TATIONpRÆSEN

AARHUSUNIVERSITY

The Role of the Literature Review

TINE WIRENFELDT JENSENCENTER FOR TEACHING DEVELOPMENT & DIGITAL MEDIAAARHUS UNIVERSITY

1

2

AARHUSUNIVERSITY

3

AARHUSUNIVERSITY

A RUBRIC FOR THE QUALITY OF A LITERATURE REVIEW In pairs: look at Lovitts general criteria for a literature review and discuss how these relate to your field

4

AARHUSUNIVERSITY

OUTSTANDING LITERATURE REVIEWS

Identifies and organizes analysis around themes or conceptual categories

Lovitts, 2007

5

AARHUSUNIVERSITY

DEMONSTRATING ORIGINALITY› Requires knowledge of the subject area› Requires a spirit of adventure (a willingness to explore new areas)

Hart, 1998

6

AARHUSUNIVERSITY

MAPPING AND ANALYSING IDEASMapping […] enables analysis and synthesis to be undertaken; in mapping work on a topic, you undertake the task of construction, putting together the different strands and elements of work that make up a body of knowledge on the subject.

Hart, p. 142

7

AARHUSUNIVERSITY

A REFLEXIVE ATTITUDEWe need to take a technical and reflexive attitude to classification, seeking to produce a symmetry between organizing ideas in the literature and thinking about how we have carried out that organizing.

Hart, p. 14

8

AARHUSUNIVERSITY

DIFFERENT TYPES OF MAPS› Feature maps› Tree constructions› Content maps› Taxonomic maps› Rhetorical mapping and analysis› Citation mapping and analysis

› Mindmapping› Building a case for your approach› Your own categories and ways to model relationships between them

› Drawing as a method

9

AARHUSUNIVERSITY

REFERENCES › Hart C. (1998) Doing a literature review: releasing the social science

research imagination. Sage Publications

› Lovitss B. (2007) Making the Implicit Explicit. Stylus.

› The Study Metro. http://studiemetro.au.dk/en/.