THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong...

33
Updated: May 2018 1 THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA Conducting Independent Enquiry About Social Media Student pack

Transcript of THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong...

Page 1: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

Updated: May 2018

1

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA Conducting Independent Enquiry About Social Media

Student pack

Page 2: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Introduction sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

2

In this pack

S-1. What is the Structured Enquiry Approach?

S-2. Part A: What are the issues I should focus my research on?

S-3. Part B: What concepts and methods are relevant to your IES?

S-4. Part C: What areas should I explain in detail for my enquiry issue?

S-5. Part D: How do I formulate an argument?

S-6. Use of footnotes and compilation of bibliography

S-7. Share your IES findings with UK students!

How will this be useful for me?

You’ll get step-by-step guidance on how to carry out

an independent enquiry study (IES) on the topic of

social media for your school based assessment in

Liberal Studies.

You’ll be able to understand research methods better

and choose the most suitable one for your enquiry.

You’ll see how university researchers organize their

research and research findings and be able to

follow their example.

You’ll have a deeper understanding of social media.

You’ll have the opportunity to share your IES findings

with students in the UK and hear about their

research findings.

Page 3: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Structured Enquiry Approach S-1 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

3

The Independent Enquiry Study is a school based assessment part of HKDSE Liberal Studies. It makes up 20% of your final exam mark. You will need to carry out an enquiry study on your own as well as submitting a report of not more than 4,5000 words1. You may write about any issues related to the six modules of the Liberal Studies Curriculum or issues related to media, education, religion, sports, art or Information and Communication Technology.

The Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority adopts the Structured Enquiry

Approach to provide a structural framework for students to organize their IES

reports. Each report should comprise the following four parts:

Part A: Problem Definition

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge / Facts / Data

Part C: In-depth Explanation of the Issue

Part D: Judgement and Justification

This student pack will use examples from real-life social media

research conducted at universities to help you to complete the

four parts step by step.

1 Some schools adopt non-written assessment. You can present your ideas by making a video, PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need to submit a report of maximally 1,000 words.

S-1. What is the Structured Enquiry Approach?

Page 4: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part A: Problem Definition S-2 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

4

1. Getting you thinking

Why are you interested in studying social media?

Why do you think that social media is significant to research on?

Watch the video below to see what the researcher of the Why We Post

project says.

“What is significance of a study of social media?”

https://sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media/v/significance

Why does the researcher think that impact of social media is

worthwhile to study?

The research team of the Why We Post project studied the impact of social media, specifically focusing on:

Education and young people

http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries/2-social-media-is-

education

Work and commerce

http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries/why-we-

post/discoveries/9-social-media-promoted-social-commerce-not-all-

commerce

S-2. Part A: What are the issues I should focus my research on?

I will complete S-2 Part A by…

Page 5: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part A: Problem Definition S-2 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

5

Gender relations

http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries/12-social-media-can-

have-a-profound-impact-on-gender-relations-sometimes-through-using-

fake-accounts

Inequality

http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries/4-equality-online-

doesnt-mean-equality-offline

Political participation

http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries/6-public-social-media-

is-conservative

Individualism

http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries/1-social-media-is-not-

making-us-more-individualistic/

Culture

http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries/why-we-

post/discoveries/8-social-media-is-not-making-the-world-more-

homogenous

Communication

http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries/why-we-

post/discoveries/7-we-used-to-just-talk-now-we-talk-photos

Privacy 1

http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries/15-we-tend-to-

assume-social-media-is-a-threat-to-privacy-but-sometimes-is-can-

increase-privacy

Privacy 2

http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries/10-social-media-has-

created-new-spaces-for-groups-between-the-public-and-private

Which of the above themes interests you the most? Why? Why is it socially significant?

Page 6: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part A: Problem Definition S-2 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

6

2. Choosing a controversial issue

Apart from choosing a topic which interests you, you also need to choose something

which is controversial about social media. This is because the issue you select for

your enquiry should allow you to explore different people’s views. This should lead

ultimately to you explaining and justifying your own stance in these debates. Take

the following extract as an example:

Extract 1

There is considerable uncertainty and anxiety over the broader impact of social

media on young people’s education and welfare. There are those who believe that

social media is destroying the educational system and will lead to a dramatic fall

in grades, which can only be solved by banning access to phones and other

Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs.) Others see social media as

potentially re-energising the experience of education and believe that, by forcing

formal education to embrace new forms of informal and interactive learning, the

use of such technologies will inevitably benefit all concerned. … Instead we feel

it important to pay more attention to how social media is reshaping the key

relationships relevant to education: those of student-student, teacher-student

and teacher-parent.

- Adapted from “How the World Changed Social Media” Chapter 5 p. 70

What controversial issues does the researcher address in this extract?

Whose views on the impact of social media on education are discussed in the extract?

Page 7: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part A: Problem Definition S-2 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

7

Are there any other groups whose views might also be important to consider, that

are not mentioned in this extract? Give reasons for your answer.

Go to the Why We Post website http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries

to find out what other controversies about social media are discussed in the

project.

Can you think of any other debates about social media which are not discussed by

the researchers?

Which controversy(ies) would you like to discuss in your Independent Enquiry Study?

Why?

Page 8: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part A: Problem Definition S-2 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

8

3. Choosing focus questions

After choosing your topic and the debates, you should design focus questions.

Focus questions help you understand what data you will need to collect, so that in

Part D you can put forward a particular view or argument based on evidence. For

example, to study the impact of social media on young people’s education, the

researchers from the Why We Post project collect data to answer the following

questions:

How do teachers develop school policy to regulate the use of social

media in school?

How do teachers and students use social media?

How useful do parents from various socio-economic classes see social

media in terms of their children’s formal and informal education?

What focus questions do you plan to ask?

The researchers of the Why We Post project carry out their studies in nine places:

Brazil, Chile, North China, South China, England, India, Italy, Trinidad and Turkey.

They studied people’s online and offline life.

Page 9: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part A: Problem Definition S-2 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

9

Where do you plan to carry out your study? Why?

To sum up Part A: Problem Definition What is your enquiry issue and major enquiry question?

Why is your study significant? Who might the results be useful for and why? Could

your results be used to create social policy? If so, how?

What controversy(ies) are you going to discuss in your IES?

Page 10: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part A: Problem Definition S-2 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

10

What do you aim to achieve?

What focus questions do you ask?

Who do you want to study?

Where would you base your research and why?

Page 11: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge Facts / Data

S-3 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

11

1. Choosing the key concepts relevant to your enquiry

In Part B you have to define the key concepts relevant to your enquiry question and

focus questions clearly, and explain how you are going to apply them in your

analysis.

What is a concept?

A “key concept” speaks about an important idea that a number of

different people, normally experts, might agree on. Not everyone will

agree on a particular concept, though, and different people may

suggest different understandings of a key concept.

For example:

Gender is biological. Men and

women have different bodies

from birth.

I disagree, gender is social. We

learn how to act like a man or a

woman as we grow up.

S-3. Part B: What concepts and methods are relevant to your IES?

I will complete S-3 Part B by…

Page 12: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge Facts / Data

S-3 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

12

Now we’ll look at a different key concept – social media – because different

experts have different ideas on what social media actually is.

Use the different types of social media shown here and make notes on the ways each

provides new or different ways of communicating with others.

Facebook

Instagram

Snapchat

What do you think social media is? Do you find it difficult to define social media?

Why?

Page 13: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge Facts / Data

S-3 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

13

Read the following extract to see how social media is defined in the Why We Post

project and why it is defined in that way.

Extract 2

Many previous studies of social media emphasise specific platforms…. It is clearly

important to understand Twitter, for example, as a platform: the company that

owns it, the way it works and the very idea of social media based on messages

that must remain below 140 characters. …

- Adapted from “How the World Changed Social Media” Chapter 1 p. 1

Social media should not be seen primarily as the platforms upon which people

post, but rather as the contents [e.g. memes, photos, tweets etc.] that are posted

on these platforms. These contents vary considerably from region to region, which

is why comparative study is necessary…. Social media is today a place within which

we socialize, not just a means of communication.

- Adapted from “How the World Changed Social Media” Summary of

Contents p. x

How do the researchers of the Why We Post Project define social media?

How is their definition different from the definition of previous studies?

Why do they define social media in ways different from other researchers?

Page 14: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge Facts / Data

S-3 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

14

2. Operationalising key concepts

Operationalisation is to make abstract concepts measurable so they are concrete

enough to observe. You have to explain how you operationalise the key concepts in

your definition.

How do you operationalise a concept?

For example, we may apply the idea that gender is social to a setting

such as shopping for clothes in a number of ways:

• To test whether the theory is correct.

• To examine how we might look at clothing shopping differently

using this idea.

Example: How do we operationalise gender?

Gender is biological Gender is social

Gender is defined by one’s sex Gender is defined by one’s self-

organ and physical sexual identity and learned behaviour of how

characteristics. to be a man or a woman. For example,

a man wears trousers and a woman

and a woman wears a dress.

According to Extract 2, how do researchers make social media measurable and

observable based on different definitions?

Social media as platform Social media as content, as a place for people to socialise

Page 15: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge Facts / Data

S-3 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

15

To sum up… What do you think is the best way to define social media in your IES?

How is your definition of social media useful to your analysis?

How would you operationalise (to make measurable) the concept social media?

What are the other key concepts in your enquiry question and focus questions?

How would you define, operationalise and explain them?

Tips: It’s best to start with reading literature about your key concepts. Adapt a

definition which is the most relevant to your study. We’ve provided a list of some

resources that offer a range of different concepts regarding social media that you

can draw on to kick-start your research:

sociology.hku.hk/social-media-concepts

Page 16: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge Facts / Data

S-3 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

16

3. Choosing your research method

After defining all the key concepts, you have to explain and justify the method(s)

you use to collect data. The researchers of the Why We Post project studied the

impact of social media by ethnography. They collect primary data and use both

quantitative and qualitative methods in their research. Find out why.

Definition:

Ethnography — the detailed study of a group of

people, usually involving the researcher living among

with the group over a significant period of time

Example of ethnography:

Social Media in Rural China (2016) is one of the eleven books to be written about

the Why We Post research.

This book comprises of a monograph reflecting on the fifteen months Tom spent

living in the rural town of Anshan, which has a population of around 31,000. Tom

prepared for his research by being fluent in the local language (Mandarin) and

making sure he understood customs and norms associated with daily life. He had

also spent some years living in cities in China before this. Since rural China is often

quite closed to foreigners, he had to get help from a university teacher in Beijing,

the capital of China who was able to introduce him to

people in the local Government in Anshan Town.

The aim of the research was not to see if social media has

a positive or negative effect on people’s lives but to see

what social media has become in each place, looking at

both local consequences and local people’s thoughts

about what role social media has in their lives.

Page 17: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge Facts / Data

S-3 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

17

Do you want to collect primary data or secondary data?

Secondary data: data already collected by

government, non-governmental organizations, think tanks or university researchers etc.

• Example: A student analyses the questionnaire results of the Why We Post project and writes on the impact of social media on privacy in China.

Primary data: data collected by researchers

themselves for specific purposes.

• Example: A student interviews a group of parents and write on the perceived impact of social media on parent-child relationships.

Page 18: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge Facts / Data

S-3 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

18

Secondary data:

Although secondary data are inexpensive and easily accessible, you may not find the

specific data you want, or it may be too general to really help answer your focus

questions. It’s a good idea to search through academic journals, government reports,

and research papers published by think tanks and non-governmental organizations

and newspapers to see if you can collect relevant and quality secondary data.

Tips: Useful websites for searching for secondary data

Academic journals: https://scholar.google.com.hk/

Legco papers: https://www.legco.gov.hk/general/english/library/index.html

Research reports of Central Policy Unit: http://www.cpu.gov.hk/en/research_reports/archives/archives_all.html

Public Opinion Polls: https://www.hkupop.hku.hk/english/

Start searching for secondary data. Have you found anything useful to answer

your focus questions?

Page 19: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge Facts / Data

S-3 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

19

Primary data:

If secondary data is not available, you may need to collect primary data.

Questionnaires and in-depth interviews are the most common methods students use

to collect data for their IES.

Questionnaires are standardized set of questions with pre-set answers for

respondents to choose. Questionnaires produce quantitative data. Interviews are

non-standardized and open-ended questions for interviewers to discuss with

interviewees. Interviews produce qualitative data. Watch the video to learn the

strengths, weaknesses and data analytical skills of questionnaires and interviews

respectively.

https://sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media/v/methods

Questionnaire /

Quantitative data Interviews /

Qualitative data

Strengths

Weaknesses

Data

analytical

skills

required

Page 20: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge Facts / Data

S-3 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

20

Do you think you can conduct an ethnographic study? Why?

Apart from strengths and weaknesses of each method, what else do you need to

consider when choosing the method for your IES?

Page 21: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part B: Relevant Concepts and Knowledge Facts / Data

S-3 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

21

To sum up…

Which methods would be most suitable for and why?

Who would you wish to research as your questionnaires respondents or interviewees?

Why?

What sorts of skills might you need?

How would you record and analyse your results?

What have you learnt from this activity about the challenges of researching the

impact of social media? How can you overcome those challenges?

Page 22: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part C: In-depth Explanation of the Issue S-4 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

22

You will need to present your findings and discuss both positive and negative views

on the issue. Your analysis should be from multiple perspectives (e.g. perspectives

of different stakeholders, etc.) ALL focus questions you have asked in Part A have

to be answered in this part.

Quantitative data is generally represented in tables, charts and graphs. You will

need to label all the tables, charts and graphs in your IES properly. Analyse the

tables, charts and graphs and elaborate on the views reflected. Describe the data

to support your analysis.

An example of analysis of quantitative data

We then asked if people felt social media was good for education…. Here we can see how polarized views on the impact of social media on education are both across countries. Schools in Chile (60%), Rural China (50%), South India (66%), and Trinidad (62%) were very encouraging of social media usage as an educational tool, while schools in Italy (36%) and Turkey (38%) have the highest percentage of respondents seeing social media as bad for education.

S-4. Part C: What areas should I explain in detail for my enquiry issue?

I will complete S-4 Part C by…

Page 23: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part C: In-depth Explanation of the Issue S-4 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

23

Qualitative data, by contrast, are not necessarily easily reduced to numbers. They

are related to people’s views and behaviour. To present qualitative data, you have

to provide rich description of both your own observations and also what your

interviewees tell you and your observations. You may quote your interviewees.

An example of analysis of qualitative data

In rural China parents placed great importance on their children’s education, believing that academic achievement would help their children’s education would help their children obtain a secure and comfortable life. In this context, social media was largely understood by parents, teachers and students as having a negative impact on educational progression and learning as the following quote from a rural Chinese teacher demonstrates:

I taught the third grade of middle school for a while. On one occasion, I confiscated five or six mobile phones. When they’re using phones they’re not doing anything else, just chatting on QQ, reading [online short stories] … In China, with this kind of education for the purpose of examinations, you must study; communication is put in a secondary position. Because each year there is just one chance in the exam. If you don’t pass the exam, you can only enter [manual] employment, and it will be a very bad environment, and you won’t have any good way out.

Students spent long hours in school each day. During the summer holidays they often attended expensive private tuition classes in the town. Parents wanted their children to reach university, but had little understanding of what skills students needed to do well in exams or what life inside university was actually like.

All of these constituted considerable restrictions, despite which students found ways to access social media. They made extensive use of ‘QQ Groups’, instant messaging groups whose membership often responded to their physical class groups. Apart from allowing for continued socializing with classmates outside of school time, students used QQ Groups to share homework answers and get help from other classmates. Asking for help from peers was especially important given that parents often lacked knowledge relevant to their homework and physically meeting with classmates outside school time was often difficult in this rural area.

- Adapted from “How the World Changed Social Media” Chapter 5 pp. 74-75; and “Desiring mobiles, desiring education: mobile phones and families in a rural Chinese Town” (in Mobile Communication and the Asian family:

transforming technologies, changing households), pp. 22.

Page 24: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part C: In-depth Explanation of the Issue S-4 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

24

Questions for planning the presentation of your research findings

How would you present the findings of your own research and why?

Do you have enough data to answer all the focus questions? What are your major

findings?

What have you learnt from this process about the challenges of understanding the

way people use social media?

Page 25: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part D: Judgment and Justification S-5 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

25

1. What is an argument?

An argument is a claim supported by reasons and evidence. It takes a

stand on an issue and seeks to persuade an audience. Watch the video

to learn more.

https://sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-

media/v/argument

Exercise: Which of the following is an argument? Explain your choice.

Extract 1

Parents from the least economically developed field sites (Brazil, China, and the

rural component of our south India field site) . . . often expressed a general

frustration at the failings of local schools to equip students properly with the skills

and knowledge required for success in formal education, work and life more

generally.

- Adapted from “How the World Changed Social Media” Chapter 5 p.73

Is this an argument? Give reasons for your answer.

S-5. Part D: How do I formulate an argument?

I will complete S-5 Part D by…

Page 26: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part D: Judgment and Justification S-5 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

26

Extract 2

Although people often complain about social media as a threat to education, we

found that for some people social media does not detract from education – it is

education. Many of our field sites recognize that social media simultaneously

assists informal learning as well as being a distraction from formal education.

Often it mainly benefits low income families with poor prospects in formal

education. For example in Brazil, with limited access to formal schooling, many

people turn to social media, and particularly YouTube videos, as an important

source of education.

- Adapted from Why We Post Project Discovery 2

http://www.ucl.ac.uk/why-we-post/discoveries/2-social-media-is-

education

Is this an argument? Give reasons for your answer.

2. How do I formulate a good argument?

A good argument is fair, unbiased, logical and evidence-based. To

formulate a good argument, you’ll need to evaluate (to weigh up) the

strength of supporting and opposing arguments of your issue and take

up a stance. One way to do this is to consider if an argument has more

strengths or weaknesses before you conclude about the overall

usefulness of an argument. In your writing, you’ll need to explain why

you disagree with opposing argument to justify your stance.

Page 27: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part D: Judgment and Justification S-5 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

27

Example

Statement of

argument Reasons Evidence

Supporting

argument Social media

has a

harmful

effect on

education

• Widespread public

opinion exists saying

social media is bad

for education

• Schools have taken

action against social

media

• Many teachers &

parents say that

social media distracts

students from

learning.

• Schools ban students

from using mobile

phones in class.

• Students were seen

playing on their

phones during class

time.

Opposing

argument

Social media

has a

positive

effect on

education

• Opinions differ in

different places.

While some people

understand

education as formal

education, others

define education as

informal learning

happening both

inside and outside

school.

• Statistical data

looking at exam

scores and phone

ownership does not

support the

argument

• In Brazil, people use

YouTube videos as an

important source of

education. In China,

migrant workers rely

on social media as

important source of

information and

practical knowledge.

• Students with mobile

phones do not have

worse exam scores

than those without.

Page 28: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part D: Judgment and Justification S-5 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

28

Which argument do you agree with, and why?

I think social media has a positive effect on education. Although public

opinion may say social media is bad for learning, just because many people

think it does not mean it is correct. School bans might be responding to this

opinion, rather than the evidence.

Looking at the relationship between owning a mobile phone and good exam

results is a more reliable way to find out whether or not social media has a

good result on education. Statistical analysis shows that students mobile

phones do not have worse exam scores than those without, reflecting that

social media is not bad for academic achievement at school.

On the other hand, social media is an important tool for learning outside

school. In Brazil and China, people gain information and practical knowledge

through social media, showing the positive effect of social media on education.

(Add detailed description of statistical data to support your reason)

(Add detailed description of quantitative or qualitative data to support your reason)

Page 29: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part D: Judgment and Justification S-5 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

29

Now it’s your turn. Create your own evaluation of an argument using the same

format below.

Statement of

argument Reasons Evidence

Supporting

argument

Opposing

argument

Page 30: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Part D: Judgment and Justification S-5 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

30

Which argument do you agree with, and why?

3. How do I organize Part D?

You should organise Part D with the following section:

Introduction: what is your argument?

Main body: what are the reasons and evidence supporting your argument?

Main body: what are your counter-arguments? What are the reasons and evidence supporting them?

Main body: why do you disagree with the counter-arguments?

Conclusion

Page 31: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Footnotes & Bibliography S-6 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

31

To avoid plagiarism, and get into good writing habits you will need to cite references

clearly when you use others’ work in your writing. You are not required to use any

specific citation style as long as you are consistent. Most students cite in footnotes. Footnotes are notes placed at the bottom of a page. Apart from citation, you can

add comments or information which is not directly relevant to the main text.

One example of this was the project on American teens’ new media use by Ito and her

colleagues.1 … This theme is taken up here, where social media is found to make a more

positive contribution if we consider learning more generally, rather than a narrow sense

of formal education.2

__________________________________________

1. Ito, M., Horst, H., Bittanti, M., boyd., Herr-Stephenson., B., Lange, P. G., Pascoe, C. J. and Robinson, L.

2008. Living and Learning with New Media: Summary of Findings from the Digital Youth Project.

Cambirdge, MA: The MIT Press.

2. Anthropologists have frequently challenged this distinction between formal and informal learning. For

example see Borofsky, R. 1997. Making History: Pukapukan and Anthropological Constructions of

Knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

At the end of the report, you have to compile a list of the sources you have used.

The list is called bibliography. You can categorize your sources then arrange them

according to alphabetical order.

Bibliography

Books

Adorno, T.W. 1991. ‘Free time.’ Bernstein J. M., ed. The Culture Industry: Selected

essays on mass culture. 162-70.

Akdenizli, B., ed. 2015. Digital transformation in Turkey: current perspectives in

communication studies. Maryland: Lexington Books.

Academic journals

Bargh, J.a., et. al. 2002. ‘Can You See the Real Me? Activation and Expression of the

“True Self” on the Internet.’ Journal of Social Issues 58(1): 33-48.

Chadwick, A. 2003. ‘Bringing E-Democracy Back In: Why it Matters for Future Research

on E-Governance.’ Social Science Computer Review 21(4):443-55.

S-6. Use of footnotes and compilation of bibliography

I will complete S-6 by…

Page 32: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Footnotes & Bibliography S-6 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

32

Learn different styles of citation here!

American Psychological Association (APA) Style

http//www.bibme.org/citation-guide/apa/

American Sociological Association (ASA) Style

http://lib.trinity.edu/research/citing/ASA_Style_Citations_4.pdf

Page 33: THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA - University of Hong Konghub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/253885/1/complete-student-pack-hk-20180… · PowerPoint presentation, etc. In that case, you only need

THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

Sharing with UK students S-7 sociology.hku.hk/impact-social-media

33

Now that you have completed your IES, you have the opportunity to share your

findings and reflections with students in the UK who have been doing similar

research to yourself. This allows you to see the impact of social media in cross-

cultural settings. The idea is that you compare your ideas, in a similar way to how

the Why We Post research team compared their own findings from different

countries.

There are several ways that you can organise this:

1. A short video

2. A story board

3. A Prezi

Choose a method of expressing your findings from the list above, and post your

results onto the Hong Kong University website.

Ready to share your findings? Upload them at:

sociology.hku.hk/share-findings

About the UK

The UK is a country in Europe with a population of 65 million people. The UK is a

mainly English-speaking country with a high degree of development. The UK also

has a history of immigration, with many people from around the world choosing

to move to the UK in order to live there. As such, the UK is a relatively

multicultural country.

S-7. Share your IES findings with UK students!