Technology Assessment Framework - TAF
description
Transcript of Technology Assessment Framework - TAF
Technology Assessment Framework -TAF
Sekuma Simon PeterNETWAS UgandaNSWG
Introduction
Water & sanitation services fail due to choice of technology e.g. a good percentage of rural water supply schemes in Uganda are not functioning
Promising technologies frequently do not go beyond the pilot stage.
WASHTech Project has 2 main outputs; TAF, Technology Introduction Process (TIP) guide
Introduction
TAF- A decision making tool on the applicability and sustainable use of a specific WASH technology and on its readiness for introduction within a specific context
Use To stimulate discussion about a WASH technology To assess the potential of a particular WASH technology in a
specific geographic and socio-economic context Assess readiness of a sector to scale up a technology Support M& E systems for technology introduction
Design Participatory tool that brings together user, regulator, and
producer/provider perspective Field data is collected by a diverse stakeholder group and verified in
workshops Designed to assess a single WASH technology
The TAF
Steps in the TAF Assessment
Screening & In-depth Assessment
The Process
Collection of relevant information for
specific technology.
Orientation workshop/ Training of field
staff
Field survey using guiding questions-
User, producer, regulator perspectives
Preliminary analysis and validation &
scoring in a workshop
National level scoring workshop
Scoring & Results
Technologies tested – UgandaCountry Technology Original rating New ratingBurkina Faso Rope Pump Promising Successful
VIP Latrine Successful SuccessfulIndia Mark II Successful SuccessfulUDDT Successful SuccessfulSand Dam New PromisingWater Harvesting Tank New Promising
Ghana Rope Pump Promising PromisingPour Flush Promising PromisingEnviroloo Failed FailedGhana Modified India Mark II Successful SuccessfulBiofil Toilet New PromisingSlow Sand Filter Successful Successful
Uganda Rope Pump Failed FailedUDDT Successful FailedSolar Water Pump New PromisingU2 Pump Successful SuccessfulFerro Cement Tank Promising SuccessfulTippy Tap No conclusion No conclusion
Urine Diversion Dry Toilets (UDDT)Successful and particular conditions Suitable for water
logged areas and collapsing soils,
Suitable at HH level Not suitable for public
places- need for a strict O&M system.
Gap at introduction- no design for Muslim community
U2 PUMP Suitable for deep wells Easy to operate/ man Available HPMs for
minor and major repairs. Limited knowledge on
minor maintenance/ repairs by the communities
Highlights per technology
Rope pump Viewed as promising as
opposed to failed The pump is still being
used in pockets (afew places, 7 pumps in total)
Not suitable for capacities beyond 300 HH
Very slow and low uptake Well managed at individual
level Issues of contamination
Tippy Tap Confirmed to be promising Low cost; available
L/material Mechanism of use prevents
contamination 20% of technology adopters
do abandon them while replication was estimated at about 30% (ACORD).
Gap-lack of a policy framework and standards.
Highlights per technology
UGA pump Fabrication of the NIIRA pump New technology (2009) Still being piloted and yet to be approved by the ministry Installed No. is about 30 in the country. Viewed as a suitable option for shallow wells. Suitable for Rural communities No break downs have been experiences.
Highlights per technology
TAF is well received in Uganda Global WASH professionals contacted confirm value of
processes & tools for evaluating & monitoring Embedding process resulted in agreed TAF hosts; Uganda- the
Appropriate Technology Centre (ATC) under the Ministry of Water & Environment
Tools have the potential to be used for urban water & sanitation technologies
Training Institutes to consider processes & TAF in their syllabi TAF recommended for adaptation in other countries for
sustainable WASH services
Conclusions & Recommendations
Thank you
For more info:Visit www.washtechafrica.wordpress.comwww.rural-water-supply.net/enwww.netwasuganda.orgwww.washuganda.net