TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan...

30
TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang Woo Kim, Emma Leeds, Jessica Mui, Ellen Wu, Rong Xiang

Transcript of TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan...

Page 1: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

TEAM 7: Cognitive Science

Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang Woo Kim, Emma Leeds, Jessica Mui, Ellen Wu, Rong Xiang

Page 2: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Background

● Fixation o Fixation Duration

● Saccade

● Dynamic loop between visual input and cognition

Page 3: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Table of Contents

1.Line spacing2.PSA3.Lying4.Antisaccade

Page 4: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

1. The Effects of Line Spacing on Eye Movements and Comprehension

Ellen Wu and Rong Xiang

Page 5: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.
Page 6: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

IntroductionHypothesis: Increasing line spacing results in increased fixation duration and thus, increased reading comprehension.

Page 7: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Experimental Design

Read 40 s

Questions40 s

Break15 s

Break (15 seconds)

Page 8: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Experimental DesignGroup 1

Group 2

A1 B2 C1

A2 B1 C2

Page 9: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Results

Spacing

Fixa

tion

Dur

ation

(ms)

Comprehension

Score (%)

Single Spaced Double Spaced

Page 10: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Participant Data

Fig. 2 The average comprehension scores across all subjects

Participants

Com

preh

ensi

on S

core

s (%

)

Page 11: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Discussion

● Lack of correlation between line spacing, fixation duration, and comprehension levels

● Future experiments

● Practical application

Page 12: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

2. PSA Text PlacementEmma Leeds, Raje Enjeti, Rachana Balasubramanian, Jessica Mui

Page 13: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

PSAs: Public Service AnnouncementsHypothesis: Text placement at top would create longer fixations and thus higher comprehension than if text was at the bottom

Page 14: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Methods

Page 15: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Results

Page 16: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Conclusion

=

Page 17: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Eye Movements when Lying

Saavan Chintalacheruvu & Nevil Abraham

Page 18: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Introduction

● Common notion that eyes focus on top-left when lying● Some experimental evidence supporting this

Page 19: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Materials & Methods

Page 20: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Results: Average Fixation Duration

● T:360 ± 370 milliseconds● L: 370 ± 4.0x10^2 milliseconds● p = 0.468

Bum-Shik Kim
Do you guys want to have the font specifically in color (black)? Consistent color theme is the third color under "theme colors" so if we are going consistent we may want to switch font color. One of slightest of comments so least of worries in the end.
Page 21: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Possible Errors/Improvement

● Nature of the stimuluso Why do people lie?o People usually lie to peopleo not a good representation of lying

● Improvemento Lie to an actual human beingo Give participants a reason to lie

Page 22: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Conclusion

● No correlation within the experiment’s parameters● However:

o data was highly variableo results are inconclusiveo must be repeated with improvements

Page 23: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

The Antisaccade Task Under Changing Fixation Points Grace Chen, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang Woo Kim

Page 24: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

What is an antisaccade?

Saccade Antisaccade

● Inhibition of reflexive saccade● Frontal cortex ability

Page 25: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Antisaccade ability will vary with:

Hypotheses

vs

vs

1. stationary vs. moving fixation point

2. moving in opposite vs. same direction as cue

Page 27: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Experimental Design

Controlstatic fixation pointcues appear on L/R

Experimentalmoving fixation pointcues appear in same/opposite direction

30 trials 64 trials

15 left 15 right 32 opposite direction

32 same direction

16 left16

right16 left

16 right

Page 28: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Analysis of Results

Grace Chen
add avg for moving point
Page 29: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

General Conclusions

● Eye patterns remain steady under varied conditions● Moving fixation point reduced antisaccade ability ● Dynamic feedback between eyes and cognition● High variability between participants

Page 30: TEAM 7: Cognitive Science Nevil Abraham, Rachana Balasubramanian, Grace Chen, Saavan Chintalacheruvu, Rajeshwari Enjeti, Cynthia Guo, Bum Shik Kim, Kang.

Acknowledgements

Dr. Minjoon KouhFrank Minio

NJ Governor’s School of the SciencesDr. Adam CassanoDr. Steve Surace

Anna Mae Dinio-BlochBayer Health Care

Independent College Fund of NJ/Johnson & Johnson

AT&T

Actavis PharmaceuticalsCelgeneNovartis

Laura (NJGSS ’86) and John OverdeckNJGSS Alumnae and Parents of Alumnae

Board of Overseers, New Jersey Governor’s Schools

State of New JerseyDrew University

and all of NJGSS’s generous sponsors!