The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern...

33
Felix Flicker The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics

Transcript of The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern...

Page 1: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Felix Flicker

The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics

Page 2: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid
Page 3: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

ParadoxesTwo lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid premises,

lead to an apparent contradiction

Page 4: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

ParadoxesTwo lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid premises,

lead to an apparent contradiction

Veridical Falsidical

Antinomy

YIELDS A FALSEHOODYIELDS A TRUTH

Page 5: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

ParadoxesTwo lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid premises,

lead to an apparent contradiction

Veridical Falsidical

Antinomy

YIELDS A FALSEHOOD

Dialetheia

YIELDS A TRUTH

Page 6: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Veridical Paradoxes

Page 7: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Hilbert's Paradox of the Grand Hotel

Page 8: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Hilbert's Paradox of the Grand Hotel

Page 9: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid
Page 10: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Erwin Schrödinger

Page 11: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Erwin Schrödinger

Page 12: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

stable unstable

Page 13: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Gömböc

Page 14: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Gömböc Indian Star Tortoise

Page 15: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Falsidical Paradoxes

Page 16: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid
Page 17: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Albert Einstein Boris Podolsky Nathan Rosen

Page 18: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Penrose Stairs Penrose Triangle

Page 19: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid
Page 20: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Antinomy

Page 21: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Dialetheia

Page 22: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Korean Dharma Combat Koans

(from Ten Gates, The Kong-an Teaching of Zen Master Seung Sahn)

Page 23: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Korean Dharma Combat Koans

(from Ten Gates, The Kong-an Teaching of Zen Master Seung Sahn)

Master

Student

Page 24: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Korean Dharma Combat Koans

(from Ten Gates, The Kong-an Teaching of Zen Master Seung Sahn)

Master

Student

What is the way of Nam Cheon?

Page 25: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Korean Dharma Combat Koans

(from Ten Gates, The Kong-an Teaching of Zen Master Seung Sahn)

Master

Student

What is the way of Nam Cheon?

This sickle cost me thirty cents!

Page 26: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Korean Dharma Combat Koans

(from Ten Gates, The Kong-an Teaching of Zen Master Seung Sahn)

Master

Student

What is the way of Nam Cheon?

This sickle cost me thirty cents!

I didn't ask you about your sickle!

Page 27: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Korean Dharma Combat Koans

(from Ten Gates, The Kong-an Teaching of Zen Master Seung Sahn)

Master

Student

What is the way of Nam Cheon?

This sickle cost me thirty cents!

I didn't ask you about your sickle!

The dog runs after the bone.

Page 28: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Korean Dharma Combat Koans

(from Ten Gates, The Kong-an Teaching of Zen Master Seung Sahn)

Master

Student

What is the way of Nam Cheon?

This sickle cost me thirty cents!

I didn't ask you about your sickle!

The dog runs after the bone.

Is this correct?

Page 29: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Korean Dharma Combat Koans

(from Ten Gates, The Kong-an Teaching of Zen Master Seung Sahn)

Master

Student

What is the way of Nam Cheon?

This sickle cost me thirty cents!

I didn't ask you about your sickle!

The dog runs after the bone.

Is this correct?

A second offence is not permitted.

Page 30: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Korean Dharma Combat Koans

(from Ten Gates, The Kong-an Teaching of Zen Master Seung Sahn)

Master

Student

What is the way of Nam Cheon?

This sickle cost me thirty cents!

I didn't ask you about your sickle!

The dog runs after the bone.

Is this correct?

A second offence is not permitted.

Oh, Wonderful!

Page 31: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Niels Bohr

Page 32: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

ParadoxesYIELDS A

FALSEHOODY

IELDS

ATRUT

H

Veridical Falsidical

Antinomy

Dialetheia

Page 33: The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics - Felix Flicker · The Puzzling Paradoxes of Modern Physics. Paradoxes Two lines of seemingly-sound reasoning, following from seemingly-valid

Thanks for listening!

Jenny Steer for photographing the Exeter Book

Stuart MacWilliam, Assistant Librarian, Exeter Cathedral Library

Megan Cavell for translating Exeter Book passages

David Beadle, Jack Winter, Leo Tarasov, John Holme, John Hannay, and James Arnold for many helpful discussions

Many thanks to:

Nick Diao for calculating the double pendulum solution