The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung,...
Transcript of The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung,...
![Page 1: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1
Geophysical Research Letters
Supporting Information for
TheimportanceofENSOphaseduringvolcaniceruptionsfordetectionandattribution
Flavio Lehner1, Andrew P. Schurer2, Gabriele C. Hegerl2, Clara Deser1, and Thomas L. Frölicher3
1ClimateAnalysisSection,NationalCenterforAtmosphericResearch,Boulder,USA2School of Geosciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
3Environmental Physics, Institute of Biogeochemistry and Pollutant Dynamics, ETH Zürich, Switzerland
Content
1 CoincidenceofvolcaniceruptionsandElNiñoeventsinpaleoclimaterecords2 Alternativeobservationaldatasets(FigureS1)3 Detectionandattributionextendedfigure(FigureS2)4 Detectionandattributionsensitivityanalysis(FigureS3andS4)5 Uncertaintyrangesandcontrolsubsampling(FigureS5)6 ResultswithGFDLmodels(FigureS6)7 AdditionalfigureforCESM1‘Pacemaker’simulations(FigureS7)8 AdditionalfigureincludingtheSantaMariaeruptionin1902(FigureS8)9 Tablesonmodels,simulations,andsubsampling(TablesS1,S2,S3)
![Page 2: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
1CoincidenceofvolcaniceruptionsandElNiñoeventsinpaleoclimaterecordsReconstructions of volcanism (Crowley and Unterman 2013) and ENSO (Li et al. 2013)suggestthatthecoincidenceofElNiñoeventswiththreeconsecutivevolcaniceruptionsofthe sameor greatermagnitude asAgunghas not occurred in at least the past 700 years.ThiswastestedbysearchingforcoincidencesoferuptionsandElNiñoeventsinthesameorfollowingyear.
2Alternativeobservationaldatasets
FigureS1:Globalmeansurfacetemperature(GMST)anomalyrelativetothemeanofthe5years preceding the eruption start date (dashed vertical line) averaged over the threerecent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observationaldatasets.Timeserieshavebeensmoothedwithatriangular1-2-1filterforvisualpurposesonly.
![Page 3: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
3DetectionandattributionextendedfigureFigureS2isanextentionofFigure3ofthemainpaper.FigureS2bandS2dareidenticaltoFigure3aand3b.
FigureS2: Estimated contribution by natural (green) and anthropogenic (red) forcing toglobalmean surface temperature anomaliesusing (a,b) all CMIP5 simulations and (c,d)only thosesimulationswith theobservedENSOphase. Bold linesaremulti-modelmeansmultiplied by the best-fit scaling factor. This scaling factor is also plotted as a thickhorizontal line in (b) and (d). The shading shows the models multiplied by the 5-95%uncertainty range as plotted by the bar in (b) and (d). Dashed line shows the unscaledmodelresults(‘historicalNat’only).Anomaliesaretakenfromthemeanofthewholeperiod(a)orthemeanofeachsegment(c).Theverticaldashedlinesindicatetheeruptiondatesofthethreemajorvolcanoes.Timeserieshavebeensmoothedwithatriangular1-2-1filterforvisualpurposesonly.
![Page 4: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
4DetectionandattributionsensitivityanalysisAseriesofanalyseswerecarriedouttotestthesensitivityoftheresultsshowninFigure3andFigureS2tothedifferentanalysissteps.FiguresS3aandS3fshowthebestfitscalingfactorfortheunsampled,continoustimeseriesas also shown in Figure 3a and3b in themain paper. They show that the anthropogenicforcingisdetectable(valuesalwayssignificantlygreaterthanzero)andconsistentwiththeobservations(uncertaintyrangeencompassingone),whilethenaturalforcingisdetectablebut has a stronger response in models than in the observations (uncertainty rangesignificantlylessthanzero).Forthefinalsubsampledanalysis(FigureS3eandS3j;Figure3aand3binthemainpaper,respectively)thenumberofmodelsimulationsusedtoformthemulti-modelmeanandthenused in the regression analysis, was limited to 35 ‘historical’ simulations and 13‘historicalNat’simulations.Totesttheeffectofrestrictingthenumberofmodels,FigureS3bandS3g show the rangeof scaling factors for100 randomcombinationsof 35 ‘historical’and13 ‘historicalNat’simulations(withoutsplittingthetimeseries intosegmentsyet).Asexpected, the ranges of the scaling factors show some sensitivity to the subset ofmodelschosen,yet themainconclusionsareunchangedfromthefullsetofsimulations(compareFigureS3btoS3aandFigureS3gtoS3f).In the final sub-sampled analysis, the GMST time series is split into three equal-lengthsegments.Theeffectofthisontheresultsfor35randomlyselected‘historical’simulationsand13randomlyselected ‘historicalNat’ simulations is shown inFigureS3candS3h.Thebest-fit anthropogenic scaling factors increase slightlywhen the time series are split intothreesegments,likelyduetotheshorteningofthetimeseries.Takinganomaliesoverthreeshortsegmentsinsteadoftheentiretimeperioddecreasestheimportanceoftheendpointsintheregressionanalysis,inparticulariftheregressionslopehasacontinuoustrend,asisthecasefortheanthropogenically forcedresponse.Foragivensegment, thisalsoreducesthe signal-to-noise ratio andwith that the sensitivity to the choice of randomly selectedmodels. This results in a slightly noisier uncertainty range in Figure S3c and S3h.Importantlyforthemainconclusionsofthestudy,thescalingfactorsforthenaturalforcingresponseremainunchanged(compareFigureS3gandS3h).ThefinalsensitivitytestaddressesthesubsamplingofthemodelstoselectonlythosewithanElNiñoeventintheborealwinteraftereachofthelargevolcaniceruptions.TheresultsareshowninFigureS3dandS3ifor100differentrandomcombinationsofthesubsampledmodels(again,foreachofthe100randommodelcombinationswepick35from‘historical’and13 from ‘historicalNat’).Thebest-fitanthropogenicscaling factorsareverysimilarastheones fromthefullsetofmodelsimulations(compareFigureS3dtoS3c).There is lessdependence on the choice of model, i.e., the uncertainty range is less noisy, in thesesubsampled results because there are generally fewermodels to choose from due to the
![Page 5: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
ENSOphasesubsamplingcriteria.Thescaling factors for thenatural forcingareshown inFigure S3i, in which, crucially, the scaling factor range now always encompasses one,regardlessofmodelselection,whileifthemodelsarenotsub-sampled(FigureS3f,g,h)theuncertainty range is always significantly less than one. This demonstrates that ourconclusionsarenotaconsequenceofthemodelselection.One finalconcernregarding themodelselection is the largenumberofsimulations in theCMIP5 archive from one particularmodel family, namely theNASAGoddard Institute forSpace Studies (GISS) models: 45 out of 198 ‘historical’ simulations and 20 out of 68‘historicalNat’simulationsarefromGISS-E2-H-CC,GISS-E2,GISS-E2-R-CC,orGISS-E2-R.Wererantheanalysis inFigureS3ontheCMIP5archiveexcludingallGISSmodelsandfoundnot discernable difference to the results using all CMIP5models (compare Figure S3 andS4).Theresultspresented in themainpartof thepaperare thecombinationofall thescalingfactorscalculated foreachof the100modelcombinationswhichareshowninFigureS3dandS3i.ThesecombinedrangesareshowninFigureS3eandS3j.
FigureS3:Scalingfactors fortheresponsetoanthropogenicandnatural forcings.(a)and(f) are based on the continuous timeseries from the unsampled multi-model meanensembles;(b) and(g) arebasedon100different combinationsof35 randomly selected‘historical’ and 13 ‘historicalNat’ simulations; (c) and (h) are based on 100 differentcombinations of 35 randomly selected ‘historical’ and 13 ‘historicalNat’ simulations splitintothreesegments;(d)and(i)arebasedonthesamecriteriaas(c)and(h)butrestricted
![Page 6: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
to those simulationswhich fulfill the ENSO phase selection criteria. (e) and (j) show thecombinedresults forallmodelcombinationsshownin(d)and(i).Colorshadingindicatesthe5-95%range,andthesolidcurvesshowthebest-fitscalingfactor.
FigureS4:SameasFigureS3,butexcludingallGISSmodels.
![Page 7: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
5UncertaintyrangesandcontrolsubsamplingTo calculate the uncertainty range for the scaling factors, internal variability samples areadded to the noise-reduced fingerprints (themulti-model mean from the ‘historical’ and‘historicalNat’ simulations) and observations. For each combination of internal variabilitysamplesascaling factor is calculated.Theuncertaintyrange is thendetermined fromthisdistributionofscalingfactors(seeFigureS5a).Toestimateanuncertaintyrangeonthescalingfactorsof thefullCMIP5modelset,1,000different combinations of ‘piControl’ simulation samples are used to calculate a 5-95%rangeforeachoftheforcingscalingfactors.Fortheanalysisonthesubsampledsimulationswe repeat this procedure 100 times with 1,000 different combinations of ‘piControl’simulations. A 5-95% uncertainty range is then calculated from the combination of all100,000calculatedscalingfactors.Another concern regarding the estimation of an uncertainty range is the question ofwhetherthepresenceofanElNiñoduringaneruptionsystematicallychangesthecharacteroftheinternalvariability.Ifso,thismightaffecttheuncertaintyrangeonthescalingfactorfornaturalforcing.Theinternalvariabilitysamplesarerealizationsofthevariabilityaroundthemeanstateofaclimateintheabsenceofexternalforcing.Usually,samplesfromcontrolsimulations (e.g., ‘piControl’ simulations) are used for this. In the case here, where themodel fingerprints have been subsampled to only include thosewith the observed ENSOphaseduringpost-eruptionwinters, the internalvariabilitymightbedifferent than in theunconstrainedcase.Toinvestigatethis,wesubsamplethe‘piControl’samplesinexactlythesamewayasinthe‘historical’and‘historicalNat’simulations(FigureS5b).Unsurprisingly,theglobalmeansurfacetemperatureincreasesfollowingthethreevirtualeruptionsduetothe presence of an El Niño event, which occurs, by definition, in every sample. Cruciallythough,thevariabilityaroundthemeanisnotnoticeablydifferentfromtheunconstrainedcase, as can be shown by subtracting the multi-model mean time series (Figure S5c).Consequently, in the main paper the uncertainties as derived from the unsampled‘piControl’simulationsareusedforsimplicity.
![Page 8: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
FigureS5:GMSTanomaliesfordifferentsamplesof‘piControl’simulations.(a)Unsampled,‘piControl’simulations.(b) ‘piControl’simulationssubsampledtohaveanElNiñoeventinthe first virtual post-eruptionwinter (vertical dashed line). (c) Same as (b) butwith themulti-model mean subtracted. No effect in the variability due to subsampling followingvolcaniceruptionscanbeseen.Notethat thecyclicalvariability is theseasonalcyclewithGMSTinborealwinterbeingmorevariablethaninborealsummer.
![Page 9: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
6ResultswithGFDLmodelsInadditiontotheCESM1LargeEnsemble,weinvestigatethe30-memberGeophysicalFluidDynamicsLaboratory(GFDL)ESM2MLargeEnsemble,setup inaverysimilarwayas theCESM1LargeEnsemble(Rodgersetal.2015).TheGFDLESM2MLargeEnsembleisinitiatedin1950andalsofollowstheconventional‘historical’forcingprotocolofCMIP5.Finally,weinvestigate a 10-member ‘Pacemaker’ ensemblewithGFDLCM2.1, a GFDLmodel versionthat performs very similarly to GFDL-ESM2M (Dunne et al. 2012). This GFDL‘Pacemaker’ensemblewasalsoconfiguredfollowingKosakaandXie2013.FigureS6showsresultsfromtheGFDLESM2Mfree-running30-memberLargeEnsembleaswell as the 10-member GFDL CM2.1 ‘Pacemaker’ ensemble. The 30-member LargeEnsemblehasanaveragecoolingof−0.32°Caftervolcaniceruptions(measuredasthefirstpost-eruptionminimum in GMST). By subsampling the simulations according towhethertheycontainanElNiñointhefirstwinterafteraneruption,itcanbeseenthatthevolcaniccoolingisinhibitedbytheElNiño,therebyimprovingthetimingofthecoolingascomparedtoobservations.However,inalmostallofthesesubsampledsimulationsthereisastrongLaNiña2-3yearsafter theeruption,unlikeobservations, leading toanunrealistic coolingof−0.41°C.ThisbiasiscausedbythesystematicoccurrenceofLaNiñaafteranElNiñointhismodel version (Dunne et al. 2012). Besides being too regular, the ENSO amplitudes arelikelytoostronginthismodel,leadingtounrealisticamplitudesinGMST.UsinginsteadtheGFDL ‘Pacemaker’ simulations, inwhich theENSO chronologymatches that in reality,wefindthatwhilethepacemakerrunsareattheupperendoftheentiremodeldistribution,themodel stilloverestimates thepost-eruptioncooling, indicating that itmay indeedhaveanoverly strong response to volcanic forcing and that the discrepancy with observationscannot be fully explained by the ENSO phase sampling. Investigating the reasons for thisoverestimatedcoolingintheGFDLmodelsisbeyondthescopeofthisstudy.
![Page 10: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
Figure S6: Observed and simulated global mean surface temperature (GMST) anomalyrelativetothemeanofthe5yearsprecedingtheeruptionstartdate(dashedverticalline)averaged over the three recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo). (a)GFDL-ESM2Mlargeensembleand‘Pacemaker’simulations.Theaverageover3eruptionsisshown(seetextfordetails).Thecoloredshadinggivesthe5-95%confidenceinterval.Thenumberof ensemblemembers considered is given inbrackets. Themonthsduringwhichtheblueandredcurvesaresignificantlydifferent(t-test,95%confidence)areindicatedinbrightgreenalongthex-axis.Timeserieshavebeensmoothedwithatriangular1-2-1filterforvisualpurposesonly.
![Page 11: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
7AdditionalfigureforCESM1‘Pacemaker’simulations
FigureS7:CESM1‘Pacemaker’resultsfortheindividualeruptionsof(a,d,g)Agung,(b,e,h) El Chichon, and (c, f, i) Pinatubo. (Top row) Same as Figure 1. (Middle row) Globalmean surface temperature (GMST) response relative to the five years preceding theeruptionmonthfromobservations(black)andtheCESM1‘Pacemaker’simulations(green:shading indicatesminimumandmaximumacross the10-member ‘Pacemaker’ ensemble).Timeserieshavebeensmoothedwithatriangular1-2-1filterforvisualpurposesonly(onefilter iteration for models, and five iterations for observations to make spectralcharacteristics comparable between models and observations). (Bottom row)Temperaturedifference (observationsminus ‘Pacemaker’ ensemblemean)during a threemonthsperiodfollowingtheeruptionstartdate,centeredonthepeakpositiveanomalyinobservations.Numberinbottomrightcornerofeachmapgivesthespatialmeanofthemap,i.e.,howmuchwarmerobservationsarerelativetothe‘Pacemaker’simulations.
![Page 12: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
8AdditionalfigureincludingtheSantaMariaeruptionin1902
FigureS8:GlobalmeansurfacetemperatureresponsetothefoureruptionsofSantaMaria,Agung, El Chichon, and Pinatubo combined. The colored shading gives the 5-95%confidenceinterval.Thenumberofensemblemembersconsideredisgiveninbrackets.Themonths during which the blue and red curves are significantly different (t-test, 95%confidence)areindicatedinbrightgreenalongthex-axis.Timeserieshavebeensmoothedwith a triangular 1-2-1 filter for visual purposes only. Note that the total number ofsimulations (187) is slightly smaller than in Figure 2 (198), as not all simulations cover1902.
![Page 13: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
9Tablesonmodels,simulations,andsubsamplingThe number of simulationswhichmeet the ENSO selection criteria for each of the threevolcaniceruptionsisgiveninTableS1(formoredetailsseeTablesS2andS3).Table S1: Available simulations. Total number of ensemble members available for eachexperiment(column2)andnumberofensemblemembersthatmatchtheobservedENSOstateduringtheborealwinterfollowingtheeruption(columns3to5).Experiment Numberofensemblemembers
All Agung ElChichon PinatuboCMIP5historical 198 35 55 42CMIP5historicalNat 68 17 20 13CESM1 LargeEnsemble
40 9 12 7
GFDLLargeEnsemble 30 8 3 1TableS2:‘historical’simulationsusedforentireanalysis(column2)andthosethatmatchtheobservedENSOevolutionforindividualvolcaniceruptions(columns3to5).FGOALS-g2 and the CMCCmodels were excluded, as they do not include volcanic forcing for thehistoricalperiod. EnsemblemembershistoricalModel All Agung ElChichon PinatuboACCESS1-0 r1i1p1 ACCESS1-0 r2i1p1 ACCESS1-0 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 ACCESS1-3 r1i1p1 r1i1p1 ACCESS1-3 r2i1p1 ACCESS1-3 r3i1p1 r3i1p1bcc-csm1-1 r1i1p1 r1i1p1bcc-csm1-1 r2i1p1 r2i1p1 bcc-csm1-1 r3i1p1 r3i1p1bcc-csm1-1-m r1i1p1 bcc-csm1-1-m r2i1p1 r2i1p1 bcc-csm1-1-m r3i1p1 BNU-ESM r1i1p1 r1i1p1 r1i1p1CanESM2 r1i1p1 r1i1p1 CanESM2 r2i1p1 r2i1p1 CanESM2 r3i1p1 CanESM2 r4i1p1 CanESM2 r5i1p1 r5i1p1 CCSM4 r1i1p1 r1i1p1 CCSM4 r1i2p1
![Page 14: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
CCSM4 r1i2p2 r1i2p2 CCSM4 r2i1p1 CCSM4 r3i1p1 CCSM4 r4i1p1 CCSM4 r5i1p1 r5i1p1 CCSM4 r6i1p1 r6i1p1 CESM1-BGC r1i1p1 CESM1-CAM5 r1i1p1 CESM1-CAM5 r2i1p1 CESM1-CAM5 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2 r1i1p1 CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2 r2i1p1 CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2 r3i1p1 r3i1p1CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2 r4i1p1 CESM1-FASTCHEM r1i1p1 CESM1-FASTCHEM r2i1p1 r2i1p1 CESM1-FASTCHEM r3i1p1 CESM1-WACCM r1i1p1 r1i1p1 CESM1-WACCM r2i1p1 CESM1-WACCM r3i1p1 CESM1-WACCM r4i1p1 CESM1-WACCM r5i1p1 CESM1-WACCM r6i1p1 r6i1p1 CESM1-WACCM r7i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r10i1p1 r10i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r1i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r2i1p1 r2i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 r3i1p1CNRM-CM5 r4i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r5i1p1 r5i1p1 r5i1p1 r5i1p1CNRM-CM5 r6i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r7i1p1 r7i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r8i1p1 r8i1p1 r8i1p1CNRM-CM5 r9i1p1 CNRM-CM5-2 r1i1p1 r1i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r10i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r1i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r2i1p1 r2i1p1 r2i1p1CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r4i1p1 r4i1p1 r4i1p1CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r5i1p1
![Page 15: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r6i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r7i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r8i1p1 r8i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r9i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3L-1-2 r1i2p1 CSIRO-Mk3L-1-2 r2i2p1 r2i2p1CSIRO-Mk3L-1-2 r3i2p1 r3i2p1 EC-EARTH r12i1p1 r12i1p1 EC-EARTH r1i1p1 EC-EARTH r2i1p1 EC-EARTH r6i1p1 r6i1p1EC-EARTH r8i1p1 r8i1p1EC-EARTH r9i1p1 FIO-ESM r1i1p1 FIO-ESM r2i1p1 r2i1p1 FIO-ESM r3i1p1 r3i1p1 r3i1p1GFDL-CM2p1 r10i1p1 GFDL-CM2p1 r1i1p1 GFDL-CM2p1 r2i1p1 GFDL-CM2p1 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 GFDL-CM2p1 r4i1p1 r4i1p1 r4i1p1GFDL-CM2p1 r5i1p1 GFDL-CM2p1 r6i1p1 GFDL-CM2p1 r7i1p1 GFDL-CM2p1 r8i1p1 GFDL-CM2p1 r9i1p1 r9i1p1GFDL-CM3 r1i1p1 GFDL-CM3 r2i1p1 GFDL-CM3 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 GFDL-CM3 r4i1p1 r4i1p1 r4i1p1 GFDL-CM3 r5i1p1 r5i1p1GFDL-ESM2G r1i1p1 GFDL-ESM2M r1i1p1 r1i1p1 r1i1p1GISS-E2-H r1i1p1 GISS-E2-H r1i1p2 r1i1p2GISS-E2-H r1i1p3 r1i1p3 r1i1p3GISS-E2-H r2i1p1 GISS-E2-H r2i1p2 r2i1p2 GISS-E2-H r2i1p3 GISS-E2-H r3i1p1 GISS-E2-H r3i1p2 r3i1p2
![Page 16: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
GISS-E2-H r3i1p3 GISS-E2-H r4i1p1 GISS-E2-H r4i1p2 GISS-E2-H r4i1p3 r4i1p3 GISS-E2-H r5i1p1 r5i1p1 GISS-E2-H r5i1p2 GISS-E2-H r5i1p3 GISS-E2-H r6i1p1 r6i1p1GISS-E2-H r6i1p2 GISS-E2-H r6i1p3 r6i1p3GISS-E2-H-CC r1i1p1 r1i1p1 r1i1p1 GISS-E2-R r1i1p1 GISS-E2-R r1i1p12
1
GISS-E2-R r1i1p122
GISS-E2-R r1i1p124
r1i1p124 r1i1p124
GISS-E2-R r1i1p125
r1i1p125
GISS-E2-R r1i1p126
GISS-E2-R r1i1p127
r1i1p127
GISS-E2-R r1i1p128
r1i1p128
GISS-E2-R r1i1p2 GISS-E2-R r1i1p3 GISS-E2-R r2i1p1 GISS-E2-R r2i1p2 r2i1p2GISS-E2-R r2i1p3 r2i1p3 GISS-E2-R r3i1p1 r3i1p1 r3i1p1GISS-E2-R r3i1p2 r3i1p2 GISS-E2-R r3i1p3 r3i1p3 GISS-E2-R r4i1p1 r4i1p1GISS-E2-R r4i1p2 r4i1p2 GISS-E2-R r4i1p3 GISS-E2-R r5i1p1 GISS-E2-R r5i1p2 r5i1p2GISS-E2-R r5i1p3 GISS-E2-R r6i1p1 r6i1p1 GISS-E2-R r6i1p2 r6i1p2
![Page 17: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
GISS-E2-R r6i1p3 r6i1p3 GISS-E2-R-CC r1i1p1 r1i1p1 HadCM3 r10i1p1 r10i1p1HadCM3 r1i1p1 HadCM3 r2i1p1 HadCM3 r3i1p1 HadCM3 r4i1p1 r4i1p1 HadCM3 r5i1p1 r5i1p1 r5i1p1 HadCM3 r6i1p1 HadCM3 r7i1p1 r7i1p1 r7i1p1HadCM3 r8i1p1 r8i1p1 r8i1p1 r8i1p1HadCM3 r9i1p1 r9i1p1 r9i1p1HadGEM2-AO r1i1p1 HadGEM2-CC r1i1p1 r1i1p1 HadGEM2-ES r1i1p1 HadGEM2-ES r2i1p1 HadGEM2-ES r3i1p1 r3i1p1 HadGEM2-ES r4i1p1 r4i1p1 HadGEM2-ES r5i1p1 inmcm4 r1i1p1 r1i1p1IPSL-CM5A-LR r1i1p1 r1i1p1 r1i1p1 IPSL-CM5A-LR r2i1p1 r2i1p1IPSL-CM5A-LR r3i1p1 r3i1p1 IPSL-CM5A-LR r4i1p1 IPSL-CM5A-LR r5i1p1 r5i1p1 IPSL-CM5A-LR r6i1p1 r6i1p1 IPSL-CM5A-MR r1i1p1 r1i1p1 IPSL-CM5A-MR r2i1p1 r2i1p1IPSL-CM5A-MR r3i1p1 IPSL-CM5B-LR r1i1p1 MIROC4h r1i1p1 r1i1p1MIROC4h r2i1p1 r2i1p1 MIROC4h r3i1p1 MIROC5 r1i1p1 MIROC5 r2i1p1 MIROC5 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 MIROC5 r4i1p1 MIROC5 r5i1p1 MIROC-ESM r1i1p1 MIROC-ESM r2i1p1 MIROC-ESM r3i1p1 r3i1p1 r3i1p1
![Page 18: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
MIROC-ESM-CHEM r1i1p1 MPI-ESM-LR r1i1p1 r1i1p1 MPI-ESM-LR r2i1p1 MPI-ESM-LR r3i1p1 r3i1p1 MPI-ESM-MR r1i1p1 MPI-ESM-MR r2i1p1 r2i1p1MPI-ESM-MR r3i1p1 r3i1p1 MPI-ESM-P r1i1p1 r1i1p1 r1i1p1MPI-ESM-P r2i1p1 r2i1p1MRI-CGCM3 r1i1p1 r1i1p1 r1i1p1MRI-CGCM3 r2i1p1 r2i1p1 r2i1p1MRI-CGCM3 r3i1p1 r3i1p1MRI-CGCM3 r4i1p2 MRI-CGCM3 r5i1p2 r5i1p2 MRI-ESM1 r1i1p1 r1i1p1NorESM1-M r1i1p1 NorESM1-M r2i1p1 r2i1p1 NorESM1-M r3i1p1 r3i1p1 NorESM1-ME r1i1p1 r1i1p1 NorESM1-ME r1i1p2 r1i1p2 Totalnumber 198 35 55 42Table S3: historicalNat simulations used for entire analysis (column 2) and those thatmatchtheobservedENSOevolutionforindividualvolcaniceruptions(columns3to5). EnsemblemembershistoricalNatModel All Agung El
ChichonPinatubo
bcc-csm1-1 r1i1p1 BNU-ESM r1i1p1 CanESM2 r1i1p1 r1i1p1 CanESM2 r2i1p1 r2i1p1 r2i1p1 CanESM2 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 CanESM2 r4i1p1 r4i1p1 r4i1p1CanESM2 r5i1p1 r5i1p1 CCSM4 r1i1p1 CCSM4 r2i1p1 r2i1p1 CCSM4 r4i1p1 CCSM4 r6i1p1 r6i1p1CESM1-CAM5 r1i1p1 CESM1-CAM5 r2i1p1 r2i1p1
![Page 19: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
CESM1-CAM5 r3i1p1 CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2 r1i1p1 r1i1p1 CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2 r4i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r1i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r2i1p1 r2i1p1 r2i1p1CNRM-CM5 r3i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r4i1p1 r4i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r5i1p1 CNRM-CM5 r8i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r1i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r2i1p1 r2i1p1CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r3i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r4i1p1 CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 r5i1p1 GFDL-CM3 r1i1p1 r1i1p1GFDL-CM3 r3i1p1 r3i1p1 GFDL-CM3 r5i1p1 r5i1p1GFDL-ESM2M r1i1p1 r1i1p1 GISS-E2-H r1i1p1 r1i1p1 GISS-E2-H r1i1p3 r1i1p3 r1i1p3GISS-E2-H r2i1p1 GISS-E2-H r2i1p3 r2i1p3 r2i1p3GISS-E2-H r3i1p1 r3i1p1 GISS-E2-H r3i1p3 r3i1p3 r3i1p3 GISS-E2-H r4i1p1 GISS-E2-H r4i1p3 GISS-E2-H r5i1p1 GISS-E2-H r5i1p3 GISS-E2-R r1i1p1 r1i1p1 GISS-E2-R r1i1p3 r1i1p3 GISS-E2-R r2i1p1 GISS-E2-R r2i1p3 r2i1p3 GISS-E2-R r3i1p1 GISS-E2-R r3i1p3 r3i1p3 r3i1p3 GISS-E2-R r4i1p1 r4i1p1 GISS-E2-R r4i1p3 r4i1p3 GISS-E2-R r5i1p1 GISS-E2-R r5i1p3 r5i1p3HadGEM2-ES r1i1p1 r1i1p1 HadGEM2-ES r2i1p1
![Page 20: The importance of ENSO phase during volcanic eruptions for ... · recent volcanic eruptions (Agung, El Chichon and Pinatubo) from different observational data sets. Time series have](https://reader035.fdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022062607/605c20f7a28e747b4c65b018/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
HadGEM2-ES r3i1p1 r3i1p1HadGEM2-ES r4i1p1 r4i1p1 IPSL-CM5A-LR r1i1p1 IPSL-CM5A-LR r2i1p1 r2i1p1 IPSL-CM5A-LR r3i1p1 r3i1p1 r3i1p1IPSL-CM5A-MR r1i1p1 r1i1p1IPSL-CM5A-MR r2i1p1 IPSL-CM5A-MR r3i1p1 r3i1p1 MIROC-ESM r1i1p1 r1i1p1 MIROC-ESM r2i1p1 MIROC-ESM r3i1p1 r3i1p1 MIROC-ESM-CHEM r1i1p1 r1i1p1 MRI-CGCM3 r1i1p1 r1i1p1 NorESM1-M r1i1p1 r1i1p1Totalnumber 68 17 20 13References
Crowley,T.J.,andM.B.Unterman,2013:Technicaldetailsconcerningdevelopmentofa1200yrproxyindexforglobalvolcanism.EarthSyst.Sci.Data,5,187–197,doi:10.5194/essd-5-187-2013.
Dunne,J.P.,andCoauthors,2012:GFDL’sESM2GlobalCoupledClimate–CarbonEarthSystemModels.PartI:PhysicalFormulationandBaselineSimulationCharacteristics.J.Clim.,25,6646–6665,doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-11-00560.1.
Kosaka,Y.,andS.-P.Xie,2013:Recentglobal-warminghiatustiedtoequatorialPacificsurfacecooling.Nature,501,403–407,doi:10.1038/nature12534.http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23995690.
Li,J.,andCoauthors,2013:ElNiñomodulationsoverthepastsevencenturies.Nat.Clim.Chang.,3,822–826,doi:10.1038/nclimate1936.http://www.nature.com/doifinder/10.1038/nclimate1936\nhttp://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/v3/n9/full/nclimate1936.html(AccessedAugust10,2014).
Rodgers,K.B.,J.Lin,andT.L.Frölicher,2015:EmergenceofmultipleoceanecosystemdriversinalargeensemblesuitewithanEarthsystemmodel.Biogeosciences,12,3301–3320.