The Scientific Trend in Indian Philosophy _ Sulekha Creative

8/11/2019 The Scientific Trend in Indian Philosophy _ Sulekha Creative

1/4

CreativeCreative The Scientific Trend In Indian PhilosophyThe Scientific Trend In Indian Philosophy

Rashmun / 5 yrs ago /

The Scientific Trend In Indian Philosophy

In Indian philosophy, the doctrine of sheer chance (called 'yadrccha' or 'akasmikatva') is

accepted by a section of the ancient Indian philosophers; according to this doctrine, pure

accident is the ultimate cause.

On the other hand, we also have in Indian philosophy a description of a doctrine called

'svabhava-vada' which is translated as 'doctrine of nature' or 'naturalism'.

According to the doctrine of yaddrchha, everything being fortuitous, it is futile to search for

any cause of the world, either natural or supernatural.

In contrast, according to svabhava-vada although the supernatural cause is illegitmate,

the natural cause is not so. In fact,according to svabhava-vada, the exclusive reality of

natural causation is the ground for the total rejection of the possibility of any supernatural

causation.

The two doctrines thus represent the alternative standpoints of pure scepticism

(yadrccha); and positive science(svabhava-vada) in which Nature by its own inherent

efficacy accounts for the origin and maintainance of the world.(Or, in other words,

svabhava-vada considers the concept of a first cause (God) over and above the natural

laws to be fictitious.)

Incidentially, both yadrccha and svabhava-vada are described in the Upanisads, but as

purva paksa (i.e. they are the views of the philosophical opponents of the Upanisadic

writers. See the Svetasvatara Upanisad i.1-2 and vi.1)

Adi Sankaracharya, while explaining svabhava-vada and yadrccha, writes (in his

commentary to the Svestasvatara Upanisad i.2):

By svabhava is meant the power invariably belonging to the material objects, as for

instance the radiation of heat by fire....by yadrccha is meant purely fortuitous origin.

By far the clearest description of svabhavavada is to be found in the writings of the 14

century Jain philosopher Gunaratna. In his Tarkarahasyadipika, Gunaratna writes:

The naturalists (svabhavavadinah) claim as follows. By svabhava is meant the

transformation of objects by themselves (i.e. because of their inherent nature).

Everything that exists comes into being because of the operation of svabhava.

Thus, for instance, earth is transformed into pot and not into cloth etc.From the

threads, again, is produced the cloth and not the pot, etc. Such regular occurrence

cannot happen without the operation of svabhavaTherefore, everything is to be

finally viewed as svabhava. So it is said:

'Who makes the thorn sharp?

And the beasts and birds so varied?

Alka GirdharMellowing Monsoons The rain fell incessantly in a continuousnoisy torrent, but its seemingly immaculatefall was a mere puppet in the hands ofangry gushing winds that made it sway thisway and that way, this way3 hrs ago

MeghnaVinodTHE LOVE OF MY LIFE IS HERE

THE LOVE OF MY LIFEBangalore. 13February. 6pm.Samiksha: It was raining.Raining hard. I could hear the raindropsfalling on our tilled roof pitter patter. I juststood there enjoying the slight3 hrs ago

TheBigThinkg BlogThe Lusty Love.. I looked at her longingly..There she was,probably with her little son next to her..I amnew to this village. I had come here withfour of my f riends. The sacrifice festival ofthis village is4 hrs ago

DhAmodharanpardhaeshi ! pardhaeshi !! jAnAnaheem!!! mujae choad kae !, mujaechoad kae !!. .. Hopefully, a BhArath-shaking real story !With the heady mix of train and raindescending on our poor Dhushyanth, thehero of this real story, name changed, whowAs really f eeling like an elated yAthri, inthat distant land of RAjAsthAn, without theproblems of daily life weighing on him, thebeat

Contest Entries (135)

Sign in | Register

Home TalkHome Talk Property BeatProperty Beat CreativeCreative Monsoon Romance - Short Story ContestMonsoon Romance - Short Story Contest

th

cientific Trend in Indian Philosophy | Sulekha Creative http://creative.sulekha.com/the-scientific-trend-in-indian-philosophy_412...

8/18/2014 11


2/4

All these come to being from svabhava.

There is none whose desire forms them;

what is the use of [postulating any supernatural] effort?'

'The thorns of the palm-tree are sharp,

Some of these are straight, some others

twisted. But its fruit is round.

Tell us, who has shaped these?'

Let alone the cases of other effects, even the boiling of beans (mudga) cannot occur

without svabhava. Moreover, in spite of the presence of the cooking-pot, fuel, time,

etc. the kanka-duka-mudga (stone chips resembling beans) cannot be boiled.

Therefore, that in the absence of which something does not originate is related by

agreement in presence (anvaya) and agreement in absence (vyatireka) to that

something and hence that something is due to it. [In the presence of svabhava,

something takes place; in the absence of svabhava, it does not take place. Hence,

svabhava is the cause of it.] Thus the boiling of mudga is to be viewed as due to

svabhava.Therefore, it is to be concluded that all these objects are caused by

svabhava.

In his book 'Outline of Indian Philosophy' [pgs 103-104], M.Hiriyanna renders the word

svabhava-vada as 'naturalism' and then observes that it rejects the idea that nature

reveals a divine power working behind it or indeed any transcendental being controlling it

or implicated in it; nor does svabhava-vada seek any supernatural sanction. He comments

further that svabhava-vada recognizes that

'things are as their nature makes them... it acknowledges the universality of

causality, but only traces all changes to the thing itself...hence, according to

svabhava-vada, it is not a law-less world in which we live, only there is no external

principle governing it. It is self-determined, not undetermined....What needs tonoticed about it first is its positivistic character which is implied by the contrast that

is sometimes drawn between it and the adrstavada or 'belief in the supernatural'.

From what we understand of svabha-vavada, in its earliest stage, it was apparently some

form of an independent world-view without any rigid affiliation to any philosophical system.

In the later development of Indian philosophy, such an affiliation grew amongst those

philosophies which saw in its naturalism a distinct possibility of fortifying their own

philosophical positions, particularly against the theists and their doctrine of the creation of

the world by a divine agency. This is obvious in the case of Sankhya and

Lokayata/Charvaka, and it can be argued that it was also the case for the ancient Indian

atomists ; in all presumption, therefore, these philosophies were science-motivated.In what follows, i wish to focus on svabhava-vada in Sankhya philosophy.Nilakantha, the

traditional commentator on the Mahabharata, categorically declared that the doctrine of

svabhava was that of the Sankhyas. Gaudapada and Vachaspati Mishra, in their

commentary on the Sankhya Karika, also admit that that according to the Sankhyas there

was a cause in the form of svabhava.

Adi Sankara clearly explained why this admission of cause in the form of svabhava was

logically necessary for the Sankhya philosophers. These philosophers, said Adi Sankara,

would have argued thus (Adi Sankara on Brahma Sutra ii.2,3 and ii.2,5; in what follows,

pradhana= prakriti = primeval matter in Sankhya terminology)

7 hrs ago

NovelideasSPEECHLESS I waitfor this distant horizonto gatherscattered petalsof crimson glory from itscanvassinto a spongy blanketbillowing tospread its wingswith the whispering zephyrIwishnow to be let into those8 hrs ago

Chitra ViswanathanThe magic of the rain after a storm Swetha, are you ready asked hermother, Prema. It is getting late. It will notbe nice if we go late to receive Venkatesh.They all got into the car. There was great8 hrs ago

TriptiAll I want is you.. 26th June, 2014 Mumbai 18:30hours"Feeling numb." "As I pen this down,I''m sitting closer to the entrance, staringoutside my tent so that the wetness hits me.I''m not enjoying it,8 hrs ago

Shalini PrasadThe Magic the Rain Brings - Part 3

This year, people expected a lot of rain. Tosay that they were disappointed would bean understatement. The monsoon seasonwas as dry as the summer. The farmerswere suffering, the lakes were10 hrs ago

ArunaIn Reference To Monsoon RomanceContest To day is the day of birth day ofKrishna.How we can forget him when wetalk of romance here.He gave a new look tolove. Radha was his lady love though henever married to her.When we are facing1 day ago

Nandini DekaThat Monsoon..... Ah the rain is here! While the little tinklingdroplets of rain splatter the rooftop, thehumming of the cuckoo birds and the coolbreezy wind brushing your face. Have youever tried walking in1 day ago

More ArticlesThe Five Best Treks In Himachal Pradesh byPavane Mann

Mellowing Monsoons by Alka Girdhar

Poonchhe by Charumati Ramdas


8/18/2014 11


3/4

As unconscious milk flows forth from its own nature (svabhavena eva) merely for

the nourishment of the young animal, and as unconscious water, from its own

nature (svabhavena eva) flows along for the benefit of mankind, so the pradhana

also, though unconscious, may be supposed to move from its own highest nature

(svabhavena eva) merely for the purpose of effecting the highest end of man....

Just as grass, herbs,water,etc. independently of any other instrumental cause

(nimitta antara nirapeksa) transform themselves, by their own nature (svabhavat

eva) into milk, so we assume, the pradhana also transforms itself into the GreatPrinciple (Mahat) and so on. And, if you ask how we know that grass transforms

itself independently of any instrumental cause, we reply 'Because no such cause is

observed.' For, if we did perceive some such cause, we certainly should apply it to

grass, etc. according to our liking, and thereby produce milk. But, as a matter of

fact, we do no such thing. Hence, the transformation of grass and the like must be

considered to be due to its own nature merely, and we may infer therefrom that the

transformation of the pradhana is of the same kind.

Adi Sankara's own rebuttal of Svabhava vada is hardly satisfactory. Argues Adi Sankara:

grass becomes milk only when it is eaten by a cow or some other female animal, not

if it is left either uneaten or is eaten by a bull. If the transformation had no special

cause, grass would become milk even on other conditions than that of entering a

cow's body

And further, that:

men are also able, by applying a means in their power, to produce milk from grass

and herbs: for when they wish to produce a more abundant supply of milk they feed

the cow more plentifully and thus obtain more milk from her.

In the arguments of Adi Sankara (in which he seeks to refute svabhava-vada), the crucial

axiom of svabhava-vada has been somewhat distorted by him.

The question is, whether it is necessary to postulate any extra-natural cause, over andabove the merely natural, to explain changes and modifications.The evidence of the

necessity of the physiological apparatus of the female animal (for milk production) does

not indicate any extra-natural cause.

From the point of view of svabhava vada, the cause of milk would not be grass as such

but the entire natural complex consisting of gras-as-eaten-by-the-cow.Svabhava vada can

only be refuted on the basis of the demonstration that some further spiritual factor is

necessary for the causation of milk.

That men can get a more abundant supply of milk by feeding the cow more plentifully

only proves that man can attain mastery over nature only by recognizing the laws of

nature.

To sum up: The doctrine of svabhava remains of considerable interest because we see in

it a distinct tendency to oppose the theistic assumption from the point of view of positive

science. In the clash between the 'doctrine of God' and 'the doctrine of Nature' we have

perhaps the first glimpse of the conflict between religion and science that took place in

Indian history.

The Love Of My Life by MeghnaVinod

What Did Krshna Mean When He Said I Am Time

(Kaal) by Suresh Rao


8/18/2014 11


4/4

General

Post a Comment

Submit

All Comments

Corporate

About UsContact UsMeet Our UsersSulekha RivrMedia CoverageAds/CommercialsCareers/JobsAdvertise onSulekhaTerms/ConditionsPrivacy Policy

Copyright Policy

Top Domains

Yellow PagesProperty/RentalsRoommates/Home StayBuy/SellCars/BikesHome NeedsOffice NeedsMobilesDealsEducationMovies

Top Cities(India)

BangaloreChennaiDelhiMumbaiHyderabadPuneKolkataAhmedabadChandigarhCoimbatore

Cochin

Top Cities(US)

AustinAtlantaBay AreaBostonChicagoLos AngelesNew JerseyNew YorkToronto

Follow Us

Download yourSulekha.com app now!

2014 CopyrightSulekha.comAll Rights Reserved.


8/18/2014 11

The Scientific Trend in Indian Philosophy _ Sulekha Creative

Documents

Transcript of The Scientific Trend in Indian Philosophy _ Sulekha Creative