The Effect of Heat Gas Nitriding on Some Mechanical ... · form tetrahedral sites with radius r tet...

8
Energy Procedia 19 (2012) 167 – 174 1876-6102 © 2012 Published by Elsevier Ltd. Selection and/or peer review under responsibility of The MEDGREEN Society. doi:10.1016/j.egypro.2012.05.196 The effect of heat gas nitriding on some mechanical properties of plain carbon steel B St-3 sp Afif Barhoum a , Badr Alaraj b a Asst. Professor at Physics Department, Faculty of Science, Tishreen University, Lattakia, Syria b Professor at Physics Department, Faculty of Science, Tishreen University, Lattakia, Syria Abstract This paper describes the effect of heat NH3-gas treatment of samples of plain carbon steel ( B St-3 sp) to improve some mechanical properties (hardness, corrosion rate ). The samples represent machine parts and tools . The purpose of sample treatment is to get more wear, fatigue and corrosion resistance under abnormal working conditions (pressure, temperature, etc.), keeping the core of samples flexible to absorb the exerted shocks. The study aims to determine the micro-hardness using Vickers tester , and it ranges between 150-400 kg/mm2. To verify this data the micro-structure of surface layers was studied by using optical microscope and scanning electron microscope (JMS- 6490LV). To examine corrosion resistance, the samples were monthly plunged in seawater for a period of Keywords plain carbon steel (B St3 sp) , nitriding, micro-hardness, microstructure, corrosion resistance; Introduction Increasing reliability and wear of machine parts, metal tools and utilities to improve their performance and productive life is a critical issue and thus economized consumption of metals and alloys and reduced corrosiveness at the present time. Changing the properties of surface layers in the desired direction is due, in part, heat treatment of surface layers of different metals and alloys. The chemical composition of ( B St-3 sp ) analyzed by spark emission spectrometer is shown in table 1 . Tab. 1 : chemical composition of ( B St-3 sp ), wt.% chemical composition C Si Mn P S Cr Ni Cu Fe GOST 380-94 0.14-0.22 0.12 0.3 0.4 0.65 <0.04 <0.05 <0.3 <0.3 <0.3 balance B St-3 sp Wt.% 0.18 0.16 0.48 0.02 0.04 0.15 0.2 0.18 balance Therefore, this research aimed to study the effect of surface layer saturation of plain carbon steel ( B St-3 sp ) with nitrogen on some mechanical properties. The most important factors of heat gas treatment are heat temperature and exposure time to temperature. However, heat gas treatment is associated with three symmetrically-speed processes: decomposition, adsorption and diffusion (Fig. 1). As a result of adsorption and diffusion, the surface layers are saturated with nitrogen interacting with base metal and other elements forming alloy, resulting in solid solutions or chemical compounds. Available online at www.sciencedirect.com © 2012 Published by Elsevier Ltd. Selection and/or peer review under responsibility of The MEDGREEN Society. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.

Transcript of The Effect of Heat Gas Nitriding on Some Mechanical ... · form tetrahedral sites with radius r tet...

Page 1: The Effect of Heat Gas Nitriding on Some Mechanical ... · form tetrahedral sites with radius r tet =0.23r Fe and the second ones build octahedral sites with radius r oct =0.41r Fe

Energy Procedia 19 ( 2012 ) 167 – 174

1876-6102 © 2012 Published by Elsevier Ltd. Selection and/or peer review under responsibility of The MEDGREEN Society.doi: 10.1016/j.egypro.2012.05.196

The effect of heat gas nitriding on some mechanical properties of plain carbon steel B St-3 sp

Afif Barhoum a, Badr Alaraj b

a Asst. Professor at Physics Department, Faculty of Science, Tishreen University, Lattakia, Syria bProfessor at Physics Department, Faculty of Science, Tishreen University, Lattakia, Syria

Abstract This paper describes the effect of heat NH3-gas treatment of samples of plain carbon steel ( B St-3 sp) to improve some mechanical properties (hardness, corrosion rate ). The samples represent machine parts and tools . The purpose of sample treatment is to get more wear, fatigue and corrosion resistance under abnormal working conditions (pressure, temperature, etc.), keeping the core of samples flexible to absorb the exerted shocks. The study aims to determine the micro-hardness using Vickers tester , and it ranges between 150-400 kg/mm2. To verify this data the micro-structure of surface layers was studied by using optical microscope and scanning electron microscope (JMS- 6490LV). To examine corrosion resistance, the samples were monthly plunged in seawater for a period of

© 2011 Published by Elsevier Ltd. Selection and/or peer-review under responsibility of [Medgreen-sy2011] Keywords plain carbon steel (B St3 sp) , nitriding, micro-hardness, microstructure, corrosion resistance;

Introduction Increasing reliability and wear of machine parts, metal tools and utilities to improve their performance and productive life is a critical issue and thus economized consumption of metals and alloys and reduced corrosiveness at the present time. Changing the properties of surface layers in the desired direction is due, in part, heat treatment of surface layers of different metals and alloys. The chemical composition of ( B St-3 sp ) analyzed by spark emission spectrometer is shown in table 1 .

Tab. 1 : chemical composition of ( B St-3 sp ), wt.%

chemical composition C Si Mn P S Cr Ni Cu Fe

GOST 380-94 0.14-0.22 0.12 0.3 0.4 0.65 <0.04 <0.05 <0.3 <0.3 <0.3 balance

B St-3 sp Wt.% 0.18 0.16 0.48 0.02 0.04 0.15 0.2 0.18 balance

Therefore, this research aimed to study the effect of surface layer saturation of plain carbon steel ( B St-3 sp ) with nitrogen on some mechanical properties.

The most important factors of heat gas treatment are heat temperature and exposure time to temperature. However, heat gas treatment is associated with three symmetrically-speed processes: decomposition, adsorption and diffusion (Fig. 1). As a result of adsorption and diffusion, the surface layers are saturated with nitrogen interacting with base metal and other elements forming alloy, resulting in solid solutions or chemical compounds.

Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

© 2012 Published by Elsevier Ltd. Selection and/or peer review under responsibility of The MEDGREEN Society.Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.

Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.

Page 2: The Effect of Heat Gas Nitriding on Some Mechanical ... · form tetrahedral sites with radius r tet =0.23r Fe and the second ones build octahedral sites with radius r oct =0.41r Fe

168 Afi f Barhoum and Badr Alaraj / Energy Procedia 19 ( 2012 ) 167 – 174

Fig. 1. diffusion of nitrogen in steel.

Iron nitrogen system:

The most important phases in the equilibrium case of Fe N system are the - phases (Fig. 2). They are in form of solid solutions and gases.

Fe, ferrite phase: is crystallized in the form of body centered cubic BCC. This structure contains two largest cavities: the first largest cavities form tetrahedral sites with radius rtet =0.29rFe and the second ones build octahedral sites with radius roct =0.15rFe where rFe -3]. Nitrogen occupies capillary pores and holes in surfaces.

-phase does not exceed 0.11% at eutectoid transformation while at room temperature is 0.004% (Fig. 2b).

Fe, austenite phase: Fe is arranged in a cubic close packed fashion FCC in the phase, where the atoms occupy all corners of the cube as well as centers of its faces .This structure contains two largest cavities: the first largest cavities form tetrahedral sites with radius rtet =0.23rFe and the second ones build octahedral sites with radius roct =0.41rFe where rNi = 0.55rFe. Thus, the interstitial cavities in phase are larger than those phase, allowing greater solubility of nitrogen in phase. Maximum value of nitrogen solubility in phase is about wt. 2.8% (Fig. 2a). When temperature rises to 950 0 C, the phase is moved to eutectoid dissociation ' . At

over cooling conditions of phase, the austenite phase is transformed to martensite phase which is a solid solution of nitrogen in phase. Saturated martensite with nitrogen has a unit cell of centered tetrahedral sides, the nitrogen atoms are distributed in the symmetric centers in the sides of the unit cell, causing deformation of iron crystal.

phase (Fe4N): is a solid solution stable up to temperature 670 0C, and with increasing temperature it is transformed - phase. - phase is crystallized in BCC and the nitrogen is dissolved in the centers of the unit cell (1/2 , 1/2

,1/2). - phase (Fe2-3 N): is a solid solution crystallized in the close packed hexagonal type where the maximum nitrogen

solubility is (wt. :4.55 11%) (Fig. 2). At temperature 650 0 -phase is subjected to phase dissociation '

.Nitrogen atoms are distributed in the gaps and pores which are formed under the surface. The maximum of nitrogen solubility in this phase is up to 4.5%.

Page 3: The Effect of Heat Gas Nitriding on Some Mechanical ... · form tetrahedral sites with radius r tet =0.23r Fe and the second ones build octahedral sites with radius r oct =0.41r Fe

Afi f Barhoum and Badr Alaraj / Energy Procedia 19 ( 2012 ) 167 – 174 169

- phase (Fe2 N): is a solid solution crystallized in the cubic system where the maximum nitrogen solubility is (wt. :11.07 11.18%) - phase where the iron atoms are replaced by nitrogen atoms.

Fig. 2. (a) phase diagram Fe - N, (b) nitrogen solubility in the ferrite [4].

Structure of the nitrided external surface:

By nitriding, compounds or nitrides are formed in the surface layer of the interactive diffusion zone. As soon as iron and its alloys are saturated with nitrogen phase (Fe2-3 N) is directly formed on the surface followed by a layer of

' phase (Fe4 N), [4,5].

Based on the structure of iron alloys the amount and composition of phases are changed according to elements forming alloy, for example (Mn, Cr, Mo, etc.,) with the exception of elements (Al, Si, Ti) which reduce nitrogen solubility in the - phase, thus causing lower nitrogen concentration and thickness of the nitrided layer, while the presence of these

elements develops the nitrided layer of ' phase with formation of continuous layers or layers of the needle shapes on the borders of slides and granules probably extending to great depth, resulting in fragility of interactive diffusion zone. Also, a high concentration of nitrogen in the nitrided layers forms phase (Fe2 N) which

-phase is cooled, where the concentration of nitrogen is (wt. 11% - 11.32% N). When steel is nitrided by rich gas ammonia, nitrides and oxides are formed. Here it is noteworthy that nitriding in medium rich in nitrogen can be associated with frangibility of surface layers and appearance of pores, thus destroying this layer [6,7].

Depending on research findings of [8,11] the generated pores and cracks appear in the at nitrogen concentration of more than wt.8.15% in the nitrided layer. This part of the nitrided layer, once cooled quickly, remains single phase with a low concentration of nitrogen wt. 6.1% - 7.15%. Following slow cooling the nitrided layer becomes

' phase. ' as time of nitriding increases, but more cracks -phase.

Page 4: The Effect of Heat Gas Nitriding on Some Mechanical ... · form tetrahedral sites with radius r tet =0.23r Fe and the second ones build octahedral sites with radius r oct =0.41r Fe

170 Afi f Barhoum and Badr Alaraj / Energy Procedia 19 ( 2012 ) 167 – 174

Structure of the nitrided internal layer:

The internal nitrided zone is multiphase: solid solutions of fundamental metal nitrides, nitrides of elements forming alloy and others. Based on the chemical activity of alloy elements two zones of internal nitriding can be observed: The first consists technically of pure metals and low amounts of nitrides of alloy elements. These zones consist of solid solutions. The micro-hardness of the first type is low (150 300 kg/mm2), but it increases the capacity of steel overload [12-17].

The second type is formed in alloy elements more compatible with nitrogen than the base metal, so the nitrogen is significantly dissolved in these elements and its diffusive movement is greater than that of elements forming alloy.

Importance and aims of research:

The importance of this research is to maximize the hardness of the surface layers of steel tools and pieces of special interest, and thus to resist abrasion and corrosion. Simultaneously, the inner part remains flexible to absorb the shock to which the pieces are experienced during the service. Therefore, the purpose of this study was:

1. determine the micro-hardness of plain carbon steel ( B St-3 sp ) after heat gas treatment by Vickers method using MHT-3 tester.

2. study the microstructure after heat gas nitriding using optical microscope MNM-8 and scanning electron microscope (JMS- 6490LV).

3. for testing corrosion resistance, the samples were monthly plunged in seawater for a year, and the monthly corrosion rate )%/( mm was determined using the electronic balance mmin = 0.01gr.

Experimental Procedure:

The samples of plain carbon steel ( B St-3 sp)were prepared in the form of cylinder bars with 6 8 mm diameter and 50mm long. They were placed in a quartz tube for 45min inside the heat chamber of electric furnace at room temperature (Fig.3). Meanwhile, the ammonia gas was pumped into the chamber to discharge air from the system. Nitriding was conducted in the quartz tube for 8 h at temperatures (600 0C , 800 0C , 950 0C). Temperature was measured using the thermocouple of platinum at accuracy ± 10 0C. Speed of gas flow to operating medium was 25cm3/min. After nitriding the samples were left cooling inside the heat chamber to room temperature. For micro-hardness measurements, the samples were ejected from the furnace, from each sample a transitional cross-section was made and in good way sophisticated . To determine the micro-structure and phase types, a developing process for samples was carried out by means of 96% ethanol plus 4% HNO3. On the other side, for determining the corrosion rate the samples were put together in a cloth sac and then it was monthly immersed in seawater for a year. After that, each month the samples were pulled out from the seawater, cleaned, dried, weighed and then again returned to the seawater.

Page 5: The Effect of Heat Gas Nitriding on Some Mechanical ... · form tetrahedral sites with radius r tet =0.23r Fe and the second ones build octahedral sites with radius r oct =0.41r Fe

Afi f Barhoum and Badr Alaraj / Energy Procedia 19 ( 2012 ) 167 – 174 171

Fig. 3: Diagram of the apparatus used in heat gas treatment of samples. 1.ammonia cylinder; 2 cylinder of butane and propane (for treatment by gas mixture);

3 , 4 valves ; 5 ,6 ,7 control valves; 8 , 9 gas pressure gauges; 10 electric heat assembly; 11 quartz tube; 12 samples; 13 power supply; 14 water basin.

Results and Discussion:

The micro-hardness was determined by using Vickers technique where small loads p were used with load-time (5 - 10 sec). The micro- hardness of materials is considered as ratio between loading and impact of the printed area A on the surface of the sample under study . The number of micro-hardness HV is given by the following relation [3 , 4]:

/mmN , dp1.8544 )2/sin(2 2

2ApHV

0 the angle between the two adjacent sides of the diamond pyramid whose base is square, d is the average

diameter of the spurred mark on the surface of the sample.

Figure 4 shows the results of distributed micro- hardness in terms of thickness of the diffusion layer in (B St-3 sp)after NH3 gas heat treatment at temperatures (600 oC, 800 oC, 950 oC) for 8 h. This profile shows that the micro-hardness at 600 0C fluctuated in the range (150 300 Kg/mm2). The major contribution to increase the micro-hardness is ascribed

phase which contains pores and voids filled with atomic nitrogen. Increasing temperature to 800 0C the micro-hardness values ranged in the interval (150 420 kg/mm2). Major increase in micro- ' phase (solid solutions of nitrides Fe4 N). Moreover, low overlap of hardness distribution curves at the surface layer at different temperatures and a sharp decline of the hardness of the layer near the surface were noticed at 800 0C. With increasing temperature to 950 0 -phase disappears and the micro-hardness ranging in the interval (150 350 kg/mm2). This is consistent with the results of [5,6]. Fe uniform layer, but

- layer where nitriding will continue because the holes and gaps in this case are filled with atomic nitrogen considered as reservoirs for the supply of nitrogen atoms moving between holes and pores, resulting in continuous nitriding even after stopping ammonia gas pumping into treatment chamber.

To verify this data we studied the micro-structure of the ( B St-3 sp ) with a optical microscope (Fig. 5) which shows the change of micro-structure in terms of temperature after nitriding for 8 h and using scanning electron microscope (JMS 6490 LV) equipped with X-ray scanner to determine the distribution the main element concentration of the entire thickness of the diffusion layer after nitriding (Fig. 6). Figure 7 shows the resistance of plain carbon steel ( B St-3 sp ) after heat gas nitriding against corrosion when the samples are immersed in seawater for one year near Higher Institute for Marine Research in Lattakia where seawater pH is 8.2 and the salinity 38.3

Page 6: The Effect of Heat Gas Nitriding on Some Mechanical ... · form tetrahedral sites with radius r tet =0.23r Fe and the second ones build octahedral sites with radius r oct =0.41r Fe

172 Afi f Barhoum and Badr Alaraj / Energy Procedia 19 ( 2012 ) 167 – 174

distance from the surface , mm

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5

Hard

ness

,Kg/m

m2

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

600 0C800 0C950 0Cuntreated at RT

Fig. 4. Correlation between HV with depth for plain carbon steel (B St-3 sp)

After heat gas nitriding.

Fig. 5. Micro-structure of the ( B St-3 sp) after heat gas nitriding with a scanning electron microscope. (a) untreated case (preliminary case ), (b) after heat gas nitriding for 8h, 600 oC, (c) after heat gas nitriding gas for 8h, 800 oC, (d) after heat gas nitriding for 8h at 950 oC.(X200)

(a) (b) (d)(c)

Page 7: The Effect of Heat Gas Nitriding on Some Mechanical ... · form tetrahedral sites with radius r tet =0.23r Fe and the second ones build octahedral sites with radius r oct =0.41r Fe

Afi f Barhoum and Badr Alaraj / Energy Procedia 19 ( 2012 ) 167 – 174 173

Fig. 6. Micro-structure of the ( B St-3 sp ) after heat gas nitriding taken by scanning electron microscope. (a) after heat gas nitriding for 8h at 950 0C (b) distribution of the concentration of elements (nitrogen, oxygen, carbon) in the sample.

month

oct/09

nov/09

dec/09

jan/10

feb/10

mar/10

apr/1

0

may/10

jun/10jul/1

0au

g/10se

p/10

m/m

)%

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

1.4

1.6

nonnitridingT=600 0CT=800 0CT=950 0C

Fig. 7. represents corrosion rate after sample ( B St-3 sp ) immersion in seawater for one year

Conclusions and Recommendations: 1. An increase in the thickness -layer in interactive zone by 1.5 times than the diffusion zone was noticed. It is ascribed to the available of pores - phase, which explain the much larger solubility of nitrogen in this phase. 2. Heat gas (NH3) treatment increased micro-hardness about 2.5 times in the diffusion layer, keeping the core sample flexible to absorb external shocks and stresses. 3 . An increase in ( B St-3 sp ) resistance against corrosion after nitriding above Curie temperature due to seawater compared with its resistance to corrosion at a temperature lower than the Curie point. This may be due to the heterogeneity of the surface layer nitriding in the latter case. 4. Further study on the effect of gas mixture on the mechanical properties of ( B St-3 sp ) is recommended.

References

[1] Ivatkalcec , Mechanical properties and microstructure of a high carbon steel -2004,these N0 3089 , p.6, Croatia.[2] Yakub Adesoga Tijani , modeling and simulation of thermochemical heat treatment processes (a phase field calculation of nitriding in steel) 2008,Dissertation,p.10, Uni. Bremen,Germany.

[3] M.G. Krukovich, Simulation of the nitriding process. MiTTM , Moscow ,- -2004-24-31

(b)

Page 8: The Effect of Heat Gas Nitriding on Some Mechanical ... · form tetrahedral sites with radius r tet =0.23r Fe and the second ones build octahedral sites with radius r oct =0.41r Fe

174 Afi f Barhoum and Badr Alaraj / Energy Procedia 19 ( 2012 ) 167 – 174

[4] V.Ya Syropyatov, V.M. Zintchenko, Yu.A. Perekatov, Current concept of the nitrogen potential . MiTTM , Moscow ,- -2004--.7-12

[5] . . , . . , . . . : . 7--

[6] .- M OM - -1980 12-15

[7] Yu.P.Trykov, A.F .Trudov, I.B. Stepanishchev ,Structure and properties of explosive welded joints of carbon steels MiTTM , Moscow ,- -2002 -26-30

[8] , , -. M OM, - -2008 . 42-45 .

[9] , , .- -. M OM - -2010 - 29-36

[10]Yu.M.Buravlev, M.P .Kushnir,O.G. Myloslavskyy, A. barhoum.- The peculiarities of formation the upper layers of steels after their gas chemical and physical treatment,-Bulletin of Donetsk National University, Series A. Natural Sciences,- Donetsk,- 2010 , 107-111.

[11] - --

[12] , -- , M OM - -2009 33- 39

[13] -. M OM - -2008 44-48.

[14] , ., -2005.-

[15] Yu.P.Trykov, A.F.Trudov, S.V.Klochkov.,Influence of the deformation conditions on the local weakening of explosively welded St3 + 12X18H10T steel bimetal Steel in Translation. 2007. . .p. 918-919.

[16] M. Goodarzi, S.P.H. Marashi, M. Pouranvari . Dependence of overload performance on weld attributes for resistance spot welded galvanized low carbon steel , Journal of Materials Processing Technology , Moscow.- 2009, T 209.- -4384. [17] Yu.M.Buravlev, M.P .Kushnir,O.G. Myloslavskyy, A. barhoum.- -

-20 P. 301.