TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
Transcript of TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
1/38
K SubramanianDeloitte Haskins & Sells
September 2010
Tax Deduction at Source
on payments toNon Residents
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
2/38
Contents
2
Section 195 & Objective
Issues
Capital Gains
Quantum
Chargeability
Rate 112 vs. rates in force anomaly
Cross Border M&A
Reimbursements
Inter Corporate Loans
Payments to partnership firms / pass thru entities
Permanent Account Number
OthersCA Certificate
Payments to Branches / Head Office
E-Commerce Transactions
Gross Sum vs. Income element
Determining residential status
Other issues
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
3/38
Section 195 & Objective of Tax Deduction at Source (TDS)
Regular inflowof revenue forGovernment
Checking oftax evasion
Widening oftax base
To ensure that the tax due from non-resident is secured at the earliest point of time
To avoid difficulty in collection of tax subsequently at the time of regular assessment
Failure to deduct tax at source may result in loss of revenue as the non-resident may nothave assets in India from which tax could be collected at a later stage
- Circular No. 152 dated 27 November 1974
3
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
4/38
Issues
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
5/38
Capital Gains
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
6/38
TDS on what amount
Cost of acquisition = Rs 5000
Sale consideration = Rs 8000
At the time of remittance by Y Co India,
section 195 comes into play
6
Capital Gains Quantum Case Study 1(a)
X Co
Ind Co
USA
India
10 shares
Y Co
Transfer ofshares inInd Co
ISSUE:TDS on what amount?Rs 8000 (sale consideration) OR Rs 3000 (capital gain)
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
7/38
Determination of cost of acquisition
Capital Gains = Sale Consideration lessCost of acquisition
How does Y Co India determine the cost ofacquisition of shares in the hands of X Co
US?
Does Y Co obtain FIRCs or other supportingdocuments from X Co?
What if the supporting documents are not
available?
7
Capital Gains Quantum Case Study 1(b)
X Co
Ind Co
USA
India
10 shares
Y Co
Transfer ofshares inInd Co
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
8/38
Brought forward losses
Ind Co 100% subsidiary of X Co US
Ind Co buys back part of its shares from XCo resulting in capital loss to X Co
Next year, Ind Co again buys back a partof its shares from X Co this time, X Cohas a gain
Overall, if capital gain is set off against thebrought forward capital loss, net position
is a loss
Can Ind Co set off the brought forwardcapital loss against the current capitalgains to determine withholding taxliability?
8
X Co
Ind Co
USA
India
100%
Capital Gains Quantum Case Study 1(c)
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
9/38
Brought forward losses Contd.
Section 197
Application by payee
To AO
For grant of certificate for receipt of
income without deduction of tax at sourceor for deduction at lower rates
Issues
In the previous example, can X Co make
an application to AO u/s 197 on theground of brought forward losses?
197 application only to determine rate oftax
9
X Co
Ind Co
USA
India
100%
Capital Gains Quantum Case Study 1(c) Contd.
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
10/38
197 Application Alternatives
Section 195 (2)
Application by payer
To A.O.
To determine the appropriate portion of the sumchargeable to tax
Section 195(3)
Application by payee
To A.O.
For the grant of a certificate for receipt ofincome without deduction of tax at source
Subject to certain conditions Rule 29B
Alternative
In the previous example,
Can Ind Co make an application u/s 195(2)?
Can X Co make an application u/s 195(3)?
10
X Co
Ind Co
USA
India
100%
Capital Gains Quantum Case Study 1(c) Contd.
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
11/38
Rule 29B Conditions for 195(3) application
Has been regularly assessed to Income-tax in India
Has furnished the returns of income for allassessments years
Not in default or deemed to be in default in respect of
any tax, interest, fine or any sum payable under theAct
Has not been subjected to penalty for concealment ofparticulars of income
Where not a banking company:
Has been carrying on business or profession inIndia continuously for at least 5 years
Value of Fixed Assets in India > Rs. 50 Lacs
Certificate issued by the AO valid only for the FinancialYear mentioned therein
11
X Co
Ind Co
USA
India
100%
Capital Gains Quantum Case Study 1(c) Contd.
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
12/38
Non resident to non resident transfer
Shares in an Indian Company chargeable tocapital gains tax in India
Triniti Corporation165 Taxman 272 (AAR)
Satellite Television Asian Region Ltd. v. DCIT
99 ITD 91 (ITAT, Mum)
12
Capital Gains Chargeability Case Study 2(a)
X Co
Ind Co
USA
India
10 shares
Y Co
Transfer of shares
in Ind Co
ISSUE:Whether Y Co (non resident) to withhold taxes on payment made to X Co(another non resident)?
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
13/38
Proviso to Section 112
In the previous example, Y Co has to withholdtaxes on payments made to X Co
Non resident eligible to benefit of proviso toSection112
Proviso to Sec 112 20% if indexation benefit availed i.e. on Sale
Consideration less Indexed Cost of acquisition
10% of indexation benefit not availed i.e. onSale Consideration less Cost of acquisition(without indexation)
13
Capital Gains Rate Case Study 2(b)
X Co
Ind Co
USA
India
10 shares
Y Co
Transfer of shares
in Ind Co
ISSUE:At what rates should Y Co withhold taxes?Can it apply proviso to Section 112?
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
14/38
Vodafone ruling
14
Capital Gains Cross Border M&A Case Study 3
X Co
Ind Co
USA
India
Y Co
ISSUE:Transfer of X Cos shares to Y Co whether taxable in India?
A Co Transfer ofshares in X Co
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
15/38
Reimbursements
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
16/38
Reimbursement of actual expenses Not in the nature of income
CIT v. Industrial Engineering Projects Pvt. Ltd. 202 ITR 1014 (HC, Del)
Decta 237 ITR 190 (AAR)
CIT v. Fortis Health Care Ltd 181 Taxman 257 (HC, Del)
Bangalore International Airport Ltd v. ITO 307 ITR 295 (ITAT, Bang)
CIT v. Dunlop Rubber Co Ltd 142 ITR 493 (HC, Cal)
Should be backed up with supporting documentation and evidence of such expenses
Technical services availed. Reimbursement of incidental expenses also held as fees fortechnical services
Cochin Refineries Ltd. v. CIT 222 ITR 354 (HC, Ker)
Steffen, Robertson and Kirsten Consulting Engineers And Scientists v. CIT 230 ITR
206 (AAR) Hindalco Industries Ltd v. ACIT 278 ITR 125 (ITAT, Mum)
16
Reimbursements
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
17/38
Employees on the payrolls of X Co
Seconded to Ind Co (subsidiary of X Co)
Salary cost of seconded employees crosscharged by X Co to Ind Co no mark up
DCIT v. HCL Infosystems Ltd. 211 Taxation29 (ITAT, Del)
AT and S India (P) Ltd. v. CIT 287 ITR 421(AAR)
IDS Software Solutions India (P) Ltd. v. ITO122 TTJ 410 (ITAT, Bang)
17
Reimbursements Case Study 1
X Co
Ind Co
USA
IndiaSecondmentof employees
ISSUE:Whether taxes are to be withheld on such reimbursement of salary costs?
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
18/38
Ind Co sends its employees to X Co for a
training
X Co incurs expenditure on travel,accommodation etc of such employees
X Co cross charges the expenditure at cost to
Ind Co
18
Reimbursements Case Study 2
X Co
Ind Co
USA
IndiaEmployeessent fortraining
ISSUE:Whether taxes are to be withheld on such reimbursement of expensesincurred by X Co?
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
19/38
X Co acts as a global procurement center for
all subsidiaries
X Co enters into agreements with serviceproviders centrally
Invoice raised by service providers on X Co
X Co, in turn, allocates the cost to thesubsidiaries in ratio of the utilization ofservices and raises debit notes on subsidiariesfor cross charge of such cost no mark up
19
Reimbursements Case Study 3
X Co
Ind Co 1
USA
India
ISSUES:Will payments by subsidiaries to X Co attract TDS?Will X Co be the deemed service provider to its subsidiaries?
Will the payments to X Co be classified as Royalty / Fees for technical services?
Service provider
Ind Co 2
Invoice raised for allservices rendered to
various subsidiaries
Y Co
Debit notes raised
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
20/38
20
Reimbursements Case Study 4
X Co(R&D centre)
Ind Co 1
USA
India
Ind Co 2
Y Co
Debit notes raised forservices rendered
X Co has a centralized research and
development (R&D) unit
The research done at the unit benefits all thesubsidiaries
Cost contribution agreement between X Co
and subsidiaries entire costs sharedbetween the entities
X Co cross charges proportionate costs to allthe group companies who benefit from suchresearch
ISSUE:Whether taxes are to be withheld on such reimbursement of expensesincurred by X Co?
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
21/38
X Co renders services to Ind Co in USA
No services rendered in India
X Co recovers the expenses incurred atactuals from Ind Co no markup
Timken India Ltd 143 Taxman 257 (AAR) Danfoss Industries 268 ITR 1 (AAR)
21
Reimbursements Case Study 5
X Co
Ind Co
USA
India
ISSUE:Whether taxes are to be withheld on such reimbursement of expensesincurred by X Co?
Servicesrendered inUSA
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
22/38
Inter Corporate Loans
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
23/38
Ind Co 1 gives loan to Ind Co 2 (resident group
company) in which non resident shareholder(X Co) has substantial interest
Deemed dividend u/s 2(22)(e)
Does not attract dividend distribution tax
Taxable in the hands of non residentshareholder
No payment / credit to the account of nonresident shareholder
23
Inter Corporate Loan Case Study
X Co
Ind Co 1
USA
India
ISSUE:Whether taxes are to be withheld u/s 195 at the time of remitting the loan toInd Co 2?
Loan
Ind Co 2
100%
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
24/38
Pass thru entities
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
25/38
Payments to partnership firms / pass thru entities
Partnership firm fiscally transparent entities
not liable to tax profits taxed in the hands ofthe partners
Entitlement to the benefits of DTAA whetherincluded in the definition of resident as given
in DTAA
Indo-UK DTAA Resident defined to meanany person who, under the law of that State, is
liable to taxation therein by reason of his .
25
X Co(Partnership Firm)
Ind Co
UK
India
ISSUE:Whether the partnership firm is eligible to avail the benefit of Indo UKDTAA?
Servicesrendered
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
26/38
Payments to partnership firms / pass thru entities Contd.
Partnership firm eligible to treaty benefits even
when the firm is taxable in respect of its profitsnot in its own right but in the hands of thepartners Linklaters LLP v. ITO 132 TTJ 20(ITAT, Mum)
Issues
What if the partners are residents of differentcontracting states? Which DTAA wouldapply?
Can the partners take credit of such taxeswithheld?
26
X Co(Partnership Firm)
Ind Co
UK
IndiaServicesrendered
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
27/38
Permanent Account Number
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
28/38
Permanent Account Number (PAN)
Recent provisions introduced by the Finance Act, 2009 with regard to furnishing of PAN bythe deductee to the tax deductor also applies to tax deducted u/s 195
As per the new provisions, w.e.f. FY beginning 1 April 2010, where the deductee of the taxfails to furnish its PAN, the deductor of tax will be required to withhold taxes at higher ofthe following rates:
At the rate specified under the Income-tax Act; or
At the rates in force; or At the rate of 20%
PAN to be indicated in all correspondence, bills, vouchers and other documentsexchanged between the deductor and deductee
No certificate for lower rate of withholding taxes u/s 197 shall be issued by the Revenueauthorities to the deductee, unless the PAN of the deductee is furnished
28
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
29/38
PAN Issues
Particulars Rate under the
Income TaxAct, 1961
Rate under the
DTAA
Applicable rate
w.e. isbeneficial
In absence of
PAN, willhigher rate of20% u/s 206AAget attracted?
Situation 1 X Greater than X Act i.e. X Yes
Situation 2 X X X Yes
Situation 3 X Less than X DTAA i.e. lessthan X
Yes
Situation 4 X Not taxable i.e.Nil
DTAA i.e. Nil ?
Situation 5 No TDSrequired X Act i.e. Nil No
29
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
30/38
PAN Issues Contd.
Would Section 206AA apply where taxes are to be borne by payer?
Whether 206AA rates to be increased by surcharge and cess?
Tax deducted at the higher rates u/s 206AA Can payee claim refund of the tax in excessof his actual liability?
Foreign tax credit for higher taxes deducted by virtue of Section 206AA?
PAN not available at the time of deduction but furnished subsequently
Difficulties in obtaining PAN for non residents
30
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
31/38
Others
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
32/38
Others C.A Certificate
Alternative mechanism Certificate of a Chartered Accountant certifying the tax withholding amount
CBDT Circular No. 759 dated 18 November 1997; Circular No. 767 dated 22 May 1998 and CircularNo. 10/2002 dated 9 October 2002
Issues regarding Certificate by CA
Understanding the nature of payments
How to determine residential status Tax Residency Certificate issued by overseas tax authorities Difficulties in obtaining Residency Certificate (TRC)
What if TRC not available?
Dual residency issues
To examine PE issues Determination of PE is PE certificate sufficient?
Applicability of DTAA Eligibility to treaty benefits
Which Article of DTAA to apply
Name & address of beneficiary meaning Beneficial Owner or Recipient?
32
Despite amendment by Circular No. 10/2002 permitting Managing Directoror anyperson authorized by him in writingto sign the verification in Form 15CA, no
corresponding amendment to the Form facilitating the same
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
33/38
Payment by Indian Branch to HO
Branch separate entity Interest payment to HO liable to TDS Circular 740 dated 17April 1996
Dresdner Bank 105 TTJ 149 (ITAT, Mum)
Legal validity of circular questioned since Branch is not a separate entity under law
ABN Amro Bank 280 ITR 117 (SB, Kol)
Fees for Technical services to HO liable to TDS Circular 649 dated 31 March 1993
Payment to Indian branch of foreign company in India (e.g. Branches of foreign banks)
Circular 20 (II-4) dated 3 August 1961 Since branch of NR will be NR, deductible
Foreign branches could obtain Nil TDS certificates u/s 195(3)
33
Others Payments to Branches / Head Office (HO)
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
34/38
a) Software
Copyright v. Copyrighted article Samsung
Sonata Software
Recent Karnataka HC decision overruled by SC
b) Subscription charges for standard service/data
c) Bandwidth charges
d) Advertisement procurement and revenue share
e) Royalty / Fees for technical services
Services utilized OR rendered in India OR both
Make available
If make available not satisfied, should Article on Business Profits be analyzed?
Business profits not taxable in absence of Permanent Establishment In such a case,should Article on Other Income be analyzed?
34
Others E-Commerce transactions
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
35/38
Base to be adopted for TDS Gross amountor net amountwhich may represent income
Any sum chargeable to tax means sum chargeable to tax and it not only applies to the
amount paid which wholly bears an income character but the gross sum, the whole of
which may not be income or profits.
Transmission Corporation 239 ITR 587 (SC)
The obligation of the assessee to deduct tax u/s 195 limited only to the appropriateproportion of the income chargeable under the Act forming part of the gross sums ofmoney paid to the non-residents CIT vs. Superintending Engineer, Upper Sileru 152ITR 753 (HC, AP)
Payments to non-residents would be subject to withholding tax only if the income ischargeable to tax No TDS if there is no income element at all in payments GE IndiaTechnology Centre Private Ltd. Civil Appeal Nos.7541-7542 of 2010 (SC)
35
Others Gross sum vs. Income element
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
36/38
Others Determining residential status
36
Case Study
X Co incorporated in UK Control and management situated wholly in India
Residential status = Resident
Payment by Ind Co (resident in India) to X Co whether section 195 applies ?
Payee Definition
Non-resident, not being a company Defined in section 6 of the Act
Foreign company Defined in section 2(23A) of the Act
ISSUE:Indian partnership firm control and management wholly outside IndiaHow does the payer come to know ?
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
37/38
Payments in kind
The assessee is liable to deduct tax at source u/s 195 on the payment made to the non-resident even though the payment is not made in cash but made in kind
Kanchanganga Sea Foods Ltd. v. CIT 325 ITR 540 (SC)
Net payment received
The assessee is liable to deduct tax at source u/s 195, even under an arrangement wherehe receives only net payment from other party after deducting commission/ managementfees etc.
Raymond Ltd. v. DCIT 86 ITD 791 (HC, Mum)
Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd. V. DCIT 30 SOT 374 (ITAT, Mum)
37
Other issues
-
8/8/2019 TDS Payments Non Residents Deliotte
38/38
Thank you