Securing Privileged Accounts with Hitachi ID Privileged Access Manager
THE PRIVILEGED LINK: OPEN ACCESS, VERSION OF RECORD, OR ... · THE PRIVILEGED LINK: OPEN ACCESS,...
44
THE PRIVILEGED LINK: OPEN ACCESS, VERSION OF RECORD, OR LET THE USER DECIDE? Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe, Professor/Librarian, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Aaron Tay, Library Analytics Manager, Singapore Management University Johan Tilstra, Chief Executive Officer, Lean Library Maria Aghazarian, Digital Resources and Scholarly Communications Specialist, Swarthmore College #CNI18s #privilegedlink
Transcript of THE PRIVILEGED LINK: OPEN ACCESS, VERSION OF RECORD, OR ... · THE PRIVILEGED LINK: OPEN ACCESS,...
THEPRIVILEGEDLINK:OPENACCESS,VERSIONOFRECORD,
ORLETTHEUSERDECIDE?
LisaJanickeHinchliffe,Professor/Librarian,UniversityofIllinoisatUrbana-ChampaignAaronTay,LibraryAnalyticsManager,SingaporeManagementUniversity
JohanTilstra,ChiefExecutiveOfficer,LeanLibraryMariaAghazarian,DigitalResourcesandScholarlyCommunicationsSpecialist,SwarthmoreCollege
#CNI18s#privilegedlink
WHYTHISSESSION?
LisaJanickeHinchliffe
lisahinchliffe.com
@lisalibrarian
#CNI18s#privilegedlink
ManyVersions….
• AO=Author’sOriginal
• SMUR=SubmittedManuscriptUnderReview
• AM=AcceptedManuscript
• P=Proof
• VoR=VersionofRecord
• CVoR=CorrectedVersionofRecord
• EVoR=EnhancedVersionofRecord
JournalArticleVersions(JAV):RecommendationsoftheNISO/ALPSPJAVTechnicalWorkingGroup-April2008 https://groups.niso.org/publications/rp/RP-8-2008.pdf
ManyVersions….
• AO=Author’sOriginal
• SMUR=SubmittedManuscriptUnderReview
• AM=AcceptedManuscript
• P=Proof
• VoR=VersionofRecord
• CVoR=CorrectedVersionofRecord
• EVoR=EnhancedVersionofRecord
JournalArticleVersions(JAV):RecommendationsoftheNISO/ALPSPJAVTechnicalWorkingGroup-April2008 https://groups.niso.org/publications/rp/RP-8-2008.pdf
ANYORALL
(ORNONE)
COULDBE
OPENACCESS
WhattoPrivilege?
• WhenThereisaDifference
• Options–LibraryDecideorUserChoice?
• UnmediatedAccessPrivilegeApproaches–PriorityListingvsOnlyOption
• MediatedAccess–PriorityCascadevsServiceLimitation
Perspectives
(Alignedand/orConflicting?)
Reader
Author
Library
Publisher
OpenAccessAdvocate
Ifyouhadtodecideaprioritytoday….
BeforeThisPresentation:
❑ OpenAccess
❑ VersionofRecord
❑ LettheUserDecide
❑ Other:__________________
TheStateofOAandLinking
LibraryAnaly+csManagerSingaporeManagementUniversity@[email protected]
Musingsaboutlibrarianship
h<ps://musingsaboutlibrarianship.blogspot.sg/
50%
*
Archambault,É.,Amyot,D.,Deschamps,P.,Nicol,A.,Provencher,F.,Rebout,L.,&Roberge,G.(2014).Propor+onofopenaccesspaperspublishedinpeer-reviewedjournalsattheEuropeanandworldlevels—1996–2013.
“AsofApril2014,morethan50%ofthescien+ficpaperspublishedin2007,2008,2009,2010,2011,and2012canbedownloadedforfreeontheInternet."
2014
h<p://www.lazyscholar.org/2017/10/06/new-sta+s+cs-on-full-text-availability-using-lazy-scholar/
“Inotherwords,LazyScholarfindsafreefulltextsomewherebetween36-41%ofthe+me..IfIrestricttheanalysistoonlypaperswhereaDOIisavailable,LazyScholarfindsafreefulltext49-54%ofthe+me"
2017
Piwowar,H.,Priem,J.,Larivière,V.,Alperin,J.P.,Ma<hias,L.,Norlander,B.,...&Haustein,S.(2018).TheStateofOA:Alarge-scaleanalysisoftheprevalenceandimpactofOpenAccessar+cles.PeerJ,6,e4375.
“wefindthatUnpaywallusersencounterOAquitefrequently:47%ofar+clestheyviewareOA"
2018
Marln-Marln,A.,Costas,R.,vanLeeuwen,T.,&López-Cózar,E.D.(2018).EvidenceofOpenAccessofscien+ficpublica+onsinGoogleScholar:alarge-scaleanalysis.arXivpreprintarXiv:1803.06161.
“Thedatashowsanoverallfreeavailabilityof54.6%,...ThedataextractedfromGSyieldedverysimilarresultstothosefoundbyotherstudiesthatanalysedsimilarsamplesofdocuments,butemployeddifferentmethodstofindevidenceofOA,thussugges>ngarela>veconsistencyamongmethods”
2018
RiseofPreprints
Transi+ontoaworldwithasignificantpoolofOpenAccess*ar+cles
Riseofopenaccessfindingtools
Integra+onintolibraryservices
Possibilitytoconsidersubscrip+onandrenewaldecisionsusingavailabilityofOpenAccessasaconsidera+on
5,634 users
4,399 users
8,896 users
10,802 users
128,698 users
1,621,345 users
SomeChromeextensionstofindfreetoreadar+cles&userbase@April1,2018
HighestProfileintegra+on–WebofScience(Clarivate)
OtherIntegra+ons
Be<ersupportforOA*cominginSummon&Primo
• OAindicatorinSummon,comingforPrimo
• Integra+onofmoreOAsources–e.g.CORE(planned),
• Be<eriden+fica+onoffreefulltextinjournals(hybrids)&repositories(metadataonlyrecordsvsfulltext)
Subs+tu+onwithopenaccess*ar+cles?
Antelman,K.(2017).Leveragingthegrowthofopenaccessinlibrary
collec+ondecisionmaking.ProceedingfromACRL2017:AttheHelm:LeadingTransforma=on.
“Foraperiodof+meGreenOAadvocateswereasser+ng,almostasifitwereanaturallaw,thatGreenOAdoesnotleadtocancella+ons…Nowthereistherecogni+onthatcancella+onsarelikelytoresultonceacri+calmassofar+clesacrossarangeofjournalsbecomesOA”
WaystodetermineOAlevelsofjournals
1Science–Oafigrservice
1
UseUnpaywallAPI • RyanRegier’sOacountspythonprogram-h<ps://github.com/ryregier
2
UseDimensionstofilterbypublica+on+tleandstatus
3
UnderlyingAssump+on
Allversionsofar+clesfoundarethesameorequally
worthwhile!
Johan Tilstra CEO, founder of Lean Library [email protected] @leanlibrary / @johantilstra
The Library in the (Work)Flow: Connecting Users to Content
What’s presented to the end user
Library collection
What’s ‘out there’
‘What’s (easily) available to me?’
OA material
Library collection
What’s ‘out there’
OA material
Library collection
What’s ‘out there’
Expanded library assistance
Library collection as a mere convenience tool
Help with retrieving material outside of the library collection
Help with determining what version to use
[email protected] @leanlibrary / @johantilstra
From the Open Access Button’s guide: “How to Protect Your Work From Being Taken Down”
"We have shown that, within the boundaries of our corpus [arXiv], there are no significant differences in aggregate between pre-prints and their corresponding final published versions."
Klein, M., Broadwell, P., Farb, S. E., & Grappone, T. (2016)
"The picture for the bioRxiv corpus is very similar, but we do see a slightly larger divergence between pre-print and final published paper versions in this case, suggesting that varying disciplinary practices regarding formatting and copyediting can and do influence the degree of detected similarity between pre-print and final published articles.” Klein, M., Broadwell, P., Farb, S. E., & Grappone, T. (2018)
AM PDF 3,000+
VOR PDF 60+
The Conflict
Questions?Comments?Refutations?Affirmations?
LisaJanickeHinchliffe,Professor/Librarian,UniversityofIllinoisatUrbana-Champaign
AaronTay,LibraryAnalyticsManager,SingaporeManagementUniversityJohanTilstra,ChiefExecutiveOfficer,LeanLibrary
MariaAghazarian,DigitalResourcesandScholarlyCommunicationsSpecialist,SwarthmoreCollege
#CNI18s#privilegedlink
Ifyouhadtodecideaprioritytoday….
BeforeThisPresentation:
❑ OpenAccess
❑ VersionofRecord
❑ LettheUserDecide
❑ Other:__________________
AfterThisPresentation:
❑ OpenAccess
❑ VersionofRecord
❑ LettheUserDecide
❑ Other:__________________
