THE LOI EVIN :

29
1 THE LOI EVIN : A FRENCH EXCEPTION

description

THE LOI EVIN :. A FRENCH EXCEPTION. What is « loi Evin ». An alcohol and tobacco policy law voted in France in 1991. What is « loi Evin ». One of the most severe law on advertising in Europe In a country where « passion » for alcohol is hot In a country where alcohol control is often low - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of THE LOI EVIN :

Page 1: THE LOI EVIN :

1

THE LOI EVIN :

A FRENCH EXCEPTION

Page 2: THE LOI EVIN :

2

What is « loi Evin »

• An alcohol and tobacco policy law voted in France in 1991

Page 3: THE LOI EVIN :

3

What is « loi Evin »

• One of the most severe law on advertising in Europe

• In a country where « passion » for alcohol is hot

• In a country where alcohol control is often low

• How can we explain this real French paradox ?

Page 4: THE LOI EVIN :

4

Why this law ?

• Former French law (in the seventies) was discriminating : it gave advantage to French products

• France was condemned in 1979 by the European Court of Justice

• But French governments took time to change the law

Page 5: THE LOI EVIN :

5

A Decade of French advertising

From 1980 to 1990 alcohol producers used this legal gap

The ad became more and more provocative

Page 6: THE LOI EVIN :

6

Sexe, alcohol and French life

• Alcohol and sexe • Alcohol and sport

Page 7: THE LOI EVIN :

7

Help! What does the police ?

• Ignoring their own codes of good practices the ad men and producers went high in provocation and played with fire.

• The only way to stop these ads was to legislate

• ANPA and health experts lobbied until

• Loi Evin was voted by the French parliament

Page 8: THE LOI EVIN :

8

Articles of Loi Evin on alcohol

• Definition of alcoholic drinks

• Nature of advertising authorized

• Content of advertising

• Others topics : i e alcohol selling automate are forbidden

Page 9: THE LOI EVIN :

9

1. Definition of drinks

• The law gives a clear definition of alcoholics drinks :

• All drinks over 1,2 % alcohol

Page 10: THE LOI EVIN :

10

2. Places and media of authorized advertising

• Advertising is forbidden

- when targeted to young people

- on TV and cinema

• No sponsorship is authorised

Page 11: THE LOI EVIN :

11

3. Within these media

•Messages and images should refer only to the qualities of the products : it allows to give information on the products as the producers ask

•A health message must be included : « L’abus d’alcool est dangereux pour la santé » Alcohol abuse is dangerous for health

Page 12: THE LOI EVIN :

12

Consequences of the law 1991-2004

• Illegal advertising have been condemned

• Since 1991 : - 20 advertisements were brought to the Court by ANPA

- And 18 were condemned

Page 13: THE LOI EVIN :

13

Consequences of the law 1991-2004

• Penalties are high

• So alcohol producers, media and admen became more careful

• And advertising has lost most of its seductive character

Page 14: THE LOI EVIN :

14

Changes in advertising

• Before the law • After the law

Page 15: THE LOI EVIN :

15

These ads were judged illegal in France in 2004 !

Page 16: THE LOI EVIN :

16

Consequences on Media and Sports

• Cancellation of international football matches

• American brewer Anheuser Bush could not sponsor the 1998 Football World Cup

• And France won the Cup for the first time

Page 17: THE LOI EVIN :

17

What are the limits of the law ?

• Many marketing tools are not controlled

• Mailing• Internet• Social events

• Control of advertising is only a part of an overall strategy of prevention

Page 18: THE LOI EVIN :

18

A law difficult to assess

• Difficult to assess the role of one factor (here advertising) on consumption and harm

• The effect of advertising on consumption is weak

Page 19: THE LOI EVIN :

19

A law difficult to assess

• Assessment is more difficult in the French situation where we benefit of a dramatic diminution of the average consumption

- since 1960

- 1 % per year

- from 30 to 13 litres alcohol per capita per year

Page 20: THE LOI EVIN :

20

A law difficult to assess

• Quantitative effects may be impossible to assess…

• … but symbolic effects are visible

Page 21: THE LOI EVIN :

21

The symbolic effect of the law

• Advertising reinforces preconceived ideas about alcohol

• In most European countries advertising associates alcohol consumption with personal, sexual and social success… even if it forbidden by codes of practice

• A law is the only way to change this seductive language

Page 22: THE LOI EVIN :

22

European ads

Page 23: THE LOI EVIN :

23

Where have the French images gone ?

• Authorized ad in • Illegal ad in France

Page 24: THE LOI EVIN :

24

The need for a European legislative framework

• Development of multinationals

• Products and images cross frontiers

• Internationalization of life styles and drinking cultures

Page 25: THE LOI EVIN :

25

A law that cannot be ignored

• The law has been attacked in and outside France

• Very recently…

while the law has been attacked by the French wine producers…

it has been defended by the Advocate General of the European Court of Justice

Page 26: THE LOI EVIN :

26

The Advocate General proposes that the Court should rule that

• French measures on advertising limit the consumption

• French rules are not disproportionate

• The French law allows the freedom to provides services enshrined in the Treaty

Page 27: THE LOI EVIN :

27

We hope that the law is here to stay because this text

• is easy to apply• is difficult to distort• has modified the seductive language of

advertising • is compatible with European legislation

• This is no real surprise as the law was a response to the 1979 European Court decision

Page 28: THE LOI EVIN :

28

We hope that the spirit of the law could be applied in Europe

• Minimal measures compatible with subsidiarity

• In order to protect the younger generations

Page 29: THE LOI EVIN :

29

We propose for instance inside the European Union to

• Forbid all forms of marketing using sport events

• Forbid advertising on television