There are three things extremely hard: steel, a diamond, and to know one's self.

43
There are three things extremely hard: steel, a diamond, and to know one's self. Benjamin Franklin Poor Richard’s Almanac

description

There are three things extremely hard: steel, a diamond, and to know one's self. Benjamin Franklin Poor Richard’s Almanac. 1. Our primate selves. Gorillas in the Mist: The Story of Dian Fossey (original title) 1988. Huxley, 1863. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of There are three things extremely hard: steel, a diamond, and to know one's self.

Page 1: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

There are three things extremely hard:

steel, a diamond,

and to know one's self.

Benjamin FranklinPoor Richard’s Almanac

Page 2: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

1. Our primate selves

Gorillas in the Mist: The Story of Dian Fossey (original title)

1988

Page 3: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Huxley, 1863• "It is quite certain that the ape which

most nearly approaches man is either the Chimpanzee, or the Gorilla..." (p86).

Page 4: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Modern cladistics supports Huxley

• synapomorphies = elongated skulls, shortened but stout canine teeth, changes in upper jaw, fusion of certain bones in wrist, enlarged ovaries and mammary glands, changes in muscular anatomy

Page 5: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Sarich and Wilson, 1967•Injected rabbits with human serum albumin, let rabbits make anti-human antibodies•Removed blood serum from rabbits (with anti-human antibodies)•Mixed rabbit’s anti-human antibodies with purified serum albumin from humans and variety of other primates•ID increases among phylogenetically more distant relatives and at a constant rate through time; it is a sort of molecular clock

•Strongest immunological reaction to human, then chimp, then gorilla, then others.

•Concluded: Humans and chimps were nearest relatives and diverged 5 mya.

Page 6: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Sarich and Wilson, 1967

Page 7: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

• A host of molecular papers in the 1990’s said humans and chimps are the nearest relatives

• “Gorillas not in the midst”

Page 8: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

March 2011

Page 9: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

• Perelman et al., 2011:

• 34,927 bp• 54 nuclear genes • 191 taxa, including 186

primates representing 61 genera

• 90% of all primate genera

Page 10: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Perelman et al., 2011

6.6 mya8.3 mya

Page 11: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

From Perelman et al., 2011

Page 12: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 13: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Gracile Australopithecines

Page 14: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 15: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 16: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 17: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 18: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 19: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 20: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 21: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Robust Australopithecines

Page 22: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 23: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 24: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 25: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Early humans

Page 26: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 27: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 28: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 29: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Recent Humans

Page 30: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 31: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 32: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 33: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 34: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 35: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Some fossil species were contemporaries:These two species are both from

Koobi Fora, Kenya, 1.7 mya

Page 36: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 37: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.
Page 38: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Cladogram adding Ar. ramidus to images of gorilla, chimpanzee, and human, taken from the frontispiece of Evidence as to Man's Place in Nature, by Thomas Huxley

C O Lovejoy et al. Science 2009;326:73-106

Published by AAAS

Page 39: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

2. Out of Africa

Page 40: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Out of

AfricaDrift associated with migration should cause a reduction of genetic diversity as compared to an ancestral population…

Page 41: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

3. WhataboutNeandertals?

Page 42: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

2010http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bPWm58ACMtoStop at 5:20

Page 43: There are three  things extremely hard:  steel,  a diamond,  and to know one's self.

Homo neanderthalensis was distributed across Europe, the Middle East and Western Asia when Homo sapiens arrived 80,000 ya(The two species split ca. 270-440,000 ya)