Summar Training Report - Financial Statment Analysis

8/3/2019 Summar Training Report - Financial Statment Analysis

1/24

A

SUMMER TRAINING REPORT

ON

CREATIVE ANALYSIS

OF FINANCIAL

REPORT

SUBMITTED TO

N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS

MANAGEMENT

GUJARAT UNIVERSITY

AHMEDABAD

SUBMITTED BY

PRANAY SHAH


2/24

Preface

During my training at PUNYAM MANAGEMENT PVT.LTD.,

I observed that the practical training has a great importance to

get familiar with the industrial environment because it is very

essential to import a practical knowledge along with a

theoretical knowledge provide in the four wall of the class room.

In objective behind the industrial training in the summer

vacation is gain in depth knowledge about the specialized

functional area of management i. e. Financial Management.

During the training period at PUNYAM MANAGEMENT PVT.

LTD. I learn many things which one are necessary for being a

student of Financial Management. Training provided me a

comprehensive & analytical study of industrial environment of

the organisation.

My heartly but wishes are always with the company for its

bright future.


3/24

Acknowledgement

I would like to take the opportunity to express my profound

thanks to and gratitude to my guide respected Mr. Devang Jhaveri (MD,

PUNYAM MANAGEMENT PVT. LTD.) For his unceasing effort,

encouragement, help and valuable guidance at every step which has

contributed the most towards the success of this project.

I am also thankful to staff ofPUNYAM MANAGEMENT to

for giving their full support and providing me necessary direction for the

various topics related to the project.

Project student

Pranay Shah


4/24

Executive Summary

Today in the global market reputation and recognition of the

business is must, because competition of the business not only in country

but also internationally. The prime objective of this CREATIVE

ANALYSISis to improve the creativity of the organization.

Doing this project I am getting the knowledge of the banking

system. For this creative analysis there are different types of analysis like

internal analysis, external analysis, trend analysis, ratio analysis and cash

flow analysis. I am using the ratio analysis for my project because it is

used for both internal and external users can understand that how the

company performs for the year.

So I can conclude that proper education and direction with benefits

of analysis can be helpful for improve the performance of theorganization.


5/24

TABLE OF CONTENT

ORGANAIZATION OVERVIEW ............................................................................................................6

PUNYAM IS COMMITTED FOR ........................................................................................................7

WHY MANY UNITS HAD TAKEN PUNYAM CONSULTANCY ...................................................7

MANAGEMENT ...................................................................................................................................7TYPES OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS ...................................................................................................10

Internal analysis .............................................................................................................................. .....10

External analysis ................................................................................................................................ ..10

TOOLS OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS ............................................................................................ .......11

Trend Analysis .............................................................................................................................. .......11

Ratio Analysis .................................................................................................................................. ....11

Debt Equity Ratio .................................................................................................................................12

Shareholders Equity Ratio ........................................................................................................... ........13

Fixed Asset To Long Term Fund .........................................................................................................14

Dividend Cover Ratio ..................................................................................................................... .....15

Current Ratio ........................................................................................................................................15

Return On Capital Employed (ROCE) or Return on Investment (ROI) ............................................. .16

Earnings Per Share ........................................................................................................................... ....18Cash Earnings Per Share ......................................................................................................................18

Net Profit Margin ............................................................................................................................. .... 19

Net Profit Margin ............................................................................................................................. .... 20

Return On Asset ............................................................................................................................... ....21

Asset Turnover Ratio ......................................................................................................................... ..22

Bad Debt Turnover ...............................................................................................................................23

Profit Per Employee ......................................................................................................................... ....24

Expenses Per Employee .......................................................................................................................24

LIMITATION OF THE RATIO ANALYSIS ........................................................................................ .24


6/24

ORGANAIZATION OVERVIEW

PUNYAM (PMSPL) was born in November'1995 in the field of consultancy for ISO:

9000, other international standard, and Management areas and is growing and having

total 250 clients for various types of certification and very rich experience in ISO and

management consultancy.

Group of 12 qualified engineers and management graduates (M.B.A) having

experience of different type of industry and done ISO: 9001, 2000 and other

international certifications for many clients.

PUNYAM is having its office in Vapi for clients located near Vapi areas as well as

Mumbai.

At present Punyam is taking 9 new clients per month and completing their work

within 3 months. After every 3 days average 1 client of Punyam is getting ISO: 9001,

ISO: 14001, HACCP, CE Mark or any other certificate.

All the Punyam clients have got ISO: 9000 series certificate from the leading

certifying body like KPMG, BVQI, SGS, LLOYDS, DNV, TUV, U.L. LAB. Etc.

Punyam is also working for vendor Developments & Auditing of companies in India

on behalf of leading international customers.

Their clients include capacity-wise No. 1 companies in Asia as well leading group of

India like

Reliance Industries Limited.

Modern Terry Towels Limited. (Modern Group)

Gujarat Telephone Cables Limited. (GTCL Group)

Meghmani Group Of Companies

Metrochem Industries Limited

Shri Digvijay Cement Co. Ltd.

Binani Cements Limited.


7/24

INDEXTb (Industrial Extension Bureau., Govt. of Gujarat Organization)

Pay back of their consultancy is less than 2 months because of quantification

of measurable goals and providing continual improvement platform.

PUNYAM IS COMMITTED FOR

Personal involvement & Commitment from first day.

Optimum charges.

To complete project in minimum period (Within three months).

Professional approach

To depute dedicated persons to suit client requirements.

Hard work and get work done from others

Strengthening clients by system establishment to make their house in proper

manner

Establishing system in finance and other departments for fund flow

management.

To establish strong internal control with the help of system.

WHY MANY UNITS HAD TAKEN PUNYAM CONSULTANCY

Practical suggestions recommended and having vast experience in the bigger as

well as small companies.

Experience in all kinds of industry like Engineering, Textile, Chemical, Machine

manufacturer, Electronics, Electrical, Pharmaceuticals, etc.

Professional approach and more than 12 highly qualified persons comprise

Engineers / MBA from various disciplines with extensive experience are involved

in their team.

MANAGEMENT

They are providing help to the clients in management areas listed below in four

main ways.


8/24

Arranging in-house training programs.

Establishing system on project base.

Profit sharing based on improvement achieved.

They do total management activity.

a) SYSTEM CERTIFICATION

Reliance Industries Limited. ISO: 9001(Quality System)

ISO: 14001 (Environment)

HACCP (Food Safety)

CE markWHO GMP

OHSAS:18001

BS 7799 ( Information Security Mgt. System)

SA 8000 ( Social Accountability)

NABL Accreditation (ISO/IEC 17025)

b) STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT

Competitive strategy

Organizational leadership for 21st century

Business Process Improvement (BPI)

Six sigma

c) MARKETING

International marketing

Market research

Managing retailing

Institutional marketing

Product policy & new product management

Franchisees management

Customer based business strategies

SWOT analysis and marketing plans


9/24

d) PURCHASE

Sharpening negotiation skills

Vendor development and evaluation

Supply chain management

System audit for vendors

e) PRODUCTION AND QUALITY CONTROL

Project management

Process refinement

Excellence in manufacturing

Quality assurance establishment

f) FINANCE

Creative solutions to finance problems

Advanced data analysis for financial decisions

Strategic finance management

Finance and costing for non financial staff

g) HRD

Human resource management

Leadership & change management

Key performance appraisal system (KPA)

Creative solutions to HR problems

Goal setting & performance management

Bench marking


10/24

TYPES OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS

The classification of analysis can be made on the basis of material used or according

to the modern operational of the analysis. On the basis of material used financial

analysis can be of two types.

Internal analysis

This analysis is done by those who have accessed the books of accounts and other

information relating to the business concern. This type of analysis is meant for

management purpose. This is conducted by executive employee of the firm as well as

government agencies which have statutory control over such firm.

External analysis

This type of analysis is done by those who are outsider to the business. The outsiders

are investors, creditors, government, etc. these persons mainly depends upon the

published financial statements.


11/24

TOOLS OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS

A no. of technique or devices is used to undertake financial analysis. The fundamental

objectives of any analytical method are to simplify the data to more understandable

terms. The following are the important tools of financial analysis:

Comparative Financial Statements

Trend Analysis

Ratio Analysis

Fund Flow Analysis

Cash Flow Analysis

Trend Analysis

In trend analysis, trends of various financial parameters are observed and discussed.

Ratio Analysis

Ratio analysis is a very powerful analytical tool useful for measuring performance of

an organization. The ratio analysis concentrates on the inter-relationship among the

figures appearing in the aforementioned four financial statements. The ratio analysis

helps the management to analyse the past performance of the firm and to make further

projections. Ratio analysis allow interested parties like shareholders, investors,

creditors, Government and analysis to make an evaluation of certain aspects of a

firms performance.

Ratio analysis is a process of comparison of one figure against another, which makes

a ratio and the appraisal of the ratios to make proper analysis about the strengths andweaknesses of the firms operations. Ratio analysis is extremely helpful in providing

valuable insight into a companys financial picture.


12/24

Debt Equity Ratio

This ratio indicates the relationship between loan funds and net worth of the company

which is known as gearing. If the proportion of debt to equity is low, a company is

said to be a low geared, and vice a versa. A debt equity ratio of 2:1 is the norm

accepted by financial institution. The higher the gearing, the more explosive the return

to the shareholders.

Higher debt has lower cost as it provide tax shield. But as the present scenario of

many banks are now days reduce their debt component and then we considering the

debt equity proportion.

Debt Equity Ratio

2.4559

3.0174

1.5538

1.2882

BOI

BOM

UB

VB

Interpretation:-

The relationship between borrowed funds and owners capital is a popular measure of

long-term financial solvency of the firm. The ratio reflects the share holders against

the assets of the firm. As debt-equity ratio is the safety margin for creditors.

In Bank of Maharastra (BOM) the debt-equity ratio is high. It means the bank has

more long term liabilities towards its creditors. This is the warning for the long term

creditors of the bank. In future it is uncertain for company to meet is long term

obligation for improving the condition the firm has to reduce long term debt orincrease shareholders fund.

Ratio BOI BOM UB VB AVG Better when Type

Debt Equity 2.4559 3.0174 1.5538 1.2882 2.0788 Balanced Solvency


13/24

In Bank of India (BOI) and Uco Bank (UB) the debt-equity ratio is near to the average

bank sectors debt-equity ratio. So the condition of these banks are better then BOM.

According to Earnings per Share BOI's position is strong because it is highest

amongst other banks.

Shareholders Equity Ratio


Shareholders Equity 0.0473 0.0446 0.0407 0.0555 0.0470 Higher Solvency

This ratio will supplement the debt-equity ratio. In this ratio the relationship is

established between the shareholders fund and total assets. A reduction in

shareholders equity signaling the over dependence on outside sources for long-term

financial needs and this carries the risk of higher levels of gearing. This ratio indicates

the degree to which unsecured creditors are protected against loss in the event of

liquidation.

Shareholders Equity Ratio

0.0473

0.0440.0407

0.0555

BOI

BOM

UB

VB

Interpretation:-

This ratio is higher when ROCE, EPS, Cash EPS is good for the organization. Here

the position of the BOI is very strong because the EPS is higher then others and Cash

EPS is for BOI is also higher.

This ratio of all the banks is good with the comparison of the average. To interpret

with ROCE the Bank of Maharastra is very good because its return on capital

employed is the higher then other. But to interpret with EPS the Bank of India has the


14/24

highest EPS as compare to the Shareholders equity. So we infer from this ratio that

other banks EPS is not enough as compare to the Shareholders equity ratio.

Fixed Asset To Long Term Fund

This ratio indicates the proportion of long-term funds deployed in fixed assets. Fixed

assets represent the gross fixed assets minus depreciationprovided on this till the date

of calculation. Long term funds include share capital, reverse and surplus and long

term loans. The higher the ratio indicates the safer the funds available in case of

liquidation. It also indicates the proportion of long-term funds that is invested in

working capital.

Fixed Asset to Long Term Fun

0.0100

0.0000.0093

0.0084

BOI

BOM

UB

VB

Interpretation:-

For all the banks this ratio is good for all the banks. It means the ratio for all the banks

is near the average of all the banks. As this ratio says all the banks are safer the funds

in the liquidation.

Belongs to this ratio the fixed assets turnover ratio for the Bank of India is good and

also near the average ratio of all the banks. And the position of other banks is also

good with compare to this ratio. The Asset turnover is slightly depending on this ratio.

Ratios BOI BOM UB VB AVG Better when Type

Fixed Asset to Long Term Fund 0.0100 0.0060 0.0093 0.0084 0.0084 Balanced Solvency


15/24

To interpret with the current ratio the position of all the banks are well but in the case

of the UCO Bank the liquidity is very good as it requires in the banks requires

generally. The total fixed assets with compare to net worth are also the strong in the

case of UCO Bank.

Dividend Cover Ratio


Dividend Cover 0.0061 4.4212 5.4471 3.3641 4.4108 Higher Profitability

This ratio indicates the number of times the dividends are covered by net profit. This

highlights the amount retained by a company for financing of future operations.

Dividend Cover Ratio

0.001

4.4212

5.4471

3.341

BOI

BOM

UB

VB

Interpretation:-

As this ratio says the UCO Bank covers dividend highest number of time by the

profit. And then after the Bank of Maharastra covers dividend highest number of time

by net profit. For this the Bank of India is very poor performance because its dividend

cover ratio is near to the zero. So to improve the image of the organization the bank

has to cover dividend maximum possible number of times. Other banks have average

for dividend cover ratio.

Current Ratio


Current 1.6067 1.4541 1.7565 0.8083 1.4064 Higher Liquidity

This ratio measures the solvency of the company in the short term. A current ratio of2:1 indicates a highly solvent position. A current ratio of1.33:1 is considered by bank


16/24

as the minim\um acceptable level for providing working capital finance. The

constituents of the current assets are as important as the current assets themselves for

evaluation of a companys solvency position.

A very high current ratio will have adverse impact on the profitability of the

organization. A high current ratio may be due to the piling up of inventory,

inefficiency in collection of debtors, high balances in cash and bank accounts without

proper investments.

It is a measure of short term financial strength of the business and shows whether the

business will be able to meet its current liability.

Current Ratio

1.07

1.4541

1.755

0.8083

BOI

BOM

UB

VB

Interpretation:-

The current ratio indicates the working capital position. It is generally believed that

2:1 ratio shows a comfortable working capital position. In Bank of Maharastra

(BOM) the working capital position is much comfortable. In Vijya Bank (VB) the

working capital is about 0.8083 but the Net Profit Margin it has the best position

amongst other banks. So it can infer that the high profit margin of the Vijya Bank is

on the account of scarification of liquidity.

Return On Capital Employed (ROCE) or Return on Investment(ROI)

Ratio BOI BOM UB VB AVG Better when TypeReturn On Capital Employed (ROCE) 0.0128 0.0218 0.0105 0.0191 0.0161 Higher Profitability


17/24

Return on investment analysis provides a strong incentive for optimal utilization of

the assets of the company. This encourages managers to obtain assets that will provide

a satisfactory return on investment and to dispose of assets that are not providing an

acceptable return. In selecting amongst alternative long term investment proposals,

ROI provides a suitable measure for assessment of profitability of each proposal.

This ratio measures the relationship between net profit before interest and tax &

capital employed. This ratio estimates how efficiently long term debts and

shareholders fund has been used.

Return On Capital Employed (ROCE

0.0128

0.02180.0105

0.0191

BOI

BOM

UB

VB

Interpretation:-

This ratio measures the ability of the firm to generate profit per rupee of capital

employed. Higher will be the ratio, higher will be efficiency of the firm.

Interpreting from the graph, it can be infer that Bank of Maharastra (BOM) has the

highest return because of the profitability. In UCO Bank the return is reduced due to

the low profitability. And other banks have around average return. To interpret with

Debt-equity Ratio the ROCE is highest for the BOM so the organization has to reduce

debt for improving the high profitability. Reducing the expenses on debt by reducing

debt-equity ratio can increase the profitability.

So for improve the productivity of the organizations have to reduce the expenses for

getting high productivity.


18/24

Earnings Per Share


Earning Per Share 0.0206 0.0071 0.0054 0.0095 0.0073 Higher Profitability

The EPS is one of the important measures of economic performance of organization.

The flow o capital to the companies under the present imperfect capital market

conditions would be made on the evaluation of EPS. Investors lacking inside and

detailed information would look upon EPS as the best to take their investment

decisions. Higher the EPS means better capital productivity.

Earning Per Share

0.020

0.0071 0.00540.0095

0.0000

0.0050

0.0100

0.0150

0.0200

0.0250

BOI BOM UB VB

Banks

Ratio

Earning Per Share

Interpretation:-

Among all these banks in Bank of India has highest Earnings per Share. And it is very

good for Bank of India. Other banks are very poor with the comparison Bank of India.

In this ratio the position of BOI is good to interpret with Debt Equity & Shareholder's

equity ratio among others but it is not good also because Bad debt turnover ratio is

very high which is not good and other banks are in the strong position in this case

because there is no bad debt of very less.

Cash Earnings Per Share


Cash Earning Per Share 0.0224 0.0081 0.0058 0.0101 0.0116 Higher Profitability,Liquidity


19/24

This is more reliable yardstick for measurement of performance of companies,

especially for highly capital intensive industries where provision for depreciation is

substantial. This measures the cash earnings per share and is also a relevant factor for

determining the price for the companys shares. This method is not as poplar as EPS

and is used as a supplementary measure of performance.

Cash Earning Per Share

0.0224

0.0081

0.0058

0.0101

BOI

BOM

UB

VB

Interpretation:-

This ratio is very important for the external parties who are wanted to buy or invest in

the organization. As we show that as EPS the Cash EPS is high for Bank of India. So

it is clear that BOIs position is very strong.

As EPS and Cash EPS is increases debt-equity and shareholders equity is also

increases. So that share capital is also increases for the organization.

Net Profit Margin


Net Profit Margin 0.1329 0.1141 0.1170 0.1668 0.1327 Higher Profitability

The ratio is designed to focus attention on the net profit margin arising from business

operations before interest and tax is deducted. This ratio reflects net profit margin on

the total sales after deducting all expenses but before deducting interest and taxation.

This ratio measures the efficiency of operation of the company.


20/24

Net Profit Margin

0.1329

0.11410.1170

0.18 BOI

BOM

UB

VB

Interpretation:-

The net profit margin of the Vijya Bank is the highest. The net profit margin, higher is

better for any industry. It suggests that Vijya Bank management is more efficient to

lend or/and borrow at most efficient way than that of the other banks. Performance of

the BOM, BOI and UB are equal and there is a scope of improvements.

Net Profit Margin


Net Profit Margin 0.1329 0.1141 0.1170 0.1668 0.1327 Higher Profitability

Te ratio is designed to focus attention on the net profit margin arising form business

operations before interest and tax is deducted. This ratio reflects net profit margin on

the total sales after deducting all expenses but before deducting interest and taxation.

This ratio measures the efficiency o operation of the company. The net profit is

arrived at from gross profit after deducting administration, selling and distribution

expenses. The nonoperating incomes and expenses are ignored in computation of net

profit before tax, depreciation and interest.

This ratio could be compared with that of the previous years and with that of

competitors to determine the trend in net profit margins of the company and its

performance in the industry. This measure will depict the correct trend of

performance where there are erratic fluctuations in the tax provisions from year to

year.


21/24

Net Profit Margin

0.1329

0.1141

0.1170

0.18

BOI

BOM

UB

VB

Interpretation:-

This is the most important ratio for the organization. Amongst all these banks Vijya

Banks profit is highest. But to interpret with the current ratio the liquidity of the Vijya

bank is not much good as compare with the other banks. So for improve the

performance of the organization the bank has to maintain the liquidity with reference

to the net profit margin.

Return On Asset

The profitability of the firm is measured by establishing relation of net profit with the

total assets of the organisation. This ratio indicates the efficiency of utilization of

assets in generating revenue.

Return on Asset

0.0119

0.0095

0.0099

0.0171BOI

BOM

UB

VB


Return on Asset 0.0119 0.0095 0.0099 0.0171 0.0121 Higher Profitability


22/24

Interpretation:-

Return on Assets is better as it is higher. The Vijya bank is the highest return on the

assets. It means the bank has the highest utilization of the assets during the year.

Other banks have average return on the assets. So for getting the higher return they

have to use maximum assets and this is the based on the net profit.

Now to interpret this ratio with the asset turnover ratio we can also know from with

this two ratio that the profitability of the organization. And again in this case also the

Vijya Bank has the strong position. Other banks profitability is near about the

average.

Asset Turnover Ratio


Asset Turnover 0.0894 0.0828 0.0850 0.1024 0.0899 Lower Activity

This measures the companys ability to generate sales revenue in relation to the size

of the asset investment. A low asset turnover may be remedied by increasing sales or

by disposing of certain assets or both. To assist in establishing which part of the asset

structure I not being used efficiently, the asset turnover ratio should be sub-analyzed.

The higher the ratio indicates overtrading of total assets while a low ratio indicates

idle capacity.

Asset Turnover Ratio

0.0894

0.0828

0.0850

0.1024

BOI

BOM

UB

VB


23/24

Interpretation:-

As this ratio is lower the better then the Bank of Maharastras position is very good

but to interpret with the return on assets the Bank of Maharastra is very week and the

profitability of the organization is also lower then other banks.

Now to interpret both the return on assets and asset turnover ratio with the net profit

margin ratio the Vijya bank is the most efficient bank amongst all the four banks.

So recommendation to each bank regarding assets turnover and the profitability with

reference to present market position.

Bad Debt Turnover


Bad Debt Turnover 83.5120 - 0.0900 - Lower Activity

This ratio indicates the efficiency of the credit control procedures of the company. Its

level will depend on the type of business. The actual ratio is compared with the target

or norm to decide whether or not it is acceptable.

Bad Debt Turnover Ratio

83.5120

0.0900

BOI UB

Interpretation:-

This ratio is as lower as better. Here only two banks have bad debts but the Bank of

India has the highest bad debt which is not good for the organization. So for

increasing the profitability as well as performance of the organization the organization

have to decrease the bad debt with reference to the Sales or Income. Other banks have

no bad-debt so their profitability and the performance is good and the business of theorganization is running very well.


24/24

Profit Per Employee

.6 .

6.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

6.

BOI BOM UB VB

Banks

Profit

Profit Per Employee

Expense Per Employee

. 66.

.

6.

.

.

.

.

.

.

BOI BOM UB VB

Banks

Expenses

Expense Per E mployee

Profit Per Employee

Expenses Per Employee

Profit per Employee is measured that how much the organization getting from the

employee.

Interpretation:-

From the above both graph we can interpret that the expanse per employee is higher

then the profit per employee. So for improve the performance of the organization

there are two ways one is to decreases the expenses on the employee. And the another

way is to decrease the staff of the organization. And this is for all the four banks.

LIMITATION OF THE RATIO ANALYSIS

- Single years ratio has limited utility

- Other factors must be considered

- Use of one ratio is misleading

- Investigation Necessary

- Rigidity harmful

Ratios BOI BOM UB VB AVG Better when Type

Profit Per Employee 234.6193 214.8937 560.2391 353.8457 267.7862 Higher Profitability

Expense Per Employee 1530.9519 1668.1305 4228.1776 1767.4388 1655.5071 Lower Profitability

Summar Training Report - Financial Statment Analysis

Documents

Transcript of Summar Training Report - Financial Statment Analysis