The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and...

26
p is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces str ooth, like old lettering scored on a stone; es – since the people who left them tarried ave repeated their months ordinary and sacr ed to ask the place – but how can we questi ocks, whose speech is incomprehensible? Labíd ibn Rabi'a, c. 600 CE (trans. after AJ Arberry and Eric Ormsby)

Transcript of The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and...

Page 1: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos,at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate –and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped,made smooth, like old lettering scored on a stone;the ashes – since the people who left them tarried hereyears have repeated their months ordinary and sacred.…I stopped to ask the place – but how can we questionsolid rocks, whose speech is incomprehensible?…

Labíd ibn Rabi'a, c. 600 CE(trans. after AJ Arberry and Eric Ormsby)

Page 2: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

The Sahara landscape over the Holocene

• life in the Hoggar (southern Algeria) c.9000 to 4000 BP

• stratigraphic approaches to reconstructing Saharan vegetation and hydrology

• a chronology

• a speculation

Nir Krakauer

Page 3: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

the setting

Hoggar

Aïr

Tibesti

Page 4: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

Hoggar

Tassilin’Ajjer

Page 5: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

the Tassili n’AjjerAtlantis,

199

0

Page 6: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.
Page 7: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

Henri LhoteM. Henri Lhote (1956)

Page 8: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

copying the picturesrock…

to paper

Page 9: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

the ‘round-headed’, hunting phases

Page 10: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

herding (Bovidian) phases

Page 11: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.
Page 12: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.
Page 13: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

What happened?

• a chronology of Holocene conditions in the Sahara has been reconstructed primarily from the following 14C datable materials:– ocean sediments– lake-bed carbonates, peat,diatoms – pollen

Page 14: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

the Sahara was dustier at the

glacial maximum…

Ruddiman 1997

Page 15: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

and less dusty in the mid-Holocene

Page 16: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

Hoelzmann, Jolly et al 1998

pollen sitessabkhas, middens…

Page 17: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

some vegetation m

apping: a legend

(E Shulz &

coworkers)

Page 18: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

N Africa 8,000 y before-present

Page 19: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

nowadays

Page 20: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

the expandable Chad-Niger basin

Page 21: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

the Servants: some lake level histories

Servant and Servant-Vildary 1980

Page 22: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

the P/E index -diatom reconstructionServant and Servant-Vildary 1980

Page 23: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

savanna

desert

Lake Chadbasin moisture

% terr. offMauritania

degradation

N Nigerpollen

Sahelriverdeposits

14CkyBP

ephemeralbraided

meandering

deflationbraided

deflationbraided

ephemeral

Tibestisilt terraces

aeolian + calcrete

humanartifacts

more sites

epi-paleolithic

neolithic

potterysheep& cow domestic

herding spreads

round -head

period?

Bovid

ian period?

Egypt: Old Kingdom

the bigpicture

Page 24: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

a speculation on the Afroasiatic language family

or, Fermi’s question

Egyptian

5000

Akkadian4500

Canaanite3800

Somali

N Arabic2000

Hausa

Amharic1700

S Arabic2700

Page 25: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

credits• z

http://www.nationalgeographic.com/resources/ngo/maps/view/africam.html

• http://perso.wanadoo.fr/mohamed.sahnoun/Images/algeriamap.jpeg

• http://www.tara.org.uk/images/tassili.gif• http://www.paleologos.com/• http://rsta.pucmm.edu.do/biblioteca/pinacoteca/arte

%20prehistorico/prehistoria%20p1.htm• http://home.t-online.de/home/Jochen_Baumann/ • http://worldroom.tamu.edu/mideast/photos/sts036-152-252.jpg• http://www.edunetconnect.com/cat/timemachine/images/

scan1.gif• http://www.uni-wuerzburg.de/geographie/fachi/

pal_atlas_afrika/index_atlas.htm#start• http://www.ship.edu/~cgboeree/languagefamilies.html

Page 26: The camp is effaced, its pavilions and lean-tos, at Miná – both Ghawl and Rijám desolate – and the torrent-beds of Er-Raiyán—their traces stripped, made.

printed referencesLhote H (trans. A Brodrick) The Search for the Tassili Frescoes, New York, 1959

• Ruddiman WF, Marine Geology 136:189-207(1997)• deMenocal P, J Ortiz et al Quat Sci Rev 16:347-

61(2000)• Hoelzmann P, D Jolly et al Global Biogeochem Cycles

12:35-51(1998)• Schulz E, Hydrobiologia 214:359-65(1991)• Talbot MR, in The Sahara and the Nile (MAJ Williams

and H Faure, eds.), 37-62, Rotterdam, 1980 • Servant M and Servant-Vildary S, in The Sahara and the

Nile (MAJ Williams and H Faure, eds.), 133-162