Suggested State Legislation 2012 Volume 71, The Council of State Governments

7/30/2019 Suggested State Legislation 2012 Volume 71, The Council of State Governments

1/269

\^EEN\YNI\YDYN

FNEJ\FDYJMH;?4;

Rmf~gn 54

Inrnfmpni kz ycn

Lmggjyynn mh \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh

Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|

Fnsjheymh& @nhy~l`z

Cndit~d{yn{|1 #3>:* ;99'3???Bds1 #3>:* ;99'3??4

N'gdjf1 |dfn|Ol|e(m{eJhyn{hny1 uuu(l|e(m{e

;?4; \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh 4


2/269

; Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|

Lmpz{jecy ;?44

Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|;52? [n|nd{lc _d{` I{jrn

Fnsjheymh& @Z 9?>44

Gdh~bdly~{ni jh ycn ^hjyni \ydyn| mb Dgn{jld

J\KH1 :53'?'35;:;'559';

Dff {jecy| {n|n{rni( Jht~j{jn| bm{ ~|n mb dhz gdyn{jdf |cm~fi kn ij{nlyni ym1Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|

;52? [n|nd{lc _d{` I{jrnFnsjheymh& @Z 9?>44

#3>:* ;99'3???_~kfjldyjmh \dfn| M{in{ Inpd{ygnhy

4'3??'3??'4:4?N'gdjf1 |dfn|Ol|e(m{e


3/269

\cd{jhe Ldpjymf Jind|(

Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy| j| ycn p{ngjn{ g~fyjk{dhlc m{edhjqdyjmh bm{nld|yjhe

pmfjlz y{nhi| bm{ ycn lmgg~hjyz mb |ydyn|& lmggmhundfyc| dhi yn{{jym{jn| mh d hdyjmhdf dhi{nejmhdf kd|j|(

L\E dfn{y| |ydyn nfnlyni dhi dppmjhyni mbbjljdf| ym ngn{ejhe |mljdf& nlmhmgjl dhipmfjyjldf y{nhi|0 mbbn{| jhhmrdyjrn |ydyn pmfjlz {n|pmh|n| ym {dpjifz lcdhejhe lmhijyjmh|0 dhidirmldyn| g~fyj|ydyn p{mkfng'|mfrjhe ym gdsjgjqn {n|m~{ln| dhi lmgpnyjyjrnhn||(

L\E p{mgmyn| nslnffnhln jh inlj|jmh'gd`jhe dhi fndin{|cjp |`jff| dhi lcdgpjmh| |ydyn|mrn{njehyz(

Lm~hljf Mbbjln{|

Lcdj{1 [np( Kmk Emib{nz& LY _{n|jinhy1 Emr( K{jdh \lcunjyqn{& GYLcdj{'Nfnly1 \nh( Adz \lmyy Ngfn{& @\ _{n|jinhy'Nfnly1 Emr( F~j| Bm{y~m& _[

Rjln Lcdj{1 \nh( Ed{z \ynrnh|& D@ Rjln _{n|jinhy1 Rdldhy

Lm~hljf Mbbjln|

Cndit~d{yn{|1

Idrji Di`jh|& Nsnl~yjrn Ij{nlym{ LNM;52? [n|nd{lc _d{` I{jrnFnsjheymh& @Z 9?>44_cmhn1 #3>:* ;99'3???BDS1 #3>:* ;99'3??4N'gdjf1 jhbmOl|e(m{e

Jhyn{hny1 uuu(l|e(m{eNd|yn{h1Unhinff Cdhhdbm{i& Ij{nlym{4?? Udff \y{nny& ;?yc Bfmm{Hnu Zm{`& HZ 4???>

_cmhn1 #;4;* 93;';


4/269

Bm{num{i

Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy| #L\E* j| pfnd|ni ym mbbn{ ycn ;?4; \~een|yni \ydynFnej|fdyjmh rmf~gn& d rdf~ni |n{jn| mb lmgpjfdyjmh| mb i{dby fnej|fdyjmh dkm~y ympjl| mbjgpm{ydhln ym ycn |ydyn|( Ycn i{dby fnej|fdyjmh bm~hi jh ycj| kmm` {np{n|nhy| gdhz cm~{| mb um{`kz Ycn Lm~hljf| Lmggjyynn mh \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh dhi L\E |ydbb( Ycn nhy{jn| jh ycj|

kmm` un{n |nfnlyni b{mg c~hi{ni| mb |~kgj||jmh|( Gm|y d{n kd|ni mh nsj|yjhe |ydyn |ydy~yn|(Hnjycn{ Ycn Lm~hljf hm{ ycn Lmggjyynn |nn`| ym jhbf~nhln ycn nhdlygnhy mb |ydyn fnej|fdyjmh(Yc{m~ecm~y ycn znd{|& cmunrn{& kmyc cdrn bm~hi ycdy ycn nspn{jnhln| mb mhn |ydyn gdz p{mrnknhnbjljdf ym mycn{|( Jy j| jh ycj| |pj{jy ycdy ycn|n p{mpm|df| d{n p{n|nhyni(

Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy| Idrji Di`jh|Fnsjheymh& @nhy~l`z Nsnl~yjrn Ij{nlym{ LNM

\ydbb Dl`hmufniegnhy|

Ujffjdg @( Rmjy& \nhjm{ _{manly Ij{nlym{Hdhlz A( Rjl`n{|& Hdyjmhdf _{me{dg Digjhj|y{dym{

Ad|mh Gm|nfnz& Enhn{df Lm~h|nf

9 Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|


5/269

Lmhynhy|

Jhy{mi~lyjmh ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( 5\\F _{mln|| (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :\\F L{jyn{jd (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( 4?\~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh \yzfn ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( 44

\dgpfn Dly (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( 4;

\~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh I{dby|

Dbbjidrjy mb Ld{nejrn{ Lmh|nhy bm{ d Gjhm{| Cndfyc Ld{n (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( 444& #3>:* ;99'3???& bds #3>:* ;99'3??4& m{ ||fOl|e(m{e(

[ndin{| |cm~fi `nnp jh gjhi ycdy hnjycn{ Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy| hm{ ycn \\FLmggjyynn dirmldyn ycn nhdlygnhy mb jyng| ycdy d{n p{n|nhyni jh \\F Rmf~gn|( Jh|yndi& ycnnhy{jn| d{n mbbn{ni d| dh dji ym |ydyn mbbjljdf| jhyn{n|yni jh i{dbyjhe fnej|fdyjmh jh d |pnljbjl d{nd&dhi ldh kn fmm`ni ~pmh d| d e~jin ym d{nd| mb k{mdi l~{{nhy jhyn{n|y jh ycn |ydyn|(

Jhyn{n|yni {ndin{| ldh bjhi m~y gm{n dkm~y ycn \\F p{me{dg kz rj|jyjhe ycn \\F pden| dyL\E| Jhyn{hny Unk |jyn dy uuu(l|e(m{e(



9/269


10/269

\\F L{jyn{jd

Imn| ycn j||~n cdrn hdyjmhdf m{ {nejmhdf |jehjbjldhln= D{n b{n|c dhi jhhmrdyjrn dpp{mdlcn| drdjfdkfn ym dii{n|| ycn j||~n= J| ycn j||~n mb |~bbjljnhy lmgpfnsjyz ycdy d kjff i{dbyn{ um~fi knhnbjy b{mg cdrjhe d

lmgp{ncnh|jrn i{dby drdjfdkfn=

Imn| ycn kjff m{ Dly {np{n|nhy d p{dlyjldf dpp{mdlc ym ycn p{mkfng= Imn| ycn kjff m{ Dly {np{n|nhy d lmgp{ncnh|jrn dpp{mdlc ym ycn p{mkfng m{ j| jy

yjni ym d hd{{mu dpp{mdlc ycdy gdz cdrn fjgjyni {nfnrdhln bm{ gdhz |ydyn|=

J| ycn |y{~ly~{n mb ycn kjff m{ Dly fmejldffz lmh|j|ynhy= J| ycn fdhe~den dhi |yzfn mb ycn kjff m{ Dly lfnd{ dhi ~hdgkje~m~|=Ycn um{i Dly d| ~|ni cn{njh {nbn{| ym kmyc p{mpm|ni dhi nhdlyni fnej|fdyjmh( Dyyngpy|

d{n gdin ym nh|~{n ycdy jyng| p{n|nhyni ym lmggjyynn gngkn{| d{n ycn gm|y {nlnhy rn{|jmh|(Cmunrn{& jhyn{n|yni pd{yjn| |cm~fi lmhydly ycn m{jejhdyjhe |ydyn bm{ ycn ~fyjgdyn ij|pm|jyjmh jh ycn|ydyn mb dhz iml`ny nhy{z jh t~n|yjmh& jhlf~ijhe |~k|yjy~yn kjff| dhi dgnhignhy|( B~{ycn{gm{n&ycn Lmggjyynn mh \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh imn| hmy e~d{dhynn ycdy nhy{jn| p{n|nhyni mh jy|iml`ny| m{ jh d\~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh rmf~gn {np{n|nhy ycn nsdly rn{|jmh| mb ycm|n jyng| d|nhdlyni jhym fdu& jb dppfjldkfn(

4? Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|


11/269

\~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh \yzfn

\yzfn j| ycn l~|ymg m{ pfdh bmffmuni jh yzpme{dpcjl d{{dhengnhy m{ ij|pfdz( \~een|yni\ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh i{dby| enhn{dffz bmffmu ycn |dgn |yzfn( Cmunrn{& knejhhjhe ujyc ycn 4::5rmf~gn& jyng| p{n|nhyni jh\~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh gm{n lfm|nfz {nbfnly ycn |yzfn dhi bm{gd| ycnz un{n |~kgjyyni ym ycn p{me{dg( Ycn um{i Dly {nbn{| ym p{mpm|ni dhi nhdlyni kjff|(

Dyyngpy| d{n gdin ym nh|~{n ycdy jyng| p{n|nhyni ym lmggjyynn gngkn{| d{n ycn gm|y {nlnhyrn{|jmh|( Jhyn{n|yni pd{yjn| |cm~fi lmhydly ycn m{jejhdyjhe |ydyn bm{ ycn ~fyjgdyn ij|pm|jyjmh jh ycn|ydyn mb dhz jyng jh t~n|yjmh& jhlf~ijhe |~k|yjy~yn Dly| dhi dgnhignhy|(

Jhy{mi~lym{z Gdyyn{

Ycn bj{|y lmgpmhnhy jh d \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh i{dby j| dh dk|y{dly( Dk|y{dly|p{mrjin d k{jnb in|l{jpyjmh mb ycn Dly& cjecfjecy ~hjt~n bndy~{n|& dhi p{mrjin kdl`e{m~hi dkm~ymycn{ |ydyn|& jb dppfjldkfn( \\F dk|y{dly| d{n yzpjldffz lmgpjfni b{mg ycn kjff |~ggd{jn| jhfnej|fdyjmh ycdy j| |~kgjyyni dhi dpp{mrni bm{ jhlf~|jmh jh \\F rmf~gn|& m{ b{mg ycn m{jejhdyjhe|ydyn| fnej|fdyjrn |ydbb dhdfz|j|( Lmpjn| mb mycn{ |ydyn kjff| m{ fdu| {nbn{nhlni jh dk|y{dly| m{ jh

\\F Hmyn| ldh kn mkydjhni kz lmhydlyjhe ycn |ydyn| ij{nlyfz(

\~kgjyyni D|

Ycj| lmgpmhnhy jhijldyn| ycn |ydyn& yjyfn& kjff h~gkn{ m{ fnedf ljydyjmh dhi dimpyjmh idyn mbycn m{jejhdf kjff m{ fdu d| |~kgjyyni ym ycn \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh _{me{dg( [ndin{| |cm~fikn dud{n ycdy dfycm~ec fnej|fdyjmh p{n|nhyni jh\~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh j| kd|ni mh |ydyn kjff|dhi fdu|& ycn Lmggjyynn mh \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh imn| hmy e~d{dhynn ycdy jyng| p{n|nhynimh jy| iml`ny| m{ jh \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh rmf~gn| {np{n|nhy ycn nsdly rn{|jmh| mb ycm|njyng| d| nhdlyni kz d |ydyn(

\ydhid{ijqni \nlyjmh| dhi Bm{g

Jyng| p{n|nhyni jh ycj| dhi b~y~{n\~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh rmf~gn| ujff {nydjh& ym ycnnsynhy pm||jkfn& ycn |dgn nh~gn{dyjmh d| ycn kjff m{ Dly d| |~kgjyyni kz d |ydyn( Ycj| jhlf~in||nlyjmh|& |~k|nlyjmh| dhi& pd{de{dpc|( Cmunrn{& gmijbjldyjmh| |~lc d| diijhe1 \nrn{dkjfjyz&[npndfn{& dhi Nbbnlyjrn Idyn& ujff kn gdin ym ycn i{dby d| hnln||d{z(

Mbynh jy df|m j| hnln||d{z jh i{dby fnej|fdyjmh ym jhijldyn d |ydyn dfyn{hdyjrn ym ycn hdgn mbdh denhlz& ycn h~gkn{ mb gngkn{| mh d lmggjyynn& p~hj|cgnhy bm{ dh mbbnh|n& nyl( Jh ycn|nld|n| k{dl`ny| d{n ~|ni jh|yndi mb pd{nhycn|n|(

Nhy{jn| b{mg ycn Hdyjmhdf Lmhbn{nhln mb Lmggj||jmhn{| mh ^hjbm{g \ydyn Fdu| d{n{d{nfz lcdheni b{mg ycnj{ |~kgjyyni bm{gdy(



12/269

4; Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|

4

;

2

5

3:

4?

44

4;

4

4245434:

;?;4

;;;

>2

>5

>3

>:

2?

242;

2

22

25

23

2:

5?

54

5;5

52

55

53

5:

3?

\nlyjmh >( PDbbjidrjy mb Ld{nejrn{ Lmh|nhy(W Dh Dbbjidrjy mb Ld{nejrn{ Lmh|nhy bm{ dGjhm{| Cndfyc Ld{n |cdff jhlf~in ycn bmffmujhe1

#4* Ycn ld{nejrn{| hdgn dhi l~{{nhy cmgn dii{n||0#;* Ycn ld{nejrn{| kj{yc idyn0#* Ycn gjhm{| kj{yc idyn0#2* Ycn fnheyc mb yjgn ycn gjhm{ cd| {n|jini ujyc ycn ld{nejrn{0#5* Ycn ld{nejrn{| |jehdy~{n ~hin{ mdyc dbbj{gjhe ycn y{~yc mb ycn gdyyn{ d||n{yni

jh ycn Dbbjidrjy0#3* Ycn |jehdy~{n mb ycn gjhm{| pd{nhy& e~d{ijdh m{ fnedf l~|ymijdh lmh|nhyjhe ym

ycn ld{nejrn{| d~ycm{jyz mrn{ ycn gjhm{| cndfyc ld{n& p{mrjini& ycdy ycn |jehdy~{n mb ycn gjhm{|pd{nhy& e~d{ijdh m{ fnedf l~|ymijdh j| hmy hnln||d{z jb ycn Dbbjidrjy jhlf~in| ycn bmffmujhe1

#d* d |ydyngnhy ycdy ycn ld{nejrn{ cd| dyyngpyni& k~y cd| knnh ~hdkfn ymmkydjh& ycn |jehdy~{n mb ycn gjhm{| pd{nhy& e~d{ijdh m{ fnedf l~|ymijdh0

#k* d |ydyngnhy ycdy ycn gjhm{| pd{nhy& e~d{ijdh m{ fnedf l~|ymijdh cd| hmy{nb~|ni ym ejrn lmh|nhy bm{ cndfyc ld{n dhi y{ndygnhy mb ycn gjhm{ lcjfi0 dhi

#l* d in|l{jpyjmh& jh inydjf& mb ycn dyyngpy| ycn ld{nejrn{ gdin ym mkydjh ycn|jehdy~{n mb ycn gjhm{| pd{nhy& e~d{ijdh m{ fnedf l~|ymijdh0 dhi

#:* D |ydyngnhy& d| bmffmu|1

Enhn{df Hmyjln|1

Ycj| inlfd{dyjmh imn| hmy dbbnly ycn {jecy| mb ycn gjhm{| pd{nhy& e~d{ijdh

m{ fnedf l~|ymijdh {ned{ijhe ycn ld{n& l~|ymiz dhi lmhy{mf mb ycn gjhm{& mycn{ ycdhujyc {n|pnly ym cndfyc ld{n& dhi imn| hmy ejrn ycn ld{nejrn{ fnedf l~|ymiz mb ycngjhm{(

Ycj| Dbbjidrjy j| rdfji bm{ mhn znd{ ~hfn|| ycn gjhm{ hm fmhen{ {n|jin| jhycn ld{nejrn{| cmgn( B~{ycn{gm{n& ycn gjhm{| pd{nhy& e~d{ijdh m{ fnedfl~|ymijdh gdz dy dhz yjgn {n|ljhi ycj| Dbbjidrjy mb Ld{nejrn{ Lmh|nhy bm{ dGjhm{| Cndfyc Ld{n kz p{mrjijhe u{jyynh hmyjbjldyjmh mb ycn {n|lj||jmh ym ycndpp{mp{jdyn cndfyc ld{n p{mbn||jmhdf(

D pn{|mh ucm {nfjn| jh emmi bdjyc mh ycj| Dbbjidrjy mb Ld{nejrn{ Lmh|nhybm{ d Gjhm{| Cndfyc Ld{n cd| hm mkfjedyjmh ym lmhi~ly dhz b~{ycn{ jht~j{z m{jhrn|yjedyjmh dhi |cdff hmy kn |~kanly ym ljrjf m{ l{jgjhdf fjdkjfjyz m{ ym

p{mbn||jmhdf ij|ljpfjhd{z dlyjmh knld~|n mb ycdy {nfjdhln(

\nlyjmh 2( P[nrmldyjmh dhi Yn{gjhdyjmh mb Lmh|nhy(W#D* Ycn Dbbjidrjy mb Ld{nejrn{ Lmh|nhy bm{ d Gjhm{| Cndfyc Ld{n j| |~pn{|nini kz

u{jyynh hmyjbjldyjmh b{mg ycn gjhm{| pd{nhy& e~d{ijdh m{ fnedf l~|ymijdh ym ycn cndfyc ld{np{mbn||jmhdf| p{mrjijhe |n{rjln| ym ycn gjhm{ ycdy ycn Dbbjidrjy cd| knnh {n|ljhini(

#K* Ycn Dbbjidrjy mb Ld{nejrn{ Lmh|nhy bm{ d Gjhm{| Cndfyc Ld{n j| rdfji bm{ PmhnW znd{~hfn|| ycn gjhm{ hm fmhen{ {n|jin| jh ycn ld{nejrn{| cmgn m{ d pd{nhy& e~d{ijdh m{ fnedfl~|ymijdh {nrm`n| cj| m{ cn{ dpp{mrdf kz u{jyynh hmyjbjldyjmh ym ycn cndfyc ld{n p{mbn||jmhdf|



15/269

;?4; \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh 4>

34

3;

3

32

35

33

3:

:?

:4

:;

:

:2

:5

:3

::

4??4?4

4?;

4?

4?2

p{mrjijhe |n{rjln| ym ycn gjhm{ ycdy ycn Dbbjidrjy cd| knnh {n|ljhini( Jb d pd{nhy& e~d{ijdh m{fnedf l~|ymijdh {nrm`n| dpp{mrdf& ycn ld{nejrn{ |cdff hmyjbz dhz cndfyc ld{n p{mrjin{ m{ cndfyc|n{rjln pfdh| ujyc ucjlc ycn gjhm{ cd| knnh jhrmfrni yc{m~ec ycn ld{nejrn{(

\nlyjmh 5( PEmmi Bdjyc [nfjdhln mh Dbbjidrjy(W#D* Dhz pn{|mh ucm {nfjn| jh emmi bdjyc mh ycn Dbbjidrjy mb Ld{nejrn{ Lmh|nhy bm{ d

Gjhm{| Cndfyc Ld{n cd| hm mkfjedyjmh ym lmhi~ly dhz b~{ycn{ jht~j{z m{ jhrn|yjedyjmh dhi j| hmy|~kanly ym ljrjf m{ l{jgjhdf fjdkjfjyz m{ ym p{mbn||jmhdf ij|ljpfjhd{z dlyjmh knld~|n mb ycn {nfjdhln(

#K* Ycn p{mrj|jmh| mb |~k|nlyjmh #D* mb ycj| |nlyjmh dppfz nrnh jb gnijldf y{ndygnhy j|p{mrjini ym d gjhm{ jh lmhy{drnhyjmh mb d inlj|jmh mb d pd{nhy& fnedf l~|ymijdh m{ e~d{ijdh mb ycngjhm{ ucm |jehni ycn Dbbjidrjy jb ycn pn{|mh p{mrjijhe ld{n cd| hm dly~df `hmufnien mb ycninlj|jmh mb ycn pd{nhy& fnedf l~|ymijdh m{ e~d{ijdh(

\nlyjmh 3( P_nhdfyz bm{ Bdf|n \ydyngnhy(W D pn{|mh ucm `hmujhefz gd`n| d bdf|n|ydyngnhy jh dh Dbbjidrjy ~hin{ ycj| Dly j| e~jfyz mb d gj|ingndhm{ dhi& ~pmh lmhrjlyjmh ycn{nmb&|cdff kn bjhni hmy gm{n ycdh P)4&???W(

\nlyjmh :( P[~fn|(W Ycn P|nl{nyd{z mb ycn inpd{ygnhy mb cndfyc dhi c~gdh {n|m~{ln|W j|

d~ycm{jqni ym p{mpm|n {~fn| hnln||d{z ym jgpfngnhy ycn p{mrj|jmh| mb ycj| Dly jh dllm{idhln ujycPjh|n{y ljydyjmhW(

\nlyjmh 4?( P\nrn{dkjfjyz(W PJh|n{y |nrn{dkjfjyz lfd~|n(W

\nlyjmh 44( P[npndfn{(W PJh|n{y {npndfn{ lfd~|n(W

\nlyjmh 4;( PNbbnlyjrn Idyn(W PJh|n{y nbbnlyjrn idyn(W


16/269

De{jl~fy~{df Mpn{dyjmh| dhi \~|ydjhdkfn De{jl~fy~{n

Ycj| Dly nhdkfn| de{jl~fy~{df mpn{dyjmh| ym jhlm{pm{dyn |~|ydjhdkfn de{jl~fy~{df p{dlyjln|ujycm~y hnln||d{jfz knjhe inngni d h~j|dhln kz fmldf m{ijhdhln| m{ qmhjhe {ne~fdyjmh|( Ycn Dly{nt~j{n| dhz digjhj|y{dyjrn {ne~fdyjmh p{mg~fedyni kz dhz denhlz ycdy n|ydkfj|cn| |ydhid{i| bm{cd{rn|yjhe m{ p{mi~ljhe de{jl~fy~{df l{mp| jh d |~|ydjhdkfn gdhhn{ kn kd|ni mh p{dlyjln| m~yfjhni

jh ycn Dly( Ycm|n d{n |ljnhln'kd|ni p{dlyjln| ycdy d{n |~ppm{yni kz {n|nd{lc dhi ycn ~|n mbynlchmfmez& ingmh|y{dyni ym fndi ym k{mdi m~ylmgn|'kd|ni pn{bm{gdhln jgp{mrngnhy| ycdy gnnyycn hnni| mb ycn p{n|nhy& dhi ycdy jgp{mrn ycn dkjfjyz mb b~y~{n enhn{dyjmh| ym gnny ycnj{ hnni|ucjfn dirdhljhe p{me{n|| ymud{i nhrj{mhgnhydf& |mljdf& dhi nlmhmgjl emdf| dhi ycn unff'knjhemb de{jl~fy~{df p{mi~ln{| dhi {~{df lmgg~hjyjn|(

\~kgjyyni d|1@nhy~l`zCK 932 #Nh{mffni rn{|jmh*\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;?4?(

\~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh

#Yjyfn& nhdlyjhe lfd~|n& nyl(*

\nlyjmh 4( P\cm{y Yjyfn(W Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| Dh Dly ym Nhdkfn De{jl~fy~{dfMpn{dyjmh| ym Dimpy \~|ydjhdkfn De{jl~fy~{df _{dlyjln|(

4

;

2

5

3:

4?

44

4;

4

42

45

43

4:;?

;4

;;

;

;2

;5

\nlyjmh ;( PDe{jl~fy~{df Mpn{dyjmh| dhi \~|ydjhdkfn De{jl~fy~{n _{dlyjln|(W#D* Jy j| ycn inlfd{ni pmfjlz mb Pycj| |ydynW ym lmh|n{rn& p{mynly& dhi nhlm~{den ycn

inrnfmpgnhy dhi jgp{mrngnhy mb jy| de{jl~fy~{df fdhi dhi |jfrjl~fy~{df fdhi bm{ ycn p{mi~lyjmh mbbmmi& yjgkn{& dhi mycn{ de{jl~fy~{df dhi |jfrjl~fy~{df p{mi~ly|( Ucnh hmhde{jl~fy~{df fdhi ~|n|

nsynhi jhym de{jl~fy~{df dhi |jfrjl~fy~{df d{nd|& de{jl~fy~{df dhi |jfrjl~fy~{df mpn{dyjmh| mbynhknlmgn ycn |~kanly mb h~j|dhln |~jy| m{ fnedf dlyjmh| {n|y{jlyjhe de{jl~fy~{df m{ |jfrjl~fy~{dfmpn{dyjmh|( D| d {n|~fy& de{jl~fy~{df dhi |jfrjl~fy~{df mpn{dyjmh| d{n |mgnyjgn| njycn{ l~{ydjfni m{bm{lni ym lnd|n mpn{dyjmh|( Jhrn|ygnhy| jh bd{g dhi yjgkn{ jgp{mrngnhy| gdz kn ij|lm~{deni( Jyj| ycn p~{pm|n mb ycj| |nlyjmh ym {ni~ln ycn fm|| ym ycn |ydyn mb jy| de{jl~fy~{df dhi |jfrjl~fy~{df{n|m~{ln| kz lfd{jbzjhe ycn lj{l~g|ydhln| ~hin{ ucjlc de{jl~fy~{df dhi |jfrjl~fy~{df mpn{dyjmh|gdz kn inngni ym kn d h~j|dhln m{ jhyn{bn{ni ujyc kz fmldf m{ijhdhln| m{ fnedf dlyjmh|(

#K* Hm de{jl~fy~{df m{ |jfrjl~fy~{df mpn{dyjmh m{ dhz mb jy| dpp~{ynhdhln| |cdff kn m{knlmgn d h~j|dhln m{ y{n|pd||& p{jrdyn m{ p~kfjl& m{ kn jh rjmfdyjmh mb dhz qmhjhe m{ijhdhln& m{ kn|~kanly ym dhz m{ijhdhln ycdy um~fi {n|y{jly ycn {jecy mb ycn mpn{dym{ mb ycn de{jl~fy~{df m{|jfrjl~fy~{df mpn{dyjmh ym ~yjfjqn hm{gdf dhi dllnpyni p{dlyjln|& kz dhz lcdheni lmhijyjmh| jh m{

dkm~y ycn fmldfjyz ycn{nmb dbyn{ ycn |dgn cd| knnh jh mpn{dyjmh bm{ Pgm{n ycdh mhnW znd{& ucnh ycnmpn{dyjmh ud| hmy d h~j|dhln dy ycn yjgn ycn mpn{dyjmh knedh( Ycn p{mrj|jmh| mb ycj| |~k|nlyjmh|cdff hmy dppfz ucnhnrn{ d h~j|dhln& y{n|pd||& m{ qmhjhe rjmfdyjmh {n|~fy| b{mg ycn hnefjenhympn{dyjmh mb dh de{jl~fy~{df m{ |jfrjl~fy~{df mpn{dyjmh m{ jy| dpp~{ynhdhln|(

#L* #4* Bm{ ycn p~{pm|n| mb ycj| |nlyjmh& de{jl~fy~{df mpn{dyjmh jhlf~in|& k~y j| hmyfjgjyni ym& dhz bdljfjyz bm{ ycn p{mi~lyjmh mb l{mp|& fjrn|yml`& nt~jhn& pm~fy{z& fjrn|yml` p{mi~ly|±~fy{z p{mi~ly|& cm{yjl~fy~{df p{mi~ly|& dhi dhz enhn{dffz dllnpyni& {nd|mhdkfn& dhi p{~inhygnycmi bm{ ycn mpn{dyjmh mb d bd{g ym mkydjh d gmhnyd{z p{mbjy ycdy lmgpfjn| ujyc dppfjldkfn fdu|dhi digjhj|y{dyjrn {ne~fdyjmh|& dhi j| pn{bm{gni jh d {nd|mhdkfn dhi p{~inhy gdhhn{ l~|ymgd{z

http://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/2431b02kysustainableag.pdfhttp://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/2431b02kysustainableag.pdfhttp://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/2431b02kysustainableag.pdf


17/269

dgmhe bd{g mpn{dym{|( De{jl~fy~{df p{dlyjln| p{mynlyni kz ycj| |nlyjmh |cdff jhlf~in& k~y hmy knfjgjyni ym& bn{yjfjqn{ dppfjldyjmh& ycn dppfjldyjmh mb pn|yjljin| m{ cn{kjljin| ycdy cdrn knnhdpp{mrni kz p~kfjl d~ycm{jyz& pfdhyjhe& l~fyjrdyjhe& gmujhe& cd{rn|yjhe& fdhi lfnd{jhe& dhilmh|y{~lyjhe bd{g k~jfijhe|& {mdi|& fd`n|& dhi pmhi| d||mljdyni ujyc d bd{gjhe mpn{dyjmh(

;3

;:


18/269

Dj{l{dby _jfmy dhi _d||nhen{ _{mynlyjmh

Ycj| Dly {ne~fdyn| k~jfijhe hnd{ p~kfjl'~|n dj{pm{y|( Ycn Dly {nt~j{n| muhn{| mb p{mpm|ni|y{~ly~{n| ujycjh d yc{nn'gjfn d{nd |~{{m~hijhe d p~kfjl'~|n dj{pm{y ym eny |pnljdf pn{gjy| b{mgycn |ydyn dn{mhd~yjl| lmggj||jmh knbm{n k~jfijhe |~lc |y{~ly~{n|(

\~kgjyyni d|1M`fdcmgdCK ;:4: #Nh{mffni rn{|jmh*\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;?4?(



\nlyjmh 4( P\cm{y Yjyfn(W Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| ycn Dj{l{dby _jfmy dhi _d||nhen{_{mynlyjmh Dly(

4

;

2

5

3

:

4?

44

4;

4

42

45

43

4:

;?

;4

;;

;;2

;5

;3

;:


19/269

44( _n{|mh gndh| dh jhijrji~df& bj{g& pd{yhn{|cjp& lm{pm{dyjmh& d||mljdyjmh& m{ kmizpmfjyjl dhi jhlf~in| d y{~|ynn& {nlnjrn{& d||jehnn& m{ mycn{ |jgjfd{fz d~ycm{jqni {np{n|nhydyjrn mbdhz mb ycng0

9

>>

>2

>5

>3

>:

2?

24

2;

2

22

25

23

2:

5?

54

5;

5

52

55

53

5:

3?

34

4;( _{jgd{z |~{bdln j| d |~{bdln fmhejy~ijhdffz lnhyn{ni mh d {~hudz( Ucnh ycn {~hudzcd| d |pnljdffz p{npd{ni cd{i |~{bdln& ycn p{jgd{z |~{bdln nsynhi| Pyum c~hi{ni #;??*W bnnyknzmhi ndlc nhi mb ycdy {~hudz0 k~y ucnh ycn {~hudz cd| hm |pnljdffz p{npd{ni cd{i |~{bdln& m{pfdhhni cd{i |~{bdln& ycn p{jgd{z |~{bdln nhi| dy ndlc nhi mb ycdy {~hudz( Ycn nfnrdyjmh mb dhzpmjhy mh ycn p{jgd{z |~{bdln j| ycn |dgn d| ycn nfnrdyjmh mb ycn hnd{n|y pmjhy mh ycn {~hudzlnhyn{fjhn( Ycn ujiyc mb ycn p{jgd{z |~{bdln j| Pmhn ycm~|dhi #4&???*W bnny0

4??&???*W dllm{ijhe ym ycngm|y {nlnhy Bnin{df Inlnhhjdf Lnh|~|0

49( [~hudz gndh| ycn pm{yjmh mb dh dj{pm{y in|jehdyni d| ycn d{nd ~|ni bm{ ycn fdhijhe

m{ yd`nmbb mb dj{l{dby04>( [~hudz p{mynlyjmh qmhn j| d y{dpnqmjidf qmhn lnhyn{ni dfmhe ycn nsynhini {~hudz

lnhyn{fjhn& knzmhi ndlc nhi mb ycn p{jgd{z |~{bdln& Pyum ycm~|dhi bjrn c~hi{ni #;&>??*W bnnyfmhe& ujyc dh jhhn{ ujiyc mb Pmhn ycm~|dhi #4&???* bnnyW dhi dh m~yn{ ujiyc mb Pmhn ycm~|dhi|nrnh c~hi{ni bjbyz #4&5>?*W bnny( Ycn b~hlyjmh mb ycn {~hudz p{mynlyjmh qmhn j| ym nhcdhln ycnp{mynlyjmh mb pnmpfn dhi p{mpn{yz mh ycn e{m~hi0

42( \y{~ly~{n gndh| dhz lmh|y{~lyni m{ jh|ydffni mkanly& jhlf~ijhe& k~y hmy fjgjyni ymk~jfijhe|& ymun{|& ujhi y~{kjhn|& |gm`n|ydl`|& nfnly{mhjl y{dh|gj||jmh m{ {nlnjrjhe ymun{|& dhidhynhhdn dhi mrn{cndi y{dh|gj||jmh fjhn|( Ycn yn{g imn| hmy jhlf~in dhz drjdyjmh hdrjedyjmhdfdji| ycdy d{n bjsni kz b~hlyjmh m{ dhz lmh|y{~lyjmh m{ jh|ydffni mkanly mh p{mpn{yz muhni kz ycnbnin{df emrn{hgnhy0 dhi

45( Ymydf |y{~ly~{n cnjecy gndh| ycn nfnrdyjmh mb ycn e{m~hi dkmrn gndh |nd fnrnf dyycn |y{~ly~{n| fmldyjmh& pf~| ycn cnjecy mb ycn |y{~ly~{n dkmrn e{m~hi fnrnf jh bnny& pf~| ycndppfjldkfn |~{rnz yzpn dia~|ygnhy(

\nlyjmh


20/269

#L* Inpnhijhe ~pmh ycn yzpn mb |~{rnz ~|ni& dh dia~|ygnhy ujff kn gdin ym ycncm{jqmhydf dhi rn{yjldf gnd|~{ngnhy| mb d p{mpm|ni |y{~ly~{n d| bmffmu|1

3;

3

32

35

33

3:

:?

:4

:;

:

:2

:5

:3

::

4??

4?4

4?;

4?

4?2

4?5

4?3

4?:

44?

44444;

44

442

445

443

44:

4;?

4;4

4;;4;

4;2

4;5

4;3

4;:

\~{rnz Cm{jqmhydf \~{rnz Rn{yjldfYzpn Dia~|ygnhy Yzpn Dia~|ygnhy

4 ;? by #2 g* D < by #4 g*; >? by #4> g* K 4? by #< g*< 4?? by #


21/269

4( Bm{ lmh|y{~lyjmh jh d p{jgd{z |~{bdln m{ {~hudz p{mynlyjmh qmhn ~hin{pd{de{dpc 4 mb |~k|nlyjmh D mb ycj| \nlyjmh1

4


22/269

5( Fdhi ~|n inh|jyz045:43?

434

43;

43

432

435

433

43:

4:?

4:4

4:;

4:

4:2

4:5

4:3

4::

;??

;?4

;?;

;?

;?2

;?5

;?3;?:

;4?

;44

;4;

;4

;42

;45

;43

;4:;;?

;;4

;;;

;;

;;2

;;5

3( Lmggnhy| b{mg dff jhyn{n|yni pnmpfn0 dhi:( Dppfjldkfn bjhijhe| dhi inyn{gjhdyjmh| mb mycn{ emrn{hgnhy denhljn|(

#C* Jb BDD Bm{g 592?'4 j| {nt~j{ni& ycnh ycn Plmggj||jmhW |cdff hmyjbz ycn dppfjldhy mbjy| inyn{gjhdyjmh ujycjh Pycj{yz #


23/269

;?4; \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh ;9

>>

>2

>5

>3

>:

2?

24

2;

222

25

23

2:

5?

54

5;

5

5255

53

5:

3?

34

3;

3( P\lcmmf _mfjlz _{mcjkjyjhe Cd{d||gnhy& Jhyjgjidyjmh m{ K~ffzjhe(W

;?4; \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh


32/269

#D* Ndlc |lcmmf ij|y{jly |cdff dimpy d pmfjlz p{mcjkjyjhe cd{d||gnhy& jhyjgjidyjmh m{k~ffzjhe mh |lcmmf p{mpn{yz& dy d |lcmmf'|pmh|m{ni b~hlyjmh m{ mh d |lcmmf k~|( Ycn |lcmmfij|y{jly |cdff dimpy ycn pmfjlz yc{m~ec d p{mln|| ycdy jhlf~in| {np{n|nhydyjmh mb pd{nhy| m{e~d{ijdh|& |lcmmf ngpfmznn|& rmf~hynn{|& |y~inhy|& digjhj|y{dym{|& dhi lmgg~hjyz{np{n|nhydyjrn|(

4;4

4;;

4;

4;2

4;5

4;3

4;:

4


33/269

#k* ycn {n|~fy| mb ycn jhrn|yjedyjmh |cdff kn {npm{yni ym ycn |~pn{jhynhinhymb |lcmmf| ujycjh PyumW |lcmmf idz| mb ycn lmgpfnyjmh mb ycn jhrn|yjedyjmh& dhi jh dllm{idhlnujyc {ne~fdyjmh| p{mg~fedyni kz ycn P|ydyn kmd{i mb ni~ldyjmhW p~{|~dhy ym Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW& ycn|~pn{jhynhinhy gdz inljin ym p{mrjin jhyn{rnhyjmh |n{rjln|& n|ydkfj|c y{djhjhe p{me{dg| ym {ni~lncd{d||gnhy& jhyjgjidyjmh& m{ k~ffzjhe dhi nhcdhln |lcmmf lfjgdyn& jgpm|n ij|ljpfjhn& m{in{lm~h|nfjhe d| d {n|~fy mb ycn bjhijhe| mb ycn jhrn|yjedyjmh& m{ yd`n m{ {nlmggnhi mycn{dpp{mp{jdyn dlyjmh0

45?

454

45;

45

452

455

453

45:

43?

434

43;

43

432

435

433

43:

4:?

4:4

4:;

4:

4:2

4:5

4:3

4::;??

;?4

;?;

;?

;?2

;?5

;?3

;?:

;4?;44

;4;

;4

;42

;45

;43

#l* ycn {n|~fy| mb ndlc jhrn|yjedyjmh |cdff kn {npm{yni ym ycn kmd{i mbni~ldyjmh hm fdyn{ ycdh ycn idyn mb ycn kmd{i mb ni~ldyjmh gnnyjhe hnsy bmffmujhe ycn lmgpfnyjmhmb ycn jhrn|yjedyjmh& dfmhe ujyc jhbm{gdyjmh mh dhz |n{rjln| p{mrjini& y{djhjhe n|ydkfj|cni&ij|ljpfjhn jgpm|ni&m{ mycn{ dlyjmh yd`nh m{ {nlmggnhini kz ycn |~pn{jhynhinhy0

#i* pd{nhy| m{ e~d{ijdh| mb ycn |y~inhy| ucm d{n pd{yjn| ym ycn jhrn|yjedyjmh|cdff kn nhyjyfni ym {nlnjrn jhbm{gdyjmh dkm~y ycn jhrn|yjedyjmh& jh dllm{idhln ujyc bnin{df dhi|ydyn fdu dhi {ne~fdyjmh& jhlf~ijhe ycn hdy~{n mb ycn jhrn|yjedyjmh& ucnycn{ ycn ij|y{jly bm~hinrjinhln mb cd{d||gnhy& jhyjgjidyjmh& m{ k~ffzjhe& m{ ucnycn{ ij|ljpfjhn ud| jgpm|ni m{ |n{rjln|p{mrjini ym dii{n|| ycn jhljinhy mb cd{d||gnhy& jhyjgjidyjmh& m{ k~ffzjhe( Ycj| jhbm{gdyjmh |cdffkn p{mrjini jh u{jyjhe ujycjh P>W |lcmmf idz| dbyn{ ycn {n|~fy| mb ycn jhrn|yjedyjmh d{n {npm{yni ymycn kmd{i( D pd{nhy m{ e~d{ijdh gdz {nt~n|y d cnd{jhe knbm{n ycn kmd{i dbyn{ {nlnjrjhe ycn

jhbm{gdyjmh& dhi ycn cnd{jhe |cdff kn cnfi ujycjh P4?W idz| mb ycn {nt~n|y( Ycn kmd{i |cdff gnnyjh nsnl~yjrn |n||jmh bm{ ycn cnd{jhe ym p{mynly ycn lmhbjinhyjdfjyz mb ycn |y~inhy|( Dy ycn cnd{jheycn kmd{i gdz cnd{ b{mg ycn |lcmmf dhyj'k~ffzjhe |pnljdfj|y dkm~y ycn jhljinhy& {nlmggnhidyjmh|bm{ ij|ljpfjhn m{ |n{rjln|& dhi dhz p{me{dg| jh|yjy~yni ym {ni~ln |~lc jhljinhy|0

#n* dy ycn hnsy kmd{i mb ni~ldyjmh gnnyjhe bmffmujhe jy| {nlnjpy mb ycn{npm{y& ycn kmd{i |cdff j||~n d inlj|jmh& jh u{jyjhe& ym dbbj{g& {nanly& m{ gmijbz ycn|~pn{jhynhinhy| inlj|jmh( Ycn kmd{i| inlj|jmh gdz kn dppndfni ym ycn Plmggj||jmhn{ mbni~ldyjmhW& jh dllm{idhln ujyc ycn p{mlni~{n| |ny bm{yc jh fdu dhi {ne~fdyjmh& hm fdyn{ ycdh P:?Widz| dbyn{ ycn j||~dhln mb ycn kmd{i| inlj|jmh0 dhi

#b* d pd{nhy& |y~inhy& e~d{ijdh& m{ m{edhjqdyjmh gdz bjfn d lmgpfdjhy ujycycn Pijrj|jmh mh ljrjf {jecy|W ujycjh P43?W idz| mb ycn mll~{{nhln mb dhz jhljinhy mb cd{d||gnhy&

jhyjgjidyjmh& m{ k~ffzjhe kd|ni mh gngkn{|cjp jh d p{mynlyni e{m~p d| nh~gn{dyni jh Pjh|n{yljydyjmhW0

#5* ycn {dhen mb udz| jh ucjlc d |lcmmf ujff {n|pmhi mhln dh jhljinhy mbcd{d||gnhy& jhyjgjidyjmh m{ k~ffzjhe j| jinhyjbjni& ucjlc |cdff kn inbjhni kz ycn p{jhljpdf jhlmha~hlyjmh ujyc ycn |lcmmf dhyj'k~ffzjhe |pnljdfj|y& k~y |cdff jhlf~in dh dpp{mp{jdyn lmgkjhdyjmhmb lm~h|nfjhe& |~ppm{y |n{rjln|& jhyn{rnhyjmh |n{rjln|& dhi mycn{ p{me{dg|& d| inbjhni kz ycnPlmggj||jmhn{W0

#3* d |ydyngnhy ycdy p{mcjkjy| {np{j|df m{ {nydfjdyjmh dedjh|y dhz pn{|mh ucm {npm{y|dh dly mb cd{d||gnhy& jhyjgjidyjmh m{ k~ffzjhe dhi ycn lmh|nt~nhln dhi dpp{mp{jdyn {ngnijdfdlyjmh bm{ d pn{|mh ucm nheden| jh {np{j|df m{ {nydfjdyjmh0

#:* dlyjmh bm{ d pn{|mh bm~hi ym cdrn bdf|nfz dll~|ni dhmycn{ d| d gndh| mb

{nydfjdyjmh m{ d| d gndh| mb cd{d||gnhy& jhyjgjidyjmh m{ k~ffzjhe0#4?* d |ydyngnhy mb cmu ycn pmfjlz j| ym kn p~kfjljqni& jhlf~ijhe hmyjln ycdy ycn

pmfjlz dppfjn| ym pd{yjljpdyjmh jh |lcmmf'|pmh|m{ni b~hlyjmh|0#44* d {nt~j{ngnhy ycdy d fjh` ym ycn pmfjlz kn p{mgjhnhyfz pm|yni mh ycn cmgn

pden mb ycn |lcmmf ij|y{jly| unk|jyn dhi ij|y{jk~yni dhh~dffz ym pd{nhy| dhi e~d{ijdh| ucm cdrnlcjfi{nh nh{mffni jh d |lcmmf jh ycn |lcmmf ij|y{jly0 dhi

#4;* d {nt~j{ngnhy ycdy ycn hdgn& |lcmmf pcmhn h~gkn{& |lcmmf dii{n|| dhi|lcmmf ngdjf dii{n|| mb ycn ij|y{jly dhyj'k~ffzjhe lmm{ijhdym{ kn fj|yni mh ycn cmgn pden mb ycn|lcmmf ij|y{jly| unk|jyn dhi& mh ycn cmgn pden mb ndlc |lcmmf| unk|jyn& ycn hdgn& |lcmmf pcmhn

;?4; \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh


34/269

h~gkn{& |lcmmf dii{n|| dhi |lcmmf ngdjf dii{n|| mb ycn |lcmmf dhyj'k~ffzjhe |pnljdfj|y dhi ycnij|y{jly dhyj'k~ffzjhe lmm{ijhdym{( Ycn jhbm{gdyjmh lmhln{hjhe ycn ij|y{jly dhyj'k~ffzjhelmm{ijhdym{ dhi ycn |lcmmf dhyj'k~ffzjhe |pnljdfj|y| |cdff df|m kn gdjhydjhni mh ycnPinpd{ygnhy|W unk|jyn(

;4:

;;?

;;4

;;;

;;

;;2

;;5

;;3

;;:

;


35/269

#;* lmffdkm{dyn ujyc |lcmmf dhyj'k~ffzjhe |pnljdfj|y| jh ycn ij|y{jly& ycn kmd{i mbni~ldyjmh& dhi ycn |~pn{jhynhinhy mb |lcmmf| ym p{nrnhy& jinhyjbz& dhi {n|pmhi ym cd{d||gnhy&23jhyjgjidyjmh& dhi k~ffzjhe mb |y~inhy| jh ycn ij|y{jly0;2:

;25

;5?

;54

;5;

;5

;52

;55

;53

;5:

;3?

;34

;3;

;3

;32

;35

;33

;3:

;:?

;:4

;:;

;:

;:2;:5

;:3

;::


36/269

#2* pd{yjljpdyn jh ycn y{djhjhe {nt~j{ni p~{|~dhy ym Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW dhi mycn{y{djhjhe ucjlc ycn p{jhljpdf m{ ycn ij|y{jly dhyj'k~ffzjhe lmm{ijhdym{ gdz {nt~n|y0


37/269

#C* Ycn Plmggj||jmhn{W |cdff nh|~{n ycdy ycn pn{|mhhnf mb ycn mbbjln mb ycn nsnl~yjrnlm~hyz |~pn{jhynhinhy mb |lcmmf| ucm d{n {n|pmh|jkfn bm{ lmhi~lyjhe ycn jhrn|yjedyjmh| {nlnjrny{djhjhe dhi ynlchjldf |~ppm{y mh ycn ~|n mb ycn lmgpfdjhy jhrn|yjedyjmh p{mymlmf(


38/269

knfjnb| m{ ynhny| mb ycdy bdjyc kz ycn {nfjejm~| m{edhjqdyjmh mpn{dyjhe ycn |lcmmf m{ kz ycn |lcmmf|bdl~fyz& |ydbb& m{ |y~inhy kmiz(

949

94>

942

945

943

94:

9;?

9;4

9;;

9;( PNbbnlyjrn Idyn(W PJh|n{y nbbnlyjrn idyn(W


40/269

Kdh`jhe Inrnfmpgnhy Ij|y{jly|

Ycj| kjff d~ycm{jqn| ycn |ydyn lmggj||jmhn{ mb kdh`jhe dhi jh|~{dhln ym l{ndyn d p{me{dgdhi p{mg~fedyn {~fn| ym nhlm~{den kdh`| ym n|ydkfj|c k{dhlcn| jh enme{dpcjl fmldyjmh| jh ycn|ydyn ucn{n ycn{n j| d ingmh|y{dyni hnni bm{ kdh`jhe |n{rjln|( Ycn l{jyn{jd bm{ |~lc d{nd| ym knin|jehdyni d| kdh`jhe inrnfmpgnhy ij|y{jly| jhlf~in ycn h~gkn{ mb |jyn| mbbn{jhe kdh`jhe

|n{rjln| ycdy d{n df{ndiz jh ycn d{nd& ycn hnni bm{ kdh`jhe |n{rjln| jh |~lc d{nd|& dhi ycn pmynhyjdfjgpdly ycdy diijyjmhdf kdh`jhe |n{rjln| um~fi cdrn mh nlmhmgjl inrnfmpgnhy jh ycn d{nd|(

Ycn fnej|fdyjmh d~ycm{jqn| kdh`| jh |~lc d{nd| ym kn in|jehdyni inpm|jym{jn| mb p~kfjlgmhnz dhi dffmu| ycn |ydyn y{nd|~{n{ dhi g~hjljpdf emrn{hgnhy| ym inpm|jy p~kfjl gmhnz jh |~lckdh`| dy d |pnljdf& bjsni jhyn{n|y {dyn mb {ny~{h(

\~kgjyyni d|1Hnu An{|nzLcdpyn{ ;9& ;?44 #D49>3*\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;?44(



\nlyjmh 4( P\cm{y Yjyfn(W Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| ycn Kdh`jhe Inrnfmpgnhy Ij|y{jlyDly(;

4

2

5

:

4?

44

4;

4

42

45

43

4:;?

;4

;;

;

;2

;5

\nlyjmh ;( PInbjhjyjmh|(W D| ~|ni jh ycj| Dly14( Kdh` gndh| d |ydyn m{ bnin{dffz lcd{yn{ni kdh`& |drjhe| kdh`& |drjhe| dhi fmdh

d||mljdyjmh& m{ l{nijy ~hjmh imjhe k~|jhn|| jh ycj| |ydyn(;( Kdh`jhe |n{rjln| gndh| inpm|jy yd`jhe& lcnl` ld|cjhe& |dfn mb gmhnz m{in{|& dhi

m{jejhdyjmh mb {n|jinhyjdf m{ lmggn{ljdf gm{yeden|& lmh|~gn{ fmdh|& dhi lmggn{ljdf fmdh|(3( Inpd{ygnhy gndh| ycn Pinpd{ygnhy mb kdh`jhe dhi jh|~{dhlnW(2( Ij|y{jly gndh| d kdh`jhe inrnfmpgnhy ij|y{jly dpp{mrni ~hin{ ycj| Dly(5( _{me{dg gndh| ycn Kdh`jhe Inrnfmpgnhy Ij|y{jly _{me{dg n|ydkfj|cni p~{|~dhy ym

ycj| Dly(

\nlyjmh


41/269

;( Ycn jinhyjbjldyjmh mb lmh|~gn{ hnni| bm{ kdh`jhe |n{rjln| ujycjh ycn ij|y{jly0;3;:


42/269

9; Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|

55

53 \nlyjmh 4?( PNbbnlyjrn Idyn(W PJh|n{y nbbnlyjrn idyn(W


43/269

Kjmkd|ni _{mi~ly|

Ycj| Dly inbjhn| d kjmkd|ni p{mi~ly dhi ij{nly| ycn |ydyn ij{nlym{ mb digjhj|y{dyjrn|n{rjln| ym n|ydkfj|c d Kjmkd|ni _{mi~ly _{nbn{nhln _{me{dg( Ycn fnej|fdyjmh {nt~j{n| |ydyndenhljn| dhi |ydyn jh|yjy~yjmh| mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmh ym k~z kjmkd|ni nt~jpgnhy& gdyn{jdf& m{|~ppfjn| jh dllm{idhln ujyc ycn p{me{dg( Jy {nt~j{n| ycn ij{nlym{ mb ycn |ydyn digjhj|y{dyjrn

|n{rjln| denhlz ym inrnfmp {~fn| dhi p{mlni~{n| |ydyn denhljn| dhi cjecn{ ni~ldyjmh jh|yjy~yjmh|g~|y ~|n ym k~z kjmkd|ni p{mi~ly| jh dllm{idhln ujyc ycn p{me{dg( Ycn Dly lmhydjh| p{mrj|jmh|dffmujhe ycn|n denhljn| ym k~z hmh'kjmkd|ni p{mi~ly| ucnh kjmkd|ni p{mi~ly| d{n ~hdrdjfdkfn&bdjf ym gnny {nfdyni pn{bm{gdhln {nt~j{ngnhy|& m{ d{n ymm nspnh|jrn(

Ycn Dly {nt~j{n| rnhim{| ucm mbbn{ p{mi~ly| ~hin{ ycn p{me{dg ym ln{yjbz ycnj{ p{mi~ly|d{n kjmkd|ni dhi p{mrjin {nfdyni jhbm{gdyjmh d| {nt~n|yni kz ycn |ydyn(

\~kgjyyni d|1Mcjm\K 4

2

53

:

4?

44

4;

4

42

45

434:

;?

;4

;;

;

;2

;5

\nlyjmh ;( PInbjhjyjmh|(W D| ~|ni jh ycj| Dly1#D* De{jl~fy~{df gdyn{jdf| gndh| de{jl~fy~{df'kd|ni gdyn{jdf| m{ {n|ji~n|& jhlf~ijhe

pfdhy& dhjgdf& dhi gd{jhn gdyn{jdf| m{ {n|ji~n|& ~|ni jh ycn gdh~bdly~{n mb lmggn{ljdf m{

jhi~|y{jdf hmhbmmi p{mi~ly|(#K* Kjmkd|ni p{mi~ly gndh| d p{mi~ly inyn{gjhni kz ycn ^hjyni \ydyn| \nl{nyd{z mbDe{jl~fy~{n ym kn d lmggn{ljdf m{ jhi~|y{jdf p{mi~ly& mycn{ ycdh bmmi m{ bnni& ycdy j| lmgpm|ni&jh ucmfn m{ |jehjbjldhy pd{y& mb kjmfmejldf p{mi~ly|& {nhnudkfn imgn|yjl de{jl~fy~{df gdyn{jdf|& m{bm{n|y{z gdyn{jdf& m{ j| dh jhyn{gnijdyn jhe{nijnhy m{ bnni|yml`(

#L* Kjmfmejldf p{mi~ly| gndh| p{mi~ly| in{jrni b{mg fjrjhe gdyn{jdf| mycn{ ycdhde{jl~fy~{df m{ bm{n|y{z gdyn{jdf|(

#I* In|jehdyni jyng gndh| d enhn{jl e{m~pjhe mb kjmkd|ni p{mi~ly| jinhyjbjni jh|~kpd{y K& 5 L(B([( ;:?;(4? ym ;:?;(9;(

#N* Ij{nlym{ gndh| ycn Pij{nlym{ mb ycn |ydyn inpd{ygnhy mb digjhj|y{dyjrn |n{rjln|W(#B* Bm{n|y ycjhhjhe| gndh| ummiz gdyn{jdf| {ngmrni b{mg d inh|n bm{n|y ym jgp{mrn

e{muyc& nhcdhln bm{n|y cndfyc& m{ {ngmrn y{nn| ym {nlmrn{ pmynhyjdf gm{ydfjyz(#E* Bm{n|y{z gdyn{jdf| gndh| gdyn{jdf| in{jrni b{mg ycn p{dlyjln mb pfdhyjhe dhi ld{jhebm{ bm{n|y| dhi ycn gdhdengnhy mb e{mujhe yjgkn{ ucn{n |~lc gdyn{jdf| lmgn b{mg |cm{y'{mydyjmh ummiz l{mp| ycdy d{n Pfn|| ycdh ynh znd{| mfiW& |~|ydjhdkfz gdhdeni bm{n|y|& ummi{n|ji~n|& m{ bm{n|y ycjhhjhe|(

#C* Jhyn{gnijdyn jhe{nijnhy m{ bnni|yml` gndh| d gdyn{jdf m{ lmgpm~hi gdin& jhucmfn m{ jh |jehjbjldhy pd{y& b{mg kjmfmejldf p{mi~ly|& {nhnudkfn de{jl~fy~{df gdyn{jdf|& m{bm{n|y{z gdyn{jdf| ycdy d{n |~k|nt~nhyfz ~|ni ym gd`n d gm{n lmgpfns lmgpm~hi m{ p{mi~ly(

#J* \ydyn denhljn| Pjh|n{y fj|yW(#A* \ydyn jh|yjy~yjmh mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmh gndh| dh jh|yjy~yjmh d| inbjhni ~hin{ Pjh|n{y



44/269

ljydyjmhW(;3;:


45/269

;?4; \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh 9>

55

53

5:

3?

34

3;

3

32

35

33

3:

:?

:4

:;

:

:2

:5

:3

::

4??

4?4

4?;

4?

4?2

|cdff hmyjbz ycn Pij{nlym{W( Jb& dbyn{ d||n||jhe ycn b~hlyjmh| mb in|jehdyni jyng|& d P|ydyn jh|yjy~yjmhmb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmhW inyn{gjhn| ycdy hmhn mb ycn in|jehdyni jyng| d{n b~hlyjmhdffz ldpdkfn mbgnnyjhe d |pnljbjl hnni mb ycn jh|yjy~yjmh& ycdy jh|yjy~yjmh |cdff hmyjbz kmyc ycn Pij{nlym{W dhi ycnPlcdhlnffm{ mb ycn kmd{i mb {nenhy|W( Ycn hmyjbzjhe denhlz m{ jh|yjy~yjmh ycnh gdz p~{lcd|n dhmhkjmkd|ni p{mi~ly ycdy j| b~hlyjmhdffz ldpdkfn mb gnnyjhe ycdy |pnljbjl hnni mb ycdy P|ydyndenhlz m{ jh|yjy~yjmh mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmhW ujycm~y knjhe inngni m~y mb lmgpfjdhln ujyc ycnp{me{dg kz ycn Pij{nlym{W m{ knjhe p{nlf~ini b{mg mycn{uj|n pd{yjljpdyjhe jh ycn p{me{dg(

\nlyjmh 9( P[npm{yjhe Kjmkd|ni _{mi~ly _~{lcd|n|(W#D* Hmy fdyn{ ycdh Pjh|n{y idynW& dhi ycn Pycj{yjnyc idz mb \npyngkn{ ndlc znd{W ycn{ndbyn{&

ycn Pij{nlym{W |cdff p{npd{n dhi |~kgjy ym ycn Pemrn{hm{& ycn p{n|jinhy mb ycn |nhdyn& dhi ycn|pnd`n{ mb ycn cm~|n mb {np{n|nhydyjrn|W d {npm{y in|l{jkjhe ycn h~gkn{& yzpn|& dhi dgm~hy mbgmhnz |pnhy kz P|ydyn denhljn|W ym k~z kjmkd|ni p{mi~ly| ~hin{ ycn Kjmkd|ni _{mi~ly|_{nbn{nhln _{me{dg n|ydkfj|cni kz ycj| Dly(

#K* Hmy fdyn{ ycdh Pjh|n{y idynW& dhi ycn Pbjbynnhyc idz mb \npyngkn{ ndlc znd{ ycn{ndbyn{W&ndlc P|ydyn jh|yjy~yjmh mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmhW |cdff p{npd{n dhi |~kgjy ym ycn Plcdhlnffm{ mb ycnkmd{i mb {nenhy|W d {npm{y ycdy in|l{jkn| ycn h~gkn{& yzpn|& dhi dgm~hy mb gmhnz |pnhy kz ycnP|ydyn jh|yjy~yjmh mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmhW ym k~z kjmkd|ni p{mi~ly| ~hin{ ycn Kjmkd|ni _{mi~ly|

_{nbn{nhln _{me{dg n|ydkfj|cni kz ycj| Dly(#L* Hmy fdyn{ ycdh Pjh|n{y idynW& dhi ycn Pycj{yjnyc idz mb \npyngkn{ ndlc znd{ ycn{ndbyn{W&

ycn Plcdhlnffm{ mb ycn kmd{i mb {nenhy|W |cdff p{npd{n dhi |~kgjy ym ycn Pemrn{hm{& ycn p{n|jinhymb ycn |nhdyn& dhi ycn |pnd`n{ mb ycn cm~|n mb {np{n|nhydyjrn|W d {npm{y in|l{jkjhe ycn h~gkn{&yzpn|& dhi dgm~hy mb gmhnz |pnhy kz P|ydyn jh|yjy~yjmh| mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmhW ym k~z kjmkd|nip{mi~ly| ~hin{ ycn Kjmkd|ni _{mi~ly| _{nbn{nhln _{me{dg n|ydkfj|cni kz ycj| Dly(

\nlyjmh >( P\nrn{dkjfjyz(W PJh|n{y |nrn{dkjfjyz lfd~|n(W


\nlyjmh 5( PNbbnlyjrn Idyn(W PJh|n{y nbbnlyjrn idyn(W


46/269

Kfjecyni _{mpn{yjn|

Ycj| Dly e{dhy| pmun{| ym d g~hjljpdfjyz ym yd`n dlyjmh dedjh|y dh muhn{ mb {ndf p{mpn{yzycdy j| jh |n{jm~| rjmfdyjmh mb lmin m{ dh muhn{ ucm bdjf| ym lm{{nly d lmhijyjmh ucjlc ld~|n| ycnp{mpn{yz ym kn {ned{ini d| d p~kfjl h~j|dhln( Bm{ nsdgpfn& d g~hjljpdfjyz gdz jhjyjdyn dh jhpn{|mhdg dlyjmh dedjh|y dh muhn{ bm{ d lmhyjh~jhe rjmfdyjmh bm{ ucjlc ycn muhn{ yd`n| hm

|~k|ydhyjdf |ynp ym lm{{nly ujycjh |js gmhyc| mb {nlnjrjhe dh m{in{ ym lm{{nly d rjmfdyjmh( Ycng~hjljpdfjyz gdz df|m {nlmrn{ dh dgm~hy nt~df ym dhz pnhdfyjn| jgpm|ni dedjh|y ycn muhn{ dhidhz lm|y| mb {ngnijdyjmh jhl~{{ni kz ycn g~hjljpdfjyz ym bjs ycn lmin rjmfdyjmh( Ym {nlmrn{ ycndgm~hy& d fjnh gdz kn pfdlni dedjh|y ycn d||ny| mb ycn muhn{(

D g~hjljpdfjyz gdz inhz d pn{gjy ym dh dppfjldhy ucm muh| {ndf p{mpn{yz jh dhzg~hjljpdfjyz dhi cd| d yds& udyn{& |nun{& m{ {nb~|n lmffnlyjmh infjht~nhlz m{ bm{ bdjfjhe ym dkdyn d|n{jm~| rjmfdyjmh mb |ydyn fdu m{ lmin& bm{ ucjlc d ij|y{jly a~ien m{ g~hjljpdf lm~{y cd| jgpm|nibjhn| m{ pnhdfyjn|(

Ycn Dly nhdkfn| lm~hyjn| ym n|ydkfj|c d cm~|jhe lm~{y ym cnd{ dhi inljin gdyyn{| d{j|jhe~hin{ ycn Dly dhi mycn{ fdu| lmhln{hjhe {ndf p{mpn{yz(

Ycn fnej|fdyjmh nhdkfn| ycn digjhj|y{dyjrn mbbjln mb ycn lm~{y| ym inrnfmp dhh~df y{djhjhe

p{me{dg| bm{ a~ien| dkm~y |ydyn fdu| ucjlc dii{n|| kfjecyni dhi dkdhimhni p{mpn{yz(

\~kgjyyni d|1_nhh|zfrdhjd\K :??\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;?4?(



\nlyjmh 4( P\cm{y Yjyfn(W Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| Ycn Hnjeckm{cmmi Kfjecy&[nlfdgdyjmh& dhi [nrjydfjqdyjmh Dly(

4;

2

5

3

:

4?

44

4;4

42

45

43

4:

;?

\nlyjmh ;( PInbjhjyjmh|(W D| ~|ni jh ycj| Dly1#4* Kmd{i |cdff gndh d qmhjhe cnd{jhe kmd{i m{ mycn{ kmiz e{dhyni a~{j|ijlyjmh ym

{nhin{ inlj|jmh| jh dllm{idhln ujyc Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW& m{ d |jgjfd{ kmd{i jh g~hjljpdfjyjn| hmy|~kanly ym ycdy Dly(

#;* K~jfijhe gndh| d {n|jinhyjdf& lmggn{ljdf m{ jhi~|y{jdf k~jfijhe m{ |y{~ly~{n dhi ycnfdhi dpp~{ynhdhy ym jy(

#* Gm{yeden fnhin{ gndh| d k~|jhn|| d||mljdyjmh inbjhni d| d kdh`jhe jh|yjy~yjmh m{

gm{yeden fnhin{ ~hin{ Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW ycdy j| jh pm||n||jmh mb m{ cmfi| yjyfn ym {ndf p{mpn{yzp~{|~dhy ym& jh nhbm{lngnhy mb m{ ym p{mynly {jecy| d{j|jhe ~hin{& d gm{yeden& gm{yeden hmyn& innimb y{~|y m{ mycn{ y{dh|dlyjmh ycdy l{ndyni d |nl~{jyz jhyn{n|y jh ycn {ndf p{mpn{yz(

#2* G~hjljpdfjyz gndh| d ljyz& km{m~ec& jhlm{pm{dyni ymuh& ymuh|cjp m{ cmgn {~fn&mpyjmhdf pfdh m{ mpyjmhdf lcd{yn{ g~hjljpdfjyz m{ g~hjljpdf d~ycm{jyz jh ycj| |ydyn dhi dhz nhyjyzp~{|~dhy ym Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW(

http://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/0632b05PASB900neighborhoodblight.pdfhttp://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/0632b05PASB900neighborhoodblight.pdfhttp://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/0632b05PASB900neighborhoodblight.pdf


47/269

#5* G~hjljpdf pn{gjy| gndh| p{jrjfnen| {nfdyjhe ym {ndf p{mpn{yz e{dhyni kz dg~hjljpdfjyz& jhlf~ijhe& k~y hmy fjgjyni ym& k~jfijhe pn{gjy|& nslnpyjmh| ym qmhjhe m{ijhdhln| dhimll~pdhlz pn{gjy|( Ycn yn{g jhlf~in| dpp{mrdf| p~{|~dhy ym fdhi ~|n m{ijhdhln| mycn{ ycdhinlj|jmh| mh ycn |~k|ydhyjrn rdfjijyz mb d qmhjhe m{ijhdhln m{ gdp m{ ycn dllnpydhln mb d l~{dyjrndgnhignhy(

;4

;;

;

;2

;5

;3

;:


48/269

#I* Ucn{n& dbyn{ {nd|mhdkfn nbbm{y|& |n{rjln mb p{mln|| bm{ d hmyjln m{ ljydyjmh bm{ dhzlmin rjmfdyjmh bm{ dhz {ndf p{mpn{yz muhni kz dh d||mljdyjmh m{ y{~|y ldhhmy kn dllmgpfj|cni kzcdhijhe d lmpz mb ycn hmyjln m{ ljydyjmh ym dh nsnl~yjrn mbbjln{& pd{yhn{ m{ y{~|ynn mb ycnd||mljdyjmh m{ y{~|y m{ ym ycn gdhden{& y{~|ynn m{ lfn{` jh lcd{en mb ycn p{mpn{yz& ycn infjrn{z mbycn hmyjln m{ ljydyjmh gdz mll~{ kz {nej|yn{ni& ln{yjbjni m{ ^hjyni \ydyn| Nsp{n|| Gdjf&dllmgpdhjni kz d infjrn{z lmhbj{gdyjmh1

2:

5?

54

5;

5

52

55

53

5:

3?

34

3;

3

32

35

33

3:

:?

:4

:;

:

:2

:5

:3::

4??

4?4

4?;

4?

4?2

4?5

4?3

4?:44?

444

44;

44

442

#4* ym ycn {nej|yn{ni mbbjln mb ycn lm{pm{dyjmh& k~|jhn|| d||mljdyjmh& m{ y{~|y(#;* ucn{n ycn d||mljdyjmh m{ y{~|y imn| hmy cdrn d {nej|yn{ni mbbjln& ym ycn gdjfjhe

dii{n|| ~|ni bm{ {ndf n|ydyn yds lmffnlyjmh p~{pm|n|& jb dllmgpdhjni kz ycn pm|yjhe mb dlmh|pjl~m~| hmyjln ym ycn p{mpn{yz dhi kz cdhijhe d lmpz mb ycn hmyjln m{ ljydyjmh ym ycn pn{|mhjh lcd{en mb ycn p{mpn{yz dy ycdy yjgn(

#N* D pn{|mh ucm fjrn| m{ cd| d p{jhljpdf pfdln mb {n|jinhln m~y|jin ycj| |ydyn& ucm muh|p{mpn{yz jh ycj| |ydyn dedjh|y ucjlc lmin rjmfdyjmh| cdrn knnh ljyni ~hin{ Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW& dhiycn pn{|mh j| lcd{eni ~hin{ Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW& dhi ucm cd| knnh p{mpn{fz hmyjbjni mb ycn rjmfdyjmh|gdz kn nsy{dijyni ym ycj| |ydyn ym bdln l{jgjhdf p{m|nl~yjmh ym ycn b~ff nsynhy dffmuni dhi jh ycngdhhn{ d~ycm{jqni kz Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW(

\nlyjmh 9( PLmhijyjmh| bm{ G~hjljpdfjyjn| Inhzjhe _n{gjy| ym Dppfjldhy| Ucm Muh [ndf

_{mpn{yz(W#D* D g~hjljpdfjyz m{ d kmd{i gdz inhz j||~jhe ym dh dppfjldhy d g~hjljpdf pn{gjy jb ycn

dppfjldhy muh| {ndf p{mpn{yz jh dhz g~hjljpdfjyz bm{ ucjlc ycn{n nsj|y| mh ycn {ndf p{mpn{yz1#4* d bjhdf dhi ~hdppndfdkfn yds& udyn{& |nun{ m{ {nb~|n lmffnlyjmh infjht~nhlz mh

dllm~hy mb ycn dlyjmh| mb ycn muhn{0 m{#;* d |n{jm~| rjmfdyjmh mb |ydyn fdu m{ d lmin dhi ycn muhn{ cd| yd`nh hm

|~k|ydhyjdf |ynp| ym lm{{nly ycn rjmfdyjmh ujycjh P|jsW gmhyc| bmffmujhe hmyjbjldyjmh mb ycnrjmfdyjmh dhi bm{ ucjlc bjhn| m{ d a~iegnhy ym dkdyn m{ lm{{nly un{n jgpm|ni kz d Pgdej|yn{jdfij|y{jly a~ienW m{ Pg~hjljpdf lm~{yW& m{ d a~iegnhy dy fdu m{ jh nt~jyz ud| jgpm|ni kz d Plm~{y mblmggmh pfnd|W( Cmunrn{& hm inhjdf |cdff kn pn{gjyyni mh ycn kd|j| mb d p{mpn{yz bm{ ucjlc ycna~iegnhy& m{in{ m{ inl{nn j| |~kanly ym d |ydz m{ |~pn{|nin d| kz dh m{in{ mb d lm~{y mb lmgpnynhy

a~{j|ijlyjmh m{ d~ymgdyjldffz dffmuni kz |ydy~yn m{ {~fn mb lm~{y ~hyjf ycn |ydz m{ |~pn{|nin j|fjbyni kz ycn lm~{y m{ d cjecn{ lm~{y m{ ycn |ydz m{ |~pn{|nin d| nspj{n| d| mycn{uj|n p{mrjini kzfdu( Ucn{n d |ydz m{ |~pn{|nin d| j| jh nbbnly& ycn p{mpn{yz muhn{ |cdff |m dirj|n ycn g~hjljpdfjyz|nn`jhe ym inhz d g~hjljpdf pn{gjy(

#K* D g~hjljpdfjyz m{ kmd{i |cdff hmy inhz d g~hjljpdf pn{gjy ym dh dppfjldhy jb ycng~hjljpdf pn{gjy j| hnln||d{z ym lm{{nly d rjmfdyjmh mb |ydyn fdu m{ d lmin(

#L* Ycn g~hjljpdf pn{gjy inhjdf |cdff hmy dppfz ym dh dppfjldhy| infjht~nhlz mh ydsn|&udyn{& |nun{ m{ {nb~|n lmffnlyjmh lcd{en| ycdy d{n ~hin{ dppndf m{ mycn{uj|n lmhyn|yni yc{m~ec dlm~{y m{ digjhj|y{dyjrn p{mln||(

#I* Jh j||~jhe d inhjdf mb d pn{gjy kd|ni mh dh dppfjldhy| infjht~nhlz jh {ndf p{mpn{yzydsn| m{ g~hjljpdf lcd{en| m{ bm{ bdjf~{n ym dkdyn d |n{jm~| rjmfdyjmh mb |ydyn fdu m{ d lmin mh {ndf

p{mpn{yz ycdy ycn dppfjldhy muh| jh ycj| |ydyn& ycn g~hjljpdfjyz m{ kmd{i |cdff jhijldyn ycn |y{nnydii{n||& g~hjljpdf lm{pm{dyjmh dhi lm~hyz jh ucjlc ycn p{mpn{yz j| fmldyni dhi ycn lm~{y dhiiml`ny h~gkn{ bm{ ndlc pd{lnf ljyni d| d kd|j| bm{ ycn inhjdf( Ycn inhjdf |cdff df|m |ydyn ycdy ycndppfjldhy gdz {nt~n|y d fnyyn{ mb lmgpfjdhln b{mg ycn dpp{mp{jdyn |ydyn denhlz& g~hjljpdfjyz m{|lcmmf ij|y{jly& jh d bm{g |pnljbjni kz |~lc nhyjyz d| p{mrjini jh ycj| |nlyjmh(

#N* Dff g~hjljpdf pn{gjy| inhjni jh dllm{idhln ujyc ycj| |nlyjmh gdz kn ujyccnfi ~hyjf dhdppfjldhy mkydjh| d fnyyn{ b{mg ycn dpp{mp{jdyn |ydyn denhlz& g~hjljpdfjyz m{ |lcmmf ij|y{jlyjhijldyjhe ycn bmffmujhe1



49/269

#4* ycn p{mpn{yz jh t~n|yjmh cd| hm bjhdf dhi ~hdppndfdkfn yds& udyn{& |nun{ m{{nb~|n infjht~nhljn|0

445

443

44:

4;?

4;4

4;;

4;

4;2

4;5

4;3

4;:

4


50/269

#>* n|ydkfj|c p{mlni~{n| bm{ gmhjym{jhe cm~|jhe lm~{y| dhi ycnj{ {nfdyni |n{rjln|dhi bm{ nrdf~dyjhe ycn nbbnlyjrnhn|| mb cm~|jhe lm~{y| dhi ycnj{ {nfdyni |n{rjln|(

422

425

423

42:

45?

454

45;

45

452

455

453

45:

43?

434

43;

43

432

435

433

43:

4:?

4:4

4:;

4:4:2

4:5

4:3

4::

;??

;?4

;?;

;?

;?2;?5

;?3

;?:

;4?

;44

;4;

;4>

>2

>5

>3

>:

2?

24

2;

2

22

25

23

2:

5?

54

5;

5

52

55

53

5:

3?

34

3;

#;* Jh diijyjmh ym dhz i~yz {nt~j{ni ym kn pn{bm{gni kz fdu m{ kz ycn lmhy{dlyl{ndyjhe d lcd{yn{ |lcmmf lmffdkm{dyjrn& ycn lmffdkm{dyjrn |cdff cdrn dhi pn{bm{g ycn bmffmujhei~yjn|1

#d* Ym dly lmh|j|ynhyfz ujyc ycn p{mrj|jmh| mb ycj| Dly0#k* Ym dkjin kz ycn lmhy{dly ycdy l{ndyn| dhi m{edhjqn| ycn lcd{yn{ |lcmmf

lmffdkm{dyjrn0 dhi#l* Ym dly lmh|j|ynhyfz ujyc ycn lcd{yn{ lmhy{dly dhi gj||jmh mb ndlc

lcd{yn{ |lcmmf ycdy pd{yjljpdyn| jh ycn lcd{yn{ |lcmmf lmffdkm{dyjrn(#C* D lmhy{dly ym n|ydkfj|c d lcd{yn{ |lcmmf lmffdkm{dyjrn |cdff& dy d gjhjg~g& |pnljbz1

#4* Ycn hdgn dhi p~{pm|n mb ycn lcd{yn{ |lcmmf lmffdkm{dyjrn dhi ycn b~hlyjmh|&|n{rjln|& m{ bdljfjyjn| ycdy ycn lcd{yn{ |lcmmf lmffdkm{dyjrn |cdff p{mrjin m{ mpn{dyn095

#;* Ycn n|ydkfj|cgnhy dhi m{edhjqdyjmh mb d kmd{i mb ij{nlym{| mb ycn lcd{yn{|lcmmf lmffdkm{dyjrn& jhlf~ijhe k~y hmy fjgjyni ym1

#d* Ycn h~gkn{ mb ij{nlym{|& ycn gdhhn{ mb dppmjhygnhy& ycn yn{g| mbmbbjln& ycn dgm~hy mb lmgpnh|dyjmh& jb dhz& dhi ycn p{mlni~{n| bm{ bjffjhe rdldhljn|0

#k* Ycn mbbjln{| mb ycn lcd{yn{ |lcmmf lmffdkm{dyjrn& ycn gdhhn{ mb ycnj{|nfnlyjmh& dhi ycnj{ i~yjn|0

#l* Ycn rmyjhe {nt~j{ngnhy| bm{ dlyjmh kz ycn kmd{i mb ij{nlym{|0 nslnpyycdy& ~hfn|| |pnljbjldffz p{mrjini mycn{uj|n jh ycn lmhy{dly& d gdam{jyz mb ij{nlym{| |cdff lmh|yjy~ynd t~m{~g dhi d gdam{jyz mb d t~m{~g |cdff kn hnln||d{z ym d~ycm{jqn dhz dlyjmh yd`nh kz ycnkmd{i mb ij{nlym{|0

#* Ycn yn{g|& jb dhz& ~hin{ ucjlc d lcd{yn{ |lcmmf ycdy j| hmy jhjyjdffz dpd{yjljpdhy jh ycn lcd{yn{ |lcmmf lmffdkm{dyjrn gdz amjh ycn lmffdkm{dyjrn dhi ~hin{ ucjlc lcd{yn{|lcmmf pd{yjljpdhy| gdz ujyci{du b{mg ycn lcd{yn{ |lcmmf lmffdkm{dyjrn(

#J* Ycn P|ydyn kmd{i mb ni~ldyjmhW& kz {~fn& gdz n|ydkfj|c d bnn ym kn pdji kz ndlc lcd{yn{|lcmmf lmffdkm{dyjrn ym mbb|ny dhz ij{nly lm|y| ycdy ycn Pinpd{ygnhy mb ni~ldyjmhW gdz jhl~{ jhlmffnlyjhe idyd b{mg m{ {ne~fdyjhe ycn lcd{yn{ |lcmmf lmffdkm{dyjrn( Ycn dgm~hy mb ycn bnn |cdffhmy nslnni ycn dgm~hy mb |dji ij{nly lm|y|( Dhz dgm~hy jh bnn| {nlnjrni kz ycn Pinpd{ygnhy mb

ni~ldyjmhW p~{|~dhy ym ycj| |nlyjmh j| lmhyjh~m~|fz dpp{mp{jdyni ym ycn Pinpd{ygnhyW bm{ |djiij{nly lm|y|(

#A* Hmycjhe jh ycj| Dly |cdff p{mcjkjy d lcd{yn{ |lcmmf b{mg pd{yjljpdyjhe d| d gngkn{ jhdh m{edhjqdyjmh bm{gni bm{ ycn p~{pm|n mb g~y~df |~ppm{y& lmhy{dlyjhe bm{ |n{rjln|& pd{yjljpdyjhejh jhyn{emrn{hgnhydf de{nngnhy| mycn{uj|n d~ycm{jqni kz fdu& m{ pd{yjljpdyjhe jh dhz mycn{ bm{gmb m{edhjqdyjmh d~ycm{jqni kz fdu dhi dpp{mp{jdyn ym p~kfjl m{ hmhp{mbjy m{edhjqdyjmh| jh ycj||ydyn(

\nlyjmh 9( P\nrn{dkjfjyz(W PJh|n{y |nrn{dkjfjyz lfd~|n(W

;?4; \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh >


54/269

>9 Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|

3

32

\nlyjmh >( P[npndfn{(W PJh|n{y {npndfn{ lfd~|n(W



55/269

Ljrjf _{mynlyjmh M{in{| dhi Dhjgdf|

Ycj| Dly dffmu| lm~{y| ucnh j||~jhe d ljrjf p{mynlyjmh m{in{ m{ ngn{enhlz p{mynlyjmhm{in{ ym jhlf~in {n|y{djhjhe |mgnmhn b{mg yd`jhe m{ cd{gjhe dhjgdf| muhni kz ycn pn{|mh|nn`jhe ycn m{in{(

\~kgjyyni d|1Lmfm{dim\K 4?'?3? #Nh{mffni rn{|jmh*\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;?4?(



\nlyjmh 4( P\cm{y Yjyfn(W Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| Dh Dly ym Dffmu Lm~{y'Nhyn{ni Ljrjf_{mynlyjmh M{in{| ym Jhlf~in Ij{nlyjrn| Lmhln{hjhe Dhjgdf|(

4

;

2

5

3

:

4?

44

4;

4

42

45

43

4:

;?

;4

;;

;;2

;5

;3

;:


56/269

nhyn{jhe m{ {ngdjhjhe mh p{ngj|n|& m{ b{mg lmgjhe ujycjh d |pnljbjni ij|ydhln mb d p{mynlynipn{|mh m{ p{ngj|n|(

9

>>

>2

>5

>3

>:

\nlyjmh ( P\nrn{dkjfjyz(W PJh|n{y |nrn{dkjfjyz lfd~|n(W



>2 Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|


57/269

Lfjhjldf _cd{gdlj|y _{dlyjyjmhn{

Ycj| Dly l{ndyn| ycn p{mbn||jmhdf lfd||jbjldyjmh mb lfjhjldf pcd{gdlj|y p{dlyjyjmhn{( YcnDly |pnljbjn| ycdy mhfz d pcd{gdlj|y ln{yjbjni kz ycn |ydyn pcd{gdlz kmd{i gdz fnedffz knjinhyjbjni d| d lfjhjldf pcd{gdlj|y p{dlyjyjmhn{(

\~kgjyyni d|1Gmhydhd\K?459\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;??:(



\nlyjmh 4( P\cm{y Yjyfn(W Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| Dh Dly L{ndyjhe ycn _{mbn||jmhdfLfd||jbjldyjmh mb Lfjhjldf _cd{gdlj|y _{dlyjyjmhn{(

4

;

2

5

3

:

4?

44

4;

4

42

45

43

4:

;?

;4

;;

;;2

;5

;3

;:


58/269

Lmffnen _d{yhn{|cjp Fdkm{dym{z \lcmmf|

Ycj| Dly inbjhn| d lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf d| d p~kfjl& hmh|nlyd{jdh&hmh{nfjejm~| |lcmmf n|ydkfj|cni kz d p~kfjl jh|yjy~yjmh mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmh ycdy mpn{dyn| d yndlcn{ni~ldyjmh p{me{dg dpp{mrni kz ycn |ydyn kmd{i mb ni~ldyjmh( Ycn Dly d~ycm{jqn| lmffnenpd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf| ym |yjg~fdyn ycn inrnfmpgnhy mb jhhmrdyjrn p{me{dg| bm{

p{n|lcmmf yc{m~ec e{din 4; |y~inhy| dhi p{mrjin mppm{y~hjyjn| bm{ jhhmrdyjrn jh|y{~lyjmh dhid||n||gnhy(

\~kgjyyni d|1Rj{ejhjdLcdpyn{ 354 mb ;?4?\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;?4?(



\nlyjmh 4( Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| Dh Dly ym N|ydkfj|c Lmffnen _d{yhn{|cjp Fdkm{dym{z\lcmmf|(

4

;

2

5

3

:

4?

444;

4

42

45

43

4:

;?

;4

;;;

;2

;5

;3

;:


59/269

|n{rjln|( Nh{mffgnhy |cdff kn mpnh ym dhz lcjfi ucm j| inngni ym {n|jin ujycjh ycj| |ydyn yc{m~ecd fmyyn{z p{mln|| mh d |pdln'drdjfdkfn kd|j|( D udjyjhe fj|y |cdff kn n|ydkfj|cni jb dint~dyn |pdlnj| hmy drdjfdkfn ym dllmggmidyn dff |y~inhy| ucm|n pd{nhy| cdrn {nt~n|yni ym kn nhyn{ni jh ycnfmyyn{z p{mln||( \~lc udjyjhe fj|y |cdff df|m kn p{jm{jyjqni yc{m~ec d fmyyn{z p{mln|| dhi pd{nhy||cdff kn jhbm{gni mb ycnj{ |y~inhy| pm|jyjmh mh ycn fj|y(

>2

>5

>3

>:

2?24

2;

2

22

25

23

2:

5?

545;

5

52

55

53

5:

#L* D lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf |cdff kn digjhj|yn{ni dhi gdhdeni kz demrn{hjhe kmd{i( _~{|~dhy ym d lmhy{dly dhi d| |pnljbjni jh Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW& lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjpfdkm{dym{z |lcmmf| |cdff kn |~kanly ym ycn {nt~j{ngnhy| mb ycn P\ydhid{i| mb T~dfjyz& jhlf~ijhe ycn\ydhid{i| mb Fnd{hjhe dhi ycn \ydhid{i| mb Dll{nijydyjmhW& dhi |~lc {ne~fdyjmh| d| inyn{gjhnikz ycn Pkmd{i mb ni~ldyjmhW(

#I* Lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf| d{n nhlm~{deni ym inrnfmp lmffdkm{dyjrnpd{yhn{|cjp| ujyc p~kfjl |lcmmf ijrj|jmh| bm{ ycn p~{pm|n mb k~jfijhe |ndgfn|| ni~ldyjmhmppm{y~hjyjn| bm{ dff |~lc |y~inhy| jh ycj| |ydyn& b{mg p{n|lcmmf ym pm|y|nlmhid{z ni~ldyjmh(

#N* _~{|~dhy ym d lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf de{nngnhy& d lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjpfdkm{dym{z |lcmmf |cdff kn {n|pmh|jkfn bm{ jy| muh mpn{dyjmh|& jhlf~ijhe& k~y hmy fjgjyni ym& |~lck~ieny p{npd{dyjmh& lmhy{dly| bm{ |n{rjln|& dhi pn{|mhhnf gdyyn{| d| d{n |pnljbjni jh ycnde{nngnhy(

#B* D lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf gdz hnemyjdyn dhi lmhy{dly ujyc d |lcmmf

kmd{i& ycn emrn{hjhe kmiz mb d p~kfjl jh|yjy~yjmh mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmh& m{ dhz ycj{i pd{yz bm{ ycn~|n mb d |lcmmf k~jfijhe dhi e{m~hi|& ycn mpn{dyjmh dhi gdjhynhdhln ycn{nmb& dhi ycn p{mrj|jmhmb dhz |n{rjln& dlyjrjyz& m{ ~hin{yd`jhe ycdy ycn lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf j| {nt~j{niym pn{bm{g jh m{in{ ym ld{{z m~y ycn ni~ldyjmhdf p{me{dg in|l{jkni jh jy| lmhy{dly( Dhz |n{rjln|bm{ ucjlc d lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf lmhy{dly| ujyc d |lcmmf kmd{i m{ jh|yjy~yjmh mbcjecn{ ni~ldyjmh |cdff hmy nslnni ycn |lcmmf ijrj|jmh| m{ jh|yjy~yjmh| lm|y| ym p{mrjin |~lc|n{rjln|(

#E* D lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf |cdff hmy lcd{en y~jyjmh(#C* Dh dpp{mrni lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf |cdff kn in|jehdyni d| d fmldf

ni~ldyjmh denhlz& k~y |cdff hmy lmh|yjy~yn d |lcmmf ijrj|jmh d| inbjhni ~hin{ Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW(

\nlyjmh 9( PLmffnen _d{yhn{|cjp Fdkm{dym{z \lcmmf Dppfjldyjmh dhi Lmhy{dly(W#D* Dhz p~kfjl jh|yjy~yjmh mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmh mpn{dyjhe ujycjh ycj| |ydyn dhi cdrjhe d

yndlcn{ ni~ldyjmh p{me{dg dpp{mrni kz ycn Pkmd{i mb ni~ldyjmhW gdz |~kgjy dh dppfjldyjmh bm{bm{gdyjmh mb d lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf(

#K* Ndlc lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf dppfjldyjmh |cdff p{mrjin m{ in|l{jknycm{m~ecfz dff mb ycn bmffmujhe n||nhyjdf nfngnhy| mb ycn p{mpm|ni |lcmmf pfdh1

#4* Dh nsnl~yjrn |~ggd{z0#;* Ycn gj||jmh dhi rj|jmh mb ycn p{mpm|ni lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf&

jhlf~ijhe jinhyjbjldyjmh mb ycn yd{enyni |y~inhy pmp~fdyjmh0#* Gjhjg~g& pfdhhni& dhi gdsjg~g nh{mffgnhy pn{ e{din pn{ znd{ bm{ ycn yn{gmb ycn lmhy{dly0

#2* Kdl`e{m~hi jhbm{gdyjmh mh ycn p{mpm|ni bm~hijhe emrn{hjhe kmd{i gngkn{|dhi& jb jinhyjbjni& ycn p{mpm|ni |lcmmf fndin{|cjp dhi gdhdengnhy yndg0

#5* Ycn |lcmmf| p{mpm|ni ldfnhid{ dhi |dgpfn idjfz |lcni~fn0#3* D in|l{jpyjmh mb ycn dldingjl p{me{dg dfjehni ujyc |ydyn |ydhid{i|0#:* D in|l{jpyjmh mb ycn |lcmmf| ni~ldyjmhdf p{me{dg& jhlf~ijhe ycn yzpn mb

fnd{hjhe nhrj{mhgnhy #|~lc d| lfd||{mmg'kd|ni m{ jhinpnhinhy |y~iz*& lfd|| |jqn dhi |y{~ly~{n&l~{{jl~f~g mrn{rjnu& dhi yndlcjhe gnycmi|0

;?4; \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh >:


60/269

#4?* Ycn |lcmmf| pfdh bm{ ~|jhe jhyn{hdf dhi nsyn{hdf d||n||gnhy| ym gnd|~{n dhi{npm{y |y~inhy p{me{n|| jh dllm{idhln ujyc ycn P\ydhid{i| mb Fnd{hjheW dimpyni ~hin{ Pjh|n{yljydyjmhW0

3?

34

3;

3

32

35

33

3:

:?

:4

:;

:

:2

:5

:3

::

4??

4?4

4?;

4?

4?2

4?5

4?3

4?:44?

444

44;

44

442

445

443

44:

4;?4;4

4;;

4;

4;2

4;5

#44* Ycn |lcmmf| pfdh| bm{ jinhyjbzjhe dhi |~lln||b~ffz |n{rjhe |y~inhy| ujycij|dkjfjyjn|& |y~inhy| ucm d{n Nhefj|c fdhe~den fnd{hn{|& |y~inhy| ucm d{n dldingjldffz kncjhi&dhi ejbyni |y~inhy|& jhlf~ijhe k~y hmy fjgjyni ym lmgpfjdhln ujyc dppfjldkfn fdu| dhi {ne~fdyjmh|0

#4;* D in|l{jpyjmh mb lm'l~{{jl~fd{ dhi nsy{dl~{{jl~fd{ p{me{dg| dhi cmu ycn|nujff kn b~hini dhi infjrn{ni0

#4* Dh m{edhjqdyjmh lcd{y ycdy lfnd{fz p{n|nhy| ycn |lcmmf| m{edhjqdyjmhdf|y{~ly~{n& jhlf~ijhe fjhn| mb d~ycm{jyz dhi {npm{yjhe knyunnh ycn emrn{hjhe kmd{i& |ydbb& dhz{nfdyni kmijn| #|~lc d| dirj|m{z kmijn| m{ pd{nhy dhi yndlcn{ lm~hljf|*& Pkmd{i mb ni~ldyjmhW& dhidhz nsyn{hdf m{edhjqdyjmh| ycdy ujff pfdz d {mfn jh gdhdejhe ycn |lcmmf0

#42* D lfnd{ in|l{jpyjmh mb ycn {mfn| dhi {n|pmh|jkjfjyjn| bm{ ycn emrn{hjhe kmd{i&ycn |lcmmf| fndin{|cjp dhi gdhdengnhy yndg& dhi dhz mycn{ nhyjyjn| |cmuh jh ycn m{edhjqdyjmh

lcd{y0#45* D |ydbbjhe lcd{y bm{ ycn |lcmmf| bj{|y znd{ dhi d |ydbbjhe pfdh bm{ ycn yn{g mb

ycn lmhy{dly0#43* _fdh| bm{ {nl{~jyjhe dhi inrnfmpjhe |lcmmf fndin{|cjp dhi |ydbb0#4:* Ycn |lcmmf| fndin{|cjp dhi yndlcn{ ngpfmzgnhy pmfjljn|& jhlf~ijhe

pn{bm{gdhln nrdf~dyjmh pfdh|0#;?* D pfdh bm{ ycn pfdlngnhy mb lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z |lcmmf p~pjf|&

yndlcn{|& dhi ngpfmznn| ~pmh yn{gjhdyjmh m{ {nrmldyjmh mb ycn lmhy{dly0#;4* Nspfdhdyjmh mb dhz pd{yhn{|cjp| m{ lmhy{dly~df {nfdyjmh|cjp| lnhy{df ym ycn

|lcmmf| mpn{dyjmh| m{ gj||jmh0#;;* Ycn |lcmmf| pfdh| bm{ p{mrjijhe y{dh|pm{ydyjmh& bmmi |n{rjln& dhi dff mycn{

|jehjbjldhy mpn{dyjmhdf m{ dhljffd{z |n{rjln|0#;


61/269

kd|j| bm{ d||n||jhe ycn dppfjldhy| pfdh| dhi ldpdljyjn|( Dh dpp{mrni lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjpfdkm{dym{z |lcmmf dppfjldyjmh |cdff hmy |n{rn d| ycn |lcmmf| lmhy{dly(

4;3

4;:

4


62/269

#L* Jb ycn Pkmd{i mb ni~ldyjmhW {nrm`n| m{ imn| hmy {nhnu d lmffnen pd{yhn{|cjp fdkm{dym{z|lcmmf lmhy{dly& jy |cdff lfnd{fz |ydyn& jh d {n|mf~yjmh& ycn {nd|mh| bm{ ycn {nrmldyjmh m{452hmh{nhnudf(455

45>

453

45:

43?

434

43;

43

432

435

433

43:

4:?

4:4

4:;

4:

4:2

4:5

4:3

4::

;??

;?4

;?;

;?

;?2

;?5

;?3

;?:

;4?

;4;

;43

;4:

;;?

;;4

;;;

;;

>2

>5

>3

>:

2?

242;

2

22

25

23

2:

5?

54

5;5

52

55

53

5:

\nlyjmh


66/269

ed{inh| |cdff hmy kn ~|ni ym dlcjnrn gm{n ycdh Pyunhyz pn{lnhyW mb ycn {nydjf ij|y{jk~ynienhn{dyjmh |ydhid{i jh znd{| P;?44 yc{m~ec ;?4

32

35

33

3:

:?

:4

:;

:

:2

:5

:3

::

4??

4?4

4?;

4?

4?2

4?5

4?3

4?:44?

444

44;

44

442

445

443

44:

4;?4;4

4;;

4;

4;2

4;5

4;3

#L* Bm{ ycn bj{|y Pyc{nnW lmgpfjdhln znd{| lmggnhljhe ujyc ycn Pjh|n{y lmgpfjdhln znd{W&d t~dfjbzjhe {nydjf ~yjfjyz |cdff hmy kn mkfjedyni ym p~{lcd|n ycn m~yp~y b{mg gm{n ycdh P|jsWgnedudyy| mb hnufz jh|ydffni lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh enhn{dyjmh(

#I* Bm{ ndlc t~dfjbzjhe {nydjf ~yjfjyz| lmgpfjdhln znd{| lmggnhljhe jh Pjh|n{y idynW dhiycn{ndbyn{& ycn P|ydyn p~kfjl ~yjfjyjn| lmggj||jmhW |cdff inyn{gjhn ycn gjhjg~g dhi gdsjg~gp~{lcd|n| mb nfnly{jldf m~yp~y b{mg hnufz jh|ydffni lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh| mb ijbbn{nhy m~yp~yldpdljyz ycdy ycn t~dfjbzjhe {nydjf ~yjfjyz |cdff pfdh ym dlt~j{n& ujycm~y {ned{i ym ycn P|js'gnedudyyW lnjfjhe mb ycn bj{|y Pyc{nnW lmgpfjdhln znd{|( Jh diijyjmh& d| hnln||d{z& ycn P|ydyn p~kfjl~yjfjyjn| lmggj||jmhW |cdff bm{g~fdyn dhi jgpfngnhy pmfjljn| lmh|j|ynhy ujyc ycj| |nlyjmh ycdy|jg~fydhnm~|fz nhlm~{den1

#4* Ycn muhn{|cjp kz l~|ymgn{| mb |~k|l{jpyjmh| jh lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh| dhimb mycn{ bm{g| mb ij|y{jk~yni enhn{dyjmh& ym ycn nsynhy ycn P|ydyn p~kfjl ~yjfjyjn| lmggj||jmhW bjhi|ycn{n ym kn l~|ymgn{ ingdhi bm{ |~lc muhn{|cjp0

#;* Muhn{|cjp jh lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh| kz {n|jinhyjdf {nydjf l~|ymgn{|& dhide{jl~fy~{df p{mi~ln{|& jhlf~ijhe fmu'jhlmgn l~|ymgn{|& ym ycn nsynhy ycn P|ydyn p~kfjl ~yjfjyjn|lmggj||jmhW bjhi| ycn{n ym kn ingdhi bm{ |~lc muhn{|cjp0

#* Ycn dlcjnrngnhy mb ycn emdf| dhi mkanly| ym inrnfmp {nhnudkfn nhn{ez jh ycj||ydyn d| inbjhni ~hin{ Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW(

#N* Ycn m~yp~y b{mg d lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh |cdff kn |mfi mhfz ym ycn t~dfjbzjhe {nydjf~yjfjyz |n{rjhe ycn enme{dpcjl d{nd ucn{n ycn lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh j| fmldyni( Mhln dlmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh j| pd{y mb d t~dfjbzjhe {nydjf ~yjfjyz| pfdh bm{ dlt~j|jyjmh mb {nhnudkfn{n|m~{ln|& d| dpp{mrni kz ycn P|ydyn p~kfjl ~yjfjyjn| lmggj||jmhW& ycn t~dfjbzjhe {nydjf ~yjfjyz |cdff

p~{lcd|n dff mb ycn nfnly{jljyz dhi {nhnudkfn nhn{ez l{nijy| enhn{dyni kz ycn lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ed{inh( Ycn dgm~hy mb nfnly{jljyz dhi {nhnudkfn nhn{ez l{nijy| enhn{dyni kz ndlc lmgg~hjyz|mfd{ ed{inh |cdff kn inyn{gjhni kz d p{mi~lyjmh gnyn{ jh|ydffni kz ycn t~dfjbzjhe {nydjf ~yjfjyz m{ycj{i'pd{yz |z|yng muhn{ dhi pdji bm{ kz ycn muhn{ mb ycn lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh(

#B* Ycn p~{lcd|n mb ycn m~yp~y mb d lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh kz d t~dfjbzjhe {nydjf ~yjfjyz|cdff yd`n ycn bm{g mb d hny gnyn{jhe l{nijy dedjh|y ycn t~dfjbzjhe {nydjf ~yjfjyz| nfnly{jl kjff ymndlc lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh |~k|l{jkn{ dy ycn p{ngj|n| |ny bm{yc jh ycn |~k|l{jkn{| |~k|l{jpyjmh(Ycn hny gnyn{jhe l{nijy |cdff kn ldfl~fdyni kz g~fyjpfzjhe ycn |~k|l{jkn{| |cd{n mb ycn nfnly{jljyzp{mi~lyjmh b{mg ycn lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh kz ycn t~dfjbzjhe {nydjf ~yjfjyz| ymydf dee{nedyn{nydjf {dyn d| lcd{eni ym ycn |~k|l{jkn{& gjh~| d {nd|mhdkfn lcd{en d| inyn{gjhni kz ycn P|ydynp~kfjl ~yjfjyjn| lmggj||jmhW ym lmrn{ ycn ~yjfjyz| lm|y| mb infjrn{jhe ym ycn |~k|l{jkn{| p{ngj|n|

ycn nfnly{jljyz enhn{dyni kz ycn lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh& jhyne{dyjhe ycn |mfd{ enhn{dyjmh ujyc ycn~yjfjyz| |z|yng& dhi digjhj|yn{jhe ycn lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh| lmhy{dly| dhi hny gnyn{jhel{nijy|( Ycn P|ydyn p~kfjl ~yjfjyjn| lmggj||jmhW |cdff nh|~{n ycj| lcd{en imn| hmy {nbfnly lm|y| ycdyd{n df{ndiz {nlmrn{ni kz ycn ~yjfjyz b{mg ycn |~k|l{jkn{ yc{m~ec mycn{ lcd{en|( Jb& dhi ym ycnnsynhy ycdy& d |~k|l{jkn{| hny gnyn{jhe l{nijy nslnni| ycn |~k|l{jkn{| nfnly{jl kjff jh dhz kjffjhepn{jmi& ycn hny gnyn{jhe l{nijy |cdff kn ld{{jni bm{ud{i dhi dppfjni dedjh|y b~y~{n kjff|( Ycnt~dfjbzjhe {nydjf ~yjfjyz dhi ycn muhn{ mb ycn lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh |cdff de{nn mh ucnycn{ ycnp~{lcd|n mb ycn {nhnudkfn nhn{ez l{nijy| b{mg |~k|l{jkn{| ujff kn dllmgpfj|cni yc{m~ec d l{nijymh ndlc |~k|l{jkn{| nfnly{jljyz kjff m{ kz d pdzgnhy ym ycn muhn{ mb ycn lmgg~hjyz |mfd{ ed{inh(



67/269


4;:

4


68/269

Lmhy{dly| ujyc D~ymgdyjl [nhnudf Lfd~|n|

Ycj| Dly {nt~j{n| fdhe~den ycdy d~ymgdyjldffz {nhnu| ln{ydjh lmhy{dly| ym |nff emmi| m{|n{rjln| ym lmh|~gn{| kn lfnd{fz dhi lmh|pjl~m~|fz hmyni jh ycn lmhy{dly m{ lmhy{dly mbbn{(

\~kgjyyni d|1

Fm~j|jdhdDly :?2 mb ;?4?\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;?4?(



\nlyjmh 4( P\cm{y Yjyfn(W Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| Dh Dly ym Dii{n|| D~ymgdyjl[nhnudf Lfd~|n| jh Lmhy{dly|(

4

;

2

5

3

:

4?

44

4;

442

45

43

4:

;?

;4

;;

;

;2;5

;3

;:


69/269


70/269

L{jgjhdf Edhe|-Edhe'B{nn Qmhn|

Ycj| fnej|fdyjmh nhdly| d h~gkn{ mb p{mrj|jmh| dkm~y edhe'{nfdyni mbbnh|n|( Bm{ nsdgpfn&jy l{ndyn| dh mbbnh|n bm{ d|pj{jhe ym lmggjy m{ lmggjyyjhe ln{ydjh l{jgn| d| d gngkn{ mb dl{jgjhdf |y{nny edhe dhi jy n|ydkfj|cn| pnhdfyjn| bm{ ij{nlyjhe ycn dlyjrjyjn| mb |y{nny edhe|( Jy df|m{nt~j{n| lcjfi{nh ucm d{n d{{n|yni bm{ lmggjyyjhe l{jgn| d| edhe gngkn{| ym pd{yjljpdyn jh edhe

jhyn{rnhyjmh p{me{dg|(Ycn Dly nhcdhln| pnhdfyjn| bm{ ln{ydjh m{edhjqni l{jgjhdf dlyjrjyz lmggjyyni jh m{

d{m~hi d edhe'b{nn qmhn dhi p{mrjin| ycdy d gdp b{mg d g~hjljpdf lm~hyz nhejhnn{ j| digj||jkfnd| nrjinhln mb d edhe'b{nn qmhn( Jy {nt~j{n| jhbm{gdyjmh dkm~y edhe'b{nn qmhn| kn jhlf~ini jh ycn|y~inhy cdhikmm`| m{ nt~jrdfnhy p~kfjldyjmh| mb p~kfjl m{ p{jrdyn nfngnhyd{z m{ |nlmhid{z|lcmmf| dhi jh|yjy~yjmh| mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmh dhi df|m kn ij|y{jk~yni ym ycn pd{nhy| dhi e~d{ijdh|mb lcjfi{nh ucm dyynhi idz'ld{n|(

Jy nhdkfn| ycn |ydyn m{ dhmycn{ emrn{hgnhydf nhyjyz ym k{jhe dh dlyjmh dedjh|y d gngkn{ mbd l{jgjhdf |y{nny edhe bm{ idgden| ucnh ycn gngkn{ rjmfdyn| d yngpm{d{z m{ pn{gdhnhyjha~hlyjmh( D ij|y{jly& lm~hyz& m{ ljyz dyym{hnz m{ ycn dyym{hnz enhn{df ldh |~n ym {nlmrn{ dly~dfidgden|& ljrjf pnhdfyjn|& dhi lm~{y lm|y| dhi bnn|(

Ycn fnej|fdyjmh gd`n| ycn p{mpn{yz mb d l{jgjhdf |y{nny edhe m{ jy| gngkn{| |~kanly ym|njq~{n ~hin{ ln{ydjh lmhijyjmh|( Gmhnz {nlnjrni bm{ idgden| m{ d| d ljrjf pnhdfyz g~|y kn ~|niym knhnbjy mb ycn lmgg~hjyz m{ cd{gni hnjeckm{cmmi(

Jy d~ycm{jqn| d lm~{y ym jgpm|n nfnly{mhjl gmhjym{jhe mh d gngkn{ mb d l{jgjhdf |y{nnyedhe d| d lmhijyjmh mb e{dhyjhe lmgg~hjyz |~pn{rj|jmh( Ycn kjff d~ycm{jqn| d pd{mfn pdhnf ymjgpm|n mh d gngkn{ mb d l{jgjhdf |y{nny edhe ucm j| d {npndy mbbnhin{ nfnly{mhjl gmhjym{jhe d| dlmhijyjmh mb {nfnd|n mh pd{mfn m{ gdhidym{z |~pn{rj|jmh(

Ycn Dly n|ydkfj|cn| l{jyn{jd bm{ jhlf~ijhe nrjinhln mb gngkn{|cjp jh d l{jgjhdf |y{nnyedhe jhynffjenhln idydkd|n dhi dffmu| ycdy jhbm{gdyjmh ym kn {nydjhni bm{ bjrn znd{|(

Ycn fnej|fdyjmh df|m p{mrjin| bm{ ycn l{ndyjmh mb d |ydyn dhyj'edhe e{dhy p{me{dg ym |~ppm{y{nejmhdf& g~fyjij|ljpfjhd{z dpp{mdlcn| ym lmgkdy edhe rjmfnhln(

\~kgjyyni d|1Ynsd|CK ;?32 #Nh{mffni rn{|jmh*\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;??:(



\nlyjmh 4( P\cm{y Yjyfn(W Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| Dh Dly ym Dii{n|| L{jgjhdf Edhe

Dlyjrjyz(

4

;

2

5

3

:

4?

\nlyjmh ;( PMbbnh|n| bm{ Lmggjyyjhe Ln{ydjh Dly| d| _d{y mb d L{jgjhdf \y{nny Edhe(W#d* D pn{|mh lmggjy| dh mbbnh|n jb& ujyc ycn jhynhy ym n|ydkfj|c& gdjhydjh& m{ pd{yjljpdyn jh

d lmgkjhdyjmh m{ jh ycn p{mbjy| mb d lmgkjhdyjmh m{ d| d gngkn{ mb d l{jgjhdf |y{nny edhe& ycnzlmggjy m{ lmh|pj{n| ym lmggjy mhn m{ gm{n mb ycn bmffmujhe1

#4* g~{in{& ldpjydf g~{in{& d{|mh& dee{drdyni {mkkn{z& {mkkn{z& k~{efd{z& ycnby&dee{drdyni `jihdppjhe& `jihdppjhe& dee{drdyni d||d~fy& dee{drdyni |ns~df d||d~fy& |ns~df d||d~fy&bm{en{z& indifz lmhi~ly& d||d~fy p~hj|cdkfn d| d PLfd|| D gj|ingndhm{W& k~{efd{z mb d gmym{

5? Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|
http://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/0532b02txgangs.pdfhttp://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/0532b02txgangs.pdf


71/269

rncjlfn& m{ ~hd~ycm{jqni ~|n mb d gmym{ rncjlfn0 dhz edgkfjhe mbbnh|n p~hj|cdkfn d| d PLfd|| Dgj|ingndhm{W0

44

4;

4

42

45

43

4:

;?

;4

;;

;

;2

;5

;3

;:


72/269

#4* L{jgjhdf |y{nny edhe cd| ycn gndhjhe d||jehni kz Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW02?24

2>

22

25

23

2:

5?

54

5;

5

52

55

53

5:

3?

34

3;

3

32

35

33

3::?

:4

:;

:

:2

:5

:3

::

4??4?4

4?;

4?

4?2

4?5

#;* Edhe'{nfdyni lmhi~ly gndh| lmhi~ly ycdy rjmfdyn| d pnhdf fdu mb ycn e{dinmb PLfd|| K gj|ingndhm{W m{ cjecn{ dhi jh ucjlc d lcjfi nheden| ujyc ycn jhynhy ym b~{ycn{ ycn2;l{jgjhdf dlyjrjyjn| mb d l{jgjhdf |y{nny edhe mb ucjlc ycn lcjfi j| d gngkn{0 edjh gngkn{|cjp jh d2\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;??:(



\nlyjmh 4( P\cm{y Yjyfn(W Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| Dh Dly ym L{ndyn dh Ni~ldym{Jinhyjbjn{ \z|yng(

4

;

2

5

3

:

4?

444;

4

42

45

43

4:

;?

;4

;;;

;2

;5

;3

;:


94/269

>

>2

>5

>3

>:

2?

242;

2

22

25

23

2:

5?

54

5;5

52

55

53

5:

3?

\nlyjmh


95/269

idyd ym ij|y{jly| dhi p{me{dg| ym kn ~|ni bm{ p{me{dg jgp{mrngnhy dhi gdz {nt~j{n ycdy idyd knlmh|jin{ni dhi {n|pmhini ym d| pd{y mb ycn dll{nijydyjmh p{mln|| n|ydkfj|cni p~{|~dhy ym Pjh|n{yljydyjmhW dhi ycn dpp{mrdf p{mln|| n|ydkfj|cni p~{|~dhy ym Pjh|n{y ljydyjmhW( Ycn Pinpd{ygnhyW dhiPinpd{ygnhy mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmhW& jh lmffdkm{dyjmh ujyc jh|yjy~yjmh| mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmh& |cdff |ny~p p{mymlmf| bm{ {nfnd|jhe |z|yng idyd mb e{di~dyn| ym ycnj{ {n|pnlyjrn ni~ldym{ p{npd{dyjmhp{me{dg| bm{ ycn p~{pm|n mb |nfb'nrdf~dyjmh( _{mymlmf| |cdff lmgpfz ujyc dff bnin{df fdu|( YcnPinpd{ygnhyW dhi Pinpd{ygnhy mb cjecn{ ni~ldyjmhW gdz df|m ~|n ycdy idyd ym jinhyjbz p{dlyjln|ycdy gdz |cmu p{mgj|n jb ycn p{dlyjln| d{n rn{jbjni kz diijyjmhdf nrjinhln(

34

3;

3

32

35

33

3:

:?

:4

:;

:

:2

:5

:3

::

4??

4?4

4?;

4?

4?2

4?5

4?3

4?:

44?444

44;

44

442

445

443

44:

4;?

4;44;;

4;

4;2

4;5

4;3

4;:

#B* Idyd mkydjhni b{mg ycn |z|yng |cdff kn drdjfdkfn ym |ydyn denhljn|& |lcmmf ij|y{jly|&hmhemrn{hgnhydf nhyjyjn|& dhi jhijrji~df|& yc{m~ec rd{zjhe ine{nn| mb dlln||& d| in|jehni kz ycnPT~dfjyz Yndlcn{| Lmggj||jmhW dhi jh ycn |~k|nt~nhy {npm{y dimpyni kz ycn P|ydyn kmd{iW(

#E* Ycn |z|yng |cdff ~|n g~fyjpfn idyd pmjhy|(#C* Ycn |z|yng |cdff lmgpfz ujyc dff |ydyn dhi bnin{df p{jrdlz fdu| jh m{in{ ym nh|~{n ycn

lmhbjinhyjdfjyz dhi dpp{mp{jdyn ~|n| mb jhbm{gdyjmh bm~hi jh ycn |z|yng(#J* Idyd dhdfz|j| |cdff jhlf~in ycn lmgpfnyn h~gkn{ mb ni~ldym{| jh ndlc pd{yjljpdyjhe

|lcmmf ij|y{jly( Ycn idyd |cdff kn {npm{yni mhfz jb d |lcmmf ij|y{jly m{ fmldf ni~ldyjmh denhlzjhlf~in| d gjhjg~g yc{n|cmfi jh ycn h~gkn{ mb ni~ldym{| ym nh|~{n ycdy jinhyjbjdkfn jhbm{gdyjmhmb jhijrji~df ni~ldym{| j| hmy {npm{yni(

#A* Hmyujyc|ydhijhe dhz p{mrj|jmh| mb ycj| Dly ym ycn lmhy{d{z& d |lcmmf ij|y{jly m{ fmldfni~ldyjmh denhlz gdz ~|n ycn |z|yng ym gn{en& gdhden& m{ dlln|| dhz jhbm{gdyjmh ycdy jy j|mycn{uj|n d~ycm{jqni ym mkydjh dhi ycn ~|n mb |~lc jhbm{gdyjmh |cdff hmy kn {n|y{jlyni jh dhz udzycdy j| mycn{uj|n pn{gjyyni kz |ydy~yn( Jhbm{gdyjmh mkydjhni yc{m~ec ycn |z|yng ycdy |lcmmfij|y{jly| m{ fmldf ni~ldyjmh denhljn| d{n hmy mycn{uj|n d~ycm{jqni ym mkydjh gdz kn ~|ni ymdlcjnrn ycn p~{pm|n| in|l{jkni jh |~k|nlyjmh #L* mb ycj| |nlyjmh& |m fmhe d| jy j| hmy ~|ni jh dhzudz jhlmh|j|ynhy ujyc ycn p{mynlyjmh| inbjhni jh |~k|nlyjmh #I* mb ycj| |nlyjmh(

#@* Ycn Pinpd{ygnhyW |cdff hmy kn mkfjedyni ym jgpfngnhy ycn p{mrj|jmh| mb ycj| |nlyjmh~hyjf |~bbjljnhy b~hi| cdrn knnh {nlnjrni dhi l{nijyni ym ycn Pb~hiW n|ydkfj|cni ~hin{ \nlyjmh 9(Hm Penhn{df b~hiW gmhnz |cdff kn dpp{mp{jdyni ym jgpfngnhy ycj| Dly(

#F* Ycn Penhn{df d||ngkfzW |cdff {nlmh|jin{ ycn dpp{mp{jdynhn|| mb ycn p{mrj|jmh| mb ycj|

Dly dbyn{ ycn P|ydyn kmd{iW ln{yjbjn| jh u{jyjhe ycdy ycn |z|yng j| b~ffz mpn{dyjmhdf dhi drdjfdkfn ymndlc |lcmmf ij|y{jly dhi fmldf ni~ldyjmh denhlz jh ycn |ydyn p~{|~dhy ym ycn p{mrj|jmh| mb ycj| Dly(

\nlyjmh 9( PNi~ldym{ Jinhyjbjn{ B~hi(W#D* Ycn{n j| l{ndyni dh PNi~ldym{ Jinhyjbjn{ B~hiW(#K* Ycn Pinpd{ygnhyW j| d~ycm{jqni ym |nn` dhi dllnpy ejby|& e{dhy|& m{ imhdyjmh| b{mg

p{jrdyn m{ p~kfjl |m~{ln| bm{ ycn p~{pm|n| mb ycj| Dly0 nslnpy ycdy ycn Pinpd{ygnhyW |cdff hmydllnpy d ejby& e{dhy& m{ imhdyjmh jb jy j| |~kanly ym lmhijyjmh| ycdy d{n jhlmh|j|ynhy ujyc ycj| Dly m{dhz mycn{ fdu mb ycn |ydyn( Ycn Pinpd{ygnhyW |cdff y{dh|gjy dff p{jrdyn dhi p~kfjl gmhnz| {nlnjrniyc{m~ec ejby|& e{dhy|& m{ imhdyjmh| ym ycn P|ydyn y{nd|~{n{W& ucm |cdff l{nijy ycn |dgn ym ycnPNi~ldym{ Jinhyjbjn{ B~hiW(

#L* Ycn gmhnz| l{nijyni ym ycn Pb~hiW |cdff kn lmhyjh~m~|fz dpp{mp{jdyni ym ycnPinpd{ygnhyW bm{ ycn ij{nly dhi jhij{nly lm|y| d||mljdyni ujyc jgpfngnhyjhe ycj| Dly(

#I* Dhz gmhnz| jh ycn Pb~hiW hmy nspnhini bm{ ycn p~{pm|n| mb ycj| Dly gdz kn jhrn|ynikz ycn P|ydyn y{nd|~{n{W d| p{mrjini kz fdu( Dff jhyn{n|y dhi jhlmgn in{jrni b{mg ycn jhrn|ygnhydhi inpm|jy mb gmhnz| jh ycn Pb~hiW |cdff kn l{nijyni ym ycn Pb~hiW(

#N* Dhz ~hnspnhini dhi ~hnhl~gkn{ni gmhnz| {ngdjhjhe jh ycn Pb~hiW dy ycn nhi mb dbj|ldf znd{ |cdff {ngdjh jh ycn Pb~hiW dhi |cdff hmy kn l{nijyni m{ y{dh|bn{{ni ym ycn Penhn{df b~hiWm{ dhmycn{ b~hi0 nslnpy ycdy dhz ~hnspnhini dhi ~hnhl~gkn{ni gmhnz| {ngdjhjhe jh ycn Pb~hiWd| mb Pjh|n{y idynW& |cdff kn y{dh|bn{{ni ym ycn Penhn{df b~hiW(

;?4; \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh :>


96/269

:2 Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|

4


97/269

Nhn{ez Jhb{d|y{~ly~{n Lm{{jim{| \ydyngnhy

Gdjhn _~kfjl Fdu& Lcdpyn{ 2>> mb ;?4? dii{n||n| nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n lm{{jim{|& ucjlcjy enhn{dffz inbjhn| d| enme{dpcjl d{nd| ujycjh ycn |ydyn in|jehdyni bm{ |jyjhe nhn{ezjhb{d|y{~ly~{n( Nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n jhlf~in| nfnly{jl y{dh|gj||jmh dhi ij|y{jk~yjmh bdljfjyjn|&hdy~{df ed| y{dh|gj||jmh fjhn|& dhi mycn{ pjpnfjhn|( Nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n imn| hmy jhlf~in

enhn{dyjmh jhyn{lmhhnlyjmh y{dh|gj||jmh bdljfjyjn|& nhn{ez enhn{dyjmh bdljfjyjn|& m{ nfnly{jly{dh|gj||jmh dhi ij|y{jk~yjmh bdljfjyjn| m{ nhn{ez y{dh|pm{y pjpnfjhn| ycdy l{m|| dh nhn{ezjhb{d|y{~ly~{n lm{{jim{(

Ycn Dly dii{n||n| yum yzpn| mb lm{{jim{|& pnyjyjmhni dhi |ydy~ym{z(Ycn Dly nhdkfn| ycn |ydyn Mbbjln mb ycn _~kfjl Dirmldyn& ycn Nsnl~yjrn Inpd{ygnhy&

Emrn{hm{| Mbbjln mb Nhn{ez Jhinpnhinhln dhi \nl~{jyz& dhi inrnfmpn{| ym pnyjyjmh ycn |ydynp~kfjl ~yjfjyjn| lmggj||jmh ym in|jehdyn d lm{{jim{( Ycn lmggj||jmh in|jehdyn| pnyjyjmhnilm{{jim{| kz {~fn( Ycj| gndh| jy g~|y cmfi cnd{jhe| dhi dllnpy p~kfjl lmggnhy| dhi yn|yjgmhzdkm~y ycn p{mpm|ni pnyjyjmhni lm{{jim{( Ycn Dly df|m {nt~j{n| ycn lmggj||jmh ym hmyjbz dhilmh|~fy ujyc rd{jm~| |ydyn denhljn|& fmldf emrn{hgnhy|& dhi Hdyjrn Dgn{jldh y{jkn| ucjlc muhfdhi m{ d||ny| ujycjh ycn p{mpm|ni lm{{jim{ ucnh nrdf~dyjhe d pnyjyjmh ym n|ydkfj|c dh nhn{ez

jhb{d|y{~ly~{n lm{{jim{(Ycn |ydyn p~kfjl ~yjfjyjn| lmggj||jmh ldh dpp{mrn d hnu pnyjyjmh ym n|ydkfj|c d lm{{jim{ jb

jy inyn{gjhn| ycdy ycn b~y~{n inrnfmpgnhy mb nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n ujycjh ycn pnyjyjmhni lm{{jim{j| {nd|mhdkfz fj`nfz ym kn jh ycn p~kfjl jhyn{n|y& nhlm~{den| lmffmldyjmh mb nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n&nhcdhln| ycn nbbjljnhy ~|n mb nsj|yjhe nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n& cd| d fjgjyni jgpdly mh ycnfdhi|ldpn& dhi j| lmh|j|ynhy ujyc |ydyn nhrj{mhgnhydf dhi fdhi ~|n fdu|( Ycn lmggj||jmh ldhhmydpp{mrn d pnyjyjmh bm{ d lm{{jim{ mh bnin{dffz muhni fdhi& |ydyn pd{` fdhi& m{ ln{ydjh y{jkdf fdhi|(

Ycn Dly l{ndyn| yc{nn |ydy~ym{z nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n lm{{jim{|( Yum d{n dfmhe Jhyn{|ydyncjecudz|( Ycn fdu l{ndyn| dh Jhyn{denhlz [nrjnu _dhnf ym mrn{|nn ycn ~|n mb |ydy~ym{z lm{{jim{|(Jy ij{nly| ycn pdhnf& jh lmh|~fydyjmh ujyc d p{mbn||jmhdf dpp{dj|n{& ym jinhyjbz dh jhjyjdf {dhen mbrdf~n bm{ ycn ~|n mb |ydyn'muhni fdhi m{ d||ny| ujycjh d |ydy~ym{z lm{{jim{( Jy ij{nly| ycn pdhnf ym

n|ydkfj|c d p{mln|| ym |mfjljy& nrdf~dyn& dhi dpp{mrn p{mpm|df| ym k~jfi nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{nujycjh ycn |ydy~ym{z lm{{jim{|( D| pd{y mb ycn p{mln|| ycn pdhnf g~|y p{mrjin p~kfjl hmyjln mb ycndrdjfdkjfjyz mb ycn |ydy~ym{z lm{{jim{| bm{ nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n inrnfmpgnhy& d in|l{jpyjmh mb ycnyzpn mb inrnfmpgnhy dhyjljpdyni jh ycn |ydy~ym{z lm{{jim{ dhi mppm{y~hjyz bm{ pmynhyjdf inrnfmpn{|ym |~kgjy p{mpm|df| bm{ ~|n mb ycn |ydy~ym{z lm{{jim{|(

Ycn Dly lmhydjh| p{mrj|jmh| {nt~j{jhe p{m|pnlyjrn k~jfin{| mb nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n jh ycnlm{{jim{| ym eny d lm{{jim{ mb ~|n ln{yjbjldyn b{mg ycn |ydyn p~kfjl ~yjfjyjn| lmggj||jmh dhi dlmh|mfjidyni nhrj{mhgnhydf pn{gjy b{mg ycn |ydyn nhrj{mhgnhydf inpd{ygnhy( Jy d~ycm{jqn| ycm|ndenhljn| ym inyn{gjhn ycn jhbm{gdyjmh {nt~j{ni kz d ln{yjbjldyn dhi lmh|mfjidyni pn{gjy&{n|pnlyjrnfz(

Ycn fdu nhdkfn| ycn |ydyn p~kfjl ~yjfjyjn| lmggj||jmh dhi ycn Jhyn{denhlz [nrjnu _dhnf

ym dpp{mrn p{mpm|df| ym k~jfi nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n jh ycn lm{{jim{| jb1 Ycn p{mpm|ni p{manly| gdyn{jdffz nhcdhln m{ im hmy cd{g y{dh|gj||jmh

mppm{y~hjyjn| bm{ nhn{ez enhn{dyjmh ujycjh ycn |ydyn0

Jy j| {nd|mhdkfz fj`nfz ycn p{manly| ujff {ni~ln nfnly{jl {dyn| m{ mycn{ {nfnrdhynhn{ez p{jln| m{ lm|y| bm{ k~|jhn||n| dhi {n|jinhy| jh ycn |ydyn|0 m{

Ycn muhn{ m{ mpn{dym{ mb ycn p{mpm|ni nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n de{nn| ym dhh~dffzpdz ym ycn |ydyn dh dgm~hy inyn{gjhni kz ycn lmggj||jmh m{ pdhnf ym {ni~ln {dyn|& p{jln| m{ lm|y|mrn{ ycn fjbn mb ycn p{mpm|ni nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n0 dhi

;?4; \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh :5
http://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/0332a05meenergycorridors.pdfhttp://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/0332a05meenergycorridors.pdf


98/269

:3 Ycn Lm~hljf mb \ydyn Emrn{hgnhy|

Ycn p{manly| d{n jh ycn fmhe yn{g jhyn{n|y mb ycn |ydyn d| inbjhni kz |nrn{df mycn{l{jyn{jd& jhlf~ijhe {ni~ljhe e{nnhcm~|n ed|n|(

Ycn Dly lmhydjh| p{mrj|jmh| nhdkfjhe ycn Jhyn{denhlz [nrjnu _dhnf ym hnemyjdyn fmhe'yn{g mll~pdhlz de{nngnhy| ujyc p{manly inrnfmpn{| jh |ydy~ym{z nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n lm{{jim{|(

Ycj| fdu n|ydkfj|cn| dh Nhn{ez Jhb{d|y{~ly~{n Knhnbjy| B~hi dhi |ny| {nt~j{ngnhy| bm{inpm|jyjhe gmhnz jhym ycdy b~hi( Jy {nt~j{n| |mgn mb ycn {nrnh~n| jh ycj| b~hi kn ~|ni ym p{mrjine{dhy| dhi fmdh| ym p{manly| ycdy p{mgmyn nhn{ez nbbjljnhlz dhi dfyn{hdyjrn nhn{ez {n|m~{lnjhjyjdyjrn|( Ycn kjff df|m ij{nly| d pn{lnhyden mb ycdy gmhnz kn y{dh|bn{{ni ym d Y{dh|pm{ydyjmhNbbjljnhlz B~hi df|m l{ndyni kz ycn Dly( Ycn fdu |pnljbjn| ycdy ycn |ydyn inpd{ygnhy mby{dh|pm{ydyjmh g~|y ~|n gmhnz jh ycdy b~hi ym jhl{nd|n ycn nhn{ez nbbjljnhlz mb ycn y{dh|pm{ydyjmh|z|yng ujycjh ycn |ydyn( Ycdy jhlf~in| {djf& p~kfjl y{dh|jy& ld{ dhi rdh pmmfjhe& qn{m'ngj||jmhrncjlfn|& kjmb~nf& dhi mycn{ dfyn{hdyjrn rncjlfn|(

Bjhdffz& ycn Dly lmhydjh| p{mrj|jmh| emrn{hjhe ycn ngjhnhy imgdjh d~ycm{jyz mb dy{dh|gj||jmh dhi ij|y{jk~yjmh ~yjfjyz ujycjh dh nhn{ez jhb{d|y{~ly~{n lm{{jim{(

\~kgjyyni d|1Gdjhn_~kfjl Fdu& Lcdpyn{ 2>> mb ;?4?\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;?4?(
http://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/0332a05meenergycorridors.pdfhttp://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/0332a05meenergycorridors.pdfhttp://ssl.csg.org/dockets/2012cycle/2012volume/2012volumeoriginalbills/0332a05meenergycorridors.pdf


99/269

Nhcdhlni& \pnljdf Bm|yn{ Ld{n

Ycj| Dly l{ndyn| d pjfmy p{me{dg ym p{mrjin nhcdhlni& |pnljdf |n{rjln| ym lcjfi{nhknyunnh bm~{ dhi ynh znd{| mfi ucm d{n pfdlni jh bm|yn{ ld{n( Ycn p{me{dg j| jhynhini ym {ni~lnycn ngmyjmhdf y{d~gd ym lcjfi{nh ucm nhyn{ bm|yn{ ld{n(

\~kgjyyni d|1Un|y Rj{ejhjdNh{mffni Lmggjyynn \~k|yjy~yn bm{ CK9429\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;??3(



\nlyjmh 4( P\cm{y Yjyfn(W Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| Ycn Nhcdhlni Bm|yn{ Ld{n Dly(4;

2

5

3

:

4?

44

4;

4

42

45

43

4:

;?

;4

;;

;;2

;5

;3

;:


100/269

#N* Ycn |cm{y'yn{g pfdh {nt~j{ni kz |~k|nlyjmh #L* mb ycj| |nlyjmh |cdff dii{n|| ycnlcjfi| hnni| bm{ ycn bj{|y Pycj{yzW idz| ~hin{ ycn Pinpd{ygnhy|W |~pn{rj|jmh(

9

>>

>2

>5

>3

>:

2?

24

2;2

22

25

23

2:

5?

54

5;

5

52

55

53

5:

3?

#B* I~{jhe ycn jhjyjdf nrdf~dyjmh pn{jmi& dhi ucnh d lcjfi j| knjhe pfdlni jhym bm|yn{ ld{n&ycn Pinpd{ygnhyW |cdff ucnh pm||jkfn pfdln ycn lcjfi jhym dh nhcdhlni |pnljdfjqni bm|yn{ ld{ncmgn( _{mrjin{| mbbn{jhe nhcdhlni |pnljdfjqni bm|yn{ ld{n cmgn| |cdff mbbn{ l{j|j| jhyn{rnhyjmh|n{rjln| |ydbbni kz y{djhni p{mbn||jmhdf| dhi df|m mbbn{ |pnljdfjqni y{djhjhe ym gdhden d lcjfi|{ndlyjmh ym ycn y{d~gd mb knjhe {ngmrni b{mg ycn l~|ymiz mb d pd{nhy& pd{nhy|& m{ mycn{e~d{ijdh|& ujyc ngpcd|j| mh d lcjfi| ngmyjmhdf hnni|( Ycj| p{me{dg |cdff fjgjy ycn h~gkn{ mblcjfi{nh jh mhn fmldyjmh ym Pyc{nnW bm|yn{ lcjfi{nh dy d yjgn( D e{ndyn{ h~gkn{ j| pn{gjyyni jb dff mbycn lcjfi{nh d{n |jkfjhe|(

#E* Dbyn{ d |cm{y'yn{g pfdh dhi fmhe'yn{g pfdh d{n inrnfmpni& ycn Pinpd{ygnhyW |cdff1#4* _{mrjin ycn bm|yn{ bdgjfz ujyc y{djhjhe dhi ni~ldyjmh jh ycn pfdh0#;* Nrdf~dyn ycn jhyn{dlyjmh knyunnh ycn lcjfi dhi bm|yn{ pd{nhy| m{ pd{nhy0#


101/269

;?4; \~een|yni \ydyn Fnej|fdyjmh 4?4

34

3; \nlyjmh >( PNbbnlyjrn Idyn(W PJh|n{y nbbnlyjrn idyn(W


102/269

Bjhdhljhe Nhn{ez Nbbjljnhlz Jgp{mrngnhy|

Ycj| Dly nhdkfn| ed| dhi nfnly{jl ~yjfjyz l~|ymgn{| jh ycn |ydyn ym bjhdhln ycn lm|y| mbjh|ydffjhe nt~jpgnhy dhi gd`jhe {npdj{| ym ycnj{ cmgn| ym lmh|n{rn nhn{ez kz pdzjhe dhdiijyjmhdf Gnyn{ Lmh|n{rdyjmh Lcd{en d| pd{y mb ycnj{ gmhycfz ~yjfjyz kjff|( ^yjfjyz l~|ymgn{|g~|y pn{gjy ycn ~yjfjyjn| ym pn{bm{g dh nhn{ez d~ijy mb ycnj{ cmgn| knbm{n ycnz ldh |jeh d lmhy{dly

jhjyjdyjhe ycn lcd{en( Ycn nhn{ez d~ijy g~|y kn lmhi~lyni kz dh nhn{ez d~ijym{ ln{yjbjni kz ycnK~jfijhe _n{bm{gdhln Jh|yjy~yn m{ |jgjfd{ m{edhjqdyjmh( Ycn d~ijy g~|y p{mrjin dh n|yjgdyn mb ycnlm|y| mb ycn p{mpm|ni nhn{ez nbbjljnhlz dhi lmh|n{rdyjmh gnd|~{n| dhi ycn nspnlyni |drjhe|d||mljdyni ujyc ycn gnd|~{n|& dhi jy g~|y {nlmggnhi gnd|~{n| dpp{mp{jdynfz |jqni bm{ ycn|pnljbjl ~|n lmhyngpfdyni(

Lmhy{dly| ym jgpm|n d Gnyn{ Lmh|n{rdyjmh Lcd{en g~|y |ydyn pfdjhfz ycn jhyn{n|y {dyn ym knlcd{eni ym bjhdhln ycn lm|y| mb ycn nhn{ez nbbjljnhlz dhi lmh|n{rdyjmh gnd|~{n|( Ycn jhyn{n|y {dyng~|y kn d bjsni {dyn mrn{ ycn yn{g mb ycn de{nngnhy dhi g~|y hmy nslnni bm~{ pn{lnhy dkmrn ycn|ydyni zjnfi bm{ mhn'znd{ Y{nd|~{z kjff| d| p~kfj|cni kz ycn Bnin{df [n|n{rn dy ycn yjgn ycnde{nngnhy j| nhyn{ni( L~|ymgn{| ldh pdz mbb ycnj{ lmhy{dly| ujycm~y jhl~{{jhe pnhdfyjn| dhzyjgnknbm{n ycnj{ lmhy{dly| nspj{n(

Ycn Dly {nt~j{n| ycdy d ~yjfjyz g~|y bjfn d hmyjln ycdy d gnyn{ lmh|n{rdyjmh lcd{en cd| knnhjgpm|ni mh d {n|jinhyjdf dllm~hy& |m ycdy dllm~hy cmfin{| ujff kn dud{n mb ycn bjhdhljhed{{dhengnhy( Cmunrn{& ycn Dly nspfjljyfz p{mrjin| ycdy hmyjln mb d gnyn{ lmh|n{rdyjmh lcd{enimn| hmy lmh|yjy~yn d fjnh mh ycn p{mpn{yz(

\~lc lmhy{dly| g~|y df|m |pnljbz ycn gnd|~{n| ym kn lmgpfnyni dhi ycn lmhy{dlym{{n|pmh|jkfn bm{ lmgpfnyjmh mb ycn gnd|~{n|( Ycn lcmjln mb d lmhy{dlym{ ym pn{bm{g ycn um{` g~|ykn gdin kz ycn muhn{ mb ycn {n|jinhln( ^pmh {nt~n|y& ycn nfnly{jljyz p{mrjin{ m{ hdy~{df ed|p{mrjin{ g~|y p{mrjin ycn muhn{ mb ycn {n|jinhln ujyc d fj|y mb lmhy{dlym{| t~dfjbjni ym im ycnum{`(

^pmh lmgpfnyjmh mb ycn um{`& jy g~|y kn jh|pnlyni kz dh nhn{ez d~ijym{ ln{yjbjni kz ycnK~jfijhe _n{bm{gdhln Jh|yjy~yn m{ |jgjfd{ m{edhjqdyjmh( Dhz um{` ycdy j| inyn{gjhni ym cdrn knnh

imhn jgp{mpn{fz m{ ym kn jhdpp{mp{jdynfz |jqni bm{ ycn jhynhini ~|n g~|y kn {ngnijni kz ycn{n|pmh|jkfn lmhy{dlym{( ^hyjf ycn um{` cd| knnh {ngnijni& b~hi| i~n ym ycn lmhy{dlym{ g~|y kncnfi jh n|l{mu kz ycn nfnly{jljyz p{mrjin{ m{ hdy~{df ed| p{mrjin{(

\~kgjyyni d|1\m~yc Ld{mfjhdDly 494 mb ;?4?\ydy~|1 Nhdlyni jhym fdu jh ;?4?(



\nlyjmh 4( P\cm{y Yjyfn(W Ycj| Dly |cdff kn ljyni d| Dh Dly ym _n{gjy Nhn{ez Gnyn{Lmh|n{rdyjmh Lcd{en|(

4

;

2

5

3

\nlyjmh ;( PInbjhjyjmh|(W D| ~|ni jh ycj| Dly1#4* Nfnly{jljyz p{mrjin{ gndh| dh nfnly{jl lmmpn{dyjrn& dh jhrn|ym{'muhni nfnly{jl

~yjfjyz& ycn |ydyn Pp~kfjl |n{rjln d~ycm{jyzW& m{ d g~hjljpdfjyz m{ g~hjljpdf kmd{i m{ lmggj||jmh mbp~kfjl um{`| ycdy muh| dhi mpn{dyn| dh nfnly{jl ~yjfjyz |z|yng(

#;

Suggested State Legislation 2012 Volume 71, The Council of State Governments

Documents

Transcript of Suggested State Legislation 2012 Volume 71, The Council of State Governments