The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the...

46
The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto Associate Director, Centre for Patient Safety University of Toronto NICHQ 2010

Transcript of The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the...

Page 1: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks

Anne Matlow MD FRCPC

Medical Director, Patient Safety

Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto

Associate Director, Centre for Patient Safety

University of Toronto

NICHQ 2010

Page 2: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

DISCLOSURE

I am Canadian

Page 3: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

And I won’t rub it in!!!

Page 4: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks

Anne Matlow MD FRCPC

Medical Director, Patient Safety

Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto

Associate Director, Centre for Patient Safety

University of Toronto

NICHQ 2010

Page 5: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Trigger tool

Page 6: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

9 year old girl. Fell out of bed. Presented to ER with decreased level of consciousness and hypertension. Admitted to PICU. Management focused on determining cause of lethargy (CT, MRI) and treating hypertension. Nephrology consulted when BP still elevated. Elicited history from Mom of periorbital edema. Diagnosis post- infectious glomerulonephritis with hypertension and encephalopathy. On review, proteinuria and hematuria present on admission. Improved on antihypertensives and low sodium diet.

Page 7: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Country Charts Reviewed

Year Incidence of AE Preventable

Canada 3,745 2000 7.5% 37%

Denmark 1,097 1999 9.0% 40.4%

New Zealand 6,579 1998 12.9% 37%

England 1,014 1998 11.7% 50%

Australia 14,000 1992 16.6% 51%

USA (Utah &

Colorado)15,000 1992 2.9% -

USA (NY) 30,121 1984 3.7% 58%

Page 8: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

1. Unplanned admission pre2. Unplanned readmit within

12 months3. Hospital incurred injury4. Adverse drug event5. Unplanned transfer to ICU6. Unplanned transfer to

another acute care hosp7. Unplanned return to OR8. Unplanned removal, injury

or repair intra-operatively9. Other patient complications

10.New neurological deficit11.Unexpected death12. Inappropriate discharge home13.Cardiac/ resp arrest / low

APGAR score14. Injury related to delivery or

abortion15.Hospital acquired infection/

sepsis16.Documented dissatisfaction

with care17.Documentation or

correspondence re litigation18.Any other undesirable

outcomes

SCREENING/EXPLICIT CRITERIA

Page 9: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 10: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Detecting Adverse Events

Method AE/1000 admissions

Incident Reports (2-8%) 5Retrospective Chart Review 30Stimulated Voluntary Reports 30Automated Flags 55*Daily chart review 85Automated Flags and Daily review 130*

*triggers

Jha J Am Med Inf Assoc 1998;5:305 O'Neil Ann Int Med 1993;119:370 Original slide courtesy of Dr Philip Hebert

Page 11: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

• Manual – Paper-based retrospective chart review

• Semi-automated– Screening electronically + review manually– Prospective, Concurrent, Retrospective

• Fully automated– Screening + reviewing electronically– Only some types of AEs

• e.g. INR>6 in pts on warfarin, ICD-9 codes

– Not if implicit judgement is required

Page 12: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Voluntary reporting and computerized surveillance not as good as chart review

Manual Chart Manual Chart ReviewReview

367

Computerized Computerized SurveillanceSurveillance

331 205

20

Voluntary Voluntary ReportingReporting

Classen DC, Pestotnik S. Evans S et al. Computerized surveillance of adverse drug events in hospitalized patients. JAMA. 1991;226:2847

Page 13: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 14: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Sensitivity of routine system for reporting patient safety incidents in an NHS hospital: retrospective patient case note review Sari BMJ  2007;334:79

• 324 patient safety incidents were identified in 230/1006 admissions (22.9%; 95% CI 20.3% to 25.5%).

• 270 (83%) patient safety incidents were identified by case note review (TT) only,

• 21 (7%) by the routine reporting system only, and 33 (10%) by both methods. – TT 12x more sensitive than routine reporting

system

Page 15: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Trigger Tool 2 stage ReviewTrigger Tool 2 stage Review

TRIGGERS ADVERSE EVENTS

Page 16: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Rate of Adverse Events without using Trigger Tools

–All adverse events: ~1.0-3 / 100 patients

(Miller Pediatrics 2003 and 2004; Slonim Pediatrics 2003; Woods Pediatrics 2005; )

–Adverse drug events: • True: 2.1-11/ 100 admissions • Potential: ADE 14.6/ 100 admissions

• 22-60% preventable (Kaushal JAMA 2001; Holdsworth APAM 2003; Kunac Pediatric Drugs 2009)

Page 17: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Adverse Events in the NICU Sharek et al. Pediatrics. 2006:118:1332-1340

n=55474 per 100 admissions of which 56% preventable

Page 18: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 19: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 20: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Incidence of Adverse Events and Negligence in Hospitalized Patients

Brennan NEJM 1991

Page 21: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 22: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Adverse events and preventable adverse events in children Woods Peds 2005:115:155

Page 23: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Adverse events and preventable adverse events in children Woods D. Pediatrics. 2005 Jan;115:155-60.

Page 24: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Quality in Australian Health Care StudyWilson Med J Aust 1995

Page 25: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 26: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Diagnostic errors are commoncause of adverse events

De Vries QSHC 2008; Soop IJQHC 2009

AE rate DiagnosticNY 1984 3.7% 7%Utah/Col 1992 2.9% 6.9%Australia 1992 16.6% 13.3%NZ 1998 13.1% 8%UK 1999 10.8% 4.2%Canada 2001 7.5% 10.6%Sweden 2003 14.2% 11.3%

Page 27: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 28: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 29: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 30: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

DIAGNOSTIC ERROR Graber Arch Int Med 2005

Occurrences for which diagnosis was

1. Unintentionally delayed (sufficient info was available earlier),

2. Wrong (another diagnosis was made before the correct diagnosis), or

3. Missed (no diagnosis was ever made),

as judged from the eventual appreciation of more definitive information

Page 31: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

CAN TRIGGER TOOLS HELP US IDENTIFY DIAGNOSTIC

ERROR?

Page 32: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 33: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 34: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 35: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 36: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Sensitivity and Specificity of the Canadian Paediatric Trigger Tool

Adverse Event

Trigger Yes No Total

Yes 78 283 361 (60%)

No 11 219 230

Total 89 (15%) 502 591

89 patients experienced at least 1 AE

Page 37: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Clinical Care Process vs #AE

Surgical 50

Medical Procedure 16

Diagnostic 14

Clinical management 10

Drug/Fluid 10

Fractures 1

System Issue 1

Other

Total number of AEs

21

123

Page 38: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Clinical Care Process vs #AE

Surgical 50

Medical Procedure 16

Diagnostic 14

Clinical management 10

Drug/Fluid 10

Fractures 1

System Issue 1

Other

Total number of AEs

21

123

11.4% of adverse events were diagnostic

Page 39: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Distribution of AEs by Age Category

Surg Med Proc

Diag Clin Man

D/ FL Other

0-28 d 18 11 4 9 2 12

29- 365 d 11 2 4 0 1 9

366 d-

5 yr14 0 3 0 6 1

>5 yr 7 3 3 1 1 1

Total # AEs

50 16 14 10 10 23

Page 40: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

DIAGNOSTIC ERROR

Delayed diagnosis of post streptococcal glomerulonephritis in 9 year old. Presented with

hypertension and decreased level of consciousness.

Work up focused on neurological findings. Diagnosis actually glomerulonephritis with hypertension

and encephalopathy. Delay in initiating appropriate treatment. Improved on antihypertensives and

low sodium diet.

Page 41: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

CAN TRIGGER TOOLS HELP US IDENTIFY DIAGNOSTIC

ERROR?

METHODOLOGY DEPENDENT

Page 42: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

CPTT

Page 43: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.
Page 44: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Two types of Second stage review

Focused Chart Review- Facilitates standardized

second phase chart review

- More efficient- Better to show

improvement over time?

Complete Chart Review- ? Finds more AEs?- ? Can find different AEs eg

diagnostic error?

Page 45: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

FOCUSING ON DIAGNOSTIC ERROR WILL FILL IN A BLANK

Page 46: The Role of Trigger Tools in Detecting Adverse Events in Hospitalized Children: Filling in the Blanks Anne Matlow MD FRCPC Medical Director, Patient Safety.

Preventing DVT in Hospitalized Patients

Preventing DVT in Hospitalized Patients

Normal growth Rafat Mosalli MBBS FRCPC FAAP Rafat Mosalli MBBS FRCPC FAAP 5Th Year Medical students.

Normal growth Rafat Mosalli MBBS FRCPC FAAP Rafat Mosalli MBBS FRCPC FAAP 5Th Year Medical students.

Treatment of COVID-19 in the Hospitalized Patient of COVID-19 in the Hospitalized... · Treatment of COVID-19 in the Hospitalized Patient Michelle Harkins, MD Pulmonary/Critical Care

Treatment of COVID-19 in the Hospitalized Patient of COVID-19 in the Hospitalized... · Treatment of COVID-19 in the Hospitalized Patient Michelle Harkins, MD Pulmonary/Critical Care

Marc Carrier, MD, MSc, FRCPC

Marc Carrier, MD, MSc, FRCPC

Sleep Deprivation in Hospitalized Patients

Sleep Deprivation in Hospitalized Patients

Hospitalized child by Jinesh TM

Hospitalized child by Jinesh TM

Preparing a Written Report Prepared by: R Bortolussi MD FRCPC and Noni MacDonald MD FRCPC.

Preparing a Written Report Prepared by: R Bortolussi MD FRCPC and Noni MacDonald MD FRCPC.

Play Therapy With Hospitalized Children

Play Therapy With Hospitalized Children

Prophylaxis for Hospitalized and Non-Hospitalized Medical ...

Prophylaxis for Hospitalized and Non-Hospitalized Medical ...

Sleep in the Hospitalized Patient

Sleep in the Hospitalized Patient

Documentation requirements of hospitalized patients

Documentation requirements of hospitalized patients

Samuel Law MDCM; FRCPC

Samuel Law MDCM; FRCPC

Exploring Communication Options When Hospitalized

Exploring Communication Options When Hospitalized

Substance abuse comorbidity in hospitalized psychiatric patients Population – 470 consequently admitted hospitalized patients Kfar Shaul – 250 patients.

Substance abuse comorbidity in hospitalized psychiatric patients Population – 470 consequently admitted hospitalized patients Kfar Shaul – 250 patients.

Care of the Hospitalized Child

Care of the Hospitalized Child

CanadianJournalofDiabetes · 2018ClinicalPracticeGuidelines DiabetesandPregnancy DiabetesCanadaClinicalPracticeGuidelinesExpertCommittee DeniceS.FeigMD,FRCPC,HowardBergerMD,LoisDonovanMD,FRCPC

CanadianJournalofDiabetes · 2018ClinicalPracticeGuidelines DiabetesandPregnancy DiabetesCanadaClinicalPracticeGuidelinesExpertCommittee DeniceS.FeigMD,FRCPC,HowardBergerMD,LoisDonovanMD,FRCPC

US Flu VE Network and US Hospitalized Adult Influenza ... Hospitalized Adult Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness Network ... age, sex, race/ethnicity, self ... US Hospitalized Adult Influenza

US Flu VE Network and US Hospitalized Adult Influenza ... Hospitalized Adult Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness Network ... age, sex, race/ethnicity, self ... US Hospitalized Adult Influenza

Public Health Risk Assessment Bonnie Henry, MD, FRCPC Doug Sider, MD, FRCPC Public health CBRN course.

Public Health Risk Assessment Bonnie Henry, MD, FRCPC Doug Sider, MD, FRCPC Public health CBRN course.

THE HOSPITALIZED ELDERLY PATIENT

THE HOSPITALIZED ELDERLY PATIENT

Martin Gignac, MD, FRCPC

Martin Gignac, MD, FRCPC