The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen...

30
The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske 2nd NEON summer archive school 08.09.2006

Transcript of The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen...

Page 1: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs

(UCDs)

The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs

(UCDs)

Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela

Tutor: Steffen Mieske

Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela

Tutor: Steffen Mieske

2nd NEON summer archive school08.09.2006

Page 2: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

OutlineOutline

IntroductionPhotometric search for UCD candidates UCD candidates in Abell 1689:

spectroscopic follow-upRedshift determination and results

IntroductionPhotometric search for UCD candidates UCD candidates in Abell 1689:

spectroscopic follow-upRedshift determination and results

Page 3: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

IntroductionIntroduction

Page 4: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

The search for the smallest galaxies starts

The search for the smallest galaxies starts

Where do we start looking for them?

We have a clue :

Ultra compact dwarfs in galaxy clusters

Page 5: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Early types family albumEarly types family album

M87: ~7kpc Globular cluster: ~3pc

dE: ~700pc

Page 6: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Brightness/size distributionBrightness/size distribution

Page 7: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

How are UCDs created?How are UCDs created?

Zur Anzeige wird der QuickTime™ Dekompressor „Cinepak“

benötigt.

Page 8: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Two formations scenarios:

1. Compact remnants of tidally stripped galaxies (Bekki et al. 2003)2. Merged stellar super clusters (Fellhauer & Kroupa 2002)

Observations & simulations: stellar super clusters have masses <108 Msun

Idea: Search for very luminous UCDs that are too massive to be explained by merged star clusters. If found, support for „galaxian origin“ of at least some UCDs.

Where? Search in very massive galaxy clusters!

Two formations scenarios:

1. Compact remnants of tidally stripped galaxies (Bekki et al. 2003)2. Merged stellar super clusters (Fellhauer & Kroupa 2002)

Observations & simulations: stellar super clusters have masses <108 Msun

Idea: Search for very luminous UCDs that are too massive to be explained by merged star clusters. If found, support for „galaxian origin“ of at least some UCDs.

Where? Search in very massive galaxy clusters!

How are UCDs created?How are UCDs created?

Page 9: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Photometric search for UCD candidatesPhotometric search for UCD candidates

Page 10: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Abell 1689: A massive Galaxy ClusterAbell 1689: A massive Galaxy Cluster

RA 13:11:34.2 Dec -01:21:56z = 0.183 (m-M) = 39.7Distance ~ 700MpcDiameter ~ 6.5Mpc

Mass ~ 2*(10^15) M⊙

RA 13:11:34.2 Dec -01:21:56z = 0.183 (m-M) = 39.7Distance ~ 700MpcDiameter ~ 6.5Mpc

Mass ~ 2*(10^15) M⊙ (NED; Broadhurst et al. 2005)

Page 11: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Photometric Search for UCD candidates in Abell 1689

Photometric Search for UCD candidates in Abell 1689

HST/ACS drizzled griz images from June 2002 PSF FWHM = 0.1'' (2 pixels) --> 300pc. UCDs are unresolved! Source detection and extraction with SExtractor

HST/ACS drizzled griz images from June 2002 PSF FWHM = 0.1'' (2 pixels) --> 300pc. UCDs are unresolved! Source detection and extraction with SExtractor

Page 12: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Candidate SelectionCandidate Selection

Detected on all bands group A: SExtractor independently on all 4 bands, 5 group B: SExtractor in dual detection, 10

class_stargroup A: class_star > 0.1 in all 4 bandsgroup B: class_star > 0.5 in at least 1 band

FWHMgroup A: FWHM < 2*PSF in all bandsgroup B: FWHM < 2*PSF in i band

i < 26.5 Colour cuts + photo-z (next slide)

Detected on all bands group A: SExtractor independently on all 4 bands, 5 group B: SExtractor in dual detection, 10

class_stargroup A: class_star > 0.1 in all 4 bandsgroup B: class_star > 0.5 in at least 1 band

FWHMgroup A: FWHM < 2*PSF in all bandsgroup B: FWHM < 2*PSF in i band

i < 26.5 Colour cuts + photo-z (next slide)

Page 13: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Dots: resolved sources

Page 14: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Group AGroup B

Page 15: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

2 UCD candidates marginally resolved!Reff few 100 pc, Mz~-17 mag if at cluster distance

Page 16: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Spectroscopicfollow-up

Spectroscopicfollow-up

Page 17: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

UCD candidates in Abell 1689spectroscopic follow-up

UCD candidates in Abell 1689spectroscopic follow-up

redshift ESO ARCHIVE:search for spectroscopic data VLT telescope spectrograph: all available data were taken with

the FORS2 spectrograph (MXU) Type of files you get:

- acquisition

- flat field

- bias

- science

redshift ESO ARCHIVE:search for spectroscopic data VLT telescope spectrograph: all available data were taken with

the FORS2 spectrograph (MXU) Type of files you get:

- acquisition

- flat field

- bias

- science

Page 18: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

THE INSTRUMENT: FORS2THE INSTRUMENT: FORS2

field of view 7'x7' (2048x2048 pix) GRISM GRIS_150I MOS MODE (MXU)

field of view 7'x7' (2048x2048 pix) GRISM GRIS_150I MOS MODE (MXU)

Page 19: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

DATA REDUCTIONDATA REDUCTION

bias subtraction image combination candidates search

list a) :12 photometric candidates => 4 have spectra list b) :20 photometric candidates => 3 have spectra

spectrum of brightest candidate (z = 21.95; Mz= -17.8 mag):

bias subtraction image combination candidates search

list a) :12 photometric candidates => 4 have spectra list b) :20 photometric candidates => 3 have spectra

spectrum of brightest candidate (z = 21.95; Mz= -17.8 mag):

Page 20: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

SPECTRA EXTRACTIONSPECTRA EXTRACTION

spatial cut (y direction): 1D spectra:spatial cut (y direction): 1D spectra:

Page 21: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

WAVELENGTH CALIBRATIONWAVELENGTH CALIBRATION

extract the 1D spectra from the wavelength calibration lampspectra using the same trace from the candidate spectra

extract the 1D spectra from the wavelength calibration lampspectra using the same trace from the candidate spectra

Page 22: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Page 23: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Redshift determination and

Results

Redshift determination and

Results

Page 24: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Spectroscopic Redshift determinationSpectroscopic Redshift determination

locate the prominent H&K break for CaK: 3933.663 A0 for CaH: 3968.468 A

locate the prominent H&K break for CaK: 3933.663 A0 for CaH: 3968.468 A

Page 25: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Redshift determination cont.Redshift determination cont.

measure the center of each of the 2 absorption lines in our calibrated spectra

calculate the redshift:

measure the center of each of the 2 absorption lines in our calibrated spectra

calculate the redshift:

z =λ − λ 0

λ 0

Page 26: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Final resultsFinal results

candidate 13:11:32.56 - 01:19:50.61 13:11:32.91 - 01:19:24.22 ________________________________________________________

redshift 0.18781 ± 0.0003 0.20640 ± 0.0005

Mz -17.75 -17.25

Lsun 5.0*108 3.2*108

Msun 1.5*109 9.5*108

candidate 13:11:32.56 - 01:19:50.61 13:11:32.91 - 01:19:24.22 ________________________________________________________

redshift 0.18781 ± 0.0003 0.20640 ± 0.0005

Mz -17.75 -17.25

Lsun 5.0*108 3.2*108

Msun 1.5*109 9.5*108

Page 27: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Luminosity <-> sizeLuminosity <-> size

UCDs in Fornax

Page 28: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

Luminosity <-> sizeLuminosity <-> size

UCDs in Fornax

Page 29: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

SummarySummary

We discovered two UCDs with masses ~ 10 times higher than merged star cluster limit in Abell 1689.

Support for galaxian origin of (some) UCDs.

We discovered two UCDs with masses ~ 10 times higher than merged star cluster limit in Abell 1689.

Support for galaxian origin of (some) UCDs.

Page 30: The Quest for Ultra compact dwarfs (UCDs) Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen Mieske Guillermo, Melanie, Emanuela, Micaela Tutor: Steffen.

September 8th 2006 2nd NEON archive summer school

OutlookOutlook

Spectroscopic follow up of fainter UCD candidates.Spectroscopic follow up of fainter UCD candidates.