Annapolis House Rentals - Finding a New Home with Annapolis Property Services
The Maryland Collaborative to Reduce College Drinking and ......• Towson and Annapolis outlets...
Transcript of The Maryland Collaborative to Reduce College Drinking and ......• Towson and Annapolis outlets...
TheMarylandCollaborativetoReduceCollegeDrinkingand
RelatedProblems:
TexasBehavioralHealthInstitute2016
June6,2016
DavidH.Jernigan,Ph.DAssociateProfessor,DepartmentofHealthBehaviorandSocietyDirector,CenteronAlcoholMarketingandYouthJohnsHopkinsUniversityBloombergSchoolofPublicHealth
Acknowledgments
• UniversityofMaryland,CollegePark– AmeliaArria PhD– AndreaSoongMPH
• JohnsHopkinsBloombergSchoolofPublicHealth– MollyMitchellJD– CassandraGreisenMPP
Overview
• Twoparts:– IntroductiontotheMarylandCollaborative– Casestudyofhowweworktobringaboutenvironmentalchange
EffectiveBestPracticesInclude…
• SocialHostOrdinances• Multi-componentinterventionswithcommunitymobilization
• Restrictingalcoholmarketing• Compliancechecksforalcoholoutlets
• EnforcingfalseIDlaws
5StepstoEnvironmentalChange
1. Formcampus-communitycoalitions2. Identifyhigh-riskdrinking“hotspots”3. Chooseabestpracticestrategytoaddress
those“hotspots”4. Worktogethertoimplementthestrategy5. Evaluateoutcomes
IdentifiedEnvironmentalStrategies
LocalSocialHostOrdinance
• FrostburgStateUniversity
• JohnsHopkinsUniversity
• TowsonUniversity• Goucher College• UMBC• UMES
EnhancedEnforcement
• LoyolaUniversity• McDanielCollege• NavalAcademy
LandlordLeaseAgreements
• AlleganyCollege
CampusAlcoholPolicies• Collectedallpubliclyavailablepoliciesviaweb• Analyzingeachcampus’alcoholpoliciesfor:– Clarity– Accessibility– Effectiveness
• DelphiPanelofexpertsrating38policiesand13consequencesforeffectiveness
• Willclassifypoliciesaccordingtoeffectivenessandprovidefeedbacktocampuses
GovernanceCouncilActivities
• PresidentsoftheMarylandCollaborativewereinstrumentalinpassinglegislation:– Tobantheretailsaleofextreme-strengthalcohol(190-proofandstronger)inMaryland
– Togeta2-yearmoratoriumontheretailsaleofpowderedalcoholinMaryland
Environmental scans
• Developedninescanninginstrumentstocollectdatainoff-campusandon-campusenvironmentsthatcancontributetohigh-riskdrinking
• Providedetailedinformationthatcanbeusedtoidentifyevidence-basedstrategieswell-suitedtoaddressproblemsand/orsupportexistingpolicies
• TowsonandAnnapolisoutletsnearmembercampusesscannedbystudents
CaseStudy:EnvironmentalChange
• Hotspots§ Identifytheenvironmentswhereexcessivedrinkingisoccurring
§ Socialvs.Commercialsettings
• Evidence-basedApproach§ Identifyabestpracticeapproachtoaddressingthatenvironmenttoreduceand/orpreventexcessivedrinking
Hotspotforhigh-riskdrinking
73.2% 60.3%
0%15%30%45%60%75%90%
Studentsunder21 Students21to25
Percen
tofS
tude
nts
Percentageofpast-monthdrinkerswhodrankatleastonceinthepastmonthatanoff-campushouse
party.(MD-CAS)
Atooltoreducecollegedrinkingandloudandunrulysocial
gatherings
SocialHostPolicies
WhySHOareeffective
Theory of Deterrence1. Swift2. Certain3. Severe
Evidenceofeffectiveness
• Fewerpolicecallsforservicerelatedtodisturbances
• Adolescentsarelesslikelytodrinkinlargepeergroups
Howtheywork
1. Allowlawenforcementtowritecivilcitations,similartotraffictickets,tothepropertyowners,propertymanagersand/orhostsofloudandunrulyparties;
2. Levyafineforafirstoffenseandfinesincreasinginseverityforsubsequentoffensesatthesamelocation;
3. Canenablelocalgovernmentstorecovercostsforrepeatedlawenforcementorotheremergencyserviceresponsestoaproperty.
BaltimoreCity(15-0540)
BaltimoreCounty(90-15)
PrincessAnne(2016-1)
June2015
Jan2016
April2016
ThreeMarylandSHO
1. Developapolicyactionstatement2. Engageenforcement3. Collectdatatoestablishalegalbasis4. Makeyourcase5. Draftpolicylanguage6. Usemediaadvocacy7. Mobilizesupportandprovidecommunityeducation8. Getthepolicyadopted9. Ensureenforcementofthepolicy10. Evaluatecampaigneffectiveness
10PolicyAdvocacySteps
TheBaltimoreCityCouncilwillpassacivilSocialHostOrdinanceholdingaccountablethosewhohostandallowloudandunrulypartiestopersist.
Step1:DevelopaPolicyActionStatement
Step2:EngageEnforcement
§ Includeenforcementfromthebeginningtohelp:
§Collectlocaldata§ Identifylocalconditions§Selectpolicyresponse(s)§Draftpolicylanguage
Step2:EngageEnforcement
Baltimore City+++ BaltimoreCounty++ PrincessAnne+++
Supportfromuppercommand,Commissioner’stopadvisorssupportive
Providedtestimonyatpublichearing
Support fromlowercommand,Chiefwasnotsupportive
Helpeddesignpolicy,encouragingcommunityserviceinadditiontofines
Support fromuppercommand,Chiefwassupportive
Providedtestimonyatpublichearing
Step3:CompileRelevantData
Compileappropriatedatato:§ Substantiateanddefinethelocalconditionsanditsconsequencesinthecommunity
§ Establishanevidencebasefortheproposedpolicysolution
§ Usingbothquantitative andqualitative data
Step3:CompilingDataBaltimore City++ BaltimoreCounty+++ PrincessAnne+
Qualitative data- Quotesfromneighbors- Pictures
Quantitativedata- Dataprovidedbycity
universities,includingneighborhoodcallsforservice
- Consumptiondata
Qualitative data- Quotesfromneighbors,law
enforcement- Pictures
Quantitativedata- Policecallsforservicefrom
enforcement- Neighborhood complaint,
alcoholtransportsandconsumptiondataformuniversity
Qualitative data- Pictures
Quantitativedata- Policecallsforserviceform
enforcement- Consumptiondataforcollege
byuniversity
ExcessiveDrinking&Consequences
NuisancesandNoise
High-riskdrinkingHotspots
73.2% 60.3%
0%15%30%45%60%75%90%
Studentsunder21 Students21to25
Percen
tofS
tude
nts
Percentageofpast-monthdrinkerswhodrankatleastonceinthepastmonthatanoff-campushouse
party.(MD-CAS)
0.7%0.8%2.9%3.1%3.8%5.8%6.9%7.9%8.3%9.4%13.1%13.9%15.2%
20.3%23.9%
33.6%64.3%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
ArrestedforDWI/DUI
Hadsexwithsomeonewithouttheirconsent
Gotintroublewithoff-campuspolice
Physicallyinjuredsomeoneelse
Gotintroublewithcampuspolice
Droveacarorothervehiclewhiledrunk
Gottakenadvantageofsexually
Gotintroublewithresidencehallstafforother…
Damagedproperty
Physicallyinjuredyourself
Droveacarwhenyouhadbeendrinkingalcohol
Gothurtorinjured
Hadunprotectedsex
Rodeinacardrivenbysomeonewhohadbeen…
Performedpoorlyonatest/projectand/ormisseda…
Blackedout(forgotwhereyouwereorwhatyoudid)
Hadahangover
Percentofstudents
Alcohol-related Consequences
Step4:MakingYourCase
CreateanIssueBriefthat:• Describestheproblemanditsimpactonthecommunity
• Identifycoststocommunityifproblemisnotresolved
• Explainhowtheproposedpolicyaddressescommunityconcerns
• Identifieswaysforcommunitymemberstogetinvolved
Step5:PolicyLanguage
Draftpolicylanguage§ Researchsimilarpolicyexamplesfromother
communities§ Tietolocalconditions§ Clarifylegalbasis§ Compilesupportingdocuments(caselaw,etc..)§ Controlthelanguage§ WorkwiththeCityAttorney/CountyCounsel
Step5:PolicyLanguageBaltimore City+++ BaltimoreCounty+++ PrincessAnne+++
- Providedmodellanguage
- CitybilldrafterinsertedintoBaltimoreCitycode
- ProvidedmodellanguagetolegalpublichealthexpertwhointegratedintoBaltimoreCountycode
- Countybilldrafterdidfinaltouches,amendments
- Provided modellanguagetolegalpublichealthexpertwhointegratedintoPrincessAnne’scode
- TownAttorneydidfinaltouches,amendments
Step6:WorkwithMedia
• FramingforContent• Messagingandcorevalues
• Accountabilityforstudentsandpropertyowner,
• Safetyofstudents• Protectionoftaxpayers
• FramingforAccess• Op-eds,letterstoeditor,newsreleases,
newsconferences
Step6:WorkwithMedia
Baltimore City+ BaltimoreCounty+++ PrincessAnne++
- Oneprintnewsstory - Twoprintstories- Oneeditorial- TwoTVstories
- Four printnewsstories
Step7:CommunityOrganizing
Communityorganizinginvolvesa“topdown”and“bottomup”approachthatincludes:
• Engagingpolicymakersand“influencers”usingaPowerAnalysis
• Mobilizing“grasstops”support&providingcommunityeducation
PowerAnalysis
Who are the most important
individuals?
Who must you talk with before you
approach the him/her?
How do you influence them if they are elected officials?
What is the self-interest of each?
Who will approach this person?
AssesstheIndividualsWhoCanGiveYouWhatYouWant
Whohasthepowertoadoptyourpolicy?
Step7:CommunityOrganizingBaltimore City+++ BaltimoreCounty++ PrincessAnne++
- Top-downapproach- Universitysupport- Neighborhood
support- BCPDsupport- Cityadministration
supportive
- Bottom-upapproach- Strongneighborhood
support,ledorganizing
- Universityneutral- County
administrationopposing
- BCPDneutral
- Top-down approach- University staffled
organizingtobringpolicysolutiontocityleadership
- Cityleadership,policecarriedit
- Minimalcommunitysupport
- Universityambivalent
• Collaborativememberspreparepresentationtodecisionmakers
• Usethetalkingpointsand“frame”developedintheissuebriefandusedinthemediaadvocacy
• Knowwhichdecisionmakerssupportoropposeyourpolicybeforemakingpresentation
Step8:GetthePolicyAdopted
Step8:PolicyAdoptionBaltimore City+++ BaltimoreCounty++ PrincessAnne++
- PassedJune2015- 2yearstoadopt
- Legislation- $500for1st offense,
$1000for2nd andsub- 12-monthlookback
periodforenhancement
- Holdshostandlandlordsaccountable
- Cangivewarning,butdon’thaveto
- Affirmativedefense
- PassedJanuary2016- 3yearstoadopt- 2introductions(8/15,12/15)
- Legislation- $500for1st offense,$1,000for2nd
andsuboffense- 24-monthlookbackperiod- Tiedtorentalpermit- Holdshostandlandlords
accountable- Mustgivewarningfirsttohostand
landlord- Affirmativedefense- Onlyin2geographicareasby
universities,onlyfor6-unitdwellingsorfewer,2-yearpilotprogram,
- PassedApril2016- 3yearstoadopt
- Legislation- $500for1st offense,
$1000for2nd andsub- 12-monthlookback
periodforenhancement- Holdshostandlandlords
accountable- Cangivewarning,but
don’thaveto- Affirmativedefense
*loseifyouhave3ormoreoffensesin12months
Step9:EnsurePolicyEnforcement
§ Analyze potentialbarrierstoenforcementafterpolicyispassed
§ Collaborate withlawenforcementtodeveloppotentialsolutionstobarriersinordertoensurethatthepolicywillbeimplementedandenforcedafterpassage
§ Determine waystobolsterenforcementeffortswithCollaborativeandcommunitysupport
Step9:EnsurePolicyAdoptionBaltimore City+++ BaltimoreCounty+++ PrincessAnne+++
- Engagedenforcementearly,investedtoenforce
- Multiplemeetingswithenforcementtodiscussimplementationstrategy
- Trackingappealsthroughcourts
- Engagedenforcementearly,investedtoenforce
- Heldmeetingswithprecinctcaptainstodiscussimplementation
- Createdspreadsheettohelptrackcases
- Reportquarterly
- Engagedenforcementearly,investedtoenforce
- Meetingsneedtobeheldtodiscusstrackingcases- Justwentinto
effectrecently
Step10:Evaluation
§ Evaluatecampaigneffectiveness§ Passageofpolicy§ Implementation&enforcementofpolicy§ Collaborativecohesiveness&momentumforfuturepolicywork
§ Changeinnorms&communitydiscussionaboutalcohol-relatedproblems
§ Foundationbuiltforadditionalalcoholpolicies
Step10:EvaluationBaltimore City+++ BaltimoreCounty PrincessAnne
40citationsissuedfirst7months
24%reductionincallsforservice
Anecdotalevidencefromcommunitymembers
TBD
Mustproveeffectivetokeepordinance
TBD
LessonsLearned• Dataarekey,butonlyfootinthedoor• Musthavecommunitysupport,multiplestakeholders• University,parents,schools,lawenforcement,churches,neighborhoodassociations,etc.
• Alliesandoppositionchange• Relationships,relationships,relationships• Luck=Preparation+opportunity
• Flexibleandcreative• Lastmanstanding
Barriers• Accesstolegalexpertiseandtechnicaladvisor• Policyadoptionexperience• Relationshipswithcommunity,enforcement,etc.• Politicalwill• City/Countyleadership,enforcement,etc.
• Powerfulinterests• Landlords,propertyowners
ElPasoSHO
Thankyou!
www.marylandcollaborative.org