The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 ·...

19
Christian Apologetics PE 420/PE 620 Historical Challenges to Christianity 2: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the Church “For if the dead are not raised, not even Christ has been raised. And if Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile and you are still in your sins. Then those also who have fallen asleep in Christ have perished. If in this life only we have hoped in Christ, we are of all people most to be pitied.” (Paul, 1 Corinthians 15)

Transcript of The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 ·...

Page 1: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

Christian Apologetics

PE 420/PE 620

Historical Challenges to Christianity 2:

The Historicity of Christ

The Resurrection

The Emergence of the Church

“For if the dead are not raised, not even Christ has been raised. And

if Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile and you are still in

your sins. Then those also who have fallen asleep in Christ have

perished. If in this life only we have hoped in Christ, we are of all

people most to be pitied.” (Paul, 1 Corinthians 15)

Page 2: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

Lecture overview

One Solitary Life … Worshipping Jesus

Challenges to Our Story/Discussion

Different Apologetic Approaches to Jesus

Jesus on Trial Activity

Page 3: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

One solitary life

What grabs you about Jesus? …

Fill the whiteboard with worship

Page 4: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

*Challenges to Our Story*

Page 5: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

Challenges to our story

-question—something you don’t get, or want to clarify

-challenge—something you disagree with, or want to nuance

-implication—“so what” for your apologetic approach

-application—something useful right now in your context

+ show and tell

Page 6: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

CLASSICAL: Jesus, the alternatives

(1)Jesus’ claim to deity excludes him as a mere man

(2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord?

CLASSICAL: Jesus, the alternatives

(1)Jesus’ claim to deity excludes him as a mere man

(2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord?

Apologetics for Jesus

Page 7: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

CLASSICAL: Jesus, the alternatives

(1)Jesus’ claim to deity excludes him as a mere man

(2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord?

EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence

(1)Jesus’ resurrection can be proved historically

(2)False dilemma: Jesus of history or Christ of faith

REFORMED: Jesus, the self-attesting Christ of Scripture

(1)Jesus is the self-attesting Christ of Scripture

(2)Jesus should be believed because He is God

FIDEIST: Jesus, the Christ of faith

(1)Jesus is self-attesting Christ as witnessed in Scripture

(2)Jesus is someone no human could invent

CLASSICAL: Jesus, the alternatives

(1)Jesus’ claim to deity excludes him as a mere man

(2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord?

EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence

(1)Jesus’ resurrection can be proved historically

(2)False dilemma: Jesus of history or Christ of faith

REFORMED: Jesus, the self-attesting Christ of Scripture

(1)Jesus is the self-attesting Christ of Scripture

(2)Jesus should be believed because He is God

FIDEIST: Jesus, the Christ of faith

(1)Jesus is self-attesting Christ as witnessed in Scripture

(2)Jesus is someone no human could invent

Apologetics for Jesus

Page 8: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

CLASSICAL: Jesus, the alternatives

EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence

REFORMED: Jesus, the self-attesting Christ of Scripture

FIDEIST: Jesus, the Christ of faith

CLASSICAL: Jesus, the alternatives

EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence

REFORMED: Jesus, the self-attesting Christ of Scripture

FIDEIST: Jesus, the Christ of faith

Apologetics for Jesus

Page 9: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

INTEGRATED: Jesus, the answer

(1) Classical Apologetics (immanent aspect):

Jesus as Lord – the divine Christ (John)

(2) Reformed Apologetics (transcendent aspect):

Jesus as Lord – the biblical Christ (Matthew)

(3) Evidentialism (situational perspective):

Jesus as Saviour – the risen Christ (Luke)

(4) Fideism (existential perspective):

Jesus as Saviour – the crucified Christ (Mark)

INTEGRATED: Jesus, the answer

(1) Classical Apologetics (immanent aspect):

Jesus as Lord – the divine Christ (John)

(2) Reformed Apologetics (transcendent aspect):

Jesus as Lord – the biblical Christ (Matthew)

(3) Evidentialism (situational perspective):

Jesus as Saviour – the risen Christ (Luke)

(4) Fideism (existential perspective):

Jesus as Saviour – the crucified Christ (Mark)

Apologetics for Jesus

Page 10: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

� Q1) Did Jesus Even Exist - & can we trust the Bible & other sources of evidence?

� Q2) Did Jesus believe He was God - & was He Right or Crazy?

� Q3) Was Jesus the MESSIAH (Saviour of the World) –predicted in the Bible even before He was born?

Q4) Did Jesus really Die on the Cross – or did He just fake it?

� Q5) Did Jesus come back to life (the resurrection) after being killed?

� Q6) Even if this is all true, isn’t it irrelevant in today’s modern society?

� Q1) Did Jesus Even Exist - & can we trust the Bible & other sources of evidence?

� Q2) Did Jesus believe He was God - & was He Right or Crazy?

� Q3) Was Jesus the MESSIAH (Saviour of the World) –predicted in the Bible even before He was born?

Q4) Did Jesus really Die on the Cross – or did He just fake it?

� Q5) Did Jesus come back to life (the resurrection) after being killed?

� Q6) Even if this is all true, isn’t it irrelevant in today’s modern society?

Jesus on Trial

Page 11: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

� Q1) Did Jesus Even Exist - & can we trust the Bible & other sources

of evidence?

� Q1) Did Jesus Even Exist - & can we trust the Bible & other sources

of evidence?

Jesus on Trial

Page 12: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

� Q2) Did Jesus believe He was God - & was He Right or Crazy?� Q2) Did Jesus believe He was God - & was He Right or Crazy?

Jesus on Trial

Page 13: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

� Q3) Was Jesus the MESSIAH (Saviour of the World) – predicted in the Bible

even before He was born?

� Q3) Was Jesus the MESSIAH (Saviour of the World) – predicted in the Bible

even before He was born?

Jesus on Trial

Page 14: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

Q4) Did Jesus really Die on the Cross – or did He just fake it?

Q4) Did Jesus really Die on the Cross – or did He just fake it?

Jesus on Trial

Page 15: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

� Q5) Did Jesus come back to life (the resurrection) after being killed?

� Q5) Did Jesus come back to life (the resurrection) after being killed?

Jesus on Trial

Page 16: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

� Q6) Even if this is all true, isn’t it irrelevant in today’s modern society?� Q6) Even if this is all true, isn’t it irrelevant in today’s modern society?

Jesus on Trial

Page 17: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

Dead BodyDead Body

Empty TombEmpty Tomb

Multiple WitnessesMultiple Witnesses

Lives TransformedLives Transformed

Page 18: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

The Incomparable ChristThe Incomparable Christ

In Christ Alone …In Christ Alone …

Page 19: The Historicity of Christ The Resurrection The Emergence of the … · 2019-12-20 · (2)Quantilemma: Legend, lama, liar, lunatic, Lord? EVIDENTIAL: Jesus, the evidence (1)Jesus’

-question—something you don’t get, or want to clarify

-challenge—something you disagree with, or want to nuance

-implication—“so what” for your apologetic approach

-application—something useful right now in your context

+ show and tell