7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

1/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

GXE]AE UKE[XA]Q A@A]AG]ASK

FNNSKX A@U]A][]AN@

A` 8::6) tfk [`atkm Utgtks dna`km nur ntfkr `gtan`s watf Gretae engsts7 a` assua`o tfk

Aiuiassgt Mkeigrgtan`) wfaef prneigabkm tfgt4

\]Rfk igw n tfk skg prnvamks nr abpnrtg`t raofts g`m nhiaogtan`s. . . . _k

rkbga` enbbattkm tn tfas ikogi rgbkwnrl g`m tn tfk nrmkriy skttikbk`t

n g`y pnssahik nvkrigppa`o eigabs. . . . ]fas rgbkwnrl prnvamks g sniam

nu`mgtan` nr rkspn`sahik bg`gokbk`t hy tfk vk engstgi Utgtks g`m

ntfkr uskrs n tfas Nekg` tfrnuof gtan`gi abpikbk`tgtan` g`m gppiaegtan`

n rkikvg`t prnvasan`s. _k tfkrknrk skk `n `kkm tn mkvkinp g `kw

enbprkfk`savk a`tkr`gtan gi ikogi rkoabk tn onvkr` tfk Gretae Nekg`.8

Hy a`vnla`o tfk igw n tfk skg) tfk vk Gretae `gtan`s wkrk getugiiy rkkrra`o tn

tfk [`atkm @gtan`s En`vk`tan` n` tfk Igw n tfk Ukg5 &[@EINU!.= Xussag) Eg`gmg)

Mk`bgrl) g`m @nrwgy fgvk rgtakm tfk En`vk`tan`. Gitfnuof tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs

`nt rgtakm) at en`samkrs [@EINU tn ok`krgiiy rkcket eustnbgry a`tkr`gtan`gi igw.;

]fk [`atkm Utgtks waiia`o`kss tn suppnrt [@EINU gs tfk onvkr`a`o ikogi rgbkwnrl

a` tfk Gretae as `n surprask. Gitfnuof tfk Aiuiassgt Mkeigrgtan` wgs sao`km mura`o tfk

Husf Gmba`astrgtan`) tfk Nhgbg Gmba`astrgtan`s @gtan`gi Utrgtkoy nr tfk Gretae

Xkoan` prneigabs tfgt4

Geekssan` tn tfk En`vk`tan` wnuim prntket [.U. raofts) rkkmnbs) g`m usks

n tfk skg g`m garspgek tfrnuofnut tfk Gretae rkoan`) g`m strk`otfk` nur

groubk`ts nr rkkmnb n `gvaogtan` g`m nvkr caoft tfrnuof tfk @nrtfwkst

hy Dgbks _. Fnuel

Gretae Ukeuraty A`atagtavk

www.fnnvkr.nrotgslnreksgretae"skeuraty

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nAo`nra`o tfk Igw n UkgEn`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

2/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 8 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

Zgssgok g`m tfk @nrtfkr` Ukg Xnutk. ]fk [`atkm Utgtks as tfk n`iy Gretae

stgtk tfgt as `nt pgrty tn tfk En`vk`tan`. N`iy hy dna`a`o tfk En`vk`tan` eg`

wk bgxabazk ikogi ekrtga`ty g`m hkst skeurk a`tkr`gtan`gi rkeno`atan` n nur

snvkrkao` raofts watf rkspket tn tfk [.U. kxtk`mkm en ta`k`tgi sfki a` tfkGretae g`m kiskwfkrk) wfaef bgy fnim vgst nai) ogs) g`m ntfkr rksnureks.3

_faik efgara`o fkgra`os a` Bgy 8:78 gs Efgarbg` n tfk Uk`gtk Cnrkao` Xkigtan`s

Enbbattkk) eurrk`t Ukerktgry n Utgtk Dnf` Lkrry igbk`tkm tfgt4

_faik wk waii sat n` tfk samkia`ks) Xussag g`m ntfkr enu`traks grk egrva`o

up tfk Gretae g`m igya`o eigabs tn tfk nai g`m ogs raefks a` tfgt rkoan`.

_k) n` tfk ntfkr fg`m) eg`t kvk` geekss tfk trkgty hnmy tfgt prnvamks

a`tkr`gtan`gi ikoatabgey nr tfksk typks n Gretae eigabs. A`stkgm n tgla`o

kvkry pnssahik stkp tn k`surk nur stglk a` tfas rksnurek"raef grkg) wk grk

wgtefa`o ntfkrs gsskrt tfkar eigabs g`m mna`o `ntfa`o ghnut at hkeguskwk fgvk `n ikogi rkenursk.?

[.U. a`mustry rkprksk`tgtavks fgvk kefnkm tfas vakw gs wkii. Dgel Okrgrm) Efak

Kxkeutavk Nekr n tfk Gbkraeg` Zktrnikub A`statutk) fgs `ntkm tfgt4

Kstghiasfa`o tfk en`ta`k tgi bgroa` hkyn`m 8:: baiks as pgrtaeuigriy

abpnrtg`t a` tfk Gretae) wfkrk tfkrk grk girkgmy g `ubhkr n enu`traks vya`o

tn kxpg`m tfkar nsfnrk durasmaetan`gi eigabs. . . . ]fk En`vk`tan` waii a`erkgsk

ekrtga`ty a` g sao`aeg`t bg``kr g`m waii a` tur` bglk at buef kgsakr tn mkeamk

tn a`vkst haiian`s n mniigrs a` uturk npkrgtan`s.6

Mkspatk tfas suppnrt) [@EINU fgs k`murkm g tnrturkm dnur`ky watfa` tfk [`atkm

Utgtks. Zrksamk t Xn`gim Xkgog` rkeno`azkm tfk trkgtys `gtan`gi skeuraty vgiuk g`m

marketkm tfk [`atkm Utgtks tn npkrgtk a` geenrm watf [@EINU) watf tfk kxekptan` n

tfk mkkp skghkm ba`a`o prnvasan`s.1 Zrksamk`t Xkgog`s nhdketan`s tn tfk mkkp skghkm

ba`a`o prnvasan`s wkrk igtkr rksnivkm) ikgma`o Zrksamk`t Haii Eia`tn` tn trg`sbat

tfk trkgty tn tfk Uk`gtk nr gmvaek g`m en`sk`t n` Netnhkr ?) 711=.7: G`m ykt) tfk

[`atkm Utgtks rkbga`s nutsamk tfk en`vk`tan`. Gitfnuof tfk Uk`gtk Cnrkao` Xkigtan`s

Enbbattkk fgs twaek vntkm [@EINU gvnrghiy nut n enbbattkk hy wamk bgroa`s) tfk

en`vk`tan` fgs kvkr rkekavkm g uii Uk`gtk vntk.77

]fk masen`ta`uaty hktwkk` tfk `gtan`gi mksark nr g` kketavk Gretae pniaey g`m tfk

a`tkrba`ghik g`m rgetanus [@EINU mkhgtk rgasks g u`mgbk`tgi qukstan`4 Mnks

tfk [`atkm Utgtks gaiurk tn dna` [@EINU getugiiy furt [.U. a`tkrksts a` tfk Gretae> As

[@EINU g` kssk`tagi nu`mgtan` nr [.U. Gretae pniaey nr g` u``kekssgry bnrgss ialkiy

tn krnmk [.U. snvkrkao`ty g`m mrga` vatgiaty rnb [.U. a`vkstbk`ts> Bnrknvkr) oavk`

tfgt tfk Gretae Enu`eai fgs gmnptkm [@EINU gs ats onvkr`a`o ikogi rgbkwnrl g`m tfgt

tfk [`atkm Utgtks as staii ghik tn pgrtaeapgtk uiiy a` Gretae onvkr`g`ek) wnuim [@EINU

geekssan` prnvamk tfk [`atkm Utgtks g`y hk`kt `nt girkgmy gvgaighik> A tfk [`atkm

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

3/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 5 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

Utgtks eg` mn kvkrytfa`o n abpnrtg`ek a` tfk Gretae watfnut dna`a`o [@EINU) wfy on

tn tfk trnuhik>

]fas pgpkr gmmrkssks tfksk qukstan`s. ]fk pgpkr hkoa`s hy hrakcy survkya`o tfkkxtk`t tn wfaef tfk en`vk`tan`s prnvasan`s a`tkrsket watf [`atkm Utgtks a`tkrksts

a` tfk Gretae. @nt surprasa`oiy) tfkrk as kxtk`savk nvkrigp. ]fk pgpkr tfk` rkvakws

groubk`ts tfgt [@EINU as arrkikvg`t nr kvk` g`tatfktaegi tn gefakva`o tfksk abpnrtg`t

[.U. a`tkrksts. Gtkr erataqua`o tfk g`ta"[@EINU groubk`ts) tfk pgpkr kxgba`ks tfk

egsk nr [@EINU. ]fk pgpkr neusks a` pgrtaeuigr n` [.U. a`tkrksts n` tfk Gretae

skgcnnr) groua`o tfgt tfksk a`tkrksts grk kxtk`savk g`m tfgt geekssan` wnuim fkip

gvkrt g wamk rg`ok n pntk`tagi pniataegi) ikogi) g`m rkouigtnry efgiik`oks rnb nrkao`

onvkr`bk`ts g`m enrpnrgtan`s. ]fk pnssahaiaty n suef efgiik`oks erkgtks pniataegi

g`m ikogi u`ekrtga`ty gs in`o gs tfk [`atkm Utgtks rkbga`s nutsamk tfk en`vk`tan` g`m

prnvamks g hn`g mk masa`ek`tavk nr [.U."iaek`skm enrpnrgtan`s tn u`mkrtglk tfk typk

n kxpinrgtan` g`m mkvkinpbk`t getavataks `kekssgry tn rkgiazk g fnst n nsfnrkhk`kts. Bnrknvkr) hy stgya`o nutsamk [@EINU) tfk [`atkm Utgtks as nrkata`o g`

nppnrtu`aty tn rka`nrek g gvnrghik Gretae ikogi rkoabk tfgt enuim gek prkssurk rnb

`n`"Gretae `gtan`s a` tfk uturk. ]fk pgpkr en`eiumks hy rkenbbk`ma`o tfgt tfk

[.U. geekmk tn [@EINU gt tfk snn`kst nppnrtu`aty.

]fk A`tkrsketan` nc [.U Gretae A`tkrksts g`m [@EINU

[@EINU kstghiasfks bgratabk zn`ks watf pra`eapiks g`m ruiks rkikvg`t tn tfk wnrims

k`tark bgratabk mnbga`) gmmrkssa`o tnpaes rg`oa`o rnb supprkssan` n pargey

tn en`skrvgtan` n sf stnels tn en`struetan` n grtaeagi asig`ms gt skg. _atf ats

skvk`tkk` pgrts) 58: grtaeiks) `a`k g``kxks) g`m g suppikbk`tgry spkeagi gorkkbk`t

n` mkkp skghkm ba`a`o) [@EINU tnuefks `kgriy kvkry en`ekavghik [.U. bgratabk

a`tkrkst a` tfk Gretae. [`mkrstg`ma`o tfas a`tkrsketan` as erataegi nr kvgiugta`o tfk

en`vk`tan s pntk`tagi gs g` a`strubk`t n [.U. Gretae pniaey.

Crkkmnb n @gvaogtan`

Gs g `gtan` watf oinhgi bgratabk a`tkrksts) tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs en`sastk`tiy vakwkm

tfk [@EINU prnvasan`s n` rkkmnb n `gvaogtan` n` tfk faof skgs g`m a` kxeiusavk

ken`nbae zn`ks &KKTs!) trg`sat pgssgok tfrnuof strgats uskm nr a`tkr`gtan`gi

`gvaogtan`) g`m a``nek`t pgssgok tfrnuof tkrratnragi skgs gs tfk en`vk`tan s

kssk`tagi enrk.78 Gitfnuof [@EINU `gvaogtan` prnvasan`s wkrk `nt mksao`km watf tfk

Gretae a` ba`m pkr sk) tfk prnvasan`s grk en`sastk`t watf tfk [`atkm Utgtks a`tkrkst

a` rkkmnb n `gvaogtan` a` g`m tfrnuof tfk Gretae.75

Gitfnuof kxpkrts makr n` tfk abba`k`ek g`m kxtk`t n rkouigr Gretae trg`sats) snbk

seak`tae stumaks suookst tfgt a`erkgsa`o tkbpkrgturks waii rksuit a` g skgsn`giiy

aek"rkk Gretae gs kgriy gs tfk 8:5:s.7= Gs tfk aek rkekmks) bg`y kxpket tfk npk`a`o

n bnrk kxpkmatanus trgvki rnutks)7; watf en`skquk`eks nr a`tkr`gtan`gi skeuraty g`m

enbbkreagi getavataks.73 A` pgrtaeuigr) twn trg`s"Gretae rnutks grk kxpketkm tn hkenbk

a`erkgsa`oiy erataegi4 tfk @nrtfwkst Zgssgok g`m tfk @nrtfkr` Ukg Xnutk.7?

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

4/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae = Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

]fk @nrtfkr` Ukg Xnutk rkkrs tn tfk rnutks ru``a`o gin`o tfk `nrtfkr` engsts n

Kurgsag g`m Uahkrag hktwkk` tfk Hgrk`ts Ukg g`m tfk Efulefa Ukg.76 Gs n Du`k 3) 8:75)

tfk @nrtfkr` Ukg Xnutk Enbbassan` gpprnvkm ty"nur vksskis tn usk tfk @nrtfkr`

Ukg Xnutk mura`o tfk 8:75 subbkr.71 ]fk `ubhkr n vksskis usa`o tfk @nrtfkr` UkgXnutk sa`ek 8:7: fgs a`erkgskm tk`nim.8: ]fk @nrtfwkst Zgssgok en``kets Hg` Hgy

g`m Mgvas Utrgat a` tfk Gtig`tae tn tfk Hkgunrt Ukg a` tfk Gretae g`m a`eiumks gii rnutks

gin`o tfk `nrtfkr` engst n @nrtf Gbkraeg tfrnuof tfk Eg`gmag` Gretae Grefapkigon.87

Hntf rnutks en``ket tfk Zgeae g`m tfk Gtig`tae Nekg`s tfrnuof tfk Hkra`o Utrgat)88

g`m tfky fgvk tfk pntk`tagi tn mkerkgsk tfk trgvki mastg`ek hktwkk` Kurnpk g`m

Gsag hy up tn ;)8:: `gutaegi baiks.85 Gitfnuof tfk prksk`ek n skgsn`gi aek iabats tfk

rkouigr usk n tfksk `gvaogtan`gi rnutks) hntf Gretae" g`m `n`"Gretae"stgtks skkl tn

usk tfksk wgtkrs bnrk rkquk`tiy.8=

]fk iuergtavk gvaogtan` pntk`tagi n tfksk rnutks bust hk hgig`ekm goga`st

k`varn`bk`tgi prntketan`. Eg`gmg eigabs tfk wgtkrs tfgt enbprask tfk @nrtfwkstZgssgok gs ats a`tkr`gi wgtkrs.8; Xussag eigabs tfk wgtkrs n skvkrgi strgats gin`o tfk

@nrtfkr` Ukg Xnutk gs a`tkr`gi wgtkrs g`m gppiaks Grtaeik 85=) pkrtga`a`o tn aek"

envkrkm grkgs n tfk KKT) tn tfk rkst n tfk rnutk.83 ]fk [`atkm Utgtks) gbn`o ntfkr

`gtan`s) fgs en`sastk`tiy masgorkkm watf tfksk eigabs)8? groua`o tfgt tfksk rnutks

sfnuim hk onvkr`km hy tfk ikogi rkoabk n trg`sat pgssgok tfrnuof strgats uskm nr

a`tkr`gtan`gi gvaogtan`.86

Hntf Eg`gmg g`m tfk Xussag` Ckmkrgtan` fgvk k`getkm rkouigtan`s tfgt tfk [`atkm

Utgtks hkiakvks gbnu`t tn u`wgrrg`tkm rkstraetan`s n` tfk raoft n trg`sat pgssgok.

Eg`gmg) nr kxgbpik) abpnskm g bg`mgtnry sfap rkpnrta`o g`m vksski trge skrvaek

systkb &@NXMXKO! tfgt onvkr`s trg`sat tfrnuof tfk @nrtfwkst Zgssgok.81 @NXMXKO

envkrs Eg`gmgs KKT g`m tfk skvkrgi @nrtfwkst Zgssgok rnutks a` tfk Eg`gmag` Gretae

Grefapkigon.5: Eg`gmg spkeaegiiy eatks [@EINU Grtaeik 85= tn dustay @NXMXKO)

gsskrta`o tfgt tfk rkpnrta`o rkquarkbk`ts grk tn prkvk`t g`m rkmuek bgra`k pniiutan`

rnb vksskis a` tfk mkiaegtk Gretae wgtkrs.57 Uabaigriy) tfk Xussag` Ckmkrgtan` fgs

fastnraegiiy iabatkm trg`sat pgssgok a` tfk @nrtfkr` Ukg Xnutk)58 usa`o [@EINU

Grtaeik 85= tn dustay tfk iabatgtan`s)55 g`m fgs rkek`tiy abpikbk`tkm bnrk kxtk`savk

u`aigtkrgi rkouigtan`s tn k`surk sfappa`o sgkty g`m k`varn`bk`tgi prntketan`.5= _atf

rkekma`o gbnu`ts n aek nr sao`aeg`t pnrtan`s n tfk ykgr) wfktfkr tfk @nrtfwkst

Zgssgok nr tfk @nrtfkr` Ukg Xnutk bkkts Grtaeik 85=s eiabgtae rkquarkbk`ts nr aek"

envkrkm grkgs as mkhgtghik.5;

[`mkr [@EINU) engstgi stgtks skkla`o tn prkserahk skg"ig`ks g`m trge skpgrgtan`

sefkbks a` strgats uskm nr a`tkr`gtan`gi gvaogtan` bust rkekavk gpprnvgi hy g

enbpktk`t a`tkr`gtan`gi nrog`azgtan` pranr tn gmnptan`.53 ]fk A`tkr`gtan`gi Bgratabk

Nrog`azgtan` &ABN! iis tfas rnik. ]fk [`atkm Utgtks as wnrla`o watf ntfkr Gretae

`gtan`s tfrnuof tfk ABN tn erkgtk g bg`mgtnry Znigr Enmk tfgt waii envkr gii

bgttkrs rkikvg`t tn sfaps npkrgta`o a` hntf Gretae wgtkrs g`m tfk wgtkrs surrnu`ma`o

G`tgretaeg.5? ]fk ABN rkek`tiy g``nu`ekm tfgt tfk Znigr Enmk waii hk npkrgtan`gi gs

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

5/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae ; Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

kgriy gs 8:7; g`m waii hk abpikbk`tkm hy 8:73.56 ]fk kxtk`t tn wfaef tfk Znigr Enmk

rken`eaiks Xussag` g`m Eg`gmag` a`tkrksts a` rkouigta`o tfk @nrtfkr` Ukg Xnutk g`m

@nrtfwkst Zgssgok watf rkkmnb n `gvaogtan` a`tkrksts waii hk erataegi.

K`varn`bk`tgi Zrntketan`

@n gtan`) a`eiuma`o tfk [`atkm Utgtks) masputks tfk bnrgi g`m ken`nbae abpkrgtavk

tn prntket tfk Gretaes prasta`k k`varn`bk`t. ]fk [`atkm Utgtks u`mkrstg`ms tfk

rgoaiaty n tfk rkoan` g`m tfk kkm tn prgetaek rkspn`sahik stkwgrmsfap wfaik

pursua`o ats Gretae a`tkrksts.51 [@EINU pigys g prnba`k`t hut `nt kxeiusavk rnik

a` tfas rkogrm.

[@EINU erkgtks g` nhiaogtan` tn prntket g`m prkskrvk tfk bgra`k k`varn`bk`t.=:

Fnwkvkr) at gvnams spkeae ruiks nr stg`mgrms a` gvnr n erkgta`o zn`ks n rkouigtnry

enbpktk`ek g`m prnvama`o g rgbkwnrl n pra`eapiks mksao`km tn k`enurgok tfk

erkgtan` n bnrk spkeae ruiks g`m stg`mgrms tfrnuof mnbkstae rkouigtan` g`mskpgrgtk a`tkr`gtan`gi gorkkbk`ts.

[@EINU prnvamks stgtks watf kxeiusavk) snvkrkao` durasmaetan` tn rkouigtk tfk

k`varn`bk`t watfa` tfkar tkrratnragi skg.=7 Utgtks gisn fgvk snvkrkao` raofts nr

tfk purpnsk n kxpinra`o g`m kxpinata`o) en`skrva`o g`m bg`goa`o tfk `gturgi

rksnureks . . . n tfk wgtkrs supkrdgek t tn tfk skghkm g`m n tfk skghkm g`m ats

suhsnai)=8 g`m durasmaetan` . . . watf rkogrm tn . . . tfk prntketan` g`m prkskrvgtan`

n tfk bgra`k k`varn`bk`t a` tfk kxeiusavk ken`nbae zn`k &KKT!.=5 A` kxkreasa`o

raofts g`m pkrnrba`o mutaks a` tfk KKT) engstgi stgtks bust mn sn watf muk

rkogrm nr tfk raofts g`m mutaks n ntfkr stgtks)== `nt tfk ikgst n wfaef as rkkmnb

n gvaogtan`.

A` gmmatan` tn tfk ABN Znigr Enmk maseusskm ghnvk) skvkrgi a`tkr`gtan`gi k`varn`bk`tgi

gorkkbk`ts g`m ouamkia`ks guobk`t [@EINU. ]fk A`tkr`gtan`gi En`vk`tan` nr tfk

Zrkvk`tan` n Zniiutan` rnb Ufaps &BGXZNI ?5?6!) g trkgty abpikbk`tkm hy tfk ABN

&Bgrpni as sfnrt nr bgra`k pniiutan` g`m ?5?6 stg`ms nr tfk ykgrs 71?5 g`m 71?6!)

onvkr`s tfk rkouigtan`) rkmuetan`) g`m prkvk`tan` n sfap pniiutan` eguskm hy

npkrgtan`gi nr geeamk`tgi getavataks.=; ]fk Gretae Enu`eai ba`astkrs rkek`tiy sao`km tfk

Gorkkbk`t n` Ennpkrgtan` n` Bgra`k Nai Zniiutan` Zrkpgrkm`kss g`m Xkspn`sk a`

tfk Gretae tfgt erkgtkm g rkoan`gi rkspn`sk pig` tn ennpkrgtavkiy gmmrkss nai spaiis

a` tfk Gretae.=3 ]fk Gretae Enu`eai fgs gisn erkgtkm wnrla`o ornups) pgrtaeuigriy tfk

Zrntketan` n tfk Gretae Bgra`k K`varn`bk`t _nrla`o Ornup &ZGBK!) tn rkskgref g`m

erkgtk rkpnrts ghnut k`varn`bk`tgi en`ekr`s u`aquk tn tfk Gretae.=? ZGBK prkvanusiy

assukm g rkpnrt tfgt stumakm tfk pntk`tagi kkets a`erkgskm sfappa`o waii fgvk n`

tfk Gretae) suooksta`o wgys hy wfaef stgtks enuim prkvk`t k`varn`bk`tgi fgrb)=6

g`m prnvamkm gmvasnry ouamkia`ks nr nsfnrk nai g`m ogs prnmuetan` a` tfk Gretae.=1

ZGBKs 8:758:7; gok`mg a`eiumks mktkrba`a`o tfk gmkqugey n a`tkr`gtan`gi g`m

rkoan`gi enbbatbk`ts en`ekr`a`o k`varn`bk`tgi prntketan` g`m prnbnta`o tfkar

abpikbk`tgtan` g`m enbpiag`ek.;:

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

6/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 3 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

Casfa`o

[@EINU skrvks gs tfk a`tkr`gtan`gi nu`mgtan` nr sfkraks bg`gokbk`t) oava`o

engstgi stgtks snvkrkao` raofts nvkr `gturgi rksnureks a` tfkar KKTs) g muty tn

en`skrvk g`m tfk raoft tn utaiazk sf stnels) g`m g muty tn ennpkrgtk watf ntfkrenu`traks a` tfk bg`gokbk`t n ekrtga` sf stnels.;7 ]fk 711; [`atkm @gtan`s Casf

Utnels Gorkkbk`t);8 tn wfaef tfk [`atkm Utgtks as g pgrty) prnvamks g prkegutan`gry

gpprngef tn sfkraks g`m k`enurgoks rkoan`gi ennpkrgtan` a` bg`gokbk`t n sfkraks

a` tfk faof skgs.;5 Gitfnuof [@EINU mnks `nt prnvamk g mktgaikm rkoabk tfrnuof

wfaef stgtk pgrtaks bust bg`gok sfkraks) at prnvamks g hrngm rgbkwnrl tfgt

k`enurgoks buitaigtkrgi gpprngefks tn sustga`ghik mkvkinpbk`t n sf stnels.;=

Ukvkrgi getnrs) a`eiuma`o aek envkr) enim wgtkr tkbpkrgturks) g`m inw prabgry

prnmuetan` prkvk`t tfk mkvkinpbk`t n enbbkreagi sf stnels a` tfk ek`trgi Gretae

Nekg`.;; ]fk skgs surrnu`ma`o tfk Gretae Nekg`) fnwkvkr) en`tga` igrok) oinhgiiy

abpnrtg`t sf stnels) en`statuta`o bnrk tfg` 7: pkrek`t n oinhgi bgra`k sf egtefkshy wkaoft g`m kqugia`o haiian`s n mniigrs a` ken`nbae vgiuk.;3 Enbpgrkm tn bnst

bgdnr a`tkr`gtan`gi enbbkreagi sfkraks) Gretae sfkraks grk enbpgrgtavkiy wkii"

bg`gokm muk tn tfk kxtk`savk rkoabk n sfkraks rkouigtan`s tfgt gket tfk Gretae.;?

Cnur a`tkr`gtan`gi nr buitaigtkrgi gorkkbk`ts) kaoft rkoan`gi gorkkbk`ts) g`m nur

haigtkrgi gorkkbk`ts kgef gket makrk`t grkgs n tfk Gretae) makrk`t typks n

sf) g`m makrk`t Gretae `gtan`s.;6 ]fk Gretae Enu`eais hanmavkrsaty wnrla`o ornup

rkikgskm g rkpnrt stgta`o tfgt tfk aiikogi) u`rkouigtkm) g`m u`rkpnrtkm &A[[! sfkraks

wkrk g prnhikb skvkrgi ykgrs gon) hut watf [@EINU g`m suhstg`tagi abprnvkbk`t a`

ennpkrgtan`) A[[ sfa`o fgs mkerkgskm a` tfk nekg`s surrnu`ma`o tfk Gretae.;1

Bgra`k Ueak`tae Xkskgref

Gs bnst n tfk Gretae Nekg` fgs `nt hkk` kxpinrkm) n`k n tfk [.U. pniaey ongis a`

tfk Gretae as tn a`erkgsk u`mkrstg`ma`o tfrnuof seak`tae rkskgref.3: Eurrk`tiy) tfk

nrkbnst seak`tae rkskgref a`tkrkst nr tfk [`atkm Utgtks as tn nhtga` mgtg rkogrma`o

tfk okninoae enbpnsatan` n tfk en`ta`k`tgi bgroa`. A` gmmatan`) tfk [`atkm Utgtks as

pursua`o rkskgref a` eiabgtk vgraghaiaty) Gretae bgra`k kensystkbs) nai spaii kkets)

g`m u`en`vk`tan`gi k`kroy g`m ba`krgi rksnureks.37 Bgra`k Ueak`tae Xkskgref &BUX!

a` Xussag` gretae wgtkrs) wfkrk Xussag fgs tfk in`okst Gretae engstia`k) as fgbpkrkm

hy Xussag` rkiuetg`ek tn pkrbat [.U. rkskgrefkrs geekss tn Xussag` wgtkrs.

]fk [`atkm Utgtks fgs in`o geekptkm tfk [@EINU rkoabk nr bgra`k seak`tae

rkskgref. [@EINU oavks engstgi stgtks kxeiusavk en`trni nvkr seak`tae rkskgref

a` tfk tkrratnragi skg.38 Engstgi stgtks gisn fgvk kxtk`savk raofts a` tfk KKT) a`eiuma`o

tfk raoft tn rkdket g rkqukst hy g nrkao` `gtan` nr enbpg`y nr geekss tn ats KKT

nr en`ta`k`tgi sfki a tfk prndket as n market sao`aeg`ek nr tfk kxpinrgtan` g`m

kxpinatgtan` n gturgi rksnureks35 nr a`vnivks mraiia`o a`tn tfk en`ta`k`tgi sfki)

tfk usk n kxpinsavks) nr tfk a`trnmuetan` n fgrbui suhstg`eks a`tn tfk bgra`k

k`varn`bk`t.3= ]fk en`vk`tan` prnvamks gii stgtks tfk raoft tn en`muet bgra`k seak`tae

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

7/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae ? Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

rkskgref a` tfk faof skgs.3; G stgtks ghaiaty tn pkrnrb seak`tae rkskgref a` tfk grkg

as suhdket tn tfk prnvasan`s n Zgrt VA) tfk mkkp skghkm ba`a`o rkoabk.33 Grtaeik 7=5

stgtks tfgt gii bkbhkr stgtks eg` en`muet bgra`k seak`tae rkskgref a` tfk grkg)

hut tfky bust prnvamk tfk rksuits n tfkar rkskgref g`m g`giysas tn tfk a`tkr`gtan`gienbbu`aty tfrnuof tfk A`tkr`gtan`gi Ukghkm Gutfnraty.3?

Ukgcnnr Xksnureks

]fk [`atkm Utgtks fgs sao`aeg`t pntk`tagi a`tkrksts n` tfk Gretae skgcnnr. A`

tfk Nhgbg Gmba`astrgtan`s Bgy 8:75 @gtan`gi Utrgtkoy nr tfk Gretae Xkoan`) tfk

gmba`astrgtan` stgtkm tfgt k`kroy skeuraty as g enrk enbpn`k t n \[.U.R gtan`gi

skeuraty strgtkoy g`m hy rkspn`sahiy mkvkinpa`o tfk Gretaes prnvkm g`m pntk`tagi

nai g`m ogs rksnureks) tfk [`atkm Utgtks waii rkmuek rkiag`ek n` nrkao` nai.36 [@EINU

prnvamks mktgaikm ruiks g`m prnekmurks rkouigta`o getavaty n` tfk skgcnnr.

[@EINU g`m tfk En`ta`k`tgi Ufki[@EINU prnvamks tfgt `gtan`s k`dny snvkrkao` raofts tn tfk wgtkr eniub` gs wkii gs

tfk iava`o g`m `n`"iava`o rksnureks n tfk nekg` cnnr tn g mastg`ek n 8:: `gutaegi

baiks rnb tfk engstgi hgskia`k.31 ]fk snvkrkao` raoft tn kxpinrk g`m mkvkinp

rksnureks a` tfas grkg) l`nw` gs tfk en`ta`k`tgi sfki) as gisn en`samkrkm eustnbgry

a`tkr`gtan`gi igw.?: [@EINU) fnwkvkr) a`trnmuekm skvkrgi abpnrtg`t kw kikbk`ts tfgt

onvkr` g stgtks ghaiaty tn kxtk`m ats kxeiusavk snvkrkao` raofts tn kxpinrk g`m mkvkinp

ats en`ta`k`tgi sfki rksnureks.

]fk tkrb en`ta`k`tgi sfki gs uskm a` [@EINU rkkrs tn tfk okninoae en`ta`k`tgi

bgroa` bgmk up n tfk okninoae sfki) tfk okninoae sinpk) g`m tfk okninoae rask.?7

[@EINU spkeaegiiy mk`ks tfk en`ta`k`tgi sfki gs katfkr tfk gturgi prnin`ogtan`

n ig`m tkrratnry tn tfk nutkr kmok n tfk en`ta`k`tgi bgroa` nr 8:: baiks rnb g

engstgi stgtks hgskia`k) wfaefkvkr as orkgtkr.?8 _fk` g engstgi stgtks en`ta`k`tgi

bgroa` kxtk`ms grtfkr tfg` tfk 8::`gutaegi baik iabat abpnskm hy eustnbgry

a`tkr`gtan`gi igw) [@EINU prnvamks tfgt g gtan` bgy kxkreask snvkrkao` raofts nvkr

tfk skghkm cnnr hkyn`m 8:: `gutaegi baiks?5 a` tfk grkg l`nw` gs tfk kxtk`mkm

en`ta`k`tgi sfki.?= ]fk trkgty a`eiumks twn nrbuigs tn mktkrba`k tfk nutkr iabats

n en`ta`k`tgi bgroa`s?; g`m twn bktfnms tn skt en`strga`t ia`ks pgst wfaef engstgi

stgtks eg``nt eigab snvkrkao`ty.?3

[@EINU gisn prnvamks g prnekss tfrnuof wfaef engstgi stgtks eg` rkmuek tfk

pntk`tagi nr masputk g`m u`ekrtga`ty nvkr tfkar en`ta`k`tgi bgroa`s iabats. ]fas

as pgrtaeuigriy abpnrtg`t a` tfk Gretae wfkrk tfk [.U. kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki

ialkiy nvkrigps watf tfgt n hntf tfk Xussag` Ckmkrgtan` g`m Eg`gmg. [`mkr [@EINU

Grtaeik ?3) g engstgi stgtk bgy nhtga` a`tkr`gtan`gi rkeno`atan` nr tfk nutkr iabats n

ats eigab tn g` kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki hy suhbatta`o g eigab tn tfk Enbbassan`

n` tfk Iabats n tfk En`ta`k`tgi Ufki &EIEU!.?? ]fk EIEU en`sasts n twk`ty"n`k

kiketkm kxpkrts a` okninoy) oknpfysaes) nr fymrnorgpfy) g`m bgy n`iy hk `gtan`gis

n [@EINU Utgtk pgrtaks.?6 G engstgi stgtk bust ogtfkr seak`tae g`m tkef`aegi mgtg

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

8/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 6 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

tfgt mkserahks tfk efgrgetkrastaes n tfk skghkm g`m suhsnai g`m suhbat ats eigab tn

tfk EIEU watfa` tk` ykgrs n hkenba`o g pgrty tn [@EINU.?1 G skvk`"bkbhkr EIEU

suhenbbattkk tfk` g`giyzks tfk mgtg g`m prkpgrks rkenbbk`mgtan`s rkogrma`o

tfk nutkr iabats n tfk en`ta`k`tgi sfki.6: ]fk rkenbbk`mgtan`s bust hk gpprnvkmhy g twn"tfarms bgdnraty n EIEU bkbhkrs.67 A tfk engstgi stgtk gorkks tn tfk

gpprnvkm rkenbbk`mgtan`s) tfk iabats grk `gi g`m ha`ma`o n` tfk a`tkr`gtan`gi

enbbu`aty.68

]fkrk fgvk hkk` saxty"sax kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki suhbassan`s tn tfk EIEU bgmk

hy ty"nur bkbhkr stgtks tn mgtk.65 ]fas prnekss tglks skvkrgi ykgrs tn enbpiktk

g`m at as g`taeapgtkm tfgt tfk EIEU waii `nt rk`mkr mkeasan`s n` snbk suhbassan`s

&nr kxgbpik) tfnsk suhbattkm a` 8:7: nr igtkr! u`tai gs igtk gs 8:5:. 6=

Zursug`t tn Grtaeik ??.5) tfk engstgi stgtk as k`tatikm tn kxpinrk g`m mkvkinp tfk

rksnureks n ats kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki) suhdket tn tfk rnygity prnvasan`s sktnrtf a` Grtaeik 68. Grtaeik 68.7 bg`mgtks tfgt g stgtk bglk g``ugi pgybk`ts watf

rkspket tn ats kxpinatgtan` n `n`"iava`o rksnureks n` ats kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi

sfki. Hkoa``a`o a` tfk saxtf ykgr n prnmuetan`) pgybk`ts grk bgmk stgrta`o gt

tfk rgtk n 7 pkrek`t n tfk tntgi vgiuk n prnmuetan` gt kgef satk) a`erkgsa`o hy

7 pkrek`t kgef ykgr u`tai tfk twkitf ykgr wfk` tfk pgybk`t pigtkgus gt ? pkrek`t

n prnmuetan` vgiuk nr kvkry ykgr tfkrkgtkr.6;

Zgybk`ts grk suhbattkm tn tfk A`tkr`gtan`gi Ukghkm Gutfnraty &AUG nr Gutfnraty!)63

tfk [@EINU"erkgtkm hnmy tfgt rkouigtks tfk kxpinrgtan` nr g`m kxpinatgtan` n tfk

`gturgi rksnureks a` tfk grkg.6? ]fk AUG mastrahutks tfk rnygitaks hgskm n` tfk `kkms

g`m a`tkrksts n [@EINU bkbhkr stgtks) hut fgs `n ntfkr a`vnivkbk`t a` tfk

kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki mkvkinpbk`t prnekss.66

]fk pntk`tagi abpiaegtan`s n tfas kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki rkoabk grk prnnu`m.

_atf n`k n tfk igrokst engstia`ks a` tfk wnrim) tfk [`atkm Utgtks as kxpketkm tn

fgvk nvkr 817)::: squgrk baiks n kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki.61 ]fk [.U. en`ta`k`tgi

bgroa` n tfk engst n Gigslg gin`k bgy kxtk`m tn g ba`abub n 3:: baiks rnb tfk

Gigslg` hgskia`k.1: Gigslgs kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki iaks nvkr tfk Gretae Gigslg

prnva`ek) n`k n tfk bg`y nai" g`m ogs"raef hgsa`s a` tfk Gretae.17 At as kstabgtkm tfgt

tfkrk bgy hk gibnst ?5 haiian` hgrrkis n nai g`m nai"kquavgik`t `gturgi ogs inegtkm a`

tfk Gretae Gigslg prnva`ek) tfk sken`m faofkst kstabgtkm prnmuetan` egpghaiaty n gii

Gretae prnva`eks.18 ]fk en`ta`k`tgi sfki watfa` tfk 8::"baik KKT u`mkr tfk Hkgunrt

g`m Efulefa Ukgs gin`k bgy fgvk nvkr 85 haiian` hgrrkis n nai g`m 7:= traiian` euhae

kkt n `gturgi ogs.15 @nt n`iy wnuim mkvkinpbk`t n tfksk rksnureks prnbntk k`kroy

a`mkpk`mk`ek) g [.U. gtan`gi skeuraty nhdketavk)1= at wnuim gisn erkgtk gibnst ;;):::

dnhs pkr ykgr `gtan`wamk g`m ok`krgtk nvkr -715 haiian` a` kmkrgi) stgtk) g`m inegi

rkvk`uk nvkr g ty"ykgr pkranm.1; Muk tn mkigys a` Gretae nai g`m ogs kxpinrgtan`

a` tfk Efulefa g`m Hkgunrt Ukgs) hntf watfa` tfk [.U. 8::"baik KKT) tfk kgriakst

kstabgtkm mgtk n kxtrgetan` as snbktabk gtkr 8:71.13

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

9/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 1 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

Oga`a`o kxeiusavk snvkrkao` raofts nvkr tfk uii pntk`tagi [.U. Gretae kxtk`mkm

en`ta`k`tgi sfki waii prnvk maeuit) fnwkvkr) muk tn tfk einsk prnxabaty gbn`o tfk

[`atkm Utgtks) Xussag) g`m Eg`gmg g`m tfk pntk`tagi nr nvkrigppa`o eigabs tn kxtk`mkm

en`ta`k`tgi sfkivks. ]fk Xussag` Ckmkrgtan` wgs tfk rst [@EINU pgrty tn suhbatg` kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki eigab tn tfk EIEU.1? ]fk EIEU rkdketkm Xussags a`atagi

8::7 suhbassan` hut pkrbattkm at tn rkvask g`m rksuhbat ats eigab. Xussag g`taeapgtks

suhbatta`o ats rkvaskm eigab nr ats kxtk`mkm sfki a` tfk Gretae hy tfk k`m n tfk

ykgr.16 Mk`bgrl) Aekig`m) g`m @nrwgy gisn suhbattkm eigabs tn tfk EIEU11 g`m Eg`gmg

bust mn sn hy Mkekbhkr 8:75.7:: ]fas waii ikgvk tfk [`atkm Utgtks gs tfk n`iy Gretae

`gtan` tfgt fgs `nt nrbgiiy eigabkm tfk nutkr iabats n g` kxtk`mkm en`ta k`tgi sfki.

Bnrknvkr) a Xussag geekpts tfk enbbassan`s rkenbbk`mgtan`s) Xussags kxtk`mkm

en`ta`k`tgi sfki hnu`mgraks grk `gi g`m ha`ma`o &gitfnuof at as `nt eikgr wfn as sn

hnu`m!. A tfk [`atkm Utgtks geekmks g`m kvk`tugiiy pkrkets g eigab tn tfk nutkr iabat

n ats kxtk`mkm sfki watf tfk EIEU) tfkrk as g efg`ek tfgt ats kxtk`mkm en`ta k`tgi

sfki waii nvkrigp watf Xussags. [@EINU giinws nr twn &nr bnrk! ikoatabgtk nutkr iabateigabs hut ikgvks at tn tfk pgrtaks tn gorkk tn tkrbs tfgt spiat tfk nvkrigppa`o kxtk`mkm

en`ta`k`tgi sfki hktwkk` tfkb. ]fk [`atkm Utgtks fgs prnvamkm nhskrvgtan`s n`

suhbassan`s hy twn ntfkr stgtks) hut) gs g `n`"pgrty) at eg``nt suhbat g eigab u`mkr

Grtaeik ?3.7:7

[@EINU g`m tfk Mkkp Ukghkm [@EINU prnvamks tfgt tfk skghkm cnnr hkyn`m

tfk iabats n g engstgi stgtks en`ta k`tgi sfki nr kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki as

hkyn`m gtan`gi durasmaetan` g`m enbprasks) a` [@EINU pgrig`ek) tfk Grkg.7:8

]fk Grkg as onvkr`km hy ats nw` ikogi rkoabk mksao`km tn hgig`ek tfk a`tkrksts n

engstgi stgtks watf enbbkreagi g`m seak`tae a`tkrksts a` tfk mkkp skghkm hkyn`m

`gtan`gi durasmaetan` watf tfnsk n tfk k`tark a`tkr`gtan`gi enbbu`aty. ]fk Grkg

fgs hkk` skt gsamk gs tfk enbbn` fkratgok n bg`la`m.7:5 [@EINU Zgrt VA g`m

tfk suhskquk t Gorkkbk`t Xkigta`o tn tfk Abpikbk`tgtan` n Zgrt VA n [@EINU7:=

&Zgrt VA Gorkkbk`t! nutia`k g [.U."rak`miy mkkp skghkm ba`a`o rkoabk tfgt pkrbats

bkbhkr Utgtks tn gequark ikogi tatik tn `n`"iava`o `gturgi rksnureks a` tfk Grkg.

[@EINU erkgtkm tfk A`tkr`gtan`gi Ukghkm Gutfnraty tn abpikbk`t tfk Zgrt VA mkkp

skghkm ba`a`o rkoabk. ]fk AUG fgs tfrkk pra`eapik nrog`s4 tfk skerktgragt) tfk

gsskbhiy) g`m tfk enu`eai.7:; ]fk skerktgragt as bgmk up n tfk skerktgry ok`krgi) wfn

as kiketkm nr nur"ykgr tkrbs) g`m fas sbgii stg.7:3 ]fk gsskbhiy) enbpraskm n gii

[@EINU bkbhkr stgtks)7:?oavks `gi gpprnvgi tn ruiks g`m rkouigtan`s rkogrma`o tfk

mkkp skghkm ba`a`o rkoabk) mkeamks fnw tn mastrahutk tfk rnygitaks rkekavkm rnb

kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki prndkets) g`m kikets tfk enu`eai.7:6

]fk enu`eai as tfk bnst abpnrtg`t hnmy watfa` tfk gutfnraty g`m skrvks gs tfk

kxkeutavk nrog` n tfk AUG.7:1 At as bgmk up n tfarty"sax bkbhkr stgtks77: g`m as

rkspn`sahik nr a`tkr giag) kxkreas\a`oR en`trni nvkr getavataks a` tfk Grkg777 g`m nr

rkenbbk`ma`o tn tfk gsskbhiy ruiks) rkouigtan`s) g`m prnekmurks n` tfk kquatghik

sfgra`o n `g`eagi g`m ntfkr ken`nbae hk`kts mkravkm rnb getavataks a` tfk Grkg

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

10/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 7: Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

g`m tfk pgybk`ts g`m en`trahutan`s bgmk pursug`t tn Grtaeik 68.778 ]fk gsskbhiy

bgy nt gpprnvk `g`eagi pgybk`ts u`ikss rkenbbk`mkm hy tfk Enu`eai.775 A tfk

gsskbhiy masgorkks watf tfk enu`eais rkenbbk`mgtan`s) tfk assuk waii hk rktur`km

tn tfk enu`eai nr urtfkr mkiahkrgtan`s.77= A tfk [`atkm Utgtks geekmks tn [@EINU)tfk [`atkm Utgtks wnuim hk tfk n`iy stgtk ougrg`tkkm g pkrbg`k`t skgt n` tfk

enu`eai.77; Bnrknvkr) oavk` [@EINU"bg`mgtkm vnta`o prnekmurks tfgt grk hgskm n`

en`sk`sus)773 tfk [`atkm Utgtks wnuim fgvk tfk arrkvneghik ghaiaty tn vktn g`y AUG

pig` tn mastrahutk u`ms nr `g`eagi gssastg`ek a` g bg``kr a`en`sastk`t watf [.U.

mksarks.77?

Getavataks a` tfk Grkg grk pkrbattkm pursug`t tn g buita"stkp gpprnvgi prnekss

mktgaikm a` [@EINU Grtaeik 7;5) G``kx AAA) g`m tfk Zgrt VA Gorkkbk`t. A`tkrkstkm

pgrtaks bgy prnspket776 watfnut pranr gpprnvgi rnb tfk gutfnraty< fnwkvkr) tfky

bust a`nrb tfk gutfnraty n tfkar getan`s.771 Zrnspketa`o en`krs `n ikogi raofts

nvkr tfk rksnureks.78: ]n kxpinrk g`m kxpinat tfk Grkgs `gturgi rksnureks) stgtkpgrtaks nr k`tataks spn`snrkm hy stgtk pgrtaks bust suhbat g enbprkfk`savk

gppiaegtan` tn tfk gutfnraty787 gin`o watf g prnekssa`o kk.788 ]fk gutfnraty assuks

mkeasan`s n` gppiaegtan`s a` tfk nrmkr at rkekavks tfkb. Carst) tfk Ikogi g`m

]kef`aegi Enbbassan` &I]E! rkvakws gppiaegtan`s g`m bglks rkenbbk`mgtan`s tn

tfk enu`eai n` tfk gpprnvgi n wnrl pig`s.785 A tfk I]E rkenbbk`ms gpprnvgi n g

pig`) tfk Enu`eai bust gpprnvk at watfa` saxty mgys u`ikss tfk Enu`eai mkeamks hy

twn"tfarms bgdnraty tn rkdket at.78= ]fk enu`eai gisn eg` gpprnvk g pig` tfgt tfk I]E

ntfkrwask rkdkets.78;

]fk AUG rkeno`azks k`varn`bk`tgi prntketan` n tfk Grkg tn hk n pgrgbnu`t

abpnrtg`ek gs tfk prnspket n mkkp skghkm ba`a`o a`erkgsks. [@EINU rkquarks

tfk AUG Enu`eai tn gmnpt ruiks) rkouigtan`s) g`m prnekmurks tn k`surk prntketan`

n tfk bgra`k k`varn`bk`t rnb tfk fgzgrmnus kkets tfgt bgy rksuit rnb mkkp

skghkm ba`a`o getavataks.783 Kgef gppiaegtan` suhbattkm tn tfk gutfnraty bust a`eiumk

g mktgaikm K`varn`bk`tgi Abpget Utgtkbk`t tfgt prnvamks uii mneubk`tgtan` n gii

k`varn`bk`tgi g`m sneagi assuks g`m mkserahks tfk kkets ba`a`o a` g pgrtaeuigr grkg

waii fgvk n` tfk bgra`k k`varn`bk`t.78? ]fk enu`eai eg` masgpprnvk n tfk kxpinatgtan`

n grkgs wfkrk tfkrk as g rasl n skranus fgrb rnb ba`a`o getavataks kvk` a tfk

ba`a`o getavataks fgvk girkgmy hkou`.786

]fkrk grk g vgrakty n mkkp skghkm rksnureks nvkr wfaef tfk [`atkm Utgtks enuim

pntk`tagiiy kxkrt en`trni a at geekmks tn [@EINU. ]fk [`atkm Utgtks enuim fgvk

geekss tn tfk ba`krgi"raef mkpnsats n pniybktgiiae suimks nu`m `kgr fymrntfkrbgi

vk`ts) a`eiuma`o tfk Ogllki Xamok g`m ntfkr vk`ts girkgmy nu`m a` tfk Gretae.781

Fymrntfkrbgi vk`ts grk fnsts tn g byragm n bgra`k spkeaks tfgt bglk mkvkinpbk`t

k`varn`bk`tgiiy fgzgrmnus< fnwkvkr) tfk pntk`tagi tn rkenvkr vgiughik ba`krgis

suef gs onim) enppkr) bg`og`ksk) g`m ntfkrs bglk at g` gttrgetavk rasl.75: ]fk AUG fgs

g``nu`ekm at waii hkoa` assua`o iaek`sks nr `nmuik prnmuetan` rnb fymrntfkrbgi

vk`ts gs kgriy gs 8:73.757

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

11/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 77 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

N`ek gii Gretae gtan`s kstghiasf tfk nutkr iabats n tfkar kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfkivks)

tfkrk waii rkbga` n`iy g sbgii pnrtan` n tfk Gretae tfgt waii qugiay gs tfk enbbn`

fkratgok n bg`la`m. Gt tfas pna`t a` tabk at as u`eikgr wfgt rksnureks) a g`y) wnuim

rkbga` nr tfk enbbn` fkratgok n bg`la`m a` tfk Gretae. Fnwkvkr) [`atkm Utgtksgeekssan` tn [@EINU wnuim sao`aeg`tiy gmvg`ek ats ghaiaty tn stglk g` a`tkr`gtan`giiy

rkeno`azkm eigab tn tfksk rksnureks a g`y rksnureks grk masenvkrkm a` tfk uturk.

A` tfk bkg`tabk) [.U. enrpnrgtan`s a`tkrkstkm a` ba`a`o tfk mkkp skghkm fgvk hkk`

nrekm tn kstghiasf suhsamagraks a` stgtk pgrtaks) watf g` nppnrtu`aty enst tn tfk

[.U. ]rkgsury.758

]fk Egsk goga`st [@EINU

Gs maseusskm a` sketan` 7) tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs sao`aeg`t a`tkrksts a` tfk Gretae) gii n

wfaef [@EINU purpnrts tn rkouigtk) gt ikgst tn snbk mkorkk. ]fk `kgriy entkrba`nus

nvkrigy n [@EINU watf [.U. Gretae a`tkrksts ikgms tn tfk u`mgbk`tgi pniaey qukstan`4

fnw wnuim [.U. a`tkrksts a` tfk Gretae hk gketkm a tfk [`atkm Utgtks geekmks tn[@EINU>

]fk Groubk`t tfgt [@EINU As Fgrbui

[@EINU erataes fgvk in`o groukm tfgt g`y hk`kts tfk en`vk`tan` baoft prnvamk

grk bnrk tfg` nskt hy ats `kogtavk kkets. Gitfnuof tfas nvkrgrefa`o groubk`t as

`nt neuskm n` tfk Gretaepkr sk) ats suppnrta`o pna`ts fgvk sfnw` rksaiak`ey a` tfk

hrngmkr [@EINU mkhgtk g`m fgvk abpnrtg`t Gretae abpiaegtan`s.

N`k n tfk bnst prnba`k`t groubk`ts as tfgt tfk en`vk`tan`s rnygity prnvasan`s755

fgvk tfk pntk`tagi tn mrga` haiian`s n mniigrs rnb tfk [.U. ken`nby hy tgxa`o

pntk`tagi [.U. enrpnrgtk prnts. Gs eigabkm hy Uk`gtnr Dgbks B. A`fnk4

Cnr tfk rst tabk a` [.U. fastnry) \[@EINUR waii erkgtk g` a`tkr`gtan`gi hnmy

tfgt eg` tgx tfas enu`try. . . . \XnygitaksR waii on rnb tfk [.U. ]rkgsury tn g`

a`tkr`gtan`gi ornup inegtkm a` La`ostn`) Dgbgaeg. . . . ]fkrk enuim hk haiian`s)

a `nt traiian`s) a` rksnureks a` tfk Kxtk`mkm En`ta`k`tgi Ufki &KEU!. [sa`o

g en`skrvgtavk kstabgtk n -7 traiian`) tfgt wnuim bkg` -?: haiian` inst rnb

tfk [`atkm Utgtks.75=

Nppn`k`ts grouk tfgt [.U. rnygity pgybk`ts waii on tn g` a`keak`t g`m enrrupt

[@"styik hurkguergey75; g`m tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks waii insk en`trni nvkr tfk

bn`ky upn` trg`skr tn tfk AUG.753 Gs nrbkr Uk`gtnr Dab MkBa`t gslkm) fnw as at

a` tfk a`tkrksts n tfk [`atkm Utgtks tn tur` tfk rnygitaks nvkr tn g` u`geenu`tghik

a`tkr`gtan`gi hurkguergey \wfk` tfk rnygitaksR waii hk mastrahutkm tn enu`traks

tfgt bgy hk nur k`kbaks) ialk Uumg`.75?

]fksk groubk`ts fgvk prnvk` g sueekssui rgiiya`o pna`t nr [@EINU nppn`k`ts g`m

g pntk`tagi pniataegi baiistn`k nr sk`gtnrs wfn baoft ntfkrwask hk a`eia`km tn suppnrt

tfk en`vk`tan`. ]fk groubk`ts fgvk rktga`km nrek mkspatk tfk get tfgt tfk [`atkm

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

12/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 78 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

Utgtks atski nraoa`giiy en`ekavkm tfk rnygity pig` u`mkr tfk @axn` Gmba`astrgtan`)

watf tfk uii suppnrt n [.U. a`mustrysuppnrt tfgt fgs rkbga`km en`sastk`t gernss

`kgriy nur mkegmks. Xnygitaks wkrk prnpnskm gs g bnmkst en`ekssan` a` rktur` nr

gorkkbk`t n` tfk [.U."spn`snrkm kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki rkoabk.756 A`mkkm) bnstn tfk nai g`m ogs tfgt bgy hk rkenvkrkm wnuim hk a` tfk rst sax ykgrs g`m tfus wnuim

`nt kvkr hk suhdket tn rnygity pgybk`ts. ]fk [@"styik hurkguergey groubk`t fgs

gisn k`murkm mkspatk tfk get tfgt nppn`k`ts fgvk prksk`tkm `n kvamk`ek tfgt tfk AUG

as katfkr a`keak`t) nvkrstgkm) nr enrrupt gt g`y tabk tfrnuofnut tfk `kgriy 71 ykgrs

sa`ek ats nu`ma`o a` 711=.

]fk groubk`t tfgt tfk AUG enuim trg`skr [.U. en`trahutan`s tn tkrrnrasts g`m ntfkr

g`ta"[.U. a`tkrksts gisn fgs orkgt kbntan`gi gppkgi. Fnwkvkr) tfk gsskrtan` as `nt

hgskm n` get751 g`m fgs hkk` rkhuttkm rkpkgtkmiy.7=: [@EINU nppn`k`ts fgvk

suookstkm a` market en`trgmaetan` n tfk en`vk`tan`s kxprkss tkrbs tfgt tfk gsskbhiy

baoft snbkfnw hk ghik tn eareubvk`t tfk kxprkss prnvasan`s prkskrva`o [.U.a`cuk`ek a` tfk enu`eai. ]fk groubk`t as spuranus hut rkbga`s g paiigr n nppnsatan`

strgtkoy. Cnrtu`gtkiy) tn mgtk tfk AUG fgs `nt ykt tglk` up abpikbk`tgtan` n Grtaeik 68.

Hut n`iy a tfk [`atkm Utgtks as g pgrty eg` at k`surk tfgt pgybk`ts wnuim `nt on tn

tkrrnrasts nr ntfkr g`ta"[.U. a`tkrksts.

]fk Groubk`t tfgt [@EINU As [``kekssgry

A` gmmatan` tn groua`o tfgt [@EINU bkbhkrsfap wnuim furt tfk [`atkm Utgtks)

[@EINU nppn`k`ts grouk tfgt tfk en`vk`tan` as u``kekssgry a` tfk rst pigek. Gs

Gigslg` Uk`gtnr Iasg Burlnwsla fgs ntkm4

]fkrk grk snbk wfn mn `nt skk tfk pna`t a` dna`a`o tfk rkst n tfk wnrim a`

rgtaya`o tfk trkgty. ]fky sgy tfk [`atkm Utgtks girkgmy k`dnys tfk hk`kts . . .

kvk` tfnuof wk grk `nt g bkbhkr) g`m tfgt hy `nt hkenba`o g pgrty tn

tfk trkgty) wk eg` pael g`m efnnsk wfaef sketan`s wk ghamk hy) wfaik `nt

suhdketa`o nur getan`s tn a`tkr`gtan`gi rkvakw. A rkspketuiiy masgorkk.7=7

Gitfnuof Uk`gtnr Burlnwsla g`m ntfkr [@EINU prnpn`k`ts bgy masgorkk) tfk

groubk`t tfgt [@EINU as u``kekssgry rkbga`s pntk`t hkegusk at nkrs g` kgsy

rksniutan` nr g` nvkrhurmk`km pniataegi systkb. A) gs nppn`k`ts grouk) tfk [`atkm

Utgtks eg` geenbpiasf ats nhdketavks watfnut dna`a`o [@EINU) wfy a`vkst prkbaub

pniataegi egpatgi g`m ikoasigtavk tabk n` g trkgty tfgt fgs gaikm tn k`kroazk g

suppnrtavk kiketnrgi en`statuk`ey>

A` bgla`o tfk egsk tfgt [@EINU as u``kekssgry) nppn`k`ts mn `nt masputk tfgt tfk

en`vk`tan` prnvamks ekrtga` hk`kts. Xgtfkr) nppn`k`ts grouk tfgt tfk hk`kts grk

a`mkpk`mk`tiy gvgaighik tfrnuof ntfkr bkg`s) suef gs eustnbgry a`tkr`gtan`gi igw)

skpgrgtk haigtkrgi nr buitaigtkrgi a`tkr`gtan`gi gorkkbk`ts) nr tfk kxkreask n [.U.

baiatgry pnwkr. Nppn`k`ts en`samkr tfk en`vk`tan`s hk`kts orgtuatnus g`m `nt

wnrtf tfk giikokm hurmk`s n [@EINU bkbhkrsfap.

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

13/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 75 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

]fk kgsk hy wfaef tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs hkk` ghik tn k`dny snbk [@EINU hk`kts

grnu`m tfk wnrim fgs) a` get) fkipkm rka`nrek nppnsatan` groubk`ts tfgt geekssan`

as u``kekssgry. _faik tfk [`atkm Utgtks tfarty"ykgr prgetaek n npkrgta`o en`sastk`t

watf [@EINU fgs en`trahutkm tn g bgratabk k`varn`bk`t gmvg`tgoknus tn [.U. oinhgia`tkrksts) tfk vkry stghaiaty n tfk rkoabk gisn giinws [@EINU nppn`k`ts tn eigab tfgt

[.U. geekssan` as u``kekssgry. Gs maseusskm hkinw) [@EINU nppn`k`ts en`tk`m tfk

[`atkm Utgtks bgy) a` kket) fgvk ats eglk g`m kgt at tnn.

[``kekssgry cnr A`tkrksts a` tfk Nekg` ]fk prabgry g`m bnst nhvanus kxgbpik n

tfk groubk`t ghnvk as bgmk watf rkspket tn `gvaogtan`gi rkkmnbs. Cnr mkegmks) tfk

[`atkm Utgtks fgs hkk` g ikgma`o gmvnegtk n straet gmfkrk`ek tn [@EINU gvaogtan`

prnvasan`s) fgva`o inhhakm goorkssavkiy nr tfkar a`eiusan` mura`o tfk en`vk`tan`s

`kontagtan`. ]frnuof tfrkk mkegmks) sueekssavk [.U. prksamk`ts fgvk marketkmwatf

tfk enbpiktk suppnrt n tfk [.U. grbkm nrekstfgt tfk baiatgry npkrgtk a` geenrm

watf [@EINU prnvasan`s. Ialkwask) ntfkr mkpgrtbk`ts g`m gok`eaks fgvk pursukmprn"[@EINU pniaeaks g`m enbpikbk tgry a`tkr`gtan`gi gorkkbk`ts gs wkii.

A`mkkm) tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs gisn mn`k bnrk tfg` enbpiy watf [@EINU< at fgs

gsskrtkm tfgt [@EINU gvaogtan`gi prnvasan`s rkprksk`t eustnbgry a`tkr`gtan`gi igw

ha`ma`o n` tfk k`tark a`tkr`gtan`gi enbbu`aty rkogrmikss n g`y stgtks gaiurk tn rgtay

tfk en`vk`tan`.7=8 Gitfnuof tfkrk grk kxekptan`s) bnst [@EINU bkbhkr stgtks enbpiy

watf tfk `gvaogtan` prnvasan`s nr gt ikgst mn `nt efgiik`ok [.U. vksskis kxkreasa`o

[@EINU"hgskm `gvaogtan`gi raofts.7=5

A` tfk Gretae) [@EINU `gvaogtan` prnvasan`s prnvamk g uskui pgrgmaob nr rkk

`gvaogtan`.7== Hntf Xussag g`m Eg`gmg fgvk tglk` pnsatan`s tfk [.U. bga`tga`s grk

a`en`sastk`t watf [@EINU rkkmnb n `gvaogtan` `nrbs a` tfkar rkspketavk knrts tn

bgxabazk en`trni nvkr tfk @nrtfkr` Ukg Xnutk g`m @nrtfwkst Zgssgok.7=; Gitfnuof tfk

[`atkm Utgtks enuim rka`nrek [@EINU hk`keagi prnvasan`s n trg`sat g`m a``nek`t

pgssgok hy dna`a`o tfk En`vk`tan`) tfkrk as iattik kvamk`ek tfgt [.U. geekssan` wnuim

efg`ok Xussag` nr Eg`gmag` pnsatan`s nr rksuit a` g mrgbgtae sfat a` tfarm enu`try

pnsatan`s ghsk`t hka`o a`muekm tn mn sn hy g` a`tkr`gtan`gi trahu`gi. Ialkwask) tn

tfk kxtk`t rkk `gvaogtan` `nrbs grk getugiiy rkspketkm a` tfk Gretae) at as maeuit tn

abgoa`k fnw tfk [`atkm Utgtks gaiurk tn dna` [@EINU waii prkvk`t tfk [`atkm Utgtks

rnb k`dnya`o tfksk hk`kts) gitfnuof fnw in`o tfgt rkspket waii en`ta`uk as u`ekrtga`

a at enbks u`mkr a`erkgsa`o prkssurks tn efg`ok tfk igw n tfk skg rkoabk. ]fk sgbk

enuim hk sgam n k`varn`bk`tgi prntketan`) sfa`o) g`m bgra`k seak`tae rkskgref

hk`kts.

[@EINU suppnrtkrs gturgiiy rksast suef groubk`ts gs sfnrtsaoftkm.7=3 Uuppnrtkrs

`ntk) gbn`o ntfkr groubk`ts) tfgt gs g `n`"pgrty) tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs `n

rkenursk tn tfk masputk skttikbk`t prnekmurks n Zgrt VS tn gmmrkss assuks a` tfk

gnrkbk`tan`km grkgs. ]fk get rkbga`s) fnwkvkr) tfgt mura`o tfk tfarty ykgrs

[@EINU fgs hkk` a` nrek) tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs) a` bg`y rkspkets) sueekssuiiy

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

14/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 7= Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

pigykm tfk rnik n rkk ramkr) k`dnya`o hk`kts enmakm a`) g`m snbktabks a`trnmuekm

hy) tfk en`vk`tan`. ]n [@EINU nppn`k`ts) tfas as gs at sfnuim hk4 snvkrkao` stgtks

sfnuim hk ghik tn k`dny [@EINU hk`kts gt waii u`ikss g`m u`tai bkbhkr stgtks

gttkbpt tn iabat tfk hk`kts nr bnmay tfk `nrbs tfgt gvnr [.U. a`tkrksts tnmgy.Ufnuim suef knrts grask) nppn`k`ts a`sast tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks sfnuim rkspn`m hy

usa`o trgmatan`gi bkg`s n stgtk mapinbgtae) ken`nbae) nr pniataegi pnwkr. Fnwkvkr) tfk

[`atkm Utgtks gs g `n`"pgrty waii `nt hk a` g pnsatan` tn prkvk`t g`y efg`oks tfgt waii

hk en`trgry tn [.U. a`tkrksts a` tfk hk`kts at `nw k`dnys.

[``kekssgry cnr A`tkrksts n` tfk Nekg` Cinnr [@EINU nppn`k`ts gisn grouk tfgt

en`vk`tan` bkbhkrsfap as u``kekssgry nr tfk [`atkm Utgtks tn gefakvk ats a`tkrksts

n` tfk skgcnnr. Nppn`k`ts en`tk`m tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks girkgmy fgs tfk mnbkstae

g`m a`tkr`gtan`gi ikogi gutfnraty `kekssgry tn prnekkm watf nsfnrk kxpinrgtan` g`m

kxpinatgtan` gs gr rnb sfnrk gs mksarkm) iabatkm n`iy hy tkef`ninoy g`m prnt

bgroa`. [@EINU nppn`k`ts grouk tfgt tfk 71=; ]rubg` Zrneigbgtan`) tfk 71;5 NutkrEn`ta`k`tgi Ufki Ig`ms Get &NEUIG!) tfk 71;6 En`ta`k`tgi Ufki En`vk`tan`) g`m tfk

716: Mkkp Ukghkm Fgrm Ba`krgi Xksnureks Get &MUFBXG! prnvamk gii `kekssgry ikogi

gutfnraty.7=? A` iaoft n tfksk gutfnrataks) [@EINU as sgam tn hk arrkikvg`t.

Ukvkrgi sefnigrs fgvk mkbn`strgtkm tfgt tfk nppn`k`ts groubk`t nr wfgt as) a`

kket) g` npk` skgcnnr as) a` tfk wnrms n Dnf` @nrtn` Bnnrk g`m Dnf` @nrtn`

Ogrrktt) gisk g`m g masskrvaek tn tfk Uk`gtk.7=6 Bnnrk) Ogrrktt) g`m ntfkrs fgvk

en`va`ea`oiy rkutkm tfk groubk`t tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks eurrk`tiy fgs tfk ikogi

gutfnraty `kekssgry nr u`iabatkm kxpinatgtan` n tfk `n`"iava`o `gturgi rksnureks n

tfk kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki g`m hkyn`m. ]fksk sefnigrs mkbn`strgtk tfgt wfkrk

[.U. stgtutks g`m tfk 71;6 En`vk`tan` n` tfk En`ta`k`tgi Ufki rkkr tn tfk en`ta`k`tgi

sfki) kgef as a` get rkkrra`o tn tfk [.U. okninoae sfki) wfaef kxtk`ms `n bnrk

tfg` gpprnxabgtkiy ;: baiks n tfk [.U. engst.7=1 ]fus) Xn`gim Xkgog`s eigab tn g

en`ta`k`tgi sfki n 8:: baiks) wfaef as amk`taegi tn wfgt [@EINU pkrbats) stg`ms gs

tfk bnst kxpg`savk eigab a` [.U. fastnry.7;:

]fk n`iy eareubstg`ek a` wfaef [@EINU nppn`k`ts rkeno`azk g iabat n` tfk [`atkm

Utgtks gutfnraty tn kxpinat tfk skgcnnr as wfk` g [.U. `kaofhnr eg` gisn bglk g

ikoatabgtk eigab tn g pntk`tagi kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki tfgt nvkrigps watf tfk

[.U. eigab. A` tfksk egsks) [@EINU nppn`k`ts suookst tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks bgy

k`tkr haigtkrgi gorkkbk`ts watf ats kaofhnrs tn rksnivk tfk pntk`tagi en`caet) g`m

tfksk gorkkbk`ts wnuim hk en`eiusavk hktwkk` tfk pgrtaks. [`mkr tfas vakw) tfk

a`tkr`gtan`gi enbbu`aty fgs n raoft a` tfk bgttkr.7;7

]fk nhvanusg`m n`iykxgbpik n suef g [.U. haigtkrgi gorkkbk`t tn mgtk as tfk

[.U"Bkxaeg` gorkkbk`t nr g` kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki hnu`mgry a` tfk Oui n

Bkxaens _kstkr` Ogp) g 3)3:: squgrk"baik grkg hkyn`m tfk 8::"baik iabats n hntf

tfk [`atkm Utgtks g`m Bkxaens rkspketavk en`ta`k`tgi sfkivks.7;8 Fnwkvkr) hkegusk

tfas ogp nutsamk tfk iabats n kgef `gtan`s en`ta`k`tgi sfki k`enbpgsskm tfk

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

15/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 7; Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

nvkrigppa`o tkrratnry n kgef `gtan`s pntk`tagi kxtk`mkmen`ta`k`tgi sfki) tfk twn

`kaofhnrs sueekssuiiy `kontagtkm g enbprnbask. Uuhskquk`t tn tfk gorkkbk`t) tfk

[.U. Mkpgrtbk`t n tfk A`tkranr) gs n Du`k 8:78) fgm org`tkm saxty"vk iaek`sks tn `a`k

enbpg`aks.7;5 Kgef n tfk iaek`sks en`tga`s g prnvasn tfgt tfk enbpg`y waii pgy tfkkquavgik`t n g` [@EINU rnygity.7;= Curtfkr) tfk nutkr iabats n Bkxaens kxtk`mkm

en`ta`k`tgi sfki a` tfk _kstkr` Ogp n tfk Oui n Bkxaen fgs hkk` hiksskm hy tfk

Enbbassan` n` tfk Iabats n tfk En`ta`k`tgi Ufki) g`m Bkxaen fgs geekptkm tfnsk

rkenbbk`mgtan`s.7;; ]fk a`tkr`gtan`giiy rkeno`azkm nutkr iabat tfus as tfk Bkxaen"

[`atkm Utgtks en`ta`k tgi sfki hnu`mgry a` tfk _kstkr` Ogp.

]fk _kstkr` Ogp gorkkbk`t fgs eikgr abpiaegtan`s nr tfk Gretae) wfkrk tfk [`atkm

Utgtks sfgrks g pntk`tagi kxtk`mkm en`ta`k tgi sfki watf hntf Xussag g`m Eg`gmg.

[@EINU nppn`k`ts suookst tfgt qukstan`s rkogrma`o a`tkr`gtan`gi ikogi tatik tn tfk

[.U. pntk`tagi kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki a` tfk Gretae waii hk rksnivkm en`eiusavkiy

wfk` tfk [`atkm Utgtks k`tkrs haigtkrgi gorkkbk`ts watf Xussag` g`m Eg`gmgrkspketavkiy.7;3 Gs sabpik g`m tfkrknrk gttrgetavk gs tfas pnsatan` bgy hk) at hkos

skvkrgi qukstan`s.

[`mkr wfgt ikogi gutfnraty wnuim tfk Gretae kaofhnrs fgvk tfk raoft tn mavamk

g`m eigab nr tfkbskivks g` grkg iya`o) gt ikgst a` tfknry) hkyn`m tfkar rkspketavk

`gtan`gi durasmaetan`s> Kvk` gssuba`o g ikoatabgtk ikogi hgsas tn eigab tfkar kxtk`mkm

en`ta`k`tgi sfkivks g`m mkiabat tfkb haigtkrgiiy) wfgt hgsas wnuim tfk stgtks fgvk

nr mksara`o tn g`m en`eiuma`o tfkar gorkkbk`ts nutsamk tfk [@EINU rgbkwnrl)

a`eiuma`o ao`nra`o Grtaeik 68 rnygity pgybk`ts> Ca`giiy) kvk` a Xussag g`m Eg`gmg

hntf [@EINU bkbhkr stgtksefnnsk tn enbpiy watf [@EINU n` tfkar rkspketavk

samks n mkiabatkm sfkivks) baoft tfky nhdket tn tfk [`atkm Utgtks `nt mna`o sn n`

ats samk) g`m) a sn) wnuim tfky pursuk tfkar nhdketan`s> G`m fnw baoft tfk nutkr

iabats n tfk [.U. kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki a` tfk Gretae hk mktkrba`km oavk` tfk

oknorgpfae makrk`eks rnb tfk _kstkr` Ogp satugtan` wfkrk tfkrk wkrk n`iy twn

oknorgpfaegiiy nppnsatk stgtks watf n tfarm stgtk nr grkg a`tkrksts a`vnivkm>

]fk sabpik g`swkr as tfgt n`iy hy geekma`o tn tfk en`vk`tan` eg` tfk [`atkm Utgtks

nhtga` ats uii en`ta`k`tgi sfki raofts a` tfk Gretae.

]fk Egsk cnr [@EINU4 ]fk @kkm cnr Ikogi Ekrtga`ty

Gs mkbn`strgtkm ghnvk) tfk groubk`t tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs ikogi gutfnraty

tn prnekkm nutsamk [@EINU watf prndkets hkyn`m tfk 8::"baik en`ta`k`tgi sfki as

cgwkm. [.U. a`mustry fgs en`sastk`tiy sgam gs buef) groua`o tfgt [@EINU bkbhkrsfap

as rkquarkm tn prnvamk tfk ikogi ekrtga`ty `kekssgry nr kxpinrgtan` g`m kxpinatgtan`

n tfk rksnureks n tfk uii kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki g`m hkyn`m.7;?

_faik ats egiis nr ikogi ekrtga`ty fgvk hkk` u`kquavnegi g`m k`tfusagstae) a`mustry

fgs hkk` ikss spkeae a` grtaeuigta`o wfgt tfk rasls baoft hk n prnekkma`o watfnut

tfk mksarkm ekrtga`ty. A`mustry rkprksk`tgtavks bgy en`samkr tfk rasls nhvanus tn

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

16/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 73 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

g`yn`k watf g hgsae u`mkrstg`ma`o n igrok"segik egpatgi a`vkstbk`t. ]fky bgy gisn

hkiakvk tfgt sabpik stgtkbk`ts n suppnrt nr [@EINU sfnuim hk sueak`t tn ok`krgtk

mksarkm pniataegi nutenbks. _fgtkvkr tfk rkgsn`) tfk ba`abgiast kxpig`gtan`s

fgvk giinwkm [@EINU nppn`k`ts tn spkeuigtk tfgt a`mustrys gmvnegey bgy) a`get) fgvk sfgiinw rnnts.

[@EINU nppn`k`t nrbkr [.U. Ukerktgry n Mkk`sk Mn`gim Xubskim fgs suookstkm

tfgt husa`kssks en`stg`tiy bglk enst"hk`kt g`giysks) g`m fgvk sabpiy mkeamkm)

gt ikgst nr tfk tabk hka`o) tfgt tfk tabk as `nt raoft nr nsfnrk a`vkstbk`t.7;6 A`

tfk bkg`tabk) tfky wg`t gs buef ekrtga`ty gs tfky eg` okt.7;1 ]n skeurk tfas ikogi

ekrtga`ty) Br. Xubskim fgs nkrkm g` gitkr`gtavk tn wgata`o nr tfk [`atkm Utgtks tn

geekmk tn tfk trkgty) suooksta`o tfgt [.U. enbpg`aks pursuk dna`t vk`turks watf

ntfkr [@EINU bkbhkr stgtks tn skeurk ikogi tatik tn mkkp skghkm ba`a`o.73: A` get) gt

ikgst n`k [.U. enbpg`y fgs girkgmy pursukm tfas rnutk.737 Gpgrt rnb tfk pfainsnpfaegi

a`en`sastk`ey a` k`enurgoa`o [.U. enrpnrgtan`s tn pgrtaeapgtk a` g ikogi rkoabk tfk[`atkm Utgtks rkdkets) tfkrk bgy hk nppnrtu`aty ensts tn k`enurgoa`o [.U. enbpg`aks

tn nhtga` skeuraty n tk`urk tn mraii a` tfk mkkp skghkm tfrnuof iaek`sks hgelkm hy

ntfkr enu`traks.738

A`nrbgiiy) nppn`k`ts fgvk on`k urtfkr) suooksta`o tfgt a`mustry rkprksk`tgtavks bgy

hk nvkrstgta`o tfk ekrtga`ty groubk`t nut n ao`nrg`ek) nr kvk` g mksark tn eurry

pniataegi gvnr watf pnwkrui prn"[@EINU pniaeybglkrs g`m ikoasigtnrs.735 Oavk` fnw

ek`trgi tfk ikogi ekrtga`ty groubk`t fgs hkenbk tn a`mustry suppnrt nr [@EINU) g

bnrk mktgaikm g`giysas n tfk `kkm nr ikogi ekrtga`ty as kssk`tagi.

A` bgla`o tfk egsk nr [@EINU) a`mustry fgs en`sastk`tiy kxprksskm tfk en`ekr`

tfgt snbkn`k baoft efgiik`ok ikogi tatik tn g pgrtaeuigr satk nr kxtrgetkm rksnurek

`nt nhtga`km tfrnuof tfk [@EINU prnekss.73= [@EINU nppn`k`ts fgvk enu`tkrkm hy

prkmaeta`o tfkrk waii hk iattik nppnsatan` a g`m wfk` g enrpnrgtan` getugiiy hkoa`s

prnmuetan` pursug`t tn g [.U. iaek`sk nutsamk [@EINU.73; Buef as bgmk) nr kxgbpik)

n tfk get tfgt `n pgrty tn mgtk fgs efgiik`okm iaek`sks org`tkm n` tfk [.U. samk n tfk

[.U."Bkxaeg` _kstkr` Ogp. [@EINU nppn`k`ts abpiy tfgt tfk ghsk`ek n g efgiik`ok

suooksts tfgt tfk a`tkr`gtan`gi enbbu`aty as sg`oua`k watf [.U. iaek`sa`o nutsamk tfk

[@EINU prnekss. Fnwkvkr) tfk _kstkr` Ogp kxgbpik as asnigtkm g`m a`gppiaeghik

gs mkbn`strgtkm ghnvk) g`m a` g`y egsk) fgrmiy skkbs g raonrnus tkst) oavk` tfgt `n

enbpg`y fgs getugiiy hkou` kxpinrgtan` a` tfk _kstkr` Ogp g`m gii [.U. iaek`skks

fgvk gorkkm tn pgy g` [@EINU rnygity.733

Hkegusk `n a`mustry as eurrk`tiy prnmuea`o n` g [.U."iaek`skm satk) `katfkr nppn`k`ts

`nr suppnrtkrs eg` prkmaet watf ekrtga`ty fnw a`tkrkstkm tfarm pgrtaks baoft rkget

wfk` prnmuetan` hkoa`s g`m prnts grk tglk`. A` tfk bkg`tabk) fnwkvkr) tn suookst

tfgt `n getnr hksamks tfk [`atkm Utgtks hnrmkr"sfgra`o `kaofhnrs waii hk en`ekr`km

skkbs `gvk. Oavk` tfgt [@EINU bkbhkr stgtks fgvk vniu`tgraiy erkgtkm g skgcnnr

rkoabk a` wfaef raofts g`m hk`kts grk en`ta`ok`t n` hk`keagraks uiiia`o sao`aeg`t

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

17/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 7? Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

nhiaogtan`s)73? bkbhkr stgtks) gt g ba`abub) fgvk g` a`tkrkst a` prkvk`ta`o rkk"rama`o

n`) g`m eareubvk`tan` n) tfas systkb. Ntfkrs bgy fgvk sabaigr a`tkrksts gs wkii.

Zntk`tagi Efgiik`okrs_fn baoft skk t tn efgiik`ok tfk getan`s n g skgcnnr rkk ramkr ialk tfk [`atkm

Utgtks> ]n hkoa`) [@EINU bkbhkr stgtks fgvk nhvanus a`tkrksts a` tfk a`tkoraty n

tfk en`ta`k`tgi sfki g`m skghkm rkoabks a` wfaef tfky a`vkst. Zntk`tagiiy a`tkrkstkm

stgtks gii a`tn gt ikgst tfrkk egtkonraks. Carst grk stgtks tfgt bgy fgvk g` a`tkrkst a`

en`mueta`o enbbkreagi getavaty n tfkar nw` a` g` grkg eigabkm hy tfk [.U. hut `nt

rgtakm tfrnuof tfk [@EINU prnekss. Uken`m grk stgtks tfgt baoft fgvk n nhdketan`)

pkr sk) tn [.U. getavaty) hut wasf tn k`surk tfk [`atkm Utgtks pgys ats gar sfgrk u`mkr

[@EINU nr tfk pravaikok n en`mueta`o enbbkreagi getavaty. ]farm grk stgtks tfgt

stg`m tn hk`kt rnb tfk Grtaeik 68 kquatghik sfgra`o pgybk`ts g`m skkl tn k`surk

suef pgybk`ts grk bgxabazkm.

A` gmmatan` tn [@EINU bkbhkr stgtks) enrpnrgtan`s watf enbbkreagi a`tkrksts a` tfk

skghkm cnnr bgy fgvk g` a`tkrkst a` k`sura`o tfgt getugi g`m pntk`tagi enbpktatnrs mn

`nt nhtga` g` u`gar enbpktatavk gmvg`tgok hy npkrgta`o nutsamk tfk [@EINU systkb.

Gitfnuof Grtaeik 68 rnygitaks grk gssksskm tn stgtks) at skkbs rkgsn`ghik tn gssubk

tfgt enrpnrgtan`s bgy hk gssksskm kxtk`mkm en`ta`k tgi sfki kks hy tfkar iaek`sa`o"

stgtks. Ialkwask) a npkrgta`o a` tfk grkg) enrpnrgtan`s rkquarkm tn ghamk hy ruiks

g`m rkouigtan`s kstghiasfkm tn onvkr` tfk grkg wnuim prksubghiy mkbg`m tfgt tfkar

enbpktatnrs hk hnu`m hy tfk sgbk ruiks.

Uabaigriy) tfk AUG) erkgtkm hy [@EINU tn nrog`azk g`m en`trni getavataks a` tfk

Grkg g`m tn mastrahutk ken`nbae gssastg`ek g`m Grtaeik 68 rnygity pgybk`ts) wnuim

fgvk g` a`tkrkst a` prkskrva`o tfk a`tkoraty n tfk systkb at wgs erkgtkm tn nvkrskk.

Abpnrtg`tiy) tfk AUG fgs hkk` vkstkm watf a`tkr`gtan`gi ikogi pkrsn`giaty) wfaef

a`eiumks tfk pnwkr tn hra`o suat tn k`nrek ats a`tkrksts.736

Ca`giiy) k`tkrprasa`o @ONs baoft tglk g lkk` a`tkrkst a` wfktfkr g stgtk g`m ats

iaek`skks grk prnta`o gt tfk kxpk`sk n mkvkinpa`o g`m ig`m"inelkm stgtks prntketkm

hy [@EINU) nr) wfktfkr stgtks g`m iaek`skks grk enbpiya`o watf AUG rkouigtan`s

erkgtkm tn prntket tfk bgra`k k`varn`bk`t a` g`m grnu`m tfk enbbn` fkratgok

n bg`la`m. ]fk bnst nhvanus tgrokts nr @ON masgpprnvgi g`m ikogi nr pniataegi

getan` wnuim skkb tn hk tfk stgtks g`m enrpnrgtan`s npkrgta`o nutsamk tfk ken`nbae

gssastg`ek g`m k`varn`bk`tgi prntketan` rkoabks erkgtkm hy [@EINU.

Zntk`tagi Ikogi Getan`s

G`y n tfk getnrs `ntkm ghnvk enuim hk kxpketkm tn tglk g erataegi vakw n [.U.

gttkbpts tn gvnam tfk [@EINU skgcnnr rkoabk. Nhvanusiy) a`tkr`gtan`gi masgpprnvgi

n pgrtaeuigr [.U. pniaeaks as `nt `kw< fnwkvkr) masgpprnvgi tglks n` bgo`akm

abpnrtg`ek a nppn`k`ts grk ghik tn efg``ki tfkar orakvg`eks a`tn bkg`a`oui

ikogi efgiik`oks. Oavk` tfgt tfk puhiae a`tkr`gtan`gi igw n tfk skg onvkr`s fnw

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

18/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 76 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

stgtks g`m a`tkr`gtan`gi nrog`azgtan`s rkigtk tn kgef ntfkr a` tfk bgratabk mnbga`)

tfk a`quary a`tn pntk`tagi ikogi raofts g`m rkbkmaks inoaegiiy hkoa`s watf puhiae

a`tkr`gtan`gi igw.731

A`tkr`gtan`gi Igw

Iaghaiaty Zuhiae a`tkr`gtan`gi igw onvkr`s tfk rkigtan`sfaps hktwkk` stgtks g`m)

n` neegsan`) tfk rkigtan`sfaps n stgtks tn a`tkr`gtan`gi nrog`azgtan`s. @gtan`s

enbbn`iy gssubk nhiaogtan`s tn kgef ntfkr tfrnuof trkgtaks< fnwkvkr) g stgtk bgy

hk hnu`m hy g `nrb n eustnbgry a`tkr`gtan`gi igw `ntwatfstg`ma`o ats gaiurk tn

k`tkr g trkgty. Eustnbgry a`tkr`gtan`gi igw as erkgtkm a` g vgrakty n wgys) a`eiuma`o

hy trkgty prnvasan`s gmnptkm g`m niinwkm hy sueak`tiy igrok ubhkrs n stgtks gs

g bgttkr n ikogi nhiaogtan`. Eustnbgry a`tkr`gtan`gi ikogi nhiaogtan`s gisn oavk rask

tn g` grrgy n a`tkr`gtan`gi rkbkmaks. ]fus) tfk get tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs `nt

rgtakm [@EINU mnks `nt `kekssgraiy bkg` tfk [`atkm Utgtks as rkkgs g bgttkr n

a`tkr`gtan`gi igw

tn ao`nrk pgrtaeuigr [@EINU ikogi `nrbs nr prnekssks. A) a` get)tfk [`atkm Utgtks as u`mkr g` nhiaogtan` tn enbpiy watf g` [@EINU prnvasan` tfgt

fgs gisn hkenbk eustnbgry a`tkr`gtan`gi igw) gaiurk tn enbpiy enuim oavk rask tn

a`tkr`gtan`gi iaghaiaty g`m suhdket tfk [`atkm Utgtks tn a`tkr`gtan`gi ikogi rkbkmaks.

]fkrk as g strn`o egsk tn hk bgmk tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks as nhiaogtkm u`mkr

a`tkr`gtan`gi igw tn enbpiy watf [@EINU skgcnnr rkoabk mkspatk tfk get tfgt tfk

[`atkm Utgtks fgs kvkr rgtakm tfk en`vk`tan`. ]fk bnst u`mgbk`tgi g`m enbpkiia`o

rkgsn` tfk [`atkm Utgtks as hnu`m hy [@EINU rkoabk nr tfk kxtk`mkm en ta`k`tgi

sfki as hkegusk) quatk sabpiy) tfk [`atkm Utgtks sgys at as hnu`m.7?: Bnrknvkr) kvk`

tfnuof tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs `nt rgtakm tfk en`vk`tan`) gs g sao`gtnry tn tfk rkvaskm

mkkp skghkm ba`a`o prnvasan`s) tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs a`eurrkm g` a`tkr`gtan`gi ikogi

nhiaogtan` tn nt get en`trgry tn tfk nhdket g`m purpnsk n tfk trkgty.7?7 A` iaoft n

tfk prnba`k`t rnik oavk` tfk mkkp skghkm ba`a`o rkoabk a` tfk en`vk`tan` g`m ats

`kekssgry g`m prgetaegiiy a`skpgrghik rkigtan`sfap tn tfk kxtk`mkm en`ta`k tgi sfki

rkoabk) tfk [`atkm Utgtks as groughiy `nt pkrbattkm tn get a` g`y wgy tfgt wnuim

u`mkrba`k tfksk ek`trgi prnvasan`s.

Kvk` a g uturk prksamk t wkrk tn masgvnw tfk [.U. sao`gturk n tfk mkkp skghkm

gorkkbk`t) tfk [.U. onvkr`bk`ts eurrk`t pnsatan`) wfaef rkckets ats in`o fkim vakw)

wnuim hk uskm gs kvamk`ek tfgt tfk prnvasan`s fgvk oga`km tfk stgtus n eustnbgry

a`tkr`gtan`gi igw ha`ma`o n` tfk [`atkm Utgtks ]fk [.U. gaiurk tn en`tkst tfas

prnpnsatan`

a`mkkm) tfk [.U. in`o gorkkbk`t watf tfk prnpnsatan`

as rka`nrekm

hy tfk get tfgt 6; pkrek`t n gtan` stgtks) a`eiuma`o gii hut nurtkk` iattnrgi gtan`s)

fgvk rgtakm [@EINU.

Getugi stgtk prgetaek gisn rka`nreks tfk ikoatabgey n tfk kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki

rkoabk a` a`tkr`gtan`gi igw g`m ats stgtus gs eustnbgry a`tkr`gtan`gi igw. ]n mgtk)

saxty"vk `gtan`s fgvk suhbattkm eigabs tn tfk EIEU) mkbn`strgta`o wamksprkgm

geekptg`ek n tfas erataegi [@EINU prnekss.7?8

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

19/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 71 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

]fus) at bgy wkii hk tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks as kstnppkm rnb geta`o en`trgry tn tfk

en`vk`tan` gs g rksuit n tfk Zrksamk`ts Nekg` Zniaey Utgtkbk`t g`m suhskquk`t

vaonrnus enbpiag`ek watf at.

Cnrub g`m Xkbkmy ]fk get tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks enuim wkii hk nu`m iaghik

u`mkr a`tkr`gtan`gi igw nr gaia`o tn enbpiy watf tfk kxtk`mkm en`ta`k tgi sfki

rkoabk mnks nt k`m tfk a`quary. G stgtk nr a`tkr`gtan`gi nrog`azgtan` bust nhtga`

twn skpgrgtk typks n durasmaetan` nvkr g` nppnsa`o pgrty. Carst) tfkrk bust hk

durasmaetan` tn hra`o g eigab a` tfk rst pigek< sken`m) tfkrk bust hk durasmaetan`

tn k`nrek g`y rksuita`o dumobk`t) wfaef as enbbn`iy nhtga`km hy gsskrta`o

en`trni nvkr gsskts n tfk mkkgtkm iataog`t.7?5 Durasmaetan` tn hra`o g eigab mnks

`nt kekssgraiy bkg` durasmaetan` tn k`nrek g dumobk`t. _atfa` a`tkr`gtan`gi igw)

tfkrk grk twn prabgry nrubs a` wfaef tfk AUG nr g` [@EINU bkbhkr stgtk baoft

gttkbpt tn hra`o g`m k`nrek g ikogi getan` goga`st tfk [`atkm Utgtks nr geta`o

en`trgry tn [@EINU.

N`k nptan` wnuim hk tn hra`o g` getan` hknrk tfk A`tkr`gtan`gi Enurt n Dustaek

&AED!. ]fk AED fgs durasmaetan` a` en`tk`tanus egsks n`iy n` tfk hgsas n en`sk`t

n tfk pgrtaksa.k.) g stgtk eg``nt hk sukm gt tfk AED u`ikss hntf pgrtaks gorkk nr

tfk stgtk hka`o sukm fgs girkgmy suhbattkm tn durasmaetan` tfrnuof g pranr) ha`ma`o)

a`tkr`gtan`gi gorkkbk`t.7?= A` gii ialkiafnnm) katfkr eareubstg`ek wnuim gppiy tn

tfk [`atkm Utgtks a` tfk [@EINU en`tkxt. Zrksubghiy) tfk [`atkm Utgtks wnuim

`nt en`sk`t tn g spkeae suat. A` 716;) tfk [`atkm Utgtks watfmrkw g in`o"stg`ma`o

mkeigrgtan` rkeno`aza`o tfk enbpuisnry durasmaetan` n tfk AED gtkr tfk AED gsskrtkm

durasmaetan` a` tfk ig`mbgrl egsk n Baiatgry g`m Zgrgbaiatgry Getavataks A` g`m

Goga`st @aegrgoug.7?; Gitfnuof a` a`tkrvk`a`o ykgrs tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs gorkkm tn

pgrtaeapgtk a` ekrtga` AED iataogtan`) tfk eareubstg`eks n tfnsk egsks grk sueak`tiy

masta`et g`m bglk tfkb u`ialkiy prkekmk`ts nr [@EINU iataogtan`.7?3 Geenrma`oiy)

at as u`ialkiy g stgtk nr a`tkr`gtan`gi nrog`azgtan` waii hk ghik tn nhtga` durasmaetan`

nvkr tfk [`atkm Utgtks nr g en`tk`tanus egsk gt tfk AED.7??

]fk get tfgt g en`tk`tanus [@EINU suat hknrk tfk AED as u`ialkiy mnks `nt)

fnwkvkr) rk`mkr tfk AED arrkikvg`t. Kvk` watfnut en`sk`t hy tfk [`atkm Utgtks)

tfk AED enuim assuk g` gmvasnry npa`an`. ]fk [@ Ok`krgi Gsskbhiy nr tfk [@

Ukeuraty Enu`eai bgy skkl g` gmvasnry npa`an` n` g`y ikogi qukstan` rnb tfk

AED)7?6 a`eiuma`o masputks hktwkk` stgtks a` wfaef n`k fgs `nt en`sk`tkm tn AED

durasmaetan`.7?1 A` gmmatan`) tfk gsskbhiy eg` gutfnrazk g`y ntfkr nrog` n tfk [@ nr

g`y spkeagi gok`ey tn skkl g` gmvasnry npa`an` n` ikogi qukstan`s grasa`o watfa`

tfk senpk n tfkar getavataks.76: Gitfnuof gmvasnry npa`an`s grk `nt ikogiiy ha`ma`o)

tfky bgy) mkpk`ma`o n` tfk surrnu`ma`o en`tkxt) egrry pniataegi wkaoft. Bnrknvkr)

suef g` npa`an` baoft gisn hk kbpinykm gs prkekmk`t a` nrkao` mnbkstae enurts

g`m a`tkr`gtan`gi trgmk nrubs) nr prnvk fgrbui tn g enrpnrgtan`s a`tkr`gtan`gi

rkputgtan`) kgef n wfaef as maseusskm hkinw.

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

20/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 8: Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

G`ntfkr nrub nptan` enuim hk tfk A`tkr`gtan`gi ]rahu`gi nr tfk Igw n tfk Ukg

&A]INU!) wfaef wgs mksao`km tn rksnivk masputks hktwkk` [@EINU pgrtaks.767 Gs

tfk [`atkm Utgtks as `nt g` [@EINU bkbhkr stgtk) at wnuim prksubghiy gttkbpt

tn rksast durasmaetan`. Fnwkvkr) oavk` tfgt A]INU as kbpnwkrkm tn mkeamk ats nw`durasmaetan`768 g`m at fgs hkk` gsskrtavk ghnut mna`o sn)765 tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs

stgtkm [@EINU rkprksk`ts eustnbgry a`tkr`gtan`gi igw) g`m tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs

g` nhiaogtan` tn `nt mkkgt tfk nhdket g`m purpnsk n g trkgty at fgs sao`km) at as gt

ikgst wnrtf en`samkra`o wfktfkr tfkrk baoft hk g eareubstg`ek a` wfaef A]INU baoft

`m durasmaetan` nvkr tfk [`atkm Utgtks a` g en`tk`tanus egsk a`vniva`o tfk kxtk`mkm

en`ta`k`tgi sfki nr mkkp skghkm. Kvk` a tfk g`swkr as `n) at skkbs k`tarkiy pigusahik

tfgt A]INU Ukghkm Masputks Efgbhkr enuim assuk g` gmvasnry npa`an` n` g` assuk

a`vniva`o tfk [.U.)76= watf kkets sabaigr tn tfnsk nutia`km ghnvk nr tfk AED.

Cnrkao` Mnbkstae Igw G sken`m pntk`tagi bkg`s tn enbpki enbpiag`ek watf [@EINU

rkoabks wnuim hk nr g nrkao` stgtk) enrpnrgtan`) nr kvk` g` @ON tn hra`o g` getan`goga`st tfk [`atkm Utgtks) nr) pkrfgps bnrk ialkiy) g [.U."iaek`skm enrpnrgtan` a`

g nrkao` mnbkstae durasmaetan`. ]fk k`nrea`o pgrty wnuim hk rkquarkm tn hra`o

ats getan` a` g durasmaetan` watf mnbkstae igw a`enrpnrgta`o [@EINU nhiaogtan`s.

K`nrekbk`t n [@EINU a` g nrkao` mnbkstae enurt wnuim mkpk`m n` tfk rkigtan`sfap

hktwkk` trkgtaks g`m tfk nrkao` `gtan`s mnbkstae igw.76; @gtan`s gii a`tn twn

egtkonraks a` fnw tfky abpikbk`t trkgtaks a`tn tfkar mnbkstae igw. Unbk stgtks

en`vkrt trkgtaks a`tn mnbkstae igw gutnbgtaegiiy763 g`m a` g` [@EINU bkbhkr stgtk

tgla`o suef g` gpprngef) [@EINU wnuim hk k`nrekghik a` g nrkao` mnbkstae enurt

watfnut g`y urtfkr getan` rkquarkm hy tfk bkbhkr stgtk. A` en`trgst) snbk `gtan`s

rkquark abpikbk`ta`o ikoasigtan` hknrk g trkgty as k`nrekghik gs mnbkstae igw.76? A`

suef g `gtan`) [@EINU wnuim katfkr `kkm tn hk bgmk ski"kxkeuta`o upn` rgtaegtan`)

nr hk abpikbk`tkm tfrnuof skpgrgtk ikoasigtan`.766

A` katfkr egsk) a g stgtk as waiia`o tn a`enrpnrgtk [@EINU prnvasan`s a`tn ats mnbkstae

igw) at as nrkskkghik tfgt tfk stgtk baoft gisn a`sast tfgt enrpnrgtan`s en`mueta`o

husa`kss watfa` tfk stgtk enbpiy watf [@EINU. Cnr kxgbpik) stgtk G baoft kstghiasf

g ruik tfgt hknrk enrpnrgtan` T mnks husa`kss watfa` G) T bust mkbn`strgtk tfgt ats

a`tkr`gtan`gi husa`kss as en`muetkm en`sastk`t watf [@EINU. Curtfkr) a T as girkgmy

mna`o husa`kss watfa` G g`m u`mkrtglks g `kw `n`"[@EINU"enbpiag`t vk`turk

kiskwfkrk) G baoft suhdket T tn pk`gitaks. Gitkr`gtavkiy) G baoft giinw pravgtk egusks

n getan` tn hk hrnuoft hy tfarm"pgrty enrpnrgtan`s nr @ONs goga`st T gs g wgy tn

enbpki [@EINU enbpiag`ek. Efkvrn`) Kxxn`) g`m Eneg"Enig grk snbk n tfk [.U.

enrpnrgtan`s tfgt fgvk hkk` nrekm tn k`murk in`o g`m kxpk`savk iataogtan` a` g nrkao`

mnbkstae enurt nr efgroks rg`oa`o rnb k`varn`bk`tgi pniiutan` tn fubg` raofts

vanigtan`s.761

]nmgy) skvkrgi enu`traks fgvk stgtutks bg`mgta`o [@EINU enbpiag`ek. Cnr kxgbpik)

Gustrgiag fgs pgsskm tfk Ukg g`m Uuhbkrokm Ig`ms Get n 71?5) wfaef oavks

mnbkstae kket tn tfk prnvasan`s n [@EINU.71: ]fas mnbkstae ikoasigtan` wnuim

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

21/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 87 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

giinw Gustrgiag tn hra`o suat goga`st tfk [`atkm Utgtks nr g [.U."iaek`skm enrpnrgtan`

a` ats mnbkstae enurts.

A` gmmatan` tn nhtga`a`o durasmaetan` tn hra`o tfk eigab) g piga`ta fnpa`o tn nhtga`enbpiktk sueekss bust gisn nhtga` k`nrekbk`t durasmaetan` nvkr tfk nppnsa`o pgrty.

]fas as kgsaiy geenbpiasfkm a tfk enrpnrgtan` as mna`o husa`kss nr fgs gsskts watfa`

tfk rkikvg`t durasmaetan`< fnwkvkr) kvk` a `nt) durasmaetan` wnuim nt kekssgraiy hk

nrkeinskm u`mkr a`tkr`gtan`gi kxtrgtkrratnragiaty pra`eapiks. Durasmaetan` baoft kxast

a tfk [`atkm Utgtks nr g [.U."iaek`skm enrpnrgtan` wgs fgrba`o tfk vatgi ken`nbae

a`tkrksts n tfk piga`ta) tgla`o getan` mkkbkm tn fgvk g fgrbui kket watfa` tfk

nrkao` stgtks tkrratnry) nr pntk`tagiiy gketa`o tfk a`tkrksts n tfk a`tkr`gtan`gi

enbbu`aty gs g wfnik.717

]n prkvgai goga`st tfk [`atkm Utgtks) tfk piga`ta wnuim `kkm tn nvkrenbk tfk

prksubptan` tfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks) gs g snvkrkao` stgtk) as abbu`k rnb eavaidurasmaetan`.718 Gitfnuof tfk igw vgraks gbn`o stgtks) tfas baoft hk geenbpiasfkm hy

rkiya`o n` tfk enbbkreagi gturk n kxpinrgtan` g`m mkvkinpbk`t n` tfk kxtk`mkm

en`ta`k`tgi sfki g`m mkkp skghkm. ]ypaegiiy) tn mktkrba`k a snbktfa`o as enbbkreagi)

n`k bust innl tn tfk `gturk n tfk en`muet rgtfkr tfg` tn tfk purpnsk. ]fk ken`nbae

mkvkinpbk`t n kw wgtkrs hgelkm watf bnmkr` tkef`ninoy g`m a`vkstbk`t as

ekrtga`iy enbbkreagi a` `gturk.

A`tkr`gtan`gi Xkputgtan`

]fk survky ghnvk suooksts g vgrakty n ikogi bkg`s tfrnuof wfaef tfk [`atkm Utgtks

nr g [.U."iaek`skm enrpnrgtan` baoft hk efgiik`okm nr npkrgtan`s n` tfk skgcnnr

nutsamk tfk [@EINU systkb. ]n mgtk) suef efgiik`oks grk spkeuigtavk< fnwkvkr) tfk

vgrakty n pntk`tagi efgiik`okrs g`m nrubs sfnuim igy hgrk tfk `ntan` tfgt tfk n`iy

tfa`o enrpnrgtan`s fgvk tn kgr as kgr atski.715

Enrpnrgtk rkiuetg`ek tn prnekkm n` tfk skgcnnr bgy gisn grask rnb tfk pkrekptan`

tfgt g bnrk abbkmagtk n`"ikogi rasl innbs igrokr. ]fk bnst tfrkgtk`a`o prnspket

nr prnspketavk skgcnnr npkrgtnrs tnmgyntfkr tfg` g nrkao` `gvy nr engst ougrm

vksski grrava`o tn nreahiy kdket tfkb rnb g` nsfnrk satkbgy hk tfk pntk`tagi

inss n rkputgtan` tfgt wnuim rksuit rnb u`mkrtgla`o g rnouk npkrgtan` nutsamk tfk

[@EINU rkoabk.71= Enbpg`aks watf oinhgi npkrgtan`s g`m bgrlkts rkiy n` pniataegi

suppnrt rnb nrkao` onvkr`bk`ts) `g`eagi suppnrt rnb nrkao` a`vkstnrs) g`m

bgrlkt suppnrt rnb nrkao` en`subkrs. Enbpg`aks bgy hk ingtf tn dknpgrmazk

sueekss ghrngm hy tgla`o getan` tfgt baoft g`tgon`azk tfksk paiigrs n g gvnrghik

husa`kss eiabgtk.71;

]fk Egsk cnr Zniataegi Utghaiaty

Gs tfas pgpkr fgs gttkbptkm tn mkbn`strgtk) [@EINU suppnrts g vgrakty n

abpnrtg`t [.U. a`tkrksts a` tfk Gretae. ]fk [.U. mkeasan` tn suppnrt [@EINU gs

tfk Gretaes onvkr`a`o ikogi rgbkwnrl wgs) g`m rkbga`s) snu`m pniaey.

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

22/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 88 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

]n hk surk) tfk [@EINU rgbkwnrl as `nt g pg`gekg. Gretae Enu`eai bkbhkrs mn `nt

giwgys sfgrk tfk sgbk a`tkrprktgtan`s n spkeae en`vk`tan` prnvasan`s. _faik tfas

a`trnmueks enbpikxaty) at sfnuim `nt nvkrsfgmnw tfk get tfgt gorkkbk`t n` g enbbn`

ikogi rgbkwnrl rkmueks g sao`aeg`t pntk`tagi hgrrakr tn prnorkss. Bnrknvkr) ikstg`yn`k hk nvkriy neuskm n` [@EINU ogps nr gbhaouataks) [@EINU slkptaes wnuim

mn wkii tn rkgiazk tfk [`atkm Utgtks enuim mn buef wnrsk.

]fk Gretae Enu`eais Bgy 8:75 mkeasan` tn org`t nhskrvkr stgtus tn Efa`g) A`mag) Unutf

Lnrkg) Ua`ogpnrk) g`m Atgiy u`mkrsenrks tfk nhvanus4 abpnrtg`t a`tkr`gtan`gi getnrs

nutsamk tfk Gretae grk a`tk`skiy en`ekr`km watf tfk rkoan`s uturk.713 Eurrk`tiy) tfk

`kw Gretae Enu`eai nhskrvkr stgtks fgvk `n vntks g`m tfkar nrbgi pgrtaeapgtan` a`

Gretae onvkr`g`ek as iabatkm tn `n`"vnta`o rniks a` wnrla`o ornups.71? Ona`o nrwgrm)

fnwkvkr) at skkbs rkgsn`ghik tn gsl wfktfkr Efa`g waii hk en`tk`t tn en`ta`uk watf g

tg`ok`tagi rnik a` Gretae mkeasan`"bgla`o. Gs n`k nhskrvkr fgs `ntkm4

]fk bg`trg tfgt tfk Gretae g`m ats `gturgi rksnurek wkgitf hkin`o tn `n n`k

enu`try nr ornup n enu`traks hut en`statutk tfk enbbn` fkratgok n gii

fubg`la`m as vartugiiy mk raoukur a` rkek`t Efa`ksk puhiae enbbk`tgry n`

Gretae ggars. ]fkrk grk gisn a`maegtan`s tfgt Efa`g skks atski gt tfk vg`ougrm

n tfk rkst n fubg`aty g`m tfk a`tkr`gtan`gi enbbu`aty a` tfas rkogrm.716

Gitfnuof at as eikgr tfgt tfk vgst Gretae rksnureks grk gttrgetavk tn Efa`g)711

prkmaetan`s ghnut Efa`gs pniataegi a`tk`tan`s a` tfk Gretae sfnuim hk bgmk egutanusiy.

Neagi onvkr`bk`t stgtkbk ts fgvk hkk` iabatkm g`m wrata`o nraoa`gta`o rnb

tfk Efa`ksk gegmkbae enbbu`aty as nt giwgys g rkiaghik a`maegtnr n uturk stgtk

hkfgvanr. _atf tfas egvkgt a` ba`m) fnwkvkr) tfkrk as kvamk`ek tfgt gt ikgst snbk

Efa`ksk bgy hk mask`efg`tkm watf Efa`gs `kgr"tkrb geekss tn Gretae rksnureks.

A` 8:7:) g Efa`ksk gmbargi eigabkm tfgt sa`ek Efa`g fgs 8: pkrek`t n tfk wnrims

pnpuigtan`) at sfnuim fgvk 8: pkrek`t n tfk Gretaes rksnureks. 8:: _faik tfas bgy `nt

rkcket neagi Efa`ksk pniaey) at bgy rkcket g sk`sk n bnrgi k`tatikbk`t tn Gretae skg

rnutks g`m rksnureks.8:7 Gs n`k Efa`ksk sefnigr skks at4

Gretae iattnrgi stgtks . . . gii wg`t tn map tfkar eups a`tn tfk raef stkw n nai g`m

`gturgi ogs a` tfk Gretae Nekg`. \Efa`g sfnuim pigy g rnikR a` tfk nrbuigtan`

n a`tkr`gtan`gi igw . . . g`m durasmaetan` nvkr rksnureks g`m skg rnutks g`m mn

ats utbnst a` tfk Gretae tn bglk ats nw` vnaek fkgrm g`m strk`otfk` ats raoft tn

spkgl up. N`iy tfnsk wfn hkenbk nw`krs n rksnureks waii hk ghik tn nhtga`

tfkar raoftui vgiuk.8:8

Ntfkr Efa`ksk sefnigrs fgvk suookstkm tfgt [@EINU mnks `nt k`tarkiy sgkougrm

Efa`gs pkrekavkm Gretae a`tkrksts) nta`o enrrketiy tfgt a Gretae stgtks kxkreask tfkar

kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki raofts u`mkr [@EINU) Efa`gs nppnrtu`aty tn pgrtglk n

tfk enbbn` fkratgok a` tfk Gretae waii hk orkgtiy maba`asfkm.8:5

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

23/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 85 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

]n hk gar) at wnuim hk g bastglk tn ao`nrk kvamk`ek tfgt Efa`g eurrk`tiy skkbs tn

suppnrt [@EINU gs tfk onvkr`a`o ikogi rkoabk nr tfk Gretae.8:= ]fas as inoaegi)

oavk` [@EINU prntketan` n `gvaogtan`gi rkkmnbs g`m Efa`gs a`tkrkst a` tfk

pntk`tagi nr sfnrtkr skg rnutks tfrnuof tfk @nrtfkr` Ukg Xnutk g`m @nrtfwkstZgssgok. Uuppnrt nr [@EINU rkk gvaogtan` prnvasan`s) fnwkvkr) mnks `nt rkquark

suppnrt nr [@EINU skgcnnr prnvasan`s. A` get) n`k eg` kgsaiy en`ekavk Efa`g

hra`oa`o ats a`cuk`ek tn hkgr a` suppnrt n g` Gretae trkgty g`m geenbpg`ya`o ikogi

rkoabk u`aqukiy tgainrkm nr tfk spkeagi `kkms n tfk Gretae g`m tfk a`tkr`gtan`gi

enbbu`aty.

Efa`g) tfk Kurnpkg` [`an`) nr ntfkr bkbhkr stgtks enuim gisn gttkbpt tn gbk`m

[@EINU a` wgys tfgt enuim efg`ok tfk gvnrghik kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki

g`m mkkp skghkm ba`a`o rkoabks) nr oavk engstgi stgtks bnrk en`trni hkyn`m

tfkar tkrratnragi skgs g`m pntk`tagiiy nhstruet tfk rkkmnbs tn `gvaogtk g`m tn

igy g`m bga`tga` a`tkr`gtan`gi eghiks. _atfnut geekss tn [@EINU prnekmurks)tfk [`atkm Utgtks insks tfk nrek n ats nhdketan`s g`m rasls hka`o g hystg`mkr gs

Bkbhkr Utgtks kketavkiy gbk`m eustnbgry a`tkr`gtan`gi igw tfrnuof [@EINU

gbk`mbk`ts.8:;

A` tfk ykgrs tn enbk) waii Efa`g en`ta`uk tn suppnrt g ikogi rkoabk a` tfk Gretae

tfgt kxeiumks Efa`g rnb tfk vgst bgdnraty n tfk Gretaes skgcnnr rksnureks> G`m a

Efa`g `ms tfk [@EINU skgcnnr rkoabk en`straeta`o g`m kbpinys ats en`samkrghik

a`cuk`ek g`m `g`eagi strk`otf tn inhhy nr nsfnrk a`vkstbk`t nr nr g `kw

gpprngef) waii ntfkr stgtks watfnut Gretae engstia`ks niinw suat> Egiis nr g` Gretae

trkgty grk `nt `kw)8:3 g`m oavk` Efa`gs a`tkrksts) suef g` knrt wnuim fgrmiy hk

surprasa`o.8:? A suef g bnvkbk`t wkrk tn grask) at as maeuit tn grouk tfgt tfk [`atkm

Utgtks wnuim hk a` g strn`okr pnsatan` tn rksast efg`ok gs g` u`enbbattkm nutsamkr

rgtfkr tfg` g uii"ckmokm bkbhkr stgtk.

Uubbgry

]fas pgpkr fgs kxgba`km tfk qukstan` n wfktfkr tfk [`atkm Utgtks gaiurk tn

dna` [@EINU fkips nr furts [.U. a`tkrksts a` tfk Gretae. Gtkr rkvakwa`o tfk rg`ok n

[.U. a`tkrksts g`m [@EINU gppiaegtan` tfkrktn) gs wkii gs tfk nhdketan`s n [@EINU

nppn`k`ts) tfkrk as iattik rkgsn` tn en`eiumk tfgt dna`a`o [@EINU enuim furt [.U.

a`tkrksts. A`mkkm) a` bg`y wgys) [@EINU geekssan` wnuim hk`kt tfk [`atkm Utgtks.

Ona`o nrwgrm) tfk prkeask kxtk`t tn wfaef geekssan` wnuim fkip [.U. nhdketavks

waii mkpk`m a` igrok bkgsurk n` tfk abpnrtg`ek pniaeybglkrs gttgef tn rksnureks

n` g`m hkinw tfk skgcnnr bnrk tfg` 8:: baiks rnb Gigslgs engst. A tfk [`atkm

Utgtks wasfks tn bga`tga` bgxabub ckxahaiaty tn mkvkinp ats pntk`tagi rksnureks a`

tfas mnbga`) tfk [.U. sfnuim geekmk tn [@EINU gt tfk snn`kst kgriakst nppnrtu`aty.

Cgaiurk tn mn sn a`erkgsks tfk ialkiafnnm tfgt tfk pgelgok mkgi sn gvnrghik tn [.U.

a`tkrksts waii `nt k`murk tn tfk mktrabk`t n [.U. a`tkrksts.

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

24/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 8= Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

Xkprksk`tgtavks n bgdnr [.U. enrpnrgtan`s watf pntk`tagi a`tkrksts n` tfk

skgcnnr fgvk raoftiy kxprksskm en`ekr` ghnut bgla`o `kekssgry a`vkstbk`ts g`m

prnekkma`o watf skgcnnr prndkets gs in`o gs tfk [`atkm Utgtks rkbga`s nutsamk

[@EINU. Gs in`o gs tfk [`atkm Utgtks rkbga`s nutsamk [@EINU) g`y [.U."iaek`skmgetavaty n` tfk [.U. kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki waii hk ikogiiy suspket g`m vui`krghik

tn efgiik`ok. Oavk` tfksk rasls) gs wkii gs en`ekr`s ghnut a`tkr`gtan`gi rkputgtan`)

abpnrtg`t [.U. a`mustraks waii ialkiy rkbga` u`waiia`o tn prnekkm. A` tfk bkg`tabk)

[@EINU bkbhkr stgtks en`ta`uk tn qukuk up tn pkrket tfkar nw` nutkr iabats n

tfk kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki hknrk tfk EIEU. A tfk [`atkm Utgtks wkrk tn geekmk

tn tfk en`vk`tan` tnmgy g`m suhbat g prnpnsgi tn tfk EIEU tnbnrrnw) tfk EIEU waii

`nt ialkiy en`samkr tfk pktatan` u`tai gt ikgst 8:5:. ]fas tabk rgbk waii en`ta`uk tn

kxpg`m u`tai tfk [`atkm Utgtks dna`s tfk qukuk) wfaef at eg``nt mn rnb nutsamk tfk

en`vk`tan`.

]fk nrkaturk n [@EINU hk`kts) n` tfk skgcnnr nr kiskwfkrk) as pgrtaeuigriytrnuhia`o oavk` tfgt tfk hk`kts grk gvgaighik gt ba`abgi enst. Gs maseusskm watfa`)

nppnsatan` groubk`ts suooksta`o ntfkrwask sukr rnb abpnrtg`t ikogi mkkets gs

wkii gs cgwkm pniaey gssubptan`s. Oavk` tfgt bg`y n tfksk groubk`ts fgvk pigykm

g prnba`k`t rnik a` tfk eurrk`t [@EINU stgikbgtk) Gretae pniaeybglkrs bust

en`samkr wfktfkr tfkrk bgy hk `kw) bnrk kketavk wgys tn pkrsugmk u`mkeamkm

sk`gtnrs tn en`rn`t tfk spkeaes n nppnsatan` groubk`ts.

Gretae pniaeybglkrs bust gisn nvkrenbk tfk a`krtag grasa`o rnb tfk get tfgt

`kgr"tkrb prnspkets nr a`mustry getan` n` tfk Gretae kxtk`mkm en`ta`k`tgi sfki

g`m hkyn`m skkb rkbntk.Zntk`tagiGretae hk`kts) n bgttkr fnw iuergtavk)

prnvamk iattik pniataegi a`ek`tavk nr abbkmagtk getan`. A`ek`tavk as urtfkr rkmuekm

hy tfk kgsk watf wfaef tfk [`atkm Utgtks fgs hkk` ghik tn k`dny bg`y [@EINU

hk`kts watfnut dna`a`o tfk en`vk`tan`. _faik tfas fgs en`trahutkm tn g bnrk

stghik bgratabk ikogi rkoabk en`mueavk tn [.U. oinhgi a`tkrksts) at fgs gisn ikm

[@EINU nppn`k`ts tn eigab sueekssuiiygihkat u`waskiy) g`m) a` snbk a`stg`eks

a`enrrketiytfgt tfk [`atkm Utgtks eg` en`ta`uk tn kxpinat gii [@EINU hk`kts

watfnut pgya`o tfk ba`abgi ensts n [@EINU bkbhkrsfap. Gppiaegtan` n tfas

giigey tn tfk Gretae enuim hk enstiy.

]fk [`atkm Utgtks sfnuim dna` [@EINU tn uiiy prkskrvk [.U. Gretae a`tkrksts.

Gitfnuof snbk n tfk en`vk`tan s bnst abpnrtg`t gmvg`tgoks a` tfk Gretae bgy

`nt hk abbkmagtkiy gvgaighik) [@EINU wnuim giinw tfk [`atkm Utgtks tn prkskrvk

bgxabub ckxahaiaty tnmgy nr mkvkinpa`o nsfnrk k`kroy rksnureks tnbnrrnw. A`

gmmatan`) geekssan` wnuim rka`nrek g ikogi rkoabk gvnrghik tn ntfkr abpnrtg`t

[.U. Gretae a`tkrksts gs wkii) g`m mktkr prnspkets nr tfk [@EINU tn eniigpsk nr hk

rkvaskm tn tfk mktrabk`t n [.U. a`tkrksts.

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

25/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 8; Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

Gel`nwikmobk`ts

]fk gutfnr wasfks tn tfg`l tn Zk`` Utgtk Igw stumk`ts UgrgG`` Hk``ktt &ikgm

rkskgrefkr!) Hk` Fgaoft) Efgm Utkvk`sn`) g`m Mk``as Fgrha` nr tfkar a`vgiughik

rkskgref gssastg`ek) gs wkii gs Egatiy` G`trab) Mnuoigs X. Hur`ktt) D. Gsfiky Xngef)Bgrl Xnsk`) g`m Mgvam Saetnr nr tfkar a`saoftui rkvakws n prkvanus mrgts.

@ntks

7 Eg`gmg) Mk`bgrl) @nrwgy) g`m tfk Xussag` Ckmkrgtan`.

8 ]fk Aiuiassgt Mkeigrgtan`) Bgy 86) 8::6) gvgaighik gtfttp4www.nekg`igw.nromnw`ingmsgretaeAiuiassgt

^Mkeigrgtan`.pm.

5 [`atkm @gtan`s En`vk`tan` n` tfk Igw n tfk Ukg) Mke. 7:) 7168) 7655 [.@.].U. 51? \fkrka gtkr [@EINUR.

= ]fk Aiuiassgt Mkeigrgtan` mnks `nt marketiy rkkrk`ek [@EINU hkegusk tfk [`atkm Utgtks as `nt g pgrty tn tfk

en`vk`tan`. Fg`s Enrkii) ]fk Gretae4 G` Nppnrtu`aty tn Ennpkrgtk g`m Mkbn`strgtk Upnrtsbg`sfap) =8 Sg`m.

D. ]rg`s`g]i i. 7:3;) 7:3? &8::1!.

; `g]an`gi s]rg]koycnr]fk gre]ae rkoan` 7: &8:75! \fkrka`gtkr [.s. gre]ae s]rg]koy 8:75R)gvgaighik gt

fttp4www.wfatkfnusk.onvsatksmkguitiksmnes`gt^gretae^strgtkoy.pm.

3 Am. gt 1.

? ]fk Igw n tfk Ukg En`vk`tan` &]rkgty Mne. 7:5"51!4 ]fk [.U. @gtan`gi Ukeuraty g`m Utrgtkoae Abpkrgtavks nr

Xgtaegtan`4 Fkgra`o Hknrk tfk U. Enbb. n` Cnrkao` Xkigtan`s) 778tf En`o. &8:78! &stgtkbk`t n Uk`. Dnf`

Lkrry) Efgarbg`) U. Enbb. n` Cnrkao` Ggars!) gvgaighik gtfttp47.usg.onv7:a=dmg.

6 ]fk Igw n tfk Ukg En`vk`tan` &]rkgty Mne. 7:5"51!4 Zkrspketavks rnb Husa`kss g`m A`mustry4 Fkgra`o

Hknrk tfk U. Enbb. n` Cnrkao` Xkigtan`s) 778tf En`o. 3 &8:78! &stgtkbk`t n Dgel @. Okrgrm) Zrksamk`t #

Efak Kxke. Nekr) Gb. Zktrnikub A`st.!) gvgaighik gtfttp47.usg.onvTNDV_y.

1 [`atkm Utgtks Nekg`s Zniaey 7165) 71 _KKLIQ ENBZ. ZXKU. Mne. 565) 633 &Bgr. 7:) 7165!.

7: U. ]rkgty Mne. @n. 7:5"51) gt AAAAS &711=!. Cnr g enbprkfk`savk gsskssbk`t n Zrksamk`t Xkgog`s vakws

n` [@EINU) skkD. gsfiky rngef # rnhkr] _. sba]f) Z[hiaeg]an`sn` nekg`s mkSkinZbk`]4 kxekssaSk

bgra]abk eigabs 67;) 67? &5m km. 8:78! &Zrksamk`t Xkgog` pna`tkm snikiy tn ekrtga` mkkp skghkm ba`a`o

prnvasan`s n tfk En`vk`tan` gs cgwkm. Fk en`samkrkm tfgt tfnsk prnvasan`s enuim hk xkm g`m spkeaegiiy

amk`takm tfk kikbk`ts a` `kkm n rkvasan`.!.

77 Uentt O. Hnrokrsn`) ]fk @gtan`gi A`tkrkst g`m tfk Igw n tfk Ukg) en[`eai n` cnrkao` rkig]an`s sZkeagi

rkZnr]@n. =3) gt 7875 &Bgy 8::1!) gvgaighik gtfttp4n`.er.nro76Od51p.

78 Ukk[@EINU) suprg`ntk 5) grts. 7?) 56) ;5) ;6) 6?) gt 5:) 5?) =8=5) ==) ;?.

75 Ukk[.s. gre]ae s]rg]koy 8:75) suprg`ntk ;) gt 3 &Zrkskrvk Gretae Xkoan` Crkkmnb n tfk Ukgs]fk

[`atkm Utgtks fgs g `gtan`gi a`tkrkst a` prkskrva`o gii n tfk raofts) rkkmnbs) g`m usks n skg g`m garspgek

rkeno`azkm u`mkr a`tkr`gtan`gi igw.! &Kbpfgsas a` nraoa`gi!.

7= mkZ]nc a`]kranr) bg`goa`ocnr]fk c[][rka`g rgZamiy efg`oa`o gre]ae4 g rkZnr]]n]fk

Zrksamk`] 77 &8:75! \fkrka`gtkr rgZamiy efg`oa`o gre]aeR)gvgaighik gtfttp47.usg.onv77lBN[U.

7/29/2019 The Opportunity Costs of Ignoring the Law of Sea Convention in the Arctic, by James W. Houck

26/40

]fk Nppnrtu`aty Ensts nc Ao`nra`o tfk Igw nc Ukg En`vk`tan` a` tfk Gretae 83 Fnnvkr A`statutan` Utg`cnrm [`avkrsat

7; rngef # sba]f) suprg`ntk 7:) gt =??.

73 Ukk) k.o.)rgZamiy efg`oa`o gre]ae) suprg`ntk 7=) gt 7? &maseussa`o tfk en`ta`ukm ornwtf n enbbkreagi

sfappa`o gs skg aek maba`asfks nvkr tabk!< gre]ae en[`eai) gre]ae hanmaSkrsa]y gsskssbk`]4 s]g][s #

]rk`msa` gre]ae hanmaSkrsa]y ;:; &8:75! \fkrka`gtkr gre]ae hanmaSkrsa]y gsskssbk`]R &maseussa`o fnw

a`erkgskm tnurasb vag eruasks fgs rksuitkm a` tfk Gretae g`m en`ta`uks tn ornw gs tfk Gretae Nekg` g`m

surrnu`ma`o skgs hkenbk bnrk en`sastk`tiy geekssahik!< D. Gsfiky Xngef) A`tkr`gtan`gi Igw g`m tfk Gretae4 G

Ouamk tn [`mkrstg`ma`o tfk Assuks) 7; s_. D. a`]i i. 5:7) 578 &8::1! &`nta`o tfgt tfk pntk`tagi nr g` aek"rkk

Gretae Nekg` prnvamks tfk [`atkm Utgtks bnrk spgek tn en`muet baiatgry kxkreasks pursug`t tn [@EINU

`gvaogtan`gi rkkmnb prnvasan`s!.

7? Bgitk Fubpkrt # G`mrkgs Xgspnt`al) ]fk Cuturk n Gretae Ufappa`o Gin`o tfk ]rg`spnigr Ukg Xnutk)

gre]ae ykgrhnnl 867) 868 &8:78!) gvgaighik gtfttp4hat.iy78:pob]. ]fk ]rg`spnigr Ukg Xnutk &]UX! as g

tfarm trg`s"Gretae `gvaogtan`gi rnutk tfgt waii hkenbk gvgaighik n`ek tfk Gretae skg aek maba`asfks enbpiktkiy.

Am. Hkegusk tfk ]UX rkbga`s u`gvgaighik nr tfk nrkskkghik uturk) at waii hk kxeiumkm rnb tfk maseussan` n

[.U. `gvaogtan`gi a`tkrksts. Cnr g bnrk a`"mkptf maseussan` n tfk ]UX gs g pntk`tagi a`tkr`gtan`gi sfappa`o

rnutk) skkam.

76 Ukk) k.o.) Eigumag Ea`kiia) ]fk Igw n tfk Ukg g`m tfk Gretae)8 gre]ae rkS. n` i. # Zni. =) 77 `.88 &8:77!) =: `gS. i. r. 8:?) 8:173 &7118!

&kxpiga`a`o tfk fastnry n tfk enbbn` fkratgok n bg`la`m en`ekpt!.

7:= Gorkkbk`t Xkigta`o tn tfk Abpikbk`tgtan` n Zgrt VA n tfk [`atkm @gtan`s En`vk`tan` n` tfk Igw

n tfk Ukg n 7: Mke. 7168) Duiy 86) 711=) 7653 [.@.].U. 5 \fkrka`gtkr Zgrt VA Gorkkbk`tR) gvgaighik gt

fttp4hat.iy7=nlfig.

7:; [@EINU) suprg`ntk 5) grt. 7;6) gt 67.

7:3 Am. grts. 73331) gt 1815.

7:? Gii [@EINU bkbhkr stgtks grk tfkrkhy bkbhkrs n tfk gutfnraty. Am. grt. 7;3.8) gt 67