Supplement to BP344

download Supplement to BP344

of 38

Transcript of Supplement to BP344

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    1/38

    National Commission Persons withDisability

    December 2000ISBN 99909-71-08-0

    These guidelines are to be reviewed within a year from

    publication.Comments, suggestions and modifications are to be

    addressed to the:

    National Commission

    Persons with DisabilityTel: 487789; 448521

    Centru Hidma Socjali Textelefon: 446536

    Triq il-Kbira San Guzepp Fax: 484609

    Sta. Venera HMR 18Email:

    [email protected]

    Malta Webpage: www.knpd.org

    Drawings adapted by Adrian Fenech

    Produced by Outlook Coop - MaltaWeb Version - IT Soltuions - Malta

    The information on this site is subject to a disclaimer

    and a copyrightnotice.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    2/38

    List of Figures

    1. Kerb details. 11

    2. Alignment of kerb ramps. 12

    3. Kerb ramp arrangement at street corners. 12

    4. Kerb ramp arrangement at street corners. 12

    5 . Grate orientation to path of travel. 13

    6. Parking provisions for wheelchair users parallel to kerb. 14

    7. Parking provision perpendicular to kerb. 14

    8. Permissible minimum ramp and landing dimensions for straight run

    ramps.15

    9. Layout showing dimensions for ramps with 90 degree turns. 16

    10. Layout showing dimensions for ramps with 180 degree turns. 16

    11. Unacceptable stairs. 18

    12. Acceptable stairs. 18

    13. Max widths of stairs between handrails. 19

    14. Acceptable handrail profiles. 20

    15. Handrail dimensions. 21

    16. Dimensions for staircases with enclosed well. 21

    17. Dimensions for open well staircase. 22

    18. Door widths. 24

    19. Doors to have glazed panel. 24

    20. Door ironmongery. 24

    21. Lobby Minimum Dimensions. 24

    22. Permissable Threshold Level. 2623. Hazards of Inadequately Anchored Mats. 26

    24. Minimum widths of corridors. 29

    25. Turning Space in Corridors. 30

    26. Corridor widths for 90 degree turns. 30

    27. Corridor widths for turns around obstructions. 30

    28. Passing Alcoves in lieu of 1.5m width corridors. 31

    29. Lift dimensions. 32

    30. Toilet room (sectional elevation). 35

    31. Toilet room (plan). 35

    32. Layout showing shower cubicle for use by disabled persons. 37

    33. Control height for window opening / closing controls. 38

    34. Height of power sockets and lighting switches. 38

    35. The international symbol of access. 40

    36. Provision for wheelchair users in areas of assembly. 43

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    3/38

    IMPORTANT

    Most of the dimensions which appear in these guidelines should be regarded as MINIM UM

    requirements.

    Therefore, where circumstances permit, more generous dimensions should be used.

    Contents

    Preface 5

    1.0 Introduction 7

    2.0 Layout Of This Document 8

    3.0 Main Goal 8

    4.0 Overall Objectives 9

    4.1 External Environment 9

    4.2 Entrances to Buildings 10

    4.3 Internal Environment 105.0 The External Environment Of Buildings 11

    5.1 Access 11

    5.2 Kerbs And Pavements 11

    5.3 Car Parking 13

    5.4 Approaches to the Entrance of a Building 15

    5.5 Ramps 15

    5.6 Stairs 17

    5.7 Handrails 20

    5.8 Guards and Barriers 216.0 Entrances To Buildings 23

    6.1 Entrance Doorways 23

    6.2 Entrance Lobbies 25

    6.3 Thresholds 26

    7.0 Internal Environment Of Buildings 27

    7.1 Building Surface Finishes 27

    7.2 Internal Lobbies 28

    7.3 Internal Doors 28

    7.4 Corridors and Passageways 29

    7.5 Passenger Lifts 31

    7.6 Sanitary Facilities 33

    7.7 Sanitary Accommodation 34

    7.8 Lighting 37

    7.9 Counters and Checkouts 39

    7.10 Seating and Tables 39

    8.0 Communication 40

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    4/38

    8.1 Signs 40

    8.2 Other Aids to Communication 41

    9.0 Miscellaneous Building Types Requirements 42

    9.1 Restaurants and Bars 42

    9.2 Facilities Providing Accommodation for the Public (e.g. hotel

    bedrooms, etc.)42

    9.3 Assembly Facilities (e.g. auditoria, theatres, stadia, etc.) 43

    References 44

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    5/38

    PREFACE

    REMOVING DISABLING BARRIERS

    Disabling barriers are often the single most important cause of social isolation and

    discrimination which many people, especially people with impairments, have to confront in

    their daily lives. Very often, disabling barriers are also the root cause preventing individualswith disability from enjoying an acceptable quality of life. Such barriers may easily be

    identified. They include inaccessible:

    design of buildings;

    modes of transport and communication discriminatory attitudes.

    A widespread misconception is that architectural barriers only effect people who are

    disabled: this is not so.

    Such barriers seriously disable a wide spectrum of users. Elderly people, pregnant women,

    families with young children and workers carrying heavy objects, are amongst the groups

    which spring to mind. In respect of the elderly, it is important to bear in mind that ours isan ageing population, an inescapable fact which makes it imperative for the building

    industry in general to comply with the principles of Design for All.

    Another misconception is that disabling barriers are part of the immutable laws of nature

    and, as such, they can never be changed. This is clearly not true. Disabling barriers are

    man-made, and, as such,they can be removed. What is required is a willingness to take

    positive and timely action.

    Timely action consists of tackling disabling barriers at the design stage. The majority of

    developers only confront the issue of Access for All, after a development project has been

    completed. Unfortunately, this approach usually involves them in extra costs, costs which

    they often find prohibitive and which they are therefore reluctant to incur. However, when

    the issue of Access for All is tackled at the design stage, the vast majority of problems

    associated with alternative access are solved efficiently and with a minimum overall outlay.

    That is why we believe that if the concept of Design for All is given priority right at theinception stage of any development project, compliance with the provisions of the Equal

    Opportunities (Persons with Disability) Act and other Access for All regulations, will be

    trouble- free and cost effective.

    Finally, this document was produced by a team of people made up of Mr. F. Bezzina, Mr. F.

    Cachia and myself on behalf of the Secretariat of the Kummissjoni Nazzjonali Persuni

    b'Dizabilita and the following group of architects whom I would like to take the opportunity

    to thank for the sterling contribution they have made and are making in this, and other,

    accessibility-related issues:

    P.E.Camilleri BE&A (Hons.), A&CE

    Ph. Grech BE&A (Hons), MSc(Bir), MCIWEM, A&CE

    V. Schembri BE&A (Hons.), A&CE J. H. Spiteri BE&A (Hons), MSc(Edin), PhD(Leeds), MCIOB, A&CE (Team Co-

    ordinator)

    H. Zammit BE&A., Dip C Eng (Glas), PG Dip (Env Mgt), A&CE.

    Joseph M. Camilleri

    CHAIR

    KUMMISSJONI NAZZJONALI PERSUNI B'DIZABILITA

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    6/38

    1.0 INTRODUCTION

    Architecture should involve the creation of spaces for use by people. In the organisation of

    such spaces, shortcomings in design may create 'architectural barriers'. Architectural

    barriers are everywhere in existing buildings: in schools, shopping areas, workplaces and a

    large number of buildings that are intended for and are in fact used by the general public.

    The environment continues to hamper and frustrate the functioning of disabled persons,while most 'able-bodied' persons are unaware of the problem. Within the existing building

    stock, providing access for all may require a number of alterations, including structural

    alterations.

    The question of providing access for all in new buildings has deeper significance than merely

    providing means to negotiate physical barriers (e.g., ramps in changes of levels, etc.). New

    buildings should be designed in such a way that physical barriers would not exist as a

    matter of course. This requires a new mentality towards the design of buildings and building

    services.

    A number of publications containing architectural design guidelines for Accessibility for All

    exist. However, these criteria are not uniform; they vary in standards and may give rise to

    some degree of ambiguity. This publication has been designed to incorporate the standards

    that will be adopted by the National Commission Persons with Disability in executing its

    responsibility and authority under the Equal Opportunities Act, 2000. It includes graphicalillustration of the standards contained in the text, for further ease of reference.

    2.0 LAYOUT OF THIS DOCUMENT

    This document is laid out in a manner to assist designers and all those concerned in

    determining the spatial layout and fitting of buildings. It is important that all the features

    relating to building development are designed in a manner that conforms to Access for All

    requirements.

    The applicability of this document is primarily to all those forms of development scheduled

    in the circular PA 3/99 issued on 14 December 1999. However, the objective of Access forAll should not be perceived solely as a legal requirement, but one that enhances the usage

    of any development

    Sections 3 and 4 of this document indicate the basic overall objectives of Access for All.

    These sections outline in a general way the objectives that are considered vital to achieving

    the aspirations expressed in the Equal Opportunities Act 2000. These general objectives are

    articulated in greater detail in the subsequent sections.

    For ease of reference the features required to provide Access for All have been sub-divided

    into three building

    zones. The first (Section 5) relates to the 'outside' areas of buildings, including car parks

    and approaches to the building. The standards concerning ramps, staircases and handrails

    included in this section refer to both outdoor

    and indoor areas. Therefore they are not repeated in section 7 concerning internal areas.

    This is followed by section 6 which describes the desirable features at the interface of

    buildings with the external environment, namely the entrances (and exits) to buildings.

    Finally, section 7 provides guidance to Access for All features within the internal areas of

    buildings. This section includes sub sections that are likely to be relevant to all buildings,

    such as WC facilities and lobby and corridor dimensions.

    The final section of this document refer to features that are likely to be relevant to particular

    types of buildings, such as restaurants, hotels etc.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    7/38

    3.0 MAIN GOAL

    In designing buildings it is important that everybody including persons with disability are

    able to reach and use the internal and external facilities associated with the building or

    facility.

    4.0 OVERALL OBJECTIVES

    4.1 EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT

    A suitable means of access to the building is to be provided for persons with

    disability in outside areas, from the point of entrance to the building, and from car

    parking provided within the building site.

    Suitable recognition shall be made of the difficulties encountered by wheelchair users

    and ambulant persons with disability in negotiating changes of levels.

    The risks to persons with disability, particularly those with sight disabilities, must be

    taken into consideration when designing routes passing close to buildings. Persons with disability should be able to use the principal access to a building and

    not be relegated to a secondary entrance whether they are a customer, visitor or a

    member of staff. Where this is not possible, an additional entrance is to be provided,

    giving suitable internal access to the principal access/ entrance area.

    Consideration should be given to providing alternative means of access as the needs

    of all persons with disability vary.

    All approaches should be level. In exceptional cases, where a level approach cannot

    be provided, gradients should be kept as low as possible.

    Where possible, easy going steps should complement a ramped approach.

    Consideration should be given to the space requirements of persons with disability inapproaching buildings from the point of view of the:

    1. the characteristics of their impairment and the mechanical assistance they employ,

    2. those who accompany persons with disability, and

    3. the need to provide access to persons overtaking or coming in the opposite direction.

    Routes to entrances to buildings should be clearly signed and appropriately lit.

    Single steps and obstructions near entrances should be avoided.

    The use of colour, details, materials and position to distinguish the entrance from the

    facade should becarefully considered.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    8/38

    4.2 ENTRANCES TO BUILDINGS

    A suitable means of entry into the building is to be provided for persons with

    disability from outside areas, to the point of entrance to the building, to entrance

    lobbies and to the interior of the building.

    Entrances to buildings should be placed in a logical relationship with routes that

    serve them and be easily distinguishable from the facade.

    Clear signs indicating the entrance should be provided. These should be visible fromall approaches to the building. Signs hanging perpendicular to the building facade are

    useful.

    Door closers should be adjusted to the minimum force necessary, be slow in

    operation and regularly maintained.

    Thresholds should be flush wherever possible.

    Lobbies should be sized to allow wheelchair users to move clear of the first door

    before negotiating the second.

    Signs should be obvious and clear indicating where visitors should go to find

    reception, information point, lifts stairs or WCs.

    Exit doors, particularly those intended for emergency egress are as important asentrances. Hence, similar conditions apply to emergency exits.

    4.3 INTERNAL ENVIRONMENT

    A suitable means of access is to be provided for persons with disability in all areas.

    The layout of spaces and minimum dimensions of all circulation spaces and other

    facilities should be designed to allow, inter alia, easy and safe access by wheelchair

    users and ambulant disabled persons.

    Clear signs indicating facilities should be provided.

    Door closers should be adjusted to the minimum force necessary, be slow in

    operation and regularly maintained.

    Changes in level should be avoided wherever possible in the internal layout of

    buildings.

    Internal lobbies should be sized to allow wheelchair users to move clear of the first

    door before negotiating a second set of doors. Sanitary facilities suitable for use by persons with disability should be provided both

    in terms of location within the building as well as in terms of the dimensions of the

    facilities intended for use by disabled persons and the sanitary fittings incorporatedin these facilities.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    9/38

    5.0 THE EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT OF BUILDINGS

    5.1 ACCESS

    5.1.1 Access shall be provided through the principal entrance. Where separate entrances

    are provided for visitors or customers and staff, the respective entrances shall each be

    accessible by persons with disability.

    5.1.2 In exceptional cases, where the space outside a principal entrance is restricted, or

    likely to be congested, or the site is on sloping ground, access through an alternative

    entrance may be accepted, if this is also intended for

    general use.

    5.1.3 Hanging signs, lights, awnings and similar objects shall have a minimum clearance of

    2.00 metres above the ground or finished floor level of the access route or usable area.

    5.2 KERBS AND PAVEMENTS

    At entrances to public buildings and road crossings, ramped kerbs should be provided. The

    following principles apply:

    5.2.1 Where a new pavement is being constructed or an existing pavement is being

    renewed ramps should have a gradient as defiend in the table in section 5.5.1. The

    pavement should have a tactile surface extending 1.5m or the full width of the pavement,

    whichever the greater (Figure 1).

    5.2.2 A textured surface or painted edge is desirable to assist the partially sighted.

    5.2.3 Sudden changes in level should be avoided. (Figure 1)

    5.2.4 Figures 2 to 4 show recommended kerb ramp locations at intersections.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    10/38

    5.2.5 Where gratings are necessary, these should to oriented with the long dimension

    perpendicular to pedestrian route. The maximum width between ribs is not to exceed 10mm

    in the direction of traffic flow.

    5.2.6 Figure 5 Grate orientation to path of travel

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    11/38

    5.3 CAR PARKING

    5.3.1 Car parking bays for use by persons with disability shall have a minimum width of

    3600mm and a minimum

    length of 4800mm (perpendicular parking) or 6600mm (parallel parking). (Figures 6 and 7).

    5.3.2 Suitable, adequate car parking space provision shall be made for persons with

    disability. The following table indicates the number of parking spaces suitable for disabledpersons required in terms of accessible spaces per total number of parking spaces.

    Total number of

    parking spacesNumber of accessible of spaces required

    3 - 10 1 space*

    11 - 25 1 van accessible space**

    26 - 50 2 including 1 van accessible space

    51 - 75 3 including 1 van accessible space

    76-100 4 including 1 van accessible space

    101-150 5 including 1 van accessible space

    151-200 6 including 1 van accessible space

    201-300 7 including 1 van accessible space

    301-400 8 including 1 van accessible space

    401-500 9 including 2 van accessible spaces

    501-1000 2% including 3 van accessible spaces

    More than 1000

    20 + 1 per 100 or fraction, including minimum 1

    van accessible space per 8 accessible spaces or

    fraction thereof

    * A space refers to the dimensions indicated in paragraph 5.3.1.

    ** A van accessible space should be minimum 7300mm long and 2900mm wide with

    2300mm headroom.

    5.3.3 A sign incorporating the symbol of access shall identify car parking spaces for persons

    with disability. The sign shall be readily visible from a vehicle at the access to the parking

    area, or guide signs shall be provided to indicate the direction of the space. Bays should be

    identified as provision for disabled drivers or passengers only.

    5.3.4 Parking bays should be close to entrances to the facilities the car park serves - within

    50m if uncovered, 100m if covered.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    12/38

    5.3.5 Kerbs between the parking area and routes to buildings should be dropped to give

    access to wheelchair users.5.3.5 The car park surface should be smooth and even and free from loose stones.

    5.4 APPROACHES TO THE ENTRANCE OF A BUILDING

    5.4.1 The approach shall preferably be level. Where it is not possible to have a level

    approach the slope should not

    be steeper than the gradients indicated in table 5.5.1, below.

    5.4.2 The approach shall have a clear width of at least 1200mm.

    5.4.3 Where a pedestrian route to the building is intended for use by persons with different

    needs, and where provision is made for bollards, rails or the like to limit vehicular access

    the following criteria shall be observed:

    i) The bollards, rails or other devices shall be located to give 1000mm clear width access.ii) A textured surface to warn those with limited sight should be provided.

    5.4.4 Polished floors are not acceptable for external areas.

    5.5 RAMPS

    The following conditions are to be adhered to in all instances where ramps are provided to

    negotiate difference in levels, both in external as well as in internal areas.

    5.5.1 Gradients

    Gradients shall be no steeper than the values indicated below:

    Vertical height of Ramp Maximum permissible gradient

    Less than 100mm 1:10

    Less than 250mm 1:12

    Less than 500mm 1:16

    Greater than 500mm 1:20

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    13/38

    5.5.2 Markings of change of level Where there is any change of level along a pedestrian

    access route the position of the change shall be visibly and permanently marked.

    5.5.3 Top and bottom landings shall have a textured surface.

    5.5.4 Length of Ramp

    The maximum horizontal length of a ramp should be limited to twelve (12) metres. Longer

    ramps are to have

    intermediate landings. (Figures 9 and 10)

    5.5.5 Landings

    Flights shall have landings at the top and bottom, each of whose length shall not be less

    than 1200mm and, if necessary, intermediate landings, each of whose lengths is not less

    than 1500mm, in all cases clear of any door swing. (See Figures 8 to 10 for dimensions of

    ramps and landings)

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    14/38

    5.5.6 Widths of Ramps

    Ramps shall have flights whose surface widths are at least 1200mm and unobstructed

    widths at least 1000mm.

    5.5.7 Surface Finishes

    Ramps shall have a surface which reduces the risk of slipping.

    5.5.8 Where any material is likely to alter the character of a surface with which pedestrians

    and vehicles are likely or intended to come in contact then appropriate consideration must

    be given to ensuring that any risk of slipping is reduced to an appropriate degree.

    5.5.9 Headroom All ramps and landings shall have a clear headroom throughout of at least

    two metres.

    Handrails for ramps

    5.5.10 All ramps shall have at least one handrail that should be continuous along the length

    of the ramp.

    5.5.11 Ramps shall have a handrail on both sides of the ramp where the length of the ramp

    exceeds 2.0 metres.

    5.5.12 Ramps shall have a handrail on both sides of the ramp where the ramp is greater

    than 1.5 metres in width.

    5.5.13 The handrails should have a suitable profile (normally round) and manufactured with

    appropriate materials to provide a good grip and should have a maximum outside diameterof 50mm (Figure 14).

    5.5.14 Ramps where crowding or heavy volumes of traffic can be anticipated shall

    additionally have a central handrail where the flight is wider than 2400mm.

    5.5.15 Handrails should give firm support.

    5.5.16 Handrails shall extend at least 300mm beyond the beginning of the ramp and at

    least 300mm beyond the end of the ramp.

    5.5.17 Handrails should be fixed at a height of 900mm above the ground level of ramps and

    1000mm above landings

    (Figure 8).

    Guarding for ramps

    5.5.18 Ramps shall have a raised kerb at least 100mm high on any open side of a flight or a

    landing, if no other equivalent protection is provided (Figure 8).

    Adjacent steps to ramps

    5.5.19 A ramp should always have an adjacent flight of steps to negotiate the difference in

    levels connected by the ramp.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    15/38

    5.6 STAIRS

    N.B. The conditions for stairs apply both to external as well as internal stairs.

    Steepness of stairs

    5.6.1

    The angle of pitch of staircases shall be limited to 42 degrees in private stairs and 38degrees in common/public stairs

    Rise and going dimensions

    5.6.2

    In any flight of stairs all steps shall have the same rise height and the same going width

    throughout the entire flight.

    5.6.3 If the landing of an outside stair is formed by the ground and slopes across the width

    of the flight, then

    the rise of the step shall be measured at the mid-point of the width of the flight. However,

    the variation at each end should not exceed 15mm from the normal rise adopted.

    5.6.4 The normal relationship between the dimensions of the rise and going is that twice theriser plus the going shall be between 550mm and 700mm. However, the rise of each step

    shall not be greater than the figures

    given in the Table below.

    Stairs Riser Maximum

    Private Stair 200mm

    Stairway in external public and common areas 150mm

    Internal stairway in public buildings 170mm

    Construction of steps

    5.6.5 Steps shall have level treads.

    5.6.6 Open risers staircases will only be permitted in public areas where an alternative

    staircase that has closed risers is provided in reasonable close vicinity to the open-riser

    staircase.

    5.6.7 Steps may have open risers but the treads shall then overlap each other by at least

    16mm. Where open risers are constructed, the gap left should reject a 100mm sphere.

    5.6.8 Recessed risers are not acceptable as they may cause persons with disability to trip.

    (Figure 11)

    5.6.9 To facilitate stair use by persons with disability, tread/riser/nosing profiles as

    indicated in Figure 12 are recommended.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    16/38

    Width of flights

    5.6.10 The minimum width of stairs in outdoor areas should be 1800mm provided that any

    stairs in outside areas or places of assembly shall have no flight wider than 1800mm unless

    it is divided by handrails into widths no greater than 1800mm. (Figure 13)5.6.11 The minimum width of stairs in indoor areas should be 1200mm provided that any

    stairs inside a public building shall have no flight wider than 1200mm unless it is divided by

    handrails into widths no greater than

    1200mm.

    The width of flights, landings and ramps is to be measured as the unobstructed width

    between walls or handrails, whichever is the narrower. Minor intrusions such as posts or

    strings and skirting may be ignored.

    Length of flights

    5.6.12 The number of risers in between landings in a flight shall be limited to a maximum of

    11 if a stairway is in a public building or serves an area used for assembly purposes.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    17/38

    Headroom

    5.6.13 All stairs shall have a clear headroom over the length and width of the stairway and

    its associated landings of at least two metres measured vertically from the line of pitch.

    Staircase landings

    5.6.14 Landings shall be provided at the top and bottom of every flight. The width anddepth of landing shall be large enough to provide at least 400mm clear space from any door

    swing.

    5.6.15 Part of the floor of the building may be considered as a landing.

    5.6.16 To afford safe passage, landings shall be clear of any permanent obstruction.

    5.6.17 A landing need not be provided between a flight and a door if the rise of the flight is

    not more than 600mm and the door slides or opens away from the steps.

    5.6.18 A door may swing across a landing at the bottom or top of a flight provided that it

    will leave at least a clear space equivalent to the width of the flight.

    5.6.19 Landings shall be level unless they are formed by the ground at the top or bottom of

    a flight. They may then slope up to 1 in 20 provided that the ground is paved or otherwise

    made firm.

    5.7 Handrails

    5.7.1 Handrails should be continuous to flights and across landings, with the rails

    distinguishable from the background by colour and brightness.

    5.7.2 Handrails should give firm support and should have a suitable profile (normally round)

    with a maximum outside diameter of 50mm. See Figure 14 for guidance of acceptable

    handrail profiles.

    5.7.3 Indoor flights shall have a handrail on at least one side if they are less than 1200mm

    wide. A handrail on each side should be provided for flights that are between 1200mm and

    2400mm wide. Central handrails providing bays of 1200mm should be provided for flights

    exceeding 2400mm in width.

    5.7.4 Outdoor flights and those in areas of assembly shall have a handrail on both sides if

    they are less than 1800mm wide. Flights wider than 1800mm shall be provided with central

    handrails providing bays of not more than 1800mm in width.

    5.7.5 Handrails shall extend at least 300mm from a point vertically above the lowest stair

    nosing of a flight and at least 300mm from a point vertically above the top stair nosing of a

    flight. (Figure 15)

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    18/38

    5.7.6 The top of the handrail is to be 900mm above the pitch line of a flight and 1000mm

    above the surface of a landing.

    5.7.7 It is recommended that a second handrail is provided at a height of 650mm above the

    line of pitch of the stairs.

    5.7.8 For compliance with Access for All provisions, each building shall have at least one

    staircase complying to the minimum dimensions shown in Figures 16 and 17 for staircaseswith enclosed wells and open well staircases, serving all floors, apart from any necessary

    mechanised vertical lift device suitable for wheelchair user.

    5.8 GUARDS AND BARRIERS

    5.8.1 Guarding shall be provided where it is reasonably necessary for safety to guard the

    edges of any part of a raised floor, gallery, balcony, roof (including roof-lights and other

    openings), and other places to which people have access, (unless it is only for the purpose

    of maintenance or repair) and any light well, basement or similar sunken area next to a

    building. Guarding shall also be provided where there is a difference in level between vehicle

    parks, but not on ramps used only for vehicle access.

    5.8.2 Any glazing panels used in guards or barriers shall be constructed of glass blocks orlaminated glass.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    19/38

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    20/38

    6.0 ENTRANCES TO BUILDINGS

    6.1 ENTRANCE DOORWAYS

    6.1.1 To be suitable as a means of access, an entrance door should provide:

    i) sufficient space for manoeuvres.

    ii) space outside the leading edge of the door to reduce the risk of wheelchairs striking awall.

    iii) the opportunity to be warned of the approach of people from the other side of a door.

    6.1.2 The principle entrance door should a have a minimum clear opening width of not less

    than 900mm. (See Figure 18).

    6.1.3 The principle entrance door should permit an unobstructed space on the side next to

    the leading edge of the door of at least 300mm unless the door is controlled by a suitable

    automatic control.6.1.4 The principle entrance door should be provided with a glazed panel giving a zone of

    visibility from a height of 900mm to 1500mm from the finished floor level wherever the

    opening action of the door could constitute a hazard. (See Figure 19).

    6.1.5 The principle entrance door should be designed, marked or signed in such a way so

    that persons of different

    needs can readily identify the glass.

    6.1.6 The principle entrance door should be clearly marked to indicate whether the door is

    to be pushed or pulled to open.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    21/38

    6.1.7 Where doors are fitted with self closing mechanisms, the pressure to open such doors

    should not exceed

    the following values:i) external doors 2.50 kgf

    ii) internal doors 2.25 kgf

    iii) fire doors 6.75 kgf

    6.1.8 An entrance fitted with a revolving door shall also have an adjacent door conforming

    to paras. 6.1.1 to 6.1.7 above.

    6.1.9 Exit doors, particularly those for emergency egress, are as important as entrances. A

    minimum 900mm clear opening, level thresholds and external ramps where necessary also

    apply to exits that are not combined with entrances.

    6.1.10 Door furniture should be clearly distinguishable from the door using tonal contrast

    and be designed and positioned to be easily reached and gripped. Door handles should

    preferably be fixed at 1000mm above ground level. Figure 20 illustrates acceptable door

    ironmongery.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    22/38

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    23/38

    6.3 THRESHOLDS

    6.3.1 The tolerated change in level at thresholds is 6mm. (See Figure 22).

    6.3.2 Where provided, firm, flush mounted mats are preferable to mats which may be

    inadequately anchored and

    interfere with wheelchair traffic. (Figure 23).

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    24/38

    7.0 INTERNAL ENVIRONMENT OF BUILDINGS

    7.1 BUILDING SURFACE FINISHES

    Protection against slipping

    7.1.1 All building flooring surfaces, pavements and roads upon which pedestrians are likely

    to come into contact with shall be designed, specified and constructed so as to reduce the

    risk of slipping.

    7.1.2 Polished floors are only acceptable in areas where water or materials giving a similar

    effect are not likely to be spilled or splashed.

    7.1.3 Polished floors are not acceptable for external areas, bathrooms, toilets, indoor pool

    areas, industrial plants and other spaces where water or other similar materials are likely to

    give rise to danger.

    Protection against falling

    7.1.4 All floors, ramps and stairways in or associated with buildings are to be designed,

    specified and constructed to protect pedestrians from significant drops in level.

    7.1.5 All windows shall be designed to protect against users, particularly visually impaired

    persons, falling through an opened window.

    Floors

    7.1.6 All flooring surfaces are to be firm, regular, functional and provide an indication of

    significant hazards or changes in levels.

    7.1.7 Floor surfaces should be flush at intersections with particular attention paid to the

    installation of grates and mats.7.1.8 The use of deep pile, open texture, soft mats or unsecured carpets that impede

    wheelchair movement are to be avoided.

    Walls

    7.1.9 Features on walls and floors should be recessed wherever possible.

    7.1.10 Sharp angles or junctions in finishes should be avoided.

    7.1.11 Where wall finishes are accessible to touch, rough textures should be avoided.

    Work surfaces

    7.1.12 Sharp edges on work surfaces should be avoided. Due consideration should be taken

    to provide for persons

    with restricted reach.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    25/38

    7.2 INTERNAL LOBBIES

    7.2.1 Internal lobbies should cater for similar requirements as entrance lobbies.

    7.2.2 Internal lobbies shall have at least the minimum dimensions set out in the Table

    below:

    Conditions within lobbies Internal Internal width length

    Single door ope+ning into the lobby on the same line as the outward opening exit door

    1200mm* 2000mm or 1500mm** 1700mmSingle door opening into the lobby on the same line as the inward opening exit door

    1200mm* 2400mm or 1500mm** 2100mm

    Single door opening into the lobby, the access line being at right angles to the outward

    opening exit door. 1200mm 2000mm

    One pair of double doors opening into the lobby one the same line of access as an outward

    double leaf opening exit pair 1800mm 2000m

    Two pairs of double swing double doors both opening into the lobby and on the same line of

    access 1800mm

    2400m

    * A 600mm minimum unobstructed space should be provided next to the leading edge of

    the door.

    ** A 300mm minimum unobstructed space should be provided next to the leading edge of

    both doors.

    7.3 INTERNAL DOORS

    Door openings

    7.3.1 Doors should have ironmongery that is suitable for use by persons with disability.

    7.3.2 Any door fitted with a self-closing device should be suitable for operation by a person

    with disability.

    7.3.3 The door and its opening should contain a leaf which provides a minimum clear

    opening width of not less than 850mm.

    7.3.4 The door and its opening should permit an unobstructed space on the side next to the

    leading edge of the door of at least 300mm unless the door is controlled by a suitable

    automatic control.

    7.3.5 Each door across an accessible corridor or passageway should be provided with a

    glazed panel giving a zone of visibility from a height of 900mm to 1500mm from the

    finished floor level.

    Ironmongery

    7.3.6 Door handles or door pulls should be located at a height of 1000mm from the finished

    floor level. Ironmongery

    should conform to the styles and dimensions shown in Figure 20.

    7.3.7 Handles are to be of the lever type.

    7.3.8 Where a lever door handle is used it should have a diameter of at least 20mm.7.3.9 Where a pull handle is used it should have a maximum diameter of 35mm.

    7.3.10 Both a lever and pull door handle should have a clear distance to the door face of

    45mm.

    Glazed doors

    7.3.11 Where full glazed doors are installed, a minimum 300mm high kick plate should be

    provided to protect the bottom of the door.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    26/38

    7.4 CORRIDORS AND PASSAGEWAYS

    7.4.1 Corridors and passageways shall have a clear width of at least 1100mm for corridors

    of length up to 15m and a minimum width of 1500mm for lengths over 15 m (see Figure

    25).

    7.4.2 Corridors must have sufficient space at corners to accommodate the turning

    movement of a wheelchair as set out in Figures 25 to 28.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    27/38

    7.5 PASSENGER LIFTS

    7.5.1 Passenger lifts shall be designed to cater for persons using wheelchairs. (See Figure

    29).

    7.5.2 Persons with disability should be able to summon and control the lift as well as reach

    any emergency communications device.

    7.5.3 All lifts serving more than two floors shall have an auditory and visual signal to

    indicate the floor level

    the lift has reached.

    7.5.4 Measures should be adopted to ensure that no one, particularly persons with disability

    will come in contact with the closing doors of the lift.

    7.5.5 Access by a suitable lift shall be provided to serve any storey above or below the

    principle entrance storey, if that storey contains function or use that falls within the uses as

    defined from time to time by the competent authorities.

    7.5.6 A suitable means of access from the lift to the remainder of the storey shall be

    provided in all cases.

    7.5.7 A passenger lift meeting the requirements of Access for All shall have:

    i) a clear landing at least 1500mm wide and at least 1500mm deep in front of the lift doors.

    ii) a door or doors with a clear opening width of at least 900mm.

    iii) a car whose width is at least 1100mm and whose depth is at least 1400mm. (See Figure

    29).

    iv) a landing and car controls which are between 900mm and 1200mm above the landing

    and the car floor, and at least 400mm from the front wall of the car.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    28/38

    v) a suitable tactile indication on the landing and adjacent to the lift call button to identify

    the relevant storey.

    7.5.8 Lifts shall incorporate a drop down seat, designed to support a load of not less than

    130 kg.7.5.9 Lifts shall incorporate a suitable tactile indication on, or adjacent to, the lift buttons

    within the car to confirm the floor selected.

    7.5.10 The distance between lifts and the extremity of the floor it serves shall be no greater

    than forty metres.

    7.5.11 Lifts shall incorporate a signalling system that gives 5 seconds notification that the

    lift is answering a call, and a dwell time of 5 seconds before its doors begin to close after

    they are fully open. The system may be overridden by a door reactivating device which

    relies on photo-electric or infra red sensor, but not a pressure sensitive device, provided

    that the minimum time for a lift door to remain fully open is 5 seconds.

    Wheelchair stairlifts

    7.5.12 Where it may be impractical to provide a passenger lift, a wheelchair stairs lift may

    constitute a reasonable alternative.

    Platform lifts

    7.5.13 The provision of a ramp within a building to effect a change of level within a storey

    may be impractical for planning reasons. Under these circumstances it is reasonable to

    install a platform lift.

    7.5.14 Where a platform lift is installed, a stair access shall be provided to complement the

    platform lift, such that:

    a) the stairs shall be designed to satisfy the needs of ambulant persons with different

    needs, and,

    b) the stairs shall be designed to satisfy the needs of people with impaired vision.

    7.5.15 The minimum dimensions of a platform lift are 850mm by 1200mm.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    29/38

    7.6 SANITARY FACILITIES

    7.6.1 Sanitary accommodation should be readily available for persons with disability.

    7.6.2 Travel distances to accessible sanitary accommodation from any point in the building

    is to be no greater than 40m.

    7.6.3 A wheelchair user should not have to travel more than one storey to have access tosanitary accommodation.

    7.6.4 Sanitary accommodation for wheelchair users may be provided in unisex or integral

    basis. Unisex provision should be made separately from any provision made for male and

    female sanitary accommodation. Preferably, integral provision should be made within the

    male and female areas of sanitary accommodation.

    7.6.5 Sanitary accommodation for both unisex and integral facilities must conform to the

    standard as indicated below. The facilities should:

    i) permit manoeuvrability of a wheelchair.

    ii) permit frontal, lateral, diagonal and backward transfer onto the WC with the provision for

    hand washing and drying within reach from the WC prior to transfer back to the wheelchair.

    iii) have space for a helper to assist in the transfer.

    7.6.6 Consideration should be given to the need for different characteristics of sanitary

    provision to be made for those who work in a building and those who visit.

    7.6.7 If a building contains more than one WC compartment for wheelchair users, the

    opportunity should be taken to provide both left-and right-handed transfer layouts.

    Staff facilities

    7.6.8 Provision of sanitary accommodation for staff may be within integral or unisex

    compartments.

    7.6.9 Access for different sexes should be, at least, on alternate floors if unisex toilets are

    not provided.

    7.6.10 Cumulative horizontal travel distance should be no more than forty metres from any

    point in the building to sanitary accommodation accessible to persons with disability.

    7.6.11 In a building that has stair access only, sanitary accommodation should be located inthe principal access

    storey unless that storey contains only the principal entrance and vertical circulation areas.

    7.6.12 If a building contains more than one WC compartment for wheelchair users, the

    opportunity should be taken to provide both left-and right-handed transfer layouts.

    7.7 SANITARY ACCOMMODATION

    7.7.1 To be suitable for wheelchair users WC compartments shall have as a minimum, the

    dimensions, equipment and fittings as set out in Figures 30 and 31.

    7.7.2 The WC compartment should have minimum internal dimensions of 2000mm by

    1500mm.

    7.7.3 The WC compartment should have a 850mm single leaf outward opening door set

    lockable from the inside fitted with a lever handle and horizontal pull rail.

    7.7.4 The WC compartment should have a WC installed as follows: the front to be 750mm

    from the wall behind it, the top of the WC 450mm from the finished floor, and the centre

    line to be no closer to the side wall than 450mm.

    7.7.5 The WC compartment should have a wash hand basin, the top to be 750mm from the

    finished floor, and fitted with lever handles.

    7.7.6 The WC compartment should have 35mm diameter horizontal support rails that shall

    be positioned at

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    30/38

    no more than 500mm from the centre line of the WC, on both sides of the WC, at least, one

    being a hinged support rail to permit access and support.

    7.7.7 The height of the support rails in the WC compartment is to be 250mm above the

    height of the WC seat.

    F lever flush (to transfer side)

    P paper towel dispenser

    T toilet paper dispenser

    M mirror

    H hand drier (electric)

    A alarm cord (distinguish from light pull)

    C coat hooks (1200-1400mm high)

    W sealed container for incontinence pads and other disposables

    1 Fixed vertical rail

    2 drop-down rail (easy to use from seated position)

    3 fixed horizontal rail behind WC

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    31/38

    4 fixed horizontal rail

    5 horizontal door pull (to enable door to be closed when entering)

    7.7.8 The WC compartment should have a 35mm minimum diameter 600mm long vertical

    support rail is to be fixed on the free side of the WC, 800mm from the floor, and a second is

    to be fixed at the same height and immediately to the side of the wash hand basin.

    Toilet fittings

    7.7.9 Hand basin, toilet paper holder, rails and other fittings should be located close to the

    toilet bowl at the heights included in Figure 31. A hot air hand drier is preferred to a towel.

    7.7.10 Shallow basins are preferred and should not project into circulation space.

    7.7.11 Adequate knee-room should be allowed beneath the basin to enable a wheelchair

    user to reach the taps. Pedestal basins should not be used.

    7.7.12 Hot water and other pipes should be lagged or boxed beneath basins in order to

    protect those with paralysed limbs.

    7.7.13 Lever taps are required for the purposes of controlling both flow and temperature.

    Shower compartments

    7.7.14 Reasonable provision is to be made in recreational facilities for the provision of

    suitable areas and facilities for persons with disability.

    7.7.15 Shower compartments shall be dimensioned and provided with the facilities as shown

    in Figure 32 and as set out below:

    i) Minimum internal width 1000mm and minimum internal length 900mm.

    ii) Horizontal grab rail 700mm from the floor.

    iii) Vertical grab rail from 900mm to 1400mm from the floor

    iv) Centrally located controls at 900mm from the floor.

    v) The showerhead variable between 1200mm and 2200mm from the floor.

    Dressing cubicles

    7.7.16 Dressing cubicles shall be dimensioned and provided with the facilities set out below:

    i) Internal width 1800mm and internal length 1400mm.

    ii) Horizontal grab rail 700mm from the floor at the side of the seat.

    iii) A mirror from 550mm to 1450mm above floor level.

    iv) A zone for switches etc. at between 900mm and 1200mm above floor level.

    v) A minimum unobstructed internal height of 2200mm.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    32/38

    7.8 LIGHTING

    7.8.1 Lighting shall be appropriate and adequate for the uses to which it is employed.

    Wherever communication is going to take place lighting levels should be adequate to allow

    lip reading.

    Natural lighting

    7.8.2 Windows should be located and detailed to minimise glare.

    7.8.3 Large glazed areas should incorporate a design feature to identify the window.

    7.8.4 Handles and locks should be easy to use in a single action and readily distinguishable.

    7.8.5 Controls should be located in a zone between 900mm and 1200mm from finished floor

    level. (See Figure 33).

    7.8.6 Where applicable sills should be no higher than 800mm above finished floor level in

    order to permit wheelchair users to see on the other side. In all cases due regard to safety

    provisions should be observed.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    33/38

    Artificial lighting

    7.8.7 Light fittings and luminaires should be selected and fixed in places to avoid glare.

    7.8.8 Artificial lighting should be employed to balance natural lighting where there is

    excessive contrast.

    Controls

    7.8.9 Switches and controls should be accessible and easy to operate for those with

    different needs.

    7.8.10 Remote controls should be provided where those with limited mobility may have

    difficulty operating switches.

    7.8.11 Controls should be readily identifiable by devices such as c olour coding.

    7.8.12 Switches should be positioned approximately 1000mm above finished floor level.

    (See Figure 34).

    7.9 COUNTERS AND CHECKOUTS

    7.9.1 Provision should be made for persons with different needs to be able to have easy

    access to and use of counters.

    7.9.2 Counter heights should be located between 600mm and 800mm above finished floor

    level.

    7.9.3 At least one checkout must be provided with a minimum, clear unobstructed width of

    850mm.

    7.9.4 Where appropriate a support rail should be provided.

    7.9.5 Sufficient space should be allowed beyond a checkout for filling shopping bags.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    34/38

    7.9.6 Where turnstiles are installed, provision shall be made for a bypass gate with a

    minimum clear opening of 850mm for the use of those in wheelchairs or the ambulant

    disabled.

    7.9.7 At automatic gates a similar provision as above shall be made.

    7.10 SEATING AND TABLES

    Seating

    7.10.1 Provision should be provided for persons with different needs to rest and wait in

    comfort.

    7.10.2 An optimum height for seating is 450mm above finished floor level with arm rests at

    700mm. Where possible, a range of seating heights should be provided.

    7.10.3 One out of every twelve seats provided should be perch seating, with the seat

    projecting 300mm at a height of 600mm to 800mm above finished floor level.

    Tables and worktops

    7.10.4 Tables with moveable seats located near to an entrance with sufficient space formanoeuvrability are

    preferable to tables with permanent seats.

    7.10.5 Table dimensions for wheelchairs users are a height of between 750mm to 800mm, a

    depth of 550mm and a

    width of 800mm.

    7.10.6 There should be unobstructed space below tables, desks, workbenches and other

    work surfaces to allow wheelchair users full reach.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    35/38

    8.0 COMMUNICATION

    8.1 SIGNS

    8.1.1 The location of signs should be part of the process of planning the building. They

    should be placed in a logical position and be obviously identifiable.

    8.1.2 Signs should be situated so that they do not cause obstruction and should be well lit.8.1.3 Symbols should be used to supplement written signs. Figure 36 indicates typical

    symbols that should be

    used.

    8.1.4 The international symbol of access (See Figure 36) must be adopted within all signs

    depicting this pictogram. The wheelchair figure must always face towards the right unless

    used in a directional sign indicating to the left.

    The outer dimensions of the square should be 65mm square for indoor applications with a

    visibility requirement of up to 9m. The outer dimensions should be 115mm square for

    indoor applications with visibility requirements greater than 9m and outdoors applications

    up to 18m. For applications where the visibility requirements exceed 18m, the outer

    dimensions should be 200mm square.

    8.1.5 The signboard must contrast with the background against which it is seen, and the

    lettering should contrast with the signboard. Yellow lettering and symbols on a black

    background should be used where the background to the sign is light. Black lettering and

    symbols on a yellow background should be used where the background to the sign is dark.

    8.1.6 Lettering styles should be straightforward.

    8.1.7 The finish of all signboards should be of the non-glare type.

    8.1.8 Tactile signs (such as embossed letters, raised pictograms and direction arrows should

    be used where

    they can be easily reached.(e.g. lift controls, door numbers, lockers and WC doors).

    8.1.9 Colour can be used to signal where certain features can be found within a building. For

    example, all walls within core areas containing stairs, lifts and WCs should be painted a

    particular colour to aid orientation.

    8.1.10 Visual information should be provided by distinguishing floor, wall, and ceiling

    planes, door surrounds and decorative features.

    8.1.11 Audio guides should be considered.

    8.1.12 The character proportions of signs should be within the range of 3:5 to 1:1. Theheight of overheard symbols should be a minimum of 75mm.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    36/38

    8.2 OTHER AIDS TO COMMUNICATIONS

    8.2.1 In order to have full benefit of attending a public performance or playing a proper part

    in discussions, a

    person with impaired hearing may need to receive a signal some 20db higher than that

    received by a person with normal hearing. Whichever system is selected it should be

    capable of suppressing reverberation and audience and other environmental noise and

    provide sound without loss or distortion through bad acoustics or extraneous noise.8.2.2 Aids to communications for the benefit of those with hearing aids are to be provided

    at:

    i) Booking and ticket offices and the like where the customer is separated from the vendor

    by a glazed screen.

    ii) In large reception rooms, auditoria, and meeting rooms in excess of l00 m2 in area.

    9.0 MISCELLANEOUS BUILDING TYPES REQUIREMENTS

    9.1 RESTAURANTS AND BARS

    9.1.1 Access shall be available to the full range of services offered.

    9.1.2 Access shall be provided to all bars, self-service counters and waiter serviced areas,

    and at least to half the area where seating is provided.

    9.1.3

    Where there are changes in floor level, reasonable provision for access should be made by

    keeping them to a reasonable scale and permitting access for the ambulant disabled, and at

    least half of the facility available to wheelchair users.

    9.2 FACILITIES PROVIDING ACCOMMODATION FOR THE PUBLIC(e.g. hotel bedrooms, etc.)

    9.2.1 In hotels and guest houses the following provisions shall be made in respect of

    bedrooms:

    i) One guest bedroom out of every twenty guest bedrooms (or part thereof) shall be

    suitable, in terms of dimensions and layout, for use by a person in a wheelchair.

    ii) The entrance door to each guest bedroom shall comply to Access for All standards as

    described in this

    document.

    iii) The entrance door to any other guest bedroom shall have a clear opening width of at

    least 850mm but with the option to dispense with the 300mm space at the side of the door.

    9.2.2 Sanitary accommodation in guest bedrooms that are suitable for use by a person in a

    wheelchair shall be en suite if that is the arrangement for the remainder of the bedrooms.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    37/38

    9.3 ASSEMBLY FACILITIES (e.g. auditoria, theatres, stadia, etc.)

    Audience or spectator seating

    9.3.1 Of the total of fixed audience or spectator seats available, the number of spaces

    suitable for wheelchair users (See Figure 36) shall be no less than that shown in the table

    below.

    Audience seating capacityNumber of seats suitable for

    wheelchair users

    less than 25 1

    26-250 2

    251-500 3

    501 and over 4+

    1 per every additional 250 or part

    thereof

    9.3.2 A 'wheelchair space' should be provided with a clear view of the event.9.3.3 Wheelchair spaces should be designed and located in such a way that their occupants

    may sit adjacent to companions with or without disability.

    9.3.4 The stage as well as all other facilities such as dressing rooms should be accessible to

    persons with

    disability.

  • 7/24/2019 Supplement to BP344

    38/38

    REFERENCES

    Access Audits,

    Centre for Accessible Environments,

    London (1999).

    Access for All,Ohio's Governor's Committee on Employment of the Handicapped, Ohio, (1977).

    Accessibility For All,

    Works Division,

    Government of Malta, (unpublished).

    Americans with Disabilities Act

    Access Guide: Survey Check list,

    Department of Rehabilitation, California, (1996).

    Designing for the Disabled,

    Selwyn Goldsmith, Royal Instate of British

    Architects, England (1994).

    European Manual for an Accessible Built Environment,

    Central Co-ordinating Committee for the Promotion of Accessibility, Netherlands (CCPT)

    (1990).Ligi Opportunitajiet Indaqs (Persuni b'Dizabilita),

    Gvern ta' Malta, (2000).

    IMPORTANT

    Most of the dimensions which appear in these guidelines should be regarded as MINIMUM

    requirements.

    Therefore, where circumstances permit, more generous dimensions should be used.