The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE...

32
The Picayune Strand State Forest F W tl dE t t F il d From Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back K th W l Kathy Worley and David Addison David Addison Co-Directors, Environmental Science Department Conservancy of Southwest Florida 1450 Merrihue Drive Naples, Florida 34102

Transcript of The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE...

Page 1: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

The Picayune Strand State ForestF W tl d E t t F il dFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back

K th W lKathy Worleyand

David AddisonDavid Addison

Co-Directors, Environmental Science DepartmentConservancy of Southwest Florida

1450 Merrihue DriveNaples, Florida 34102

Page 2: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

What is this? - 1974

??

Page 3: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION DECISIONSModified Order 51 F. T. O.

IN THE MATTR OFIN THE MATTR OFCHARLES ANTELL, INC. ET AL.

ORDER REOPEXING PROCEEDING AND MODIFYIG ORDER TO CEASEAND DESIST, AND OPINION OF THE COMISSIOM

Docket 6102. Order and, Opinion, Nov. 1954

Order modifying cease and desist order of December 19, 1953 to bring it into conformity with the stipulated facts so as to prohibit representations that the main ingredient from a percentage standpoint in respondents' product Charles Antell Formula No. 9 was lanolin, and that said product would remedy the cause of cracked or split hair'product would remedy the cause of cracked or split hair .

Before Mr. John Levis hearing examiner.Mr. William L. Pencke for the Commission.

Mr. Bernard H. Herzfeld of Baltimore, Md. , for respondents

It is ordered that the respondent Charles Antell, Inc., a corporation, and its officers and respondents, Charles D. Kasher, Leonard L. Rosen and Julius. Rosen, individually, and respondent T. A. A., Inc. , a corporation, and its officers, and respondents respective agents, representatives and employees directly or through any corporate or other Charles Antellrepresentatives and employees , directly or through any corporate, or other Charles Antell Formula No. 9 and Charles Antell Shampoo, or device, in connection with the offering for sale or distribution of or any products of substantially similar composition or possessing substantially similar properties, whether sold under the same names or any other names, do forthwith cease and desist from directly or indirectly:

Page 4: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Leonard Julius

Who were these guys and how did they end yup in Florida?

Page 5: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Cape Coral - 1959Cape Coral 1959

Mangrove forest dredged in 1959 which is now Cape Coral.

Photograph reprinted from http://nsgl.gso.uri.edu/flsgp/flsgpm02003/flsgpm02003_part2h.pdf

Page 6: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

AdvertisementChicago Tribune

June 1967

Page 7: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Tree Crusheree C us e

Page 8: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

A grid of roads and canalsg

Page 9: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Golden Gate Ad – Chicago Tribune June 1967g

Page 10: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Selling “Da Blocks” - Chicago Tribune June 1967g g

Page 11: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Free flights – Free Meals – Free Sales Pitchg

Page 12: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Remuda Ranch/Port of the Islands – GAC was everywhere y

Jump in; only 80% of the land is underwater

Page 13: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

The Demise of Gulf American Corporatione e se o Gu e ca Co po at o

1968 Grand Jury Investigation1968 – Grand Jury Investigation

July 1968 – Leonard Rosen retires

10 days later – Gulf American Corporation sold to General Acceptance CorporationGeneral Acceptance Corporation

1975 – Gulf American Corporation filed for Bankruptcy

1980 – General American Corporation was renamedAvatar Holdings Incorporated

Page 14: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Golden Gate EstatesMap showing grid of roads and bisection of GAC holdings by I-75 into Northern Golden

Gate Estates and Southern Golden Gate EstatesGate Estates and Southern Golden Gate Estates

Page 15: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Golden Gate EstatesCanal Systems

Page 16: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Early Hydrologic Studiesa y yd o og c Stud es1974 - Black, Crow and Eidsness, Incorporated

surface and ground water hydrologyg y gy

1977 – Golden Gate Estates Redevelopment Study

1986 – Conservancy of SWFLgroundwater level fluctuations

1977 – Hydrologic Effects of the Canal System on Fakahatchee Strand

1988 – U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Hydrologic Studyalternatives to modifying the Faka Union Canalalternatives to modifying the Faka Union Canal System

Page 17: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Weirs on drainage canals - Southern Golden Gate Estatesg

Page 18: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Miller Blvd. was once proposed as a hurricane evacuation route by a member of the Collier County Commissionby a member of the Collier County Commission

Page 19: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Signs of the times! – Southern Golden Gate Estates g

Page 20: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Agricultural Investmentg

Marijuana plant – 1 of 214

Page 21: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Bad Luck Prairie – Dry Seasony

Page 22: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Jeep Cherokee – Bad Luck Prairiep

Page 23: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Some day all of the Bad Luck Prairie will look like thisy

Page 24: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Will someone please tell me where on a warranty deed it says that a buyer is guaranteed to make money on land purchased in Florida, especially if g y y

the land is swamp.

Page 25: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Miami Herald – 1987 Wall Street Journal - 1996

Page 26: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Land Acquisition Progress

1995 15 0001995 – 15,000 acres acquired from property ownersp p y

1998 – U S Dept of the1998 – U.S. Dept. of the Interior Farm Bill money (25 million f h i l d)for purchasing land)

1998 – Lawsuit settled -2968 acres acquired

Page 27: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Land Acquisition Progress

1998 – Florida cabinet purchased 8526 acres from Avatar

2001 – Florida cabinet authorized the State to offer 25% more2001 Florida cabinet authorized the State to offer 25% more than the appraised value to willing sellers

2002 G J b B h th i d i iti b i t2002 – Gov. Jeb Bush authorized acquisition by eminent domain (1800 acres)

2005 – Jesse Hardy sold his land (160 acres)

2005 – Miccosukee Tribe sold 800 acres to the State2005 Miccosukee Tribe sold 800 acres to the State

2006 – Acquisition Finally Completed

Page 28: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

1998 – Southern Golden Gate Estates was identified as an essential part of the esse t a pa t o t eeffort to restore the Western Everglades

Acceler 8 Projects

Page 29: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Conservation areas surrounding Southern Golden Gate Estatesg

Page 30: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

And 35 years later…y

Page 31: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Prairie Canal Today

Page 32: The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom … · The Picayune Strand State Forest FWtldE ttFildFrom Wetland Ecosystem to Failed Residential Development and Back ... Charles

Acknowledgements

Mark Benedict

Gail Brett & Rob Levern

Chris Ramsey & Ruth DiDanato

Bill Branan

Michelle Conant

Mike Duever

Kim Dryden

Howard Yamataki

Mike BerryKim Dryden

Clarence Tears

Tony Polizos

y

Tim Howard

Sonja DurrwatcherTony Polizos Sonja Durrwatcher