Sutherland Report.pdf

!"

#$%

The Portland Company: Historic Significance and Integrity

Introduction 1Methodology 1Executive Summary 2

SECTION I: Historic Significance of the Portland CompanyNational Historic Significance 9State Historic Significance 10Local Historic Significance 12Historic Architectural Significance 15

SECTION II: Integrity of the Existing Portland Company ResourcesIndividual Buildings 21Portland Company Site 34

SECTION III: AppendicesAppendix A: History of the Establishment of the Portland Company 49Appendix B: Additional Information on John A. Poor 53Appendix C: Railroads for which the Portland Company produced Locomotives 57Appendix D: Timeline of Development 59Appendix E: Other Manufacturers of Locomotives 61Appendix F: Production 63Appendix G: National Register of Historic Places Criteria for Evaluation of Significance and Integrity as Applied to the Portland Company (National Register Bulletin 15) 73Appendix H: Tremont Preservation Services Building Descriptions with Additional Information

77

Bibliography 93

'*%%+,

-+/!

+$+,+#,%8

/++;+'< =>?[*+!

$$-/#+

+\!\,,%

>,+%

+>/%+

$/!"$Y], >/+

/%

$++%

/

!

$/>+%

/$!+/%-+Q^+,$-+\%++;_!

$%< `j$+"!U$^$$%#!Y"!,%+;+%X%#;$,$_+"!U$^%+>!k"!U$_$V

,;$YXX$,$$

%+{,$$;X%$_;,+

+$V!

++/%$+< =/++$V?q%

$

%-%Y"!+!

+,,$-/+\!"$,+V$+$!%

,|+}+$+/+%%!

+++,V,$!>%$+,

>+~,++z;/++,%!/%/+/+\! $V%!

Q,U

%%>/%

+++~$

++!//+>q+,,/%%+%

,$,+

,>q/%%>

$

!",/

%

$+//!^%>q+,V$$%+\!!{+$++!

$%

,UZ-%,Y"!! !

"#$%&,

]

%+#;';$>+*!,,%,$++#+

+$!/,/,,

%+%%+!

$;+>,$$%$$#!$%;%+%,[+[!+#>V,/,!"%+>

V$%++>q

+ZQ-!

%$/!>+%!j$%V+$+++!

"

%

+/%%

++~$'*++%

%$< =?!"

,%

+<

%

+%+%

+'*+!

,/%

++!

+

++z$+

$%$z

$/%!%< =

+%%

!$+/!

%,%,++$++!+$

+/!

,%V%$++,%

!"++%

j,

+'%

*?+-+%

/+~+$%

+

!%~%+!

,+/+%

$/!/+%

+V$

$++++;!

/

$,/,,!

%

/$+++/'< =?

[

++//++>/%

+++~V+QUV%!

/++-%$

,+!

+-+%

/++~+$%

+

!+/

/#VU$,X

+,+%+$!

,++++++!+%%

$

+$/!

+/%

[,++%

'%

*!

++$$+,>$$+>++,

$$>+|}%$%

!

"++%%

,>

>%

$$+z!^+%

$$+$+|}%$Z,#,zXV!

%$%

+X

++;|!}

?

!"

//+>q+,,/%+++~< =!%+>/%

+,$

++!

%

!

\%

+, ,$ -/+ \ ! "$, + V$+$!%

,|+}+$+/+%%!

+++,

V,$!%$+ ,

>+~, + +z;/ ++, % !/%/+/+\! $V%!

!"

%+#;' ; $>+ * ! , , %, $ + + # +

+ $ ! /, /, ,

% + % % +!$ ; +> , $ $ %$$#! $ % ; % +%,[+[! + # >V, /!"%+V$%++q

+ZQ-!

^

$j "!U$^+

=,??!]>]`!$V,Y#!(**&

&)&*01231!q,Y!&-).-"1245!122!"!!#- )&%*(-

',`,?]!,X!-,??

$+#!+"!U$^,Y"!,$+$

+!

#

" ! U$,{V, ,,%,^,k%,Z,#,X#,^+z

XV

!"%+$%+#;$>+

^,^,%,X^,q%!#; ~,

V+ %V !

, + +,$,$+!

$%+>+>!k$++Q^ ,$+

+q!U$%+Q$X$V%,#,k$,k,$

+^ "!"/+

+#!]

#

+ $ ~+ %

% + %+ %

$ %!_ + , +

%, ~ + + +%V U%,$

$!k+ #, %, , ~+%

#+$k!V'

"$;+%!_$#+

]

+% [V+$

+%V$\,+%

%%~,+V,$%%,,%%%~+

+

$

%$++V

$V$$+!}=

>+%,$ z, Y! X! X$ ; ^, z ^,Z^,V,$,// !$+%

,+#z q + X #

/ zV '

$ +*! k /]

++ "!U$^+ $V$

%

+$%

!,j+%

!j$V%$,,+,$+

%$$$+$++-!>+$$

%!?

j$%V+ $ + ++! X+ + " ! U$ ^ $ + , $++++$+

+!%

$

X!+,Q%,?,< =,$#*.,$VX!z

$+,$$/%%!{

%++%$,#,Q$,"Z ! q + "!U$^ #,%~+X${V^,

+$$+$!"{V/$$,

#>q+%, $+

+#>q_$>%

+!_%$%

[

,#+,V,,z!Q|}$%%$$$"!U$^,%+!]X

`

"$,%

%

$+$+V+!#+$$%V%

,+%%! "$%

++V,+%

!k+$$

+j< =#%

%zV"!+;++$

%+Wq

!!|$}z$+j%+$%![z%

+

=

< =

+%%

!$+/!

%, %, + +$++!+$

+/!

,%V%$++,%

!"++%

j,

+'%

*?+-+%

/+j+~+$%

+

!+/

/#VU$,X

+,+%+$!%~%+!"V+%

%%,+%

++%

!+%

$+%

+ ! X %

$$+%

V++!$+%

%%$+

+%+%+%+!/%$%

,!

"~$z$

+$

+%

$+

,$$

+%

+%$

!%V%+X$

%

$jz$V!

,+/+%

$/!/+%

+V$

$+++ + ;!%

+ ++++,Z,X,$++

+Vz#!^,W+,$,V,,%

+

!

$+%W+,+!+#!

$+%W+!

)&"_@? , , % $$!" '>+*+V$%>$,,+ ! k+X

+!^ +++ > , +$

/! " % % %

, k+X

++%%,%,+! + +,++!

]

+!%++< `!U++{V^,+/+$+!+

$+%

$+{V^V$+,++!$%

++X$$>$

z!"%$+$V

!+,%

+{V^ +z!q /, /+ %

$%

!$V%

+/++%

+j%

!

%

+

+

+ %

%$ >? >!/$++++,,!k+,%

$'

][

"@#

X@

@z

_@X

Z@

#

q

#

Z/

#

Z/

q

Z/

#

/

!

"

&7+0

()

!

2

X

#

!

+

#

!

U

+

!

>

+

#

!

!

]`

#

q

#

Z/

#

Z/

q

Z/

#

/

!

"

&747

"@#

X@

@z

_@X

Z@

z@

X

V

{@X

@z

Z/

@

k+

X

!

+

#

!|X

V

}

$

+

!

+

#

!

k

%

!

+

#

!

Z

!

+

#

>

!

()

!

2

8

@

%

Z

k

Q_

"^

@^

#"

^@

]=

#

q

#

Z/

#

Z/

q

Z/

#

/

!

"

&70&

!

+

#

!U

+

#

!

>

+

#

!

U

$

+

%

!

+

#

!

$

+

+

!

+

#

!

"@#

X@

@z

Z@

z@X

V

{

@X

@z

Z

/

@k

+

X

Y@

_

+

^

@X

X

z

U@

()

!

8

9

;

#

+

#

!

$

+

$

V

!

+

#

!

"@#

X@

z@

X

V

{@X

@

k+

X

Y@_

+

^

@X

X

z

#@Z

Q@

k

@

@

X

%%

@

^@X

V

V

@X

V

V

@z

\

@

"

()

68

9

;

@

%

@

+@

@

q

z

3

>

?

/

Z

kQ

_"

^@

^#

"^

@

#

q

#

Z/

#

Z/

q

Z/

#

/

!

"

&=1=

$

+

!

+

#

!

/

%

!

+

#

!

U

%

V

!

+

#

!

/

%

!

+

#

!

"@#

X@

z@

X

V

{@X

@

k+

X

Y@_

+

^

@X

X

z

#@Z

Q@

k

@

@

X

%%

@

^@X

V

V

@X

V

V

@z

\

@

"

()

68

9

;

@

%

@

+@

@

U

%

3

> ?

/

Z

kQ

_"

^@

^#

"^

@

#

q

#

Z/

#

Z/

q

Z/

#

/

!

"

&=&7

"

+

!

+

#

!"

+

!

+

#

!

U

%V

!

+

#

!

+

#

!

"@#

X@

z@

X

V

{@X

Y@

_

+

^

@X

X

z

Q

@

k@

@

X%

%

@

^

@X

V

V

@

X

V

V

@

z

\@

"

@Z

()

68

9;

@

%

+@

@

U

%

3

> ?

/

5

Z

kQ

_"

^@

^#

"^

@

]

#

q

#

Z/

#

Z/

q

Z/

#

/

!

"

&=4&

?[

%

#

+

!

"@#

X@

z@

X

V

{@X

Y@

_

+

^

@X

X

z

Q

@

k@

@

X%

%

@

^

@X

V

V

@

z

\@

"

@Z

q@k

+

X

()

68

9;

@U

%

@

"

3

> ?

/

5

@

Z

kQ

_"

^@

^#

"^

@

#

q

#

Z/

#

Z/

q

Z/

#

/

!

"

&=7,

"@#

X@

Y@

_

+

^

@X

X

z

Q

@

k@

@

^

@X

V

V

@

z

\@

"

@Z

q@k

+

X

@#

()

6A

9;

@U

%

@

"

3

> ?

/

5

@

Z

kQ

_"

^@

^#

"^

@

?

[

#

q

#

Z/

#

Z/

q

Z/

#

/

!

"

%1&+

$

+

!

$

$

+

/!

$

%

$

>

%

!

$

%

$

%

V>

V

!

"@#

X@

Y@

_

+

^

@X

X

z

Q

@

k@

@

^

@X

V

V

@

z

\@

"

@Z

q@k

+

X

@#

()

6A

9;

@U

%

@

"

3

> ?

/

5

@

Z

kQ

_"

^@

^#

"^

@

?

(2A(/63B6//()#/6/63/#(2!6(B

$%j$+"!U$^$$%#!Y"!,%+;+%X%#;$,$_+"!U$^%+!k"!U$_$V

,;$YXX$,$$

%+

$>>>+

!$

+

,,+

V,$%!

+_+$

Q%,< `,Z/++"Y"!!Yz/$,"!q!!,!k_Q,Y!

,{q!Y"!$,q%,Q$+Z, z ! z $ / + Q

$V!"

+/Qz$!",+Z$~|%}$%

$

%~+!Q%+|%+QXUX

,},],[$$|~%!}$+

,,~+

,$+ `,?[[!"

,Q%+

+z,_+,zz,zz,z,V,,zX,z,z! "

,|$ +

$+ %+,}$VQ"!",_z/,q,

,$|$!{+$V+!}$,,$+z%+#j

!U,!$

[

$%!X$! k,$~|V{+$%$qV~,}_z/,

,,|%+X+$_+"!U$^%j++$V+,$$$^,+, +$, +++@

~~+ X^^, + $V+ ,$$%+%!}< `, %,|+

,,$+,j%$+%,}'

$%%,z$%,+z^%V*~+,$,V,!%$+;%$%%$!+;%$%%+j

+%+;+!#+|}+%$+ $+X!

V+$

,

,++$V!

X_%< `,/$V++X+_,%$_Q,%_%,$X+]/+

+ ++ ~,$! z$%%%+$QUqV!+,X{$%+V$V+

$+![

"++Q$$"!U$^~+ ! Q,+++%+$,%$%$V!Q / $ Q %%Y"!;%X!_+$

++~;$V$

Q%+%V

!z%$$~%

+%+,$

+$++%+;+z ^++"!U$^,#![ ^+,#!

[

!Z

$

/,

$%$$

,$$

%

$

%!`

X"< =,+,,,$+%V%z!$#![U-_!###XV!!X$|$V

!}"+%$+%

+#!U

!$+++,,$$!Y+z=[,%V[![_+z$V+%V'/![,*[!,|%%%!}+$=[;/`;,=[;/`;,[;/`;$+!z$-+

[]

(2A)(22/6(#63(/6696('663

Y"+$%",#,_!##

Y%X"

[

$$V

%!}[$

%%%!+++;#%!k>$,;++$%Z, $ >" , + ++z>+$V

%%$V!

$+{U,< ?,$%+

[[

+-!}?

"#$%&,

[=

"%^^"%^^"ZV^^^"V

^^"!U$^^X~^^X,k

$,#+^^X"%^^XV^V%X^^X#^^X^^^XV

k$^^X^^^^#/^^,",!U^^%X!_+^^Z!#!XX^$Z^^ZQ"^^zX^^{,^^{V^^X^^>^^Yq!%^^%^^VU%!UV#^Û/_

^Û,X^^#ÛVZ^^#^^#X++^^#^^#$V#^^#$V!^^#$V,UVq^^Q$X$V^^Q$VX^^Q$VQ^^

Q^^Q^^k%UV^^k,UV^^^^%%^^V\^^,VYV

^^

^^^,U,X^^%^^k%^^^^^^^%^^%,#,k$k^^^_

^^^+z

XV

^^^q^^^^^$^^^

^^%\^Û$"^^!z#^^!Y%UV^^!U$k$^^!X^^!+^^,X^^,q$^^\!!{\,Z^^!^^q^^q%^^q%,U^^q"^^q%^^qXV!qQ^^V%^^

(2A ! 3(#36(2 63 @! / 63/#(2 !6(B 362?!2#6!66/5

[?

(2A2/#625#6/

2(/ /< = +#< = +< = +z< =! +XV< =! +< =>

`

U

Q

U

>

/

Z/

+z

_

X

_

Sutherland Report.pdf

Documents

Transcript of Sutherland Report.pdf