The New Digital Disorder

June 2008Metadata DWG – The 3rd order of orders

66th OGC Technical Committee

Potsdam, GermanyArnulf Christl

June 02, 2008

Hosted by

Additional Sponsors:

Copyleft © 2008, Open Geospatial Consortium, Inc., All Rights Reserved.2

Helping the World to Communicate

Geographically

Agenda

• Introduction• Scope of this presentation• Three levels of order• Physical objects, catalogs, and digital data• OGC CSW• The Dewey Decimal Library Classification System• Why Categories Fail• Extracting Knowledge from Miscellany

Copyright: WhereGroup GmbH & Co. KG.Licensed under GNU FDL http://www.gnu.org/licenses/fdl.txt and CreativeCommons 3.0 ShareAlike

http://www.wheregroup.com/

http://www.gnu.org/licenses/fdl.txt



Geographically

Introduction

The original title of this presentation was: A short introduction on the third order of orders, tagging,

collaborative methodology, search engine power and failure, distributed resources and centralized registries

It was nothing but a brain dump triggered by reading:

Everything is Miscellaneous by David Weinberger. This presentation brims with citations from his book.

http://www.everythingismiscellaneous.com/

http://www.everythingismiscellaneous.com/



Geographically

Scope of this presentation

This presentation shows how meta and data have merged in the digital realm. Services, clients, software and architecture are all in place, we have:

Structured,

Ordered,

Categorized,

Hierarchical,

Meta Data

But still we fail to get it to the people!Web 2.0, social networks, tag clouds and the like

add value by exposing data and allowing dynamic creation ofKnowledge from Data.



Geographically

Three Levels of Order

In a nutshell the book states that:● The 1st order of orders is about physical things.● The 2nd order of orders is categories and hierarchies as

implemented by library card catalogs.● The 3rd order of orders is emerging right now and it

completely redefines our perception of meaning itself. Meta data catalogs are stuck right there in the second level of orders. Opening them to the miscellany of the third order of orders will make them so much more useful.



Geographically

The 1st Order of Order: Atoms

Physical things (atoms) occupy space. This creates a set of clear rules how to order (and find) things:

● One thing can only be at one location at a time● One location can only be occupied by one thing● One thing can hide another one that is behind ● The number of accessible things is physically limited.

In this context space is the limiting factor. The organization of the 1st order of orders is an art of its own. An office equipment store uses a different system than a car dealer or a gas station. All are specialized to their products.



Geographically

The 2rd Order of Orders: Catalogs

When book printing became commonplace it was suddenly possible to aggregate knowledge on papers between two covers and put them in a shelf. Thus knowledge became physical – with all its limitations.

● Catalogs helped democratize knowledge by putting meta data on a card making it much more findable.

● The limited space of a catalog card entry (a few lines) and the physical space books occupy are natural physical boundaries to this system.



Geographically

The 3rd Order of Orders – Digital Data

The great advantage of digital data bears heavy on all our concepts of matter:

● Information is most valuable when it is thrown into a big, digital pile to be filtered and organized by users themselves

● Instead of relying on experts, groups of users are inventing their own ways of discovering data

● Smart companies do not treat information as an asset to be guarded, but let it loose to be "mashed up", gaining market awareness and customer loyalty.



Geographically

Catalogue Services – Web

Catalogs list objects by putting them in a neutral order and list them in categories. The order typically is:

● Alphabetical or numerical order (start at one end and stop at the other). No preferences, no bias, neutral.

● Hierarchies are managed in trees (catalogs) with branches (categories) and leaves (items). Meaning.

Catalogs overcome the inaccessibility of the information contained in books by exposing much better accessible meta data. The lines of text on a catalog card are limited and for better accessibility it gets organized in categories.



Geographically

Trees, Categories and Hierarchies

In the 19th century Melvil Dewey created the three digit Dewey decimal library catalog numbering system with 9 top level categories.

● 100s philosophy and psychology (which in that time were considered to be the foundation of knowledge)

● 200s religion (which in this mindset gave truth)● 300s social sciences● 400s language● 500s natural sciences and math



Geographically

Categories Fail● 600s technology and applied science● 700s arts and recreation● 800s literature and rhetoric● 900s geography, history and biography

It is still being used today but in many places it is misleading if not embarrassingly wrong. While "UralAltaic, Paleosiberian and Dravidian" are a top level category (494) the language spoken by 1.2 billion Chinese is not. It can be changed but – who decides? Dublin Core, ISO Application Profile, All Fail.



Geographically

Recap our Traditional View of Knowledge

Our traditional view of knowledge goes like this:1. There is only one reality and only one knowledge. If two

have a different view, one is right, the other is wrong. 2. Knowledge is unambiguous. If something is unclear we

have not understood it. 3. Because knowledge is so big we need experts to filter

and keep bad information away from us.4. Experts achieve their positions by working their way

through institutions.



Geographically

The potential miscellany of our digital data has tremendous power. But to unleash this power it requires us to review our strategy of knowledge:

1. Filter on the way out not the way in.2. Put each leaf on as many branches as possible.3. Everything is meta data and everything can be a label.4. Give up control.

Don't start to argue why this does not work. Think what good it can do.

New Properties, New Strategies, New Knowledge



Geographically

The potential miscellany of our digitaldigital data has tremendous power. But to unleash this power it requires us to reviewreview our strategy of knowledge:

1. Filter on the way out not the way in.2. Put each leaf on as many branches as possiblepossible.3. Everything is meta data and everything can be a label.4. Give up control!

Don't start to argue why this does not workwork. Think what good it can do.

New Properties, New Strategies, New Knowledge

t a g g e d &

a n n o t a t e d



Geographically

Now What?

As so often these days, we will not know what happens when we do that. But as every other so often we will be surprised at what can be done.

Wikipedia and OpenStreetMap are just flimsy examples compiled by civilians.

Imagine to what power these technologies and concepts would rise if they were let loose in the hand of

experts and professionals!



Geographically

Discussion

Thank you for your attention.

Author: Arnulf Christl WhereGroup GmbH & Co. KGSiemensstr. 853121 BonnGermanyhttp://www.wheregroup.com/

Copyright: WhereGroup GmbH & Co. KG.

This presentation is dual licensed under GNU FDL and Creative Commons 3.0 Share Alike. Choose the one that fits your needs best. The presentation master, cover pages and last page (this one) are what the GNU FDL refers to as invariant sections. Please do not modify these pages without getting written permission by the author. Find the full text of the GNU FDL at: http://www.gnu.org/licenses/fdl.txt

http://www.gnu.org/licenses/fdl.txt

The New Digital Disorder

Education

Transcript of The New Digital Disorder