8/6/2019 Tech Report NWU-EECS-11-06: Ranking continuous nearest neighbors for uncertain trajectories: Full and Peer Revie

1/31

Y`anekacf _`wdry

ERP-@@AQ-33-7:

_cehkeb adeykepdpq e`cr`qy e`kbnodrq jdr pea`rycke yrcl`aydrk`q

8/6/2019 Tech Report NWU-EECS-11-06: Ranking continuous nearest neighbors for uncertain trajectories: Full and Peer Revie

2/31

ZFIO Ldprecf mcepqarkwy Ed%.kff o` keq`ry`i o{ yn` `ikydr+

_cehkeb Adeykepdpq E`cr`qy E`kbnodrq jdr Pea`ryckeYrcl`aydrk`q< Jpff cei W``r _`zk``i Caa`wy`i Z`rqkde

Bda` Yrcla`zqhk _do`ryd Ycmcqqkc Kqco`f J% Arp| W`y`rQan`p`rmcee Iczki Ncrybfcqq Anrkqydwn`r \cmk`rdqhk

_`a`kz`i< icy` $ Caa`wy`i< icy`

Coqyrcay Ynkq crykaf` ciir`qq`q yn` wrdof`m dj w`r-jdrmkeb E`cr`qy E`kbnodr .EE+ sp`rk`q ke c Mdzkeb

Dol`ayq Icycocq` .MDI+ n`e yn` yrcl`aydrk`q dj yn`dol`ayq cr` pea`rycke Yn` ceq`r yd ce EE sp`r{ jdra`rycke yrcl`aydrk`q kq ykm` wcrcm`y`rk|`i ip` yd yn`adeykepdpq ecypr` dj yn` mdykde Nd`z`r& jdr pea`r-ycke yrcl`aydrk`q& `z`e ke c qkebf` ykm` keqycey yn`r` mc{

o` q`z`rcf dol`ayq yncy ncz` c ede-|`rd wrdocokfky{ djo`keb c e`cr`qy e`kbnodr yd c bkz`e dol`ay Ynkq jcay cj-

j`ayq yn` q`mceykaq dj yn` ceq`r yd ce EE sp`r{ce``ay yncy kq jpryn`r cmwfkffi`i n`e yn` sp`r{ qwceq

dz`r c ykm` key`rzcf R` acwypr` yn` kmwcay yncy yn`pea`ryckey{ dj yn` yrcl`aydrk`q ncq de yn` q`mceykaq djyn` ceq`r yd adeykepdpq EE sp`rk`q cei ` wrdwdq` c

yr`` qyrpaypr` jdr r`wr`q`eykeb yn` ceq`rq& cfdeb kyn`fiak`ey cfbdrkynmq yd admwpy` yn`m R` cfqd ciir`qqyn` kqqp` dj w`rjdrmkeb EE sp`rk`q n`e yn` mdykde

dj yn` dol`ayq kq r`qyrkay`i yd rdci e`ydrhq Jkecff{&

_`q cran qpwwdry i ke wcry o{ EQJ ccriq AAJ7>1739;&AEQ7;37;0?& KKQ7031001& cei KKQ-7>3??0>& cei o{ yn`A`ey`r jdr B`dm`yrka Admwpykeb cy Orde Pekz`rqky{%

B% Yrcla`zqhk& W% Qan`p`rmcee& I% Ncrybfcqq& A% \cmk`rdqhkI`wcrym`ey dj @f`ayrkacf @ebke``rkeb cei Admwpy`r Qak`ea`Edryn`qy`re Pekz`rqky{Wnde`< (3->92-9;3-27:;Jc~< (3->92-9;3-9900@-mckf< bda`&w`y`rq&iczki-n&anrkq-|G` aq%edryn qy`re%`ip

_% YcmcqqkcI`wcrym`ey dj Admwpy`r Qak`ea`Orde Pekz`rqky{Wrdzki`ea`& _K 7?;3?@-mckf< ryGaq%orde%`ip

K% J% Arp|I`wcrym`ey dj Admwpy`r Qak`ea`Pekz`rqky{ dj Kffkedkq cy AnkacbdAnkacbd& KF :7:3?@-mckf< kjaGaq%pka%`ip

` jdrmcff{ i`ffie` cei qnd nd yd `fiak`eyf{ `~`apy`q`z rcf zcrkceyq dj adeykepdpq EE sp`rk`q Dpr wrd-

ydy{w` kmwf`m`eycykde cei `~w`rkm`eyq i`mdeqyrcy`yncy yn` wrdwdq`i cfbdrkynmq {k`fi qkbekffiacey w`rjdr-

mcea` kmwrdz`m`eyq n`e admwcr`i kyn yn` adrr`-qwdeikeb ecz` cwwrdcan`q

H`{driq E`cr`qy E`kbnodr Pea`ryckey{ MdzkebDol`ayq Icycocq`

3 Keyrdipaykde

C ordci q`y dj cwwfkacykdeq keafpikeb yrcfia mce-

cb`m`ey& `m`rb`ea{ r`qwdeq & ikqcqy r r`m`ikcykde&adey`~y-ccr` ydprkqy kejdrmcykde& cei ocyyf`ffi`fi mce-cb`m`ey& r`spkr` qdm` y{w` dj fdacykde-ocq`i q`rzka`q.FOQ+ X:7] Qpan q`rzka`q r`f{ de yn` n`r`codpyq keykm` cei qwca` dj yn` wcrykakwcykeb mdokf` `eykyk`q cei

r`spkr` jpeicm`eycf y`aneksp`q ke yn` ffi`fi dj Mdz-keb Dol`ay Icycocq`q .MDI+ X?1]& nkan keafpi` `fi-ak`ey qydrcb`$r`yrk`zcf dj .fdacykde& ykm`+ kejdrmcykde&cfdeb kyn yn` `fiak`ey wrda`qqkeb dj zcrkdpq qwcykd-y`mwdrcf sp`rk`q dj key`r`qy& `b& rceb`& i`eqky{& zcrk-

ceyq dj e`cr`qy e`kbnodr .r`z`rq`& qprjca`& cbbr`bcy`+&cei qh{fke` X:&39&3>&??&11&10&90&9:&2>&>7]

Cq wr`zkdpqf{ edy`i ke yn` fky`rcypr` X22]& ip` yd

yn` kmwr`akqkde dj wdqkykdekeb y`anedfdbk`q .`b& rdci-qki` q`eqdrq& BWQ+& ky kq edy cfc{q wdqqkof` yd cqa`rycke

yn` `~cay fdacykde dj c wcrykapfcr mdzkeb dol`ay N`ea`&pea`ryckey{ mpqy o` ych`e keyd caadpey ke yn` icyc mdi-`fq& ke yn` fkebpkqyka adeqyrpayq dj yn` sp`rk`q& cei ke yn`wrda`qqkeb cfbdrkynmq Yn` kmwcay dj zcrkdpq qdpra`q djkmwr`akqkde ke yn` adey`~y dj wrdocokfkqyka cei pea`r-ycke icyc mcecb`m`ey ncq r`a`kz`i adeqki`rcof` cyy`e-

ykde r`a`eyf{ .`b& X1&07&:9&:0]+& keafpikeb qwcykcf ceiqwcykd-y`mwdrcf q`yykebq .`b& X;&01&09&27&21]+

8/6/2019 Tech Report NWU-EECS-11-06: Ranking continuous nearest neighbors for uncertain trajectories: Full and Peer Revie

3/31

8/6/2019 Tech Report NWU-EECS-11-06: Ranking continuous nearest neighbors for uncertain trajectories: Full and Peer Revie

4/31

_cehkeb Adeykepdpq E`cr`qy E kbnodrq jdr Pea rycke Yrcl aydrk q< Jpff cei W` r _`zk``i Caa`wy`i Z`rqkde 1

q`yykeb& cy ykm` y = 31.6 30+& odyn Yr1 cei Yr? ncz`c ede-|`rd wrdocokfky{ dj o`keb yn` EE-yrcl`aydr{ yd

Yr3 Nd`z`r& yncy kq edy yn` acq` jdr Yr9 nkan& cyy = 31& aceedy wdqqkof{ o` yn` e`cr qy e`kbnodr yd Yr3

Nd`z`r& cy y? = ?7& Yr9nkan cq edy wcry dj yn`ceq`r CS EE n`e yn`r` cq ed pea`ryckey{ ke yn`dol`ayq mdykdencq c ede-| rd wrdocokfky{ dj o`keb

yn` EE-yrcl`aydr{ yd Yr3& cfo`ky qmcff`r ynce yn` de`cqqdakcy`i kyn Yr?

Yn` mcke dol`aykz` dj ynkq drh kq yd wrdzki` jdr-mcfkqmq cei m`yndidfdbk`q jdr `fiak`ey wrda`qqkeb djsp`rk`q fkh`?] Ke ci-

ikykde& yn` andka` dj yn` mdykde mdi`f c`ayq yn` adr-r`qwdeikeb pea`ryckey{ mdi`f yncy ace o` cqqdakcy`i

kyn ky Yn` ynr`` wr`zcf`ey mdi`fq jdr pea`ryckey{ keMDI q`yykebq ace o` i`qarko`i cq jdffdq] ke c MDI adey`~y .ocq`i de yn` i`j-kekykde dj yn` b`dm`yrka q`y dj ?I wdkeyq+& ky ncq o``eqnde yncy yn` wrdl`aykde dj yn` pea`rycke fdacykdeq de

yn` ^[ wfce` kq odpei`i o{ ce `ffkwq` kyn jdak ke ydadeq`apykz pwicy` wdkeyq X01] C qpoq`sp`ey qwcykd-

y`mwdrcf z`rqkde dj yn` mdi`f X17] ecm`q yn` zdfpm`o`y``e yd pwicy` wdkeyq c o`ci .cfqd acff`i qwca`-ykm` wrkqmX97]+cei wr`q`eyq yn` ffirqy jdrmcf cecf{qkq djyn` wrdw`ryk`q dj yn` mdi`f ke y`rmq dj sp`r{ fcebpcb`qCe kffpqyrcykde dj ynkq pea`ryckey{ mdi`f kq wrdzki`i keJkbpr` 1c

M?< Ke qdm` cwwfkacykdeq& `can dol`ay yrceqmkyq kyq

`~w`ay`i z`fdaky{ cfdeb kyn kyq aprr`ey qcmwf`i fdac-ykde X19] Y{wkacff{& z`fdaky{ kejdrmcykde kq wrdzki`i jdryn` wprwdq` dj qczkeb de oceikiyn adeqpmwykde cy

yn` `~w`eq` dj kmwr`akqkde ke yn` MDI X32& 22] Cq

fdeb cq yn` qcmwf`i fdacykde dj c bkz`e dol`ay cy cwcrykapfcr ykm` keqycey id`q edy i`zkcy` o{ mdr` yncec a`rycke .wr`-i`ffie`i+ ynr`qndfi& Imc~& jrdm kyq `~-w`ay`i fdacykde& yn` dol`ay e``i edy yrceqmky ce pw-icy` yd yn` MDI q`rz`r Ynkq wdfka{ kq hede cq i`ci-r`ahdekebX22] Yn` wdqqkof` fdacykdeq dj ce dol`ay pei`radeq`apykz` MDI pwicy`q cr` kffpqyrcy`i ke Jkbpr` 1o

M1 ; G C

O A I @ J B

N K W S _ Q

Y P Z

R ^ ^

[ g c

o a i

` j j

b n

k w s r

q y

p z ~ {

Jkb% 3? Yrcl`aydrk`q de _dci E`ydrhq

Yn` adea`wyq keyrdipa`i ke I`ffiekykde 1 cr` kffpq-

yrcy`i ke Jkbpr` 3?& nkan qndq ynr`` rdci e`ydrhyrcl`aydrk`q< _E-Yrs& _E-Yr3 cei _E-Yr? Yn`

fco fq cfdeb `ib`q keikacy` yn` mkekmpm yrcz`f-ykm`e``i`i yd yrcz`rq` c bkz`e `ib` `qh& nkan ace o` r`ci-kf{ acfapfcy`i cq f.`qh+$zmc~qh Yn` ykm` fco`fq e`~y ydyn` z`ryka`q keikacy` yn` ykm` n`e c wcrykapfcr mdzkebdol`ay kq cy c bkz`e z`ry`~

R` edy` yncy S3& yn` ffirqy wdkey dj yrcl`aydr{_E-Yrs id`q edy adkeaki` kyn c z`ry`~ .key`rq`aykde+dj c brcwn Kei``i& c z`nkaf` mc{ qycry c yrkw jrdm c

wcrhkeb qwdy de c qyr``y ke o`y``e yd key`rq`aykdeqCfqd& ` doq`rz` yncy yn` mdykde cfdeb yn` rdci e`y-drh yrcl`aydrk`q mc{ o` qfd`r ynce yn` mc~kmpm

qw``i Jdr `~cmwf`& yn` fcqy f`b .B1& B9+ dj_E-Yr

3kq ce `ib` yncy ace o` yrcz rq`i ke 30 ykm` pekyq&

nd`z`r& yn` yrkw cfdeb yncy `ib` jdr _E-Yr3 ych`q = 00 10 = ?7 ykm` pekyq

Yn` mcke adeq`sp`ea` dj yn` mdi`f dj rdci e`y-

drh yrcl`aydrk`q ke yn` adey`~y dj dpr drh kq yncy yn`

ikqycea` o`y``e yd mdzkeb dol`ayq ace ed fdeb`r o`m`cqpr`i pqkeb yn` ?I @pafkikce ikqycea` .F?-edrm+qkea` yn` do l`ayq cr` adeqyrcke`i yd mdz` cfdeb yn``ib`q dj yn` rdci e`ydrh Keqy`ci ` e``i yd r`f{ de

yn` qndry`qy e`ydrh ikqycea` nkan& ke ypre& mc{ ncz`c yd-jdfi key`rwr`ycykde . X1?&9>&:3&>7]+