The Golden Section and Architecture

41
The Golden Section and Architecture Do we find it pleasing?

Transcript of The Golden Section and Architecture

Page 1: The Golden Section and Architecture

The Golden Section andArchitecture

Do we find it pleasing?

Page 2: The Golden Section and Architecture

Incorporated into Buildings forMillennia

• Egyptians used it in the design of their religiousbuildings

• Had many proponents in Ancient Greece• Explosion in art and architecture during the

Renaissance• Psychologists have been examining its aesthetic

qualities since the 1870s• Today many architectural firms have it on their

web sites• Is it incorporated into Ross

Page 3: The Golden Section and Architecture

What is the golden section?

Page 4: The Golden Section and Architecture

Suppose that we were to divide a linesuch that the ratio of the shorter

segment to the longer segment equalsthe ratio of the longer segment to the

entire line.

Page 5: The Golden Section and Architecture

Mathematically, this can be shown asa/b = b/(a + b)

Where a, b represent the lengths ofthe shorter and longer segments,

respectively, and a + b = 1 Phi 1

--------------|-------- 1 phi

phi = 0.618Phi = 1.618…

Page 6: The Golden Section and Architecture

In Book 6, Proposition 30, Eucliddiscusses division of a line to obtain

the golden section 1

A G B-------------------------------

g 1 – g

GB = AG , 1 – g = gAG AB g 1

Page 7: The Golden Section and Architecture

What are some of the propertiesof Phi?

• Phi = 1.618…, phi = 0.618…• Phi = 1 + phi• Phi = 1/phi• Phi2 = Phi +1• Phi = (sqr5 +1)/2

Page 8: The Golden Section and Architecture

How can the golden section beconstructed?

Page 9: The Golden Section and Architecture

Also can be found in ratios ofFibonacci numbers

1,1,2,3,5,8,13,21,…1/1,1/2,2/3,3/5,5/8,8/13,13/21,…

1,.5,.67,.6,.625,.615,.619,…

Page 10: The Golden Section and Architecture

Which Structures HaveIncorporated It?

Page 11: The Golden Section and Architecture

Egyptians used the goldensection in their pyramids

Page 12: The Golden Section and Architecture
Page 13: The Golden Section and Architecture

In Greece, the most famousbuilding incorporating phi is

….

Page 14: The Golden Section and Architecture
Page 15: The Golden Section and Architecture
Page 16: The Golden Section and Architecture

Also popular in medieval andRenaissance architecture

Page 17: The Golden Section and Architecture
Page 18: The Golden Section and Architecture

Or Notre Dame in Paris

Page 19: The Golden Section and Architecture

Many art books talk aboutcentering objects about 1/3 of the

way across

Page 20: The Golden Section and Architecture

Many artists incorporated it intotheir works

Page 21: The Golden Section and Architecture
Page 22: The Golden Section and Architecture
Page 23: The Golden Section and Architecture
Page 24: The Golden Section and Architecture

Famous modern day architectsdiscussed its beauty

Page 25: The Golden Section and Architecture

Incorporated into buildings suchas the UN in NYC

Page 26: The Golden Section and Architecture
Page 27: The Golden Section and Architecture

Le Corbusier’s Villa Stein inGarches

Page 28: The Golden Section and Architecture
Page 29: The Golden Section and Architecture

I.M. Pei’s Bank of China

Page 30: The Golden Section and Architecture

Is it aesthetically pleasing?

Page 31: The Golden Section and Architecture

Controversial

• Many studies have been done• Conduct of studies has been controversial•

Page 32: The Golden Section and Architecture

Early Psychological Research

• Fechner (1871) “Zur experimentalenAesthetik”

• Subjects given 10 rectangles of equal areaand asked to choose most pleasing

• 35% expressed a preference for the goldensection

• 21% expressed a preference for the 1.5:1rectangle

Page 33: The Golden Section and Architecture

Criticism

• Golden rectangle was in middle ofproportion ranges (7th)

• Subjects not randomly selected• Subjects may have been cognizant of

Fechner’s hypothesis• Preference is a function of associations• Association being the human body which

all subjects had

Page 34: The Golden Section and Architecture

Angier and Division of a Line1903

• Asked 9 subjects to divide a line 72 times“at the most pleasing place.”

• Only two subjects chose the goldenproportion with great regularity

• Mean proportion was 0.6

Page 35: The Golden Section and Architecture

E.L. Thorndike 1917

• Subjects given 12 rectangles of varyingproportions, but with same height

• Height to width ratios varied from 1.3: 1 to 3.75:1• Asked to rank in terms of “which do you like the

looks of most?”• The golden rectangle and the next two most

elongated rectangles were ranked 1st, 2nd and 3rd

Page 36: The Golden Section and Architecture

Similar Studies Kept Being Done

• Studies by age groups• Preschoolers had no particular preference• 3rd and 6th graders preferred wider triangles• Post secondary students preferred rectangles

0.55, 0.60 and 0.65 ratios• Elderly subjects preferred wider rectangles

Page 37: The Golden Section and Architecture

Studies by Culture

• Canadian versus Japanese• 9% of Canadians preferred it versus 5% of

Japanese• Americans versus Europeans• Substantial differences showed up between

these two groups

Page 38: The Golden Section and Architecture

Result is a “mass of conflictingdata and conclusions.”

(Green 1995)

Page 39: The Golden Section and Architecture

• “It may simply be that the psychologicalinstruments we are forced to use in studyingthe effects of the golden section are just toocrude.” D.E. Berlyne, 1971

Page 40: The Golden Section and Architecture

According to you folks…

Dimensions:

A 0.4:1B 0.5:1C 0.92:1D 0.62:1E 0.85:1

Page 41: The Golden Section and Architecture

Thank You!