The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity...
Transcript of The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity...
![Page 1: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment The Dutch exposimeter study:
Developing an Activity ExposureMatrix (EMF – AEM)John FB Bolte*, M Pruppers, J Kamer, G van der Zande, C Schipper, S Fleurke, T Kluwer, H Kromhout and I van Kamp – Paris, 17 December 2009
![Page 2: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 2National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Goal of EMF-AEM project
• In Dutch national EMF&Health Programme by ZonMw
• Characterise “true” exposure during everyday activities in
13 frequency bands
• Develop a tool to select highly vs. lowly
exposed groups without actually measuring
• Preparation future epidemiological studies
• Collaboration:
![Page 3: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 3National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
1. Calibration and Uncertainties
2. Scenario driven measurements temporary workers• carrying RF- and ELF-exposimeter, GPS and diary• building Activity Exposure Matrix (AEM) for
30 common everyday activities1 ELF magnetic and 12 RF-communication bands
3. Population driven survey on volunteers (N=100)• testing AEM and questionnaire on daily activity patttern
for prediction qualitiesA Cross-sectional study on aspecific effects
B Cohort study on hard end effects
Stages of EMF-AEM project
National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
![Page 4: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 4National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
The measurement set
ELF magnetic
radio frequency
gps
![Page 5: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 5National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
ELF measurements in 1 band
• 8 EMDEX Lite- Bandwidth 40 - 1000 Hz- Sampling interval 4 s - 20 min - Dimensions 1.0” x 2.4” x 4.7” (2.5 x 6.0 x 12.0 cm)- Weight 6 ounces (170 grams)- Data Memory 512Kb- Meas. Accuracy ±4 %
• Powerlines, powergrid, household appliances, tools
![Page 6: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 6National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
RF measurements• 11 EME Spy (12 bands) Satimo
(formerly known as Antennessa)
Not included:
GSM-r 876.1 MHz
Mariphone 156 MHz
Amateurradio 146 MHz
etc
![Page 7: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 7National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Measurement uncertainties using the EME SPY 121
![Page 8: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 8National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Correction factors: what to do?• Goal:
- Equalise differences between EME Spy units (necessary for contrast between activities)
- Equalise differences between frequency bands (less necessary, only for “true” exposure)
• Based on:- Out of band response- Precision within band- Response at middle of band - Multiple signals / sources- Isotropy / influence of body- Polarisation
• Do these features change over time???
![Page 9: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 9National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
CalibrationGHz Transverse ElectroMagnetic (GTEM) cell
Do all devices measure the same field?
![Page 10: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 10National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
GTEM - EME Spy 121 Z-axis response
0,000,501,001,502,002,503,003,504,004,50
FM
TV3TETRATV4&5GSM txGSM rxDCS txDCS rx
DECTUMTS txUMTS rx
WIFI
Elec
tric
Fie
ld (V
/m)
1234567891011
Input = 2.5 V/m
unit 1: broke, repaired unit 2: tends to give higher registrations than rest
Variability per unit ☺
Too low: UMTStx, DECT, DCSrx, DCStx
Correction factors (input/response) typically 0.7 – 1.5
![Page 11: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 11National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Variability EME Spy 120 (France)
![Page 12: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 12National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Variability within frequencyband ☺
GTEM - EME Spy 121 Z-axis response
0,000,501,001,502,002,503,003,504,004,50
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Unit no
Elec
tric
Fie
ld in
V/m
FMTV3TETRATV4&5GSM txGSM rxDCS txDCS rxDECTUMTS txUMTS rxWIFI
Too low: UMTStx, DECT, DCSrx, DCStx
Input = 2.5 V/m
![Page 13: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 13National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
0 1 2 3 4 5 6input (V/m)
outp
ut (V
/m) FM
TV3TETRATV4_5GSMtx (UL)GSMrx (DL)DCStx (UL)DCSrx (DL)DECTUMTStx (UL)UMTSrx (DL)WIFI
Linearity (trendlines) ☺
![Page 14: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 14National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Out of band resp & precision within band
7
TDMA
TDMA
TDMA
TDMA
•Input 2.5 V/m
Unit 7
![Page 15: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 15National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Out-of-band response in field ☺/
-DCSrx -> DECT, DCStx, UMTSrx-UMTSrx ! -> GSMrx
![Page 16: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 16National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Open Area Test Site (OATS)
![Page 17: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 17National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Influence of the body (linear V/m scale)
0º 45º 90º 135º 180º 225º 270º 315º
•Vertical Polarisation•Input 2.5 V/m
•0
•1
•2
•3
•4
•5•0º
•45º
•90º
•135º
•180º
•225º
•270º
•315º
•input 2,5 V/m•FM (V/m)•TV3 (V/m)•TV4&5 (V/m)•GSMrx (DL) (V/m)•DCSrx (DL) (V/m)•UMTStx (UL) (V/m)•UMTSrx (DL) (V/m)•WIFI (V/m)
•Horizontal Polarisation•Input 2.5 V/m V/m
•0
•1
•2
•3
•4
•5
•6•0º
•45º
•90º
•135º
•180º
•225º
•270º
•315º
•input 2,5 V/m•FM (V/m)•TV3 (V/m)•TV4&5 (V/m)•GSMrx (DL) (V/m)•DCSrx (DL) (V/m)•UMTStx (UL) (V/m)•UMTSrx (DL) (V/m)•WIFI (V/m)
unit 7
![Page 18: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 18National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Concluding remarks
• Correction factors for different response of 11 RF exposimeters necessary, based on:
- Out of band response test software filter ☺/- Precision within band fin=unknown error margin- Influence of body motion average? ☺/- Polarisation reflections average? ☺/- Multiple signals / sources no detect unknown error- Response & linearity constant factor input/response ☺
• Do these features change over time???
![Page 19: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 19National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Measurements & observations
![Page 20: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 20National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Magnetic B-fieldfor activities in city centre
BikeInside shop
Walk
Inside shop
Walk
Bike
Train
Home
Anti-theft
What is this?
Railway station
![Page 21: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 21National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Magnetic B-fieldin and around Utrecht city
train station
walk
bike
bike
escalators
![Page 22: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 22National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Temporal differences B-field:same location, different timebike - 21:15 bike 16:45
0,4micro-tesla
![Page 23: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 23National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Electric E-field activities in city centre
BikeInside shop
Walk
Inside shop
Walk
Bike
Train
Home Railway station
Bike
![Page 24: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 24National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
train station
walk
bike
bike
GSM, DCS and UMTS basestations
![Page 25: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 25National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
train station
walk
bike
bike
FM and TV broadcasting
![Page 26: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 26National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Some preliminary outcomes on the scenario driven survey …
![Page 27: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 27National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Spatial differences: GSMrx transportation
0
0,02
0,04
0,06
0,08
0,1
O P S O P S S O P S O P S O P S
BU FI MO TM TR VO
V
E-fie
ld(V
/m)
B R C B R CB R C B R C B R CC
Bus Bike Metro Tram Train On foot
Built up area - Rural - Centre
![Page 28: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 28National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
StageIIb: Mean GSMrx
walk
bike
bus / minibus
tram, metro
metro underg
train
station large
bus-metro-tram stop
relaxing outdoor (excl transportation)
shop outdoor (market)
shop - daily / supermarket
shop - mall / large store
shop - in shops at open street
sleeping
ng up / walk around / rummaging around
(game) computer or game console
0.00
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
![Page 29: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 29National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Stage III: Fieldwork
• September 2009 – January 2010• N=100 selected in Amsterdam and surroundings• screened for diversity:
- sex- Living environment and housing
• city centre, city, city outskirts, village centre, village outskirts• single, chained, appartment building
- employed / unemployed- main mode of transportation- Age: 18-24, 25-35, 35-45, 45-55, 55-65, 65-
![Page 30: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 30National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Concluding Remarks
• Correction factors due to calibration of the EME Spy are necessary, range for E-field: 0.7 – 1.5
• Body shielding should be taken into account and can leadto 2 dB measurement error
• Contrasting everyday activities can be found, - main differences RF indoor – outdoor, highest at station
• Temporal differences day – night• Spatial differences Centre – Built-up area – Rural
- Centre / Rural GSMrx: factor 5
![Page 31: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 31National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Acknowledgements
• The EMF-AEM team at RIVM, Radio Communications Agency and Utrecht University
• The Netherlands organisation for health research and development (ZonMw) for funding this study under the Dutch national Electromagnetic Fields & Health Programme
![Page 32: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 32National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Stage IIb: dayscenarios & routesDayScenario 2: Rotterdam - Den Haag - late
Start time: 12.00u
End time: 21.00u
The scenario starts at 12.00u at Utrecht Central station. Preferred is to come to the station by bike, because you have to cycle around in the evening. If it is not possible to bring your bike, then rent a bike at the station.
•12.03 – 12.33u Take the train at Utrecht Central Station to Rotterdam Alexander (platform (railway) 9a)
•12.33 – 12.50u Walk around at the station and walk to the subway (Do not forget to buy an OV-chipkaart in this time also!)
•12.51 – 13.20u Take the subway at12.51u in the direction of Rotterdam Central There is a transfer/switch-over at metrostation(subwaystation) Beurs (see routedescription1).
•13.20 - 13.35u Walk out of Rotterdam Central Station in the direction of Schouwburgplein and enter café Floor (Schouwburgplein 28, see routedescription 2).
![Page 33: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 33National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Stage IIb: dayscenarios & routes
![Page 34: The Dutch exposimeter study: Developing an Activity ...whist.institut-telecom.fr/JourneeBio2009/09-Bolte.pdfNational Institute for Public Health and the Environment The Dutch exposimeter](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022012000/6072613e6271f7179f421f0c/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Whist Lab, Paris, –17 December 2009
John Bolte 34National Institutefor Public Healthand the Environment
Future plans
• Indoor measurements at home of volunteers• Calculate exposure model Buergi similar to uergi et al.
2009 and Frei et al. 2009• Prediction model of exposure• Application of Activity Exposure Matrix in:
- Cross-sectional study on aspecific effects (RIVM)- Cohort study on hard endpoints (Utrecht University)