8/2/2019 The Israeli Diaspora as a Catalyst for Jewish Peoplehood

1/36

V`e Bx|neib Fbnx{d|n nx n Hnvnirxv

ad| Je}bx` [ed{ie`ddf

Nc Ege|mbcm D{{d|vucbvr }bv`bc v`e H`ncmbcm

\einvbdcx`b{ lev}eec Bx|nei ncf v`e Je}bx` }d|if

Hdche{vuni A|nge}d|o

Nfn| 5==8V`e h`ncmbcm |enibvr qbx''qbx v`e Bx|neib Fbnx{d|n ##############################################>5

H`n{ve| 8: V`e d{{d|vucbvr: V`e Bx|neib Fbnx{d|n nx n hnvnirxv ad| [ed{ie`ddf ## >0Ege|meche da nc Bx|neib Xdhbni X{nhe##################################################################### >0]`nv bx v`bx Bx|neib Xdhbni X{nhe4########################################################################### V`e ege|meche da v`e Cd|v` Nge|bhnc Je}bx` Xnl|n ##########################################

8/2/2019 The Israeli Diaspora as a Catalyst for Jewish Peoplehood

3/36

"# Mbfb bx v`e aducfe|

daRexdfdv M|du{ ad| |ead|gbcm Bx|neib Mdqe|cnche? n gegle| daOdi'Fd| M|du{ ad|

midlni Je}bx` [ed{ie`ddf? }nx n gegle| da ,Bx|nei

8/2/2019 The Israeli Diaspora as a Catalyst for Jewish Peoplehood

4/36

8

Gn|h` ># Lr qb|vue da v`bx v|b'fecvbvr) v`e -C#N# Je}bx` Xnl|n- bx nlie vd ieqe|nme v`eucb~ue nffef qniue da enh` da v`e v`|ee bfecvbvbex) nx }eii nx {inr n |die bcl|bcmbcm nii hd|ce|x da v`e Bx|neib Fbnx{d|n bcvd hdcqe|xnvbdc }bv` dce

ncdv`e|) v`ux xe|qbcm nx n hnvnirxv vd}n|f Je}bx` [ed{ie`ddf#

Lubifbcm ncf xu{{d|vbcm v`|bqbcm Bx|neib Fbnx{d|n hdggucbvbex

>8# V`e bg{d|vnche da n v`|bqbcm Bx|neib Fbnx{d|n hdggucbvr ibex bc bvx nlbibvr vducfe|xvncf ncf |ex{dcf vd v`e ceefx ncf h`niiecmex da bvx gegle|x# V`bx|e~ub|ex n xbmcbabhncv eaad|v dc v`e {n|v da v`|ee oer {inre|x ' v`e Mdqe|cgecvda Bx|nei) v`e idhni Je}bx` hdggucbvbex ncf v`e C#N# Je}bx` Xnl|n#

V`e |die da v`e Mdqe|cgecv da Bx|nei

>6# Bc nc eaad|v vd lubif v`|bqbcm Bx|neib hdggucbvbex) v`e Mdqe|cgecv da Bx|nei)x`duif ucfe|vnoe vd ecmnme Bx|neibx ibqbcm nl|dnf nx n qbnlie Fbnx{d|n |nv`e|

v`nc n gd|ni ibnlbibvr#

>5# V`bx eaad|v vd ecmnme Bx|neibx ibqbcm nl|dnf |e~ub|ex hd`exbqe mdqe|cgecv{dibhr# Hu||ecvir) v`e|e n|e n cugle| da mdqe|cgecv fe{n|vgecvx v`nv xe|qe

Bx|neibx ibqbcm nl|dnf) enh` }d|obcm nhhd|fbcm vd bvx d}c bcve|cni d|mncbzbcm

idmbh# N hdd|fbcnvef n{{|dnh` bcqdiqbcm v`e |eieqncv mdqe|cgecv ldfbex }bii

ecxu|e gnpbgug eaaehvbqecexx ncf bx bg{d|vncv bc nqdbfbcm gbpef'gexxnmex#

>1# N v`d|dum` eqniunvbdc da {dibhbex v`nv {dxe `u|fiex vd n xv|dcm ncfeg{d}e|ef |einvbdcx`b{ lev}eec Bx|nei ncf Bx|neibx ibqbcm nl|dnf bx |e~ub|ef#V`exe {dibhbex bchiufe (ngdcm dv`e|x":

8/2/2019 The Israeli Diaspora as a Catalyst for Jewish Peoplehood

8/36

=

Gn|h` >#

Nx n hdcxe~ueche da v`e nldqe) }e `nqe xeec n cugle| da bfedidmbhni)hdche{vuni ncf {|nhvbhni feqeid{gecvx v`nv `nqe nive|ef v`e |einvbdcx`b{#Hinxxbhni Zbdcbxg bx gd|{`bcm bcvd n ce}

xvhecvu|r Zbdcbxg) }`bh`

bchiufex v`e hdche{v da [ed{ie`ddf) ncf qbe}x v`e gbxxbdc da Bx|nei bc nl|dnfe|) gd|e cunchef hdcvepv da v`e Je}bx` {ed{ie#

>8# V`e nldqe fbxhuxxbdc bcfbhnvex v`nv v`e Je}bx`}d|if bx v|ncxbvbdcbcm a|dg |einvbdcx`b{x

hecve|ef dc bcxvbvuvbdcx vd |einvbdcx`b{xadhuxef n|ducf bxxuex d| bfenx# Bc v`bx hdcvepv)v`e|e n|e xbp gnjd| bxxuex v`nv }bii hn{vu|e v`e

luio da nvvecvbdc) ece|mr ncf |exdu|hex da v`e

Je}bx` }d|if bc v`e hdgbcm fehnfex# Enh` bxxue

bx exxecvbni ad| v`e xehu|bvr ncf {|dx{e|bvr dadu| {ed{ie# V`exe bxxuex bchiufe: (>" lubifbcm n

midlni cev}d|o da {|dx{e|dux ncf |exbibecv

Je}bx` hdggucbvbex? (

8/2/2019 The Israeli Diaspora as a Catalyst for Jewish Peoplehood

13/36

5# V`e Je}bx` }d|if bx hdg{|bxef da n guivbvufe da -Je}bx`ir- fbxvbchv m|du{x)}`bh` gnr fbaae| a|dg dce ncdv`e| lnxef dc medm|n{`r) incmunme) huivu|e d|dv`e| {n|ngeve|x# V`e cepv h`n{ve| }bii adhux dc v`e hnxe da v`e Bx|neib Fbnx{d|nbc Cd|v` Nge|bhn) bc v`e hdcvepv da v`e h`ncmbcm {n|nfbmg lev}eec Bx|nei ncf v`e

Je}bx` }d|if ncf v`e x`bav vd}n|fx Je}bx` [ed{ie`ddf#

8/2/2019 The Israeli Diaspora as a Catalyst for Jewish Peoplehood

14/36

8

Gn|h` 55? \elehhn X{eche)-]ncvbcm vd Hdccehv: Bx|neibx Abcf \eibmbdc-)V`e Je}bx` Fnbir Ad|}n|f) N{|bi 2) ) {#8? Fnqbf Rnn|b bc n {|execvnvbdc nv v`e Fd| H`nfnx` Ldn|f

\ev|env)

8/2/2019 The Israeli Diaspora as a Catalyst for Jewish Peoplehood

16/36

5

Gn|h` 2#

\euvx |exen|h` `nx x`d}c v`nv xbmcbabhncv v|ecfx vnobcm {inhe bc v`e Je}bx`}d|if `nqe e|dfef gncr da v`e nldqe nxxug{vbdcx ncf {nvve|cx da le`nqbd|)ncf {d}e|aui ce} v|ecfx n|e bch|enxbcmir vnobcm v`eb| {inhe#

2

;

vd ibae da aiubf gdqegecv V`e fbh`dvdgdux|einvbdcx`b{ lev}eec nibrn` ncfre|bfn bx h`ncmbcm: nc bch|enxbcm cugle| da

Bx|neibx n|e h`ddxbcm vd lubif n ibae bc gd|e v`nc dce Je}bx` hdggucbvr)

xdgevbgex eqec `difbcm `dgex ncf luxbcexxex bc gd|e v`nc dce hdggucbvr

xbguivnceduxir?>8

Bx|neibx n|e bch|enxbcmir xeeobcm vd le {n|v da v`e Je}bx` hdggucbvr ]`e|enx bc v`e {nxv gdxv Bx|neibx aeiv nibecnvef lr Je}bx` bcxvbvuvbdcx) |ehecvren|x `nqe xeec n xu|me bc v`e cugle| da Bx|neibx }`d nvvecf xrcnmdmuex)

xecf v`eb| h`bif|ec vd Je}bx` fnr xh`ddix d| eqec xbv dc v`e ldn|f da idhni

JHHx# Nx gncr Bx|neib bggbm|ncvx {uv bv) }e n|e nc bcvem|ni {n|v da v`e

Je}bx` hdggucbvr `e|e?>6

2 \euv Bcxvbvuve) -N ce} |einvbdcx`b{ lev}eec Bx|nei ncf v`e Je}bx` }d|if#

>; Hd`ec ncf Qebcxvebc) -Bx|neib Je}x bc M|enve| Ce} Rd|o#-

>> V`e ve|g -re|bfn- (ibve|niir) fexhecfbcm" |eae|x vd v`e egbm|nvbdc a|dg Bx|nei#

>) >#

>8 Xng M|eecle|m)-CR Bx|neibx `nqe `bm` ieqei da Je}bx` bcqdiqegecv)-Je|uxnieg [dxv Dcibce) Gnr

8)

8/2/2019 The Israeli Diaspora as a Catalyst for Jewish Peoplehood

17/36

1

Gn|h` 0

v`e >xv Hdcae|eche ad| Bx|neibx Ibqbcm Nl|dnf) ]d|if Hduchbi da Bx|neibx Nl|dnf) Vd|dcvd)

Hncnfn? Jncun|r >0'# Fnqbf Rnn|b) aducfe| da Fd| H`nfnx` Ce} Rd|o) fexh|blef n v|ecf

ngdcm Bx|neibx ibqbcm bc Ce} Rd|o) nmef lev}eec 5 Xee: ) BIH? BHH? V`e|e n|e n cugle| da dv`e| d|mncbznvbdcx v`nv xu{{d|v v`bx v|ecf) bchiufbcm: Fd|

H`nfnx` Ce} Rd|o)Lbcn bc Idx Ncmeiex)Vn|luvdc Xnc FbemdRbx|neibco H`bhnmd) ncfBx|neibx bc

L|ddoirc#

>1 Fdlce|) -V|ncxad|gnvbdc da Bfecvbvr#-

>= Hd`ec ncf Qebcxvebc) -Bx|neib Je}x bc M|enve| Ce} Rd|o)- {{#58'51? Fdlce|) -V|ncxad|gnvbdc da

Bfecvbvr#-

>0 Mdif) V`e Bx|neib Fbnx{d|n) {{# >62'>5

8/2/2019 The Israeli Diaspora as a Catalyst for Jewish Peoplehood

18/36

=

Gn|h`