX�VYpnX�X « XbjJVfc Mel j¦pnXJ^ h j|U ]

c S r cTV h V S V h�MeO r 8®U ] VYXJa hxO 7�VYpnX;X O Xba"7�8 Mel VYpnX O � � M a r h V¦U ]NMPO VYp�XijbUea r MPO UWV M ^ V M&� p h j¦pVYp�X²c S r c�V h V S X O V h c2UWVTV¦Uej¦pnXJZ@{~�P�����_�b� �G»�X²j|U O UW[n[ ] 8'U�c h ^ hx] Ueag[tXba�V S a r UWV hxMPO¡hxO §¯¨ ©g¬VYp�X M a�8P�³U O Z U¤h 7Pcb� � � �n­ r ° U O Z � � �n­ r ° cfp M=� VYp�X r U O Z�cTVfa S jwV S aTX2U O Z�cT[�XJjJVfa S ^ M r VYU h�O XJZh�O §¯¨ ©g¬ VYp�X M a�8 � p�X O VYp�XoX O XJa�7�8 Mel VfpnX O � � M a r h VYU ] c MPO jbUea r MPO ck��U O Z²� Mel*U¤h 7n� � � ��UeaTX]�M=� XbaTXbZ r 8'�2X ��»�X �dh�]x] afX l XJaoV M Vfp h cv^ M ZnX ] Uecoc S r c¯� ��� �@U O ZGj M ^`[�UeafX�VYpnX2aTXbc Sn] Vfc

Page 97: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�e�

0.15 0.2 0.25

1/N

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

5.5

6Po

sitio

n (e

V)

U¤h 7 S afX � � ��� ��O Xba"7 h XJc Mel VYpnXucTV¦URVYXbc 7 h   hxO 7�a h cTXªV M [�XbU � c hxO VYp�XucT[�XJjJVYafU MelnlsS�]�] 8m� M [�V h ^ hx´ XJZ³�OnMPO � [ ] U O Uea ¬ ¹d� ��� ­ U¤h 7n� � � ± ° �W PXbaTc S cd� � & � pnXJafX & h c VYpnX O_S ^ r XJa Mel [npnX O 8 ] X O X S�Onh Vfch�O VYpnX MP]�h 7 M ^`Xbab�²�.p�Xqc Me]�h Z ]�hxO Xbc�j MPO�O XbjwV�VYpnXq[ MPhxO VYcb�¤U O Z'VfpnX4Z M VfVYXJZ ]�hxO Xbc�cfp M�� VYp�XafXJc Sn] VYc Mel U ]xh�O XbUeaDafX�7eafXbcTc hxMPO ���.pnX ]xh�O XbUeaDafX)7PafXJcfc hxMPO 7 h  PXJc h�O � Onh VfX j¦pnU h�O4]xh ^ h Vfc Mel �¤[tX|U �§\­ j h afj ] XJc ° �_� ���GX µu[�XbU � § r ­scf� S UeaTXbc ° �_������X µN[�XbU � §T§\­ Z h Ue^ MeO Znc ° }�� � � X µN[tX|U �§f§T§�­ S [ � UeafZ_� [ MPh�O V hxO 75VYa h U O 7 ] Xbc ° ��� � �`X µ�U O Z [�XbU � § ­ Z M��dOm� UeafZ_� [ MPh�O V hxO 7KVfa h U O 7 ] Xbc °��� ± 2X �

Page 98: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�m�

0.15 0.2 0.25

1/N

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

Peak

inte

nsity

/ N

U¤h 7 S afX � � � � ¬ cfj hx]�] UWV M aucTVfafX O 7eVYpnc¥­ h�O VYX O c h V h XJc °ªlsM aNVYpnX�c�V¦UWVfXbc�7 h   hxO 7�a h cfX�V M [�XbU � c h�O VYp�Xcf[tXbjwVYafU Mel�lsSn]x] 8m� M [�V h ^ hx´ XbZ�� OnMPO � [ ] U O Uea ¬ ¹d� ���� ���.pnX OnM VYUWV hxMPO\h cvUWc h�OXU¤h 7�� � � ���d�.pnXh�O VfX O c h V h XbcdUeaTX�cfp M=�dO\MPO U5[tXba¯� SnO�h VT� jbX ]�] r Uec h cb� r 8;Z h   h Z h�O 7 r 84VYpnX MP]xh 7 M ^KXJa ] X O 7eVfp³��& ��dh Vfp ¬ ¹d� ��� V M ZnXJVfXbaf^ h�O X4p M=�8� X ]x] Vfp h c2UW[n[na M Uej¦p%^ M ZnX ] c¥VfpnX²X « XbjwVYc Mel j¦pnXJ^ h j|U ]c S r cTV h V S V h�MeO � LNM ^`[�Uea h c MPO&Mel VfpnX r U O Z'c�VYa S jJV S afX Mel c S r c�� ��� U O Z ¬ ¹d� ��� afXJ eX|U ] cc M ^KX¥c S r c�V¦U O V h U ] Z hx« XbaTX O jJXbcJ�o§ O&¬ ¹d� ���� ��^ h � h�O 7 r XJV � XbX O&]xM jbU ]�hx´ XbZ\U O Z ZnX ]xM jbU ]�hx´ XbZr U O Znc M jbj S afco[na h ^KUea hx] 8 �dh VYp h�O VfpnX¥ WU ] X O jJX r U O Zncb� � p h�] X hxO c S r c�� ���� �³^ h � h�O 7 M jJj S aTch�O r M Vfp®VfpnX4 WU ] X O jbX;U O Z®j MPO Z S jJV h�MPO r U O Znc5U O Z h c5U r h V2c�VYa MeO 7PXba hxO VYpnX²j MPO Z S jwV hxMPOr U O Zncb� © XbcT[ h VfXvVYp�XbcfX�Z hx« XbafX O jbXJcb�nVfpnX M  PXbafU ]�] ^qU47 Onh V S ZnX Mel VYpnX�^ h � h�O 7 r XJV � XbX O r U O ZncUe[n[tX|UWafc l U h a ] 81c h ^ h�] Uea r XJV � XbX O c S r c�� ��� U O Z ¬ ¹d� ��� �.§ V h c²VYpnXJafX lsM afX c M ^`X � p�URVc S af[na h c hxO 7�VYpnUWV�VYp�X²cf[tXbjJVfa S ^ Mel c S r c�� ��� cfp M=� c5a MeS 7Pp ] 8'XJ� S U ]kh�O VfX O c h V38 lsM a�[�XbU � c§f§�U O Z%§f§f§¦��¢ ] c M ��[tX|U � §f§T§gp�Uec 7PaTX|UWVfXba�Vfp�U O � � j¦p�UWaYUejwVYXba lsM a B 5 � B � 5 X���j h VYUWV hxMPO cb�§ O c S ^`^KUea"8e��VYpnX2c S r c¯� ��� ^ M Z�X ] r afX|U � cgX ] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] X�c�8_^K^`XJVfa"8GU O Z 7 h  eXbcg[tX|U � §f§c S r cTVYU O V h U ]�h�O VfX O c h V38P� r S VkVfpnXoZnXwV¦U hx] c Mel VYpnXvc"8_^K^`XJVfa"8 r aTX|U �¸h�O 72Z M�OnM V.U�7PafXJX �dh VYp4VYp�XafXJc Sn] VYc M r V¦U h�O XJZ lsM aDVYpnX�UWjJV S U ] j¦p�Xb^ h j|U ] c S r c�V h V S V hxMPO4Mel@¬ ¹.� ��� ���.p h c h�O Z h j|UWVfXbcDVYp�URV

Page 99: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �[tXbaTV S a r h�O 72VYp�X�X O Xba"7�8 MelxO � M a r h V¦U ] c h c O�M V�Ut7 M�M Z²^ M ZnX ]³Mel j¦pnXb^ h jbU ] c S r cTV h V S V h�MPO �¢ ] VYp MPS 7Pp�VYpnX�c S r c¯� ��� ^ M ZnX ] h cv� S�h VYX�c h ^ h�] Uea.V M VfpnX ��� X ] XJjJVfa MPO ^ M Z�X ] c S cfXJZ r 8

�gUeaTVfcTVYX h�O WZY [^] {~���J�DU O Z L p�U O Zna M cfc WZY [^] {��e�����³VYpnXJafX`UeafX2c M ^`X�c h 7 Onh �nj|U O VgZ h « XJafX O jbXbc hxOVYp�X2afXbc Sn] Vfcb���.p�X`^ M ZnX ]�Mel �gUea�VYcTVfX hxO WZY�[^] {~���w��[nafXJZ h jwVYc�VYpnUWV�[tX|U � §T§ h co[ MP] Uea h�´ XbZ�[tXba¯�[tX O Z h j Sn] Uea�V M VYpnX`[ MP] 8_^`XbagUR� h c � p hx] X2VYpnX`^ M ZnX ]�MeldL pnU O Zna M cfc WZY![^] {~�P�R�D[naTXbZ h jJVfc¥VYp�X[ MP] Uea h�´ UWV hxMPOgh c¤[nUeaYU ]x] X ] V M VYp�Xk[ Me] 8_^KXJa�UR� h cb� U�M a VYpnXNc S r c¯� ��� ^ M ZnX ] �R[�XbU � §T§ h c¤[ MP] Uea��h�´ XbZ\a MPS 7ep ] 8i�� �8[tXbaf[tX O Z h j Sn] Uea U O Z�� ��[�UeaYU ]�] X ] V M VYp�X¥[ MP] 8_^`XbadUR� h c�­ U¤h 7n� � � �i­ r °f° �¨ M VYX�Vfp�UWV hxO&¬ ¹d� ��� ��[�XbU � §T§ h cv[ MP] Uea hx´ XbZ [�UeaYU ]�] X ] V M VYp�X�[ Me] 8_^KXJaoUR� h cb�³U O ZGc M VYp�X[tXbaf[tX O Z h j Sn] Uea�j M ^`[ MPO X O V�Ue[n[tX|UeaTc¤V M r XkU O UeaTV hxl UejwV Mel VYpnXkc S r c¯� ��� ^ M ZnX ] ���gUea�VYcTVfX hxOWZY [^] {~���J�¤U ] c M [naTXbZ h jJVo[tX|U � cv§f§ U O Z�§T§f§kV M p�U| PX2a MPS 7Pp ] 8iXb� S U ]�h�O VYX O c h V38 hxO VYp�X ]�h ^ h V Mel]�MeO 7\j¦pnU h�O cJ� � p hx] X L p�U O Zna M cfc WZY [^] {~�P�R�ª[nafXJZ h jwV�[tX|U � §T§oV M pnU= eX4c S r cTVYU O V h U ]uhxO VfX O c h V38MPO�MP]�h 7 M ^`Xbafc r S V¥ WU O�h cfp h�O 7 h�O VYX O c h V38 h�O VYpnX ]�MPO 7R� j¦p�U hxO&]�h ^ h Vb�K�.p�Xqc S r c�� ���� ^ M ZnX ][naTXbZ h jJVYc.[tX|U � c.§T§NU O Z;§f§f§�V M p�U| PXgXb� S U ]�h�O VYX O c h V38 MPO²]xMPO 72j¦p�U hxO cb�:- S V U�7mU hxO �¸VYpnX ] Uea�7PXh�O VfX O c h V38 h�O [tX|U � §f§ h cNU O UeaTV hxl UejwV Mel VfpnXoc S r c�� ���� ^ M ZnX ] ��U O Z²[tX|U � §f§ h cN[nafXJZ h jwVYXbZ4V Mr X � X|U �4lsM a ]�MPO 72j¦p�U h�O c MWl [ ] U O Uea ¬ ¹.� ��� �

U¤h�O�h VYX�� c h�´ X X « XbjwVYcdUeaTXvX��nUW^ hxO XbZ hxORU¤h 7Pcb� � � � U O Z � � ±�� � p h j¦p²j M ^`[�UeafX VYpnXvcf[tXbjJVfa S ^MelNMP]�h 7 M ^`Xbafc �dh VYp r XJV � XbX O �\U O Z �i[�pnX O 8 ] a h�O 7Pc �dh VYp&VYpnX`cf[tXbjwVYa S ^ M r V¦U hxO XbZ h�O VYp�X]�h ^ h V Melk]�MPO 7;j¦p�U h�O cJ� U¤h 7n� � � � cfp M=� c�VYp�UWV MP]xh 7 M ^`XbaTc Mel ��� Xw��p h r h V�V �NM\O X � [tX|U � cJ�] U r X ] XbZ5§ r U O Z`§ je�¸VYp�URVªUe[n[na M Uej¦pq[tX|U � §�Uec�VfpnX�j¦pnU h�O`] X O 7eVYp h c hxO jbaTX|UecTXbZ³��»'X�UWVfVfa h r S VYXVYp�XbcfX�VYafU O c h V hxMPO c.V M cTV¦URVYXbc VYp�URVvp�U| eX�VYpnX�cYUW^KX�Xw��j h V¦UWV h�MPO Uec h cd[nafXJcfX O V h�O [tX|U � §¦� r S V�dh Vfp�p h 7PpnXJa �_hxO XJV h j2X O Xba"7�8P� h �~Xe�5VYpnXS8 UeafX`p h 7epnXba�[�UWaTV h j ] Xw� hxO �¯U�� r M �\c�V¦UWVfXbc MWl VfpnXKcfUe^`XXw��j h V MeO Vfp�UWV h c�[naTXbcfX O V hxO [tX|U � §¦�P�.pnXbcTX.VYaYU O c h V h�MeO c �dhx]�]_OnM V r XkafXJc MP]  PXbZ h�O Xw��[�XJa h ^KX O VfcMPO Ue^ M af[np MPS cgcYUe^`[ ] Xbcb� c hxO jbXKUe^ M af[�p MPS c�cfUe^K[ ] Xbcgj MPO V¦U hxO UiZ h c�VYa h r S V h�MPOGMel X « XbjwV h  eXj MeORQTS 7mUWVfXbZ ] X O 7eVYpncJ�;�.pnX ]xM jbUWV hxMPO&Mel VYp�XbcfXK[�XbU � c�j¦p�U O 7PXbc�aYUe[ h Z ] 8 �dh VYp j¦p�U hxO'] X O 7eVfpU O ZiVYpnX¥U| PXJaYU�7PX M  PXJa�VYp�X¥X « XJjJV h  PX¥j MPORQTS 7mUWV hxMPO;] X O 7eVYp�c �dhx]�]³] X|UeZ;V M U r a M UeZ\cf[tXbjJVfa S ^VYpnUWV �dh�]x] Ue[n[tX|UeadUWc�U r UWj � 7ea MPSnO Z h�O VfpnXgXw��[�XJa h ^KX O VYU ] cT[�XJjJVYa S ^i�¬ ¹d� ��� U ] c M cfp M�� c¥U4[tX|U � � ] U r X ] XbZG§ r hxO U¤h 7n� � � ±��³VYpnUWVgUe[n[�a M Uej¦p�Xbcg[�XbU � § �dh Vfph�O jbafXbUec hxO 7;j¦p�U hxO ] X O 7WVYp³�`¹ M=� XJ eXbab� SnOn]xh�� X ��� � ¬ ¹d� ��� U ] c M Xw��p h r h Vfc�[�XbU � §f§ �dh VfpU4[ M c h V h�MeO VYp�URV h coaTX ] URV h  eX ] 8 hxO ZnXJ[�X O ZnX O V Mel j¦p�U hxO&] X O 7eVYp³���.pnX5X O Xba�7 h Xbc MWl VfpnX2cTVYUWVYXJcVYpnUWV 7 h  PX�a h cfX¥V M VYp�X�[tX|U � c hxOIU¤h 7n� � � ±qUeafX�[ ]xM VfVfXbZGU�7PU h�O c�V 5J h�OXU¤h 7�� � � ��� �.pnX�aTXbc Sn] Vfccfp M�� VYp�URVd[�XbU � § r h ckj MPO  PXba"7 h�O 7 MPO V M § h�O VfpnX ]�MPO 72j¦pnU h�O;]�h ^ h V|� � p hx] XvVfpnX M VYpnXJa.[�XbU � c

Page 100: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�m±UeaTXqafX ] UWV h  eX ] 8 hxO ZnXJ[�X O ZnX O V Mel j¦pnU h�O¡] X O 7WVYp³� U¤h 7n� � � ��U ] c M c S 707eXbcTVfc�VYp�URV2Uec�VfpnX4c�V¦UWVfXafXJcf[ MPO c h r ] X lsM a�[�XbU � § r jJa M cTcfXJc�VYp�UWV¤afXJcf[ MPO c h r ] X lsM a¤[tX|U � §T§¦� h V h�O VfXbaYUWjJVYc¤U O Z h c¤afXJ[�X ]�] XbZ³��.p h c�afU h cTXbcdVYpnX�[ M cfc h r h�]xh V38KVYp�UWVb�tUec�c S 707PXJcTVfXbZ r 8 L p�U O Z�a M cTc WZY [^] {~�P�R��� [�XbU � §f§N^qU'8 r Xr M afa M��dhxO 7 hxO VfX O c h V38 l a M ^�§ r ��¹ M=� XJ PXJab� U¤h 7�� � � ��� � p h j¦p&[ ]xM VYc VYpnX hxO VfX O c h V h Xbc Mel [�XbU � c§ r ��§f§dU O Z §f§f§dU47mU h�O cTV 5J �tcfp M=� c ]�h VfV ] X�X « XbjwV Mel VfpnX�jJa M cTc hxO 7 Mel [tX|U � co§ r U O Z�§T§ MPO VYp�Xh�O VfX O c h V h XbcJ���.p h c Uea"7 S Xbc U�7PU h�O c�V.[tX|U � §T§ r M afa M=�dh�O 7 h�O VfX O c h V38 l a M ^ [tX|U � § r �

U¤h 7�� � � ±qU O ZG�¤U r ] X � � �qcfp M�� VYpnUWV � Onh VYX�� c hx´ X¥X « XbjJVfc O X|UWa ] 8\Z MPS r ] X�VfpnX hxO VfX O c h V38 Mel[tX|U � §f§ afX ] UWV h  PX�V M [�XbU � §T§f§¦� U�M a O�MPO � [ ] U O UWa ¬ ¹d� ���� �³VYpnX hxO VfX O c h V38 aYUWV h�M4Mel [tX|U � §f§V M [tX|U � §f§f§ h cdU r MPS Vg����� lsM a MP]xh 7 M ^KXJafckU O Z���� ± h�O VfpnX ]�MPO 72j¦pnU h�Oi]�h ^ h V|�� M Z�XJVYXJaf^ h�O XDVYp�XN WU ]�h Z h V38 MWl�¬ ¹1Uec�U 7PX O XJaYU ] ^ M ZnX ]_MWl U ]��WM �s8¥c S r cTV h V S V h�MPO �ej|U ] j S�] UR�

V hxMPO c � XJafXvU ] c M Z MeO X MPO U¥cTXba h Xbc Mel Z h � ^`XJVYp M �s82c S r c�V h V S VYXJZ ��� cb�z­ � X ¬ � ��� ° �_�.pnXbaTXh c OnM   h c h r ] X�Z h « XJafX O jbX hxO VfpnX ¬ ¹d� ���� U O Z � X ¬ � ���� cT[�XJjJVfaYU�� hxO r M VYp VfpnX�[tXba h�M Z h jU O Z MP]�h 7 M ^`Xba�jbU ] j Sn] URV h�MeO cb� �.pnX hxO VYX O c h V h XJc MWl VYp�Xv[tX|U � cªj¦p�U O 7PX�c M ^`X � pnUWV�­s�¤U r ] X � � � ° �r S VdVfpnXgj MPO j ]�S c h�MPO c M r V¦U h�O XJZ\U r M  PX lsM a ¬ ¹d� ��� c�V h�]x] Ue[�[ ] 8e�9;:�� �£C`?GH �bF���IbC`?�.pnX�j|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO cª[naTXbcfX O VYXbZ;pnXJafX�X��nUW^ hxO XoU O¸S ^ r XJa Melzl UejwV M aTcNVYp�URV r aTX|U � X ] XbjJVfa MPO �

p MP] Xkc"8_^`^KXwVYa�8�U O Z2c M 7 h  eX h�O VfX O c h V38�V M [tX|U � §f§¦�e§ O U ]x] jbUecfXJcb�mVYp�X.[nafXJZ h jwVYXbZ2[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPOMel [tX|U � §f§ h cv[�UWaYU ]x] X ] V M VYpnX�[ MP] 8_^KXJavUR� h cb� hxO U�7PaTXbXJ^KX O V �dh VYp Xw��[�XJa h ^KX O V={��e���³�R�n�³�e�R� ��.pnXoaTXbc Sn] VfckUeaTXvc S ^K^KUea hx´ XJZ h�O �¤U r ] X � � ��� � p h j¦p ]�h cTVfcªVfpnXvafUWV hxM r XJV � XbX O VfpnX hxO VYX O c h V h XJcMel [�XbU � §T§¤U O ZK[tX|U � §f§f§¦�e�.pnX O Xw�_VT� O X|UeaTXbc�V O X h 7Pp r M a¤VfaYU O c l Xba h�O VfX�7PafU ] c�[naTXbcTX O V hxO §¯¨ ©g¬VYp�X M a�8 jbU S cfX¥VYpnX�j MPO Z S jJV hxMPO r U O ZncvV M r X O UeaTa M=� XJavVYpnU O VYp�X� WU ] X O jbX r U O ZncJ�zU O Z\VYp h ccf^KU ]x] r aTX|U �¸hxO 7 Mel X ] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] Xuc"8_^K^`XJVfa"8 ] XbUeZnc¤V M U O2h�O VfX O c h V38¥aYUWV h�MvMWl ��� �W��� L pnXJ^ h j|U ]c S r cTV h V S V h�MeO �m^ M ZnX ] XbZ2p�XbafX�Uecª��� ��Z h � p�8_Zna M �%8m� ���� ­ ¬ ¹.� ��� ° � ] X|UeZ�c�V M cTVYa MPO 7g^ h � h�O 7r XJV � XbX O®]xM jbU ]�hx´ XbZ�U O Z'ZnX ]xM jbU ]�hx´ XbZ& WU ] X O jbX r U O Z�cb� U�M a¥U\[ ] U O Uea ¬ ¹d� ���� c�VYa S jJV S afXW�VYp�X.[nafXJZ h jwVYXbZ h�O VfX O c h V38�afUWV hxM�h ck���x���_��¹ M=� XJ eXbab��¢ � �djbU ] j Sn] UWV h�MPO c MPOK¬ ¹d� ���� hxO Z h jbUWVYXVYpnUWVDVYpnX.  h�O 8 ] X O X�7Pa MPS [Ka M V¦UWVfXbc MPS V MWl VfpnX�[ ] U O X MWl VfpnX�[�pnX O 8 ] a h�O 7Pc r 8`U r MeS Vu� ^gJ��U O ZVYp h c�j¦p�U O 7PXbcDVYpnX hxO VfX O c h V382afUWV hxM V M ��� ±�� U�h�Onh VYXkc h�´ X.X « XJjJVfc lsS a�VYpnXJa h�O jJafX|UWcfX.VYpnX hxO VfX O c h V38Mel [tX|U � §f§ afX ] UWV h  PXªV M [�XbU � §f§f§¦��7 h   h�O 7�U O2h�O VfX O c h V38�afUWV hxMoMel U r MPS V.����� lsM a MP]�h 7 M ^`Xbafc �dh Vfpr XJV � XbX O ��U O Z���[�pnX O 8 ] a hxO 7PcJ� »ºp hx] XDVYp h c hxO VYX O c h V38¥aYURV h�M h c cTV h�]x] c M ^`X � p�UWV¤cf^KU ]�] XbazVYpnU O

Page 101: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �

VYp�XNXw��[tXba h ^`X O V¦U ]x] 8 M r cfXJaT PXJZ5aYUWV h�M Mel U r MPS VN���x�m{��P�¸�P�W}��e�W�n�W�P���e� � ���WVfpnXkaTXbc S�] VYc�[nafXJcfX O VfXbZpnXJafX hxO Z h jbUWVYXªVYp�URV�j¦pnXJ^ h j|U ] c S r c�V h V S V h�MPO �Wj M ^ r h�O XJZ �dh Vfp�VYpnX � Onh VfXkj MeORQTS 7mUWV h�MPO¥] X O 7eVYp�c[naTXbcfX O V hxO UW^ M aT[np MPS c.cYUe^`[ ] XJcb� ] X|UeZ�cdV M c S r c�V¦U O V h U ] X ] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] Xoc�8_^K^`XJVfa"8 r aTX|U �¸hxO 7U O Zg7 h  PXbcdj MPO c h ZnXbafU r ] X h�O VYX O c h V384V M [tX|U � §T§¦�9;:¦9 � H��²?�C�� � ��E�� � ��?4A���.p h c �uM a �4� Uec lsSnO Z�XbZ r 8²VfpnX�¨vUWV h�MPO U ] ��j h X O jbX U�MPSnO Z�URV h�MeOiL ¹ � � � �m�e±�� ���

Page 102: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �

� � ��� ���� �

� + � � �'� ��� 3q� �"+ � # � ( ( � �'� � � �¡���� ��� ���� � �8� � ��� � � � � � � � � # � � � � � � ��� �� ����¡� # � � � ��� � � � � ��� ����%� � � ���"� #

� :=< >@?4A�BDC;EGFGH.A�IJCK?L Uea r MPOgO U O�M V S r Xbc@p�U| eX r XbX O UejJV h  PX ] 8vcTV S Z h XJZ�c h�O jJX�VYpnX h a hxOnh V h U ] Z h cfj M  eXba�8 h�O � � ���P��{ �P� �¬vl [�UeaTV h j Sn] Uea h�O VYXJafXbc�V UeafX¡VfpnX%j MeO Z S jwV h�MeO [�a M [tXba�V h XJc Mel j|Uea r MeOO U OnM V S r XJcb� � p h j¦p

 WUea"8 l a M ^ ^KXwV¦U ]x]�h j�V M cfXJ^ h j MPO Z S jJV h�O 7qZnXb[tX O Z h�O 7 MeO c S r V ] X�j¦p�U O 7PXJc h�O VYpnX�c�VYa S jJV S afXW��.p h cb��U O Z M VfpnXba l X|UWV S afXJc Mel VfpnXqX ] XbjwVYa MPOnh j`cTVfa S jwV S aTXe��p�U| eX r XJX O c�V S Z h XbZ S c hxO 7\V h 7PpmVT�r hxO Z h�O 7�­ ¹��S j � X ] ° ^ M ZnX ] cb��{ � ±_� � ��� � �_�P±� ��W±��P�W±P���W±e}R���.p�XbcfXuV h 7ep¸V�� r hxO Z hxO 7.^ M ZnX ] c h�O j ]�S ZnXMPOn] 8 O X|UeaTXbcTV�� O X h 7Pp r M aoVYafU O c l XbaoVYXJaf^`cb�@U O Z&VfpnX2afXJc Sn] V hxO 7²X ] XbjJVfa MPO�h j�c�VYa S jJV S afX5Xw��p h r h VfcX ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X c"8_^K^`XJVfa"8e��¹�XJafXe� � X�ZnXJ eX ]�M [;U�c h ^K[ ] Xd^KXbU O c lsM a hxO j ]xS Z h�O 7 O X��_VT� O X|UeaTXbcTV��O X h 7Pp r M a`­�¨�¨v¨ ° X ] XJjJVYa MPO VYafU O c l XJa�VYXbaT^Kc hxO V h 7ep¸V�� r hxO Z hxO 7q^ M Z�X ] c MWlªlsS�]�] XJafX O XbcJ��� S j¦pVYXJaf^`c r afXbU � X ] XJjJVYa MPO � p MP] XNc"8_^K^`XJVfa"8e�¸U O Z2VYpnX.X « XJjJVfc MWl Vfp h c¤c"8_^K^`XJVfa"8 r afXbU �¸h�O 7 MPO VYp�Xr U O Z97mUW[\U O ZiVfpnXbaT^ M [ M=� Xba UeafX�X���Ue^ hxO XbZ���.pnX h�O j ]�S c h�MeO\MelDO Xw�_V O XbUeafXJcTV O X h 7Pp r M a�VfXbaT^Kc�p�Uec r XbX O�lsMPSnO Z V M r X h ^`[ M aTVYU O V hxO

VYp�X¥jbU ] j Sn] UWV h�MPO²MWl U O_S ^ r XJa Mel j¦pnXJ^ h j|U ] [�a M [tXba�V h XJcb��{�±R�e� ��{�±e��� �.pnX¥UeZnZ h V h�MeO²Mel VfpnX O Xw�_VO XbUeafXJcTV O X h 7Pp r M a p M [n[ hxO 7op�UWc r XbX O cTp M=�dO V M ^ M Z hxl 8�c M ^`X Mel VfpnXNX O Xba"7�8<7PUe[nc hxO2L 3 �=��{��R�� h ^ U O Z�» S p�U| PXdU ] c M�lsMeSnO Z�Vfp�UWV¤Uvc h ^K[ ] X���� X ] XbjwVYa MeO V h 7PpmVT� r h�O Z h�O 7d^ M ZnX ] jbU O X���[ ] U hxO

Page 103: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

U¤h 7 S afXi±_�x���;¢�[ M aTV hxMPO%Mel Ui7PafUe[np h VYX²cTpnXbXwV4cfp M��dhxO 7&VYpnX ]�M j|UWV h�MPO%MWl VfpnX ] UWVfV h jJX SnOnh V PXJjJV M afc �> U O Z �A�U O Z\VfpnX¥j¦pnUeaYUejwVYXJa h c�V h j¥UWaf^`j¦p�U h a.V S r X � aYUW[n[ h�O 7` eXbjJV M a��~ lsM a�� 9 � ��.pnX�Z h UW^KXwVYXba Mel VfpnXgafXJc Sn] V h�O 75V S r X �uMPSn] Z r X�� 9���� �I �VYp�X ]�M=� � X O Xba"7�8oX���j h VYUWV hxMPO cf[tXbjwVYaYU MelnL 3 � MPOn] 8 hxl¸O Xw�_V O X|UeaTXbc�V O X h 7ep r M a�VfXbaT^Kc@U O Z MeO � c h VYXX ] XbjwVYa MeO � X ] XbjwVYa MPOKhxO VYXbafUejJV h�MPO cNUeaTX hxO j ]xS ZnXJZ³� {~± � ��¨ Xw�_V O X|UeaTXbcTV O X h 7Pp r M aªVfXbaT^Kcªp�U| PXvU ] c Mr XbX O cfp M=�dO V M p�U| PX`c h 7 Onh ��jbU O VgX « XbjwVYc MPO VfpnX r U O Z cTVfa S jwV S aTX Mel [ MP] 8_Z h UejbXwV38 ] X O XW� {~±W�e��.pnX h�O j ]�S c h�MPO;Mel¤O Xw�_V O X|UWafXbc�V O X h 7ep r M a.VYXJaf^`cdp�Uec U ] c M r XbX O S cTXbZ h�O VYpnX h�O  eXbcTV h 7mURV h�MeOMel VfpnXq^`XJVYU ] � h�O c Sn] UWV M aoVYafU O c h V hxMPO h�O ^KUWVYXJa h U ] c�U O Z'p�Uec r XbX O cfp M=�dO V M r X h ^`[ M a�V¦U O Vh�O VYp�X hxO  eXbc�V h 7PUWV hxMPOºMel j S [naYURVYX c S [tXbaTj MPO Z S jJV M afcJ� {~±P±e� ��{�±e���� S Z�7 hxO 7 r 8 Vfp h c;[naTXJ  h�MeS c�uM a �`MPO j MeORQTS 7mUWVfXbZ4jbUea r MPO c�8�c�VYXJ^KcJ� h VNcfXbXJ^KcuVYp�UWVuVYpnX h�O j ]�S c h�MPOKMel VYpnXJcfX O X��_V O X|UWafXbc�VO X h 7Pp r M aqVYXJaf^`c h c O XbjJXbcTcYUea�8 h�O VfpnX�VYaTX|UWVf^KX O V Mel c"8_cTVfXb^`c � pnXbaTX&VfpnX�afUWV hxM r XwV � XJX OO XbUeafXJcTVT� O X h 7Pp r M a�U O Z VfpnX O X��_VT� O X|UeaTXbcTV�� O X h 7Pp r M aop M [n[ h�O 7 h�O VYX)7PaYU ] c h cvaTX ] URV h  eX ] 8 ] Uea"7PXe�Uec h ckVfpnXgj|UecTX h�O VYpnX lsSn]x] XJafX O Xbcb� U O Z 7PaYUe[�pnX O XgV38_[�Xgc�VYa S jJV S afXbcJ�¢ O U O�M V S r Xbc¤^qU'8 r Xu  h X � XbZ`Uec¤U 7PaYUe[�p h VfXucTpnXbXwV�VYp�UWV¤p�Uec r XbX O�� aYUe[�[�XJZ hxO V M UvV S r X

cTVfa S jwV S aTX5U O Z�jbUe[n[tXbZ&UWV�VYpnX¥X O Z�c r 8\j S aT PXJZ lsSn]�] XbafX O X�cTVYa S jJV S afXJcb�g�.pnX M a h X O V¦UWV h�MPOiMelVYp�Xoj|Uea r MeO � jbUea r MPO r MPO Znc hxO VYp�XoV S r Xoj|U O r XoZ�XbcfjJa h r XJZ r 8qZnX � O�h�O 75U � afUe[n[ hxO 7� PXJjJV M a­��~ ° VYp�URV ]xh Xbc�[tXbaf[tX O Z h j Sn] UeagV M VYpnX`V S r X²UR� h cb��U O Z¡p�Uec�U ] X O 7eVfp'VYpnUWV h c�XJ� S U ] V M VYp�Xj h afj S ^ l XJafX O jbX MWl VYpnX�V S r Xe���.p h cu eXbjJV M a.^KUQ8 r X � a h VfVfX O UWckU ]xh�O XbUeauj M ^ r hxO UWV h�MPO`Mel VYp�X] URVfV h jbX  PXbjwV M aTc¥­ �> U O Z �A °NMWl VfpnXu7PafUe[np h VYXocTpnXbXwV��~ 9 � �> B < �A=�ª�.p�X h�O VYX)7PXba.j M X��Kj h X O Vfc­ � G < ° [na M   h ZnX�U�j MPO  PX Onh X O V OnM V¦UWV h�MPO`lsM auVfpnXoV S r Xoc�VYa S jJV S afXe�D�.pnX�X ] XJjJVYa MPOnh jvcTVfa S jwV S aTXMelªO U O�M V S r Xbc�jbU O r X SnO ZnXJafc�V M_M Z h�O VYXbaT^Kc Mel VYpnX r U O ZGcTVfa S jwV S aTX MWl Uj7PaYUe[�p h VfX�cfpnXJXJVb��dh Vfp¶VYp�X h�O VYa M Z S jJV h�MPO MWl [�XJa h�M Z h j r MPSnO ZnUea"81j MPO Z h V h�MPO c`VYp�URV4V¦U � X h�O V M Uejbj MPSnO V²VYp�X� Onh VYXKj h aTj S ^ l XbaTX O jJX Mel VfpnX O U O�M V S r Xe�G�.p�XbcfX²[tXba h�M Z h j r MPSnO Z�UWa"8 j MPO Z h V h�MPO c¥cfXJaT PX4V M� S U O V hx´ XvVfpnXvjJa"8_cTVYU ] ^ M ^`X O V S ^�[�XJaf[tX O Z h j Sn] UeaDV M VfpnX�V S r XW�nU O Z4X|Uej¦p;U ]�]�M=� XbZ` eU ]�S X MelVYp�X.jba"8_c�V¦U ] ^ M ^KX O V S ^ 7 h  eXbcDa h cfXNV M UgcTXb[�UWaYUWVfX MeO Xw� Z h ^`X O c h�MPO U ] r U O Z Mel VYpnX O U O�M V S r Xe�

Page 104: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

���

¨vU O�M V S r XbcNj|U O r XvZ h   h ZnXJZ h�O V M 7PX O XbafU ] j ] UecTcfXJc r UecTXbZ MPO VfpnX M a h X O V¦UWV h�MPOKMel �~ ­ U�h 7W�S aTX®±�� � ° U O Z VYp�X 7PX O XbaYU ] X ] XbjwVYa MPOnh j�[na M [�XJaTV h Xbc Mel VYp�URV V S r X V38�[tX%Uec\[nafXJZ h jwVYXJZ r 8V h 7PpmVT� r h�O Z h�O 7&^`XJVYp M ZncJ� U¤h 7 S afX\±�� �n­�U °2h cKaTX l XJafafXJZ¶V M UecqU O UeaT^Kj¦pnU h aJ� M a`[tXbaf[tX O Z h j��Sn] Ueab��V38_[tX MWl V S r XK­ � 9 < h�O �~ ° ����c h�O 7KU MeO Xw� Z h ^`X O c h�MPO U ] �¸V h 7PpmVT� r h�O Z hxO 72^ M ZnX ]��dh VfpMPOn] 8 O XbUeafXJcTV O X h 7ep r M adp M [�[ h�O 7�� Ueaf^`j¦p�U h akV S r Xbc p�U| PX r XJX O [naTXbZ h jJVfXbZ\V M pnU= eX�^`XJVYU ]�]xh j[na M [�XJaTV h XbcJ� { � ��� � �_��±� ���±��P��±P����±e}��N�.p�XqafXJ^qU h�OnhxO 7²V �NM 7PX O XJaYU ] j ] UecfcTXbc Mel V S r XJc M jbj S a� pnX O � �9 < � U¤h 7 S afX5±�� �n­ r °vh c�U ´Jh 7 ´ U�7 M ao[�UWaYU ]x] X ] V S r X\­ < 9 ° � � p h j¦p h co[naTXbZ h jJVfXbZV M r X�^`XJV¦U ]�]�h j lsM a � U O²h�O VYX)7PXba.^ S�] V h [ ] X Mel }5U O Z;cfXJ^ h � j MPO Z S jwV hxO 7 M VfpnXba �dh cfXW� {~± W�³�.pnX] UWcTV�V38_[�X ­ U�h 7 S aTX`±�� �n­ j °f°oh c�U O Xw��Ue^`[ ] X MWl U;j¦p h afU ] V S r X ­ � �9 < �9 ° � h�OG� p h j¦p�VYp�Xj|UWa r MPO � jbUea r MPO r MPO Z�c�p�U| PXdU O2M a h X O V¦UWV h�MPO r XwV � XJX O VYp�URV h�O VfpnX.UeaT^Kj¦pnU h a�U O Z�VfpnX ´bh 7 ´ U47V S r XW� L p h aYU ] V S r Xbc UeaTXg[nafXJZ h jwVYXbZ;V M r XgcfXb^ h j MPO Z S jJV hxO 7n�� :�� � �FGH � �!����� �oC`B�� ��?GE ��B���� ��� �vCKB��

�.pnX�¹��S j � X ] ¹�Ue^ h�] V MPOnh U O�h cuU �\X ] XbjJVfa MPO ^ M ZnX ] VYp�URV hxO j ]xS ZnXJc MeO Xd[�� M a r h VYU ]�lsM aªXbUej¦pj|UWa r MPO UWV M ^ ­ c h VYX ° U O Z\U ]�]xM�� cNX ] XJjJVfa MPO VYafU O c l XJa r XwV � XJX O UWZ Q UejbX O V�c h VfXbcb�

9 ���� M�������� B �� ��������� �:M � �!��"$#&% � � G ­�±��x� °M a hxO VfXbaT^Kc Mel jbaTX|UWV h�MPO U O ZiU O�Onh p hx] UWV h�MPOKM [tXbaYURV M aTcb�

��('*)� � t � v 9 � )k+ +-, > �),+ + > )k+ +#B �) �� > + + ?�),+ > > �),+ + > > + + G ­�±�� � °

U¤h 7 S afXu±�� � �@¢ [ M a�V hxMPO¥MWl U 7eaYUe[np h VYXDcTpnXbXwV�cfp M��dhxO 7vVfpnX M a h X O V¦UWV h�MPO�Mel VfpnXNjbUea r MPO � j|Uea r MeOr MPO Znc lsM akVfpnXoVYp�afXbXu7eX O XJaYU ] j ] UecTcfXbc MWl¤O U OnM V S r XJcb�D� S r X`­ U °Nh c.U O UWaf^`j¦p�U h aªV S r Xe�nV S r X­ r ° U ´bh 7 ´ U�7 M ad[�UeafU ]�] X ] V S r Xe��U O Z\V S r X4­sj °.h c U`j¦p h aYU ] V S r Xe�k�.pnX¥Z�UecTpnXbZ Ueafa M�� cfp M=� cVYp�XkZ h aTXbjwV h�MeO�Mel VfpnXNV S r XNUR� h cb���.pnX r MP] Z¥cfXba h XJc Mel j|UWa r MPO � jbUea r MPO r MPO Z�c�U O Z2c MP]�h Z�UeaTa M=�cfXJaT eX�V MKhx]�]�S cTVYafUWVYX�p M=� VfpnX M a h X O V¦UWV h�MPO²MWl VfpnX r MPO ZncdZ hx« XbaTc hxO VYpnX�V S r XJcb�

Page 105: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�m�

U¤h 7 S afX�±���}��v�.pnX r X O�´ X O X`^ MP] Xbj S�] Xe� h Vfc 7PaYUW[npGafXJ[nafXJcfX O VYUWV hxMPO �@U O ZGVfpnX2afXJc Sn] V h�O 7²UeZ Q UR�jbX O j)8;^KUWVfa h ���� pnXJafX Q h c�VYp�X�X ] XbjJVfa MPO cT[ h�O � h � Q UeaTX�UWV M ^ h j¥c h VfXbcb� > � ­ > °�h c VYpnX�jJafXbUWV hxMPO ­�U OnOnh p h�] URV h�MeO °M [tXbafUWV M a MPO VYp�X�/ JLK j|Uea r MeO UWV M ^i� ,

h c2VfpnX MeO � c h VYX;[ M VYX O V h U ] �uU O Z ? h c2VYp�X\X ] XbjwVYa MPOVYafU O c l Xba h�O VYX)7PaYU ] ��§ O VYpnX r UWc h c Mel [�� M a r h V¦U ] cb��VfpnX`¹��S j � X ] ^ M ZnX ] c ] X|UeZnc�V M U²^KUWVYa h � MelVYp�X lsM af^ � /u1 �� ' )� � t � v 1 / � 9

, ­�±�� } °� /Z1 �� '*)��� t � v 1 8 � 9 �� � ?N­� ° hxl UWV M ^Kc /DU O Z 8qUeafX r MPO ZnXJZ M VYpnXJa �dh cTX G ­�±���� °

� pnXJafX�a h ckVYp�X r MPO Z ] X O 7eVfp³�L pnXb^ h jbU ] 7PafUe[np%VYp�X M a�8%[na M   h Z�Xbc`UGj MPO  PX Onh X O V4Ue[�[na M UWj¦p V M ¹��S j � X ] VYpnX M a"8e�NUec hxOVYp�XU7PX O XbafU ] ^KXwVYp M Znc Mel {~± ���¤U O Z%{~± �R���k�.pnX�^ MP] XJj Sn] X�^qU'8 r X�aTXb[naTXbcTX O VYXJZ r 8iU5c h ^K[ ] Xe�SnOnM a h X O VYXbZL7PaYUe[�p³� � p h j¦p j MPO c h c�VYc Mel�MPOn] 8% PXJaTV h jbXJc4U O Z¶XbZ�7PXJcb����� W ��� ]xh�O XJcqU O Z¶[ MPh�O Vfc­ cTXbX U¤h 7 S afX²±�� } lsM a�U O Xw��Ue^`[ ] X ° �'§ O®l UejwV|��VYpnX � U'8 h�O¡� p h j¦p VfpnX²cTVfa S jwV S afU ]klsM aT^ Sn] UMel U5^ MP] Xbj S�] X h c O�M af^KU ]�] 8qaTXb[naTXbcTX O VYXJZ r 8²VfpnXgj¦pnXb^ h c�V h cdXbcTcfX O V h U ]x] 8²U5j¦pnXJ^ h j|U ] 7PafUe[np³�� pnXJafXgVYpnXo eXbaTV h jJXbc Mel VfpnXM7PaYUW[npiUeafXoVfpnX�UWV M ^`c.U O ZiVfpnXgXbZ�7PXJc UeafXoVfpnXgj¦pnXb^ h jbU ] r MPO ZncJ�¢ ]xh cTV h�O 7 MWl�� p h j¦p�UWV M ^`c¥­s eXbaTV h jJXbc ° UeafX�j MeOnO XbjwVYXJZ r 8 r MPO Znc�­ XJZ�7PXbc ° jbU O r X lsMPS�O Zh�O VYp�X\ PXJaTVfXw� UeZ Q UejJX O jS81^KUWVfa h �!­ pnXJafX|U l VYXbaKUeZ Q UWjbX O j)81^qUWVfa h � °�MWl VYpnXg7PafUe[np³�� ­ cfXJX

Page 106: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P}U¤h 7 S afX�±_� } ° �

� � + � 9�� � � hxl UWV M ^`c h U O Z Q UeaTX r MeO ZnXbZ M VfpnXba �dh cfX � ­�±�� � °

§ O U;c"8_c�VYXb^ � pnXJafX4U ]�] r MPO Z ] X O 7eVYpnc�UeaTXKXJ� S U ] �@VYp�X O XbUeafXJcTV O X h 7Pp r M agp M [n[ h�O 7iVfXbaf^`cb�?u­ � °�Mel XJ� ��­�±��~� ° �RUeaTXuU ]�] XJ� S U ] U O Z¥VfpnXª¹��S j � X ] ^qURVYa h ��jbU O r XªafX � a h VTVYX O Uec Udj M ^ r h�O UWV h�MPOMel VYpnX h ZnX O V h V384^KUWVYa h �����2U O ZiUeZ Q UejJX O jS8;^qUWVfa h jbXbc MWl VfpnXgj¦pnXb^ h jbU ] 7PafUe[np³�

9, �B ? � G ­�±�� � °

� hxO jbX U O Z � j M ^`^ S VfXe�ªVYpnXS8®cfp�UeaTX\VfpnX\cfUe^`XicTXJV Mel X h 7PX O  eXbjwV M aTc={~± �n�u± ���u± ���� W� ��.pnX¥^ MP] Xbj Sn] Uea M a r h V¦U ] X O Xba"7 h XJcvUeaTX�VfpnX�X h 7PX O  eU ]�S XJc Mel VYpnX�¹��S j � X ] ^qUWVfa h �iU O Z\^qU'8 r X� a h VfVfX O �

� t 9 , B ? > t�G ­�±�� ± °� pnXJafX > t h ckVYpnXVa JLK¥X h 7PX O  WU ]�S X Mel VfpnX�UeZ Q UejJX O jS8;^qURVYa h ��� { ������ :�� � EGEGIJA�IbC`? C���� ��;A� �!��B � ��A�� ��I � � �'C`B � �oB�� �

» h Vfp1VYp�X h�O j ]�S c h�MeO1MeloO Xw�_V O X|UeaTXbcTV O X h 7Pp r M a5VYXJaf^`cb�NVfpnX�¹��S j � X ] ^KUWVYa h �®p�UWcKVYp�XlsM aT^\� � /u1 �� '*)� � t � v 1 / � 9, ­�±�� � °

� /Z1 �� ' )� � t � v 1 8 � 9������ �����?N­� ° hxl UWV M ^Kc h U O Z Q UeaTX r MPO ZnXbZp ­� ° h l�h U O Z Q UeaTX O Xw�_V O X|UeaTXbc�V O X h 7ep r M aTc M VfpnXba �dh cTX

� ­�±�� � °

§ O r X On´ X O Xe� L 3 �=��U O Z h�O � O�h VYX O U OnM V S r Xbcb� O�M V MPOn] 84UeaTXgU ]�] r MeO Z ] X O 7eVYpncNXb� S U ] � r S VdVYp�XZ h cTV¦U O jbX r XJV � XbX O\O X��_V O X|UeaTXbcTV O X h 7ep r M akjbUea r MPO UWV M ^`c h c.U ] c M Xb� S U ] ���.p h c.^`X|U O cNVYp�URV?u­ � ° U O Z p ­ � ° pnU= eX¥VfpnXgcYUe^`X� eU ]�S X lsM adU ]x] [�U h afc Mel UWV M ^KcJ�u�.pnX O X���V�� O XbUeafXJcTV O X h 7Pp r M aVYXJaf^`c Mel VYpnX5¹��S j � X ] ^qUWVfa h � Mel XJ�t�ª­�±�� � ° ^KUQ8iVYp�X O r X � a h VfVfX OGhxO VYXbaT^Kc MWl VfpnX2cf� S UeaTXMel VYpnXKUeZ Q UWjbX O j)8&^KUWVYa h ���zc h ^ hx] UeadV M VYpnX � U'8GVYpnX O XbUeafXJcTVT� O X h 7Pp r M agVfXbaT^Kc � XbafXKUeZnZ�XbZS c h�O 72VYp�X¥UWZ Q UejbX O j)8;^KUWVfa h � h�O XJ�t��±�� � ��»ºpnX O cT� S Uea hxO 75VYpnX�UeZ Q UWjbX O j)8;^KUWVYa h ����VfpnX Me« �Z h U�7 MPO U ] VfXbaT^Kc.UWafX�� h l U O Z MeOn] 8 hxl VfpnXvV �uM  PXba�V h jbXbckUeafXoj MPOnO XJjJVfXbZ r 8qU�[�UWVfp Mel@] X O 7eVfp

Page 107: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�e�V �uM � M a.Xb� Snh  eU ] X O V ] 8P�nUeafX r MPO ZnXJZiV M U5j M ^K^ MPO UWV M ^ ­ cTXbX U¤h 7 S afXg±_��� lsM adU O Xw��Ue^`[ ] X ° ��.pnXgZ h U�7 MPO U ] X ] Xb^`X O Vfc Mel ����j MPSnO VdVYpnX O¸S ^ r Xba MWl [�URVYpnc Mel ] X O 7eVfp²V �NM VYpnUWV M a h 7 h�O UWVYXU O ZiVYXJaf^ h�O UWVfX MPO VYpnX�j M aTafXJcf[ MPO Z hxO 7` eXba�VYXw���.�.p h c h c.Xb� S U ] V M ZnX)7PafXJX Mel VYpnXg PXJaTVfXw��� M aVYp�X O_S ^ r XJa Mel r MeO Znc MPO U�[�Uea�V h j Sn] UeakUWV M ^ ­�� lsM a r X On´ X O XW�tU O Zi} lsM a L 3 �=��U O Z h�O � O�h VYXO U O�M V S r Xbc ° �D�.pnX�^qURVYa h �4X ] XJ^KX O Vfc Mel ����UeaTXu7 h  eX O r 8e�

­�� )k+ > ° G 9 ������ ����� < h l / 9 8� h l VfpnXbaTX h cdU5[�UWVYp Mel�] X O 7eVfp � r XJV � XbX O /ªU O Z'8 � �dh VYpw/ �9 8 M VYpnXJa �dh cTX

G�­ ±�� � °

� pnXJafX < h c�VYp�XqZnX)7PafXJX Mel VfpnX5 PXba�V h jbXbcJ�\�.p�X4¹��S j � X ] ^qURVYa h � Mel Xb� �k­�±�� � ° ^KU'8GVYpnX O r X� a h VfVfX O � 9 ­ , � �xp�° �:BD? �jB p � G � ­ ±�� �P� °

� pnXJafX � �%p ��cfXba� PXJc�V M jbU O jbX ] VYpnXgZ h U�7 MPO U ] ^KUWVYa h �qX ] XJ^KX O VYc Mel � � hxO XJ� � ­ ±�� � ° �¢vc � X�cYU � hxO VfpnX�[�afXJ  hxMPS cDcfXJjJV hxMPO �_c hxO jbX �W� �8U O Z j M ^`^ S VfXe�mVYpnXS8`p�U| PX j M ^`^ MeO

X h 7PX O  eXbjJV M afc�U O Z&VfpnXbaTX lsM aTX�VYpnX2^ MP] Xbj S�] Uea M a r h V¦U ] X O Xba"7 h XJc � XJafX5c h ^K[ ] 8iafX ] UWVYXJZ�V M VYp�XX h 7PX O  eXbjJV M afc Mel VfpnX � ­ Xb� �@­�±�� ± °f° ���.p h c h c.U ] c M VYp�X�j|UecTX�pnXbaTXe��c hxO jbX � G j M ^`^ S VYXJc �dh Vfp�R� ���DU O Z ���.p�X\X h 7PX O  WU ]xS Xbc MWl � G UeafX²VfpnX;cf� S UeaTXbc Mel VfpnX;X h 7eX O  WU ]�S XJc Mel ���¤�.pnX^ MP] XJj Sn] Uea M a r h VYU ] X O Xba"7 h XJc ^KU'8qVfpnX O r X � a h VfVfX O �

� t 9 , � �%p B ? > t:B p > Gt � ­ ±�� ��� °¢c h ^ h�] UeakaTXbc S�] V�p�Uec r XJX O ZnXwVYXJaf^ h�O XJZ lsM a L 3 � S c h�O 7qU r Uec h c Mel  eXbjwV M aTc lsM a.VYpnX O X|UWafXbc�VO X h 7Pp r M afc Mel VYpnXgjbUea r MPO UWV M ^KcJ� {~���� :�� � � �oHdA�BDC`?�� ��C � � � �w� � ��A�B�� �GB �!� �²I|?��

��] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] Xdc"8_^`^KXwVYa�8 h cD[nafXJcfX O V lsM a���� X ] XJjJVYa MPO ^ M ZnX ] c�VYp�URV hxO j ]xS ZnX MPOn] 8 O X|UWafXbc�VO X h 7Pp r M aoVYafU O c l XJa h�O VYX)7PaYU ] cb�zc S j¦p¡UWcg¹��S j � X ] VYpnX M a"8�{��|�e����U O Z&j¦pnXb^ h jbU ] cTVfa S jwV S aTXbcgVYp�URVUeaTX5U ] VfXba O U O V|��§ O U O U ] VYXba O U O Vgj¦pnXJ^ h j|U ] c�VYa S jJV S afXW� MeOn] 8 j|Uea r MPO UWV M ^`co[�Uea�V h j h [�URVYX hxOVYp�X ��� X ] XJjJVfa MPOnh j5cTVYa S jJV S afXqU O Z'VfpnXbcTXqjbUea r MPO c¥^qU'8 r XKZ h   h ZnXJZ h�O V M V �uM Z h c QTMPh�O V�cfXwVYcJ�� ¢��kU O Z � -��¸�Rc S j¦p�Vfp�UWV OnM j|Uea r MeO UWV M ^ h c r MPO Z�XbZ¥V M U OnM VYp�Xba j|Uea r MPO UWV M ^ h�O VfpnXucfUe^`XcfXwV�{ } �W���R-NX On´ X O Xe� L 3 ��U O Z O U OnM V S r XJc�UWafXKU ] VfXba O U O V¥c�VYa S jJV S afXJc²­ cTXbX U¤h 7n�z±�� � ° �K»ºp�X O

Page 108: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�m�

U¤h 7 S afX\±��~� ��¢�cfXJjJV h�MPO1Mel VYp�X97PafUe[np h VYXicfpnXJXJVqcfp M=�dh�O 7'VYpnX O XbUeafXJcTV;U O Z O X���V O X|UWafXbc�VO X h 7Pp r M adUWV M ^KcdU O Z\U O X��nUW^K[ ] X Mel VYpnXgcf� S UWafX Mel VfpnX�UeZ Q UejJX O jS8;^qURVYa h � lsM a r X On´ X O Xe�

U¤h 7 S afX�±�� � � U S�]�] XJafX O XkV38_[�X�cTVYa S jJV S afX�­ hxO Vfp h cDj|UWcfX L 3 � °��dh VYp MPOn] 8�VYpnX r MPO Z l afUe^`X �uM a �U O Z l a MeO V l UWj h�O 7 r MPO Z�c cTp M=�dO\lsM a.j ] Uea h V38e�

Page 109: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] Xvc�8_^K^`XJVfa"8²UW[n[ ]�h XbcJ��VYp�Xo eU ] X O jbX�U O Zij MPO Z S jJV hxMPO r U O Z M a r h V¦U ] c lsM aT^�[�U h afc�dh Vfp X O XJa�7 h Xbc4Z h cTVfa h r S VYXJZ c"8_^`^KXwVYa h j|U ]x] 8®U r MPS V4VYpnX U XJaf^ h X O Xba"7�8P�§ O VYXJaf^`c Mel VYp�XUeZ Q UWjbX O j)8�^KUWVfa h ���tX ] XbjJVfa MPO p MP] X¥c"8_^K^`XJVfa"8 h ^`[ ]�h Xbc.VYpnUWV lsM a�XJ PXJa"8 [ M c h V h  PX¥X h 7PX O  WU ]�S XMel VYpnX�UeZ Q UejbX O j)8;^KUWVYa h ��� > tW�nVYpnXJafXgXw� h c�VYc U O X�7PUWV h  PXgX h 7PX O  WU ]�S Xe� � > tP� { �m�R��.pnX h�O j ]�S c h�MPOvMel_O Xw�_VT� O X|UWafXbc�VT� O X h 7Pp r M a hxO VfXbafUejJV h�MPO c h�O ¹��S j � X ] VfpnX M a�8 r aTX|U � c@X ] XbjwVYa MeO �

p MP] Xuc�8_^K^`XJVfa"8P���.p h c¤j|U O r XNcTXbX O`hxO � � ��­�±��x�=� ° � � pnXbaTXNVYpnX O Xw�_V�� O XbUeafXJcTVT� O X h 7Pp r M a¤VYXJaf^`cj MeO Vfa h r S VYX¥V M VfpnX M a r h VYU ] X O Xba"7 h XJcvVYp�a MPS 7ep�VYpnX�cT� S UeafX MWl VYpnX�X h 7PX O  eU ]�S XJc Mel VYp�X2UeZ Q UR�jbX O j)8i^KUWVYa h ��� p > Gt �u¨ M VfX�Vfp�UWVdVYp�X�X ] XJjJVYa MPO VYaYU O c l XJa VfXbaf^`cb��?¡U O Z p�Mel�� � ��­ ±�� � ° ��pnU= eXO X)7mUWV h  PXNU ] 7PX r aYU h jDc h 7 O { } �R���¤�.pnXN[ M c h V h  PXªX h 7PXJ WU ]xS Xbc Mel VfpnX.UeZ Q UejbX O j)8¥^qURVYa h ��� > tW�eVYpnXJafX��lsM aTX�j M aTafXJcf[ MPO ZGV M VfpnX� WU ] X O jbX r U O ZncJ��§ O VYpnX¥ eU ] X O jbX r U O Zncb�³VfpnX�VYXJaf^`c!? > t�U O Z p > GtMel � � �@­ ±�� ��� ° p�U| PXoVfpnX�cYUe^`Xoc h 7 O U O Z;c M VYp�X O Xw�_V�� O XbUeafXJcTVT� O X h 7Pp r M akVYXbaT^Kc h�O jJafX|UWcfXoVYp�X�dh Z�VYp Mel VYpnX  eU ] X O jbX r U O ZncJ�ª§ O VYpnX�j MPO Z S jJV h�MPO r U O ZncJ� > t h c O X)7mUWV h  PXvU O Z ? > tvU O Z p > Gtp�U| PX M [n[ M c h VYX c h 7 O cb�¤�.pnX O X��_VT� O X|UeaTXbcTV O X h 7Pp r M aªVfXbaf^`cDVYpnXJafX lsM afX ZnXbjJafX|UWcfXvVfpnX �dh Z�VYp MelVYp�X�j MPO Z S jJV hxMPO r U O ZncJ�D�.p h cdj ] X|Uea ] 8 r afXbU � c�X ] XJjJVYa MPO � p MP] Xvc"8_^K^`XJVfa"8e��.pnX.X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] Xªc"8_^K^`XJVfa"8 r aTX|U �¸h�O 7 h�O U�^KXwV¦U ]x]�h j�­���� � ° V S r X h c¤cTp M=�dO5h�O U�h 7n�W±�� ± ° �

� hxO Vf^ h afXW� ©oSnOn] Ue[³�eU O Z�»ºp h VYXP{ �b��afXJ[ M a�VYXJZ�V h 7ep¸V�� r hxO Z hxO 7�aTXbc Sn] Vfc lsM a�VfpnXkp h 7PpnXJcTV� WU ] X O jJX­�¹ ¬ � ¬g° r U O Z\U O Z ]�M=� XbcTV j MPO Z S jwV hxMPO ­�� � � ¬g° r U O Z\Uec

� ­da °:9�� ?4{ � B¶����� � ­da ° �NG ­ ±�� �=} °� pnXJafX a 9 � � � h c¤VfpnX ] X O 7eVYp MWl VfpnX � U| eXJ PXJjJV M a.U ]xMPO 7vVfpnX�\afXJj h [na M j|U ]�] UWVTV h jbXkZ h afXJjJV hxMPO �U O Z5VYp�X U XbaT^ h X O Xba"7�8 h cªUWV ´ Xba M ���.pnX�¹ ¬ � ¬ U O Z� � � ¬ r U O Znc h�O VYXJafcTXbjJV MPO X�U OnM VYpnXJa

U¤h 7 S afX�±_� � �D¢ [ M aTV h�MPO²Mel U5pnXw��U�7 MeO U ] U ] VYXba O U O V cfpnXJXJV�cfp M=�dhxO 7`VfpnXg[�Uea�V h V h�MPO�h�O 7 MWl VYp�Xj|UWa r MPO UWV M ^Kc h�O V M V �uM Z h c QTMPh�O V¤cfXJVfc Mel cTVYUeafaTXbZ`U O Z SnO cTV¦UWafafXJZ5j|Uea r MPO cb���.pnX.X h 7PX O  eU ]�S XJcMel VYpnX�UeZ Q UejbX O j)8;^KUWVYa h � h�O c S j¦p�U2j|UecTX�UWafX�c"8_^`^KXwVYa h jgU r MPS V ´ Xba M �

Page 110: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�m±

U¤h 7 S afX\±�� ± � � ]�M V Mel VfpnXip h 7Pp�XbcTV M jbj S [ h XJZ¶U O Z ]�M=� Xbc�V SnOnM jbj S [ h XbZ r U O Znc lsM a`U¶­���� � °j|UWa r MPO O U O V S r X%­ Xb� �k±��x�=� °5�dh VYp U O Z �dh Vfp MPS V O Xw�_V�� O XbUeafXJcTVT� O X h 7Pp r M a h�O VYXJaYUejwV hxMPO c4UWcj|U ] j S�] UWVfXbZ S c h�O 7�Xb� ��±�� ������{ �b� L U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO`Mel VYp�X r U O Znc hxO j ]xS Z h�O 7 MPO�] 8 O XbUeafXJcTVT� O X h 7Pp r M ah�O VfXbaYUWjJV hxMPO c²UWafXGafXJ[nafXJcfX O VfXbZ r 8 VfpnX&c MP]xh Z ]xh�O XJc²U O ZºVYp�XGZ�Uecfp�XbZ ]�h�O Xbc4aTXb[naTXbcfX O V VYp�Xj|U ] j S�]�S UWV h�MPO c²Z MPO X �dh Vfp!VfpnX hxO j ]xS c hxMPOºMel�O X��_VT� O X|UeaTXbcTV�� O X h 7Pp r M a h�O VYXJaYUejwV h�MeO cb� ? MelXb� �@±_�x��� � Uec�cTXJV�V M �����~�PX { �J��U O Z p � UecocfXwV�V M � ��? {~�R� � L a M cfc h�O 7 MWl VfpnX U XbaT^ h ] Xw PX ]M jbj S afc UWV�a 9 G) ���

UWV�VYpnX U XJaf^ h X O XJa�7�8e� � pnX O a 9 G) ���v�.p�X�X h 7PX O  WU ]�S Xbc MWl VYpnX�UeZ Q UejJX O jS8 ^KUWVYa h � lsM a�VYp�X

¹ ¬ � ¬ U O Z � � � ¬ r U O Znc Mel � � � ­�±��x�|} ° ��UWafX> t 9 � { ��B¶� � � � ­ma ° � � ­ ±�� �|� °c S j¦p\VYpnUWV h�O VYa M Z S jJV h�MPO;Mel�O Xw�_V�� O XbUeafXJcTV O X h 7Pp r M akVfXbaT^Kc ] X|UeZnc.V M r U O ZiX O XJa�7 h Xbc

� ­da °:9 � ?q{ � B¶����� � ­da ° � B p { � B¶����� � ­da ° � G � ­ ±�� ��� °U¤h 7n�z±�� ±4cfp M=� cgVYpnX5X O Xba"7 h XJc MWl VfpnXbcTX r U O Znc lsM a ? 9 �����~�PX ��VfpnX2 eU ]�S X S cTXbZ h�O & X l �ª{��b� �U O Z p 9 �� � ?ª��UecdZnXba h  eXbZ lsM a L 3 � hxO�& X l � {~�R���

Page 111: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �

� � � ��� ����� " � � ��� f� " ��� � � � � ��� � � �2����� � ����� $ �(� � �o� �!� � � ���� ���

¹�XJafXe� � Xuj MPO c h Z�Xba � pnXJVfpnXba r afXbU �¸h�O 7 Mel X ] XJjJVYa MPO � p MP] XDc�8�^`^`XJVYa�8gU ] VYXbaTczVYpnX r U O ZU7mUe[³�-NX lsM afX h�O VYa M Z S jJV hxMPO Mel�O X���V�� O XbUeafXJcTV�� O X h 7Pp r M a h�O VfXbaYUWjJV hxMPO cJ�NVYpnX r U O ZL7mUe[ h cK[�afXbcTX O Vr XJV � XbX O U` eU ] X O jbX¥U O Z�j MPO Z S jwV hxMPO r U O Z VYpnUWVoUWafX�afX ] UWVYXJZ r 8\X ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] X�c�8_^K^`XJVfa"8P�LNMPO c h ZnXJaKVfpnX�Z h « XJafX O jbX hxO X O Xba"7�8 r XJV � XbX O VYpnXJcfX r U O Znc²U l VfXba h�O VYa M Z S jJV hxMPO MelgO Xw�_V��O XbUeafXJcTVT� O X h 7Pp r M adVfXbaT^KcJ�

� � e � ­da °:9 1 ­ , � < p B > t ?XB > Gt p�° � � , � < p B�A�tu?RB�A Gt pg° 1 G ­ ±�� � � °� pnXJafX > t�U O Z A t�UeaTX�VfpnX�X h 7PX O  WU ]xS Xbc Mel VfpnX�UeZ Q UejbX O j)8\^qURVYa h � lsM a VYpnX¥j MPO Z S jJV h�MPO U O Z WU ] X O jbX r U O ZncJ��afXbcT[�XJjJV h  PX ] 8e� ©oS XoV M U ] VYXba O U O jS84c�8�^`^`XJVYa�8 hxO VYpnX�^ MP] XJj Sn] UeaNc�VYa S jJV S afXW�> t 9 � A�te��U O Z;VYpnX � � � ­ ±�� � � ° r Xbj M ^`Xbc

� � e � ­ma °�9 ��1 ? > t 1�� ­ ±�� ��± °�.pnX 7mUe[ r XJV � XbX O VYp�X r U O Znc h c�VYpnXJafX lsM afX SnO U « XbjwVYXJZ r 8oVYp�X O Xw�_VT� O X|UWafXbc�VT� O X h 7Pp r M azVfXbaf^`cb�p �� : �����oHdA� C�� � � ��H.A�B�C`?�� ��C � � � �w� � �vA�B�� �GB �!� �²I|?�� C`?

A�� � A � ��B:� C�� � �oHdA�BªIbH 'C � ��B¹�XJafXe� � X&X��nUW^ hxO X VYp�X�VYpnXJaf^ M X ] XbjwVYa h j [ M=� XJa�­ � � � °²MWl c h�O 7 ] X � U ]x] XbZ O U OnM V S r XJc

­ �¸»!¨�� ° �t�.pnX�VfpnXbaT^ M X ] XbjwVYa h jg[ M=� Xbao^`X|Uec S afXJc�VfpnX�X ] XbjwVYa h j|U ] j S afaTX O VvVfp�UWV y�M=� c h�O afX��cf[ MPO cTX�V M U�VfXb^`[�XJaYUWV S afX^7PafUeZ h X O V|���.pnX�c h 7 OqMel VYpnX VYpnXJaf^ M X ] XJjJVYa h jd[ M�� Xba h�O Z h j|URVYXbcDVYp�Xc h 7 O4Mel VfpnXo[naTXbZ M ^ h�O U O Vkj¦p�Uea"7PX�j|UWafa h XbaTc h�O VfpnXo^KUWVYXJa h U ] � � ��[tXba h ^`X O V¦U ] ^`X|Uec S afXJ^KX O VfcMel VYpnXgVYp�Xbaf^ M X ] XJjJVfa h jv[ M=� Xba p�U| PXe� SnO V h�] afXJjbX O V ] 8e� r XbX O [tXba lsM af^`XbZ h�O U h ab�nX���[ M c h�O 75VYp�XO U O�M V S r XDV M VfpnXª[nafXJcfX O jbX Mel�M �s8s7PX O ��� O ZnXba VYpnXJcfXNj MPO Z h V hxMPO cb��VYp�XªVfpnXbaT^ M X ] XbjJVfa h jª[ M=� XJaMel VfpnX5V S r Xbc h c lsMPSnO Z V M r Xq[ M c h V h  PXW� hxO Z h jbUWV hxO 7²VYp�URV�p Me] Xbc¥UeaTX`VfpnXKZ M ^ hxO U O V�j¦p�Uea"7PXj|UWafa h XbaJ� {~�e}R� & XbjJX O V ] 8P� Xw��[tXba h ^`X O VYc p�U| PX¥cfp M=�dO VfpnX�Xw�_VYaTXb^`X¥cTX O c h V h   h V38 Mel VYp�X�VfpnXbaT^ M �X ] XbjwVYa h j�[ M=� XJa Mel j|Uea r MPO O U OnM V S r XbcoV M VfpnX�[naTXbcTX O jJX MWlDM �s8s7PX O � { �P}����P��� �W�W� ¬ �s8s7PX O&h c

Page 112: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �

r X ]�h XJ eXbZ�V M²hxO Z S jJX�X ] XbjwVYa MeO VYaYUW[nc h�O VfpnX�^KUWVYXJa h U ] � c S j¦p Vfp�UWV�p Me] Xbc r XJj M ^`X�VYp�X�Z M ^ h �O U O V�j¦pnUea�7PX.jbUeafa h XJab�@»ºpnX O j|UWafX h c�V¦U � X O V M U=  MPh Z M �s8s7PX O j MPO V¦Ue^ h�O UWV hxMPO ��VYpnXk^`X|UWc S aTXbZc h 7 O MWl VYpnX�VYpnXJaf^ M X ] XJjJVYa h jg[ M�� Xba r XJj M ^`Xbc O X�7PUWV h  PXe� h�O Z h j|URV h�O 75Vfp�UWV�X ] XbjJVfa MPO coUeaTX¥VYp�XZ M ^ h�O U O V4j¦p�Uea"7PXGj|UWafa h XbaJ� LNMe]�]�hxO c WZY [^] � { �m�=�op�U| eX lsMeSnO Z VYpnUWV;UWV;}P� � �ªVfpnXG� � � h cU r MPS V � � �� �� � -NaYUeZ ] X)8 WZY [^] � lsMPSnO Z\VYp�UWVvUWVv}m� � ��VYp�X�� � � h cvURV ] X|Uec�V � � �� �� � �.p h cZ h cYU�7PaTXbXJ^KX O V p�UWc O�M V|��V M VYpnX r XbcTV Mel¤MPS a �¸OnM=�d] XJZ�7PXW� r XbX O aTXbc MP]  eXbZ³�§ O U c"8_cTVfXb^ �dh VYp�X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] XDc"8_^`^KXwVYa"8e�WVfpnXu� � � h c ´ Xba M �ec hxO jbXªVYpnXJaf^KU ] Xw��j h V¦URV h�MeO�dh�]x] jbaTX|UWVfX4Xb� S U ] Ue^ MPSnO VYc Mel X ] XbjwVYa MPO c�U O Z¡p MP] Xbc�U O Z'VfpnXbcTX4X ] XbjJVfa MPO c�U O Z'p MP] XJc �dhx]�]

p�U| PX h ZnX O V h j|U ] Zna hxl V� PX ]xM j h V h XbcJ�o�.pnXJafX �dh�]x] VfpnX O r X OnM²O XJV y�M=�Mel j S afafX O V h�O aTXbcf[ MPO cTXV M UoVYXJ^K[tXbafUWV S aTX�7PaYUeZ h X O Vb��-NafXbU �¸h�O 7 Mel X ] XbjJVfa MPO � p MP] X.c"8_^`^KXwVYa"8 �dh�]�]�] X|UWZ5V M U OnMeOn´ XJa M� � � �uU O Z pnXbaTX � X ZnXJa h  PX\U O U O U ] 8¸V h j|U ] Xw��[naTXbcfc h�MPO1lsM a2VYpnXi� � � UWa h c h�O 7 l a M ^ O Xw�_V��O XbUeafXJcTVT� O X h 7Pp r M a hxO VYXbafUejJV h�MPO c h�O U5c h�O 7 ] X O U OnM V S r XW��.pnX�cTV¦U O Z�UeaTZ � M VfV lsM aT^ lsM akVYp�X�Z�a hxl VNVYpnXJaf^ M X ] XbjwVYa h jo[ M=� XJab� h�O;MPO XgZ h ^KX O c hxMPO � h cb�

= 1 9 � � G a G.��} 6 ��� �� B� ��� G ­ ±�� � � °� pnXJafX � h coVYpnX r U O Z  eX ]xM j h V38P� � h cvVYpnX5X ] XbjwVYa MPO afX ] UR��UWV hxMPO ­scfj|URVfVYXJa hxO 7 ° V h ^KXW�zU O Z&VYp�X[na h ^`Xbc hxO Z h j|UWVfXuZnXJa h  eURV h  eXbc �dh VYp�afXbcT[�XJjJV�V M X O XJa�7�8e� {~�e}e���.pnXkaTX ] U��nURV h�MeO V h ^KX h c�Xw��[tXbjJVfXbZV M r X¥aTX ] URV h  eX ] 8 h�O Z�Xb[tX O ZnX O V Mel X O XJa�7�8�{~�e}e� ��U O Zic M VYp h c VfXbaT^ h c.V38_[ h jbU ]�] 8 h 7 O�M afXJZ³�N»�X�dh�]x] U ] c M UeZ M [�V.VYp h c Ue[n[na M � h ^qUWV h�MPO �¤�.pnX r U O Zi eX ]�M j h V38 h c,7 h  PX O r 8 � 9 5�K� �� + �t- �t ��{ � � �U�M a.Xb� ��±�� ������VfpnX � U O Z � � UeafXM7 h  PX O r 8e�� 9 �;3�� � / ��� J / � e � � J / � ) � K . g ­ �a °� �a 9 �;3 ­@? > � t B¶� p > t > � t ° ­ ±�� � � °� � 9 � �� � ­ �a ° 9 � �� �a � �a� � ­ �a ° 9 � G � ­ �a °� �a G � �a� � ­ �a ° ­ ±�� � °

9 �;3 ? > � �t B1� p > t > � �t B¶� p ­ > � t ° G? > � t B¶� p > t > � t �� pnXJafXe�5pnXJafXW��VYpnX%[na h ^`Xbc hxO Z h jbUWVYX'Z hx« XbaTX O V h UWV hxMPO �dh VfpaTXbcT[�XJjJV&V M �a�� � S r cTV h V S V h�O 7Xb�¸cv±�� � 5U O Z\±�� ��� h�O V M Xb� ��±�� � ��VYpnXgaTXbc S�] V hxO 72Xw��[naTXbcTc h�MeO\lsM akVfpnX�� �� h cb�� �� 9 ? > � �t B¶� p ­ > � t ° G B1� p > t > � �t­ > � t ° G ­@? B¶� p > t ° G � ­ ±�� ��� °

Page 113: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� U�M adU2c"8_cTVfXb^ �dh VfpiU ] VfXba O U O j)84c"8_^K^`XJVfa"8e��VYpnXgj MPO VYa h r S V h�MPO;Mel VYpnX > � �t ^ S c�V j|U O jJX ] � U�M ah�O cTV¦U O jbXW� lsM a�VfpnXi­ ��� � °�O U OnM V S r X Mel U¤h 7n��±�� ±���VfpnX r U O Z�c�jba M cfc hxO 7;UWVoVfpnX U XbaT^ h X O XJa�7�8�dh�]x]v] X|UeZ V M > � �t Mel Xb� S U ] ^KU�7 O�h V S ZnXbc r S V M [n[ M c h VYXGc h 7 O c;U O Z!Vfp S ci^KU � X jbU O jJX ]�]xh�O 7j MeO Vfa h r S V hxMPO c�V M VYp�X`� � � ���.p h c h c�Uij MPO cTXb� S X O jbX Mel VYpnX l UejwVgVYp�UWV lsM a�U;c"8_cTVfXb^ �dh VfpX ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] XNc�8_^K^`XJVfa"8P�PVfpnXbaT^qU ] X���j h VYUWV hxMPO��dh�]x] jJafXbUWVYX.XJ� S U ]nO¸S ^ r XbaTc Mel X ] XJjJVfa MPO cDU O Zp MP] Xbc�U O ZiVYpnXJcfX �dhx]�] p�U| PX�Xb� Snh  WU ] X O V  PX ]xM j h V h XbcJ� � � & Xb^ M   h�O 75VYpnX¥j MPO Vfa h r S V hxMPO c Mel > � �t �� � � ­ ±�� ��� ° r Xbj M ^KXJc � �� 9 � p ­ > � t ° G­ > � t ° G ­0?RB1� p > t ° G � ­ ±�� �P� °�.p h c�^KU'8 r X�afX�� � a h VfVfX Oih�O VYXJaf^`c MWl VYp�X¥afUWV hxM r XJV � XbX OIp U O Z�?D� L c S j¦p\VYp�UWV p�9 8 ?ª�� X M r V¦U hxO � �� 9 � 8 ­ > � t ° G

?u­ > � t ° G ­¯�\B1� 8 > t ° G 9 � 8?u­�� B1� 8 > t ° G � ­ ±�� �e} °

U�M aNUg^`XJV¦U ]�]�h jg­ �_� � ° V S r XW�_VfpnX�X h 7PX O  eU ]�S XJc Mel VYpnX�UeZ Q UejJX O jS8q^KUWVfa h ��� > t�UeafX^7 h  eX O r 8� � �N­�±�� �|� ° �2�.p�Xq¹ ¬ � ¬ U O Z � � � ¬ r U O Znc h�O VfXbafcTXbjwV�UWV�VfpnX U Xbaf^ h�] XJ PX ]�lsM ala 9 G

) ���¢kV�a 9 G

) ��� > t 9 � Bº� ��� � ­da °�9 ��5¢ r MPS V�VYpnX U XbaT^ h�] XJ eX ] U O Z j MeO c h ZnXba h�O 7 MPOn] 8�VYp�X¹ ¬ � ¬ U O Z � � � ¬ r U O ZncJ�tXJ� �t±�� �W}5aTXbZ S jbXbc V M �� �� 9 � 8

? � ­ ±�� �W� °� hxO Vf^ h afX WZY�[^] ��XJcTV h ^qURVYX�Vfp�UWV lsM a�VYpnX\­ �_� � ° V S r X ? 9 � �"�~�PX �zU O Z hxO VYpnX h aoc�V S Z%8 MelL 3 �¥»'U O 7 WZY�[^] �qcfp M=� Vfp�UWV 8 Mel XJ� �¤±_� �W�icfp MPSn] Z ]�h X r XJV � XbX O \U O Z �� �n{��e� �R��� � c hxO 7VYp h cvafU O 7PX Mel [�UWaYUe^`XJVfXbafc h�OX� �¸cJ�D­ ±�� � � ° U O Z%­ ±�� �W� °.] XbUeZnc�V M UK� � � Mel r XJV � XbX O 4U O Z� � P� � �� 9 ��� �.pnX O X)7mUWV h  PX` eU ]�S XJc Mel VfpnXq� � � j|U ] j Sn] UWVYXJZ S c h�O 7�Xb� �¤±�� �R� h�O Z h j|URVYX2VYp�URVVYp�X [�afXbZ M ^ hxO U O V²j¦p�UWa�7PX&j|UWafa h Xba hxO VYpnX UeaT^Kj¦pnU h a O U OnM V S r XJc;UeafX&X ] XbjwVYa MPO cb� �.p h c h cUec�X���[�XJjJVYXJZ³�ªc h�O jbXqVfpnX O X���V�� O XbUeafXJcTV�� O X h 7Pp r M a�VYXJaf^`c�j M ^K[naTXbcTc�VYpnX4j MPO Z S jJV hxMPO r U O ZncU O Z&X���[nU O Z&VYpnX� WU ] X O jJX r U O ZncK­ U¤h 7n��±�� ± ° � ] X|UeZ h�O 7qV M U²p h 7Pp�XbavVfpnXbaT^qU ] [ M [ Sn] UWV h�MPO\MelX ] XbjwVYa MeO cb� ¢kV²}m� � �DVYp�X [naTXbZ h jJVYXJZ VYpnXJaf^ M [ M�� Xba h c r XwV � XJX O ¡U O Z � ± � �� � �.p h c h ch�O afX|UWc MPO U r ] X²U47PafXJXb^`X O V �dh Vfp¡VYpnXq^KXbUec S aTXb^`X O V Mel � � � �� r 8 LNMe]�]�hxO c WZYT[^] { �P�R� �DU O Zj MeO c h ZnXbafU r ] 8 cT^qU ]x] XJa5Vfp�U O VfpnX ^`X|Uec S afXJ^KX O V Mel 7PaTX|UWVfXbaKVfp�U O � � � �� r 8 -NaYUWZ ] XS8 WZY[^] {~�P�����

Page 114: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� ��� :¦9 � I��H F����IbC`?�.p h c�j¦p�Ue[�VfXba�ZnXba h  PXJcoU`c h ^`[ ] X�^`X|U O c lsM a hxO j ]xS Z h�O 7 O Xw�_VT� O X|UeaTXbc�VT� O X h 7ep r M a VYaYU O c l XJa

VYXJaf^`c h�O ¹��S j � X ] jbU ] j Sn] URV h�MeO c Mel jJXbaTVYU h�O V38_[tXbc Mel j|Uea r MeO c�VYa S jJV S afXJcb�ª�.pnXgafXb� Snh afXJ^KX O VfcUeaTXªVfp�UWVk­ h ° U ]x] r MPO Z ] X O 7eVfpnc r X h ZnX O V h j|U ] ��­ hxh ° VYpnXuUWV M ^Kc ^ S c�V�U ]�] p�U| PXNXb� S U ]_O¸S ^ r Xbafc MelO XbUeafXJcTV O X h 7Pp r M afcJ��U O Z ­ h�h�h ° U ]�]tO Xw�_VT� O X|UWafXbc�V O X h 7Pp r M auZ h c�V¦U O jbXbc.^ S cTV r XoXb� S U ] ���.pnXJcfXj MeO Z h V h�MPO cKp Me] Z lsM a r X On´ X O XW� L 3 �;U O Z¶VYpnX h�O � O�h VYX O U O�M V S r XbcKVYp�UWV4UeafXiVYpnX\[na h ^qUWa"8c S r Q XbjwV Mel VYp h cdj¦p�Ue[�VfXbaJ��.pnX O Xw�_VT� O X|UeaTXbc�VT� O X h 7ep r M a.VYXJaf^`c r afX|U � X ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] X�c"8_^K^`XJVfa"8 hxO VfpnXbcTX¥c�8_cTVYXJ^KcJ�

¢ ] VYp MeS 7Pp'Vfp h c�c�8_^K^`XJVfa"8 r afXbU �¸h�O 7�pnUec OnM X « XbjwV MPO VfpnX r U O Ze7PUe[³� h V�Z M Xbc5U ] VYXJa¥VYp�XVYp�Xbaf^ M X ] XJjJVfa h jq[ M=� Xba ­ � � � ° ��»ºpnX O X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X²c"8_^`^KXwVYa�8®Ue[n[ ]xh XJcb��VYpnX;� � � Mel Uc hxO 7 ] X O U OnM V S r X h c ´ Xba M � U�M a�afX|UWc MPO U r ] XKXbcTV h ^KUWVYXJc MeldO Xw�_VT� O X|UeaTXbc�VT� O X h 7ep r M a hxO VYXbafUejw�V hxMPO cJ�@VfpnX`� � � hxO Z S jJXbZ r 8&c S j¦p hxO VYXbafUejJV h�MPO c�jbU O r XKUecgp h 7ep'Uec � ± � �� UWV¥}m� � � � �¸�[tXba h ^KX O V¦U ] XbcTV h ^KUWVYXJc h�O j ]�S Z�X � � � �� U O Z � � � �� ���.pnX¥aTXbc Sn] Vfc.[nafXJcfX O VfXbZ�pnXJafXgc S 707PXbc�VVYpnUWV.X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] Xoc�8�^`^`XJVYa�8 r afX|U �_hxO 75Z S XoV M2O Xw�_VT� O X|UWafXbc�VT� O X h 7Pp r M a hxO VYXbafUejJV h�MPO ck^qU'8UejJj MPSnO V lsM adU5c S r cTV¦U O V h U ] [ M a�V h�MeO²Mel VfpnXg� � � Mel¤O U OnM V S r XJcb�

Page 115: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� P�

� �8� � ���'�

� � � + � � �'� ��� ��� � � � #

Page 116: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� e}

� � ��� ���� �

� � � � ( ��� � � � + � � �'� ��� #�� �¡� � � ��� � � � ���� � � � ��� � ��� � ��� � � � �� �"� � # ����!�"��� � � � ��� � � �"+ � ( �� #

�;:=< >@?4A�BDC;EGFGH.A�IJCK?§ O']xh 7PpmVT� Xb^ h VTV h�O 7W� Z hxM Z�Xbc�­ � �D© c ° r UecfXJZ MPO j MPORQTS 7mUWVYXJZ'[ MP] 8_^`XbaTcb� U O X ] XJjJVYa MPO U O Z

p MP] X�UeaTX h�ORQ XJjJVYXJZ h�O V M U O;SnO Z M [tXbZ;j MPO�QTS 7mUWVfXbZ;[ Me] 8_^KXJab��c S j¦p\Uec.[ MP] 8m�w­s[�UeafUR� [np�X O 8 ] X O X  h�O 8 ] X O X ° ­ ��� ° { ��� �P±����u�.pnXJcfX�j¦p�Uea"7PXbc ^ h 7PaYURVYXvVfpna MPS 7PpiVfpnXg^qURVYXba h U ] U O Zij M ^ r h�O XoV MXb^ h VvUq[np M V MPO �v¢ O h ^`[ M a�V¦U O V � S U O V h V38 lsM avZnXw PX ]xM [ hxO 7²U O�S�O ZnXbaTcTVYU O Z hxO 7 Mel Vfp h c�[na M �jbXJcfc h c VfpnX�X���j h V MPO r hxO Z hxO 7KX O Xba"7�8P�tVYpnX¥Z hx« XbaTX O jJX hxO X O Xba�748 r XJV � XbX O U � X ]�] � cTXb[�UeafUWVYXJZX ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] XG[�U h a;U O ZºVYpnX&c�V¦UWVfX&Vfp�UWViXb^ h Vfc4VYpnX&[np M V MPO � �_VYU O Z�UWafZ!cfXb^ h � Xb^`[ h a h jbU ]� S U O V S ^ j¦pnXb^ h c�VYa"8;^ M ZnX ] c.c S j¦pGUWc ��� {�� � � � ��§¯¨ ©g¬ {~�P±=� M a � ¨ ©g¬ {~� �W� 8PX h�] Z\X���j h V MPOr hxO Z h�O 7�X O Xba�7 h Xbc Mel 7PafXbUWVYXJaNVYpnU O ��� �WX � � pnX O Ue[n[ ]xh XbZKV M U�c h�O 7 ] Xv[ MP] 8�^`Xbaªj¦p�U hxO ���.p h ch cD^ S j¦pp7PaTX|UWVfXba�VYp�U O VYp�X�X���j h V MPO r h�O Z hxO 7gX O XJa�7 h XbcªcfXJX O4hxO c MP]�h Z�� c�V¦UWVfX.j MPORQTS 7mUWVYXJZK[ MP] 8¸�^`XbafcJ� U�M a hxO cTVYU O jJXe�DVYpnXJafX h c<7PX O XJaYU ] U47PafXJXb^`X O V2VYp�URV�VYpnX²X���j h V MPO r h�O Z h�O 7GX O Xba"7�8 hxO[ MP] 8_Z h UejbXwV38 ] X O X h c �� �WX { � ��� � ��� � W����U O Z4VYp�UWVk[np M V M X���j h VYUWV hxMPO4Mel [ MP] 8PUejbXwV38 ] X O X ] X|UeZ�cV M VYpnXiaYUW[ h Z lsM af^KUWV h�MPO®Mel r M Vfp¶j¦p�UWa�7PXJZ U O Z O X S VfaYU ] c MP]�h V MPO c|{ ���e���m�_���P}R� � § O ���� �Xw��[tXba h ^`X O V¦U ] XJcTV h ^KUWVYXJc lsM a�VfpnXdXw��j h V MPO r h�O Z h�O 7gX O Xba�748 hxO j ]xS ZnX O XbUea� �� n{ �e�W� � �� �WX { �P�R� � ��~�PX { � � � �m±R����U O Z �� �eX { � ���_}��b��µ�U O ZqVYpnX M afXwV h j|U ] Xbc�V h ^qUWVfXbc h�O j ]�S ZnX ����PX { � ��� � R��U O Z

Page 117: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� W� �� �eX {~}��b� �

� U O 8�VfpnX M aTXJV h j|U ] cTV S Z h XJc Mel j MPORQTS 7mUWVYXJZ&[ MP] 8_^KXJafc S cTXKU4c h�O 7 ] Xw� j¦p�U hxO ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O[�UeafUe^`XJVYXJa hx´ XbZKV M c MP]�h Z�� c�V¦UWVfX M r cfXba� WUWV hxMPO cb��� M�M r V¦U hxO U�7PaTXbXb^`X O V �dh VYpqc MP]xh Z�� cTV¦URVYX Xw��j h �V MeO r h�O Z h�O 7¥X O XJa�7 h XbcJ��VYp�X LNMPSn]xM ^ r aTXb[ S�] c hxMPO r XJV � XbX O X ] XJjJVYa MPO cu^ S cTV r X�c S r c�V¦U O V h U ]x] 8� X|U � Xba;VYp�U O Vfp�UWV²V38_[ h j|U ]x] 8 S cfXJZ hxO cfXJ^ h � Xb^`[ h a h jbU ] � S U O V S ^ j¦pnXb^ h c�VYa�8³{~� ���k} ��k}��b� ��.p h c O XbXbZiV M5� XbU � X O VYp�X¥X ] XbjwVYa MPO � X ] XJjJVYa MPOih�O VYXJaYUejwV h�MeO c h�O U5c h�O 7 ] X�� j¦p�U hxO ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O]�hx� X ] 8�afX y XbjJVfc2VYpnX h ^K[ M aTVYU O jJX MeloLNMPSn]xM ^ r cfjJafXJX OnhxO 7 l a M ^�UeZ Q UejJX O V5[ Me] 8_^KXJa�j¦p�U hxO cb��.p h c [nUe[�XJadj MPO V hxO¸S Xbc MPS adZnXw PX ]xM [n^`X O V Mel U O X ] XbjwVYa MPOnh j�� [ MP] UWa MPO ^ M ZnX ] Vfp�UWV Xw��[ ]xh j h V ] 8h�O j ]�S ZnXbc LNMPSn]xM ^ r cfjbaTXbX Onh�O 7 l a M ^ UWZ Q UejbX O Vvj¦p�U h�O cJ�.�.pnX�^ M Z�X ]³� Uec M a h 7 hxO U ]x] 8KUe[n[ ]xh XJZV M V �uM [ MP] 8PX O Xij¦pnU h�O cJ� MeO X � c Me]�S VfX��&[ Me] 8PX O XiU O Z MPO X � c MP]  PX O V ��[ MP] 8eX O XW� & XJjbX O V ] 8e�VYp h c5^ M ZnX ] p�Uec r XbX O Xw�_VYX O ZnXJZ c S j¦p1VYp�UWV5VfpnX O_S ^ r XJa Mel c MP]  eX O Vqj¦pnU h�O c h c`c S �`j h X O VV M U ]�]�M=� U²afX ]�h U r ] X�Xw�_VfaYUe[ MP] URV h�MeO V M VfpnX2c MP]xh Z�� cTVYUWVYX ]�h ^ h Vb�o§ O r M VYp�VYp�X�V �NM � j¦p�U hxO U O Zc Me]�h Z_� cTVYUWVYXvj|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO cb�¸VYp�X�c MP]xS VYX�j¦p�U h�O²� UWc Z�XbcfjJa h r XJZ �dh VYpiU ���� ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O U O ZVYp�X�c MP]  eX O Vkj¦p�U h�O c � XJafX�ZnXbcTjba h r XJZ �dh VYp4¹��S j � X ] VfpnX M a�8P��¹��S j � X ] VfpnX M a�8 � Uec S cTXbZ lsM aDVYp�Xc Me]  PX O Vvj¦p�U h�O c r Xbj|U S cfX h V�7PaTX|UWV ] 8²c h ^`[ ]�h ��XbcuVYpnXgXJ WU ]xS UWV h�MPO²Mel VYpnX�¹�Ue^ hx] V MPOnh U O ^KUWVYa h �X ] Xb^`X O VYcJ�D§ O Vfp h c.[nUe[�XJab��VfpnX S cTX MWl ¹��S j � X ] VfpnX M a"8 lsM auVYpnXgc Me]  PX O V h cNVYXJcTVfXbZ\U O Zicfp M=�dOV M r X�Ut7 M�M ZiUe[n[na M � h ^qUWV h�MPO ��.pnXbaTXgUeafX V �NM2h ^K[ M a�V¦U O VNUecf[tXbjwVYcNV M�MPS akX ] XJjJVYa MPOnh jw� [ MP] Uea MPO ^ M Z�X ] ���.pnX ��aTcTV h cuVYp�XS cTX Mel X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] Xe�mafUWVYp�Xba�VYp�U O X ] XbjwVYa MPO � X ] XJjJVYa MPO �mcTjbafXJX OnhxO 7n��§ O VYpnXd[�UWaYUe^`XJVfXba hx´ UWV h�MPOMel Uqc h�O 7 ] Xw� j¦p�U hxO ¹�Ue^ hx] V MPOnh U O V M c Me]�h Z_� cTVYUWVYX�Z�UWVYU�� h V h c V38_[ h j|U ]x] 8²VfpnX WZ],W��ZY� �� ��� WZ],W��ZY� �� �h�O VfXbaYUWjJV hxMPO [ M VYX O V h U ] Vfp�UWV h cg^ M Z h ��XbZ@{~� �¸� } �� }��w� �²¹ XbaTXe� � X`j MPO c h ZnXJa¥p M�� h�O VYXJafj¦p�U hxOh�O VfXbaYUWjJV hxMPO c ^ M Z h l 8qVYp�X WZ],W��ZY� �� ������� ],Wkh�O VYXJaYUejwV hxMPO c [nafXJcfX O V hxO VfpnX�X���j h VfXbZ�c�V¦UWVfXbcb� �.p h ch cNU O U ]xM 7 MPS cuV M ^ M ZnX ] c Mel VfpnafXJXw� Z h ^`X O c h�MPO U ] cTXb^ h j MPO Z S jwV M aTcb� � p�XbafX h V h cuVYp�XoX ] XbjJVfa MPO �

p MP] Xg[ M VfX O V h U ] � O�M V�VfpnX�X ] XJjJVfa MPO � X ] XbjJVfa MPO [ M VYX O V h U ] �nVYp�URV h c�cTjbaTXbX O XbZ@{�� ��|���.�.pnX�cTXbj MPO Zh ^`[ M aTVYU O VkUecT[�XJjJV Mel@MeS ak^ M ZnX ]�h cNVYp�X h�O j ]�S c h�MPOqMel VYpnXoV h ^`Xw� cfj|U ] X Mel r M VYp4VYp�XoX ] XbjJVfa MPO �p MP] X\^ M V h�MPO U O Z¶VfpnX c MP]  eX O V²[ MP] UWa h�´ UWV hxMPO �1§ O X ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] XicTjbaTXbX O�h�O 7n�.VfpnX aTX ] Xw WU O VV h ^KX�� cTj|U ] XbcgUeaTX5Vfp M cTX Mel VYp�XKc MP]  eX O V�[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO U O Z VfpnX`X ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] X2^ M V h�MPO �2�.pnXV h ^KXicfjbU ] X Mel VYp�X c Me]  PX O V²[ Me] Uea h�´ URV h�MeO h c hxO  eXbaTcfX ] 8¶[�a M [ M aTV h�MPO U ] V M VfpnX M [�V h jbU ] 7mUe[³�U r MPS VN�WX �¸�.pnX�V h ^`X.cfjbU ] X lsM aDX ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] Xd^ M V h�MeO`hxO VYpnX Xw��j h V MPOKh c h�O  eXbafcTX ] 8K[�a M [ M a��V hxMPO U ] V M VYpnXgX���j h V MPO r h�O Z h�O 75X O Xba�748P��­ ¢ OnMPO � cTVYUWV hxMPO Uea�84c�V¦UWVfX�[�afXb[nUeafXJZ �dh VYpiU`Z h [ MP] X^ M ^KX O V�[ MPhxO V h�O 72V M VfpnX ] X l V �dh�]x]³M cfj h�]x] UWVfXoV M VfpnX�a h 7ep¸V MPO VYp h c.V h ^`XgcfjbU ] XW� ° »ºpnX O VYp�X

Page 118: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� P�Xw��j h V MeO r h�O Z h�O 74X O Xba"7�8 h c MPOn] 8�U l X � [tXbaTjbX O V Mel VfpnX r U O Z 7PUe[³�zUec hxO ^KU O 8 h�O�M a�7mU Onh jcfXJ^ h j MPO Z S jJV M afc|{ � ��b���_VfpnXoX ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X ^ M V h�MPO`h c M aTZnXbaTc Mel ^KU�7 Onh V S Z�X�c ]�M=� XJaNVYpnU O VYp�Xc Me]  PX O Vk[ MP] Uea h�´ UWV hxMPO �@§ O c S j¦p²c"8_cTVfXb^`cb��VfpnX�[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO2Mel VYpnX�c S aTa MPSnO Z h�O 7ecNj|U OqlsMP]�]xM=�VYp�Xo^ M V h�MeOqMel VYp�XoX ] XbjJVfa MPO U O Z²p MP] XoU O Z4Vfp S cdU�cfjJafXbX O XbZiX ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X hxO VYXbafUejJV h�MPO [ M �VYX O V h U ] �_c S j¦piUeckVfp�UWV S cfXbZ;»'U OnOnh XbaNX���j h V MPO VYp�X M a�8P� h c.U 7 M_M ZqUe[n[na M � h ^qUWV h�MPO � {�� ����s- S Vh�O j MPO�QTS 7mUWVfXbZ�[ MP] 8_^`XbaTcb��VYpnX¥Xw��j h V MPO r h�O Z h�O 7`X O XJa�7 h Xbc�^qU'8 r XU7PafXbUWVYXJa Vfp�U O �_� �WX lsM aU OGh c MP] UWVYXJZ j¦p�U hxO U O Z �� �WX M a ] Uea�7eXba hxO VYp�X�c MP]xh Z�c�V¦UWVfXe�g¢ cTXb[�UeafUWV hxMPO�Mel V h ^`Xw� cfj|U ] Xbch c�VfpnX O OnM V`UW[n[�UeaTX O V|�uU O Z%VYp�X;V h ^`XbcTj|U ] Xbc Mel r M VYp®X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X4^ M V hxMPO U O Z®c MP]  eX O V[ MP] Uea h�´ UWV hxMPO ^ S cTV r X hxO j ]xS ZnXbZ hxO VfpnXg^ M ZnX ] ��.pnX�Z;8 O UW^ h j UecT[�XJjJVfc Mel VfpnX X ] XJjJVYa MPO � p MP] XicfjJafXJX OnhxO 7¡[na M jJXbcfcq[ ] U'8 U�jJX O VYafU ] a MP] Xh�O XbcTVYU r ]xh cfp h�O 75VYpnX�Xw��j h V MPO r hxO Z hxO 7KX O Xba"7�8P��§ O VfXbafj¦pnU h�OGhxO VfXbafUejJV h�MPO c ]�M=� Xba�VfpnX�X���j h V MPOr hxO Z h�O 7¥X O Xba"7�8 r XbjbU S cTXvVYpnX � c Me]  WUWV hxMPO X O XJa�7�8 � Mel VYpnX l afXbX�X ] XbjJVfa MPO U O Z4p Me] X h c 7PafXbUWVYXJa

VYpnU O VYpnX²c MP]  WUWV h�MPO X O XJa�7�8 Mel VYpnX²X���j h V MPO �'§ O VfpnX l afXJX²X ] XbjJVfa MPO � p MP] Xq[�U h a�c�V¦UWVfXbcb�DVYp�Xj¦p�Uea"7PX ynS jJV S UWV hxMPO c�Uea h c h�O 7 l a M ^ X ] XbjJVfa MPO � p MP] XK^ M V h�MPO UeaTXqc ]xM=� U O Z�VfpnXq[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPOMel VYp�Xoc S aTa MPS�O Z h�O 72j¦p�U h�O ckj|U O²O X|Uea ] 8 lsMP]�]xM�� VYpnX�X ] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] X�^ M V h�MPO �¤�.p h c ] XbUeZncNV M UafX ] UWV h  eX ] 8 ] Uea"7PXgc MP]  eURV h�MeO X O Xba"7�8 lsM a VfpnX l aTXbX�X ] XbjJVfa MPO � p MP] X¥[nU h adcTVYUWVYXJcb�d§ O VfpnX�X���j h V MPOcTVYUWVYXW�tVfpnX�j¦pnUea�7PX�� y�S jJV S UWV hxMPO c�UeafX�� Snh VfX l Uec�V|��U O ZiVYpnX¥[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO²MWl VYp�X�c S afa MeSnO Z hxO 7j¦p�U hxO c.j|U OnOnM V lsMP]x]�M=� VYp�X�X ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] Xv^ M V hxMPO �¤�.p�X�X���j h V MPO cTVYUWVYX h cNVYpnX O;MPOn] 8 � X|U �¸] 8c Me]  WUWVYXJZ³���.pnXqX ] XJjJVfa MPO U O Z¡p MP] XKVYp�X O cfpnXJZ¡VYpnX h a¥c MP]  eURV h�MeO j ]xMPS Z � p�X O VYpnXS8 QTMeh�O V MlsM aT^�U O Xw��j h V MPO �¤�.p h cDX O p�U O jJXbcuVfpnXdZ hx« XbaTX O V h U ] c Me]  WUWV hxMPO2Mel VYpnX l afXJXdX ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] X.[�U h a PXJafc S c�VfpnXgXw��j h V MPO � U O Z ] X|UWZnc.V M U ] Uea"7PX�afXJZ S jJV h�MPO;hxO VfpnXgXw��j h V MPO r hxO Z h�O 72X O XJa�7�8e�

� ��[ ]�h j h V h�O j ]�S c h�MPO�MWl cTjbaTXbX O�h�O 7 �dh�]x]�]xh�� X ] 8 ] X|UeZ�V M r XwVfVYXJaoVYafU O c l XJaYU r h�]�h V38 Mel [�UeaYUW^5�XJVfXbaTc r XwV � XJX O Z hx« XbaTX O V2[ MP] 8_^`Xba�c"8_cTVfXb^`cb� § V2cfp MeSn] Z%U ] c M U ]�]xM�� ZnXJVYU h�] XbZ hxO�lsM af^KUWV h�MPOMPO ^ MP] Xbj S�] XbcJ��X h VYp�Xba l a M ^ Xw��[tXba h ^KX O V M avp h 7Pp�� ] Xw PX ]\[�� � � � Y � � jbU ] j Sn] UWV h�MPO cb� V M r X S cTXbZh�O VYp�X�[nUeaYUe^`XJVfa hx´ UWV h�MPO²Mel c MP]xh Z�� cTVYUWVYX�^ M Z�X ] cJ�u�.p�X S cTX Mel ^ Me] Xbj Sn] UWakZ�UWVYU h c XJcf[tXbj h U ]x] 8h ^`[ M aTVYU O V � p�X O ZnXJVYU h�] XbZ\c MP]xh Z�� cTV¦URVYX�Xw��[�XJa h ^KX O VYU ] ZnUWV¦U h c�Z h �`j Sn] VvV M4M r VYU h�O �tc S j¦p�UWc� pnX O ^ M ZnX ]�hxO 7�VYp�X�X « XJjJVfc Mel j¦pnXJ^ h j|U ] Z�X l XbjwVYc�U O Zi[np?8_c h jbU ] ^ M af[np MP]�M 748P�

Page 119: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �

U¤h 7 S afX ��� ��� L pnXb^ h jbU ] cTVYa S jJV S afX MWl VYpnX�c�8_cTVYXJ^ S cTXbZGV M cTV S Z;8 VfpnX�X « XbjwVYc MWlDh�O VYXJafj¦p�U hxOh�O VfXbaYUWjJV hxMPO c MPO VfpnXvX���j h V MPO r hxO Z hxO 7�X O Xba"7�8P��§ O U ]�] VYpnX�j|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO cD[naTXbcfX O VYXbZ²p�XbafXW��VYp�Xc Me]  PX O V�j¦pnU h�O p�Uecg��� SnOnh VdjbX ]�] cJ���.pnXgc MP]xS VYXgj¦p�U h�O;] X O 7eVYp h ck eUWa h XJZ h�O VYpnXgjbU ] j Sn] UWV h�MPO cb��;:�� �£C � GF A��A�IbC`?I� ��� ��A ��C;E��� ������� ��� � � � ���f� �

�.pnX�jbU ] j Sn] UWV h�MPO c5UeafXi[�XJa lsM aT^KXJZ MPO U�^ M Z�X ] c"8_cTVfXb^ j MPO c h c�V hxO 7 MWl V �NM [ MP] 8PX O XbcJ�MPO X c MP]xS VYXGU O Z MPO X�c MP]  eX O V;j¦p�U hxO � �dh Vfp VYpnX 7eX M ^`XJVfa h XJcqcTp M=�dO hxOqU¤h 7 S afX ���x�e� �.pnX¹vUW^ hx] V MeOnh U OKh c � 9 � � g v B � � g v � B � � g v M � g v � G ­ ���x� °� pnXJafX � � g v�h cuVfpnX�c MP]xS VYXo¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O � � � g v � VfpnX�c Me]  PX O V ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O �¸U O Z � � g v M � g v � h cVYp�X�c MP]�S VYXw� c MP]  PX O V hxO VfXbafUejJV h�MPO ¹�Ue^ hx] V MPOnh U O ��.pnX�c MP]xS VYX h c.ZnXbcTjba h r XJZ S c h�O 7 � Uea h cfXba¯� � Ueafa¯� � M [ ] XoVfpnX M a�8�{�� � � �

� � g v 9 �),+ >f+ + � ��� rZ)k+ >�B ,� g v>f+ ) � > �>f+ + > ),+ +

B �� � ) ( ­ �� ) � � ° �� )�B � )���> (�­ � > + ) ° �� > �� ) G ­ ��� � °� pnXJafX > �),+ + ­ > ),+ + ° jJafXbUWVYXJc5­ ZnXJcTVfa M 8_c ° U O X ] XJjJVfa MPO �dh VYp\cf[ hxO Q hxO VYp�X�[�� M a r h V¦U ]@MPO VYpnXV/mJLKj|UWa r MPO � �� ) h c�VYpnX5j¦p�UWa�7PX M [tXbafUWV M a MPO VfpnXC/mJLK4jbUea r MPO � �� ) 9 � � > �),+ � > ),+ � � > �),+ > ),+ ���U O Z� ),+ > h c2VYpnXiZ h c�V¦U O jbX r XwV � XJX O j|UWa r MPO c h U O Z Q � U�M a�VfpnX MeO X\X ] XJjJVYa MPO VYXbaT^KcJ� ,

� g v>f+ ) � � XS cTX O X|UeaTXbc�VT� O X h 7ep r M aoVfaYU O c l Xba hxO VfX�7PafU ] c Mel ? � g v5 9 ���_� �P���eX lsM avc hxO 7 ] X r MeO ZncgU O Z�? � g vG 9 ���� � ���|X lsM a.Z MPS r ] X r MeO Zncb� - M VfpiVfpnXgX ] XbjJVfa MPO � X ] XbjwVYa MeO U O Z O¸S j ] XbUea�� O_S j ] XbUeadafXJ[ Sn] c h�MPO cUeaTX�Z�XbcfjJa h r XJZ �dh VYp²VYpnX ¬ p OnM [ M VYX O V h U ] �

(2­� °:9 �|� ��} �m± 6� �� � 5 1� ) + 5 � � A� � G B � G ­ ��� } °

Page 120: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� P±� pnXJafX � h c5VYp�X ¹ S rnr UeaTZ¶[�UWaYUe^`XJVfXbab�¶§5U O Z ��UeaTXij¦p M cfX O c S j¦p¶Vfp�UWVqUe[n[ ]xh jbUWV hxMPO%MelVYp�X¥¹�Ue^ h�] V MPOnh U O V M U2c h�O 7 ] Xoj|UWa r MPO UWV M ^ 8 h X ] ZnckVYp�X hxMPOnhx´ UWV h�MPO [ M VfX O V h U ] U O Z;X ] XbjwVYa MPOU � Onh V38 Mel U O cT[ G p?8 r a h Z h�´ XbZ`j|Uea r MeO µ¸§ h c�cTXJVuXb� S U ] V M VfpnX hxMPOnhx´ UWV h�MPO [ M VfX O V h U ]nMel U O cT[ Gp?8 r a h Z h�´ XbZ�jbUea r MPO ���P�P� � � X ��U O Z � h c@cfXJV�Xb� S U ] V M VfpnXuZ hx« XbafX O jbX r XwV � XJX O VfpnX hxMPOnhx´ UWV h�MPO[ M VYX O V h U ] U O ZiX ] XJjJVfa MPO U � Onh V38 Mel U O cf[ G p�8 r a h Z hx´ XJZ\jbUea r MPO � � 9 �P�P� �=}eX � {�� m����.pnX�c MP]xS VYXgU O Z\c MP]  eX O V h�O VYXJaYUejwV Vfpna MeS 7Pp LNMPSn]xM ^ r h�O VYXJaYUejwV hxMPO cb�

� � g v M � g v � 9 � � + ) (�­�� + ) ° �� � �� )�G ­ ����� °

� pnXJafXl/ h c.c S ^`^`XbZ M  PXba c Me]�S VfXgUWV M ^`cdU O Z � h c.c S ^`^`XbZ M  PXba c Me]  PX O VvURV M ^`cb�»'X �dh�]�] j M ^K[nUeafXªVYpnXkaTXbc Sn] Vfc l a M ^ V �uM Z hx« XbaTX O V�^ M Z�X ] c lsM a VYpnXkc MP]  eX O V|�¤�.pnX.c h ^K[ ] Xba^ M ZnX ]³h cd¹��S j � X ] VfpnX M a"8P� � � g v � 9 �� + � + + ,

� g v �� + � > � � + + > � + + G ­ ��� � °�dh Vfp ,

� g v �� + � r X h�O 7 O X|UWafXbc�VT� O X h 7Pp r M akVfaYU O c l Xba h�O VYX)7PaYU ] cb�³­@? � g v �5 lsM akc h�O 7 ] X r MPO Znc.U O Z ? � g v �G °lsM a³Z MPS r ] X r MPO Zncb� �.pnX M VYp�Xbazc Me]  PX O V ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O h c�VfpnX ���� ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O Mel XJ� � ��� �����.p�X¹��S j � X ] ¹�Ue^ h�] V MPOnh U O2lsM ak[ MP] 8eX O XJc.p�Uec MPO�] 8`V �NM aTX ] Xw WU O V.[�UeafUe^KXwVYXJafcb��VYpnXvVfaYU O c l Xba hxO VYXw�7PafU ] c lsM aoc hxO 7 ] X�U O Z&Z MPS r ] X r MPO ZncJ�*? � g v �5 U O Z ? � g v �G �¥§ O VfpnX ]�MPO 7W� j¦p�U h�O�]xh ^ h V|� r M VYpGVYp�Xr U O Z'­ l afXJXw� j¦pnUea�7PX ° 7mUe[;U O Z M [�V h j|U ] 7mUe[;UeaTXoXb� S U ] V M � ((( ? � g v �5 � ? � g v �G ((( ���.pnX r U O Z �dh Z�Vfph c�cTXJV r 8 � ((( ? � g v �5 B ? � g v �G ((( � � p h j¦p h c�Xb� S U ] V M VfpnX2Z h « XJafX O jbX h�O X O Xba"7�8 r XJV � XbX O VYpnX�V M [Mel VYp�Xo eU ] X O jbX r U O ZiU O Z4VYp�X r M VTV M ^ Mel VYp�Xoj MPO Z S jJV h�MPO r U O Z³���.pnXg¹��S j � X ] [nUeaYUe^`XJVfXbaTcUeaTXKj¦p M cfX O V M ^ h ^ h j¥VYp�X ��� ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O �2� M\� XbXJ[%Ue[n[na M � h ^qURVYX ] 8 VfpnXKcfUe^`X r U O Z�dh Z�VYp4UWc hxO ��� VYpnX M a"8e� � XvcTXJVªVYpnX�c S ^ Mel VYpnX�¹��S j � X ] VYaYU O c l XJa hxO VfX�7PafU ] c�V M VfpnXvc S ^ MelVYp�X¥VYafU O c l Xba hxO VfX�7PafU ] c Mel ��� VYpnX M a"8e��­@? � g v �5 B ? � g v �G ° F � 9 � �"�~�� e�m�WX ��§ O ��� VYpnX M a"8e�VYp�X M [�V h j|U ] 7mUe[GjbU O r X�� S�h VYX2Z hx« XbafX O V l a M ^ VYp�X r U O Z 7mUe[����.p�X2j¦p MPh jJX Mel VYpnX5¹��S j � X ]7mUe[ ZnXJ[�X O Znc MeO � p h j¦p¡UecT[�XJjJV Mel ��� VYp�X M a�8 � XKUeafX5VYa�8 h�O 7²V M ^ h ^ h je�2�.p�XKaTX ] Xw WU O VUecT[�XJjJV�p�XbafX h cgVYpnXKafXJcf[ MPO cfX Mel VYp�Xqc Me]  PX O V�V M j¦p�Uea"7PX y�S jJV S UWV hxMPO c MeO VYp�Xqc Me]�S VfXe� h ��XW�x�VYp�X4afXJcf[ MPO cfX4V M U O Xw�_VfXba O U ] X ] XbjwVYa h j ��X ] Z³�G�.p�X²¹��S j � X ] 7mUW[ h c¥Vfp S c2cfXwV2Xb� S U ] V M VYp�XM [�V h jbU ] 7mUe[ l a M ^ ��� VYp�X M a�8P��Uec�jbU ] j Sn] URVYXbZ l a M ^�VYpnX & U O Z M ^ � p�UWcfX�¢�[n[na M � h ^qUWV h�MPO­ & � ¢ ° {�� P}�� �K�.pnX & � ¢ 7mUe[ h c S cTXbZ r XJj|U S cTXKVfpnX ]xh�O XbUeaoaTXbcf[ MPO cTX M r V¦U hxO XbZ l a M ^ & � ¢VYp�X M a�8 h c.Xb� S U ] V M Vfp�UWV M r VYU h�O XbZ l a M ^8V h ^`Xw� ZnXb[tX O ZnX O V�¹vUea�VYaTXbXw� U�M j � VfpnX M a�8 ­ � © ¹ U�° ��.pnXªj|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO c³Z h cfj S cfcTXbZ r X ]xM=�¡S cTXN¹�UeaTVfafXbX�� U�M j � VYpnX M a"8�V M jbU ] j Sn] URVYX�VYp�Xª[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO

Page 121: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� �h�O Z S jbXJZ r 8\VYpnX�c MP]xS VYX�j¦pnUea�7PX2Z h cTVfa h r S V hxMPO ��U O Z&UeaTX�VYp S cgU O U ]�M 7 MPS c V M � © ¹ U VYpnX M a"8e��.pnX & � ¢ 7PUe[ l a M ^ ��� VYpnX M a"8 h cv�_� �P� X � c M VYpnX¥¹��S j � X ] ^ M ZnX ]�lsM a.VYpnX�c MP]  PX O V S cTXbc� ((( ? � g v �5 B ? � g v �G ((( 9 �"� �e� 6� �� ������� �o� � " � � � ��� � � � � (� ��� � � %� ���

�.pnX�X « XJjJVYc MelDh�O VYXJafj¦p�U h�O hxO VYXbafUejJV h�MPO c MPO VYpnX¥Xw��j h V MPO r h�O Z hxO 7qX O Xba"7�8 UeafX M r VYU h�O XJZr 8qj M ^`[�Uea hxO 7gVYpnX�c MP]  eURV h�MeO X O Xba�748 MWl VYpnX�Xw��j h V MPO V M VYpnUWV Mel U l afXJXvX ] XbjwVYa MeO ­�U�[ MP] 8PX O XU OnhxMPO ° U O Z U l afXJX�p MP] XK­�U5[ MP] 8eX O Xgj|URV h�MeO ° �D�.pnX�c"8_^`^KXwVYa"8 Mel VfpnX�¹�Ue^ h�] V MPOnh U Oqh c.c S j¦pVYpnUWV¥VfpnXqc MP]  WUWV h�MPO X O Xba"7�8 MWl VYp�X4U OnhxMPO U O Z¡jbUWV hxMPO UWafXqXJ� S U ] �²�.p�X h c MP] URVYXbZ c Me]�S VfX h cZnXJcfjba h r XbZ �dh Vfp �¸� L §ªVfpnX M a"8 h�O U ]�M j|U ]�M a r h VYU ] r UWc h c|{�� � � �

) ) � g v e J � 1C/ � � J �e v 9 � e + � e � e ­ ��� � °� pnXJafX � e p�UecoU`p MP] X hxO VfpnX¥ WU ] X O jJXw� r U O Z M a r h V¦U ] jJX O VYXJafXJZ MPO VfpnX > JLK SnO�h V jbX ]�] U O Z U OX ] XbjwVYa MeOqh�O VYpnX j MeO Z S jwV h�MeO � r U O Z M a r h VYU ] jbX O VfXbaTXbZ MPO VYpnX � JLK S�Onh VªjbX ]�] ���.pnXvc S ^`^qUWV h�MPOMel XJ�t� ��� � h c M  eXba5U ]x] [ M c h V h�MPO c Mel VfpnX4X ] XbjwVYa MeO U O Z%p Me] Xe��U O Z'VfpnX4j M X �`j h X O Vfcb� � e UeaTXZnXwVYXbaT^ hxO XbZ² WUea h UWV h�MPO U ]�] 8e�@�.pnXgj|UWV h�MPOnh jo[ MP] 8eX O X h c.ZnXbcTjba h r XJZ �dh VYp4VfpnX� eUWa h URV h�MeO U ] VYa h U ]lsM aT^\� ) ) � g v e J � 1 � e J ) g / 9 � e �

e � e � ­ ��� ± °� pnXJafX � e p�UWc�U5p MP] X h�O VfpnX� eU ] X O jbXw� r U O Z M a r h VYU ] jJX O VYXJafXbZ MPO VYpnX > JLK SnO�h VdjbX ]�] �� ������� �D� ��� � ���2� � ��� ��\� �\� � ��� ���s� ��� �

�.pnXªc MP]  PX O V h c@ZnXJcfjba h r XbZ S c hxO 7 VfpnX lsMP]�]xM=�dh�O 7 r UWc h c@cTXJV|���.pnX r Uec h c lsSnO jJV h�MPO � � �=� h czVYp�XSnO [ MP] Uea hx´ XbZ;c MP]  eX O V|� h �~Xe��VfpnX¥c MP]  eX O V h�O VYpnX�U r cfX O jbX MWl VfpnXU7ea MPSnO Z\c�V¦UWVfX MWl VYp�X�c MP]�S VYXe�� e h c�VYpnXd¹�UeaTVfafXbX�� U�M j � 7Pa MPSnO Z`cTVYUWVYX Mel VYp�X.c MP]  PX O V h�O VfpnXd[nafXJcfX O jbX Mel VYpnX.c MP]�S VfX.j¦p�Uea"7PXZ h cTVYa h r S V h�MeO j M afaTXbcT[ MPO Z h�O 7�V M � e �d­ �.p�Xv^KU�7 Onh V S ZnX Mel VYpnX c Me]�S VfX�j¦p�UWa�7PX�Z h c�VYa h r S V h�MPO2h c^ Sn] V h [ ]�h XbZ r 8`Ugj MPO c�V¦U O VucfjbU ]�hxO 7 l UejJV M ab���n� lsM aDafXbUec MPO cªV M r XdZ h cTj S cTcfXbZ r X ]�M=� � ° � e Vfp S cZnXJcfjba h r XbcdVYpnXg[ MP] UWa h�´ UWV hxMPOqhxO Z S jJXbZ r 8iU5p MP] X MPO VfpnX > JLK SnOnh VdjbX ]x]zMel VYpnXgc Me]�S VfXgU O Z\U OX ] XbjwVYa MeO²MPO VYpnX �7JLK SnOnh VkjbX ]�] ����c h�O 7�Vfp h c r Uec h cb��VfpnXo WUea h UWV hxMPO U ] [�a M jbXbZ S afX�jbU O;M [�V h ^ hx´ XVYp�X²^qU�7 Onh V S ZnX Mel VfpnX²c MP]  PX O V5[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO r 8'^ h � h�O 7 VfpnX SnO [ MP] Uea hx´ XbZ lsSnO jJV h�MPO � � �=�

Page 122: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� ��dh VfpiVfpnX�[ MP] Uea hx´ XJZ lsS�O jJV h�MPO cJ� � e �k�.p�X�cf[nUWV h U ] Z h c�VYa h r S V h�MPO²MWl VYp�X�[ MP] Uea h�´ UWV hxMPO j|U O r XM [�V h ^ h�´ XbZ r 8i^ h � h�O 75V M 7PXwVYpnXJa VfpnX¥ WUea h�MPS c [ MP] Uea h�´ XbZ lsSnO jwV h�MeO cb� � e �d¢c h ^ hx] Uea r Uec h c h cS cTXbZ lsM aoVfpnX`j|UWV h�MPO �@j MPO c h cTV h�O 7 Mel VfpnX SnO [ MP] Uea h�´ XbZ&c MP]  PX O V � �2U O Z lsSnO jJV hxMPO c � e VYp�URVZnXJcfjba h r XoVYpnX�[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO`h�O Z S jbXJZ r 84U�p MP] X MPO VYpnX > JLK SnOnh VkjbX ]�]³MWl VfpnXoc MP]�S VfXo[ MP] 8eX O XW��.pnX�U r M  PX r Uec h c cfXJVfcoUeaTX S cfXbZ\V M ZnXbcTjba h r X�VYpnX�[ MP] Uea h�´ UWV hxMPO²h�O Z S jbXJZ r 8\U O X���j h V MPOM aup MP] X ZnX ]�M j|U ]xh�´ XJZ M  PXJa.U�[ MP] 8_^`XbaJ�¤�.pnXJcfX�j¦p�Uea"7PXoZ h cTVfa h r S V hxMPO cuUeafX�^ S j¦p4^ M afX�Z hx«�S cTX

VYpnU O VYpnXdj¦p�Uea"7PXdZ h c�VYa h r S V h�MPO c Mel � e M a � e � � p h j¦p`ZnXbcTjba h r Xdp Me] XbcDU O Z5X ] XJjJVfa MPO c ]xM jbU ]�hx´ XbZUWVvcf[tXbj h ��j�[ M c h V hxMPO c MPO VfpnX�c MP]�S VfXe���.p S c h�O 7eX O XJaYUWV h�O 7 � e U O Z � e �tVYpnX�c MP]xS VYX�j¦p�Uea"7PXZ h cTVYa h r S V h�MeO¡h c2^ S�] V h [ ]�h XbZ r 8'VYpnX;cfjbU ]�hxO 7G[�UeafUe^`XJVYXJab� � � �P�'�.p h c h c S cfX lsSn] r XJj|U S cTXVYp�X ]�M j|U ]�h�´ XbZ&j¦p�Uea"7PXqZ h cTVfa h r S V hxMPO c Mel � e M a � e jbU O jbU S cfXKVYpnXKc MP]  PX O V�[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO V MafXJcf[ MPO Z OnMPOn]xh�O XbUea ] 8P���.pnX r Uec h cdcfXwVv[tXba lsM af^`c r XJcTV � pnX O � h c j¦p M cfX O c S j¦p VYp�URV � e U O Z� e UeaTX OnM V h�O VfpnX OnMPOn]xh�O XbUea.afX)7 h ^`Xm{ � }=� �D§ O VYpnXgjbU ] j Sn] UWV h�MPO ck[nafXJcfX O VfXbZ�p�XbafXW� � 9 "� ����.pnXvjbU ] j Sn] URV h�MeO2Mel VYp�Xv¹�Ue^ hx] V MPOnh U O ^qURVYa h �2X ] Xb^`X O Vfc h cuZ h cfj S cfcTXbZ hxO VfpnX�¢�[n[tX O Z h ���

� ����� � � � � � %���T� � ����� " ��� � � �T� � � � �

�.pnX²afXbUejJV h�MPO � ��X ] Z'^ M ZnX ] Uecfc S ^KXJc�VYp�X4Z h X ] XJjJVYa h jKafXbcT[ MeO cfX Mel VfpnX²c Me]  PX O V h c¥^ S j¦pc ]xM=� XJa�VYpnU O VYp�XNj¦p�Uea"7PX ynS jJV S UWV hxMPO c¤Uea h c h�O 7 l a M ^ X ] XbjJVfa MPO � p MP] Xu^ M V h�MPOgMPO VfpnXNc MP]�S VYXe��§ OVYp�X h ^`[ ] XJ^KX O VYUWV hxMPO�S cfXbZKpnXbaTXe�mVYp�X.X ] XJjJVfa MPO U O Z5p Me] X MPO VYp�X.c MP]xS VYXdUeaTX ��afc�VªZnX ]xM jbU ]�hx´ XbZUec h�OP� �¸cb� ��� � U O Z ��� ±���U O Z&VYpnXKU| PXbafU�7PXJZ¡j¦p�Uea"7PXKZ h cTVfa h r S V hxMPOGh c�VfpnX O c MP]  eURVYXbZ��q�.p h cZ h « XJafc l a M ^ VYpnXqcfX ] l � j MPO c h cTVfX O V2afXbUejJV h�MPO � ��X ] Z ­ � L�& U�° ^ M Z�X ] {�� e�_�ª� m�R��� � p h j¦p®U ]�]xM�� ch�O VfXbaYUWjJV hxMPO5�dh VYpKVYpnX�c MP]  PX O VuV M U ] VYXJaªVfpnXvc MP]�S VYX j¦p�Uea�7eXvZ h cTVYa h r S V h�MeO ��� hxO jbX VYpnX c"8_c�VYXb^`ccTV S Z h XbZ'p�XbafXKZ M O�M V�pnU= eX4Ui[�XJaf^KU O X O V¥Z h [ MP] X2^ M ^`X O Vb� MPS a¥^ M Z�X ] cfp MPSn] Z OnM V¥Z hx« Xbac h 7 Onh ��j|U O V ] 8 l a M ^ VfpnX � L�& U ^ M ZnX ] �¤¢ OKh ^K[ M a�V¦U O VDXw��jJXb[�V h�MPOKh c � pnX O c MP]  WUWV hxMPO X « XbjJVfcUeaTX�c S �`j h X O V ] 8;cTVfa MPO 72Vfp�UWV.VYp�X � L�& U ^ M ZnX ]�l U|  M aTc c�8_^K^`XJVfa"8m� r aTX|U �¸hxO 7 MPO VYpnXgc Me]�S VfXj¦p�U hxO � U�M a h�O c�V¦U O jbXe� h�O VfpnX4j|UWcfX Mel U j¦p�Uea"7PXbZ%[ MP] 8eX O XW��VYpnX � L�& U ^ M ZnX ] ^KUQ8 l U|  M aVYp�X ]xM jbU ]�hx´ UWV h�MPO\Mel j¦p�UWa�7PX MPO c M ^`X5[ M a�V hxMPO&Mel VfpnXKj¦pnU h�O �K�.p h cgj¦p�UWa�7PX ]�M j|U ]xh�´ UWV hxMPO h cOnM V�U ]x]�M=� XJZ hxO VfpnXqaTX|UejwV h�MeO � ��X ] Z ^ M ZnX ]ªS cfXbZ'pnXbaTXe� � p h j¦p%UecTc S ^`Xbc�VYpnXKc MP]xS VYX`j¦p�Uea"7PXZ h cTVYa h r S V h�MeO²h ckVYpnUWV Mel VYpnX h c MP] URVYXbZ²c MP]�S VYXg[ Me] 8PX O Xe��.pnX²c Me]  WUWV hxMPO X O Xba"7 h XJc2UeaTX4j|U ] j Sn] UWVYXJZ r 8¡Z h U�7 MeO U ]�hx´bhxO 7²VYpnX4c MP]  eX O V`¹vUW^ hx] V MeOnh U O �h�O j ]�S Z h�O 7dVYp�X h�O VfXbaYUWjJV hxMPO¥�dh VYp�VYpnXkc MP]�S VYXªj¦p�Uea�7eXkZ h c�VYa h r S V h�MPO � hxO VfpnX r Uec h c�cfXJV¤ZnXbcTjba h r XbZ

Page 123: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P� h�O ��XJjJV h�MPO ��� ����}��� ������� � " ����� �!� � � � " ��� � � � � �%�\������� " ��� � � � �

�.p h c ]�h ^ h V h c¥Vfp�UWV Mel »¡U OnOnh XJa�X���j h V MPO VYp�X M a�8³{�� ��J� � � p�XbafX4VfpnX4Z h X ] XbjJVfa h jKaTXbcf[ MPO cTXMel VYpnX c MP]  PX O V h ciUecTc S ^`XbZ!V M r X ^ S j¦p l UecTVfXba;VYp�U O VfpnX�j¦pnUea�7PX y�S jwV S URV h�MeO c UWa h c h�O 7l a M ^ X ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] X¥^ M V hxMPO;MPO VfpnX�c MP]�S VfXe�d�.pnX¥c MP]  PX O V�[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO²h c VfpnX O cTXJV r 8iVYp�Xh�O cTV¦U O VYU O X MPS cd[ M c h V h�MPO²MWl VfpnXgX ] XJjJVfa MPO U O Zip MP] Xe� ] X|UeZ h�O 7�V M Z h X ] XbjwVYa h jocfjJafXJX OnhxO 7 MWl VYp�XX ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X h�O VYXJaYUejwV hxMPO �¶�.p h c`^ M ZnX ].h c h ^K[ ] Xb^`X O VfXbZ r 81c�V¦Uea�V hxO 7 �dh VYp®VYpnXi^KUWVYa h �afXJ[nafXJcfX O VYUWV hxMPOqMWl VfpnX�c MP]�S VYXd¹vUW^ hx] V MeOnh U O � � � g v�Mel � � � ���x�P� hxO VfpnX c MP]xS VYX r UWc h cJ� � e M a � eMel � �¸cb� ��� ±4U O Z ��� � ���.pnX5c MP]  WUWV h�MPO X O Xba"7�8 Mel VfpnX2j¦p�Uea"7PX5Z h c�VYa h r S V h�MPO c�j M aTafXJcf[ MPO Z hxO 7V M � e M a � e UeafXdVYp�X O j|U ] j Sn] UWVYXJZqU O ZqUeZ�ZnXbZ`V M VYpnX Z h U47 MPO U ]�Mel VfpnX�¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O ^KUWVfa h ����.pnX�afXJc Sn] V h�O 72^qUWVfa h � h ckVYpnX O Z h U�7 MPO U ]�hx´ XbZ��

U�M a�VfpnX.Xw��j h V MPO jbU ] j Sn] URV h�MeO �RVfpnXkc MP]  WUWV h�MPO X O XJa�7 h XbcDUeaTXkj|U ] j Sn] UWVYXJZ l a M ^VfpnX.¹vUWaTVYaTXbX��U�M j � 7Pa MPSnO ZGc�V¦UWVfX2X O XJa�7 h Xbc Mel VfpnX�c Me]  PX O V h�O VYp�X�[nafXJcfX O jbX`U O Z U r cfX O jbX Mel VYp�X�j¦p�Uea"7PXZ h cTVYa h r S V h�MeO cNj M afaTXbcf[ MPO Z h�O 7�V M � e ��¢vc.Z h cfj S cfcTXbZ h�O ��XJjJV h�MPO ��� ����}���VfpnX ]xM jbU ]�hx´ XbZKj¦p�Uea"7PXZ h cTVYa h r S V h�MeO�Mel � e ^KU'8 h�O Z S jbX²U OnMPOn]xh�O XbUea¥[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO&h�O VYpnXqc MP]  PX O Vb���.p h c h c¥[nafX�� PX O VYXbZ r 8 ��afc�V ^ Sn] V h [ ] 8 h�O 7�VYpnX�j¦p�UWa�7PXgZ h cTVYa h r S V h�MeO c r 84VYp�X�cfj|U ]�h�O 7 l UejJV M a � 9 �� �_���.pnXj|U ] j S�] UWVfXbZic MP]  eURV h�MeO X O Xba"7�8 h c.VYpnX O cfjbU ] XJZ S [�Uecfc S ^ hxO 7KU ]�hxO X|UWa.c MP]  PX O VvafXbcT[ MeO cfXW� h �~Xe�VYp�Xvc Me]  WUWV hxMPO X O Xba"7�8 Mel VYp�XvcfjbU ] XJZ²j¦p�Uea"7PXvZ h cTVfa h r S V hxMPOKh cNZ h   h ZnXJZ r 8 � G � U M aªVfpnXoj|URV h�MeOj|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO cJ�NVYp�X c Me]  WUWV hxMPO X O Xba"7 h XJc²UeaTX j|U ] j S�] UWVfXbZ S c h�O 7'VYpnX r Uec h c4cfXwV²ZnXJcfjba h r XbZ hxO��XJjJV hxMPO ��� ��� }��� ����� � � � " ��� ��� "��� ��� ��� � �

§ O VfpnX5X ] XbjJVfa MPO�h jw� [ Me] Uea MPO ^ M ZnX ] ��VfpnX`¹vUe^ h�] V MPO�h U OiMel\� � � ��� � h c�Z h U�7 MPO U ]�h�´ XbZ hxO UZ h afXbjwVT� [na M Z S jwV r Uec h c MWl c MP]xS VYX2U O Z�c Me]  PX O V lsSnO jJV h�MPO c={�� � �����.pnX2c MP]�S VfX r UWc h c lsSnO jJV h�MPO cUeaTXvVYpnX � e U O Z � e Mel*� �_cJ� ��� ±�U O Z ��� � ���.p�X�c MP]  PX O V r Uec h c lsSnO jwV h�MeO c.UeaTXvVYpnX � e U O Z � eZnXJcfjba h r XbZ h�O �_XbjJV h�MPO ��� ����}���� h�O jJXNVYpnX lsS�]�] ¹�Ue^ h�] V MPOnh U O¥h c S cTXbZKU O Z2VYpnX.^KUWVfa h �¥X ] Xb^`X O VfcUeaTXNXJ WU ]xS UWVfXbZ2Xw��UejwV ] 84­scfXJXkVYpnXk¢�[n[tX O Z h � ° � OnM Uecfc S ^K[�V h�MeO c�UeaTXN^KUeZnXkU r MPS V¤VYp�XkafX ] UWV h  PXV h ^KXvcfj|U ] X Mel X ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] Xo^ M V h�MeO Uecdj M ^`[�UeaTXbZ²V M c Me]  PX O Vv[ MP] UWa h�´ UWV hxMPO �

U�M avVYp�X`X���j h V MPO j|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO �tVYpnX2c h�´ X MWl U²j M ^K[ ] XJVfX�Z h aTXbjwVT� [�a M Z S jJV r Uec h c�cfjbU ] XJc¥UWc

Page 124: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P�e�¨ 1 �@¨ r X hxO 74VYpnX O¸S ^ r Xba MeluSnOnh V�jbX ]�] c MPO VYpnX5c Me]�S VfXe�2� M U|  MPh ZGVYp h c�aYUW[ h Z h�O jbafXbUecfX hxOVYp�X2c h�´ X Mel VYpnX r Uec h c �dh VYpGc MP]�S VYX�j¦p�U h�O&] X O 7eVYp���VYpnX lsMe]�]�M=�dhxO 7K WUea h UWV h�MPO U ]@lsM af^ h c S cTXbZlsM akVfpnXgj M ^ r h�O XJZic MP]�S VYXw� c MP]  PX O V � U| PX lsS�O jJV h�MPO ��{�� m±W�

) 9 � e + � e��� B e � � B �e � + � � + �e + e � � �e ������ 1 > � � > 1� � v e �

1 � � � �%1� � v e � � ­ ��� � °¢£c h ^ h�] Uea r UWc h c¥^qU'8 r XKj MPO c�VYa S jJVYXJZ lsM agVYpnXKj|UWV h�MPO �²¢�c � v e � h c h�O jJafX|UWcfXbZ��¤VYp h c r Uec h cUe[n[�a M Uej¦p�Xbc2VYpnX lsS�]�] Z h afXJjJV�� [na M Z S jJV r UWc h cJ��»ºpnX O � v e � 9 ��DXbUej¦p®c MP]xS VYX lsSnO jJV hxMPO � eh c�[nU h aTXbZ �dh Vfp&VfpnX2j M afafXJcf[ MPO Z hxO 7ic MP]  PX O V�[ MP] Uea h�´ UWV hxMPO � e µ VfpnX2cf[nUWV h U ] Z h cTVYa h r S V h�MeO�MelVYp�Xqc Me]  PX O V�[ MP] UWa h�´ UWV hxMPOGh cgVYp�XbafX r 8'j MPO cTVfaYU hxO XbZ V MilsMP]�]xM�� VYp�Xq^ M V hxMPO&Mel VfpnXqX ] XbjwVYa MPOU O Z\p MP] X MeO VYp�X�c Me]�S VfXe�tU O ZiVYpnX� eUWa h URV h�MeO U ] [�a M jbXbZ S afX�UeZ QTS c�VYc MeOn] 84VfpnX�^KU�7 O�h V S ZnX MelVYp�X4[ Me] Uea h�´ URV h�MeO r 8�j¦p�U O 7 h�O 7 VfpnX4afUWV hxM Mel VfpnX �`U O Z B j M X �`j h X O VYcJ��» h Vfp � v e � � ��VYp�X�c MP]  PX O V.[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO ^qU'8 ] U�7 r XJp h�O Z4VfpnXo^ M V hxMPOqMWl VfpnXoX ] XbjwVYa MPO U O Z;p MP] Xe��U O Z²VYp�X WUea h UWV hxMPO U ] [na M jbXJZ S afXKp�Uec�^ M afX y Xw� h r h�]xh V38 hxO ZnXwVYXJaf^ h�OnhxO 7²VYpnXKcf[�UWV h U ] Z h cTVfa h r S V hxMPO&MelVYp�X�[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO ��;:�� ���!��F��JA��

U¤h 7 S afXJc ��� �;U O Z ��� }icfp M=� VYp�XKjbU ] j Sn] UWVfXbZ c MP]  WUWV hxMPO X O XJa�7 h Xbc MWl U\jbUWV hxMPOnh j`[ MP] 8PX O XU O Z;VYp�X`�2#l5 � X���j h V MPO cTV¦URVYX Mel U5[ MP] 8PX O Xe�tUecdU lsSnO jJV h�MPO;Mel c Me]�S VfX�j¦p�U h�Oi] X O 7eVfp³��.pnXkc h ^`[ ]�h ��XbZ�afXbUejJV h�MPO � ��X ] Z�^ M Z�X ]¸Mel ��XJje� ��� ���~�oUWcfc S ^KXJc¤VYpnXNc MP]  PX O V�[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO�h c

^ S j¦p5c ]�M=� XJa�VYp�U O X ] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] Xu^ M V h�MPO�MPO VYpnX.c MP]�S VfXe���.pnXdc MP]  PX O Vª[ MP] Uea h�´ UWV hxMPO¥h c¤VYp�X OcfXwV r 8²VfpnX [��^W �[� W�� j¦pnUea�7PXgZ h cTVfa h r S V hxMPO²Mel VYpnXgc Me]�S VfXe��» h Vfp h�O Vfp h c.^ M Z�X ] �_VYpnXgX���j h V MPOcTVYUWVYX h c OnMPO � [ Me] Uea U O Z p�Uec ´ Xba M c MP]  WUWV hxMPO X O Xba"7�8'­ U¤h 7 S aTX ����} ° � U�M adVYp�X�j|URV h�MeO ��UWc�VYp�Xc Me]�S VfX�j¦p�U hxOG] X O 7eVYp h c h�O jbafXbUecfXJZ³�³VYp�X�c MP]xS VYX�j¦p�Uea�7eX2Z h c�VYa h r S V h�MPO r XJj M ^`Xbc hxO jbaTX|Uec h�O 7 ] 8Z h «�S cTX4U O Z¡VYpnXKc MP]  eURV h�MeO X O Xba�748�VfX O Znc¥V M=� UWafZ ´ XJa M ­ U¤h 7 S afX ��� � ° � � MP]�h V MPO&lsM aT^qUWV h�MPO�dh�]x] ]�M j|U ]xh�´ X.VfpnXvc MP]�S VfXvj¦p�UWa�7PXoZ h cTVfa h r S V hxMPO U O Z ] XbUeZqV M U � O�h VYX�c MP]  WUWV hxMPO X O Xba"7�8 hxO VYp�X]�MeO 7W� j¦pnU h�OK]�h ^ h Vb��¢ afX|UWc MPO U r ] XoXJcTV h ^KUWVYX lsM aNVYp�X�c MP]xh V MeO c hx´ XP{ � ����� �R� h ckU r MPS V��b� SnOnh VjbX ]�] c={��P� ��ª�P�P�w� �\�.p h c¥j M aTafXJcf[ MPO Znc�V M U\afUWVYpnXJa�Z h «�S cfX4j¦p�UWa�7PXKZ h c�VYa h r S V h�MPO ��U O Z®U ]�M=�c Me]  WUWV hxMPO X O Xba"7�8 h�OMU¤h 7 S aTX ��� ��� » h VYp hxO VYp h c�^ M Z�X ] � VYpnXqc MP]  eURV h�MeO X O Xba"7 h XJc M r VYU h�O XJZS c h�O 7 VfpnX²¹��S j � X ] ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U OGlsM a¥VfpnX4c MP]  eX O V`U�7PaTXbX � X ]x]u�dh Vfp'VYp M cfX M r V¦U hxO XbZ S c hxO 7VYp�X ��� ¹vUW^ hx] V MeOnh U O �

Page 125: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P�=�

U¤h 7 S afX ��� � � � MP]  WUWV hxMPO X O Xba"7�8 Mel UG[ Me] 8PX O X²j|URV h�MeO Z S X²V MGhxO VYXbafUejJV h�MPO��dh VYp U�c MP]  eX O Vj¦p�U hxO¥MWl ��� SnOnh V�jJX ]x] cb� �.pnXªafXbUejJV h�MPO � ��X ] Z³��cfjJafXbX O XbZ2X ] XJjJVYa MPO � p MP] XDU O Z�X ] XbjwVYa MPOnh j�� [ MP] UWa MPO^ M ZnX ] c�UWafXkZnXJcfjJa h r XbZ h�O �_XbjbcJ� ��� ����������� ��� �_�¸U O Z���� ��� � �¤�.pnXdc Me]�h Z ]�h�O Xbc�U O Z � ]�] XJZ�c"8_^ r MP] cUeaTX�VfpnX�aTXbc S�] VYc M r VYU h�O XbZ S c h�O 7`VfpnX ��� ^ M ZnX ]³lsM a VfpnX�c MP]  eX O V|�.�.pnX¥Z�UecTpnXbZ ]xh�O XJc�U O ZM [tX O c"8_^ r MP] cdUWafX�VYpnXgaTXbc S�] VYc M r V¦U hxO XbZ S c h�O 72VYp�X¥¹��S j � X ] ^ M ZnX ]�lsM akVYpnXgc Me]  PX O V|�¢kVzVYpnX M [�[ M c h VfX�Xw�_VYaTXb^`X h c�VfpnXDcfjJafXbX O XbZ�X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X hxO VfXbafUejJV h�MPO ^ M Z�X ]eMWl �_Xbje����� ��� ���� p h j¦pqUecTc S ^`Xbc�VfpnX.c MP]  PX O Vª[ MP] UWa h�´ UWV hxMPO�h c�^ S j¦p l UecTVfXba�Vfp�U O X ] XbjJVfa MPO � p MP] Xk^ M V hxMPO � �.pnX

c Me]  PX O Vu[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO¥h c�VYp�X O cTXJV r 8�VYp�X � ���ZYd[���Yd[�� W���� � [ M c h V h�MPO2MWl VfpnX.X ] XbjJVfa MPO U O Z5p Me] Xe�VYp S c�cTjbaTXbX O�h�O 7�VYp�XkX ] XbjJVfa MPO � p MP] X hxO VfXbafUejJV h�MPO � § O VYp h c�^ M Z�X ] �RVYpnXNc MP]  eURV h�MeO X O Xba�748 Mel VYp�Xj|URV h�MeO h cdVYpnUWV Mel U ]�M j|U ]xh�´ XbZ;p MP] Xe��U O Z Vfp S c h c�afX ] UWV h  PX ] 8 hxO ZnXb[tX O ZnX O V Mel j¦pnU h�O\] X O 7eVYp³��.pnX�c MP]  eURV h�MeO X O Xba"7�8 Mel VYp�XvXw��j h V MeO4h cDVYp�URVkUe[�[na M [�a h URVYX lsM aªU�cfjJafXbX O XbZ LNMeSn]�M ^ r h�O VfXba��UejwV h�MeO r XwV � XJX O VYpnX�X ] XJjJVYa MPO U O Z²p MP] XW� U�M auVfpnX�j|UWV h�MPO �_VfpnX�c MP]  WUWV hxMPO X O Xba"7 h XJc M r VYU h�O XJZS c h�O 7�VYp�Xd¹��S j � X ] ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U OglsM a�VYpnX.c MP]  eX O VuU�7PaTXbX � X ]�]n�dh VYp�Vfp M cfX M r V¦U hxO XbZ S c h�O 7�VYp�X��� ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O �¤¹ M=� Xw PXJab� lsM a.VYpnXgXw��j h V MeO ��VYpnXJafX h cdc S r cTVYU O V h U ] Z h cfU�7PafXJXb^`X O V|�ª�.p h ch c.Z h cfj S cfcTXbZ lsS aTVfpnXba h�O ��XJjJV h�MPO ���~�n��.pnX²X ] XbjwVYa MeOnh j�� [ MP] Uea MPO ^ M ZnX ]uMel ��XbjwV hxMPO ��� ��� � ^KU � Xbc OnM UecTc S ^`[�V h�MPO c�U r MeS V�VYp�X

afX ] UWV h  eX4V h ^`Xw� cfjbU ] X MWl X ] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] X²^ M V hxMPO  eXbafc S cqc MP]  eX O VK[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO � U¤h 7 S aTXbc ��� �U O Z�����}`cTp M=� VYp�URV VfpnX�[nafXJZ h jwVYXbZ\c MP]  WUWV hxMPO X O XJa�7 h Xbc ]�h X r XwV � XJX O Vfp M cfX Mel VYpnX�afXbUejJV h�MPO ���X ] Z�U O Z�cfjJafXbX O XbZ�X ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] X h�O VYXJaYUejwV h�MeO ^ M ZnX ] cb�@�.p h c jbU O r X SnO Z�Xbafc�V M_M Z¥Uec lsMP]x]�M=� cb�

Page 126: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P�|}

U¤h 7 S afX ����}�� � MP]  eURV h�MeO X O Xba�748 Mel VfpnX4X���j h V MPO cTVYUWVYXqZ S XqV MGh�O VYXJaYUejwV h�MeO��dh Vfp%U c MP]  eX O Vj¦p�U hxO&Mel �=� S�Onh V�jJX ]x] cb��¨ M VYUWV hxMPOGh cgUec hxOPU¤h 7 S afX���� ����� c hxO 7²VYpnX ��� ¹vUe^ h�] V MPO�h U OiMelVYp�X�c MP]  eX O V MPOn] 8 ] U47 9 �afXbc Sn] Vfc � XJafX M r V¦U h�O XJZ³�U�M af^KUWV h�MPOiMel Uq[ MP] Uea h�´ UWV hxMPO j ]�MPS ZGUea MeSnO Z�VYp�X�X ] XbjJVfa MPO U O ZGp MP] X ] XbUeZncvV M U l U|  M afU r ] XX ] XbjwVYa M cTV¦URV h j hxO VYXbafUejJV h�MPO r XJV � XbX O VYp�X`c MP]�S VYX5U O Z c Me]  PX O V¥j¦pnU h�O cJµ�p M�� XJ eXbaJ�¤VYpnX2aTXbc Sn] V��h�O 7 hxO jbaTX|UecTX hxO VYp�XKX « XJjJV h  PXK^qUecTc MWl VYpnX`X ] XbjwVYa MeO U O Z�p MP] X ]xM=� XJafc¥VfpnX`ZnX ]xM jbU ]�hx´ UWV h�MPOX O Xba�748P�v�.p�X�X ] XbjwVYa MeOnh j�� [ MP] Uea MPO ^ M ZnX ] hxO j ]xS ZnXJc�VYp�XbcfX�j¦p�U O 7PXJc h�O X « XbjwV h  eX�^KUecfcJ��c h�O jJXh V jbU ] j Sn] UWVfXbcdVYpnX�^KUWVYa h �;X ] Xb^`X O Vfc Mel VYpnX lsSn]�] ¹�Ue^ hx] V MPOnh U O � � � � ��� �P� r XJV � XbX O VfpnX r Uec h clsSnO jwV hxMPO c MWlx� � � ��� ���¤¹ M�� XJ eXbaJ�¸VfpnX hxO jbaTX|UecTX h�O X « XbjJV h  eXk^qUWcfc h c h 7 OnM aTXbZ r 8�VYpnXNcfjbaTXbX O XbZX ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X h�O VYXJaYUejwV hxMPO ^ M ZnX ] � � p h j¦p�^ M Z h ��XJc MeOn] 8oVfpnX LNMeSn]�M ^ r hxO VfXbafUejJV h�MPO r XwV � XJX OVYp�XvX ] XbjwVYa MeO U O Z4p MP] XW���.pnXvcTjbafXJX O XJZ\X ] XJjJVYa MPO � p MP] X h�O VfXbaYUWjJV hxMPO ^ M ZnX ] VYp�XbafX r 8 M  PXJafXJcTV h �^KUWVYXJcDVfpnXdc MP]  WUWV hxMPO X O XJa�7�8 Mel r M VYp2VYpnX Xw��j h V MeO U O Z`VfpnX�jbUWV hxMPO ���.pnX�c MP]  WUWV h�MPO X O Xba"7 h XJcM r VYU h�O XbZ S c hxO 7�VfpnX�¹��S j � X ] ¹�Ue^ h�] V MPOnh U O�lsM a�VYp�X c MP]  eX O V.U47PafXJX � X ]x]��dh VYp5VYp M cfX M r VYU h�O XJZS c h�O 72VYp�X ��� ¹vUW^ hx] V MeOnh U O ��;:�� �£C`?GH �bF���IbC`?��

U¤h 7 S afXJc��� �gU O Z ����}�cfp M=� Vfp�UWV|� �dh VYp MPO XdXw��jJXb[�V h�MPO �mVfpnXdc MP]  eURV h�MeO X O XJa�7 h Xbc M r VYU h�O XJZS c h�O 7 VfpnX²¹��S j � X ] ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U OGlsM a¥VfpnX4c MP]  eX O V`U�7PaTXbX � X ]x]u�dh Vfp'VYp M cfX M r V¦U hxO XbZ S c hxO 7

Page 127: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P�b�VYp�X ���� ¹vUW^ hx] V MeOnh U O � �.pnUWVd¹��S j � X ] VYpnX M a"8 h cNU<7 M_M ZqUe[n[na M � h ^qUWV h�MPO`h c OnM VNc S aT[na h c h�O 7c hxO jbX�¹��S j � X ] VYp�X M a�8º[na M   h ZnXJc U®afXbUec MeO U r ] X Z�XbcfjJa h [�V hxMPO MWl VYp�X ]xh�O XbUea²afXJcf[ MPO cTX Mel Uj MeORQTS 7mUWVfXbZ\[ MP] 8_^KXJadV M U O Ue[n[ ]�h XJZ;X ] XJjJVfa h j���X ] Z³� � On]�hx� XgZ h X ] XJjJVfa h j�j MPO V hxO_S�S ^ ^ M ZnX ] cb�� p h j¦p h ^`[ ]�h j h V ] 8KUecTc S ^`X2Uqc MP]  eX O V�^KUeZnX S [ Mel [ MPh�O V�Z h [ MP] XJcb��¹��S j � X ] VfpnX M a"8\j|Ue[�V S afXJcVYp�XqZnX ]�M j|U ]xh�´ XJZ�X ] XJjJVYa MPOnh jqcTVfa S jwV S aTX Mel VfpnXqc MP]  eX O V|� ¹��S j � X ] VfpnX M a"8'U ] c M j MeO VYU h�O c¥VYp�Xj M afafXJjJVkV h ^`Xw� cfj|U ] X lsM auVfpnXoZ h X ] XJjJVfa h j�afXJcf[ MPO cfXW��U O²h cfc S X Mel@h ^`[ M aTVYU O jbXdV M VYpnX�X ] XbjwVYa MPOnh j[ MP] Uea MPO ^ M ZnX ] �.�.p h c V h ^KX�� cfjbU ] X h c�cTXJV r 8iVYpnX M [�V h j|U ] 7PUe[�U O Z VYpnX�¹��S j � X ] [nUeaYUe^`XJVfXbaTc� XbafX�j¦p M cTX O V M 8 h X ] Z;cYUe^`X M [�V h j|U ] 7mUe[iUec ��� VYpnX M a"8e�»ºp h�] XkVYpnXJafX h c hxO 7PX O XJaYU ] 7 M�M Z5U�7PaTXbXb^`X O V r XJV � XbX O VYpnX ¹��S j � X ] U O Z ��� ^ M ZnX ] c lsM a

VYp�X.c MP]  PX O Vb� U�h 7 S aTX ����} h�O Z h j|UWVfXbc�U�afUWVYpnXJa ] Uea"7PXNZ h cYU47PafXJXb^`X O V r XwV � XJX O`lsM a¤VYp�X c MP]  WUWV h�MPOX O Xba�748 Mel VfpnX2Xw��j h V MPOGhxO VYp�X�cfjJafXbX O XbZ X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X�^ M ZnX ] �o§ O VYpnX�cfjbaTXbX O XbZ X ] XbjJVfa MPO �p MP] Xo^ M ZnX ] �¸VYpnX�c MP]  WUWV h�MPO X O XJa�7 h Xbc Mel VfpnX�j¦p�Uea"7PX�Z h c�VYa h r S V h�MPO cNUecTc M j h UWVYXJZ �dh VYp4 WUea h�MPS c[ M c h V h�MeO c Mel VYp�XqX ] XbjwVYa MeO U O Z'p MP] XW� � e �¤UeafXKj|U ] j Sn] UWVYXJZ'U O Z%UeZnZ�XbZ'V M VYp�XKZ h U�7 MPO U ]�MelVYp�X �m� L §N^KUWVfa h �G­ cTXbX ��XbjwV hxMPO ��� ��� � ° ���.pnX¥Z h cYU47PafXJXb^`X O V r XwV � XJX O VfpnX�¹��S j � X ] U O Z ����^ M ZnX ] c hxO Z h j|UWVfXbcqVfp�UWV²VYp�XbcfXGV �uM ¹�Ue^ h�] V MPOnh U O c � O Z!Z hx« XbaTX O V;c MP]  WUWV hxMPO X O Xba�7 h Xbc lsM aVYp�XbcfX�j¦p�Uea"7PXvZ h cTVfa h r S V hxMPO cb���.p h c h cDc S af[na h c h�O 7�c hxO jbX VYpnXS8qU47PafXJX MPO VYp�Xvc Me]  WUWV hxMPO X O XJa�7�8Mel VYpnX5jbUWV hxMPO ­ U¤h 7 S aTX���� � ° �@U O Z Vfp S c¥U47PafXJX MeO VfpnX2c Me]  WUWV hxMPO X O Xba�748 Mel U;p MP] X ]xM jbUWVYXJZUWVu eUWa h�MeS cN[ M c h V hxMPO c MPO VYp�Xoj¦p�U hxO � � e ��»�X�UeaTXvj S afafX O V ] 8 h�O  eXbcTV h 7mURVYXbZ4VfpnX M a h 7 hxOKMWl VYp h cZ h cYU�7PaTXbXJ^KX O Vb��.pnXvX ] XJjJVYa MPOnh jw� [ MP] Uea MPO ^ M Z�X ] ^KU � XJc OnM Uecfc S ^K[�V h�MeO cNU r MPS VuVfpnX�aTX ] UWV h  PXdV h ^`Xw� cfjbU ] XMel X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] Xk^ M V hxMPO  eXbafc S cªc MP]  PX O Vª[ MP] Uea h�´ UWV hxMPO �WU O Z5c Mgh c�VYpnXd^ M cTVDUWjbj S aYUWVfX ^ M ZnX ]

j MeO c h ZnXbaTXbZ pnXbaTXe�®» h VYp h�O VYp h c2^ M ZnX ] ��VYp�X\¹��S j � X ] ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U O�lsM a�VYpnX;c Me]  PX O Vp7 h  PXJcc Me]  WUWV hxMPO cgX O Xba�7 h Xbc¥VYp�UWV�UeaTX h�O 7 M_M Z'U�7PafXJXb^`X O V �dh VYp VYp M cTX M r VYU h�O XbZ S c h�O 7 VYpnX ����¹vUW^ hx] V MeOnh U O �.�.pnX S cTX Mel ¹��S j � X ] VYpnX M a"8 h c�^ S j¦p ] Xbcfcvj M ^`[ S VYUWV hxMPO U ]x] 8 hxO VYX O c h  eX�VYpnU O��� VfpnX M a�8P�zU O ZGU ]x]�M=� c S cvV M4hxO j ]xS ZnX S [ V M � �qc Me]  PX O V�j¦p�U hxO c �dh Vfp � `j|Uea r MPO coX|Uej¦p���.p h c h c�c S �`j h X O VgV M U ]x]�M=� Xw�_VYafUe[ MP] UWV h�MPO V M VYpnX5c Me]�h Z_� cTVYUWVYX ]�h ^ h Vb�¥�.p�XKU47PafXJXb^`X O V r X��V � XbX O VfpnX.¹��S j � X ] U O Z ���� ^ M ZnX ] c lsM a�VfpnXNc MP]  eX O V¤ WU ]xh Z�URVYXbc@VYp�X S cTX Mel ¹��S j � X ] VYp�X M a�8 hxOVYp�XbcfX¥j|U ] j Sn] UWV hxMPO cJ��U O Z\j MPO �naf^`c Vfp�UWV VYpnX�Z;8 O Ue^ h j�Z h X ] XJjJVYa h j�aTXbcf[ MPO cTX�[ ] U'8�cvU`jJa S j h U ]a Me] X h�O XJcTVYU r ]�h cfp hxO 72VYpnXgX���j h V MPO r h�O Z h�O 75X O Xba�748 h�O j MeORQTS 7mUWVfXbZi[ Me] 8_^KXJafcJ�§ O VYXbaTj¦p�U hxO hxO VYXbafUejJV h�MPO c ]�M=� XbavVfpnX2Xw��j h V MPO r h�O Z hxO 74X O Xba"7�8 r XbjbU S cfX2VfpnX � c MP]  WUWV h�MPO �

X O Xba�748 Mel VfpnX l afXJXkX ] XbjJVfa MPO U O Z2p MP] X h c 7PafXbUWVYXJa¤VYp�U O VYpnXkc MP]  WUWV h�MPO X O XJa�7�8 Mel VYp�X.Xw��j h V MPO �

Page 128: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P�=�U�M a hxO cTVYU O jJXe� hxOIU¤h 7 S afX ��� ����VfpnX�X ] XbjwVYa MeOnh j�� [ MP] Uea MPO ^ M ZnX ] [naTXbZ h jJVYc�VYp�UWVvVYpnX�c MP]  WUWV h�MPOX O Xba�748 Mel U l afXJX�p Me] X¥­�Ugj|UWV h�MPO�°¤h cªU r MPS V �� ���WX � � h�O jJXe� lsM a�VYp�Xv¹�Ue^ hx] V MPOnh U O�S cfXJZqpnXJafXW�VYp�XKc MP]  WUWV h�MPO X O Xba"7�8 Mel U O X ] XbjwVYa MPO'h c�XJ� S U ] V M VYp�URV MWl U;p MP] Xe�@VYpnX l afXJXKX ] XJjJVYa MPO � p MP] X[�U h agcTV¦URVYXbc�UeafX`c MP]  WUWVYXJZ r 8¡U r MPS V� ���}eX �@�.p h c¥c MP]  WUWV hxMPO X O Xba"7�8 h c ] Uea"7PX r XJj|U S cTXqVYp�Xj¦p�Uea"7PX ynS jJV S UWV hxMPO c�Uea h c h�O 7 l a M ^ X ] XbjJVfa MPO � p MP] XK^ M V h�MPO UeaTXqc ]xM=� U O Z�VfpnXq[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPOMel VfpnX�c S afa MPSnO Z hxO 74j¦p�U h�O c�j|U OGO XbUea ] 8 lsMP]�]xM=� VYpnX¥X ] XbjJVfa MPO � p MP] X¥^ M V h�MPO �d§ O�U�h 7 S aTX ��� }��VYp�X X ] XJjJVYa MPOnh jw� [ MP] Uea MPO ^ M ZnX ] 7 h  PXJcªU�c MP]  WUWV h�MPO X O Xba"7�8 lsM a�VYp�X X���j h V MPO`Mel U r MPS V� �� e�eX ��.p�UWV�VYp�XKc MP]  WUWV h�MPO X O Xba�748 MWl VYp�X l aTXbX`X ] XJjJVfa MPO � p MP] X`[nU h agcTVYUWVYXJc h c O X|Uea ] 8 U O�M afZ�Xba Mel^KU�7 Onh V S ZnX ] Uea�7PXJa.VYp�U O VYp�UWV Mel VfpnX�X���j h V MPO aTXb^KU h�O c Vfa S X h�O VYpnX¥c MP]xh Z�� cTV¦URVYX ]�h ^ h V|�ª�.pnXc Me]  WUWV hxMPO X O XJa�7�8 Mel VfpnX�Xw��j h V MPO c�V¦UWVfX h c�cT^qU ]x] r XJj|U S cfX¥VfpnX�j¦pnUea�7PX�� y�S jJV S UWV hxMPO coUWa h c h�O 7l a M ^�X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] X4^ M V hxMPO UeaTX l Uec�V|�uU O Z%VYpnX²[ MP] Uea hx´ UWV h�MPO�Mel VYpnX;c S afa MeSnO Z hxO 7&j¦p�U h�O cj|U OnOnM V lsMP]�]xM=� VfpnX�^ M V h�MPO5Mel VfpnX X ] XJjJVfa MPO U O Zqp MP] XW��»ºp hx] X h�O VYXJafj¦p�U h�O`h�O VYXJaYUejwV h�MeO cupnU= eXU ] UWa�7PX�X « XbjJV MeO VYpnXoX���j h V MPO r hxO Z h�O 7�X O XJa�7�8e�nVYpnXS8qpnU= eXgafX ] UWV h  PX ] 8`^ hxOnM aªX « XbjwVYc MPO VYp�XXw��j h V MeO cTV¦URVYX h VYcfX ]xl ���.pnX�X ] XbjJVfa MPO U O Z²p MP] X�^ S cTV.cTpnXbZ²VfpnX h aNc Me]  WUWV hxMPO j ]�MeS Z � pnX O VfpnX)8QTMPhxO V M4lsM aT^"U O Xw��j h V MPO ���.p h coj MPO cfXb� S X O jbX Mel Z;8 O Ue^ h j¥Z h X ] XbjwVYa h j�cTjbaTXbX O�h�O 7;X O p�U O jJXbcVYp�X`Z hx« XbafX O V h U ] c MP]  WUWV hxMPOGMel VfpnX l afXJX`X ] XJjJVYa MPO � p MP] X2[nU h ao eXbafc S c¥VfpnX5Xw��j h V MPO ��U O Z ] X|UeZ�cV M U ] Uea"7PXoaTXbZ S jwV hxMPO\hxO VYpnXgX���j h V MPO r h�O Z hxO 72X O Xba�748P�

� M aTX�7PX O XJaYU ]x] 8e��VYp�X2X ] XJjJVfa MPOnh j�[ MP] Uea MPO ^ M ZnX ] [nafXJZ h jwVYcoVYpnUWVoVYp�X2X « XbjJV h  eX2cTVYaTX O 7WVYpMel VfpnX`Z h X ] XbjwVYa h j5^KXJZ h�S ^" WUea h Xbc l a M ^�c�V¦UWVfXKV M c�V¦UWVfXqZnXJ[�X O Z h�O 7 MPO VYpnX5V h ^KX�� cfjbU ] X lsM aj¦p�Uea"7PX ynS jJV S UWV hxMPO c�­ X ] XbjwVYa MeO � p Me] Xg^ M V h�MeO °Nh�O VYp�UWV�[�Uea�V h j Sn] UeadcTV¦URVYXe� �.p h c M r cfXba� WUWV hxMPO^KUQ85p�X ] [KafXJc MP]  PX ^qU O 8 ]xMPO 7W� cTV¦U O Z h�O 7�� S XJcTV h�MPO cuj MPO jbXba Onh�O 7¥VYp�XvafX ] UWV h  eX h ^K[ M a�V¦U O jJX MelX ] XbjwVYa MeO � X ] XbjwVYa MPO;h�O VYXJaYUejwV h�MeO c h�O VYp�XbcfX�^KUWVYXJa h U ] cb��;: � H��²?�C�� � ��E�� � ��?4A�.pnX �NM a �\� Uecgc S [n[ M aTVYXJZ r 8 VYpnX2¨�UWV hxMPO U ] ��j h X O jJX U�MPSnO Z�URV h�MeO ­ ��aYU O Vg¨ M � L ¹ � �

�m�e} ��|��� ° �

Page 129: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P� ��;:¦9 � � ��?GEGI �� � � ��� � ���%�!� ��� � � � �!� � � ��� ��� � f��� � �\� �

§ O VYpnX�X ] XJjJVYa MPOnh j [ MP] Uea MPO ^ M Z�X ] �uVYpnX&¹�Ue^ hx] V MPOnh U O MWl Xb� � ��� � h cKZ h U�7 MPO U ]xh�´ XJZ hxOU Z h afXJjJVT� [na M Z S jwV r UWc h c Mel c Me]�S VfX4U O Z%c MP]  eX O V r UWc h c lsSnO jwV h�MeO cb�G¹ XbaTXe� � X²j MPO c h ZnXJa�VYp�XXJ WU ]xS UWV h�MPO²Mel VYpnX�¹�Ue^ hx] V MPOnh U O ^KUWVYa h �²X ] XJ^KX O Vfc O XbXJZnXbZ hxO VYp h c [�a M jbXbZ S afXW�u�.pnX�c Me]�S VfXr Uec h c lsSnO jwV h�MeO c�UWafX2VYp M cfX MWl �¸� L §vVYpnX M a"8e��U O Z�VYp�XK^KUWVYa h ��X ] XJ^KX O VYc�UWafX2VYpnXKcTVYU O Z�UeaTZX ] Xb^`X O VYc MWl j MPO ��7 S aYURV h�MeO � hxO VfXbafUejJV h�MPO VYpnX M a"8�{��P���R�����.pnX.c MP]  eX O V r Uec h c lsSnO jJV hxMPO cJ� � �uU O Z� e Z h cTj S cTcfXbZ h�O ��XbjwV hxMPO ��� ��� }iZnXbcTjba h r XqVYpnXqc MP]  PX O V hxO VYp�X4[nafXJcfX O jbX Mel  WUea h�MPS c�c Me]�S VfXj¦p�Uea"7PXGZ h cTVYa h r S V h�MeO cb� »�X �dhx]�] ZnXba h  PXGX���[nafXJcfc hxMPO c lsM aKVYpnX�^KUWVfa h �1X ] Xb^`X O Vfc r XwV � XJX OU O 8;V �NM²MWl VYpnXJcfX lsS�O jJV h�MPO cJ��ZnX OnM VfXbZ � U O Z � �v�.pnXJcfX lsS�O jJV h�MPO cvUeafX�VYpnX�¹vUea�VYaTXbXw� U�M j �7Pa MPSnO Z4c�V¦UWVfX Mel VYpnX�c MP]  PX O V h�O VfpnXv[�afXbcTX O jJX Mel  WUea h�MPS cªc Me]�S VfXvj¦p�Uea"7PXvZ h cTVfa h r S V hxMPO cJ��U O Zc M UeaTX�c h�O 7 ] X � ] UWVYXJa.ZnXJVfXbaT^ hxO U O VYcJ�

� 9 > � 5 > �G �2�2� 1 � µ � 9 > � 5 > �G �2�;�^1 � G ­ ��� � °� pnXJafX > �) jbaTX|UWVfXbcKU O X ] XJjJVYa MPO h�O cf[ hxO � M a r h V¦U ] )%) Mel � �kU O Z > �) jJafXbUWVYXJcqU O X ] XbjwVYa MeO1hxOcf[ h�O � M a r h V¦U ] ) ) Mel � ��.pnX M  PXJa ] Ue[ r XJV � XbX O � U O Z � h c`VYpnX lsMP]�]xM��dhxO 7&ZnXJVfXbaT^ hxO U O V MWl VYpnX cf[ hxO � M a r h VYU ]M  PXJa ] UW[\^KUWVYa h ��� � ;� ((( � 3 9 ((( = g ��� ((( ­ ��� � °

� pnXJafX = g �� h cdU2^KUWVYa h �qp MP] Z h�O 7�VfpnX M  PXba ] Ue[�c r XJV � XbX O VYp�X M jbj S [ h XbZ;cf[ hxO � M a r h V¦U ] cb�= g ���),+ > 9 � ) ) 1�)H> � µ /�G�8 9 � �;�2� & g ��� G ­ ��� �P� °

U O ZN& g �� h ckVfpnX O¸S ^ r Xba Mel�M jJj S [ h XbZicf[ hxO � M a r h V¦U ] c h�O � U O Z � ��.pnX�^KUWVYa h � X ] Xb^`X O Vfc Mel U MPO Xw� X ] XbjJVfa MPO¶M [�XJaYUWV M ab� �� 5��.^qU'8 r X M r VYU h�O XbZ r 8 ��afc�VXw��[�U O Z h�O 7`VfpnX M [�XJaYUWV M a h�O VfpnXgcf[ hxO � M a r h VYU ] r Uec h c Mel � ��� 5 9 � )k+ > � )k+ > > �) > >7G ­ ��� ��� °

� pnXJafX � ),+ > 9 � )%)f1 �� 51�)H> � � »ºpnX O �� 5 h c;Ue[n[ ]�h XJZ V M 1 � � � h V 7PX O XbafUWVYXJc c hxO 7 ] 8¸� Xw��j h VYXJZj MeO �W7 S afUWV hxMPO cJ� � e � hxOK� p h j¦p²U O X ] XJjJVYa MPO p�UWc r XbX O [na M ^ M VfXbZ l a M ^£U � ]x] XJZqcf[ h�O � M a r h V¦U ] �

Page 130: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P�=±> ��V M U O XJ^K[�V384cf[ hxO � M a r h VYU ] � �_���.pnX M  PXba ] Ue[ r XJV � XbX O VYp h c.c hxO 7 ] 8qX���j h VfXbZij MPO ��7 S aYURV h�MeOU O Z � h cNVfpnX O c h ^ hx] UeaDV M VYp�X M  eXba ] Ue[ h�O XJ�t� ���x�P�e� �dh Vfp;VfpnX > JLK�j MP]�S ^ O²Mel = g ��� aTXb[ ] UejbXJZUec lsMP]x]�M=� cb� � ;� ((( � e 3 9o= e µ ­ = e ° )k+ > 9 � = g ���)k+ > ­k8 �9 > °� ) ) ((( ) 3 ­k8 9 > ° ­ ��� �=} °�.pnX�^qURVYa h �4X ] XJ^KX O V MWl �� 5N^qU'8 OnM=� r X � a h VTVYX O �� � ((( �� 5 1 � � 9 ((( = g ��� ((( � e � e + e B � e + � + e ((( = e ((( G ­ ��� �|� °� pnXJafX > h c¥c S ^K^`XbZ M  PXba�VYpnX M jJj S [ h XbZ�cf[ hxO � M a r h V¦U ] c Mel � U O Z � h c�c S ^`^KXJZ M  PXJa�VYp�XSnOnM jbj S [ h XbZicf[ hxO � M a r h VYU ] c Mel � �

�  eU ]�S UWV h�O 7gVYp�X�ZnXwVYXJaf^ h�O U O Vl1 = e 1 h cuU¥[ M VYX O V h U ]x] 8�Xw��[�X O c h  PXoc�VYXJ[³��XJcf[tXbj h U ]x] 82c h�O jJX h VM jbj S afc h�O c h Z�X2U4V �NM � lsMP] Z M a r h V¦U ] c S ^`^KUWV hxMPO �g¹ M=� XJ eXbab��U ] Uea"7PX�c h ^`[ ]�h ��j|URV h�MeO ^KU'8 r XUej¦p h XJ eXbZ r 8 � a h V h�O 7 ((( = g �� ((( Uecb� ((( = g �� ((( 9 � ) = g ���)k+ > 8 )k+ >7G ­ ��� ��� °� pnXJafX 8 h cgVYp�Xq^KUWVYa h � Mel j Mel UejwV M aTc Mel#= g �� �;�.pnXKZnXJVfXbaT^ hxO U O V Mel#= e j|U O r X`VYpnX O r XM r VYU h�O XbZ l a M ^i� ((( = e ((( 9 �)!� g ��� � ) ) ((( ) 3 8 ),+ e 9 ((( = ((( �) � g ��� � ) ) ((( ) 3 ­ = g �� M 5 ° e + )=� ­ ��� � � °� pnXJafX�VYp�XGj Mel UejwV M aK^qURVYa h �1p�Uec r XbX Oº� a h VTVYX O¶h�O VYXJaf^`c Mel VfpnX h�O  eXbafcTX MelV= g ��� � �.pnXj M ^K[ S V¦UWV h�MPO U ]�] 8qXw��[tX O c h  PX5^KUWVYa h � hxO  eXbaTc h�MeO�O XbXJZncoV M r X�Z MPO X MPO�] 8 MPO jJX lsM avXbUej¦pGcfXwVMel lsSnO jwV h�MeO cb� � U O Z � ��.pnX�U r M  eX h c.c S �Kj h X O V � pnX O VfpnXg¹��S j � X ] ¹vUW^ hx] V MeOnh U O`h c S cfXbZ lsM aNVfpnXgc MP]  PX O V c h�O jJXr M VYp h VqU O Z¶VfpnX LNMPS�]�M ^ r h�O VfXbaYUWjJV hxMPO c �dh Vfp¶VYpnX\c MP]xS VYXW�.UeaTX MPO X�� X ] XbjwVYa MPO¶M [tXbafUWV M afcb�

¹ M=� XJ eXbab� � pnX O VfpnX ���� ¹vUe^ h�] V MPOnh U Oih c S cTXbZ lsM avVYp�X2c MP]  PX O Vb� h V h coU ] c M²O XbjJXbcfcfUea"8GV MXJ WU ]xS UWVfXoVYpnX�V �uM � X ] XbjwVYa MPO\M [�XJaYUWV M ab�

�� G 9 �� �),+ >f+ tu+ v � /*8s14aRb � > �) > �> > v > t^G ­ ��� ��± °� pnXJafX � / 821 a!b � h c�VfpnX�V �uM � X ] XbjwVYa MPOgh�O VYX)7PaYU ] r XwV � XJX O cf[ hxO � M a r h VYU ] c h�O [�p�8_c h j h cTV _�c OnM VYUWV hxMPO {��P���|� ��.p h c h c�^ S j¦p`^ M afXkZ h �`j Sn] V�VYp�U O VfpnX MPO X�� X ] XbjwVYa MeO`M [�XJaYUWV M ab� r XbjbU S cTX � pnX O �� G M [tXbafUWVYXJc

Page 131: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P� �MPO � h Vv7eX O XJaYUWVfXbc r M VfpKc h�O 7 ] 8m� X���j h VfXbZ³� � e �_U O Z`Z MPS r ] 8m� Xw��j h VYXJZ³� � + �e + . j MPO �W7 S afUWV hxMPO cb��� Mh�O UeZ�Z h V h�MPO V M Xw WU ]�S URV h�O 7 = e MWl XJ�t� ���x� � � h V h c O XbjJXbcfcfUea"8;V M Xw WU ]�S URVYXe�

� ;� ((( � + �e + . 3 9 = + �e + . µ � = + �e + . � ),+ > 9 ���� ���= g ���),+ > ­ 8 �9 > µ�8 �9 A °� ) ) ((( ) 3 ­k8 9 > °� ) ) ((( ) � 3 ­ 8 9 A ° ­ ��� � � °

�.pnX�^qURVYa h �4X ] XJ^KX O Vfc Mel �� G UeaTX�VYpnX O �� � 1 �� G 1 � � 9 �� �e + . � g ��� � > AN1,1 > A � ((( = ((( B �!�� ��������� � � / g ��� � � AN1,1 > A �

((( = e ((( B �� �!�� ��������� + � � � / g ��� � � � 1,1 > A �

((( = + �e + . ((( G�­ ��� � � °� pnXJafX � > A 1k1 > A � 9 � > AN1 > A � � � > AN1*A > � �®�.pnXiVfp h aTZ¡VYXJaf^ Mel Xb� ���� � � h c2j M ^K[ S V¦UWV h�MPO U ]�] 8Xw��[tX O c h  eXe�zZ S X�V M r M VYp VfpnX lsMPS a¯� lsMP] Z M a r h V¦U ] c S ^`^KUWV hxMPO U O Z�VYpnX�Z MPS r ] X�c S r cTV h V S V hxMPOh�O 1 = + �e + . 1 ��.pnX r Uec h c lsSnO jJV h�MPO c � U O Z � UeaTX�afXJcTVfa h jwVYXJZ&¹vUea�VYafXJXw� U M j � 7Pa MPS�O Z�cTVYUWVYXJc�U O Z�Vfp S cp�U| PXqZ MPS r ] 8m� M jbj S [ h XJZ'cf[nUWV h U ]�M a r h V¦U ] cb�q§ V h c¥j MPO  PX O�h X O V�V M aTX � a h VYXKXb� � ���x� � h�O VYXJaf^`cMel c S ^`^qURV h�MeO c M  PXJa¥cT[�UWV h U ]�M a r h VYU ] cJ�5¢£c h ^`[ ]�h ��j|URV h�MeO afXJc Sn] VYc l a M ^�VYpnX l UejwV�Vfp�UWVgVYp�XM  PXJa ] UW[ ^KUWVYa h jbXJc = g ��� � = e U O Z = + �e + . UeaTX r ]�M j � Z h U47 MPO U ]�h�O VYpnX�cf[ hxO j M�M afZ hxO UWVYXW�N§ O [�Uea��V h j Sn] Ueab� � pnX O U�U O Z r p�U| PXoZ h « XJafX O Vkcf[ hxO cb�_VYpnXoZ�XJVYXJaf^ h�O U O V Mel VfpnXoZ MPS r ] 8m� c S r c�V h V S VYXJZcf[ h�O � M a r h V¦U ] ^KUWVYa h ��� = + �e + . �³^KU'8 r X � a h VfVYX O UecvVfpnX2[na M Z S jwV Mel VYp�X�ZnXJVfXbaT^ hxO U O VYc Mel V �uMc hxO 7 ] 8¸� c S r cTV h V S VfXbZ&cf[nUWV h U ] � M a r h V¦U ] ^KUWVYa h jJXbcb��§ O VfXbaf^`c Mel cf[�URV h U ]�M a r h V¦U ] cb��Xb� � ��� � � r X��j M ^KXJc� � � 1 �� G 1 � � 9 �e + . � g ��� ­�� � > AN1 > A � � � > AN1 A > � ° ((( = ((( G B �

!�� ������� � � / g �� ­ �� ��AN1 > A � � � � ��AN1*A > � ° ((( = ((( ((( = e (((

B �!�� ��������� + � � � / g ���

� � � 1 > A � ((( = ((( ((( = + �e + . ((( B �!�� ��������� + � � � / g ���

� � � 1 > A � ((( = e ((( ((( = �. ((( � ­ ��� � °

�.pnXGZnXwVYXbaT^ hxO U O V ((( = + �e + . ((( ^qU'8 r X c h ^`[ ]xh ��XJZ h�O U¡^qU O�O XbaKc h ^ h�] Uea2V M Vfp�UWV S cfXbZ hxOXb� �����x� � �¤�.p h c h c�UejJj M ^`[ ]xh cfp�XbZ r 82j MPO c h ZnXba h�O 7 = + �e + . Uec�afXJc Sn] V hxO 7 l a M ^ U�c hxO 7 ] XNXw��j h V¦URV h�MeO= e � ((( = + �e + . ((( 9 ((( = e ((( �)!� g �� � ) ) 1�) � � � = e � M 5. + ) � ­ ��� ��� °� S r cTV h V S V h�O 75XJ�t� ���x� � hxO V M Xb� � ��� ����VYpnX O ] XbUeZnckV M �((( = + �e + . ((( 9 ((( = ((( �),+ >� g ��� � ) > 1�) � � ) ) 1�) � � ­ = g �� ° M 5e + > � = e � M 5. + ) � ­ ��� �P� °

Page 132: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�P� �»ºpnX O ¹��S j � X ] VYpnX M a"8 h c S cfXJZ lsM a�VYpnX c Me]  PX O V|�¸VYpnX ^ M cTVªj M ^`[ S VYUWV hxMPO U ]x] 8¥Xw��[tX O c h  PX�cTVfXb[h ckVfpnXgXJ WU ]xS UWV hxMPO²Mel Xb� � ��� � � � ��� VYp�X M a�8 h c.^ S j¦pi^ M afXoj M ^`[ S V¦URV h�MeO U ]�] 8`ZnXb^KU O Z hxO 7n�c hxO jbX h VdafXb� Snh afXJcdVfpnXgXJ WU ]xS UWV hxMPO²Mel Xb� � ��� �P���

Page 133: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

����

� ��� +���� ����� ��

{��b� �� » � � h�O VY^ h aTX¥U O Z�-v�t��� ©oS�On] Ue[ L �~���~»ºp h VYXW�v¢vaTX lsSn]x] XJafX O X�V S r Sn] Xbcv^`XJVYU ]�]xh j��� ��� � ��� W � ��� WZY@Y ��� � ��� � }��P��� � �m���

{~�R� L p Snh � � h�O »'U O�� �!»'X O � ��p�X O�� »'U O�� � U O Z ��p�U M � - hxO � S � � ��� � ��� W � ���d����n­ �W� ° �x�=±W� � ��� ��±W�¸±��e��� � �e�n�

{ }W� ���¹¥� - S afa MPS�� p�Xbcb� © � © � L � -uaYUeZ ] X)8e��¢�� & � -Na M��dO � & ��¨¥� � Uea � cJ� � � � UWj � U'8e�& �³¹�� U a h X O Z�� � � ���2- S a O cJ�zU O Z�¢¥�2-v��¹ MP] ^KXJcb� � h�� pmVT� Xb^ h VfV h�O�� Z h�M ZnXbc r UecfXJZ MPOj MPORQTS�� URVYXbZi[ MP] 8_^`XbafcJ� � [^Y � W � }W�¸± � �e} ���³� � � ��

{·�e� �2� � S c�V¦U l cTc MPO � !�� L U M � �5� � �u��aTX|UejS8P� U � � ] U| PXwVfVfXbab�d¨�� LNMe] U O XJa h �.U O Z ¢¥� ��¹ XbX � Xbab� U¤] Xw� h r ] X ]�h"� p¸V�� XJ^ h VfV hxO�� Z hxM ZnXJcu^KUeZnX l a M ^ c MP]�S r ] X j MPO Z S jJV h�O�� [ MP] 8�^`XbaTcb�� [^Y � W �t}m�P± �~�¸±P±���� � �m�_�

{~�R��¨��z��XJcfc ] XbaJ���2� �� © X O V MeO � U O Z & �@¹�� U a h X O Z³� �@Uec hxO��²l a M ^*j MPORQTS#� UWVYXJZ�� [ MP] 8�^`Xba^ h jJa M j|U|  h V h XbcJ�$� [^Y � W � } �m� � � �m���³� � � � �

{ � � U �P¹ h Z�Xe� � �m¢�� ©oh U ´ ���gUeafj h U���-v� �� ��j¦p � UeaTV ´ � � � & �e¢ O ZnXJafcTc MPO ��%�� � X h �_U O Z5¢�� ��¹ XbX � Xbab� �_Xb^ h j MeO Z S jwV h�O#� [ Me] 8_^KXJafc �5U O X � j ] Uecfc Mel c MP]xh Z�� cTVYUWVYX ] UecTXba¥^qUWVfXba h U ] cb�& � � W � � W � �e±e}�� � �P}P}���� � � � �

{~±R�g§ cfU r X ]�] X �zXbZ MPS � U O Z M cTXb[np � 8_cfcJ�'� � �^WZ])(�*xY � � [^],+ [^Y�W � [^] �w[�� �.-/*0*x] � � [^Y � � ���21+ � ],W�� �H] [� � � ��] � � W [� �3*xY � ���2154 � � � [ � W ��Y [^] ��[�� �.[6*0*x] � � [^Y � � ��� � M p O » h�] XS887� MeO cb� § O jW�x� ¨9!2�z� � �P±��

{ �W� M cTXb[np � 8_cfcDU O Z2§ cYU r X ]x] X �@XJZ MPS ��� ¨ MPOn]�hxO X|UWa M [�V h jJc h�O ^ Sn] V h [ MP] UWaz^KXJZ h U��@�.pnX M a"8U O Z\X���[tXba h ^`X O VYcJ�;: ��W � �<� W � ��� �e� � ±P±��³� � �e�n�

Page 134: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

���_�{ �W� © � & � � U Onh cb� � �.¢�� & UWV O XJab�vU O Z!��� �� � Uea � cJ� © XJc h"�eO U O Z j MPO c�VYa S jJV hxMPOºMel^ MP] XJj Sn] Uea5UecTcfXb^ r ]�h Xbc �dh Vfp ] Uea � X;cTXbj MeO Z�� M afZnXJa M [�V h jbU ]kOnMPO�]�h�O X|Uea h V h XbcJ��� S U O V S ^j¦pnXJ^ h j|U ] UWcf[tXbjJVfcb�;: ��W � �<� W � ��� �e���x� �P���³� � �W�n�

{�� W� ��� & � � UWafZnXJab� ��¸» � � Xbafa�8P� �5�H- MPS aTp h�]x] � L ��-v� � M aT^qU O ��U O ZR-v� �5�~� h XJ^qU O�O � & X ] UR�V h�MPO r XJV � XbX O r MPO Z�� ] X O�� Vfp²U ] VYXba O UWV h�MPO U O Z4cTXbj MPO Z;X ] XbjJVfa MPO�h jvp?8_[tXbaf[ MP] Uea hx´ U r hx]�h V38Mel j MeORQTS�� UWVfXbZ M a � U Onh j�^ MP] Xbj S�] XbcJ� & � � W � � W ��� � ��� � � � �³� � �P}��

{��P�b� © U|  h Z � � ��pnX ] V MPO U O Z Sn]xh U � � & h jbXe� � X|Uec S afXJ^KX O VfciU O Z j|U ] j S�] UWV h�MPO c Mel VYp�Xp?8_[�XJaf[ MP] UWa h�´ U r hx]�h V h XJc Mel URV M ^`cqU O Z¶cT^qU ]x] ^ Me] Xbj Sn] XJc h�O VYpnX � Uec`[np�UecTXe� : ��W � �� W � ��� �e� ��}���������� � �e�n�

{����R� U � �gUea Onh XbaJ� & ��¹�U QT] U MPSnh � ¢¥� !uUecTcYUeaJ�zU O Z � � ��a h  eUWcTV¦U| WU���¢ ]�] � [ MP] 8_^`Xba ��X ] Z�� X « XbjwVVfaYU O c h c�V M a.aTX|U ]xh�´ XJZ r 8;[�a h�O V h�O�� VfXbj¦p Onh � S XbcJ� & � � W � � W �n� � � � � � �e���³� � �e���

{��=}W� � ]�] a h j¦p � h VYcTj¦p � X¥U O Z � XwVYXba -{��|�e� � ����U| eU O U O Z � � �_j¦p S�] VYX O � ��] XbjwVYa MPOnh j Xw��j h V¦URV h�MeO c h�O � Onh VfXvU O Z h�O � Onh VfXd[ MP] 8PX O XbcJ�

� ��� � ��� W � ���.��} � �~�m}P}m±_��� � �P±��{����R� ����¨¥� ©oh � h Vb� © � � SnM ��U O Z ��� � U ´bS ^`Z�UeaJ� � cfcTX O V h U ] � cTVYUWVYXJcv^`Xbj¦p�U O�h cf^ MelDM [�V h j|U ]OnMeOn]�hxO X|Uea h V38 h�O [ h � j MeORQTS�� UWVfXbZ;[ MP] 8_^`XbafcJ� � ��� � ��� W � ���d���m}�� � ± ���P��� � ���e�{�� � � ��� � U ´JS ^`Z�Uea¥U O Z U � � SnM � ¬ r cTXbaT WUWV h�MPO�Mel VfpnafXJXqafXJc MPO U O jbXJc h�O VYpnX`VYp h afZ�p�Uea��

^ MPOnh j � X O XJaYUWV h�MPO cf[tXbjJVfa S ^ Mel j MPORQTS#� UWVYXJZ4[ MP] 8_^`Xbafc � �   h ZnX O jbX lsM a�VYpnX lsMPS a�� ] Xw PX ]XJcfcfX O V h U ] c�V¦UWVfXbcd^ M ZnX ] � � �/: ��W � � � ��� � ���³� �x� �e� ���³� � �e�n�

{���±R� �¤� �5� � M�M cJ� ��� & Ue^KUecfXJcfp�U��zU O Z © � �t� ��U ]  WU M �T-kU O ZGV M j M afafX ] UWVfXbZGjJa M cTc M  PXJa hxOU ] VYXJa O UWV h�O�� p S rnr UWafZGU O Z�[n[n[�j¦pnU h�O c � O UWV S afX Mel VYp�X ]�M=� Xbc�Voc hxO��P] XJV�Xw��j h V¦UWV h�MPOiMelj MPORQTS�� URVYXbZi[ MP] 8eXbafcJ� � ��� � ��� W � �<� WZYmY ���t±���� � � ���³� � �e}��

{�� �W� �� ���%-NafXJZ�UecJ� L � ¢vZnU O V|� � � ��Uej � ����¢�� � Xbafc M�MeO cb��U O Z�-v� � � � h XbaTjbXe�u�.p h aTZ�� M afZnXJaOnMeOn]�hxO X|Uea M [�V h jbU ] aTXbcT[ MPO cfX h�O�M a � U Onh j`^KUWVYXJa h U ] c �¥VYpnX M afXwV h jbU ] U O Z%Xw��[tXba h ^`X O V¦U ]UecT[�XJjJVfcb� : ��W � �<� W � ��� �e� � �W�m}���� � �e�n�

Page 135: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

���e�{�� �W� ��XwVYp & � � UeaTZnXbaJ� �@Ue[_� ��U � L p�X O�� � -Na S jbX �2�N� h Xb^KU OnO � U a h XbZ ]xh ¢ O Zna h X O�O X L � �

� h afX h�]�] X - ] U O j¦p�UeaTZ�� © XJcfjJXe� M cfXJ[np�» � � Xbafa�8P�¤U O Z M a � X O � �_hxO Znp M�Q � �@Uea � X���afc�Vp?8_[�XJaf[ MP] UWa h�´ U r hx]�h V h XJc h�O [ S cfp�� [ Sn]x] [ MP] 8eX O XJc r 8\V SnOnhxO��qMel VYpnX r MPO Z ] X O#� VYp U ] VfXba��O URV h�MeO U O ZiUea M ^KUej h V38P� & � � W � � W � � � }�� ���P�e��� � �W�n�

{~� W� ��� & � � UeafZnXJab� © ��¨���-NXJaYUWVYU O ��U O Z ���·� ��� L p�X O�� �D¢�[n[na M Uej¦pnXbc lsM a M [�V h ^ hx´bh�O#� VYp�X��aTcTV²X ] XJjJVYa MPOnh j\p?8_[�XJaf[ MP] UWa h�´ U r hx]�h V38 Mel j MPORQTS�� URVYXbZ M a � U Onh j;^ MP] XJj Sn] Xbcb� & � � W � � W ��P�e� �x� P}��³� � ���P�

{~���b� L X ]�h�O X U¤h�M a h�O�h � U U r a h jJX L p�UeaTaYU�� eX|U O � � h j¦pnX ] ¨ SnOn´Jh � § lsM a © �D» � ��Ue^ S X ] ��U O Z M cTXb[np � 8_cTcb� � h"� pmVT� h�O Z S jbXJZ'cfXJj MPO Z�� p�UWaf^ MPOnh j � X O XbafUWV hxMPO'hxO U O�M jwV S [ MP] UeagZ;8PXW�(�*xY ��� WZYmY ���t� �� �W� � ���³� � �m�_�

{~�P�R� �� ��� ¬�S Z�Uea U O Z © � ��� L pnXb^ ] U��ª�.pnX M a"8 Mel cfXbj MPO Z�� M afZ�Xbavc S cfjJXb[�V h r hx]�h V h XJc Mel r X O �´ X O X�c S r cTV h V S VfXbcJ� (�*xY � : � � � ���³�=} �x� � �n��� �P±P���{~�e}W� ��.¹ MPO XW� §¦� �D]x]x�uM�M Z³� � � � SnOnM ��¢�a h � h�´ X ] � � Uea�  h�O ��� LNM p�X O ��¢�� ��XwVfV ] �.¢ O �

ZnaTX � �5� &dh�On´J] XbaJ�dU O Z & � � � ��^qU ]�] XS8P�!�.pnXbaT^ M X ] XbjwVYa h j [ M=� XJa Mel c hxO��P] Xw� � U ]x] XbZjbUea r MPOiO U OnM V S r Xbcb� � ��� � ��� W � � � WZY@Y ��� � �� � e�¸����� � � ���

{~�W�e� � � &dM p ] � O�� U O Z ��� �2� � MPSnh XW� ¬ [�V h j|U ] Xw��j h V¦UWV h�MPO c hxO j MPO�QTS�� UWVfXbZ5[ Me] 8_^KXJafcJ� � ��� � �� W � ��� WZYmY ��� �m� � � �m������� � � ���

{~�P�R� � p hx]�h [ �5� LNMP]�]xh�O c ��z¹ MeO X � Uea�  hxO ��� LNM pnX O �t� �2� � MPSnh X � X h VYp -NafUeZ ] XS8P� �_X SnO�� �¹ M�MPO ep h U O Zi¢ ��XJVTV ] �D§ cdVYpnX h�O Vfa h�O c h joVfpnXbaT^ M [ M=� Xba Mel jbUea r MPOiO U OnM V S r Xbc [ M c h �V h  PX�� � ��� � �<� W � ��� WZYmY ��� �m�n­�� ° ���m} � �P���� ��

{~� � �g§¦� ¬ p�^ hxO Xe� � � � UWaf[ ]xS cb��U O Z � � ��j¦p Sn] VfX O � & X O�M af^KU ]�hx´ XJZ\j MPO � �PS aYUWV h�MPO�hxO VYXbafUejw�V h�MPO ^KXwVYp M Z lsM aªX ] XbjwVYa MeO j M aTafX ] UWV h�MPO`h�O VYpnX�Xw��j h VYXbZ²c�V¦UWVfXbc MWl [ Me] 8PX O XbcJ� � �,: ��W � �� ��� � ��� � ��� �P� � ����� �m± ���

{~�P±R� �� & h Z ] XS8 U O Z � � ��XJa O XJab�g¢ O&h�O VfXbaf^`XbZ h UWVfX O X �P] XJjJV MWl Z hx« XbafX O V h U ]�M  PXJa ] Ue[�VYXJj¦p��Onh � S X lsM a`cf[tXbjwVYa M cfj M [?8 �&[?8_afa MP] X\U O Z VYpnX U ´bhxO XbcJ��� ��W�� � : � � � � - �ZYd[ �d}m� � �P�P�P�� �P±e}��

Page 136: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

���W}{~� �W� � � ������ © X � Uea�U O Z¥» ���.p h X ] � �ga MPSnO Z¥cTV¦URVYXbc Mel ^ MP] Xbj S�] XbcJ��} ���|VfpnXu^ O Z M ^`XJVYp M Z³�

Ue[�[na M � h ^KUWV hxMPO c.U O Z\[nUeaYUe^`XJVfXbaTcb� � � - � � : ��W � � & � � ��� � ����� � � ���³� �m±P±��{~� �W�g���d¹�UecfX � U � U�� !2�k§ � UecYU��o¹¥� � SnO Ue^ S aYU�� ��� � M ZnU�� !��.� Me�_S aYU��v¹¥�k��Uej¦p h r U O U��

� � � URVYc S ^ M V M �¸U O Z ���m¢ r XW�³¨ MeOn]�hxO X|Uea M [�V h j|U ] cf[tXbjJVfa M cTj M [?8 MPO5MPO XdZ h ^KX O c hxMPO U ]X���j h V MPO c h�O c hx]�h j MPO [ MP] 8_^`XbaJ��[ MP] 8_c hx] U O Xe� � ��� � ��� W � � � WZY@Y ��� � ��� �e� ����� � �m���

{ } W� ���W¢ r Xe� � � ��j¦pna h X r XbaJ�e» � � ��� S �¸U O Z �� ! S � ¨ MPO�]�h�O X|Uea M [�V h j|U ] cT[�XJjJVYafU Mel Xw��j h V MeO chxO [ MP] 8�Z h UejJXJV38 ] X O Xe� � ��� � � � � W�� � �����e}�� ��� ���³� � �m���{ }��b� � � L p�U O Z�a M cTcb� ��� � U ´bS ^KZ�UWab� ��� eX �e]�h�O c �¸h ������»'X h � �¤� � UeafZ�X O 8P� � �W» � � �NM j � �

U O Z¶��� � � � hx]�] XJab� � ��j h V MPO c h�O [ MP] 8�­ [nUeaYUR� [npnX O 8 ] X O Xw  hxO 8 ] X O X ° � � ��� � � � W � � �d�� �x�|�m± m����� � �e�n�

{ }m�R� � a h j � � � M�M aTXoU O Z © U|  h Z !uUea MPO �@¢ O X���[ ]�h j h V�� c Me]  PX O VNZ;8 O UW^ h jw� Z h X ] XbjwVYa h jdcfjbaTXbX O �hxO�� ^ M ZnX ]�Mel X ] XbjwVYa MPO � p MP] X h�O VYXJaYUejwV h�MeO c h�O j MPORQTS#� UWVYXJZ5[ MP] 8_^KXJafcb� � ��: ��W � � � ��� � ���� ��� � �|�¸±���� � � ���

{ }P}W��¨��%- ]�M Xb^ r Xba � X O �$� � ��] � � W [� (�*xY � ��� ��» �n¢��%-uX ORQ Ue^ h�O �n§ O je� � ¨ !��z� � � �_�{ }e�e� �� ¬ � � M a ] X)8P� ���� ©oM j¦pnXba�V38P�uU O Z © � � S�� p³� ���j¦pnXb^i��c M jW�x�ª[�XJa �¸h�O VfaYU O cJ� � �

: ��W � � & � � ��� � W �� � � � [���� �����P��� �=}m���e��� � �P±��{ }m�R� © � ��� L pnXJ^ ] U%U O Z �� � 8_cfcJ�vXJZ h V M afcJ� � � ��] � � W [� (�*xY � � [^] � ��3*�W ZY � W�� ���( [�� � �

+ � ],W�� �H],W���[�� � : 6� �ZYd[^] � ��¢vj|UWZnXb^ h j � afXJcfcJ��§ O jW�x� ¨ X � ! M a � �³� � �P±��{ } � � eXbU O � � h j¦pnX ] ¨ S�On´bh � U U r a h jbX L p�UeaTaYU�� L X ]�hxO X U�h�M a h�Onh �¸U O Z M cTXb[np � 8_cfcJ��� aYU O c h X O VM [�V h jbU ]�] 8 hxO Z S jJXbZ OnMeO � jJX O VYa M c"8_^`^KXwVYa"8 hxO U c MP]xS V hxMPO MWl�M jJV S [ MP] Uea;^ Me] Xbj Sn] XJcb�

: ��W � � � ��� � ��� WZYmY ���t��� ����}e�����³� � �e���{ }m±R� U U r a h jJX L p�UWafaYU�� U U r a h jJX © Xw eU S ��� eX|U O � � h j¦pnX ] ¨ S�On´bh �¤U O Z � U Sn]\& U h ^ MPO Z³� � h �

j M cfXJj MPO Z ]�h�� pmVT� h�O Z S jbXbZ OnMPO jJX O VYa M c"8_^`^KXwVYa"8 h�O U�Z;8eX�c MP]xS V hxMPO � � ��� � �<� W � � � WZY@Y ���� � � �W�e�� ��³� � �m���{ } �W� �� © � PUWj � c MPO � : ] [ ��� � � [^]� ],W��ZY� �� � � �x[ � � ��� � M p O » h�] X)8 7 � MPO cb� ¨ !��z� �m±P�_�

Page 137: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

���R�{ } �W� � h�MeO X ] ��U ] Xb^i� � ��W � � ],W�� �H] [� � � � Yd[^]sY ��W�� � ��� ��� ��� � [^Y�W�� �6� �ZY�W � � �D» ��¢��x-NX O �Q Ue^ h�O �n¨�X � ! M a � ��� � �P� �{·�� W� © � L pnXJ^ ] U �� eXbaT[np�U �PO�MPO U O Z & ��- MeOnO XJ  hx]�] XW�¶�.pnX ZnXbcTjba h [�V hxMPO Mel VYp�X [np?8_c h �

jbU ] [na M [tXba�V h Xbc Mel j MPO ZnX O cfXJZ ^qURVfVYXJa S c hxO���h afaTXbZ S j h r ] X4VYX O c M aTcb� - ��� � � � � ��� � ����P±�­ � ° � � ��� � � ���� �m±����

{·�n�b� L � �2� ��aYU'8²U O Z � � � � � S rnr h�O cJ� � ��W�� � ��� � � ],W�� �H] [� �� � � � �21�� � ] � � W��0194 � � � [ �� W ��Yd[^] � � LN] UeaTX O Z MPO � aTXbcTcb� ¬ � lsM aTZ³�³� � �e�n�

{·�¸�R� & � » �@� XbaTp S�O Xe� � � © � � U � XbaJ�DU O Z L � � � ��U| WU � Xe� � XbUec S afXb^`X O Vfc Mel.OnMeOn]�hxO X|Uea]xh"� pmV.cTj|UWVTVYXba h�O�� � � ��� � ��� W � ��� WZYmY ���z�|� � � ���P��� � � ���{·�m}W� M cTXb[np � 8�cTcb���.p�U h�L p�U S U O � L pna h cTV M [npnX © pnX O U S V|�tU O Z\§ cYU r X ]x] X �zXbZ MeS ����¹�Uea��

^ MPOnh j�aYU'8 ] X h"� p cfj|URVfVYXJa hxO��4l a M ^ OnMPO�]�h�O X|Uea M jwV S [ MP] UWa�^ MP] XJj Sn] Uea ^KXJZ h U��.VfpnX2j|UecTXMel jba�8_cTV¦U ]   hxMP] XwV|� : ��W � � � ��� � ���³��±P± � � ���P�³� � �e}��{·�P�e� � h ^ MeO ���n¢ ] Vf^qU O�O � � [�� � � ��W�� � ��� & � ] � � �21/- �� ��Y� �� � � �ZY � � � � �� � Y ��W � � � ��Y ���

� � W� ��� & � � � WZY� � � ¬ � lsM aTZ � Onh  eXbafc h V38 � aTXbcfcJ�t¨ !2�z� � ���P�{·�¸�R��» hx]�]�h Ue^ MeO XbcdU O Z²¨ M aT^qU O ¹¥� � UeaTj¦p³� � ��W�� WZY � � [^] & � ] � � &%Y [^Y�W � ��� � � ��� � � � ] � � W

�01 � W �W��ZY � [^Y@Y � � W�� � � � � � � ] � � � � �2� ©oM  eXba � S r ]�h j|UWV h�MPO cb�n§ O jW�x� ¨9!2�z� �P±e}��{·� � �g¢ ] X Q U O Zna M � h cfU O V38P�D�.pnX�X ] XbjJVfa MPO�h j�cTVfa S jwV S aTX MWl�� afUe[np h VYXW� � �/: ��W � � � � ��� � ��� � e�n�

� � ���P�{·�¸±R� �� �D��-NafXJZ�UecJ� �� LNM a Onhx] � © ��-NX ] QTMPO�O Xe� © � ©oM c ��U O V M cb�n¢¥� ©oMPOnhx´ XwVfV h �_U O Z �¤� ��p S U h �

� ��j h VYXbZ_� cTVYUWVYX X ] XbjwVYa MeOnh jGc�VYa S jJV S afX MWl j MPORQTS�� URVYXbZ MP]�h��PM ^`XbaTc4U O Z![ MP] 8_^`Xbafc �®¢� S U O V S ^5� j¦pnXb^ h jbU ] Ue[n[na M Uej¦p V M M [�V h j|U ] [np�X OnM ^`X O U�� - ��� � : ��W � � � W�� ����}m� � � � ±��� � � ���

{·���W��» � � � � S � �� & � ��j¦p�a h X « XJab�zU O ZG¢�� ��³¹�XJX � XJab� � MP]xh V MPO c hxO [ MP] 8PUejbXwV38 ] X O XW� � ��� � �� W � ��� WZYmY �����¸� � � � � ����� �P± ���

Page 138: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

���e�{·���W� ���l-NafU ´bM  _c �¸hxh �`¨¥� � h a M  WU��2¢¥� & �l- h cfp M [�� � � ]xh ^ M  �� © � � j-NafU O j¦p³�q¨¥��¨¥�

-kUWaYUecTp �eM  t� U O Z �� � � U XbaTaYUea h cJ� � ��j h V¦UWV h�MPO ckU O Z M [�V h jbU ] [�a M [tXba�V h XJc Mel [npnX O 8 ] X O X��r UWcfXbZ\j MPO�QTS�� UWVfXbZi[ MP] 8_^KXJafcdU O Z MP]xh"�PM ^KXJafcb� (�*xY � � [^] + [^Y�W � [^] � � �����m±P���³� � � ���{~� W� © �s-uX ] QTMeOnO Xe� �¤� ��p S U h � �� LNM a O�h�] � © �³¢���Z M c ��U O V M cb� U O Z �� ���s-uafXbZnUecb� ¬oO VYp�XO URV S aTX MWl X ] XbjwVYa MPOnh jqXw��j h V¦UWV h�MPO c hxO [ Me] 8�­ [�UWaYUe[np�X O 8 ] X O XJ  h�O 8 ] X O X ° �i¢ � S U O V S ^2�

j¦pnXJ^ h j|U ]zhxO  PXbc�V h�� UWV hxMPO � � �/: ��W � � � ��� � �z�P�P��� � �P� ����� � � ���{~���b� ! S �e¨¥� ��Uea�VYc�VYX hxO � � � �� &dh jJXe�mU O Z � � � � LNMPOm� X ]�] � L p�Uea � Xkj MeORQTS�� UWV h�MPO c"8_^K^`XJVfa"8r aTX|U �¸hxO�� U O Z4VfpnX�U r c M af[�V h�MeO cf[tXbjwVYaYU Mel [ MP] 8�[�pnX O 8 ] X O XbcJ� � ��� � �<� W � � �d�n�_��� �e�W� � �

� � �m���{~�P�R� � � L p�U O Zna M cTcb��t� � U ´bS ^`Z�UeaJ� � � � h XJcfcJ� � �@¢¥� �@U O Xe� �¤� � UeafZnX O 8P� � � ¹�Ue^5�

U �eS j¦p h ��U O Z � � ! M cTp h�O�M � ¬ [�V h j|U ] U r c M aT[�V hxMPOKhxO VfpnXvc S r cTV h V S VYXJZ4[npnX O 8 ] X O X�� r UecTXbZj MPORQTS�� URVYXbZi[ MP] 8_^`Xbafc ���.pnX M a"8iU O Z;X���[tXba h ^`X O V|� � ��� � ��� W � � �d� �P� � �|��� � �³� � �P±��

{~�e}W� �� LNM a Onhx] � © ��-NX ] QTMPO�O Xe� & ��¹¥� U a h X O Z³�ªU O Z �� ����-NaTXbZ�UecJ� ¬ [�V h j|U ] U r c M af[�V h�MPO chxO [ MP] 8�­s[�UeaYUW[np?8PX O 8 ] X O X¶  h�O 8 ] X O X ° U O Z [ Me] 8�­ ��� ��� Z h ^`XJVfp M �%8m�Y�P���R� [�UeafUe[npnX O 8 ] X O X  h�O 8 ] X O X °kMP]xh"�PM ^KXJafcb�): ��W � � � ��� � ��� WZY@Y ���t�e�e}�� �m���³� � �e�n�

{~�W�e� � � � � � h�]x] XbaJ� © � ! M cTp h Z�U�� L ��!2� !uU O�� �DU O Z%¢�� ���¹ XbX � XbaJ� � MP] Uea hx´ XbZ Sn] VfaYU|  h�M �] XJV¥U r c M af[�V h�MPO Mel p h"� p ] 8 M a h X O VfXbZ�[ MP] 8�­ ��� ^KXwVYp M �s8P������­ �H_·� XwVYp?8 ] ° � pnXw�s8 ]�M �s8 ° [nUeaYUR�[np�X O 8 ] X O X¥  h�O 8 ] X O Xe� � ��� � ��� W � ���.� � ���~� �P� �e��� � � ���

{~�P�R� � � � � � hx]�] Xbab� L � !2� !uU O�� ��U O Z'¢�� ��¤¹ XbX � XbaJ� � MP] UWa h�´ XbZ Sn] VfaYU|  h�MP] XJV¥U r c M af[�V h�MeOr 8 Uqp h"� p ] 8 M a h X O VfXbZ�Z h U ]x� 8 ] ZnXJa h  WUWV h  eX Mel [ MP] 8³­s[�UeafUe[npnX O 8 ] X O X�  hxO 8 ] X O X ° � � ��� � �� W � ���d� � � � � � � ���n� ��

{~� � �g¢¥� � M p ] XJab� © �P¢¥�PZ M c ��U O V M cb� © � -uX ] QTMeOnO Xe� �¤����p S U h � ��·� ��� -uafXbZnUecb�¸¢��N-v�¸¹ MP] ^KXJcb�¢¥� � aYU S cb� � � � Sn]�] X O ��U O Z & ��¹�� U a h X O Z�� L p�UWa � XocTXb[�UWaYUWV h�MPO4hxO²]�M j|U ]xh�´ XbZKU O Z²ZnX��]xM jbU ]�hx´ XbZ²X ] XJjJVYa MPOnh j�cTV¦URVYXbc hxO [ MP] 8�^`Xba h jocTXb^ h j MPO Z S jwV M aTcb� � [^Y � W �t} �m� � � P}���� � � ���

{~�P±R� �� U Xba O U O ZnX ´ &dh j M � & � � M [�X ´ ��U O Z �2� & Ue^ h aTX ´ � � MP] XJj Sn] Uea h�O VYX � aYU ] c �dh VYp\c ] UWVYXJar UWc h cJ� h�h � l Uec�Vdj M ^`[ S VYUWV hxMPO U ] U ]"�PM a h Vfpn^`cb� � �/: ��W � � � ��� � ��� �����~�¸���|}����P����� � � ���

Page 139: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

��� �{~� �W�g¢¥� � ´ U r M U O Z¡¨¥� ¬ cTV ]�SnO Z³� + � � W ��� ��[���Y � � : ��W � � �ZY� � 1 � ��Y� �� � � �ZY � � �MY � - � �� [�� � W�� � ],W��ZY� �� � � � &%Y ���ZY � W � ��W�� 6��������� �������� ! �������������������� �! #"$� � ���%&�'�()�+*,�)-/.102 -��)%4365)07%&��&-/5!%487��-95!-/.6�-��� � 8 �:5!;682-=<?>@3BA � �C5);/;�0282>�5!%487��-D�)E

%&3/F82-:%4 �&GH�./825!%4IKJ�> 87%&��-LE?���&GM5)0287'&GN� : �PO � � � ��� � � �PQ�Q �SR Q:�T�U��:V!����XW�Y

�XW �� Z�I5��[82. ! 5)�&�)-\5)-�.\]^��_����%,`T8702_� 8 �baCcU > %&',�)Ed�07�> %&�&��-M>������& 0e5!%&82��-f��-H%43/^-/�)-/0287-/�5)���;T%482>�5)0g;/�&�);d ��%487�'��)E�;d�)0 8 5!>� % 8 07�-/!� � ��� � ��� O � � � 1 : � � �[O ��� � ++h)ijikO K�UQ � � ��� W:��� ���)�:lT�

�XW l� Zm,�onp�o`T;P5)-/�q5)-/.sro�otu�v`T�[��' �q`T >���-�.13 8 ;����;d��025)�&87(�5)_�82028w% 8 �)E^3yx/>@�!�0z��82-��)'�{u5)-T|5)0 8 %482>�5)0o���'�x/07%&'�E?����'&87(�u5)-�.D5)07%&��&-/5!%487��-q./ ;d -/./�-�>�)� � �): �PO � � � ���~} � �g�)��{���l W:� ���)� R �

�XW R Z�I5��[82. ! 5)����-b������-/0782-/�5)����;�%&82>�5)0p���'&;���-/'�$�!E�> ��-���x��:5�%4�.=;���0 8 GH���'�{6 '&'& -:%48e5!0KJ�> 87%45!%487��-/'^5)-/.N'&>�5!%&%&���82-��/� � ���} ��� O � ��� 1 : ��� �[O���} � ++h)i�i�O��K� � Q/{�Q W�Y �T�U���� W �

�XW Q) #"$� �T`d�[�� �,5)���Ta��Ttu�[rU�[�_/87'&>@3b�Ta��[m,�[���5!0 8 �[5)-�. � �[�v�T`[%4��z5!��%�����G��){o��-/ ��� -/��&5)0�;/x/�&;���'���yxP5)-:%&x/G GH�>@3/5)-/82>�5)0�GH��02 >�x/025)�fGM�[./ 0�� � � - � � : �PO � � & � � � �� Y VT{ R � Y lT�d���� � �

�XW:� Za��&87>�"��T�)�&)�,*,�-~�&5)GM87-�tF3/ �&GM5)-b��5)-/.��I5��T87. ! 5)�&��-U��n,��x�02��G�_s'�>��& �-/87-��65!-/.KJ�> 87%&��-�_�82-/./87-��D�-/ � ��87�'u82-s> ��-���x��:5�%4�.�;���0 8 GH��&' � � � : �PO � � � ���} � ��� Y)W {SQ:lT� W ���)�:VT�

�XW�W #`d�P�k8���82GM5�� � h)i �T�4O�� � Q/{ �)W �U���������XW V� Z�v5)x/0b�� 0e5)-� 8 ��� 8 ��x/-�� �[��-�n,3/�)8�� 87'&�[��-\�k3�G��/`[%4����-�tf� � ��x�82)�T5)-/.N"�5)���[82- � �

n,��3��-b� � h)i �[�@O�� R ���y< W)W�W�W AK{SQ W)W �d����������XW �! �/����"�87-:%4GH82�&�5)-/.�np�S�I�/�=3/8w%4!�/& �!�Pi �PO�i � � +�O�i�h)��}���V�VT{�l R ���b����� W ��XW �! � ���C"�87-:%4GH82�&!�C*p���@�C��x�-/0e5);U�C5)-/.�np�v�I� �=3�87%4!� � ���~} � � O � �$� O�i�i � � W �P< � A�{ W R ���

��)�:lT�

Page 140: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�~l)V

� V Y Z]^8287>@3/82����`�5)8w%4�/�b"�87%&'&x�%45)��5NmPx���8w%@5��btu�U���& '&'& 023P5!x/'�� 5)-/.$"$��`d�g�����'&'��073P5)x/' � +Dh)i �& � ��� h)� � ��� � �UO@O�� � � )��;/5 ��u�� � �U���� R �

� VT�� ! ��'�3/8 8 x/�y8U"�8 8 5)GH�)%4�/�T`[%& �)�-Ntf� � �)x/82!�T5!-/.�"�5)� �[82- � �Tn,��3/ -b� � ���~} � � O � � � O�i�i � �V W < �~l�AK{ l[�~lT���d���� W �

� V�l� Z]F�S�#� 82'�3/8��U�I5)82'�x/�)f�k-���G\5�%@5�� � -���8���5)��5)�/��"�� `d�g�����'�'&�073P5)x/' �g5)-/.�tf�b�����'&'��0 |3P5!x/'�� � � � ���~} � & � � � � *�� � � W R < W AK{ l�l � lT�U�����)Q/�

� V R Z�����&825)�y8��p5)GM5).P5T�g`T3/87-�87>@3/8 `�5��,5).P5�� 5)-/.D�z%&'&x/'�3/8��I'�3/8 8 5)GM5�� � ���~} ��� O � ��� O�i�i � �W �/< � Y AK{7� � V)���d����:lT�

� V!Q) Z�Z��m,�B��x�5!-/. � � � � ! 5)�/� + � � � � ���~} ��� O�i�i ��� �U� Y < ���:A�{S� R � � � R VT������ W �� V � #tf�B`[%&�GM5)-/-b��np�B����;�82-b�B5)-�.q"$� � 5��!5 ��-P5T� � ���} �<� O � ��� � �!Y < W AK{SQ Y V � �d����)Q/�� V W 5)��z5!- � 82G 5)-/.L�9x[|��v 8v`Txb� � ���~} ��� O � ��� � �)Y < �l�A�{S��� R l[�U����!Q/�� V�V� F�  %&'&x 8 5 "�xT%4��xb� ��5)����5)( x `T3/82_/5!%@5�� 5)-/. � 5)( x/� �� .P5�� � ���~} � � O � � � �

� V�<�lT�~AK{7� R V Y l � � R V Y:� �d��)������ V)�! Z���-P5).N� �&82-/5~��'�%&8��>)� : �PO � � �&h)��z�&h6*�� � �PO����6��� nz]�n �����'&' �B�p-/-N�p��_d��� �b�����lT�

� V)�! F��-y%&�tI�45)��!5)>)�v� �!5)-stIx�%4GM5)-b�o5)-/.1���-P5).9�v��82-P5~��' %48��>)� � �3*���� �� � �&h)�<- *0*�����h ���9i �i �PO : �PO � � }�ij� � ��� : ����� �� :h)i�O�� � ���2O�� �[�2O@} � `T;/�&87-��� � |�� �&025 �/�/� ! �����V�VT�

� � Y Z���Sa���"�5)-���02��;���x/07��'��d���S]Z�B�9�[�[.P5)020j��5)-/.+� ������mP��^02 ��� � � : �PO � � & � � ��� 4gh)��h �:h �� �&h)��} � �/���P< �V�A�{�l!Qyl�V �TR � ������:l[�

� ���� Z�I5��[82.Ha��["�5)-/�)02��;���x/07��'��)����x���025)'�]F�)�9�[�[.P5)020j��5)-�.M�v5!%4��82>@�����ymP��^02 ��� � � : �PO � �& � � � 4�h)��h �:h � � ��h)��} � �P���P<��~V�AK{ l!Q:l�V � l!Q R � �B����:l[�

� �:l� F�k�&5M�Z� � �[82-/!�Z� �/h)�Pi � � : �PO � � }�i�� �!�������-:%487>��|k�p5)070b�k-/>!�7��� �U��������� � R ������-/!�z"$� np� � 025 ��x/-��/���#� "$�C���GH�' ���#�C�I� ��3/-�'&��-b� ��a���mo87'&>@3/ �������C���

�95)07%&���'��T"$� �[nz5)'&5�!5)-:%�� �[`T>@3�GM87.�%��y5)-�.\]F�ya��[`TG\5!0202 8 �Ba�02 > %&�&82>�5)0B5)-/.f%&3/���G\5)0%&�45)-/'�;d�)��%�;/����;����%&82 'z�)E G\5 ��-/ %&82>�5)020 8 5)028���-/ .\'&87-���07��,5)020d>�5)��_d��-L-/5)-/�)%&x/_d �P02GH'��- *0*�� � � ���~} ��� O�i�i � ��V�V�< � AK{ W�W)W �Pl Y)Y�Y �

Page 141: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�~l!�

� �)Q) #`[%& �)�-9tu� � �)x/82�`T�x/-#�!|����T��- 3�8C5)-/.�"�5)���[82- � �bn,��3/�-U��a�02 > %&�&��-/87>�;/����;����%&82 '�)Ev��JT82./87(��.N>�5!�&_���-�-P5)-/�)%&x/_��'�� � ���} ��� O � ��� O�i�i � �B� � <j�:AK�

� � � Z��3/870282;#tf��n,��020782-/' � � �87%&3�*��45)./07 8 ��"�5!'45^�k'&3/87-��:5)GH8���5)-/.Z����rU�%&%&0��yaoJ[%4�& GM ��J 8 �)�-'��-/'�87%48w�[87% 8 �)E��07�> %&�&��-�82>�;/�&�);d ��%487�'g�)ET>�5)��_d�)-#-P5!-/�)%4x�_d '�� & � � O�� �@O��!l)�:VT{w�� Y �)�)l Y�Y�Y �

� � W Z���820C������'&3/> �&�)E %#5)-�.9�Z���I5��T87.$"����GM87-b� & ��� � � &Bi�h)i�O � ���} � �@}��u����0w%��g]^82-/ 3P5)��%5)-�.N�=87-/'�%&��-b�P� ! ����:V W �

� �:V� Z�Z� np� tF����-�3P5)GN�z`d� np� "N���45!%�%40j�����C����np� *,�45).�02 8 �,]F���Z��mB��82 -/.b� 5)-/.�����*p�����02GH�' ��a��H>�82 -:%�028���3:%�| �GH87%&%&82-��M./82�[./ '#_P5!'&�.9��-$;���0 8 GH���'Z�^8w%43�3/8"�)3$ 02�>�%4����-5��H-/8w%487�'�� � h)i �T�4O�� R W:� { W l!���b���� R �

� ���! � � � �T>@3/-�������Z�B*z5)'&'�02 ����*p�B��82 �))��5)-�.+tf�/�9 ��-/�� �z��3/�)%&�T> ��-/./x�> %487��-N82-N;d��0 8 ./8w|5)> % 8 02 -/\G�x/07%&820e5 8 ��I'�%&�&x/>�%4x/���'f5!-/.9'�82-���07u>�� 8 ' %@5)07'��g �[82.��-/> ME?���Z_P5)-/.[| %4��|k_P5)-�.KJ�> 87%45!%487��-b� � ���~} � &Bi h)i �y};& ��� � � ��� �P����{ W:� R �U��:V)���

� ���! � �g`T _P5)' %48e5!-$5!-/.$tu���9 82'& ��� �I-��|k.�82GH�-/'�82��-P5!0 �^87./f�-/ � � 8 _P5)-/./'I87-D5L;d��0 8 ./8w|5)> % 8 02 -/Z�& �)�5)07�.N_ 8 �02 > %&�&������P > %@5!-/>�!� � ���} ��� O � � � O�i�i � �PQ W {w��� �)W �U��������

� � Y � ��`[�_P5)' %4825)-�5)-/.�tf�v�$�82'��� �$a�07�> %&�&������P > %45)-/>��' %4x/./87�'f��-6%&3/L�JT> 87%4�)-182-6;�%&'5)-�.�./>@3�.�'&87-���07�>�� 8 ' %@5)07'�� : �PO � � � ���} � � W lT{�Q�QyVT�d��������

� ���� #tf��*p�B*,0e5!-/>@3/ %��bnp��]F�Bmo82-�>@3/�� �d5!-/.��#� �����2�)����^aoJT>�8w%@5!%&82��-�;/��� �P07FE?�)��;/3��)%4�!|�� -/��&5!%487��-��)Ev'&��0787%4�)-/'�82-�%&�45)-/'�|�<?>@3BAkJd� � ���} ��� O � �<� O�iji � � � ��{�lT� R lT�b���� R �

� �:l� � ��]��)%&3y_d � �/�F�I�I"�� .���xb�#�v������� ��^-/'& -/.b�u`��paC%4 G\5!.b�Z5)-/.�tf� � ��*z5)�!�� �mP�G#%4��'��>��)-/. . 8 -/5)GM87>�'=�)E$;/3/�)%&� �� -/��&5!%4 . '���028w%4��-/'=5!-/. ;���025)�&��-�'�82- %4�&5)-/'�|;���0 8 5)>��% 8 02�-�)� � ���~} ��� O � ��� O�iji � � W:� {w� Y�Y �b���� Y �

� � R #ro� �� 5)�&./ - 8 �g`T;��>�%4����'&> ��; 8 �!Eb;/3/�!%4�[�JT>�8w%@5!%&82��-/'�87-M;���0 8 5)> % 8 02 -/)� � ���� � � �PO���� �� ���} � & ��*0*�� � �b�)� R {S�:VT�b��)� R �

� �)Q) � �:�v5)�y_P5)()�Tnp�y�Z� � �)�y�#� �:�� 2�� ���y�I�����:��5 ��02 ���:5!-/.H���:"�>�*,�45)-�>@3b�b��5!%4x/����)E%&3/u;/�&87G\5)� 8 ;/3��)%4�[�JT>�8w%@5!%&82��-�'�82-D;���0 8 <j5!� 8 02 -/�|��T87- 8 07�-/ '@AK� & ���Pi � � +$O�i � � W Q/{�l)� � ���)�)Q/�

Page 142: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

�~l!�

� � � F�@���#��nz5)GH;/_d 020j�6�I�N�����p5 ��02 ���1��� � ��`[GM8w%43b�15!-/. ���v��mB �&�&5)�&87'�� ��8w|���> %\GM�5)'&x��&�GH�-:%M�)EI> ��-���x��:5�%4�.�;d�)0 8 GM �u�02 > %&�&��-/87>�KJT>�87%45!%487��-��-/ � ��87�'Hx/'&87-��GH %45)0��!;���0 8 GH����!GH %@5!0�' %4��x/> %&x/�& '�� � ���} ��� O � ��� O�iji � ��V W {w�� Y�Y �U���� W �

� � W Z]F���Z�T"�5)�&�y' � � �/"$�T�p5!0202' �y���[���/np�[*,�&5)./02 8 �T]Z�T�#�[mP�&87�-/.U��5)-�.\���T*p�T����07GM '����3/H;/3/�!%4�����0w%@5)87>��& '&;���-/'�M87-�;���0 8 <?;T|k;�3/�- 8 02 -/f�T87- 8 07�-/�Ap%43/87-T|��P07G .� �[82> �'�� � �� ���} ��� : ��� �[O���} � ++h)ijikO��K� W {7� R V)���U�����)Q/�

� �:V� #"$�B�� x/'&'��-b�d"$��`[>@3/�87./02 ���B5)-/.��#�B*,5)'&'�02�� �/& �!�Pi � � +�O�i � ��V R {7�~l R �b���� � �� ���! �C"$� � �-#�/� `d� ��0287-/'&�y8j� � � �9 8���]F�Ca��C*��-/-/ ����ro� �� 5!�&./ - 8 � m,��tIx/�/��5!-/.

`d�o"�5)( x/GH.P5)��� ��;�%&82>�5)0�;/�&��_��'#�)E�KJ�> 87%&�.6' %@5!%&�'�87-9;���0 8 <?;T|k;/3��- 8 02�-� �[82- 8 02 -/AK�� ���} ��� O � ��� O�i�i � ��V)lT{7� �)W �U�����)Q/�

� ���! Z� �utF�)GM '6.P5 n,��'�%45�5)-/. a��u"$�un,��-:���070�� aCJT> 87%4�)-/'s5)-/. %43� _P5)-/. �:5); 87-;���0 8 <?;/3/�- 8 02 -/F�T87- 8 07�-/�A�� � ���~} � � O � ��� �/Q:��{w���� R �U���� R �

� � Y�Y #ro��`T3yxP5)8j� � � ��*,�& .P5)' �s5)-/. ����� ��`Txb� ��5!%4x/�� �!E6;/3/�!%4�[�JT>�8w%@5!%&82��-/'=87-;���0 8 <?;P5)�45!;/3/�- 8 02 -/��[82- 8 02 -/A�5)-�.187%4'���028�����GH��&' � : �PO � � � ���~} �/� O�i�i � �,l)l)��{ R Y �����)�)Q/�

� � Y �� Z]F� � -/��Jd� � �PO����6� ��� ��� � � i ����} � & ��� � �.&Bi�h)ikO � ���} � �@}21 & � *0*��2O � O��Pi��)���p>�5)./ GM87>���& '&' �U�� � ! �)�&�B���� W R �

� � Y l� x/� ���-D��82-/( �5)-�.+�#�U�#� 5!cU!��a�02 > %&�&��-/ �:5!%&87�[87% 8 ��8j�B���&_/8w%@5)0g 02�>�%4����-/2��5!%48w�T8w% 8 �)E-/ x�%4�&5)0g5!%&��GM' � � � - � � : �PO � � & � � � �P�)Q�{ � Q Y �b�� W lT�

� � Y R Z��� �b]^��,!�#a��yxP5!%&82��-�' |k�!Ee|kGH�)%487��-�GM�%43/�[.+5)-/.q%&3/�KJT%&�-/.��.�'&3/ 020 GM�[./�0j� � O � �+ � � � � ���~} � �PQ Y {7� � R �U�� W ���

� � Y Q) ��� ��GM5)'&8�5)-�.6"$�g� ���'&82> �/�M"���07�>�x�0e5)�I87-y%&��&5)> %&82��-/'I87-D'&��07x�%487��-b{I5)-���� ���[82�� �)EGH %&3/�T.�'�_P5)'& .\��-u> ��-:%482-yx/�)x/'�./82' %4�&87_/x�%&82��-/'o�)Ed%&3/�'&�)07�� -:%�� : �PO � � � O � � �y�!Q/{ l Y l�VT���)�)Q/�

Page 143: thesis - Carnegie Mellon University · BNBXB K;BX3jORK;@#35BN3,BX3wy;@#y;BXhC2\OR@#yOR4 @ / @#hChC2+ k7 0

� R Y

� � Y:� #"$�������$��-��/� � ��*p���=82_��� �/��5!-/. "$��mP�&87'&>@3b� `T��� -y%� cd�>�%4'�� R �z%45)x�%4�)GM �&82> �[x�820287_/�&825��!cU����G\5!GM87./N5)-/.=l~| ; 8 ��82./�)-/�87- %43/ �:5)'\;�3P5)'&q5)-/. '&�)02x�%&82��-b� 5)-�5)_87-/87%&82��'�>���Eo'�%&x/. 8 � � � - � � : �PO � � & � � � �b�)��Q/{w� W Q � �d����:l[�

� � Y�W Z�Z� � � 87G��z]Z��*,8e5!-/>��/�z*p� �ztF ��%&-/�� �^5)-/. � �I�z� 8 -/ '�� � '&87GM;/07�_/5)'&87'\'&�%5);�;/�&�:5!>@3s%&�+'&��07x�%4L 02 > %4����-/87>\'�%&�&x/>�%4x/��N5)-/.1E?�& ��-/ � � 8 82-1'&�)02x�%&82��-b� � � � ���} �: �PO � � �P��VT{7�V�l R �d���� R �

� � Y V� I�=3/ -�%43�# 02�>�%4����-q5)-�.�3/��07Z5)�&Z��-�%&3/Z'45)GH#x�-/87%�>� 020j�������[�P%43/Z'&��07x�%4#5!%&��GM'5)��fx/-/>@3P5!� �� .65)-/.����87'I��yxP5)0C%&��� ��b��3/u_P5)'�82'�E?x/-�> %487��-/'������ �#5)-/.�������f5)��%&3/�-N82./ -:%482>�5)0�5)-�.�5)��F82-/> 02x/./ .���-/0 8 ��-/> Z87-L%43/F_P5)'�82' �

� � Y �! Z�Z�d��3/�)G\5)-�-b� � ��]F���I5)07%&��-b��"$�UtF�&5)_��~�^'��y8���5)-/.q�I�dnp�Un,0e5)���)!�Z� � ���} ��� O � ��� �R �){ R ��Q/���b��)� � �

� � Y �! #`d� � x/���T.P5N5)-/.9�#� `T3�82�45!�!5��,5���a�07�> %&�&��-[|k-yx/>�07�5)�F./�)x/_/02K|k���'&�)-P5)-/> \ �[87./�-/> HE?�)�%&3/F'&��0787%4�)-��z5����E?x/-/>�%482�)-�82-�;���0 8 5)>��% 8 02�-�)� � ���~} ��� O � �<� � R � {�� R � Y �d����:VT�

� ��� Y #"$��"N�3/��82-��/�P�#��tF��x/;/;b�B� �B����� ����5)-/.��#� � 5)'�'�����3/Z'�%&�&x/>�%4x/��#�)E %43�#'���028w%4��-L87-%&�45)-/'�|k;���0 8 5)>��% 8 02�-�){ 5H;�x/02'��.N�-/./�)��87-:���' %48��:5!%487��-b� & ���Pi � � +$O�i � ��l)��{ R �����d������T�

� ������ Z*p� � 87��%&G\5)-U�~"$���5)'45)-U�)5)-�.#����"$�~n,3/87;/GM5)-b�)`T��028w%4��-�'U82-I;���0 8 5)> % 8 02 -/){gGM5 ��-/�%482>3 8 ;d � �P-�Z> ��-/' %@5)-:%4'�E?����G 5)_L82-/8w%487�#>�5)02> x/0e5!%&82��-�'�� � � : �PO�� � � ���} � �P� � {�V W �)���d���������

� ���~l� F�#�o`[(�5)_��q5)-�.6�#� ��'�%&02x/-�.b� + � �[O��K��� ��h)�Pi ��� : �PO�� � }�i�� � 1 ���Pi���� � � ��i � ���1i � - � ���h)� �@O�� ���2O���i������ � � &Bij� ����i �[�4O � �PO����6��������� �������� ! �����������������