The Power Of Print, 10 November 2011
-
Upload
rachel-aldighieri -
Category
Documents
-
view
388 -
download
6
description
Transcript of The Power Of Print, 10 November 2011
The Power of
Thursday 10 November
2011
DMA House
Connect with the DMA
• The #tag for this event is: #DMAprint
• Join the DMA LinkedIn page: DMA:Direct Marketing Association (UK) Limited
• Follow us on Twitter: @DMA_UK
• DMA Website: www.dma.org.uk
• Contact us at:
[email protected] or [email protected]
Phone: 020 7291 3300
Upcoming Events
• Email Customer Lifecycle, Win-
Back – Tuesday 22 November
2011
• Ready Steady Email – Wednesday
14 December 2011
• Annual Data Conference –
Thursday 1 March 2012
Welcome from the chair
• CJ Court, Managing Director, All
response Media
• Mark Davies, Managing Director,
TNT Post (Doordrop Media) Ltd
The Power of Paper
• Martyn Eustace, Print Power/Two
Sides
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
The Power of PrintDMA
10th November 2011
Two Sides and Print Power
Promoting the sustainability and
effectiveness of our industry
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Objective
PrintPower will tell the story of print and paper’s sustainability and effectiveness
A pan-European initiative
Print Power aims to strengthen the position of print in today’s multi-media world and maximise print’s share of the total marketing & advertising spend in Europe.
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Effectiveness (brand Print Power)
Print Power will demonstrate to media-mix decision makers
the effectiveness of printed media as a vital channel for
marketing and advertising. Famous brands will be used to
prove the effectiveness of print media in newspapers,
magazines, direct mail, brochures, catalogues, folders,
corporate reports and general business communication.
Communication
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Sustainability (brand Two Sides)
Two Sides promotes the responsible production and use of
print and paper and dispels common environmental
misconceptions by providing users with verifiable
information on why Print Media is an attractive, practical
and sustainable communications medium
Communication
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
• Keep the effectiveness campaign and sustainability
initiative separate
• Do not mix messages
• Effectiveness must be hard hitting, provocative, forceful
• Sustainability must retain authority and balance. Factual
and informative
• Mixing would dilute and reduce impact of each
Communication
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
1. Pulp & paper production CEPI, CEPIFINE, CEPIPRINT, EPIS.
2. Paper merchants EUGROPA.
3. Printing INTERGRAF, ERA, VDMA, FEPE etc.
4. Publishing FIPP, FAEP, EPC, WAN-IFRA, ENPA, INMA, Fedma.
5. Postal & distribution IPC, Distripress, PostEurop
1 2 3 4 5Marketing & Advertising Audience
Print Power Partners
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Print PowerThe Effectiveness Campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Five ‘intrinsic’ qualities of print media:
• longevity
• authority
• reading (haptic) experience
• real world experience
• single attention
No other channel can offer this
combination of qualities
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Print media ‘selling’ messages:
• Print has impact
• Print is creative
• Print engages
• Print is versatile
• Print is persuasive
Print = Effective
Specific themes: print and younger generations
(“digital natives”), innovation in printing, ....
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Communication flow
Marketing
&
Advertising
audience
Social Network
Sites
Direct mail
Fulfillment
brochure
Website
Press
release
Online banners
AdvertisementsQR code
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
“I am the only thing you’re
looking at right now”
The Campaign:
• General ad
• Print is engaging
• Vital part of modern media mix
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
“The only thing missing
from your campaign is me”
The Campaign:
• General ad
• Print is engaging
• Vital part of modern media mix
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Print Power Website
• News resource
• Links to other countries
• Key advantages of different
Print Media channels
• Registration page for data
capture
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
• Every £1.00 spent on Print Advertising yields £5.00 in
revenue Microsoft, UK study
• Reader exposure to an a magazine campaign will
increase sales revenue by 11.6% from 10% (non-
exposed), to 21.6%, (exposed) PPA survey 2008
• On average, for every £1.00 spent on direct mail,
£14.00 is generated, with some campaigns even
going up to £40.00 Royal Mail, UK
Focusing on the real returns for advertisers:
Do we always sell print media in this way?
The European ‘Print Power’ campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
• Well known Brands and designers discuss print media
• Three themes:
• Relevance in a multi-media world
• Creativity
• Integration
Four page exposure in Marketing Magazine, the UK’s
premium magazine for senior marketing people
Round Tables have created the basis of the
2011 campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
April theme: Relevance and Longevity
Venue: Stationers Hall
Round Tables have created the basis of the
2011 campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
I’m seeing people reappraising
print.. Looking at its creative
appeal. Print is the only thing
that plays to all the senses.
Mark Thomson, Royal Mail
Print is growing in importance to
us. People look at different
channels for interest, but there are
certain media where they definitely
make the decision to buy. Print is
one of the, and the web,
surprisingly, is not.
Danny Homan, Historic Royal
palaces
Print.... Needs to
be more targeted
Bastien Hibon,
Mercedes GP
Print works best when we use it to inspire to
interaction. Print is an incredibly powerful tool.
Print creates trust
One of the problem that print facesis that people
make the decision in print but google takes the
credit because its the last click.
Rik Haslem, RAPP UK
Rapp UK
In the past few months we
have seen Google, Vodafone,
Boden, Asos,, online retailers,
investing in their own print
magazines
Julia Hutchison, APA
Print is a place in the (integrated
communications) puzzle. Its part of the
journey
Print is usually the first port of call...will
always have a place in the marketing of
fashion brands
Sushma Sagar, Banana Republic
The print medium is much
underestimated.
John Willacy, MC&C
Print stands the test of time
Print Power Round Tables, 2011
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
June theme: Creativity
Venue: PwC, More London
Round Tables have created the basis of the
2011 campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
The targeted potential and
measurability that print gives us
means that still forcing
ourselves down that road. Print
represents about 1/3 of our
overall spend and will continue
to do so,
Andy Graydon, Which?
If we recruit subscribers through a digital channel, we see 30 -40% churn at
the end of the year. If we recruit via a print channel, we’ll see 13 – 14% churn
and, at the end of 5 years, they’ll be significantly higher net lifetime values,
almost a 100% difference.
Print provides ‘Dwell Time’ in a blip-culture world. Print is an expensive
medium but you can see the returns from it.
Mike Colling, MC&C
Part of the difficulty is
reasserting where print fits in
the value chain, engaging
early enough with the client
Simon Steele, Guttenberg
Networks
Brands get creative in print
Everything has changed and nothing
has changed. Print still does all the
things it used to do brilliantly
But Print is becoming an add-on. It’s
not getting the same care and
attention and creativity
If you look at Cannes, and other
awards, there’s less good work in the
UK in print than there used to be
David Prideaux, Publicis Chemistry
We ensure that we integrate all types of
media into our communications and that
they are measured accurately, both
individually and collectively. But some of
our initiatives have specifically been
about print. It’s not what our customers
would expect
Sarah Speake, Google
Print Power Round Tables, 2011
In B to B we’re
experimenting quite
heavily with print.
Direct Mail....giving
customers the
chance of breathing
space among the
noise and the daily
drudge of email
overload
Sarah Speake,
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
September theme: Integration
Venue: ‘Blue Fin’, offices of IPC
Round Tables have created the basis of the
2011 campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Sometimes digital leads to us
being self-indulgent and we
forget the power of a TV ad.
You have to be clear what your
brand is about and make it
portable
Andrew Warner, Expedia
Direct Marketing works for
us and my best pack have
a 10% return rate, with a
cost per sale of £12. . We
mail people on the
birthday of their pets as an
insurance reminder. It has
not worked on email but as
a birthday card it works
phenomenally.
Peter Markey RSA/More
Than
I am a big advocate of print
although I think the standard of
print ads is declining
Andrew Warner, Expedia
Part of the difficulty is
reasserting where print fits in
the value chain, engaging
early enough with the client
Simon Steele, Guttenberg
Networks
Print meets the integration challenge
Our spring catalogue is anticipated by
customers like a subscription to a
magazine. But different channels
engage. Print is the enabler to begin,
continue and further the conversation.
I’m doing a shed load more print than
I was before. With packs we get a
50% response to multi channel
customers and retention rates have
tripled.
Alison Lancaster, White Stuff
With Print there is the opportunity to be
a jump off point for an immersive world.
Zaid Al-Zaldy, TBWA/London
I’ve ended the year with money remaining
in my digital budget because it is hard to
prove ROI in the way you can do with
direct mail.
Peter Market, RSA/More Than
Print Power Round Tables, 2011
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
‘Grand Finale’
Autumn Seminar at Stationers’ Hall
7th November 2011
• Open Round Table hosted by
Marketing Magazine
• Two Sides 10 Country research
• Info on new B to C campaign
• Launch of the Print Power new
Magazine
Round Tables have created the basis of the
2011 campaign
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Print Power MagazinePromoting the effectiveness of Print in a multi-
channel world
Issue 1, March 2011
Two versions:
Generic –
10,000 copies for general distribution
(5,000 sent to printers by BPIF)
Personalized
10,000 to Print Media buyers and influencers
5,000 to advert responses
Decision to issue 3 x a year
Editor, Sam Upton and Designer, Richard Wise
appointed.
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Print Power MagazinePromoting the effectiveness of Print in a multi-
channel world
Issue 2, March 2011
Look and Feel of a ‘real’ magazine
More newsy and engaging
Adverts offset cost and add to experience
Maintain focus on key media channels
Thanks to Magazine Group for help and advice:
Will Stone/Terry Parry, UPM
Darren Coxon, Pensord
Patrick Fuller, APA
Andy Pike, Duplo International
Graham Leeson, Fuji UK Graphic Systems
Martin Webster, HSPG
Maxine Elliott, SAPPI UK Ltd
Richard Wilson, Flint Inks
Kathy Woodward, BPIF
Nick Barbeary, IOS/Lateral Group
Matthew Parker, Print and Procurement
The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Print Power MagazinePromoting the effectiveness of Print in a multi-
channel world
Issue 2, March 2011
13,500 addressed copies will be sent in the
next two weeks
Reply paid card to get feedback
Telephone follow up to random recipients.
What works/what doesn’t
Next issues planned for February, June,
October 2012
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
The world of Print Media is changingAnd we have a great environmental story
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
‘Two Sides’The Sustainability Campaign
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Is this the way we want the
world to see us?
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Is this the way we want the
world to see us?
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
‘Two Sides’, advertisements
The ‘Two Sides’ campaign
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Two Sides messages are being developed
across Europe
Some variation but image consistent
Austria Italy Portugal Finland
The ‘Two Sides’ campaign
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
‘Two Sides’, resources-laden website
c. 3000 visitors a month
The ‘Two Sides’ campaign
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
‘Two Sides’, digital printed Sustainability booklet,
personalised for all members, March 2010
Translated into Finnish, Portuguese, Japanese!
Mills and Merchants have done versions
Other versions for printers and publishers
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Misleading statements and misinformed anti paper
organisations are growing
Take this example........
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Misleading statements and misinformed anti paper
organisations are growing
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
OutcomeBT have now changed messaging and do
not refer to ‘saving trees’ or ‘e-billing
being environmentally more friendly’.
Two Sides will now continue discussions
with other major Corporates.
Two Sides has credibility and can debate
with authority.
‘Two Sides’, addressing Greenwash, Case Study:
BT
‘Do your bit for the
environment and go paper-free
‘Save ££’s and trees with
paper-free billing’
The ‘Two Sides’ campaign
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Active campaign to CEO’s and Head of Legal Department
• 53 Utilities
• 28 Banks
• 24 Telecoms
Two Stages
• General Letter to all CEOs and Head of Legal
• Specific letters to offenders, threatening action
• Open Letter to Newspapers
Widespread publicity for the campaign
‘Two Sides’, addressing Greenwash,
New ‘Stop Greenwash’ Campaign
The ‘Two Sides’ campaign
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
43% of Banks
70% Utilities
30% Telecoms
were making false statements
• Widespread PR
• Lots of Trade Press coverage
‘Two Sides’, addressing Greenwash,
New ‘Stop Greenwash’ Campaign
The ‘Two Sides’ campaign
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Successful outcome!
• 83% of Banks
• 64% of Utilities
• 100% of Telecoms
have changed their messages!
Press and Radio coverage
Campaign Continues
‘Two Sides’, addressing Greenwash,
New ‘Stop Greenwash’ Campaign
The ‘Two Sides’ campaign
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Understanding how consumers view print and paper, in a multi media
world, is fundamental to devising new marketing campaigns
Researching consumer opinions
The ‘Two Sides’ campaign
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Two Sides
European and US
Consumer Survey
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Results
Two Sides
European and US
Consumer Survey
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
� 10 countries
� UK, France, Germany, Italy,
Finland, Austria, Portugal,
The Netherlands, Spain, and
the USA
� 5,000 online interviews, 500
per country using the IPSOS
Consumer Panel
� Split by gender, age and
religion
Survey Headlines
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
� To discover the strength and
extent of public opinion about
the environmental impact of print
and paper
� To discover how such opinions
may be playing a part in the
reduction of use of print media
as consumers are attracted to
new media channels
Purpose
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
� Research should deliver
valuable insights for a campaign
that aims to counter negative
attitudes to the use and sourcing
of paper and print (forest and
recycling issues).
� Provide background material to
be used in publicising print and
paper’s attractiveness and
sustainability
Outcome
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
� Results are for all European
countries participating
� Age exceptions are given where
significant
� No significant UK differences
European Results
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers like paper,
particularly the younger
generation!� 80% prefer reading from paper, (83%
of 18 -24 yo)
� 74% believe that paper is more
pleasant than other media, (78% of 18-
24 yo)
� 54% agreed that paper records are
more sustainable than electronic
storage, (57% of 18–24 yo)
Consumers prefer paper and see it as a
sustainable way to keep records
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
And for important documents, consumers
want them on paperHow would you like to keep
important documents?� 58% prefer to keep important
documents on paper, (63% of 18-24
yo)
� 27% prefer to keep electronically
� 16% have no preference
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Recycling and renewability
issues
� 97% see recyclability as the sign of an
environmentally friendly product
� 68% understand that Print Media is based
on a renewable resource
� 49% believe that the industry has a low or
average recycling record
� Consumers think that recycling rates in
Europe are c 20 - 40% (Act.69%)
Consumers want recyclable products but
maybe don’t connect this with paper
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Drivers of consumer concerns
� 43% said Poverty and Social inequality
is their main concern
� 22% are concerned about threats
against the environment
� 6% regard forestry as the most
worrying issue today
Is forestry a consumer concern?
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers are not aware of paper’s true
forest impact
Misunderstanding continues
� 80% believe European forests are
smaller or the same as 50 years ago.
(Act. 30% bigger)
� Paper is seen as having the biggest
impact on the forest, bigger than fuel
and the same as construction.(Act. Paper manufacture uses only 11% of the worldwide forest harvest.
Fuel and construction are the biggest users)
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Paper and Forests
� 76% believe that there is a connection
between paper manufacture and loss
of tropical rainforest
� 73% are concerned about print and
paper’s effect on forests
There is a belief that forests are under
threat from the use of paper
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
What’s the most
environmentally friendly way to
read? Electronically On Paper
Newspapers 67% 13%
Book 52% 28%
Magazines 62% 17%
Mail 71% 10%
E-communication is regarded as more
environmentally friendly
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Print Media needs to promote its
environmental friendliness
Impact of advertising is limited
� 14% of consumers have seen adverts
promoting the environmental
sustainability of print media
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Adverts , where seen, have impact!
Consumers receptive to information
� 88% find adverts about print media’s
sustainability useful
� 75% think adverts are credible
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print & Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Consumers’ Environmental Perceptions of Print &
Paper
A multi country survey commissioned by Two Sides, September,
2011Not for distribution outside of the Print Power/Two Sides organisation
Lessons to be learned
� Paper is still the preferred information medium for
reading and storage of documents – all ages
� 18-24 year olds appear to appreciate paper more
than older age groups
� Paper is not seen as an environmentally friendly
way to read
� Consumers do not understand that European
forests are getting bigger
� Print and Paper is seen as a sustainable resource,
but this needs reinforcement
� Consumers like recyclable products and need a
better understanding of the industry’s good record
� Informative marketing is needed and can be
influential
Print Power Presentation to Canon, 4th February, 2010The Power of Print, DMA, 10th November, 2011
Contacts:
Martyn Eustace [email protected]
Tim Bowler [email protected]
Vince Collins [email protected]
Sarah Collins [email protected]
Membership continues to be a priority
If you are a member – thank you and please
encourage others
If you are not – please join!
The ‘Two Sides’ campaign
Doordrops and Inserts:
Brother and Sister media
• Lucy Stafford, Managing Director,
Mindshare Direct
• Mark Davies, Managing Director,
TNT Post (Doordrop Media) Ltd
Door Drops & Inserts:
Brother & Sister Media
November 10th 2011
Agenda
Customer journey
Customer journeyTargeting/ Integration
Measurement
CUSTOMER JOURNEY
The Customer Journey
MOMENT OF
PURCHASE
#2
2.
ACTIVE EVALUATIONInformation gathering, shopping
4.POSTPURCHASE EXPERIENCE
Ongoing exposure
INITIAL CONSIDERATION
SET
#1LOYALTY LOOP
MOMENT OF
PURCHASE
#3
The Customer Journey
The Customer Journey
TARGETING/ INTEGRATION
Targeting/ Integration
Targeting/ Integration
Targeting/ Integration
Targeting/ Integration
MEASUREMENT
Last Click Doesn’t Win
Last Click Doesn’t Win
52%
The Magic Number
[ ] [ ] εφβα +∗+∗+= ∑∑j
tij
i
tiit ZXY
The Answer is…….
Econometrics Multipliers
Split by Channel
Measurement
Measurement
18%
24%
30%
41%
27%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
Door Drops Loose Inserts Directories Supplements & Listings National Press
Response : Sale Conversion
Avg Conv = 28%
Measurement
Measurement
Doordrop ROI: 1.91 DM ROI: 0.58
Inserts ROI: 0.87
Doordrop ROI: 1.43 DM ROI: 0.81
Inserts ROI: 1.66
Summary
Customer Journey
Customer journeyTargeting/ Integration
Measurement
Testing
New innovations and trends
• James Sherwin, Managing
Director, Tangerine
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
New innovations and trends
James Sherwin – Director, Tangerine
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Innovation
• As time and technology
progress, we seem to
move forwards by re-
visiting old approaches
in new ways
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
James Sherwin, Director - Tangerine
• Tangerine: a small data consultancy, providing bespoke FMCG shopper marketing solutions
• Founded Tangerine in 1998; after working with Unilever and Sainsbury’s we recognised an opportunity to help FMCG clients explore the value of retailer loyalty data
• Focus on data management, business modelling & planning, campaign planning & operational impact planning– Client - Direct Wines
– DM Agency – WWAV Rapp Collins
– Data Consultancy – Data by Design
• Personally– I live on a farm near Frome in Somerset – where
Tangerine is based.
– The farm has a boutique holiday cottage www.courtfarmstanderwick.co.uk should you be in need of a break.
– In my spare time, I make and sell significant volumes of apple juice and ciders, honey and ginger beer and I rear and butcher my own pigs & sheep
– I also run - mountain marathons are my latest joy!
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Tangerine have spent over 13 years planning and
evaluating campaigns for many iconic FMCG brands
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Working with an array of partners...
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Background to our own innovation
• FMCG brands rely on trial to grow
– DTD can be one of the best performing media
– Price promotions tend not to be effective trial-drivers
• A lot of promotional investment is wasted
– Poor targeting
– Poor operational support
• leading to unsatisfied demand through poor merchandising and out of stocks
• In FMCG trade support is vital
– To avoid the trap of relying on-going price promotions brands need to show
retailers what their A&P spend is doing for a retailer & their shoppers
• Tangerine’s FMC-G-Model™ is a specialist solution designed to support
brand growth
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
The FMC-G-Model™ allocates sales uplift across retailer
trade plans
• A bespoke gravity model forecasts sales impact at store level
– Aggregated to a retailer level
• Shopper-marketing activity becomes a sales line on the trade plan
• Offers a real opportunity for suppliers to take back control of
promotional activity and potentially reduce trade deals
94
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Store Communication
• A bespoke store communication
is developed for every
significantly impacted store to
garner support & encourage
additional stock purchase
• Telesales to drive awareness
• Field sales visits
95
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Continued Innovation
• Changes in the coupon redemption culture and processes... [driven by the IPM, wider industry pressure and by Tesco’s drive to cut costs by
destroying coupons internally ]
open up the DTD media world for renewed exploration
• Our FMC-G-Model™ is now calibrated to work with TNT Microsectors
– This has enabled us to support ‘sampling’ activity for Kellogg’s and Nivea
– Nothing new about sampling (remember the spiral!); now it can be better controlled and technology can increase reaction time in the field
– To support Nivea, we have had to include Boots/Superdrug in a bespoke version our model
• We can work at any geographical level...
– SMART-Drop is media independent, almost infinitely flexible and moves toward a ‘near-mail’ solution
– The following example illustrates the potential of SMART-Drop
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
A sub-sector summary of activity and performance
...some winners and some relative losers
B
BalsallBalsallBalsallBalsallBalsallBalsallBalsallBalsallBalsall
Balsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall Common
BarstonBarstonBarstonBarstonBarstonBarstonBarstonBarstonBarston
BerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswell
BickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhill
BirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirmingham
Corley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley Moor
EarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswood
FillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongley
Hampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in Arden
KnowleKnowleKnowleKnowleKnowleKnowleKnowleKnowleKnowle
MaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstoke
MeridenMeridenMeridenMeridenMeridenMeridenMeridenMeridenMeriden
SolihullSolihullSolihullSolihullSolihullSolihullSolihullSolihullSolihull
WythallWythallWythallWythallWythallWythallWythallWythallWythall
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
...taking a postcode level view is revealing
B
BalsallBalsallBalsallBalsallBalsallBalsallBalsallBalsallBalsall
Balsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall CommonBalsall Common
BarstonBarstonBarstonBarstonBarstonBarstonBarstonBarstonBarston
BerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswellBerkswell
BickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhillBickenhill
BirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirminghamBirmingham
Corley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley MoorCorley Moor
EarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswoodEarlswood
FillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongleyFillongley
Hampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in ArdenHampton in Arden
KnowleKnowleKnowleKnowleKnowleKnowleKnowleKnowleKnowle
MaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstokeMaxstoke
MeridenMeridenMeridenMeridenMeridenMeridenMeridenMeridenMeriden
SolihullSolihullSolihullSolihullSolihullSolihullSolihullSolihullSolihull
WythallWythallWythallWythallWythallWythallWythallWythallWythall
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
...within the winners there are losers and vice-versa...a
prime opportunity to craft bespoke distribution areas
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Innovation in design
Paper provides an large creative platform.
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Designing an effective leaflet for FMCG
1. Create stand-out on the door mat
– Shape & colour need to stand out from other leaflets – research has shown that
yellow gets most stand out
– The back cover is the alternative front cover – leaflet could land either way up
2. Give them a reason to open the leaflet
– Highlight the offer: “Coupons inside” “Half Price Coupons Inside”
– Entertain but don’t tease – its too easy to disengage
– Ensure brand identity features in the creative to gain instant recognition
3. Get the product on the shopping list
– Keep messages simple & text to a minimum
– Give shoppers a clear call to action – “Try Me!”
– Make it easy to remove the coupons – be aware of order of use, and coupon
design: www.valassis.co.uk/Page/82/Coupon-Design
4. Help shoppers to find the product in store
– Use imagery that enhances brand recognition: colour, product shots
– Tell them where to look (if necessary) e.g. “Find us on the Confectionery aisle”
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Innovation in design
Royal Mail Eye Tracking Insight
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
The Role of DTD
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
When FMCG marketing levers are mapped we
can see how they occupy various positions
along the shopper ‘journey’
Retailer Loyalty Coupons
TV Advertising
Brand led DTD
DM
eCRM
In-store media
Store Sampling
Experiential Events
Outdoor
Awareness
driving
Building
Loyalty
Trial
Driving
Shopper
‘State’
Proximity to Point of
Purchase
In-Home low
engagementOut of Home
low
engagement
Planning shop
‘list’
In-StoreIn-Home
engaged
Car park Media
Trade deal
DTD occupies a position
close to the POP whilst
also driving trial and
awareness – coupons
then act as a reminder in-
store
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Looking at potential activity reach illustrates
how DTD is uniquely scale-able
eCRM
In-store media
Store Sampling
Experiential Events
Outdoor
Awareness
driving
Building
Loyalty
Trial
Driving
Shopper
‘State’
Proximity to Point of
Purchase
In-Home
not
engaged
Out of
Home not
engaged
Planning shop
‘list’
In-StoreIn-Home
engaged
Car park Media
Trade deal
TV Advertising
DM
Brand led
Door to Door
Retailer
Loyalty
Media
Digital Integration
DTD can reach every UK
household with a letterbox
TV ‘s reach is limited at any
one time – depending on show,
time, region & audience profile
Limited to the shoppers
that walk down aisle
and engage in offerLimited to size of
database – potentially
costly to expand (see
next slide)
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
DTD can be used to drive shoppers into a brand’s
digital program
• The benefit of DTD can be summed up as ‘quality trial’
• Tangerine work with digital partners to ensure eCRM integration offers a cost effective way to maximise shopper value
– Encourage shoppers to engage with the DTD and so increase trial
– Give shoppers continual reasons to re-engage and so drive retention
– Encourage usage and so increase FOP
• However, once a shopper has redeemed their coupons, the ‘advertised message’ will gradually fade leading to an increased susceptibility to competing messages...see volume gain chart – ‘Base DTD’ (grey)
+ eCRM (Trial & Retention & FOP)
+ eCRM (Trial & Retention)
+ eCRM (Trial)
Base DTD
Time
Volume
Chart: Volume gain from DTD over time
Digital integration overlay
Base DTD Impact
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
Summarising the case for Door to Door
Brand control
A creative platform
Quality/flexibility in targeting
Measurability and improvement
A retailer volume forecast (part of the trade support plan)
Store level volume forecasts that can be pre-sold to the trade and used to manage demand
Digital Integration
Copyright © 2010 Tangerine TCVC Limited, all rights reserved
tangerine: d a t a - d r iv e n s h o p p e r -m a r k e t in g s o lu t io n s w w w . t a n g e r in e -c v c . c o m
New innovations and trends
James Sherwin – Director, Tangerine
Tangerine - Court Farm Standerwick Somerset BA11 2PR www.tangerine-cvc.com
James Sherwin - [email protected] - T: 01373 831600 M: 07771 657827
Lucy Cardew - [email protected] - Home Office: 01780 470951 M: 07801 581762
Research – How many
respond online?
• CJ Court, Managing Director, All
Response Media
• Phil Ricketts, Sales & Marketing
Director, Royal Mail
2011 Research Project
Phil Ricketts:Phil Ricketts:Phil Ricketts:Phil Ricketts: Sales & Marketing Director (D2D) - Royal Mail
CJ: CJ: CJ: CJ: Managing Director - All Response Media
� Response rates declining
� Consumers increasingly embracing the internet
� Measurement vital to understanding value
� (still) Feel print medium only partially judged
� Previous research:◦ Online response = 52%52%52%52%
◦ Range was 24% to 76%
� New 2011 research included door drops
� Clients from wider range of sectors:◦ Charity, Finance & Retail
� Timing: April - Jun 2011
� Volume: 3m items
� 5 clients
� 11 titles / distribution methods
� Excluding the retail client the average % response to go online has risen….
56%
� 250,000 A4, 2pp leaflets
� Distributed via Newshare
� Mosaic targeting (from existing customers)
� Overlaid on town catchments
� Results:
� 80% of sales in-store
� 20%20%20%20% of sales online
� 90% of online sales from new customers
� Upmarket charity that appeals to older, more male donors
� 800k inserts in both national press and lifestyle titles
� Results:
� 59%59%59%59% of donations online
� Similar to average % across all activity
� Cancer insurance product: New to UK market
� 650k inserts in national press and lifestyle titles
� 300k door drop / Newshare
� Results:
� 83% of response was online
� All of door drop response was online
� 23% of all response was “Search Engine”
� 250k via Royal Mail door drop, 250k via Newshare
� Used customer profiles to target relevant Financial ACORN Types
� Results:
� 50% of leads were online
� 50% leads offline
� 27% of leads were converted to sale
� Campaign similar to previous research
� 500k inserts across national and lifestyle titles
� Results:
� Online response was 32% (up from 27% in previous research)◦ NB 3 response routes: Phone, coupon and web
� Still affected by type of title◦ Mass market TV title: 10%
◦ Mid market Sun: 29%
◦ Mid / upmarket Sat: 54%
� Was (still) coupon
� Importance of phone
� Increasingly web
� Will be new technologies….
� Vital that client data is measured correctlyVital that client data is measured correctlyVital that client data is measured correctlyVital that client data is measured correctly
� Online response is increasing
� Online response range: 20-83%◦ “Personal” sectors are higher (as previous) ◦ Retail still had 20% online – and new customers!
� Other factors affect % response online◦ Product being promoted◦ The number of response channels◦ The readership demographics◦ The online usage of that readership
� Online response is significant
� Measurement is more vital than ever
� New technology can make measurement easier and more accurate
� New response channels can bring new customers
� The Power of Print can work withwithwithwith the internet
Tea & Coffee Break
Putting it into practice – a
retail case study
• Dean Morris, Marketing Controller,
Robert Dyas
Robert Dyas November 2011
Door Drop & Inserts
Robert Dyas November 2011
Introduction To Robert Dyas
� Established in 1872 by Robert Dyas
� 98 stores predominantly in the South East with outlying stores as far north as Solihull, East to Colchester and
West to Bristol
� Stores predominantly in High Street locations.
� Trades in a number of centre types from city of London, to large destination centres (Brighton/Bristol) to
smaller provincial market towns (Dorking, Dorchester)
� Product mix covers kitchenware, small electrical appliances, housewares, cleaning, home office, DIY and
gardening
� No one, direct competitor, but lots of competition: Wilkinsons, Supermarkets, Argos, DIY/Electrical sheds,
kitchen specialists, internet
� Customer base quite broad but tends to bias older (40+), ABC1 home owners. Two thirds of customers are
female. Customer profile does vary by centre type.
� Overall Robert Dyas proposition is based around convenience and service, but need strong well targeted,
well communicated promotions to drive sales – particularly in the current environment
Robert Dyas November 2011
Introduction To Robert Dyas
Robert Dyas Richmond
Robert Dyas November 2011
Marketing Mix
� Full year promotion plan with 12 promotional changes per year
� Each promotion is supported with:
� TV advertising (in Carlton & Meridian – beyond this store density too low to make TV cost effective)
� Promotional leaflet inserted in the national press and via door drop
� Digital activity: e-mails, PPC, SEO etc
� At key times of the year radio and press are used to give further weight to the campaign
� In addition to promotional leaflets, we also produce larger format seasonal guides to support
key seasonal opportunities e.g. gift guide, outdoor living guide
� Leaflet marketing has been a key part of the marketing mix for Robert Dyas for the past 10
years
Robert Dyas November 2011
Why Leaflet Marketing Works For
Robert Dyas
� A cost effective way of communicating a broad mix of products.
� As the number of pages increase, inserts and door drop becomes more cost efficient –media costs don’t double if the number of pages double.
� It works well for our suppliers
� opportunity for properly branded space
� opportunity to showcase a broader range of products
� huge uplift on featured lines
� Ability to target locally reduces wastage and delivers a better ROI
� Unrivalled ability to target to key customer segments
� Highly measurable media
� Direct response mechanisms
� Control store testing
� Works well with broadcast media
� TV drives awareness of an event or promotion and sales to 1-2 key lines
� Leaflets drive a response across a broad range of lines featured in the promotion
� Drives sales
� Short term: drives sales spike: c 5-8% overall sales
� Long term: keeps Robert Dyas top of mind
Robert Dyas November 2011
Why Leaflet Marketing Works For
Robert Dyas
Promotional Leaflets 2011Supplier Branded Page & ½ Page
Robert Dyas November 2011
Why Leaflet Marketing Works For
Robert Dyas
Grow Your Own Guide 2011Outdoor Living Guide 2011
Robert Dyas November 2011
Door Drop
Advantages:
� Ability to target message to a granular level:
� By location
� By customer segment
� Ability to change message locally (re-version)
� The more you know about your customer, the more powerful/less wasteful the media becomes
(who they are, where they come from, how much they spend, what they buy)
Things to look out for:
� Newshare: good cost per 1000. But coverage can be poor, publications vary in quality, no control
of what items will be inserted in the paper
� Team: more expensive cost per 1000, some subcontracted teams lead to reliability issues, don’t
cover all postcode sectors
� Royal Mail: expensive cost per 1000, but 100% household coverage and maximum number of
competing items – may be only option to cover some key postcode sectors
� Use coverage and reliability data, e.g. TNT’s Home-in Targeting (HiT), to guide your delivery
method by postcode sector:
Robert Dyas November 2011
Inserts
Advantages:
� Benefit from the brand association with the host title
� Editorial content can support the sales opportunity
� Some titles allow you to target at a more granular level than TV region.
� Maximum number of items per title
� Better distribution method for leaflets which have a longer shelf life
Things to Look out For:
� TV region distribution can be wasteful
� Ability to target at a really local level difficult – few local/regional papers carry inserts
� Declining circulation figures in many national newspapers
� Most papers will only insert at the weekend
� Size of weekend newspapers
Robert Dyas November 2011
Door Drop and Inserts: Our Experience
� Both have a strong role to play in our marketing mix, and both deliver a strong ROI
� We use a mix of both to support the main promotional calendar and results suggest the distribution methods complement each other without too much overlap
� Both work well with our ATL activity.
For certain activities we favour one method over another:
Door Drop
� Short term and tactical activities
� New store openings
� Local marketing
� Different messages on a local/regional basis
� Focus on lower price point & consumable items
Inserts
� Higher price points/more considered purchases
� Seasonal opportunities (particularly when editorial features support the theme)
� Items with longer shelf life
Integrating with the “digital
world”
• Alistair Ezzy, Business
Development Director, GI
Solutions Group
Integrating with the ‘digital world’
By Alistair Ezzy
Business Development Director
Agenda
� Evolution of Print
� Shapes
� Digital print
� Targeting
� Digital Media
� Summary
Evolution of Print
1992 GI
Founded
2011
Initially producing OPM for Agencies
Market trends favoured conventional packs
Bespoke mailing pieces
More emphasis on pack cost
ROI was the key driver
Print Management began to take off
Credit CrunchEmail
Mailings became more targeted
Social Media
Events have conspired against us
Our world became less about…
“Producing relevant and innovative marketing communications to
engage with the recipient and drive improved response rates”
…and more about…
“How cheaply we can produce an A4 Letter and enclose it to a DL
envelope?”
Digital Print
Not just gimmicks
Case study – Sky
Sky wanted to use regionalisation to increase response. To do this
meant using colour imagery but given the variety of locations, it was
impossible to do this using conventional printing
The Test pack contained clear regionalisation from the area - this
included the TV region, Name of block of flats, Street Name or
Town Name. To emphasis timing, the date of the switch over was
included in that area in both packs
The Test Pack carried a map of where the recipient lived and what
was going to happen in their area. The Core pack contained
references to regions which were not supported by imagery and there
was only generic regionalisation in the brochure
Variable Maps
Results
� While the whole campaign met target, the test packs were 50% more responsive.
� Showed regionalisation and variable digital print works
� Will use digital print on future campaigns
“We were delighted with the success of this campaign which used regional references
to make the pack more relevant to the recipient. GI Direct were instrumental in ensuring
the variability was efficient and accurate and their capability in digital print allowed the
campaign to be delivered ”
Fiona Millard
Print Production Manager, SKY
What worked?
Case study – Adrian Flux
Insurance company wanted to improve the response rates from
their monthly trigger insurance mailings
With assistance from GI Direct, changed 25,000 packs per
month to maximise the use of colour personalisation
Now use 30 different variable images per month based on
vehicle the customer owns. Gender and age images used
initially but not as effective
Multiple images and highlight colour
Different brands
Results
� Percentage of people taking out a new policy were 1.27%
� Now percentage of new policyholders is 1.81%
� This shows an increase of over 30% of new policyholders
� Have rolled out use of digital variable to more campaigns
Targeting
CRUK – Free Will Service
� Twice a year
� Personalised with solicitors’ names and addresses
� Volume varies from 500,000 to 1,400,000
� Geographic segmentation – 252 segments
� Local solicitors are part of campaign
Molson Coors
� Segmentation to postcode sector to nearest two pubs
� Personalised with pub name
� Strong offer and call to action
� Drive time analysis
Digital Media
QR Code usage
DMA Mobile & Shopping – What’s going on? October 2011
What is a QR code?
A QR (Quick Response) Code is a 2d barcode that contains a
website address
When scanned by a Smartphone, it takes the user direct to the
website
It can:
Take your customer to the relevant part of your website
Take your customer to an App to download
Link them directly to an offer
Take them to a phone number to call
Use bit.ly to monitor traffic
Sky Pop Up
� Part of a fully integrated multi channel campaign
� Used as a trigger to other stages of the customer
journey
� Use of QR code extended life of door drop
� Added content and movement to static printed
piece
What are Microsites?
� a mini-website - typically only has 1-3 pages
� sits outside the main website
� ToysRUs
� cute baby competition
� sits on GI’s servers, customers upload pictures and details
� Habitat
� used as an offer page from the emails, the offer has a printable offer with
personalised barcode
ToysRUs - GURL
Creating the offer: PURL
Fully personalised offers
Fully personalised graphics
Easy and quick to implement
Powerful reporting
Text, links and imagery vary
depending on segmentation
Habitat - PURL
Augmented Reality
AR is a way of creating a 3D virtual image of a product using print, a
webcam and a website
Social Media
� Communities with a common interest
� Creating Conversations
� Can be integrated with Direct Marketing
� Different response mechanisms and measurement
Social Media - examples
� Mont Blanc sent beautifully written letters that were bogus requests for money.
� The strapline was ‘There is nothing more genuine than a hand-written letter’.
� It was sent to bloggers and leading journalists and created £33,000 worth of ‘free’ media.
� RNLI were looking to target younger people.
� They sent 12 influential YouTube video bloggers a controversial message in a box - ‘Your generation has been branded selfish, ignorant and violent’. The box also contained a camera along with an invitation to rewrite the headlines.
� Each blogger generated a massive response online resulting in hundreds of thousands of young people learning about the RNLI. And 500 young people aged 16 to 22 joined the RNLI as volunteers.
Case Studies from Mail Media Centre website www.mmc.co.uk
Mobile
� Over a quarter of adults (27 per cent) and almost half of teenagers
(47 per cent) now own a smartphone, according to Ofcom’s latest
Communications Market Report. Most (59 per cent) have
acquired their smartphone, which includes devices such as
iPhones, Blackberrys and Android phones, over the past year
� 37 per cent of adults and 60 per cent of teens are ‘highly addicted’
to them
Ofcom: Communications Market Report August 2011
Summary
� Relevance to recipient
� Print has a role in multi channel campaigns
� Is a launching pad
� Can be a link into Social Media
� Complementary not competitive
Thank you!
� Alistair EzzyBusiness Development DirectorGI Direct
07970 232 [email protected]
www.gi-solutionsgroup.comwww.creativeformats.com
A Client’s Perspective
• Marc Michaels, Director of Direct
Marketing and Evaluation
November 2011
Door drops VS Inserts
Marc Michaels, Director of Direct and Evaluation
November 2011
Door drops AND Inserts AND Direct Mail AND Face to Face
Marc Michaels, Director of Direct and Evaluation
AND TV AND Radio AND PR AND frankly anything that works …
We’re after a media mix that works
… AND creates effective behaviour change amongst the people we’re trying to reach.
For clients it isn’t (or shouldn’t be) about which media they prefer/like/feel more comfortable buying.
It’s about identifying the media mix that works cost effectively to deliver the objectives.
Case study 1 – Sometimes the Government want to talk
to ‘everyone’ about something that ‘affects everyone’
Local Elections and referendum on
the voting system – The Electoral
Commission
� A national distribution of information
booklets to every household in UK via door
drop distribution Jan – April 2011 about the
referendum question, how to vote and
voter registration
� Supported by TV prompting people to look
out for the booklet and by direct mail to
intermediaries through the Publicity
Register.
Awareness Comprehension ‘Mop up’ Action
An established mechanism first used
on AIDS back in 1987
� A methodology has been employed successfully by COI
over the last 25 years on: AIDS, Millenium Bug, Ofgas –
gas deregulation, Patients Charter, Parents Charter,
NHS Reforms, Preparing for Emergencies and
Pandemic Flu.
� With the objective of getting to as near full coverage as
possible and provide the:
a) stature of a national communication of import
b) recognition of the door drop material as important and
needing to be read thoroughly
c) reassurance message
� Most aren’t about generating response but in two major
distribution cases we were inviting response:
a) Patient's Charter (through RM – all households) for
more detailed info - 800,000 requests, 3.4% CPR - £1.50
b) Organ Donation (through Freesheet – 16 million) with
editorial support - to join the organ donor register -
500,000 conversions, 3.1% CPC = 80p (the lowest CPC
on record for a govt campaign even today)
Case study 2 – getting across detailed/complex
information so people can take the right action
Bowel Cancer – signs and symptoms
Department of Health
Cancer Survival rates in the UK lag behind those in Europe due to low awareness of symptoms and late presentation to GP’s. There are higher survival rates if caught early.
� Printed material gives the space to get the details of the message across with the TV highlighting the issue.
� Inserts in suitable press titles and magazines.
� 30 Face to face events with a high footfall of C2DE 55+. The teams, which included one nurse, had c4,500 conversations and shared the same printed info used as an isert. 140 people had symptoms and planned to make an appointment with a GP. 92% of people visiting the stand felt they were confident about identifying symptoms, compared to just 61% before the event.
� Over 2.37 million leaflets were distributed to stakeholders and the public through direct mail (Publicity Register)
� The pilot was a success and is being rolled out.
Case study 3 – information you can ‘keep and refer to at time of need’
NHS 111 Pilot –Department for Health
� A new service enabling the public to quickly
access medical help in non-emergency situations.
But you only need to know about it at time of need
which might not be at the time of the marketing =>
need for something that can be retained.
� A door to door campaign with 731,000 leaflets
were distributed to all households falling with the
three pilot areas.
� Those who had seen the communications were
much more likely to be able to describe the service
accurately (61% comms recognisers vs 16% non
recognisers). Analysis from the Evaluation team
showed that awareness increased in line with door
drop distribution. And it promoted calls too as a
proportion of the audience did have an immediate
need.
� The results proved so effective that doordrop is a
key element of media plans for future roll-out.
Case study 4 – not everyone is ‘on-line’
FSA – Money Made Clear� Information specifically targeting the financially
vulnerable. Two pilot tests with both door-drops and
inserts being used in the North East and North West
regions alongside TV, Radio and F2F
� After the door drop the pilot areas became much
more responsive. Both the door drop and insert (TV
listings and women’s magazines) better prompted
people to call the service (rather than go on-line)
and more importantly served to contextualise the
service and give people a reason to call.
A piggy back ‘earned’
insert into bank and
building society
mailings also proved
very effective.
Case study 4 – not everyone is ‘on-line’
FSA - Money Made Clear
Getting people to call (up to 45 min long
session) or have an F2F/partner session was
much more effective than driving people on
line and a higher proportion of the really
financial vulnerable used these response
vehicles.
Door drop also performed very well from a
cost per acquisition point of view.
Case study 5 – reaching out with a
a message people don’t want to hear
Harmful drinking� Two campaigns covering only the North West of England and
East Midlands.
� Three creative approaches were tested: General Health vs Liver
vs Cancer.
� All media carried UTNs and unique coupon codes.
Good performances from both inserts and door drops for both response and initial conversion
Case study 5 –
a message people don’t want to hear
However, following these pilots, Alcohol did roll out
with a largely TV dominated campaign that didn’t
do particularly well in generating response. Partly
this could be attributed to the fact that we had seen
in the pilot that the direct channels were best
performers but also partly because the creative
changed radically to an ‘X-ray harm’ device which
didn’t seem to resonate. Given the ‘Cancer’
reference treatment did not resonate as well as
general Health messages, the X-ray harm device
may well have suffered from the same reception.
We retained the ‘pilot treatments’ for the door drops
and inserts in a straight AB test with the new
creative and they performed better and as well as
the pilot phase.
The print media were working well against the
high risk individuals as a bit of a ‘shake-up’ to
their naturally held views that they would be
‘okay’.
Case study 6 – extending the message
into a trusted environment
HSE – Agricultural Workers
After a successful first phase with Direct Mail and Press a
second phase added testing and an insert strategy in Famers
Weekly to complement the activity and see if it could
generate incremental response – which could save lives.
Inserts performed far better than trade press advertising,
providing 14% of the total campaign response v 3% for press
advertising despite advertising being far more wide-ranging in
a larger number of titles.
2 different formats were tested - an A6 postcard format and
an A5 4pp leaflet, which was further tested using 2 different
creative executions. The A6 postcard format performed
significantly better than either of the A5 4pp leaflets – the 2
creative tests of the A5 leaflet performed similarly.
Some other interesting stuff …
£-
£10.00
£20.00
£30.00
£40.00
£50.00
£60.00
Inserts - Piggy Back Inserts - Press Insert - 3rd Party
Total CPR Active CPR
Piggy back inserts – in Govt ‘owned’
or ‘earned’ channels (e.g. C4L in
schools fruit boxes or Health Start
mailings, or placed in a DWP Lone
Parents mailing and HMRC Child
Benefit letter for DFE Affordable
Childcare are always very effective
and very low cost per acquisition.
Press inserts tend to have better
conversion than 3rd party.
232,000 people signed up to C4L CRM during the peak
campaign period. The original forecasted volume
(across all channels) was 111,797. This was partly
because of success of postal response vehicle (72%),
the piggy back inserts and the door drop and standard
inserts and the survey opt-in design.
From a cost per sign
up point of view
HDS and freesheet
were similar but
response rate was
higher for HDS.
Some other interesting stuff …
In many campaigns, there is
a degree of synergy and TV
does better when there are
other media channels at play.
Door drop can also act as a
broadcast media enhancing
response rates in the areas
that have been dropped even
if they don’t appear to come
directly from door drop.
All direct media are being undervalued purely on
identifiable direct response as they will prompt on-line
search but doesn’t get the credit for it. There are loads
of ways to address this: a)use of specific landing
pages for that media, b) use of specific key word
searches so that that word/phrase is only on that
media and recognised in the web analytics, c) use of
pop up short media questions, d) watching the uplift
after the print drops and the response curve that
impacts on the baseline traffic and e) econometrics –
the example left shows that for every door drop
response on tobacco recognised another 3 have gone
to online search
However, sometimes
printed matter doesn’t work …
CMEC – Child
Maintenance
Options
Press inserts were not very effective within
this campaign – possibly because of the
restrictions in regional buying.
£-
£50
£100
£150
£200
£250
£300
£350
£400
Total CPR (£)
Valid CPR (£)
Active CPR (£)
Total CPR (£) £0.36 £0.47 £3.57 £35.00 £31.10 £103.23
Valid CPR (£) £0.36 £0.47 £3.60 £37.00 £50.71 £115.43
Active CPR (£) £43.66 £56.09 £89.12 £70.20 £88.06 £392.97
Search Display TV Direct Mail Door Drop Radio
£-
£50
£100
£150
£200
£250
£300
£350
£400
Total CPR (£)
Valid CPR (£)
Active CPR (£)
Total CPR (£) £0.36 £0.47 £3.57 £35.00 £78.30 £103.23
Valid CPR (£) £0.36 £0.47 £3.60 £37.00 £127.68 £115.43
Active CPR (£) £43.66 £56.09 £89.12 £70.20 £221.70 £392.97
Search Display TV Direct Mail Door Drop Radio
A single very poor performing Maltese Cross
format doordrop for Tobacco messed the
averages up for some considerable time!
2009
2010
Best use of B2C direct mail,
Best Customer Acquisition
Best Launch Campaign
Best Business Performance or Improvement
Department of Health
Tobacco Quit Kit
Department of Health
Change4Life
Health and Safety Executive
Make the promise
Best use of B2B direct mail
Best use of Door Drops
Best Customer Acquisition
Best Launch Campaign
Best Direct Response Print Advertising
… but mostly they do
and we have won
the odd award too.
So as you can see …
For Government, direct channels such as inserts and door drops, direct mail and face to face have consistently performed well.
Though volumes acquired are often less than broadcast, quality and conversion is higher and they give the detail and a context for the issue/communications that the broadcast media can’t.
Being better targeted, they also tend to bring in core audience whereas the broadcast media will bring in quite a lot of the ‘worried well’.
So in summary …
Door drops/inserts and printed matter should always be a key part of the media mix
because they are:
� TANGIBLE and DISRUPTIVE - They are physical, have standout and can be
retained
� EXPLANATORY - They allow us to convey detailed/complex information
� TARGETED - They allow us to target people geographically, demographically
and by interest etc
� They work well against hard to reach/offline audiences (lower socio-economic
groups)
� For inserts, they can sit within a ‘trusted environment’
� For doordrops, when needed, they allow us to talk to everyone
and
� ACTION FOCUSSED - They play a crucial role in eliciting a direct response
and will generally lead to higher quality action and behaviour change
in short … they work.
Panel Debate
Thank you for attending this
event
Please do not forget to hand your
completed evaluation forms to a
DMA member of staff