The Enron Scam
-
Upload
arunimabishnoi -
Category
Documents
-
view
222 -
download
0
Transcript of The Enron Scam
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
1/16
THE ENRON SCAMENRON AND ARTHUR ANDERSEN
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
2/16
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
3/16
BACKGROUND
ENRON:
Merger of Houston Natural Gas and InterNorth in1985.
The largest seller of natural gas in North America b 199!.
"i#ersi$cation strateg % gas &i&elines' electricit &lants' &u&a&er &lants' (ater &lants' and broadband ser#ices across th
)egan to trade commodities from $*ed assets +&i&elines,' tointangibles +contractual rights to commodities,.
ARTHUR ANDERSEN:
Among the most &restigious international accounting $rms i
-nron (as Andersens second largest client.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
4/16
INTRODUCTION
At its &ea/' -nron (as America0s se#enth largest cor&orat
Illusion % a stead com&an (ith good re#enue.
ealit % a large &art of -nrons &ro$ts (ere made of &a&e
Ho( it ha&&ened % masterfull designed accounting and m
2uestionable acts b traders and e*ecuti#es.
esult % dee& debt and surfacing information about hidingga#e big &roblems' and
In the late !331 -nron declared ban/ru&tc under 4ha&tenited 6tates )an/ru&tc 4ode.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
5/16
ENRON’S SURGE TO THE TOP
1. FROM ENERGY TO TRADING:
-arl 19930s 7 the nited 6tates congress a&&ro#ed a legthat deregulated the sale of natural gas.
Ga#e -nron the o&&ortunit to sell their energ at higher leading to greater re#enue.
6tart of -nron0s ourne from an energ com&an to a tracom&an.
The focus (ent from energ mar/ets to $nding ne( (asmone. arge in#estments (ere made around the (orld tits business and o&en itself for ne( mar/ets.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
6/16
2. MARK TO MARKET ACCOUNTING:
4hange in -nron0s accounting sstem from a straightfor(ard /indaccounting to the mar/%to%mar/et accounting sstem.
-arlier % listed actual re#enue and costs of su&&ling and selling g
Mar/%to%mar/et method % estimations of future incomes (hen a locontract is signed.
-stimations based on the future net #alue of the cash :o(.
4osts related to the contract (ere often hard to &redict.
It means that the estimated income from &roects (ere included ethe mone (as not et recei#ed.
In#estors gi#en misleading information because of the de#iation i
estimations.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
7/16
3. SPECIAL PURPOSE ENTITY:
6&ecial &ur&ose entit % legal entit created onl to carr s&eci$c or tem&orar tas/.
;ur&ose % to handle assets either b funding or b ris/ ma
A s&onsor creates the entiti but the funding comes from In -nron0s case the s&ecial &ur&ose entities (ere not onl
dodge the traditional accounting con#entions but also to
The entities made it &ossible for -nron to underestimate' debts and o#erestimate its e2uit.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
8/16
ENRON’S COLLAPSE
1. MARK-TO-MARKET ACCOUNTING:
The use of mar/%to%mar/et accounting later bac/$red.
4orru&ted its boo/s and allo(ed it to be far too o&timisticassum&tions about the future &ro$ts.
4ash is a necessit for an com&an to run and -nron mo&a&er re#enue.
) the middle of !331' the came to the conclusion that tcrisis had struc/ them.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
9/16
2. THE ENRON CULTURE:
)onuses in form of cash or stoc/ o&tions came in bundlesou (ere considered one of the mone%ma/ers.
Made -nron a #er com&etiti#e (or/ &lace.
-#erone (as in a hurr to close deals +good or bad, beca
after a closed deal' the got their bonuses regardless of tthe deal.
;roblem % there (ere a lot of &roects being made but no No one (anted to be res&onsible of a done deal' the ustclose it and get their bonus.
A culture that re&laced coo&eration (ith com&etition.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
10/16
3. SPECIAL PURPOSE ENTITY: In order to hide losses and fabricate earnings' multi&le 6;
created.
re2uirements? +>@ of the e2uit had to come from outside in#estors +i.e. -nron,' +!, the entit could not be controlled b -nron' an-nron (as not liable for an loans or other liabilities.
)ut the (ere not inde&endent % run b -nron em&loees
Therefore' had to be disclosed in -nron0s $nancial statem
de&ressing earnings and debt le#els se#erel.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
11/16
AUDIT ISSUES - ANDERSEN
1. COMMERCIALIZATION AND INDEPENDENCE:
Auditors must be inde&endent of management and e#aluate thre&resentations of management for all users of $nancial statem
ess than >3@ of the fees Andersen recei#ed from -nron cameauditing' (hile the balance from consulting.
Andersen acted as -nrons e*ternal auditor and as its internal a(or/ as a consultant raises se#eral 2uestions.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
12/16
2. INTERNAL CONTROL WEAKNESSES AT ENRON: T(o serious (ea/nesses % the 4=C (as e*em&ted from a co
interest &olic' and internal controls o#er 6;-s (ere a shamform but not in substance.
Man $nancial oDcials lac/ed the bac/ground for their obs(ere not &hsicall secured.
The trac/ing of dail cash (as la*' debt maturities (ere notoE balance sheet debt (as ignored although the obligation and com&an%(ide ris/ (as disregarded.
Internal controls (ere inade2uateF contingent liabilities (eredisclosedF and
Andersen ignored all of these (ea/nesses.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
13/16
3. EVALUATION OF ACCOUNTING MATERIALITY:
Auditors focus on material misre&resentations.
Material % if /no(ledge of the misre&resentation (ould chdecisions of the user of $nancial statements.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
14/16
ANDERSEN CONVICTED
une !33! % Andersen con#icted in a 6 federal court of thobstructing ustice b shredding (or/ing &a&ers related toaudits.
)ecause Andersen &ersonnel /ne( that the &a&ers (oulde#idence in a 6-4 +6ecurities and -*change 4ommission,in#estigation.
A criminal con#iction (ould mean that Andersen could noregistrants.
Andersen announced its intent to go out of business befotoo/ formal action.
August !33! % the Te*as 6tate )oard of ;ublic Accountanc
Arthur Andersens license to &ractice accounting in the 6t Te*as because of the $rms &rofessional and ethical misco
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
15/16
SARBANES-O!LEY ACT
6arbanes%C*le Act % a 6 federal la( that came after thescandal.
4ontains a set of standards that regulate &ublic com&anmanagement and &ublic accounting $rms.
All com&anies must ha#e a maorit of inde&endent direc
audit committee should consist of members that are $naneducated and one of the members ha#e to been an e*&er
Increased &enalties for destroing' altering' or fabricatingfederal in#estigations or for attem&ting to defraud shareh
Increased the accountabilit of auditing $rms to remain uand inde&endent of their clients.
-
8/19/2019 The Enron Scam
16/16
CONCLUSIONS
Morall 2uestionable acts (ere made from both e*ecuti#etraders. Cne thing that is una#oidable is the fact that em-nron (ere &artiall &aid in stoc/s (hich moti#ated the (ta/e actions that (ere unethical in order to raise the stoce2ui#alentl their o(n mone.
Mar/%to%mar/et accounting mi*ed (ith the use of 6;-s mloo/ $nanciall health (hen it actuall (as bleeding' blese#erel. Misleading information (as gi#en to the in#estothe accounting sstem' (hich e#entuall led to decreasin&rice (hen the information about this started to surface.