The Low Energy Photon Tagger...

32
1 / 16 Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with Real Photons ☻Diego Semmler, Thomas Aumann, Christopher Bauer, Martin Baumann, Michael Beckstein, Jacob Beller, Alexander Blecher, Nebojsa Cvejin, Marc Duchene, Florian Hug, Julian Kahlbow, Michael Knörzer, Kathrin Kreis, Christoph Kremer, Ronan Lefol, Bastian Löher, Philipp Ries, Christopher Romig, Heiko Scheit, Linda Schnorrenberger, Dmytro Symochko, Christopher Walz

Transcript of The Low Energy Photon Tagger...

Page 1: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

1 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUN:

Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with Real Photons

☻Diego Semmler, Thomas Aumann, Christopher Bauer, Martin Baumann,Michael Beckstein, Jacob Beller, Alexander Blecher, Nebojsa Cvejin,

Marc Duchene, Florian Hug, Julian Kahlbow, Michael Knörzer, Kathrin Kreis, Christoph Kremer, Ronan Lefol, Bastian Löher, Philipp Ries, Christopher Romig,

Heiko Scheit, Linda Schnorrenberger, Dmytro Symochko, Christopher Walz

Page 2: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

2 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Outline● The Pygmy Dipole Resonance (Motivation)● Overview About The Full Project

– γ³ @ HIγs

– CoulEx (R³B @ GSI)

– (α,α') @ RIKEN● NEPTUN @ S-DALINAC

– The Principle of Photon Tagging

– NEPTUN Setup

– Results from the Last Beam Time

Page 3: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

3 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

The Pygmy Dipole Resonance

Two phonon excitation

Pygmy Resonance?

Giant dipole resonance

● Nature of the pygmy dipole resonance still unknown● Addresses the understanding of the strong force● Important also for astrophysical questions

➔ e.g. supernova models, isotope abundances

Graphic from Andreas Zilges: E1 excitations in atomic nuclei

Page 4: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

4 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

The Pygmy Dipole Resonance

● The pygmy dipole resonance is hard to measure● Lot of weak states

➔ Not to distinguish from background● Measurements below and above neutron threshold required

Graphic from J. Endres et al.: PRL 105, 212503 (2010)Isotope: 124Sn

Page 5: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

5 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Experiments below and above Sn

Graphic from Linda Schnorrenberger

A-1X

En

AX

Sn

Eγ‘

Eγ • excitation energy

• γ decay

• n emission

PDR ● NEPTUN is able to mea-sure below and above neutron separation energy S

n

● Unique ability● Measure the

complete pygmy dipole resonance

Page 6: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

6 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Overview About The Full Project

Page 7: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

7 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

γ³ @ HIγsHPGe 135° 0°, 90°

LaBr Large 90° 45°

LaBr Small 35° 0°, 90°

Graphics from B. Löher at al.:Nucl. Instr. Meth. Phys. Res. A 723 (2013) 136

● Determination of➔ Parities with HPGe➔ Branching ratios with all

detectors in coincidence➔ Reduced transition

probabilities with HPGe● Shieldings and filters (Pb, Cu)

Page 8: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

8 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

γ³ @ HIγs

Energy (keV)

Asy

mm

etry

Identified 188 g.s. transitions between 5.1 and 8.6 MeV.91 g.s. transitions were not published before.Determined Jπ: 177 with 1-, 7 with 1(-), 1 with 1(+), 3 with 1.

Master thesis of Marc Duchêne

Page 9: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

9 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

CoulEx (R³B @ GSI)

PhD thesis of Philipp Schrock (data under analysis)

Detection:n: LAND

(Fe converter + organic scintillator)

Charged fragments:TFW (scintillation detector)

γ: Crystal Ball (CsI-detectors array)

Isotopes: 124Sn, 126Sn, 128Sn, 130Sn, 132Sn

Page 10: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

10 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Photon Tagging

● Photons are produced by electrons emitting bremsstrahlung● Idea: determine energy of electron to deduce photon energy

● Conservation of energy:

● Eγ = E

0 - E

e

● tagging via time relation

Slide from Linda Schnorrenberger

Page 11: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

11 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

electrons

scattered electrons

photons

NEPTUN Setup

Picture from Linda Schnorrenberger

● Measure the momentum of the electrons with scintillating fibers– Resolution:

1 mm ≈ 25 keV● Electron target:

Gold foil– 4,8 µm to 20 µm

● γ target:– 112Sn, 116Sn, 120Sn,

124Sn planed– S used as test for

commissioning

^

Page 12: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

12 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

NEPTUN Setup

Graphic from Christopher Walz

● Detect scattered gammas with the GALATEA LaBr array● For calibrating we also use a HPGe

detector● Detect neutrons with organic scintillators

– Not implemented, yet– Test planned for next beam time

Page 13: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

13 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Sulfur Peak in HPGe

● Energy resolution: 1.2 keV● Time resolution: 9 ns● Number of events:

– 52 ± 7 events in energy peak– 66 ± 14 events in a 3σ environment of time

● Significance: 3.2σ (Statistical hint)

Page 14: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

14 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Sulfur Peak in LaBr

● Worse energy resolution: 79 keV● Better time resolution: 2.8 ns● More events but also higher background:

– 643 ± 209 events in a 3σ environment of energy– 571 ± 19 events in a 3σ environment of time

● Same significance: > 3σ (We had problems with the calibration)

Page 15: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

15 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Conclusion● Using tin isotopes we will provide the pygmy strength over a

large A/Z range from 2.24 to 2.64● Data combined from 4 facilities● 124Sn used as benchmark in all experiments● Will hopefully lead to a better understanding of the pygmy

dipole resonance

Experiment Facility Status Isotopes

γ³ HIγs In analysis 124Sn only

CoulEx R³B @ GSI In commissioning Radioac. Beams

(α,α') RIKEN To be done in October

Radioactive Beams

NEPTUN S-DALINAC Commissioning in October

Stable Isotopes only

Page 16: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

16 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Thanks to my collaborators: Thomas Aumann, Christopher Bauer, Martin Baumann,Michael Beckstein, Jacob Beller, Alexander Blecher, Nebojsa Cvejin,Marc Duchene, Florian Hug, Julian Kahlbow, Michael Knörzer, Kathrin Kreis,

Christoph Kremer, Ronan Lefol, Bastian Löher, Philipp Ries, Christopher Romig, Heiko Scheit, Linda Schnorrenberger, Dmytro Symochko, Christopher Walz

Page 17: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

17 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Page 18: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

18 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Extra Slides

● Start

● The Pygmy Dipole Resonance

● Experiments below and above Sn

● Overview about the full project

● Photon Tagging

● NEPTUN Setup

● Sulfur Peak in HPGe

● Sulfur Peak in LaBr

● Conclusion

● Background Sources

● Problems

● Outlook to Beam Time in 2014

● NEPTUN - Facility

● Background Sources

Page 19: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

19 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Background Sources

1,93 / nC 31%

1,02 / nC 16%

3,33 / nC 53%

Sulfur targete- beamdumpWall and Collimator

Page 20: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

20 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Problems

● Fiber rates are partially higher than expected– Probably due scattering of electrons in the magnet

● Still much background– May be less with new tungsten collimator

– Gamma-beam-dump wanted

– Neutron shield for e- beam-dump

● Lot of things to do until next beam time

Page 21: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

21 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Outlook to Beam Time in 2014

● Switch to Digital DAQ● Readout Fibers Individually● Carbon Fiber Beam Pipe● Gamma Beam Dump● Improve shielding● More Probes● Gamma Monitor● Automatic Picture Taking● And many small changes

Page 22: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

22 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Outlook to Beam Time in 2014

● Better time resolutionσ = 1.2 ns instead of5.4 ns

● Factor 4.5 less Background

● Energy readout possible

● Switch to Digital DAQ● Readout Fibers Individually● Carbon Fiber Beam Pipe● Gamma Beam Dump● Improve shielding● More Probes● Gamma Monitor● Automatic Picture Taking● And many small changes

Data

Filter (done on FPGA)

Digital Data

Page 23: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

23 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Outlook to Beam Time in 2014

● Distinguish between interesting and scattered electrons

● Hope to remove up to an other factor 2 background

Interesting e-

Scattered e-

● Switch to Digital DAQ● Readout Fibers Individually● Carbon Fiber Beam Pipe● Gamma Beam Dump● Improve shielding● More Probes● Gamma Monitor● Automatic Picture Taking● And many small changes

Page 24: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

24 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Outlook to Beam Time in 2014

● High transparency– For gammas– and for neutrons

● Low Z materials (Z ≤ 6)● Only 1.2 mm thickness● Stability against air

pressure

Photo goes here

● Switch to Digital DAQ● Readout Fibers Individually● Carbon Fiber Beam Pipe● Gamma Beam Dump● Improve shielding● More Probes● Gamma Monitor● Automatic Picture Taking● And many small changes

Page 25: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

25 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Outlook to Beam Time in 2014

● Avoid backscattering● Made from borated

Polyethylene to absorb neutrons

● Lead cover to absorb gammas

● Gamma monitor included

● Switch to Digital DAQ● Readout Fibers Individually● Carbon Fiber Beam Pipe● Gamma Beam Dump● Improve shielding● More Probes● Gamma Monitor● Automatic Picture Taking● And many small changes

Page 26: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

26 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Outlook to Beam Time in 2014

● Cares about the biggest part of the background

● Several changes needed:– Polyethylene at the

gamma beam pipe and the electron beam dump to absorb neutrons

– Stuffed holes in the wall– Optimized the position

of the concrete blocks● Too less beam time to

evaluate all changes individually

● Switch to Digital DAQ● Readout Fibers Individually● Carbon Fiber Beam Pipe● Gamma Beam Dump● Improve shielding● More Probes● Gamma Monitor● Automatic Picture Taking● And many small changes

Page 27: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

27 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Outlook to Beam Time in 2014

● Hall probe– Foreseen from the

beginning– Monitor magnetic field– Changes of ‰ will

affect resolution dramatically

● Temperature probe– Will add the chance to

debug for temperature dependencies

● Switch to Digital DAQ● Readout Fibers Individually● Carbon Fiber Beam Pipe● Gamma Beam Dump● Improve shielding● More Probes● Gamma Monitor● Automatic Picture Taking● And many small changes

Page 28: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

28 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Outlook to Beam Time in 2014

● Provides a 2D image from gamma beam

● Used to debug beam

Photo goes here

● Switch to Digital DAQ● Readout Fibers Individually● Carbon Fiber Beam Pipe● Gamma Beam Dump● Improve shielding● More Probes● Gamma Monitor● Automatic Picture Taking● And many small changes

Page 29: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

29 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Outlook to Beam Time in 2014

● Raspberry Pi camera● Takes a picture from the

setup at each run● Excludes human failure in

protocoling

Photo goes here

● Switch to Digital DAQ● Readout Fibers Individually● Carbon Fiber Beam Pipe● Gamma Beam Dump● Improve shielding● More Probes● Gamma Monitor● Automatic Picture Taking● And many small changes

Page 30: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

30 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Outlook to Beam Time in 2014

● Switch to Digital DAQ● Readout Fibers Individually● Carbon Fiber Beam Pipe● Gamma Beam Dump● Improve shielding● More Probes● Gamma Monitor● Automatic Picture Taking● And many small changes

Page 31: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

31 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

NEPTUN Facility

Slide from Linda Schnorrenberger

Page 32: The Low Energy Photon Tagger NEPTUNcrunch.ikp.physik.tu-darmstadt.de/erice/2014/sec/talks/thursday/semmler.pdfTagger NEPTUN: Toward a Detailed Study of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance with

32 / 16Diego Semmler · TU Darmstadt

Background Sources

Test Difference Cmp Run Run

Air in the beam pipe 18.76% ± 0.91% 28 29

Lead between beam pipe and detector and table 13.64% ± 1.10% 28 30

More lead between beam pipe and table -12.02% ± 0.72% 30 31

PE shielding closer to the beam pipe -3.00% ± 0.53% 31 33

Lead stones in front of HPGe -7.10% ± 1.47% 33 34

Wrapped lead instead of wall -28.64% ± 2.18% 33 37

Added lead wall in front and on top of the detector -51.76% ± 2.65% 37 39

HPGe threshold changed from 1,1 to 2,2 at discriminator

14.05% ± 2.23% 58 50

Without Sulfur Target -18.84% ± 0.92% 56 54

With air in the gamma beam pipe 3.69% ± 0.59% 56 55

Full target 10 µm -4.02% ± 0.57% 56 61 & 63

Full target 1 µm -18.73% ± 0.76% 56 62

PET at opposite wall -5.70% ± 0.81% 56 64

PET bricks on the top of lead shielding of HPGe -12.59% ± 1.05% 64 65